Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#131 - Emojiland (feat. Hayley St. James)

"Sometimes it's even hard for me to even speak, 'cause I'm Sad on the inside..." Cross your bones and hope to die we are joined by playwright Hayley St. James to talk about "Emojiland!" Our unabashed love for this show is so contagious, we just love the show so much... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 9 mins
3/4/21

About

"Sometimes it's even hard for me to even speak, 'cause I'm Sad on the inside..." Cross your bones and hope to die we are joined by playwright Hayley St. James to talk about "Emojiland!" Our unabashed love for this show is so contagious, we just love the show so much. Yes, the Emoji show is THAT GOOD! Come join our love!

Donate to Black Lives Matter here

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jess on Twitter

Jess on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew on Instagram

Andrew on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna on Twitter

Brianna on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Jess McEnally: Hello, I'm Jess McEnally.

[0:09] Andrew DWolf: And I am Andrew DWolf.

[0:10] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.

[0:12] Jess McEnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:15] Jess McEnally: And today, you guys, we have a super special guest.

[0:18] Andrew DWolf: A very special guest.

[0:20] Brianna Jones: Very special guest.

[0:22] Jess McEnally: A specialist of guests.

[0:23] Andrew DWolf: The best guest.

[0:24] Brianna Jones: All our guests are great, but this week is great because it's this week.

[0:28] Jess McEnally: Please welcome our very special guest. We have self-described, queer surrealist, playwright, and all-around awesome human being, Hayley St. James!

[0:35] Brianna Jones: Cute Kerriport!

[0:41] Jess McEnally: How are you doing, Hayley? Thanks for slumming it down here on the Musicals with Cheese podcast.

[0:45] Hayley St. James: I'm certainly here for this. I'm very excited. It's been a while since I've actively listened to any musical theater because, you know, since the shutdown, it's been like if I think about theater or watch theater, I will be very sad. So I've distanced myself a little bit and just put out my writing. But you know, y'all asked me to talk about my favorite show, so one of my favorite shows, how could I say no?

[1:10] Jess McEnally: And how about we just cue it up? What is that favorite show?

[1:13] Hayley St. James: I'm wearing it on my sweatshirt, y'all. It's Emojiland, the hit off-Broadway musical.

[1:17] Jess McEnally: Cue the music, Bree.

[1:22] ♪ Musical number: "Attention, Emojiland" — performed by Information Desk Person ♪

[1:41] Hayley St. James: Emojiland is a musical with music, lyrics, and book by Keith Harrison and Laura Schleining. It is based on emojis, you know, like the ones on your phones. It premiered on Broadway on January 19th, 2020, at the Duke Theater on 42nd Street.

[1:58] Jess McEnally: Is that correct?

[1:59] Hayley St. James: Yes, it is. I was there opening night. They invited me. So, thing for people who are listening, before we get any further, I saw this show twenty-three times. The show ran seventy performances. I was there for a third of the entire run.

[2:18] Andrew DWolf: That's a lot.

[2:20] Brianna Jones: That's impressive.

[2:21] Hayley St. James: That's incredible. I don't think I've seen anything that many times, movies and stuff.

[2:26] Hayley St. James: This isn't even my most seen show. That's Something Rotten at forty-one. But that was over, you know, two and a half years. I like that one. That was a good show as well. That's the show that made me become a playwright, so that's incredible. Like that, I love these feel-good shows. Musical theater saved my life. Let's be completely real.

[2:50] Jess McEnally: But anyway, yes. I just want to talk about what is Emojiland and how is it different from the Emoji Movie? Because that was, it's even on their website. Like, if I didn't like the Emoji Movie, will I like Emojiland? They're like, yes, yes, it's nothing like that. Please, please come see our show.

[3:05] Hayley St. James: Well, the premise is similar, the name is similar, like I don't know. They were actually, the show was in development years before the Emoji Movie was even in development, so it's incredible. Because it was like all the way back to like fringe festivals in 2018, like a long, long time ago.

[3:21] Jess McEnally: Yeah, no, they've been working on it for a while. Because it first premiered at Nymph at New York Musical Festival, at least a year and a half before they brought it to the Duke. I didn't get to see it at Nymph, and I wish I did, but it's—

[3:32] Hayley St. James: Hey, you've got an impressive track record, as is with seeing this twenty-three times when it played for like less than three months.

[3:42] Hayley St. James: Nearly three months, really, but yeah.

[3:45] Jess McEnally: Yeah, thanks. Thanks, COVID.

[3:47] Hayley St. James: I'm gonna stop for a moment and make Andrew tell us what the plot of this is, and you can tell us how good he gets the plot.

[3:55] Andrew DWolf: Okay.

[3:56] Andrew DWolf: Yeah, sure. I can run through it.

[3:58] Andrew DWolf: Okay. I'm definitely gonna mess it up, and I have not seen it twenty-three times. I've only seen it once.

[4:04] Hayley St. James: One time you watched it.

[4:05] Andrew DWolf: I remember the one time I watched it though. Alright. There's a lot of different characters. It opens up and you're in Emojiland, and you have Smiles, who is a smiley emoji, and she's kind of the main character-ish, but there's also Nerd Emoji, but he doesn't come till later. So we're gonna leave him out for a sec. Smiles and Sun. I think he's supposed to be the son with the glasses emoji. Is that—is that—

[4:36] Hayley St. James: Yes, he's the smiling face with sunglasses.

[4:35] Andrew DWolf: Yes, yes. So, yeah. The smiling face with sunglasses and the smiling face are in a relationship kind of. He's sort of a dude bro, I guess is the way he's—

[4:50] Hayley St. James: He's the biggest fucking dude bro.

[4:52] Andrew DWolf: Yeah, you know, he's an alpha male, to use internet terminology. And then who else is the princess who runs Emojiland, and then there is the building like construction worker and police officer who are also in a relationship.

[5:13] Hayley St. James: Yes, we love the Emojiland lesbians.

[5:15] Andrew DWolf: Yes. So the plot really is that there's an update. The update happens and it adds a few more emojis, which is the prince who threatens the princess's power and the Nerd Emoji—Nerd Face Emoji, pardon me. Not Nerd, Nerd is not the good term. Nerd Face Emoji and the prince. And the Nerd Face meets Smiling Face and they hit it off in a way. But she is dragged away by the dude bro because obviously dude bros and nerds don't get along at all. The Nerd Face meets the Skull, and the Skull is probably the best character, but the Skull is great and is evil-ish. I mean, it's a skull. Justin Skeletor, he wants to kill everybody.

[6:12] Hayley St. James: Because, yeah.

[6:15] Andrew DWolf: So the Nerd makes a poison for the Skull to kill himself. But the Skull is like, haha, I tricked you, I'm actually gonna kill everyone and myself. And he releases the virus into Emojiland. Oh, while all that is happening, the princess and the prince realize that there could be more royalty that could be added in future updates, so they work with the businessman on a hoverboard.

[6:47] Hayley St. James: Levitating businessman.

[6:49] Andrew DWolf: Leviting businessman in a business suit levitating. They work with him to set up a firewall around Emojiland. Not to actually stop viruses or anything, but because they don't want any more updates. The construction worker doesn't want to do it, but the police officer breaks the strike, basically, and forces them to. Then there's more. There's still more. There's already a lot that happened right there. Love stories.

[7:23] Hayley St. James: Um, Smiley.

[7:26] Andrew DWolf: Nerd Face and Smiley. Smiley.

[7:28] Hayley St. James: Oh, Nerd Face and Smiley.

[7:30] Andrew DWolf: Okay. Nerd Face sees. Okay, this I'm actually have to go back a little bit. Nerd Face and Smiley. It's fine. I can't try to explain everything. There's a lot. It is an ensemble piece in the best sort of way. Everyone's got such a deep story, you don't want to forget it. It's not confusing, though. I'm explaining it really poorly. When you actually watch it, it's not confusing, but there is a lot for me to try to go over.

[7:55] Hayley St. James: Um, do rate that out 10 out of 10. For a summary of act one of Emojiland, that's like 99% accuracy.

[8:06] Andrew DWolf: Very good job, Andrew.

[8:08] Hayley St. James: Okay, actually. I've only seen it one time, and I nailed it. Better than Ben Brantley could have ever done.

[8:14] Andrew DWolf: Ben Brantley didn't even write the critic's pick.

[8:16] Hayley St. James: It was, I think, Lauren Collins Hughes.

[8:19] Andrew DWolf: There's Laura Collins Hughes.

[8:21] Hayley St. James: Yes, we're gonna dive into that a little later. It's gonna be fun.

[8:23] Andrew DWolf: Okay. Act two. The virus is spreading everywhere. Nerd Face is trying to stop it. There's some love triangle stuff between Kissy Face, Sunglasses Face, and Smiling Girl Face, or just Smiling Face, I'm not sure about it.

[8:42] Hayley St. James: Smiling Face with Smiling Eyes.

[8:44] Andrew DWolf: Smiling Face with Smiling Eyes.

[8:45] Hayley St. James: Yeah, like on—yeah. I get it, okay.

[8:46] Andrew DWolf: Smise, yeah.

[8:48] Hayley St. James: Because of the eye.

[8:50] Andrew DWolf: Okay, that makes sense. I thought it was short for smiling.

[8:53] Hayley St. James: Yeah, that was no, that's not what it is.

[8:55] Andrew DWolf: Okay. Smiling Eyes, Smise, okay. Um, there's that. The virus infects a lot of people, and they all start dying. So Nerd Face goes into the phone. He leaves the firewall. And there's stuff with the police officer and construction worker that allow him to do that. And he wants to do a full total reset of the phone to bring it back to before all the stuff happened. The Skull tries to stop him, but the Skull eventually agrees that actually maybe killing everybody's not the right move. So then they do a total reset and everyone's happy, the end.

[9:35] Hayley St. James: Yeah.

[9:36] Andrew DWolf: So you're saying a virus takes over a group of happy people, but they can't like save themselves because they built walls around their country or whatever and can't escape. What does that sound like?

[9:46] Hayley St. James: Emojiland was a documentary.

[9:51] Andrew DWolf: Yeah, I don't know. It almost sounds like the far-right conspiracy theory of like a virus is being released into the country because they want to perform a great reset, like the deep state.

[10:01] Hayley St. James: I don't know. That's a film coming out by Zack Snyder, Zack Snyder's Emojiland.

[10:13] Jess McEnally: Alright, that we've got all the groundwork for people to be able to follow us because right now all there is is that wonderful cast album. There's not unless they're looking at SLAM tutorials, which of course they shouldn't be doing. My next question is going to be to you, Hayley. How did you get involved with this? What is your history with this show?

[10:32] Hayley St. James: I'm sure it's long, but it's not actually that long. I bought tickets to the first preview because they announced the cast. I heard about it, and I was like, oh yeah, this could be fun. I don't know. I see pretty much everything, but I don't know. I should save my money. I don't know. There's some people I like in it. I don't know. Like, I love Leslie Margarita. I love Josh Lehman. Like, I will see this. And then they just are like, oh yeah, by the way, Lucas Steele is playing Skull, and I'm just like, my boy, where have you been?

[11:00] Hayley St. James: So I saw Great Comet a lot. Lucas Steele is the reason I'm non-binary. That's a long story. But I never miss Lucas Steele in anything. So I bought my ticket to first preview because I wanted to see Lucas. I mean, I wanted to see everybody because there were a bunch of people I knew and loved. So I go to first preview. I know absolutely nothing about the show going in. I leave first preview. I'm like, this is the happiest I felt since Spongebob was on Broadway, honestly. Like, I'll come back. I don't know when that will be, but probably soon. Hopefully. I don't know. A few days later, I'm like, I think I'm gonna try to go see Slave Play. So I get in the rush line. The person in front of me gets the last rush ticket, and I'm like, well, there's an afternoon wasted. What should I do? Does Emojiland have rush? Walk over to the Duke. Oh yeah, we have Rush. I'm like, here, take my money.

[11:42] Hayley St. James: And it just kind of went from there, and by that point, because most of the very short last season, I had seen most of the things that were coming to Broadway, because I also I saw them all when they were, you know, doing the pre-Broadway engagements in Boston, because I'm from Boston normally. That's where I am right now. Thanks, pandemic. So I'd seen pretty much everything that had already opened that season musical-wise. So I was—and most of the plays were limited engagements that were hard to get tickets to. So I pretty much just spent all my time at Emojiland, and I don't regret any seconds of it.

[12:16] Hayley St. James: I just, the thing is as the show kept going on and like the run as the run kept going on and like, you know, news of like, oh, so there's this coronavirus that's, you know, coming from China and we need to be a little, you know, maybe I don't know, just keep, you know, cautious, maybe start wearing masks. I don't know, just wash your hands a lot, hear some hand sanitizer at the front of the theater, like okay. But then by the time I kept seeing the show later and later into the run, by act two, it's like this is just hitting way too hard. This is a musical comedy about singing and dancing emojis. Why am I crying? It's just, I mean, Gretchen, the show makes me cry anyway because it's just really so shockingly deep for a show that is, you know, very much taken at face value by, you know, anybody who even hears about it, because of course the Emoji Movie is so infamously terrible.

[13:10] Jess McEnally: Yeah. That's what I thought when I heard we were covering Emojiland, and I was like, is that like an adaptation of the Emoji Movie? Is this gonna be horrific? And apparently it has nothing to do with it.

[13:22] Hayley St. James: Nothing at all. I've never seen the Emoji Movie, but even from what I've seen of it, this already feels like it's a hundred billion times better.

[13:30] Andrew DWolf: You are correct.

[13:32] Hayley St. James: You are correct. I haven't seen the Emoji Movie either, but I don't ever plan to because I'd rather just have an adaptation, animated adaptation of this, actually.

[13:42] Hayley St. James: That's kind of exactly what I want. Especially because Keith and Laura worked on a lot of the songs in the Ugly Dolls movie, if you didn't know any of like their prior work.

[13:52] Hayley St. James: And I watched that, like during the pandemic, because I was like, wow, I miss Emojiland. Oh yeah, I forgot Keith and Laura worked on this, so I watched it. It was like, wait, this is actually really cute, first of all. Second of all, these songs rock. Oh my god, of course they wrote it. So I think they should make an animated movie. I don't know how, but they should.

[14:08] Jess McEnally: I agree.

[14:09] Hayley St. James: I think that this is like some of my favorite songwriting, like on stage in like ten years. Like, as far as original musicals, and I do consider this original musical in the same way as like The Prom is. Like this is an original idea, original story, original characters, all that. Um, and I think they're both right up there as like things that brought me the most joy in like the last few weeks of my life. Like things that have been on repeat that make me happy but also make me feel things, I think they're like right there for me.

[14:39] Andrew DWolf: And I am thankful for you for giving me a reason to look into this.

[14:43] Hayley St. James: Thank you, Hayley.

[14:44] Andrew DWolf: Oh, I'm so honored.

[14:45] Hayley St. James: You're very welcome. You're very welcome. I uh I it's I love this score as well. Um, I've started taking musical theater writing classes last fall. I'm taking some right now, mostly focusing on lyrics and book because of this show, really, more than Synthie Rotten just wanted to make me become a playwright in general, and like that gave me the push to do that.

[15:06] But Emojiland, seeing it so many times in just in such a short amount of time made me really appreciate the writing in a way that I don't know, I never really got to appreciate with a lot of other shows, even though like I love meeting creative teams and talking to writers on shows. Like, I don't know, like what Keith and Laura were doing with the show is just so really special and clever.

[15:28] Like, as I'm saying, like this show has no right to be this deep or this relatable. I honestly just wonder where they even got the ideas, because if someone approached me and was like, "Hey, can you write a show about emojis?" I mean, like, where do you even start? You know, it's there's nothing.

[15:46] Jess McEnally: Yeah.

[15:46] Hayley St. James: It's like it's little smiley faces on your phone. Why is there now two properties about these little smiley faces on a phone? Because the nice thing is their characters unto themselves, they all I mean, they all have like the way that they're designed, the way like if you look at how Unicode works, if you like follow like the Emojipedia on Twitter, they always post like the history of like how these designs came to be made.

[16:09] I don't know. It's just really interesting to see like why culturally we have specific images in the emoji, you know, alphabet. Like every time we get new updates, it's like, oh, these are cool. Like, why haven't we actually had these before? Like, it took them how long to get a trans flag emoji? It took them this long to get like an accordion. Like, there's so many.

[16:27] I don't know, just I I mean, I know they went through a lot of different plot concepts before settling on this one specifically. Like, I think originally it was like a very Alice in Wonderland sort of thing of like a girl being sucked into her phone, but they were like, "There's too many shows like this."

[16:41] Jess McEnally: Yeah, yeah, that would that would not have been as good, I don't think.

[16:44] Hayley St. James: I mean, it was actually about to bring up the fact that we don't see the human world is one of my favorite things about this because it makes this reality more real. It doesn't take us out of like, oh, this is ridiculous. They're just things in our phone because it's real to them, it's real to us.

[16:58] Jess McEnally: Yeah, like the stakes are very high for them, so we don't get that deflated by seeing a human being like, "Oh, my phone's acting weird."

[17:05] Hayley St. James: Yeah, it's like you can just pretend that this is taking place on your own phone. Like, I mean, granted, by the time I, you know, stop by them, like, "Oh yeah, no, like this isn't my phone. Emojiland takes place on my phone." But I mean, really, it does.

[17:17] But the Emoji Movie does the thing where you actually have the human characters, and like a lot of the plot is based on that.

[17:24] Andrew DWolf: And I mean, I haven't seen it, but the commercial looks bad.

[17:27] Hayley St. James: Yeah, and you they show you that, so yeah.

[17:30] Andrew DWolf: From what I can tell, the Emoji Movie is like the emojis are having like this weird adventure in the phone, and it's affecting the human who owns the phone's life in like weird ways.

[17:39] Hayley St. James: Yeah.

[17:40] Andrew DWolf: And I just don't really love that because I mean, we see enough things about humans as is. I think it's super cool that we're focusing on characters that entirely exist that are just pixels.

[17:50] Hayley St. James: I mean, but even then they matter and they have lives and they have souls, and I just think that's super neat. And it's really I mean, what I love about the show is how as existential it gets. I mean, which hopefully we'll talk about.

[18:05] Jess McEnally: Yes.

[18:07] Hayley St. James: We can talk about it right now, I think. I want to talk about that so badly.

[18:09] Jess McEnally: Oh my god.

[18:10] Hayley St. James: Uh, so there is like some like what does life mean for people talking this. Like, why are we alive? And my god, it's like this original version of the SpongeBob musical when it was a lot more existential and dark and a little bit more melancholy.

[18:29] Jess McEnally: I love both versions of SpongeBob.

[18:31] Hayley St. James: I mean, I prefer the Broadway version just a little bit because I think the book's a lot tighter. Um, yeah, I do remember the Chicago version being very existential. Um, but with Emojiland, like we have, you know, Smise is a smiling emoji who has depression and she's constantly questioning her self-worth.

[18:48] And then we have Nerdface, who is just so incredibly optimistic, and he always knows that there's gonna be a bright side and that we matter. And, you know, then he, you know, runs into Skull, who is a nihilist, and he's uh, you know, I love Skull very much. Andrew, I am so glad you said Skull is your favorite character.

[19:06] Andrew DWolf: Skull is very well, Skull's phenomenal though. I mean, the song, uh, I mean all the songs that he has, but definitely the uh the act one closer is the best.

[19:16] Hayley St. James: What kills me is that between the uh the cast album, the cast album was recorded right before they started previews.

[19:24] Andrew DWolf: So yes.

[19:25] Hayley St. James: Okay. So that's the only reason why Lucas doesn't hit the high F sharp at the end of "Thank Me Now." Because when he did it live, normally he would hit a high F sharp at the end, which is higher than the Petersburg note in Great Comet, which is so it's getting to see that multiple times a week was always a lot in a good way.

[19:47] But just the way that Lucas played Skull as this complete nihilist Victorian dandy with a death wish was just so utterly captivating. And they're like, wow, of course Nerdface would fall for this guy. He's so charismatic.

[20:04] And of course you'd trust him to, you know, accidentally, you know, cause a pandemic.

[20:10] Andrew DWolf: Yeah, and Nerdface's funny.

[20:13] Hayley St. James: Like he's very funny.

[20:14] Andrew DWolf: He is so funny.

[20:15] Hayley St. James: God, yeah. I love that Nerdface as a friend is just like, "Oh, you want to die? Okay."

[20:20] Andrew DWolf: You see.

[20:23] Hayley St. James: Just call me Jack of Orkian. Nerdface is so naive and so willing to help anybody because he's a nerd and he likes to help people solve problems, that he's just, yeah, no, sure, I'll gladly help assist in your suicide. It's like kind of shocking for a show that seems so family friendly.

[20:41] Um, but you know, and by the end when he realizes this awful mistake, but then allows Skull to have a change of heart, is very, very cool. And like, I mean, even the scene before that, when we have "Anyway," which is one of if not the best song in the show, which lyrically is the heart of the material.

[20:59] Well, like Smise is dying. She has the virus. She's dying in Nerdface's arms as she's singing about how like we're all, you know, we may think that we're just little pieces of code, but like we matter and we're all put on this phone for a reason.

[21:16] Like no matter, like if anybody barely uses our emoji or not. And just, you know, in 2020, considering everything that was going on, like that message hit so deep. And God, Laura, Laura and George sell the hell out of it.

[21:33] And it just breaks me. It just absolutely breaks me. I carry that song with me always. It's played without an ounce of like winking to the audience, like, "We're emojis, we're emojis, don't forget we're in a f." like this is played so dead serious, which makes your heart break for it.

[21:47] It makes you think about like, oh my god, like am I their god technically because I have the phone? Like I mean, they consider the code, they consider the Unicode itself to be God. So in the book they're always like, "We thank the code for all it's bestowed." So the code is is God really.

[22:03] Andrew DWolf: So they're just thinking whoever coded them.

[22:06] Hayley St. James: So yeah, they're basically, yeah. And the reset at the end is also one of those things that's like what makes us what we are is the question. Like if we get a full reset and we lose all our prejudices and like all our past things and we become brand new, how does that change us as people?

[22:23] Andrew DWolf: Mm-hmm.

[22:24] Hayley St. James: Yeah, for sure. It's like a really interesting philosophical question. Like this show, as I said, shouldn't be as deep as this is a show about emojis, but it really makes you think about like your place in the world and like how we I mean also the entire show is about you know, not really taking people at face value, learning to not take people at face value because as I said, Smise has depression.

[22:44] She's that wonderful, you know, character introduction song with "Sat on the Inside" where we, you know, she's really depressed. She's not really happy with Sunny. She just, you know, she wants to be happy, but it's really hard. And I mean that's super relatable.

[22:57] Um, a lot of the characters get songs like that, which is really cool. And I mean, this does what the best musicals do in songs, which is like reinforce their thematic meaning as well as give them basic wants and needs and explains it.

[23:12] Andrew DWolf: And even the Pooh song.

[23:13] Hayley St. James: Yes, God, we love it.

[23:15] Andrew DWolf: Which is probably my least favorite, not even a reason for negativity, it's just like one of them has to be at the moment. And I still like that song a lot.

[23:24] Hayley St. James: It's just it's a nice little like little breather song before we get into like the real, real emotional like whiplash that is the second half of act two of Emojiland. But like even then, it's like this sort of like Smise is really sad after, you know, everything that's gone on in act one, and she feels bad about everything.

[23:44] She needs a pep talk. Why not have the Pooh emoji show up? It's great.

[23:49] Andrew DWolf: So does the Pooh just live in the bathroom?

[23:52] Hayley St. James: Or that's the thing I actually don't know. I never asked. I know I was thinking, well, I mean, I was thinking, okay, they're at they're at the royal ball and she goes to the bathroom and the Pooh's there. So either the Pooh lives in the bathroom, or they invited the Pooh and not the nerd to the ball.

[24:10] Andrew DWolf: They're like, yeah, the poop can come.

[24:13] Hayley St. James: The nerd, no, not having it. It's interesting because the show tackles prejudices and xenophobia in really interesting ways. So that's a really interesting question.

[24:21] Andrew DWolf: I've never actually thought about it because like Pooh is kind of like, you know, the fairy godmother character who shows up to help and then moves the plot along.

[24:32] Hayley St. James: So I've never actually thought about that until now. So maybe they should stigmatize it.

[24:36] Andrew DWolf: I have another musical theater structure question here. Um, who, in your opinion, is the main character of this?

[24:43] Hayley St. James: Smise and Nerdface are deuteragonists. Um I'd say. Um Skull is it's funny 'cause then technically in a way cause Skull is the antagonist, but so are Prince and Princess.

[24:54] Andrew DWolf: Yes.

[24:55] Hayley St. James: But businessman, I love man in business suit levitating. There was a running thing at the end of every show when um pr where in a man in business suit and Pooh would get together and like we find out like man in business suit name.

[25:09] Andrew DWolf: Every single show Max Crumb would change what his name was like or Anne would like just Anne Horata would just randomly like pull a random name out of a hat before she went on and would call man in business suit levitating something completely random and my favorite time was one time at the show and she calls him Tupac and everyone lost.

[25:29] Hayley St. James: And it's still my favorite I still just call man in business suit levitating Tupac. Like that's his name.

[25:34] Andrew DWolf: That's his name it's Tupac.

[25:36] Hayley St. James: As far as I'm concerned that is my headcanon now forever and ever. Every single time um but yeah I'd say man in business suit is more of like he's a henchman. He's not I mean he does come up with ideas that Prince and princess follow through with but yeah Prince and Princess and Skull are the Deuteronists or the Dude or uh not the protagonist, they're the uh and they're they're the Deuterantagonists and we have two protagonists.

[26:00] Andrew DWolf: And there's a you know big ensemble.

[26:02] Hayley St. James: So agreed. So um, I do I thought if there's three of them I don't know there's three villains there's three villains and two heroes.

[26:12] Andrew DWolf: Yeah.

[26:14] Hayley St. James: The thing is like Smise has the I Want song, quote unquote, in the place where it usually quote unqu is. It's the second song after the So like I went through a good chunk of w listening through the audio you you sent me, and I was like, "Oh, okay. I like uh this is her story, I'm following it." And then Nerdface comes in, I'm like, "Oh no, this I don't know where this is going now, but I'm in."

[26:41] So it kind of breaks musical theater structure in a way that works. Like a lot of times people feel I find a lot of playwrights find themselves confined by that structure and being like, "Alright, we gotta put this here and this here." And here I'm like, you're using those tools, but I don't know where this is going now.

[26:58] Hayley St. James: Yeah, I mean, for me, like as a playwright, I tend to like sometimes just introduce new characters, you know, a bit into a show. At least one of my uh one of my faux lengths does that.

[27:09] Andrew DWolf: Um, yeah.

[27:11] Hayley St. James: I just I mean, I think it's a cool storytelling structure because they get a reset like basically a third into the show, we get their first reset that adds new characters, and then we get a second reset at the end of the show that resets everybody.

[27:25] Andrew DWolf: So that's great.

[27:26] Hayley St. James: Mm-hmm. Um, but you know what? We've talked and talked about this show and how much we liked it, but now it's time to compare our opinions with those of the New York theater critics of when it came out. It's time for everyone's favorite segment of the show.

[27:41] Jess McEnally: It's time for previews.

[27:43] Jess McEnally: It's time for previews.

[27:48] Jess McEnally: Alright, so Laura Collins Hughes of the New York Times said this is occasional trouble too, with the orchestra overwhelming the vocals, including at the climax of act one.

[28:03] Jess McEnally: But these are nitpicks. This is a tonic of a musical, big-hearted and comforting. In Emojiland, even world-threatening mistakes can sometimes be repaired by the people who made them. And if you sense an allegory there, it might just cheer you up.

[28:18] Jess McEnally: I love this review. I love sincere New York Times reviews. Like this one specifically, like was a breath of fresh air compared to like the Ben Brantleys of the world that we had for like 10, 15 years before that. Where it's just like I was so grateful they didn't send Brantley. I was or Redel. Like I just kind of wondered what he would have said about Reddle shouldn't be near a Broadway.

[28:40] Hayley St. James: Yeah.

[28:41] Jess McEnally: I've got opinions there.

[28:41] Hayley St. James: Yeah, no.

[28:41] Jess McEnally: Um, my thing is, I mean, depending on where you sit in that theater, because the Duke is only a 200 seat house. Um, depending on where you sit, the sound mix is a little iffy. I mean, I was usually towards I was usually smack dab front row center, like about 80% of the times I was there. So I never had a problem hearing anything. But I mean, if a critic, you know, wasn't sitting that close to the stage, yeah, they might have some problems with the sound mix. Um, I mean, at least by like opening, like I think the sound mix was like really solid. Um, and I could hear everything just fine. And I was not s I was I sitting front row opening. I can't remember. But I don't know. Um it's interesting because the act one finale, I mean, I get like there's that part where um there's kind of the all skate moment when everybody is singing under Lucas Riffing like crazy.

Um, and like I get that, like that mix was a little difficult to like parse while watching it live, but once we got the cast album, I was like, oh yes, now I understand every word. And then by the time I would see the show again and again, it was like, yes, I'm getting everything now. I love how sincere it is. Um, but I can see where they're coming from with the audio, but that that is a nitpick, and they admit it. Like, I love it that a New York Times review is admitting that they're nitpicking.

[29:58] Hayley St. James: Absolutely. I love that they're like, yeah, yeah, we're not perfect. Yeah, we're not perfect theater goers. Like, that's kind of nice to hear from a critic.

[30:06] Jess McEnally: Yes.

[30:07] Jess McEnally: Um, yeah. Um, let's hear what Raven Snook said, because I'm very interested in w how they decided to start this review. So Breed, take it away.

[30:16] Hayley St. James: Um, Raven Snook of Time Out said, Keith Harrison and Laura Shines over the top musical comedy Emojiland aims for crying laughing emoji, but inspires smiley face emoji.

[30:30] Jess McEnally: Um at best. Ridiculous. Ridiculous way to start a review. But keep going.

[30:38] Hayley St. James: It's thematic. It's thematically. I get it. It matches, you know, the theme of this. Alright. Um, with 16 musical numbers, dozens of characters, three main plot lines, including a heavy-handed political one about building a firewall, and a running time of over well over two hours. Emojiland is a case of more is way too much, especially since the cyber silliness isn't that well scripted. Thankfully, it's good old fashioned analog performances prevent the show from crashing.

[31:10] Jess McEnally: I I don't agree with that. I feel like they're not a good idea. Did she not read the book? I mean, that's a thing. Like, I think uh most of the reviews I remember saying we love the cast, they do a great job with the material, but they don't love love the material, or they don't think the material is funny enough, or they think the material is too political, which is just lies. It's perfectly political. All theater is political, so I don't even think it's that political. The firewall isn't really an allegory for the trunk. Spongebob was more political. SpongeBob is more political than Emojiland. Emojiland just happened to be really, really timely more than you know, overtly political. Some people don't recognize that not all walls are the same wall. Just because there's a wall doesn't mean it's the wall. Hades Town. Hades Town, even though that Hades, even though NAS Mitchell often says that that's not the same wall she was talking about either.

[31:58] Hayley St. James: Um the thing is though, with Emojiland, I mean Prince and Princess are very much like we don't want new emojis as well as we don't want to be replaced with a king or queen emoji. They they do feel distrust written, and then they start blaming the virus on new emojis who have come who were here before the firewall. So it's it's definitely political. I just don't think it's heavy-handed political. I don't think it's heavy-handed whatsoever. But the way the sing the book isn't that I I love the script, I think. I mean, as a as someone who's taking book writing right now, like I mean, I think it's because unfortunately I have the advantage of seeing it so many times. I could analyze this book for hours, honestly. I mean, the character. I mean, it's strong. Every scene like gets out quick, starts late, and it's great. It it moves super fast, and like all these mixes of characters means that you're never bored in any one scene.

[32:49] Jess McEnally: Mm-hmm. For sure.

[32:50] Hayley St. James: Yeah, I had not read Ravensnook's review before. Don't know why I didn't. We got one more, and uh um this one's from Brittany Crowell of the New York Theater Guide. Um and I remember this one being the one of the more infuriating ones um for me.

[33:05] Jess McEnally: Alright, let's dive into Brittany so we can get mad.

[33:08] Hayley St. James: I get to be the bearer of bad news.

[33:11] Jess McEnally: Heck yeah.

[33:12] Hayley St. James: Okay. This is Bree's review. She wrote this.

[33:14] Jess McEnally: No, she didn't.

[33:15] Hayley St. James: I did not write this. I'm judging this person. Let's go.

[33:20] Jess McEnally: Okay, so Brittany, and did you say it was Crowell?

[33:24] Hayley St. James: I believe it's Crowell.

[33:26] Jess McEnally: Anyway. We can't pronounce names.

[33:27] Hayley St. James: We get names wrong.

[33:28] Jess McEnally: Oh, yeah, we get names wrong all the time. Our patrons, we say wrong every week. Sorry, Brittany.

[33:34] Hayley St. James: So Brittany Kroll, Crowell, however she may pronounce it, um, of the New York theater guide said, Unfortunately, Emojiland feels too simple and straightforward to add any real substance to your night at the theater. But it is not family friendly enough to be accessible to children whose appetite is perfect for its energy. Performed fabulously by the all-star cast. It is an entertaining and wonderfully designed piece that falls short of its potential in narrative and meaning.

[34:03] Jess McEnally: I disagree entirely. It rises above all the potential it had.

[34:09] Hayley St. James: Exactly. And also what potential did it have to start? I mean, um it's an emoji musical. You expect nothing going in.

[34:14] Jess McEnally: You go exactly.

[34:18] Hayley St. James: For sure. Like the bar is just like the bar say is the emoji movie, so literally anything will be better than that. And you know, they go completely blow it out of the water. Um but also she's saying it's I mean, yeah, it's not family friendly, but most of the times I were there, there were plenty of children who were having a great time. Literally, the only swear in the entire show is bitch, and it's one character, and that's princess, and that's what she calls herself. So it's, you know, it's decidedly tame for a show that, you know, if they were like, oh, we're doing emojis, but it's like this is, you know, a thoughtful, you know, adult musical, then you know, it could have gotten I don't know. I always like to joke with the casting was like, what if like y'all wrote a sequel and it's Emojiland after dark? But we don't talk about that.

[35:00] Jess McEnally: Oh my gosh. I want that in my life now.

[35:03] Hayley St. James: Because then they do that with like oh, I forget what the uh spelling bee. Um 25th annual Putnam County spelling bee. They would do like adult only nights.

[35:10] Jess McEnally: Yeah, I think it would have been cool. Um, I don't know, like, I mean, I don't know if they'd read a sequel, because musical sequels aren't always a good idea. But there's gotta be the first really great one, and I don't see a reason why it couldn't be Emojiland. I mean, I feel like there's plenty more that we could do with these characters. I mean, but yeah, no, that that review puzzles me because it's like the tone swaps. It's like, oh yeah, it's a really fun time and the cast is great, but like it's not a good show, and it's like, what? Huh? Very confused by the tone of that review.

[35:40] Jess McEnally: I like it. A rare event where the New York Times is the most glowing review out of all the New York theater critics. And it makes me happy to see, because it basically means all good things for Emojiland. Um, and it pr likely would have if COVID hadn't like ruined theater for a while.

[35:58] Hayley St. James: Yeah. So let's go into a mid-show and talk about some songs.

[36:01] Jess McEnally: Yeah.

[36:08] Jess McEnally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Um today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Uh we love our patrons so much. Um I'm gonna read the names this time, just cause I I'm in the mood, and we've sure gotta change here. Um our current patrons are Terry Needleman, John Donna, Max Lutnig, Layton Accles.

[36:30] Hayley St. James: Um, congrats on coming out as non-binary Leighton. Welcome.

[36:33] Jess McEnally: Um, Danielle Rennes, Jessica Stampede, Iwan Casty, Taskier, Fire of September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Hayley Murray, Allison Wonderland, B Way Flicks, Atheno, Stacey Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Ira Gale, Drewe Whiter, Christine Malmadell, Cole Birchfield, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vinhous.

[36:49] Hayley St. James: Heck you, I go by Elijah now.

[36:51] Jess McEnally: Russ Walker, Emily Gracie, Tablam, Kyle Summers, Jen A C, Christina Francis, Felice A. Liz Lynn, Corey Wilmarth, Allison Steller, nothing is certain, except Beth and Taxes. Elizabeth, John Vin's, Thesbian, Ren Collin, Wayne the Wings, Lady Malvolia, Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Robert Benjamin, Rachel T, Jessica Tubus, Genevieve Hartness, Cass, parentheses, just Cass. Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Hayden Wilder, Katie McDonough, Gent Kai G.

[37:22] Hayley St. James: Oh gosh, some new names.

[37:24] Jess McEnally: Geng Gengius?

[37:26] Hayley St. James: No.

[37:27] Jess McEnally: I think it's Gen Genki Geist.

[37:29] Hayley St. James: Genki Geist, welcome. Stakas, welcome. And Timothy Keys, welcome. These folks give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks such as patronly commentaries, our episodes a day earlier even earlier, come join us over at Patreon. Also, if you guys like to have our dumb faces on your body, buy our merch. Um, just go to Muscles with Cheese.com and click the merch button and then buy it and give Andrew all the money.

[37:59] Jess McEnally: Do we sell merch with our faces on it?

[38:01] Hayley St. James: We will soon.

[38:03] Jess McEnally: Oh no.

[38:05] Hayley St. James: Just you wait.

[38:08] Jess McEnally: It'll just be like this. It'll literally be a zoom call image on people's chest.

[38:14] Hayley St. James: That would be the shittiest shirt ever.

[38:16] Jess McEnally: People will buy it, I'm sure.

[38:18] Hayley St. James: Just because we'll even put like the shittiest shirt ever. If you just do it ironically, people will buy it.

[38:24] Jess McEnally: Oh no.

[38:26] Hayley St. James: Alright, well, no one's gonna buy it.

[38:28] Jess McEnally: They're gonna buy it, I promise.

[38:30] Hayley St. James: See, now I actually have to make this shirt now. Thanks, Andrew.

[38:38] Jess McEnally: It's so great to be alive.

[38:39] Hayley St. James: It's just so great to be alive.

[38:41] Jess McEnally: It really is.

[38:42] Hayley St. James: It really is, Jess.

[38:43] Jess McEnally: What makes you say that, though?

[38:45] Hayley St. James: That's the opening number of the show.

[38:49] Jess McEnally: Oh, he got me.

[38:56] Hayley St. James: Whatever's installed, I'm sure. Gonna bump up my followers.

[39:03] Jess McEnally: When you gotta face a light mind, you ain't gotta be me.

[39:08] Hayley St. James: Oh, it's powerful.

[39:15] Jess McEnally: So how freaking out a little my beauty soul show to me. Our love is real. Spies, tell them how you feel. It's just so great to be alive.

[39:31] Hayley St. James: I love this song so much. Like it put me right in the mood. It's such a delightful opener because it's one of those all skate numbers where you get to introduce all the characters in you know, really fun ways. You get to get a little bit of everybody's personality, but it's still like a great opening introduction to this world.

[39:49] Jess McEnally: I'd put it up there with like bikini bottom day and welcome to the Renaissance for sure.

[39:55] Hayley St. James: Well, it has a very difficult job of building a world in and of itself, which is very difficult in in most media, but let alone in a musical where you're stuck like in the black box behind you.

[40:06] Jess McEnally: Yep.

[40:06] Hayley St. James: This nails it. My goodness, this like nails it. Um in a way like SpongeBob, we have that. Like we we have the previous versions of that to kind of take with us. Nothing. They have to build everything from scratch. And it works. I am shocked at how well that worked. That was the minute I knew like this is not gonna be the emoji movie.

[40:29] Jess McEnally: I'm really glad it wasn't like a number about like kids being on their phones all the time. And then, oh, there's emojis in the phones. Look at that. It's like kids today.

[40:41] Hayley St. James: I mean, the nice thing is the waiters are not cringe boomers. They're like in their 30s. They're like young musical theater writers, which is super cool.

[40:48] Jess McEnally: Which is great.

[40:49] Hayley St. James: Which is great. That's the difference between the emoji movie and Emojiland. Um yeah, I guarantee the emoji movie musical would have opened with the kids these days, they're always on their phone song.

[41:06] Jess McEnally: Always on the phones, never never wanna talk.

[41:10] Hayley St. James: And then we were like, wow, they've got a whole world in their phones. Can you imagine? The world of emojis.

[41:23] Jess McEnally: Wow.

[41:25] Hayley St. James: Cursed.

[41:26] Jess McEnally: That's very cursed.

[41:27] Hayley St. James: Thank goodness that wasn't it.

[41:29] Jess McEnally: Thank goodness that was not what we ended up with.

[41:31] Andrew DWolf: Oh no, that was not even close.

[41:33] Jess McEnally: It's it's like the opposite of that. But that set up for like what was gonna be an above-average like family musical. The next song was what made me realize no, this is not a family musical.

[41:45] Hayley St. James: And that is "Sad on the Inside," which broke my heart and tore it into a million pieces for this happy face emoji that I just met and fell in love with immediately. Stand in here smelling the flowers for hours and hours, wondering why this is something I do. I should feel perfectly sunny with no chance of showers. They see the me that's yellow, but they never see the blue.

[42:22] Jess McEnally: Ooh.

[42:22] Hayley St. James: Laura is so so wonderful, and she really just taps into that very universal feeling of, you know, we hide people. We're really good at hiding their emotions. And like Smise is kind of the best at it in, you know, a really heartbreaking way because she is, she's, you know, this is her job as an emoji. She is the smiling face with smiling eyes emoji. She is just all smiles all the time, but no, inside, she's just so sad.

[42:51] Andrew DWolf: God, such a move. Is there a subplot in the emoji movie where the meh face wants to be a different face?

[42:57] Hayley St. James: That's like the whole plot of the show of the movie, I think, is that meh doesn't want to be meh, he wants to be something else.

[43:04] Jess McEnally: That is just one piece of Emojiland. That's and it's so much deeper because it's done a lot better in this.

[43:11] Hayley St. James: Everything is done a lot better.

[43:13] Jess McEnally: Probably. I don't know. Maybe the emoji movie is a masterpiece. I'm like, should I imagine the worst version of the super smiley happy emoji, which would be like, oh, they're vapid and always about themselves, but and there might be secretly evil or something because they're always so happy. But here it's like, nah, depression. We're gonna we're gonna talk about this. We're opening up this for a discussion.

[43:33] Hayley St. James: And my god, and like she also wrote the show, right?

[43:38] Jess McEnally: Yes, she did her yes, yes. Laura co-wrote the show and starred in it. Um, because she wrote, yeah, she co-wrote the book and she wrote and she co-wrote the lyrics.

[43:47] Hayley St. James: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Eat your heart out, Lynn Manuel Miranda. Let's see you be an emoji.

[43:53] Jess McEnally: Dave Malloy. Come on. Come be an emoji.

[43:56] Hayley St. James: Dave Malloy is the accordion emoji.

[43:58] Jess McEnally: Dave Malloy just and it's just Pierre. He just comes on with the accord and he's like, I'm the accordion emoji. I'm just gonna do accordions just for fun.

[44:08] Hayley St. James: I don't know. I mean, I was I like thinking about like Emojiland, but like all the other musicals. Like, cause there's um someone did like I don't know, it's it was like you know the parody bill, you know, the people who do like the parody play bills. They did um the opening night post for Emojiland was Emoji Town, and it was Emojiland but Hades Town, and I was I was very here for that because I love I love Hades Town.

[44:29] Jess McEnally: It was it was nice. Very good. What other musicals could you tell with emojis now that I'm thinking about it?

[44:35] Hayley St. James: There's a lot. Isn't that already a thing? Isn't there like Twitter accounts that do that?

[44:40] Jess McEnally: That makes sense, yeah. They do like some people do like, oh, describe it a mu a musical using only emojis. They do those kind of posts all the time.

[44:48] Hayley St. James: Alright, describe Emojiland using only emojis.

[44:51] Jess McEnally: And I just use every emoji from that are the main characters of the show. Like I just do all of them. I think there was a point where I actually had all of them lined up in order, like as like a hotkey on my phone. So if I just typed in Emojiland cast, it would just be, you know, smiling face with smiling eyes emoji, nerd face emoji, skull emoji, prince emoji, princess emoji.

[45:11] Hayley St. James: I can't find the levitating businessman.

[45:13] Jess McEnally: Oh, he's there. He's right underneath the dancing girl emoji. I like hate that this show made me memorize my emoji keyboard. But it did.

[45:21] Hayley St. James: I've kind of realized that I don't emoji. I cry. I don't really know most of the emojis that exist. I I only kind of use like three of 'em.

[45:33] Jess McEnally: Let's talk about "Cross My Bones."

[45:39] Hayley St. James: We don't need an album by code. It's in my comb. And home today.

[46:06] Jess McEnally: Is that the villain song? Because it is kind of like a trickery song.

[46:09] Hayley St. James: Skull gets two villain songs, which is very cool. We get this sort of introduction to Skull that's like sort of like the you know, the seduction, kind of in a way. The seduction to the dark side, where, you know, Skull is, you know, just wanting Nerdface to be his friend, because he's very lonely and he's very depressed and very suicidal.

[46:31] Jess McEnally: So yeah, he's uh this is definitely more of a seduction song as opposed to the outright villain song, which is the act one finale.

[46:39] Hayley St. James: Yeah. Yeah.

[46:40] Jess McEnally: The oxymoron of a villain that's goal is to die and take everyone with him is like incredible. Skull is a nihilist, and I love it.

[46:50] Hayley St. James: I I love I love it so much. I feel like there's other villains that are like that, but maybe not.

[46:56] Jess McEnally: Not in musical theater.

[46:59] Hayley St. James: Nine musical theater.

[47:00] Jess McEnally: Oh no. No, not in music theater.

[47:03] Hayley St. James: Yeah. No, I mean, most villains do want something for themselves. Whereas Skull does legitimately just want to kill everyone and himself.

[47:11] Jess McEnally: Mm-hmm.

[47:12] Hayley St. James: Like it's not a world domination. It's not even world destruction. It's like I'm taking all y'all with me.

[47:18] Jess McEnally: Yeah. Skull is Skull is Skulls, I I like to describe Skull as an he's like a goth anarchist. He's just, he just wants everything to be destroyed.

[47:27] Hayley St. James: Yeah. Andrew, what'd you think of this song? Like, in general.

[47:30] Andrew DWolf: Uh, I think this one is fine. I like the introduction of the skull character, and I think that especially the first couple of lines with him and everything is very funny, but this one doesn't really compare to "Thank Me Now." That one's just amazing.

[47:44] Hayley St. James: I like this one because it takes its time. It is a little bit like a droning, kind of like depressive. And you never really believe what what's being said, but you are kind of like, alright, may maybe this is a sympathetic, and I'm judging because of the nose ring or something.

[48:05] Jess McEnally: Jess just would make Jess would make the poison.

[48:08] Hayley St. James: Yeah. I would, I would.

[48:10] Jess McEnally: The virus.

[48:11] Hayley St. James: Yeah. Literally just the test tube emoji.

[48:14] Jess McEnally: Literally just the test tube emoji. I'd make it and be like, just don't drop it, okay? But yeah, I kinda like how it kind of sounds like a Radiohead song, kind of.

[48:25] Hayley St. James: Yes.

[48:26] Jess McEnally: Like the tone it's going for is very like.

[48:29] Hayley St. James: It's yeah, it's very much almost it's very creep-esque, like in the best way.

[48:34] Jess McEnally: I can't unhear it now, thank you.

[48:37] Hayley St. James: Like yeah, yeah, yeah, that's about right. Um how would you describe "Thank Me Now"?

[48:43] Jess McEnally: Oh, "Thank Me Now" is more Muse.

[48:45] Hayley St. James: "Thank Me Now" is more on the Mew side.

[49:27] Jess McEnally: "Thank Me Now" I think is my favorite song in the show without being the best, if that makes sense.

[49:33] Hayley St. James: That's also how I feel. But I'm also biased. I think it is the best song in the show. I don't I don't know. I'm very, very much anyway, starts again. Like anyway is the best, but "Thank Me Now" is my favorite.

[49:42] Jess McEnally: "Thank Me Now" is like in my top five. Um I mean I'm very biased because I love how Lucas sounds on it. I I love I just love how it's staged. I love just it just feels like yes, I am this is it feels like you're like it feels like the musical equivalent of like the evil villain telling you their plot and how they're finally gonna take over the world, and like it has that driving sense of doom and you know, triumph in a way, like triumphant doom, because like he's finally done it, he's done the thing, and it's just so so cool.

[50:18] Hayley St. James: And then getting that little all skate bit in.

[50:20] Jess McEnally: I know I keep I use the word all skate so much, I just miss ensembles. I I miss, I miss, I miss this cast because they all played so wonderfully silly and delightful off of each other. Like even when the material got really serious, and I kind of loved that. Incredible. But this song slaps. And as I said, normally on not on the cast album, but live most of the time, high F sharp. He would riff at the end and do this high F sharp before dropping the test tube.

[50:49] Hayley St. James: He hits the high note, drops the test tube, blackout. Just one. But let's say, like, as an act one closer. You we're literally all about to die because of me with this virus, is as good a reason to come back for Act Two as I've ever seen.

[51:04] Andrew DWolf: I completely concur. Alright, alright. Um Act Two, I'm not gonna lie, there's not a crazy amount of songs I really want to talk about, aside from Anyway, which is the best song in the show in my opinion. Like, there's things we could stop and chat about, like um "Pile of Pooh," which is fun and a lot of lot of energy and like great hilarious, but anyway breaks my heart.

[51:28] Hayley St. James: It's funny because for me, I think the three best songs on the show come back to back to back, and that's uh "Police Officers," um "A Thousand More Words," um followed by "Anyway," followed by "Start Again." That is basically the holy trinity right there for the show for me.

[51:42] Jess McEnally: Um they're just all so good. I I can see the argument that the none not a single one of them are the eleven o'clock number. They are all the eleven o'clock.

[51:52] Hayley St. James: They're the eleven o'clock number for each specific character arc, because that's you know, "Police Officer" literally just lost the love of her life to the virus, and she is mourning despite she has to go do her job. She's just mourning, and God, Felicia Boswell on that song. Like, I was like, they should just release this as a single. Like, out of context, this song is just phenomenal.

[52:16] Jess McEnally: Um, and by the end of that run, like it I think she got a standing O's quite a few times, which is very rightfully deserved. She's amazing. It's just so powerful.

[52:25] Hayley St. James: Um, and then you know you go straight to "Anyway," which is just the heart of this show. Like, I quote it pretty much in in its entirety in my review for the site that I wrote for. Because I'm like, guys, critics who didn't like the book or the lyrics, have you not like read the lyrics to "Anyway"? This is the heart of the show. If you were like, what was the point of this show? It's a fun musical comedy. I'm like, did you not listen to the song about existentialism and why we were put on this planet? Like, hello.

[52:56] Jess McEnally: Emojiland. Why were you put on this planet?

[52:59] Hayley St. James: Pretty much. And more fun ideas. The question is like, for me, is like, do emojis have a heaven? Like, I know they worship the code, but what what happens to their old selves when they reset? Like, these are the questions I'm left, like, with like who like will they find each other again in the end?

[53:21] Jess McEnally: Um, Smiley and Nerdface.

[53:24] Hayley St. James: Smiley and Nerdface, like and if it does, will it mean as much because they didn't have all the previous history together? All that stuff is like bubbling inside my head. It's just it there's so many good questions that the show raises, and I love that. Like a Charlie Kaufman story, but about emojis.

[53:40] Jess McEnally: Oh my god, you're right. Let's talk about "Start Again" now.

[53:44] Hayley St. James: Yeah.

[53:48] Jess McEnally: Shallow fool is cruel and plain hateful.

[53:51] Hayley St. James: That's how our triviators chose to design us.

[53:56] Jess McEnally: Oh enjoy the profound truth's fleeting. Crazy is not wanting out from where they can find us.

[54:17] Hayley St. James: Nothing you can do.

[54:20] Jess McEnally: Oh my gosh. Like this, like the the growth of buddies together to to like reset the world. Uh it's such a all of it. What causes the skull to change his mind, though?

[54:33] Hayley St. James: Um, Nerdface just convinces him through his, you know, his positive, optimistic outlook on life, and thinking about how, like, hey, if you have the opportunity to reset, maybe, you know, you'll have a change of heart too when we all reset. And like, it's not a good idea. I don't know, he just he he cares. Nerdface is just so hopeful and kind, and uh, he's so good.

[54:58] Jess McEnally: I love I love that. Nerdface is everything that rational big boys should strive to be. Smart and emotional.

[55:06] Hayley St. James: Yes.

[55:07] Jess McEnally: Come on. He's he's backs do care about my feelings.

[55:11] Hayley St. James: Yeah. And I it's just it's such a good number the way we get between the two of them. Like it's funny because between "Cross My Bones" and "Start Again," like Georgia Boo and Lucas Steele's harmonies are just killer.

[55:25] Jess McEnally: It's so great. They sound so good together. At one point when they have like the legitimate emojis on like the projections and all that, I was like, oh no, I wanna see I want to see the actors I fell in love with for my climax, and then they come on. I'm like, oh thank god. And they get their final battle. It's so good. It's so sad. For a second, you're like, oh, are they really gonna just do like these emojis fighting each other? Is that her ending? I was they were gonna bonk into each other. That was a legitimate because you have not seen Jekyll and Hyde revival enough to know how much people will rely on projections.

[56:02] Andrew DWolf: Oh no, I don't see the remote. I've only seen the Hasselhoff version. It's Constantine Marula screaming at a screen that is the Hyde, and the screen is singing at him. And I'm like, no. I love Constantine, but why? That's not his fault. That's a choice. That is absolutely a choice.

[56:25] Jess McEnally: But yeah, I love the projections in this show. Like it's one of those shows that's like, oh, I'm tired of shows where the set is just one big projection, but here no, it's actually like a physical tactile set where they use projections on specific elements, which like one specific element in the center of the screen at the center of the stage, and there's lots of cubes that they move around, kind of like falsettos. It's pretty great. Pretty great set design. Incredible. Because I didn't really get that from like the audio, the cast recording, and of course the slime tutorial on the inter YouTube's.

[56:55] Hayley St. James: Yeah. Unfortunately, the person who filmed that did a lot of close-ups, which is not ideal for a show that is this visual and is so much an ensemble piece. Because I'm so mad we should have had a pro shot because this is a show that one kind of one really deserves it because it deserves a wider audience. But on top of everything, this is a show that is so visually really special, the costume design, especially.

[57:17] Jess McEnally: Yeah. I mean, we can hope that they'll come back.

[57:21] Hayley St. James: I'm hoping. My big comment honestly I who knows at this point. My big hope is because I think I think they put I don't know if they they kind of put the entire set away after once the shutdown happened or they had to clean out. I know the last time I saw Lucas Steele, he went to clean out his dressing room. But I was thinking that like once like if like they're starting to record more shows, like during the pandemic to release, like they filmed Diana, they're gonna go film come from away. They should get the cast back and you know, do a pro shot of Emojiland because I think it would be really timely and really cool.

[57:55] Jess McEnally: Also, what kills me is there are more photos of me and my stage accurate skull cosplay than there are of Lucas in the skull costume, and I can't decide if that's really impressive or really sad.

[58:09] Hayley St. James: I think it sits in the middle somewhere, which is we need more, but you're also awesome, Hayley. I don't want to be the BL Lendel. I just I love this show a lot, but it's not my whole life. It's just a show that means a lot to me. And now I think it's time that we all sum it all up. All right, folks. What is our overall thoughts on Emojiland the musical and our cheese rating? I'm not sure if Hayley knows about our cheese rating, so I'm gonna make Andrew go first.

[58:35] Andrew DWolf: Sure. Overall thoughts. I mean it's a pretty fun show to watch, and it's a lot deeper and more interesting than you would expect from anything based on emojis. I certainly was expecting it to be a lot worse than it was. Like a lot worse. Ended up being pretty good. So I would recommend at least listening to whatever you can out there. I know it's not really easy to find and watch at this time, but you know, I think you could still listen to the cast recordings and everything, so I'd recommend that. As far as a cheese rating, this is a very easy one. I am going to give it the cheese emoji, obviously. I don't think there's anything else you can give it.

[59:22] Jess McEnally: So I'm gonna disagree. Haley, you're up next. What is your overall thoughts and your cheese rating?

[59:31] Hayley St. James: Okay. Well, this is a show that I went in with zero expectations, and I left it just feeling very, very moved, shockingly moved, having an amazing time, it's entertaining, it's thoughtful. It's delightful. It's so charming and clever. An amazing score that deserves a lot more credit than it gets. It's a true ensemble piece, which I adore and I'm always here for. It's got some pretty amazing songs, some of my favorite lyrics and songs in general in modern musical theater. Really, really clever and thoughtful book. It's a show that I think really deserves a cult following in the best ways, and I really hope it gets the attention it deserves when theater comes back, hopefully. I mean, I'd also give it the cheese emoji because that's very, very obvious, but as someone who really loves I always go with the easy answer.

Yeah, but I also feel like if we terms like if we don't buy like our favorite cheese, because I really love a smoked gouda. And like I'd say this show is a really nice smoked gouda. It's comforting, it's delightful, it just makes you feel good to be alive despite a pandemic, despite you know, a terrifying administration that thank God is over, that the show, you know, sometimes very uncomfortably echoed. Yeah, this show is just a big comforting bowl of smoked Gouda macaroni and cheese.

[1:01:04] Jess McEnally: Yeah. I love it. That's how I feel about Emojiland.

[1:01:07] Andrew DWolf: You gave it Gouda, but you didn't do the it was good pun. I'm very glad you didn't.

[1:01:14] Hayley St. James: I love the puns, but I'm not that obvious. We've had several guests give us that one, which you know what? That's fair.

[1:01:22] Jess McEnally: Yeah. No, this is an easy one to go for. Yeah, this is this is smoked Gouda mac and cheese, the musical, but it's emojis. They're emoji shaped.

[1:01:30] Hayley St. James: Yes. Oh, like the little smiley pastas.

[1:01:35] Jess McEnally: Yeah. Exactly. SpongeBob pasta things they used to give us.

[1:01:38] Andrew DWolf: I love SpongeBob mac and cheese. It's the best shape. Like objectively.

[1:01:43] Hayley St. James: That's objectively the best.

[1:01:44] Jess McEnally: But yeah, no, this is emoji-shaped smoked Gouda mac and cheese. It's perfect.

[1:01:49] Brianna Jones: Alright, Bree, what'd you think of our discussion in your cheese rating for our discussion?

[1:01:53] Brianna Jones: Okay. Um I would say that this discussion was passion fueled. I have never heard you guys I think talk about something so positively. And it was definitely a breath of fresh air. I think it's it's been a minute since I've heard you guys really have enjoyed a musical. That mean you were very nice to this musical, I will say that. Compared to the last couple we've done, maybe. I don't know.

[1:02:23] Jess McEnally: Um, but I am excited to put this podcast together and listen to the cast recording. Um, because it sounds like it was really, really good. Um, and uh you know what? Maybe I'll just uh maybe I'll just watch it if I can find it, which I'm sure I can with the help of Jess and Andrew. Um so I think I'm going to give it a marshmallow fluff cream cheese dip. Um it is one of my favorite things to dip fruit in, and it always makes me really happy because I rarely have it because it's really bad for you because it's just sugar and cheese, cream cheese.

[1:03:02] Hayley St. James: That is a great answer. Make it's gonna put mine to shame because mine's really stupid. Um, I want to echo what everyone just said. This show makes me so happy. Like, I I've wanted a show to like make me feel the way Great Comet had, and Hades Town, as much as I liked it, didn't quite do it. This does. It might just be the Lucas Steele of it all. Like, I just need more Lucas Steele and things.

[1:03:24] Andrew DWolf: Don't we all put it put it put him as Jesus and Jesus Christ superstars. I've been saying that for years. Put Ted Neely to shame.

[1:03:32] Hayley St. James: I it would be incredible.

[1:03:41] Jess McEnally: Of course, of course. Um I don't want to repeat things. We're g we're getting to the end of the show. I know y'all are antsy. So mine is Ceso Fresco Cheese, um, a recipe found on the Curd Nerd, which would be the favorite website of Nerdface.

[1:03:58] Hayley St. James: Of course, also a nerd. Adorable.

[1:04:02] Jess McEnally: Uh, yeah, so Hayley, tell people where they can find you, like everything that you're on. Promote yourself.

[1:04:09] Hayley St. James: Okay. Well, I'm on Twitter at Hayley St. James, which is at H A Y L E Y S T J A M E S. You can also find me on New Play Exchange. Um, just look for my name, Hayley St. James if you want to, you know, inquire about producing my works. I write a lot of very queer, very neurodivergent, very fun, very, you know, surreal plays. I would love to see some, you know, stuff happen during the pandemic. Um, not really on Insta much. Um Yeah, mostly just find me on Twitter. That's where I'll be. I'll be mostly just talking about theater and cold play and David Bowie and not much else.

[1:04:47] Jess McEnally: Haley's got one of the best Twitters, like best theater Twitters out there. Like, it's wonderful.

[1:04:52] Brianna Jones: Top ten.

[1:04:55] Jess McEnally: Like better than what Broadway World's doing, I will say that.

[1:04:59] Hayley St. James: Wow.

[1:05:00] Jess McEnally: Up there with like Rachel Zegler as like theater content that's actually like informative.

[1:05:05] Hayley St. James: I love it.

[1:05:06] Jess McEnally: I really it's great. Rachel Zegler's popularity both makes me happy and baffles me. It is like the first time like people have like gathered around a person without seeing the one thing that they've done. Like, we haven't seen a frame of that movie that has officially been released, and yet we love her anyways. I met her at um Jagolittle Pill stage door like a year ago. Um, the night that Ezra went on as Joe, which was amazing because Ezra is in West Side Story with Rachel. And Rachel was so so nice at the stage door. I just told her how much I love her and how cool she is, and she was just so nice, and uh, I love her. I think she deserves the universe. Uh she's great. But you just compared me to her, and I'm just I can't deal with that. That's that's a lot. That's a lot for me to take in right now. But thank you. I'm hoping within the next few years we'll be talking about one of Hayley's musicals or plays on this show. It'll be great.

[1:05:59] Jess McEnally: Um that note, thank you guys for listening. Um, we're on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese, Twitter, Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals with Cheese. Hey patrons, people. Um, a YouTube page musicals with cheese. We have a patron only podcast where we're currently talking about Gallivant. We're going through every episode of Gallivant. It's a ton of fun. Very fun. Revive Gallivant. Revive Gallivant Disney Plus. What the hell are you doing? It is great. It's so good. I want a stage version. Real bad.

[1:06:25] Hayley St. James: I would I yes, yes, yes.

[1:06:26] Jess McEnally: But also I always see like the Tangled series as like a spiritual sequel to Gallivant. Yeah, because it's the Slater and Mencken. Yeah. And Dan Fogelman, who created Gallivant, also wrote Tangled and came back for the series. It is a good like place in my heart that Galli.

[1:06:43] Brianna Jones: Very fair. Very fair.

[1:06:44] Jess McEnally: But also we miss we miss King Richard and we love you, Tad Cooper.

[1:06:49] Andrew DWolf: Yes, a hundred percent. He Andrew has not gotten quite to like how good King Richard is yet.

[1:06:54] Brianna Jones: Oh, no spoilers.

[1:06:55] Jess McEnally: King Richard is everything. But that's all I'm gonna say.

[1:07:00] Hayley St. James: Oh, you're not ready. You're not ready, Andrew.

[1:07:07] Jess McEnally: Shoot us an email at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our transcriptions are by Lash Masha Litvanava. We love you very much, Masha. Our title card was created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Send her some love on Instagram at Jolene Casco. Spelt with a C. Um, our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Thank you for keeping track of that, because God knows I wasn't going to do it. Um this show is produced by the incredible, the fantastic, my favorite person in the world, Brianna Jones. Thank you, Brianna, for keeping us going. Um thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for keeping us on the platform and for not, you know, like sending us out back with old yeller. Um, like it's gonna happen. It's gonna happen where they're just gonna be like, alright, musicals of cheese, your time is up. Time to get get off the site now.

[1:07:44] Brianna Jones: It's dark.

[1:07:53] Jess McEnally: We're just too mean to everybody, you know? Yeah, we're we're nice to Emojiland, but yeah, not today. You guys are very nice today. I'm glad I was here for you all being nice. Like, I love when that gets to happen. I think just this show I think just brings out like joy and happiness, which I think is great. I'm glad y'all were here to talk about it with me. It was great. We were so happy to have you on, Hayley. Anytime you want to come back on, we gotta show you like, oh, I'm really passionate about this. Always feel free to reach out. We'd love to have you back on.

[1:08:28] Hayley St. James: Oh, very good to know. Very good to know.

[1:08:30] Jess McEnally: Anything y'all want to say before we wrap this on up?

[1:08:33] Brianna Jones: Everybody have a very pleasant evening or day. And play with your emojis on your phone. They need love.

[1:08:41] Hayley St. James: They really do.

[1:08:42] Jess McEnally: They really do. Alright, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

[1:08:53] Hayley St. James: Cross my bones and hope to die.

[1:08:57] Jess McEnally: We don't need to bye. It's in our code.

[1:09:01] Hayley St. James: I must comply. Cross my bones and hope to do.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred