"I'm headstrong..." Grab your Jane Austen books because we are joined by the hilarious Katelyn Robinson to talk about the wonderful new musical by Paul Gordon "Pride & Prejudice." We dive into the accuracy to the novel, the quality of the songs, and a terrible Amazon review!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"I'm headstrong..." Grab your Jane Austen books because we are joined by the hilarious Katelyn Robinson to talk about the wonderful new musical by Paul Gordon "Pride & Prejudice." We dive into the accuracy to the novel, the quality of the songs, and a terrible Amazon review! You're going to love this!
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:05] Jess McInally: Hello, I'm Jess McInally.
[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:09] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.
[0:10] Jess McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Brianna to like musical theater.
[0:14] Jess McInally: And guys, we have an extra special guest.
[0:17] Jess McInally: I'm really excited.
[0:18] Jess McInally: Very special guest.
[0:19] Jess McInally: Very special guest.
[0:21] Jess McInally: Um, please welcome the host of the Movie Check on YouTube and co-writer and editor for Lost in Adaptation.
[0:26] Jess McInally: It's Katelyn Robinson!
[0:27] Katelyn Robinson: Applause!
[0:28] Jess McInally: Lots of applause!
[0:29] Jess McInally: Come on, yeah!
[0:32] Katelyn Robinson: Oh my goodness, I'm so flattered.
[0:40] Katelyn Robinson: Obviously.
[0:41] Katelyn Robinson: Nice.
[0:42] Katelyn Robinson: Feel welcomed and immediately thrown off guard by the intensity.
[0:46] Katelyn Robinson: I feel both.
[0:48] Katelyn Robinson: Just distinct mixture.
[0:49] Jess McInally: And we did our job then.
[0:51] Jess McInally: We're there.
[0:52] Jess McInally: We're doing it.
[0:53] Jess McInally: Um, but I want you to introduce what are we talking about this week?
[0:57] Katelyn Robinson: Oh, so we're talking about, uh, I thought I saw every adaptation, but we are talking about Pride and Prejudice the Musical.
[1:07] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, it's interesting because I've seen like 80s versions, mini-series, Bollywood version, I've seen, uh, Bridget Jones' Diary, but I have not seen, uh, a strict musical where it's set in the same time period.
[1:23] Katelyn Robinson: So this was, uh, this was a trip. I'm glad we have an expert on here with us, and it's so glad.
[1:30] Jess McInally: Um, but cue the music, Bree, let's introduce the show.
[1:33] ♪ Musical number: "Amazed" — performed by the cast ♪
[2:11] Jess McInally: Pride and Prejudice is a musical with music, lyrics, and book by Paul Gordon.
[2:15] Jess McInally: Um, based on Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice.
[2:17] Jess McInally: It opened at the Lucy Stern Theater at TheatreWorks Silicon Valley on December 4th, 2019, and was filmed with three HD cameras during its run at TheatreWorks.
[2:27] Jess McInally: It closed in January of 2020.
[2:30] Jess McInally: Um, the plot of which I feel like everyone kinda has a basic idea, but this is what they have on their playbill, which is Sparks Fly when spirited Elizabeth Bennett meets single rich and proud Mr. Darcy, based on the classic novel by Jane Austen, is a new musical adaptation by Tony Award nominee Paul Gordon.
[2:48] Jess McInally: Who has been on our show before?
[2:50] Jess McInally: Paul did a really nice interview with us.
[2:52] Jess McInally: I think I might re-release that, um, this week, but he's a real nice guy, real sweet, sweet man.
[2:58] Jess McInally: Um, but let's talk about this musical real quick.
[3:01] Jess McInally: Um, so Kate, as expert here, as the one that has seen all the versions.
[3:06] Jess McInally: I've only like seen the wonderful movie and the Colin Firth mini-series, and I read the book a long time ago.
[3:12] Jess McInally: That is where I stand, which is not much.
[3:14] Katelyn Robinson: And I've seen this.
[3:16] Jess McInally: Yeah, this is Andrew's only version of Pride and Prejudice.
[3:19] Jess McInally: How does this stack up compared to the other ones?
[3:22] Katelyn Robinson: I would say, as far as being a, uh, appropriate adaptation, it's pretty high up there.
[3:29] Katelyn Robinson: I thought they did a really good job with choosing what to keep in and then kind of like what to remove and omit.
[3:34] Katelyn Robinson: And they were really able to express a lot through all of the, uh, the songs, uh, that they chose, especially anytime there was a letter, it sometimes it was in song, usually Miss Bingley, which was a delight because it was like a sing-song, very like, yes, it's just dripping with sarcasm, but I'm being so delightfully, you know, happy that you I want you to come, you know, that kind of deal.
[3:59] Katelyn Robinson: I was actually kind of amazed by that.
[4:01] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, I think there were a few, uh, interpretations of characters I wasn't a fan of, but I would say overall it was pretty strong.
[4:09] Katelyn Robinson: I will say that Paul Gordon's biggest strength as a composer and writer, he's very good at adapting direct text into lyrics and making it sound like it sings.
[4:19] Katelyn Robinson: One of my favorite musicals of all time is his adaptation of Jane Eyre, where he wholesale takes like portions of the book and just turns it into rhyming lyric, and it works so well in a way that I'm very confused as to why a lot of people that adapt novels don't tend to do that.
[4:34] Katelyn Robinson: Um, I can't recall any direct one-to-one lines from the book turned into song here.
[4:40] Katelyn Robinson: Maybe you can, Kate, but I felt like they kind of leaned into the more modernistic feel of it.
[4:46] Katelyn Robinson: Yes, they would start off a lot of the songs, I think because there's only so much of her prose that you can turn into lyrics because she is known for like layering on adjective after adjective.
[4:58] Katelyn Robinson: So you kind of have to trim that down a bit when you're doing a song if you want it to flow.
[5:02] Katelyn Robinson: But I would say almost every song starts off with direct, uh, dialogue from the books.
[5:09] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, normally they did have it mostly spoken, especially, uh, I would say the beginning of the play, especially.
[5:17] Katelyn Robinson: It more felt like they had their own asides to add on to the text.
[5:22] Katelyn Robinson: That because the way Jane Austen kind of works is everything's very dry, you can't ever really show your full emotion.
[5:29] Katelyn Robinson: So they'll keep adding in more of that emotion into their songs, making every character more sassy, and you get more of an introspective of the characters that because, uh, Pride and Prejudice is mostly in Elizabeth Bennett's POV.
[5:42] Katelyn Robinson: And I think what works about this musical is there is more than one song covering how Mr. Darcy feels, including I think my favorite one is when he realizes he has a crush on her and he just starts going on to be like, oh god, I love her eyes.
[5:58] Katelyn Robinson: So I thought it was accurate in that they took liberties, but I'm actually all for, uh, adaptations taking liberties as long as you have the core feeling of the story.
[6:07] Jess McInally: I agree.
[6:08] Jess McInally: Um, now I want to take a moment since Andrew has never seen another version of Pride and Prejudice.
[6:13] Jess McInally: I want him to try to tell, shame me on what the plot of this story is, just from the musical.
[6:19] Jess McInally: Andrew, you do your best to explain the plot of Pride and Prejudice to us.
[6:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'll do my best.
[6:26] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so there's like a family of five girls who it's during a time period where you know you marry the girls off for wealth and things like that.
[6:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um, at least it seems that way.
[6:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um, they're gonna lose their house or something like that, unless they marry somebody, but this is a little later, I guess.
[6:47] Andrew DeWolf: I don't even know.
[6:49] Andrew DeWolf: Unless you marry my own, unless you marry your cousin, one of the stories.
[6:54] Jess McInally: Okay.
[6:56] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[6:57] Andrew DeWolf: I guess more importantly, there's another guy, Mr. Darcy, who, uh, is kind of a jerk, and the main character girl, uh, Elizabeth, um, she really doesn't like him, and then she really does like him, but he really likes her the whole time, kind of.
[7:16] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, and it's like a romantic comedy kind of story, I guess, but older and cuter.
[7:25] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[7:25] Andrew DeWolf: They're dressed much cooler.
[7:27] Katelyn Robinson: They're dressed much cooler.
[7:29] Andrew DeWolf: I'm as close as I'm gonna get on one view.
[7:31] Katelyn Robinson: You got the broad strokes together.
[7:33] Andrew DeWolf: No, yeah.
[7:34] Andrew DeWolf: I would say you got it pretty down pat.
[7:36] Andrew DeWolf: There's some other side stuff, like there's a lady who is also horrible.
[7:42] Andrew DeWolf: Who she shows up every once in a while and just kind of gets told off by the main character.
[7:48] Katelyn Robinson: Didn't even bring up Mr. Bingley.
[7:50] Andrew DeWolf: Whatever, Mr. Bingley.
[7:53] Andrew DeWolf: I don't even care.
[7:57] Katelyn Robinson: To be fair, the Mr. Bingley in this musical, I think he's my least favorite of all the Bingleys I've ever seen.
[8:03] Katelyn Robinson: They really relied on him being so shy that he has like almost no lines, except like the two songs where he, I guess that was the point is that he's so in his head he he's like afraid to speak up.
[8:16] Katelyn Robinson: But I don't know.
[8:17] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, the Bingleys I usually see in like the book and adaptations is he's so affable.
[8:22] Katelyn Robinson: Like he is the most warm and charming and welcoming character in the story that you just everyone kind of falls in love with him, and it's Jane who's the more like she's in her head all the time and extremely shy.
[8:35] Katelyn Robinson: And that because that's what women are told to do back then, is you're supposed to be demure and have the man chase you, but obviously that leads to misunderstandings.
[8:42] Katelyn Robinson: But this show does the very interesting thing with Jane where there's like almost a running joke where no one talks to her, despite her like, I have a voice I want to speak, which was an interesting thing to put on that character that is known for being like a little bit more introverted.
[8:56] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm.
[8:57] Katelyn Robinson: Oh yeah, no, I would agree with that.
[8:58] Katelyn Robinson: I've only ever seen that done once.
[9:01] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, with the Kiera Knightley version.
[9:03] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, they kind of touched upon that with Jane, but this one was more so.
[9:06] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, it was just a full-on running joke.
[9:08] Katelyn Robinson: Her exasperated with her family talking over her, and no one's listening to what she has to say.
[9:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[9:15] Andrew DeWolf: I think the whole thing here feels very classic musical theater.
[9:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it reminds me of some of the older shows we watch.
[9:22] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I liked it.
[9:24] Andrew DeWolf: I actually quite liked it.
[9:26] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think Paul Gordon is one of the more talented composer writers out there that didn't get any real respect.
[9:34] Andrew DeWolf: He did Jane Eyre on Broadway, which got Tony nominees, and then he hasn't been to Broadway since.
[9:39] Andrew DeWolf: And he has two of my top favorite musicals with Daddy Longlegs, which was the first musical to ever be streamed live, which is just a very charming, wonderful musical, and then Jane Eyre, which is just a perfect adaptation of the book, which no in a way that no film ever did.
[9:56] Andrew DeWolf: I won't say that this musical is as good as Jane Eyre was as an adaptation.
[10:01] Andrew DeWolf: There's no, it isn't a replacement value to like the best versions of Pride and Prejudice on screen, but it is very good for being a musical and shortening and condensing.
[10:10] Andrew DeWolf: It's one of the shortest versions.
[10:11] Andrew DeWolf: It's like a two hours and some change and not much more.
[10:14] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, no, it was probably the shortest.
[10:17] Katelyn Robinson: I don't even think the black and white film is as short as this, but I thought it was really well placed regardless, because they honestly just cut down on the amount of parties that they attend to and the amount of letters that get read.
[10:29] Andrew DeWolf: So it was like, eh, it's okay.
[10:31] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, they got to the important bits.
[10:34] Katelyn Robinson: And there's moments where they're like, instead of writing a letter, just show up and talk.
[10:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I liked, uh, their use of scene transition was using Mary just coming in, acting like that broody teenager.
[10:46] Andrew DeWolf: We're in the drawing room now, and then just leaves.
[10:50] Katelyn Robinson: It works so well.
[10:51] Katelyn Robinson: Like this show has a sense of humor.
[10:54] Katelyn Robinson: There is not a self-seriousness to it.
[10:56] Katelyn Robinson: Like Elizabeth has a lot of asides to the audience where it's like, well, I agree with that.
[11:02] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah.
[11:03] Katelyn Robinson: No, they definitely, they took what POV narration you get in the book and like just amped up the sass.
[11:10] Katelyn Robinson: So she's constantly quipping at people.
[11:13] Katelyn Robinson: I think my favorite was her quipping at Lady Catherine as Lady Catherine singing about how great she is, and she just keeps making these little snide remarks to the point that like Darcy interrupts the song by laughing.
[11:24] Andrew DeWolf: I like that bit a lot.
[11:25] Katelyn Robinson: But you love to see it.
[11:26] Katelyn Robinson: There's so many characters that deserve it.
[11:28] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah.
[11:30] Katelyn Robinson: Oh yes.
[11:31] Katelyn Robinson: And this one kind of gives you more cake in that way.
[11:34] Katelyn Robinson: Like Elizabeth in the book and other adaptations is a little bit more to herself, and her sass kind of comes out in like small bursts of like these staccato things, whereas here she's like talking down everyone.
[11:46] Katelyn Robinson: Like when she's up against, I think it's Lady Catherine, and she's like real intense and has that like beat breakdown confrontation, and you see Darcy like horny on main in the background, and that is what triggers him to then ask her to marry him the first time is a brilliant way to turn a scene that kind of feels out of place in most film adaptations and in the book and make it an actual character triggering moment.
[12:11] Andrew DeWolf: It leads right into the next scene.
[12:13] Katelyn Robinson: And I don't know if that's been done before.
[12:15] Katelyn Robinson: Maybe I'm incorrect.
[12:17] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, it has, uh, oh god, what is, I can't, I'm blanking on the director's name.
[12:24] Katelyn Robinson: It's, uh, his last name is, oh, Joe Wright.
[12:27] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, when he did the Kiera Knightley version, it's actually even more so, I would say a much more, there's a lot more sexual tension in that version.
[12:36] Katelyn Robinson: And there's the much more horny on main Darcy walking through the fields with an open romantic white shirt.
[12:44] Katelyn Robinson: And they even, I wouldn't say they kiss, but they're like very much close to making out at the end of that like love confession scene.
[12:52] Katelyn Robinson: And that one with Judy Dench being Lady Catherine, so like possibly my favorite Lady Catherine, because she really knows how to amp up that real just real bitchiness.
[13:03] Katelyn Robinson: Um, she like comes in stalking in the middle of the night, wakes the whole house up to yell at Liz.
[13:10] Katelyn Robinson: So I would say they're both on par, just different. Uh, but there aren't really that many adaptations that go that far. Usually they're pretty strict, like the 90s BBC miniseries with Colin Firth, which was I feel is the most faithful of the adaptations. But I think it also is one of the more boring versions of the adaptations. Yeah, yeah. It's a rough watch. There should have been a lot more cutting down. Um I love the acting in it, uh, and the costumes is gorgeous, but yeah, there's definitely the pacing, I would say personally is not as tight as uh other adaptations, even like with this musical. I think one of the things that works about musicals is so much that you need to convey, especially from a book when there's a character having all these thoughts to themselves, you can burst it through song and cover a lot of ground in like under three minutes, which really, really worked in this book's favor because it's a lot of it is in Elizabeth's head.
It's her experiencing uh like a a day in the life of her. So I I really think that worked well in in this uh musical's favor. And I also enjoyed, I would say, a good like 80% of the songs. I I think that's kind of the thing, and maybe Andrew or you will disagree with this. I like the songs as they were happening. I cannot recall them by title. I I the one I can only one that's comes to mind when I think about the show is I'm headstrong. She says it like 900 times.
[14:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, headstrong, they repeat the the title line quite often.
[14:40] Katelyn Robinson: Yes, I but I could never think of it, and I would instead think of like the trapped song, and I got very confused. I was like, no, wait, that's not how it went. How did that song go? Uh no, the one I always remembered is the I don't know if it was called this was not the man I know. That one I kind of liked how it started off as a serious song and then kind of went into a jokey song and then went into like, oh, I think I'm in love with him now. I like the transition. They kind of tweak the lyrics and the enunciation between like the three different verses. Uh, which I yeah, I think that was probably m the most well executed and memorable song to me. Um there there are moments where it really does jump out like as uh a it doesn't feel feminist in the way that like the girl power, but in the way that that they have agency behind what they're acting as.
Um specifically in the moments where her and Jane are talking and they explain what they feel about this. I feel like you don't often get that in a lot of film versions where you get those like more intimate conversations, like here's what's going on and how how I'm feeling about this and how it's developing.
[15:49] Katelyn Robinson: And uh specifically in remarks to Jane, who gets basically dumped and ghosted as best as you can in the Regency area. Um, she's kind of a prop for like Elizabeth's love line, where here they kind of try to characterize her and give her a bit more of a story and like emotions and like why she's this way and why she holds in so much.
[16:11] Jess McInally: Oh, yes. I I would definitely agree with that. I think that's what's always worked about Jane Austen's works, because it is still prevalent, you know, in regards to the era, so obviously she can only be so feminist. But there is I I liked that they especially add in the beginning where she starts off with a quote from the beginning of the book, uh Liz, where you know, uh something a man of great fortune must be in want of a wife, and then they change and you're like, but why? Why did why do we need that? Why do we need to get married off so young? And then she goes on this whole thing about it, and I was like, oh, okay, I see where this play wants to say, but like it never shames you for wanting to get married, and it doesn't ever belittle the book. It seems to cherish the book as much as like its fans would, but it also wanted to update it for a more like modern sensibility, which I really enjoyed.
[16:58] Katelyn Robinson: Now, did a very good job with that, yeah. As someone that just saw this version and like there is more feminist tendencies leaning into this, did you notice them in this from I mean I don't have experience with the book or anything like that?
[17:14] Katelyn Robinson: So I can't really say like, oh yeah, this is way more feminist than the book. I don't really know. I mean, were you ever like shocked like for for a Regency story, this is this is pretty modern feeling.
[17:25] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, but it's expected. I mean, I knew that this was made like this year or last year. Um, so I was kind of expecting it. And and a lot of times when you remake these older works, you have to update them, or people are gonna be pretty upset about the material. Cause I mean, I don't know about this book. Maybe it's fine and you could just make it as is, but a lot of older material you expect an update.
[17:50] Katelyn Robinson: I'd say that this book probably ages better than a lot of them. Like the narrative is so effective while still being antiquated in the fact that I need to marry my daughters off bed, get dowry, and if they marry the wrong person or up with the wrong person and RDC. It's not a good look, that's for sure.
[18:09] Katelyn Robinson: Uh yeah. Oh, speaking on when you uh when Andrew was recalling the plot, uh the whole they're gonna lose their house, it's more that because she had no sons, it's more talked about even more so in the book.
[18:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[18:23] Katelyn Robinson: If the father dies, they basically could get kicked out because I don't I mean Mr. Collins is not exactly the nicest person, and he doesn't seem to really care. So she's like, oh, if I marry one of my daughters to him, then you'll have to let us stay.
[18:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[18:36] Katelyn Robinson: That's very common in uh her uh works of Jane Austen, because that that happens in sense and sensibility, where their father dies and their cousin basically kicks them out of the house, and that's how that story begins. Because women couldn't own property, like they just straight up didn't allow them to, which is obviously terrible.
[18:54] Jess McInally: Um and the cousin is an absolute creep in in this.
[18:59] Katelyn Robinson: It's very unsettling, but it's funny. I mean, they they play it for laughs, but yeah.
[19:06] Andrew DeWolf: I can't imagine no way it's a few.
[19:08] Katelyn Robinson: Well, you can't play it not for laughs. I mean, you could play it to like really creepy, but then you'd want them to like be killed or something, you know, you're not sure.
[19:16] Jess McInally: Pride and prejudice and zombies.
[19:18] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah. I have that's the one I have not seen. Only because I didn't read the book, Pride and Prejudice and Zombies. It it I don't know. Something about it felt slightly wrong to me, but I could be proven wrong. I have no idea.
[19:31] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not sure.
[19:34] Katelyn Robinson: But I've seen the scene, the proposal scene with um Darcy and Elizabeth.
[19:39] Andrew DeWolf: Which is fun, I guess.
[19:40] Katelyn Robinson: I was kind of annoyed. I was like, wait, I thought they were supposed to be zombies. It's just them like knife fighting in a like a library. I was very confused.
[19:46] Andrew DeWolf: So I was like, oh, maybe there's zombies eventually.
[19:50] Katelyn Robinson: So that yeah, that's the only scene I've seen as well. But I know the cousin character was played by Matt Smith in that movie, which he is an attractive enough guy.
[19:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so I'm wondering if they tried to frame him as like a more possible choice, like a more reasonable choice.
[20:05] Katelyn Robinson: Maybe honestly, as creepy as this Collins was, he is really toned down from how he is in the book, because he is a stan for Lady Catherine. All he wants to talk about is like Lady Catherine got he she suggested this furniture for me. She decorated my house, and like, oh my god, Lady Catherine's so great. I eat dinner with her every night, and it's like, I thought you're married. What the hell?
[20:27] Andrew DeWolf: That's very, very bizarre.
[20:31] Katelyn Robinson: Uh so they I think they toned him down considerably. Um he still manages to be creepy, though.
[20:37] Andrew DeWolf: He's just a creepy guy.
[20:38] Katelyn Robinson: I mean, the way he like walks up and looks at all the girls, it's like this is this is skee. It's like he's at a brothel or something.
[20:46] Andrew DeWolf: Like, yeah.
[20:47] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, it's like these are and they're your cousins too. It's like, ooh.
[20:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, well, that's yeah, unfortunately, that that's not a thing that bothers him back then.
[20:54] Katelyn Robinson: Oh, I know, I know that didn't bother them back then. But I mean Giuliani. I'm watching it now and I don't like it.
[21:00] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, I know.
[21:01] Katelyn Robinson: I think it's why they keep that in because it just adds on to like it adds more.
[21:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[21:07] Katelyn Robinson: It's even more, it's even more creepy now because it's like, oh, it's his cousins too.
[21:11] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.
[21:13] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah. Ugh.
[21:15] Katelyn Robinson: So Kate, I'm curious what what kind of musicals do you enjoy if you do enjoy them?
[21:20] Katelyn Robinson: Um, like I I am actually very, very picky. Uh I do have like a short list. Most of them I would say are more in that uh cabaret style where they're not so much breaking out into song as more as they're performing the song, like kind of like uh what's a good example? Like Chicago, the movie, not the uh Broadway musical, where it's either in someone's head or they're performing it. I really like that look of it. Especially you can get really, really creative.
[21:48] Katelyn Robinson: Uh I also do adore Singin in the Rain. I think that's probably one of the most perfect films I've ever seen. Even with it being as long as it is, there's just so much to enjoy about it. And I just like the core story. I like how each song kind of changes up. Uh, but I also like um I also like the not so great, but I love them anyway. Uh like Purple Rain. Not the greatest movie I've ever seen, but I really, really love the soundtrack and it's a very fun movie to watch.
[22:15] Katelyn Robinson: I also uh so anything in regards to that, I do love uh Roger and Hammerstein's Cinderella though. That I've loved since I was a little girl. Anytime I see there's a new version, I'm like, oh I have to watch it now. Uh unfortunately I have not seen it ever like on stage, but uh I have seen many uh uh filmed stage uh musicals or like the the brandy version from the nineties I've also seen.
[22:41] Jess McInally: So you'd call yourself more a casual like musical theater in joy.
[22:45] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah so that may means even more to me that you really kind of like this show, to be honest. Because I do kind of feel like this is more designed for folks like you and Andrew who kind of take this in a little bit more casually.
[22:57] Jess McInally: And I think the way it was shot specifically really encapsulates it. I think this is one of the better ways that a stage show has ever been shot.
[23:05] Katelyn Robinson: I think the people behind streaming musicals do an amazing job with it. Where it's very wide, it's very cinematic, but you get all the theatrical pieces. It never it's never embarrassed to be a musical, like the Miss I Gone or the uh whatcha called allegiance boot or recordings were very embarrassed to be a musical, so they tried to make it look as filmic as possible. Whereas this is like, no, that we know we are, but we're gonna make it look good.
[23:30] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not definitely good too.
[23:32] Katelyn Robinson: It was sometimes you have uh a filmed version and it's very distracting. They'll like zoom in on random things that just don't really make sense. They'll cut around during like dance numbers. Um in this one, I never never even really noticed it, which is what you want.
[23:47] Jess McInally: No, yeah, definitely. The way it's shot feels very deliberate. They want you to focus on certain parts of the scenes, how something fades out, how they bleed into the next transition.
[23:58] Katelyn Robinson: Uh I I did like the way um they would showcase how someone's reading a letter and they'll cast a shadow over someone, but you get like a full view of both of them.
[24:08] Jess McInally: Yeah, I really it never felt stagnant and it never felt like it was trying too hard.
[24:15] Katelyn Robinson: It was just it flowed very, very nicely. I was never bored watching it.
[24:19] Andrew DeWolf: I I think that's a good one.
[24:21] Katelyn Robinson: Now, Andrew, you have only ever seen an one other Paul Gordon musical, and that was No One Called a Head.
[24:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[24:28] Katelyn Robinson: Yes. Um how does this compare to that?
[24:31] Andrew DeWolf: That was okay. I think this is much better than that, actually. I mean, I don't want to be like mean to that one, but this was quite good.
[24:40] Katelyn Robinson: Um It might be the story is just uh better story, and I mean, obviously, this has held the test of time uh better than uh an original piece.
[24:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um I don't know. I I I thought this was a really uh tight show that was like cute and fun, which we don't get a lot of in modern shows, I don't think.
[25:02] Katelyn Robinson: I I I feel like there's this thing in films that exist um that i isn't allowed to happen in musicals, and I kind of hope that these more like film stage productions for like tiny audiences will bring. There are no mediocre musicals. There's either like the god-awfully bad ones that had a lot of money behind it, so it has to hit Broadway anyways, or so good that because we had to put all this work and effort and money into it, it has to be so good.
[25:28] Andrew DeWolf: There's nowhere to be like a cute, good, mediocre musical can like live.
[25:33] Katelyn Robinson: And I wouldn't even call this mediocre. I'd say it's pretty good. Um, but it's not gonna fill Broadway seats. But I'm glad it exists, and I can watch it whenever I want. I can listen to the cast album. It's not gonna be some demo recording that would be leaked a thousand years from now.
[25:48] Andrew DeWolf: It maybe it could on name recognition.
[25:50] Katelyn Robinson: I mean, I think that people know of it. I think the day of like Regency musicals kind of died in 2001 with the producers, where this uh Paul Gordon's Jane Eyre was up against that and no one saw it. No one went to see it. And I can't think of another big regency show. And if you are, you have to put a big twist on it, like Hamilton, where it's like rap.
[26:12] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[26:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh well.
[26:14] Jess McInally: We can see it now.
[26:16] Andrew DeWolf: They filmed it, you know. You know, that and I think that's a really good thing to do. We need to do more of these. We need to like embrace younger composers and new composers to try venturing into filming their stuff and putting out there.
[26:27] Katelyn Robinson: Like Starkid. They did that themselves, and now they've got an entire empire on themselves.
[26:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[26:33] Katelyn Robinson: Oh, Starkid, that's the like where they did that uh like they're very comedy-based musicals, like was that the one with like Aladdin?
[26:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[26:42] Katelyn Robinson: It's a lot of comedy and like parody uh style stuff.
[26:46] Andrew DeWolf: I saw the one about the aliens making everyone sing.
[26:50] Katelyn Robinson: I don't remember what it was called. That one was really good. I really like that one. The guy who didn't like musicals.
[26:55] Andrew DeWolf: And that that is a great way to kind of get musical theater out to audiences because kids like when I was fifteen, I wasn't able to pay 200 plus dollars to go to New York to go see a show and then like either do bootlegs or I'd pay ten dollars to see something like this on Amazon.
[27:11] Katelyn Robinson: I don't have two hundred dollars to see a show right now.
[27:15] Andrew DeWolf: Shows don't exist right now.
[27:18] Katelyn Robinson: True, but I also don't have two hundred dollars.
[27:21] Andrew DeWolf: But you know what? Who cares what we think? We gotta compare our opinions to those of the theater and film and whatever critics, cause this is a multimedia thing.
[27:32] Jess McInally: It's time for our favorite section of the show. It's time for previews where we compare our pieces.
[27:37] Andrew DeWolf: Those are reviewers.
[27:39] Jess McInally: It's time for preview.
[27:44] Jess McInally: It's time for previews.
[27:46] Andrew DeWolf: Henry Eckwitz of Splash Magazines said of the theater works production, a delightful proto-feminist interpretation of Austin's classic, well worth seeing.
[27:58] Katelyn Robinson: Everyone worked hard to make such a perspective.
[28:05] Andrew DeWolf: I've seen sometimes they just make up words.
[28:09] Jess McInally: What does that mean?
[28:11] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. Let's look it up.
[28:14] Katelyn Robinson: Oh my goodness.
[28:16] Jess McInally: Having a ready insight into an understanding of things.
[28:20] Andrew DeWolf: Ah.
[28:21] Katelyn Robinson: Alright.
[28:21] Jess McInally: Okay.
[28:22] Andrew DeWolf: Had to use that word.
[28:26] Katelyn Robinson: A perspicacious musical.
[28:30] Andrew DeWolf: Uh possible. Based on a recent reading of Martha, is it Galhorn's Galhorn's biography, the intrepid 20th century female journalist and author.
[28:41] Jess McInally: We wish to nominate her life and relationships for musical, even opera operatic, operatic, operatic treatment.
[28:49] Katelyn Robinson: Oh, in a future theater works update on women's experience.
[28:54] Andrew DeWolf: I like that one because he started with a review and then he backdoor pitched his own musical.
[29:00] Katelyn Robinson: I appreciate it.
[29:02] Andrew DeWolf: That was something.
[29:04] Jess McInally: Oh god. Is that even a review then?
[29:06] Andrew DeWolf: It's no.
[29:09] Katelyn Robinson: It's good, but here's a better idea.
[29:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[29:13] Jess McInally: Okay.
[29:14] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[29:14] Jess McInally: So we'll move on to the next one.
[29:16] Andrew DeWolf: Steve Murray of Broadway World said, all the stars have aligned in Theatre Works Engaging World Premiere of Pride and Prejudice.
[29:25] Katelyn Robinson: A musical that re-energizes and greatly enhances Jane Austen's popular romantic tale of manner set in the Regency Period of England.
[29:36] Andrew DeWolf: There's a convergence of shining talents at work here from top down.
[29:40] Katelyn Robinson: The Tony winning creative team from Theatre Works, the Excellent Direction from Departing Artistic Director Robert Kelly, a superior ensemble cast, and the marvelous score and script by Tony nominee Paul Gordon.
[29:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that was positive.
[29:58] Katelyn Robinson: That is basically all the big reviewers that we're gonna be talking about.
[30:02] Andrew DeWolf: But we agree with most of what they have to say.
[30:04] Katelyn Robinson: Um we've got one more from Sam Hurrit of Mercury News.
[30:09] Andrew DeWolf: Do you want to dive into that, Brie?
[30:10] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah.
[30:11] Andrew DeWolf: This is me being fair. I added a negative one.
[30:14] Katelyn Robinson: Okay.
[30:14] Andrew DeWolf: Let's see. You know, maybe it's constructive.
[30:17] Katelyn Robinson: Maybe.
[30:17] Andrew DeWolf: We'll see.
[30:18] Katelyn Robinson: Sam Hurrit of Mercury News said there's no particular reason why Pride and Prejudice shouldn't be a musical, but this latest version doesn't make much a case for it being one either.
[30:29] Andrew DeWolf: With some assuming tunes of phrase, the songs are tolerable ways to pass the time waiting for each song to end and the sparkling dialogue to resume.
[30:39] Katelyn Robinson: But few are particularly engaging in their own right.
[30:43] Andrew DeWolf: One notable exception is Sister Jane's touching stoic lament, a man of my acquaintance.
[30:49] Katelyn Robinson: So negative, but like I like this one song.
[30:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[30:54] Katelyn Robinson: Sounds like Mr. Dorsey wrote that.
[30:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[30:57] Katelyn Robinson: Oh my god. See, now very naive. Very negative towards the music.
[31:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[31:02] Katelyn Robinson: I don't know. The music was okay.
[31:04] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I suppose I could agree if someone said that they didn't like it that much.
[31:09] Katelyn Robinson: It's definitely a style. You have to like that kind of musical.
[31:12] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, that's why I was like when I said like I like Roger and Hammerstein, where it's just that very quirky, it's very lighthearted.
[31:20] Katelyn Robinson: Sometimes you're gonna get really, really nice string accompaniment, and sometimes it's gonna be a little light on it.
[31:24] Andrew DeWolf: I would say it keeps it simple because it wants you to more be engaged with the lyrics in the story, less so about being this big giant production, uh, where everyone like there's like 10 dancers coming out behind her or something like that.
[31:38] Katelyn Robinson: It's more I felt about the lyrics, so that's what I more paid attention to.
[31:43] Andrew DeWolf: So I thought I would have to disagree with them, and I think it was kind of backhanded of them to say, like, oh, I don't think this musical proved that it's necessary.
[31:52] Katelyn Robinson: I was like, that's so rude.
[31:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was like, your opinion, I guess, but wow, okay.
[31:58] Katelyn Robinson: That's like your opinion.
[32:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[32:01] Katelyn Robinson: Alright, alright. You guys ready for the most your opinion thing you will ever hear about?
[32:06] Jess McInally: Jess, why is there an essay on my screen here?
[32:11] Katelyn Robinson: In the Amazon reviews of this musical.
[32:14] Jess McInally: Like, there's like four views, and then you've got this long essay, and this is a shortened version.
[32:18] Katelyn Robinson: I've cut this down, and I'll read it just to get it out because I have a voice I want to use for this.
[32:23] Jess McInally: But I imagine someone scratched like before on their wet wattpad, like getting really angry about the Pride Prejudice musical.
[32:32] Katelyn Robinson: So um, so I've trimmed this down a little bit, so this isn't the full word-for-word thing they wrote.
[32:37] Jess McInally: So I'm hoping I'm not framing anything badly.
[32:39] Katelyn Robinson: Um, but this is from Amazon reviewer Julie L, who said, Let me preface every criticism I have by saying some people will really love this musical, and that clearly it is a newly developed act piece that needs time to season.
[32:52] Jess McInally: I recognize this and only write this out of personal disappointment as a musical theater actress and an avid admirer of Pride and Prejudice.
[33:00] Katelyn Robinson: Because I think this could have been a really wonderful success, but their approach seems to have been faulty.
[33:06] Jess McInally: With that being said, the acting music and certain moments in the dialect are nothing to write home about.
[33:11] Katelyn Robinson: I am very much disappointed.
[33:13] Jess McInally: Now she goes through each character.
[33:15] Katelyn Robinson: Oh no.
[33:17] Jess McInally: First, Elizabeth.
[33:18] Katelyn Robinson: Elizabeth's person was much too feminist for my liking.
[33:22] Jess McInally: Instead of allowing her to simply be a strong, capable woman who took center stage and was confident in her own capabilities and smarts, etcetera.
[33:30] Katelyn Robinson: She had to be an obnoxious in certain areas, and it was a little preachy.
[33:35] Jess McInally: Alright?
[33:36] Katelyn Robinson: Oh no. I didn't see that, but let's see what they said about Darcy.
[33:40] Jess McInally: I enjoyed seeing his change from act one to act two, but the songs went from did not match his character at all.
[33:45] Katelyn Robinson: Also, he seems to be much more of a personal reflection kind of guy, not a rock tunes kind of guy.
[33:51] Jess McInally: Of course he opens up in act two, but the music was just not written for his character.
[33:56] Katelyn Robinson: Oh wow.
[33:57] Jess McInally: That was very personal.
[33:59] Katelyn Robinson: We got we got more a very particular interpretation of this, and they don't want anyone to stray from it.
[34:06] Jess McInally: Don't mess with my Pride Prejudice.
[34:07] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah.
[34:09] Jess McInally: I don't think Julie got the part.
[34:12] Katelyn Robinson: She's a little smoothie.
[34:18] Jess McInally: This was way too feminist for my liking.
[34:21] Katelyn Robinson: Trump 2024.
[34:23] Jess McInally: Oh no, no, no.
[34:26] Katelyn Robinson: Alright, music. Pretty much all the music was disjointed and took you out of the story.
[34:31] Jess McInally: The musical score was definitely a switch.
[34:33] Katelyn Robinson: I see what they were trying to do, but it wasn't executed very well.
[34:37] Jess McInally: The lyrics were also quite badly written.
[34:40] Katelyn Robinson: The rhyming was all off, and the actual musicality was not harmonious.
[34:44] Jess McInally: The score didn't have anything catchy about it.
[34:47] Katelyn Robinson: Nothing really classy in this musical, as I expected, seeing as it is a classic story.
[34:53] Jess McInally: What?
[34:53] Katelyn Robinson: What?
[34:55] Jess McInally: Maybe the score not having catchy, like maybe I could see that.
[35:00] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, no, I would say there was probably like maybe two or three songs that I would consider like catchy as I would like listen to it on my free time and not watching the musical again.
[35:11] Andrew DeWolf: Uh not harmonious though.
[35:13] Katelyn Robinson: I mean, that's that's a lie.
[35:15] Jess McInally: What do you mean by that?
[35:16] Katelyn Robinson: That's just I mean.
[35:21] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god, so the acting.
[35:23] Katelyn Robinson: Did anyone else notice the hands?
[35:25] Jess McInally: Elizabeth overused her hands and it totally distracted me.
[35:28] Katelyn Robinson: Anyways, that might just be me.
[35:30] Jess McInally: As an acting note, it is really wonderful in a fast-paced show like this to take a moment when acting to think and respond.
[35:37] Katelyn Robinson: Moments of silence between characters draws out tension and a more tangible relationship.
[35:42] Jess McInally: This happened once, and I wanted more, but I was even too short then.
[35:48] Katelyn Robinson: There was too much going on, they needed more focus and allow for more moments of space to really draw in the audience.
[35:54] Jess McInally: Just air dead air, you know.
[35:57] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, let's can we can we schedule a bit more dead air on the stage, please?
[36:04] Jess McInally: Can we have some time where they just sit there and don't do anything, please? Thank you.
[36:09] Katelyn Robinson: I think she thought she was watching an actual movie and then realized too late that it was a stage musical.
[36:15] Jess McInally: I I don't understand what she was looking for exactly.
[36:18] Katelyn Robinson: What are you talking about?
[36:18] Jess McInally: She's an actress herself.
[36:21] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, oh my god.
[36:23] Jess McInally: Alright, she's got her final thesis statement to wrap this all up.
[36:27] Katelyn Robinson: Looking forward to it.
[36:28] Jess McInally: I am overall very disappointed with this musical.
[36:31] Katelyn Robinson: Now I have no hate for the story, what the directors were trying to do, or the thesbians, but the execution was less than stunning.
[36:39] Jess McInally: There is so much to work with, and I am very sad to see it take on a beloved classical story go in such a trendy, flaky way.
[36:47] Katelyn Robinson: The reason that it is a classic is that people are transformed into that world, not jolted out of it with rock music.
[36:54] Jess McInally: Sorry again for the long-winded review, but if you're looking for some real quality musicals, check out Phantom of the Opera, Wicked, Bandstand, etc.
[37:06] Katelyn Robinson: Oh.
[37:06] Jess McInally: I mean.
[37:08] Katelyn Robinson: Well.
[37:09] Jess McInally: Check out, go check out Phantom, which is not at all a rock musical.
[37:13] Katelyn Robinson: I was gonna say, wait a minute, the whole time about rock music, and I was like, uh, okay.
[37:19] Jess McInally: But yeah, check out Phantom and Wicked, which definitely aren't that those are classics.
[37:25] Katelyn Robinson: Get the harpsichord, baby.
[37:28] Jess McInally: What rock music did she hear in this musical?
[37:31] Katelyn Robinson: I'm like trying to think of like she heard a guitar one time and she was like, oh, it's the Beatles all over again.
[37:38] Jess McInally: It is like alternative rock, but it's not like super distracting.
[37:41] Katelyn Robinson: No, I wouldn't exactly call this like Phantom or like uh Headwake and the Angry Inch.
[37:47] Jess McInally: Like it wasn't exactly like in my face, like loud punk sounding or very operatic electric guitars.
[37:54] Katelyn Robinson: It was very like there's a mostly string accompaniment with like some acoustic guitars.
[37:59] Jess McInally: I I did she want like an actual like Beethoven style accompaniment, like tripsichord and and like uh like a string quartet.
[38:08] Katelyn Robinson: Like what did you like?
[38:09] Jess McInally: What do you want?
[38:11] Katelyn Robinson: I I think he's Yes I think you skipped over my favorite part.
[38:17] Jess McInally: Oh, what was your favorite part?
[38:18] Katelyn Robinson: I I tried to show it.
[38:19] Jess McInally: The singing part?
[38:20] Katelyn Robinson: Okay, I'm gonna be a single thing.
[38:21] Jess McInally: The singing part.
[38:22] Katelyn Robinson: I'll bring up the singing part.
[38:23] Jess McInally: I I will reinterpretate it.
[38:26] Katelyn Robinson: Um ready?
[38:28] Jess McInally: Are you ready?
[38:29] Katelyn Robinson: This is like literally right before it.
[38:31] Jess McInally: Um, her notes on the singing, because I cut a lot out of it.
[38:34] Katelyn Robinson: I noticed Elizabeth was flat.
[38:36] Jess McInally: Now I am a singer, so I completely understand a bad day, and I would never want to drag her down because of an off day.
[38:43] Katelyn Robinson: I truly think it was because of the high belting that happens when it really doesn't need to happen.
[38:49] Jess McInally: I am very tired of consonant mixing and belting within the musical theater world.
[38:54] Katelyn Robinson: There is nothing to be ashamed of. If you are a legit soprano, please, it is much more appealing to the ears to sound nice.
[39:01] Jess McInally: But that being said, occasionally belting at the right time to bring punch to a really uh add to a musical because it is a little spice.
[39:10] Katelyn Robinson: But constant belting is dangerous for singers, and honestly, obnoxious as an audience member.
[39:17] Jess McInally: But you know, watch Phantom.
[39:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, go watch Phantom though.
[39:21] Jess McInally: There's no belting at all.
[39:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, Wicked is not known for belting at all.
[39:25] Jess McInally: There is no belting in Wicked.
[39:27] Andrew DeWolf: No, no.
[39:27] Jess McInally: No, well, they do it the right amount.
[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: This one way overboard.
[39:31] Jess McInally: Yeah, you can Sadina Manzel can never belt.
[39:34] Andrew DeWolf: That's the reason why you have Adina Menzel.
[39:36] Jess McInally: Of course.
[39:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[39:37] Katelyn Robinson: Um what?
[39:39] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[39:40] Katelyn Robinson: There really wasn't that much belting in this.
[39:42] Jess McInally: I would say I thought it I mean, was I always a fan of wherever it was placed? No, but it never was like a terrible distraction. It was usually to pinpoint an emotional point in a song. I feel like if you compare this show to a lot of other shows, it's more subdued than a lot of modern shows.
[40:02] Andrew DeWolf: There was one moment that took me out of it, and I can see the argument for it where I laughed at it. It's like right after I think the start of act one or act two, and she's getting the letter from Darcy, and he's explaining his past with uh Wickham. And he's like, like, he's a great terrible man that's done me a horrible danger. It was a long time ago! Like he just goes from like normal speaking to like high-pitched wailing. And I was like, oh, okay.
[40:28] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, honestly, the that letter execution, I I get it because they had to like kind of break it down and simplify it for a song. It did come off. I'm like, wow, anyone who's never read the book or seen an adaptation will think he's just kind of overreacting and is being way too protective. But what I mean, what actually happens is he tells her, like, oh no, yeah, he uh gambled all his money away. Yes, he does mention that. But then he's like, but he colluded with her like maid to get her alone so that he could whisk her away the same thing that he does to uh uh the uh Liz's sister, and uh he finds out at the last minute right when they're about to elope, and then obviously he's like, Well, I'll pay you off, and then that was what made him leave. Uh but yeah, so the way they simplified it was by him screaming with passion at you know uh Wickham's face, which was kind of funny.
[41:22] Jess McInally: Honestly, the only time I was taken out of anyone, it wasn't even a song, it was when Liz gets uh the letter from Jane about her sister running away, and he's supposed to be like comforting her, but he like screams at her instead. He's like, Well, what are they doing about it? Like, why are you yelling at her?
[41:39] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, it almost I kind of was like, Wait, is he just really mad about the situation? Or is he like trying to make her feel better? It's hard to say.
[41:49] Jess McInally: Yeah, it was the only part that took me out. I was like, Oh, alright, well, relax.
[41:55] Andrew DeWolf: How did you skip this accents part here? This is this is classic.
[42:00] Katelyn Robinson: Why don't you read this one?
[42:02] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. Uh accents, and this is a one line. Uh Lady Catherine, not Kath Uh Ren. Diction is very important for music theater, but you can overdo it sometimes.
[42:14] Jess McInally: Who did she write this review for?
[42:18] Katelyn Robinson: What I I don't even have words for that.
[42:23] Andrew DeWolf: I okay. You mispronounced the word, guys. Throw it away.
[42:29] Jess McInally: Wait till you don't like mispronunciations. Wait till you watch Phantom.
[42:33] Andrew DeWolf: God forbid if you're French.
[42:36] Jess McInally: On that note, let's go into a mid-show announcement.
[42:44] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Andrew, tell us about Patreon and who's supporting us.
[42:53] Jess McInally: Oh boy, Patreon is uh where you can go if you'd like to give us some money and get some extra perks. I mean, we have uh commentaries, we have uh the Gallivant podcast going on right now where we're talking about all the Gallivant episodes. Me and Brie are gonna do a bunch of commentary soon. We're gonna do I think we're doing the Cheetah Girls coming up. That that's gonna be a good thing.
[43:13] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not invited to the Cheetah Girls.
[43:16] Jess McInally: Uh oh, whatever. I mean, if you had a free moment in your life, you'd be welcome, but you don't, so it's me and Brie watching the Cheetah Girls.
[43:25] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, whatever.
[43:28] Jess McInally: And also I'm jealous. Video versions of these podcasts. So you can see Kate's face right now as she's laughing at us goofing about.
[43:36] Katelyn Robinson: There you go.
[43:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, exactly. Highly recommended. In fact, Kate just recommended you joining our patriot Patreon. Like I saw it on her.
[43:45] Katelyn Robinson: Don't put words in in other people's mouths.
[43:47] Andrew DeWolf: You see it in her eyes.
[43:49] Katelyn Robinson: Fine. Don't put words in other people's eyes.
[43:54] Jess McInally: Oh no. Alright.
[43:57] Andrew DeWolf: That's not what I said.
[44:00] Jess McInally: Our current patrons. And here we go. Let's see if I can pronounce these all correctly in one. Oh, we got a bunch of real train wreck names at the end, so good luck.
[44:09] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna get them. Here we go. Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Max Loonig, Lighton Accles, Danielle Rennox, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Taskier, Fire of September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Haley Murray, B Way, Flicks, Lathaniel Stacey, Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Irigale Drew Whiter, Christine Malmadell, Cole Birchfield, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanels, Heck You, I go by Elijah now, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Tablam, Kyle Summers, Janay C, Christina Francis, Liz Lim, Cory Wilmarth, Alison Staller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, John Vanels, Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Wait in the Wings, Lady Malvolia, Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Robert Benjamin, Rochelle T, Jessica Tubas, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, Just Cass, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Hayden Wilder, Katie uh McDonough, McDono, something like that.
[45:12] Jess McInally: McDonna.
[45:12] Andrew DeWolf: McDonough, McDonough, that yeah, that makes much more sense. Uh Genki Geist, uh, Stacas, Timothy Keys, and oh, here's here's the new ones. Uh Jeffrey, uh Machado, uh Jacqueline Spring, and Toon Von Essen.
[45:30] Jess McInally: Great job. They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals to Cheese and keep Brie employed because we love keeping Bree employed, because I'm sick of editing podcasts for the rest of my life. Um, so if you would like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, such as patron only commentaries, our episodes a day early, video episodes, and a bunch of other crap. Come join us over at Patreon. Also, we've got merch. Um at this point you should have a brand new t-shirt there that says um stinkaroo to reference last week's Wizard of Oz episode. Um so you can buy that. Alright, let's get back to the music. Let's go.
[46:14] ♪ Musical number: "Happiness in Marriage" ♪
[46:39] Jess McInally: So the opening number happiness in marriage, which has become a repetitive theme. I think it does a really good job of setting up the world like of how important marriage is in this world. Um, it almost feels like it would suit better like a little women, because marriage being important is much more of a strict character piece in that, where it's kind of like a thing that is important but not really the driving force of this story.
[47:01] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. They they they sort of framed the story around that though, in in this musical. Maybe that's not the way it is in the book, but it sort of feels like it fits here.
[47:10] Katelyn Robinson: I guess. Uh yeah, I could I could agree with a a bit of that. Uh I mean in most of her books, they are all centered around um a proposal gone bad, or trying to get a proposal, or someone sh almost forces you into a proposal. So it is usually a motif without her books. I think they tried to put in the musical a little bit less focus on it than it is in the book, but I think it's always still prevalent there. It's it's sort of the situational plot that kind of gets them into all the misunderstandings, meets new characters through that. Um I do like that they add in uh Liz making more of a big deal that she's probably she makes like a reference to taming of the shrew. Like she's like, Oh, I'm probably not.
I'm gonna be a spinster, most likely, because I'm too much for people. Uh so I I also think this sets up the rules of the musical is trying to set up where Elizabeth can talk to you, other people will talk at you, but not directly to you. Where, like, yeah, the fourth wall will be broken through the form of letters and Darcy will sing his emotions out to you. But Elizabeth is talking to you.
[48:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[48:25] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, I liked that kind of breaking the fourth wall for her. Because it, I mean, I guess they were trying they were inspired by that the book is narrated by her. So they wanted you to feel as involved as you do in the book, where she's like almost like talking to her friend in a way. I I really like it when the main character talks to me. It's like in Fiddler on the Roof. It's it's just it's very comforting. I like it.
[48:48] Jess McInally: Or flea bag.
[48:50] Katelyn Robinson: I like it freaks me out when other people start breaking the fourth wall and point out the fact she's breaking the fourth wall. I it it I jumped when Sanders got did that. Because the a season had happened and that wasn't allowed to happen.
[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm.
[49:07] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm.
[49:07] Katelyn Robinson: No, I I love a good creative usage of breaking the fourth wall. Uh I I would say, like, I like that, and I mean, not that I love the movie, but uh it kind of also reminds me of Alfie or High Fidelity, where uh the character is addressing you, you're like almost like a friend. He's like explaining to you like what's going on, and that's kind of what she does, but even more so in her thoughts. Because she'll basically describe to you certain characters, you're like, Oh yeah, this is this is Lady Catherine. Yeah. Um I do like that a lot. Um all right. Uh I think the opening number is really good. Not the most memorable one, but let's dive into the I Want song for Elizabeth, which is Headstrong.
[49:47] ♪ Musical number: "Headstrong" ♪
[50:33] Andrew DeWolf: I wasn't the hugest fan of that song. It felt very Disney. I want more. You know, it it was okay. It wasn't nearly the reason why those sort of songs, like in those Disney cartoon films, were because they're very, they're the big number, the big solo. You get to really show off your pipes there. And this one was it kinda did, but it it was still very I wouldn't say flat, it was just very much more subdued, and so I don't think it hit the way I think they were hoping it would.
[51:03] Jess McInally: I mean, I think that there's no drama for Elizabeth yet at that point. So it's more like an I am song, like I am steadfast and headstrong and all these things. Whereas a proper I want song should suggest a need. Whereas what would Elizabeth's need here be, which she has none. She's pretty complacent living with her song. The need is to stay headstrong. I feel like that is the struggle in this song where it wants to be an I want song, but Elizabeth in the book and in the story as of yet, doesn't want nothing.
[51:37] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah.
[51:39] Andrew DeWolf: No, not at all.
[51:41] Jess McInally: Which I think is more the issue. But Jane, like she could have sung a song about what she wants for her sister and her family and what that like kind of like reflection in where it's like she doesn't want anything, but her family wants this, and I want to make them happy. But Elizabeth, even in the books, is like her her she's a daddy's girl, and daddy ain't gonna make her do nothing she don't want to.
[52:05] Katelyn Robinson: No, I would have to agree with that. I think the instead of Liz singing a headstrong song, it should have been an opening number for Jane, so that you kind of know where she's at. Because she really does want to find, not just get married, she wants to be in love and find a nice man who'll treat her right.
[52:22] Andrew DeWolf: I was expecting more stuff with Jane in this. They kind of hype her up with the mother character, like talking about her all the time. And then she doesn't really do anything.
[52:34] Katelyn Robinson: No. I don't know if they're trying to keep true to the book, because she never does, well, she never talks back to anyone in the book, but so when they added in that running joke, I thought it was gonna have a payoff where she finally like tells off her mom or something like that, but it doesn't happen.
[52:50] Andrew DeWolf: No, you just they keep doing it like, oh, I'm right here, I'm right here, and it's like alright, and then it just that's it, it's over.
[52:58] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, and she would pay off.
[53:00] Andrew DeWolf: You're right. She gets with the guy that can't talk to her, and there you go.
[53:05] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah. It seemed more like a payoff for him to finally speak up, but it didn't really work on the same level with her.
[53:12] Andrew DeWolf: It was just more like she's finally asked him, like, well, and that was about it. I mean, Bingley's bar barely a character in this.
[53:21] Katelyn Robinson: Like in every other version, he is a character. He's a goofball, weirdo, well-intentioned himbo. Really easily manipulated, but he's that.
[53:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. And here he's just guy, guy, guy interested in Jane and Jane interested in him.
[53:36] Katelyn Robinson: I think his songs were probably also my least favorite, just because I just didn't care enough about him as a character, so whenever he would sing about his thoughts, it's like uh that's nice, but I really don't know you that well.
[53:49] Andrew DeWolf: I guess so. So why don't we move on to uh Darcy's I Am song, which is Bravado.
[53:57] Katelyn Robinson: She's taking the bravado out of me.
[54:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I'm a fool behaving like a schoolboy. Why would she consider case that she finds bitter or can be done? Opinions happy in fashion. She can badly sign me. There is not a child, Miss Bennett that I would allow the world to know how it came to be.
[54:32] Katelyn Robinson: You've taken all the bluster out of me.
[54:38] Andrew DeWolf: Not the most subtle song in the world.
[54:41] Katelyn Robinson: No.
[54:42] Andrew DeWolf: I you know, when he first started off as a character in this, I was a little worried because he did he did come off a bit strong in his song and in his manner of speech. So I wasn't sure how I was gonna feel about him.
[54:58] Katelyn Robinson: I would say his later songs are much, much better. This one's just kind of like alright, I get it. They're establishing that he's kind of a dick and he does he I like the twist that he doesn't he kind of establishes he's afraid to care in a way, but doesn't really see it as such, just because he feels like he's you know what it reminded me of here that that song felt like a song for her other book, like Sense and Sensibility, where the Colonel who's been burned before, the older rich guy, where Darcy hasn't actually been burned by a woman before, more so just a best friend who tried to steal his sister. That was about it. So it was a decent song, but it didn't really establish who Darcy actually is in the book.
[55:42] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, I kind of just got the impression that he's just a jerk.
[55:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Which sort of makes it a little bit weird when suddenly he's not. Like he's just like, oh, well, now I love someone, so I'm not jerk anymore.
[55:54] Katelyn Robinson: That does happen in the book. He he's immediately spitten with Liz. Like after he calls her ugly, he's smitten with her because he realizes very quickly that she knows what he said.
[56:05] Andrew DeWolf: Would you agree with me, Kate? That I feel like Darcy's dickishness has been toned down in the musical. Um, because compared to like the 2006 movie and especially the Colin Firth mini-series, I feel like he's much less of an emo angry boy here, and much more of just kind of normal guy that's a little bit of a dick sometimes.
[56:26] Katelyn Robinson: He's a lot more upfront about his feelings. He's a lot less awkward and distant, how he is like in the book or in the Colin Firth version. Even um, I would say he's on par with like Matthew McFadden from the Joe Wright version.
[56:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. That one's even I would say even a much more nicer version of Darcy, where he's just sort of like this adoricable, very sweet but like super super awkward guy. Here he's like kind of like more hot-tempered.
[56:58] Katelyn Robinson: I've never seen such an aggressive Darcy before. Um, but he was like at times his battle of wits with her were a little more warm than they are in the book. Whereas like you can never tell what he's thinking, but I guess with the musical, especially when they're gonna do his songs, you constantly know what he's thinking, and he's very he's just much more forward. Like when they're when they're doing that little dance, uh, he the way that they even lead into that, he kind of just makes fun of her. He's like, Well, I figure if we're gonna argue, you might as well dance. Like, yeah, he's a maybe it's just the actor's like innate charm or not trying to put on like a kind of more off-putting persona, which might be a little bit harder to digest being in a room with them and having to see it and having to sing. Um, so maybe that was a choice. Um, it was just something I felt where I'm like, I kind of feel like they're tipping their head of like ability a little too much toward him in act one.
[57:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I could see with some of especially in the very, very beginning of Act One with him. I would agree with that, especially when you get that first song from him where they immediately want to go right out the gate. I'm a dick and rich, and I don't trust any of these women's in this ballroom. It's like okay, and then there's a switch where he sees Liz and he's like, okay, maybe I like someone here, you know.
[58:18] Katelyn Robinson: Or I'm shot.
[58:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[58:21] Katelyn Robinson: I did really I laughed out loud at that though. He has like a panic attack. Oh god, I have a crush. It was very high school, it was very funny.
[58:32] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, let's talk about the one that that one critic said was the only good song, a man of my acquaintance. Which I love this just because it characterizes Jane a lot more and kind of explains what she's going through, which no other version takes the time to do.
[58:46] Katelyn Robinson: He's really nothing special. Just a man of my acquaintance. And if I had an error of fancy, no one could blame me for that. I had my results. And his eyes always followed me. Eyes always follow me. Now he's a man of my acquaintance. Nothing more than it is, and it will never be more than it is. And will say hello in passing. And I won't regret how it has to be, and I'll wish him well in life, graciously. He's just a man of acquaintance.
[59:49] Andrew DeWolf: I would say it's probably one of the least memorable songs for me. I'm actually trying to remember, I can kind of remember bits of it. It didn't stick out to me as much, but I did enjoy it when I was re-watching it this morning. I was like, oh, that's right. I remember the song now, and I didn't remember it upon initial my first initial viewing.
[1:00:08] Katelyn Robinson: Which makes sense. It is kind of an unassuming song. Um I just appreciate it because it does something that I haven't seen in other versions.
[1:00:15] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, no. Any chance to give Jane much more depth. Uh, I like even though we said I don't think there was a proper payoff with her character. This is probably the most in-depth Jane that I've seen out of all the adaptations. There's always been hints, but this has probably been the most full-fledged version of Jane I've ever seen.
[1:00:35] Katelyn Robinson: And I think it's also the most different version of Elizabeth, where she it is a much more caustic performance, but I think it works very well in like she almost almost feels like she's got a vlog. Like that kind of vibe.
[1:00:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[1:00:51] Katelyn Robinson: She also plays it a bit older. Uh at the start of the book, uh, I believe Elizabeth is just 18, and she acts like an 18-year-old, you know, precocious, thinks she knows everything, but she does know her place. Uh, she doesn't always talk back to her elders, it's a little more reserved. But here she acts, uh she plays it a lot older and is a lot more open with how she feels. She's a lot more quick to, you know, have a sassy comeback at someone than she would in the book.
[1:01:14] Andrew DeWolf: She's a lot more feministy than I would like.
[1:01:23] Katelyn Robinson: Feministy. Sounds like anything.
[1:01:26] Andrew DeWolf: She's riding the SJW train.
[1:01:29] Katelyn Robinson: Oh no.
[1:01:30] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.
[1:01:31] Katelyn Robinson: We're not going there, Jess.
[1:01:33] Andrew DeWolf: We're not going there. We're not touching that.
[1:01:35] Katelyn Robinson: You know what? That that's fair. Um, I think there's only one more song worth talking about, and that is Not the Man That I Know, which is a very bouncy number. It almost feels like a Beatles song when I kind of think about it. It kind of has like that tinkly, like bum bump bouncy feel of like an early Beatles song.
[1:01:37] Andrew DeWolf: Not the man that I know. He's nothing like that. It is in his way. That's not the man that I know. He's not well behaved. He's never been nice. He's never been fair. Or have I misjudged him? That's not the man that I know. He must be confused. He must have it wrong. That's not the man that I know. No, surely not him. He's never been kind. He's never been war. Or am I an era?
[1:02:35] Katelyn Robinson: No, I love this song the most. I thought it was the most engaging. I loved the flow. I love how it starts off with one meaning, and then by the time that you get to the end of it, she's completely. It was a really good transition from her being like, Do I like Darcy? No, I can't like him. And then she's like, I might like him. Uh I liked that transition. It kind of reminded me of uh Won't Say I'm in Love from the Disney's Hercules movie, where it starts off like, I'm in denial. No, I don't like this guy, and then she's like, Okay, I like this guy.
[1:03:10] Andrew DeWolf: It's the same type of song, yeah. I think it does what most musical theater songs should do. Take a character from one place to another, whether it be like physically, mentally, or like character-wise, a different interpretation. I think it's one of the better ones. Um, almost on par with like something like painting her portrait from Paul Gordon's Jane Eyre, which is like Jane like hyping herself up to think she's great, but then calling right back down. We're like, Nope, nope, nope. I'm not gonna be able to ever be good enough for him. It's kind of like that where it's like, he's trash, maybe he isn't. Okay, I like him. Oh, I'm jealous.
[1:03:44] Katelyn Robinson: I really I personally am a huge fan of the book Jane Eyre. That's another one I've seen almost every adaptation of, but I saw that he did a Jane Eyre musical, but I don't think it's really available anywhere apart from the music that you can like stream. I think that's about it. When I had him on for the interview, I kind of gushed about how much I loved Jane Eyre, and he was he said, Yeah, that's gonna be another one I'm hoping to film soon. So when that happens, Kate, I hope you'll come back on to talk about that because I've got so much Jane Eyre knowledge in the back of my head, as that's the one I've seen almost every adaptation for.
[1:04:16] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, I love Jane Eyre.
[1:04:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I am a big stand of Jane Eyre. That's probably my favorite classic novel, apart from anything from Jane Austen. But it did kind of remind me of that that sort of staple you see in a good musical, where you see the transition that you start off in denial and then you kind of have to face your own feelings. Um and also it was just a very catchy tune. I would say it had the better um I would say what was the composed, the most easiest to listen to. Uh, apart from the um I don't really think there was any other songs that really stuck out to me the way that that song did in particular.
[1:04:54] Katelyn Robinson: I agree. I can see the argument there. Um, it's the least theater-y song, too, in my opinion. Maybe I feel like that while acting as a theater song and like having an effective storytelling, feels the least theatery. There's not as much strings, it's not as much of uh I'm diving into the abyss of my emotions, and more like, wow, like it could be a pop song in and of itself, kind of.
[1:05:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, kind of. Uh I would say uh other than that one, I r I oddly liked the uh the really creepy Mr.
[1:05:26] Katelyn Robinson: Uh just mostly from the accompaniment of the women singing behind him. That I really liked that flow. It was just something very quirky, but also something disturbing about it. So you're just kind of like, oh, where's the song going? Uh and also Liz refusing Mr. Collins too. Uh I would say of like good string accompaniment that would be those the two are the strongest that happened in the middle. But yeah, the strongest one for me that I enjoyed the most that I would definitely listen to without re-watching the musical would be the man that I know. I think that's a great way to wrap that up. Wrap up the songs on our highest note.
[1:06:04] Jess McInally: Um, all right. Now I want to know everyone's overall thoughts on Pride and Prejudice, the musical and their cheese rating. I'm gonna force Andrew to go first so you can kind of guess what our cheese rating structure is.
[1:06:21] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um it's not like the best thing I've ever seen or anything like that, but it's a very simple show that is effective, and there's a really good film version of which isn't that common. Um, so I would definitely recommend seeking this out if you can find the film version of it.
[1:06:40] Katelyn Robinson: Is there somewhere they can find this?
[1:06:41] Andrew DeWolf: It's yes, I watched it on Amazon.
[1:06:43] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, it's just on Amazon.
[1:06:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, right. Subscribe to Broadway HD, it's there too.
[1:06:49] Katelyn Robinson: Oh, excellent.
[1:06:50] Andrew DeWolf: I would definitely recommend watching this. I think it is an effective show. It does a really good job with what it's trying to do, and it doesn't uh overstay its welcome at all. It's uh a nice uh two hours, that's all. I liked it. I enjoyed it. This musical's a breeze. I'm gonna give it like uh like a cheese platter.
[1:07:09] Katelyn Robinson: Like uh you'd get at like a fancy party because there's quite a few fancy parties in this.
[1:07:14] Andrew DeWolf: Or there's at least one that I remember, and I think there's probably more, but yeah.
[1:07:18] Katelyn Robinson: There's a lot more in the book.
[1:07:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. So many dinner parties, dancing. Picture a fancy platter and you got some grapes on there, and you got some simple cheeses and some bread. Uh and you pick from that and it's good. Some grey coupon, like just on there just because fancy.
[1:07:37] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah.
[1:07:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's something fancy, you know.
[1:07:40] Jess McInally: All right. Uh Kate, what's your overall thoughts and your cheese rating?
[1:07:43] Katelyn Robinson: I I would say this was a solid musical, speaking from someone who does enjoy musicals but isn't an avid diehard fan. I would say this is a perfect musical to watch if you're just sitting at home and you want to, you know, have like a fun little musical to watch. It's only like only a little bit over two hours. Uh I also would even say you could watch it while you're doing chores, because it's just so especially if you read the book already. It's such a soothing, very light hearted musical. So it's uh I I would say as far as a cheese rating.
[1:08:18] Katelyn Robinson: Um, I would give this like that that block of cheese you want to impress your friends with, but you totally got it for like five bucks at Trader Joe's, and then you like bring all like the little fancy crackers out, and it's just because it's got all these different little flavors to it, but it's really just the same block of cheese that you've had like a million times before, but it's a comforting kind of you know, flavor.
[1:08:43] Andrew DeWolf: I like that cheese rating.
[1:08:43] Katelyn Robinson: It's something that you're used to. You're not expecting anything new. It's just a nice flavor.
[1:08:43] Jess McInally: I like that cheese rating. That's a good one. Actually, a really real the guests always bring the best cheese ratings. I'm not gonna lie.
[1:08:50] Andrew DeWolf: Whoever ever brought cheese out for a party was uh when I I was sent chocolate cheese by Jess, and it it was a disaster. No one liked it.
[1:08:56] Jess McInally: I did do that. I did that.
[1:09:01] Katelyn Robinson: Oh my goodness.
[1:09:02] Jess McInally: It's good. It tastes like fudge.
[1:09:04] Katelyn Robinson: It it doesn't taste like cheese at all. It's just fudge.
[1:09:06] Andrew DeWolf: Interesting.
[1:09:07] Katelyn Robinson: It's basically fudge. I mean, it's cheese because of the way they make it.
[1:09:11] Jess McInally: Yeah, but it does. I don't have a problem with things that taste like other things.
[1:09:14] Katelyn Robinson: Like I don't like like pickle flavored popcorn or like anything like that, where I'm like, uh something like my brain can't compute.
[1:09:21] Jess McInally: It's like, wait, no, this isn't well, it doesn't look like cheese.
[1:09:25] Katelyn Robinson: It looks like fudge, it tastes like fudge, and they make it like cheese.
[1:09:29] Jess McInally: So it's it was very strange, and it didn't really work.
[1:09:37] Andrew DeWolf: I disagree. Chocolate cheese is great, and the proper response when someone sends you something is thank you.
[1:09:45] Katelyn Robinson: I did thank you.
[1:09:46] Jess McInally: My goodness.
[1:09:46] Katelyn Robinson: That was like a year ago now.
[1:09:48] Andrew DeWolf: Two years ago, my man.
[1:09:50] Katelyn Robinson: Two years ago cheese.
[1:09:53] Brianna Jones: Um, alright, Brie, how would you rate our discussion? How do you what do you think of that one?
[1:09:57] Brianna Jones: Well, you know, you guys gave it so much love, but my girl Julie really didn't have the same opinion as she's fair.
[1:10:06] Katelyn Robinson: So that's fair.
[1:10:08] Brianna Jones: You know, I'm torn here. I really I want Julie is an actress.
[1:10:12] Katelyn Robinson: So I'm not an actress.
[1:10:15] Brianna Jones: I I yeah, you're not an actress.
[1:10:16] Katelyn Robinson: I yeah, you know, I'm having a very hard time.
[1:10:19] Brianna Jones: You know, we've been friends for a while, but I'm having a really hard time deciding how to lean, you know, in this conversation.
[1:10:26] Brianna Jones: So the only cheese that I can think of is the cheese that I ate all the time in eighth grade.
[1:10:34] Brianna Jones: And in eighth grade, I saw Pride and Prejudice. And so that's gonna be that like, you know, melty craft cheese that you dip your pretzels in.
[1:10:42] Katelyn Robinson: Um, and in my case, I don't even know what that cheese is called.
[1:10:46] Andrew DeWolf: Plastic cheese?
[1:10:47] Brianna Jones: Do you know what I'm talking about?
[1:10:48] Andrew DeWolf: Government cheese.
[1:10:50] Brianna Jones: Just just the it's like the coloring.
[1:10:53] Brianna Jones: It's like the stuff they put on nachos.
[1:10:56] Katelyn Robinson: That you you like dip like the little crackers in.
[1:10:59] Brianna Jones: Like cheese that isn't cheese, but probably something else.
[1:11:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, like cheese you put on nachos.
[1:11:06] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[1:11:08] Brianna Jones: I'm gonna go with nacho cheese. But when you know, when I was in middle school, everyone would get the nacho cheese and the hot Cheetos, and they would dip the hot Cheetos and the Nacho cheese.
[1:11:19] Katelyn Robinson: So that is the most Michigan thing I have ever heard.
[1:11:22] Andrew DeWolf: That's the most Lincoln Park.
[1:11:25] Brianna Jones: I don't understand why you would do that, but like that is the most Detroit thing I have ever heard in my life.
[1:11:32] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, but I mean, that was um what I thought of when I thought of Pride and Prejudice because I think that was the last time I watched it was in eighth grade.
[1:11:40] Brianna Jones: So you should re-watch it.
[1:11:41] Katelyn Robinson: It's a good movie.
[1:11:43] Brianna Jones: I know I should rewatch it.
[1:11:44] Brianna Jones: I have a lot of things to do.
[1:11:45] Andrew DeWolf: Watch the musical, it's pretty good too.
[1:11:46] Katelyn Robinson: The musical, yes, the musical.
[1:11:48] Brianna Jones: We are a music.
[1:11:48] Katelyn Robinson: Not according to Julie.
[1:11:52] Brianna Jones: Look, Julie doesn't know what she's talking about.
[1:11:53] Katelyn Robinson: I'm sorry.
[1:11:54] Brianna Jones: Julie and I are friends on Amazon, okay?
[1:11:56] Katelyn Robinson: So I'm gonna find her, and we're gonna be friends on Facebook.
[1:12:00] Brianna Jones: We're gonna like each other.
[1:12:01] Jess McInally: Alright, Jess, what did you think?
[1:12:03] Jess McInally: Um I I like this show a lot. Um I wouldn't say it's good enough to be replacement value for the 2006 movie, but I also have a really deep connection to that 2006 movie. Um I like a lot of the songs. I really like the way it was shot. I think this is one of the best filmed stage musicals I have ever seen.
[1:12:22] Jess McInally: Um really, I hope that streaming musicals keeps going, especially during this pandemic times when we don't really know when we're gonna be in a theater together. Um we'll see when that happens. But I thought this was much better than I expected, and overall told the story very quick, concise, and I feel like I didn't lose any of the emotional potency of the story with it being condensed a bit.
[1:12:44] Jess McInally: And the songs work to push the story forward. It has very high highs, and it never gets bad. There's not a single like song where I'm like, this is really bad, and even like great musicals have that.
[1:12:55] Jess McInally: Um so the only cheese rating I can give it, um, is not particularly a cheese, but a title of a book. Um by Mary Jane Hathaway called Pride, Prejudice and Cheese Grits.
[1:13:09] Katelyn Robinson: Jane Austen takes the South.
[1:13:14] Jess McInally: Um, can I just read you what the description of this book is really quick?
[1:13:19] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah.
[1:13:20] Jess McInally: This hilarious Southern retelling of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice tells a story of two hard headed Civil War historians who find that first impressions can be deceiving.
[1:13:31] Katelyn Robinson: Wow, fall in love despite Mr. Darcy being uh a confederate.
[1:13:37] Jess McInally: Um it's uh Shelby Roswell, a Civil War historian and professor, is on a fast track to tenure. That is, until her new book is roasted by the famous historian ransom Fielding and a national review.
[1:13:50] Katelyn Robinson: Is that Julielle?
[1:13:51] Jess McInally: She wrote this book with her career stalled by a man she's never met. Shelby struggles to maintain her composure when she discovers that Fielding has taken taken a visiting professorship at her small southern college.
[1:14:03] Katelyn Robinson: Uh you know, uh I've seen weirder things. I watched there's I think it is on Amazon. There's a Mormon version of Pride and Prejudice called Pride and Prejudice a Latter Day Comedy.
[1:14:13] Jess McInally: It's does not sound nearly as fascinating as that, but uh it's not the worst thing I've ever heard.
[1:14:18] Katelyn Robinson: In the end, does Darcy know both Jane and Elizabeth?
[1:14:21] Jess McInally: Oh my god.
[1:14:22] Katelyn Robinson: If A just did that, he just marries all the sisters.
[1:14:25] Jess McInally: That that would have been really funny, but no, unfortunately, it's not what happens.
[1:14:30] Katelyn Robinson: That's a Mormon comedy.
[1:14:32] Jess McInally: Yes.
[1:14:33] Katelyn Robinson: It's just big love.
[1:14:34] Jess McInally: Oh goodness.
[1:14:37] Katelyn Robinson: Wow, that's a book.
[1:14:39] Jess McInally: Yeah, that's a book. Um with familiar and relatable characters and wit to spare, pride, prejudice, and cheese grits shows you that love can conquer all, especially when pride, prejudice, love, and cheese grips are involved.
[1:14:53] Katelyn Robinson: So yeah, okay.
[1:14:55] Jess McInally: You know what? Jess win. Fine, whatever.
[1:14:59] Katelyn Robinson: Um to get the library binding version, it's 34.95 on Amazon.
[1:15:04] Jess McInally: Wow.
[1:15:04] Katelyn Robinson: Yeah, I'm not I'm not doing that.
[1:15:06] Jess McInally: Does it give me cheese grits?
[1:15:08] Katelyn Robinson: Like, does it like cook it for me?
[1:15:10] Jess McInally: $34.
[1:15:11] Katelyn Robinson: Oh my god.
[1:15:12] Jess McInally: My God.
[1:15:13] Katelyn Robinson: Um, all right, Kate, thank you so much for coming on. I know you've got a lot of stuff in the internet. Chill away.
[1:15:21] Katelyn Robinson: Uh, you can find my content on YouTube under that movie chick. I like to do uh video essays surrounding female-led content.
[1:15:31] Katelyn Robinson: I also have a retro camp series where I discuss cancel TV shows and find out why. Sometimes for good reason.
[1:15:39] Katelyn Robinson: And I am also a co-producer, writer, and editor for Lost and Adaptation, or the channel Dom Noble, where we compare books to their adaptations, whether they are films or TV.
[1:15:51] Katelyn Robinson: And I am also on Twitter, underscore that movie chick. If you want to talk to me.
[1:15:57] Jess McInally: She's got a great Twitter. I I follow it, it's great.
[1:15:59] Andrew DeWolf: What's up, Andrew?
[1:16:01] Andrew DeWolf: Did we ever find out why they canceled Elf?
[1:16:03] Katelyn Robinson: I'm still I'm still waiting for answers.
[1:16:05] Andrew DeWolf: Elf.
[1:16:07] Katelyn Robinson: Could have gone on for another 10 years, you know?
[1:16:12] Andrew DeWolf: So much potential.
[1:16:15] Jess McInally: Alright, Kate. Thank you so much for coming on. And if you guys want more of our nonsense, you can find us on iTunes Spotify Stitcher. Um, we're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals with Cheese, Instagram Musicals of Cheese, YouTube Patriots Musicals with Cheese.
[1:16:29] Jess McInally: Patreon, we've got a bunch of new crap coming up there. Galvan Podcast. Me and Bree are gonna watch the Cheetah Girls and probably a bunch of other decoms.
[1:16:37] Jess McInally: Um, hopefully we're gonna introduce some guests. And also, how are you liking our Monday podcast, Make Me a Musical, where we make a musical in less than 30 minutes?
[1:16:45] Katelyn Robinson: I I think I think people really like that.
[1:16:48] Jess McInally: But to let us know if you want us to keep doing that.
[1:16:50] Katelyn Robinson: Um, yeah.
[1:16:51] Jess McInally: Um, our transcriptions are by Masha Litvin.
[1:16:55] Jess McInally: Um, our title card was created by Jolene Casco. Follow her on Instagram at Jolene Casco.
[1:17:00] Jess McInally: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Thank you, Juliet.
[1:17:03] Jess McInally: Our show is produced by the incredible, the beautiful, my favorite person in the world, Brianna Jones. We love you so much, Brianna. You do such a good job in keeping us all afloat.
[1:17:12] Jess McInally: Um, thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off yet. We know it'll happen one day, but it hasn't happened yet, so we're looking forward to the day.
[1:17:21] Jess McInally: We'll do the TV show.
[1:17:25] Katelyn Robinson: Kate, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap this on up?
[1:17:28] Katelyn Robinson: I I had a blast. This was a lot of fun. Uh I hope I can come back.
[1:17:31] Jess McInally: Of course.
[1:17:34] Jess McInally: We've got to talk about Jane Eyre.
[1:17:35] Katelyn Robinson: Yes, okay.
[1:17:36] Jess McInally: Also, Paul Gordon did a musical on Emma, and I might like to hear your thoughts on that.
[1:17:41] Katelyn Robinson: It's a modern day version.
[1:17:43] Jess McInally: Um I have not watched it. So I'd be very interested in your opinion on that.
[1:17:47] Katelyn Robinson: Um, but just know you're coming back on the show. You you don't have a choice on this matter anymore.
[1:17:51] Katelyn Robinson: Okay.
[1:17:52] Jess McInally: Good to know.
[1:17:53] Katelyn Robinson: Damn, I knew I should have read that contract before I signed it.
[1:17:57] Jess McInally: You're trapped.
[1:17:59] Katelyn Robinson: Exactly.
[1:18:00] Jess McInally: Um, and on that note, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:18:12] Katelyn Robinson: I'm headstrong, and I've got it long, and I'm I'm Elizabeth Bennett.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
