Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep7 - Jay Armstrong Johnson, the little bouncing gay ball

Josh has known Jay Armstrong Johnson since they were in high school -- Jay is currently starring Raoul in as in Phantom. In 2001, he made his debut at the theater in a production of the musical Peter Pan... Read More

From the show: Josh Swallows Broadway

39 mins
9/10/19

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Josh has known Jay Armstrong Johnson since they were in high school -- Jay is currently starring Raoul in as in Phantom. In 2001, he made his debut at the theater in a production of the musical Peter Pan. After joining the American tour of A Chorus Line in the role of Mark, he debuted on Broadway in 2009 in the musical Hair (with Josh, duh) as a member of the ensemble and the first substitute for Gavin Creel in the role of Claude. In 2010, he played the protagonist Jack Kelly in one of the first readings of the musical Newsies.

In 2011, Johnson replaced Aaron Tveit as Frank Abagnale in the musical Catch Me If You Can. before returning to Broadway in the musical Hands on a Hard Body.

Produced by Alan Seales and Dori Berinstein.

A proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:17] Josh Lamon: Hey everybody, it's me, Josh Lamon, and welcome back to Josh Swallows Broadway here on the Broadway Podcast Network, and I am thrilled to be sitting here with somebody who is basically my little brother in this world. I've known him since he was in high school. This is Broadway's darling Jay Armstrong Johnson!

[0:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What's up, you guys?

[0:41] Josh Lamon: How are you doing, babe?

[0:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm so good.

[0:43] Josh Lamon: Good. Yeah, man. Right now you're starring as Raoul in Phantom of the Opera.

[0:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, you actually pronounce it Raúl.

[0:49] Josh Lamon: Raúl is the Spanish pronunciation.

[0:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We're in France, so it's Raoul.

[0:52] Josh Lamon: No, really?

[0:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Actually.

[0:54] Josh Lamon: And I'm such a Phantom nerd.

[0:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I guess I'm not nerdy enough.

[0:58] Josh Lamon: Are you a fan?

[0:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Ooh, is that what they call themselves?

[1:01] Josh Lamon: E-H-A-N, baby.

[1:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wow, remember during Hair we used to call the fan base, what do they call themselves?

[1:06] Josh Lamon: Hairballs.

[1:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, I think we called them hairballs, but they took offense to that, maybe.

[1:10] Josh Lamon: Oh, oops. Sorry, kids. Um, well, I think they call themselves the flower pots, actually.

[1:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, the flower pots.

[1:16] Josh Lamon: Right. Okay, whatever. Good morning, Starshine.

[1:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We linger below.

[1:21] Josh Lamon: Yeah, do we?

[1:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Think so.

[1:23] Josh Lamon: So, Jay, how you doing?

[1:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm really good.

[1:27] Josh Lamon: Good. Um, now we met. Do you remember the year?

[1:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think it had to have been either 2003 or 2004.

[1:35] Josh Lamon: Oh my god. It was either my sophomore or my junior year of high school.

[1:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I think it was 2004.

[1:40] Josh Lamon: That's bonkers. Um, I was still pretty new to the city, and um I booked, that's right, I booked.

[1:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[1:48] Josh Lamon: Um, Godspell at Casa Maniana Theater in Fort Worth, Texas.

[1:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I went down there with a suitcase filled with dreams.

[1:58] Josh Lamon: And that's where I met Jay, who was cast in the show as well.

[2:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because I also booked.

[2:04] Josh Lamon: Yeah, because you booked. What uh song did you do in that show?

[2:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We beseech thee.

[2:09] Josh Lamon: Okay.

[2:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We made it a rousing hoedown number.

[2:11] Josh Lamon: I vaguely remember that.

[2:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But I was like dressed in like sports for Gale, yeah, like really bright, like Texas Rangers, but like Dallas Stars knee pads and like a baseball cap, and they made me like bleach my hair like urine yellow.

[2:25] Josh Lamon: Wait, I thought that you bleached your hair on your own.

[2:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, no, no. That was fully a directorial decision.

[2:31] Josh Lamon: No.

[2:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[2:32] Josh Lamon: So when I dyed my hair back to its original color, it might have been 2005, actually, now that I'm thinking about it. When I dyed my hair back, it never quite got my original color back.

[2:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So because then I went like Auburn-ish.

[2:42] Josh Lamon: That's hilarious. I've been telling the story wrong for years. I've been like, I met this little bouncing gay ball with highlighter yellow hair.

[2:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, I mean they asked me to. They wanted me to look more youthful.

[2:54] Josh Lamon: Like more youthful.

[2:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're 16.

[2:57] Josh Lamon: I know. I was 16. That's crazy. Hilarious. That's so bonkers. Um, and that's where we fell in love. The first day the director had us all sing our audition songs.

[3:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: How dare you.

[3:10] Josh Lamon: And I think I sang All Good Gifts because I did that in the show, and I was like, well, I'm gonna sing this in the show, or I'm not, so this is my 32 bars.

[3:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Get into it.

[3:20] Josh Lamon: And speaking of, at that audition, he was like, So what? It says that you can do funny voices. What are some funny voices?

[3:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I was like, I do a Gwen Verdon impersonation, which oddly is also my Matthew Broderick impersonation.

[3:35] Josh Lamon: I was like, mmm, Bobby, or Sarah Michelle, or Sarah Jessica, that's her name.

[3:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm sorry, Sarah.

[3:45] Josh Lamon: Yeah, and somehow they cast me.

[3:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They did.

[3:48] Josh Lamon: I don't know why.

[3:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But um, you were very good.

[3:52] Josh Lamon: Thank you.

[3:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, thank you.

[3:54] Josh Lamon: Um, and so I got to meet you, this brilliant you, and I fell in love with you.

[4:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Why?

[4:01] Josh Lamon: Because I sang Dancing Through Life when you sing All Good Gifts.

[4:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[4:04] Josh Lamon: You sang Dancing Through Life as your audition song.

[4:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: As every 16-year-old gay boy is apt to do.

[4:10] Josh Lamon: But that moment, because I was new to Texas, so in my mind, I had all these sort of stereotypical ideas of what Texas was, like, you know, uh-oh, dang dang, King Baby Jay's the Bible's in English, I was learn it, you know, that kind of thing.

[4:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, well, not far from the truth.

[4:32] Josh Lamon: But for whatever reason, I created this story in my head of here's this poor gay boy in Texas. I don't even know if he knows that he's gay. He's probably severely abused and locked up, and his parents don't know that he's doing theater. They think he's at Bible camp, and it's up to me to protect him and nurture him.

[4:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is literally what I thought for years.

[4:58] Josh Lamon: I mean, like, yeah, gay, yes, 16, yes. Did I know it? Kind of.

[5:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, girl, you knew it.

[5:04] Josh Lamon: Yeah, well, around the professional theater people, sure I knew it because I had other examples of like gay life, and they were nice humans and they were talented, and they were all the like Christian ideals that I was told to like look up toward to you know, but then I was completely straight at high school and at church, and I mean, I was literally leading a double life, age 15, 16, 17.

[5:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, Jay.

[5:26] Josh Lamon: It was real fun though. I remember that you couldn't really hang out with us because you were still in high school. I believe I remember even like driving you home one time.

[5:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[5:34] Josh Lamon: Meanwhile, you were out drinking at downtown Fort Worth, and like I was out drinking at a house party like down the street with my friends.

[5:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Which is hilarious.

[5:42] Josh Lamon: But we did eventually have a cast party at some rich woman in the cast married some oil person.

[5:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[5:53] Josh Lamon: And lived in this enormous man.

[5:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Ridiculous house.

[5:59] Josh Lamon: Like this atrium with this pool.

[6:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[6:01] Josh Lamon: Oh yeah, there was a lot of tequila that night.

[6:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There was a lot.

[6:04] Josh Lamon: There was some naughtiness.

[6:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was like so much naughtiness.

[6:07] Josh Lamon: If Michael John LaChiusa's Wild Party and Andrew Lippa's Wild Party met and had a baby and decided to keep the baby.

[6:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Totally.

[6:16] Josh Lamon: That was that baby. Um, but then years later, like you already started working. I remember like we would run into each other here and there, but then you booked the Chorus Line tour.

[6:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[6:29] Josh Lamon: And I was like, oh, my little baby, my little baby brother Jay. Oh, look at him. He's like working and living his dreams. And then we got to make our Broadway debut together.

[6:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Which is crazy.

[6:42] Josh Lamon: So crazy. And not just like any Broadway debut, it was like Hair.

[6:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hair.

[6:46] Josh Lamon: And like we marched on Washington for gay rights because marriage equality hadn't actually happened. And so it was like we were playing hippies, like protesting in Times Square, like going to rallies. It was like the most unbelievable experience of my maybe my entire career.

[7:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Our producers and the producers down at the Public Theater literally canceled a performance so we could go down to DC and march for marriage equality.

[7:11] Josh Lamon: And also sing at the rally.

[7:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We sang Let the Sunshine In after like Lady Gaga's crazy rousing speech.

[7:16] Josh Lamon: Yeah. I mean, though, to be real, I don't really know who Lady Gaga was yet.

[7:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I kind of did because she went to NYU with me and my peers.

[7:25] Josh Lamon: Well, you're young, so you like cool things like pop music.

[7:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You know, you like what they call, oh, that is a bop, or I stan that person.

[7:36] Josh Lamon: I'm still learning because I'm not not young.

[7:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, kids in your show are like.

[7:40] Josh Lamon: Oh, well, they're babies.

[7:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They were us. That was me when I was in Hair.

[7:45] Josh Lamon: I found out that you were doing Hair via Facebook.

[7:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I forget what your status was, but I remember mine was sort of vague. It was like, I'm gonna let the sun shine in, y'all.

[7:54] Josh Lamon: Well, it was like this Facebook statuses were like Jay Armstrong Johnson is, and then you'd like to fill in a blank.

[7:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So like all the statuses were like, is making his Broadway debut in Hair. You know what I mean?

[8:03] Josh Lamon: Like we got to share a dressing room once again.

[8:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because we were swing sisters.

[8:09] Josh Lamon: Yeah. For those of you who don't know what a swing is, it is the hardest job on the planet. You're responsible for knowing every single part in the show, basically.

[8:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Essentially.

[8:19] Josh Lamon: And Jay was there to basically cover Gavin Creel.

[8:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a major Broadway debut.

[8:27] Josh Lamon: It was pretty crazy. Also, when I got cast in Hair, they didn't know Gavin was going to be.

[8:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Really?

[8:33] Josh Lamon: Yeah, I got cast before Gavin.

[8:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because I walked into that audition and I looked a lot like Jonathan Groff who played Claude in the Park.

[8:41] Josh Lamon: Right.

[8:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I thought it was gonna be John.

[8:42] Josh Lamon: Absolutely.

[8:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I got come up. People came up to me on the street during Spring Awakening and they'd be like, I love you in Spring Awakening. Like they thought I was absolutely every time.

[8:51] Josh Lamon: And so I knew I kind of had this striking resemblance to Jonathan Groff when I walked into those auditions. They saw Claude. You know what I mean?

[8:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So that's how I got the role, and then they cast Gavin.

[9:00] Josh Lamon: Did you have your fro yet?

[9:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, I mean it was kind of growing out-ish because I went for like the 70s shag thing for A Chorus Line.

[9:08] Josh Lamon: Yeah.

[9:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I just didn't really cut it after I got it. And then it really, by the time we got to opening night, it was like in full glory.

[9:16] Josh Lamon: Crazy. Now for me, like the first I don't know, four months of the show were really hard because I felt like such an outsider.

[9:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[9:23] Josh Lamon: I mean, here was this company that just did it in the park, and we're the swing team. So while they're like teching the show on stage, we're in the mezzanine.

[9:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Taking notes.

[9:33] Josh Lamon: Trying to learn the show. And like also, like I just I was a little too shy. I wasn't really ready to put myself out there. Like I felt like I was a part of something, but sort of like the distant cousin.

[9:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[9:46] Josh Lamon: That is weird and nobody really talks to.

[9:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Totally.

[9:49] Josh Lamon: I mean, they're nice to because they have to.

[9:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's your distant cousin.

[9:52] Josh Lamon: Right. But I'm like the cousin that grew up on the hog farm, and you know, like, and doesn't have many friends except the hogs.

[10:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: As if no, I didn't really grow up on a hog farm.

[10:03] Josh Lamon: But that's how it felt for me. I could have, to be completely. I lived like a mile away from one at least.

[10:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Of course you did.

[10:09] Josh Lamon: Ding ding ding ding ding ding-ding ding. Let's be real. Farm, ding ding.

[10:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But then the coolest part about Hair was that, and a lot of other Broadway shows don't do this, is that they invited the swings in to do the Tony performance, and they invited the swings in to do the original cast album.

[10:24] Josh Lamon: And so, you know, right after opening, when we were a hit and we were making money, like they really kind of ushered us into the family.

[10:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And that's when we started going on for people.

[10:32] Josh Lamon: And so we slowly integrated our way into that hippie group. Speaking of going on, I'll never forget we were decorating our dressing room.

[10:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And it was a really good idea.

[10:43] Josh Lamon: Like we were gonna paint the table red and like the doorway red or something, and it was really good on paper, and it turned out to be not so good in real life.

[10:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um but we were painting and the show was happening, and was it like it was the song Hair, and all of a sudden, like Gavin wasn't on stage, like he wasn't singing anymore.

[11:07] Josh Lamon: Do you remember this?

[11:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, not really.

[11:10] Josh Lamon: I do, because it was your I believe it was the first time that you went on, wasn't it mid-show?

[11:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, well, I think he he was not feeling well on a Friday night performance. And like they came up in the show and they were like, just want to let you know Gavin's not feeling well, so just be on alert.

[11:26] Josh Lamon: He finished that show.

[11:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I went out drinking with Alex Brightman and Jason Michael Snow till two in the morning.

[11:34] Josh Lamon: And then Saturday morning at 9 a.m. I get a phone call from Nancy being like, You're making your Broadway debut today, get your ass to the theater as fast as possible.

[11:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's amazing.

[11:45] Josh Lamon: We were in previews, so I'd never had a rehearsal.

[11:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No.

[11:48] Josh Lamon: Like I only knew the show from watching it, so I did the show via osmosis and an hour-long put in with a stage manager on stage, and that's how I made my Broadway debut.

[11:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's so insane.

[12:00] Josh Lamon: What was it like?

[12:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't remember it.

[12:02] Josh Lamon: I don't remember a second of it.

[12:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And then in between shows, I got like two pages of notes.

[12:09] Josh Lamon: Of course.

[12:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: My second show was just the worst.

[12:11] Josh Lamon: Of course. It's like, oh my gosh, you were so good. Thank you for saving us. By the way, here's where you sucked.

[12:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Exactly.

[12:17] Josh Lamon: Here is where the audience was rooting for Claude to die.

[12:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Including myself.

[12:23] Josh Lamon: Oh my god, yeah. But I remember watching in the back of the house and just sobbing for you, just watching you be the star.

[12:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And also we were lucky because like Gavin is the first person that really taught me like if you're the lead, you're the leader.

[12:42] Josh Lamon: Right.

[12:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And um, you know, I'll never forget that experience.

[12:46] Josh Lamon: Totally.

[12:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Me too. I mean, to this day. Do you remember the Tony Awards?

[12:53] Josh Lamon: Ish.

[12:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I just remember being terrified.

[12:56] Josh Lamon: I remember that shaking. That like video wall going up and all of us marching forward.

[13:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god.

[13:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And Liza was coming through us. Eliza was coming through us, and just this C at Radio City, just like top to bottom of tuxedos. And we were the finale of that like opening montage. Yeah. And like, you know, I remember being like, don't feel cocky, but for whatever reason, I was just like, oh, we're gonna win. Right. And then when the show did, we got to go on stage and accept it. Do you remember Anthony Hollock standing behind Oscar Eustace? Just like giving us memes for days. I mean, literally. Not yet, but like talk suit picked it up because Anthony Hollock was in the ensemble of the show. And he is such a character. He had this long, long curly brown hair. Gorgeous. And though he wasn't stoned, he just sort of looked stoned.

You know, he was standing right behind Oscar Eustace, who was making the acceptance speech, and his face, it just looked like somebody gave a puppy 17 edibles. And next thing you know, it's like all over television. Yeah. Just like late night shows making fun of poor Anthony Holland. Way to go, boo. I mean, he did it. He really did it. He did it. But you know, he was just like, I was just so caught up in the moment. Oh, yeah. I mean, we all were. We just didn't have a close-up on national television. No.

[14:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So tell me about life after Hair, dude. Um, life after Hair actually got sad because when it ended, like it was like the end of my Broadway debut, and like our tribe, half of our tribe had gone away to London, and you know, it was kind of like this, it ended it like wheedled off as opposed to like ending in like an explosion of glory. So it was it was a little sad for me. And I think Gavin also wrote a song about Hair ending where he like kind of went through this like grieving process. Yeah. Because we like lost a family. It was also strange, like that was our first experience watching a show close. Sure. And I don't know about you, but I remember so vividly, like the start of the show, the curtain falls down, the hippies run forward and are singing Aquarius.

And I'm looking and I'm like, oh my god, there's 40 people in the mezzanine. Right. There's only 40 people in the mezzanine. Right. And I was like, Starshine, you better save those coins, girl. And I remember like going, I think I even went to Gavin and I was like, Gavin, what does it look like when a show closes? And he was like, oh, it looks like this. And I was like, uh, I'm not ready to let go of this money. I spent so many years trying to get this. Right. And um, yeah, it was really sad. It was especially sad when that original company, when we were divided up and they went to London. Totally. And you know, it was kind of like tearing little innocent siblings apart. Truly. That's what it felt like.

Oh, yeah, definitely. And when the new company came in, they were so freaking talented, but they gave them like two and a half weeks to like get acclimated to each other and to like learn this intimate show. It's very like non-linear, like all about each character's interaction with each other. And so it was a bit of a learning curve for the whole company to like find that magic again that this original company had from their concert in the park that turned into a production in the park that turned into broad, you know what I mean? Yeah. So it was that then turned into the West End. Right. What was your your next job after that was Catch Me If You Can, correct?

[16:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And you were standing by for Aaron Tveit. Yeah. That's remarkable. And the difference between an understudy and a standby is that the standby is only there for that one leading character and no one else. What was that like? It was kind of like Hair, because I spent a lot of my time back just backstage chilling with you guys. But the thing is is that I never went on for the role. No, really? Not a once. No. Mr. Tveit was a workhorse. Okay. Yeah. So I mean, it didn't run very long. I think we ran like six or seven months, but I remember us getting our closing notice. And I was like, oh, I will never play this role. That's so sad. Yeah, I'm like really trying to get the Muni in St. Louis to do Catch Me If You Can so I can finally play the role.

Best of luck to you and the Muny at St. Louis. Can I be Norbert Leo Butz? How fun would that be? Pay there you, you naughty teen. You better stop all that lying. You better stop all that flying. Whoa! I'm really gifted. Um what thrills me so much is that like after that, it was like standby no more.

[18:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. All of a sudden, you took off. Yeah, I mean, I can't. Is that weird to for me to say to you? Ish, because it just felt like a little bit of like a oh, almost got off. Oh, we're getting, you know what I mean? Because I had to make a decision to stop going in for ensemble roles, stop going in for understudy positions, and even stop going in for standby positions to show the industry at large, like I'm serious about this. Like, I want to be a leading player. I think I have it in me. Because Broadway saw me as the understudy for Gavin and the standby for Aaron, and that's what they saw me for for three years. So I really stopped taking ensemble tracks and I started doing more regional work and you know, kind of going outside and doing some off-Broadway stuff so that I could build my resume as a leading player, and then Hands on a Hard Body happened.

[18:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Which I think definitely put you on the map. And also, like fun. It didn't last nearly as long as it should have. Right. But all of a sudden, the world got to see you. Right. The world got to meet Kayala. Right. I say it right. Kayala, yeah. Okay, Kayala. Aloha girl, if you're listening. Hey girl. That was remarkable, and that launched you to Quantico. Um, uh, On the Town first. On the Town! How could I forget On the Town? Because I remember when Hands on a Hard Body closed, I was so devastated because it was my first role actually on stage on Broadway. Opposite Allison Case from Hair. Opposite Allison. Hilarious. Which is ridiculous. Yeah. But it was also set in Texas an hour away from where I grew up.

Oh wow. And so I wasn't just like acting on stage. I was just breathing. Like I was just like being my family from back home. So it was like Texas and home and heart and love. And so when we ended so quickly and so abruptly, it was like earth shattering. And then I got an audition to go do like On the Town at Barrington Stage Company for a summer stock couple of months, and I was like, all right, all right, let's go. And then that turned into a Broadway show. I know. Which never happens. I know. And uh I did a reading of it with Jay. Right. And I was so devastated that they didn't take me with it. I wanted to do another Broadway show with you.

[20:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I like literally, I had to sit Shiva over On the Town. But I did see it many times, and you were incredible, as you know. Thanks. And then Quantico happened. Yeah. That's insane. It actually is insane because I stopped working with a manager halfway through like On the Town. I was like, I'm gonna take my own career by the balls, and I'm gonna make this happen, and I don't need a manager, and I don't need this help. I'm gonna do this. And then like On the Town ended, and I was like, well, damn. I'm unemployed again and I don't have a manager. But then Quantico came around because the showrunner and writer of Quantico was a huge Broadway fan. Oh my god. And so he'd seen me in Hands on a Hard Body, and he'd seen me in a row.

So he's a Broadway fan. Why the hell ain't there no like fat Jewish balding Quantico person? Watch, stop you, terrorist. FBI. I'm gonna kill your family pets if you don't stop. Hey. I'm pissed. I should have been in that with you. I mean, I'll tell them to write you on when they bring it back. They are sizists. Sizist, homophobic, anti-Semitic. Um, they're gonna pay for this.

[21:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and right now you're starring in my favorite, probably show Phantom as Raoul. How do you say it? Raoul. Raoul. Raoul. Raoul. I always thought that uh Phantom just amuses me. Besides the fact that I'm obsessed with it, but I'm like, okay, so let me get this straight. The best music teacher on the planet, apparently, has found this ballerina girl and is like, she looks gifted. I know. Let me find a mirror that I can give her lessons. And hopefully she'll stop by the mirror. Oh, wait, there she Yo, Christine and the Phantom. I live in a mirror, you can't see me, but trust, I know what to do. So trust here, Christine JB Christine. Say do a little vocal warm-up like da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da.

Sing! Sing for me! Sing! Angel of Music Sing! And that's your lesson. Pro bono. Pro bono. That's right. But that's your voice lesson. And then it's next thing you know, Madame Giry is let us sing for you, monsieur. She has been well tall. Yeah, Madame Giry, she's shady. She is really shady. Well, I mean, you s did you see Love Never Dies? I did. Yeah. That oh that whole family. The Girys, Meg Giry, her, Madame Giry, what's her first name? Florence.

[22:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Florence Giry. I don't know. Alexa Giry. Tiffany Giry. Love never dies. But Christine sure does. Spoiler alert. How is Phantom going? Are you loving it? Yeah, I am loving it. I, you know, this is my first Broadway show where I've replaced, which is a completely different game. You know. Like when you're when you're opening a new Broadway show, you rehearse it with the company and you have a big opening night, and then you run it and you hope to run. This shit's been running for 31 years. Amazing. Like oh I've I am only like four months older than Phantom of the Opera. Are you really? Yeah, I was born in September of 87. Phantom on Broadway was born in January of 88. You're the same age as my real little brother, but you're the little brother that I always wanted.

Well, and like all says we make our own family now. Yeah, we do. Um, I really need to come see you in the show. Yeah, I need to come see you go on for Brooks. Oh, it's heaven. Um shhh sure. Don't tell Brooks this, but when I'm on for the character, the show soars. It really takes off. I mean, finally, you're hearing the music as it needs to be sung. I have a feeling you're going to go out of your way to show Brooks this particular clip. No, no. Brooks and I are very close. He just what I've been trying to teach him is you need to listen and respond. Honestly.

[24:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, well. Oh man, but I love your show so much. Thanks for watching. I love it so much. Thanks. I am. One of these days. I love you so much. If you're ever on for a Wednesday matinee, yeah, shoot me a text immediately. I'm gonna come see you on a Thursday matinee. Right. There's no getting comps to your show. You know this, right? Correct. I've been like, I've seen the show 87 times. It's doomy. Yeah, doom and glow. Andrew, Andy, look at mommy. Mommy's not mad, but mommy wants a free ticket. Look, I'm in the show and I'd like a free ticket to get my agent to come. Broadway's hard. Yeah, man. But if they were giving away free tickets, it wouldn't be running for 31 years. Yeah, that's for sure. You know? Um, I wanna go back a little bit. Uh, what was it like growing up in Texas? Ah.

[25:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was hard because it was the 90s and like Will and Grace hadn't quite come out and like made the gay agenda thing. You know, so uh before I found theater, it was kind of like terrible. Like was your family religious? Pretty, pretty darn religious. We started out Southern Baptist, which is like really religious. Yikes. Um, but then we went to a like a more liberal denomination where they were they allow female ministers. No. Also homosexual ones. Ding dong, and not my church. Not mine. Um, so that was kind of cool. And then like church became my like literal sanctuary from like the harsh reality of like the Texas public school system, where if like you're not playing football and you're a queer, you know what I mean?

Yeah, sure. So then I found so like church led me to singing in the choir, which led me to theater, which then like led me to my literal rest of my life. What was the first show that you remember doing? A Midsummer Night's Dream, the rock musical. What? It's it was the coolest thing ever. I don't know. It was written, I don't even know who it was written by. Probably Andrew Lippa. Some like local, I think Texas artist that wrote this like 70s disco music to like Shakespeare, like literal Midsummer Night's Dream, and I split the role of Puck between two other tiny humans.

[26:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was 12 years old. Who are those two other little bitches taking away my kiddos performing stuff? You know what I mean? Split it on stage together. So we were like one unit moving all together. So it's not like we had to go. Oh, it wasn't like the red cast, blue cast, green cast. We were like all three like the pucks. Okay. Together, which was kind of fun.

[26:37] Josh Lamon: That's nice.

[26:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I had to share a role once. Um, oddly enough, it was with Adam Lambert. Um, we grew up in the same town. And um, we split the role of Tom Sawyer in Big River. And in the number, How about a hand for the hog, for whatever reason they made the Tom Sawyers hold a real pig. I know. And so I'm like halfway, it's my premier, you know, performance. The like first time I get to go on, and I'm holding this pig, and I'm doing how about a hand for the hog, and the pig shits in my hand, and I forget everything.

[27:18] Josh Lamon: Of course you did.

[27:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I'm just standing there with a hand covered in shit. And I, you know, tears are in my eyes, and I don't know what to do. And so I just skip to the end of the song. I don't even wait for it to get there. I just skip and I go, thank you. And I walk off stage and I hand the pig to the handler, and there's Adam Lambert giving me a slow clap of and he goes, Bravo, Josh. That was swell. And I flipped my little 12 year old head off. But you did. And uh, we remained frenemies through high school, but then we met again on the wicked tour. Uh-huh. And we became friends again. And now look at him. Now he's famous. Really small potatoes.

[28:06] Josh Lamon: Yeah, but um, and but he's so sweet now. Did you see his performance on the share Kennedy Center honors?

[28:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No.

[28:13] Josh Lamon: Oh my god.

[28:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: God, it was good. It was crazy good. Speaking of like Queen and all that, you need to play Freddie Mercury.

[28:21] Josh Lamon: I would really like that.

[28:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You would be incredible. Weren't you him for Halloween once or making that up?

[28:25] Josh Lamon: When I was twin during hair.

[28:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: During hair because I made my costume backstage.

[28:30] Josh Lamon: That's insane. Right? God, you make me feel so lazy.

[28:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What? You made a costume backstage.

[28:36] Josh Lamon: Josh, we literally sat on our ass for three hours a night not doing anything.

[28:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is not true. The swings, the hair building, as you can imagine, was filled with shenanigans. Too much. We would have like underwear parties. You name it. We did eight minute abs a lot.

[28:52] Josh Lamon: I don't think I did it. I think I did like my my ab, my one giant ab is good enough for me.

[29:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love it.

[29:08] Josh Lamon: Yeah, you love a big girl.

[29:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[29:10] Josh Lamon: That's right. You walk up cushion. You're hearing it firsthand on Josh Swallows. Josh and Jay Armstrong Johnson are getting married.

[29:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Swallow that.

[29:22] Josh Lamon: Yeah. Yeah, take that, Mom. Um, so when did you realize that performing was what you wanted to do?

[29:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was the two like major factors. It was the first day of tech for uh a mid summer night stream. I like walked out on stage, and there was like the stage haze and like the really cool lights, and I was like in a costume, and I was it was I was fully transported into like a different magical wonderland, and I was like, oh my god, I have to do this for the rest of my life. Yeah. And then the second time was when I did a Peter Pan with Kathy Rigby. A year later, she came to my hometown and they cast John and Michael locally. So I got cast as John Darling in Peter Pan. Oh my god. That was just like magical and fun. Because I was literally flying with Kathy Rigby at the Bass Performance Hall in Fort Worth. And then at the end of that process, I was handed a $300 check. And to 13-year-old Jay getting $300 in his hand, I was like, oh, you can get paid for this. Right. And then that's when I was like, this is what I shall do for the rest of my life.

[30:27] Josh Lamon: Did your parents let you have the 300 or did they hold on to it for you?

[30:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm pretty sure mom cashed the check. Or she w no, this is what happened. She wanted to go make a copy of the check. And then I never saw the check after that.

[30:43] Josh Lamon: We're coming after you in Texas. We're getting him his $300 back. Where's the damn check? Linda, where's the damn check?

[30:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I made uh my first equity job, I think I made like $280 a week. Uh huh. And oh my God, I was like, I can quit my job. I can buy McDonald's for everybody. It was in Pennsylvania, so I was like, wah wah is on me. Um, you know, I really thought that I was going places.

[31:13] Josh Lamon: Oh yeah. Well, and you were looking.

[31:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I guess. You're sitting here doing a podcast about Broadway, baby.

[31:19] Josh Lamon: Yes, I am. Um. So why don't we uh shift things and move on to our fan of the week? And because Jay is in Phantom, it is P-H-A-N.

[31:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right.

[31:32] Josh Lamon: Yeah, because I fan you. Um yeah, and we are going to talk to him in just a second.

[31:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Awesome.

[31:45] Josh Lamon: Hello.

[31:46] Jacques Robinson: How you doing?

[31:48] Josh Lamon: I'm doing great. I'm doing great.

[31:50] Jacques Robinson: Oh, good. I'm so glad.

[31:51] Josh Lamon: I'm Josh. What's your name?

[31:53] Jacques Robinson: Jacques Quez. Joquez Robinson.

[31:58] Josh Lamon: Welcome to the show. I am sitting here with my dear friend Broadway's darling Jay Armstrong Johnson. What's up, Joquez? And we are gonna talk to you. Now let me get this straight. You go to Amda right now when you're pursuing musical theater.

[32:13] Jacques Robinson: Um I go to Amda and I am in a studio program, it's an acting program.

[32:17] Josh Lamon: Oh nice.

[32:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, fantastic.

[32:19] Josh Lamon: Uh that's great. How's it going so far?

[32:22] Jacques Robinson: It's going great. Um I'm getting the the exact training that I need to really be good as an actor on not only stage, but on TV as well.

[32:32] Josh Lamon: Fantastic, because TV is where you make money.

[32:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: True.

[32:35] Josh Lamon: Always remember that Broadway will change your year, but year, but TV will change your life. Okay. Cool. So what is your question for us, my friend?

[32:44] Jacques Robinson: Well, I originally auditioned for the musical theater program, but got into the acting program. And they only in the acting program, they don't really need to provide as much musical theater background and dance or singing as um they do in their in their program. And I just wanted to know what can I do to get to the to get to the level of training myself so I can be on Broadway, like beyond prom.

[33:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, sure. Well, uh for me, I didn't finish school. So I did all of my training outside of an official university setting. So I think you can just take as many classes as you can, see as many shows as you can, um, dance. So many great dance studios are here. Use that student discount that you can get and go for it. What about you, Jay? What's your experience?

[33:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, I kind of had a similar experience to you, but I went to a vocal program. And so I wasn't really getting the acting and the dance training that I wanted to get on my like schooling. And so I and I didn't really have money to go take a bunch of classes in the city. And so in order to at least have an understanding of like my physicality, I went to yoga to the people, um, to really get my like core strong and to get like strength and flexibility. And it was it's a donation-based studio in many of the places at yoga to the people. So that's how I stayed in physical shape and also became like a pretty good dancer because I was finding I was getting more strength and flexibility going to yoga because I'd never done incredible before.

And then um acting classes, um, I kind of learned by osmosis. I saw my favorite actors around there and like studied them. And then I like got a couple of books on acting that just kind of gave me a um a bit of a uh a basis for it. So I would just say, You're in New York, dude. Like you can literally study whomever you want. And there are really good places out there if you don't have the money that you can go get the training. Like if you want to like become a better dancer or stronger or more limber or whatever, go to a yoga class. Or if you do have the money, go to Broadway Dance Center or go to Steps on Broadway. Especially if you're in the city, use the city. Yeah, absolutely. Because you're gonna get better training than, you know, a great program that's in Michigan, but you you're here.

And also go to auditions. Like I went to as many auditions as I possibly could while I was in school because auditioning is such a different thing. It's like different from performing. It's it's different from anything else. So if you get good at auditioning, if your skills as an auditioner get better, then I think it it gives you a like a rung up in the biz NAS.

[35:23] Josh Lamon: Totally. And here's like a thought. I don't know how your school works, but if there is some fancy person coming in to do a master class, talk to the school and say, I would like to sit in and learn. I would just like to watch. You know, I realize I'm not in that program, but I would love to see this. Or make friends with those dance teachers. Say, like, I'm I can't do this for a grade, but I would like to learn a little bit. I'm in the acting program. Do you mind if I come in and observe or dance quietly on the side? Or whatever. See see if people are open to that. And if I was a teacher at Amda, I would be like, Yes, you can come and take my tap class, even though I don't really know how to tap.

[36:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I kind of did a similar thing. I at NYU, there was a dance teacher there, and we only had to take his class for a semester. But it was a good dance class, and it it was getting me in shape for at least that semester. So I asked him if I could take it for no credit every single semester. And so I could just kind of drop in on the class whenever I wanted to. And that was another way to like keep my dance training up without actually having to pay for it. Yeah. You know? Yeah. And um, I also agree with what Jay said, like watch your favorite actors, learn from them. But listen, uh, we are out of time, but I'm so glad that we got to take your call today. And um, yeah, best of luck to you. Please keep in touch and let us know how it goes.

Also, if you have any other questions you think about, find us both on social media and shoot shoot us a direct message and be like, oh, I wanted to ask you guys this. And then I'm I answer those kinds of questions all the time. So reach out and tell Amda to reach out to us. I'd love to come in and teach a masterclass.

[37:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, so what I am though, where's my money?

[37:08] Josh Lamon: Hey.

[37:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's good to meet you, Jacques.

[37:13] Josh Lamon: Yeah, so good to meet you. Thank you so much. Have a great night, okay?

[37:14] Jacques Robinson: Thank you.

[37:17] Josh Lamon: You too. Thanks, buddy.

[37:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Alright. Bye.

[37:21] Jacques Robinson: Bye.

[37:22] Josh Lamon: Oh, that was so sweet.

[37:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's awesome.

[37:24] Josh Lamon: Yeah, he got teary.

[37:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's nice.

[37:27] Josh Lamon: I haven't shed tears in over 17 years.

[37:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wow.

[37:31] Josh Lamon: That's a medical issue.

[37:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, probably. Jay, thank you so much for coming on the show. I love you.

[37:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love you.

[37:39] Josh Lamon: So much. You have to go see him as Phantom of the Opera.

[37:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, come on over to the Majestic. We're having a good time 31 years later. And when I'm on for Brooks, he'll he'll come with you to see the prompt.

[37:55] Josh Lamon: Yeah. Yeah. We're celebrating our 13,000th performance on Monday.

[37:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Stop it.

[38:00] Josh Lamon: Isn't that crazy? Has there is there anybody there from the beginning still?

[38:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, yeah. Uh a few people in wardrobe and makeup.

[38:08] Josh Lamon: Hair, makeup, and wardrobe have been there since the beginning. That's a couple people backstage, maybe crew as well.

[38:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's amazing. Good for them.

[38:16] Josh Lamon: Right. Broadway show with a pension plan.

[38:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's incredible.

[38:20] Josh Lamon: Yeah. Um, cool. Well, thank you all so much for tuning in to this week's episode of Josh Swallows Broadway.

[38:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Josh Swallows Broadway is produced by Alan Seales and Dori Berinstein.

[38:39] Josh Lamon: Photography for the show is by Michael Pushner. Make sure to look him up. He is my favorite photographer in New York City. The theme song is by myself and Anthony Norman. Wanna be on the show? I'd love to have you. Email me at josh at joshswallows.com. Be sure to find me on Instagram at JoshPeriod Layman. See you soon! Josh Swallows, Josh Swallows, Josh Swallows, Josh Swallows Broadway.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred