David Shire's melodies have earned him an Oscar, a Grammy, countless Emmy and Tony nominations, as well a special place in the hearts of audiences spanning as far back as 1960... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Guests
Featured Shows
About
David Shire's melodies have earned him an Oscar, a Grammy, countless Emmy and Tony nominations, as well a special place in the hearts of audiences spanning as far back as 1960. David drops by Shetler Studios to look back on his career and revisit not only such films as The Conversation, The Taking Of Pelham One Two Three, All The President's Men, Return to Oz, Zodiac, Norma Rae, and Saturday Night Fever, but to explore his collaboration with Richard Maltby Jr that produced such musicals as Starting Here, Starting Now, Baby, Take Flight, Big, Closer Than Ever, Love Match, How Do You Do, I Love You, and The Sap Of Life. David pulls back the curtain on his career to discuss how he and Richard Maltby Jr created some of the canon's most known works, what it was like being a rehearsal pianist on some of the Golden Age's most iconic musicals, and why he was fired by his own brother in law! Also, David shines the spotlight on Stephen Sondheim, Barbra Streisand, and Francis Ford Coppola! Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Robert W. Schneider: Dear friends, we are so sorry about the ads. They are a nightmare in every way, but with your donations, we can get rid of ads someday.
[0:09] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Beautiful Kevin.
[0:10] Robert W. Schneider: Thanks, Rob. Bach and Harnick are smiling so hard right now. Friends, yes, we are back with a new plea. Much like those adorable puppets from Avenue Q, we are asking for you to give us your money. For those of you who have headed over to Patreon to throw a little money our way, we thank you so much from the bottom of our hearts. Your contributions are the only budget we have for this show, and it provided us a new soundboard and better studio space. So a thank you.
[0:36] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Thank you.
[0:36] Robert W. Schneider: And as you know, nothing is more fulfilling than talking to the legends of Broadway and hearing them share their thoughts, wisdom, and talents with all of us. However, it does cost money. And if you want to help us keep the show going, please head over to Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com. Search for Behind the Curtain, and you can give as little as a dollar a month. And trust me, that dollar will help us more than you will ever know. Plus, for certain monetary donations, you will get to pick your favorite thing and have advanced knowledge of our future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions.
[1:09] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Ooh.
[1:10] Robert W. Schneider: Or you can simply leave canned goods and an original cast recording of How Do You Do Jones outside our doors if you don't want to contribute on Patreon.com. Truth. So once again, please head over to Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com to help us out. Thanks.
[1:24] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Thank you.
[1:26] Robert W. Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.
[1:27] Kevin DAVID Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[1:28] Robert W. Schneider: And this is Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends. Don't forget to follow us on Twitter at Broadway Curtain. And make sure to join our Facebook page at Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends. And follow us on Instagram at Broadway Curtain Podcast. Plus, you can always listen to our podcasts on Broadway World Institute. For over fifty years, audiences have been lucky enough to leave theaters, both stage and movies, humming the gorgeous melodies of today's guest. First, let's discuss the scores that made an entire generation of filmgoers take notice. There was The Conversation, All the President's Men, The Taking of Pelham 123, Saturday Night Fever, and Norma Rae, for which his song and Norman Gimbel's song, It Goes Like It Goes, won an Academy Award.
Plus, I would be remiss not to mention his collaboration with Alan and Marilyn Bergman for the theme song from Linda Lavin's Alice. But it is the theater where today's guest has truly made a home with his frequent collaborator Richard Maltby Jr. and guest of our show. Their scores for the musical theater stage include How Do You Do I Love You, Love Match, Starting Here, Starting Now, Baby, Big, Closer Than Ever, Take Flight, Waterfall, Madame Suzatska. I mean, the list is amazing, incredible. To tell us what it was like to work with such legends as Barbra Streisand, Alan J. Pakula, Peter Eustinoff, Stephen Sondheim, Francis Ford Coppola, Julie Stein, and so many more, here is the Oscar and Grammy-winning composer, DAVID SHIRE.
[2:50] DAVID SHIRE: Hi, glad to be here.
[2:54] Robert W. Schneider: Um I have to ask you this first. We are strictly a theater podcast, right? But I'm going to go out of that realm for a little bit. Is it true that you wrote a score for Apocalypse Now?
[3:05] DAVID SHIRE: Yes, I did. Uh I wrote three quarters of a score, and then it was uh I was dumped.
[3:12] Robert W. Schneider: You were dumped. How dare they?
[3:14] DAVID SHIRE: I'm sorry to hear that.
[3:15] DAVID SHIRE: By my brother-in-law. No, it was a long story, which I will shorten to say that you know I had done uh The Conversation. So Francis asked me to do Apocalypse Now with his father, Carmen, who's a wonderful acoustic composer, but not really an electric composer, electronically knowledgeable. And uh he Francis wanted an electronic score. He wanted an imitative score, but all produced electronically, so it would sound like a uh a symphony orchestra, but strange. And uh I went to work on it, and I think it's common knowledge that during that period Francis was uh kind of having his own apocalypse down in the Philippines. His wife wrote a book about it. There was a lot of being stoned, there was uh a lot of the set being blown away and they had to cut down production, stop production for a couple of weeks, I think a month, and uh all kinds of things like that, which meant that the footage that was coming back that I was scoring um with a group called Sound Arts, an electronic music lab in Los Angeles, that we had weeks and weeks where we had nothing to do.
We had already taken, we take up a queue or a bunch of cues, they would uh say, fine, put it against a reel, uh, and then we'd go back and sit until we got uh some more footage to score. Um so after uh a year or more of this, I was offered uh Norma Rae. And um I thought, no problem taking that. I have so much downtime, I certainly can do another picture. And uh I took it, I started work on it, and one day I got a phone call from the Philippines. This is Francis, I hear you're working on another picture, and I said, uh, yeah, I've you know, I've had many weeks between working on your picture. He said, I don't want anybody working on another picture while they're working on my picture. Uh I'm letting you go.
So it was quite a shock. Um I I say right away that Francis and I are as close as close as ever we pat after he sobered up, yeah, got unstoned and came back. So much so that when a producer, uh record producer does albums for the cult of film score lovers, said found found the score among when he was going through my archives, a tape of it. He he said, This has to be released. This is terrific. I said, Who would want this? He said there's you know at least 3,000 people out there who collect these. Yeah, so we had to get permission from Francis, and uh uh I called Francis and I said, Hey, uh somebody wants to do my score for Apocalypse Now, you know, just a limited release for film score uh buffs, the cult.
And there was a silence, and he said, What score? He didn't even remember. He didn't even remember that. That's how did he say yes? Was he like, yeah, yeah, you can do it? So it's out there. There's he said, Yeah, there's a record. I would have brought one today. Oh my god. Uh I've got lots of them. Ah amazing.
[7:05] Robert W. Schneider: Okay. Now that thank you. I'm I'm a film buff, so that's satisfied my curiosity. Now we'll celebrate your theatrical triumphs. So DAVID, where did you grow up?
[7:14] DAVID SHIRE: In Buffalo, New York.
[7:16] Robert W. Schneider: Oh Buffalo, New York. The uh opposite end of the state I wanted to be in. A lot of people put down Buffalo. We used to say if you were giving New York State an enema, you'd put the tube in Buffalo. But I grew up in Almira, New York, which is also Western New York. So we they're connected. Your city's a little bigger than mine, but it was close.
[7:44] Robert W. Schneider: When's the first time you played a piano?
[7:47] DAVID SHIRE: Well, my uh take a step back. My father was a professional society band leader at night in Buffalo, and he taught piano during the day, but he taught pop piano. In those days, pop piano was theater music. Oh. There was no pop music was theater music, of course. Those are the hits of the on the parade. So I grew up where most kids are listening in their cradles to nursery rhymes. Uh I heard the strains of my father's pupils playing Kern and Gershwin and Rodgers and Hart, Rodgers and Hammerstein, uh the list, you know, the drill. Uh so I thought that was that was the first thing that was music to me. That was my my baseline. So the first time really that I sat at a piano, I guess I was on my father's knee.
I have a picture of it. I don't remember, but I have a picture of sitting on my father's knee and he's showing me things at the piano. Um eventually to be the kind of uh well, I thought it'd be a jazz pianist or um or cocktail pianist. Whatever my father did was to me was the height of show business glamour. He went out at night and all dressed up and played with his orchestras ranging from five to fifteen players. And actually my first uh professional experiences as a musician were sitting in with his band when I was old enough, and then taking out his second band or third band on a busy night like New Year's Eve, where he sent out other orchestras. And you would lead or you would be the Yeah, and I'd be the leader in the second or third band with uh his musicians who uh kind of accepted me, but when I told them I was heading for a career in music, they said uh kid, be careful, because they all had day jobs, they were terrific musicians, but during the day they were mailmen and bank presidents and every other thing. Um so anyway, my dad got me to a certain point, but I soon realized that in order to be a real musician, you have to know more than a than a few stanzas.
[10:12] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. Uh so I was I went to a classical teacher who specialized in children. I was with her until I was 12 or 13, and then went to a more of a uh uh a grown-up teacher for you know my skills were advanced enough that I could be accepted by him. And um I became a better pianist.
[10:37] Robert W. Schneider: Right, you worked the classics then. You started doing the more classics, which you know it feeds the pop.
[10:43] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, and the pop feeds the classics. It's like doing ballet bar and when you do jazz dance. I mean, it's like you gotta have a basics in order to was there a composer whose work was very influential on you that you enjoyed playing.
[10:54] DAVID SHIRE: Um the greats, you know. Of course, Gershwin, of course, among all others because he spanned both classical and popular. I must have listened to the concerto in F about 300 times. Um my influences uh became broader the older I got. And of course, there was new music coming out of Broadway all the time.
[11:24] Robert W. Schneider: Right. Yeah.
[11:25] DAVID SHIRE: And uh I guess Sondheim certainly we were at Yale when West Side Story came out.
[11:32] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[11:33] DAVID SHIRE: And uh I remember we uh those of us in the Yale Dramat quickly wore out our periods of West Side Story. And the first show that Richard and I wrote at at Yale for the Yale Dramat was uh I should have brought you a record, you'd get a kick out of it. I'll send it to you. Uh we did an adaptation of Cyrano de Bergerac, and when you when you play it, you can certainly hear how much I was stealing or trying to steal from West Side Story.
[12:04] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, really?
[12:05] DAVID SHIRE: And then the next year we did another original, and um was it the Grand Tour?
[12:05] Robert W. Schneider: Grand Tour.
[12:11] DAVID SHIRE: And by then uh I was wearing out the record to uh Most Happy Fella.
[12:17] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, yeah.
[12:18] DAVID SHIRE: And you can certainly hear the we had a number called Abondanza.
[12:25] Robert W. Schneider: That sounds familiar, right?
[12:26] DAVID SHIRE: It was set in the Napa Valley.
[12:29] Robert W. Schneider: That's funny. So how did you meet Richard?
[12:32] DAVID SHIRE: Right. This is an off-told story.
[12:35] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[12:36] DAVID SHIRE: We've heard it from Richard's perspective. We've read it in articles, but you'll probably hear it almost word for word.
[12:43] Robert W. Schneider: Great.
[12:46] DAVID SHIRE: I was accepted at three colleges, uh, Yale, Brandeis, and Columbia. And I what finally made me pick Yale was that uh they were the only one that produced original musicals every year. Uh not hairy leg shows like at Princeton and uh you know things that called themselves musicals but weren't really booking music. Because you knew you wanted to write musicals at the moment. And of course, meanwhile, Richard was at Andover, I mean at Exeter, actually writing musicals.
[13:22] DAVID SHIRE: And he picked Yale, I think largely for the same reason. So we found ourselves there early French freshman year, me looking for a lyricist and Richard looking for a composer. And luck would have it that one of Richard's Exeter buddies who was in one of his shows happened to be my next door neighbor in the dorm where we lived. And when he heard I wanted to write musicals, he went and told Richard and made what the Yiddish call a shit, which means a, as filthy as it sounds, it means a get, a fix-up, yes.
[14:05] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, yeah. And we met in the Yale Commons, and we took immediate dislike to each other. Richard thought I was a hick from Buffalo, and I thought he was a snob, a preppy snob, and we were both right. Yeah. That's exactly right. Um, but as Richard is fond of saying, we were the only game in town. Yale now has, we've done master classes back there. They have musical theater this and musical theater that. People have asked us what was the musical theater department like at Yale. I said, Richard and I were the music theater department. Um, so we, and Richard also likes to tell, and I was embarrassed about it at first, but I think now I could, I've earned the right not to be embarrassed by it. Um, I appeared at the Yale Dramat with their next show they were gonna do.
I said, I have a musical, let me sit down and play you, and I played them some melody. They said, Well, what about the lyrics and the book? I said, Well, you know, find somebody to do that. I was totally music oriented. Right. My father. I went to shows for many years and hardly paid attention to the lyrics. I think it was melody and chords and everything. So eventually the dramatic realized that I wasn't as stupid as I sounded, and we wrote our junior year, the Serena.
[16:02] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Sure, no, that's when you guys wrote that. When you finished up, then you moved to New York City.
[16:06] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. Then we made a beeline for New York as soon as we got out. And how did you get your shows out to the public? How did you get your music out of the book?
[16:15] DAVID SHIRE: Well, first we had to make a living. Right. How did you? And luckily because I was a pianist, I could start working as a rehearsal pianist, playing for auditions. Oh actually, one of the people I played auditions for was young Linda Lavin. I started my relationship with her, which eventually resulted in doing that theme that you from Alice, yeah. For Alice. Um, and I played dance classes, I played jazz dance classes at the eighth floor of Carnegie Hall. This was before the Fantasticks. And all the theater kids took those classes. They were famous jazz classes by a man named Frank Wagner, and I'd sit and play the blues for hours a day while he taught steps to the kids. But it allowed me to meet, because people would come over and say, Do you could you play an audition for me next week?
And blah blah blah. Then you couldn't that work. So I did, and I was playing auditions at the same time as Barbara Hamlish was playing auditions and Billy Goldenberg was playing auditions. We were all kind of starting out at the same time.
[17:36] DAVID SHIRE: And meanwhile, Richard and I were writing a show called The Sap of Life, which eventually got on about a year after we were in New York. Um, partly because the director of Grand Tour at Yale was a man named Bill Francisco, who also moved to New York about the same time we did, and he and a producer friend of his were determined to get our first show on, and they did in the village, and that show attracted Steve Sondheim to come down, and I think he brought Jerome Robbins and Hal Prince with him.
[18:19] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Had you met him yet?
[18:20] DAVID SHIRE: No, we hadn't.
[18:21] DAVID SHIRE: We met because of Grand Tour. Right. I mean, because of Sap of Life, we made the contact with Steve because he was very impressed with the score. And from then on, anything we wrote, we played first for Steve.
[18:35] DAVID SHIRE: Oh, yeah. First time I heard Forum was in the midst of him composing it at when we went over for a mentoring session, and he said, You want to hear some numbers from my new show? And we sat there and he played even the ones that were cut like Love is in the Air, which is one of my favorites. I love that song. And eventually, all the time I was doing rehearsal piano arranging, going up to the Catskills and playing acts for Marilyn Michaels. I've lately have become a little obsessed with the Catskills circuit because we don't have anything like that today. And there was that was a whole world that existed.
[19:22] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Did he?
[19:27] DAVID SHIRE: Not really. No. We've heard it. I would love to tell us to hear a little bit more about the Catskills.
[19:32] DAVID SHIRE: He was at Tamiment for a couple of summers.
[19:35] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh, I do repeat.
[19:35] DAVID SHIRE: Mary Rogers was there. Carol Burnett. He really got a great another dose of theatrical education. And meeting people and I was, as I said, playing making my living as a pianist while we were working on a number of shows, none of which got on.
[19:58] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Um, like what? What were some of the shows that you're working on in that one at all?
[20:01] DAVID SHIRE: We were working on a show called The Girl of the Minute. Uh, it was gonna be like about Baby Jane Holzer, if you remember Big Society in the swinging 60s, who is famous for being famous. Um, eventually some of those numbers went wound up in Starting Here, Starting Now. You know, we're great recyclers. Um, let's see, where was I? Um, we were playing rehearsal, playing rehearsals.
[20:36] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Maybe you were playing the Fantasticks at this time.
[20:38] DAVID SHIRE: Well, that came a little later. So Sap of Life closed after six weeks. It was a true success to Steam. Um, the book was, as Richard described it the other day when we were talking about it, was really nonsense. It was based on the blurb on the back of a book called The Wapshot Chronicles by John Shiver. He just took the description of the book and wrote a book about it. It's wild, but the star of it was Kenny Nelson, who left the Fantasticks.
[21:14] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh, yes, Kenny N.
[21:18] DAVID SHIRE: And that led to Harvey and Tom coming down and seeing the show, which was heavily influenced by the Fantasticks, not that in the way that those shows at Yale were and that I actually stole, but that it was the same kind of, you know, six-person cast musicals, small stage piano, two pianos and percussion playing it. And that wound up getting a much better job than just playing auditions all the time because I had a steady salary for 400 performances of the Fantasticks.
[21:59] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Wow.
[22:00] DAVID SHIRE: And I think I left the Fantasticks when Peter Daniels, who was Barbra Streisand's accompanist, did all of her early arrangements and played all of her nightclub acts, Blue Angel, and became the pianist in the pit of Funny Girl, and had been playing it for about a year, and I knew him from my other day jobs, the arranging and the accompanying.
[22:32] DAVID SHIRE: Right. Peter was having an affair with Barbara's understudy, who was Laney Kazan.
[22:42] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oops.
[22:44] DAVID SHIRE: And you not yet. Okay. I'll cue you and just say oops. And Peter made the mistake since Laney was he had written a night, wanted to get a nightclub act together for her to start trying out her stuff in Queens or whatever. And he used some of Barbara's arrangements. And Barbara found out about it, and that was the end of their relationship. Now you can, but his downfall was he asked me if I would like to replace him in the pit of Funny Girl. And by that time, we had already had a meeting with Barbara, who was, you know, the hottest young thing around. All the young composers were taking songs to Streis, and everybody strice and do a song of ours with the Blue Angel. Um, we had had a meeting with her, and she took a song called Autumn, yeah, which was the big ballad from Cyrano, right.
And she recorded it. Um, I know that a few other songs have come out of Broadway, out of college shows, but not many. And that was our first professional recording juniors and all that. So Barbara knew about me and she's approved of me, and I played 800 performances of Funny Girl. I became the assistant conductor.
[24:20] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Wow.
[24:20] DAVID SHIRE: Oh my goodness. And conducted about 30, 35 performances of the show. About some of them with Barbara, and then Barbara left to Mimi Hines.
[24:33] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, we've interviewed Mimi Hines.
[24:34] DAVID SHIRE: And I co and I played for Mimi Hines too. I mean I conducted for Mimi Hines. So that was a great job because that was a bigger weekly salary. And you were relatively young to be conducting. I mean, I mean, I mean not that who says it's a very good thing. I mean, I was what, twenty-five, twenty-six.
[24:55] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Wow.
[24:56] DAVID SHIRE: Were you a I wanted to lead from just about the time we were getting discouraged over from not getting our shows we were writing on, a man named Ivor David Balding. Remember he was a big hot shot show producer. This was I guess in the sixties. You guys are so young. That's must be like when we were thinking of Rudolph Frimo. I'm very conscious of the fact that we're eighty years old and talking about people that, no, please we usually know all of the same again, Ivor David Balding. Balding, okay. You can look him up. I'm sure he disappeared after a while. I lost track of him. But anyway, he had pr he was producing a show called Love Match, which was about Prince Albert and Queen Victoria meeting as teenagers, I guess they when they first met and she became queen.
And um was not something we would have ever picked to do a show about, but they had a score that a comp team had written. Can't remember who they were. They were I guess beginners and they didn't like it. They liked part of it, but they asked us to come in and write two numbers to replace two numbers they had. And uh I think they were offering something like a thousand dollars a number, which was, oh my god, we've moved into four figures. And uh we wrote the two numbers, and then they said, Well, these are terrific.
[26:44] DAVID SHIRE: Uh why don't you write two more? So another two thousand dollars we wrote them, and then they said, We're throwing out the score we have, and we'd like you to do the whole show. So we did the whole show. It was directed by an English prominent English director at the time named Noel Wilman, who was more Shakespearean Shakespeare director than a musical theater director, being choreographed by uh Danny Daniels.
[27:14] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[27:15] DAVID SHIRE: Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Yeah. We we know most of the names, we just didn't know Ivor. And it was fully financed and had dates at the Almundston Theater in LA. And we thought, okay, it's not so we wanted to write, but boy, we've lucked into a Broadway show with big time people, and uh wow. So we wrote the show, and some of the numbers you know, for instance, uh uh I think I may want to remember today was the first was the song that uh uh Victoria sang after her first meeting with Albert.
[27:54] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Well, that's why she's like, Albert, that's why, that's why it's the oh that song a whole new way now.
[28:01] DAVID SHIRE: They they met and she was being, you know, it was very formal and she was being very pompous. Yeah. And uh okay, and then they he left and she's oh that's why the panel part is so um and watching the big parade go by came out of Sap of Life and went into uh starting here, starting now.
[28:30] Kevin DAVID Thomas: I and I I was just gonna ask you, the score to love match is incredible.
[28:34] DAVID SHIRE: Oh, you know it. Yes, it really is incredible. Is there any recording of it?
[28:40] DAVID SHIRE: Um some group wants to do it now, some uh I think some from college or something, and I have uh Rich and I have an assistant who's digging it up from the archives and trying to see in if we can put together our version.
[28:59] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, it it um it does. I've I've avoided listening to the score, except for the numbers we we plucked out of it because it's it became an unhappy memory because we went to the Almundson. Uh we had Patricia Rutledge as and Hal Linden.
[29:21] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh yeah.
[29:22] DAVID SHIRE: Uh as uh the prime minister and Lawrence Guittard as Albert. And uh we played six weeks at the Almundsen, and we did not get great reviews. And we were supposed to go to the uh oh before before Los Angeles, we played Phoenix, Arizona in a movie theater which had been was being used part of the time as a as a uh legit theater.
[29:53] DAVID SHIRE: And we had audiences of cowboys and uh who were so interested in the story of Victoria and Albert. So that was not much fun. And then we went to LA, which we figured would be a lot better.
[30:07] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[30:08] DAVID SHIRE: Uh but we did not survive LA. Um so we never went to Detroit, which was gonna be our third stop, and then into New York. Um just ended in so it ended, and that was the beginning of my movie career.
[30:25] DAVID SHIRE: Oh, because Richard went back to New York, and I was really disgusted. I thought we I can't get our own shows on. We get this gift of a Broadway show and uh disaster. And uh I'm uh I ran into Billy Goldenberg.
[30:42] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, uh who had started writing film scores at Universal.
[30:47] DAVID SHIRE: You were in LA at the uh at this time. Uh and he said, you know, uh, and he he wanted to started out wanting to do theater, but I guess he he got the the LA bug uh before I wound up there and had become a kind of uh uh young man on the rise as a composer in the Universal uh music department, television department.
[31:14] DAVID SHIRE: And he even scored one of Steven Spielberg's first uh television movies uh called Dual, the one about the truck driver, Jason got an over. So uh he said I said I really um not anxious to get back to New York. He said, Well, I'll take you over to Universal, introduce you to the head of music over there.
[31:36] DAVID SHIRE: And um I had done just enough um television scoring. I had scored in in New York so that I had a reel of stuff to play for him. His name was Stanley Wilson. And I played those.
[31:56] DAVID SHIRE: And a week, two weeks later, I'm standing in front of a 20-piece orchestra writing the sixth season of The Virginian.
[32:05] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Well.
[32:06] DAVID SHIRE: And I became Mr. Not because I was had gone through Phoenix, but I became Mr. Western. And I thought, I wanted, I can't, I wanted to do those jazzy film screens like uh uh, you know, those shows, those cop cop shows which were prevalent even then.
[32:25] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Uh, you know, the kind that Manzini didn't have to be.
[32:28] DAVID SHIRE: Yes.
[32:29] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Peter Gunn.
[32:30] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, Peter Gunn, that kind of thing. And I said to Stanley Wilson, I wanted uh I don't think of myself as doing Western. He says, Well, you don't have to write genre scores for Westerns.
[32:43] DAVID SHIRE: Write in your style, you know. It's it's kind of a free-for-all. He said, Quincy Jones had just done uh a feature called McKenna's Gold, and he said the score was kind of half Copeland and half uh and and half him.
[32:58] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, and so I did. So it was great training ground for composing on fast deadlines, um having a uh a professional orchestra ready to play away, yeah. And hear it right away.
[33:15] Kevin DAVID Thomas: So my orchestration took a great leap.
[33:18] DAVID SHIRE: Would you orchestrate as well? I mean, because usually there's hired orchestrators.
[33:22] Kevin DAVID Thomas: The money was was not big enough then to hire uh uh an orchestrator and still make enough money for it.
[33:31] DAVID SHIRE: You would, I mean, obviously you're a smart enough musician, but you knew how to score. To me, one of the big attractions was orchestrating.
[33:38] DAVID SHIRE: Um, because I wanted to do that. I wanted to conduct uh those orchestras. And I've conducted I I've orchestrated about 90% of my film scores.
[33:50] DAVID SHIRE: And when I don't, when I haven't orchestrated them, I've written eight-line uh sketches that are uh so completely pretty specific that it's like I mean nothing is left to to chance. They don't write notes or pick instruments, they just do the labor of translating uh sketches to to a big orchestra.
[34:13] Kevin DAVID Thomas: When when you are working on composing a film score, for example, something like um the conversation, do you prefer to see the the rough cut of the film without any director communication ahead of time and get a sense of what you feel the music should be for the scene, or do you like the director to tell you it should feel moody and scary here and go have fun?
[34:34] DAVID SHIRE: Uh I like to get them to take I prefer to get them to take their temp score because they always have temp scores while they're editing off the movie when they show it to me so that I'm not listening to somebody else's music.
[34:47] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh that oh yeah.
[34:49] DAVID SHIRE: Temp score. Wow. Uh Mike Nichols temp scored um what was the big movie with Dustin Hoffman?
[34:58] Kevin DAVID Thomas: The graduate.
[34:58] DAVID SHIRE: Graduate with Simon and Garfunkel scores. And then uh songs.
[35:05] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, yeah.
[35:05] DAVID SHIRE: And then uh Dave, was it Dave Grusen? Somebody came in and wrote a whole score for the picture, which he then threw out and used the summoning type of.
[35:16] DAVID SHIRE: Um and uh one of the famous ones is Kubrick Temp Scored uh 2010 with the score that's in there now, all the classical pieces.
[35:30] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, and uh Alex North wrote like two, three hours of music for it, which has been released on record, like my apocalypse.
[35:40] DAVID SHIRE: Right, right, for the collectors and yeah, and um it was thrown out, and he found out about it when he went to the preview, apparently, because Kubrick never told him, and uh he went the preview, and uh there was none of his score in in the picture.
[35:59] Kevin DAVID Thomas: So I mean, those are in a way, those are faulty exam uh not complete analogies for that because the the scores that they wound up using were the great yeah were the the right choices, right?
[36:15] DAVID SHIRE: But most of the temp scores you get are uh you know scratch music that the editor picks out from somebody's recordings, and they're usually on the nose things, and really good scores for good pictures uh are not genre scores.
[36:31] DAVID SHIRE: They f find the particular thing that is right for that movie. Francis, the first thing he said to me in the conversation when we started talking about the kind of score, he said, I don't want electronics, and I don't want an orchestra.
[36:46] Kevin DAVID Thomas: And my heart sank because I thought this was my first high profile picture, big budget.
[36:51] DAVID SHIRE: I thought, I'll get a big orchestra and and no, he didn't want that, he wanted piano score, and I thought he was nuts, but of course he was absolutely right.
[37:00] Kevin DAVID Thomas: When you start composing for a character on stage, um, where where do you begin that process? Do you look at the lyrics and then write around that?
[37:09] DAVID SHIRE: Or the first is the book, uh discussing the scenes before you even discuss the uh any specifics about the song.
[37:19] DAVID SHIRE: You discuss what the song is going to do, what action it's going to be, what is going to illustrate, what part of the story arc it has to deal with.
[37:33] DAVID SHIRE: Because our songs are like all good theater songs are scenes.
[37:38] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yes, that's right.
[37:39] DAVID SHIRE: And do you feel then the composition has to have an emotional arc to it, the same way the character has an arc?
[37:45] DAVID SHIRE: Well, the arc that if you're just writing the scene, the the emotional emotional journey if it's that kind of song. Certainly uh uh Oh It a Beautiful Morning uh is not an action song, but it sets up a character and and a milieu is it has that job.
[38:07] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Um people have asked me many times which I prefer better writing film scores or theater scores.
[38:20] DAVID SHIRE: I bet it was on your list.
[38:21] Kevin DAVID Thomas: No, no, I have no questions down, just facts.
[38:24] DAVID SHIRE: But I am curious, yeah.
[38:25] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Or how do they one affect the other?
[38:28] DAVID SHIRE: Uh and I say they're really in many ways they're two different things, but they're really the same thing.
[38:35] DAVID SHIRE: And I think the reason why film scores, the ones that stand out stand out, is because of the dramatic and melodic gifts that developed in the theater, because I've had written lots of theater music before I even touched a film.
[38:51] DAVID SHIRE: And film gave me technique in orchestration and a more uh more of a compositional, more compositional skills that I've used back in the theater.
[39:05] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Wow.
[39:05] DAVID SHIRE: Um and speaking of the theater, um, I'd like to jump back to the 60s first we can expect that.
[39:11] Kevin DAVID Thomas: No, no, this is great.
[39:12] DAVID SHIRE: This is really fantastic.
[39:13] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Um were you involved with anyone can whistle?
[39:17] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, I was uh second rehearsal panelist on that.
[39:20] Kevin DAVID Thomas: So what's it like being in the room? This is the with the legendary nine performance musical that that everyone wish they could have seen.
[39:28] DAVID SHIRE: So what was it like being in the room with uh Stephen Sondheim and Arthur Lawrence and Well, I mean it was Mana.
[39:37] DAVID SHIRE: Uh I was just a wide-eyed kid going out of town with my first Broadway musical.
[39:45] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, we were in Philadelphia. Well, after that we rehearsed in town. And uh it was it was a real adventure.
[39:53] DAVID SHIRE: Uh I loved the score. I thought the show would just be another hit.
[39:58] DAVID SHIRE: Uh I think I was as surprised as everyone when it took the dive that it did.
[40:03] DAVID SHIRE: And I thought Steve Sandham, Arthur Lawrence, Her Bros, they were untouchable. They just wrote hits. So I guess that was a valuable lesson.
[40:14] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Uh and then you you wrote TikTok from company, is that correct? Did you so how did that come into your orchestra?
[40:21] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, I shouldn't say I wrote it. It's it's it's an arrangement, a dance arrangement. Um, how did you come to this dance arrangement? Um Jonathan Tunick had orchestrated a show I forgot to mention in the chrono early chronology called How Do You Do I Love You?
[40:42] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[40:43] DAVID SHIRE: Also Magnificent. Yes, we're which was a theater tent show that Lee Goober produced. And um I had uh uh I had had my relationship with Steve, and he came out to see How Do You Do I Love You. And the night before he had to make his decision on the orchestrator for company, um he called me up and he said, I don't know whether to use Don Walker again, who had done anyone can whistle, or Jonathan Tunick, who really s I was really very impressed with.
[41:30] DAVID SHIRE: I said, absolutely, Jonathan, I said, Don is not the right orchestrator for that. Because on anyone can whistle, I was in the room when the piano parts were given to the orchestrator, and I had to play them while Steve discussed as much as he could uh indicate about what was going to be in those uh what he wanted in the orchestrations. Um and then the orchestrations came in, and I thought they were ex really wrong for the st Steve Steve writes very transparently, and the uniqueness of his sound is that transparency, that it doesn't sound like traditional Broadway music and Broadway orchestrations.
[42:28] DAVID SHIRE: And Don, who I think wrote some of the best orchestrations in the world for say uh uh the Napa Valley show. Most happy fella. He was a work with did things like double double a lot of lines. I think he thought I know that early orchestrators working with Steve earlier would see his music as, well, this is you know, this sparse music. I've got to make it Broadway. So they thickened it up, and it didn't sound like Steve. It sounded like this kind of hybrid between this music that wasn't typical Broadway music and these orchestrations which were the same thing that you heard all the time.
[43:17] DAVID SHIRE: So uh that was another footnote to history that I got Jonathan Tunick and Steve Sondheim together. But anyway, Steve they were out of town, and by that time we were friends with Hal Prince. And um who uh who did the original dance arrangements? Uh he died Wally Harper had done the dance arrangements, and most of them were very good, but that piece they were not happy with because it didn't sound like Steve.
[43:49] DAVID SHIRE: And one of the reasons Steve was uh was impressed with me as a composer, because uh I had taken from Steve, I guess he was enjoying his own music as well. But Richard claims that I did a lot of things that Steve didn't do that Steve was impressed with. But anyway, uh who knows. But they had to pick somebody who could come in and do that, redo that uh uh ballet or whatever you want to call it for for Donna McKechnie. And um I was the name that obviously came to mind.
[44:33] DAVID SHIRE: And uh I was just about to get married to my first wife, Talia Shire, and uh I said, Hal, I'm I'm getting married in in in three days. He said, Well, get on a plane at the day after you're married, and I guarantee that in Boston you'll have the best honeymoon. So the honeymoon started out with Talia having bronchitis locked in her room in whatever that hotel was they they all use in Boston, and me locked in a room with Jonathan and Michael Bennett and and Donna McKechnie doing that whole dance arrangement again for hour after hour after hour.
[45:26] DAVID SHIRE: And uh Talia was not happy. Oh and we lasted 13 years, even though Steve said I give them six months.
[45:39] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Happy honeymoon.
[45:40] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. What was interesting too, they were tickled by the fact that when they were writing Bobby, I was one of their models because they were always trying to fix me up with Gloria Steinem. They fixed me up with uh Mary Travers. They fixed, they were always trying to get DAVID fixed up.
[46:02] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Right.
[46:02] DAVID SHIRE: So I was one of those guys who was uh That's amazing never never gonna get married and there there I was getting married. They were still looking for the end of the show.
[46:15] Kevin DAVID Thomas: It's right here.
[46:16] DAVID SHIRE: It's right here in front of you. Um I have to say that uh a wonderful moment was when Steve finally wrote Being Alive and called us all up to his hotel room to hear it.
[46:31] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh I was there.
[46:32] DAVID SHIRE: Oh wow that's incredible. What was that song, Someone in the Tree?
[46:39] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, someone in the hotel.
[46:41] DAVID SHIRE: Exactly. I was there. Those are epic moments though.
[46:44] Kevin DAVID Thomas: They really are.
[46:45] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, they really are, you know. And so now you're out in Hollywood, having a very successful career, and then all of a sudden you get a call from is it Manhattan Theater Club that says, hey, we'd love to do some of your songs in a review?
[46:59] DAVID SHIRE: Got a call from Richard. Richard who said uh it's uh I'm putting to throwing together this review of our songs. And by then I was A, I was getting sucked into the life in LA. Yeah, and and B, I uh I had mixed feelings about uh I didn't want my heart broken again back in New York.
[47:26] DAVID SHIRE: And I said, Well, what do you want to dig those out? They're all from flop shows, and and he said they're good songs, a lot of them are good songs. I I want to put them together. And uh if you don't like what I do, uh you don't like what's up there when we put it together, you come back from LA and look at it.
[47:47] DAVID SHIRE: Um I'll scrap it. So uh I can't remember if I went back and and found the the dog eared yellowing sheet music from all these shows in in my uh archive, which is more I thought of as a graveyard. And uh but anyway, he got the music and he put together Starting Here, Starting Now, or the the one act germ of it.
[48:21] DAVID SHIRE: And I came back, sat down in a rehearsal studio much like these, yeah, and listened and and was just terribly moved. I it I I realized that yeah, we had written really some good songs, and just because the books were not what they were supposed to be, the songs could could have a life.
[48:45] Kevin DAVID Thomas: So uh he he pulled me back in.
[48:48] DAVID SHIRE: That's awesome. And um uh start, you know, starting here opened at uh nightclub uh Barbara Anne's and then oh, it stayed at Barbara Anne's. Oh, first it was done at eighty-eights, I think.
[49:06] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh yeah, and uh uh and then we had to add more songs to make it a full evening. Um the same thing happened with Closer Than Ever, uh after Baby only ran eight months, even though it got a lot of attention, and some people I know love that show and love that score.
[49:28] DAVID SHIRE: Again, it was another show that you know we we've had a very odd career. Yes. Uh we sometimes get introduced these days as uh Broadway legends, but I don't feel that way.
[49:45] Kevin DAVID Thomas: I understand that.
[49:46] DAVID SHIRE: Because I I know what well when I talk like this to to Didi, my wife. Yes, yes, yes. She she gets very annoyed with me. She said, That that isn't the point. She said, see the work that you've done and see how people react to it. It doesn't necessarily mean you're a failure because uh you you don't have a uh a hit.
[50:15] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Right.
[50:15] DAVID SHIRE: I mean Stephen Sondheim, you someone might say, you know, none of his shows ran longer than two years, really. So it's you know, it's I read an interesting thing. Uh uh Adam Gopnick, I wrote a show with the New Yorker writer last year, which um uh was tried out at in New Haven at the Long Wharf.
[50:35] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[50:36] DAVID SHIRE: Um and he's become a great friend. I've always enjoyed his writing so much. I was reading an article of his the other day that ended with the thought, he said, most artists who look at their career from the inside see all the things that they wanted to do that they haven't done or the accomplishments they wanted to make that they have.
[51:00] DAVID SHIRE: And he said, and the people who are looking at their career from the outside don't see that, they see what's on the outside. And I thought, yeah, that's exactly it. I'm looking at the inside, and they're looking at the outside.
[51:14] Kevin DAVID Thomas: So, and I think it's good to be aware of the difference, but I shouldn't get crazy about it.
[51:19] DAVID SHIRE: I think I'm more c more comfortable with it now. Um, and we're still writing, we still got a couple more lottery tickets. You know, I got three shows that are circling New York still, Take Flight, Suzatska and Waterfall.
[51:37] DAVID SHIRE: I thought they were all dead, they've all come alive again, or rewriting them for the umteenth time, and uh who knows.
[51:47] Kevin DAVID Thomas: How has your uh writing relationship with Richard evolved over the decades?
[51:54] DAVID SHIRE: Um, since college. It pretty much was there from the beginning. I would say it's evolved in the sense that uh for many years I felt I was his student, you know. I was the guy who came into the dramatic just melodies, and he was show wise, and but right away I had to start learning that a film uh theater score was not you could have the greatest melodies in the world, and still it could go down the drain.
[52:24] DAVID SHIRE: And and Richard was really tough with me. He was a great mentor. He threw away songs of mine right from the beginning. And I remember when we were trying to write a song for the autumn scene, I came in with something that I thought was really terrific, and he said, No, no, that's that's not good enough, and then came in with another one.
[52:45] DAVID SHIRE: Well, it's better, but you know, this is like 11 o'clock number guy. And I finally got really angry and sat down at the piano and wrote all of them and came in with it. He said, That's a song.
[53:00] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Wow.
[53:01] DAVID SHIRE: But for many years, uh I've always thought of him as the person who knows. But I got more adept as a lyric writer.
[53:11] DAVID SHIRE: Oh, yeah. During that period, during as the as the years progressed, because Richard in those days would feel he had to have a perfect first line before he could write the second line, and a perfect second line before he could write the third line.
[53:28] DAVID SHIRE: And I would say, well, why don't you just you know do a draft? So I've something to work with. Um and the lyrics sometimes took painfully long. You know, it was like uh I know Rogers complained that Hammerstein took, then he'd set the lyric in ten minutes and Hammerstein. Um so that I I started writing dummy lyrics to get Richard, I because Richard was great rewriter, but when he was writing his own lyrics, he was rewriting them at the same time and trying to make them perfect. And I'd turn in a dummy lyric and he'd say, Oh yeah, but that's that's not right. And then he immediately corrected and he'd have a good first draft of of the lyric. And my dummy lyrics got better and better, and there are lines in Baby even that that are that are mine.
We can't even remember. But on the other hand, he is more in a way more of a natural theater composer than I am because his sense of structure and drum and and what music has to do, even though he doesn't play an instrument, uh first of all he has a a tape recorder memory for music. So things that I wrote and he says play 'em did you record that? And I said, No. He said, But that was terrific. But he could sing it back to me. Or I'd be writing a uh a playing a piece I had played the day before and he said, That's not the chord that was there yesterday. I said that that modulation could only take place with that chord. Uh what do you mean? He said, No no you played something different yesterday and he turn on his Walkman and sure enough there was a chord that I didn't think existed that I had played the day before.
Wow. So even though I've made a contribution, I've been a a great editor for his lyrics, uh the same thing has gone the other way. He is uh he really almost should have a credit as uh as part of uh in fact we once toyed with the idea of doing just a double credit music and lyrics. But in truth he he has the final say and for the kind of lyrics he writes, uh I I can't touch that 'Cause he he doesn't think of them as lyrics. He thinks of them as little plays and scenes and um and he likes to have the melody first, by the way.
[56:11] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh, interesting.
[56:12] DAVID SHIRE: Unless it's a Patters song where you pretty much the lyric has to dictate the rhythm. Uh especially when it's a ballad or something. He likes the jagged unpredictability. He said, because when he tries to write a lyric first, it comes out sounding Hallmark and and too regular. Right. Uh it's like those wonderful lyrics that uh Hal David wrote for for Bert Bacharach. Oh. Because Bert wrote those wonderfully jagged melodies. Right. Weird time signatures and going in and out of the yeah, yeah. And Hal loved that. Yeah. But who would write who would go that? Do you know the way to San Jose? Yeah. Blah blah blah blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. That's wow. And Richard loves that. And and h his job, he said, is finding he says my instincts are are right when I c when I connect.
And when he knows when he knows the music is right, he can find the lyric. The whole lyric, the whole melody for autumn existed before he wrote that very sparse lyric, which sounds like it came out right at the same time as as the melody. So that it to finish that line, uh our relationship has become m much more reciprocal as I've grown. And he's grown too, but I think I've grown a lot more, and it's mainly mainly due to due to him. Wow. That's beautiful. Which song do you think best epitomizes your collaboration?
[58:01] DAVID SHIRE: You know, you have an awful lot of favorites. But I the first one that popped into my mind was one of the good guys. Which I think is an absolutely stunning lyric. And a song. Richard likes us to write songs that have never been written before, like the end of the first act of Baby Story Goes On. Yeah. And uh and the odd thing about that, I will now admit it in public, that melody existed because I was working trying to write pop songs with uh uh uh Hollywood lyricist. Uh during my days out there, I was desperately trying to get a hit. Yeah. And uh I played it for Richard, and he said, if you give that song to anybody else, that melody to anybody else, we're done. So I luckily the girl hadn't finished the lyric yet, and I took it back.
And then Richard wrote that incredible lyric for a pre existent well, I mean I had to add a few notes there, but the basic structure, the whole thing was was there. Wow. Yeah. Um and and yet, by the way, Norman Gimbel handed me the lyric for It Goes Like It Goes, and I didn't think of myself as very good at uh nearly as good at setting lyrics, because when I set lyrics often it the melodies seemed very workmanlike. They did the obvious thing. But he handed me that lyric and said, Don't change your word and went off on a skiing trip. And uh I sat down and in a day or two that that melody came. So I guess when the connection is right and the lyric is right, uh I c I can do uh do settings. Yeah. Um whose idea was it to do Baby?
[1:00:11] DAVID SHIRE: Interesting story. Um Tally and I would go up and spend and do visit uh Francis Nelly in uh Napa where they had a wonderful house and he had just bought his 1500 acres of prime vineyard. Um he's he wrote shows when he was in college, directed them and wrote books for them. He he too came out of the theater. He loves loves theater. Yeah. And uh we were driving I don't in Napa, I don't know f where we were going to, but we were taking a long drive and he started chatting. He said, What are you writing? I said I said, I you know we don't get good ideas for shows. Uh it's so hard to find a a decent idea because we don't want to do obvious things, and when we want to do a adaptation to a really terrific thing, we can't get the rights.
He said, Well, what's the most interesting thing? Uh the most exciting thing that's happened to you in the last couple of years. And without without even giving it a second thought, I said being birth being present at the birth of uh Talia son Matthew, uh and he looked at me and he went, and that was the germ. I went back to New York. He said, Oh, by the uh he also said that this was in the days when big musicals were uh coming in, and those were gonna be the salvation of Broadway, the big monster shows. Uh and he said people might be getting tired of that. Why don't you just do something that really comes out of you that's um honest and heartfelt and related to your own experiences, you know, you don't know about kings and queens, Alberts and Victoria's and all that.
Um he said that do a small musical that's involved with that. So I came back and told it told that to Richard, and Richard said, that's a terrible idea. A show about a babe called Baby and Diaper Show and uh diaper jokes, and uh and then he went away and uh came back a few days later, he said it isn't really about the baby, it's about the couples having the baby. It's really about that. The baby's just a catalyst having the baby. And then he really got interested. But then he had to go off to England to do uh if he's doing Ain't Misbehavin', or yeah, he's doing Ain't Misbehavin' while we were doing that, and he was doing uh Miss Saigon while we were trying to write Big. He's always off doing something.
Um that's one of the reasons why I I wanted to write a show with a with Adam, because I wanted to write one show that I did with somebody else. And even though it it wasn't Broadway ready, it had a lot of really good stuff in it, and I made a good lyricist out of out of Adam, who had a lot of natural talent, but I really was uh I really was just channeling everything Richard had taught me and Stephen Sondheim had taught me Adam, because he t his lyrics tended to be a little too prosy or off off the the mark and that whole thing of that Steve taught us. Um a lyric has to be uh understood in real time. It's not a poem. Poem you linger over, you wonder what it means. He said if the audience is confused for one word and has to stop and think about it, they lose the next line. Yeah. Yeah. So even though Adam knew that, his natural instinct was, you know, to to say too much. So uh that was an interesting experience. Did um Baby change a lot in the rehearsal process?
[1:04:36] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. We uh did many workshops and the first day of rehearsal after multiple workshops, we had the first reading and had our meeting afterwards and said the second act doesn't work. So we threw away the second act on the first day of rehearsal. Do you remember what happened in the original second act? They didn't make it work. I don't know, but Richard and the book writers said it just not working. It might have parts of it might have worked. So Richard said, I'll direct, I'll stage the first act, and at night we'll rewrite the second act, which we did. Wow. And then we still shot ourselves in the foot because uh the producer, Jim Freiburg, thought the second act was too dark. So we took out Patterns.
Right. Uh and since it's gone back in. Right. And um Fathers of Fathers, we couldn't make work, so we cut that too. And some of the smarter reviews said the book is not as good as it could have been because the fathers are too dimensional and the women are really three-dimensional. And if those if that song had been in there it would have given more color, yeah. It would have given the shown the the the guts of the of the father. Has that song gone back in in any of the revisions?
[1:06:14] DAVID SHIRE: We couldn't get uh we never solved getting um Fathers of Fathers back in because it involved having all three fathers at a certain point in the plot where they could all sink together. And we always, if we got one father in, it was like whack them all. Right. Whack a father. Couldn't couldn't get them all believably into the same thing. But we got Patterns back in and that's been big.
[1:06:45] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, that's a great iconic song. Um and it was nominated for Best Musical. It was nominated for Best Musical and Best Score. And it was up against Jerry Herman for uh uh uh La Cage aux Folles on one side and Stephen Sondheim for uh Sunday in the Park with George on the other side. And I thought we have about as much chance of winning as winning the lottery. Yeah. And oddly enough, Jerry Herman won, and I thought how outrageous. Yes. And a lot of people did. Yeah. And he made that kind of snide comment, like at least the show tune still exists. Right, yes. Yeah. Yeah. Can't imagine sitting there hearing. It's just been wild. Uh what a wild time there. But anyway, the show, as you know, had its lovers and still does.
Oh yes. And we hope that, still hope that, uh if say Vertel wants to do it on course that it could finally get it. Yeah. Because we've done lots of rewriting. It's been done regionally all over the world. Oh, yeah. And every time there's been a regional production that we've been involved with, we've used the opportunity to um uh make some more changes. In fact, we even wrote a new number that's uh a trio for the women called The End of Summer, which they have in the second act, like uh Fathers of Fathers would have been. Uh the three women singing kind of in different places, but the same idea. They are at the same point in their plot.
[1:08:39] Kevin DAVID Thomas: That's marvelous. Um, how does Closer Than Ever come about?
[1:08:42] DAVID SHIRE: How much was, how does Closer Than Ever come about? Um I think was it was it because Lynn? I I can't remember. Uh that if Lynn asked us to do another uh evening. I know we did a uh a one act version again uh at um I think it was '88 again. I'm I'm very bad at remembering specifics from 30, 40 years ago. Doing great so far. But maybe Richard we had done a show, oh yeah, we did a show for uh made contributions to a show for Manhattan Theater Club called Urban Blight. You ever see that? It was a review that about 10 or 15 writers contributed to. Playwrights contributed sketches, Terrence McNally did one, I think John Shanley might have done one, you know. And um Lynn asked us to do all the songs, which are about sixty-seven songs, and among those songs were Miss Bird. Uh the exercise song, um and one of the good guys. Oh.
[1:10:10] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[1:10:10] DAVID SHIRE: So at one point I think Richard felt we had a nucleus of another review. New material, yeah. And it might have been a period when nothing was happening. And we were a bit post-Baby and pre-Big, I think. And I take it you had moved back to New York City at that point?
[1:10:31] DAVID SHIRE: I've been back in New York for twenty, twenty-five years.
[1:10:34] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh wonderful.
[1:10:35] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. Moved back w uh when we went into rehearsal on Big.
[1:10:39] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh.
[1:10:40] DAVID SHIRE: Because I had to be back here for that. And by that time, I was not uh entranced with the LA California. The LA life was no more. I knew where my roots were and it was time. And also the technology made it possible to keep scoring movies wherever you are.
[1:11:03] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh yeah.
[1:11:04] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. I scored uh uh the Fincher movie. Oh uh Zodiac.
[1:11:13] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Zodiac.
[1:11:14] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, that was good. Oh without I was in New York, he was prepping Benjamin Button in South Carolina, and uh the sound designer who I was working with uh was in Marin County, and we all had the same access to the same server that had the cut up to date each day. Incredible and so we all sat in our studios and worked on the picture and then sent our work to Fincher, and Fincher would make his notes and go back and we'd make our fixes and send it in again. And he'd green light a cue and then we go on and write the next year. We had to write, make uh demos of cues of the whole picture, the whole score, that were so good that if it had been a low budget picture that couldn't afford an orchestra, they could have very well used our temp score and it would have been creditable.
But anyway, the technology made it easy to service my career in LA, but it has suffered. I mean, I also you reach a certain age and you kind of age out. I remember when I started working at Universal, I couldn't believe that DAVID Raksin was doing these low budget pictures because he couldn't get a big one anymore. David Raksin. I mean, my God, one of my heroes. Uh and now I'm in about the same position. I do indie features back here. I've done four low budget indie features got to New York in the last uh five years. And I'm about to start on another one this fall.
[1:12:54] Kevin DAVID Thomas: That's awesome.
[1:12:55] DAVID SHIRE: But it's good because it fills in the blanks because these musicals take F and Fever.
[1:13:02] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, so insane.
[1:13:04] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, and I was just gonna ask you, uh, when did you get the offer for Big?
[1:13:10] DAVID SHIRE: Um Didi and I had trouble having uh um uh fertility trouble having our child and we did all of these techniques like ZIFT, LEFT, ZIFF, BIFT, all of them. There was a whole bunch of them, and nothing happened. And one of them was, I think it was ZIFT, where eggs had to be taken out and replanted uh to be available, and it involved Didi spending a night in the hospital. And while she was there, I had to go home for and and leave her alone for for a good part of the night. And she couldn't sleep, and she was watching television, and the movie of Big came on. And when I came back the next day, she said, I've got something you can you can uh this this would make a great musical, Big. And I said, Well, first of all, we can never get the rights. She said, Oh, yes, you can. She said, because one of the producers of Grease was Larry Mark, and he happened to produce.
[1:14:21] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh my goodness.
[1:14:22] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. And he would love to be co-producer. Uh and so no trouble getting the rights. He's like, I already called him. He's already said Jim Freidberg thought it was a great idea. And uh that took six or seven years in workshops like crazy.
[1:14:39] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[1:14:39] DAVID SHIRE: And fifty-seven songs.
[1:14:41] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah, fifty-seven.
[1:14:43] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, we just and Mike Ockham kept throwing away songs, many of which are back in the show now. The uh variety reviewer who just trashed the show when it opened on Broadway, um came and up to Hartford to see the regional production, which we had totally revamped. We put back in a lot of the songs that that Mike cut. We so was scaled down to not be big anymore, which also killed it for the people for whom it it killed it for.
[1:15:22] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[1:15:23] DAVID SHIRE: And uh he came up and reviewed it in Hartford, and the gist of his review was why wasn't this on Broadway? This is a hit this is oh man yeah I know can't even imagine yeah but it hopefully might come back someday well again it MTI says it's they it's one of their biggest sellers it's done all over the place we were involved in its original incarnation this is now the version uh Eric Schaeffer yeah directed it and the first thing he did when uh was say I want all the previous drafts and he contact us every few days he said why was this cut why was this cut how could you get rid of this so he just made us restore what what he finally restored was the show that we went into rehearsal with yeah did Mike just not understand the world um we had wanted Susan Stroman choreographer and when she came for us to audition the show for her uh she brought Mike because they were engaged at the time right and we didn't have a director yet and um I thought well that that seems to make sense he's done a couple of musicals but Richard realized later the musicals he's he had done were uh Me and My Girl with a song with existing score and Crazy for You with a great score by Gershwin.
[1:17:07] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Right.
[1:17:07] DAVID SHIRE: So he thought that, you know, songs were just these come and go. And we wrote songs for a different kind of show than he had ever done. That's right. And I I feel funny, you know, saying publicly, I've said it before. Mike was terrific. We had we had a totally unadversarial collaboration. But at one point Richard remembers saying to him when he wanted to cut a certain number, he said, Mike, if you cut this number, there's no score left. I said, what do you mean? There's all these other s we wrote a number for uh Susan to sing uh just before the end of the end of the show when Josh has to separate from her. He said you can't put a ballad in and at the end of the show a new song you gotta have a reprise. Audience can't take he had all these formula things that he learned from doing the musicals that he had done which were not really the same aesthetic and then he died which was really terrible.
[1:18:16] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Tragic yeah.
[1:18:16] DAVID SHIRE: And Susan did the most wonderful dances. The FAO Schwartz the kid and all also we were treated a little bit like we're f we're gonna give you guys the hit you should finally have that you've always wanted and that you deserve so it was like making a hit rather than taking what we gave them and Widem gave them which was a a sh a a much more gentle interior show which is what the rewrite was like.
[1:18:51] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Theater.
[1:18:51] DAVID SHIRE: You're trying to create theater, not a hit.
[1:18:52] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[1:18:53] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. And that probably would have been a hit because all the dances still would have been there. But it would have been a you know about the emotions primarily, not about the scenery.
[1:19:05] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah. And so now coming up, you've got a bunch of stuff brewing.
[1:19:10] DAVID SHIRE: We have Take Flight, um Madam Susatska, which was in Toronto.
[1:19:16] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Toronto.
[1:19:17] DAVID SHIRE: Uh huh. And with the famed Arthur Kraminsky.
[1:19:20] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh yes.
[1:19:21] DAVID SHIRE: Oh yes. That's been I could do another hour on the back.
[1:19:25] Kevin DAVID Thomas: And so could Lynn and Steve.
[1:19:27] DAVID SHIRE: Yes that told us.
[1:19:28] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh yeah.
[1:19:29] DAVID SHIRE: I said we've got some real great war stories to give you the city.
[1:19:32] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Well we'll give you some back you um and Take Flight.
[1:19:38] DAVID SHIRE: Take Flight um Joey Parnes and Josh the choreographer did uh Bright Star.
[1:19:47] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Josh Rhodes.
[1:19:48] DAVID SHIRE: Josh Rhodes really fabulous.
[1:19:51] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[1:19:52] DAVID SHIRE: Uh Joey Parnes made uh uh a and also the d the uh producer of the Old Globe. They had a spot that was available uh at the end of I guess it's it would have been right about now and about a year ago they said if you can get the show in shape, we did a workshop for them and they they said uh yeah but it's it's still not quite ready.
[1:20:19] DAVID SHIRE: And uh so we had weekly meetings for a while up at work sessions up at Joey's office in his conference room uh Joey and John. I mean, uh uh Josh and John and me and Richard. And we've substantially reworked the first fifteen minutes of the show, which was one of the major things that had to be done because it was how to get those three stories seemingly inevitable seeming to be inevitable in the same evening.
[1:20:53] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Right. And what are those three stories?
[1:20:54] DAVID SHIRE: Lindbergh, uh Amelia Earhart and the Wright Brothers. And um there were it, you know, the show was done in in uh at the chocolate factory in London. Uh it was done uh in Japan by Alma and Miyama Miyamoto. Oh no, that yeah Am and Miyamoto and uh at the McCarter most recently.
[1:21:26] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Which is where I saw it, yeah.
[1:21:28] DAVID SHIRE: And uh each time we've almost gotten there, but it's never been exactly right. But Josh is terrific. He under he seems to be totally on the same wavelength as as uh the three of us. And these meetings have been very good, but very frustrating because we didn't get the get it done in time to make uh um the producer at at the old globe comfortable.
[1:21:58] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Right.
[1:21:59] DAVID SHIRE: And so he had to give the spot to somebody else, and now we can't the next possible opening is like a year from now.
[1:22:09] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Okay.
[1:22:09] DAVID SHIRE: So you know, the beat goes on. And what was great about having a date that was like that is that was that's what makes you right. Yes, yeah. We met every week. Now we're it's kind of well, we got a year, right? John is tremendously busy, we're tremendously busy, Josh is tremendously busy, so you don't make sure you have that weekly weekly meeting. But uh our hope is still the old globe.
[1:22:38] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Okay.
[1:22:39] DAVID SHIRE: Uh I don't know what's gonna happen with uh Suzatska, which will not have that name, that awful title. Um Garth who was so hands-on for the the first production that Adrian couldn't do his job, none of us could do our job. Craig Lucas couldn't do his job. Uh Craig uh isn't with the show anymore, and Garth is trying to find a new writer. Uh we just came back from three days in Toronto where we worked on a new outline with Adrian there, and without and with Garth seeming really chastened and amenable to listening to people, and um uh allowing us to do our work without nipping it in the bud, you know.
[1:23:40] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Wow.
[1:23:40] DAVID SHIRE: Adrian would have an idea at rehearsal, and Garth was sitting there for every minute of rehearsal. No, no, you can't do and uh it was just not a not a good situation. But um and w waterfall, we're going to Richard and I are going to Bangkok, all expenses paid. Oh, okay. June 6th, yeah, yeah. It sounds wonderful. We were there once before, and uh we sit in a room and work uh on the outskirts of the city where all of the, you know, like in LA, the business section. Yeah, either downtown or way out. None, no Hollywood.
[1:24:27] Kevin DAVID Thomas: No.
[1:24:28] DAVID SHIRE: We landed in Bangkok and checked into our hotel and looked out the window, and Richard said, We're in Chicago. Because there was no none of those wonderful book owners or whatever those things.
[1:24:44] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yes.
[1:24:45] DAVID SHIRE: And the last day we had a sightseeing tour. Went to all the temples and things. Uh and did a research tour at a music school. But we're going back for a work session. And again, starting in many ways from square, well, not from square one. We got a lot of good songs. Again, it's the book and the the way the show flows. There's a uh uh economist called Schumpeter, who invented the term creative destruction. I've been reading things in my spare time to get away from the I love math and systems theory and all of these left brain things that I'm working my right brain all day.
[1:25:40] DAVID SHIRE: I know my writer friends listen to music at night, and they asked me what I do at night. I said the one thing I don't want to do is listen to music. I I read books, I read the books you're writing during the day. So thank you. And you're listening to my music at night.
[1:25:56] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Exactly.
[1:25:58] DAVID SHIRE: But Schumpeter invented the term uh creative destruction. Yeah. Like for a new thing, a really new thing to exist when a system has gotten to such a point that it just doesn't work anymore. It has to go so something, a really new thing. Instead of making fixes with the old thing, right, uh like an economic system that gets more and more complex point. Like what's happening with capitalism.
[1:26:26] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yes.
[1:26:26] DAVID SHIRE: It isn't capitalism anymore. It's this thing with all of these stuff on it. It it has to fall by its own weight until a new so a new thing commercial. And I saw uh light bulb went on. That's exactly what's happening with with uh take f with um Susatska and Waterfall. They the decks have been cleared for a lot of drak and everybody seems willing to to try to f to start from a little ways back and build something. So it could go either way. Um but you know what? I'm eighty years old and I'm very happy to be working all the time in movies and theater, and uh uh the having the hit isn't as important as just working and loving what I do. And I love what I'm doing.
[1:27:20] DAVID SHIRE: I love the work now more than I've ever loved it. I was terribly anxious uh most of my life about meeting a deadline or having this song be better the best thing I've ever written. Or and now I'm much more in tune with what my gifts are. I know what I can do, I also know what I can't do, looking at it from the inside. But I'm trying to get over the make making that uh making letting that make me feel make me feel bad.
[1:27:57] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Yeah.
[1:27:58] DAVID SHIRE: Uh just keep keeping my eye on what's what's important. And uh Didi and I are working on uh uh a children's musical cartoon series for young kids that were pitching to PBS. We've made a pilot of it. Every show has four little mini songs. The idea is to make a children's show for really young children with music that is not plum stuck in a right, but real book book songs. And uh I've been doing both music and lyrics for that. During the period uh about five, six years ago when I didn't have any Richard and I were not working and I wasn't getting pictures, did that, and uh that might that might happen.
[1:28:55] Kevin DAVID Thomas: That's wonderful.
[1:28:55] DAVID SHIRE: And Dee Dee's writing a one-woman show for herself. She'd been writing it for three or four years. Um uh that's gonna need incidental music, so we're gonna work on that together. And uh, you know, that's great. And I get to see the band's visits. So happy. I love it.
[1:29:18] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Um, DAVID, you know, on behalf of us and all of our listeners, thank you so much for all the wonderful work that you've given us these these years. It's incredible. Um, and I hope you know this because we teach at college so much. Um, you and Richard's work is really instrumental to integral. It's integral to the education.
[1:29:35] DAVID SHIRE: It's essential, yes.
[1:29:36] Kevin DAVID Thomas: But it really does that a lot, and it's very gratifying. So that's how really you're so known in that way.
[1:29:41] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah. We do uh we've done some um uh master classes with groups. Uh we did one at Carnegie Mellon where they have a wonderful music theater department, and the kids all learned songs of ours, and then we went down and they did them the first day, and we gave Richard gave them directorial notes, I gave them music notes, and they came back the next day, and boy, oh it was like night and day. It's amazing how few of the because our songs, as Richard probably has said, are they not easy? No, they're very easy to miss to misunderstand because they seem like another song, but the subtext is something else.
[1:30:26] DAVID SHIRE: And Richard uh really became a director out of out of to protect our our own stuff because he knows how to direct it. Yeah, which is why they're so useful in the education because that there is they're inherently challenging. And we've been told that by so many uh young people, and and it's really uh gratifying because I think of uh I tend to think of myself as a dinosaur.
[1:30:51] Kevin DAVID Thomas: They're timeless, those are no and and when we hear that we realize that's a contribution.
[1:30:56] DAVID SHIRE: Exactly.
[1:30:57] Kevin DAVID Thomas: I don't think there is a musical theater student in the past 20 years who has not done a multi and shire piece.
[1:31:03] DAVID SHIRE: Oh, we hear that all the time.
[1:31:06] Kevin DAVID Thomas: And you are worshipped and revered, not just by them, but by us as well. So thanks for joining us today.
[1:31:11] DAVID SHIRE: Thanks for watching.
[1:31:12] Kevin DAVID Thomas: What are we so much?
[1:31:14] DAVID SHIRE: I know.
[1:31:14] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Who wants as much time as Richard?
[1:31:16] DAVID SHIRE: Anecdotes up to Gwazu.
[1:31:18] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Oh, that'll be we'll do a part two with anecdotes.
[1:31:20] DAVID SHIRE: Yes, I know.
[1:31:20] Kevin DAVID Thomas: We'll start with Garth Krabinski and see what we got.
[1:31:23] DAVID SHIRE: Umright till next time.
[1:31:24] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Bye, everybody.
[1:31:29] DAVID SHIRE: Good day, Mr. Thomas.
[1:31:30] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Good day, Mr. Schneider.
[1:31:31] DAVID SHIRE: Well, it has happened. We finally hit over 100 iTunes reviews, and would like to thank each and every person who took the time to do so.
[1:31:40] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Huzzah.
[1:31:42] DAVID SHIRE: Now we want to climb those charts even faster. And that is where you lovely folks who have not yet rated us come in. The process is very simple. On your podcast app, tap the search tab, enter our name behind the curtain, Broadway's Living Legends, tap the search key, tap our beautiful logo, tap the reviews, tap write a review, then tap your way into our hearts.
[1:32:05] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Tap your troubles away.
[1:32:06] DAVID SHIRE: That's nice, Rob. Once you are there, you can rate us from one star to five stars. Think of one star as Hervey V Rob, how do you say this name?
[1:32:14] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Herve Villech.
[1:32:16] DAVID SHIRE: Oh, dear God. I walked right into that one. Think of one star as Erve Via Jez. And Ima Sumac in Sideshow and five stars as front row seats to the opening night of Gypsy.
[1:32:27] Kevin DAVID Thomas: But they keep me.
[1:32:28] DAVID SHIRE: Yeah, they keep me for the third time. I thought that was pretty good.
[1:32:34] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Excuse me, Arthur Lawrence.
[1:32:36] DAVID SHIRE: Excuse me, but trying to liven up our commercial ads a little bit.
[1:32:40] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Eight minute long commercial.
[1:32:43] DAVID SHIRE: It's an infomercial at this point. I'm gonna be like that lady that sells you the copper pots. Look at this. You can put 400 pounds of manure in it and it slides right out. Then you can make an omelet.
[1:32:55] Kevin DAVID Thomas: You got another line, Kevin?
[1:32:57] DAVID SHIRE: I'm waiting for you to say plus you can leave your comment and let us know if you like and what guess we're like.
[1:32:57] Kevin DAVID Thomas: Plus you can leave a comment, let us know what you are liking, what you're not liking at this point, or what guess you'd like to hear next. So head on over to iTunes and let us know what you think of our little show. Speaking of little, I'll tell you a story about Charles Lawton later. Thanks, guys.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
