This week we start a brand new format...MUSICALS WE LOVE… We love Musicals, we miss musicals… Starting this week we’re going to explore some shows you might not know and get a closer look at the shows you love. This week… Joe’s favorite musical of all time... Read More
From the show: Guys Who Like Musicals
About
This week we start a brand new format...MUSICALS WE LOVE… We love Musicals, we miss musicals… Starting this week we’re going to explore some shows you might not know and get a closer look at the shows you love. This week… Joe’s favorite musical of all time. PASSING STRANGE . . "You know its weird when you wake up that morning and realize that your entire adult life was based on the decision made by a teenager… A stoned teenager.” Passing Strange won the Tony for Best Book of a Musical at the 2008 Tony Awards and closed WAY soon. If you don’t know this show… YOU MUST!! Check out the Spike Film on iTunes or Amazon and check the cast album wherever you get music. This show changed Joe’s life and super charged his love for theater at a time when the theater was nowhere to be found. A search for “the real”, a mother’s love might feel insane, nothing ever made him feel as real as when she mended him, remove your mask .. I'll give you all the love life allows… Passing Strange is everything we love about theater. We’re thrilled to bring you this new segment and celebrate the art form we love so much. I wonder what we'll cover next week???
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:05] Dan Tracy: No, it's from the show that we're talking about.
[0:07] Joe Carroll: Oh.
[0:08] Dan Tracy: This is a brand new Guys Who Like Musicals. Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals. Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals. This is a very exciting week. I'm really excited about this week. We haven't had excitement in our voice for months.
[0:21] Joe Carroll: Well, that's true.
[0:23] Dan Tracy: This is a completely new segment. We've been talking about it for, uh, sort of hinting at it for a couple of weeks. Basically, Dan, what we're gonna do is for the next handful of weeks, months, maybe forever.
[0:40] Joe Carroll: Yeah, but we're very excited about this idea now. Um, we're calling this segment, uh, like we love musicals or music.
[0:47] Dan Tracy: Musicals we love.
[0:48] Joe Carroll: Musicals we love. Um, we love musicals and we miss musicals, and so what this segment is gonna be is exploring some shows that you might not know and getting to know shows that are your favorites a little more in depth. So we're basically gonna take some stuff that we love and we're just gonna dive in, like deep dive, like super book report, you know, um, and just give you all sorts of, you know, fairly useless information about stuff that we really love. Um, and this, uh, this is probably my favorite show.
[1:18] Dan Tracy: No, it's not probably. This is my favorite show of all time. This is Joe's favorite show since 2008. This has been my favorite show. This is the 2008 Tony Award winning Best Book, PASSING STRANGE. And we're gonna talk about it. PASSING STRANGE is the musical we love this week.
[1:39] Joe Carroll: Q Music.
[1:45] Dan Tracy: Shopping all the price for the small run with me. It's all nice.
[2:03] Joe Carroll: It's alright. I'm really excited about this. I think that we started. Well, I don't know why we picked my favorite musical first, but, uh, we'll do your favorite musical next week or whatever. But basically, we're gonna talk about PASSING STRANGE, uh, this week and we're gonna drop in a whole bunch if you don't know anything about it. This is a great opportunity to, um, explore this cast album. And one of the things we wanted to do with this segment was explore things you can see right now. Like you can go and watch, you can, um, you know, this, this was this musical, uh, where we're gonna get into all of it, but they, it didn't run for a terribly long time on Broadway, but Spike Lee filmed, uh, filmed the final two performances on Broadway, and it is a remarkable movie.
You can rent it, you can buy it on iTunes, you can rent it on iTunes for $3.99. It's available on Amazon through an IFC subscription for $5.99, which has a free trial for a week. The movie has a 100% on Rotten Tomatoes. 100% on Rotten Tomatoes. 100%.
[3:02] Joe Carroll: And so I, a little bit of, I guess, my journey with it. Um, it feels, this sounds dramatic, and I'm probably, I might start crying at some point over the course of this hour because this show means just, hey, listen, man. Uh, this show means so much to me. Um, I, my junior year of college, uh, was a really difficult first semester of college was a really difficult semester, and frankly, I, I was questioning all of this. I was, I was really thinking about a world where I gave up on musical theater and went to do something else. I wasn't inspired by it. I was like kind of going through the motions and didn't love it anymore. Um, and I discovered PASSING STRANGE. I was in London studying abroad.
My friend Matt would, uh, was like, you know, we, it was one o'clock in the morning, and he was like talking about PASSING STRANGE, and he's like, "Have you heard of that?" And I was, I had never heard of the show. And he was like, "Okay, stop everything. We are going to turn on the Spike Lee movie right now." We started it at about one o'clock in the morning, one thirty in the morning. We've watched the whole thing. I cried like a baby, stayed up all night, and basically it reinvigorated my love for the art form in general. This to me is what musicals can be, it's what musicals should be. It's theater at its purest. It's, you know, seven, eight actors, you know, it was understood just sitting on stage with a band on stage and a bunch of chairs playing 1,800 characters a piece.
Um, it is to me everything that I want musical theater to be. And I watch it, I go back and watch the Spike Lee movie at least once a year. Um, anytime I'm feeling bummed out, anytime I'm feeling like artistically stuck, um, I watch it again, and it was really fun to revisit this the, you know, this past week because I freaking love musicals. You love, we love musicals, and we're really sad these days. We're like, what are we doing? The industry is shuttered, we have nothing, you know. And to sit there and watch this show and be like, it's all right, you know, it was really, uh, therapeutic for me.
[5:13] Dan Tracy: So yeah, for sure. I, uh, I don't have as deep a history. I mean, I've, I've watched this movie when we were in college on probably your request after, uh, if you know me after a split or two. Chances are I've told you about this. Chances are if we've done a show together, if you're my friend, if you've heard me, I to, I bring this up to everybody. Have you seen PASSING STRANGE? Well, no. And I'm like, you have to go home, you have to watch it. You have to drink something or smoke something, and you have to watch this frickin' show. It is about mothers and sons. It's about an artist's journey. It is the search for, it's about searching for the real, you know, like all of these things that like if you don't know the show, please, please go back. And after we're done talking about it, go and listen to it because, um, it'll blow your mind if, if, uh, if you don't know it already. So let's get on this journey together.
[6:04] Joe Carroll: Yeah. Spoilers, spoilers only after this point. So if you haven't seen it, you should maybe watch it and then come back and listen with us.
[6:13] Dan Tracy: Well, and one spoiler thing that I, I don't want, I don't want to spoil the very, very end.
[6:17] Joe Carroll: Sure.
[6:18] Dan Tracy: I want, I want because there isn't a wonderful twist at the end that will just make you weep. I don't care who you are, I don't care how black your heart is, it'll make you cry. And so I like, I want to leave that. I want to leave that for, for people to explore. So like don't worry, we're not gonna, we're not gonna ruin the whole thing. Um, but god damn it do I love this show. I don't know if you can hear it in my voice. So let's jump into it.
[6:43] Joe Carroll: So A.O. Scott wrote, uh, in the New York Times about, um, PASSING STRANGE. It burst onto the Broadway stage as the most explosive and acclaimed new musical of our time, sweeping the major theater awards and electrifying millions. Now two-time Academy Award nominee Spike Lee captures all the emotion, humor, and full throttle energy of the groundbreaking rock opera by singer-songwriter Stu in the semi-autobiographical story of a young man who leaves 70s LA for a European Odyssey of sex, drugs, rock and roll, and redemption.
[7:17] Dan Tracy: And, uh, Charles Isherwood of the New York Times called it, he said, "Call it a rock concert with a story to tell, call it a sprawling work of performance art. Call it whatever you want, really. I'll just call it wonderful." Like we don't always love critics, right? But like come on. Like they ever, it was so critically acclaimed at the time. People just, people loved it. And I mean, one of the things that Isherwood said was, you know, if you call it a, if you call it a rock musical, um, that may scare away, uh, the people who would actually love this thing.
[7:50] Joe Carroll: Yeah, I was gonna say, I think we, we'll get into that. But I think that watching it again and thinking back on, you know, my career having done American Idiot and then watching kind of the world of theater progress, it's just ahead of its time in that audiences were not ready to see a show like this. Listening to this dude rock scream, like, we talk about like singing dirty. Like dude can sing dirty. This cast can sing dirty. There's also beautiful sounds in it too. But like that sound in a season, we'll get to this too, but like in a season where South Pacific, you know, it's like right. You're just, you couldn't be a more different time.
[8:32] Dan Tracy: Exactly. So we're talking about 2008. This show opened on February 28th, 2008, and it closed July 20th, 2008, after 165 performances. It played the Belasco Theater, which is the current home of Girl from the North Country. Hope, hope to God when things get back to normal. And, uh, for a little bit of context about 2008, before we keep going, is, uh, in 2008 was, uh, that Black Monday huge stock market dip that took out like much of the market and the European markets and the Asian exchanges on January 21st. So there was like, that was the cataclysmic beginning of the 2008 recession.
[9:11] Joe Carroll: Wow, you know what? I didn't think about that at all.
[9:13] Dan Tracy: Right.
[9:14] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[9:19] Dan Tracy: At that time, it's gonna be a similar moment that we have coming out of what's happening right now. You, it's shows don't stay open. Same thing happened in 2001 after 9/11 shows didn't stay open, right?
[9:32] Joe Carroll: Right?
[9:33] Dan Tracy: Yeah, you're no, you're 100% right because when you think about the fact that it, you know, just back to what Dan said, 165 performances. It closed in the middle of July. You know, that's, it did not run for a very long time. And I think I did not think about the, the, you know, the recession part of the context, which makes perfect sense as to like probably one of the, the, you know, one of the reasons, one of the things they point to to be like, God, yeah, you know, we do that on Broadway all the time. You point to some reason why a show closes, and there's absolutely no reason. But I, I think that a housing crisis is definitely partially one of the reasons why this didn't run. The other historical thing though that I wanted to talk about the moment that the show happens in is obviously this is a show about black voices, uh, featuring black voices.
It's really ahead of its time in that way, and is something that like I wish maybe they'll revive it because it feels like it has such a good moment right now, and we can talk about that later. But in 2008 was when Obama had basically just secured Super Tuesday, was just about to happen when this show opened.
[10:37] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[10:37] Dan Tracy: So in June 3rd of 2008, right before, right before the Tony Awards was when he had that speech at the XL Energy Center in St. Paul where he was officially the nominee and he made that whole speech about hope. And I mean, I will never forget watching that because I was like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah." So thrilled.
[10:56] Joe Carroll: Yeah, that was our first election.
[10:57] Dan Tracy: That was our first, our first election where we could vote.
[10:59] Joe Carroll: Yeah, but also just like having a black nominee for president and thinking that like this is the guy that you'd want to win, or at least I did at the time, and it was just a c such a cool moment to think about this show in that political moment as opposed to this political moment is so diametrically different. But yeah, totally the themes are still so relevant right now, you know.
[11:21] Dan Tracy: It's wildly relevant. And I, you know, again, you know, as people who don't know, it is an all black cast and they play thousands of characters. They play Dutch people, they play German people, they play churchgoers, they play parents and friends, and you know, it's just, it's a wash of just actors acting, you know. Um, one thing just for a second that I love just because it is such a, it's an interesting thing. I was thinking about like a couple of white dudes talking about PASSING STRANGE and PASSING STRANGE being my favorite show. It was, it's such a story about black identity, and, and Stu talks a lot about that, um, just in various interviews. Um, and we could talk about the relevance of the actual title and the where the title PASSING STRANGE comes from, which it was, it was originally, um, first, uh, sort of coined in Othello.
Um, and one of the things that he says is, uh, you know, this is a quote that Stu had in the original program saying the way that Desdemona fell in love with Othello from hearing all of his crazy war stories reminded me of the tales that rock and roll guys tell to impress women. And I thought that was so interesting. Um, he, you know, and so he used, you know, PASSING STRANGE also applies in the context of people passing for what they are not culturally, uh, psychologically, and so on, people passing as white or rich or passing, you know, rich people passing as poor. Um, it was a huge reason why the title is what it is. But for me back in the day, like I had no idea who James Baldwin was or who Chester Himes was or who Josephine Baker was.
And so he's shouting these names, and because you're watching it on film, I, I got to, I was like watching it, and then I went back the next day and, and I was like, who is James Baldwin? You know, I was like, I was like a 20-year-old, I was like 20 at the time, right? To be like, oh my, oh my god, you know, like he opened my eyes to a world that only I, I don't know if I would have had otherwise, you know, and just, you know, so, so in that way, like he's gonna shout, if you watch the movie, he's gonna shout out like all of these different names of, you know, uh, different black, uh, people of unbelievable prestige and history that like you should look up. Like what, what does he mean when he says, like, you know, you know, Josephine Baker and James Baldwin own Paris and Amsterdam's gonna be his.
He goes to Amsterdam searching for himself, the way that James Baldwin and Josephine Baker went to Paris to try to, you know, shed the America that didn't love them and didn't accept them, you know, searching for some sort of, uh, some, you know, searching for the real. That's what the show's about.
[13:50] Joe Carroll: Right. Um, yeah. So I, that, uh, that's, that's super duper, um, that's super interesting about all the, the just the context of like where they were because then we talk about like, you know, yeah, it was South Pacific, Little Mermaid opened that season, Laura Osnes won the Grease, you know, the one that I wanted, whatever show.
[14:09] Dan Tracy: You know, and then in that, and we were talking about it just before we got on in 2008, In the Heights won the Tony Award.
[14:14] Joe Carroll: Right.
[14:15] Dan Tracy: So and at that time, everything that we read was like PASSING STRANGE and In the Heights were neck and neck.
[14:21] Joe Carroll: They were, it was like who it was, it was back and forth for the Tony that season right up until the very end.
[14:28] Dan Tracy: And once they got to the Tony Awards, they uh Stu won Best Book of a Musical.
[14:32] Joe Carroll: Daniel Breaker and Stu were nominated for acting in the acting category, Best Featured Actress, uh DeAndre Zizo was nominated. They were nominated for orchestration score and musical.
[14:42] Dan Tracy: So they had a run at the Tonys, but like In the Heights is now like one of the biggest musicals of all time.
[14:49] Joe Carroll: And the runner up, you know what I mean? It's just it's like wild.
[14:52] Dan Tracy: It's wild.
[14:54] Joe Carroll: Lynn is now like, you know, a face of like Disney.
[14:59] Dan Tracy: Lynn is now like, yeah, you know, he's Mary Poppins.
[15:03] Joe Carroll: Like the guy. He's a modern day, you know, it it's hard to even compare him to anyone.
[15:08] Dan Tracy: He's like an such an icon. And here we are, like, you know, this is just the little show that could in the same season, and there's so many of those.
[15:18] Joe Carroll: Yeah. Um yeah, like to just to think about the runner-ups, you know, like like just you know, and so anyway, you know, the way that In the Heights changed so many people's lives, like, you know, PASSING STRANGE totally changed mine.
[15:28] Dan Tracy: So and it's amazing to think about how shows would hit differently in different seasons based on, you know, what's going on at the time and and all of those other things.
[15:38] Joe Carroll: So I think that context is really fun and important to go through. But let's talk a little bit about the development of the show, how PASSING STRANGE came to be to at least like what we know.
[15:50] Dan Tracy: I think sometimes it's fun for us to talk about this kind of stuff because uh we can get these insider stories. So I don't know if we have any of those here, but what we have been able to find on the internet is uh that the show started in Utah at the Sundance Institute, uh at the Sundance Institute Theater Lab in 2004, and then they were asked back in 2005, which basically never happens.
[16:19] Joe Carroll: And that was their first rounds of like developmental productions, their workshops, if you will.
[16:25] Dan Tracy: Yep. And then uh went to they had productions in Berkeley, and then they went to the public.
[16:31] Joe Carroll: And one of the things that's interesting just about you know, the also the world that we live in with like rock stars making theater, like Stu famously he he come, he's like he's one of these guys who says he hates theater, he hates musical theater, which I find to be bullshit because like you know, the guy has had a total career of basically making concept records, and you know, he had a band called the Negro Problem, which has made up of a lot of the people who played in the band on stage in the in the the Broadway production.
[17:02] Dan Tracy: But like he like kind of hates, you know, he's one of these guys like I hate musicals, I hate musicals, but like spent, I mean, this is this is an opus in a way that like you can't hate musicals if you spend two years at the Sundance Lab.
[17:14] Joe Carroll: If you but you know, to spending nearly a decade making a musical.
[17:17] Dan Tracy: Yeah. Um, you know, that's always the thing that's funny to me. Like, he, you know, when people are like, Oh, I I hate musicals, it's like, man, you don't hate musicals. You know this the you you were up for, you know, you won a frickin' Tony Award.
[17:30] Joe Carroll: Uh the uh, but yeah, I just so that would that was it's that was his journey, and when it got to the public, it really, you know, as so many things do.
[17:37] Dan Tracy: Um, you know, obviously Hamilton and Girl from the North Country most recently, you know, things that just like sort of you know become shooting to Broadway from there.
[17:45] Joe Carroll: Um I mean yeah I think that the you know one of the things I you know just to go through the creative team a little bit um if we want to jump to that uh is directed by Annie Dorson.
[17:54] Dan Tracy: Uh they collaborated together.
[17:56] Joe Carroll: Uh Annie Dorson is is credited as uh like created in collaboration with right.
[18:01] Dan Tracy: So she directed it, but also was like, you know, taking these these rock stars, you know, taking their concept record and basically turning it, you know, this this idea and really turning it into a piece of theater.
[18:11] Joe Carroll: Um and she's like she's super artsy and does a whole bunch of stuff in Europe and is a MacArthur genius.
[18:16] Dan Tracy: And honestly, with researching her uh this week, I was like, I was like, she needs to somebody needs to call her to be the next Julie Tamor.
[18:22] Joe Carroll: You know, people we need, you know, like because like back when Julie Tamor before she did uh Lion King was like this this experimental off-Broadway, like, you know, director doing like mask work and stuff, and then Disney was like, Hey, will you come and do this thing?
[18:36] Dan Tracy: And she was like, No, commercial theater is is a construct, you know, or whatever.
[18:39] Joe Carroll: And they were like, that's exactly what that's like.
[18:41] Dan Tracy: That's what we need for Lion King.
[18:42] Joe Carroll: That's what we need for Lion King.
[18:44] Dan Tracy: Uh Annie Dorson's really cool.
[18:45] Joe Carroll: She won a Guggenheim Fellowship too, and she recently has been developing this piece that is uh it's called Algorithm Theater.
[18:54] Dan Tracy: So they've built an algorithm that dictates a script.
[18:59] Joe Carroll: Uh and I don't know what the obviously the parameters of the algorithm are, but they used Shakespeare's anthology, the Bible, and like Twitter threads to basically create a script, and then they perform that script either the same night or like they've then, you know, that's how they're like developing their process for scripts, kind of taking this idea of like the way that technology has influenced our life, life, and then forcing it down the throat of our of us as artists to make us think critically about you know the world we live in.
[19:32] Dan Tracy: Pretty cool.
[19:33] Joe Carroll: I I I just I just love that.
[19:34] Dan Tracy: It's a little deeper than Broadway, I think.
[19:36] Joe Carroll: It's so much cooler.
[19:37] Dan Tracy: It was so much cooler than like anything.
[19:40] Joe Carroll: Um it was uh it was produced by uh uh Joey Parnes.
[19:45] Dan Tracy: Um one of the one of the things that uh real connection here for me, David Corns did the set, and David Corns did the set for Hamilton and for Bandstand and a million other things.
[19:55] Joe Carroll: It is one of these it's one of these sets that like you it does take your breath away even on on film.
[20:02] Dan Tracy: And uh Alex, my wife talks about seeing it live.
[20:05] Joe Carroll: I didn't get to see it on Broadway, but she did she actually got to see the show the day that they got their closing notice.
[20:10] Dan Tracy: Um, and got to she like she was 17 and you know, stage doored the show and talked to everybody about how much the show meant to her, and um, you know, uh it was one of these moments that that we talk about often.
[20:23] Joe Carroll: Uh but she she talks about when this light wall really just like hits you uh, you know, in like the you know, the third row or whatever, where it comes out of nowhere.
[20:34] Dan Tracy: It basically is like a blank set.
[20:35] Joe Carroll: It's just like you know, a bunch of chairs, like I said, and some in this band, the band on stage, sort of in the stage, and then out of nowhere when he gets to Amsterdam, the lights just flash on, and it's like you know, this this sort of technicolor um, you know, sort of crazy technicolor, like you know, everything is is bright and beautiful now that he's left Los Angeles.
[20:58] Dan Tracy: Um, and uh and so that was really cool.
[21:00] Joe Carroll: I didn't know that David had done that, and I was like, Oh, yeah, look.
[21:02] Dan Tracy: Yeah, it's cool.
[21:03] Joe Carroll: I like how they built the um the floor of the set, has uh those moving platforms that sink into the floor so that the band is always there, but then they can be sunken in.
[21:16] Dan Tracy: Um, really cool use of like we'll we can talk about that kind of once we get into more of the show.
[21:22] Joe Carroll: But the band the band's integration in the piece is really fun.
[21:27] Dan Tracy: There was another uh connection here.
[21:30] Joe Carroll: Um Steven Brackett was the associate director of this, and he's the guy who directed Be More Chill and Lightning Thief this season.
[21:39] Dan Tracy: Uh he also he was attached to the bad years for a while, so I've I've worked with him before.
[21:44] Joe Carroll: Um he's kind of an up and coming, he was sort of like tertiary off Broadway guy, but now that he's obviously done Be More Chill, so he's moving into the commercial space, and also the lighting designer of PASSING STRANGE is a guy named Kevin Adams, and Kevin Adams was also the lighting designer for another very famous rock musical called American Idiot.
[22:11] Dan Tracy: Well, there's another there.
[22:12] Joe Carroll: Look at that look at American Idiot.
[22:15] Dan Tracy: We're gonna have another even connection connection about American Idiot for the moment.
[22:19] Joe Carroll: So we're gonna we'll get we'll get to that.
[22:20] Dan Tracy: But yeah, when you're talking about the way that the the use of like light and rock light as as it integrates itself into theater, like the difference between when you see a concert at a venue and the difference between when you see a musical on Broadway, though the way that people express themselves with light is very different, and they're not usually throwing light on the audience, they're not usually trying to make the audience feel exposed, but this is the opposite.
[22:49] Joe Carroll: Like Kevin's style is like, let's throw strobe lights into the audience's eyes so that they feel like they're at a punk show.
[22:55] Dan Tracy: And he did that here, and then he brought a lot of that stuff into his work in American Idiot.
[22:59] Joe Carroll: He also did SpongeBob, Head Over Heels, Head Wig, and The Hair Revival.
[23:04] Dan Tracy: Oh, yeah.
[23:05] Joe Carroll: So, you know, he's done a lot of that stuff that seems to be his his calling card.
[23:10] Dan Tracy: And um Yeah, it's so freaking cool.
[23:13] Joe Carroll: And and just adds so much.
[23:14] Dan Tracy: And one of those things that like doesn't always translate to like musical theater on film.
[23:19] Joe Carroll: Right.
[23:19] Dan Tracy: And it really does.
[23:20] Joe Carroll: I mean, it's spite Spike Lee's behind the camera for this.
[23:22] Dan Tracy: So like you know it's gonna be remarkable, but like you really get a sense of like all of that work that those you know, the lighting, you know, that he put into it.
[23:29] Joe Carroll: Um, because sometimes that does get lost on film, you know.
[23:32] Dan Tracy: Yeah.
[23:33] Joe Carroll: Um let's talk about the cast.
[23:35] Dan Tracy: The cast all right.
[23:36] Joe Carroll: So we talked about the the the about Stu and Heidi.
[23:39] Dan Tracy: Uh did we talk about Heidi yet?
[23:40] Joe Carroll: The co-collaborator.
[23:41] Dan Tracy: So Heidi Heidi Rodewald um was was his uh was Stu's um uh co um creator of Pass Exchange.
[23:49] Joe Carroll: She's credited with uh the music along with Stu.
[23:51] Dan Tracy: Stu is credited with the book and lyrics, and she's credited with the music um as well.
[23:55] Joe Carroll: They've played it uh she was uh uh a member of the Negro Problem, uh the band.
[23:59] Dan Tracy: Uh she's the bass player, she's in the show, and there's a lot of like, and this is a little bit of speculation, but I know that like they were together and then they weren't.
[24:09] Joe Carroll: It's kind of like Glenn Hansard and Marketta, like there's like this like love that was there, and a lot of people think that the the love story that he in Germany when he goes to Germany, um, you know, and falls in love, that like that was Heidi aspects of their relationship.
[24:27] Dan Tracy: So like it's very autobiographical in that way, and she's right there, um, you know, on stage with him the whole time.
[24:33] Joe Carroll: So like it's just this this autobiographical show that that you can't this is the thing about reviving it too, is it's like it's his story, it's Stu's story, he's telling you his story.
[24:44] Dan Tracy: Um, um and so the way that like I want to see it revived in a way because I wonder if it would work even, you know, to like have somebody else up there being like, I'm gonna tell you my story of like my artist journey as a you know, a kid growing up in South Central LA and try to be a musician and find myself, you know what I mean?
[25:02] Joe Carroll: I just think it'd be interesting.
[25:03] Dan Tracy: I know it, I know it will translate, but it'll still work as a story to him.
[25:07] Joe Carroll: Yeah, that's an interesting point.
[25:08] Dan Tracy: I think it'll still work as a piece because the the idea that this narrator is also the writer, if it's not actually him, it'll take a little bit of a less meta turn when you get into the moments where he actually is able to speak to his own self.
[25:30] Joe Carroll: However, if it's just two characters, it still plays the same way.
[25:35] Dan Tracy: It's like, oh, this character's talking to another version of himself, and it becomes clear kind of what's happening for the purposes of the story.
[25:42] Joe Carroll: I think it could work.
[25:43] Dan Tracy: Right.
[25:44] Joe Carroll: Yeah, me too.
[25:45] Dan Tracy: Um, so so this cast is just like kind of I still I we'll why don't we start with Rebecca Naomi Jones?
[25:53] Joe Carroll: Because she can wait, but we can start with notable debuts is the segment.
[26:00] Dan Tracy: Yeah.
[26:00] Joe Carroll: Um sorry, notable debuts.
[26:02] Dan Tracy: We'll start a week again.
[26:03] Joe Carroll: No, no, it's all good.
[26:04] Dan Tracy: I got excited.
[26:06] Joe Carroll: This is the first time we're doing this, and I jumped into the street.
[26:07] Dan Tracy: I think if we this if we use the title of the section, then people will recognize it when we go back to that in the next episode.
[26:14] Joe Carroll: Anyway, I understand.
[26:17] Dan Tracy: So a lot of debuts, obviously Stu.
[26:21] Joe Carroll: Um and uh Rebecca and Amy Jones would be the next one.
[26:26] Dan Tracy: I mean, she's so strong.
[26:31] Joe Carroll: It's it's like you could not tell.
[26:36] Dan Tracy: I I don't know how old she is.
[26:38] Joe Carroll: She's not old.
[26:39] Dan Tracy: It doesn't right.
[26:40] Joe Carroll: Because I know that she did an idiot before she was 30.
[26:43] Dan Tracy: So she has the charisma.
[26:47] Joe Carroll: She's gotta be 22.
[26:48] Dan Tracy: She has the charisma of a 38-year-old.
[26:50] Joe Carroll: Like you just would not know that she's like a kid, and this is the first time she's been on Broadway.
[26:55] Dan Tracy: She plays eight characters.
[26:59] Joe Carroll: With five accents, German, Dutch, uh, you know, a kind of like American urban.
[27:07] Dan Tracy: My favorite is her as the bass player in the band.
[27:09] Joe Carroll: When she like, they the very first band that they tried that they form, um it's called the Stereotypes, and she like, you know, she gets she plays bass and she's she's pretending to be twelve years old, like not understanding how to play the bass, but wanting to be in a punk rock band.
[27:23] Dan Tracy: It is so fucking hilarious.
[27:25] Joe Carroll: She's great.
[27:26] Dan Tracy: And if you don't if if that name doesn't ring a bell for you, she uh was just nominated for a Tony for the Oklahoma revival.
[27:33] Joe Carroll: She was uh what's her name in American Idiot, she was in Murder Ballad, and she played Yitsag in Hedwig, and she was in a play called Significant Other.
[27:43] Dan Tracy: She's a huge star and been in so many things and Yeah, I I remember wa seeing her at an audition one time and getting and it was like I had said what's her name scene or something.
[27:56] Joe Carroll: I couldn't handle it. For me, it's like she's passing strange. Like, you know, this, and then we'll get to this later, but with some of the songs and what they, you know, our favorite moments in the show. But like I just couldn't, I couldn't. It broke me a little bit. So still, like if I were to meet any of these people, and we'll get to all of them, I don't think I'd be able to handle it. And they're all like working all the time. I mean, there's a, I mean, they're this calendar Colman Domingo. Yeah, which him, his opening of act two of this show, "What's Inside" is just a lie. This he does a performance art piece that just from that, and then he plays Mr. Franklin, the choir teacher's son, the choir teacher in act one, and that is probably my Arlington Hill is like it's like the wizard and I of this show.
But for me, like it's but it's backwards. It's like he is telling the youth, he's telling Daniel Breaker, like, you know, all of his failings that then make almost it's the impetus to act, you know, it's the impetus for him to go on this journey. Yeah, and it's not in the album, but it is obviously in the show when you watch the movie. That like it is the reason that he sets off on this journey, and it is like it is every time I watch it chills right now, chills, he's just perfect, so unbelievable. And like so, like dynamic. The performance you can tell he has that German character that he plays, the performance artist is so like golemy. He's like so like, you know, he's got that like hunched over like thing, but then that's completely different in the first act when he's playing the pianist slash closeted choir teacher, son of the preacher of their church.
Yeah. You know, I didn't recognize him watching this back, but then I went and looked up his resume, and I was like, I've seen this guy in every, he's in four episodes of Euphoria, he was in Selma. He's a regular on Fear the Walking Dead, 80 episodes. He's in Beale Street could talk. He was in Lincoln. The opening scene, the opening scene of Lincoln. Yeah. I remember like seeing going to movie theater to see Lincoln being like, oh, that's him. That's Mr. Franklin. You know what I mean? And like he's a playwright. He was Tony nominated for The Scottsboro Boys. Yeah, he wrote the book for Donna Silvia. Yeah, I mean like just goals. Unbelievable. Unbelievable. Yeah, goals. Like literally just like unbelievable.
Also a great follow on Instagram. But like, you know, is directing a bunch. And anyway, just he's just mind blowing. Let's get into the rest of the cast. Um yeah, so the rest of the cast, also Chad Goodrich. It was his Broadway debut. We live in the same neighborhood. So I see Chad Goodrich sometimes. Not gonna talk to him. Not gonna tell him I like PASSING STRANGE, because like that's, you know, I just saw, you know, see him walking around. I'm like, hey dude. Um and then Daniel Breaker, Issa Davis, DeAndre Ziza, obviously. Um it just continued to work. Daniel Breaker most is most notably still, he's Aaron Burr in Hamilton right now. Or will be on Broadway. Uh he was in Shrek, The Book of Mormon.
He's currently on Billions, he's on this season of Billions. He's got a recur on that, so you can see him in that. Singing like a dream. Yep. And he was Tony nominated for this. And he was in Mozart in the Jungle too. Um and it's just he's remarkable. It's just like he, I mean, he sings like the raw, like unfettered like rock and roll rasp. And then when he's like light and you know, yeah, that's like floating. So long, feeling so alone, like just like, you know, floaty falsetto, just unbelievable. Also just like raw emotional presence, you know, not pushing, not like forcing emotion, but just like totally vulnerable when he needs to be totally like erratically youthful when he needs to be the tough part, man.
Like I don't because you've gotta buy the, you need like the strong black man presence, but at the same time he's like this quirky weird kid. So you need like yeah, it's like he's a teenager who is desperately, you know, like he's like everything sucks, but I don't know what I want, you know. I just need something to then really what I find the show to show's most remarkable for is this like, you know, the consequences, the only truth of youth are the grown-up consequences, the consequences of following your dream, but more so the consequences of being an asshole, you know what I mean? Like while you're being an artist, you know, it's like some people will think that art, you know, you gotta be in sad to write a sad song, you gotta be angry to write an angry song.
You don't have to be an asshole to be an artist. And I think what's interesting is like this is a show about how art is more real than anything. So you go through these phases of his life, and it's just every, it's just spot on. Everything and then he has a performance art piece in act two, right? Um that is so spikely, and I think it's probably even better for certain ways the capturing of his performance art piece from, uh yeah you know, from when he's in Berlin. It's just like it's unreal. So um love him and then DeAndre's, Issa Davis has been in like literally every television show you've ever seen, House of Cards, Successfully, Jack Ryan, Tower Jack Ryan, she's a superstar so she's everywhere.
Uh DeAndre Z, the same way, she's gotta have it. She did a couple episodes of that, the code, that show that you might recognize me from slightly not really but um she was in Woman of the Verge of Nervous Breakdown, uh David Yazbek's show. Uh anyway, so she's done a million things too, they're just like they're just killing it, it's an unbelievable cast. Um uh but so yeah and then the we were gonna do these like what if dream casting things but like I don't know if you can dreamcast, I wouldn't change a single person.
[34:08] Joe Carroll: Yeah but it's just fun to talk about like if you were casting this show today who do you think you could put into it? I mean I wrote down James Monroe Iglehart as Stu, but they could just because they're kind of like doppelgangers, you know they could be the, you know and like but I'd like to see like maybe like Josh Henry. It's a different vibe because Stu like has like he just has such a j, like a very specific vibe that if you like put super muscular built jacked insane Josh Henry in it, it changes. But I think Josh Henry probably was auditioning for this role that Daniel Breaker got too and he I think he would have been great. He might have been a little younger than that. I would cast Rebecca Naomi Jones again but also I'd love to see like Taylor Jones or somebody like that do that.
Um Yeah. I mean, I mean, I yeah, one of the one of the things that I'm just sort of putting together that I don't I don't know if it's right, but like to have somebody like Gary Clark Jr. Uh, you know, the songwriter, I don't know if you know Gary Clark Jr., but like to have to have like a rock star, an actual rock star playing Stu, I think could be very cool, you know, like because it is that combination of like, you know, he's a musician, and you know, he's yeah, he's like, you know, gotta tell he's gonna set the scene, tell you a story about a rock band. So I don't know, that could be a good one.
[35:35] Dan Tracy: Yeah, that's a good idea. I'd dig that. Um, okay, so then uh this is the part where you know we're gonna show off our editing skills because this is our this is about the songs. This is songs we love. Uh this is the songs the songs from this thing. First of all, we were talking about it before we just got on that. Like the last 20 minutes of this thing is just quotable perfection. I mean, that's what you get when when the thing wins best book. It's like every single lyric over and over and over again just feels like they're it's perfect. I mean, they're they're so great. Um I think my my number one, "Come Down Now," which is the song that Rebecca Naomi Jones sings to Daniel Breaker in Act Two, is just everything that you want in a love song, basically.
I put part of it um when I got married, I arranged a processional for Alex to walk down the aisle to, and I put this in there. Um remove your mask, see all you gotta do is ask me. I'll give you all the love life allows. Uh we're gonna let her sing it. Dan, put it in here. Great. So calm down now. Remove the mask. See, all you gotta do is ask me. I'll give you all the love life allows. So come down now. It's unbelievable. I mean, remove your mask. Like, love is more real than anything else. Then all the bullshit, all the like, you know, your goals, hopes, dreams, money, fame, whatever. It's like that's what the whole that's what it's about. That's what it's about. It's just the perfect song. Um also on here, like, just we gotta we gotta put I think we'll should start the episode this way, but the it's alright.
The it's the it's all right breakdown, and then when they then we cut it a cappella, you know. She said, the kind of place I wanna be is where no one's cool or scared of me, and then she handed him, please. Her keys. Yeah, I guess no one ever made him feel as real as when she landed him by lending him. Her keys. She said, Well, welcome to Amsterdam, welcome to Amsterdam, welcome to Amsterdam. She said, Yeah, life look alike Sodom from top to bottom. Uh shall we follow voice, but it's all right with me. She said it's all right. She said, Yeah, my look alike. Oh, it's just I mean, it's too good. What a nerd. It's too good.
[38:30] Joe Carroll: And then I know, and then Arlington Hill also just is like, I the whole Arlington Hill sequence from the the from the movie um is just perfect, and you don't get all of it on the record. So I would highly recommend like watching the whole sequence because you get the whole scene and it's funny and it's heart wrenching. Blast in everyone's tears. Oh, she sees you in the rear view. And if you should have further seen. Yeah, man. It's just it's so good. What are yours?
[39:17] Dan Tracy: Passing Phase and Church Blues Revelation, like Passing Phase is just like the kind of 11 o'clock number that I always dig. That's like can be about so many things for so many people, you know, in this context, it means one thing. But I think what's interesting about this story being a black story is that in most cases, when you're gonna talk about passing, it's gonna be about passing for white. It's like a huge part of black culture in this country. But for him, it was something totally different, but he still knew to use the words in a way that would connect with the most amount of people, you know, because we can still I can connect to PASSING STRANGE and to being feeling like an outsider and to feeling like you don't belong.
Yeah, you know. I need something more than real. Someday the cords of age will drown out the life you've been dreaming of. Then you'll be out on your ass and cursing alas. Your song is just passing for love. My song was just passing for love. And you know, passing and passing it announcing. You know, in trying to, you know, you know, pretend to be whatever. Um, but yeah, I mean, you're a hundred percent right because I think that one of the things that Stu has written up, you know, has said very openly, it's it's a show about him passing for black. You know, it's like his black experience as a young black kid trying to pass as black, going to going to Germany and being like, you know, I'm, you know, I'm represent, you know, I represent this ghetto upbringing, and he actually had a really stable upper middle class suburban upbringing, and does not know what it's like to hustle for dimes on the mean streets of South Central and makes a huge joke about it.
It's really like it it's really like just hysterical and also really, you know, heart-wrenching because you know, from a black experience, you can, you know, we can not imagine what that's like, but we can imagine what it's like to try to be an artist and like pass for an artist. We're like to feel like you don't know what the hell you're doing, and then the minute somebody sees you and sees right through you, you're like, ah, I think I'm just gonna go from Amsterdam to Berlin real quick, you know.
[41:46] Joe Carroll: Right. I'm just gonna, I'm not gonna leave. I'm just gonna, you know, right when it's starting to feel real. I'm just gonna leave.
[41:52] Joe Carroll: Um, yeah, I mean, I love that passing phase, the whole that whole the end of the show. I mean, we're getting into fame, you know, our favorite lyrics, and again, there's way too many to count. But um, I finally found a home between the clicks of a metronome. So I finally found the home between the clicks of a metronome and the song you see. Could not relate to that more as a as a drummer, you know, like as a young kid, being like, that is that's that's ever that that one knocked me off my feet. I mean, there's just a thousand of these. So, like we could sit here talking about our favorite lyrics the whole, but like, you know, if it was any more real, it'd be fictional. Which is like that's the sort of shit we're living in now.
Like, if you if some of the shit that's happening in our lives, is like if we wrote it, you'd roll your eyes out. It'd be a it exactly, it'd be a bad movie. If you wrote the movie of the coronavirus, it would be a bad movie, you know. Um, you know, so I mean that's just you know, I love it. This one was great too. When when uh uh Mr. Franklin says to to the youth uh to Daniel Breaker, we're all freaks depending on the backdrop. Right. That to me is like exactly right. We're all freaks depending on the context, you know what I mean? That's just like so I love so real. And after so long feeling so alone, I feel like picking up the phone and calling up that place called home to say I found a brand new family where I can be that thing called me.
No more saying uncle to Uncle Sam. Um telling her just where I am. Calling me. Which has such a different context now because you feel like that could be on a Black Lives Matter poster today. Absolutely.
[44:02] Joe Carroll: You gotta go to you gotta go to another, you know, when he talks about James Baldwin and you know, you gotta go to another country to get to Giovanni's room. You know, like it's right now. We're talking about all the same shit and uh right right now. And so I think that's one of the you know, one of the parts of this that we were so excited to just talk about the show, like it is so culturally revel relevant, like just you know, I don't know, history repeats itself. You know, and I love um oh, culture, the idea that culture is cosmetic, right? Culture is cosmetic, yeah. Ideas are dependable, that's a nuova navig. Emotions are expendable because they aren't unique. Culture is cosmetic. Culture is cosmetic.
Culture is cosmetic, culture is cosmetic. What's inside is just a lie, but's inside is just a lie, what's inside is just a lot of people. Right. There's a whole thing about how we're trained, basically, how to have culture, what to think, right? And that's the same, it's interesting because that's exactly what they're singing about in South Pacific. You've got to be carefully taught in the same season. Right. But to think about it, it you know, that just has such depth and so many different contexts for it. Then just that, like what what you know, that whole thing, culture's cosmetic, what's inside your mind is a lie that has been taught to you by society to tell you that you need to buy a bunch of shit, you need to lurk a certain way, you need to uphold these ideals of a capitalist society that you don't even necessarily agree with, but you've been brainwashed up to this point. And it's like it doesn't even necessarily have that negative connotation to it. Like it also is the positive connotation.
[45:53] Joe Carroll: Right. A lie. That's not necessarily a lie, but it's like a thing that has been created that totally is not an original thought or may not be true. You know, it's just there's so much there that is relevant now. I I think that for for me too, like the the number one quote from this show, the number one lyric is in the movie. It's not on the album. He stands there and he says, you know what's weird when you wake up that morning and realize your entire adult life was based on the a decision made by a teenager. Right. A stoned teenager. And I'm like, anybody in our business? Yeah. He goes on to make a joke. I bet there's a lot of investment bankers in the house that know what I'm talking about.
It's just so real. Like I remember I'm like talking to 16-year-old Joe, and I'm like, really, really, dude? Real this is this is what you want to do. Was it worth it? Yeah, totally. Which is like, so there's just anyway, there's a there's a thousand of those, and I I have a whole list here, but I feel like we should maybe move on to another segment. Um, but I think you know, we these songs, Songs Thin O, the songs that always slap, the songs that are, you know, just if you need to feel just put on put on the you know, it's all right. Um because that's a huge part of it, you know, like asking, yeah. Like can't get out of my head. You know, it's the one that you hear, and you're like, oh, yeah.
[47:29] Dan Tracy: Well, we've we've been kind of talking about this already, but how do the themes hold on to the times? Um, what age the best and what age the worst. You know, I there's very little I think the stuff that ages the worst in it is is just that it's all still very relevant. That's what I was gonna say, too. It's just the same, like, you know, seeing talking about double consciousness and talking about you know all of the stuff that we're talking about that the black community deals with and is still dealing with, and it's like it's like, oh shit, it's this was just 2008, and I mean James Baldwin was writing about it 50 years ago and a hundred years before that, and you know, it's just still all the same. So I think that that's the thing that's the kind of the biggest bummer.
[48:14] Joe Carroll: I completely agree, and I would like add on like the references to Obama, you know, because this in this moment before he's even elected, can you imagine the amount of hope that this group of people would have had as artists in this space, hoping for something that might change, and here we are 12 years later, and it's like we're 12 years earlier. Like it's it's just it's all just doesn't age well. You're like, oh man, this hurts totally, totally. And I think one of the things that age the best for me was the like so often I find that like some of these movies about high school experience or like you know, I I was listening to an interview with with uh Jonah Hill uh and Terry Gross. Uh and Terry Gross was like this about uh no, well, it was about mid 90s, but it was about the line in Super Bad when he says, like, you know how girls get all fucked up and drink too much and and you know, make out with with guys, like we could be that mistake.
Basically promoting the idea that like they want women to drink so much that then they'll sleep with them or whatever. And Terry Gross was like, Don't you think that that's incredibly sexist and and promotes rape culture and you know all and he's like, absolutely like that that that line does not age well. Right. And almost famous when they're when they're driving the bus and you know, they're they're they drive past high school girls and they're like trying, you know, and they and the the part where like the kid, you know, the young reporter kisses um you know her unconscious body. There is some shit that really doesn't hold up, you know, 20 years later or whatever, in in the response to like a teenage and you know, a young person's sexual awakening sort of, you know what I mean?
And all of the sexual awakening in this show feels incredibly like uh applicable, but not shitty. I don't know. I wish I had a better way to say it. It just is like very it's it's exactly how you feel when you're 13, it's exactly how you feel when you're 20, but it's not gross, it's not misogynistic, it's not, it's just like it's about European free love, and it's about you know, there's a whole song where he says, you know, they're singing about threesomes. They sing a song, they're singing about threesomes, and they're you know, it's we just had sex, and it's about it's basically about him like desperately wanting to lose his virginity and Europeans just being like, Oh yeah, we'll have sex, whatever.
Right. Like, no big deal. And they're you know, I love that they're so nonchalant about the only thing I want. It's like that is that's how you feel when you're, you know, when you're 18 or 16 or you know, whatever.
[50:51] Dan Tracy: And it's not gross, right? You know what I mean? It's it's just so like it's gotta be the speculating, but it's gotta be the uh female collaboration, you know, we got two a female director and a female writer. You better believe that they're not they're not gonna sit by and watch something happen that that doesn't represent both sides of the gender spectrum, you know.
[51:12] Joe Carroll: Totally totally because super bad is that's that's a that is a tough example because you look at Super Bad, and that was the funniest thing I'd ever seen in my life in 2005. But you watch it now and you're like and you're like uh it's even worse some of the movies before that. Some of those early Appeton movies are like Yeah, yeah, exactly. Some stuff does not, but it also is a sign of the times. You have to like watch almost watch it through the lens of 2005 or 1985. Totally, you know. This is my favorite musical. Thank you for listening to me and Dan talk about my favorite musical. Um this is a time I feel like to celebrate the stuff that we love.
[51:51] Dan Tracy: Yeah. And if if you know, please like send us messages. Text we have the text number, we have we have DMs. Just if you like this stuff, if you want us to keep nerding out about shows this way, like please let us know what you like and what you don't, and what you shows you'd like us to talk about.
[52:07] Joe Carroll: Exactly. If you have a show that you think that you'd love to hear us talk about because you want to hear, you want to learn about it, or you want to hear us fight about it. I think there'll be eventually there'll be some shows that we can have words about, like when a couple weeks ago when we started dishing about wicked, you know. I think we could do an a wicked episode and really get into it, and that might be fun for people to listen to. It's just a break from the drudgery of the fact that we don't have an outlet right now. A lot of you have been writing us on Instagram and over text saying, you know, you're so happy that there's stuff to listen to at this time because you need an outlet.
And so we're trying to find opportunities to create that for you, and this is what we're doing. So any thoughts you might have on shows we should cover or things you want to hear about, or you know, if this is terrible and you want us to go back to the old format, that's fine too.
[53:00] Dan Tracy: I think eventually we want to bring guests on. Yes. Yeah, we'll have guests on to talk about their experience with the show, or even just people who love you know these shows, you know. Like um, I I really I think that we could talk about PASSING STRANGE again with somebody, you know, either who was in the original cast or somebody who just loves it, because that's gonna be a huge part of this too, to just like have other people's perspective. But God, I just if you if you just watch the movie, listen to the lyrics, they will shake you, they will they will make you feel, and the ending is just if you if anyone who has a mother, you know, anyone who's ever been a child, so everyone, um, it'll just make you it'll just wreck you. It'll just wreck you.
[53:46] Joe Carroll: Only love is real, Dan. That's right. If you wanted to know why Joe thought he had to be an asshole for most of his life, because he thought it would make him a better artist. Thanks, dude. No, it's the opposite. Oh, God, no. He's we've learned nothing. Is there nothing in this hour? Oh my god. So uh that's that's it. That's it. That's what we got. Um we leave listening to the end.
[55:22] Dan Tracy: Thank you for listening to Guys Who Like Musicals. We are produced by Dan Tracy and Joe Carroll, your hosts. You can find us on Instagram at Guys Who Like Musicals or on Twitter at Musical Guys. For more information about us or our show, please visit our new website at Guys Who Like Musicals dot com. You can find our merch store, our Patreon page, and more. Thanks for listening.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
