One of Broadway's busiest and most respected set designers, Tony Award winner John Lee Beatty, swings by Shetler Studios to sit down with Rob and Kevin and review his portfolio which includes over 100 Broadway credits including the set designs for Ain't Misbehavin, Talley's Folly, Baby, The Most Happy Fella, Chicago, Once Upon a Mattress, Wonderful Town, and so many shows over at Encores!.. Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Featured Shows
About
One of Broadway's busiest and most respected set designers, Tony Award winner John Lee Beatty, swings by Shetler Studios to sit down with Rob and Kevin and review his portfolio which includes over 100 Broadway credits including the set designs for Ain't Misbehavin, Talley's Folly, Baby, The Most Happy Fella, Chicago, Once Upon a Mattress, Wonderful Town, and so many shows over at Encores! John pulls back the curtain on his career to discuss how a day with Michael Kidd transformed his career, what it was like working with Ming Cho Lee, and why he is the go to designer for living rooms everyone wants to live in! Also, John shines the spotlight on Douglas W Schmidt, Richard Maltby Jr, and Gerald Gutierrez! Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Robert W. Schneider: Headed over to Patreon to throw a little money our way. We thank you so much from the bottom of our hearts. Your contributions are the only budget we have for this show, and it provided us a new soundboard and better studio space. So a thank you. Thank you. And as you know, nothing is more fulfilling than talking to the legends of Broadway and hearing them share their thoughts, wisdom, and talents with all of us. However, it does cost money. And if you want to help us keep the show going, please head over to Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com. Search for Behind the Curtain, and you can give as little as a dollar a month. And trust me, that dollar will help us more than you will ever know.
Plus, for certain monetary donations, you will get to pick your favorite thing and have advanced knowledge of our future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Ooh. Or you can simply leave canned goods and an original cast recording of How Now Dow Jones outside our doors if you don't want to contribute on Patreon.com. Truth. So once again, please head over to Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N dot com to help us out. Thanks. Thank you.
[1:01] Kevin David Thomas: Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.
[1:03] Robert W. Schneider: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[1:04] Kevin David Thomas: And this is Behind the Curtain, Broadway's Living Legends. Don't forget to follow us on Twitter at Broadway Curtain. And make sure to join our Facebook page at Behind the Curtain, Broadway's Living Legends. And follow us on Instagram at Broadway Curtain Podcast. Plus, you can always listen to our podcasts on Broadway World and Stitcher. Today's guest has over 100 Broadway credits as a scenic designer. This does not include his work off Broadway. One hundred regional theater, so he's a figure going up. He's going higher than one tenth. He's doing eleven, twelve, thirteen, fourteen. It's like an auction. 16, 100 and 16 Broadway credits as a scenic designer. This does not include free general or off Broadway.
When does the man's sleep? His work has been rewarded with two Tony Awards, 13 nominations, five drama desk awards, and a place in the American Theater Hall of Fame. Not to mention the fact that he was trained by a titan of American theater design, the great Ming Cho Lee. Now, some of his credits include Ain't Misbehavin, Tolly's Tally's Folly, Fifth of July, Baby, the Most Happy Fellow, A Delicate Balance, Chicago, Dinner at Eight, Wonderful Town, 20th Century, Doubt, The Odd Couple, Rabbit Hole, Good People, The Nance, and Countless Countless Others. We could be here all day. Here is the Tony Award-winning scenic designer JOHN LEE BEATTY.
[2:31] Robert W. Schneider: John, how are you?
[2:31] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I'm here.
[2:34] Robert W. Schneider: We're grateful. I mean, how do you have time?
[2:36] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Thank you.
[2:39] Robert W. Schneider: So where did you grow up originally, John?
[2:41] JOHN LEE BEATTY: In Claremont?
[2:42] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I grew up in uh Clarence, Southern California. I was born in Northern, but I grew up in Claremont, California.
[2:47] Robert W. Schneider: And how did you discover theater living in Claremont, California?
[2:50] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I had academic parents. I grew up on the campus of Pomona College, and I was taken to the theater. I cannot remember when, but I think I regressed out at the Oregon Shakespeare Festival, and I think I saw a Shakespeare all the way through at age five, maybe. But they took me to the tryout of Peter Pan with Mary Martin in Los Angeles on stage.
[3:14] Kevin David Thomas: You were like seven or something.
[3:16] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Seven. And it took. I came home, interestingly. Children are fascinating, but um interestingly, I wanted to fly. I wanted to fly on a wire, and I wanted to design scenery, which is really weird, but I totally uh got it. You understood that that was something that you got.
[3:35] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Totally different. I did someone had to design that scenery up there. I got the activity. I understood ground plan, and I was watching the painting and I the technical part. I totally got it, which is kind of weird. And then I continued being the only set designer in my elementary school. Fill in the blanks right up, you know. I went to Brown University where all theater was extracurricular. So I was a set designer there. And it was only when I got to Yale School of Drama for graduate school that Ming Cho Lee was standing in front of me. And that was the first time I'd actually seen uh a real designer who'd, you know, had dinner and was standing up.
[4:19] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[4:19] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah. All those qualities that you wanted, a profession you were pursuing. Now, your undergraduate did not have a theater major, is that correct?
[4:28] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Not until later. Uh as I just did my last year, we had a uh a technical director who had a technical theater course. One of the problems for me, and it's a problem for any student, was I was the best set design student because I was usually the only set design student.
[4:45] JOHN LEE BEATTY: By default. And the interesting thing, uh, I was always doing well, and uh the fact that I could, you know, I don't know what came over me. I would build all the costumes from carousel, and then in the spare time do the scenery in the poster. And uh, you know, I was still had a full academic program going. I even graduated with honors. I don't understand what happened.
[5:06] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Youth.
[5:07] Kevin David Thomas: But youth, yes, exactly.
[5:10] JOHN LEE BEATTY: But uh I think that I had that ability to do things with my hands and do it quickly, but I had never had any competition really, per se. I thought the designing scenery was such an honor, I didn't understand nobody else wanted to do it. But uh then I got to Yale, and then there was competition. There were other people in my class, and my first project wasn't so good. Ming Cho Lee told me some things that were wrong with it, and then there were other people in the class. And once there was a little competition out there, I would say the next week my work was 100% better than it had been, and I picked up a lot about designing, and um it's a sort of a wake up.
[5:57] Kevin David Thomas: How long uh what was the time between graduating from undergrad and going into Yale?
[6:03] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Immediately.
[6:03] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, immediately you did it immediately, right?
[6:05] JOHN LEE BEATTY: As I said, I come from an academic family. We just keep on going. In fact, when I got to New York, I can't I finally took the union exam in scene painting and uh the United Scenic Artists in scene painting and in set design, and I got in and I went from Summerstock then that last year at Yale, I came straight to New York because I I needed a job. So uh I went in a straight line right through all of school, and then all of a sudden I woke up and I wasn't in school, and I was like, wow, this is fun, and I'm so glad I went straight through school, but but I also realized I liked working and wasting my own money for a change and uh not being in school. I loved school, but then I didn't realize I'd never questioned it.
[6:55] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, of course.
[6:56] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, it happens.
[6:57] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. Um tell us about May I say for to be a set designer or a costume designer, any sort of designer, you do not have to go to graduate school.
[7:05] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I I a lot of us did, and a lot of us went to Yale, but uh and NYU and other schools, but one of my best friends was an actress and became a wonderful costume designer because she had good intuitive skills about clothing and actors, and you know, and Ken Billington famously lighting designer, he went straight into assisting Therin Musser. I mean, that's right. He didn't do the academic route at all.
[7:32] Kevin David Thomas: What are the pros and cons of going to graduate school for design?
[7:36] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, in my case, I was such a boy that I needed a little growing up time. But uh the wonderful thing about the graduate school in design for me was uh it gives you a chance to try out a lot of things. So I ended up with a stack of different designs. I was uh you know, cranking them out and not cranking them out. I seriously considered them. And I I learned a lot about rendering and and uh began to learn about drafting and um just having the opportunity of having designs assigned to you and doing them and and sort of being in the laboratory and not being on the line quite yet.
[8:16] Kevin David Thomas: Yep.
[8:16] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Not to say you weren't critiqued, but uh not I needed to get some of that out of me.
[8:22] Kevin David Thomas: Um when you hire interns to work with you or assistants to wait.
[8:27] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I never hire interns, I only hire people I pay.
[8:30] Kevin David Thomas: You assistants, paid assistants.
[8:32] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Amazing. I and I'm not I've had one, I did have an intern with, but you know, um I found the problem with interns for me, I really think people deserve to be paid to work.
[8:43] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, and if you're the right intern, you're probably the right worker for me. So that's one thing. I also don't it's a profession where you show up, and I I didn't I don't want someone telling me that they have a vacation planned for four days next week when we're trying to get a musical on. That doesn't work for me.
[9:06] Kevin David Thomas: Of course, of course.
[9:08] JOHN LEE BEATTY: But when uh a resume comes through for someone to assist you, does it matter one way or another if they have graduate school experience or not?
[9:16] JOHN LEE BEATTY: No, not necessarily. Uh uh I like to talk to them. Uh what people forget when they're going for jobs a lot, uh, is that I'm gonna spend eight, ten, twelve, sometimes sixteen hours a day with you. And I check out for personality defects, but uh my own included. But we you're gonna have to get along, and often you're I'm checking for attitude and uh industry, obviously, and um uh ability, but uh I can I'm a designer, I can tell very quickly about people's abilities. Uh it's mostly uh dealing with them as a human being. So much of our work, no matter you think you're just sitting at a drawing board, you're not, you're interacting with people.
[10:08] Kevin David Thomas: Of course.
[10:09] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah.
[10:10] Kevin David Thomas: Uh you graduate Yale, and then you come to the big bad city of New York.
[10:15] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I do.
[10:16] Kevin David Thomas: And what year was this?
[10:17] JOHN LEE BEATTY: 1973. I actually this was the a recession, and I it was the regional theaters were the thing, and I really wanted to go to a regional theater, but uh nobody I tried a couple, nobody was interested, so I ended up coming to New York because I'd gotten into the union. And I actually ended up uh a friend of mine had a job assisting Douglas W Schmidt, uh Broadway designer, wonderful guy, and he quit with before he even got there because he got an expensive apartment and he couldn't afford the low pay of the theater.
[10:56] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh so I took the job and um I had a cheaper apartment. And uh I was also I was also in in um the painter's part of the my union. So uh an important side light to all of my work and it still affects my designing today, is that I'm also a scenic artist painter. So there's a huge union contingent in New York of people painting scenery, and my other teacher at Yale on Saturday mornings at eight was Arnold Abramson, who's probably the most famous scenic artist in Broadway history, and um he owned a studio named Nolan's and uh he hired me some of the time to paint scenery.
[11:48] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So I was alternating assisting Douglas W Schmidt and um then I was painting scenery when Doug ran out of money. I would go out and paint scenery for a while and learned a lot on the floor.
[12:02] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.
[12:02] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Sometimes we're painting six, seven drops at a time.
[12:05] Kevin David Thomas: And then we're talking like a full drop.
[12:08] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Full drawers. Think about 1973 music. I want our younger listeners to really picture this. Before projections, a full drop. Will you be painting it like would it be hanging in your painting? Or is it like flat on the ground or no?
[12:21] JOHN LEE BEATTY: No, we we called them blanks, and a blank was a big piece of unbleached muslin. They checked it for oil stains because you could ruin the drop if there was a hidden oil stain. But they were whacked, it was an old roller rink in Bedford Stuyvesant, and you stapled them down to the floor, which is an art in itself. And then you sized them and then you painted on the floor. The ceiling leaked. So if you had a drop that was very watercolor effect, you put it under the leak in the ceiling, because it sometimes you come in in the morning and the drop had a new sort of watercolor effect to it. But uh we we knew parts of the floor very well.
[12:57] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[12:58] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So I took Arnold Abramson's scene painting class for two years at Yale. I loved it so much it met, and may I repeat, at eight o'clock Saturday morning. So oftentimes I was the only student in the class, which endeared me to Arnold. Arnold is a great Broadway personality, wonderful painter. His first Broadway show he painted on was King and I. So you do the math. I mean, he he started and he was the touch-up artist on the original My Fair Lady.
[13:28] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[13:29] JOHN LEE BEATTY: The stuff he knows, and I wish I'd written down because even about other things about these shows, but yeah, and and you know, Hello Dolly, you name it. He he painted it. So that is absolutely incredible.
[13:43] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Uh, you were um you were uh defined by what you were good at and your speed of painting, and I was a fast painter, uh, but I usually got the um folk art type of projects. I was very good at doing sort of naive painting. Um, but they different people had different uh skills. I mean, we all painted everything, but certain times we were assigned to certain projects. Forget my ignorance, but this is I don't know much about this, but would you would the scenic, whatever you were painting, the scenic designer or someone had had a a sketch and they're saying this is an elevation, a painter's elevation.
[14:24] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So it's called a painter's elevation, and this would be usually in one half-inch scale, but as long as it's in scale, it could be three-quarter scale, one-inch scales, a rather large piece of cardboard. Most drops would be about 22, 24 feet tall by about 36 feet wide, depending for Broadway shows.
[14:46] Kevin David Thomas: For Broadway shows, yeah. Do you remember going to a theater and seeing something you actually painted in the first time you saw it, and you were like, that's my that's my art. What was it? Do you remember?
[14:54] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I mean, uh Rachel Lily Rosenblum and don't you ever forget it? It ran like I think one night before it closed, right? Thank God I saw a preview of it. Yeah, I know. Never was in your work. Yeah, that was Robin Wagner. Um, I know I you would see sure, you'd go to a Broadway show and see some of your work. Although you they didn't always even tell us the name of the show. We'd have to figure out, yeah.
[15:18] Kevin David Thomas: Who were some of your influences uh when you first started in the world of design?
[15:24] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Um, well, think about it. Coming from a small town, I I um who were some of the influences? Um coming from uh Southern California, small town, I mostly saw roadshows of Broadway shows, so a lot of Oliver Smith's uh designs. Peter Larkin did the original uh Peter Pan, but I mostly saw Oliver Smith was the biggest star at the time. Uh, but I also was seeing Shakespeare's at colleges, and we lived in Europe for a year when I was eight and nine. So I saw Shakespeare designs at the Old Vic, uh opera at the Paris Opera, you know, La Scala, you know, you name it. So there were other influences.
[16:13] Kevin David Thomas: Were there any schools of architecture that appealed to you or any architects specifically that ignited your fire?
[16:20] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, you know what I think is more important than uh I think that if everything that you do, it's very much like acting, I think, being a set designer. I'm using a lot of my life experience. I'm also using my childhood, and I'm always aware when one of my sets is feels right to me. I'm thinking, oh, what part of my childhood have I managed into this at this point? Oh yeah. But uh I mean the ones that won the Tony are all ones that make me remember my childhood oddly. But it's sort of method, if you want to call it method designing. But uh I think I grew up in a lot of old Victorian houses, uh big wooden houses and with a lot of molding, and I think that took. Um creeped into Tally's Folly a little bit.
I also just grew up with a very strong visual memory. I can't remember people's names, but I can remember what they were wearing when I first met them, and I can remember uh it's almost a standing joke in my hometown. Like I'll tell people what their living room looked like in 1958, you know. I just I I have a uh sense memory for places. And I was I think you see it in my work because there's oftentimes in the most successful ones, there's a sort of a like a sense of place.
[17:37] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah. I was I mean oh yeah, I was reading an interview with you where you said sometimes an object uh can connotate a deep memory within an individual. And that's part of the job of a scenic designer.
[17:50] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Sure. You can create emotion. Uh and I I we all know this actually. You scenery can create emotion. You don't, it is not just the actor or the musician or the composer. I mean, I can create emotions as well. I mean, you look at a certain thing and you feel a certain way. And in the world of musical theater, I uh when I did the survival of Most Happy Fella on Broadway, we the director, Gerald Gutierrez, Jerry, and I would change the uh in the finale when they sing My Heart is So Full of You, we would change the the cues on the moving units uh that moved during the song, and we'd uh change where we would call the cue. And it was fascinating if you called it at this place the audience cried. If you called it at that place, the audience cried. But if you called it at this place, the audience didn't cry. So you can create emotion with um scenery.
[18:48] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. Obviously, we all know when it the sky is blue and deep blue and there's stars, everyone goes, ooh, but there's other emotions you can create by.
[19:00] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Absolutely. Or take away the emotion. Look at the set for Chicago, which is uh very neutral. You're saying ain't no emotion here. Right. You're on your own, kid. It's a rough world. Right, and there are subliminal, there's subliminal hints.
[19:18] Kevin David Thomas: Sure, yeah. What is your collaboration like with a director? Or the ideal collaboration between you and a director.
[19:25] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, first of all, my major relationship is with the director. Once the producer has hired me and possibly, I hope, told me what their aims for the show are basically then I am with the director. And I think it's easiest just to think about it as a ship because the director is the captain of the ship, and I'm doing a certain job. I don't know what sail I'm in charge of, but I, you know, I have a specific job on the ship, and the producer is the ship owner. So um not to beat that one to death, but so my relationship is with the director then. Uh until and that can be uh one meeting, two meetings, three meetings, thirty meetings, and oftentimes I'm alone with the director. Once in a while, it's not that. Usually the scenery comes before the lighting and costumes, not always. Uh some people like to give a party differently. But uh usually the scenery has to be ready before the others, so it tends to lead anyhow.
[20:36] Kevin David Thomas: And what do you talk about in your initial meetings with the director?
[20:40] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, this is a thing I think students have trouble with, and I have trouble with, and any human being has trouble with, and it's hard to imagine. But like designers, all directors are also all different. I used to work with John Tillinger, whose name is actually Joey Tillinger, but he liked to talk about food, sex, politics, and how the New York Times hates him. He oftentimes never talked about the scenery at all. And yet, fascinatingly, I would come back to the next meeting with a sketch, and so something came through. And I did the thing I did appreciate about that with that kind of director was that he's being very straight with me. Because he was telling it like it was from his point of view.
And he wasn't faking it for, oh, you know, like trying to be a technical person when he's not a technical person. So I was actually getting sincerity from uh Jose Quintero, famous director, was the same way. Oh, yeah. Uh we were doing a play about Ireland and Scotland, and he came in with pictures of a gypsy village in southern Spain. And I'm like, well, okay, but I got what he meant because his he was saying my emotional reaction to this material, even though it takes place in Ireland, is that I have when I look at this picture of this very simple whitewashed thing in southern Spain. But some people are totally analytical and very well organized and quite the opposite. The question, you have to roll, you, the designer, have to roll with the punches.
The director also, at that point, is required to answer the questions. I mean, later on, you can't always bombard the director with questions, but early on they owe you some answers. And they often go to the author for the answer. Uh sometimes we'll have a list of questions, but they usually uh isolate uh insulate me, I is a better word. Insulate me from the author or authors because they get confused or been out of shape or or uh whatever. Or and it's better to have just the director be the filter for all the information.
[22:56] Kevin David Thomas: Tell us a little bit about uh your apprenticeship or your assistant of Douglas W Schmidt.
[23:01] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, I lucked out. Um first of all, Douglas W Schmidt is Doug is a great guy, really nice and is a friend of mine to this day. Um he didn't pay very well, but um I could walk to work. He was nearby. Uh he was working on a variety of shows. Uh I worked on the last bus and truck of the original production of Greece that he had designed. Very cool. The kind that it was on rolling chalkboards because they couldn't be sure that they could hang any scenery. I think it was amazing. Um I worked on the Andrew Sisters, Sherman Brothers, Andrew Sisters musical over here. Um I went out of town. So he took me out of town with him to um work on shows with him, and I would go in the basement. I I didn't break union rules, but you know, they didn't the sometimes the lampshades needed fringe or you weren't in the union yet as an assistant.
No, I was, I was, but uh you're very when you're in the union, I don't paint Broadway scenery that's painted by the union painters, and I don't pick up things and take them and off stage and back and stuff. It's all very delineated, which I find very pleasant. Everybody knows their jobs, and you do not interfere with the other person's job. Neither are they supposed to make gratuitous comments about your job. Uh-huh. So um I would go out of town with them, and I also, you know, a lot of my job was cheering them up. You know, things would get rocky on a flop show. Uh one show we were doing, went to three different cities, and I think we had three different ingenues. One we get a new anjou each city we went to so um it was the old Broadway where you tried out basically usually start in New Haven then went to Boston then Philadelphia and then came in and my first Broadway shows went that route we have to ask about your design for Tally's Folly which was one of those designs that sort of defined who you were as a designer for so many years. Tell us how did the collaboration of Tally's folly come to be or how did you get attached to that project?
[25:10] JOHN LEE BEATTY: And Lanford Wilson. Right. Uh I was lucky in many ways I first actually worked at Manhattan Theater club w in 73 which was my first off off off off off off off Broadway. I love that and it was known as an off off off off Broadway. Yes it was they had an off-Broadway theater in the building with them but they couldn't afford to use their own stage except once a year. However I was willing and I was working I did a show there and I I think I sewed the costumes on the floor of my apartment and I painted the scenery in their basement and uh hilariously they couldn't afford to cover the floor of their shop and it had been a bowling alley so the scenery could be very long but not very wide. So I designed some scenery that was well fill in the blank.
Yes. But I then I got an off-Broadway show from that basically it progressed and I went out to Queen's Playhouse to do a show and I was introduced to Marshall Mason, who was the uh artistic director and director at uh Circle Repertory Company.
[26:23] JOHN LEE BEATTY: And they were an off-Broadway theater company, which is really the main method of production of my generation in the early 70s, the great off-Broadway theater companies like Circle Rep and Players, Playwrights Horizons and Manhattan Theater Club, all these Chelsea theaters, and all these things were happening.
[26:41] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So I just accidentally met Marshall Mason, who when we did a play together, and he brought me to Circle Rep to do—they were doing a Tennessee Williams play.
[26:54] JOHN LEE BEATTY: They lost their theater. We moved downtown and were building a theater around it and doing the scenery, staying up all night.
[27:03] JOHN LEE BEATTY: And I remember I had those skills, so we were staying up all night building and painting scenery, and then it opened, and then Lanford Wilson was the resident playwright, and he liked what I did, so I did his play, and then I did the rest of the season, and then I got an Obi Award.
[27:21] JOHN LEE BEATTY: And the next season, I think...
[27:24] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I don't even remember now. Uh we did Tally's Folly down the uh we did knock knock there, and that took me to Broadway. Then we did Tally's Folly. Uh and Lanford wrote for the company. Lanford Wilson wrote for the company, so it would star Judd Hirsch and Trish Hawkins, and it was written for them. And he actually hung out in the theater listening to people talk, and uh they would these voices would come into the plays, you know. And but he wrote Tally's Folly. Um he said, also for me and for Dennis Parishy, the lighting designer. And when I won the Tony, I said, How did you uh why did you do this for me? And he said, I thought you'd be good at it. I was like, Oh, yeah. Okay, okay, Chuck. Yeah, exactly. Now, we're gonna post images of this uh for our listeners to take a look too. But can you describe the set for Tally's Folly? I mean, it's stunning.
[28:20] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, but you know, this Sally's Folly set is a product of a theater company in a very trusting collaboration with the author and the director. Right. You would never put this ground plan on your first time around with anybody because the downstage center is killed with water and there's a boat there, and the set is actually divided into many pieces, so it's a it's sort of an obstacle course. But the director, Marshall Mason was very gifted technically. Sound was excellent. Uh he really could read a ground plan and all that. But oddly, for someone who had all those technical gifts, he was very trusting. Yeah, but he would inspire you, and then that set design came out of maybe one meeting, two meetings.
It sort of burst on the world full grown. But um if you follow it, the script and the blocking and the set, the downstage center never gets used until the last moments of the play when the boy and the girl get into the boat, and all the other scenes, they're always separated by uh uh the set, so they're always divided for the whole play until they finally join in the one place you haven't used, which is downstage center, which has been no. If you're an audience member, it's been gnawing at you all that time. Nobody's ever been downstage center, and it drives you crazy. And then, of course, you feel so good when they finally the two people end up together downstage center. It's very clever.
[29:58] JOHN LEE BEATTY: It's well, it's clever design, too, because it is where the the reasonable response. Yeah, exactly. But the set and the and the blocking and the writing are all the collaboration on the same page. This happened earlier for me, a bit with production of uh ashes that I did at Manhattan Theater Club, where the set and the script were flowing at the same rate. And it was very pleasant. But Tally's folly, yeah, it was a big thing. Also, Tally's Folly, I even called my father one night when I was doing it, and I was trying to uh my childhood memories of we had a honeysuckle on one side of the porch and a wisteria on the other, and we had these cabbage roses in a on a bower on the back side of the house, and I was just trying to remember all the flowers and using my father as a technical advice. That's fine. So a lot of it is a childhood memory as well.
[30:55] JOHN LEE BEATTY: That's really, really sweet. It's also a color if you look at the set, it's very green. Yes. Dennis Parishy, the lighting designer, I designed for the lighting designer as well. And I knew him. Dennis, there are a lot of obstructions. He looks good with obstructions, but he used a very strong shade of sort of pinkish, orangey pink. And I knew uh it needed something that would kill the orange-ish pink. It was beautiful for a sunset, but you didn't want the whole set turning that color. And so the green was the opposite color. And I knew the costume designer was Jennifer von Meyerhauser, and her favorite color was this sort of indescribable sort of violet, pinky-violet color, and uh the scenery is is a greeny yellow behind it, and that's a good way to make the actor stand out.
Also, Judd Hirsch has a long monologue to start the play, and I actually drew him first. And the set, if you look at it, is is concentric circles like a target. Yeah. Going round and round and round with Judd Hirsch, Judd Hirsch in the center.
[32:06] JOHN LEE BEATTY: That's so smart. So so smart. When you do design. And yeah, but no, you're going to a good point. The difference between doing a play and a musical, see, that's designing for a play. And in the play, I'm usually designing for the upper half of someone's body. They're gonna talk a lot, and my job is to make you listen. Not just their job, my job too. I cannot distract you with something over there while this guy's speaking. You have to buy into listening to Judd Hirsch talk for I think the monologue was I don't know, 12 minutes, 17 minutes. It's a long monologue to start a play. Anyhow, if you look at my musical theater designs, quite different. And uh, you know, I was lucky enough to go up and work at the Good Speed Opera House for four seasons, and I learned a lot about designing for dance and for musical theater dance and for musicals, and there are a lot of horizontal lines. You see it in Chicago, nothing to interfere with the actor moving, and also the composition is full body always because even if you're not a dancer in a musical, it's a full body experience.
[33:11] JOHN LEE BEATTY: That's right. I didn't even think of any of those things. That's um my mind. You could do a play, you could practically put a sofa in front of people and still do a play. Although that's not good for an entrance, let me tell you, professionally speaking. I was thrown in with people, wonderful people, but not one, but two at least two generations ahead of me, and sometimes they were very famous people. But you know, I didn't realize that, you know, grown-ups could make mistakes too. Right. So I wouldn't always speak up. I think that's not gonna work. And but I thought, but they're famous. Right, or legendary and yeah, they're a legend. Well, so they must know something I don't know. And and I wasn't doing them a favor because as a designer, I should have said, gee, that I think we should do something else.
But I I was just sort of like, whoa. And a lot of those people, I didn't realize it. When you're young, they I didn't know I was gonna be successful, but they picked it off. And their careers were uh oftentimes plateauing or going the other direction, and I didn't understand that they might be having personal conflicts of a totally different sort.
[34:29] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Right. And like, and I did have great trouble early on. I did a oh, this is fun. I did a production of Irma La Deuce for Civic Light Opera in LA, which is no longer produced by Fewer and Martin, like the most famous producers of the guys and dolls. Oh, yeah. Can can big time just huge producers. And Robert Randolph was the lighting designer. He's also a set designer, he'd worked with them for years. He had now moved to California. I didn't compute, of course, that he was gonna hate seeing me show up as the future. Right when he had moved to California because Broadway wasn't working out for him anymore. And he that's the only lighting designer who I think actually tried to make my scenery not look good.
Like he purposely tried because he wanted to show the producers that I was bad so that they would hire him next time. You see what I mean? Yeah. And the producers were sort of twirling themselves. Yeah. The fun part of it was the director was Michael Kidd, who had done worked with them for years. And he I mean, I just learned a lot. At the time I didn't know how to take advantage of it, but now I'm like, I'm so glad I worked with him. And it was fascinating to watch Michael Kidd at work.
[35:44] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah now I look at his other work and I think, oh, I know what he was doing. You actually see. Well, it was this is fun. Irma Laduce, which I've designed three times, and every time it's been a failure. Uh and twice the director didn't like it, like I did one with John Doyle. He just didn't like it. I mean, no sin in not liking Irma Laduce, it hasn't aged well. Right. But and Michael Kidd scared the bejesus out of me one day. He we were in rehearsal. He said, John, I read the second act last night, and I'm like, what? You read it last night? We're I mean, the show's built. I mean, like totally oh my god. Uh but Michael Kidd said this, it was wonderful. He said, John, you know, there um oh, I wish I'd remembered everything because he had just choreographed the movie of Hello Dolly, and he had done star with Julie Andrews, and he was telling me stuff off the record, and of course I should have written it down. I'm so sorry, I don't can't remember. But um, but you got a lot about his attitude about what he would say bad about someone or but what he would not say bad about somebody.
[36:52] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh, yeah. But he said to me, Oh, okay, Ermela Deuce has six six numbers I gotta do. So two of them I'm gonna choreograph completely. Don't worry about those. But two of them I'm gonna stage. So they're gonna be some props, but I'm gonna stage them. People will walk around to music and but the last two, you're really gonna working hard because those are just gonna be props. We'll be moving around props. Because you can't choreograph six big numbers, you can only do two. And you I look at his work now and like Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. Think about all the props that they're using. Like those boys are like jumping business and boards and they're swinging things, and he does all that stuff, and I was like, and we had all these collapsing tables that were in nightmare and to build because they have to come back together and be used the next night, obviously.
And there was a lot of stuff like that. But it was funny, and I remember watching, it was like uh learning about how to do a musical, watching this chorus guy who was a friend of mine. He had to go up, climb up a ladder, run across a platform, and drop a French flag on this 17 counts. I didn't even understand what he was doing, but I would watch them every night, thinking, wow, has the audience noticed that nobody's danced yet? But they didn't. I mean, we flew in a wall of light bulbs that were blinking and stuff. You really didn't notice that they hadn't danced. It was fascinating.
[38:14] Kevin David Thomas: That's really fascinating. But he was a hard worker, and you know, his day his idea of fun was on his day off, he installed a sprinkler system in his front lawn. He came in, he said, Johnny had the best time yesterday. But you see, like the choreographer as a worker as someone who constructs things, and that's what that's where that mind was at.
[38:35] JOHN LEE BEATTY: That's incredible. Um let's talk about the first musical that was uh in terms of your Broadway credits, and this is Ain't Misbehaven. Am I correct in that?
[38:43] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yes. Yes. Yes, it would be yes, it was my fifth Broadway show, and yes. But the first musical.
[38:50] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Which was only supposed to be a Manhattan Theater Club, right? I I was busy elsewhere. Uh I was up at Goodspeed, and I was told to go to Manhattan Theater Club. It was being done in their cabaret space on a platform with no scenery whatsoever. And although I designed a lot of shows at uh Manhattan Theater Club, uh that was not the connector. Well, it was a connection, which I'll explain, but uh no, it was in it was just the best amazing review you ever saw in a small space on a small platform. The funny thing is if you see Ain't Misbehaven, it's still actually for all the bullshit around it, it's actually still done in an eight foot by sixteen-foot area is Ain't Misbehaven.
[39:37] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I was gonna say preserving it. Yeah, was that one of the challenges of keeping it? Yeah, although they changed the show a little bit. Uh Woodard, Charlene. With Charlene Woodard, and uh uh things like that. And oddly, uh Richard Wompe was given because he sort of had the piece, uh Andy Eisenberg and gave him the choice of who he wanted to design it and where he wanted it to go. And Richard had seen my work on a very serious play, Ashes by David Rudkin, and that um made him think of doing me doing Ace. I don't have a clue. I I have no clue. But we're just lucky it happened. I know, I uh and oddly I'd done the water engine down at the public, that may have affected it too, which was also not a musical, but it had a kind of unique look.
And from that, actually, Tommy Toon had asked me to do Best Little Whore House. But there was a horrible snowstorm that year, and I had to pull out of whorehouse for which Tommy I don't think ever forgave me. And I now realize I was so young and stupid, I didn't realize what I was doing. But anyhow, uh I ended up being free, kind of free for Ain't Misbehaven. But there was only about three and a half weeks to get it on before the Tony cut off. We were already in spring, so um I could design anything I wanted as long as it could be built in less than three weeks.
[41:08] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So I mean some things we couldn't build because like Pete Feller, who was in charge of building a famous Pete Feller, said, "Oh, this design's nice, but we can't do it. We can't get those materials you've spec'd in time, so you have to do something else." And all to get into the Tony cutoff. Yeah, it was and it was the best musical of the music. I was gonna say '78. It also was a jukebox musical, and this is one of the first jukebox musicals. I'm almost embarrassed to tell you that the original design for it that was too was a jukebox that lit up and doors opened and they came out of it. And the arch shape in Ain't Misbehavin' is an echo of the Arch of a Wurlitzer. Yeah, but and the overpass.
I was busy commuting to Goodspeed, so I kept passing that overpass on the West on where 125th Street hits the west side, and those overpasses and the jukebox blended, and that's why Ain't Misbehavin' had those arches that were either an underpass or a jukebox lit up. But can you imagine now doing a jukebox musical and actually having a jukebox set as it boggles the mind?
[42:18] Kevin David Thomas: But you were a pioneer.
[42:19] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I was a pioneer. I didn't even know quite what stride piano was. I didn't realize about Luther Henderson, who God bless him, I adore it, sat me down at the piano to show me what it was. And it turned out my father had been doing stride piano all through my childhood. I didn't really—I had an older father, and he showed me you just ignore the bass clap and tinkle the melody over here and go bing bing bing bing bing while you're left. And I was funny that part of it. Ain't Misbehavin' also was so fast. The Schuberts were co-producing. Richard picked the Longacre, which had been empty and was considered a dud house. But Richard won a Tony for best direction, and I have to say for a show that had seven lines, I think.
But that's funny. Arthur Ferrier was a wonderful choreographer, of course, but Richard kept his eye on the—he said it was a hot box, and he picked the theater because it was sort of compressed on the sides, and he felt the energy should burst out of the show. And he kept saying hot box, hot box, which paid off later because we were in a meeting with the Schuberts and Dash Epstein and Manny Eisenberg, and the whole set was done in shades of bronze, and it was three shades of brown and bronze allure and copper trim and everything was bronze. And Dasha Epstein, I remember she was co-producing or something, and as the meeting ended, and everyone said, "Okay, we're gonna build this." I mean, the set model was horrible. We were going so fast that we had to make the metal out of spray-painted spaghetti because we didn't have time to weld it. We just got to for the mock-up, I mean.
[44:02] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, the mock-up model. So we were just going so fast, I mean, just so fast. There was like craziness. And as the meeting broke up and people were straggling out the door, Dasha Epstein says, "Well, if it's a hot box, how come the set isn't red?" And I looked at Dasha and I said, "Hold it, come back in." And everybody sort of looked weird and came back in. And I said, "Dasha just asked a good question." And if you look at the original drafting, it's all shades of brown written on the drafting, and I switched them all to shades of red, and thus Ain't Misbehavin' was red. And as African American skin looks really good against red, and you can put yellow-green light on African American skin, and it looks really good.
And so, and that's a good color to dull red. So as Patricia Zipprodt, the costume designer said after seeing it, she said, "Well, any color's a neutral, red can be a neutral," and Ain't Misbehavin' everything's red, and you eventually—that's the neutral of—it's a funny hot, wonderful neutral, but it isn't neutral.
[45:10] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, that's so interesting to think about.
[45:12] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I was gonna say when you look at the pictures, yeah, red seems like such a predominant color. And I was wondering how I came up to that. Patricia Zipprodt, a wonderful costume designer. Any memories of working with her, anecdotes about working with her?
[45:24] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, I did plays with her. Patricia was—she'd been through the wars. I loved her. She was kind of tough and kind of very vulnerable. She came back from a meeting with Jerome Robbins one day and she said, "I—" she burst into tears and she said, "John, I know I've done all these shows with him and everything, but he still makes me cry." She was just so overwrought by what he had said to her or something. She was a great artist. She was an artist, really an artist. Every show she did, there'd be one sort of dud costume, partly because she was an artist, like one this Neil Simon show, Fools we did. She decided that there should be a fishnet trench coat. And yes, I see your expressions, but that—it was executed.
It turned out exactly as you'd expect. It just didn't work. And I could never figure out why she was so obsessed with it. But something in her brain. She had all—Boris Aronson had trained her a bit, and she had all these file cards, huge long files, like you know, 15, 20 feet long, with little drawers of colors on fabric, and you pulled out drawers with her. And if you said red, you pulled out a drawer and you said what red, and you showed what red you thought and what white and all this stuff. She was very organized, but that she was a little wicked because you do the show, and then the white she had agreed to be was just like one infinitesimal notch brighter than she said it was gonna be. But not enough that you could prove that she had misled you.
And she was very clever that way, very clever. She's awesome. I love her work. She was quite vulnerable though. She'd been a huge musical theater star, and then did I think seven years of flops in a row every, you know, like two or three musicals a year, every single one of failure. And it had taken a toll on her emotionally because she was up there with the big ones.
[47:23] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[47:24] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I mean, Pippin, think about that show without that armor. I—you can't even imagine.
[47:28] Kevin David Thomas: It's incredible.
[47:29] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Can't imagine. Incredible. Then your next musical is called Whoopi.
[47:34] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Whoopi. Well, I did a lot of shows up at the Goodspeed. I did four years at the Goodspeed, and Whoopi was the tip-top Whoopi she loves me year. I always loved that. That was the repertory that year. Whoopi was a charmer, Charlie Ruppeli. Frank Cassaro of all people directed it, and I wish I had been older and I knew more how to deal with him, but it was very odd to have Frank Cassaro directing it. But well, you couldn't do it now because there were so many politically incorrect things in it. So very many. But at the time, you know, you could throw teepees onto the southwestern desert with Indians that should have been in Adobe's. I mean, it just didn't make any sense. The fun thing about that one, one of the fun things, especially Goodspeed.
I talked to someone who had seen the original, and I kept asking him how could this three hours of Whoopi work and or three plus hours of Whoopi? And he had seen it at the Ziegfeld, and he was a—you know, he said, "Oh, we went as a group, and you go down—you go down to the smoking room and have a cigar and a drink during parts of this show, and then come back to your seat." And that sort of explained it. And the girls would still be sort of singing another bride, another groom. So, you know, it was like a much more relaxed atmosphere, which allowed me to sort of understand it. We had to tighten it up, of course, for modern taste and make it much more sort of deco campy. We were really lucky though.
[49:10] JOHN LEE BEATTY: We were really lucky because Danny Serretta, who directed it, who did the choreography actually, was into John Held and knew John Held's wife, the illustrator John Held. And we got permission to copy John Held, which is just heaven on earth.
[49:33] Kevin David Thomas: Oh wow.
[49:34] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So I went wild with—I love John Held, and I went wild using him as a source and making up JOHN LEE BEATTY, John Held, John Held as well. But it was all this sort of deco, nutsy deco, and he'd actually done a lot of Southwestern deco art, which was so much fun to copy. It moved, and you know, Goodspeed musicals, like any musical, moving from a less expensive venue started to suffer rather quickly. You know, it didn't have the charm of being in the small theater, and people sort of did it on a shoestring because they thought since it had been done on a shoestring before. And this has sort of been the painful story of many of the moves and musicals I've done. One of your favorite musicals is a cult musical called Is There Life?
[50:19] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Is there life after high school? Question mark. Which I have to say, I hear is coming back. This is a musical that Craig Cornelia wrote. I hope so. It has the most wonderful score. I love the score to this movie. I still sing songs from it, which is funny.
[50:35] Kevin David Thomas: Do you get it inside?
[50:38] JOHN LEE BEATTY: He asked me over to his. I love that is one of my all-time favorite songs. Nothing really happened. It's really good.
[50:47] Kevin David Thomas: It's a really wonderful song.
[50:49] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Alma Cuervo song.
[50:50] Kevin David Thomas: Alma Cuervo, yes.
[50:51] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, I love that. I sing better than that in real life.
[50:55] Kevin David Thomas: I believe it's a good idea.
[50:56] JOHN LEE BEATTY: He was just marking, he was just—Is there life after high school? Was originally, I was just up at working at Hartford Stage, and we started it up there with Melvin Bernhardt directing. And it was fast-tracked, again fast-tracked for Broadway, but I there were some flaws. Melvin wasn't very dear friend of mine, wasn't terribly experienced in musicals. And a regional theater musical is very different than a Broadway musical, and because thrust and we built sort of a high school set, which was fine up there, and we had all these—it was kind of fun, all these banners of basketball teams hung all over the auditorium. It was kind of a hoot. The authors went with the producers who didn't ask for changes in the book, and Manny Eisenberg was interested in that one as well, but Manny thought they needed to do some flips in the book.
There's—the book chose to change characters—they would sort of flip around. And Manny and some others who wanted to produce it felt they needed to be to find characters, and that didn't happen that way.
[52:08] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I um so we went on with others, and it sort of—we had some problems in the theater eventually, and it just didn't really—we didn't quite nail it visually, I didn't think, and something about the concept of it wasn't working. The songs were fantastic. They were sort of of the Sondheim era in terms of them not having boffo endings. They tended to—they're much more to the modern taste. He was ahead of his time, probably, because they tended not to end with your hands upstretched with a huge button that caused huge applause to happen. So some people—well, anyhow, we had some problems. Melvin left, and the lighting designer left, and we were sort of there, and the director of record Don Nigro, by it was too late by then. That's it just got—yeah, it got a little out of whack and it just sort of stayed out of whack. There were some other backstage problems that I don't need to go into.
[53:20] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh but you know, it's when you're doing musical, everybody's contribution is important, and you know, something can happen with backstage staff that can affect things horribly, as well as you know, quote unquote the talent. So let's talk. We just had David Shire in here, right?
[53:37] Kevin David Thomas: Um so let's talk about Baby.
[53:40] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Ooh, Baby. There were plastic curtains and projections.
[53:43] Kevin David Thomas: There were not plastic curtains.
[53:45] JOHN LEE BEATTY: People made fun of them saying, "No, you go ahead," because I—this is where we're gonna go with Baby, because they called it a shower curtain. It was not, it was actually Lynn's Grim, and it was quite a soft fabric painted in the style of Monet of all things, but well doing musicals or plays. The group of us, Pat Collins lit it, JOHN LEE BEATTY did the scenery. We were a lot of us from Ain't Misbehavin'. Randy Barcelo was no longer with us, who was sort of genius on the costumes for Ain't Misbehavin' were really brilliant. So we started out, it was supposed to have be 90 minutes long and be a concept musical. By the time it opened, it was two and a half hours and was a book musical. And we were on our third book writer.
It went into workshop, but like most post-Chorus Line musicals started doing these workshops because it worked so well for Chorus Line. So we went into Chorus Line mode, and I would go to the workshop and you'd see where they'd put their folding chairs that day and tried to follow through on it.
[54:56] JOHN LEE BEATTY: But actually, one of the characters got written out eventually.
[55:00] Kevin David Thomas: So I was very hard to keep up with.
[55:28] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So I didn't really think projections were used even in the... Yeah, well, it was hard, and they were, you know, we always joke projections are the things that get cut, and they decided just to cut them before they spent the money.
[55:41] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, that was the problem.
[55:48] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Nowadays, projections are the thing that are not cut. They really are the backbone of so many shows.
[55:55] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I just saw, uh, Mean Girls.
[55:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, which is almost all.
[55:58] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, but you we were unfortunately in Baby, we were cut technologically speaking, because we could... projections got so much better within 10 years, and then lighting equipment changed also, and computer scenery, and this was just before and these curtains which were really based again Richard Maltby had seen my Ashes play at Circle at Manhattan Theater Club so these curtains these dancing curtains that went around in circle eights and finally twirled up into a big corkscrew and went up through the ceiling and exited which was really a phenomenal technological accomplishment all had to be done mechanically and not with a computer and um it just we were just trying too hard too early and and um the scenery didn't really match the play anymore and they would add scenes like remember the book writer being so frustrated because she when we rewrote the second act again um she wanted a closet but I say but how can you have a closet in a set that has no windows or doors I mean it would look like an outhouse wouldn't it I mean because you just have a box with a door and and it's sort of the problems you get into as you rewrite musicals.
[57:13] JOHN LEE BEATTY: If you listen to the album you can actually tell where we ran out of time about halfway through the second act it changes because they spent a lot of time fixing the first act and then got into the second act.
[57:26] Kevin David Thomas: Oh interesting.
[57:26] JOHN LEE BEATTY: It's quite a minefield Baby though because think of abortion and and miscarriage and all sorts of things I mean one of the charming things about that play and I loved a lot of it we loved it a lot I mean this Calloway singing that song it's just and the first time she did it we were in a rehearsal hall and it was a stormy day and for some reason the clouds parted and a ray of sunshine came down and hit her, and she goes, the story goes on, and you're like weeping but right um there was a row for expectant mothers in the back because they had to get to the bathroom so often, so they just sit the row with all these pregnant ladies in the background.
[58:02] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, that's funny.
[58:02] JOHN LEE BEATTY: And the other funny one was, uh, women, these batine ladies came the first matinee, and they were so disappointed they thought Baby was going to be the life story of Lauren Bacall.
[58:15] Kevin David Thomas: Because she was called Baby by Bogart.
[58:18] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh my no, they couldn't have been far. And then there were the... there was some gay guys, I'm not gonna name them, who came in, and the first number was the March of the Sperm, and they would trot through their seats, sit down, up would come human procreation, and they would get up out of their seats and trot right out of the theater again.
[58:35] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I had to learn a lot about procreation.
[58:38] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh, yes. Storyboards, sperm swimming around, and things like that.
[58:43] Kevin David Thomas: That must be so fun though, as a designer, because every show you're going into is an entirely new world.
[58:47] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So this is true.
[58:49] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, and I learned a lot about, uh, this was my second time through because Ashes had been about procreation as well, and I had to learn all about barrenness and blah blah blah blah blah. And this time I had to learn all about how sperm march and, uh, this is fascinating.
[59:03] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Richard wanted the back wall to open and a big opening come through the back of the side. And I said, I don't think so, but I don't know. It's a little too literal on the notes. Wonderful performers and some wonderful music, but it was a little bit of a minefield, and then the set, uh, didn't match the material with the book material by the time we opened. I'm sorry to say.
[59:30] Kevin David Thomas: Do you fix that? Do you think it's...
[59:31] JOHN LEE BEATTY: You can't? I mean, at a certain point you can't, you just can't.
[59:36] JOHN LEE BEATTY: The ship has sailed at that. That would be one of the more frustrating parts on the... and then people started calling it the shower curtain and blah blah blah.
[59:43] Kevin David Thomas: Which it was not, you said it was not.
[59:45] JOHN LEE BEATTY: It was muslin curtain.
[59:46] JOHN LEE BEATTY: No, it was actually scrim. It was a expensive linen scrim.
[59:51] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Whatever. It was actually fascinating technically and and really kind of pretty sometimes, but um you know, the first time out on a musical, especially a musical that's changing, sure. I if I did it again, I would do something different. But um you don't know what that animal is, and especially when they've changed book writers twice, you know.
[1:00:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it's tough to keep up with that.
[1:00:17] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Um now in the mid-90s, you get involved with Encores.
[1:00:20] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah.
[1:00:21] JOHN LEE BEATTY: That becomes flukishly because, uh, Encores came out of I was working with Jerry Gutierrez. So I was working up at Lincoln Center, we were doing these plays with Dan Sullivan and Jack Gutierrez, etc. And Andre Bishop producing, and Ira Weitzman was called me one day or I saw him in the hallway and said he was doing this musical concerts over at City Center, and would I come just arrange a few things?
[1:00:47] JOHN LEE BEATTY: And that was the beginning of Encores. Um I went over and we did, um, Fiorello directed by Walter Bobby, and then, uh, we did, uh, Allegro, and then we follow... I'm trying to remember the order, then we did Lady in the Dark Verse Season. The clear standout was Fiorello, which Walter Bobby directed, and eventually Walter became the artistic director, and that started, uh, artistic friendship and a personal friendship from there forward.
[1:01:17] Kevin David Thomas: So what was the original design of Encore's like?
[1:01:21] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, the thing that you had to remember was, uh, supposed to be... I don't think I think we did three performances of Fiorello. It was very small and rehearsed for five minutes, and they were carrying books. Poor Faith Prince never got to rehearse I'm gonna marry the very next man. She never got to rehearse it with an orchestra. We ran out of rehearsal time. So she poor thing went out and of course stopped the show, but still, uh, poor thing went out and had to do it unrehearsed.
[1:01:50] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So it was like that. Uh, Walter was very clever getting Jerry Zaks to come back to play Fiorello because Jerry had stopped acting and was a beloved director and had directed Walter and Geis and Dahls. And they were, but once Jerry Zaks signed down, all the rest of them wanted to do it. So it sort of created momentum and it was a delightful evening. Um, the band on stage.
[1:02:16] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, from the beginning.
[1:02:18] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, they didn't weren't sure. We did it for Fiorello, and then we put them down in the pit for, uh, for Allegro, and, uh, nobody liked that. And we were inventing this as we went along. Uh, this whole Encore style of presentation was, uh, uh, Allegro had I think Christopher Reeve lecturing on the side about the creation of the show and very boring photos coming up on a screen, and then some really nice Kathy Zuber costumes, but, but um it just, uh, that was sort of DOA and, uh, then Lady in the Dark was a little more summer stocky, just trying to do it not quite well enough. And, uh, so the clear winner was Fiorello, and that became the Encore's style, and reinventing the bandstand every time till that you have to understand Encores was meant to be a few performances like a public, like a community event for all of us to work on. Who knew like I did 22 years of it and stopped finally was like enough, okay.
[1:03:23] JOHN LEE BEATTY: But, uh, and then the orchestra got a little feisty, you know, when they started doing five, six performances sitting in cramped redesign. I had to redesign the orchestra layout every time, which was very interesting, but very hard. Um, because what like a layman going into it, uh, I learned so much, it was wonderful fun, some of it learning, or intellectual fun. Uh, like now I know what a Kurt Weill show would probably be laid out as and how a Gershwin orchestra would be laid out. Not all orchestra, and the people kept saying, Well, everyone's so unhappy, why don't you just create one bandstand that will work for all of them? I said that isn't the solution because they lay them out differently and and they orchestrate them differently, and different orchestrators have different, uh, instrument layouts.
So what's important in one show is not important in another, vice versa, and you know, a piano and some musicals don't have a piano. I mean, there's so many variations in musical, uh, arrangement and, uh, and just the taste of the composers.
[1:04:35] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So that was very interesting, but very painful sometimes having people yell at me and, uh, for the layout. I always joked, like I going in, I could alienate, let's see, 31 people in the orchestra. The choreographer always hated me because there was never enough time to get the props right for the dancers. You know, it was like, and the management wanted me, wanted and didn't want to spend any money, so they always made me say, go in there and tell him no, he can't have it. And I said, Well, why can't you go in? But it was always they wanted me to go in and say no, no, no, no, no. And of course, it kept growing, and you know, it was like, uh, it was out of control because it was like a locomotive going down the track encore.
There were some fabulous things. You know, do you remember Patti LuPone returning to New York and Pal Joey, and I mean, just events happening and wonderful people writing books, and then eventually David Ives, who was so wonderful at, uh, weeding through these horrendous scripts and finding something about them that was so fresh. Um, it was a kind of amazing event, and it of course morphed as the book holding the book started to fall away, and then rules, and then they got too big, and then all sorts of things went on. I was gonna do 10 years and leave, but then, um, someone else was leaving, so I decided I'd stay on, and then it was eventually 22.
[1:06:01] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[1:06:01] JOHN LEE BEATTY: I know I can't believe it was 66 musicals. I, you know, it's just beyond me. What, um, the most famous one, of course, is Chicago, which is the Pittsburgh and is from forever and ever. Um, one interesting number of interesting things about Chicago, uh, it had a smaller orchestra than most because it was newer and, uh, and oddly, um, uh, uh wonderful score, but, uh, some of it reminiscent the Kurt Weill layout is more operative for their work.
[1:06:35] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Um, the fact that it was small and the fact that they had to dance meant that people were liberated. It was the first one where people wore mics on them. We used to have just like the two leads would have a mic, and then four leads would have a mic, and then six leads would have a mic, and we had standing mics. And Chicago still had standing mics in front of it. But so some scenes would have to be blocked down to the mics, which turned out was sort of the secret of Encore is we first pretty early discovered that some musicals benefit by not having to tell people where you are, not having to fly in a drop of a street. Like in Fiorello, you don't really need to fly in a drop of a street to tell the story.
And we were, and the story became very important and very condensed. In Chicago, they we didn't play a card game. You know, half the book was gotten rid of, uh, chopped out, and and that encouraged distillation thing turned out to be Chicago's best friend. You know, if you read the history of the musical, you see what was happening, and it, uh, just and it concentrated the energy on the performers who were thrilling.
[1:07:45] Kevin David Thomas: How did your design change from the Encores presentation to then when it played, um, Broadway for the first time?
[1:07:52] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Well, the biggest argument, oddly, um, was Walter felt we should still have the microphones across the front or and mechanize them to come up and down for a presentational quality to save that presentational quality. Um, Barry Weissler wasn't keen on that. I don't know whether it was for money or more for um taste. Or not that they couldn't be both, but uh that was a little bit of an argument that went on. We tried to do some magic tricks for James Naughton, uh, flying off the bandstand. And actually, some of the early publicity stuff for it, uh, we had mirror balls that flew in over the set to make and they ended up in the house and we cut the ones on stage.
[1:08:36] JOHN LEE BEATTY: So um there were things like that, but it was pretty much a revving up of what was there. We added an elevator. Um I I had seen the original Chicago, so uh the set the only homage, I mean it doesn't look like the original Chicago, but uh I did vaguely remember Cheetah coming up on an elevator, so that got in there and uh the ladders on the side actually were I uh um sort of more an homage to Pippin, I think, because they went up and down the sides of the proscenium and we were making it up like you know, like someone say, what about a ladder? And you know, the next thing you know, we I got ladders and we hinged them to the proscenium, and I was a lot of it was on the fly, and the when they moved it, they only allowed like a week and a half rehearsal or something crazy because they thought they knew it.
And of course they didn't. They'd said, Oh no, I was faking it. You don't know what you were doing down there. No, I was just doing some sort of Fossey thing. So uh we it was a rude awakening. Walter worked a lot though. Once the scripts were gone, of course, Walter worked, he he doesn't like it but uh me to say it, but his transitions were heavenly, and he he worked the transitions as much as the scenes. And uh you don't realize watching Chicago, just how that courtroom scene is set up and taken away before you even know what happened. I mean, a lot of the choreography or uh and it we were all working together as a group, so no one knows who did what, but this kind of you know, I I think I told you last time I was here.
Chicago is my prime prime example of my theory about designing though, that uh there can be two virgins and a whore or two uh whores and a virgin, but you can't have three virgins, you can't have three whores. Uh and in Chicago, obviously, no offense to my friend Ken Billington, he's the whore with the color. And William I. B. Long and I both pulled back and did black and I did black and gold, he did black, um very sexy black, but yes, and so and we sort of looked at each other and knew Ken would probably get the Tony and we would be ignored. And of course that's the case. But I always built that on designing that you you can't you can't have three people showing off at the same time, you know. And so we were very uh the three of us got along great. Uh and uh we were very disciplined about how we how we approached it.
[1:11:01] Kevin David Thomas: I was gonna ask you uh about Wonderful Town.
[1:11:01] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Which also transferred. Yeah, we had a number of transfers from uh we had um some better than others, uh uh from Encore's Finan's Rainbow, the Apple Tree, Wonderful Town, um Chicago. Um that wasn't meant to it was wonderful at Encores, Kathleen Marshall, who I uh like tremendously, and had become artistic director there as well. Um and that had been uh Donna Murphy and Laura Benanti, uh, which was a delightful combination. Um and uh unfortunately uh uh Donna uh had some medical problems that prevented us from doing it when it was supposed to go and it got postponed, and as it turned out, we could have gone and um it got out of sync time wise. It was sort of a uh wasn't that after um September 11th.
I uh yes. It was sort of a celebration of it was a sort of a celebration of New York that everyone was eager for, but then the timing got off and um it slipped through our fingers a bit when it moved. I'm afraid I'm sorry to say. Uh we changed costume designers. Uh um it had been William I. B. Long. Uh you know, the the collaboration shifted a little. And Marty Pakladinus did the quite wonderful clothes, but they weren't the same as William Ivy Long's, you know, that it was different and Laura Benanti wasn't available. And it just chemically just changed this way and that way. But a fun design that you came up with with all the windows and fire escapes.
[1:12:48] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah, we cut a uh the voice I don't know whether it wasn't selling or what, but in the middle of it, all the uh like a lot of the scenery got eliminated. So uh I mean they never build it so I i it uh it's not one of my favorite designs, sorry to say. That's okay. I I and I actually I felt that that pinpointed the problem with Encores. If you couldn't say why the orchestra was on stage, you had a problem. In Chicago, the orchestra is the obviously it's a jury box on stage. And you know, it's a jazz band, so it made total sense that they be there, and it's so presentational anyhow. But in Wonderful Town, it was like, gee, I wonder if the orchestra shouldn't have been there. I and that happens a lot with the moves, and then you know, we move Finian's Rainbow, and the I said, I can't do the orchestra on stage, I don't know why there's in the middle of Missiture, you know, sawing away at violins.
So we put that in the pit, but then you ended up with this sort of gap. You realized that a lot of the dynamic of the show had been 30 more people upstage participating. So you were kind of damned if you do, damned if you don't. And I found that uh the moves got painful for me, except for Chicago, which I liked.
[1:14:09] Kevin David Thomas: Where do you see the future of uh design musicals heading?
[1:14:12] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Uh we have so much technology now. Uh so many musicals are using projection or um where do you see this world going? Well, what's the next step? What's the next step? What's the next step? Wow. Well, almost holograms, sure. Yeah. I I did I saw Frozen recently. I thought, boy, I they could probably use a hologram or two in that ice palace, you know. Uh I think I don't I don't really know. No, I don't know. Isn't that fun to see? I mean, if you look back though, you wouldn't have thought that Boris Aronson, for example, would become a star musical theater designer because he seemed the least likely candidate. And and um famously Harold Prince said he'd never work with him again after he did uh Dor Remy, which is one I did research when we did it over at Encores.
Uh, and it was a bizarre, strangely artistic, but bizarre sad. And then you see, oh, they just didn't know where the musical was going, and it turned out that Boris Aronson in a bizarre way was ahead of the curve, or he became, as we say, extremely useful. Uh I thought it was funny when I saw Cabaret, the recabaret revival, the Sam Mendes Rob Marshall one, because I started laughing watching it. I thought, oh, actually, he's just taking the way they started doing Shakespeare in England like 10 years ago and changed it over to musicals. And a lot of uh really, I mean, I started giggling a little bit because it was like very cleverly done. But it you might you could have been doing uh, you know, Oswald It Endswell in the same way.
But uh in fact they probably had, but but I it's weird how how something that's happening over here, say you know, Ivo van Hove or something is going to come over and end up overhearing your most commercial situation. It's uh it's an interesting. In fact, I always thought back in the crazy drug failed 60s, 70s, you realize that uh no no net was so far to one side that it actually became uh kind of oddly data and sort of modern in a bizarrely, you know. If you go far enough conservative that way, you meet you meet uh experimentalization in the other direction, you know. It's like it happens with musicals sometimes, especially now the uh all of our technological gifts, like I'm doing a play right now where we use moving lights and we use winches and we use a revolve and you know all this stuff, and the language uh is because directors and authors and designers go from both worlds, the the they cross-pollinate uh they cross-pollinate.
But predicting how musical in the future would look I don't know I mean like uh as you asked me about Albert Johnson I mean there's somebody who was changing uh yeah changing the way we looked at musicals and building upon it but if you look back I don't know I don't know oddly you know I uh also about musicals we did hair and promises promises over at Encores I always felt having seen the original promises promises that because of the music mixing in that that it was the first mixed yeah Broadway musical that's right in a funny and we did hair and you listen to hair and you know this is the problem with this problem is okay you think of hair as a hippie musical but actually promises promises in its own way was much more forward looking than hair hair was happened to be hippies but you produced it the same way but promises promises that music the way they produce the music changed everything everything.
[1:17:12] Kevin David Thomas: What's next for you? I know you have Dan Codisian coming up.
[1:17:12] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Oh I'm going to do a Shakespeare out in at the Old Globe with Kathleen Marshall and here's another interest speaking of cross pollinization cath I did Love's Labor's Lost with Kathleen Marshall out at the Old Globe and I'm going out to do Much Ado About Nothing but turns out Kathleen is good at Shakespeare and I'm thinking well duh you know if you come from the world of musicals first of all she is an intelligent woman comes from a I've better family you know he's her father's a professor. I mean, it's not like she's dumb or anything. Far from it. Uh, but her ability in Love's Labor's Lost for clarity of staging and how to get people to move to tell the story, you know, because Love's Labor's Lost, for example, has four couples, and you have to keep them straight all the time.
And Kathleen, it seemed so natural to her that and she knew how to place them and how to have them talk and walk and talk. And again, another way of cross-pollinization, I just did Age of Innocence up at Hartford Stage. Sierra Boggess is one of the leading ladies, and she's in an 1875 show, and she's playing a discreet, the enigmatic lady from the 1870s. And people say Sierra Boggess, you know, sort of implying that she's chewing gum and wearing pink sports clothes. But actually, the gift of a musical theater performer, of course, she can enter a stage. She can move, she can sing, and she can wear clothes. 1875, you're almost there. I mean, a little more in you, and it's fascinating to think about how musical theater and straight theater, quote, straight theater can affect each other and how the skills can be transferred. I like that. I wish there's more of that.
[1:20:10] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, me too.
[1:20:11] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Yeah. This was fantastic. Thank you so much for coming in. Until next time, bye.
[1:20:17] Kevin David Thomas: Okay.
[1:20:19] JOHN LEE BEATTY: Good day, Mr. Thomas.
[1:20:20] Kevin David Thomas: Good day, Mr. Schneider.
[1:20:22] Robert W. Schneider: Well, it has happened. We finally hit over 100 iTunes reviews, and would like to thank each and every person who took the time to do so. Huzzah. Now we want to climb those charts even faster. And that is where you lovely folks who have not yet rated us come in. The process is very simple. On your podcast app, tap the search tab, enter our name. Behind the Curtain, Broadway's Living Legends. Tap the search key, tap our beautiful logo, tap the reviews, tap write a review, then tap your way into our hearts. Tap your troubles away.
[1:20:56] Kevin David Thomas: It's nice, Rob. Once you are there, you can rate us from one star to five stars. Think of one star as Hervey Villechaize.
[1:21:04] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, dear guy. I walked right into that one.
[1:21:08] Kevin David Thomas: Think of one star as Herve Villechaize and Ema Sumac in Sideshow and five stars as front row seats to the opening night of Gypsy.
[1:21:16] Robert W. Schneider: But they keep me.
[1:21:18] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, they keep me for the first time. I thought that was pretty good.
[1:21:24] Robert W. Schneider: Excuse me, Arthur Lawrence. Excuse me for trying to liven up our commercial ads a little bit.
[1:21:30] Kevin David Thomas: Eight-minute long commercial.
[1:21:32] Robert W. Schneider: It's an infomercial at this point. I'm gonna be like that lady that sells you the copper pots. Look at this. You can put 400 pounds of manure in it, and it slides right out. Then you can make an island.
[1:21:45] Kevin David Thomas: You got another line, Kevin?
[1:21:46] Robert W. Schneider: I'm waiting for you to say, plus you can leave your comment and let us know if you like and what guests were like to hear.
[1:21:46] Kevin David Thomas: Plus, you can leave a comment to let us know what you are liking, what you're not liking at this point, or what guests you'd like to hear next. So head on over to iTunes and let us know what you think of our little show. Speaking of little, I'll tell you a story about Charles Lawton later. Thanks, guys.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
