Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ This time around we are diving head-first into the magical waters of Cora Hoover Hooper’s town and breaking open the Cookie Jar as we explore Stephen Sondheim’s ‘Anyone Can Whistle.’ Often penned as his biggest flop, ‘Anyone Can Whistle’ has opened the doors for a ton of discussion and Jimi and Tommy never shy away from that... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
About
This time around we are diving head-first into the magical waters of Cora Hoover Hooper’s town and breaking open the Cookie Jar as we explore Stephen Sondheim’s ‘Anyone Can Whistle.’ Often penned as his biggest flop, ‘Anyone Can Whistle’ has opened the doors for a ton of discussion and Jimi and Tommy never shy away from that. Here they discuss what caused it to flop and why sometimes that can be a good thing, some of the genius music Sondheim wrote for the show and start the revolution - #MusicalTheatreNerdsUnite!
Anyone Can Whistle (Original Broadway Cast)
As we do with every Sondheim episode, check out his incredible collection of lyrics and attendant comments, principles, heresies, grudges, whines and anecdotes. A must-have for any musical theatre nerd.
For some more analysis about why it flopped check out Tommy’s video guide from his Sondheim September series.
If you’ve burned through your copy of the OBC and want more of the story, then it’s well worth checking out the Carnegie Hall recording starring Madeleine Kahn, narrated by Angela Lansbury herself!
One of the cut songs from ‘Anyone Can Whistle’ found a brilliant new home in Putting It Together. Here is Ruthie Henshall and Carol Burnett singing ‘There’s Always a Woman’ - the cut 11 o’clock number from the show.
For more of a deepdive into Angela Lansbury’s involvement in ‘Anyone Can Whistle’ check out Arthur Laurents’ book ‘Mainly on Directing.’
One of Jimi’s all-time favourite musical theatre writers, Scott Miller, says that ‘Anyone Can Whistle’ is “still a better musical than two thirds of what Broadway has turned out in the last fifty years.” Check out his write-up on this week’s musical here (as well as the rest of his books, he’s amazing!)
#MusicalTheatreNerdsUnite - let’s get it trending! We want people to join in the wonderful conversation that we have about musical theatre and nerd out alongside us. Be proud, unleash your nerd and help legitimise the art form that we all know and love!
What is YOUR all-time favourite Sondheim lyric? Let us know on Twitter!
If you’re not following us on Instagram come join in the party for some behind the scenes fun! Leave us a comment letting us know the kinds of things you want to see on here.
Have you got any big thoughts about ‘Anyone Can Whistle’ and what could’ve made it work? Come join the discussion over on our subreddit!
A Plutonic Quiz Question
Hades is hoppin’ in New York Theatre right now. When this show opens later this year, it will mark the third time the Greek god has “trod the boards” in 2019. What show?
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Tommy: Rumming and humming, rum and humming.
[0:02] Jimi: Rum and hum.
[0:04] Tommy: Rum rum punch and we can't do rum punch because we just did rum punch.
[0:09] Jimi: No, we did just rum punch.
[0:11] Tommy: Uh uh vodka and shmodka.
[0:16] Jimi: Umdka.
[0:18] Tommy: It's uh Swedish.
[0:20] Jimi: Um vodka stingers and Oh, and chorus line stingers!
[0:27] Tommy: Hey, there it is chorus singers.
[0:31] Jimi: Somebody get us another drink!
[0:33] Tommy: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's musical theater happy hour.
[0:36] Jimi: I'm Tommy.
[0:37] Jimi: And I'm Jimmy, and this is the only musical theater podcast with vodka stingers.
[0:42] Tommy: And chorus line singers.
[0:44] Jimi: Here it day.
[0:48] Tommy: You weren't you weren't gonna let me get past it.
[0:50] Jimi: You gotta turn off that lamp.
[0:52] Tommy: Um here, uh, we take apart your favorite shows, muddle them together with a shot of buffoonery, and pour you a refreshing glass of musical theater conversation.
[1:02] Jimi: Jimmy, what are you drinking today?
[1:04] Jimi: Well, Tommy, I uh decided on a delicious Oreo milkshake.
[1:12] Tommy: I was so expecting you to pick enchanted water.
[1:16] Jimi: Oh yeah, okay, that would work too.
[1:18] Tommy: That would work too.
[1:19] Jimi: No.
[1:20] Tommy: Why just cause I love cookies so much.
[1:23] Jimi: Oh, I got it.
[1:24] Tommy: Okay.
[1:25] Jimi: I don't even call them cookies.
[1:27] Tommy: That was for you, America.
[1:29] Jimi: That one was for you.
[1:30] Tommy: Why are you?
[1:30] Jimi: Did you call Oreos cookies?
[1:32] Tommy: Yes.
[1:33] Jimi: They're kind of cookies.
[1:35] Tommy: Would you would you not qualify them as a biscuit?
[1:38] Jimi: No, we do qualify them as a biscuit, but you guys are weird.
[1:40] Tommy: For us, biscuits are other things.
[1:41] Jimi: What do you call our kind of biscuits?
[1:43] Tommy: Have you ever had a a biscuit?
[1:45] Jimi: Yeah, I have.
[1:46] Tommy: It's like uh a kind of like it's basically a scone.
[1:50] Jimi: Oh, sure.
[1:51] Tommy: Like a clean scone.
[1:52] Jimi: But not it's it's like less sugar.
[1:55] Tommy: Yeah, but uh yeah, our scones have more sugar.
[1:57] Jimi: Um like our scones are dessert where biscuits you'd have with lunch, but a lot of desserts we have with lunch anyway.
[2:03] Tommy: Yeah anyway, Jimmy.
[2:04] Jimi: You have a quick question for us.
[2:06] Jimi: I do, I truly do.
[2:07] Jimi: Um hey Tommy, rumor has it that this musical is cursed.
[2:11] Jimi: During out of town tryouts, the ladies' bathroom in the theater caught on fire.
[2:17] Jimi: A dancer ran into the pit, injuring a saxophonist slash saxophonist, who would die of a heart attack after being rushed to the hospital, and the leading actor dropped dead in the wings during the second preview.
[2:32] Tommy: What show.
[2:33] Jimi: Jimmy, it sounds like we're gonna talk about anyone can whistle.
[2:37] Tommy: Everyone hates me.
[2:39] Jimi: Yes, yes.
[2:41] Tommy: Being the mayor.
[2:44] Jimi: Yes.
[2:46] Tommy: All of the peasants throw rocks in my presence, which causes me nervous distress.
[2:53] Jimi: Yes.
[2:55] Tommy: Ooh.
[3:03] Jimi: Me and my town.
[3:08] Jimi: Everyone in it would like to get out.
[3:12] Jimi: Me and my town, we just wanna be live.
[3:21] Jimi: Stores are for rent, theater's a dark, grass on the sidewalks, but not in the park.
[3:30] Jimi: Me and my town, we just wanna be lost the loo The people are stopping, so they sleep the day through my pool.
[3:53] Tommy: What can they do?
[3:57] Jimi: Lost you.
[3:59] Tommy: Not you.
[4:01] Jimi: Definitely not.
[4:03] Tommy: So I used to be able to.
[4:05] Jimi: Yeah.
[4:05] Jimi: And then you make them just very bad.
[4:07] Jimi: And you listen to the show and then it it That's not bad.
[4:12] Tommy: It just when I get high breathy.
[4:13] Jimi: It's not bad.
[4:14] Jimi: I can whistle.
[4:15] Jimi: The the uh off off forgotten Sontime September one-off vlogs um all begin and end with me whistling uh a bit of a Saundheim number.
[4:28] Tommy: That was you whistling.
[4:29] Jimi: That was me whistling in every single one of those.
[4:31] Jimi: Um that was good whistling.
[4:34] Tommy: A bizarre, bizarre recording session of me just sitting in my in my room being like, well, now my lips are dry, I can't do it.
[4:45] Jimi: That was breathy.
[4:52] Tommy: So what is it?
[4:52] Tommy: What's the skill of whistling?
[4:55] Jimi: But there's a whole musical about it.
[4:56] Tommy: Haven't you listened?
[4:58] Jimi: Nah.
[4:59] Jimi: I I blew my teeth.
[5:00] Jimi: I've got an open bait, everyone.
[5:02] Tommy: That might be part of it.
[5:03] Jimi: It has lots of mouth shape.
[5:06] Tommy: Yeah, mine is weird.
[5:08] Jimi: Fun facts.
[5:09] Tommy: Anyway.
[5:10] Tommy: So this episode we're just gonna talk about how to whistle.
[5:14] Jimi: No, anyone can whistle.
[5:15] Jimi: Um is a uh I would say short-lived uh musical.
[5:19] Jimi: That's a word, yeah.
[5:20] Jimi: By Stephen Sondheim, music and Lyrics, and book and direction by Arthur Laurents.
[5:25] Jimi: It premiered on Broadway way back in 1964.
[5:28] Tommy: This was basically Sondheim's second folly into doing it all himself.
[5:33] Jimi: Yes, yes, it was.
[5:34] Jimi: And yeah, it was nominated at the Tony's uh for best choreography.
[5:39] Tommy: Well done, Sondheim.
[5:40] Jimi: Which is surprising because it played for uh basically a week.
[5:44] Tommy: Um I think it's like nine performances.
[5:44] Jimi: Nine performances.
[5:49] Tommy: Yep.
[5:50] Jimi: The the joke in uh uh finishing the is that uh there were more uh producer-backer auditions than there were performances for the actual show.
[6:01] Tommy: It's such a shame.
[6:03] Jimi: It is.
[6:03] Jimi: Uh, but since it's floppage, um it has had uh kind of a cult following.
[6:09] Tommy: There was a very notable 1995 Benefit uh concert at Carnegie Hall.
[6:14] Jimi: There was an encore's performance in the beginning of the aughts.
[6:17] Tommy: Um, and you know, people love songs from this show, I would say.
[6:23] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, like uh I would say anyone can whistle and everybody says don't are too iconic Sondheim songs.
[6:31] Tommy: Absolutely.
[6:31] Jimi: Uh from a musical, you know, the only had nine performances.
[6:35] Tommy: That's pretty impressive.
[6:36] Jimi: That's very impressive.
[6:37] Jimi: I I a lot of this stuff uh, you know, has seen itself recast in the bevy of uh Sondheim revivals and jukebox musicals that are out there.
[6:46] Tommy: So it certainly has gained a life of its own, even despite being such a uh a minor blip otherwise in the the Broadway compendium.
[6:55] Jimi: Indeed, oh um I think uh in order to say what it's about, let's hear from the man himself, shall we?
[7:02] Tommy: Yeah, I just have Sondheim in my room.
[7:06] Jimi: Here it is.
[7:08] Tommy: Now you could do your Sondheim voice and make everyone believe that he's here.
[7:11] Jimi: I was expecting you to like shake awake a a a bearded old man be like, What do you want?
[7:11] Tommy: What do you want?
[7:17] Jimi: What do you like?
[7:18] Tommy: You're like garbing a home to I think that's how he sang it in his part.
[7:29] Tommy: She doesn't sing like that at all.
[7:30] Jimi: No, but you've got a lovely voice.
[7:31] Jimi: You sound like uh Christine Petty doing her Elaine Stritch impression.
[7:35] Tommy: Yes, I do.
[7:36] Tommy: I absolutely do.
[7:39] Jimi: Right.
[7:39] Jimi: Okay.
[7:40] Jimi: So anyone can whistle.
[7:44] Jimi: A fanciful story about a small, economically depressed American town whose Venal mayoress.
[7:51] Tommy: Venal?
[7:52] Jimi: Venal?
[7:53] Tommy: I think Xenol.
[7:54] Jimi: I think I looked that one up after I got in trouble for mispronouncing words on the internet.
[7:58] Tommy: Let's go for Phenol.
[7:59] Jimi: Um gets the bright idea of arranging a fake miracle to attract tourists.
[8:05] Jimi: The tourists arrive, but they become intermixed with the inmates of the local cookie jar.
[8:11] Tommy: A rest home for non-conformists.
[8:13] Jimi: Farcical complications ensue.
[8:17] Tommy: Oh boy.
[8:20] Jimi: Easy as that, right?
[8:21] Tommy: Right.
[8:22] Jimi: God, I think that synopsis might be as succinct as you can get a description of this show.
[8:28] Tommy: And also misses vast swaths of the plot of this show.
[8:33] Jimi: What misses out like two whole plots in the show, basically.
[8:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[8:37] Jimi: Um but also are those plots important?
[8:39] Tommy: A good question.
[8:40] Jimi: A good question that we will discuss.
[8:43] Tommy: We should.
[8:44] Jimi: Um so yeah, what are these other little plots?
[8:46] Tommy: Yeah, well.
[8:50] Tommy: These are the little plots.
[8:50] Jimi: So that's so patronizing.
[8:51] Jimi: These are the little tiny plots that well, in the in the um I don't know if it's in the distinct libretto or if it just exists in uh the God, I don't even know which recording I heard it in.
[9:04] Jimi: But there's one point in act three where uh Cora Hoover Hooper says um I think to her cronies, like, Oh boys, looks like we need another plot complication or something to that effect.
[9:16] Tommy: And it's like in the middle of plant of of act three, and it's very much like, wow, the the action of this musical sure is stalling.
[9:23] Jimi: What other complications can we introduce?
[9:26] Tommy: Yep.
[9:27] Jimi: Oh man.
[9:28] Tommy: It's also like because the show didn't play for long and and had kind of a rough out-of-town try-out session.
[9:35] Jimi: There's a bunch of songs that like were cut but then put back in, but then cut, but then exist, and so like aren't very adequately woven into the book, but people perform and all the concert revision, so like part of the plot doesn't even make sense around some of the songs.
[9:49] Tommy: Like there won't be trumpets and um uh the woman song.
[9:54] Jimi: Um there's always a woman.
[9:57] Tommy: Um but generally I think you know, Cora Hoover Hooper, uh the the venial mayoress um wants to create a mil miracle in her town.
[10:08] Jimi: She is diametrically opposed to Faye Apple, who is the the chair of the cookie jar.
[10:15] Jimi: She's in charge of all these they never they never say mentally disturbed people.
[10:18] Tommy: They always say like use words like people ostracized from society or people on the outside of society, which is an interesting category that like it's important, but they are really general with it's not it's not the same as the inmates at Fog's Asylum and Sweeney Todd, for example.
[10:36] Jimi: Exactly.
[10:37] Jimi: Like they've got something more complex wrong with them, or maybe nothing wrong with them.
[10:42] Tommy: Yes.
[10:42] Jimi: But maybe that's the point.
[10:44] Jimi: But so Korra manufactures this miracle where a girl licks a stone on the outside of town and water comes from it.
[10:51] Jimi: It sounds it is as bizarre as it sounds.
[10:55] Tommy: Tourists flock.
[10:56] Jimi: But the cookies from the cookie jar go to drink the water, and the people of the town are or the leadership of the town are nervous that if these people aren't cured by the water, then it'll disprove the miracle.
[11:15] Tommy: And in the mayhem, the tourists of the town get confused with the cookies, and Hapgood uh eludicates the fact that we all might be crazy, and it's hard to tell the difference between group one and group A.
[11:29] Jimi: That ends act one.
[11:31] Jimi: Uh uh group A and group one are now these opposing factions in this town.
[11:38] Tommy: Uh uh Cora Hoover Hooper doesn't know what to do.
[11:42] Jimi: Uh Faye Apple dresses up as a French lady.
[11:47] Tommy: Yeah, time for plot number two.
[11:49] Jimi: Right.
[11:49] Jimi: Uh ostensibly in order to seduce Hapgood, but also because she can't get out of the state.
[11:54] Tommy: Shout needs to write a French witticism.
[11:57] Jimi: Yeah, and she can't get out of her like by the rules world unless she puts on this costume that I think in the in the book she says was from a college production she was in, which is like an awfully weird justification for this.
[12:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:12] Jimi: Um we discover that Faye can't whistle.
[12:16] Jimi: Um intrinsic.
[12:19] Tommy: Very important to the show.
[12:21] Jimi: Uh Hapgood encourages Faye to rip up the records of the cookies from the cookie jar so that no one can figure out who they are.
[12:29] Tommy: Thus ends Act 2.
[12:32] Jimi: We move on to Act 3.
[12:34] Jimi: They try to find all the cookies in some versions of the show.
[12:39] Tommy: Faye disguises herself as Kora for some reason.
[12:43] Jimi: We've also learned that Hapgood was not a doctor, but is actually the 50th cookie that's supposed to be in the cookie jar.
[12:50] Tommy: And we need to get all the cookies back in the cookie jar because otherwise we're gonna lose our government funding for the cookie jar, which is the only way this town's getting money anymore.
[12:57] Jimi: Money, yeah.
[12:58] Tommy: Um a bunch of cookies, or not cookies get caught, but then escape.
[13:03] Jimi: Faye Apple's replacement finally arrives, and she's much more by the books than even Faye herself is, and then Faye and Hapgood tr run away together, and water actually comes out of the stone, I think.
[13:19] Tommy: Yep.
[13:19] Jimi: So if you'd like to get in touch with us, you can uh follow us on Twitter.
[13:24] Tommy: Yeah, you know, tell me tell me the plot points you think I missed out on.
[13:28] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, I think that was very impressive.
[13:30] Tommy: It does.
[13:31] Tommy: And you weren't even reading that from anything.
[13:33] Jimi: So I literally wasn't.
[13:35] Jimi: Um the uh do you have the card game Apples to Apples?
[13:40] Tommy: No, I do know what it is, though.
[13:42] Tommy: Where you like pick different ones and you have to compare them to each other.
[13:45] Jimi: It's cards against humanity, isn't it?
[13:47] Tommy: It's cards against humanity, but for children.
[13:49] Jimi: Yes.
[13:50] Jimi: This musical feels like someone pulled like 10 apples for apples cards and like forced themselves to write a musical about it, plot wise.
[13:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:59] Jimi: It's it it's a lot of ideas.
[14:01] Tommy: It's a lot of ideas, and there's not.
[14:04] Jimi: It is interesting to read Sondheim wax poetic about it in finishing the um because he does a lot of uh both self-flagellation and self-justification.
[14:15] Jimi: Um, he certainly knows it was a flop. Um, but he blames a lot of it on direction, which sure, certainly. Um, but like it's just a mess. The whole thing's just a mess. It's a total mess. Um, quite auspicious that we just covered Suessical.
[14:36] Tommy: Sure.
[14:36] Jimi: Uh, because you know, we said that the book of that was also a mess, but I feel in it's in the converse.
[14:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[14:43] Jimi: Like they're both messes, but they're very different messes. Suessical was like, um, let's take all of this fun stuff and put it in.
[14:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[14:51] Jimi: This is like let's take all of these things that we really want to write about and put it in.
[14:58] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, so Suessical was more like ideas and trivial and fun.
[15:04] Jimi: Right. This is like we have so much to say. We have a point. We want to shoehorn it all in all into one show.
[15:10] Tommy: Yeah, without a big theme underneath it.
[15:13] Jimi: And it made for a very, you know, that all all of the reviews, all of the literature about this called a very audience hostile piece.
[15:20] Tommy: Yes.
[15:21] Jimi: Um, and I think because of that and because of its confusingness, it did not do very well.
[15:21] Tommy: It did not do well.
[15:29] Jimi: Um, let's work out why.
[15:33] ♪ Musical number ♪
[16:20] Tommy: It's almost like where do you begin? And it's interesting, actually, as Tommy and I were writing out our notes for this. Um, we were like, okay, well, we should obviously start with the fact, like, yes, it's a flop, and we'll work out why. And then we realize that all of our notes were in that section.
[16:33] Jimi: Right.
[16:33] Tommy: Because basically, everything about this in some way contributes to it not working.
[16:40] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely. And it is fascinating watching, like, unlike some other notorious flops that you see on Broadway, where it is much easier to pinpoint, like, oh, this artist was the one who is full of themselves, or here was the part where they didn't put enough, uh, you know, audience preview or whatever into this to like rewrite and write this thing.
[17:03] Jimi: Like they did out-of-town previews. They rewrote, they recast, they retried a whole bunch of things.
[17:10] Tommy: Yep.
[17:11] Jimi: And this show did not end does not work. And I maintained does not work, which is a shame for a lot of reasons, but you're not gonna see a Broadway revival of Anyone Can Whistle, unless like Sondheim comes out and is like, all right, we're ripping big pages out.
[17:25] Tommy: Yeah, and that's never that isn't gonna happen.
[17:28] Jimi: It's never gonna happen. Um, yeah, you're completely right. This, this does it, it doesn't work. There's no like, ah, but if you look at it in this light, right, then it's fine. And that there's just there's no scope for that. There's too much.
[17:39] Tommy: And not to say that we're not gonna spend about 50 more minutes, uh, laying out like, oh, but if you look at it this way, you can see these themes.
[17:48] Jimi: Yes, absolutely. That is the tragic part about this, is you can see it underneath there. You can see what they were trying to say, maybe.
[17:56] Tommy: But well, the thing is is like Sondheim and Arthur Laurents are just too good of two good geniuses, yeah, not for this to have some kind of substance in it somewhere.
[18:05] Jimi: Sure. Um, the curse was is they were just a bit too young, they were still a bit too fresh, particularly Sondheim.
[18:12] Tommy: Absolutely.
[18:12] Jimi: Um, obviously Arthur Laurents had done a fair amount, uh, by this point.
[18:17] Tommy: Yeah, but this was him, he was really, really passionate about, uh, both writing the book and directing, yeah, despite much warning from very reputable people.
[18:27] Jimi: Yes.
[18:28] Tommy: Um, he yeah, I think he wanted that kind of Jerry Robbins flavor of like, you know, I am look at me and I can do this.
[18:37] Jimi: Right.
[18:37] Tommy: Uh, and I don't think at this time I don't think he cared.
[18:41] Jimi: No, and I think doesn't the story go that David Merrick was on board to produce it but would only produce it if Arthur Laurents wouldn't direct it.
[18:48] Tommy: Exactly, because he was like, it just doesn't work. You need that third voice there to critique and to, uh, work things out when it's just you and you alone, yeah.
[19:00] Jimi: Um, there's just no scope for it. And Sondheim in finishing that, he cites quite a lot of other people as having the same issue. Weirdly he says James Lapine never had that issue, and yeah.
[19:11] Tommy: Uh, but um, I will I will say, and I think we've talked about this plenty. There are you find in musical theater very few, you know, renaissance people of musical theater. They're not a lot of people in this business that do it alone.
[19:25] Jimi: Um, James Lapine wears diverse hats often from time to time, um, uh, Meredith Wilson, um, and then contemporarily Lin-Manuel Miranda.
[19:35] Tommy: Um, but other than that, as I like scan through my brain, you don't get a lot of things.
[19:43] Jimi: Well, I think there's not there's certainly not a lot, it's certainly not the done thing.
[19:47] Tommy: Yeah, you know, uh there are obviously examples all the way through, and I'm sure everyone is gonna tell us all that's seriously on Reddit right now.
[19:54] Jimi: Yeah, um, you know, Dave Malloy.
[19:55] Tommy: Hey, why um but the uh the thing is here is that it people were giving him this advice. I think that's where this is where the issues start to come through, and where you start to see some of the reasons why this might not have worked.
[20:12] Jimi: Um, because really the chief fault, the principal fault, or the thing that could be so easily fixed is the book.
[20:20] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely.
[20:21] Jimi: Because the, uh, the songs people still sing, let's be honest.
[20:25] Tommy: Definitely, and but there's just there's too many, there's too many strands in that book, and I wonder if Arthur Laurents wasn't directing it and wasn't, you know, so passionate about oh, I want I can't wait till I direct this bit and get the story out of this bit.
[20:40] Jimi: Um, if he would be able to, I don't know, even just kill a few more of his darlings because someone's saying he might be able to see actually this doesn't work, right?
[20:51] Tommy: Yeah, that is because he has that detachment, but right, because you're built from inside of it.
[20:56] Jimi: Um, you know, it is also I find it interesting. So this was the 18th Tony Awards.
[21:01] Tommy: Um, and the nominations for best musical that year were Hello Dolly, Funny Girl, High Spirits, which I don't know, and then She Loves Me.
[21:11] Jimi: Um, and so certainly the flavor of Broadway was in a different place then.
[21:17] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:18] Jimi: Um, and interestingly, like the last time I approached this during Sondheim September, a decade and a half ago, um, a lot of what I fell into was kind of the opposite conclusion of that, that like Broadway might have been ready for something newer and more subversive, but was kind of past the particular brand of subversiveness that Sondheim and Laurents were working towards.
[21:41] Tommy: Um, that's true.
[21:42] Jimi: You did yeah. Kind of moved.
[21:44] Tommy: Yeah, because you were like looking towards Hair, weren't you?
[21:46] Jimi: Right. We're moving the, the whole thesis is we're moving from the beatniks, who I think are the cookies in, uh, Whistle towards the hippies of Hair.
[21:56] Tommy: Um, and I think that's true. I don't know, like I will I look back at that video and I I don't disagree with it.
[22:03] Jimi: Um, it's just interesting because also none of the other musicals on that list are any kind of sociopolitical commentary, like no, not at all.
[22:13] Tommy: Like at this at this point in time, Broadway was embracing the integrated book musical.
[22:18] Jimi: Do you know? I mean, they were loving their Hello Dolly, they were loving their Fiddler's, you know. This is this is the time.
[22:25] Tommy: Yeah, you know, I mean, in many ways, this is like the new golden age.
[22:29] Jimi: The renaissance for that sort of thing.
[22:31] Tommy: Absolutely. Um, and it it it's what I find quite interesting is uh how kind of quick Sondheim was to jump on this bandwagon um because of his reasons for writing for him.
[22:45] Jimi: Yes, so Forum had just perceived this, I think like two years before.
[22:49] Tommy: Yeah, not not long before.
[22:50] Jimi: Um, yeah, a brief moment before, um, and Sondheim wanted to write it because as like an antidote to the integrated book musical.
[23:01] Tommy: Right.
[23:02] Jimi: He wanted to write that as like just a fun night at the theater, you could come, you could laugh, and you could have a great old time.
[23:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:08] Jimi: Um, and then the next thing he comes out with is a big massive F you to the integrated book musical where it's like, no, let's make a statement.
[23:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:21] Jimi: Excuse me, let's make a statement, let's get high concept.
[23:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:25] Jimi: And that is what a strange turnaround to have. And to be what what I read that as, what I kind of mentally analyze that is someone who knows they're fantastic and has four million ideas and knows how to fix everything.
[23:41] Tommy: Right.
[23:42] Jimi: There's a lot of, uh, unchecked ego there. Um, not that I don't think Sondheim isn't deserving of his ego, but we we all need some bounds around that.
[23:52] Tommy: Absolutely.
[23:53] Jimi: The man's a god, you know. But and it's the thing is is what what I quite love about it is he learned.
[23:59] Tommy: Yeah.
[24:00] Jimi: Oh yeah. Anyone Can Whistle is that the spark that ignited us so we could get Company.
[24:06] Tommy: Yeah, I think we are in many ways lucky that Sondheim flopped so early.
[24:10] Jimi: Um, and didn't have a chance to be like imagine if this show had done well. He w his ego would have become unstoppable.
[24:16] Tommy: Um, and it would have been such a crushing defeat for when something eventually did flop.
[24:21] Jimi: Um, it is intri I find it interesting the comparison between the very musical theatriness of Forum and the decidedly not musical theater of this, or maybe that's the wrong way to put it, but in rereading in the in prep for this, um, one of the things Sondheim talks about is uh the very first song, Me and My Town, uh Cora Hoover Hooper's song.
[24:42] Tommy: Um, I'm gonna say all three of her names every time. Don't you worry about it.
[24:44] Jimi: That's great. Um, but he says of the song, this was my first attempt to use musical comedy pastiche as a means of characterization.
[24:56] Tommy: Uh, uh here it was an attempt to convey Korra's heartlessness through the use of a slick jazzy showbiz style, exemplified by Kate Thompson and the William brothers.
[25:05] Jimi: Um, and like fascinating, and I don't want to do too much psychoanalysis that Sondheim is using the decidedly musical theater sound to underscore who was the person who is the villain of this show.
[25:20] Tommy: Um yeah, that's true, that's interesting.
[25:23] Jimi: Which had never crossed my mind previously.
[25:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[25:25] Jimi: And it that is I mean, but uh all of the you know, in um, uh if you if you you can always lean on me, you didn't lean on me.
[25:32] Tommy: Yeah, whatever they are.
[25:33] Jimi: I never remember the names of the songs in the show.
[25:34] Tommy: I've got you to lean on.
[25:36] Jimi: There it is.
[25:36] Tommy: With I've got you to with I've got you to lean on um as well, like it reads as, you know, it's it's two lost souls, yeah, it's um friendship, it's that buddy, you know, that buddy song.
[25:48] Jimi: Yeah, uh you can always count on me. Like it's yeah, it it's all of that um rolled into one, and again that musical theater trope being used for the villains.
[25:58] Tommy: The villain, quote unquote, yeah.
[25:59] Jimi: Yeah. Which it you know, I wonder I'm sure that wasn't forefront in his mind, but as a as a back reading analysis, it is an interesting thing.
[26:10] Tommy: Well, because in the in the converse of that, uh and we'll we'll go on to talk about the music a little bit more, um, but uh he also has you know, we first get to see Sondheim's romantic songs in this musical.
[26:24] Jimi: This is the first thing because they didn't really exist in Forum.
[26:27] Tommy: No, I mean this is I think one of the reasons Anyone Can Whistle has stayed such a a cult following um, uh filled piece is because it is one of the first pieces where we're really starting to hear Sondheim solidify his sound.
[26:43] Jimi: Um, it's the first time he attempts like a really integrated music and acting number, it's the first time he attempts a lot of these things.
[26:51] Tommy: Um, and were Sondheim not, you know, a ridiculously famous musical theatre artist afterwards, this would be nothing but a blip and a uh a page full of trunk songs instead of a music musical that we're talking about on the podcast.
[27:04] Jimi: Yeah, completely.
[27:05] Tommy: Yeah, it's it's nice.
[27:06] Jimi: It's sort of like the archive, the Sondheim archive where you get to see the raw materials.
[27:10] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:10] Jimi: Um, and that's that is just generally what it feels like. It feels like this might sound really condescending to say, but it just it feels like someone who was really young, um, who did have loads of ideas and who was extremely talented and had a lot of people telling him, You're very talented.
[27:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:23] Jimi: Um and then be like, okay, well, here's my talent.
[27:26] Tommy: Right.
[27:26] Jimi: Um that's kind of undeniable. You know, I mean, there's there's there is so much good in this and in the music, and the raw materials are great, they just need honing.
[27:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:37] Jimi: Um, and I feel like we eventually got there. Do you know I mean I feel like you polish Anyone Can Whistle down enough and you angle grind it and everything, right?
[27:47] Tommy: And out pops Company.
[27:48] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. That's a good thing. That's still genuinely the way I feel. Like, I know no, obviously they're completely different shows, but the idea of like taking a concept and making a statement um and using a blend of musical pastiche and romantic songs, yeah, um, and ending on a a bittersweet you know, question mark.
[28:06] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:06] Jimi: Um, all of these things exist in Anyone Can Whistle.
[28:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:09] Jimi: They're just not as honed.
[28:11] Tommy: They're just yep, they as they became.
[28:13] Jimi: So much more scattershot, and there's not enough. There's too many yes men around you, and not enough people like accurately critiquing your work in a way that can be heard and acted upon.
[28:22] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:23] Jimi: Which is the depth to any artist.
[28:25] Tommy: Absolutely.
[28:27] Jimi: One of the one of the things as well that I think and what might have been going through his head, I get he's never said it, but I love to just like sit in Sondheim's head.
[28:37] Jimi: Sure.
[28:39] Tommy: But obviously one of his biggest mentors was Oscar Hammerstein.
[28:44] Jimi: And uh one of Oscar Hammerstein's only major flops was Allegro.
[28:52] Tommy: Sure, yeah. Um, which many people cite as the first concept musical and it flopped because it was ahead of its time.
[28:58] Jimi: I'm inverting comments here, ahead of its time and too high concept and trying to say too much.
[29:04] Tommy: Um this is what I'm this is what I'm seeing in Sort of said. So here's my mentor, here's his thing that he did wrong.
[29:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[29:13] Tommy: I've learned from him, I can fix that.
[29:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[29:16] Tommy: I can fix Allegro.
[29:18] Jimi: Yeah.
[29:18] Tommy: Um, I know how to do it. And out pops the cog starting to turn for anyone can whistle of I can write a concept musical here.
[29:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[29:28] Tommy: Um I will be able to, you know, twist the musical genre as we know it into something new, yeah.
[29:38] Jimi: Um, and create this and fix what my mentor couldn't create.
[29:42] Tommy: Because if you if you successfully do that, yeah, then you've you've succeeded.
[29:46] Jimi: Yeah. Do you wonder?
[29:49] Tommy: I have wondered this sometimes, but I don't know if I've ever been able to put the right words around it.
[29:54] Jimi: If we are beyond the point of any musical reaching any kind of listenability or performability where that musical is what we would call ahead of its time.
[30:08] Tommy: So to say this is why I've struggled putting words around this.
[30:11] Jimi: I think I know what you mean.
[30:13] Tommy: So are you trying to say nowadays, as now, contemporary, um we've kind of heard it all almost?
[30:19] Jimi: Like it's that there's gonna be nothing that is like this isn't working right now in ten years.
[30:26] Tommy: Yeah, that like I think we've we've we have tuned the system very well so that we're not gonna see something so daring as to be ahead of its time.
[30:40] Jimi: Like the stuff we see is ahead of its time in the most appropriate ways.
[30:46] Tommy: Like Hamilton absolutely is ahead of its time and was very specifically ahead of its time right when it came out in a way that people very much appreciated.
[30:59] Jimi: Whereas something like anyone can whistle, we could describe as ahead of its time.
[31:04] Tommy: Um or I would say even company in many ways, a lot of the revivals of company, I think are much better than the original production.
[31:10] Jimi: Um but company was just on the right side of that seesaw, whereas anyone can whistle wasn't, whereas uh Allegro wasn't, whereas a lot of these musicals weren't ju like they were too far ahead of their time.
[31:27] Tommy: They were too ambitious.
[31:31] Jimi: Yeah. Their ideas were just too fruitful.
[31:35] Tommy: Yeah, like too untethered, too, you know, not as well honed, and I think we have certainly built the like musical theater creating machine to prevent these problems.
[31:47] Jimi: Um, Great Comet didn't come to Broadway until it was ready, you know?
[31:52] Tommy: Um But it's still the Great Comet from Ars Nova to the Great Comet and Broadway wasn't so dramatically different.
[32:03] Jimi: Sure, okay, Hades Town from Hades Town is a good one because it is very dramatically different.
[32:08] Tommy: From from the first like back a bar performances through Toronto through the what you know, West End and back.
[32:15] Jimi: Um like But the thing is though, is um Great Comet, it wasn't a flop.
[32:21] Tommy: Hades Town definitely wasn't a flop, isn't a flop.
[32:24] Jimi: Um so I think we would need to look at the flops.
[32:26] Tommy: I think we would need to be like scandalous with a head risk.
[32:30] Jimi: I know what's what's the flop that we missed that was ahead of its time?
[32:33] Tommy: Was it transit ahead of its time?
[32:35] Jimi: Like maybe well we were there, we were there.
[32:40] Tommy: That's the thing I I mean, like in our in our post-Disney mega musical Phantom of the Opera Broadway, yeah.
[32:47] Jimi: You know, we're not gonna see maybe we're heading back to that with the Hades Towns and the Great Comets and even the elements of the day.
[32:54] Tommy: People are now really trying to experiment, and uh it it has come as a response to the big mouse taking over New York.
[33:03] Jimi: Sure. Um of people being like, Yeah, I know we've heard that in the same way that Sondheim's like, yeah, no, we've heard the integrated book musical.
[33:11] Tommy: Right.
[33:12] Jimi: And he tried two very, very distinct ways of combating it.
[33:15] Tommy: You know, we'll go old school, okay. That okay, we'll go new school, very new school.
[33:20] Jimi: Right.
[33:20] Tommy: Um until he finds his balance.
[33:22] Jimi: Yeah. I don't know.
[33:23] Tommy: I don't I don't know.
[33:25] Jimi: It uh but there is also the element of have we heard it all?
[33:29] Tommy: What else is there?
[33:30] Jimi: What else is there in musical theater?
[33:32] Tommy: Yeah. I mean, we I you know Great Comet was surprising. I'm still ready to be surprised every season.
[33:37] Jimi: Um I think Moby Dick will surprise a lot of people.
[33:40] Tommy: Yeah, sure.
[33:41] Jimi: Um I think it really will. Um and I you know, on paper, Moby Dick is not going to work on Broadway for a long, long time.
[33:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:50] Jimi: So perhaps maybe that's ahead of its time.
[33:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:53] Jimi: I don't know. Who knows?
[33:54] Tommy: It uh you know six, I think, is surprising in interesting ways.
[33:59] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[34:00] Tommy: It's definitely not ahead of its time.
[34:01] Jimi: I don't think it's ahead of its time, but it it is rewriting the script as to it is.
[34:06] Tommy: I would say I would say it's on the pulse.
[34:08] Jimi: Yeah, it's certainly on the pulse.
[34:10] Tommy: But like an an intellectual pop commentary is new.
[34:13] Jimi: Like it's it is it is the intellectualism of Hamilton meets the the pop catchiness of Mamma Mia, um which no one has tried yet.
[34:22] Tommy: Um whenever we see a flop that comes back up like this that has somehow stuck around and isn't lost to you know, the mysteries of time and uh Feinstein's fifty-four below concert readings.
[34:36] Jimi: Um it is always fascinating to me is like why did this flop but still stick around?
[34:42] Tommy: Yeah.
[34:43] Jimi: Why was this bad then, but we still listen to it now? And like teasing that out, I think says something a lot about the the musical theater string through the ages.
[34:52] Tommy: Yeah. It's it's interesting actually you say that because I think um uh being a flop can be quite valuable yeah to a show.
[35:02] Jimi: Like being a big flop.
[35:04] Tommy: I think only in only since the eighties, let's say.
[35:09] Jimi: Um How do you mean?
[35:11] Tommy: Only uh only since the advent of the internet, only since our kind of remix revive culture um I don't know though I because I don't mean in terms of revivals I just mean in terms of cult status because sure um you know anyone can whistle would be that cash recording that you're like oh there it is I'm gonna get that because that's that's a gem.
[35:33] Jimi: Yeah you know see you have you watched um uh Bathtubs Over Broadway we're gonna get kind of tangential here for a second.
[35:41] Tommy: Uh let's do it.
[35:42] Jimi: Uh have you watched Bathtubs over Broadway?
[35:44] Tommy: You should um it is about it's on Netflix.
[35:47] Jimi: Um highly recommended but to watch uh I enjoyed it less than I wanted to um it is about one of David Letterman's uh staff comedy writers um and the whole narrative starts with him uh expressing this sorrow that he has experienced this kind of comedy death that when you live in comedy for so long like as a job it becomes really really difficult to find things funny or novel anymore because you've kind of experienced it all.
[36:19] Tommy: And in the course of trying to you know tease the minds of human comedy um also living in New York one of the things he keeps finding are these uh old records of what were called industrial musicals um and so they'd be like you know Ford Motor Company employs a bunch of people to write and perform in a musical for their uh salesmen who and they would come and see this musical all about how great Ford is, or how how about how great Maytag dishwashers are, or we've talked about this our medical supply companies are.
[36:57] Jimi: Yeah, we talked about this in ragtime because of Ford.
[37:00] Tommy: Yes.
[37:00] Jimi: But just briefly touched on it.
[37:02] Tommy: Yes, that's this is coming back to me.
[37:03] Jimi: And so it is his exploration of like tracking down these records and then the people who did them, and they're the same people we know.
[37:12] Tommy: Susan Strowman cut her teeth directing these things.
[37:14] Jimi: Bach and Harnick also got their start writing industrial musicals.
[37:18] Tommy: Um like you watch this thing and you're like, I recognize all these people, and it was a way to pay the bills.
[37:24] Jimi: Um because they were these big high production numbers, and so it becomes this, you know, then journey of that this guy goes on to like collect all these really non-collectible records.
[37:34] Tommy: And there are some catchy songs on there, right?
[37:38] Jimi: My point being, you've never heard any of them.
[37:42] Tommy: They have not reached that cult status.
[37:45] Jimi: Maybe they will a little bit now that this documentary exists, but they were in enough people's brains and exant enough that they could have burst that bubble of cult status, but people aren't clammon it clamoring to you know get their um hands on my new bathtub, the great hit from uh DuPont or whoever.
[38:06] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:07] Jimi: Um so I do think being a flop can be a benefit to a musical, but it there's a there's a particular set of boxes you have to tick.
[38:20] Tommy: Not every flop can pull that like switcheroo.
[38:24] Jimi: Yeah, I I do agree with you. I think but I think one of the things that really helps it is being a big flop.
[38:30] Tommy: You know what I mean?
[38:31] Jimi: Like having nine days.
[38:33] Tommy: Right.
[38:34] Jimi: Turn off the dark.
[38:35] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:36] Jimi: Not a not a flop officially.
[38:39] Tommy: Well, yeah.
[38:40] Jimi: Yeah, I guess.
[38:41] Tommy: But infamous for its own.
[38:42] Jimi: But infamous for its own reasons.
[38:44] Tommy: I see your point.
[38:44] Jimi: Like yeah, like it's got it it's almost like they're USP.
[38:48] Tommy: Yeah, sure.
[38:49] Jimi: The the like the the the meta the meta theatricality around the whole thing buoys it more than the floppage of it.
[39:00] Tommy: Yes, it more than the floppage of it.
[39:03] Jimi: That is brilliant. Um yeah, because like, you know, something yeah, yeah, it it it is that because something like Tuck Everlasting.
[39:10] Tommy: Right, um, which is like a contemporary kind of damp squib, like it's nice enough.
[39:15] Jimi: It's nice enough, people love it for good reason, but it didn't do well.
[39:18] Tommy: Yeah, but and it it ain't gonna get cult status.
[39:20] Jimi: No, I don't think, yeah, who knows?
[39:23] Tommy: I'd be surprised.
[39:23] Jimi: Um but yeah, and I d I don't know, maybe as well just because it's Sondheim.
[39:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:30] Jimi: It's Sondheim's flop, like wow, that's and do you know what I mean?
[39:33] Tommy: And basically it what what it just means is it becomes great again.
[39:37] Jimi: Right.
[39:37] Tommy: Because it's Sondheim's flop.
[39:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:40] Tommy: So it's a really good flop.
[39:41] Jimi: And I I saw this really, really interesting quote from one of my favorite musical theatre authors, uh huh I've never shown it out before.
[39:46] Tommy: Um, but I love all of his books.
[39:48] Jimi: You might know him, Scott Miller.
[39:50] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:51] Jimi: I've seen some of his stuff.
[39:52] Tommy: He wrote uh it writes those of like Assassins to or um from West Side Story to Assassins or like things like that.
[39:59] Jimi: Just like lots of musical theater history books, and I thoroughly recommend them all.
[40:03] Tommy: Anyway, uh he wrote this quote, which I'm like, you're such you're just kinda right.
[40:07] Jimi: Um said, It's still a better musical than two thirds of what Broadway has turned out in the last fifty years.
[40:13] Tommy: And I'm like, yeah, is that correct?
[40:15] Jimi: So I'm like actually, do you know what? Probably kind of is.
[40:17] Tommy: It kinda is.
[40:19] Jimi: Um because you can rack it up against a lot of this the mediocre stuff that's just been kind of trawled out, and you're like, well, it's obviously better than that, particularly just in the music.
[40:28] Tommy: You forgive the book because the music is so good.
[40:30] Jimi: I do. Um it does make me wonder, and I feel like fucking Max Bialistock.
[40:36] Tommy: But like I I could see the right kind of people putting together a 2020 surefire flop that's actually really good on Broadway.
[40:53] Jimi: Like in a in a kind of like Sasha Baron Cohen-esque, like really publicize this terrible director who's so excited to bring this terrible idea to the stage, but in a really spectacular way, in where i the everyone, as far as you can tell, isn't doing it ironically and doesn't think it's a joke, but the comedy in it is about how terrible the whole thing is.
[41:25] Tommy: It's just the producers.
[41:27] Jimi: It's just the producers, but like knowing that it's gonna do well.
[41:30] Tommy: You don't scam a bunch of little old ladies.
[41:32] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:33] Tommy: But in that that kind of like in that kind of meta-theatricality piece It's super meta.
[41:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:41] Tommy: It's two meta?
[41:45] Jimi: It would have I I mean it would have to be done really well.
[41:47] Tommy: I mean, just today you saw that that all-star musical that's coming up the pipes.
[41:52] Jimi: Um you know, something like that.
[41:56] Tommy: That's true, like a meme meme the musical.
[41:58] Jimi: Meme the musical, but you can't sell it as meme the musical.
[42:00] Tommy: It has to take itself 100% seriously.
[42:03] Jimi: Exactly.
[42:03] Tommy: Yeah, true.
[42:04] Jimi: And then you go see it for the spectacle of it all.
[42:08] Tommy: Anyway. Could that happen? That'd be funny if that happens.
[42:11] Jimi: Maybe we'll be the ones to write it.
[42:12] Tommy: No, you can't say that because it won't be us, it has to be our pen names.
[42:17] Jimi: Well, they'll never know.
[42:19] Tommy: They will, because now we said it.
[42:21] Jimi: That's true. Damn it.
[42:23] Tommy: Ruined everything.
[42:24] Jimi: Anyone can whistle any old day easy.
[42:34] Tommy: It's all so simple.
[42:38] Jimi: Relax, let go, let fly.
[42:43] Jimi: So someone tell me why.
[42:55] Tommy: I can dance a tango.
[42:58] Jimi: I can read Greek.
[43:01] Tommy: Easy.
[43:05] Jimi: I can slay a dragon.
[43:08] Tommy: Any old week.
[43:10] Jimi: Easy.
[43:14] Tommy: What's hard is simple. What's natural comes hard.
[43:27] Jimi: Maybe you could show me how to let go. Lower my guard. Learn to be free. Maybe if you whistle. Whistle for me.
[43:56] Jimi: So for all of its foibles, for all of its floppiness, um, you know, uh the 20-minute long plot description will have told you that there's lots to this show.
[44:07] Tommy: Yeah, they certainly are trying to say something.
[44:10] Jimi: There really are.
[44:11] Tommy: They're saying a lot.
[44:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[44:13] Tommy: Every act.
[44:15] Jimi: All three of them.
[44:16] Tommy: They're like, let's add another.
[44:18] Jimi: Why was there three acts?
[44:19] Tommy: They talk a little bit about that, and Sondheim says unqualified, but he's pretty sure this is the last three-act musical.
[44:25] Jimi: Um, which is another interesting milestone on the history of musical theater.
[44:29] Tommy: I bl from what I've seen, I haven't found anything to disprove that.
[44:33] Jimi: Um but there really hadn't been one before after Oklahoma, like sure.
[44:39] Tommy: I don't think there are a lot of integrated book musicals that are three acts, but I think there are plenty pieces, plenty of pieces of musical theater lost to history that are three acts.
[44:47] Jimi: Potentially, yeah. Because a lot of the traditional play and performance structure was just three acts.
[44:51] Tommy: Um it's the the the why we derive the contemporary plot structure, get the protagonist up a tree, throw rocks at him, and get him out of the tree. Each one of those is an act.
[45:00] Jimi: Um so but they fair they do talk a lot of the cut songs were a last ditch effort to try and cut it down to two acts, which they did try to do before its opening, but found that they were so entrenched in some of the costume changes and technical bits that they needed the intermissions.
[45:19] Tommy: Yeah, which is a crappy reason to have intermissions, as I'm sure everyone knew at the time, but you're just too late.
[45:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[45:27] Tommy: Um anyway. So within those three acts, uh, they talk a lot.
[45:32] Jimi: So I mean, we're not gonna get into like deep, you know, rooted discussion about all the themes here because like the thing is is they talk about so much that they actually don't talk that much about it.
[45:42] Tommy: Yeah, they kinda like they kind of like signal a bunch of themes, but never really say a lot about all of them.
[45:48] Jimi: Instead, you know, they'd spend time singing a French bedroom song.
[45:51] Tommy: Um you diss that song.
[45:54] Jimi: I'm gonna get to it.
[45:57] Tommy: Um so yeah, I but I guess like the the main theme, the main kind of overarching is this idea of conformity, yes, and um and fitting.
[46:06] Jimi: What is what is normal.
[46:08] Tommy: Yes.
[46:09] Jimi: Um that well, so I've read quite a lot about that being the response to McCarthyism, and you know, we're just kind of coming out of that in the 50s.
[46:21] Tommy: Um but and actually that's another reason why it gets cited a lot as a flop because people are like, well, that was in the 50s, that was the 50s, this kind of done there, yeah.
[46:30] Jimi: Or post-JFK.
[46:31] Tommy: Um I think that's that's fair enough, but I still think uh as a topic, you know, this idea of of conforming and not um it's still I'd I still say it was relevant.
[46:46] Jimi: I don't think people would be like, I don't get this anymore, you know what I mean?
[46:49] Tommy: Like I think it's still relevant today.
[46:51] Jimi: I think uh simple end of act one is some of the most is is as deep as some of this musical gets.
[46:59] Tommy: Um, you know, the whole watch crowd dividing people into bits and pieces.
[47:05] Jimi: Yeah, so simple simple ain't simple.
[47:09] Tommy: Sure.
[47:09] Jimi: When that's the point.
[47:11] Tommy: Right.
[47:12] Jimi: But my goodness, that's the thing. Like it says so much.
[47:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[47:17] Jimi: You really like you're kind of sweating by the end of it, and I again that's that's probably the reason, but it's not that's the thing, is it's not meta enough.
[47:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[47:30] Jimi: I will say, simple simple to me watching it now, um, especially in today's American sociopolitical landscape.
[47:40] Tommy: Um, and like there's a moment where Cora Hoover Hooper um has decided she's figured out the system and declares that one of the uh the people goes in group A or group one, I don't remember.
[47:54] Jimi: And it's a joke. Like the gu, you know, the guy makes some comedy, oh, he must belong in group A.
[48:00] Tommy: Um, and like she has no idea what determines these groups.
[48:03] Jimi: That's the whole point of the song.
[48:05] Tommy: Yeah, and like man, watching uh uh contemporary America's political discourse and its divisiveness and its like partied nature, I would say even internationally, you see it in the UK too.
[48:18] Jimi: Um, like this like you're either with us or you're against us mentality, and it's really really important for us to figure out which side you're on.
[48:27] Tommy: Yeah is a hugely contemporary theme that I think you know we're we are grappling with very much right now.
[48:36] Jimi: I'd say yes, but I think I think with with simple with anyone can whistle, it's not it's not flagging that up.
[48:45] Tommy: That isn't sure really what it's talking about.
[48:47] Jimi: I think it's just going straight down the line of identity.
[48:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[48:51] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[48:52] Tommy: And the fact that that is a blurred line, and that is just something that will always I mean it's just one of those perennial themes that humans are complex, go figure.
[49:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[49:04] Jimi: I think that we get muddled in the politics of it because of who Cora is.
[49:09] Tommy: Right, and that it is the there is this kind of almost political espionage that underscores the whole thing.
[49:15] Jimi: Exactly.
[49:17] Tommy: I will counter. I mean, Act Two opens with uh the A's and the ones both campaigning for Hapgood to become the mayor.
[49:25] Jimi: Um, you know, the the political underscoring is revisited.
[49:30] Tommy: It's yeah, but it is is the the politic well I guess, and they do talk about like the I vote for the guy who always wins.
[49:37] Jimi: Yeah, I will say it's not done well.
[49:41] Tommy: There's just there's just too much it's not like this is what we're talking about, zing.
[49:46] Jimi: Right.
[49:46] Tommy: Like if if this show just like that was it, and then we spend the rest of the show talking about the difference between A's and ones, like if the A in the one March is like the climax ch chasing for Harold Hill across the town to try and find him before we take him to town hall, like if that was the show, this show would be playing to this day.
[50:07] Jimi: Um, you know, or would be revived right now.
[50:10] Tommy: Um it does feel like in the same way that like um why we build the wall is kind of a political accident, um that it was never written to be a part of today's contemporary political discourse, but has kind of fallen into that.
[50:23] Jimi: I feel the same way about this.
[50:25] Tommy: Like you're you have found a theme that has since become important and you've described it really well, but accidentally.
[50:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[50:34] Tommy: It's like I'm just it's interesting. Like I'm looking at the themes that we've written here.
[50:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[50:38] Tommy: Of gender norms, race, conformity, politics, and mental health.
[50:42] Jimi: Yeah.
[50:43] Tommy: Um these all exist in simple.
[50:46] Jimi: These all get discussed in simple.
[50:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[50:50] Jimi: That's ridiculous.
[50:51] Tommy: Well, and but that's one of the things I I will say, and I from you know, I wonder if this is our uh the terrible different political circles we spin in.
[51:03] Jimi: But like there's a lot of talk right now about how ridiculous it is that politics, quote unquote capital P politics, is mired in all of these other things conformity, rental health, race, gender norms, and religion.
[51:17] Tommy: Um whereas we have we have this ideal, at least in America, that it's not conflated with a lot of these things.
[51:23] Jimi: Um and since has become as a means to protect, but also is becoming very uh, you know, divisive in the the preceding days.
[51:32] Tommy: Um you know, I it feels when you ask people about politics, they think about these other things.
[51:42] Jimi: They think about social you can hide all of these things under the umbrella of politics.
[51:48] Tommy: Politics.
[51:48] Jimi: Um whether that's right or intentional doesn't really matter at that point.
[51:54] Tommy: But that's so I guess that's the thing is that this is what I mean about simple being tricky, is because it's it is actually trying to make a statement on each of these things.
[52:03] Jimi: And I think it does, yeah, but the point isn't hammered home.
[52:06] Tommy: And so what happens is you you're just kind of mired in this confusion, which the thing is is like kind of to give it its credit.
[52:14] Jimi: Yeah, that's the whole point. You're supposed to be disarmed and you're supposed to be flummoxed.
[52:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[52:20] Jimi: Um because that is how you that's how you feel.
[52:23] Tommy: So maybe it's genius.
[52:25] Jimi: Who knows?
[52:26] Tommy: Um yeah, perhaps.
[52:28] Jimi: I mean, there's there's that whole part. Are they are they John and Joan?
[52:32] Tommy: Yeah, John and Joan.
[52:34] Jimi: Who were each other's secretaire and one employs the other and blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah.
[52:39] Tommy: Um, and it just is just to confuse you.
[52:42] Jimi: Um yeah, and it but it's also like that is a commentary on uh gender roles in 60s America and how it it kind of doesn't matter.
[52:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[52:54] Jimi: Ta-da.
[52:55] Tommy: Like um actually what I will say is of all of the things that this musical talks about inadvertently or not, uh gender norms and uh gender is actually the thing that I really like most about it because of their female characters, yeah, and just the way that they are quite just flexible, like it doesn't really feel like gender plays a huge part in anything.
[53:20] Jimi: It's all quite agendered.
[53:22] Tommy: Yes.
[53:22] Jimi: Because someone like Cora, who is our one of her I feel like saying a protagonist, but yeah, I think she kind of is.
[53:31] Tommy: You were along on her ride.
[53:33] Jimi: Yeah, that's one of the difficulty difficult parts of the show is like I don't think Hapgood is even the hero, but he is introduced as such overtly.
[53:41] Tommy: Um and part of that is the point, like, right?
[53:45] Jimi: Like we're subverting the traditional plot structures and like confusing antagonists and protagonists and muddling them up, sure.
[53:52] Tommy: And Cora Hoover Hooper is not quite redeemable enough to not entirely be the villain.
[54:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[54:01] Tommy: Like she doesn't have the like, but I'm actually the good guy moment that makes her more redeemable.
[54:07] Jimi: But she does almost does almost yeah, and she almost kind of recognized her faults a little bit, and then she kind of changes.
[54:14] Tommy: But you know, she's still at the heart, you see, it's still her story in many ways.
[54:18] Jimi: Um so there she is leading the forefront, and then you've got Faye, who is a really, really interesting character.
[54:27] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:27] Jimi: Um, is kind of cartoonish, all of these characters are, um, I'd say Faye is one of the ones who is the most three-dimensional and who does go on a journey the most.
[54:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:39] Jimi: Absolutely.
[54:41] Tommy: Um, and we'll talk again when we get to talking about the music, we'll look at a bit about you know what's happening there.
[54:47] Jimi: But I think just to put these kind of two really strong female characters right at the forefront, the guys in even Hapgood in a way, because Hapgood's such a question mark.
[54:56] Tommy: Right.
[54:56] Jimi: Um, these two female characters are really the the center of it all.
[55:01] Tommy: And I think um And they're obviously we've just had Dolly, but this is yet another example of really good female writing.
[55:10] Jimi: And where Dolly is like, you know, Dolly is strong and female and empowered, and her whole thing is at the end she wants to marry Horace Vandergelder, and they'll all she does is set up horror heteronormative relationships that all go well in the end.
[55:25] Tommy: Yeah, you know, Faye you know, runs away with Hapgood in the end, maybe in a pretty you know, Cora Hoover Hooper is a is a widow when we meet her.
[55:37] Jimi: Like she's she's the mayoress because she inherited it from her dead mayor husband.
[55:42] Tommy: Um like and has certainly romantic overtones, but they're a joke.
[55:48] Jimi: They're not in that same, it feels different.
[55:52] Tommy: It's certainly tinged by its time period, and I would, you know, wouldn't call it imperfect by any.
[55:56] Jimi: Yeah, we're not like way, this is the one like yeah, feminism.
[56:00] Tommy: Um but you do see tinges of powerful female musical theater characters here in a really interesting way.
[56:08] Jimi: And I like I think that's that's good. That's something to laud about the show.
[56:12] Tommy: Absolutely.
[56:12] Jimi: Um actually I think a lot of that's probably to do with Angela Lansbury.
[56:16] Tommy: Yeah, fair.
[56:18] Jimi: It's quite uh apocryphal tale now of when she almost left the piece um because uh she just wasn't happy with Cora as a character.
[56:29] Tommy: She felt she was just too too much of a cartoon um and that there was no depth and she wasn't able to to act that role um because she was an actor first before singer.
[56:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[56:40] Tommy: Um and uh someone who was like, okay, well, how would you fix it?
[56:45] Jimi: And she just kind of pauses and thinks and then says, Well, I mean, and also the other girl has uh five songs and I only have four.
[56:54] Tommy: And it's like, well, we can fix that.
[56:57] Jimi: Um, I love that.
[56:59] Tommy: But that's actually quite interesting because what he then gave her was a piece of acting through song.
[57:04] Jimi: Yeah, a really powerful song that was informed by her request, whether her request was veiled in, you know, an actor request or a story request.
[57:14] Tommy: Yeah.
[57:16] Jimi: But it still exists.
[57:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[57:19] Jimi: You know?
[57:19] Tommy: Um, so I think, yeah, well done, Ange.
[57:21] Jimi: I so much enjoy listening to her narrate the Carnegie Hall concert version of this because she sounds so joyful, and all the stories about this show are that she had just a terrible time on it.
[57:36] Tommy: Um, she couldn't quite sing it, and the music director was real mean to her, and certainly, you know, the reviews did her no favors and the out of town previews did not go well.
[57:45] Jimi: Philadelphia was like everyone's dying.
[57:49] Tommy: Like doesn't sound like a fun show to be a part of.
[57:52] Jimi: No, I mean she says it, doesn't she? Like when she hears it, she's like, fear, yeah, fear.
[57:56] Tommy: Like it this was a terrible, terrible experience.
[57:58] Jimi: And to hear her talk, you know, about and certainly she's acting, it's a concert version, we want to sell it well.
[58:04] Tommy: But it is a really nice I'm glad that that got to be a part of her closure with the piece, as opposed to this terrible, terrible memory of it.
[58:14] Jimi: I just want to talk a little bit about the ending.
[58:16] Tommy: Yes.
[58:16] Jimi: The very, very ending.
[58:18] Tommy: No, sorry, what am I saying? The act one ending.
[58:20] Jimi: Ah, yes, the most probably ending.
[58:22] Tommy: One of the most challenging parts of the show.
[58:24] Jimi: Right.
[58:24] Tommy: And one of the most interesting.
[58:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[58:27] Tommy: So if you it it's not represented well on any cast recording.
[58:31] Jimi: Um, the idea is after simple, um, the lights go down, say for a spotlight on Hapgood, and he says something to the effect, You're all crazy, don't you know?
[58:43] Tommy: It's something like that.
[58:44] Jimi: Um to the audience.
[58:46] Tommy: And the light comes up back on all the actors who are sitting in theater chairs looking at the audience, pointing and laughing and clapping.
[58:56] Jimi: Blackout end of act.
[58:58] Tommy: With the implication that like not only are all the cookies up on stage, but you're all crazy people too.
[59:06] Jimi: And it's so this is one of the things that often gets cited as the reason why anyone can whistle flopped because it was like in poor taste to do this to an audience.
[59:15] Tommy: You know, they were along for the ride, and here you are laughing at them.
[59:18] Jimi: Right.
[59:19] Tommy: Um to me, I'm like, this is kind of this is something.
[59:26] Jimi: There's something in this because this idea, this kind of uh sort of Pippin-esque yeah breaking down of the fourth wall and flipping it back on you, and um it hadn't really been touched in musical theater no not particularly touched I can'm sure someone will tell me but you know from the beg hairs it's not that didn't happen in Fiddler do you know what I mean?
[59:53] Tommy: Um they didn't like we are Anatevka there was none of that right um so here's this really interesting kind of like swing lens yeah um and I can see why the audience would be like hang on whoa because you bring this you bring the lights up on an audience so like this doesn't it's very unsettling.
[1:00:13] Jimi: Yeah I do always enjoy because a lot of the a lot of the I've delved deep into a lot of this stuff for the uh sometime September video and a lot of the quotes about it being challenging to an audience come from contemporary critics of the time.
[1:00:29] Tommy: Like that was a moment they cited that made them feel uncomfortable.
[1:00:32] Jimi: And there is a sense of you know how dare this be a part of theatre you must make your audience comfortable um and I I see that feeling come up over and over again throughout a lot of pieces, which is fascinating to me because we've been doing it for centuries.
[1:00:51] Tommy: Like there there's the longstanding story about um the the futurist movement in Italy around the turn of the last century.
[1:00:58] Jimi: Um and infamously there were several futurist theater productions where immediately before the show the the production company, the actors would come out and apply fresh paint to the theater seats so that when the fancy fancy people coming to see the show came and sat on them, they would stand up and have paint on their asses.
[1:01:20] Tommy: And you know, it's been a part of theater forever.
[1:01:23] Jimi: Like you gotta get over lights turning on you in the 60s.
[1:01:28] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:28] Jimi: Been painting people's butts for you know half a century by that point.
[1:01:32] Tommy: Well I mean it's still happening today.
[1:01:33] Jimi: People are still quite alarmed in Oklahoma at the end when you know they're having a gay old time, and then suddenly uh Judd is killed and everyone's kind of looking at each other, and it's like, ah, we have to react and share this experience.
[1:01:46] Tommy: Right.
[1:01:46] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[1:01:47] Tommy: Like, how do we all feel about this?
[1:01:49] Jimi: Um, and people are still like, I don't know if that works.
[1:01:52] Tommy: Right.
[1:01:52] Jimi: It's like, no, uh we're we're here, you know.
[1:01:54] Tommy: I mean, this we're in theater land.
[1:01:55] Jimi: The uncomfortableness is the point.
[1:01:58] Tommy: The point, yeah.
[1:01:59] Jimi: And I I do wonder if maybe as public we have a sliding scale of acceptance around that, and maybe this hit the wrong side of that pendulum.
[1:02:07] Tommy: So I just w what I think is I don't think it hit it hard enough.
[1:02:11] Jimi: Sure.
[1:02:11] Tommy: Um, I think what it screams as is here's a fun idea, let's do this.
[1:02:16] Jimi: Right.
[1:02:17] Tommy: Um, without actually m integrating it.
[1:02:20] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:20] Tommy: Um because they never bring that conceit up ever again.
[1:02:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:26] Tommy: Um you know, the idea of the audience being a part of the show.
[1:02:30] Jimi: Right.
[1:02:31] Tommy: Never comes back.
[1:02:32] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:33] Tommy: And that, therefore, you're just kind of being like, Well, why did they do that?
[1:02:33] Jimi: Why did they do that?
[1:02:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:38] Jimi: Like, what was the point in that?
[1:02:39] Tommy: I f that I feel bad about that.
[1:02:40] Jimi: And you've not shaken my hand, you know?
[1:02:43] Tommy: Sure.
[1:02:43] Jimi: It's it's that kind of thing, it's like when um when you don't get a curtain call at the end of a show.
[1:02:47] Tommy: Right.
[1:02:48] Jimi: And you're like, excuse me, right?
[1:02:49] Tommy: I'm applauding you.
[1:02:50] Jimi: I would like to clap for you now.
[1:02:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:52] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:52] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:53] Jimi: Um, and they're just standing there.
[1:02:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:55] Jimi: And you're like, No.
[1:02:56] Tommy: And it is, it's there is a there's a conversation that's happening there.
[1:02:59] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:59] Tommy: Um, and so I feel like here in anyone can whistle, when they flip it around, it's like, ha ha ha, there you are.
[1:03:05] Jimi: It's that um i it's poking fun at the audience at the audience's expense.
[1:03:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:03:12] Jimi: It's um in spelling B, yeah, uh, when they get the guest spellers on, the cardinal rule is they are like little babies, and you have to guide them through and make sure that they are having the best time because the second you poke fun at them and second their expense, terrible, yeah.
[1:03:29] Tommy: Everyone will hate you.
[1:03:29] Jimi: And it's so true.
[1:03:30] Tommy: Well, it's funny, I was thinking I was like running through my mind, like, how do you fix that?
[1:03:34] Jimi: And one of the options I was running through is like during simple, does Hapgood start running out into the audience and is like, you sir, what is it you do?
[1:03:41] Tommy: And like picks an audience member and like finds a way.
[1:03:44] Jimi: I I don't think that entirely solves it, but I think it makes it more like part of the problem is just the theatrical presentation of it is just confusing.
[1:03:53] Tommy: Like you can't communicate that entirely in what turns into ten seconds of stage business.
[1:04:00] Jimi: Yep.
[1:04:01] Tommy: Um, does it need to be you as you said, do we need to go bigger with this?
[1:04:06] Jimi: Pull some audience members up on stage and maybe they're cookies for the rest of the F and show.
[1:04:11] Tommy: Maybe it's that, but maybe just you bring it back.
[1:04:13] Jimi: Maybe you bring the house lights back up at the end of act two.
[1:04:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:04:16] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[1:04:16] Tommy: During the the record destroying and you brings, I don't know, like you integrate it that way.
[1:04:20] Jimi: Or maybe right at the end, you bring the house lights back up and instead of laughing and having fun, yeah, like the audience on stage are like, oh like, wow, or a different emotion, uh an emotion that is more welcoming.
[1:04:35] Tommy: Well where it's like that kind of idea, it's like we are all one, we're all a part of this.
[1:04:39] Jimi: It does almost seem out of order in the points they're trying to make, because one of the points they're trying to make is that everyone's crazy and that's fine, right?
[1:04:48] Tommy: Yep.
[1:04:48] Jimi: Everyone's crazy and we enjoy that.
[1:04:50] Tommy: We haven't quite reached that milestone yet at the end of Act One.
[1:04:55] Jimi: We still assume that the cookies are bad or broken in some way.
[1:04:59] Tommy: But we're incorporating the audience in that thing of bad or broken.
[1:05:04] Jimi: And like if we bring it back and either say, like, you're crazy just like them, but we like them, so we like you too, even though you're crazy.
[1:05:11] Tommy: Or wait and save that moment to the end of the show about how like you've all been cookies all along.
[1:05:17] Jimi: Didn't you know that?
[1:05:19] Tommy: Because you've been as crazy and as ostracized as them, but we love you for it.
[1:05:23] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:05:24] Tommy: You know?
[1:05:25] Jimi: Uh come completely and utterly.
[1:05:27] Tommy: I think that is exactly it.
[1:05:28] Jimi: Like, there's no there's no ending to that storyline.
[1:05:31] Tommy: Right.
[1:05:32] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[1:05:33] Tommy: The cookies the cookies just go off as cookies at the end.
[1:05:37] Jimi: There's not really uh you know, we're all mad here, right?
[1:05:41] Tommy: Everyone's together happy happy.
[1:05:45] Jimi: And so all that has happened is you've just called the audience crazy.
[1:05:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:49] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:05:50] Tommy: And really stupid.
[1:05:52] Jimi: Um is is kind of the implication in that time.
[1:05:55] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:56] Jimi: Um so that was a mistake.
[1:06:00] Tommy: And I do think there's a way to use that great, great revolutionary, fun idea.
[1:06:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:07] Tommy: And just keep going with it.
[1:06:11] Jimi: Um it is it is one of the reasons why I think, and you see a lot of this discourse in musical theater of the time, like different musical theater creators calling each other up in the 60s, 70s and 80s, and be like, hey, will you come see my show out of town?
[1:06:24] Tommy: I don't know what to do.
[1:06:25] Jimi: Um, like a lot of times then they end up ghostwriting or becoming directors, like that's when you usually hear about it.
[1:06:31] Tommy: Um, and I'm certain it still happens contemporarily, we just don't hear about it as much.
[1:06:36] Jimi: But those are the most useful pieces of feedback you can get.
[1:06:39] Tommy: People who haven't seen the thing, but know enough about the art form to have a discourse about it, yeah, they're the ones who you want to show your draft to.
[1:06:48] Jimi: They're the ones whose input you want, who can be like, you're trying to say this and you're not.
[1:06:53] Tommy: Um and you know, as we've discussed, they didn't really do that.
[1:06:59] Jimi: They didn't who knows.
[1:07:02] Tommy: It's it is really interesting because like it it could it it could there have ever been a moment where it was like actually this is it, this is the one, anyone can whistle the first concept, you know, working concept musical.
[1:07:14] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:07:14] Tommy: Um if only they I don't know, spokes Jerry Robbins, if only they brought Bob Fossey on board early to know.
[1:07:20] Jimi: It feels like that that ship has sailed.
[1:07:22] Tommy: It does make me while I I appreciate and understand um, you know, uh intellectual property and things like that, it does make me wish there was a way to like take anyone can whistle and unabashedly attempt to fix it.
[1:07:35] Jimi: Um you know, forget about its history, just take it as a piece, and what would you do to just totally, you know, fix the thing?
[1:07:43] Tommy: Not rewrite the thing, not restructure the thing, but like fix it.
[1:07:47] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:07:48] Tommy: And I guess right, to to bring it back, uh huh.
[1:07:50] Jimi: Um do you think there's value in home homing in on one particular theme and not trying to throw so many points?
[1:08:01] Tommy: That is a tough question.
[1:08:02] Jimi: Because I love I love musicals that do very well hitting a lot of different things, and I think plenty musicals can do it successfully.
[1:08:12] Tommy: I think you need specificity in a certain domain.
[1:08:20] Jimi: So whether that is you're hitting a bunch of different things, but each one is really, really specific.
[1:08:26] Tommy: Um or gosh, I don't have a good way to phrase this.
[1:08:31] Jimi: Um you mean like you've got the song that's about politics.
[1:08:31] Tommy: Right.
[1:08:31] Jimi: You've got the song that's about legit.
[1:08:38] Tommy: You don't have the song that's about politics.
[1:08:40] Jimi: You have the song that's about a down and out country farmer who's always wanted to become mayor of his own town and climbs up the political ladder to suddenly become president, right?
[1:08:53] Tommy: Yes.
[1:08:54] Jimi: Like it's not about politics, it's about that guy.
[1:08:57] Tommy: Um but the theme, the overarching theme is there.
[1:09:01] Jimi: Whereas this show has the song about politics, and that's as deep as it gets.
[1:09:05] Tommy: And like I think in whatever I guess really I think that would be my if were were I giving advice to people who do a thing I've never done, um my advice to writing musical theater would be like go deep wherever you can as much as you can.
[1:09:20] Jimi: Be as specific as possible in these things.
[1:09:22] Tommy: It makes your story better for it.
[1:09:24] Jimi: The cookies are notoriously undefined.
[1:09:27] Tommy: Um define them.
[1:09:29] Jimi: Why are they all here?
[1:09:31] Tommy: Is it because they all got recommendations from people they know?
[1:09:34] Jimi: They all got rejected from their what is the thing they have in common?
[1:09:37] Tommy: We never know, we never find out.
[1:09:39] Jimi: What is Hapgood's problem?
[1:09:41] Tommy: Like, we disguise it around like he's a you know a former ideologist with five PhDs, or blah blah blah, blah blah.
[1:09:49] Jimi: No, no, no.
[1:09:50] Tommy: Pick a thing.
[1:09:52] Jimi: Pick one thing, make him that, and make it so important that it's emblematic of whatever it is you're trying to say.
[1:09:58] Tommy: Um, but that does stray into you know, kill your darling's territory, and that's the problem.
[1:10:05] Jimi: It's tricky.
[1:10:06] Tommy: Yeah, I guess the point's still the point, the main the main point here is that we know best.
[1:10:12] Jimi: It clearly, yes, we are the forefront and experts.
[1:10:16] Tommy: We are the authority.
[1:10:17] Jimi: We have a podcast after all.
[1:10:19] Tommy: That's us.
[1:10:20] Jimi: I couldn't get through it without laughing.
[1:10:22] Tommy: No, that disclaimer.
[1:10:24] Jimi: That was I really did suck at the time.
[1:10:26] Tommy: I'm really excited for that quote to be taken out of context.
[1:10:28] Jimi: Don't take that quote out of context.
[1:10:31] Tommy: Uh good.
[1:10:32] Jimi: Um well, hey though.
[1:10:34] Tommy: Speaking of being the authority, let's go to let's go to you.
[1:10:39] Jimi: Oh, jeez, whenever my world turns to dust.
[1:10:45] Tommy: I've always got someone to trust.
[1:10:49] Jimi: Whatever the sort of support that I need, I've got you to lean on.
[1:10:57] Tommy: When everything's hollow and black.
[1:11:01] Jimi: I've always got you at my back.
[1:11:05] Tommy: No matter how hollow, we'll follow your lead.
[1:11:10] Jimi: And with us to lean on your succeed.
[1:11:14] Jimi: What comfort it is to have always known that if they should catch me, I won't go alone.
[1:11:22] Tommy: I always give credit.
[1:11:23] Jimi: Where credit is due.
[1:11:28] Tommy: I've got you to lean on.
[1:11:31] Jimi: We got you to lean on.
[1:11:34] Tommy: I've got you to lean on, Darlis you.
[1:11:40] Jimi: I'm gonna— we're gonna flip the script here, ladies and gentlemen.
[1:11:42] Jimi: I'm gonna interview Tommy.
[1:11:44] Tommy: I was gonna say your full name, but I guess I kinda could see your full name now.
[1:11:46] Jimi: You could, I'm a hashtag now.
[1:11:47] Tommy: I don't like it.
[1:11:48] Jimi: It's fine.
[1:11:49] Tommy: You're a hashtag?
[1:11:50] Jimi: They hashtagged both of our names in one of the tweets.
[1:11:53] Tommy: Oh, I see.
[1:11:53] Jimi: Sorry.
[1:11:54] Tommy: I thought you meant like your fans did.
[1:11:55] Jimi: No, no.
[1:11:56] Tommy: It was just they made a hashtag.
[1:11:58] Jimi: They made a hashtag once, which was weird.
[1:12:00] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:12:01] Jimi: But I get it.
[1:12:01] Tommy: That's par for the world they live in, just not the world we live in.
[1:12:05] Jimi: Yes.
[1:12:05] Tommy: Mr. Mash No More.
[1:12:07] Jimi: God, I know.
[1:12:08] Tommy: It's officially— we don't need to say it up, but Mr. Shalulu.
[1:12:11] Jimi: Tommy Shalulu.
[1:12:16] Tommy: So you made a video about Anyone Can Whistle.
[1:12:21] Jimi: As part of Sondheim September.
[1:12:23] Tommy: It's one of the videos I'm more proud of from that month.
[1:12:26] Tommy: I dove deep into a lot of Sondheim research that month.
[1:12:30] Jimi: But the weird thing now, as Jimmy pointed out in our pre-show chat, when you look up Anyone Can Whistle, a lot of it's me.
[1:12:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:12:43] Jimi: Completely and utterly, you know, it's weird.
[1:12:48] Tommy: It is weird.
[1:12:48] Jimi: Well, and this is a part you and I fall into a lot.
[1:12:51] Tommy: Like we get emails all the time.
[1:12:52] Jimi: You're good at responding to them, I'm not.
[1:12:55] Tommy: About like, hey, I've cited something you said on your podcast in my PhD. Is that okay?
[1:13:01] Jimi: How do I quote you?
[1:13:02] Tommy: How do I cite you?
[1:13:04] Jimi: First and foremost, it's amazingly flattering.
[1:13:10] Tommy: We'd feel like idiots all the time.
[1:13:15] Jimi: A lot of the time, our...
[1:13:19] Tommy: Right.
[1:13:19] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:13:20] Tommy: But like it is weird entering and becoming a part of the world of musical theater discourse.
[1:13:27] Jimi: I guess I don't know how much this is entirely related to Anyone Can Whistle, but one of the difficult things is there are certainly think pieces written about this thing.
[1:13:37] Tommy: But not a lot.
[1:13:38] Jimi: Um, there's really not.
[1:13:39] Tommy: I mean, like if you are looking to research a bit more into this, I would really recommend Scott Miller.
[1:13:47] Tommy: It's called Rebels with Applause.
[1:13:50] Tommy: I mean honestly, his books are all fantastic, but he does some really good deep analysis, he goes into specifics about the songs and the music.
[1:13:59] Jimi: Yeah, and that's a fantastic place to go.
[1:14:03] Tommy: But it's a shame that there's not more.
[1:14:06] Jimi: Yeah, well, I think this is one of the reasons we went into doing this podcast.
[1:14:06] Tommy: This is one of the reasons I started doing the YouTube channel.
[1:14:13] Jimi: From what people say, it's one of the reasons people I think like listening to our show, is that there's people want this kind of discourse about musical theater, and people don't do this kind of discourse about musical theater.
[1:14:27] Tommy: They really don't.
[1:14:28] Jimi: They really don't.
[1:14:29] Tommy: And it's something obviously working now with a Broadway Podcast Network.
[1:14:34] Jimi: It feels like more than ever before, the hashtag musical theater nerd, it needs to be more legitimized.
[1:14:48] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:14:49] Jimi: You know what I mean? Like in this world where people do think pieces about every Disney revival and like all these other pieces of pop culture, you know, musical theater is huge pop culture that doesn't experience the same kind of meta-analysis that other pieces of art do.
[1:15:07] Tommy: And I find as well, like people maybe who aren't as in the musical theater world as the majority of our listeners are, when they listen to the podcast, they're like, oh god, you— I didn't realize you could speak so long about that show.
[1:15:21] Jimi: Or, you know, wow, you've— how'd you find so much to say?
[1:15:24] Tommy: I'm like, because this is art.
[1:15:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:15:26] Tommy: I mean, like people who spent a long time writing this for a reason.
[1:15:30] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:15:31] Tommy: You know, people can write essays and essays upon plays.
[1:15:36] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:15:36] Tommy: Why should that be any different from musical theater?
[1:15:39] Jimi: People can write essays and essays upon McDonald's commercials.
[1:15:42] Tommy: Like all of this is infinitely infractally explorable, so why not musical theater?
[1:15:42] Jimi: Why not musical theater?
[1:15:49] Tommy: And musical theater, perhaps more so and more generally so than McDonald's commercials.
[1:15:54] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:15:55] Tommy: Um, so I don't know.
[1:15:57] Jimi: I guess is this like a call to arms?
[1:16:00] Tommy: Uh, maybe.
[1:16:03] Jimi: I wish smarter people than us wrote things.
[1:16:06] Tommy: I don't mean that as an insult, I mean that as a cry.
[1:16:09] Jimi: Not at all.
[1:16:10] Tommy: Like, I think like don't— don't be ashamed about being a fan of musical theater.
[1:16:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:16:15] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[1:16:16] Jimi: Don't let that be the thing that you don't tell people about.
[1:16:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:16:18] Jimi: Like, be really proud of it and help legitimize the art form that we all love.
[1:16:23] Tommy: You know, one of my favorite moments on this planet as a human being was when we were in between interviews during the Great Comic Cast recording.
[1:16:40] Jimi: Um, and we were sitting around with some of the other musical theater nerds there.
[1:16:44] Tommy: No one involved, no one in the cast, but you know, some production assistants and stuff, and we just started shooting the shit about musical theater generally, and different shows and different like the stuff we do here on this podcast, but casually and among friends.
[1:16:59] Jimi: And without the requisite script I have rehearsed about like, oh yes, I enjoy musical theater.
[1:17:05] Tommy: No, no, I can have a discussion that— like the preamble that sometimes I have to give other people about like, no, no, we can have a long discussion about West Side Story.
[1:17:14] Jimi: Um, but just like, yeah, let's talk about this deeply and articulately.
[1:17:18] Tommy: And it was in that moment I had this fear like, am I missing out on this because I'm not in New York?
[1:17:18] Jimi: Am I missing out on this because I don't trade in this world or with these people?
[1:17:29] Tommy: But I see corners and bits of it on the internet, and I always, always wish there was more of it.
[1:17:35] Jimi: Always, every time.
[1:17:38] Tommy: It's just such a shame that there's not an opportunity.
[1:17:41] Jimi: For example, I really— I actually really want to give this guy a shout out.
[1:17:45] Tommy: He sent us an email after the Meet Me and St. Louis podcast.
[1:17:49] Jimi: Yes.
[1:17:50] Tommy: His name is Galen. Sorry if I'm pronouncing that wrong.
[1:17:53] Jimi: Um, he wrote basically a thesis about Meet Me and St. Louis.
[1:17:59] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:18:00] Jimi: A musical that we were like, who knows anything about this?
[1:18:03] Tommy: He does.
[1:18:03] Jimi: Well, turns out he does, you know, I mean, it's incredible, and it was such an incredible read.
[1:18:09] Tommy: Um, and it's like, I just feel like you've sat there with nobody talking about Meet Me and St. Louis because, you know, in many ways, why would they?
[1:18:18] Jimi: Right.
[1:18:18] Tommy: And you have all this amazing insight.
[1:18:20] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:18:21] Tommy: And no way to talk about it, no avenues to talk about it.
[1:18:24] Jimi: Um, it's always fascinating.
[1:18:28] Tommy: It is always interesting.
[1:18:30] Jimi: No matter the show, no matter the story, you know, it's something I feel about this show.
[1:18:33] Tommy: Like, we will be done with the show when they're done writing musicals.
[1:18:36] Jimi: Like, yeah, we're gonna be able to unpack every single show.
[1:18:41] Tommy: Um, the only thing that gets in our way usually is how much of the stuff was recorded.
[1:18:46] Jimi: Um, not like audio recorded, but like how much of a record of a show, you know, what happened in the 60s exists.
[1:18:53] Tommy: Um, and that's sometimes all we have to go on.
[1:18:55] Jimi: Um, totally.
[1:18:57] Tommy: Uh, I don't know.
[1:18:58] Jimi: I just feel like let's just keep talking, you know.
[1:19:03] Tommy: I mean, let's just— more people talk.
[1:19:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:19:06] Tommy: Well, it is some— I don't know if you feel this, but I feel this all the time.
[1:19:09] Jimi: I feel a pressure that I don't like.
[1:19:12] Tommy: And I think we've gotten better at— you listen back to some of our early episodes and like we screwed up, we made mistakes, we said wrong things, we missed big things.
[1:19:20] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:19:21] Tommy: And like I think we're better at that, but certainly not perfect by any means.
[1:19:26] Jimi: Um, but the more and more you become a part of the discourse, the more I feel like, God, I hope all of this is right or close to the case.
[1:19:35] Tommy: Definitely.
[1:19:36] Jimi: Um, but it's such a weird thing to feel when I start to like meta-meta analyze it because this is, you know, a lot of this is conjecture and analysis and opinion and extrapolation and, you know, all those fancy words for stuff we made up, but we think is true.
[1:19:51] Tommy: Um, I spoke for about 50 minutes about what Sondheim thought in 1964.
[1:19:56] Jimi: Right, yeah.
[1:19:56] Tommy: How the hell am I supposed to know that?
[1:19:58] Jimi: Who knows?
[1:19:58] Tommy: He's alive.
[1:19:59] Jimi: You could ask him.
[1:19:59] Tommy: He exactly wouldn't respond.
[1:20:02] Jimi: Um, but I don't know.
[1:20:03] Tommy: It's just— it's an interesting place to be.
[1:20:05] Jimi: I happen to exist in that place around Anyone Can Whistle.
[1:20:09] Tommy: Um, which is weird.
[1:20:12] Jimi: It will always be a good one.
[1:20:13] Tommy: It's weird but nice.
[1:20:14] Jimi: And how— but that's the thing is like, well, very grateful that you did that.
[1:20:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:20:19] Jimi: Because nobody else did.
[1:20:21] Tommy: And you know, there's 24,000 people out there now who know a little bit more about Anyone Can Whistle.
[1:20:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:20:27] Tommy: Which, you know, whether or not it's entirely accurate.
[1:20:32] Jimi: Hey, they know a little bit more, and then they can go and find out more and realize, hey, Toby, you were so freaking wrong.
[1:20:37] Tommy: That's fair.
[1:20:37] Jimi: Yeah, well, I've met— I've met most of those people in the comments, don't worry.
[1:20:40] Tommy: Yes, absolutely.
[1:20:42] Jimi: Um, just keep the conversation going, everyone.
[1:20:47] Tommy: You know?
[1:20:48] Jimi: That's what we're— that's what we're trying to do with this podcast.
[1:20:50] Tommy: Is this enhance this community?
[1:20:52] Jimi: God, yeah.
[1:20:53] Tommy: Because we all exist— we very much exist.
[1:20:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:20:56] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[1:20:57] Jimi: Um, so let's keep it going.
[1:21:00] Tommy: We'll make t-shirts.
[1:21:02] Jimi: We'll invent a secret handshake or something.
[1:21:04] Tommy: Oh, that'd be good.
[1:21:05] Jimi: The musical theater nerd handshake.
[1:21:06] Tommy: Yeah, we'll work that out.
[1:21:09] Jimi: Doctor, Doctor W Zet Charmont.
[1:21:13] Tommy: Mademoiselle.
[1:21:17] Jimi: You like my hair?
[1:21:19] Tommy: Yes.
[1:21:20] Jimi: My leaves, yes.
[1:21:22] Tommy: The sway of my arm, you say of my eaps.
[1:21:26] Jimi: Yes.
[1:21:27] Tommy: You want to play with me?
[1:21:30] Jimi: Okay, with me.
[1:21:32] Tommy: Come out and play with me.
[1:21:35] Jimi: Mademoiselle.
[1:21:40] Tommy: Doctor, Doctor.
[1:21:42] Jimi: See gentle.
[1:21:44] Tommy: You like my style.
[1:21:45] Jimi: Yes.
[1:21:47] Tommy: My brand.
[1:21:48] Jimi: Yes.
[1:21:53] Tommy: Yes.
[1:21:54] Jimi: You want to pray with me?
[1:21:56] Tommy: To stray with me.
[1:21:59] Jimi: Come out and play with me.
[1:22:02] Tommy: Mademoiselle Rose and Timmy.
[1:22:07] Jimi: Doctor, Doctor.
[1:22:09] Tommy: You're so right.
[1:22:10] Jimi: I like your how you say.
[1:22:13] Tommy: Imperturbable perspicacity.
[1:22:16] Jimi: It isn't all you say, it's what you see.
[1:22:20] Tommy: We have the lark.
[1:22:22] Jimi: Yes.
[1:22:23] Tommy: Zee fling.
[1:22:25] Jimi: Yes.
[1:22:26] Tommy: The play is the all you say is the thing.
[1:22:44] Jimi: But back to Anyone Can Whistle.
[1:22:47] Tommy: Great.
[1:22:48] Jimi: The music of Anyone Can Whistle— it's like even a witty chapter title.
[1:22:54] Tommy: No, but it's the best part.
[1:22:56] Jimi: It really is, right?
[1:22:58] Tommy: Okay, all balls out the barrel here.
[1:23:00] Jimi: There's some cracking stuff.
[1:23:01] Tommy: And you know what I'm gonna start with?
[1:23:03] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:23:03] Tommy: I'm gonna start with the song that holds within it my favorite Sondheim line of all time.
[1:23:11] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:23:12] Tommy: Of all time.
[1:23:13] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:23:13] Tommy: That line is in time, may we, we may.
[1:23:21] Jimi: Come now.
[1:23:22] Tommy: Come now, Thomas.
[1:23:23] Jimi: I mean, it's a good line.
[1:23:25] Tommy: It doesn't justify the rest of the song.
[1:23:29] Jimi: I listened, right? So when I for the very first time I listened to Anyone Can Whistle, just like having a gay old time be like, what the hell's going on?
[1:23:35] Tommy: This is funny.
[1:23:35] Jimi: Then this song comes on, I'm like, oh, okay, this is— I can— I'm with this.
[1:23:39] Tommy: This is a fun duet, quirky, you know, to lustful style, like um...
[1:23:47] Jimi: And that line came on, and I buckled over in laughter.
[1:23:55] Tommy: Buckled over, stopped in tracks, and buckled over because I was like, that is genius.
[1:24:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:24:05] Tommy: That's genius, Stephen Sondheim.
[1:24:07] Jimi: It's very clever.
[1:24:08] Tommy: In time, may we, we may, may we, we may.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:24:13] Tommy: That is the most simple thing in the world, but my goodness, it does— it does— is satisfying.
[1:24:13] Tommy: It does make you wonder if like the advantage that Lin-Manuel Miranda has over Stephen Sondheim is that he's actually bilingual potentially.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Like what?
[1:24:13] Tommy: It still works.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Um, yeah, like till the King Cassitois c'mois from Hamilton is nowhere near as good work with French as in time.
[1:24:13] Tommy: Sure, I was thinking more of his work with Spanish, but that's okay.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Um, time may we wait— like I— it's just so— it's so bloody good.
[1:24:13] Tommy: Yeah, it's so good.
[1:24:13] Jimi: It's Sondheim.
[1:24:13] Tommy: Yeah, like that's— that's it.
[1:24:13] Jimi: You are seeing in what I qualify as kind of a throwaway song some very, very cleverness.
[1:24:13] Tommy: Um, very, very cleverness.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Gonna stick by that sentence, right?
[1:24:13] Tommy: Get that in the t-shirt.
[1:24:13] Jimi: And that is, you know, we are— these are the parts where we're seeing Sondheim's, you know, baby genius coming out in this.
[1:24:13] Tommy: Even in— yeah, no one auditions with this song, no one performs this song in a cabaret, this song's not a part of Sondheim jukebox musicals.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Like the song's gone outside of the show, but it's very clever.
[1:24:13] Tommy: That's a— and it has this golden line in it.
[1:24:13] Jimi: Yeah, that nobody knows about.
[1:24:13] Tommy: Yeah, it's so good.
[1:25:45] Jimi: So the just the music, the music in this whole show is fantastic. And obviously the two big kind of killer songs are "Anyone Can Whistle" and "Everybody Says Don't." And everybody says, yep, so I would say "Anyone Can Whistle" has kind of garnered a bit more fame. Um, because it's a great female song.
[1:26:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:26:08] Jimi: Um, B, it's weirdly been attributed to being like Sondheim's autobiographical song. He addresses this in "Finishing the Hat," that it is very apocryphal, that like it is not, you know. There may be songs in his lexicon that are an exemplification of Sondheim the Man. "Anyone Can Whistle" is not that song.
[1:26:32] Tommy: No, absolutely not.
[1:26:33] Jimi: And it's strange because I've even seen Arthur Laurents say, "Yes, it's autobiographical, that song, isn't that amazing?" It's like, well, no, you're supposed to know him. You're supposed to be his like best mate.
[1:26:41] Tommy: Right.
[1:26:43] Jimi: Um, I think that I really do find that weird because it's strange that even with the existence and the fame of "Finishing the Hat," the fact that those words are there of him saying this isn't a thing.
[1:26:54] Tommy: Yeah, like it's still very much a thing that people say.
[1:26:57] Jimi: Well, and even if you know anything about Sondheim's character, like even in the writing of this show, the thesis of "Anyone Can Whistle" is like anyone can whistle, but I can't. I can do all these other things, but I can't do this one thing.
[1:27:12] Tommy: Right.
[1:27:18] Jimi: You know, so if only I could learn how to, you know, be more free, maybe I'd be able to whistle. Um, and like that was absolutely not Sondheim's interior monologue in writing "Anyone Can Whistle." You know, his interior monologue in "Anyone Can Whistle" is like, "I'm Stephen Sondheim, fuck you, I can do this," right?
[1:27:36] Tommy: Yeah, it's like I'm the best whistler.
[1:27:38] Jimi: I'm the best, and this is why we end up with "Finishing the Hat," which is the song that he says is quite autobiographical. Um, like the one he can most relate to.
[1:27:48] Tommy: Yes.
[1:27:49] Jimi: Uh, because he isolates himself because he's so good at everything. You know what I mean? Like that's what happens here. I find that such a strange thing. I think people say that so much.
[1:28:03] Tommy: He touches on it in his expounding upon why "Anyone Can Whistle" isn't his song but is attributed to him. More about how like we do this with artists. We're like, "Oh, that must be you. That thing you did, that was you." Like, you know, we're seeing the artist through the art, and how that kind of bothers him.
[1:28:23] Jimi: Um, and I really agree with him on that. That is the thing that has bothered me for a long time. We've talked about it before that we have this truism that artists must be broken to be a good artist, and like it's so fake and so terrible. Um, but it survives anyway.
[1:28:41] Tommy: Um, but there is something of that in attributing "Anyone Can Whistle" to Sondheim's inner psyche that like, oh well he must feel some kind of broken to be as good as he has at what he does.
[1:28:53] Jimi: Um, yeah, it's like, oh what a poor man that he, you know, feels so cut off or shut out by the world, yeah, that he can't access this, you know.
[1:29:02] Tommy: I'm like, no. No, you can be a happy artist. Certainly you can take tragedy in your life and turn it into art, but you do not need to make art from tragedy.
[1:29:12] Jimi: Um, which is such a terrible assumption.
[1:29:15] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely.
[1:29:16] Jimi: Uh, it's funny. Um, the other one I kind of want to pick out is the opening.
[1:29:22] Tommy: Yes, okay.
[1:29:23] Jimi: Um, it's an interesting way to start the show.
[1:29:27] Tommy: It’s a very interesting way to start the show. I think it's actually kind of masterful though.
[1:29:32] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:29:33] Tommy: Right. And I think it's a shame that the rest of the show wasn't as great because I think as a setup, yeah, it really works.
[1:29:42] Jimi: So we've talked about this before, I think, you know, in um about how like the first was it the first 30 seconds of your show should tell you everything you need to know or something like that.
[1:29:51] Tommy: Sure.
[1:29:52] Jimi: Yeah. There's uh there's some, oh gosh. I feel like it's a novel writing truism that maybe Hemingway said, but I'm sure I'm making that up. Um, that like the first sentence of your novel defines the rest of the novel.
[1:30:06] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:30:07] Jimi: Um, but that holds true in a lot of sequential art.
[1:30:11] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:30:11] Jimi: Um, I think in and certainly musical theatre terms, you know, as the integrated book musical was coming to the fore.
[1:30:17] Tommy: Oh, yeah.
[1:30:18] Jimi: Um, you know what everyone always cites "Tradition" because it is the perfect world setup.
[1:30:22] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:30:23] Jimi: Um, and you meet your characters and you know everything by the end of that song.
[1:30:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:30:26] Jimi: Um, so with "Me in My Town," the opening, um, you get that exact same thing, basically. Um, you meet Cora.
[1:30:37] Tommy: Uh, right away in a big way.
[1:30:40] Jimi: Yep.
[1:30:40] Tommy: Um, the very, very first thing she says, "Everyone hates me."
[1:30:44] Jimi: Yes, yes, being the Marius, yes.
[1:30:47] Tommy: Um, you've been introduced to her character and her whole thing.
[1:30:52] Jimi: Yep.
[1:30:53] Tommy: In the first two lines.
[1:30:55] Jimi: Um, which is fantastic. And then she goes on to explain what's happening. That uh everyone's in a terrible depression, um, the state has no money.
[1:31:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:31:07] Jimi: Uh, and then um, so you know you're in the world, you know the character, yeah.
[1:31:14] Tommy: In the world, yeah, the bigger picture gets brought out more with this idea of it's kind of like diagesis in a way, or the idea of it, and that this song is kind of like half and half um because there is a performative element to it, yeah.
[1:31:34] Jimi: You know, at the end she bows and you know pushes other people out of the way to bow, which means like, okay, you know she's been or she knows that she's been singing a song, she interacts with her backing singers, the Page Boys, yeah.
[1:31:46] Tommy: Um, so there is this, but at the same time, it's very firmly uh singing for the love of singing.
[1:32:57] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? It's I've been too, I'm have too much emotion in me that I can only say it's very much firmly in that idea, yeah.
[1:32:57] Tommy: Um, which predominantly is the way that the whole the rest of the show flows, yeah.
[1:32:57] Jimi: But what it sets you up for is this idea of like this show will be a little bit different, yeah. Just play about with things, certainly, um, and then the final thing if is we zoom out and take a further step back, um, it does something which musicals very rarely do for starters, um, but especially ones that kind of tear up the rule book as much as this song establishes the role of the audience.
[1:32:57] Tommy: Yes.
[1:32:57] Jimi: Or certainly what the role of the audience should be, sure.
[1:32:57] Tommy: Or could be.
[1:32:57] Jimi: Could be, is probably more apt. Um, because at the end, uh Cora bows to the applause of the audience, yes.
[1:32:55] Tommy: She's bringing them into it.
[1:32:57] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? The house lights could go up at that point.
[1:33:00] Tommy: Right.
[1:33:00] Jimi: And it would be fine. You are connected to a part of the show. She knows you're there.
[1:33:03] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:33:05] Jimi: And you know she's there. This is performative. This is a musical we're doing. We are embracing an aspect of the form with the form.
[1:33:14] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:33:15] Jimi: Exactly. And you, the audience, are an integral part of this. So when the end of Act One happens, it's like here you are. You're kind of set up. And that's what I think I mean is like they need more of it because they've set it up at the opening.
[1:33:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:33:26] Jimi: They've set it up at the end of Act One, and then never again do we have that audience on stage interaction.
[1:33:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:33:39] Jimi: I think it is. Cora is the first. Pardon me. Cora Hoover Hooper is the first uh important person we meet in this show. There's a little bit of a prologue with a narrator and a sandwich man. Um, Cora is certainly, you know, we meet Cora after her lackeys, Cooley, uh is it McGruger?
[1:34:03] Tommy: McGrudger.
[1:34:05] Jimi: Yeah, McGregor, I think. Whatever. Uh, you know, the three other government lackeys. Um, technically we meet them first, but Cora's the one who gets the song first.
[1:34:15] Tommy: Um, it's still a dozen pages before we ever meet Faye Apple, who is more arguably the protagonist.
[1:34:23] Jimi: Um, which is a really even when you're tearing up the form, it is an interesting choice to meet your antagonist first.
[1:34:32] Tommy: Um, I don't think them did I don't think it did them any favors.
[1:34:39] Jimi: Um, like it would have been interesting to have a there is a brief prelude that happens before uh Cora Hoover Hooper's song that's not filled with Faye or the cookies.
[1:34:52] Tommy: It should be.
[1:34:53] Jimi: We should meet them first, even if it's like her walking them across the stage, you know, come along now, kids or whatever.
[1:35:02] Tommy: Um, I don't know if I agree with that.
[1:35:05] Jimi: Do you know that?
[1:35:06] Tommy: Yeah, okay. Tell me why.
[1:35:06] Jimi: Because I really firmly believe it's Cora's story.
[1:35:10] Tommy: Interesting.
[1:35:11] Jimi: Because she doesn't change.
[1:35:14] Tommy: She doesn't change, but it's her journey, it's her I want song.
[1:35:20] Jimi: It is her I want. I mean she's the first thing that we see.
[1:35:22] Tommy: I just want to be loved.
[1:35:23] Jimi: Um, but they're, you know, she's not redeemable, like she, you know, she could take less money and unbank the town. Like she couldn't have to be a big thing.
[1:35:32] Tommy: But what's I get like, you know, absolutely filled with thought, but you're along for her ride, she sets up everything.
[1:35:38] Jimi: Sure.
[1:35:39] Tommy: Um, at the end, it's interesting, it's like if you let the camera roll for another ten minutes, yeah, um, after the miracle suddenly starts to exist, yeah, what might Cora react?
[1:35:51] Jimi: Right, yeah, might she have a change?
[1:35:53] Tommy: Do you know I mean might you get Cora's song of like awakening?
[1:35:56] Jimi: Yeah, that's fair. Perhaps, you know, and but I think that's the thing, is just for me, it is so it's very apt that she's at the front because she, you know, it being a conceptual piece, yeah, she's the one you're looking at.
[1:36:11] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:36:12] Jimi: You know, it's not you're not being steeped in the naturalism in the love story of Faye.
[1:36:17] Tommy: No, like that isn't the intention of the show.
[1:36:20] Jimi: Yeah, that's like a byproduct almost of the show. Um, what you're seeing is okay. Well, what is this kind of corrupt, misguided woman gonna do? How is she dealing?
[1:36:32] Tommy: And like even I think corrupt oversells it because she does, maybe not with the best of intentions, but still wants her town to love her, still wants her town to be okay.
[1:36:41] Jimi: Yeah, you know, has the plan that we need a miracle. Don't tell me what it is.
[1:36:45] Tommy: Um, yeah, no, I see you.
[1:36:48] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Like, I just I just feel it yeah, I just think it's always I think if Faye came to the front at the start, if we saw Faye, then it's not enough about her.
[1:36:59] Tommy: Sure.
[1:37:00] Jimi: This the show is not enough about her.
[1:37:02] Tommy: She feels like the secondary love story.
[1:37:07] Jimi: Yeah. I mean, I think that is the one of the, you know, more emblematic of the bigger problems with the show is that you know Faye has her literally like page and a half long monologue before "There Won't Be Trumpets," whether or not it's cut.
[1:37:22] Tommy: Um, and like it's almost that her power is shoehorned in.
[1:37:27] Jimi: Like she is not given her status uh for any other reason than she stands up on a box and says that she deserves it.
[1:37:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:37:40] Jimi: You know?
[1:37:40] Tommy: Um, and that's not a strong character choice.
[1:37:43] Jimi: Her the text is really strong and very convincing, but like as a character description, it feels so, you know, it's like a Deus Ex Machina in act one.
[1:37:55] Tommy: Um, why is she powerful?
[1:37:58] Jimi: Well, because she said so.
[1:37:59] Tommy: Um, which I guess I guess you could simplify that around a lot of pieces of show or a lot of pieces of musical theater, but this one it feels just so much more like, well, you smug little man in your smug little schemes. I'm I there are heroes in the world, listen to me, Faye Apple, hey, double P L E, right?
[1:38:18] Jimi: Like she doesn't have any reason or really any backstory or any, you know. Cora Hoover Hooper is a much more interesting character than Faye Apple.
[1:38:28] Tommy: Right.
[1:38:28] Jimi: That's what I mean. It's like Faye gets the great songs.
[1:38:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:38:29] Jimi: Faye gets the great songs, and I think probably because Lee Remick uh was a great singer.
[1:38:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:38:38] Jimi: You know what I mean?
[1:38:39] Tommy: Um, but she's n yeah, it's that isn't the one you're necessarily rooting for.
[1:38:48] Jimi: I don't know. Like it just it feels firmly in B plot.
[1:38:52] Tommy: Right.
[1:38:52] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:38:53] Jimi: Like I think in the in the no history world where we could rewrite this show to the cows come home, there we need to put the things that Cora Hoover Hooper does up on a board and the things that Faye Apple does up on the board, and mix them all up and redistribute that.
[1:39:09] Tommy: Whatever that character is.
[1:39:11] Jimi: Um they don't have a good reason to be in competition with each other.
[1:39:16] Tommy: Um and they need one.
[1:39:18] Jimi: Or all it really is is like we're both female.
[1:39:22] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[1:39:23] Jimi: I and I just want well in and Cora Hoover Hooper cares about her town, Faye cares about her cookies, and neither are really in direct opposition with each other.
[1:39:36] Tommy: No, because it's not even like there's a love triangle storyline.
[1:39:41] Jimi: Right.
[1:39:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:39:42] Jimi: You know, or that there's like a zero sum game that like if we give money to this, we won't give resources to that, or we only have we can only choose one of the like that doesn't exist.
[1:39:53] Tommy: They just don't like each other because we've cast them in the we don't like each other bubbles.
[1:39:57] Jimi: Um you're just supposed to go along with that. And like this, I think is the difficulty with doing what Sondheim himself calls an absurdist piece of musical theater. Um I am all for stretching the bounds of this sort of stuff and absurdism and these sort of things. But like you take a look at Waiting for Godot, which is absurdist to the nines.
[1:40:19] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:40:20] Jimi: But there are through lines to find there, there are things to find there. This is intentional, and that's why the show sticks on. Is like you don't quite know why, but there's something in here that you understand. Um like you can go absurdist in a piece of performance, but if you want it to be commercially viable, which Sondheim also says he wants it to be, then you have to give your audience something, and clearly that wasn't a priority for them.
[1:40:50] Tommy: Um you have to do something to either acknowledge these to embrace, I think, these built-in character tropes, or more fully break them, like break them more succinctly and destructively, so that we know you've like we learn that the protagonist is the bad guy. We learn, you know, we understand that you have changed, you've broken this rule, not just kind of like you know, fiddle faddle and wipe it away.
[1:41:14] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:41:26] Tommy: Um it's interesting. So I've not written this here, but something I've thought a lot about, and I mean, I don't know, I guess I'm interested to see what you think. It's not, I've not got a fully formed idea of it or anything, but um the relationship between Anyone Can Whistle and Urinetown.
[1:41:42] Jimi: Interesting.
[1:41:44] Tommy: I think it is interesting. I think Urinetown is what Anyone Can Whistle wanted to be. I think you could say that unabashedly. And came around the right time and was more properly structured.
[1:41:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:41:57] Tommy: Um, and just like even with like some of the through lines and some of the plot, like um with the mayor, he feels like Cora.
[1:42:09] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.
[1:42:10] Tommy: You know, I mean, like fumbling he's a comic villain. Um not but not hugely villainous, and obviously at the end of Urinetown, spoiler alert, um, kind of was right all along.
[1:42:21] Jimi: Right, was the good guy who flung, which you can say of Cora Hoover Hooper. In some ways, roll that camera ten minutes more. Let's see.
[1:42:27] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:42:28] Jimi: Um, like uh the love story between Bobby Strong and Hope feels I don't know, weirdly similar to the love story between the Apple and Hapgood.
[1:42:28] Tommy: I don't know.
[1:42:44] Jimi: There's a thesis there that I'll work out when we get to Urinetown. I'll bring this back up again. But I think it's entirely real. And it has this sociopolitical commentary that is in-depth, and you know, it's meta after there's pastiche everywhere. It embraces the like direct address to the audience narration.
[1:43:03] Tommy: Um wouldn't work if it wasn't a musical, like has that separation built in there.
[1:43:07] Jimi: Yeah, no, absolutely. Set in a dystopian small town city, do you know what I mean? City that has its own set of rules. Like um so, yeah, I guess Anyone Can Whistle owes no, Urinetown knows everything to Anyone Can Whistle. Probably.
[1:43:23] Tommy: I wonder, you know, I haven't I've not seen anything out there that is a direct comparison to the two. I haven't done it, I haven't done a deep dive in Urinetown reviews, but I wonder if there's a review that's like this is very Anyone Can Whistle-esque.
[1:43:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:43:40] Tommy: It is as I think a strong and interesting comparison.
[1:43:43] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:43:44] Tommy: I'll work on it. When we get to Urinetown, I'll have it, I'll have it written out.
[1:43:48] Jimi: I'm excited to read the thesis.
[1:43:49] Tommy: It'll be fully published. I'll be a doctor.
[1:43:51] Jimi: Can you cite your own work in our part of the musical theater pantheon in this podcast?
[1:43:57] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:43:58] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:43:59] Tommy: Um yeah. Uh before we leave Faye though, um, and I kind of mentioned this earlier, like she does have a really good arc.
[1:44:08] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:44:09] Tommy: I mean, like this is what I mean. This is it feels really I feel like as we're talking about this, we're just like idea, idea, idea, thought, thought, thought. And it is, it's because that's the way the show is.
[1:44:18] Jimi: It is the way the show is.
[1:44:19] Tommy: It's like, I'm just gonna present this to you.
[1:44:21] Jimi: Right.
[1:44:22] Tommy: And there it goes again. Um, but yeah, with Faye, so she kind of has four main songs. Um, if you include trumpets, uh so if you do include trumpets, if not her speech kind of works.
[1:44:43] Jimi: Yes.
[1:44:43] Tommy: Um, so trumpets is is almost like her I want song, but it's it's kind of an I a warning song or like a I want song. It isn't I want song. She wants a hero for this world kind of.
[1:44:56] Jimi: Yes.
[1:44:57] Tommy: Uh-huh. She knows that it's it's like I want, but it's a very she she really believes it.
[1:45:02] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:45:02] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? It's a very firm. In the she believes in logic and you know, human spirit is as close as we get to a miracle. Um, and like someone's someone's gonna help us, but it it's not gonna be what you think.
[1:45:16] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:45:17] Tommy: Um, and so then the next time we hear her, um, okay, is it complain with me, but sure that's fine. We'll just technically a different character at that point.
[1:45:26] Jimi: But very good.
[1:45:27] Tommy: Thank you very much for that. Uh so then the next big moment is Anyone Can Whistle where we explore her vulnerability and we see a bit more about what she's thinking and what she feels.
[1:45:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:45:39] Tommy: Um then we have now it's weird though. I would even though she doesn't sing it, yeah.
[1:45:47] Jimi: Everybody says don't.
[1:45:48] Tommy: Yeah. Isn't a direct response to her. Is a song to her. It might as well be a duet in a rewriting. Like if Hapgood kept singing the song, Faye might join in in chorus as she tears up the paper and then the act ends.
[1:46:01] Jimi: Yes, exactly.
[1:46:02] Tommy: Um, and she does reprise it in her um act three song, yeah, which is called uh See What It Gets You.
[1:46:02] Jimi: See What It Gets You, where it's a direct retort to um Hapgood being annoying, basically.
[1:46:19] Tommy: Yeah, um, and then finally they come together and she sings to him um with so little to be sure of, or sings with him, sorry, with so little to be sure of, uh, and has this kind of closure moment.
[1:46:32] Jimi: Yeah, and so there's like a really nice clear arc that nobody else in the show has.
[1:46:37] Tommy: Yep.
[1:46:38] Jimi: Um, and really good musical theater writing all the way through that and bringing in the illusions of all of those numbers back into the final song, um, and peppering them out, even just through um through the orchestrations and just through the writing, um, is really, really smart musical theater writing.
[1:47:00] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:47:01] Jimi: It's quite it's quite golden. It gives her a really strong through line that I think a lot of the plot blows up. Like if you just totally did a show of like just her, it'd be great.
[1:47:15] Tommy: Yes, exactly. That's the thing, is like, you know, it goes back to like all of these little pockets that we talk about, um, with all of these little disparate ideas that are all in their own way golden.
[1:47:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:47:27] Tommy: If they just focused on one or two, right? I just feel like this show could have been something extremely special.
[1:47:35] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:47:35] Tommy: Um all it is is it's just it's special, but not for the reasons that the authors intended.
[1:47:44] Jimi: Sure.
[1:47:44] Tommy: They they well, and they wanted to intend too much. Like I think part of it is, you know, I think some of the most successful pieces are the author certainly has a a thesis, but the thesis is story related.
[1:47:58] Jimi: Um is much more story-tied.
[1:48:00] Tommy: Whereas it seems like uh Sondheim and Laurents went into this with a thesis that was very idea-tied and tried to write a story around that. And I think the best stories, the ideas are sprung from them. You discover your idea in it, and then you write uh Children Will Listen.
[1:48:19] Jimi: You know, Children Will Listen is inspired from the story of Into the Woods, not the other way around.
[1:48:25] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:48:25] Jimi: Content dictates form.
[1:48:28] Tommy: What a crazy thought.
[1:48:30] Jimi: Right.
[1:48:30] Tommy: Um, this is this is the birth of that. And that this is why I'm so glad that we have Anyone Can Whistle because it does feel like it's it's all of the bits of paper that are in finishing the and look I made a yeah, you know, that is what I feel like we're seeing here, but for Sondheim's whole musical career is that little glance in to be like wow, you're uh you are a genius.
[1:48:53] Tommy: Yeah. You just need to polish that down and look at what you can do. Oh, you can write Company.
[1:49:02] Jimi: I think the thing, like this is this is why I find uh the the hat book so inspiring is that it it feels it makes you feel like yes, Steven Sondheim is a genius and you can too. Um like take a look at this, take a look at Anyone Can Whistle. He knows it flopped, he knows it wasn't great, and there were bits and pieces here that he stuck with and kept with and kept on working and kept on trying and kept on finding until he made his Company and Woods and Todd and the rest of them.
[1:49:30] Tommy: Um and like you have that inside you too, and you're gonna have to get over some floppage along the way.
[1:49:39] Jimi: Yep.
[1:49:40] Tommy: Um so join the conversation, geek out, and have the discussions and show us your floppage.
[1:49:49] Jimi: Did I do that right?
[1:49:50] Tommy: Oh, you spoiled it.
[1:49:52] Jimi: You just spoiled it.
[1:49:56] Tommy: Um please don't show us your floppage. I understand we have Instagram now, but that's not good as far.
[1:50:01] Jimi: Thanks for everything we did.
[1:50:05] Tommy: Everything that's past.
[1:50:08] Jimi: Everything that's over so far.
[1:50:14] Tommy: None of it was waste.
[1:50:16] Jimi: None of it was waste.
[1:50:18] Tommy: All of it will lie.
[1:50:19] Jimi: All of it will last.
[1:50:21] Tommy: Everything that's here.
[1:50:29] Jimi: It was marvelous to know you.
[1:50:36] Tommy: And it's never really through.
[1:50:48] Jimi: Can't complain about the time.
[1:50:51] Tommy: Where can I somewhere to be sure in this one?
[1:51:49] Jimi: Well, Tommy. That was Anyone Can Whistle.
[1:51:53] Tommy: Has it has it taught you how?
[1:51:55] Jimi: Hey, look.
[1:51:56] Tommy: That was oh my god.
[1:51:57] Jimi: That was actually really good.
[1:51:59] Tommy: Thank you.
[1:51:59] Jimi: Come back to me.
[1:52:01] Tommy: Come back to me and we'll kiss.
[1:52:03] Jimi: Uh well.
[1:52:04] Tommy: And then water will spurt out of a rot.
[1:52:08] Jimi: Stop it.
[1:52:09] Tommy: I gotta I got a quiz question for you to dig us out of this hole.
[1:52:13] Jimi: Thank you. Please do.
[1:52:14] Tommy: Um. Hades is hopping in New York theater right now. When this show opens later this year, it will mark the third time that the Greek God has trod the boards in 2019. What show?
[1:52:27] Jimi: It's Happen.
[1:52:28] Tommy: Hades, it's Happen.
[1:52:31] Jimi: If you would like to get in touch with us, you absolutely can. Our show Twitter is @JimAndTomic. That is J A M A N D T O M I C.
[1:52:40] Tommy: Or you can join the Reddit discussion. Links are in the show notes and your podcatcher right now, or you can head over to JimAtomic.com.
[1:52:48] Jimi: And while you're there, you can check out our Patreon if you'd like to financially support the show.
[1:52:52] Tommy: As always, thank you to all of our current patrons. We adore each and every one of you.
[1:52:58] Jimi: And also, uh reviews on Apple Podcasts are so helpful in pushing us up the charts there.
[1:53:04] Tommy: They truly, truly are. But most of all, we just love it when you tell your pals all about us.
[1:53:11] Jimi: Get them involved in that conversation. Boom. Be the change. I don't know. Teach them how to whistle.
[1:53:19] Tommy: God, I am nailing this.
[1:53:22] Jimi: That is all we got. And thanks for listening.
[1:53:25] Tommy: Cheers.
[1:53:26] Jimi: Cheers.
[1:53:41] Tommy: Yes, we're colleagues with Donna McKechney.
[1:53:45] Jimi: Does she have an Instagram?
[1:53:46] Tommy: No, she doesn't have an Instagram, so it's it's not her fault.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
