Skip to main content
BPN Logo
20 - James Claffey

James Claffey is the President of Local One, the powerful Stagehands’ union. He worked throughout the Local One jurisdiction since 1982 in venues including Radio City Music Hall, the City Center 55th Street Dance Theatre, Madison Square Garden, CBS-TV, ABCTV and various Broadway theatres... Read More

From the show: The Producer's Perspective Podcast with Ken Davenport

34 mins
5/17/15

About

James Claffey is the President of Local One, the powerful Stagehands’ union. He worked throughout the Local One jurisdiction since 1982 in venues including Radio City Music Hall, the City Center 55th Street Dance Theatre, Madison Square Garden, CBS-TV, ABCTV and various Broadway theatres.

Listen in to hear . . .

  • How one becomes a Stagehand and how you can, too.
  • Why he responds to emails he gets right away, even at midnight.
  • The one myth about Stagehands that he can’t stand.
  • What the 2007 Broadway Stagehands Strike taught him.
  • The one crisis that is crippling all unions and all companies, including Producers.

Keep up with me: @KenDavenportBway

www.theproducersperspective.com

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer with a hit show on Broadway.

[0:07] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer.

[0:10] Ken Davenport: You're listening to the Producers Perspective Podcast.

[0:13] Ken Davenport: This week the show is sponsored by Hand to God, the most Tony nominated new American play on Broadway.

[0:18] Ken Davenport: The New York Times calls Hand to God flat out hilarious and a true tour de force.

[0:22] Ken Davenport: And the Huffington Post raves it's the best play of the season.

[0:25] Ken Davenport: For tickets, visit telecharge.com and now on with the podcast.

[0:30] Ken Davenport: Hello, everybody. Welcome back to the Producer's Perspective Podcast. Before I introduce my next guest, I want to tell you a little story.

[0:37] Ken Davenport: Back from the days of the 90s, 1993, when I witnessed my first tech of a Broadway show. It was Greece. I was the production assistant, which meant I got everybody coffee. As you all know, tech is a very arduous process where the cast and the physical elements of the production finally come together. We actually had a lot of moving parts on that show. Lots of scenery, props, a billion Varolites and cues to go with it. It took us a couple weeks to get through teching the show, and when we did, I remember the PSM saying, "Okay, now let's run it from the top." And I remember thinking, this is going to be a disaster. I had never seen a Broadway show come together, but still I knew after two weeks there was no way we were gonna get through it.

And then we started and we got through it. Just like that. We only stopped, I think it was twice, and it was because the cast had questions. The crew did not. And after the dinner break, I went to the stage manager and I said, "Is this typical for a Broadway show? Is this a fluke? Was this an easy show?" And he said to me verbatim, "Ken, that's what happens when you have the best stage hands in the world working on your show." And today I'm talking to the leader of those stage hands, James Claffey Jr., the president of Local One, the Stage Hands Union. Welcome, Jimmy. How are you?

[1:51] James Claffey: Thanks for having me.

[1:52] Ken Davenport: And Jimmy has a long family tradition in Local One, including five brothers who are members of the union. I hope you didn't have to lobby too hard for their votes.

[2:00] James Claffey: No, no.

[2:01] Ken Davenport: He's been a member himself since 1982. As a stagehand, he worked at venues all over the city, including Radio City, Madison Square Garden, and of course most of our Broadway houses. He studied labor and negotiation at both Cornell and Harvard.

[2:14] James Claffey: Never heard of it.

[2:15] Ken Davenport: And has been serving as an officer of Local One since 1996 and was elected president in 2004 and is now on his fourth term. So Jimmy, before you were president, back when you were a stagehand, which I love, you worked yourself up through the ranks.

[2:29] James Claffey: Sure.

[2:30] Ken Davenport: Tell me a bit about the process of how you became a stagehand in the first place.

[2:35] James Claffey: Well, I became a stagehand because I followed in the footsteps of my father. It's not unique. I mean, there are a lot of father and sons and nephews and cousins in the industry. That doesn't preclude others from getting in the business. But I came in, I'm proud that I came to my father. My father had five of his sons that he trained personally at City Center, which is the 55th Street Dance Theater over on 56th Street. He trained us all for years, we became members and then we all branched out. I happened to be at City Center for quite a while and then I branched out to Madison Square Garden and branched out to actually the television portion of our jurisdiction through the networks. My brothers went through various locations, Radio City, Broadway. We all kind of branched out and you know my father did a good thing for us.

[3:27] Ken Davenport: Was he a carpenter, electrician?

[3:29] James Claffey: My father was the head electrician at City Center for about fifteen years.

[3:34] Ken Davenport: And you were an electrician as well?

[3:36] James Claffey: I was an electrician at City Center later on, and that's why we like to say at Local One you're a jack of all trades, because later on I moved over to Radio City, I was in the property department. I worked at ABC television on One Life to Live in either the carpenter department, prop department, or the electric department. And I think that our most successful stage hands are probably ones that are well-rounded. I would suggest that there are stage hands that are far more talented as far as the technical skills, but having a general knowledge in every area must serve you well.

[4:10] Ken Davenport: What was the first project that you worked on at City Center? Do you remember?

[4:13] James Claffey: I do. It was The Music Man with Dick Van Dyke. And that was unusual because City Center's a dance house. So for thirteen years I was the head spotlight operator for a lot of the dance companies, Alvin Ailey, Joffrey Ballet, a lot of the incoming ballet companies from around the world and around the country that came in and I got really exposed to the dance world. But Music Man was a musical, but it was not typical at City Center 'cause it was a dance house, but it was fabulous. It was a terrific experience.

[4:42] Ken Davenport: You're coming right out of high school.

[4:45] James Claffey: You know, for a guy who wanted to be a baseball player, I became a stagehand. And to experience that was really something quite remarkable.

[4:54] Ken Davenport: You were how old?

[4:56] James Claffey: I was eighteen.

[4:57] Ken Davenport: Eighteen years old. Right out of high school. Were you nervous backstage?

[5:00] James Claffey: No. You know what? I was probably, you know, the boss of the sonic probably made it a little bit easier. But you really when you're backstage you really have to know what the heck you're doing or you're not gonna be successful because you can't be in the way. And City Center, you know, it's much bigger now, it's been renovated and they have larger all stage space. But back then you had some smaller wings and if you're not in the right place you could be dangerous. But my dad, I'd like to think my dad taught us really well.

[5:25] Ken Davenport: It's funny you say being in the way. On that same production of Greece, I ended up subbing as a stage manager.

[5:30] James Claffey: Oh.

[5:30] Ken Davenport: And it was at the O'Neill, which doesn't have a lot of experience at all. And I literally, after about two or three times subbing, running the deck, I was like, I don't want to do this anymore. Literally, because the stage, you know, we talk about choreography on stage. There is as much or more choreography backstage.

[5:48] James Claffey: Absolutely.

[5:48] Ken Davenport: And I just kept getting in the way of stage hands who were very politely told me perhaps backstage is not the best place for me.

[5:57] James Claffey: At least they were polite.

[5:58] Ken Davenport: Yes. Tell me a little bit about the apprentice program because for those people out there that are listening that I would like to be a stagehand, I would like to get involved. You do have an extensive apprentice program.

[6:11] James Claffey: Absolutely, and I appreciate that you brought that up. We have an apprentice program that we're very proud of. It's administrated by a state organization, so we really don't have control over it. What we do is we try to reach out to all different areas, all different demographics, all different forms of communication and reach out to anybody at all that wants to take our apprenticeship program. It's about every two and a half to three years that we offer it because there's only a certain amount of apprentices that we have to fill positions and we negotiate them in our contracts for apprentices. But anybody that can do well on the test, typically we're taking the top forty out of maybe a couple of hundred folks that take the test, and those top forty we will place them per the order of their aptitude, how their scores for them.

We also have our replacement room, which is open to the public. So, you know, we encourage folks to come in and if they can gain some experience, if they have some sort of knowledge and we can help them through our replacement room and place them whether it's cancellations or additional hires. That room is open to anybody and everybody that can come in and provide a good service. But it's very competitive. I like because you're the top tier. I mean this is the best of the best. I have an ego about it and I say we're the premier stagecraft local on the planet. We're the oldest entertainment union in the United States of America for folks that don't know. But you know, like I said, I have an ego but I carry that with great pride.

[7:41] Ken Davenport: And I appreciate you see. Yeah, and look it's just like the actors union as well. We have the best people in the world on the stage. I don't care what London says—don't tell them. But the same, I'm with you, the best backstage as well.

[7:54] Ken Davenport: Did you go to the theater a lot when you were a kid? Did your dad take you to the—

[7:56] James Claffey: I did not.

[7:58] Ken Davenport: I did not. And I said I was, I was like my whole life I wanted to be a baseball player, so I was playing baseball and you know occasionally I'd go see a concert here and there but I was not a theater goer. And especially I was not a big fan of the ballet until you know I sat there and I watched it and I became a very big fan of the ballet, believe it or not. And it and modern dance and so on but over the years because it's good for my crew to have a presence at their opening nights and it's good for our employers to see me represent my local, I've gone to more productions and I have a greater grade of knowledge and a greater respect for, you know, from seeing it out front rather than from backstage where I was for so many years. So yeah, it's wonderful. It's a wonderful, wonderful business.

[8:43] Ken Davenport: So after a number of years working as a stagehand, you decided to start to work out of rooms like the one we're in, administrative rooms. What drew you to the other side of the stage?

[8:55] James Claffey: I was actually, I was elected, even not by my own choice. I was elected as shop steward at City Center and then later I was elected a shop steward at Radio City Music Hall when I moved over to there and frankly I was pushed by some of my friends who probably maybe saw a little bit more in myself than I didn't see. And I really wasn't, it was never my dream to be the president of Local One. It was not. It was, you know, I was making a good living and I had a good lifestyle and I was proud of what I was doing but I had my brothers and my sisters that said, "We'd really like you to go ahead and make a shot and try to win an election." And I was very, very surprised at my first election and I ran for chairman of Board of Trustees and I actually ran for a trustee but I was elected as chairman to my surprise and it was a very good experience. And from there I was pushed further and finally I didn't have to push it myself and thought, you know what? I could help my local and I ran for president.

[9:56] Ken Davenport: I hear this a lot from people actually, this idea of like I never thought I would produce this. I never thought I would direct this, but you just said yes along the way.

[10:06] James Claffey: I did. And you know what? And frankly I found my niche. You know what? I care about my members. I care about the labor movement. I care about my employers who we have to provide a good service for and I think that I'm better at what I do now than I when I was actually on the stage. I'm gonna bet that some of my brothers and sisters will say the same thing. But you know what? Everybody has their niche and I try to represent them well.

[10:32] Ken Davenport: They'd rather see you in here than holding a follow spot.

[10:35] James Claffey: Yes.

[10:36] Ken Davenport: We'd like to ask them that. Maybe a few ballerinas are happy about that as well. So tell me, you're now the president of Local One. What does that mean? What are your role and responsibility as the president of a union?

[10:47] James Claffey: My role is, one is to make sure that our more than thirty-two hundred members of Local One are served and again the other is to make sure that our employers are served. I have an executive board that we, you know, that we're the leadership that are elected by the membership of Local One. I have four business managers who are, you know, frankly enforce our contracts with employers but also make sure that we're providing a good service and you know I oversee the negotiations of, you know, every employer's contract. We have our negotiations, we have grievances, we have issues, but I'm also, I'm supposed to be the lead promoter of the local. I'm a reflection of the local. I'm supposed to be setting policy that I'm supposed to be a reflection of their sophistication and their honor and that's every day that's something that I take very seriously.

And I think a lot of us again mistakenly believe that Local One is just Broadway stagehands, but it's not. As you said, it's television, it's concerts, it's industrials right in certain venues and we can't overlook the Metropolitan Opera House because frankly I think I know I have an equal amount of stagehands and shop workers at the Met Opera, the same number of stagehands at the Met that I do with all of Broadway combined.

[12:15] James Claffey: Wow, folks do not know that. I did not know that. Metropolitan Opera House is the number one theatrical employer of not only Local One but of the country. So three hundred and fifty stagehands at the Met. It's a twenty-four hour operation. You know, they come down a little bit in the summer because the American Ballet Theater goes in there instead of the traditional opera schedule. Um but we have 350 stagehands there and we have, you know, and you know the industry as well as I that you know on Broadway, you know, whatever the show is, there could be a greater amount of stage crew on the show or depending on how much the needs are, it could be less. But the load-ins and the loadouts predominantly a larger part of our employment, and then the shows, you know, are scaled down.

But the Met has as many as all of Broadway combined. And you have Lincoln Center, you know, all the industrials surrounding that, Radio City, Madison Square Garden, and we service every television network and cable. So we're pretty broad out there.

[13:15] Ken Davenport: I can't imagine it the issues are the same in each different media.

[13:19] James Claffey: Totally, totally different. And I even try to explain that, you know, I sit on the Central Labor Council where predominantly they'll say our contract's up. You know, like the MTA, our contract's up with the city. So every venue, you know, every space has its own contract. We actually have a benefit with the League of America, you know, with the Broadway League where, um, you know, they represent with us 31 theaters where we can negotiate, uh, you know, the Needle Landers and Jampson and the shoe was to negotiate a master agreement and pretty much some of the, uh, the theaters that surround it we can follow through. But you know, everybody else has their own individual agreement and they all have to be individually bargained.

And, uh, it's, you know, it's ongoing. I have twelve open negotiations right now that we're working with twelve. And we have to get a deal on each, and then we've got to move to the next set. And it’s that's why we have four business agents as well.

[14:13] Ken Davenport: It can't be an easy gig for you keeping members of the union that's at the opera and the Broadway stream happy.

[14:20] James Claffey: Very true. And you and it's the same thing with employers. Employers are comparing their contracts with everybody else, and our members are saying, "Why are we not getting more or in the less than somebody else's?" and um, you know, it's a delicate balance. We try to please everybody.

[14:36] Ken Davenport: You've seen a lot of changes, I would imagine, in our industry over the past couple of decades. What’s the biggest change that you've noticed in your work?

[14:46] James Claffey: Uh well, for the union itself, the biggest changes are one, the automation, which has reduced frankly some of our crews for the shows that I was talking about. And the healthcare crisis that's affected not only, you know, our union, every union, but every organization across the country. So, you know, with automation, uh, you know, becomes greater challenges because of the technical aspects and we gotta, you know, there's just as we say this and it's with respect. You know, we're no longer, you know, uh the industry of box pushers. Everybody brings the talent, everybody has to get added knowledge or added skill. And, uh, and automation has increased, you know, requirements on the load ins and the tech periods, but when you get to show, you're breaking down to a smaller crew, and that means that some of those folks that are on a load in the tech period are, uh, looking for work elsewhere.

And again, as a matter of respect, you know, even to our employers on Broadway, um, you know, we're now in a really successful period of time where there's shows in the theaters, but then as folks backed up waiting to come in. You know, some of our members will say, "Well, you know, let's wait for the next show, let's wait for this show to leave and bring the next show in," because we have a load in period where we actually can be employed. So that's contrary to some of our producers obviously, because they want their show to run through possible. So it's, uh, it’s a balance that you have to deal with. The healthcare crisis, everybody's dealing with it, and, uh, and you know, we're part of that as well, and until somebody with a white horse, uh, comes in for, you know, across this country and changes something, we're all gonna be, uh, dealing with it, and our employers have, uh, for the most part acknowledged it and helped us with contributions as far as the board.

[16:26] Ken Davenport: Yeah, we're all going through it. I have a healthcare. I'm an at pan member, which is covered by Atsy now as well, but I, we all, my, as a business owner with my employees, we have an issue. It's a struggle.

[16:37] James Claffey: So one thing that I've noticed about you is you're a very hands-on president. When I was a company manager and a general manager, I would see you backstage talking to people. As a producer, I remember having an issue on Godspell and I emailed you, and you emailed me back right away. We settled an issue, the issue with the business rep. Um, do you have a style of management that you would describe or, uh, you want?

[16:55] James Claffey: And I I'm, uh, I appreciate you acknowledging that. My style is I get a hundred and ten emails a day, and I try to respond to every email in a moment's notice because I know I'm gonna get the following ones followed. I'm sure you have the same thing. I get ninety phone calls a day, just like listen, it's like every other, you know, uh, somebody that has a leadership role. Um, I try to tell my members you make a phone call, I'm gonna return a call that day because you need me if you called me that day. Say the same thing to our employers because I respect their needs as well. But my style is just is deal with it now, because it's not going away, and don't deal with something, you know, later that you can take care of now.

Um, and I'm very, very sincere that I have to provide a service to both our members and to the employer, and I need to do that with honor. And I live by that. I have a two-minute rule. If I can respond or solve the problem within two minutes, I have to do it right then and there. That's what I tell my, uh, employees.

[17:55] Ken Davenport: Well, even us, I think I responded to you at midnight and you responded back.

[17:59] James Claffey: I know. Because that's what, and frankly, that's when the best time to get it done because you're just so much here on the go. It's, it's, it is what it is.

[18:07] Ken Davenport: Do you like dealing directly with producers when producers email you and say, "Hey, there's an issue, can we talk about this?" or does it...

[18:07] James Claffey: I'll deal with any, anybody that's gonna have a productive result. Frankly, there's not a lot of producers that contact me directly. So don't think they'll ask a theater owner at home, but, uh, I've had producers that have contacted me and I'm glad to do that. Um, listen, I, I'm not gonna say no to anybody that it's gonna, it's gonna have a result. I really am not. And I again, first and foremost, I need to do a job.

[18:36] Ken Davenport: Uh, who are your favorite producers and who are your least favorite? I'm kidding. You don't have to answer that. You don't have to answer that.

[18:43] James Claffey: I may know the answer to that question anyway. Um now, uh, let's talk. You were president during the one strike in the union's hundred plus year history, two thousand seven, which was, uh, again it was the first strike. What was it about that time that which things got to such a head that they had never been before for both sides actually, if you think?

[19:06] James Claffey: My view on that is that, um, I'm gonna be honest, and even some of my friends on the other side of the table might not appreciate it, but I think that it was a time that we're the producers are becoming more vocal and the producers are becoming more demanding, and the theater owners who in the past, and listen, uh, my job is to review the past and see the history. And the theater owners frankly controlled our negotiations in the past, and I saw a turn where the producers had more involvement. And frankly, it's their money on the productions, and they want to see, they want to see they have demands and they want to see results, and I saw that change. Um, with the strike, which is unfortunate because nobody wanted to strike.

I can tell you our own internal problems with our international was part of it. I'm gonna say it. Uh, I think that maybe, uh, you know, our international at the time, because it's totally different now, um, that might have created politics that shouldn't have been. And, uh, and we don't listen, we didn't have the relationship back then that we do now. I mean, that's actually it's healed, you know, really well. I have, I've had relationships with the folks in the Broadway League in the past and, and, you know what? They didn't apologize, they wanted cuts, they wanted serious cuts, and and it's my job, you know, it's only news leadership jobs to protect, uh, the money that our folks are making. It's, and you've again you try to find that balance. They want to give us less and we want to make more. And you try to find the middle ground. And it was unfortunate that that it came to that.

[20:38] James Claffey: But, uh, we can sit in the room now and I think that I'd like to think that I matured out of that as well, and try to get a better understanding and, and I have better relationships with the same people and that's actually with my next comment as after that strike, there's been one or two negotiations since that's the first time. Uh, two thousand and seven, so two thousand and ten, so there's been two. So there's been six actually, no, there was a five-year deal. And so there's been one. So we go back to the table this summer. Soon.

[21:09] Ken Davenport: Yeah. And I have heard really n I heard didn't hear anything about the first negotiation. I haven't heard really anything about the second. So it does feel like things have quieted down on the relationship front between the two parties.

[21:21] James Claffey: It was very fragile right after the strike. And we all knew that. But I think everybody had had a little bit of a relief because you know what? The result of that negotiation was, you know, we gave and we got. And the Broadway League, they gave and they got. And, and both sides suffered. Um, at the same time, I think there was also a little bit of, um, uh, added respect for both sides, and I'd like to believe that. But since then we had a negotiation that was very cordial. It was uneventful, frankly. And, uh, but even since then now is I think that the relationship has even grown much, much better. Like I said, I’d like to think that I learned as much as maybe the other folks did and that, uh, we all figured out a little bit better.

[22:04] Ken Davenport: Looking ahead to the future a little bit, what do you think about, and I asked your opinion on this as a really an audience member as well as the president of, uh, the stagehand union. What do you think about telecasting Broadway shows being shown in theaters around the country, like it is at the opera, actually, where you have a deal?

[22:23] James Claffey: They do have a deal. Um, I'm, I’m gonna tell you is I, I don't know if I have an educated guess.

[22:31] Ken Davenport: My opinion is that whatever promotion that we can possibly do to sell tickets is a good thing and at a price that the audience can afford. Our concern at the Met was that we were, you know, the market was being challenged because of that. And until I see some sort of statistic, you know, I can't really give an educated guess on that. But at the end of the day, if we can get the shows out there and folks can see them, it's gonna bring them into the theater, that's a good thing. I don't know if I've actually seen that at the Met. And that's the only thing that I can really leave an example for. I actually don't know the answer to this question. Broadway doesn't have a deal in place to do this.

Right, we have if we wanted to do this, if I was producing a Broadway show and I said, you know what, I want to show this in movie theaters, there's no, there's some precedent there for some shows that have done it, but there's no formula for it. There was an organization, oh my goodness, it had to be thirteen, fourteen years ago, there was a Broadway television network that tried to bring up that concept. And I think there was one example, there was a show years ago that Carol the Net was what it and they broadcast it, but that deal has since expired because it was untested. It really didn't, it wasn't really something that worked. You know, pretty much now if you do a broadcast, we would negotiate a buyout fee as all the other unions would for the folks that have creative involvement with the show. But no, there is no general agreement in place and frankly we've come accustomed, you know, if that would come up we would just sit down and we'd negotiate a deal.

[24:09] Ken Davenport: I joked about your favorite least favorite producers, but all joking aside, you've worked with a lot of them, you've seen a lot of them, you've negotiated with many of them, you've been at opening night parties with many of them, charity events. What are some of the qualities that you think make a great producer today in this market? You know, and I'm gonna tell you it, I don't know if it's going to be like a cliché, but a producer does like anybody else. If they have, if they're creative and they have respect for the product to produce them and the folks that are, you know, making that product and they, you know, and they're prepared and they're willing to acknowledge everybody's input, to me, not only a producer but anybody in our industry, I'm gonna appreciate that person.

And I'm also gonna respect if they say, listen, there's things that you can help us with, and I'm willing to listen to that. And again, it's only what my authority can grab at the end of the day. You know, if I'm asking them to allow input, I'm gonna say, hey, why don't you give us in it pretty well with anybody, anybody that's gonna respect anybody's opinion and involvement and allow creativity, I'm on board with that.

[25:25] Ken Davenport: Where do you see labor relations? You said you're interested in the labor movement as a whole, not just in product. Where do you see labor going in the next twenty, fifty years? You know what? New York City is the number one labor city in the country, if not the world. So the same struggles that are around the country right now are not necessarily existing now, but they could come here. You know, for folks that don't care about the labor movement, you know, versus somebody like me who leads a labor organization. The challenges across the country where states are trying to eliminate the ability for collective bargaining, then I think collective bargaining overall is, you know, I think it's a right that folks have to say like what I just said.

Come back, come at the table, talk about what each other's requirements are, talk about whatever each other's needs are, and try to come out to a mutual agreement. And I never saw, you know, I thought I would never see in my lifetime where there would be states suggesting that collective bargaining wasn't a right for anybody in this country or the right to even, you know, choose a union to represent them. And if it can happen in Wisconsin, if it can happen in Indiana, you know, it might take a whole lot of time, but it could happen here as well. So, you know, unions as a whole are under attack and maybe a lot of it is justified and I'd like to think in the cases where I believe some locals are sophisticated and honorable and doing the right thing providing a good service, I don't think that's wonderful so to each their own but I'd like to think that we're more successful than most.

[26:39] James Claffey: There are lots of jokes about producers out there and you made a comment of we're not a union of box pushers anymore. Are there any myths about stagehands that you'd like to dispel? Like what's the biggest myth when you hear like, oh geez, not the how many stagehands does it take to turn in a light bulb joke? What irks you about people's public perception of the powerful almighty stagehands union? Yeah, the biggest thing that irks me and it irks some of our members is when it comes out in the press and typically it'll happen, it's listen, it's all fair game, it comes out in the press on how much money our stagehands earn. It usually comes out before a major negotiation. That's all fun and I wonder how that happens.

And you know what again that's part of the process. It's all on war. You know that's a small group that will earn that kind of money but even when they put that kind of money in the paper it's not all telling the truth. So when they put in there that they're making certain hundreds of thousands of dollars, that's inclusive of their welfare coverage. That's inclusive of their pension fund contribution. That's inclusive of their sick day amount. And it's kind of unfortunate because it's very misleading. I'm not going to suggest that anybody's eating cat food at Carnegie Hall from our crew or some of our other crews. But I will tell you that some of our members that who are not coming close to those earnings are disturbed by the whole myth, which is a good word that everybody's making that.

Because I have a lot of members that are trying to get by and I have a lot of members that are in the median of earnings and I have a lot of members who are more fortunate than others making more. But it's just a generalization that those making at Carnegie Hall, which is still a kind of expanded number, it's not typical of everywhere else. But you know what? It's all fair and love and you know and you do what you gotta do.

[28:58] Ken Davenport: It's funny, I never thought about that though. You may get calls from producers saying I can't believe these people make so much money, but you also make calls from members going like I can't believe they're making that much money, I'm not making that much money.

[29:10] James Claffey: Yeah, and they necessarily wouldn't even, the average member that makes a certain amount, you know, they're not, if there's somebody makes sixty thousand dollars, you're not putting in the press that they're making the, you know, whatever it costs for their healthcare. So you add, you know, ten thousand dollars on top of that, whatever their pension contribution is, you add another ten thousand, whatever their sick day value. No, the wage is the actual wage that they're taking home each week and they're adding at the end of the year. It's unfortunate that the press accumulates all the significant of different contributions because it's very, very misleading. Again, I'm not suggesting that some of our folks are not doing well. Not as well as people think.

[29:50] Ken Davenport: Okay, my last question. I want you to imagine that the genie from Aladdin who comes to your office, knocks on the door, and says, Jimmy, you've been a great president for now in your fourth term and a great commitment to the local and to the labor movement. I'm going to grant you one wish. You can change whatever it is in our industry that drives you crazy, that upsets you, that keeps you up at night, whatever it is that really bugs you. It can be answers to this have varied from sippy cups to ticket prices. So it could be just the one thing that really gets at your craw about this industry that with the snap of a finger that genie would change instantly. What would that one thing be?

[30:41] Ken Davenport: That was the last question.

[30:43] James Claffey: Alright, so you stomp me on the very last question. I gotta think about that. Could be Sundays, all Sundays off, so you could spend time with your children. It could be, well, yeah, if you want to know the big thing is that New Year's Eve, where I don't think that anybody should be out on New Year's Eve. So yes, if I'm really thinking about something, that's probably the thing that bothers me because I think it's dangerous out there. That's unfortunate. But I also think that it's a challenge for folks to get home. So but what I'm thinking is that if that's the only thing I can think of, things aren't so bad, are they? Right? Things are not so bad. I'm sure if I had some time I could think of, but it's really if that's the thing I can think of, that's, I think we're doing okay.

But no, New Year's Eve, and we've actually talked about, especially with the Broadway League, about adjusting the schedule and trying to negotiate something. It used to be that everyone did shows on New Year's, like everybody was a, when I was at Showboat, we had a champagne toast at midnight. It was a big deal. Now it's much, much less. It's been addressed, and because, like I said, it's unfortunate, but it has become pretty dangerous out there.

[30:54] James Claffey: I gotta come back to that. You're gonna tell I'm gonna think of something. Is that the last question?

[32:01] Ken Davenport: And you even get holiday pay for New Year's Eve, right?

[32:02] James Claffey: Not really. No, New Year's Day.

[32:05] Ken Davenport: New Year's Day.

[32:06] James Claffey: Which is rare.

[32:07] Ken Davenport: So we can work New Year's Day.

[32:08] James Claffey: We can work New Year's Day.

[32:10] Ken Davenport: So it is what it is. Jimmy, thank you so much for spending time with me and the listeners today. You know, before I asked you to do this, I told one of my peers that I was hoping to get you on the podcast, and one of my peers literally said he'll never do it. And as you indicated before, you responded to me faster to my request for doing this than anyone else I've asked. And you said, and I quote in that email that I asked for this interview, you said, if an interview will help promote our industry, I will gladly do it. So thank you, Jimmy, for spending time with me today and for reminding all of us that even though we're on opposite sides of the table sometimes, we're as a whole, we're on the same team, all rooting for the success of Broadway. Thanks to all of you for listening. Thanks for being here. And don't forget to subscribe to the blog and the podcast. Fun guests are coming up, including an actual Tony nominator. Ooh, tune in next time.

[33:04] Ken Davenport: You've been listening to the Producers Perspective Podcast. This episode was sponsored by the Tony nominated play Hand to God. New York magazine says Hand to God is irresistible, intelligent, and heartbreaking. It's Broadway's unlikeliest new must-see play. Get tickets to Hand to God at Telecharge.com.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred