In this Artist Exploration, Marcia and Charlie discuss: How she became an actor who is also a casting director. Marcia explains the real role of a casting director. Type and how networks should cast real people! The Differences of mediums TV vs T heater... Read More
From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast
About
In this Artist Exploration, Marcia and Charlie discuss:
- How she became an actor who is also a casting director
- Marcia explains the real role of a casting director
- Type and how networks should cast real people!
- The Differences of mediums TV vs T heater
- Things to keep in mind going into an casting room
- The dos and don'ts of self tape
If you want to hear more from Marcia, check out the following places:
If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.
Follow Us!
Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition
YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)
TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions
Charlie Murphy:@charmur7
Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014
About MTCA:
Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.
About Charlie Murphy:
Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.
With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.
This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:13] Charlie Murphy: Hello, happy holidays, and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.
[0:23] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, director of MTCA. That's Musical Theatre College Auditions. And today we have got an explicitly wonderful show lined up for you.
[0:34] Charlie Murphy: Marcia Debonis, who is an amazing casting director and actor, you're gonna hear all of her wonderful credits in a second, they really will blow you away. Um, I met Marcia doing theater together 15 years ago. Oh my, and that has morphed into what is now a Broadway show league style rivalry. Um, you were worried. I know that we were losing our string of having athletes on the pod. Well, fear not, here's another great athlete on the pod, uh, from the show league.
[1:00] Charlie Murphy: I will say to our younger listeners, um, those maybe still auditioning for college, that this episode may actually be a bit further along for you. So if you're just right in the midst of college audition craziness and you want to archive this and come back to it, it'll be here waiting for you as a little holiday gift for next year. Um, I think this is like a really fascinating look into the professional world for our students. So maybe our students are in college or maybe right out of college, certainly those who are farther along in their career. Um, but it is definitely more later career focused when we talk about stuff like how to get cast in a pilot. Um, not that that's not interesting to us as 16, 17 year olds, for those who are in that listenership, um, or the parents of such, uh, but just maybe a little bit far away from uh actually happening for you.
[1:41] Charlie Murphy: Also, for our parents of young children, a warning here that a little bit of swearing pops into this episode. Um, I'm actually for like the second time on this podcast, we had to add an explicit tag. I don't know if you saw that on your podcast platform, but um, if you would prefer not to hear that, this might be one to skip, though I truly, this is not nothing gets too graphic or gratuitous or anything. There, you know, if you have a teenage child, I don't think it'll bother you, depending on what your sensibilities are. I guess I should say for my sensibilities wouldn't bother me for um what we do uh in terms of what we're talking about. But a little bit of colorful, jovial shop talk kind of language where a couple F bombs and S bombs and bombs of different kinds are dropped.
[2:21] Charlie Murphy: In MTCA news, we just finished uh a really incredibly successful um MTCA private audition weekend. Um, it was really fun to have we had four great schools come to audition our kids in one weekend. Uh, and you know, as all things, we really try to place things strategically throughout the year, and this is something we've been talking about doing for four years almost now. Um, of just what if there was this really strategic weekend placed, um, which is why we had it in late December, where the students were ready to audition for some great schools, but still not maybe overload the weekend so much that you know it's gonna overwhelm their upcoming prime season in January and February.
[2:57] Charlie Murphy: So far, it seems like it's been a real success. We've been hearing raves from the faculty about the talent and from the students about how much they enjoy their experience in the rooms, which is all music to our ears. Um, we're hoping it becomes a launching pad to have those students all the more prepared for their upcoming slate of auditions in the new year. Um, I was thinking about many of our students who maybe got to participate in Pittsburgh Unifieds, where they got to meet a lot of emerging programs, and now this weekend meeting some established excellent programs before going on to their maybe private audition day with us with Baldwin Wallace and then the three big unified cities, as well as their on-campus auditions. Those kids are about as prepared for 2023 as you possibly can be, and all the joys that it's gonna bring us.
[3:38] Charlie Murphy: Speaking of ready, let's get to the great Marcia Debonis to talk some career advice from behind the table.
[3:51] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so honored to have Marcia Debonis on the pod today. Marcia is a true multi-hyphenate in being not like half actor and half casting director, but having like two complete careers that span these 30 years. She has a BA in theater arts from UCLA.
[4:07] Charlie Murphy: And as an actor, she's appeared in films like 13 Going on 30, Sully, Bride Wars, many more, TV shows like Orange is the New Black, Homeland, Lipstick Jungle, Curb Your Enthusiasm. In casting, she spent eight years casting for 20th Century Fox Studios for their pilot season, where she cast the pilot of Arrested Development.
[4:25] Charlie Murphy: We've heard of it. Then she spent four years casting pilots for NBC. She also cast many films like Morning Glory, What Lies Beneath, and Bride Wars, where she appears to have combined her two hats and cast herself. Very smart to do that. No, absolutely not. She has also taught at Juilliard Yale. She's worked extensively in theater, where she's perhaps best known for spending a summer around 2007 teaching and performing in a production of A Wilderness at Chautauqua Theater Company, where she met your favorite podcast host.
[4:52] Charlie Murphy: That would be Charlie. That's me. She also was part of uh, she started a company called The Tape Room with Amy Christopher, which is a company that helps actors with self-tapes, and also proudly boasts years of casting for the Atlantic Theater Company, for whom she plays in the Broadway Show League softball and trounced a very despondent downtowner team with a roped single that I can still feel whizzing past my head in my dreams.
[5:15] Charlie Murphy: You make me laugh. Marcia, welcome on the pod. How are you doing today?
[5:18] Marcia Debonis: I am good. I'm so happy to be here.
[5:20] Charlie Murphy: We are so happy to have you. And I'm gonna start you off with the same question I ask everyone, um, which is to think back, you know. So our listeners span that 16 to 17 year old age, and then some really up into the 20s and even early 30s, but think back to that 16, 17 year old self. I'd love to talk about what led you to UCLA in terms of like what were you thinking about in terms of if you had like a college goals or college mission statement of what you were looking for? Were you thinking about different hyphens back then? What did you want from a college education?
[5:49] Marcia Debonis: I grew up in California, and which has a spectacular school, you know, UC system. So um my parents were very much like you're going to one of the UC schools. Like I it wasn't, I didn't have a choice. For costs, that was the goal. That was it. It's like you go to one of the UC things. I grew up in the good part of California, Northern. And um, I didn't want to go to Berkeley. I wanted to get further away. And UCLA, I knew I wanted to be, I did know I wanted to be an actor. That's I I think I wanted to be a nurse when I was like five or six, and then I realized I don't like what I wanted to be a hairstylist, and then I just decided I wanted to be an actor.
[6:29] Marcia Debonis: So when I was 16 or 17, I knew I wanted to be an actor, and I figured I would probably, you know, uh apply for UCLA, where I could not not get into now, nor could I afford it because it's grown up so and were you thinking, were you thinking then? I mean, I know the there weren't as many BFAs back then or conservatory style programs. Was that something on your radar of I wanted to get a BA or theater arts degree, or just I want to get a theater degree?
[6:53] Marcia Debonis: No, I and I really regret that I did not two things. I I regret that I did not get a BFA. And in fact, I'm so dumb that I thought I had one for like 20 years until one of my UCLA classmates was like, Marcia, we didn't get a BFA. You don't have a BFA. She's like, I've got a BFA from UCLA. And they're like, No, you don't have to. Um, UCLA, I had a ball there. I met friends who I've been friends with since there, in particular, one. Um he was a MFA director, Michael Edwards, who is now the um artistic director at the Oslo down in Florida.
[7:28] Marcia Debonis: But so I learned a lot and stuff. Um, but I I really wish I had understood. I started school, I'm old. I started school in 1978, and I didn't really get the whole she was two years old at the time, just to clear everyone. Just to do that. I was an early um bloomer, but I didn't kind of get like I obviously I didn't know that there were there's a difference between BA, which felt feels to me at UCLA got a very over umbrella thing. I had to take a lighting class and a you know, all those kind of things.
[8:01] Marcia Debonis: However, I never had to take a Shakespeare class, so I completely without any of that and feel it. Um, and we just it just was a way too much of a just sort of general thing. So A, I wish I had realized there was a difference between BFAs and BAs, because BFAs you get more training, correct?
[8:22] Charlie Murphy: Right, you get more structured, sort of specific training.
[8:24] Marcia Debonis: But do you feel like the BA contributed to? I mean, again, you've had these both of these hats. We'll talk about both of them. Do you feel like that overarching education helped you to be like, I do understand more sides of the table, or I understand a little bit more of how production works, some of the side?
[8:38] Marcia Debonis: Look, could I tell the difference between a Lico and a Fresnel light? Sure. Who gives a shit? So I really, really regret that I did not get a more focused, specialized um, uh undergrad. And I really wish I had gone to grad school. Just because you feel as an actor, that lack of like whatever that mystery of the specific Shakespeare training, a specific, you know, high-level I just you know to me, it was it's always been daunting any anything other than kitchen sink drama because I have no training.
[9:10] Marcia Debonis: I never took like we had one voice class at UCLA. I just happened to have a really loud voice, so I'm okay.
[9:17] Charlie Murphy: I was yeah, we've turned our volume knob all the way down on the podcast.
[9:22] Marcia Debonis: Um it was much different. This is 40 years ago. I've been in New York for 40 years, and just the whole training thing was much different. It was not as specialized people. I don't think kids my age or 16, 18 knew about what was going on as much.
[9:37] Charlie Murphy: Of course, but the we didn't have the internet, you were and you're looking at a brochure or something.
[9:40] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, um but how how it seemed like it didn't hold you back. So I guess how did you how did those years post-UCLA work as you're hitting the ground running in NYC and figuring out what your career was going to be?
[9:50] Marcia Debonis: Well, one of the big things was I met the fabulous Seth Barish, who is the artistic director of the Barrel Group Theater Company, which has become primarily a school, and it's a fabulous school. Um, and so I had met, you know, we were friends from UCLA, and he actually moved here at the same time.
[10:10] Marcia Debonis: Um, and I, you know, ignorance is bliss. Like, thank God I did not know how hard it is.
[10:20] Charlie Murphy: We hear that all the time.
[10:21] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, I'm just diving in because you didn't know how bad the how cold the water was. And I do remember going, I'm gonna give myself five years and thinking to myself at 21, come on. Of course, I'm gonna be working within, I mean, come on. Within five years. Five years so old. And like, of course, and of course, I was not working within five years.
[10:44] Marcia Debonis: But, but and this is what I tell all my students. I started a theater company with Seth Barish, pulled together people he'd met in a variety of places. UCLA, he studied Utah Hogan was still alive when he moved here. So he studied with Guta. And so he pulled people from Uda's class. There was another. So I I started a theater company, the Barrel Group, in 1986.
[11:07] Marcia Debonis: And for seriously, the first, and we were together loosely for the year before. So that was really the only place I worked. I didn't have an agent when I first got here. And so, you know, I just that was sort of my home. I don't think I would still be in New York if I hadn't had the barrel group. I'm not sure I would still be an actor if I hadn't had the barrel group.
[11:30] Charlie Murphy: And what about sort of the decision to get into casting and what that journey was like? So I guess when did that happen? Why did it happen? And then a little bit, how did you make that? Because I think a lot of people be like, I'd be interested in doing casting, but how does that happen?
[11:41] Marcia Debonis: I I have my my best friend from UCLA used to call me a walking talking playbill or a walking talking TV guide. Because I just have that kind of head, and you either have it or you don't. I don't think it's something you can learn.
[11:54] Marcia Debonis: So I just had We're gonna be testing that in our game today, Marcia. Don't you worry. We'll be testing your walking talking TV guide.
[12:00] Marcia Debonis: So I just would always, you know, people would always say, Marcia, what did they what have they done before? So I had sort of thought, oh, if I ever give up acting without any sense that I was gonna give up acting, I would kind of like to get into casting. I think that would be fun.
[12:12] Marcia Debonis: So I went on an audition for the fabulous casting director, Linda Lowy, who is out in LA. Um, and she's spectacular. And literally right before I got there, they'd got a phone call that the part I was auditioning for, a non-sexual helper, because that's all I'm allowed to say. That wasn't the name of it, non-sexual helper. Probably. Oh my gosh. That's very descriptive. But anyway, the part had been cut.
[12:41] Marcia Debonis: So I just started to talk to Linda about, oh, I'm you know interested in casting. And she said, well Bonnie Finnegan, who's a fabulous casting director who happened to be in the office next door to her back in the old video portfolios days.
[12:59] Marcia Debonis: You should go next door and I was like, oh no, I'm not, I'm going away to do a play regionally and this is just like, I think I'm, no, you should go next door, you should go next door. So I was sort of shamed into sticking my head into Bonnie Finnegan's work where I was met with the, what is an actor that I don't know and don't have an appointment for doing in my doorway look, but she was desperate. She had hired someone but they couldn't start for a couple weeks. So she said, look, you want to, you know, are you interested? I was waitressing, I was the meanest waitress in Manhattan and she said, you know, you can leave at four or whatever to get to, you know, the days that you have to. And so I was like, sure, I'll do it and I loved it and I loved Bonnie and I learned stuff from Bonnie that I use to this day.
You want to hear what it is? Yes, please. Never write anyone off. You know, her point was you can spend five minutes arguing with the agent about why their client isn't right, or you can see them. And that is such to me, such a big, big lesson. She and the never writing anybody off thing. Her point was specifically when kids, when people have children, that, you know, they're particularly with men, no offense, but their hearts open. And all of a sudden, you know, they are able to access something that they never could before. And I have found that to be true, and I won't say her name, but there was a wonderful Yale trained actress, I'll tell you later, who was just fabulous, but icy, icy, like just, uh, you couldn't cast her literally as anybody who needed warmth.
She had a baby. No, she's not a ball of warmth, but it's amazing the change. Your heart grows three sizes. I mean, I wrote it in my little after she was, my daughter was born. I wrote the thing of like, I really feel like it's like the Grinch soul crisis happens to you. And all of a sudden, you're not the primary focus. You become thin-skinned in a way, too. And in a way that's scary as a man, especially where you're like, I'm insane, and then you're like, oh my god, I'm crying at anything. I'm just like this, which as an actor is fantastic. So this is a whole other podcast about my fatherhood, and we'll talk about it. Um, but so anyway, so I started with Bonnie, and then she asked, because I'm a, um, I'm a workhorse.
I have a little OCD, so I found a career that works with my mental illness. Um, because casting is very much about organizational. People think, oh, it's just about having a good eye. That's not true. You have to be incredibly organized. Um, you know, it's a lot of anticipatory things. If this happens, then what are we gonna do? Yep. And someone from 10 years ago who I did see them, I wonder where they are now. How can they exactly? So, well, maybe it'd be helpful just for our listeners, because we'll, and we're gonna get deep into casting in the second half a little more, but just to kind of define. So I mean, some of our listeners, of course, will know what a casting director is, but just from an overarching perspective, like what does a casting director do? And maybe if how it's a little different in TV and film versus theater, but just like what is your general job as a casting?
[16:12] Marcia Debonis: So our general job is we are hired by the producers of the theater or the TV or the film. Um, and oftentimes with TV and film there are actors already attached, like there's a big, like when I did Morning Glory with Ellen Lewis, um, Rachel McAdams was already attached, which was fabulous. She's spectacular and so was Harrison Ford and Diane Keaton. But then what our job is is to put out what's called a breakdown, which my guess is your most of your kids know what that is, but that's something that is released to the agents and it just breaks down all the characters. Um, we would usually write our own breakdowns and get it to break down because sometimes it would put weird things on it. Um, and then the agents will look through their clients and then submit who they think is appropriate, and then we will go through the submissions and choose who we would like to see.
It's different nowadays because we used to be able to have people come in and now it's primarily self-tape, although I hear theater is getting back to in person. Uh-huh. For sure. And what maybe talk about some of those differences of self-tape and and get into some of the specifics. Um, but then so for a TV and film, in general, you, uh, there are some roles perhaps that you would actually be able to cast, right? Versus some roles that you're gonna be sending up to other people to make the decisions and going here's the final five, right? Here's the casting director has no power, and that's something, and I know and I don't mean that in a bad way, I mean that in an I think actors give casting directors way too much um prominence, like oh, you know, we don't, all we can do is get you in front of whoever our director is.
Now there are obviously really fancy casting directors who probably have a lot of pull. But in general, our job is to give some choices to our director and producers. We have no, I mean, and in television, it's everywhere, it's become a nightmare of the approval because you literally now have to send it to everyone. And you're saying even with roles like, you know, policeman number two or whatever, you're like, I think still with like episodics and stuff that they still, you know, it doesn't have to go way up to the top of NBC on Law and Order, but it does go to Trey Lawson, at, you know what I mean? So there's still, and then for the series regulars, which was when I covered pilot season, I only covered series regulars, so I never had to worry about casting the co-stars.
Policeman number three or whatever. Um, but yeah, it's a whole, you have to pass this, then that, then da-da-da-da-da. And it's different now because it used to be, um, as far as TV goes, you would test, and it was a two-pronged thing. First, you would go in front of the studio. There was usually three to five choices, and then the studio would usually narrow it down to two, and they had to be fine with either of those two, because it then becomes the network's decision of which of those two. Um, it's just whoever has the most Instagram followers. Kind of, that's it. You just make that. I mean, honestly, though, that I had a friend who wrote a um script. This was a few years ago, but um, and you know, it was about um, I don't want to say what it was about because you could look it up and find out who it was, but um, it was about something that happened in the 70s at real people, and of course, because it was network television, it became about with the women being all drop dead gorgeous.
But one of them was even prettier than drop dead gorgeous. So this model came in, read for the one that's even prettier, and she said she was fine. She wasn't bad, she was fine. Uh-huh. And she left, and the entire room was like, oh my god, we found, oh, this is so great. We've solved our problem. And my friend was like, finally was like, but um, she's she's not really an actress. And they're like, I know, but you can't stop looking at her. And she's dating Kevin Love, and he has two million followers. He's a basketball player. And she, our listeners know who Kevin Love is. Believe me, we're very deep in basketball analogies. I love sports. Um, so yeah, and she got cast, and guess what? The pilot did not get picked up.
And one of the reasons was there was a big black hole in the lead. Uh-huh. So, you know, I do, uh, unfortunately, I think if you're over 50 or so, the network and and stuff will let you alone. But if you're under it, they want you to do social media. If you're a non-sexual helper, you can, they'll leave you alone.
[20:48] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, exactly. Non-sexual helpers. And the non-set rule. I want to dive deeper into some of these casting stuff first, but uh, or uh, uh in the second half, but I want to first just talk a little bit about, you know, one of the things that I think is most remarkable about you is your insistence and persistence in being both a casting director and an actor, right? I think when we met at Chautauqua all those years ago, you were teaching casting classes, but you were also acting in the shows, and the way you would lead was also, I'm an actor, right? Um, I think it's something that seemed you clearly um insisted on keeping that hyphen strong for yourself. And I think, you know, many of our young students are, they want to be multi-hyphenates now.
They've heard that term, they go, I like the idea of doing many things and how that's gonna be part of my career. I guess was that advice that was given to you? Was it something you always knew? What made you lead with that?
[21:30] Marcia Debonis: Well, I one thing that happened was when I very first moved to New York and had my first, you know, like big audition. I was told, or my, I did have an agent by that time, and this was when I was probably 23, 24, 25. I had an agent who I knew from UCLA, and they, the feedback was she's fabulous, she's gonna start working like crazy when she's 30. Uh-huh. Then I turned 30. And I was told she's fabulous. She's gonna really start working when I'm a character actress when she's 40. And I just, I was like, I can't. Um, and so I fell into the casting, but the real reason I committed to it because I worked for Bonnie for two weeks, and then I went away and did a regional theater show. And I, when I came back, the restaurant I'd worked at for eight years had closed.
And I was just like, I'm not working my way up. I just, the thought of having, you know, I don't know if you ever waited on tables, but for a brief time, but yes, it was okay. So I just was like, I, you know, I worked at a place that was two blocks away, they let me come and go, and I got back, they closed, and I just thought I can't. I just can't, I cannot work my way up. So I called Bonnie. She did not need anyone, and I had right before I had gone up to do the thing, I had actually finally gotten an audition for um Law and Order. And I went in and I said to Suzanne Ryan, who is a dear friend of mine now, I said, Look, I just helped Bonnie Finnegan out. If you ever need any help, let me know.
7:30 the next morning. Bring, can you come in? So I'd worked there. So then I called Lynn Crussels and was like, I'm back. And I, you know, are you looking for someone? And then I started, and then I got sucked in. And that was not intentional. And that's the one thing that I um not warned, but I feel like actors are good at a lot of things. I don't know any actor who has gotten a temp job who has not been asked to stay. Like I think our ability to engage and be friendly and whatever is something that a lot of people don't have. And I know I couldn't make a living as an actor at that time. I am a, you know, I'm, I'm an, I'm ethnic but not diverse. I'm overweight. It's just like that was that, you know, I couldn't make a living.
So the truth of it is when I got into casting, it was a relief in the sense that like, oh good, you know, I don't have to waitress anymore or whatever, but I couldn't do any theater forever. So I didn't do a play. I did my last play regionally at that time in 1993, and then I didn't do another play till 2004. Uh-huh. But I, and I'm, and I got to act more than anybody I know. I got to act because I covered primarily pilot season. I got to act from 11 in the morning until six at night playing just behind the camera. Behind the camera, but getting to read with kick-ass actors, like kick-ass actors. Uh, everybody has to start somewhere. Um, and um, and I got to play, you know, not just female parts that I would never be considered for, but I got to read male parts.
And so in fact, I feel as a casting person, I got to act much more than any of my friends. And that is including people who were series regulars. But I guess you've mentioned that idea of being sucked in, which I guess that's I'm interested in that because, you know, I certainly can understand the sort of blow to the ego that it becomes as you go, wait a second, I've got this pretty cool, high power. I just cast a rest of development, right? And then to throw yourself back into what is such a low status vulnerable field as an actor.
[25:14] Marcia Debonis: Of actors um, and I don't want this to sound conceited. But if you are meant to act you will end up acting. And I feel like that is what I'm best at. And so I, you know, I fed my acting Jones because I got to act all the time. I could, you know, finally my boss about five years in knew that she had, uh, you know, a total workhorse in me and said, you know, if you want to audition for like a TV or thing, you know, a day or two here or there, do. So and then I started auditioning, you know, literally for the guest star and whatever.
[25:58] Marcia Debonis: And then I started working a little bit more and it was kind of fabulous because I would work January, February, March, April each year, make a nice chunk of change for me, and then not ever have to take an acting job for the rest of the year because I knew that I had pilot season every year.
[26:18] Charlie Murphy: Does that it be?
[26:19] Marcia Debonis: And were there times it it does, it does make sense. It's I mean, uh, you know, I guess the idea of being what is a pretty high power, let's say I'm working for NBC, I'm working for some amazing, you know, and then going in for guest stars. I guess, did you feel the difference of status? Like, did ever that make you want to feel like, ugh, I don't know if I want to be someone says no to three lines after I have this other fabulous job?
[26:40] Marcia Debonis: The one thing that I learned early in casting, and it was both liberating and horrifying, is that two things. Uh, the best person, the best actor does not get the part, I would say 50% of the time, and the only thing we can do as actors is the best we can do. That's it. So, in fact, uh, while horrifying to realize, wait a second, the best actor didn't get that part. That was a bum. But to recognize that, like, oh, I literally, if I go in and do what I wanted to do, that's as good as it's gonna get, unless you get the job. So, so it did help me in the sense that I just kind of realized that like all I can do is best I can do. And although you can recognize that in your head, I think being involved in casting got me to recognize it in my gut.
You know, so then it's not such a blow to the ego or such a blow to I suck. It's just well, I didn't get the job. I know, I know all the machinations of the song. I mean, we are in an irrational business. So I always caution my students do not try to apply rationality to this business. You are not in control. If you are a control freak, you might be in the wrong seriously, because what other business? I mean, even singers or whatever, you can sit or practice and sing. We don't sit on our beds and do monologues. We need an audience. And there's more objective. I mean, when you're talking about musical theater, there is more objective. I mean, Elizabeth is objectively the best singer in the history of the world.
Objectively. That's not me being so much. And that's very true. But also dancers and whatever, you know, there's a level of sub of objective measurement of a dancer. I think it's a good idea. And the way that acting is taste, right? I never thought of it. I mean, there's not nothing. There is something that we go, a bunch of acting teachers would get together and go, This one's better than this one, I think. If there's a big difference, but they would not all agree who is the best. There are certain technical things that you have to be able to do in order to be considered good. And I feel like with singing, it's the same thing. With acting, it's not. Well, the way you talked about kitchen sink versus Shakespeare.
I mean, it is a skill set to be amazing at Shakespeare. It's also a skill set to be amazing at Kitchen Sink. And I don't remember when people used to be like Jennifer Aniston is not good as an actor because she can't do other things. I was like, She's great as an actor. She does that thing really well. It's hard to do. We all have our bag of tricks, and don't let anyone tell you that that's not the case.
[28:57] Marcia Debonis: Um, I wanted to talk a little bit about the two different hats that you were wearing in terms of you know, you sort of scoffed, and so maybe I'm wrong in Bride Wars that you didn't cast yourself. But were there ever times that the connections you knew from the world of being on the other side of the table then helped you actually get cast in the world? A couple of things. I have been cast in uh two or three of the films I worked on. I never cast myself. I was reading with the actors, and every time the director said, I want you to play something. I'm horrified. I never take any credit. Literally, I don't have a screen credit. And if I did, I would want it to say the director asked me. I did not I promise I didn't do it.
Because seriously, I do, you know, I would have people go, Oh, I saw you cast yourself. That's so it's like, no, I did not cast myself. I just didn't. Yep. However, and this is getting so much better, but I would guess that I covered uh between my first pilot pilot season, which was 94, and my last one, which was 2013. So 20 pilot seasons. I didn't do it for like two years in there. I would say I covered 250 to 300, at least 250 pilots. This is network television. There was not one part, not one, not one part that someone that looked like me would get cast in. Not one. Now, were there parts I could have played? There are fucking million parts I could have played. Right. But I, you know, as I used to joke, I hit the uncastable twifecta.
I was over 40, I was overweight, and I was ethnic, but not diverse. And so literally, I think it was easier for me to be a casting director than if like Elizabeth or someone or you, a leading lady or a leading man. Incredibly handsome an incredibly handsome man with a monster. You didn't have to say it. It was obvious. They are but I do think it would be harder because it's like you would kind of be like, well, I can, but with me, it's like I was very aware of the looksism in in the network. And so I did, there was one um thing I won't say who it was for. Um, but I did I my agent said Marcia really wants to put herself on tape to play the wife of the lead, who is a character guy. And the producers were interested and showed it to the character guy who said she's too ugly for me.
And that was the end of that. Now, let me just say this. There's no way in the world that if I had been walking down the street with that character guy, that anyone would have said, who's that handsome man with that dog? Right. Right, right. But that and so I um I think it was like I said, I think it was easier for me because there was never I I was realistic. It's like, oh yeah, I would never get cast in this. It is, it does feel like it's one of the last bastions of you know isms that are kind of allowed in this because we go, ugly, ugly is not some on TV. That's like the last thing that we don't want to show. We'll we'll show any kind of racial minority, any kind of gender, but we don't really want to show ugly if we can avoid it.
And I'm of the mind, not that you're ugly, I would never say that, Marcia you're just sort of like I look like a normal person, and I am of the mind that normal people actually would like to see themselves represented, just as diverse people would. And I keep waiting for the dime to drop. And it has to a certain degree in the sense that there's orange is you know, there's a ton, girls, all those, but the networks, it's still pretty, you know. You know, one of the frustrating things was I would I'm married to a black actor, so I would always try as hard as I could to cast diverse actors, and and um, you know, finally they they kind of was like, okay, we really have to make this was my last pilot season, 2013, and then they just hired pretty shitty diverse actors instead of pretty shitty white ones.
And I was just like, I I can't, I can't do this. I know it was so this is not uh uh condemning of the show, but Elizabeth just did an episode of Gossip Girl. So we were watching the new gossip girl. Oh my god, the level of attractiveness of those people, it's disgusting. I'm like, nobody looks like that. And like I said, they're all modeled. Because I get the aspirational, but it's I I think they're so they the they're dumb. They're missing out on seeing real people, and I try to just bother people whenever I work, I try to shake my fat just to freak out people. It's like, yes, I have arm fat, and so do most people. It drives me fucking mad.
[33:27] Marcia Debonis: I I it makes me wonder. I mean, so I've just recently I never watched reality television until the pandemic. I just got into Survivor. My best friend really was into Survivor. And you you get to see, I wonder how much of the appeal is you'd get to see real people on those. I don't know. I you know, I never, I mean, that let's look at reality TV, right? I mean, right. Certainly there's some of the Jersey Shores and some of the aspirational still, right? But some of those shows you do see some normal. But clearly, people are fascinated by real people. So why not cast real people on television? We're starting the movement right here, Marsha. We're starting it.
[34:00] Marcia Debonis: Exactly. Um, I did want to ask, as an actor, you know, so you mentioned feeling more comfortable in the kitchen sink world than in the maybe, you know, classical theater, that kind of stuff. But what about you know you had a career that does film, TV, and and theater. What have you learned between the different media in terms of what is helpful to you as an actor and how they compare and contrast?
[34:17] Marcia Debonis: What I have learned is that there honesty is honesty, truthfulness is truthfulness. There is much less of a difference between theater acting and TV and film acting than a lot of k people getting out of school think. And they get really tied up in thinking, oh, this is different. It is not different. Like I said, truthfulness is truthfulness. It's oftentimes, you know this, Charlie, a matter of volume. You know, you will either have a lav mic on when you shoot or a boom mic or both. So you never have to talk louder than this. And that's you know, the biggest thing that I always say nowadays we don't go into the room, but if you do happen to be auditioning on uh, you know, on via Zoom, and there is a casting director or producer, director, you're gonna have to chat with them.
You know, hello, hello. If you can slip into the text of your audition without feeling the difference. So you're chatting, chatting, and then all of a sudden you're acting. Well, that's not right. But the great thing is we have our own barometer. We you can tell that's not right. I try so hard to get kids to understand. Don't, I mean, look, if you just got your MFA from Yale or Juilliard, I would say this. Do not pronounce the H in what? What? No one says fucking walk. What are you talking about? Yeah, exactly. You'll just sound affected. So those and and it's and TV and film is very mumble mouth. So it's it's about not being on your voice, not supporting yourself by your diaphragm. It's very sort of like dropping your G's, not pronouncing the H's. It's very mumbly. Um, so I try really hard to make kids understand that like don't be daunted. Being real is being real. You know?
[36:10] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, I love that advice. That's something I I often do with our you know, our students when they're we're helping them get into college, they have to do monologues, which is its own foreign thing. And just in the difference between the slate and beginning it, you say, wait, well, what happened then? Why do we all of a sudden we got real? And so that means we got breathy and what I'm saying. Well, let's say one thing about slates while I think of it.
[36:28] Marcia Debonis: Please.
[36:29] Charlie Murphy: Unless it says put it at the front, always put your slate at the end of your audition.
[36:34] Marcia Debonis: I love it.
[36:35] Charlie Murphy: Because nobody feels comfortable standing there going, hi, I'm Marcia Debonis, I'm five four. So you don't want their first hit of you to be you standing awkwardly. So unless it says put the slate first, put it the end. And another thing that I'm a big believer in because we are now self-taping, and most of the time you don't have the advantage of even Zooming with producers and stuff. If you fuck up your slate, leave it. It'll be the only time they'll get to see you. So, like one time I was like, hi, I'm Marcy DeBonis. I'm 5'4, and I I'm based, where am I? I'm based in New York. And I just left it because they got to see a little glimpse of me. I'm not saying you should do a slate and fuck up on purpose, but don't think that your slate is going to get you or lose you a job. It's not.
[37:23] Marcia Debonis: This is fantastic advice, and it's getting directly into the second half of the thing. So let's do it. Let's take our little break. And on the back end, we're going to talk a little bit about some casting tips with Marcia Debonis.
[37:36] Charlie Murphy: All right. We are back with Marcia Debonis. And we're going to talk about some casting tips. Um, and I really want to span a lot of territory. Some of the stuff you're doing with slates, I have those exact questions. I can't wait for that. But especially maybe focusing on what's going to be relevant for young actors right out of school, um, who's a lot of our audience now. Um, I'd love to start with like when you meet a young actor, maybe especially in a situation where you're not directly casting a role or a like on a general. Right, on a general, or even maybe you're coming to school and doing a class with them, or you're seeing a showcase. But I'm not actually auditioning now. What are you looking for in that experience? What are you filing away? What information are you taking in about those actors when you meet a classroom?
[38:16] Marcia Debonis: I used to do every year was uh pilot season starts in January. So in December, I would reach out to all the agents that I knew I had the same sensibility, and that's one thing I think it's important for everybody to know. Just because one casting director doesn't like you doesn't mean that a million other will. And and that, and just because I'm saying one thing doesn't mean that's right. So just know that everybody has an opinion and no one is right. There's no hard and fast. Now I would have generals and I would call my the agents that I liked and say, Who have you signed since last pilot season? So it was usually kids out of MFA and undergrad, um, that you feel are ready to carry a show because I was casting the the series regulars, so that that's a you know a very specific thing.
[39:03] Marcia Debonis: And then I would have a general with them. And when you have a general, and I know this is easier said than done, but it's just about trying to be yourself. The reason I would have these is so that when pilot season was in full swing and cuckoo, like crazy busy, I would have a context because I wouldn't know them as actors, but I would know that they're with an agent who I respect, and oh right, this girl reminded me of a cross between Aubrey Plaza. That's what I would do a lot. I would literally just say, like some either emotionally or physically, they remind me of something so that when they're submitted, I'll go, oh, right, I loved her. She was, you know, da-da-da-da-da.
[39:41] Charlie Murphy: And is that all in your brain, or do you have a system where they live where there's an Aubrey Plaza button or something?
[39:45] Marcia Debonis: Well, I you know, I would write it into my little, I mean, now I'm sure everybody has it in a computer, but you know, we would have a schedule sheet, and I would just write in my little things. And I just found for me giving a physical comparison, like, oh, they remind me of a cross of this and that was helpful. Um, but I'm not looking for anything per se. And as hard as it is to just go in and try to be yourself, that truly is.
[40:18] Charlie Murphy: What about that's a, you know, wonderful situation if you're gonna go in for a pilot scene in general? You're good about yourself. But let's imagine a young actor who maybe is not at that point in their career, but they're meeting a casting director for the first time, being brought in for a role. I guess when you're meeting that young actor for the first time, because I felt like this was true for me right out of school. A lot of times they're like, I'll just bring them in for something. Like even often I wasn't necessarily right for it. Like I'd be like, I'm 10 years too young for this part, I think, but they're just getting to know me, right? How much do you suggest that actor is like being themselves versus trying to do a great job with that role? Like if they think they're brought in for something that's not quite right for them, my sense of humor is a little different.
[40:56] Marcia Debonis: Um, and I'm glad you said this because there's one thing if you were go went in on something that you were right for, but you were 10 years too young, right? Then I would say, um, I would say go ahead, even though you look at it and are like, yeah, I'm too young for this, go ahead, because theoretically you're right for the thing. What I advise against is getting in whatever way, agent or some other way, getting an audition for something that you really are not right for, and you know it. Because what's gonna happen is you're gonna go in and the main remembrance is they weren't good because they're not right for you.
[41:34] Charlie Murphy: Right, bad for this right, yeah.
[41:35] Marcia Debonis: So I am not a big believer in just, well, you know, I figure it's good for the casting directors to see me. It's like, no, it's not good for the casting director to see you do a reading for a role that you're not right for, unless you're a fucking genius, and then fine. But you know, most of us aren't, so.
[41:49] Charlie Murphy: And is that something then would you say to the agent? Hey, maybe I don't want to, this is not the right one for me to go in.
[41:57] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, and I come from a very loving place. It's like I don't want them to, can't think of a polite way to say blow their wand, but it's like don't come in, don't send them in for something they're not right for. You're not doing them a service, you're doing them a disservice. It's such a, that is a piece of advice I wish I'd gotten maybe six months earlier than I did of like everyone's gonna want to meet you once of just like you're that first impression is valuable and going and then they'll have seen you and then it's harder to win over that first impression. But the biggest piece if I can of advice I would give to kids just starting out, um, let your freak flag fly. Do not try to pretend you are something you're not.
Who you are, there's a Margaret Mead quote that I always use: always remember that you are absolutely unique just like everyone else. So keep your unique, you know what I mean? It's like don't try to will yourself down into something that you think that they're looking for. And don't try to hide your quirks and be, don't hide who you are because guess what, that's denying and then that's not real.
[43:20] Charlie Murphy: Yep. It's how do you actualize that advice though? Because I think that's the kind of thing, it's such good advice they get it from the colleges too, they all say be yourself, right? But especially now when in a professional sense when I'm being called in for Joe and Angels in America, it's like how do I bring Charlie into that and as a freak flag? So let's say this because I think one of the things that young actors waste a lot of time on is trying to figure out what the casting director wants, right? So instead of just bringing, because television in general is playing yourself within the circumstances. It's not about transforming, which theater is and which film is. TV in general is playing yourself within the circumstances. So even if the prototype says, you know, think what would the kids know. Uh, they all watch what, the one about drugs.
[44:06] Marcia Debonis: They all watch Euphoria.
[44:08] Charlie Murphy: Euphoria, Euphoria, thank you. Zendaya or Zendaya, however you pronounce the thing. No one is going to out Zendaya, Zendaya, Zendea, Zendaya. So don't use that maybe as a jumping off thing, but you know, like what, well the prototype said it's like Kramer from Seinfeld. Again, no one will out Kramer, Kramer. So what I mean is don't try to fit your choices into what you think they're looking for because they do not know what they are looking for. And people spend a lot of time trying to go, well, I think, you know, they said Kramer. So it's like, nope, don't do it.
[44:48] Marcia Debonis: It's such good advice. I feel like I often say that to Elizabeth when we're doing self-tapes together. I'm always like, if you're, if it's gonna be that far away from you, they're gonna cast them out.
[44:56] Charlie Murphy: That's right.
[44:56] Marcia Debonis: If you're doing that much acting, it's just not your part. Especially on TV, because they don't want you to have to work that hard. You know what I mean? They want you with 101 degree temperature to be able to do your thing.
[45:05] Charlie Murphy: Right.
[45:06] Marcia Debonis: It's like it feels against our instincts, especially as trained actors, though, because we can want to go, but I can play anything. Here's what I would do with this role. I would transform myself. Look how much I can. I'm not saying that you can't transform on TV because you can, but I am saying that trying to figure out what they're looking for and or trying to play a prototype is a waste of your time.
[45:28] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh. Okay, so let's imagine now. I've let my freak flag fly. We've met wonderfully, had a great audition. I didn't get a call back from you, and then crickets, right? So then I've not heard anything from you in a while. I have probably heard this advice from my school at some point that I should be keeping in touch with you. How do you like to, do you want a thank you email? Do you want to know about the shows I'm doing?
[45:49] Marcia Debonis: I like feeling appreciated. So I, you know, we used to joke in Lynn Cressel's office back way back when I worked there, like, did we prefer flowers or food? Thank you. I like flowers. Um, everybody else, I think wanted food. I think it's nice to, you know, don't go on. I but I think it's lovely to write either email if you can get it, or send an actual handwritten note just saying it was so nice to meet you, and I hope you'll keep me in mind if I'm ever right for something.
[46:18] Charlie Murphy: Um, one other thing that I want to talk about. This is my cheat sheet.
[46:21] Marcia Debonis: Marcia's got notes.
[46:23] Charlie Murphy: See, this is what you should do, Sue. We want notes.
[46:26] Marcia Debonis: Um, you trust that the CD likes what you're doing if they continue to call you in, even if you haven't booked anything. Because what Suzanne, again, I'll reference Suzanne Ryan, who cast Law and Order, the mothership, and she said she could tell actors, you know, because when she liked them, she just keep trying. Just keep trying them, trying different parts, da-da-da-da. And she said she could tell you, usually around the third or fourth time, they would, she could tell that they thought, well, I'm doing something wrong because I haven't booked, and they would change. And she always was like, No, no, no. No, keep doing, you've been getting the call. So just don't, you know, don't go let your, or try not to go to the oh no, they don't like me.
And another thing, a good audition will always pay off. Always, always, always, always, all ways. And truthfully, a good audition in this business is kind of the best you can hope for. Well, you're not gonna get cast most of the time. It's just the reality. But there's juice, there's value in that good audition for who you see it for your own self.
[47:31] Charlie Murphy: Totally. And it's a weird thing because you know, you would like to think that, oh, I remember everybody, but the reality is it is helpful to have an agent because I might not have thought of you, and then someone says, Well, what about Charlie? And I'm like, oh my God, of course.
[47:44] Marcia Debonis: Yep. So all right. So then I send, I don't send chocolates or flowers because I whatever. I'm just out of school and I have any money, but I do send a note to you. And it was nice and I think, you know. Now it's been how long? Six months, a year, two years. Do you want more correspondence? Do you think it's smart for them to be necessary?
[48:01] Marcia Debonis: Although I, this is what I don't think is, what I really don't think is necessary, and I don't even know if people do this anymore. But it used to be that we would get like postcards saying, I had a call back for the title and all commercial. No one cares. Right. I don't care. No one cares. So I'm not suggesting keeping in touch like with that kind of thing. But, but you know, you could send a Chris happy holidays, you know, da-da-da-da-da-da. Um, but the kind of like I got this call back and I did this, we don't need to hear.
[48:33] Charlie Murphy: You know, what about do you like when people ask to be readers for you?
[48:37] Marcia Debonis: I never let anyone read for me because that's what I love to do. So everybody's like, I'd love to read, be a reader. It's like, yeah, that's not gonna happen.
[48:45] Charlie Murphy: You're like that part is cast in the case.
[48:46] Marcia Debonis: Exactly. I am cast in that role. Um, however, I'm a huge believer in getting on the other side of the table. So I'm a huge believer in offering to be a reader. You will learn, you know.
[48:57] Charlie Murphy: Have you ever been on, you've been on the other hour?
[48:59] Marcia Debonis: You better believe it. It, you learn so much.
[49:06] Charlie Murphy: So, and maybe let's speak to, so there's maybe some of our older listeners who've been out of school a little bit and have gotten maybe done some pilot seasons, gotten a couple, a little bit of a bit of momentum. You know, you mentioned that idea of, you know, a good audition always will pay off. I guess I'm, um, I have had many students and, and have myself been somewhat in this position of going, you're in that place where you're getting lots of callbacks, you're getting lots of interest, but maybe you're not booking, and you're like, what do you do with that as an actor, especially? What do you do with that? You know, feeling of like there's juice, there's momentum, I feel like I'm moving, but it's not, it's not manifesting, it's not happening at all.
[49:40] Marcia Debonis: I think, and I know this is easier said than done, but I think you'd be really thrilled with the fact that you actually are getting auditions and getting callbacks, that you're on the right track. It takes time. And again, it's not that you didn't get it because you weren't the best, it's you didn't get it because you have brown hair and they decided they wanted a blonde. I mean, literally, sometimes it's as stupid as that. So I think what you try to do is appreciate that you're doing a lot more than most people. If you're getting callbacks, you're doing a lot more than most actors. Try to appreciate that and know that if that is happening, it means you are on the right track. And eventually you will not get callback, call back, call back, call back, and not book something. That won't happen. You will book something, and it's about being patient. And if you don't, you know, and some people, as I said, just don't have the stomach for this. And get out of here.
[50:39] Charlie Murphy: It feels like it's hard from the outside world sometimes. Like I remember I was doing Shakespeare in the park with Andre Holland, and this was before he liked before anything had happened in his crazy. I mean, he was playing a lead in Shakespeare in the park, but you know, he kept, he was trying to describe this thing to me of like, I have so much good stuff happening in my life. Like, I'm so close to these projects that are so big, but that like maybe the outside world, you know, when you talk to your parents, you talk to whatever, it's like they don't understand any of that. It doesn't mean anything. It's not, it's not you, you can't, you can't say I've got the 42 or I've got the thing that it's gonna launch my career. So I think about being patient and also recognizing if you have the stomach for it.
[51:20] Marcia Debonis: I ultimately, after being here for a little over 10 years, was like, uh-uh, I didn't have the stomach to go get another restaurant job, so I, you know, fell into casting. Um, but you know, you this is a business we are not in control. So if you have an issue with being in control, you are so in the wrong business.
[51:40] Charlie Murphy: Can I say two other things that I say that's say two other things, yes?
[51:43] Marcia Debonis: Um, this is what's gonna get me canceled, but I'm gonna say okay, here we go.
[51:47] Charlie Murphy: Yes.
[51:54] Marcia Debonis: Safe acting is boring acting. I understand that we're living in a nightmare of a world, I understand it's terrifying what's happening. Being safe, if you want to feel safe, don't be an actor. If you have an issue with triggers, don't be an actor. We trigger ourselves for a living. That is what we do. So I have no patience, even though I would like to think I understand it for this need for safety. It's like an art, good art is not safe. In my not that, not that un not that dissimilar to you saying if you have a need for control, but to some extent, extreme safety is a need to complete it. You're you know, so unless you get lucky, um and get cast right away, if you have a need for control, get out. Don't spend all the time doing it.
[52:51] Marcia Debonis: Well before we leave that idea of momentum and callbacks or whatever, I just wanted to, I'm always curious. Sometimes actors will describe, hey, I feel like that casting director felt like they owed me, and so they threw me this bone or they found something for me because I did 10 great callbacks for them or whatever. Is that do you ever have that feeling? You're like, I owe that actor. That's been seven great little bit of an oh, but I also think that a lot of time, I mean, I you know, I had my favorites, so I would you know, I'm a talent whore, so I just love people who are talented. I'm gonna get this person a job. I think they're great.
[53:26] Marcia Debonis: For example, this is one thing that I don't know that everybody knows. But if you are lucky enough to get an agent, and if for some chance you, you know, it's three years on and you've had SAG insurance, and now all of a sudden, for whatever reason, you need now it's on the amount we make, right? Not on the weeks. I think it's on the map. Let's say you, oh, I need five thousand dollars in order to make my thing. You have your agent call casting directors and say, I have an actor who really needs to make their insurance, and people that's what I mean, like for throwing them a bone. People will be happy to cast you as you know, the jury foreman who says we find that, but you worked for a week and you got your five thousand dollars.
[54:10] Marcia Debonis: Okay, you started doing it earlier, but I want to get into the self-tape since it is such a part of what we do now. I mean, you know, you talk about theater, and there's some theater auditions that are coming back. Have you had any? Have you had any in-person audition? This has a listener. Nothing in person. It says Elizabeth, nothing, all everything is about self-tape. But that was true before the pandemic. I mean, she booked Jagged Jaguar. That's why I opened up the tape room because it felt like it had so this was in 2014 and it felt like it is much more an issue of convenience and cost than it is an issue of everything in this business is cost. And don't think for a second that we wouldn't be back to in-person if the producers hadn't recognized, oh, we can have the casting directors work from home.
[54:47] Marcia Debonis: We don't even have to, you know, so I feel like the right office space. Yeah, exactly. And or we could just have to rent one little office. We don't need a taper room. Here's the main thing I would say about self-tapes. Have your reader in the room with you if possible. Even if it's you have an appointment with it online or Zoom with a casting director, a producer, or director. If you have an agent, then you have your agent say, would you mind horribly if Charlie had his reader in the room? I have never known a casting director, except for me, to say no. I wouldn't say no, but you know what I mean. And it's like what Aaron Sorkin reads with all these people.
[55:27] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, I mean, it's just sort of like there most casting directors are thrilled to not have to deal with that aspect of it. Also, I would posit that Zoom is the death of spontaneity. I don't think you can be spontaneous on Zoom, you can't overlap. So ha if you can just have a friend right there with you. Yep. I love it. And that leads me to one of my questions that I had written down was how much do you like the reader to be, I'm gonna say like fully acting, as opposed to kind of a polite distance? Like I'm gonna say, especially in a scene where maybe it's very dramatic or it's very where the reader has something really interesting to do. Do you want Charlie Murphy giving his incredible Carnegie Mellon performance behind the camera?
[56:09] Marcia Debonis: Well, yes, I would like Charlie Murphy to do that, but I don't want some shitty reader doing that. But I'm saying if I'm reading, I'm sorry, so I'll say I'm reading for Elizabeth. Do you want my amazing crying now? It's sort of like in general, as when I'm auditioning, I'm just sort of like, unless you're really good and can keep up with me, which most casting directors can't because they're not actors like us. I'm fine with you just sort of like Suzanne Ryan once again, you know, she's not a great actress, but she gives you what she needs to give you.
[56:41] Marcia Debonis: She's just yeah, so you know, I remember a couple of times way early on in when I was doing pilot season, some actor was hellbent on bringing their own reader, and I was like, you don't need to. Well, they really want to read with an actor. It's sort of like I can act circles around you, dude, but fine. Well, they brought their own reader, and then the reader tried to take the scene from them. Right. So one of the things when you are a reader is you have to be aware that you are in support of the actor and not trying to, you know. It's finding that line sometimes of generosity of I'm generously giving the scene, but I'm not so sitting back that I'm not and so not living with it.
[57:17] Marcia Debonis: And I'm a huge believer, and again, this is all different because we're not going in like we used to. And when we did go in, there was a reader. But I'm a huge believer in picturing what are you going to do if you have a bad reader? Uh-huh. How are you going to handle it? And that goes for online too. And if you don't have the luxury of having your own reader in the room and you've worked on it, how what are you going to do if the reader is bad? Because what the tendency is, particularly with young actors, is you start the scene and you start third eyeing and going, Oh my god, this reader is like the shittiest reader I've ever had.
[57:51] Marcia Debonis: And then you're halfway through the scene. Third eyeing, and you mean stepping out of the scene. So now you're not. Yeah, like you're literally going, Oh my god, I'm not in the scene because I'm so appalled by the bad acting, and yet I'm shooting myself in the foot. So I'm a big believer in really being clear, like I'm not gonna let it throw me off if the reader is shitty. Um, do you like a prop or a set piece of at home when you could read at the kitchen table where the scene takes place at the kitchen table? Do you like that or does that feel too kitschy to you?
[58:17] Marcia Debonis: I do, but I also have I came up under Ellen Lewis, who is a very fabulous and fancy casting director. She does all of Martin Scorsese's movies. She hates props. Uh-huh. And some of it, Charlie, and you know this. It's like, I I've had fights with her, and in fact, I threw some Mike Nichols shit at her because she was like, I don't like activities. She's from you're thinking about some shit that was Mike Nichols you threw at her, or you're and I threw it at her. Um, he was talking about when he did The Odd Couple. There's the card game and how it's written so that everybody talks, you know, at a certain time.
[58:54] Marcia Debonis: And he just was like, No, we're playing a game every night, and they play the game every night, and the lines came out, and it's as an actor, I find an activity incredibly helpful. Here's the thing a lot of people don't, like I said, Ellen Lewis actively opposed to it, keep whatever activity is below the framework. Uh-huh. So it's helping you, right? But it's not too busy. It's not distracting the scene. Yep. What about in terms of like costume? So, you know, this advice is now many years older for me leaving school was like, Hey, for TV and film, you're probably gonna dress a little bit more in character than you would for a theater thing, right?
[59:31] Marcia Debonis: A little bit of a suggestion. Yeah, and I think that's true, but just a little. You know, you don't need to wear a white coat or a stethoscope. But for I always use this as an example. I cast the Julie Tamore movie Titus about type, you know, Titus Andronicus. One girl came in for Lavinia, who's the pure as a driven snow ingenue, in like a mini skirt, and it was just sort of like that that's just dumb. You know, but you don't so if you're auditioning for a lawyer, then yes, you should without putting on a suit, you should have a button-down shirt if you're a cop. You know what I mean?
[1:00:08] Marcia Debonis: So I think a suggestion is helpful without going too far. Does a self-tape change? I mean, does a self-tape give you a little more liberty to maybe throw on that suit jacket or throw on a yeah, would you wear a little more on a self-tape? Totally, totally, totally. That was I was impressed by how much Elizabeth would dress in character, and I would go, I never do that. I never wear that. Where she'll must be like, you basically look like the character. And also it helps you. It's not just helping them, it's helping you.
[1:00:34] Marcia Debonis: You do the full makeup, and while you're doing the makeup, you're also giving yourself self-time to get in charge. Um, okay, what about slates? You mentioned you like the slate at the end, which I love. Is this something do you like when an actor sort of slates kind of in character? So this is so funny because I did a little salon last night with a bunch of diverse actors, and I don't like it, but again, just because I don't doesn't mean that other people what I think, particularly in this era of not being in the room, is the slate is the only time you've already, if you're good, you've already proven you can play the cop.
[1:01:10] Marcia Debonis: You can play a cop. You don't need to slate as a cop. You need to slate as you, so they go, Oh wow, she's not at all like the cop she just read for. She's really good. And you don't think that will pull them out and they go, Oh, I guess that was fake. I guess that was acting before. If we said not if not if it's at the end. See, that I think that end is a great suggestion. I think sometimes actors are worried about going, hi, I'm Charlie. Okay.
[1:01:31] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, exactly. And then and then you're like all of a sudden the serious thing. Not if it's at the end. But like I said, you know, oftentimes I would say 30% of the time, they will say put your slate first. It's at the beginning, yeah. How do you feel about lighting and sound and those little technical stuff? Do you feel like I have talked to a lot of my casting director friends, and the thing that I feel very strongly is that we are worrying way too much. Not as an older person, I have recognized that they don't give a shit.
[1:02:01] Marcia Debonis: Like I could tape it with this in the background. I see plenty of actors do they just literally on the wall and for kids because they are more technically, you know, good. I think you know, buy a blue sheet that you can tack to the wall. That you can never fold up into it's whatever this is. There's me just stepping on it a lot. There's a lot of stepping on it. So, you know, you want the first hit that when they see you to not look like shit. But I think as good as self-taping is in the sense that we do have a little bit more control, I feel like actors do it take way too many takes.
[1:02:42] Marcia Debonis: If you are prepared, you should probably not do more than two or three or four takes in casting. I usually found the last take was the best, but that doesn't, you know, that doesn't necessarily mean that. Um, anything I miss in terms of whether it's self-tape just the casting world of like any questions that you or big advice, anything else on that sheet that you want to give to the state of the state. If you do have the luxury of actually being in a Zoom with the director or producer, or even just the casting director or actually in the room.
[1:03:12] Marcia Debonis: I every audition I go in, after I say hello, I say, are there any traps to avoid or helpful hints? Because if the casting director is a good casting director, they have like whenever I would start a pilot, I would call LA to say, have you had sessions? And if so, are there any helpful hints or traps to avoid? Uh-huh. Because a lot of times there are, and it's usually because the writing's not great. And so what you you ask that, and they'll go, you know what? There are actually.
[1:03:38] Marcia Debonis: People are getting way too mad in that second scene. They don't want that. So I ask that every single audition I go to. That is fantastic advice. I've never asked that. Helpful hints or traps. And I've often wondered if I've stepped into that trap. Yeah. And you know what? Nine times out of ten, they'll look at you and go, like, what? But the tenth time someone will go, yeah, don't fall into the anger trap. I don't meant to be so emotional. It seems like you might want to go there.
[1:04:10] Marcia Debonis: And again, I usually it's because of the writing hips them that way. That's great. And I think I would that's something we I remember from first graduating of like always ask a question, or some people said, Don't ask too many questions, or but it was always there's always that nervousness of going, how much should I talk before the thing my audition before I do? I think start to feel because I have watched people flap their jaw to the degree. Let's get on to the audition.
[1:04:50] Charlie Murphy: All right, we're gonna get to our game.
[1:04:52] Marcia Debonis: Okay, and we're gonna test that encyclopedic knowledge you've mentioned.
[1:04:56] Charlie Murphy: Uh oh. This game is called Casting a Wide Net. I'm gonna throw out a few remakes potentially of some classic movies and TV shows, and let you try to read these as best as possible. We'll see what you can do. Now remember, I haven't done any casting in 10 years. It can be outdated, no one's gonna know. And you could also make up names because you could be like they're a hot young actor and no one's gonna know until we have to find that. Are you ready to play casting a wide net?
[1:05:20] Marcia Debonis: I am ready to play.
[1:05:21] Charlie Murphy: They're doing a remake of Forrest Gump. Forrest Gump is coming back in 2022. Who is our new Forrest? Who we bringing into the room?
[1:05:28] Marcia Debonis: There's a kid, um, and I'm spacing on his name, but he is the lead in The Bear.
[1:05:36] Charlie Murphy: Um, yes, yes. You know who I mean?
[1:05:38] Marcia Debonis: Yes, from uh the one with William H. Macy.
[1:05:40] Charlie Murphy: It'd be really interesting to have us try to... Wait, is he it? It's the one about the restaurant, right?
[1:05:44] Marcia Debonis: Yes, no, I'm saying he's from the... he was from Shameless.
[1:05:46] Charlie Murphy: Oh, yes, that's right.
[1:05:48] Marcia Debonis: And I never watched Shameless. Um, Jeremy Allen White.
[1:05:51] Charlie Murphy: There's Jeremy Allen White. That's our new Forrest Gump, huh?
[1:05:55] Marcia Debonis: Um, I also think someone like Paul Dano, who has a sort of interiorness to him would be interesting.
[1:06:04] Charlie Murphy: Would we not think that we might need a neurodiverse actor to play?
[1:06:07] Marcia Debonis: Oh, yeah. Well, that's another thing. And such an interesting thing this you are now only allowed to play what you are.
[1:06:14] Charlie Murphy: I'm trying very hard to get you cancelled.
[1:06:16] Marcia Debonis: You promised you'd get canceled.
[1:06:17] Charlie Murphy: You have nothing offensive so far.
[1:06:18] Marcia Debonis: No, but I mean I feel like having three quarters of the appointment.
[1:06:21] Charlie Murphy: That's interesting.
[1:06:22] Marcia Debonis: Is that yes, you would like to, but by virtue of the fact that neurodivergent people have been have have had that held against them, the pool is so much smaller.
[1:06:35] Charlie Murphy: And I that is something we'll talk about maybe at the end of what is changing. That is something we've had now so many neurodiverse students who are now entering school, so it's more 2021, you know, movies.
[1:06:45] Marcia Debonis: Now neurodiversity is in general Asperger's or on the spectrum.
[1:06:51] Charlie Murphy: Is that good?
[1:06:52] Marcia Debonis: And yeah, good. More and more and more, but certainly of adult actors, there's way fewer than there are.
[1:06:58] Charlie Murphy: Right.
[1:06:59] Marcia Debonis: And that's that's very true.
[1:07:00] Charlie Murphy: Marvel just can't get enough and wants to do a new Iron Man, a new Iron Man.
[1:07:06] Marcia Debonis: This probably actually is actually happening. I don't know. But who's gonna replace the great Robert Downey Jr. as well?
[1:07:10] Charlie Murphy: I will let's talk about Andre Holland.
[1:07:14] Marcia Debonis: Why not? Andrew get in here.
[1:07:16] Marcia Debonis: Who I saw, you know, when he graduated from NYU, I flipped my lid for him, and I just tried and tried, and this is what it was like when he came out.
[1:07:27] Charlie Murphy: When did he come out?
[1:07:28] Marcia Debonis: About when you did?
[1:07:29] Charlie Murphy: Uh probably a little bit, I think a little after me. He's he's because of grad school. I was undergrad, so he was a little older than me.
[1:07:35] Marcia Debonis: He was right out of school basically when we were anyway. I just tried him for like we were doing because nobody has an original idea, a remake of The Rockford Files, which is an old thing.
[1:07:45] Charlie Murphy: And I tried him for Rockford, and guess what their reaction was?
[1:07:49] Marcia Debonis: He's so good. Could you try him for the sidekick?
[1:07:51] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.
[1:07:52] Marcia Debonis: And he and I did, and he booked it.
[1:07:54] Charlie Murphy: Yep.
[1:07:55] Marcia Debonis: Um, why did but Andre Holland in my from my money is the genius. He's got everything, he's got humor, he's sexy, he's just a fucking amazing actor.
[1:08:06] Charlie Murphy: Totally.
[1:08:06] Marcia Debonis: I can see him in the suit trying to be, you know, show a little bit of wealth. I got these big towers or whatever.
[1:08:12] Charlie Murphy: All right, what about they're making a new Kramer versus Kramer?
[1:08:15] Marcia Debonis: One of my favorite movies.
[1:08:16] Charlie Murphy: Great new Kramer versus Kramer, two amazing actors. They need two actors you're gonna be able to hold up.
[1:08:20] Marcia Debonis: Um, think about like that would to the mirror street doesn't.
[1:08:26] Charlie Murphy: Um, should we try to cast a real life cover?
[1:08:29] Marcia Debonis: Oh you know what I mean?
[1:08:31] Charlie Murphy: Um, so I hate to go back to Paul Dano, but he and Zoe Kazan, yeah, um Alessandra Nivola, and that uh lady who's married to him, that British, you know who I mean.
[1:08:46] Marcia Debonis: Oh, that's fun.
[1:08:46] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, kind of fun.
[1:08:47] Marcia Debonis: Oh, yeah.
[1:08:49] Charlie Murphy: Make it, you know, half reality TV, half a movie.
[1:08:51] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, like they're in, you know, there are you and Elizabeth can do it.
[1:08:55] Charlie Murphy: There are several Ray and I will do it.
[1:08:58] Marcia Debonis: I just wanted to say this game was gonna go on until you cast me in something.
[1:09:01] Charlie Murphy: I was gonna say now you've won the game, you've won, it's fantastic. Um, what about they're making a new Twitter biopic, and we need an Elon Musk, who is gonna be the wonderful Elon Musk uh um portrayer um who's gonna the downfall of Twitter.
[1:09:16] Marcia Debonis: How while he's too old, I was gonna say my uh Rylance.
[1:09:20] Charlie Murphy: Um Mark Rylance, oh a little age makeup on him, yeah.
[1:09:25] Marcia Debonis: Um well now they can CGI it.
[1:09:27] Charlie Murphy: CGI that's just CGI the whole thing.
[1:09:30] Marcia Debonis: Um I feel I feel like that would be a part that I literally would check out South African actors.
[1:09:39] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.
[1:09:40] Marcia Debonis: You know, he's South African, I mean he grew up there.
[1:09:42] Charlie Murphy: Um, and I have a feeling, and trust me when I say I I um I hate that Brits and Aussies and all the other people are casting Americans.
[1:09:53] Marcia Debonis: It's so uh frustrating to me.
[1:09:56] Charlie Murphy: But Elon Musk somehow feels like it would not be an American.
[1:09:56] Marcia Debonis: Would not be an American.
[1:10:01] Charlie Murphy: I think that's probably true.
[1:10:02] Marcia Debonis: You know, what's his name? Um, you know, the guy from uh again, he's probably too old, but he was in um Schindler, not not Ray Fiennes.
[1:10:12] Charlie Murphy: Um God, who am I thinking of?
[1:10:15] Marcia Debonis: He was in, I'll think of it and tell you, and you can put it in.
[1:10:18] Charlie Murphy: Perfect.
[1:10:18] Marcia Debonis: But he's a I think he's German.
[1:10:20] Charlie Murphy: Some ADR here for the...
[1:10:22] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, exactly.
[1:10:23] Charlie Murphy: We'll AD.
[1:10:23] Marcia Debonis: Um, all right, what about they're making a movie all about COVID-19?
[1:10:26] Charlie Murphy: Um, which I don't know why they're doing this.
[1:10:28] Marcia Debonis: Um, but we need an Anthony Fauci. Who's an Anthony Fauci character?
[1:10:32] Charlie Murphy: If anyone lives in New York, yeah, you will probably have seen a local commercial of a guy who has a uh paving thing around pools.
[1:10:41] Marcia Debonis: Looks exactly like we gotta find the guy who's paving things about pools.
[1:10:46] Charlie Murphy: Oh wow, Fauci.
[1:10:48] Marcia Debonis: I mean, I feel like Dustin Hoffman could do it.
[1:10:50] Charlie Murphy: You know, a lot of it would sort of be like who right age and and but I also feel like with all the makeup, like people can kind of pass for anyone.
[1:11:01] Marcia Debonis: You can look like anyone, yeah.
[1:11:02] Charlie Murphy: The magic of that.
[1:11:03] Marcia Debonis: I mean, Gary Oldman played, didn't he play Churchill?
[1:11:06] Charlie Murphy: Okay, you know what I mean?
[1:11:07] Marcia Debonis: So to get on the challenge.
[1:11:09] Charlie Murphy: All right, what about let's go to television?
[1:11:11] Marcia Debonis: Because you mentioned a remake of Seinfeld.
[1:11:13] Charlie Murphy: And we gotta know who who is gonna out Kramer Kramer, who's our Jerry?
[1:11:18] Marcia Debonis: Oh, well, our Jerry is may I mean we're fantasy casting.
[1:11:23] Charlie Murphy: Oh for sure.
[1:11:24] Marcia Debonis: So our Jerry is maybe Chris Rock.
[1:11:28] Charlie Murphy: Oh.
[1:11:29] Marcia Debonis: Um, and we would be a diverse cast.
[1:11:32] Charlie Murphy: Oh, Chris Rock as Jerry Seinfeld. I could see that.
[1:11:34] Marcia Debonis: Okay.
[1:11:35] Charlie Murphy: Um still a comedian.
[1:11:36] Marcia Debonis: Yes.
[1:11:37] Charlie Murphy: Kramer, I'm not sure.
[1:11:39] Marcia Debonis: But but someone, you know, who's an antic, I mean Martin Lawrence.
[1:11:44] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.
[1:11:44] Marcia Debonis: Uh-huh. An antic, physical kind of comedian.
[1:11:48] Charlie Murphy: Exactly.
[1:11:49] Marcia Debonis: Um, all right.
[1:11:49] Charlie Murphy: What about I Love Lucy?
[1:11:50] Marcia Debonis: We're making a remake of I Love Lucy.
[1:11:52] Charlie Murphy: Who could be a Lucille Ball?
[1:11:54] Marcia Debonis: Well, I know Deborah Messing has always wanted to play her.
[1:11:57] Charlie Murphy: Did you know that?
[1:11:57] Marcia Debonis: I didn't know that.
[1:11:58] Charlie Murphy: And was this bitter as a pill that um Cole Kidman got to do it?
[1:12:03] Marcia Debonis: I didn't see it.
[1:12:04] Charlie Murphy: That didn't feel right to me.
[1:12:06] Marcia Debonis: Um, who is I feel like there is somebody that I was like, she's so sort of I love Lucy-ish.
[1:12:12] Charlie Murphy: I didn't also give you the warning to bring your Rolodex where you could have really done something like that.
[1:12:15] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, exactly.
[1:12:15] Charlie Murphy: My last question is a little bit easier. It's just to of all the projects you've done, and again, we said you've never cast yourself in something, you've only done it when you've been forced to. What is one where you wish you could have dove into? Or what's a project that you go, God, I would have been so good in this.
[1:12:29] Marcia Debonis: Oh, if only I could have could have been cast.
[1:12:31] Charlie Murphy: That I worked on.
[1:12:33] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, it could also be just something from the world that you go. I always want to play this part.
[1:12:35] Charlie Murphy: You're on Lucille Ball.
[1:12:37] Marcia Debonis: But if there was one that you go, oh, I just missed this one, and I think I would have been so good in this.
[1:12:41] Marcia Debonis: I you know, I can't I can't think of any.
[1:12:44] Marcia Debonis: I do feel like I should just follow Jane Howdy Shell around and just take whatever job she rejects.
[1:12:51] Charlie Murphy: And one quick thing, I find it helpful to casting directors and agents if you can kind of um for your own self, try to figure out like like who would you follow around and take the parts.
[1:13:04] Marcia Debonis: I would take Chris Pratt before all the parts that he's got.
[1:13:07] Charlie Murphy: That's exactly right. You know what I mean?
[1:13:08] Marcia Debonis: Like when he got in amazing shape, and I'm like, but I didn't, so I can take the parts for the city.
[1:13:12] Charlie Murphy: Well, I can take the parts that he's no longer right for.
[1:13:14] Marcia Debonis: Um but but but try to be realistic.
[1:13:17] Charlie Murphy: Sometimes I'll say that and then some like character guy will like Ben Affleck, and it's like, dude, you are not like Ben Affleck.
[1:13:24] Marcia Debonis: Give me the Batman suit. I'll be fine.
[1:13:25] Charlie Murphy: I can put the suit on. That's no problem at all.
[1:13:28] Marcia Debonis: Um, all right, our last chance to cancel you, Marcia, before we let you go. It's just, I want to talk a little bit about how do you feel this industry changing in 2022.
[1:13:35] Charlie Murphy: So I know you got out of 2013 casting, but let's talk about how things have shifted.
[1:13:40] Marcia Debonis: I think things have shifted so much, but not enough.
[1:13:44] Marcia Debonis: Um, as I said, I'm married to a black actor.
[1:13:47] Marcia Debonis: Um, I refuse to just try diverse actors for the supporting roles.
[1:13:54] Marcia Debonis: Um, and I think LA actually, without saying it, liked that that they had one person who wasn't about the pretty and the whatever.
[1:14:03] Marcia Debonis: So, for example, the place that I worked talked a big, big, big, big, big, big thing about diversity. Talk, talk, talk, talk.
[1:14:10] Marcia Debonis: They did nothing about it.
[1:14:11] Marcia Debonis: They did not hire diverse writers, they did not hire diverse directors, they did not hire diverse casting directors.
[1:14:18] Marcia Debonis: So, what would happen each year is they would make a big thing, and then we would cast it, and there would come a point where it would be like, oh no, we had six parts to cast.
[1:14:28] Marcia Debonis: We cast five of them with white people, and then they would try to shove a diverse actor into the part, whether it supported it or not.
[1:14:36] Marcia Debonis: And this happened quite a bit.
[1:14:37] Charlie Murphy: And what would inevitably happen is they would cast some pretty diverse actor who couldn't act, they would do the table read and they would be fired.
[1:14:47] Marcia Debonis: And then the place that I worked would claim that they couldn't find their best any diverse actors, and it drove me mad.
[1:14:56] Charlie Murphy: So I feel like now they're not just talking, they're actually casting diverse actors.
[1:15:04] Marcia Debonis: And so now it's still not enough, in my opinion.
[1:15:08] Marcia Debonis: Um, I I also, you know, 10 years ago when I taught at Juilliard, I would have to have a conversation with the diverse actors.
[1:15:16] Marcia Debonis: And the conversation was don't, you know, you're gonna have to be patient and don't take it personally if your white classmates get agents from the showcase and you don't.
[1:15:28] Marcia Debonis: That means nothing other than we are in a racist industry.
[1:15:32] Charlie Murphy: And now I have the exact same conversation with the white actors.
[1:15:37] Marcia Debonis: Um, because in typical fashion, our business has overcorrected to the point of ridiculousness.
[1:15:43] Charlie Murphy: Um but but you know, I I just um, you know, pay patient.
[1:15:49] Marcia Debonis: Yeah, so now I do feel like, and so all of a sudden people are given an opportunity.
[1:15:54] Charlie Murphy: Um, and good for them.
[1:15:56] Marcia Debonis: I am fundamentally against that you're only allowed to play the people that the person you are.
[1:16:02] Marcia Debonis: I am Italian, and um I I don't I would never uh go in for a you know orthodox Jew or a Hasidic Jew or anything like that.
[1:16:12] Charlie Murphy: But someone with the last named Kong, I'll go in for all the time.
[1:16:16] Marcia Debonis: And I'm waiting for the time where I'm going to be told that I can't do that.
[1:16:20] Marcia Debonis: My husband and I want to do um Driving Miss Daisy, and I guarantee you someone will be like, mm-mm, he's not Jewish.
[1:16:28] Charlie Murphy: So I'm I'm sick of all of this bullshit.
[1:16:30] Marcia Debonis: I mean, you know, I am Jewish, and you would never know it looking at me.
[1:16:33] Charlie Murphy: So I can never play that part.
[1:16:35] Marcia Debonis: You know, I can never play sort of stereotypical Jewish part because I don't look.
[1:16:38] Charlie Murphy: It's really interesting.
[1:16:39] Marcia Debonis: I I well, the Irish part is Murphy seems to be.
[1:16:42] Charlie Murphy: I'm half Irish, half Jewish.
[1:16:45] Marcia Debonis: Which is much like acting.
[1:16:46] Charlie Murphy: But no, it's so interesting.
[1:16:48] Marcia Debonis: And and you know, the way we're talking about this is gonna get a little esoteric financial point, but the way that like we raised interest rates, which to try to combat inflation, it there is that like delayed effect that happens, which I think a lot of actors are now feeling in stuff like agents.
[1:17:01] Marcia Debonis: Agents are really looking for diverse, um...
[1:17:01] Charlie Murphy: Oh yeah, no, I I can't get a white actor and an agent.
[1:17:07] Marcia Debonis: But that's because the Asian stables were so uh didn't have enough, and now people are asking for them, right?
[1:17:12] Charlie Murphy: So that's like it's a weird slow delayed effect of going, we're trying to fix this thing, but it's not actually meaning that there are no parts for white actors.
[1:17:19] Marcia Debonis: Clearly there are, but you feel like in in weird segments of the economy, feel the interest rate goes up and hopefully it trickles down, and you know, it's can be...
[1:17:19] Charlie Murphy: That's exactly right.
[1:17:27] Marcia Debonis: But we are experiencing as white actors what diverse actors have experienced for a hundred years since the business started.
[1:17:35] Charlie Murphy: So I, you know, I get that people are frustrated, but it's just like suck it up, kids, because we're just having to go through what and it was wrong when it was done to black actors, and it's wrong when no, you know, that when it's done to white actors.
[1:17:48] Marcia Debonis: My friend, and I won't say her name, but she casts something in a TV series, and she was told, unless it's a plot point, do not cast anyone white or over 30.
[1:18:00] Charlie Murphy: Oh, not over 30.
[1:18:01] Marcia Debonis: How to uh I'm young, we're so young still.
[1:18:04] Charlie Murphy: Yep, nope.
[1:18:05] Marcia Debonis: Yep. So that's you know, the ridiculousness that happens in this.
[1:18:10] Charlie Murphy: I don't think anyone's gonna cancel you over that.
[1:18:12] Marcia Debonis: Those are some very reasonable thoughts. We failed at the goal for I mean, as long as they don't cancel and I can still work in theater, I could give a shit if I never do any TV or film.
[1:18:21] Charlie Murphy: Um, what about so uh my last question is to throw out uh to a young actor, maybe especially who wants to have your career, who wants to have whether it's specifically casting and acting but wants to have this multi hyphenate dual career. What advice would you give to that young person of like how they can have a marsh of honest career?
[1:18:36] Marcia Debonis: It's an interesting thing because I don't know whether um casting direct I think it depends, but I'm not sure that saying I'm an actor is but I and I want to continue acting and also cast. I'm not sure you would get the job. You know, I just got kind of lucky. Um but but so I don't feel like I know some of my friends were like, oh, Marcia kind of got like I ended up getting an agent from a better agent from the my contacts with casting, and they tried to do it, but it's sort of like, well, A, you have to be talented, and and B, you know, it may or may not happen that way. But I do know when I have tried to get actor friends gigs with casting director friends, they don't want they don't want them to because they don't want to have to worry that they're gonna leave for an audition and da-da-da-da-da.
[1:19:29] Charlie Murphy: But writing writing and directing is so I mean that's that's what a lot of my friends do, hyphen it was because they can also project.
[1:19:38] Marcia Debonis: Well, and you started a theater company too. I mean, you you that's yeah, another way to go.
[1:19:41] Charlie Murphy: I'm gonna give myself and I started a you know, I did the tape room, and which is now not it's just online, but all right. Is there anything else you need to plug in terms of where people could be following you?
[1:19:50] Marcia Debonis: I'm trying to think if there was anything here that I any words of wisdom we'll certainly put the links to the tape room there. Do you have a social media where people could be following you if they were to oh I think I don't I do know it.
[1:20:03] Marcia Debonis: Um, one really quick little thing. Don't be afraid to bring humor to comedy to humor to drama and drama to comedy. It it lifts it, it lifts it. Like you're watching Law and Order and there it's serious, and then someone laughs and it's like, oh, that's real.
[1:20:22] Charlie Murphy: So my last such good advice. I feel like that is uh every every monologue I work on always like, where's the opposite of this thing? Where is the thing that's and that's another thing? I'm a huge believer, play the opposite, particularly if the writing is sappy, do not play into that, you play against that. If the writing is angry, do not play into that, you play against right I wouldn't I would never want to sound sappy if if it sounds like it's that I almost have to try not to right but you see people fall into that and don't fake tears.
[1:20:51] Marcia Debonis: But if I'm really if you can't exactly and it's like my my big thing on that is if you feel yourself getting up here you're faking it and just go into a lower register. Or once again Suzanne Ryan who had to cast people who had for law and order who just you know their kid had just died she would as she was walking them into the room she would always say if you're not full emotionally play shock and guess what shock and stillness is interesting for sure or you or of course you could have a kid right if you have a kid you'll just cry at the drop of a hat anyway exactly or you have a child and then you're acting at better.
[1:21:27] Charlie Murphy: Marcia this was such a pleasure thank you so much for the time today.
[1:21:27] Marcia Debonis: Thank you.
[1:21:36] Charlie Murphy: Happy Hanukkah it's night three as I record this um and I really hope you enjoyed that conversation with Marcia she is just so whip smart and funny and I just love the way she came in with a sheet full of advice uh especially so much advice that is like good and specific to casting today that was so cool. And she was so smart to say in my opinion with so much of the stuff that is different from casting director to casting director uh that was definitely a lesson for me early in my career as you kind of try to adjust to like what is different in terms of the advice you'll get in school versus in the professional world and recognizing how different those two things can be from each other as well as the delivery method of those different sources.
[1:22:17] Charlie Murphy: Someone who's a teacher is so much more likely to be reasoned in the way they talk about this, whereas some of the kind of industry business people can be much quicker and more cavalier with things and maybe more abrupt in their delivery. Like it is this. It can be really jarring coming out of an educational institution, which is normally full of very heart-centered people who aren't leading with the dollar sign. Um, and this is where Marcia, like Jeff before her, are potentially deceptive examples, and that they both do tend to lead from the heart and are more educator-centered than the average industry person, um, which maybe helps them serve as a bit of a bridge to some of the folks you'll meet.
Um, which of course is not to say that like most human beings behind the table are like monsters. Of course not. Most people in the industry are very kind human beings. I just remember being jarred by how quick and crass some people in the kind of real world could be coming out of school, and the way they would talk about things would just be like, oh God, that's not the complicated discussion that we'd have in school. It's like this is this.
[1:23:12] Charlie Murphy: Um, and even here in this discussion where I think we rarely ventured into something crass, there's an ease that creeps into a familiar conversation between actors where it's easy to land on quote unquote answers that really aren't capital T true, um, like we talked about TV only being pretty people, or um, only people with an Instagram following can book TV, right? And of course, there are great counterexamples, right? That is hyperbolic to say it like that. And when we discuss delicate topics like diversity in the industry, I mean it has to be acknowledged that things are never as um pardon my pun here, never as black and white as it can sound from listening to a short conversation, right? There is no such place as the industry out there. There are only thousands of people and companies with different motivations and different perspectives who kind of coalesce to make up the economy of Broadway TV and film.
[1:24:02] Charlie Murphy: So people will say the industry is X, but there is no industry there to be X as one monolith, right? It it is impossible to accurately describe the movements of all the parts in a shifting shifting landscape, just like it's impossible to, you know, locate a particular electron in an atom. I'm not sure if that's the right metaphor. I haven't taken a science class in two decades. But you know, that idea of like it's somewhere in there, and if you can kind of describe all of the general idea of it, but you can't describe an exact place. I'm gonna stop with this metaphor because I think it's it's reached its place of usefulness, um, as we say. But just to say that, like, you know, uh a word of caution to anyone who's hearing things that we are said kind of cavalierly between um two actors, as if that is you know, capital T true, because of course it's not.
[1:24:44] Charlie Murphy: One thing I do want to highlight um is just some of the great acting advice Marcia gave here. This is where I think she is really different than a lot of casting directors in her ability to give some of these high-level acting tips. Not to say that there aren't other casting directors who came uh from the acting world and who are great actors, but I think Marcia is particularly um well resourced in that in that vein. You know, she's giving these these tips and tricks that really come from an acting perspective and aren't just tricks, you know, even though she she used that word tricks. You can tell like they're based in something that is acting. And again, when we talk about that bridge from school to life, which many of you, if you're in school now or right out of school, are gonna be navigating.
This is a case where how do you add some of the tips and tricks from you know, people who know on camera work, who know self-tapes, who know the industry, but not actually throw away all of that great acting training that you spent four years getting.
[1:25:34] Charlie Murphy: It is easy to hear some of the industry advice you're often gonna get from an agent managing cast uh agent manager, casting director, those kind of people, and think, oh, that's the only thing. What they mean is this, which then can lead to a really hollow performance. Just as you would often do with the director who might give you a kind of result-oriented note. Your job is to synthesize and integrate that through the lens of the other great work that you're doing. So if someone tells you to be mumbly, like Marcia did here, right? So TV's kind of mumbly. So I'm not gonna do it like this, right? That doesn't mean only do that, right? You still have to act and do all that stuff you were doing before.
You're just making a kind of dialect style change, right? You're adding in the dialect of mumble, but you're still playing the same objective and fight, fighting for the same truth and stuff that you were doing before, right? And the same could be true for something like a tone note. Um, you know, sometimes uh a director or casting director will give you a note about tone, and we know as actors we're not supposed to be play tone.
[1:26:25] Charlie Murphy: Um, you know, an emotional quality, we know we're not supposed to play our emotions, right? These are the kind of things that as trained actors, we know that we are not supposed to play into those, but we still have to take the note and achieve the result that the director of the casting director wants. So often you're kind of taking that adjustment and translating it into a bit of something that will still allow you to play actively while making sure you achieve the result that's looked for. You know, too often what young actors do, and I see this mistake a lot, is they jump right to that step and try to give the result. Like, oh, I got it. I can I can give you what I think you're looking for, what I think you want it to sound like, which will give you the pat on the head of, oh, they took the note, which is good, but it often leads to not very interesting work, right?
Because imagining many people are getting this note that they're giving. If it's like, oh, I think she needs to be X, right? And as she says she needs to be X, you can't just give them what you think Marcia's idea of X is. You have to give Charlie's fully fleshed out performance, integrating the idea of X that Marcia's throwing at you.
[1:27:21] Charlie Murphy: Okay, that's it. We achieved a holiday. Next week we have our pre-recorded mailbag show, which I think was fun and actually had some pretty good info from some of your great questions. We got so many great questions. Mostly via email, though we got a bunch from Instagram too. Um, and so it was so fun to get to do that. And you know, Megan and I got a little fun and spicy with it. We thought about having a drink before we did it. We didn't, but we still brought a little bit of that holiday cheer as if you know they were sip and eggnog. And we played some games. Megan attempted a password style game for me, and I came back at her with a nice trivia-based game. You all will be able to play along as listeners of the pod, because they're all based on previous episodes of the podcast, especially this year, though some going back into last year for sure. Most of all, a huge and happy holidays to you all.
[1:28:04] Charlie Murphy: I'm gonna end on this note. I can't believe we're in the outro and I'm still talking. I have more to say. We're already at like you know over 90 minutes. It's fine. Um, which is just some big love to the artists in your life. Um, we often talk about the difficulty of the industry, and you know, sometimes we people criticize the career choice to be an actor, you hear that a lot. But can we also just give some love to the incredible bravery it takes to be it takes to decide to be an actor, to be an artist really of any kind. You know, Elizabeth and I went to a holiday party last night full of a lot of actors and artists, and I just walked out of there saying, I love this community so much, you know.
Um at first it was just nice to, you know, be social, which is something we haven't done for as much, you know, during the pandemic and all that. Um, but I feel like actors sometimes all we just hear about their the negatives in terms of the stereotype with the image of an actor. And you know, there is just something truly special about the kind of people who choose to become actors in general, right? Um often we're sort of compared to, you know, muggles versus artists, you'll see that from the schools will say, like, oh yeah, as opposed to the muggles, we're in this thing. And I really do feel like there is a special magic, you know, in what it is to be in a room full of like charming and deeply engaging people.
Um I think artists and especially actors, we tend to be empaths and sensitive and just generally very smart. And we tend to be all around great people. So not to go on a long rant about how amazing actors are, but I just was feeling that and I'm gonna say that into the universe because I think it's really true.
[1:29:31] Charlie Murphy: So if you're ever out there and someone's going, oh you decided to be an actor eye roll, you're like, that's actually pretty amazing and good for that person. And I think it's just, yeah, maybe I'm specifically countering the the whatever that eye roll is inducing of sort of the vainglorious image of an actor, um, let's counter it with the people I met at that party who were just sensitive and wonderful and charming and fun and all the things that I think we know most actors to be. You know, it's just it's a really special community. All right, now go rate us, review us, tell us why you love being an artist or tell us why you love the artist in your life if you're a follower of one. You also can follow us at mapping the college audition which is our own special feed of all pod all the time and check us out at mtca.nyc for help with your individual prep for your college audition process. Two of my young artists out there mapping their journeys have a wonderful holiday. We'll see you next week for our mailbag.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
