Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#138 ETHAN MORDDEN, Author

He has inspired countless generations with his observations on the world of musical theatre and his literary output is staggering... Read More

From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast

1 h 21 mins
9/17/18

Featured Shows

About

He has inspired countless generations with his observations on the world of musical theatre and his literary output is staggering. His name is Ethan Mordden and just a few of his books are: When Broadway Went To Hollywood, Anything Goes: A History of the American Musical, Make Believe: The Broadway Musical in the 1920s, Sing For Your Supper: The Broadway Musical in the 1930s, Beautiful Mornin: The Broadway Musical in the 1940s, Coming Up Roses: The Broadway Musical in the 1950s, Open A New Window: The Broadway Musical in the 1960s, One More Kiss: The Broadway Musical in the 1970s, The Happiest Corpse I Have Ever Seen: The Last 25 Years of the Broadway Musical, and biographies on Kurt Weill, Florenz Ziegfeld, Rodgers and Hammerstein, and many others. His most recent book, All That Jazz: The Life and Times of the Musical Chicago, is now available in stores and on kindle. Ethan pulls back the curtain on his career to discuss how he fell in love with musical theatre, what musicals are deserving of a second look, and why Bob Fosse is the most iconic choreographer in musical theatre history. Also, Ethan shines the spotlight on Gwen Verdon, Tony Randall, and Maurine Dallas Watkins! Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] ♪ Musical number: "Money" — performed by Unknown performer ♪

[0:15] Robert W. Schneider: Friends, congratulations. You are getting a new Patreon advertisement from us. As you know, we've had one for a whole year. So enjoy the Money Money song because you're gonna hear it for the next year. But you know, I'm not singing I dreamed a dream anymore, so I'm gonna miss it. Okay, so friends, you should know the drill by this point. We have 47 wonderful patrons on Patreon. Thank you. Thank you. Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com as Patreon. P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com. Reon sounds like a drag queen from the 80s. Don't tell mama. So as you know, we are an entirely, we are not funded by anybody except Patreon patrons. There was a lot of peas in that sentence, a lot of explosive peas. Um thank you. It's very emotional. Thank you. After I had my stone removed, there was a lot of explosive peas as well. Thank you. I'll be here all week, folks. So once again, we need your help. Head on over to Patreon.com. How is that spelled, Kevin?

[0:35] Kevin David Thomas: Patreon.

[0:35] Robert W. Schneider: P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com. When you head over there, you're gonna search for Behind the Curtain, Broadway's Living Legends. And once you get there, you're going to hit a button that says it's gonna say become a patron. And you can give us whatever you got. A dollar, two dollars, five dollars. Anything that you give us will be a wonderful contribution to helping us get this thing going. Thank you to keep it on the air. We love you guys for it. We love you. Money, money, money, money, money, money, money, money, money, money, money, money, marka, yana, bucket around. It's all that makes up around and makes up waggle. Right. I thought I did good. That was pretty good. Thanks. I'm a star. Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.

[1:45] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.

[1:46] Robert W. Schneider: And this is Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends. Don't forget to follow us on Twitter at Broadway Curtain. And make sure to join our Facebook page at Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends. And follow us on Instagram at Broadway Curtain Podcast. Plus, you can always listen to our podcasts on Broadway, Rolling Stitcher. When growing up in our respective hometowns, which were way more than 45 minutes away from Broadway, and being born in a time when the musical theater's most prolific accomplishment of the era was to have an entire cast on roller skates, we had no way of traveling back in time to understand the Broadway we loved and heard on records. But it was today's guest with his vivid writings who brought us and many thousands of others like us back into a bygone era and made us feel like we were there.

His contributions to preserving the history of the American musical are, in a way, vibrant. While our guest has over 20 titles to his credit, we know him for the wonderful Musicals by the Decade series that include our favorites: The Happiest Corpse I've Ever Seen, One More Kiss, Open a New Window, Make Believe, plus biographies of Florenz Ziegfeld, Kurt Weill, as well as books on the Hollywood Studios, Guides to Orchestral Music, Stephen Sondheim, and most recently, All That Jazz: The Life and Times of the Musical Chicago. To let us turn the spotlight on the man who kept the spotlight on the evolution of musical theater in a way so interesting that it inspired countless folks from around the world to want to be a part of the world he articulated, including yours truly. Hello. Here is one of our favorite people and author of the sensational new All That Jazz: The Life and Times of the Musical Chicago, ETHAN MORDDEN. Ethan, welcome to the podcast.

[3:20] ETHAN MORDDEN: Thank you. You are one of our when we first created the podcast, you're at the top of our list, and I'm so happy we had you. Okay, so we're gonna start with this amazing book, which we talked about on a previous episode. We've encouraged all of our listeners to buy it. So I'm gonna ask you a question. It's 1973. Bob Fosse's just won the Triple Crown in directing. I'm one of the first people, only people, I think, to have accomplished that in one single year. Um why did he could choose any property to work on next? Why some obscure play from the 1920s?

[3:50] ETHAN MORDDEN: Well, actually, it wasn't that obscure in the sense that from about 1954, five, six on, everyone on Broadway wanted to get the rights to Chicago by Maureen Watkins and turn it into a musical because everyone seemed to sense that there was something sensational, lively, crazy. I mean, if you go back to the play, it's very, very close to what they ended up with in 1975 when Chicago went up, you know, at the 46th Street Theater, now the Richard Rodgers. It was a play in 1926, then it was a silent film, late silent, 27, then it was a talkie with Ginger Rogers, and the two films changed it considerably. But Fosse's version on stage goes back to Maureen Watkins. It slims it a bit, emphasizes things differently, but still, that's the show that everyone, everyone on Broadway wanted to see this as a musical.

And I don't know who the other people were going to be who were in it, but Fosse and Verdon, right from the start, this is as they were emerging around the time of New Girl in Town, when Verdon could carry a show. You went to see the show because Verdon was in it. And even a show that people didn't enjoy that much, New Girl in Town is a good example. I love it. And I in fact I remember it very, very vividly because I saw him as a kid. But I think a lot of people felt it really wasn't good enough. It was one of those George Abbott things where the book is only good enough to, you know, put the dances for exactly. And I think excuse me. Yeah. At that time, that was 57, Fosse and Verdon, like everyone else on Broadway, they kind of knew about Chicago, the play.

And they made inquiries. Maureen Watkins was at that point living in um around Jacksonville in Florida. She'd moved there to be with her parents. And she kept saying no, no, no, no, to everybody. She didn't want to see it as a musical. And the man who was in charge, I can say this because he's not with us anymore, who's in charge of the rights, saw all these plays starting to be turned into hit musicals. And he would, of course, get his commission on these long-running shows, and they'd play in London and they'd play and so on. And he was really angry at her. And he invented this legend of Maureen Watkins that she had become a born-again Christian, and astrology ruled her life, and she was a recluse, she would not go out of the house, and so on and so on. All of it was false.

[6:10] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yes, he made it up. Well, he used what was there and kind of tweaked it and twisted it and you know, built it around and threw confetti on it and painted it green. The fact is she was, as her parents were, a member of the Disciples of Christ, which is a very little known Protestant sect, which is Bible centered. That's basically what it is. And it's all about Bible study and thinking about the Bible and what it could mean and so on. But she was, contrary to what that suggests, a very live wire. She was voted the prettiest girl in her class in high school, and she became a reporter in Chicago, and I mean a reporter, not the editor of the recipes column. She was a crime reporter, which in those days was very unusual for a woman.

And there was this too. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact, if you you can read her columns, they're in print. And she was scathing about these two women who were the models for Gwen Verdon and Gina Rivera in the show. She was scathing about the way that they were going to get off because it was basically showbiz instead of justice, which is what you know the show was about. And all of these the legend is so big then I was talking on the phone with John Kander. I wanted to speak to him about, you know, see if I could pick up some things. Actually, we didn't end up speaking, but we did, we were on for about 20 minutes. And he started telling me the legend of Maureen Watkins. He thought it was true too.

Nobody knows that this is all false. She wasn't into astrology, she wasn't a recluse at all. And she had it in her will that if Fosse and Verdon still wanted to make the musical Chicago, they can go ahead. They got first refusal. So she, in effect, said yes. It was just a delayed yes. It was a time delay. That's insane. Like the vitamin C you take. It was a little bit, you know, but the fact is, I think it's a wonderful story because it shows that she was aware that if there's gonna be a musical of that play, the best one is going to be the Fosse musical with Verdon. I mean, this this is the show they were made to. This of course was Verdon's, you know, farewell to the Broadway musical. Everyone knew that at the time. It was his present to her, even though they were fighting horribly, you know, in the backstage of it. Really, he was as vicious as he could have been, he was a very complicated man.

[8:20] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[8:20] ETHAN MORDDEN: And he was, you know, he uh when he started rehearsals for Chicago, there was a week with the chorus, and then I think on the first or second day of the full cast, he got his heart attack. And of course, he had to recover. He had to undergo medical procedures in the hospital. Finally, they get back together and they're rehearsing, and everyone says it was a changed Fosse. He was always complex, he was always now he's friendly, now he's not so friendly. He says to you know, some girl on the chorus, you know, just because I fucked you last night doesn't mean you're getting in away with anything today. And but he was much worse now. He was angry, he was an angry guy. But he was a very complicated man.

He was charming, he was funny, he was sharp, he was lacking in self-esteem, obviously bad parenting. He never believed that he was worth the success that he had had. He just never, he always felt I must be a guy with three tricks. You know, I actually this is something else, but um Al Capp was a very successful, of course, cartoonist of Little Abner, and it was everyone in the country was reading. And somebody once said to him, you know, you're a guy with one trick. Little Abner never marries Daisy Mae. That's all that is in that story. That's not true, by the way. It's a lot of political satire. Oh yeah. But still, but still. And Fosse thought he was a guy with three tricks, and it's not true at all.

And the fact is that now, if you go back to golden age choreographers, Dumille and choreographer directors, DeMille, Robbins, Michael Kidd, Joe Leighton, all these people, Anna White, Hanya Holm, the one who's most famous now is Fosse.

[9:52] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[9:53] ETHAN MORDDEN: More so than Robbins. And the one whose style is most imitable, in the sense that if you want to do 10 seconds, give me 10 seconds of Fosse. Everyone knows everyone looks like hands back and one arm is broken, one arm is exactly. And and the derbies, and that funny way they have, I'm doing a visual, even though your listeners can't see it. They don't hold it the way we would hold it. They hold it in a strange, delicate way, kind of thing. And the the the tongue clicks, as in steam heat. I got, you know, that kind of thing. And at one point, um, in fact, uh, Candor and I were writing a song for Chicago. It was uh Razzle Dazzle, and they played it for somebody, and he said, Oh, Fosse's gonna love that.

It's got finger snaps in it. This guy is, he was instant showbiz. He was totally. Now, when you think of a brilliant, hot, sexy musical comedy, it's not what we have anymore. And what we used to have, it was Bob Fosse. And you know, there's this other interesting thing. I find this always fascinating. I used to speak to a lot of these people, not only because of books, but because I knew them a lot of them. And they all the Fosse, the core that he liked to keep together from show after show. They would always say he would tell them at some point in the action, pick someone out in the audience and glare at him all through the rest of the show. He said, I don't I want these people to have a good time, but I don't want them to be comfortable.

If they're comfortable, it isn't art. That kind of thing. And this is he was always very eager to get respect, and then when he got respect, he didn't believe it. He thought he was fooling them. It's very, very sad. If only he could know now, he's the one.

[11:30] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[11:33] ETHAN MORDDEN: Totally, and and it's gonna keep on going too. They're always gonna want. I mean, look at Chicago, it was a hit enough in its day. It really made its money on the tour, kind of thing. But now it's been running for 22 years again. It's incredible. I mean, it's quite amazing. It really is. Yeah. I mean, we know this the iconic Fosse dance pieces.

[11:50] Kevin David Thomas: Sure.

[11:50] ETHAN MORDDEN: Um, so my question for you is this what if his do you think is underappreciated that you wish more people could have seen?

[11:56] ETHAN MORDDEN: Well, I got the answer all set. Redhead. It was the greatest staging I've ever seen.

[12:01] Kevin David Thomas: Really?

[12:01] ETHAN MORDDEN: And the show is not great. That's why it's not really revivable. The show was a vehicle for Fosse and Verdon. But keep in mind, it must have played well because it won all the Tonys. It swept kind of thing. And I think it even best musical for a show that basically was it started in the late 40s. It was going to be a murder mystery. The Fields is Herbert and Dorothy Fields, brother and sister team, got this great idea. It's gonna be set in a waxworks, and the heroine is going to be in trouble for most of the show because she knows who did it. And he's going to be chasing her. Okay, that's all they firmed up. Now who shall play it? Ethel Merman, no. And this one, no. This one, no. And they were ready to tailor the show to the talents of starting.

Knocked around for almost 10 years before finally Fosse was looking for a show that he could completely control. This was his director choreography. He did not want Rogers and Hammerstein because he knew he couldn't supervene over them. He did not want major people who would have fancy ideas about think of the fight he had on Pippin with Schwartz. And he finally had to bar him from the theater. Fosse wanted to be the guy who is the author of the show, which is why, as his career went on, he used less and less new people writing new work. His last show was all it was a jukebox musical. Yeah. And it was terrible, by the way, but let's not go there. But New Girl in Town, uh, sorry, I uh Redhead was I this is another show I remember vividly because the staging was so wild, and I'd never seen this before.

[13:34] ETHAN MORDDEN: Because in those days, musicals were all big. This was the 50s now, we're '59. They were big, they had lots of sets, and the sets came down like this, and the wing pieces came in. It wasn't, you know, nowadays everyone in theater speaks about the set. Because we're so used to unit sets, even though there were different things that you see, it's the set. No one would have said the set in the 1950s. It was the scenery because there was so much of it, and it kept changing. But he arranged for this show constantly to be offering a completely bare stage. He wanted a dancer space, and then when he needed to, for the book scenes, in came the scenery, but it would go right out again. That kind of thing.

And the whole thing was based around dance. Every number followed was followed by a dance or big dance, this kind of thing, that kind of thing. You can hear it when you listen to the album. It sounds as if the whole show wants to stop singing and talking and just dance. And I still remember because it was so shocking that the audience cried out. It was a real surprise. This is in the Big Dream Ballet that NZAC won. And this is a big ballet. It took her establishing number, merely marvelous. No, that isn't her establishing number, sorry, but Nick is that's her first big number. And it put it through musical variations four times, and each variation was a completely different change of costumes and a completely different style of dance.

There was a gypsy one, there was a ballet one, there was a marche militaire, and there was something else. And for the gypsy one, there were like three gypsies on it. Usual um Bob Fosse gypsies was Eddie Phillips, Buzz Miller, and someone else. The same people you kept seeing in all these shows in the 50s. And suddenly, out of nowhere from the stage left wings, Verdon came flying through the air. They caught her just in time. The audience jumped ten feet in the air. Wow. I can't, I still can't believe that she did that. What if they were thinking about lunch or something? You know, what could happen? She apparently she was launched off a trampoline or something in the wings. And the fact is, Fosse would create these marvelous roles for her, such that no one else could play them.

When New Girl in Town went on tour, they had to get two different actresses to play the role, one to act and sing and the other to dance. They couldn't find anyone else who could. Yes, they could not find anyone else who was as loaded with talent as Verdon. And there was this too. Unlike a lot of people in musical comedy in those days, she acted. She really was an actress. A lot of these people, I'm not saying they were not good. Yes. And even in the book scene, she could carry. Look, New Girl in Town is Eugene O'Neill. It's Anna Christie. And the fact is, I also remember another great moment when the audience gasped. Her entrance in New Girl in Town. It's like the one in the movie with Greta Garbo, but it's more blatant.

She's all dressed up in those flashy colors that prostitutes are always assumed to wear in the theater in the old days, kind of thing. And it was a bar scene, and there was no heralding like here she comes, which sometimes happened in those days. Just the door opened and there she was, and she looked so prostitute that the audience went, kind of thing. Is that Gwen Verdon? Kind of thing. And she really could carry all these things off. She was this good, and she didn't want to be thought of as a dancer because she knew that everyone on Broadway thinks of dancers as being empty heads. She wasn't at all. She's very smart. And she was this natural actress. She wanted to, she didn't want to give up dancing, but she wanted to bust out of the category of dancer.

She wanted to be an actress who sings and dances, in the same way that, you know, Barbara Streisand didn't want to be a singer. She became, she always says, I became a singer because I couldn't get acting jobs. And she's always been a singer, but she's also an actress. That's what she wanted. And I think it's amazing that these two came together, Fosse and Verdon. And that they, without each other, they never would have gone where they went. That's what I mean. It really was it. It was a chemical thing that made everything bigger. It wasn't just the bigness of Fosse and the, you know, the bigness of Verdon. It got much larger than that because they could do so much for each other. And the interesting thing about this is that they really were meant for each other.

He wasn't a great listener, I will admit, but somehow or other, he understood her. And she was a good listener, and she understood him. And you know, it's very rare to find someone that you're close to who really does understand you. You can have tons of friends, but they aren't all listening to you all the time. In order to listen to somebody else, you have to take all the stuff out of your head and lay it aside for a moment and simply be an empty vessel that the other person can pour his heart out into. And if you come across three people like that in your lifetime, you're lucky. And these two really matched in that way. And you know, they never did divorce, they separated because she couldn't stand all his womanizing.

Right. You know, that's the way he was. She knew that not only her career, but her sense of self was bound up in the relationship with Bob Fosse and his with her. It's quite an amazing love match with her, yeah. And there's going to be a TV series, it seems about their relationship. Who's gonna play the roles? It's um oh, I know this. It's uh Sam Rockwell. Oh, yes, I have heard that. Bob Fosse, and I cannot remember who's playing Gwen Verdon. I want to hear Michelle. Someone's saying it's a good one. She is Michelle Lee, yes. Well, she's awfully good. Yeah, she's talented, she's very talented. Yes, she is. Am I correct in saying that Gwen Verdon's last appearance on stage was Chicago? She was her last musical, but I think she might have done, could when was children children was that I think that was after, and that was a play.

One night at the Ritz at the Ritz theater. I think that was. It was a mystery. Yeah. I think the children are bad. Why did she not want to continue being on stage? Because she was 50 and it slows you up like crazy. You know, at a certain point, you can't. How many athletes can dancing is athletics. How many athletes can you name that are still active in 50? Yeah, no. Even at that, you know, Cheetah had more dancing in the original Chicago than Gwen did. Yeah, that's true. That's right. And there was one big Gwen's big dance number was going to be me and my baby. And they laid out this very elaborate Fosse laid out this very elaborate. It was an Eddie Cantor number, because we know that all the, not all, but all the interesting numbers in Chicago are actually, they're all interesting, all the most interesting.

And um, and the chorus boys were all dressed as I think babies. And she was, it was me and my baby, my baby and me. And I saw Chicago several times in the original run. One night she just sang very slowly one chorus of the song, and that was all you got. Because there were certain nights when she just looked, she was carrying a show eight times a week. You know, every novelty star, and I'll get to what they are in a minute. The people who like Rex Harrison are not used to musicals and then get high, you know, or Richard Burton in Camelot, or Tony Randall in O Captain, because the roles got more interesting, the characters got more interesting in the 1950s as a result of the Rogers and Hammerstein model.

And they couldn't just have musical comedy people and they had to go to the acting world and pull them in and beg them to sing, kind of thing. But all of these people said the same thing after, you know, once they got used to doing eight shows a week. I had no idea it was going to be this exhausting. You know, we take it, the people who are dancing in chorus, the people who want to start, and Barbara Cook and so on, they know how tiring it is. Right. But the people who are busy just acting and not moving a lot, much less dancing and singing, yeah, never know what they're getting into. It's much tougher than it looks. And sure, by 50, this is as much as she could do. So there were certain nights when she only gave you one little chorus, and finally, Bob Fosse thought, we have to fix this.

This is not gonna work. And he redid the number as a, again, it was a marche militaire with two men. It was called the Scrat. So she would sing the number, but then it's much easier to march around and do this kind of thing. And she can make it look like it's just the most fabulous thing on earth. But still it's not at all hard. And she was able to do that. But when Liza came in for five weeks spelling Gwen Verdon, they put back in the big baby number. Because you know, Liza could do it. Kids can go all night. When did you start going to theater? You got started at an early age, right? Yes, I was taken when I was three years old the first time. King and I. King and I, yes. And she was still alive.

She was in it. I don't remember that one that was Lawrence. Yes, Gertrude Lawrence. I don't remember that one that well. But then I saw all the hits, basically. I saw Can Can, Kiss Me, that kind of thing. The one that gave me trouble was Candide. I had the album. I needed to go. And I was too young to know that sometimes I didn't realize the shows close. I thought, like, I kept saying, Can't you take me to Oklahoma? And they said it's not playing. I didn't know what they meant. I didn't realize the shows open, they run, and then they close. I have the album in my thing. But Candide was the first time that I realized this show is not successful. I don't know how I knew that. But we got the times.

And I was very eager to see the show, and I was worried that it would close, and my birthday was coming up. I always got a show on my birthday, I got one in the summer, all sorts of reasons. And Candide had opened in December, and little did I know, I got in, I got to see it on the last Saturday afternoon. Oh my gosh. It's the first time I was in the front row, too. Very, very exciting. And I remember that show very, very vividly, I have to say. Tell us about it, because I'm that's like one of our time machine shows. It was the first time I ever saw a drag queen, and I didn't even know what they, yes. There, you know, you know the scene in Venice when Max Adrian is going lady frilly, lady silly.

Well, there was about five women and three of them were men. But they were dressed as women. This was part of this very strange show. I mean, it really was odd. It was a wacky show. And the last scene, when the which ends, of course, with Make Our Garden Grow, everyone looked as if he had this all this complicated costume plot and these wigs, which is why the show was so expensive. Those, if you do wigs right, shows it it's another hundred thousand dollars in your budget. I'm talking 50s money. And after all these fabulous costumes of, you know, Europe in the 1700s, everyone looked in the last scene as if he'd come out of a bomb shelter after a nuclear war. It's an amazing show. It did everything differently from what I was used to.

Everything differently. And also, of course, there was that fabulous overture. And then normally the curtain would go up in those days. There'd be a scrim, and everyone would be frozen. And then the lights would pick up, you know, and the scrim would go up and everyone would start moving around. Can Can started that way. I remember that very well. And this didn't, this started with this one guy. It was Max Adrian as Dr. Pangos. Came out, apparently those curtains don't just go up and down. There's a split in them. He just came out of the middle and he started talking. I thought, what? You can't start a musical with, and I became afraid. I have the album, I know they sing. It was like Phantom of the Opera.

Now, is this a musical or not? But, and then of course the curtain did go up and everyone was there, and it was great. I, it really was a marvelous show. I think even at that young age, I was aware that everyone was basically eligible for social security when they were supposed to be like, you know, 22. They all, everyone was in their 40s. You could tell. And then when wigs always age you too, those white, you know, those peruks that they wear. They can turn anyone into a 40-year-old, even Barbara Cook. You know, I saw I saw every one of her musicals except the Portofino one. Really? I saw all the other ones. Yes. Well, I didn't see Flahooley, I was too young. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I did from plain and fancy on, I saw her in everything.

I thought she was a major star. Of course, she became one later, but at the time she was taken for granted. A lot of talent was, yeah. She never really was. I mean, in the gay life, she was, you know, starred. But like even in the shows before that, even the Music Man, her name wasn't above the title. It was just Robert Preston and the Music Man. Oh, interesting. Yeah, she got good billing below, but it was, it was with Barbara Cook kind of thing. You know, that we have our Gwen Verdon, we have our Barbara Cooks. Who else from the golden age do you think should have reached that status but never did? Gosh, I never thought of it that way. I mean, so many people were so wonderful, but they were often in, they was, you know, they were in sidekick parts.

Like a Susan Johnson. Yes. Now there's one of the greatest voices we've ever had. Now I did see Susan, every one of Susan Johnson's musicals I saw her Broadway once, except when I saw The Most Happy Fella, she was out. I got Helen Blount, who was actually quite good. Yes, well, Susan was great. I mean, that voice was incredible. Yeah, she was, and she had great presence too. There was, you know, even in something like Whoop Up that she must have known was absolute, you know, fun Dreck, but direct all the same. Still, you know, she had a way of performing as though it were Hello Dolly, you know. I love the idea that these people are not going to let it get you down. I even said I had a friend, I had a lot of actor friends when I was in my 20s, and I had one who would, he never stopped working.

Always on Broadway, straight plays, not musicals. And as soon as one play closed, and they always did very quickly, he would go right into another. He was in nothing but flops. You would find him in theater world. He would be in like 20 shows just for that one season. In out, in out. And I said to him, How do you stand it? Because some of these plays really are, because if you know actors, you have to see their show. Some of these plays are really terrible, I have to tell you. He said, in every audience, there's one person who thinks this is the greatest show he's ever seen. I look for him or her, I isolate the person, and I play to them.

[26:56] ETHAN MORDDEN: Oh, wow. Yes. Now, of course, that was a lot of that is imaginary because you know, not everyone goes. But the thing is, you've got to fix on something that gives you motivation for giving the audience the most you can. Because basically they're gonna be sitting on their hands.

[27:12] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[27:12] ETHAN MORDDEN: I the last time I saw the revival of Chicago, it was so what's the word? You know, everyone who likes theater has seen it as many times as he wants to. So who's left at this point? Right, you know, in a long run like that. I'll tell you, there were two straight couples behind me and my critic friend, and just before the show started, one of the women said, "You know, I've never seen a Broadway show before." So, in other words, it was pulling in, it was pulling in people who I guess they hear about it. Someone they know saw it, or the playbill is on the coffee table, that kind of thing. And I have to tell you, she really this woman so enjoyed it. And at one point in the trial scene, there's this if you keep going to that Chicago revival, they add things in now and again.

And there was one new thing that I hadn't seen before, and it's certainly not in the script. During the trial scene, when they have this one guy who keeps changing his disguise, he plays all the jury people and so on. There's this one very cute touch he has when, who was it? Greg Butler has had, who was the dance captain, took over the role of Fred Casey, who's murdered, but he still is in the trial seat kind of thing. And at one point he's sitting on in one of the jury chairs, and Butler is this really big guy, really big muscles, huge. And of course, Fred Casey works in just a black leather vest. This is the Michael Barress role. Yeah, he originated in the row. Okay, so and his chest is just bursting out, he's pushing the, and at one point the jury guy gets so offended, he tries to close things.

How dare you show up in the jury like this? In any case, so then in comes, I guess it's Roxy, and she's doing her, or she's doing her testimony, and the jury guy stands up and he's looking at her, and I thought, whatever this is, they have not done this before in this revival. And he started to mouth, "I love your shoes." And the woman behind us was so into it, she cried out, "I love your shoes," along with him. That's I mean, people really get involved in these things.

[29:16] Kevin David Thomas: That's awesome.

[29:17] ETHAN MORDDEN: So in case. But for the but except for these two couples, or at least this woman, the audience really was they were they were enjoying it. You could tell by the way they were clapping at the end, but they were not really getting the jokes. They were this is Lynn Fontan said, after five weeks, it's all tourists. And she didn't mean from Kansas, yeah. She meant from Roslyn Heights. Yeah, yeah. And the thing is the actor, it forces the actors to emphasize everything. They're kind of shouting the punchlines at the audience, trying to get them to understand that this is a joke and you're allowed to laugh.

[29:45] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[29:46] ETHAN MORDDEN: Okay, so let's go on to the novelty star, which I think. The novelty star is great because it I mean, I'll tell you one of the greatest performances I've ever seen. This was in Philadelphia, because I have a lot of family in Pennsylvania, and I would sometimes see shows when they were trying out. And O Captain was so big in Philadelphia that they had to call out the cops because there were so many people trying to captain, yes, with Tony Randall. It was one of the greatest performances I've ever seen. I mean, he's a novelty star because he's not associated with musicals. He sang well enough, but that was not the point. He just took that stage over. It was this is why everyone loved it. Also, there was another thing, too.

It's a very smuddy show. And in Philadelphia, if it's done the right way, they love smud because they don't get a lot of it in their lives. But New Yorkers have tons of smud. So in other words, when it came to New York, and I think also the critics got mad that it was a hit in Philadelphia. Same thing happened with Flahooli. Huge hit in Philly, bad reviews in New York. You don't see the it's not good. It doesn't work the other way either, though. Anyone can whistle was a huge bomb in Philly. Came into New York and it was a huge bomb again. But Philadelphia is a very old-fashioned audience.

[30:50] Kevin David Thomas: I saw, believe it or not, Holly Go Lightly, because I went to college in Philadelphia.

[30:53] ETHAN MORDDEN: Where was your college really quickly?

[30:55] Kevin David Thomas: Uh University of Pennsylvania.

[30:56] ETHAN MORDDEN: Great, great. So here we are in Philadelphia. It's trying out at the forest, of course. That's the better of the basically two theaters that were up. The Schubert's too big. And I went down to the last minute. I must have gotten house heat. I had a great seat, and the audience is sitting there. And they word of mouth has not been great. But who knows? Because it was a very strange show. Very, very strange. Because it's such an elfin idea. You know, it's it's really hard to, it's it's capricious, the material. I'm talking about the movie because the book is very the novella is very different. But it's obviously based on the movie. And A. Burroughs basically tried to turn it into a conventional musical comedy.

It's not conventional material, so it didn't work well. But I'm everyone was just sitting there, and you could just tell. They were not angry. They were not bored, it wasn't boring, it was strange, but this is not the Edward Albee version. This is that came later.

[31:47] Kevin David Thomas: Gotcha.

[31:47] ETHAN MORDDEN: And people are sitting there thinking, I don't know whether this is good or not. It was that kind of show. I knew whether it was good or not. But I was having a good time. And then halfway through Act Two, there was this ballad. It was called What's the Italian for um not Sionara? What's the Italian? Ciao Campari. Ciao Campari, that's the number. Ciao Campare. And the gangster sang it, Baritone, backed up by three cops. So it was like a close harmony thing. Nice song. Except it's instead of A B A, it's just A A. Uh-huh. He didn't write it right. Bob Merrill. Right. But it's a nice tune. And you could you could feel everyone in the theater going, oh, so it is a good show. After all, it's a little late in the evening.

But it and then, of course, what happened was then they went to Boston. And Merrick must have decided, look, the show is not working. Yes. All right. And there's no way to fix this show. I'm gonna bring in Edward Albee to write a new book and change the whole thing around. And poor Bob Merrill has to write yet more score. Not a bad score, but not a great one. Although I think he was a very underrated talent.

[32:51] Kevin David Thomas: I agree.

[32:52] ETHAN MORDDEN: Very, very interesting. But in any case, so they're busy rehearsing the Edward Albee book, which is very dark. You know, you know what Edward Albee does. He doesn't do musical comedy, he does. The great musical comedy writer, Edward Albee. Yes. So but I Merrick must have felt the regulars have failed me on this show. I need to pull someone from a novelty writer. A while. I mean, it can't it it i if if it's bad, I'll close it. But at least it's not gonna be good if I don't do something drastic. So the show comes into previews in New York. It plays Monday night, it plays Tuesday night. I'm the only one who knows this. It did not play Wednesday afternoon, they canceled to rehearse some more. It played Wednesday night and then he closed it. So when you hear that it it lasted four previews and never opened, it lasted three previews. And the reason I know this is I'm friendly with Anne Kaufman, who was the daughter of George S.

[33:42] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[33:42] ETHAN MORDDEN: And her husband, Fred um Schneider, not Fred Schneider, um Irving Schneider. He loved to go to the theater, and he decided to go down and catch the matinee. And down he goes, and about 20 minutes later he comes back giving Anne a great moment, just like the maid in A Little Night Music. She can say, "My that was a short play." Then he said they canceled it. They canceled the matinee. So it only played those three previews. And I know tons of people who had tickets for The Saturday, and they'll miss out. No one I think I'm the only person who saw that musical. That's why I'm not sure. And it was called Holly Go Lightly once. Holly Go Lightly, yeah. I also saw Chu Chem. Also, because that also played Philadelphia and it closed there.

[34:23] Kevin David Thomas: Did you actively see did you like get a train ticket to Boston to Philly, to New Haven?

[34:27] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, no, no. No, I'm not that ambitious. I happened to be in college in Philly. So yeah, exactly. And I sometimes saw shows trying out in Philly when I was a little kid, yeah, because my family would be busy relatives and they'd park me at a matinee.

[34:40] Kevin David Thomas: What did you major in when you were in school?

[34:42] ETHAN MORDDEN: History.

[34:42] Kevin David Thomas: History, American history.

[34:44] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, medieval English.

[34:46] Kevin David Thomas: Oh.

[34:46] ETHAN MORDDEN: Anything to be different.

[34:47] Kevin David Thomas: Was there any so there was no chance you were?

[34:53] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, no, no, the piano. I think you're a music director, too.

[34:55] Kevin David Thomas: I was a music director for a while, and I thought I would I was in the BMI uh workshop.

[35:00] ETHAN MORDDEN: Can we talk about the uh yes?

[35:01] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, oh, I'd be happy to. That was a lot of fun. I wouldn't look because we have actually not talked about uh the BMI uh or angle at all, really.

[35:07] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, we haven't. It was we did this, of course, for your listeners, Lehman Engel at BMI, teaching this course, and Layman is very doctrinaire. But the great thing about Lehman was he had been a conductor, a music director on musicals from the 30s on. He had plenty of stories. And he'd seen the awakening or the dawn of the golden age in musical theater, musical comedy. The Golden Age. He came in on that, you know, early in it, and he saw the Rogers and Hammerstein Revolution, the changing in musical comedy, Sondheim comes along, but also he has all these experiences that he's constantly telling us about, and I just file them away for use in. Plus, there was this odd thing. The first year, it was assignments.

Like you had to write a ballad for a streetcar named Desire. And you had to write a comedy song for Come Back Little Sheba. And you had to write us something else, I forget what. And at that time I was just a composer. I had a lyricist partner, and then I wasn't Sondheim enough for him, so then he got someone else who was actually quite good. And then I had another um lyricist partner who was absolutely terrible. But then I thought, well, I'll just write them myself. Anyone can write lyrics. Music is the is the privileged, you know, compositional terrain. But anyone can write words, you know. I speak English. So and then I wrote a musical based on Measure for Measure, and then I wrote one on based on Max Bierbaum's Zulika Dobson.

And I made a big mistake because Zulika Dobson is satiric and it's cold-hearted and funny. But I tried to turn everyone into Rogers and Hammerstein people who love it. It was completely wrong. But cute music, but very old-fashioned. Lehman liked my stuff, but he said, "This is very old-fashioned music. This is the kind of music they were writing in the 1950s, and this is now the 1970s." And I said, "But this is the only music I like." So he accepted that. And the great thing was at the end of the year, what the um uh workshop turned into the showcase. Layman hired a hall and got the best people, the best people. And you could you were the accompanist, because it's your music, yeah, and these wonderful people, Betty Buckley and Hal Waters, all people you've seen on Broadway would perform your stuff for an invited audience. And you know, tons of people, tons and tons and tons of people were in that class and got to Broadway. I don't off the head, off the top of my head, I can't. But I a lot of them were after me.

[37:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[37:18] ETHAN MORDDEN: There was a a year, there was a class above me, and there's a year after me. And the class would shrink over that first year because layman would get mad at somebody and say horrible things, and that person would never come back. So at we started a little temper too, yes. We started, well, he didn't like people who weren't good looking, but let's not go there. So it would start with like 30 people, and it shrunk and shrunk and shrunk and shrunk. So finally you were combined with the seniors. If you got if you survived the first year, maybe even the second year, you were combined. And I remember at one point, Ed Cleban was in our class.

[37:48] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[37:48] ETHAN MORDDEN: And everyone liked Ed. The musical uh class act actually features, you know, Layman. Indeed, yes, it does. The whole scene about the although it changes everything. It's not exactly the same. And the guy the guy it isn't. The guy who plays Layman was this kind of Cyril Richard character. He was tall and and sort of English-you know, play the melonies. Yes, Jonathan Freeman. That's but that's not what Layman was like. He was short and dumpy and very angry at everybody. So my in any case, so um Ed Cleban comes and he says, now I'm working on a show with someone who's not in the class, and it's about people auditioning for a musical, but they're not going to like read lines and sing their you know their uptune. They're going to talk about their lives. And I turned to Melanie Chardoff, who was sitting right over to my right, and I said, "That show is gonna close in a week."

[38:37] Kevin David Thomas: Oh I was off by 15 years.

[38:40] ETHAN MORDDEN: And and the thing is, I didn't even, but Ed was not a great performer of his own material. I mean, he you're he's the he's the author, so he should. But the the thing is he didn't have a great voice, and he said he did he performed every everything is beautiful at the ballet. It really needs those three women. Yeah, and I think we would have been knocked away. Yeah, maybe everyone else was, I don't know. But you know, after Ed died, then everyone in the class started to kind of adopt him.

[39:01] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, really?

[39:02] ETHAN MORDDEN: It's like that moment in the Streisand of Star is Born where where the that that hideous disc jockey who has this huge feud with forget the name again, who's her co-star in that?

[39:12] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Chris Christofferson.

[39:13] ETHAN MORDDEN: They and Chris Christofferson ends up in trying to make it up. He brings a case of Jack Daniels, and he can't make it up because the guy is such a creep. And Chris Christofferson throws it through his the glass wall, the glass window of his cubicle and so on. But after Chris Christofferson has the accident and dies, the guy says, "He was like a brother to me." You know, they this is a show biz. They adopt, yeah, right, you know, because it enriches their own sort of their own brand. He's part of the tribe. And so I think Ed suddenly became this great winner after you know that it in that musical, the A Class Act, you we see everyone going up to I think Toronto because he did the dance arrangements for some show.

[39:54] Kevin David Thomas: No, that never happened.

[39:56] ETHAN MORDDEN: People it would take the second coming of Ella Logan for people to take a plane to Toronto just to see a musical. I mean, come on. Yeah, but uh, but it was a fun class. Lehman was fun. If he liked you, it was fun. And when you were combined with the seniors, it was fun. And we had two, I don't remember their names now. We had two guys, the the composer and the lyricist. Everyone thought they were gonna be the big stars. There have been like 25 uh BMI alumni shows on Broadway, but not from these guys.

[40:25] ETHAN MORDDEN: But I will say, at one point, we were, you know, you have to rehearse, of course, for the showcase. And they, I won't say who it was, but they had some performer, and I said, you know, she has a sort of reputation. How is it working with her? And the guy said, Oh, it's very easy. You call her up, and the phone rings for a hundred times, and on the hundred first ring, she picks up. That's so there were all these, you know, little showbiz things that we're kind of getting, we're getting our feet wet, so to say. I had a great time at it. And of course, that there was this program for the showcase, and I had to give them my bio, so I made one up, that kind of thing. And Layman was furious, actually.

He didn't like it. He felt it was letting down the side, I guess. But he, you know, he was very, very interesting because of all his experiences. He told us things that I don't know, I think they went right. And a lot of the kids in the class really weren't, they weren't savvy about Broadway. You were a sponge, it's I was a sponge, yes. A lot of them, I don't know. I can't, and the worst thing was it was interesting to get the criticism from Layman. If you wrote a song, you'd bring it in, you'd say, and in this scene in Measure for Measure, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And you'd perform your song, and Layman would, you know, make some very interesting comments. But then it was open to the class, and the class are all morons.

They don't know what's good or what isn't. And yet they feel they have. But the great moment was Lehman said to us, Richard Rogers is coming to the class. He wants to hear everyone's song. So ready your best number, and each of you will come up and I thought, this is great. Richard Rogers. Now, but what did Lee Vullman say in the commercial for I Remember Mama? I am singing Richard Rogers' music. And I was thinking, I am playing ETHAN MORDDEN's music for Richard Rogers. So the day comes, and he was in that last stage of. If you go to horror, you're not so hard, so he didn't say anything. He just sat there, and one by one we came up. I did a song from Measure for Measure. It's called Advice to Animals.

I just remember that this two lines that there's it's the people in Vienna are very upset for reasons not worth going into now. And they're talking to animals, metaphorically, but how to get out of this. And they talk to the wildebeest. And I just remember this line, you do one to others, and they can't do back. That's all I remember of it. But so there we are singing our numbers for Richard Rogers. And at the end there was a bit of QA, and someone did say, What's your favorite of your shows? And he did say carousel. Okay. So we know that's official. Yeah. That's his favorite. And they said, What do you like on Broadway of the new people now? And he said, Raisin. And they were right in the room, the two authors.

Okay. Oh. He loved Raisin, who knew? Kind of thing. Yes. I mean, I wouldn't it have been something more like Rogers and Hammerstein, but I guess it is in a sort of way. Taking a play and then putting the songs into character interaction, very interesting. Yes. And I and what I thought was so wonderful was just that this golden age guy was curious about us. So I was telling a friend, and he came in and we one by one, we sang our music. I don't know what he thought, but it was so nice. And he said, You dope. He's run through every good lyricist in town, and now he's looking for a new partner, and he wants somebody young so he can, you know, boss you around. I don't know if that's true, but that's what he said.

That's what he said. I wouldn't be surprised though. Well, in any case, but he had John Sandra now. Well, he ended up with Martin Charnon, so who knows? But the fact is that the fact is, it was the class is very good. I can't speak highly enough. Yes, it's still on, it's still on. It's very worthwhile. Even if nothing happens, it's good to have the reason to have to write, is to perform in the class and so on. And shows did get written at wrote a chorus line.

[44:07] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, go ahead, so go ahead.

[44:08] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, no, go ahead. I was gonna say at what point did you realize maybe I'm not gonna be a composer, or maybe I'm not gonna be a music director, or I'm not gonna do this part of the business.

[44:15] ETHAN MORDDEN: Of that I can answer, it was very simple. I had a job at Opera News. I was the assistant editor of Opera News magazine. And my a good friend of mine who was a literary agent was in conversation with a guy at Viking, and he said, you know, the one book I would really like to do is a history of the American musical. And she said, I know who can write that. So she set me up with him, and that was my first book contract. So then I figured I'm gonna be writing books. It'll be easier because I can work by, you know, Lillian Hellman always said, I'm only happiest in the theater when I'm home alone writing my scripts. And because you don't have anyone saying, now we need it. That's what happened to Ron Candid.

I'm not saying this is good or bad, and I think she was a horrible person, but the fact is she has this wonderful, she thinks a wonderful scene. And Bernstein and the others say, No, we can't use that scene. We need something or other right here, and quick, write one now. She's thinking, I can't just write one now. That's not how you write shows. It wasn't her métier, let's face it. She likes to write a script, hand it to Kermit Bloomgarden, who will treat it with respect and make sure whoever directs it will treat it with respect too, and not ask her to change a line. So, but the fact is that's what happened to me. I just fell into writing, and I just stayed with it because it was easy.

[45:27] Kevin David Thomas: And you enjoy the process.

[45:29] ETHAN MORDDEN: Absolutely. Yeah. Like Lillian Hellman. I like being alone at home writing a book. When you were hearing all these little tidbits and anecdotes of all these, you know, musicals that were coming before you and stuff. Did you go home and just like write them down so you would keep them in a file somewhere?

[45:41] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, yeah. It's in my head. But you know what I do sometimes, I have friends who have, shall we say, interesting tapes of shows. And I don't take notes during them, but when I go home, I take all my notes down because I don't want to, you know, interfere with watching. But you, it's very useful to take notes.

[45:58] Kevin David Thomas: Wait, when you said you want to interfere with watching, is that what you said?

[46:01] ETHAN MORDDEN: Indeed, yes. You want to take you wanna really be an uh the person in the audience watching the show rather than someone like a critic who's busy doing this and missing everything.

[46:09] Kevin David Thomas: Exactly. My critic friend, for instance, when we saw the last row of the orchestra, Raggedy Ann, was that the name of it?

[46:16] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yeah, it was a raggedy, which I by the way greatly enjoyed. Oh greatly, I thought was wonderful. And by the way, I was on the aisle and he was next to obviously next to me. And right here was now what's her name, the choreographer who directed it.

[46:28] Kevin David Thomas: Pat Burch.

[46:29] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yes. And she was, thank you, and she was giving her notes to her assistant. So for the entire time, half of what I heard was the show, and the other half was tell them not to stand right in front of the balloon. Get the lighting on the stage stage right, not stage left. We have to fix that line just for and I thought, and she has no problem speaking very loud in a theater, too. I mean, I've heard friends that have worked with her, I've said that you know, they're all on stage and they can hear her literally giving notes to her. No, no, she actually it was an undertone, but I thought this was interesting because now I would have preferred just to be watching Raggedy Ann. But still, if someone said to me, Would it ever be interesting to you to hear exactly what a director says while we're editing the show?

Yes, I would say that would be great. So I got two things. But the point is my critic friend was busy with his when Act Two began, he was busy getting notes about the entrepreneur whatever it was. And the curtain did not go up, it went down into this like little suction tube in the center of the stage. Whoa. And I said, And now I'm enshrined forever in his audio tape of the score. I said, the curtain's going down. So we'll listen for it if we ever get our hands on it. But to close with Lehman, he was a great repository of all this wonder. And he had he had smarts, like he would tell us. This is in one of his books, I know. It the song in Fanny to My Wife, the Panisings, very sentimental and very sweet.

It's one of those low-key songs that the audience is loath to clap after because it casts a very gentle atmosphere over the whole auditorium in the Majestic Theater, the Belasco for its last week of its run. And the way this the song was scored, it just sort of stopped. And Layman said, because the audience wasn't clapping. Harold Rome, who loved Lehman, Lehman always conducted Harold Rome shows. He said, Why aren't they clapping? Lehman says it needs a button. We have to have the bass instruments go boom. That's the signal to the audience. The song is now over, please clap. And sure enough, once they put the button in, everyone started clapping. So he oh, he was really smart in these in the housekeeping.

[48:30] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[48:30] ETHAN MORDDEN: The housekeeping of the musical. Yes. And you know, he because he was there while they were changing everything. And he knows what works and he knows what doesn't. You know, we were having this discussion a couple of days ago with somebody else. You're sitting at a show, the curtain goes up about 10 minutes in, you realize it's maybe not going to be the best thing you see. Do you ever leave it in her mission?

[48:49] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, no, no, no. First of all, if I write about this stuff, I have to stay for everything. Because who knows? Second of all, my parents, for instance, saw Sail Away, and they didn't like it. And my father wanted to leave, and my mother said no, because there's an 11 o'clock number, and ETHAN Bud is what I was known as those days. We'll kill us if we don't stay for the 11 o'clock number. She looked, notice she even knew the terminology. It is because it's why do the wrong people travel.

[49:15] Kevin David Thomas: Oh.

[49:15] ETHAN MORDDEN: Of course. Of course. Yes. Yes. Yes. Luckily they stayed for that. And that is the best thing in the show.

[49:19] Kevin David Thomas: We didn't ask you earlier. What are your parents? What did your parents do?

[49:21] ETHAN MORDDEN: They were so supportive. My mother was a housewife.

[49:24] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[49:24] ETHAN MORDDEN: What did she do?

[49:25] Kevin David Thomas: She napped and shopped.

[49:27] ETHAN MORDDEN: And my father was a building contractor.

[49:29] Kevin David Thomas: And they were supportive of this? They sound like so supportive of you.

[49:31] ETHAN MORDDEN: Uh they took you to the theater. I mean, you're three, and they're and you've got a cast album collection, it seemed, like LPs and stuff.

[49:37] ETHAN MORDDEN: Well, actually started they owned the albums, like Harris L Oklahoma and so on. But eventually I got to the, you know, they were supportive. I think they realized that it's good culture. I mean if you're gonna be a smart little precocious kid, and I was it's good to feed the intelligence because musicals make you smart. Of course, then the up the downside is later on my mother said, you know, how come you were gay? And I said, Well, you took me to Cancan when I was five years old. What did you think would happen? I mean, come on. My parents took me to Lakage when I was four, and I think I had to.

[50:06] Kevin David Thomas: That'll do it.

[50:07] ETHAN MORDDEN: I heard the same discussion. I said, This is you. And I I uh uh who is it? You know, an old queen, the kind that mentor you when you first come to New York after after college. He said to me that the champion of this was the Tallulah Bankhead revival of a streetcar named Desire at the city center. He said, at the everyone who attended the performance, including the ushers, was instantly struck A. And he said on Tallulah's good nights, even people passing outside the theater on the sidewalk. That's it. He said, and that's where gay started. There was no gay before that. It's Oscar Wilde, dreams, visions. But this is Tallulah Bankhead and the streetcar named Desire. 1951, I think it was. That's where it started.

[50:44] Kevin David Thomas: That's good.

[50:45] ETHAN MORDDEN: So it's still a young thing. It's still a young culture. That makes me so happy. You're killing me.

[50:52] ETHAN MORDDEN: Oh, yes. The reason why people think of it as, you know, Rex Harrison can't sing, and he's in it, but you know, it's an odd role. It's the kind of thing that, although I think this new guy, um Haddon Payton, Harry Haddon Payton.

[51:04] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[51:04] ETHAN MORDDEN: Um he's so good in The Crown.

[51:08] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[51:08] ETHAN MORDDEN: I just saw the first season recently. I took it out of the library. He's really wonderful in that. And I like I think he should be young. I like Higgins doesn't have to be, you know, old. But the thing is that everyone assumes that this is because it's English, My Fair Lady, and Rex Harrison is right for the role, so it doesn't matter if he doesn't sing and so on. That's irrelevant to the fact that because of Rogers and Hammerstein, musicals like My Fair Lady were made possible because they didn't have to be musical comedies with character stereotypes anymore. They could have these unusual, these one-of-a-kind characters, which would call us I've already said on the show, for actors with real dimension. And that's where they came from. So it wasn't just Rex Harrison, it was Tony Randall, too.

[51:51] Kevin David Thomas: Well, Tony Randall really was more a charm actor, because that is not a great acting role.

[51:55] ETHAN MORDDEN: But there's a lot in Harold Hill. And I don't know that the normal people who, and you know there weren't a lot if you don't count the comics, there weren't a lot of male stars in the musical before Rex Harrison and Robert Preston and so on. The stars were all women and comics.

[52:11] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. You're right.

[52:12] ETHAN MORDDEN: You know, if you think of like who was the go-to guy for, you know, in musical comedy in the 1920s.

[52:18] Kevin David Thomas: Alfred.

[52:18] ETHAN MORDDEN: That was but I'm talking about the 20s. Way back then. There really there weren't parts for them, so how could there be stars?

[52:24] Kevin David Thomas: You're right.

[52:24] ETHAN MORDDEN: I mean, Dennis King in operetta, I suppose. Dennis King sort of, but he wasn't a household name the way Robert Preston was.

[52:30] Kevin David Thomas: Alfreds, yeah.

[52:31] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yeah, yeah. Um, you know, you mentioned the term novelty star. What other classifications are there for different actors out there?

[52:37] ETHAN MORDDEN: Well, novelty star is my coining. That's your coin, yeah. Wait, but we needed one kind of thing, and it and it says what it is. I don't know, there are a number, I mean, if you go back to the Victorian era, there literally were character types like the heavy father, the singing chambermaid. The singing chambermaid was simply a kind of it could be a maid or a sidekick. There's one in the black crook, believe it or not. And she's the one who, just when the audience needs a pick me up, comes out and sings a charm song and has nothing to do with the show, and that doesn't matter. The heavy father, later shortened to heavy. If you think of, you know, the famous scene in melodrama, it's in the winter, the front door is open, it's sleet outside, the family is like this, they're all in, you know, gesturing and sadness, and there is an unmarried woman with the babe in her arms, and her father is standing there pointing to the door, and he says, Go and never darken my doorway again. That's the heavy father.

[53:32] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, and that became the villain.

[53:35] ETHAN MORDDEN: That's why we speak of the villain as the heavy. But it really was an older guy with a certain amount of weight to him. These were all types, and there were types in musical comedy kind of thing. And there were, but Rogers and Hammerstein came along, and all of their shows, no types.

[53:50] ETHAN MORDDEN: Everyone is a distinct character. Think of Anna and the King and the King and I. And that call it starts to call for people who are not out of the normal I do musicals line. And they started bringing people in from Hollywood or the straight theater. And there actually are a lot of them. And you know, like even the pajama game, when it went into rehearsal, it wasn't with John Wright, it was with the guy from picnic. I, you know, my brain is so addled with age now that when I leave the building in the morning, the neighborhood kids come and dance around me singing, Here comes Mr. Jell-O Brain. Because they know that I can't summon up the titles. Ralph Meeker. See, sometimes it takes me a few seconds.

That was good though. That was a good little bit. See that kid he remembers. I could tell you were thinking, Oh my god, what story is this guy? He's gonna look it up for us, and then bam, we got a Ralph Meeker. Got it. Ralph Meeker, and of course it turned out that Ralph Meeker couldn't sing. And so at a certain point, through mutual, and they bring in John Ray, who really should have had the role in it. Ray was a good actor. I saw him in a lot of things. He really was. And he's wonderful in the movie, too. Yes. He reads exactly what because Sit Sorokin in the pajama game is not your average, he's not like Curly in Oklahoma. He's not your average musical comedy guy. This is a very masculine sort of guy, doesn't fool around, he's very blunt about it, and then he's thrust into this strange position.

He's in love with the woman from the other side. And you know, he's such a his side his side kind of guy, and she's such a her side kind of woman. Yep. That's what makes Pajama Game so interesting. That you know, that it's not just a musical comedy, it's got some density in it. I agree. Same with Damn Yankees. This poor guy is now 22, and he's still in love with his wife who's in middle age, and he's taken a room in her house. It's such a strange story. We don't normally think of it that way because musical comedies aren't played that way. George Abbott directed the original. Here's another thing, too, something I also remember, which nobody I think ever really knows. And I don't think it's mentioned in the script.

And I was we were late for it, and I missed the overture, which was not on the recording. I didn't speak to my father for five years. Because granted, we had to come all the way from Pennsylvania, but I remember the curtain was up when we came in. Now it was we only missed like 30 seconds because they hadn't even gotten to the first number yet, six months out of every year. But um in the second scene, when he's outside and the devil is going to come in. I still things you remember after all these decades, the orchestra started to play this eerie music. And Bob Schaefer, who was playing the old guy who's gonna become young, started looking in a very worried way, stage left. So we all look stage left, and Ray Walston just walks on stage right.

So that when we realize he materializes because we didn't see him walk in. Old theatrical smoke and mirrors trick, yes. And George Abbott knew them all. Yeah, he did. He invented them. Yeah, I wish we could have seen a George Abbott show at some point. Um they did they play as furiously paced as is as it comes across. Um no, it wasn't it it's just that when he started directing, he started as an actor. Yeah, because he was tall and very good looking. And I don't know what quality of acting he was. And by the way, he was a cousin by marriage of who was the second most famous woman in the 1930s. Mrs. Roosevelt was the first Thompson. She was the first woman pundit, famous woman pundit. Dorothy Thompson.

Oh, wow. She used to be very famous, she's not famous anymore. One of my favorite people, though, very heroic. Cool. And in any case, she's the first cousin by marriage of George Abbott. So then he becomes a director. And at the time, the playing style of the day was slow. People wanted their money's worth. There were three hour evenings in the theater. Yeah. And things were not done fast. And he directed things to be much more quick. Chicago, the original play, 1926, was directed by George Abbott. He kept the thing moving. People were so unused to it that they said, I can't understand a word they're saying. Everyone's jumping around. It's hop-toed theater kind of. But that was only in comparison with what everyone else was doing.

It wasn't that fast. I saw a lot of George Abbott musicals when I was young, Nugaron Town, for instance, Damn Yankees. They weren't that fast. They were fast enough. They should be. But the thing is he did give line readings. That Gwen Verdon hated that more than. I have a feeling that it was for the best that they had to wait till Maureen Watkins died to do Chicago, because by then George Abbott wasn't really the go-to guy. Yeah. But and she really wanted to cut free of George Abbott. Chicago is not the kind of show where you want someone, you know, giving line readings to people. You have to cast the right people and set them free to figure out what their characters are. But of course, the main thing about Chicago, and I emphasize this in my book, is Bob Fosse and that brilliant showbiz.

Showbiz and Fosse to me are synonyms. Much more so that Agnes de Mille wasn't showbiz, she was the musical play. And Jerome Robbins was always from the ballet world and so artistic and marvelous. Right. Not putting them down. But Bob Fosse is special, and he's the most famous one for a reason. And Bob Fosse passed away relatively young, I would say. Yes, he did. And so my question for you is is there a property that you've encountered in your life that you go, oh, I would love to have seen what Bob Fosse would have done with that property. No, I never think in those terms. To me, it's just it is what it is. And you know, there's there's some maybe there's intelligent design, or maybe it's just coincidence, who knows?

But there's a reason why Fosse got to do Chicago and something someone else got to do something else. It's just the way these things fall out. Yeah. Um we wanted to ask you, we have a lot of academics who listen to the podcast, and uh, you know, I I'm just curious. When you look when you created your book, Make Believe, obviously, you were not around for the 1920s of musicals. How did you research that? That's the only book I want to talk about in terms of research. How did you research that? It's very, very simple. Upstairs at Lincoln Center is an incredible resource. The Billy Rose. Would you tell us about that for our listeners who are in there a couple of core times shall we say? It's the third floor of Lincoln Center.

It's and it's really everything is behind, not everything, actually, there's a little room where there's stuff that you can go to, magazines and watching it. It's very magical reference books. It is because you never know what you're going to find there. And the thing is, you sometimes have to outsmart the computer because it doesn't necessarily know. For instance, when I did the Ziegfeld biography, there are boxes. You know, there are Ziegfeld boxes. There are Anna Held his first wife boxes. And the boxes aren't specifically cataloged. They're there though. Yes, they are. It is in other words, his papers, something, they're just dumped there. There's a box of this, there's a box of this, there's a box of this, and you have to ask for the boxes because you don't know what's in them.

And in one box there might be bank statements. In another box, there might be, and there was the first act script of Betsy, which was a Ziegfeld Rogers and Hart show that was thought lost. No way. Thought lost. And there's the first act. Unfortunately, we don't have the second. Just sitting there, just sitting there. Because the computer doesn't say Betsy. Script. It just says box one, box two, box three. You never know what you're going to get. Treasure hunt. The Anna Held boxes, one of them was her address book. What? And yes, and I was paging through and I thought, my gosh, if I want to call Lillian Russell, here's her phone number. That's the same. Yes. And there are other things too. For instance, I was doing research for another book on Frank Bacon, not famous anymore, but he was a very, very famous actor in his day.

And he was a character actor. And he had knocked around, and he was in his 50s now, and he thought, the only way I'm ever gonna make it is if I write a great character part for me. And he wrote a play called Lightnin. It was co-written. He had to have a and he played Lightning Bill Jones, who is this, you know, the kind of wily hotelier who always seems like he's a rube, but he outsmarts all the city folk, that kind of thing. And it was perfect for him. And it was a really long run. I think it was three years in New York. This is in the like 1919. Oh. And and so this was special. And something interesting happened. This is the 1919 actors' equity strike. Lightnin is a big hit, remember, big hit.

And he and Lightnin are one, Frank Bacon. This is his baby, his shot at stardom, and he has become a big star. He doesn't miss a performance. No matter what, he's at that theater. And will they strike? Won't they strike? And everyone, uh, there was a play going on on Broadway, the night the first night of the strike. Everyone was running around watching to see what would happen. The Schuberts are suing everybody, Georgium Cohen insists on going on, his entire cast quits. He grabs people from the street, throws them on stage. Here's a here are your sides, do the play kind of thing. And then word comes down, Lightnin has struck. And if he walks out with his company of Lightnin, this the strike is on, kind of thing.

And it lasted for I think four or five weeks. And the producers had to give in. They had to. They were completely in the wrong. And besides, they need the actors. And do you know when Frank Bacon's last night in New York, they deliberately, they didn't tell him this, they deliberately lengthened the second intermission so that actors from other shows could in costume and makeup come running over to the Fulton Theater, I think he was playing at, so that at the very end they could all come on stage and congratulate him. And the president sent down the Secretary of Labor to commend this guy for his help in because without his, if Lightnin hadn't struck, the strike might have failed. Isn't that incredible?

Frank Bacon. Frank Bacon is named us. He was very famous in his day. So then that's chronicled in your book, I believe, right? No? No, it's uh it's in some book or other. My point about the library is you can't just look up Frank Bacon and get you have to look up other things as well. Obviously, Lightnin, Winchell Smith, various other people he worked with, because the computer doesn't always know what the library has. You've got to outsmart it. So I found my way to a scrapbook. Someone had put it together, and then you know, his heirs, when he died, handed it over to the library. And it was the scrapbook of I don't know what, but there was this clipping, it was in Chicago. Frank Bacon had taken the show out on tour, of course.

And Chicago was a great city for Lightnin because they liked their old play, they like their plays old-fashioned and Lightnin was. This is going to be even a longer run than in New York. But he had had a long, exhausting life. And he took ill, and he died in his wife's arms. And his last words were, I am tired out. Which works so well for the story. And I this is what you find in the library, and it was in this scrapbook that wasn't, you know, officially, you know, you have to just keep looking and looking. But the resources are incredible, and I don't understand why people have to keep donating their papers to the Library of Congress. Right. Because nobody lives in DC. The people who write about, well, the academics live in all sorts of places in this country.

But if you're not an academic and you're writing about the musical, you live in New York. Right, yeah. So they should they should leave the stuff where we are. Because you can go to that library over and over again. The Library of Congress, you have to go down to DC, you have to check into a hotel, and the people there are not so great about making everything available to you. And by the way, nothing's on site. They have to get it from some other place. I know people who've worked there, and it's it's a lot of trouble. So and if anyone is listening out there, leave all your papers to Lincoln Center Library. You have to. It's a lot of fun. That's incredible. I love it. I wanted to ask you. So, you know, one of my favorite books of yours is Open a New Window, which is the musicals of the 1960s. And in it, very clearly, you state that Zorba is just a piece of shit.

I think it's it's so a historian that has such a colorful writing style, where where did you adopt the colorful writing style from? As as a post-most history books that are more clinical. Yeah, I know. No, it just comes through. The reason I did that though is see, there's this thing that uh bothered me even then, and I'm not PC at all, and this is not virtue signaling. But but the fact is, in that in the material itself, I haven't read the novel, I presume it's in the novel, but it's certainly in the movie. There's this woman known as the widow, right? And she's very independent, she lives by herself, and there's this loser who's in love with her. And when he sees her um admit Nico, Nikos into her bedroom, the um the loser kills himself, and his outraged family kills her because she refused to serve as a tool of his will.

Right. And I find this so outrageous. As living as independently as I do, the idea of someone trying to impose his will on you always gets gets me going. And I think, you know, I I don't think that the score is good to Zorba. It's not that, and it was an interesting show, frankly, but for them not to have dealt with this in some healthier way, to just accept it as part of the Zorba narrative, which it is, they could have done something with this and they should have done something with this. And that's why I hate that show. I I think it's it's just it just so outrageous in its treatment of women. Yeah. There it is. Of course, now everyone would notice it. You know, for of course when I wrote that book, it this wasn't an issue.

And I'm not doing this to get on the Me Too bandwagon or anything. The fact is, I I find it repellent what they did to the widow, the character of the widow. Where do you think musical theater is going in the next 10 or 15 years? I have no idea. I I think we're going to, I think right now as we speak, every producer is saying, please write me Hamilton.

[1:07:15] ETHAN MORDDEN: Please give me a Hamilton. What made Hamilton, I mean, it's the zeitgeist musical. You can't imitate its musical. They're one-offs, you know. But I I'm sure just as Hair spawned about 30 hideous rock musicals, you know, like Dude, for instance, Dude. Just a lot of sand, huh? No, it was mud. It was mud, yes. It was dirt, but then it got wet. Throw that in there. And the fact is, what's odd is Hair isn't really rock, it's pop. It's not rock. Yeah, right. You know, and but the fact is we're gonna get a lot of rap now because of Hamilton. But there's no way how do you imitate an epic show like that? And especially how are you gonna imitate the staging, all that movement? Yeah, it's hypnotic. Yes, yeah.

I found it incredibly absorbing. I couldn't understand all the lyrics, but everyone says that about it. But the fact is, you know, nowadays there's this infrastructure. In the 1920s, if you couldn't hear the lyrics, you never would hear the lyrics. Because all you got was the show. They didn't have cast albums in those days. Now you have cast albums. You have a huge book that can contain not only the libretto of Hamilton, but various essays, notes by the author. Very, very useful. Very useful.

[1:08:33] ETHAN MORDDEN: The time machine question. You could go back in a time machine and see a show you didn't get to see. What would that show be? I want to see Funny Girl with Streisand again. Again. Again. I saw it with her. And I saw it with Mimi Hines too. But in those days, as I say, we were taking greatness for granted. And I didn't realize I should have gone back. She was incredible. An electric performance.

[1:08:52] Kevin David Thomas: Which three underappreciated musicals do you think that every student of musical theater should have on their shelf?

[1:08:57] ETHAN MORDDEN: Not the big ones that they, you mean the album? Yeah, the album. Well, The Gay Life, but I there's no should. I don't want to assign, but it's very tuneful and a wonderful show. Recommending, we're recommending, I like that. The Gay Life is a little bit of a good idea. I would recommend The Gay Life, absolutely. It's a wonderful album. It also, it's one of those albums that it's not only a good score, somehow the way it was recorded, it just, especially in stereo, it just jumps out at you. Jamaica's like that too, by the way. But it's not just the score. Again, it's the way it was recorded. The sound pops. Yes, it pops, exactly. So I would say The Gay Life, Condee, of course, but everyone knows about Condee.

I don't know. I've never, you know, this is not something I've ever thought about before. I uh you know, and if you had told me in advance, I'd prepare a hundred. No, no, that's a we like so many of them. I you know, I can enjoy almost anything. It has to be a really bad show for me not to be having a good time. But if I like a show, that doesn't mean I'm gonna say it's good necessarily.

[1:09:53] ETHAN MORDDEN: I liked um what's the one based on Therese Racin? Um Truth. The Truth, no, Thou Shall Not See. Yes. I like that score. I'm not gonna be able to do it. Oh, I like the score too. But I don't know Harry Connick Jr. I really enjoyed the show. First of all, it is a good story, even though the songs didn't necessarily fit where they were supposed to fit, kind of thing. But I thought it was interesting. I thought the staging was good. I was wrapped up in it enough, and I could tell that I was with my critic friend, so it's you know, fancy New York is there at critics' performances. And everyone is busy being I knew the show. So at one point near the end, the two lovers who now hate each other were locked in an embrace, and they started to turn.

They revolved on the not that there was a revolving stage, they just started to turn as they were embraced, and you saw that she had this huge bread knife behind her back. And I went, kind of thing. And everyone around me turned to glare at me like, stop enjoying this hideous musical, kind of thing. They don't like it when you same thing at La Bette. Everyone was really getting irritated at the five of us who were laughing nonstop. Right. It's a very good thing. It's a brilliant and funny show. I don't understand what their problem was.

[1:11:09] ETHAN MORDDEN: And as I say, the real guy was much worse than that. But in any case, I think that the whole thing is all these albums are around now, and it seldom happens now that a book musical doesn't get recorded. Very true. I mean, like that's why everyone keeps mentioning James Joyce's The Dead, because it didn't get an album. That's very unusual nowadays. You know, a lot of times they things are so expensive now, they budget the cost of the 200,000 into the capitalization of the musical. I'll tell you another one that I think I would recommend. I already mentioned it was uh what's the one again? The Almodovar? The Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown. That song that Patti LuPone has at the near the end, is it called Dangerous?

It's got one, it's a one-word title. Not Dangerous. I know what you're talking about, though. She goes on for a while, and at the end she goes, ta-da. It's a marvelous. She's terrific in it. Great performer, let's face it. But also, it's a wonderful, a wonderful song. It's so strange. I like the offbeat. Offbeat is good. I like that too.

[1:12:12] Kevin David Thomas: Are we allowed to ask what you're working on next?

[1:12:14] ETHAN MORDDEN: Well, my next book is Barbara Streisand, but it's already in production.

[1:12:17] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, amazing. Would you tell us a little bit more about that? When's that when's it gonna be released?

[1:12:20] ETHAN MORDDEN: About six months, I guess. Oh, we're up to the game. Yeah, yeah, we're in the galley. I've already seen the galleys.

[1:12:25] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, congratulations.

[1:12:27] ETHAN MORDDEN: But the book after that is the British musical. I'm gonna do the history of it's a book I've always wanted to do.

[1:12:33] Kevin David Thomas: That's gonna be incredible.

[1:12:35] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yes, that'll be fun. I love British musicals. What's your starting point in that timeline?

[1:12:39] ETHAN MORDDEN: The Beggar's Opera. Yeah. And then we're just gonna keep moving forward from there.

[1:12:42] Kevin David Thomas: That's yes, well, actually, it's The Gentle Shepherd, which is literally the first musical.

[1:12:46] ETHAN MORDDEN: But the first anything always has to be the famous one. You know, it's not it's it you can't have, you know, the first, like, for instance, the first musical to deal with race relations is Deep River. And that's no good. No one's ever heard of it. I was like, what? It's the year before Showboat. It has to be Showboat, even though it's not the first, it's the second.

[1:13:04] ETHAN MORDDEN: Deep River. Deep River is a very interesting, it's by Lawrence Stallings. It's basically a play with music. The score is not good, but the entire second act, the middle act, is a voodoo ceremony. Very interesting idea. Very interesting idea. It only ran four weeks. I think Broadway wasn't ready for it. And also, it needed the Showboat score to get, you know, kind of thing. But the producer was oh no, what's his name? Gilbert Miller, I think. And in fact, the guy who originally sang Old Man River, Joe, um, who was um Bledsoe. What's his first name? Not Tom. Is it Jules Bledsoe? That's I think it starts with a J. I think you're at, I think. In any case, this guy Bledsoe, who sang Old Man River the following year, he was a wonderful singer.

And if you hear his Old Man River, it's very unusual. He acts his way through it. Paul Robeson just, you know, Oratone. He lets out the voice. But um Jules Bledsoe, it is Jules. He acts it. He gives you all the feeling that he has about the river and slavery. Well, of course it isn't really slavery, but it is in a way. And um he was in Deep River too, and he wasn't a good performer, he's a good singer, but he never on stage he didn't have the right presence, and he would enter from the wrong, you know, door, and he would look off and wonder, kind of thing.

[1:14:26] ETHAN MORDDEN: And during an early performance of this play Deep River, was it Gilbert Miller? Let's just say it is, because I don't remember now. It's who would be Henry Miller's son, by the way, of Henry Miller's Theatre. Um he's just throwing himself around. Ah, he goes. And remember in those days, producers capitalized their shows themselves. They didn't have angels. It's in the 1920s. And Jules Bledsoe was doing the wrong thing. He goes, Oh my god. And he's just carrying on, and finally a woman says, if you're having such a bad time, why don't you go to the box office and get your money back? And he says, Madam, I wish I could. But in case, so Deep River is the first, but Showboat is the first. In the same way, The Gentle Shepherd is the first. But The Beggar's Opera is the first. And I'm just gonna take it on from there.

[1:15:11] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, we can't wait to read that.

[1:15:12] ETHAN MORDDEN: And you know, I saw a lot of these. I saw the original Salad Days, believe it or not. I was a little kid, my parents took me to Europe, and we were staying at the Savoy, and we were in a cab, and I didn't I knew about Salad Days, because my aunt, in those days, it was this typical thing. You would go to London, you'd see a few shows, and you always brought back one cast album from London, because they never were available here. That was the thing that always happened. My aunt was a big theater goer, my Aunt Agnes, and she brought back the Salad Days album. So I would when I would Thanksgiving, Christmas, big family parties, I would simply play these albums. And she had 17 too, which I didn't have.

So she brought back Salad Days, and I knew about it. I had known by this time I was old enough to know that shows definitely don't run forever, and Salad Days would have to have been playing for five years at this point. Well, in fact, it did. And it was on at the Vaudeville Theatre, which was just down the street from the Savoy. So we were passing in. I see the marquee, and I could see my parents going, Oh no, we have to take it to this, or he'll burn the Savoy down. And so I did see it, I saw Matinee, and I remember it very vividly. The weirdest thing of all was I didn't know that you have to pay for a program in London.

[1:16:20] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yes. So when the whatever the cedar was there, she had a little tray, I remember. And I asked for a program, and she said that'll be one in six. So I bought the souvenir book in the case. And my father had, when we went to the box office, he said, Do you have a seat down front for this young lad? And did they? It was a midweek matinee, and in those days, midweek matinees in London, especially for musicals, there would be like two rows of matinee matrons halfway down the because the English don't like sitting up close. It looks too avid, kind of thing. You know, you have Far Bella Figura. So they're sitting in the back there, and I'm in the front all by myself. There's no one for the next ten rows, kind of thing.

And so the show begins, and they're playing My Country 'Tis of Thee. And I thought, that's so nice. They must have known that there's a and I happened to turn around. And the women are all like this because it's their song. What is it called? God Save Our Gracious King. That's and and it they started playing that before shows during the war. And they kept it up for a long time after the war was over. So I leapt to my feet, of course, in due respect. But it was not the usual musical because there were two pianos and drums in the pit. Which I was not used to. I was used to orchestras kind of thing. And I distinctly remember this. The actors must have thought, and this is they've been in the show for five years, they didn't get a lot of replacements in those days.

And they thought it was so cute that this little boy is sitting in the front row, and they started to play to me. But in a condescending way, like, you know, like because it's a sort of dippy show. I love it, but it's not a grown-up, it's not a grown-up musical.

[1:17:57] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[1:17:57] ETHAN MORDDEN: And they were, you know, really, but I've seen a lot of shows in London. So I have the personal experience.

[1:18:06] Kevin David Thomas: We cannot wait to read it. And also, once again, All That Jazz: The Life and Times of the Musical Chicago that ETHAN wrote is absolutely fantastic. Please, please, please pick up a copy. It's so wonderful. And you're so wonderful, and thank you so much for spending so much time with us today.

[1:18:21] ETHAN MORDDEN: No, no, no, thank you for having me.

[1:18:22] Kevin David Thomas: And for all you've given us.

[1:18:24] ETHAN MORDDEN: Yeah, it's been a special one for us.

[1:18:25] Kevin David Thomas: Till next time. Bye, everybody.

[1:18:29] Robert W. Schneider: Stars in your multitude. Scarce to be counted, filling our iTunes.

[1:18:35] Kevin David Thomas: They're not scarce to be counted, actually, Rob. No, that is crazy. There's many to be counted. In fact, scarcely there's less than four. I believe there are five stars for almost all of them.

[1:18:44] Robert W. Schneider: Five stars for most of our podcasts, ladies and gentlemen. So this is how iTunes works. Thank you. Every time you rate us positively, we move up on the iTunes chart. So anytime anyone searches for theater and Broadway, the first things that come up are the highest rated podcasts. Huzzah!

[1:18:58] Kevin David Thomas: Huzzah! We would like to be there as well. So now we're going to give you instructions on how to rate and review us that we hope. It's very simple and yet not simple at all. So Kevin, we go to podcasts.

[1:19:07] Kevin David Thomas: Go to podcasts and then what do you search for?

[1:19:08] Robert W. Schneider: You actually go to iTunes if you can.

[1:19:10] Kevin David Thomas: Go to iTunes. Don't go to Podcast.

[1:19:12] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, and then go to Podcast. And then you search for it.

[1:19:17] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, that's our podcast. It's lovely. I hear it's great. Robert W. Schneider, Dead Sexy. And then go to ratings and reviews. Click that. That's in the middle of the page. Then you're gonna go to write a review. It's under custom reviews. It's a little tab, it's tiny, it says write a review. Click it. Give us five. Don't give us four. Give us five. If you want to give us four, that's okay, but just let us know why.

[1:19:33] Robert W. Schneider: No, I have issues with that.

[1:19:34] Kevin David Thomas: Okay, okay. Rob doesn't want you to do that. But give us five.

[1:19:37] Robert W. Schneider: Um and um and we'll thank you. Um and Rob always sends them to me, and it makes my day when he emails them to me.

[1:19:43] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it can't I Kevin sometimes cries a lot, so it's nice to see Kevin get a he he just bucks up like a happy little young filly when he sees five stars coming his way.

[1:19:55] Robert W. Schneider: That's right. I promise Kevin that if we could get all five stars, I will stop doing my impressions that he doesn't like so much. So there we go, you guys. That's all it takes.

[1:20:02] Kevin David Thomas: Where am I going? Jesus Christ.

[1:20:05] Robert W. Schneider: Because I didn't get a star.

[1:20:09] Kevin David Thomas: I feel like Judy God. Moving on down. I'm Estebett in a Star is Born. I was not allowed back on set after I stole James Mason's penny loafers. They looked marvelous on me.

[1:20:25] Robert W. Schneider: See, this is what happens. Give me five stars, you never have to hear it again. Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred