"Gods of the Theatre Smile on Us..." It's been years in the making but this week we're finally talking about the ill fated Sondheim musical "The Frogs" and how it may be one of the most important and prophetic musicals of Sondheim's canon... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"Gods of the Theatre Smile on Us..." It's been years in the making but this week we're finally talking about the ill fated Sondheim musical "The Frogs" and how it may be one of the most important and prophetic musicals of Sondheim's canon.
Credits:
Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf
Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf
Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK
Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio
This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:05] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.
[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[0:09] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater week by week and show by show. How are you doing today, Andrew?
[0:15] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I uh I'm feeling motivated, you know?
[0:20] Jesse McAnally: Oh, really?
[0:22] Andrew DeWolf: I'm thinking about trying to bring an artist back to life to kind of change the world a little bit, you know.
[0:26] Jesse McAnally: Okay, which artist?
[0:27] Andrew DeWolf: I you know, I'm not I think an Edgar Allan Poe, you know, he feels like a salty sailor. I'd do that just to find out how he died.
[0:38] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. Who would you bring back?
[0:40] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? I think I'd bring back Andy Kaufman.
[0:43] Jesse McAnally: Just so he can start f he would do great things with YouTube, is all I'm saying.
[0:48] Andrew DeWolf: He really would, and honestly, he'd probably get assassinated by the CIA or something.
[0:53] Jesse McAnally: He'd somehow find FBI secrets.
[0:56] Andrew DeWolf: And he and he would release them in the most deadpan way imaginable.
[1:00] Jesse McAnally: As a joke. What a tangent we went on. Um, you know what, Andrew? There is something I do have to say before we get started properly.
[1:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:10] Jesse McAnally: Gods of the podcast smile on us. You who sit up there stern in judgment, smile on us. Those who look down on podcasts, and who doesn't? Blast this little podcast, and please smile on us. We offer you talk and dance. We offer you rights and ravels, we offer you grace and beauty. Smile on us for this while.
[1:45] Andrew DeWolf: Show perhaps uh the frogs.
[2:01] Jesse McAnally: Not your pointy jointy intellectuals, not your hippie hippie homosexuals, just your easy goalie simple boy, cool-blooded frogs of the pond, and the frogs can never go beyond. When you rearrange a single frog, we respond with us. Mighty and Bob Sous near father I got. The Frogs is a musical written by Bert Shrevelov and Nathan Lane with the 2004 revisions, with music and lyrics by the one and only Stephen Sondheim. Um, it is based on The Frogs by Aristophanes. Um, and The Frogs were performed for the first time at the Yale Repertory Theater in the Yale Swimming Pool in May 20th of 1974 for around eight performances. Um but get this. The ensemble included Yale Students, Meryl Streep, Sigourney Weaver, and Christopher Durang, all dressed as frogs swimming around in this pool.
Like, I don't know why that's so wild to me, but it is. But shortly after premiering a concert adaptation in 2001, Nathan Lane um wanted to revise and expand the show into a two-act musical instead of the 90-minute show it was in the Yale Swimming Pool. Um, he expanded the first act and condensed the second act a little bit, and he explained what drew him to expand The Frogs, and guess what it was? It was September 11th. Nathan Lane was quoted saying, "After September 11th, I started to think there's something in this piece right now. There's something idealistic about the notion of someone believing that the arts can make a difference. I found it moving." In light of all that was going on in the world, it was great.
Um, this new book included direct references to George W. Bush and the Iraq War. Um, it was labeled as even more freely adapted by Nathan Lane, and it opened on July 22nd, 2004 on Broadway. Um, Lane played Dionysus and Roger Bart was Xantheists, I believe it is. Um he brought on also his director from The Producers, uh Susan Stroman, who also choreographed it. Um, it opened to mixed critical reception. Most complained that Lane's new plot was even looser, while others noted that the mix of lowbrow and highbrow comedy really seemed at odds, although others noted that this was what Aristophanes did in the original The Frogs. It closed on October 10th, 2004 after 92 performances. Um, it did not get any Tony Awards, but it was nominated for three Drama League Awards.
Now, the plot of The Frogs is Stephen Sondheim and Bert Shrevelov's musical retelling of Aristophanes' satire, in which Greek god Dionysus seeks to inspire better efforts from current playwrights. It premiered at Yale University in 1974. The Broadway production features additional songs by Sondheim and a revised book by Nathan Lane. Um, so there's that. So, all this being said, we have talked about The Frogs probably since our first like 10 episodes. This has been a long coming. It has everything that I like, which is frogs and Dionysus.
[5:30] Andrew DeWolf: So, running gag, Andrew will just randomly send me pictures of frogs throughout the day.
[5:36] Jesse McAnally: Um, not as often anymore, but early on in this podcast, he would just kind of do that a lot. Um, and he was probably the most excited to talk about this musical out of all the other ones.
[5:46] Andrew DeWolf: And he had convinced himself that it's just Cats with frogs.
[5:49] Jesse McAnally: And he wasn't entirely wrong, but it's not, but it sort of is. What did you think of The Frogs?
[6:00] Andrew DeWolf: So The Frogs is not at all what I was expecting. Um to be honest, I thought it was gonna be more uh in line with Sondheim's a lot of Sondheim's other work where it's more highbrow.
[6:12] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[6:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but honestly, this was like a this is like a lowbrow comedy. Uh though I did watch the uh the revival, which maybe is different.
[6:22] Jesse McAnally: Um, but I did enjoy it anyways. So Sondheim has worked with this book writer once before, and that was on a comedy and the first musical that Sondheim wrote both music and lyrics for called A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, and this is very much connected in both tone and vibe with that, um, which is another very same lowbrow comedy vibe.
[6:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and this is his only ever real big dip into that pool, no pun intended. Um I I thought that's good, but this is like if Forum had something to actually say about the world.
[6:58] Jesse McAnally: So I think I like this better.
[7:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean it actually has a sort of uplifting message where it's it's trying to say that art can change things, or or trying to maybe it doesn't directly say that art can change things, but it's trying to inspire people to believe that it can.
[7:14] Jesse McAnally: Like, okay, can you please try to break down the plot of The Frogs if you could?
[7:19] Andrew DeWolf: Uh yeah. It's it's relatively simple, though it's a little bit kind of uh all over the place.
[7:27] Jesse McAnally: Yes, it's a bit of a mess.
[7:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. But the the the main points of it is uh Dionysus is not happy with the current state of drama, and he is the god of drama and wine.
[7:38] Jesse McAnally: Um he's perfectly happy with the current state of wine, it seems, but not the state of drama.
[7:43] Andrew DeWolf: Uh little wine can get you a lot of drama. So he wants to bring back um I'm I'm not gonna remember this guy's name. What what was the uh it was a it was a playwright from like the 1900s.
[7:55] Jesse McAnally: George Bernard Shaw, yeah.
[7:57] Andrew DeWolf: How do you forget that? He wrote Pygmalion and then they were like, well, Pygmalion, My Fair Lady, let's make a thousand My Fair Lady references.
[8:04] Jesse McAnally: I am not good with names.
[8:07] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. I I remember that he wrote My Fair Lady because they did bring that up a shit ton of times.
[8:12] Jesse McAnally: No, no, he wrote Pygmalion, and then other people wrote My Fair Lady.
[8:16] Andrew DeWolf: Uh the fact that they equated just a panda to the There's a lot of things about little things that bother me.
[8:22] Jesse McAnally: It there's a whole bunch of jokes that I didn't get, because I'm only in for the lowbrow humor.
[8:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[8:28] Jesse McAnally: Regardless, he wants to bring back Shaw, so he has to go to the underworld. He disguises himself as as Heracles, um, for reasons I can't remember.
[8:38] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I guess it would be easier to get into the underworld as Heracles.
[8:41] Jesse McAnally: Travels there, he does the whole Hades Town thing, you know.
[8:46] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, and when he gets there, uh for whatever reason, Shaw and and uh Shakespeare are now both up for the for uh up for it.
[8:55] Jesse McAnally: Like maybe they're maybe one of them is gonna have to go and and they have to continue literary competition.
[9:01] Andrew DeWolf: And this is a reference to while George Bernard Shaw was alive, he was one of Shakespeare's biggest critics so far as to rewrite Shakespeare's work more often than not.
[9:11] Jesse McAnally: Um specifically the play that um Shakespeare quotes from um George Bernard Shaw rewrote while alive and was a very vocal critic of.
[9:21] Andrew DeWolf: So they they literally battle it out and and Shakespeare ends up winning.
[9:25] Jesse McAnally: Um and the titular frogs basically exists as a they're just a thing that exists that's going to try to turn other people into frogs, and they attack Dionysus, I think only one time, maybe maybe two, I can't remember if they come back.
[9:43] Andrew DeWolf: I I believe it's only once at the end of Act One.
[9:46] Jesse McAnally: Once, and then they're referenced quite a bit throughout. They are referenced before they show up and after.
[9:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um and yeah, that's that's what happens. He he leaves the underworld with uh with Shakespeare and and then he actually directly addresses the audience.
[10:03] Jesse McAnally: Well, so I believe a lot of musicals, especially Sondheim's musicals, have a message that they like to impart at the end, um, like Into the Woods, careful the things you say, children will listen.
[10:15] Andrew DeWolf: This one, it's saying quit sitting on your ass and make something that matters.
[10:20] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[10:21] Andrew DeWolf: And the uh the song is literally titled Final Instructions to the Audience. We start with instructions to the audience, though, as I famously saying at the beginning of this episode, um, where they give a list of do's and don'ts, but mostly don'ts, while at the show, and then they contradict it at the end, saying, No, engage with your art.
[10:41] Jesse McAnally: Don't sit back and enjoy it. You have to respond and critique it and be a part of it, or else it means nothing.
[10:48] Andrew DeWolf: Don't just go for entertainment, go for something that stimulates you.
[10:52] Jesse McAnally: Or else you're gonna end up being like one of those people that goes to see DC movies by Zack Snyder, and they just sit there and and it washes over them.
[11:00] Andrew DeWolf: By this show's own definition, a frog.
[11:03] Jesse McAnally: Someone that is apathetic and trying to drag you down with it, both in art and as far as society goes.
[11:10] Andrew DeWolf: Societal change. They the frogs are representing complacent, useless things in the world of this.
[11:17] Jesse McAnally: I think frogs are fine in real life, that are just trying to drag others to their level so there's more of them.
[11:23] Andrew DeWolf: Is it is it part of the joke that they kind of are like the cats from Cats?
[11:28] Jesse McAnally: A little bit.
[11:29] Andrew DeWolf: They c they look like that. They didn't look like that in the 70s production.
[11:32] Jesse McAnally: But like Cats didn't exist when the 70s production came out.
[11:36] Andrew DeWolf: Are they are they mocking?
[11:38] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[11:39] Andrew DeWolf: Because I think they are.
[11:39] Jesse McAnally: I think that they're trying to say that Cats is uh meaningless art that you can't even engage with.
[11:44] Andrew DeWolf: I think that is subtext, but not in the text.
[11:49] Jesse McAnally: I think that might be something Susan Stroman and Nathan Lane might have opinions on, but that's what I picked up from it.
[11:58] Andrew DeWolf: It was certainly I could see the implication.
[12:02] Jesse McAnally: Um we make jokes about how they they're too too big to be frogs.
[12:06] Andrew DeWolf: This doesn't make sense. They're like people.
[12:09] Jesse McAnally: I can see the reference, but I'm not gonna say it's there.
[12:12] Andrew DeWolf: I already said it for you. It's okay.
[12:14] Jesse McAnally: Um so let me talk about the 70s production for a minute. Um so there's a really garbage audio recording of of the 70s production.
[12:23] Andrew DeWolf: And even if you were there in person, apparently it sounded terrible.
[12:27] Jesse McAnally: Um Stephen Sondheim was quoted as saying it sounds as the sound quality was equivalent of a men's urinal.
[12:54] Andrew DeWolf: And who doesn't hear the festival and small this was the one where they performed in a pool.
[13:10] Jesse McAnally: They performed in the Yale swimming pool, yes.
[13:13] Andrew DeWolf: Do people know what water does to acoustics?
[13:17] Jesse McAnally: Unhelp.
[13:18] Andrew DeWolf: It's not very good.
[13:20] Jesse McAnally: It's not good for acoustics.
[13:22] Andrew DeWolf: I do want to say it's a tight 90 minutes.
[13:26] Jesse McAnally: We meet Herc Heracles at 10 minutes in.
[13:29] Andrew DeWolf: We are at the point where the frogs take control at 22 minutes, and then the rest of Act 2 is the rest of the show.
[13:37] Jesse McAnally: It is a succinct, poignant piece that really works.
[13:41] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know if it should have been done in a swimming pool, but I really really engage with that one and all the pieces.
[13:47] Jesse McAnally: You don't know if it should have been it should not have been done in a swimming pool.
[13:52] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna say that. I don't think it was a good idea.
[13:55] Jesse McAnally: It is funny that the frogs literally swim in the pool.
[13:59] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's it's a very funny image.
[14:01] Jesse McAnally: I showed you some pictures of it, like just generally, it looked hilarious.
[14:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but and the audience, the audience at that Yale 8 performance thing were laughing so loud that it's reverberating off the walls, and the jokes about them being in a pool really land, but there weren't many modern references that I could pick up.
[14:23] Jesse McAnally: There was no like of that, like there's the general stuff like jokes about no shit and like what an ass and stuff like that.
[14:31] Andrew DeWolf: That stuff's in there. You realize that after 2001, every single piece of media for the next like 10 years had to reference 9-11 in some way, right?
[14:40] Jesse McAnally: There had to be a joke about George Bush, there had to be uh God, there were so many jokes about George Bush.
[14:47] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like George Bush got made fun of more than Trump did.
[14:51] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. I feel like Trump media is also gonna be really cringy in about three years.
[14:56] Andrew DeWolf: It's already kind of cringy now.
[14:58] Jesse McAnally: Three years, it's already cringy.
[15:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um but going from that to the two-hour Nathan Lane revised Broadway show, I can see why this show doesn't get the best name.
[15:10] Jesse McAnally: It is a very overlong first act, but when it gets to the point where it gets to the pathos or it gets to the message of act two, it really worked for me.
[15:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I do not know if Susan Stroman was the correct person because she's a very tits and teeth kind of director that really works well for The Producers or The Music Man.
[15:29] Jesse McAnally: Um doesn't work that great for what this is until we get to act two, where we have George Bernard Shaw and William Shakespeare going head to head in like rap battles, Hamilton style, and it's pretty great, and the big kind of takes are really good.
[15:44] Andrew DeWolf: Act two is absolutely where it picks up.
[15:47] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[15:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um Act One feels like it's basically just like a comedy hour.
[15:53] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[15:54] Andrew DeWolf: They just have, you know, they keep doing jokes. Some of the jokes are good, some of the jokes aren't.
[15:59] Jesse McAnally: Uh a lot of them are kind of dated. You know, I there was some stuff that did make me laugh, so it wasn't like a total waste, but it definitely gets a lot better in act two.
[16:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I really I thought I hated this show because I mostly engaged with Act One, and then Act Two kind of washed over me.
[16:21] Jesse McAnally: For years, I thought I didn't like this show. I think I really like this show. It just needs to be 90 minutes.
[16:28] Andrew DeWolf: I think that this show could be great and honestly, um do another rewrite to fit more with what modern politics are and everything, and I think this could be a perfectly relevant show to put on right now.
[16:42] Jesse McAnally: I think this sincerely, I think the message of the show has only gotten more important over the last 20 years.
[16:49] Andrew DeWolf: I think the frogs represent general apathy of the world. I think I said this a little bit earlier, where you this group of individuals that are basically identical and trying to keep their heads down in the water, away from anyone else, and just trying to make more of them so that there's um bigger apathy, more and more apathy, sitting back, not thinking, people that want to see things as far as Broadway is concerned, people that want to see the cat or the Andrew Lloyd Weber shit.
[17:18] Jesse McAnally: Um You were talking about it in a more political sense though, as well.
[17:23] Andrew DeWolf: That too. People that sit back and aren't engaging in the world around them or the change they want to see around them, because it is easier to hide away and not engage with the crowds and drama, so to say. People that don't want to really be changing the world and would rather sit and be a conglomerated nothing, be apathetic.
[17:45] Jesse McAnally: And I think that's just what the frogs represent is general apathy. And the message at the end where it's like, please do something. I don't care what you do, but do something, is super poignant right now.
[17:59] Andrew DeWolf: I wonder if this didn't wasn't as well received because I think in 2004, a lot of people uh probably were the frogs in a way. 9-11 kind of fucked politics in America for uh let's see, how many years has it been? Uh 22 years. Uh still still going. But like, did people want to hear that then when a lot of them were just kind of the uh gung-ho war good, don't think America good types.
[18:35] Jesse McAnally: There's a specific line in the final like message, which the final song is basically stating the thesis of the show, what you were just watching. And it's taken right from Aristophanes, the original frogs, like paraphrased. Um, but Dionysus says, I know that this sounds a little crass, but citizens of Athens, if you're smart, don't sit around while Athens falls apart, which I think represents everything that the show is trying to say.
[18:59] Andrew DeWolf: The original line from um Aristophanes tells the audience to follow the politicians who will save Athens. The city was involved in the Peloponnesian War and had put on trial many of the generals from their last naval victory. Athens lost the war the year after Aristophanes' play was first performed. The use of Athens rather than replacing it in the city maintains a consistency of the show's opening. Like basically, it's using comedy to try to convince you to stand up for something, or else we're all gonna burn down with it.
[19:29] Jesse McAnally: It's sad, because like 20, 20 something years later at this point, I mean it will be 20 years in next year. Uh we failed.
[19:38] Andrew DeWolf: I think the uh message of the show did not spread in any real way. Uh and the things have only gotten worse.
[19:47] Jesse McAnally: No.
[19:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it has, as far as apathy goes, you can't bring up anything. And literally, any tr problem going on, a literal murder of a child is a political statement nowadays. Because whether or not you disclose whether their full existence is pro or anti-the murder of the child.
[20:06] Jesse McAnally: Exactly.
[20:07] Andrew DeWolf: Why does the fact that the child was trans matter?
[20:10] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it matters because it was a politically charged murder, you fucking idiot.
[20:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, but like, what if they deserved it? Like, could you think about that? Did you ever think that the right person died, so I shouldn't feel bad?
[20:25] Jesse McAnally: God damn, that is literally politics now, isn't it?
[20:28] Andrew DeWolf: It is. It is. And I I this show specifically brings on criticism. In the final words, it says, um, something I that also hit with me. We can be booed, please. It shows that you're awake.
[20:43] Jesse McAnally: Which is a good thing to say. Like, yes, engage with us. Say that we're stupid, because it shows that you are paying attention.
[20:49] Andrew DeWolf: And I think that that's a lot of people these days. It's not just that, it's art as well. People don't engage with art in any way.
[20:55] Jesse McAnally: Uh I think media literacy is at maybe not an all-time low. That's exaggerator when somebody says that.
[21:04] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, I think it's at a pretty bad low. Look at like we can bring up Doug Walker a lot, um, who apparently is your favorite person because people don't understand sarcasm on a podcast, but we're making fun of him.
[21:16] Jesse McAnally: We don't like Doug Walker.
[21:18] Andrew DeWolf: But he, CinemaSins, and a lot of other people have basically destroyed media literacy and engaging with artistic choices.
[21:28] Jesse McAnally: I have something to say on that. I don't think that that's correct. I think it's the other way around. I think that Doug Walker and CinemaSins and all of this are representative of what the people want to see, because they don't have media literacy, so they don't give a shit to see real critics.
[21:43] Andrew DeWolf: They want to see just people asking if what would happen if Batman met Mario.
[21:48] Jesse McAnally: Exactly. Which is the world we're living in, that is the only part of any kind of media that people are engaging with.
[21:55] Andrew DeWolf: What if The Flash met Batman?
[21:58] Jesse McAnally: What who's gonna be in the next Marvel?
[21:59] Andrew DeWolf: Is Paul Rudd gonna be in the next Marvel?
[22:02] Jesse McAnally: It's a disheartening, horrendous world we're living in right now.
[22:06] Andrew DeWolf: And let's take a look at Broadway right now. Tootsie the musical.
[22:10] Jesse McAnally: We've got um Bad Cinderella.
[22:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's a homogenization where they're asking you to not pay attention to Broadway, and then things like A Strange Loop, while critically lauded, closes after a very short run.
[22:24] Jesse McAnally: Which A Strange Loop was probably the best thing on Broadway for the entire last season, for sure.
[22:30] Andrew DeWolf: Say within the last 10 years. It was incredible.
[22:34] Jesse McAnally: And if you haven't seen A Strange Loop, like come on, you are missing out big time. That was so good.
[22:39] Andrew DeWolf: And as far as Sondheim revivals go, um, I love Sondheim.
[22:44] Jesse McAnally: I think what he says in a lot of his work is important. As far as the important ones go, I think that Merrily We Roll Along and Into the Woods and Sweeney Todd, while all great works, all deserving of the things, has a lot less to say about our society today than some of his lesser-known shows, like The Frogs or even Passion.
[23:06] Andrew DeWolf: It is funny that we're having this conversation with The Frogs of all things, because I know this is such a lowbrow comedy in a lot of ways.
[23:14] Jesse McAnally: But the message means so much.
[23:17] Andrew DeWolf: And it honestly, I think it helps it because uh when you deliver a message like this in a lowbrow comedy, it can reach the people that needs to like actually see it. If this was in some highbrow snooty thing where I fall asleep halfway through, like I'm not even gonna pick up on it.
[23:34] Jesse McAnally: And that seemed to be Sondheim's trick through a lot of his work.
[23:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um, at least post Sunday in the Park with George, because Sunday in the Park with George is probably his most artsy fartsy one with the message that probably means the most to him. But then you've got things like Into the Woods, which is a very gaudy like comedy for most of it, and then it goes into like the tr how we treat our children and what stories we give down to them, and like then it becomes an important message.
[23:59] Jesse McAnally: Um, as well as Assassins, which is very goofy throughout, but it has something to say.
[24:05] Andrew DeWolf: So I think it's fair to say that we did enjoy The Frogs, yeah, at least some level.
[24:10] Jesse McAnally: Um, and I think from what I've heard, and maybe this was your opinion.
[24:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, do people not like this show?
[24:17] Jesse McAnally: Most people don't. This is like on any Sondheim ranking list.
[24:21] Andrew DeWolf: Um, literally Google one, just Google Sondheim shows rank. Tell me where it lands.
[24:26] Jesse McAnally: Sure. The best Sondheim musicals ranked by fans.
[24:30] Andrew DeWolf: Let's see. Company number one, scroll down.
[24:34] Jesse McAnally: Command F, just say.
[24:36] Andrew DeWolf: Just take a snuff.
[24:36] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god, The Frogs is number 19 with one below it uh Saturday Night.
[24:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Saturday Night. Saturday Night was the first show he ever wrote when he was like a kid.
[24:46] Jesse McAnally: Is there is I don't even see Bounce.
[24:48] Andrew DeWolf: There might be another page.
[24:49] Jesse McAnally: Bounce, Bounce, I think is Saturday Night.
[24:51] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, it is.
[24:52] Jesse McAnally: Okay. I think they're the same show.
[24:54] Andrew DeWolf: So literally. That means Frogs, they think is the second worst.
[24:58] Jesse McAnally: Okay, it's Road Show?
[24:59] Andrew DeWolf: Road Show and Bounce are the same show.
[25:01] Jesse McAnally: Um, Road Show is 18.
[25:03] Andrew DeWolf: Road Show is above Frogs.
[25:05] Jesse McAnally: Somehow.
[25:07] Andrew DeWolf: How did that happen?
[25:09] Jesse McAnally: The Frogs never had to get renamed. Let me just say that one.
[25:09] Andrew DeWolf: So people think that this is apparently just a horrendous show.
[25:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[25:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh this ranking list puts Evening Primrose above.
[25:19] Jesse McAnally: I think that shows a good um vibe of how most people interpret The Frogs.
[25:24] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe it's because it expects a lot of folks.
[25:27] Jesse McAnally: And I will give credit, it does.
[25:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but I don't know. Like, I feel like the ones that are a little bit more hard to swallow are the medicines that you need to take.
[25:39] Jesse McAnally: Now, on some level, I can understand why the show would get hate, though.
[25:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah. There's a lot of stuff where it's just very like silly comedy, like, and it that's not gonna go over well with everybody.
[25:46] ⚠ About 4 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.
[29:42] Jesse McAnally: This gives Sheave Love the chance to mock a gallery of dead authors from Beaumont and Fletcher to Brecht.
[29:48] Andrew DeWolf: When Shakespeare beats Shaw and is about to leave Hades with Dionysus, Pluto bargains, take Shaw, and I'll throw an Ibsen.
[29:55] Jesse McAnally: That shows you the kind of jokes that they were pulling in the 70s version.
[29:58] Andrew DeWolf: The literary sparring match was a comic apex in the original.
[30:02] Jesse McAnally: For this Frogs, Michael Feingold has cold quotes from Shaw and Shakespeare, and the result is unfortunately a dead spot in the show, proving that at least in this case, Shaw and Shakespeare cannot compete with Shivlove.
[30:16] Andrew DeWolf: But most of Frog's 90 minutes without an intermission is good unadulterated fun.
[30:20] Jesse McAnally: Larry Blyden is a splendid, mock confident Dionysus.
[30:23] Andrew DeWolf: He crosses the sticks as if it were the Delaware, and he a Toged Washington, while frogs dip and flip like extras in a splashy MGM epic.
[30:32] Jesse McAnally: Now, I think that just sums up like maybe you just had to be there kind of vibe of that show.
[30:39] Andrew DeWolf: I actually really liked what Sondheim was doing with the score. It was very quirky and choral-based rather than like proper ballad numbers.
[30:46] Jesse McAnally: Um, so I don't really agree with that there.
[30:49] Andrew DeWolf: But he saw the potential in this and had a good time.
[30:53] Jesse McAnally: But the things that he didn't like are the things that I like the most.
[31:06] Andrew DeWolf: It seems like a lot of the stuff he didn't like though gets changed because there's more songs in the revival in 2004.
[31:06] Jesse McAnally: Um, so like a lot of that kind of thing is addressed, which maybe they took this into account, this sort of review.
[31:14] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe, but I feel like they might have overcorrected.
[31:17] Jesse McAnally: Um, but let's go into the time machine into the future to July 23rd, 2020, with New York Times chief theater critic Ben Brantley reviewing.
[31:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.
[31:31] Jesse McAnally: Let me guess. This is an uber negative review.
[31:34] Andrew DeWolf: Let's just hear the first sentence really quick.
[31:36] Jesse McAnally: Alright, New York Times, Ben Brantley, July 23rd, 2004.
[31:41] Andrew DeWolf: Even the crème de la crème can curdle every now and then.
[31:45] Jesse McAnally: Consider The Frogs, which opened last night at the Vivian Beaumont Theater as part of the Lincoln Center Festival.
[31:54] Andrew DeWolf: This musical updating of the 1974 adaptation of Aristophanes' 2,400-year-old comedy of gods and playwrights has the highest concentration of blue ribbon talent of any show now on Broadway.
[32:10] Jesse McAnally: Which is basically him saying, it's got a lot of people in it, but too bad it sucks.
[32:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[32:14] Jesse McAnally: After dwelling with such craven procrastination on the fine ingredients that make up The Frogs, I am forced to concede that what should have been a zesty airy soufflé is a soggy, lumpy batter that never shows the slightest signs of rising.
[32:31] Andrew DeWolf: Staged in 1974 as a publicity garnering hour-long novelty by the Yale School of Drama around and in the University Gymnasium swimming pool, if you please.
[32:43] Jesse McAnally: This bauble of a show has been reshaped to fill two and a half hours.
[32:47] Andrew DeWolf: The results suggest that to stretch something this slight is to shatter it.
[32:53] Jesse McAnally: So I mean, on some level he's right here. It probably shouldn't have been made longer.
[32:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um, although two and a half hours, the one I saw was only two hours.
[33:02] Jesse McAnally: Did they shorten it?
[33:03] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, intermission.
[33:04] Jesse McAnally: Oh, intermission.
[33:05] Andrew DeWolf: Ben Brantley, you don't count an intermission as part of the show.
[33:09] Jesse McAnally: Jesus Christ.
[33:10] Andrew DeWolf: You're just adding that in there to make it seem like it's even longer.
[33:14] Jesse McAnally: We've actually watched shows that are two and a half hours. We've watched We Will Rock You, three hours of garbage.
[33:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, what was that, a three and a half hour show?
[33:22] Jesse McAnally: Because intermission.
[33:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it was. Um, basically that sums up his opinion of it, and that has basically been the consensus opinion of The Frogs, including myself, who I thought I didn't like this show for a very long time. Um, I gaslit myself into thinking I didn't like this show for a very long time. But I had just saw it on surface level. So I feel you, Ben Brantley, but also quit being an asshole. Yeah, I think there's definitely criticisms to have of The Frogs, and I think the main ones that I have are some of the jokes are just super dated, it's a little overlong. Uh, but honestly, I think overall, I could see an updated version of this being very funny and very good. Sincerely, if they announce tomorrow that like someone like oh god, the Moulin Rouge director guy, uh, Alex Timbers, was doing the show with Josh Gad as the lead.
I'd be like, yeah, fine, do it. Josh, you know what? Reunite Josh Gad and Andrew Rannells as the two leads. I'm in. Oh my god, that'd actually be hilarious. Like that we have our two com it would be like the two comedy greats. We'd have even a similar, it's even a similar vibe to uh Book of Mormon. Exactly. Like their relationship. Oh, that would actually be really good. And really just focus on the message and don't lose the message. Still be funny. Like, obviously, with that casting, be funny, embrace the humor, but focus on the message, keep it a tight 90, put it at the Circle in the Square and make it a tight 90, get people out, no intermission. And add a swimming pool. Musicals with Cheese presents The Frogs.
The Musicals with Cheese theater presents The Frogs, starring Andrew Rannells and Josh Gad. We'll go bankrupt faster than Rebecca. Ben Brantley will come out of retirement just to write the fucking review. I will invite him. I will sit next to him. I will give him the hand job while he's writing his review. He will have a good night. He ignored the balls more, but somehow he happened to know that I didn't like much ball work. Oh my god. Okay. Mid show time.
[35:38] Jesse McAnally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Patreon's this beautiful place where you can give us money and you get perks. Sometimes, if Andrew will get off his ass. Uh, excuse me, I gave you a time and you didn't show up. Um, yeah. That's my bad. Um, what are you doing tomorrow? Uh, depends what time, but probably good. What about noon? Let's do it. Let's do it. Alright. We'll get you things this week, promise. But Patreon's great. Come join us there. Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Daniel Renek, Justin Ampedio, and Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Mina Meneer, Brent Black, Lathaniel, Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans, Green, Mary Lou Choquet, John Van Alz, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Kyle Summers, Jen A C, Scootin' Technicolor Dream Code, Liz Limb, Nothing Is Certain Except Beth and Taxes, Desbian, Ren Cullen, Rafael, Martina Salaz, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai T Cop, Katie McDonough, Chris Marco, Kiji Maria Anastasio, Trevi Joseph, Layla, RJ Norija, Charlie B. Bjorn Hermans, Erica S. Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most Lopez, Liana Morton, Keely Blazier, Cinemagin Reviews, Villa Miss, Sofiana Ali, the Omega Geek, Carrie Pearson, Maddie Worgle, Alyssa Erdman, Anna Loscatova, Chesca Varage, Sarah Den Bleckier, Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Gathering Party before venturing forth, Aura Morasso, Moore Mara Fourloyne, Captain Rod Taskstick, Lisa Ellen, Sarah Walsh.
[37:03] Andrew DeWolf: I do want to say Captain Rodastic did an amazing piece of art last week. Um, where when we did our Music Man episode, we did a pitch where I said that Sutton Foster would have been a like they should have swapped roles. He did art of that, and it's pretty cool.
[37:19] Jesse McAnally: Oh wow. That this is how the show should have actually been.
[37:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it really should have been. Um, we do have some patron questions if you want to answer it really quick.
[37:27] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, what do we got?
[37:29] Andrew DeWolf: Kyle Summers wrote in asking what non-English, non-Western musical would you like to see get brought to the United States?
[37:36] Jesse McAnally: Oh man, I'm supposed to have an answer for that. I don't know. I really would like to see Rebecca brought to the US one day. Sincerely. What comes to mind? Um, Rebecca would be interesting. Uh, I would like to see how they translated and everything. Um, but I mean, that Hunchback of Notre Dame thing. I mean. Um, I don't even know if I want it translated. Um, I would uh, Mozart L'Opéra Rock.
[38:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that one was pretty good.
[38:03] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I'd love to see that too. Um yeah, I would love to see that. Um, I would honestly I would like another production of La Bohème. Like a really big gaudy production of La Bohème. I don't know if I know that's opera and that's a whole different category, but I would love to see that. And for shits and giggles, Death Note the musical. Fucking do it. The Grinning Man is also pretty good, I hear.
[38:26] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know anything about that one. Um definitely, uh definitely some stuff we've covered in other languages has been pretty good. So I don't know why they don't do that more often. That would be really nice to see.
[38:40] Andrew DeWolf: More translations.
[38:41] Jesse McAnally: Captain Rod Tastic did compliment that question by saying, are there any foreign non-English versions of Western musicals that you think are better than their English-speaking counterparts?
[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, once again, Notre Dame or Glockner Hunter.
[38:56] Jesse McAnally: That wicked non-replica production where a TV falls out of the sky and Dorothy walks out, looked cool as shit.
[39:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh wow.
[39:03] Jesse McAnally: I literally showed you this footage on the podcast before, Andrew.
[39:06] Andrew DeWolf: I'd honestly like more people to recommend us foreign stuff that's really good, please.
[39:12] Jesse McAnally: I love non-foreign stuff.
[39:13] Andrew DeWolf: Not foreign stuff that's garbage.
[39:15] Jesse McAnally: I don't want to cover We Will Rock You, but in Spanish. Please.
[39:20] Andrew DeWolf: I would really like to do a lot more. Cause what we've done in the last year, I really enjoyed doing The Magic Flute.
[39:26] Jesse McAnally: That was a fun episode in my opinion. I don't quite remember how well it was received, but I enjoyed watching and recording it.
[39:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and Mozart Lapa Rock was really fun and good.
[39:36] Jesse McAnally: We had a bit of an opera with cheese moment last year.
[39:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[39:41] Jesse McAnally: I wouldn't mind having another one.
[39:42] Andrew DeWolf: That was a good time.
[39:44] Jesse McAnally: Maybe do an opera month or something.
[39:46] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe.
[39:47] Jesse McAnally: Opera October.
[39:48] Andrew DeWolf: Just we're just dedicating a month to losing the downloads.
[39:55] Jesse McAnally: Oh, you're not right.
[39:56] Andrew DeWolf: It's gotta be January. No one ever listens to our show in January.
[40:00] Jesse McAnally: Our downloads go down so hard every time the new year hits.
[40:03] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know what happened. Does Christmas really depress people?
[40:06] Jesse McAnally: Fuck you. It's January month.
[40:09] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, that's pretty common on YouTube too. The algorithm just, I don't know. Maybe people just don't want to do things after dealing with their families.
[40:16] Jesse McAnally: Alright, patrons. We're gonna move on to some songs now.
[40:19] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, let's go.
[40:26] Jesse McAnally: I love invocation and instructions for the audience. This was actually originally written for A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.
[40:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, but first, some do's and don'ts.
[40:39] Jesse McAnally: Mostly don'ts. Please don't cough. It tends to throw the actors off.
[40:45] Andrew DeWolf: Have some respect for Aristophanes, and please don't cough.
[40:50] Jesse McAnally: Don't say "what" to every line you think you haven't got. And if you're in a snip because you've missed the plot, of which I must admit there's not an awful lot, still don't say "what."
[41:04] Andrew DeWolf: If we see flaws, please don't drop your jaws, please. No loud guffaws, please.
[41:11] Jesse McAnally: When actors enter late. When there's a pause, please, lots haul the applause, please.
[41:18] Andrew DeWolf: And we'd appreciate you turning off your cell phones while we wait.
[41:25] Jesse McAnally: But the director at the time could not hum it in his own words to Sondheim. So he made him rewrite it.
[41:31] Andrew DeWolf: And Sondheim wrote a song called "Love is in the Air," which is a little cringy, but the director could hum it.
[41:38] Jesse McAnally: And then they performed that at out-of-town tryouts, and that flopped, and nobody knew what the show was about. And Sondheim went to his old buddy and he was like, "What's going on? Come on, tell me what's going on." I think it was Jerome Robbins.
[41:49] Andrew DeWolf: And he's like, "Well, you have an opening number that doesn't tell the audience what the show is about."
[41:54] Jesse McAnally: He's like, "I wrote one already, but the director didn't like it." And he says, "Well, write another one that does that, that the director likes."
[42:01] Andrew DeWolf: And then he wrote "Comedy Tonight."
[42:05] Jesse McAnally: I love young, sassy, angry Sondheim.
[42:08] Andrew DeWolf: So wait, wait. Which one is this?
[42:10] Jesse McAnally: This was the first one. The first one he wrote that was supposed to start A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum.
[42:15] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, this one's pretty good, though.
[42:17] Jesse McAnally: I think it's great. I really, really like it.
[42:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, "Comedy Tonight" is iconic, though. If they used that there, they couldn't have used this for Frogs.
[42:25] Jesse McAnally: So, and I think it works better in The Frogs. Um, I really like the list. I think the rhymes in it are very, very clever. And it is Sondheim showing off.
[42:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but come on. Sondheim always shows off.
[42:37] Jesse McAnally: I mean, that's what people want. That's what they go to him for. We want to hear four rhymes in a row that are all internal that no one knows. And we want to see you work the word "fart" into your opening number.
[42:47] Andrew DeWolf: Don't they almost work it into the ending number as well?
[42:49] Jesse McAnally: I feel like they bring it back. And but then, but then they subvert it, and instead of saying "fart," they say "smart."
[42:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[42:56] Jesse McAnally: Well, so he, the line here, if I remember correctly, it's "please don't fart. There's not a lot of air, and this is art."
[43:05] Andrew DeWolf: There's a lot, and a lot of this has to do with Nathan Lane's specific delivery that I think really makes this work. I think the song is very funny, sets up the show perfectly, and really just kind of sells me on the entire vibe.
[43:20] Jesse McAnally: Then we have other songs that I don't love as much. So you're gonna have to just help me a little bit. What songs are new to the 2004 one?
[43:29] Andrew DeWolf: I'd say a good majority of act one. Isn't it like it's like six songs are new, or seven?
[43:34] Jesse McAnally: Nine.
[43:34] Andrew DeWolf: Nine.
[43:35] Jesse McAnally: Nine songs are new.
[43:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[43:37] Jesse McAnally: Okay. So that one was always a part of it. Um, "I Love to Travel" was always a part of it. And so was Heracles' song, and then we just get into The Frogs.
[43:49] Andrew DeWolf: So we get "Invocation," "I Love to Travel," "Dress Big," and "The Frogs," and that was Act One. Like that was all the songs that were in the original.
[43:57] Jesse McAnally: So all of the stuff with Karen is just not there.
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. That makes actually a lot of sense because nothing happens. Like there. He's a character, but there's not really songs.
[44:10] Jesse McAnally: Does he do the gag where he doesn't let the Xanthus on board?
[44:19] Andrew DeWolf: Very briefly, yes. It's very, very briefly. It's not as drawn out as it is in the final version. It's probably just it feels more drawn out because then also they sing a song.
[44:28] Jesse McAnally: Um, when I hear "I Love to Travel," I don't know if this is just for you, but my brain goes, "I love to sing, I love to travel, don't you? I love a change of pace. I love a change of space. I love to see a place that's absolutely new. I love to travel on, don't you?"
[44:48] Andrew DeWolf: Of course you know that song?
[44:57] Jesse McAnally: I do know that song. That's, there's like a famous Looney Tunes cartoon with that. And also the first ever episode of South Park.
[45:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[45:07] Jesse McAnally: The two most important cultural lines. But every time I hear that song, like it comes in on my iPhone. Um, I think of that. I have nothing more to add to that, sincerely, but like I thought that was interesting.
[45:19] Andrew DeWolf: Look, so we could talk about how the songs that are additional are not great, but we could also just talk about The Frogs.
[45:25] Jesse McAnally: Let I, uh, sincerely, I'd rather. I do like Ariadne. I do like that number. I don't have much to say about it, but I do think it adds needed pathos and depth to Dionysus, which I'm always happy to have.
[45:37] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. But let's talk about The Frogs.
[45:41] Jesse McAnally: It's like what was that? Prick kick! Xanthus, wake up, Xanthus, please wake up. Old man, I need your help!
[45:54] Andrew DeWolf: I may be losing my mind, but that sounds like frogs.
[46:04] Jesse McAnally: Rip it!
[46:10] Andrew DeWolf: It is, it is!
[46:11] Jesse McAnally: It's Frog!
[46:12] Andrew DeWolf: Sondheim is well!
[46:26] Andrew DeWolf: No listen!
[46:32] Jesse McAnally: I think that I think this song's funny. I think this song is great. I think it's staged perfectly. It's literally like half the song is just them making these random noises.
[46:42] Andrew DeWolf: And then they have um, they have the staging is incredible with the wire work where they're hopping, like they're jumping up in the air. Like it's very fun, especially when like most of the rest of the show, they don't do anything like that. This is like the only time.
[46:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and it's the act one closer. It kind of leaves you wanting more. Uh, sincerely, it is a pretty big thing to end on.
[47:07] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, there are some actually good visual gags.
[47:10] Jesse McAnally: Yes. That I think we should mention quickly. Uh, my personal favorite is Heracles' introduction. They roll in this set with this tiny house.
[47:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[47:20] Jesse McAnally: Uh, on a hill, and you think it's just like, oh, well, they're just there or whatever. And then Heracles actually opens up this tiny house and steps out.
[47:31] Andrew DeWolf: That's a great gag. I thought that was really funny because it looked like the set looks like it's supposed to be way off in the distance or something.
[47:40] Jesse McAnally: It's very funny. Um, then there's the giant like firebelly frog or whatever they want to call it, where it rolls up behind him and then grabs him with his tongue, which I thought was pretty humorous too.
[47:54] Andrew DeWolf: It's the only frog that actually looks like a frog. All the other frogs are people in costumes.
[47:56] Jesse McAnally: Um, a gag I didn't mind was when we have Charan and his twin brother, where it's like, "Wait, you have a twin?" "Yeah, we were separated at birth, and I'd like to keep it that way." Like little throwaway lines like that really got a tickle out of me.
[48:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, there are some good humorous stuff in here. Um, speaking of humorous stuff, I kind of like, I really liked Hades' song. Like, I feel like we finally have an adaptation of something to do with Hades that shows how Hades actually was in the fucking Greek mythology.
[48:36] Jesse McAnally: Everybody dumps on Hades, people yelling, "Go to hell." Well, let me take a life in Hades, it shall swell. It's got flash, it's got flair, it's got spectacle to spare. People come from everywhere, like it or not. Mostly not, and they see what we've got. And they like it a lot. Such a lot! Hell is hot, so hot.
[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Hades in most cultures' portrayal, because he's the king of the underworld, they often portray him as the devil. Essentially, so he's always evil. Disney does this, and I think probably popularized it a lot for a lot of our generation.
[49:25] Jesse McAnally: Um, but in the actual mythology, he's kind of chill. He's just kind of a guy. He's not great. I mean, he does have some stories where he does some pretty shitty things. He's more King Herod than Pilate, I think is the best way to say.
[49:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[49:39] Jesse McAnally: Um, so yeah, it's interesting they portrayed him this way in here. I just think the song is actually catchy. I know it was written for this. It's one of the few songs I actually feel fits the tone of this new version.
[49:50] Andrew DeWolf: It seems like a lot of the newer songs are just for these characters that probably didn't have songs before.
[49:56] Jesse McAnally: That is correct.
[49:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[49:58] Jesse McAnally: But it's got the Sondheim lyrics, and it's got a good hook.
[50:02] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, this is a personal thing. This is me getting angry unreasonably.
[50:07] Jesse McAnally: That's fair.
[50:08] Andrew DeWolf: Do you remember My Fair Lady at all? Or even our episode on it?
[50:13] Jesse McAnally: Barely. I do remember that we did it.
[50:16] Andrew DeWolf: This, there's a song in My Fair Lady called "You Did It." Um, that I hate.
[50:24] Jesse McAnally: I said to him, "You did it, you did it, you did it. They thought he was ecstatic and so damned aristocratic, and they never knew that you did it."
[50:36] Andrew DeWolf: Like, unreasonably, I will admit. Where it's like, "Tonight, oh pal, you did it, you did it, you did it, and how do you do it? And indeed you did," and I just think it's terrible.
[50:47] Jesse McAnally: Stephen Sondheim basically just rewrites it and makes it about George Bernard Shaw right here.
[50:54] Andrew DeWolf: I knew that I could do it, I knew it, I knew it. I knew they don't pull poop it, and indeed they did.
[51:01] Jesse McAnally: They took my least favorite thing, and I don't even like the fact that they connected George Bernard Shaw to My Fair Lady, the musical, because technically he didn't really have anything to do with that except for the basis, and then literally recreate one of the worst songs in My Fair Lady and just put it in this musical.
[51:20] Andrew DeWolf: I felt angered that I did not.
[51:23] Jesse McAnally: But you think it was intentional.
[51:25] Andrew DeWolf: It was intentional. There's no way it wasn't.
[51:28] Jesse McAnally: So, but he did it.
[51:30] Andrew DeWolf: Do you believe that he did it?
[51:31] Jesse McAnally: I indeed I do.
[51:36] Andrew DeWolf: This is the nitpick of all nitpicks. I just hated the fact that that happened. It is clever that they actually referenced that song though.
[51:45] Jesse McAnally: No, it isn't.
[51:46] Andrew DeWolf: It's pretty clever.
[51:47] Jesse McAnally: No, no.
[51:48] Andrew DeWolf: You gotta admit.
[51:49] Jesse McAnally: No, I don't have to admit.
[51:50] Andrew DeWolf: You gotta admit that.
[51:51] Jesse McAnally: I don't have to do a goddamn thing.
[51:54] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, but for real though, the Shakespeare Shaw battle, the ending song that Shakespeare does.
[52:00] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[52:00] Andrew DeWolf: Come on. That's good. Fear no more.
[52:02] Jesse McAnally: That's good shit.
[52:03] Andrew DeWolf: Fear no more.
[52:04] Jesse McAnally: That's good shit.
[52:05] Andrew DeWolf: Fear no more the heat of the sun.
[52:12] Jesse McAnally: No, the furious winter's rages. Thou thy worldly task has done. Home art gone and change I waiters. Golden lads and girls all must.
[52:36] Andrew DeWolf: As Jimmy Sweeters come to that's good shit, but it's also from Shakespeare's Cymbeline, which was a play that George Bernard Shaw criticized so much that he rewrote most of it.
[52:56] Jesse McAnally: So George Bernard Shaw was beaten by a show that George Bernard Shaw had vocally discredited and said was garbage during his days so much that he rewrote it.
[53:05] Andrew DeWolf: He does get very angry after losing to this as well.
[53:08] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, if you know that, it's interesting. I do find it fascinating. And this is the thing that I always find interesting. Um, when people within the same art form comment on other artists. Um, I know it can get very jack-offy, but I find it interesting when they criticize them. Like Sondheim and Bert Love, or did I say his name right? I want to make sure I get it right, because I am cringe. Um Bert Shivlove, um, they are criticizing George Bernard Shaw and commenting on the same art form. This is like if Lynn Manuel Miranda did an entire musical and the final scene takes place between Rogers and Hammerstein and Roger or yeah, Rogers and Hammerstein and who would be the contemporaries of that time, probably fucking Jerry Herman. Like that would be the same kind of thing happening. And I find shit like that fascinating because it says more about the artist than it does about the person they're criticizing, in all honesty.
[54:06] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it says who they side with in the whole thing for sure. But art isn't a winning game, which is interesting to say that it is in this case.
[54:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, they literally, somebody does win. Although, in this case, they're just trying to win Dionysus's favor, which is, I guess, interesting.
[54:22] Andrew DeWolf: Well, he is the god of drama and wine.
[54:24] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. There should have been more wine.
[54:26] Andrew DeWolf: There was a whole scene with wine, though. Um, so with that, they had to defend what is it, three categories? Women, love, and death.
[54:35] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[54:36] Andrew DeWolf: With death being the one that uh quenches it. Shakespeare really wins because he's able to identify death from an old person and a young person's perspective, or something like that. Um, which Shaw doesn't get a chance to rebut. But whatever. Um, I yeah. Um, I like the final scene. I like the final song, the final instructions to the audience. Once again, it's the message to take home and think about. And I think that's important. And I like it when they talk directly to me. It's like I'm part of the show.
[55:13] Jesse McAnally: No, please. Don't not. Agreeing with me, just cause I'm a god. Have some respect for Aristophanes. And please, don't not. Don't just shrug. Content to be a conscientious slug. It's fine to feel contented, safe and snug, but soon enough contented. Turns to smog. Don't shovel what's uncomfortable underneath the rug. Speak up. Get sore. Do something more than just deplore.
[56:00] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, sometimes I do. Uh, but then you got moments like in a strange loop where they make you clap along to AIDS's god's punishment, and then you realize what you're doing, and you don't know how to stop. I like being criticized. Make me feel uncomfortable. That is also what the frogs is saying to you. Yeah, criticize us, boo us. At least we know that you're awake out there. I just I enjoyed this show a lot more than I was expecting going in. Not because I had personal opinions about it, but because of what I had heard.
[56:25] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[56:26] Andrew DeWolf: And uh I'm happy that I liked it because it's the frogs, and the frogs deserves to be a good show.
[56:31] Jesse McAnally: Well, that being said, how about we get your ranking with the rest of the Steven Sondheim tier that you have created? And this is our first Steven Sondheim. Like, we haven't covered one since West Side Story, like two December.
[56:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and I abbreviated everything, so now I'm gonna have to remember what they mean. Alright. In A tier, you have Sweeney Todd, um, the Mama Rosbies going into the woods. And B tier, you have Merrily We Roll Along, Sunday in the Park with George, Company, Follies, West Side Story. And C tier, you got Pacific Overtures, Assassins, and Passion, and in D tier, you have Evening Primrose.
[57:06] Jesse McAnally: I am gonna be very, very interested in where you put this. I this is like blasphemy, but I think this goes at least probably the bottom of B tier.
[57:16] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[57:17] Jesse McAnally: Above Pacific Overtures and Assassins and Passion.
[57:21] Andrew DeWolf: You sure about that one, buddy?
[57:22] Jesse McAnally: I think so. I enjoyed this more than I enjoyed those. I might have to rewatch Assassins. Maybe I could maybe the ranking of Assassins would change if I rewatched it.
[57:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that was very early on in our run. Though I don't think my opinion of Pacific Overtures or Passion would change, I'm gonna be honest.
[57:39] Jesse McAnally: Why don't you like Passion?
[57:40] Andrew DeWolf: Passion's great.
[57:41] Jesse McAnally: I thought it was snooze.
[57:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, you I think that was the critic's reaction to Passion's too. I thought I was like falling asleep.
[57:51] Jesse McAnally: Frogs, uh frogs at the bottom of B. I guess we could you maybe could put it at the top of C to make Jess feel better.
[57:59] Andrew DeWolf: No, you don't have to do a goddamn thing to make me feel better. I I thought it was pretty good, honestly. I I thought it was enjoyable. I get it. I I mean I don't think I'd put it. See, this is where the Sondheim ranking comes. It's not because I think anything is bad, it's just that some things I like more than others. I don't think he's done like absolute garbage. I think even Evening Primrose, which is sitting alone in D tier, is still not like horrendous. It is better than most Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals.
[58:26] Jesse McAnally: But as of right now, your list goes Sweeney Todd, Mama Rose, Into the Woods, Merrily We Roll Along, Sunday in the Park with George, Company, Follies, West Side Story, The Frogs, Pacific Overtures, Assassins, Passion, and at the bottom, Evening Primrose.
[58:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, guess we're gonna have to figure out where Saturday Night and Road Show slash Bounce are gonna fit in one day.
[58:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. The only ones that I think could change on this list right now, Frogs could maybe move down if I get more time to think about it. I'm not sure. And Assassins, if I rewatched it, I think maybe go up, but I think I'd need to evaluate that.
[58:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. But I think people you should give Frogs a chance. Okay?
[59:03] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um I think a lot of people are just they just haven't seen it, like at all. I think that's what's really has gone on with this. Or they just see Nathan Lane and a toga, and they're like, oh, is that forum? Cause like a couple years before that, Nathan Lane was in a toga and Sondheim's Something Happened Way to the Forum, and you might just think it's the same show.
[59:23] Andrew DeWolf: That's true. Um I'm gonna be very interested to see where that's gonna rank in your list, to be honest. Because it is obviously the goofiest one, but also it's kinda like goofy shit. A lot of it's gonna depend on if I think it's funny. Like this show, like, if I didn't think this show was funny, it probably would have been in D tier. Cause it's just like it's a comedy, it has to make you laugh, right? Like, if it's not funny, it's not funny.
[59:42] Jesse McAnally: Agreed.
[59:46] Andrew DeWolf: What is your overall thoughts on The Frogs and your cheese rating, though?
[59:50] Jesse McAnally: I think The Frogs is pretty fine. Uh you should definitely check it out at least. Give it a chance, you know? How many people out there, and be ruckin' real. I want to see like a Twitter thread or something. How many people out there have completely dismissed this show without even having seen it at all? I think it's gonna be a lot.
[1:00:10] Andrew DeWolf: I would be very interested. Um, but you know what? If you guys are doing Musicals with Cheese fan art, um me just and Andrew as Dionysus and the slave, come on. It's it it's right there. I I don't want I I would love I would hang that on this wall. Because that's a very specific reference, and that's my esoteric sense of humor.
[1:00:32] Jesse McAnally: But the cheese, Andrew. What about the cheese?
[1:00:34] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like I haven't ever given anything feta, although that's probably I'm gonna be proven wrong by that in like a day. But uh tweet at him, Juliet. Tell him he's wrong. I've probably given it like five or six times and I'm just like not remembering. I'm gonna get it's give it feta, and there's like five fetas in a row. Literally.
[1:00:58] Jesse McAnally: Um that's good. I enjoyed The Frogs a lot more than I expected to. I was angered by not by the message, but the way that I I don't know, it made me feel a thing. It gave me like this fire under my ass I didn't feel before, where it just told you to stop being an apathetic piece of shit and go out and do something. And I don't know. Having that kind of message really kind of messed with me. And it's still kind of something I'm unpacking right now. And part of me wishes I had like thought about this longer because I feel like that's something we could still unpack. Because I was literally, as I was talking to you before we started, I was figuring out what I thought the message was of this show.
And I wish I had jumped into that. But I know the show isn't for everyone. I don't love the humor. I don't think it works in its current form. However, update it every 10 years. It's an important message. It is an important message. Put famous people in it. Film it. Make this an accessible. Make this like one of the Sondheim standards, because I think it deserves to be. I think this would actually be go. This would be pretty decent as a movie.
[1:02:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, even an animated film.
[1:02:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I think it would go it, it could work. Yeah. It's got that like adventurous kind of vibe to it, and then you could do some funny gags. The visual humor, like, keep that kind of stuff. That's funny. That's fun. And a lot of what works on stage as visual humor also translates to animation very well.
[1:02:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:02:23] Jesse McAnally: So uh, you know, there's this of there's a lot you can do with this. But my cheese rating is gonna be Chipotle Gouda, because most people love Gouda and think that like that's a pretty good choice. But this is a little spicy, a little harder to swallow, not as easy just to snack on. You have to ration your bites and actually understand what you're eating. Like, make it good for your palate. It's important to have a diversified palate, and if you don't, you're just gonna be eating the same shit as everyone else, like the frogs in the fucking sea below us in the river sticks that are trying to drag you down and make you one of them.
[1:02:59] Andrew DeWolf: I can't believe we're gonna get roasted on Twitter for liking The Frogs, but here we are.
[1:03:03] Jesse McAnally: Wow. Time to get cancelled, Andrew.
[1:03:06] Andrew DeWolf: If that's what gets us cancelled for liking The Frogs, then that's the hill that we're gonna do. I love this show because it criticizes media analysis and the lack of it in our modern society. Even in 1974, even in 2004, it is not as bad as it was it is right now. But you know who isn't shit at media analysis? Us for sure. And them and our wonderful patrons. Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on IT and Spotify Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese or on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals Cheese, Instagram Musicals with Cheese, YouTube page Musicals with Cheese. We have a patron only podcast called Patreon with Cheese. Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com or keep the cheeses, Juliet Antonio.
This show is edited by Andrew DeWolf, and he's doing a fucking great job lately. Aren't you enjoying the memeification of this show? I think our show is better. Um, our themes are created by Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off or making fun of fucking Ben Brantley. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:04:15] Jesse McAnally: Adorable frogs, not your hoity toity intellectuals, not your hippie dippy homosexuals, just your easygoing, simple, warm-hearted, cold-blooded frogs.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
