In this week’s episode Tori and Libby take a deep dive into the world of Dear Evan Hansen, discussing the family dynamics, the impacts both positive and negative of Social Media, actions and consequences and one of the big themes of the show, mental health... Read More
From the show: Stage Door Podcast
Featured Shows
About
In this week’s episode Tori and Libby take a deep dive into the world of Dear Evan Hansen, discussing the family dynamics, the impacts both positive and negative of Social Media, actions and consequences and one of the big themes of the show, mental health.
Leave us a rate and review, and let us know what you’d love to hear in our next episode on our Instagram @ps.stagedoorpod or via our email at ps.stagedoor.podcast@gmail.com
Created, Edited and Produced by Victoria Bullard & Elizabeth Gunther
Music by Catherine Gunther
https://www.psstagedoorpodcast.com/
Mental Health Resources:
https://www.beyondblue.org.au/
https://www.lifeline.org.au/
https://headspace.org.au/
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Tori Bullard: Before we begin this week's episode, we would like to acknowledge the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation, the traditional custodians of this land on which we work, live, and record, and recognize their continuing connection to land, water, and community.
[0:14] Tori Bullard: We pay respect to elders past, present, and emerging.
[0:18] Tori Bullard: Hi guys, it's just Tori popping in really quickly before the episode starts to say we spoke a lot on mental health in this episode, and right now, with the state of everything and in the arts, we're all feeling a bit uneasy.
[0:32] Tori Bullard: If you ever need to talk to someone, we've listed some great resources in our episode details as well as on our social media, such as Lifeline, Headspace, Beyond Blue, as well as just checking in on each other.
[0:45] Tori Bullard: Never be afraid to speak up and speak out.
[0:48] Tori Bullard: After all, no one deserves to be forgotten.
[0:51] Tori Bullard: Enjoy the episode.
[0:57] Tori Bullard: Hi everyone, and welcome back to PS Meet Me at Stage Door.
[1:01] Tori Bullard: Today we are so excited to be bringing you a brand new deep dive into Dear Evan Hansen.
[1:07] Tori Bullard: But before we jump into it, over to Libby for the bulletin.
[1:13] Tori Bullard: So, um, it's actually Tori again. Unfortunately, Libby is really sick and has lost her voice, so I'll be doing the bulletin for today.
[1:22] Tori Bullard: It has been announced this week that the 2020 Tony Awards will be going ahead and transitioning to an online live show this year.
[1:31] Tori Bullard: Although there has not yet been a confirmed date, the American Theatre Wing is aiming to stream at the end of October.
[1:39] Tori Bullard: We cannot wait to see who will take out the Tonies this year and what they have in store for the live streamed awards.
[1:46] Tori Bullard: In exciting news for the Aussie Theatre community, Sydney Theatre Company has announced their plans to return to the stage with a COVID-safe, socially distanced performance of Angus Sereni's Wanagata, starring Wayne Blair and Hugo Weaving at the Rosalind Packer Theatre from the 21st of September 2020.
[2:06] Tori Bullard: The excitement doesn't stop there as they have planned performances of Rules for Living and The Picture of Dorian Gray later in 2020.
[2:14] Tori Bullard: So make sure to keep your eyes and ears peeled for any further news on those shows.
[2:20] Tori Bullard: If you have been missing seeing mainstage musicals, get ready, because on November 24th, 2020, Pippin, the Tony Award winning show will be coming to the Sydney Lyric Theatre for a strictly limited run, full of extraordinary acrobats, wonderful magical feats, and soaring songs from Steven Schwartz.
[2:39] Tori Bullard: We cannot wait to see this incredible John Frost production.
[2:43] Tori Bullard: Tickets are on sale now.
[2:44] Tori Bullard: But that's it for the bulletin for this week.
[2:47] Tori Bullard: Back over to me, I guess.
[2:49] Tori Bullard: Alright, so for today's deep dive, we actually put it out to you guys and we did a little bit of a poll to see what you guys would be interested to hear us talk about.
[2:58] Tori Bullard: And unanimously you guys voted for Dear Evan Hansen.
[3:03] Tori Bullard: So just a little bit of background. So obviously, today we're going to be discussing the hit Broadway musical Dear Evan Hansen.
[3:10] Tori Bullard: So of course, be warned, there are going to be spoilers in this, so if you haven't seen the show already and you're not interested in spoilers, well, you have been warned.
[3:19] Tori Bullard: The show was nominated for nine Tony Awards, which it won six of, including Best Actor in a Musical as well as Best Musical.
[3:28] Tori Bullard: The story centres around a senior student, Evan, who struggles being an outsider and longs to fit in with his fellow peers.
[3:36] Tori Bullard: Through a series of unfortunate events, Evan finds himself in a web of lies as he fabricates a relationship with Connor, a recently deceased student who took his own life.
[3:47] Tori Bullard: Connor's family discover a letter not intended to be read by anyone other than Evan and mistakes it for a friendship.
[3:54] Tori Bullard: Thus begins this string of misunderstandings.
[3:57] Tori Bullard: In a way, this is where the story really starts.
[4:00] Tori Bullard: The show tackles a myriad of different topics, which has made it one of the most talked about shows in recent years.
[4:06] Tori Bullard: So I guess we've kind of pretty much the way that we do these, we've got a list of kind of things that we want to talk about, and we're just gonna pretty much chat with each other about it.
[4:16] Tori Bullard: There's gonna be stuff that we agree on, stuff that we disagree on, and obviously we want to hear what you guys think about our opinions about the show as well.
[4:25] Tori Bullard: So I guess a good starting point to kind of talk about is something that the show does, you know, have um a center around, which is the mental health of it all.
[4:35] Tori Bullard: So, you know, a few things being obviously you have Connor who does take his life quite early in the show, and of course, you have Evan who struggles with um an social anxiety disorder.
[4:48] Tori Bullard: Something we are gonna talk about a little bit later on, is if there is there another thing underlying that social anxiety disorder.
[4:54] Tori Bullard: But the show really does center around mental health, social media. There are a lot of things that go into this show that made it such an impactful show, not only for a younger generation, but just for I think everyone.
[5:10] Tori Bullard: I think everyone in this show can find something to relate to, whether it be in Evan, in Alana, in Zoe, in Connor, in Heidi, even there is just something to relate to.
[5:22] Tori Bullard: The family dynamics. I think the thing that makes this show really connect to such a young audience, especially people our age, I think Evan is a really interesting character because the way that they wrote the show, Evan's anxiety is very realistic.
[5:40] Tori Bullard: It's more a realistic interpretation of anxiety in a lot of ways because there's always that um you know those shows that kind of do, oh I'm really nervous, and like I'm I'm kind of jittery to meet that that guy, or that's how they show anxiety.
[5:55] Tori Bullard: It's very like fake and it's almost just like put on.
[5:59] Tori Bullard: Whereas I think what Dear Evan Hansen does so well and why it was so successful in that way is that it shows mental health in a more realistic way on stage that I think has never been done in a musical as well.
[6:11] Tori Bullard: I think you have um next to normal, for example, yeah, which is um tackles mental health, but it's not from a young person's perspective.
[6:19] Tori Bullard: Um I think that's no well, don't forget it is because you have Natalie as well.
[6:24] Tori Bullard: Um and I think the important thing to remember is yeah, I I do agree.
[6:28] Tori Bullard: I think Evan does show quite a realistic and and the extremes of anxiety, the fact that you know Heidi does everything she can to help him, and you know, he does see a therapist.
[6:40] Tori Bullard: She he has exercises that Heidi really wants him to do.
[6:44] Tori Bullard: Um, and while that's all you know really good, and it's good that she's helping him, there's also this feeling of um like if you do these things, anxiety will just go away.
[6:54] Tori Bullard: And that's not how anxiety works.
[6:56] Tori Bullard: It's something that will stay with you pretty much for your entire life, and yes, it will have its you know, its ebbs and flows, days where it will be easier, days where it will be harder, months, years where you will barely feel the sting of anxiety.
[7:08] Tori Bullard: But I think the important thing to remember as well is that everybody experiences anxiety in a different way.
[7:14] Tori Bullard: So for some people it is that more outward, jittery feeling, others it's much more suppressed and inward, and it might express itself through ticks and things like that.
[7:24] Tori Bullard: So I just think that that is definitely what he does.
[7:27] Tori Bullard: Yeah, and that's kind of also where it kind of leads into is there something underlying his um social anxiety?
[7:37] Tori Bullard: Could there be um a deeper disorder, anxiety, um, anxiety and depression are already very heavy um mental health issues to go through as it is.
[7:50] Tori Bullard: Um, but is there something underlying?
[7:52] Tori Bullard: Like I've read a few articles online, possibly he has Asperger's.
[7:56] Tori Bullard: And this was coming, this article that I read it was actually coming from someone who themselves has Asperger's, and when they saw the show, it made them think that that's possibly how he was being portrayed.
[8:08] Tori Bullard: To have, you know, he has that social anxiety disorder, but there's possibly another underlying disorder that helps feed it because anxiety is also a symptom of Asperger's as well.
[8:20] Tori Bullard: So I just think that's kind of an interesting thing that is not necessarily written in words anywhere, but it could be an underlying thing, and again, that could just be how that particular actor chooses to portray the character.
[8:35] Tori Bullard: We don't know the inner workings of what the creative team necessarily decided or what the actors decided in their creative process.
[8:43] Tori Bullard: But it's an interesting concept to think about because he does have the ticks and the little mannerisms, and again, that can be a symptom.
[8:52] Tori Bullard: Not a symptom, sorry, that can be something to do with anxiety.
[8:56] Tori Bullard: Um, but there obviously are other disorders out there that could also be an underlying issue for Evan that kind of helps with that not helps, but you know, it adds to that build up.
[9:06] Tori Bullard: And I think the thing that makes um Evan such an interesting character, like as an actor, I think it would be so interesting to play him because you can go in a different direction.
[9:16] Tori Bullard: I feel like he's a character that you really can mould to what you think um are his issues and what what do you think he's driven by, you know, especially because it is definitely strongly suggested that he also tries to hurt himself or take his life.
[9:34] Tori Bullard: It's quite strongly suggested that he does that.
[9:37] Tori Bullard: I find it quite interesting to figure out what what like what made him do that, and I think the family dynamics is a quite an interesting one for that.
[9:45] Tori Bullard: Because in I've read I've read that he almost did that because he was seeking attention from his mum, because his mum is never there.
[9:54] Tori Bullard: She loves him so much, but yeah, she's really not there for him, and he feels so alone, like he feels he says like I was so alone, and that's why I did it.
[10:03] Tori Bullard: And so it's a really interesting, um, it's an interesting place to look at what what drives him and why why he's done the things that he's done because then you kind of understand a lot more in act two.
[10:15] Tori Bullard: Because in act one, which I find really really cool, is that in the writing, they never say what Evan's like family situation is like.
[10:26] Tori Bullard: For example, they don't really tell you why the dad left or like daddy left, or like how does he see his dad?
[10:32] Tori Bullard: Does he not see his dad? Things like that.
[10:35] Tori Bullard: They kind of teeter on the edge of like, you know, what what the family situation is like, but it's not till act two that you realize that um all of that has affected him, and also it's all to do with how Evan plays it, which is really interesting because it's not specifically said any of this happens, but you are alluded to it because it's how the actor plays it rather than what physically is written in the script.
[11:02] Tori Bullard: It's actually more what what the actor chooses to do with his mannerisms and things.
[11:07] Tori Bullard: I think I I totally agree about um, you know, he does feel very lonely, like his his mum does love him and she tries so hard to support him and make these taco nights and things like that, but then also he does have the pressure of losing his dad.
[11:24] Tori Bullard: Well, his dad leaving, and again, like you said, that's not something that's touched on really until act two, and in So Big So Small, I think that's the song title.
[11:33] Tori Bullard: I think also though, from Does Anybody Have a Map, you kind of get this feeling that Heidi is struggling because it kind of feels like she has to be, and again, this is my interpretation.
[11:44] Tori Bullard: It feels like she has to be everything for Evan. She has to be mum, she has to be dad, she has to be friend, because you know, he doesn't really have a lot of friends. Really, the only friend he has is Jared, and that's a family friend. They're not really necessarily like the best of the buds. But then you also have, you know, you see Heidi, and they still seem relatively happy though, together as a family, as the two of them, and then you go over and you see a full family with Zoe and Connor, and you see the mum and dad, you see kind of a full family picture, but then you do see how dysfunctional they are from the get-go.
[12:21] Libby: I agree. I think it's been it, and I also think it's really interesting how they have approached the mother figure in this show. Because in "Does Anyone Have a Map," I think it really does. I mean, both you and I have been working as nannies and like full-time nannies during COVID, and honestly, like spending an entire day with a three-year-old all the time, you go, you don't know what you're doing. And I've seen those kind of roles that are placed on women, and I think that it's really interesting how they word it is very contemporary, and it's more realistic of how I feel like women do feel in those mother roles. Like, I don't know what I'm doing, I'm trying everything, I'm trying so hard, and I still feel like I'm failing. Because I feel like so many mothers feel that way. They feel like they're doing everything they can possibly do, but it's still not enough.
[13:13] Tori Bullard: Yeah, and you definitely do, like you said, you definitely really do get that feel from the get-go in "Does Anyone Have a Map," because you know, it's like another masterful attempt ends with disaster, another cup of coffee and watched it all crash and burn, it's a struggle, it's a maze. Like, they're talking about they just want to do right by their kids, they want to be a good mother, they want to, you know, be lenient but still be strict, but not be the bad guy, but be there for them and do what's gonna be right for them. And I think every parent will go through that, especially, you know, especially I think the teenage years is always probably gonna be one of the hardest because it's when they're forming their own opinions and you don't want to necessarily form them for them, but you want to make sure that they're being safe and that they're careful, but that they're being their own person, it's that constant battle, and you do really feel that.
Um, so I think the dynamics of the two different families, and I wouldn't say that Evan's family is poor, but Connor and Zoe's family is definitely a bit more well off and that probably comes from the fact that you know the dad works very hard.
[14:24] Libby: Um and you do see that in later in the show as well when he's having this interaction with Evan that you can see that he worked so, so hard when Connor was young that he maybe didn't quite get to have that same connection with Connor because he wanted to be there to support his family. And again that's another struggle that people go through that Heidi goes through as well. It's like being there to support your family financially but also being there for them emotionally and you know being able to spend that time, it's work-life balance can be really hard for single parents and you know parents working together alike.
[15:04] Tori Bullard: Exactly, and I think what is really interesting is when they, you know, when they do that whole social media part and it's where the suicide note itself gets published and then everyone kind of like goes crazy and there's all these like threats and things like that. One of the things that I noticed when that was like 'cause you know it's kind of a jumble of like people and what they say. Um I noticed that someone said that like they're so rich why couldn't they spend more of their money on helping their son? It was something along those lines. And I was like that really hit me because I was like it doesn't matter, it doesn't matter where you come from or what you have, like I think that they did try. And I think like Heidi tries too, and you can see that even though you can try so hard, sometimes it just doesn't work.
[15:57] Libby: I mean, I think you know, I definitely know a lot of people who have been to psychologists and things like that, and some work really well for them, and then some don't. And if you just get someone who just doesn't work for you, it's not like it, it's like finding the right life partner. You've got to find the right psychologist for you.
[16:16] Tori Bullard: It's totally true, and also making that step to begin with to talk to someone is one of the hardest things. Like from personal experience, that was a super uncomfortable thing for me to do because I don't want to share that information, and I don't want to share those thoughts and that I want to keep that to myself. And I definitely feel that Connor was like that. Maybe he, you know, we all kind of sometimes feel oh, we can't talk to such and such, or we can't talk to our parents, they won't get it, but they will, and I think that that is a bit of a struggle. But money does not fix all the problems in the world. You could have all the money in the world, talk to the best psychologist and still suffer from depression and anxiety because it's not just a curable thing, it's just not how it works.
[17:05] Libby: So the important thing is, like you said, Tori, you have to find someone that you're comfortable with, and it's like it is like finding a life partner, it's trial and error, and you know, going to a psychologist for a couple of appointments and being like, this is great, this person really does understand me, it's really helping me, or going to a psychologist and going, uh, I just I don't feel a proper connection to this person, I don't feel comfortable, or you know, I've even had people saying, you know, that their psychologist made them feel degraded, and just it didn't necessarily make them feel whole as a person, so it is definitely a trial and error thing, and money does not necessarily is not the be-all end all of you know helping mental health issues.
[17:52] Tori Bullard: All these things that you can read behind the lines of this story that maybe he was kind of was seeking help, maybe he wasn't, because they say, um, especially the parents say, like, I thought he was getting better, like we thought he was getting better. So it's like, I don't know if he was seeing anyone or if he wasn't. But that family dynamic is definitely an interesting one in the show, and I think we could talk for days about that because it's most definitely so many things. But I think something that I really want to touch on, and we kind of already did, but social media and its impact that it has.
[18:27] Libby: And I actually have this quote from one of the creative team when they were talking about their use of social media in the show. So they said, we all noticed a really fascinating bizarre phenomenon of public grieving on social media, whether a celebrity would die or something really tragic would happen. There was this outpouring online of people kind of making it about themselves. And you really do see that, and I think that Alana is a great character in the show, but when she hears about Connor's death, it kind of feels like she takes it upon herself to, you know, she felt really bad, and it's such a tragedy, and I was like, you didn't really know him, and you weren't really friends with him, and it becomes an interesting dynamic in, you know, she wants to be the vice president or something, and it's kind of like, ah, hmm, okay.
[19:28] Tori Bullard: I don't know how I feel about the way you've approached that. And I think that this is the thing about all the characters, no one is good, and everyone is perfect, ugly. And that's what they it's like, and that's exactly what it's trying to say. It's like everyone is quite ugly in the way that they can they can be a really lovely person, but everyone does ugly things or things that um they perceive to be being doing the right thing, or or things, especially with Alana's character, you can see that so much, but it's it's also that no one's perfect. Evan isn't perfect. He is, you know, he's innocent at first, but then he gets so wrapped up in everything that he ends up becoming ugly because of it, and he changes so much during the whole show. It's quite a huge um progression, character progression.
[20:22] Libby: Yeah, and I think, like you said, they are like Alana is still a really good person, and it you know, behind it all, it's because she wants to help people that she kind of takes advantage of the situation. Um but social media does play such an impact, and I it has and something that we wanted to talk about was it has its positive and its negative impacts. Like the positive was, you know, the Connor project bringing awareness, just how many people in this show and in real life that affected, bringing that awareness to it and asking people like, are you okay? And being there for everyone, even if they're not your best friend in the world, just you know, letting them know that you're there for them, and that no one deserves to be forgotten.
[21:10] Tori Bullard: Um but and you really do see that, and you see the positives and the negative effects that social media has. Like Connor suddenly, not Connor, sorry, Evan gets this attention, and it helps his confidence a little bit, boosts him a little bit, but it also fuels him to kind of continue with this lie and charade rather than coming clean, which would have, you know, if he came clean at that point in time, it still would have been awful, and there still would have been a lot of consequences, but it would have been a little bit easier, I think, for him and the family, whereas he kept going.
[21:48] Libby: Yeah, that's the thing that's like really it's that's a hard thing for him because he, as a character, progresses and becomes so much better. He you can see his mental health improving throughout the show, which is very interesting, because he gets to this point where he's created everything that he's ever wanted, and he's got the girl, he's got a family who is supporting him and loving him, all the things that he wanted, and it actually is kind of weird because he does improve, and this is everything he ever wanted, but he got it through lying. He didn't get it through um being a truthful person, and it's not real, it's all fake.
[22:26] Tori Bullard: Yeah, so it's and then when that all crumbles away, you see at the end of the show where he kind of comes to this realization, it's like, no, I deserve to be happy, and I deserve these these things, and I'm able to get these things. I've put limitations on myself, but I'm able to get these things. Now I need to do it in a way like I need to heal from this, and then I need to do it in a way that um is truthful and honest, and really looking at the people who care about you, yeah, rather than yeah, not like the people who actually care about you rather than going about it with all the people that love and care you about you, but it's because of a lie, not because of actual truth.
[23:05] Libby: Yeah, and I think that you really do see that, and you also see him crossing this boundary of he kind of gets a little bit lost in what's real and what was fake, and also any time that it was brought up, like you kind of then he there are times when he can get quite aggressive about it, and you can tell that that's kind of the anxiety of fueling him of having to tell the truth, and because he like you said, he does, he kind of gets everything you want, and it's kind of it's really quite sad because you see his mental health and his confidence building, and he gets better, but like you said, it's all fake, and he didn't necessarily get it by finding happiness in himself and those who care about him and those that want to be around him, and I think there's definitely an odd dynamic with Connor's mum as well that kind of takes him on as being her own child, and that really hurts in the process, and so everyone really everyone that's in the kind of close, you know, even Jared, like they kind of all get hurt in the process of this, but they all add to the lie.
[24:15] Libby: Oh, yeah, they fuel the fire. It's definitely like the social media aspect is very interesting because they comment a lot on how you that entity belongs to the internet, like you belong, your story, it belongs in social media, and that's where really it starts to spiral is when they bring social media in and how they comment on its toxicity in that way of like young people and feeling like you have to give everything out to the public and everything is public knowledge, and that's when it actually really starts to spiral a lot because Evan could have just gone, you know what, it's just only a couple people that know this. I should come clean, but then once it accidentally becomes like public, and like Alana pushes it public, and when his video goes viral, yeah, and it speaks on viral culture as well of how toxic that culture is, and so it's really it's quite a really interesting musical in the way that it looks at so many different themes within one show, like the mental health about how social media feeds into that and how family dynamics feed into it.
It's not just one thing that forces either Connor or Evan to do bad things, it's a myriad of different elements of life that force them to do that. It's not like he Evan went into it going, yeah, I'm gonna use this to my best of the my ability. It was really his social anxiety in that that kind of got him stuck in this place because you know Connor's mum had the letter that was actually Evan's letter to himself that he writes at the beginning of the show and she made this assumption that for someone with anxiety it would be so hard to in front of this family who have just lost a son who have gone through so much to say, actually no, I wasn't his friend. And so for that brief moment, he is stuck in this place and he just goes with it, and it's kind of where it all starts.
[26:28] Tori Bullard: Yeah, I think if I was in that situation, I wouldn't know what to do. Like, obviously, I would think I would say that I would tell the truth, but because he has such a like, you know, he has anxiety, and that would be very, very difficult for someone to be like, no. And how it plays out, you can see exactly why he did the thing he did.
[26:45] Libby: Yeah. Because he's also embarrassed that it's the letter that he wrote it.
[26:49] Tori Bullard: Yeah. And the girl that he likes.
[26:50] Libby: Okay, but when you're in high school, right? The pe the person that you like is such a visceral thing that's like, they cannot find out that I like them. This is so like, it cannot happen. And so, like, even that as an extra added on, not just the silver side and not just the things that he wrote in it, because it also shows that he's also depressed and he's not in a good head space as well. So, I understand why he did the thing he did because it's like I think for him it was really tough to be like, Yes, this is exactly how I'm feeling, and there was a lot of pressure in that moment as well for him. That's what they wanted to hear, and they put it upon him that they wanted him to have been Connor's friend.
And how can you tell a grieving family no? Like it kind of it's so hard, and the anxiety plays our part in that, and you can see in that moment the pressure building up coming from them and within Evan of that anxiety and having to make the choice of what do I say, and the girl that I have a crush on is there, and I wrote about her in this letter, and this was my red letter that I wrote to myself about my anxiety, and these random people that I don't even know have read it, and you can see all that build up because the mannerisms really, really come out in that moment.
[28:09] Tori Bullard: Exactly. You do see in the songs of the show, how Connors and Evans and everyone's kind of mental state is like one of my absolute favorite songs in the show. And I think, look, I think everybody loves this song because it hurts so much. And you feel in the song watching it, you feel what Evan is going through in Words Fail, where it kind of is almost also a reflection of that first moment in the school office when Evan didn't know what to say in response to this family. You know, he talks about not wanting to make it such a mess, and this song it goes through its waves, it goes through quite a manic phase where he is so scared of the fact that he has to tell the truth of a truth that was kind of forced upon him, but he also went along with it.
[29:03] Libby: Yeah, and it's a journey. That song is a journey as well. Like on stage, it like starts where he talks to the family, and then he's like talking to himself, and then he's like, and then he goes to his mum. Like it's like a whole journey which I really enjoy because it was like it's such a long song, and so it's really lovely. Like the words, it doesn't feel that way because the words are so poignant and and it's like so raw because it's literally what he's feeling, like it's he's like literally telling the truth now. It's a song that it hurts when you listen to it because you feel like it does whether it be exactly the same or to that extreme or lesser than that, we've all kind of been through a similar experience where we fibbed or we've stretched the truth a little bit, and comes a time when we have to admit that that wasn't quite the truth. So I think the songs of this show have just impact constantly, whether it be a happy impact or a sadder impact, it just but that's like for me one of my favorite songs.
[30:02] Tori Bullard: Can I just say one of my favorite parts things about this show is actually how it is also funny? Like I know we've halved on about all the mental health, but it's actually so funny. And I think that the part where they do sincerely mean is hilarious. I love that song. It's so funny, like because it it um and that's why the show is so impactful because it it makes it has like light moments, but then it has its really dark and and um real moments, but without those comedic moments, it just wouldn't it wouldn't have the same impact. It's just like I am sitting here depressed the whole time. Like, you know, and I think also that's Sincerely Me is such a great song that also shows about kind of how little Evan communicates with people and how little he knows about people in general, like the whole bit where they're talking about drugs and about how the fact that Connor got high and he I can't even remember exactly what he says, but he like talks about meth and stuff, and Jared just is like, no, that's not it's something about like smoking drugs or drugs if I saw smoking drugs, and it's like Evan, that's not how that works.
[31:16] Libby: Yeah, it's so so good. Something else that I think is very interesting. This is actually we posted on our Instagram as well if there was any topics that you guys wanted us to talk about, and one of our listeners sent us a message asking us who our favourite Evan was.
[31:35] Tori Bullard: Ooh.
[31:36] Libby: So I mean, well, it's kind of hard because you know, you have Ben Platt. I mean, sorry, I'm just gonna put it out there.
[31:44] Tori Bullard: It's Ben Platt all the way.
[31:45] Libby: You're kidding me? I've seen Jordan Fisher's like clips and I'm still like and I mean um is it oh what's his name oh the 16 year old oh um Andrew Bath Andrew Bath I think that he's probably like great for the role as well because I've seen him do a couple things I'm sure he's awesome but I'm still like I can't get past Ben Platt.
[32:05] Tori Bullard: I just can't he's his mannerisms are just so unique and they're so to him and I feel like he is Evan like there's just no other Evan in my mind. What about you Tori?
[32:16] Libby: So my favorite Evan Hansen look it's hard because you know Ben Platt phenomenon like Platt he did that role so well and obviously every Evan does it you know has does it a little bit differently which is something we are gonna talk about. But I think my favorite because it was the Evan that I saw I'm gonna say his name wrong but Taylor Trench he was the Evan that I saw on Broadway and oh it just it just kills you like watching just watching him sing words fail just like I was just bawling my eyes out because I was like I feel you I know that just overwhelming sense of anxiety and I mean it's it's so hard but I would say that Ben Platt Taylor Trench my favorite obviously Andrew Bath I think is a great testament to age accurate casting.
[33:11] Libby: No I agree he's a good testament to the age casting which is definitely something that we wanted to discuss is the fact that while we're here, may as well discuss casting. He is really interesting because he won the uh uh what's it called again where it's like high schoolers and you win a special what's it called?
[33:30] Tori Bullard: The Jimmy Awards.
[33:31] Libby: Jimmy Awards! There we go, the Jimmy Awards. So we watched I watched them in the Jimmy Awards and s and after the Jimmy Awards, they blew up so much, and he ended up going on as Evan in Dear Evan Hansen, and he was the youngest Evan ever, and he was actually age accurate Evan, which I find is such an interesting concept. Should we be um casting you know, 16-year-olds in these roles? Because it is very emotionally heavy.
[33:59] Tori Bullard: It's so emotionally heavy and it's and it's physically taxing. So I wonder if is it in the best interests of of that child, because it's still a child, yeah, to be playing this role because it's um he doesn't like leave the stage at all. I think it's really a testament to casting the right person for the role.
[34:21] Libby: Regardless of age, unless it's a thing where you know it's like a 37-year-old and they really don't look like they can pass the 16 years. I think it's about casting the right person for the role, regardless of age or ethnicity or religious background. It's casting the role as it is and should be to whoever is going to tell the story how the producers and the directors want it to be told.
[34:48] Tori Bullard: And I think he definitely did that. But I do think it's yeah, 100% definitely, especially a role like Evan Hansen, it is so emotionally draining. Like I honestly don't know how after that show you can just like you would have to take so much time just for yourself to kind of be like become yourself again to kind of step away from it.
[35:12] Libby: And also still doing high school.
[35:13] Tori Bullard: Yeah.
[35:14] Libby: Like it's like Presley Ryan who went on and who was the cover for Lydia on Beetlejuice and then went on to become Lydia when the previous Lydia left, and that would be a lot she's the same age, it's like she still goes to school.
[35:33] Tori Bullard: Yeah, it's not just Broadway, it's high school.
[35:35] Libby: Yeah, so I wonder that's uh I I think uh that would be something very interesting. I mean, I think that's a whole thing that we can talk about, and we have talked about in the past is like the like um safety for kids, like is it necessarily the best thing for that individual? And and I definitely think 16 is like at that older end of the things where it feels like that's that's it's not a bad thing, um, because obviously they are more adult.
[36:00] Tori Bullard: Yeah, and I think especially for kids, you know, and for young adults like Andrew, this is what they've always wanted, so they understand, and I think it's also learning to understand that balance, making sure you're getting your study done, you're getting sleep, you're doing what you need to do to take care of yourself while still working professionally on Broadway.
[36:22] Libby: And I think any younger than that doing every night is probably tough.
[36:29] Tori Bullard: It would be too taxing. There was actually a second part to one of uh one of the questions we got asked um by you guys. What makes it such an impactful music?
[36:40] Libby: I think we've kind of already answered that question.
[36:40] Tori Bullard: I think we have uh it's it is the thing of you know, and something else we're gonna get into actions and consequences, it's powerful music, it's a story that people young and um older can relate to because whether you've only experienced anxiety mildly or those kinds of things lightly, we still understand the feeling.
[37:04] Libby: Yeah.
[37:05] Tori Bullard: Well, let's talk about consequences then.
[37:07] Libby: Oh, yeah, because I agree. I think we've definitely touched on that. Tori, you had such an interesting view uh of this. Can you uh share it?
[37:15] Tori Bullard: It's not actually my view, because I personally think that Evan, like the consequences of the show are fair. And because, you know, there's a lot of emotional trauma that goes along with the telling of that truth, not only for Evan, not only for his family, but for Connor's family and for his friends as well. But I read an article when I was doing some research into Dear Evan Hansen that someone from an older generation felt that there wasn't enough consequences for the actions of the show, that there wasn't enough public consequences, like that the public should have been told that Evan made this all up. And I think that's really interesting. I spoke to my mum about it, who I actually saw the show with, and she completely disagrees.
She thinks that the consequences that were kind of served in the show were enough because of the emotional trauma of that. Like that does so much to Evan, and it does so much to Connor's family to kind of find out that it was all a lie. But I thought it was really interesting that this person thought that the public should know that Evan lied, and it kind of leans itself into cancel culture a little bit, which I do not agree with at all.
[38:33] Libby: I do not know.
[38:35] Tori Bullard: I think it also maybe it's um it's different age demographics.
[38:39] Libby: Exactly.
[38:40] Tori Bullard: And like you said, it's like I feel like maybe us now we understand the emotional toll that that took and and the consequences that he took on himself, not necessarily um I mean he lost the girl, he lost the family, he lost everything that he he had gotten. I think that that that is consequence, and and he did suffer from mental things and he you know what I mean? Like there is consequence in there, but for a modern audience of like our age, I think we can see the consequences slight maybe we see the consequences slightly different to an older demographic, and maybe that's why that was how they felt.
[39:20] Tori Bullard: I think that's exactly it, and I think it obviously like let us know what you guys think. Do you think that the consequences were just? Should there have been more? But also what I think is important to realize is that if they had have made it public, how much would how badly would that affect Connor's family? Who he might even himself have committed suicide? Do you know what I mean? Like because he he was wrapped up in all these these yeah, Evan himself. Like, is that the consequence that we need? But you do face that thing towards the end of the show where you do find out that Evan didn't fall out of the tree, that he let go of the tree and kind of opens up the question of things that are not um spoken of in the show and it's not confirmed nor denied whether he was trying to take his own life.
Did he want to hurt himself for attention from his mum? Or you know, y you don't really know that. But you do have to think about the fact that if they had gone public with that, what would have happened to Evan? How would that have impacted him? How would that have impacted Heidi? The family. Like, like there are so many things to take into consideration, and the family ultimately were the ones to decide not to say anything. Because Evan was waiting for it. He was waiting for the ball to drop. And the family didn't want to go through any more. And they were so happy with what had become of the Connor project and how many people it was helping as well.
[40:44] Libby: Yeah, it's that thing of like the Connor Project was helping so many people, but also on the flip side, the family might also realize they obviously could tell that he's suffering himself from some sort of mental um something mentally, and would they they wouldn't want anything to happen to Evan because they've already been through so much themselves. So why would they why would they announce that to everyone? Because they've already been so much.
[41:13] Tori Bullard: Yeah, they don't want to put another they don't want to see another child go through what Connor did.
[41:18] Libby: Yeah, but personally, I think we can both agree that the consequences that were dealt were fair, and any more than that, it would have ended quite badly, I think.
[41:30] Tori Bullard: I think in terms of the show as well being a show, that was a good way to end it. It could have ended. I think it was, and we have discussed this show in a lot of depth today. I think there is still so much more that Tori and I could talk about this show. So of course, if you want a part two to this, let us know. There is a lot of stuff like the Connor Zoe Evan issue, the fact that Connor, you know, he dies quite early in the show, but is still there throughout the entire show. Is that a mental thing? Is that just a directoral choice to include the actor in the rest of the show? There are so many more things that we could talk about. But let us know what you guys think if we if there was anything that you agreed with, anything that you disagreed with, and of course, as always, if there was anything that you know we said incorrectly or wasn't quite right, please do let us know because you know we're obviously constantly growing and learning, and we're so glad to have such an awesome community of listeners behind us to grow with us.
[42:36] Libby: But I think uh we should do a little cheeky uh bedtime story.
[42:40] Tori Bullard: I think we sound a little cheeky bedtime story. What uh which one are we we thinking today, Tori?
[42:46] Tori Bullard: So today's bedtime story was sent in by one of our listeners who would prefer to remain anonymous. Now, this is a little bit of a tricky story, so follow along with us. So they say, I was playing a lead role in a pantomime. The scene was that we were in a forest looking for the main character who was missing. We'll call her Blue. It was my character, my character's brother, the love interest of Blue, and Blue's mum. That's a lot of characters. Basically, we were thinking of different ways to look for Blue, and one of the ideas was to look for people in the audience to help us and make fun of them, saying things like, they are very handsome, but they look very weak, and stuff like that. Anyway, Blue's mum targets a man sitting in the front row and starts calling him weak and stuff, and she was getting really into it, so like usual, I was giggling my head off.
Basically, she gets this man up on stage to do push ups and starts making fun of him, and I was so confused because we were really spending a lot of time on this one scene. It gets to the point that we have to count how many push-ups he was doing, and I'm dying of laughter. And once we've embarrassed the heck out of this man, they sent him back to his seat, and it was my line. So my mic was on. But I just kept laughing. The audience had kind of stopped laughing, but I couldn't stop. And at this point, everyone is looking at me like I laughed so hard that I snorted. And the entire audience heard it, and a few people laughed. To make matters worse, I tripped over walking off stage because I was wearing ridiculous chorus heels. That show was not my best. Anyway, it turned out that the push-up dude was the MD's husband and we just didn't know it.
[44:32] Libby: I love that.
[44:33] Tori Bullard: Which is oh my gosh. So fun! I don't know how I would deal with improv scenes in a s in a show. I would I would love to say that I would do well. I think if you got into the gist of it a little bit more. That was amazing. Thank you so much to that person for sending that in. We we loved that story.
[44:53] Libby: But anyway, you guys, that is it for today's episode. But please do let us know if you have suggestions for our next deep dive or if you want a part two episode of Dear Evan Hansen deep dive. But let us know. We had such a great time chatting to you guys about all things Dear Evan Hansen. It has been a blast and so good to be able to talk in depth about a show that I feel like Tori and I both really, really love, and obviously you guys all love as well because you voted for.
[45:26] Tori Bullard: But um, thank you guys so much for listening and stay happy, healthy, and safe, and we'll see you next time.
[45:33] Libby: Thank you so much for listening to today's episode, and we hope you enjoyed. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a rate and review on Apple Podcasts, and to send us your bedtime stories and stagedoor Sunday pics. We also would love to hear your feedback on the episode and what you'd like to hear from us in the future. You can let us know on our Instagram at ps.stagedoorpod via our email at ps.stagedoor.podcast@gmail.com or contact us via our website psstageddoorpodcast.com. We love hearing from you and we will see you next time.
[46:04] Tori Bullard: Bye!
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
