Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#152 FRANK RICH, Critic for The New York Times 1980-1993

While he was known by many as The Butcher of Broadway, Frank Rich is still considered to be one of the greatest critics who ever covered The Great White Way. Despite that savage moniker, he was, and is, a proud theater geek whose desire to collect obscure anecdotes and musicals makes him a kindred spirit to all of us... Read More

From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast

46 mins
12/24/18

Featured Shows

About

While he was known by many as The Butcher of Broadway, Frank Rich is still considered to be one of the greatest critics who ever covered The Great White Way. Despite that savage moniker, he was, and is, a proud theater geek whose desire to collect obscure anecdotes and musicals makes him a kindred spirit to all of us. Frank pulls back the curtain on his career to discuss how he first fell in love with the theatre, what it was like battling some of Broadway's greatest names, and why David Merrick was a consistent source of frustration and inspiration! Also, Frank shines the spotlight on Stephen Sondheim, Arthur Gelb, and Wendy Wasserstein. Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] FRANK RICH: I'm surprised you have time to sleep and eat.

[0:10] Robert W. Schneider: So I have to ask my first question. I know that you are a connoisseur of David Merrick's stories. Do you have a favorite Merrick story that you'd like to share with us?

[0:16] FRANK RICH: I absolutely have a favorite Merrick story. It is told, and I may be if people want to find the source, Harvey Sabinson, who was for many years Merrick's press agent, and later when I knew him much later, was the head of the New York Theater League, the Broadway Theater League, and now is retired, wrote a memoir called I think it was called Darling You Are Wonderful. Anyway, this may be a slightly garbled version, but it's absolutely priceless. Of course, it involved Subways of Sleeping, which was, alas, never saw. I was about eleven, ten or eleven, twelve years old when this happened. But it's famous to most people because of a prank that Merrick did, which was in the days of seven New York Daily Newspapers, he had been waiting to find a show for which he could hire essentially seven people with the same names as the New York drama critics and take a fake quote ad with all of them raving the show.

And he couldn't, he was stymied for years because the most important drama critic of that day, Brooks Atkinson, at the New York Times had a one-of-a-kind name. He could never find a Brooks Atkinson. But when Atkinson retired, he was succeeded by a critic named Howard Talbman, and so the roster was complete, and Merrick found the seven people, took them out to a steak dinner, to a preview of Subways of Sleeping, had them sign onto a quote ad with quotes like, "Makes my fair lady look like junk, you know, not merely the best musical of the season, the best musical of the century." And it was a Julie Stein, Betty Camden, and Adolph Green, lesser known, lesser show with Sidney Chaplin and Carol Lawrence and Phyllis Newman, and it was mediocre, and he placed the ad to run the morning after the opening in the Times and the Herald Tribune.

The Times caught the ad and yanked it before the first edition. The Tribune didn't. It ran for one edition, which is all he needed, then they pulled it when they discovered it was a hoax. It made front pages all over the world, and this mediocre show which got lousy reviews ran for a season and almost made its money back. However, that's not the story. The less famous story is about the same show. It tried out in the Forest Theater in Philadelphia. It got terrible reviews. Sabinson, as Merrick's press agent, was dispatched to Boston. The next stop was going to be the Colonial Theater in Boston to drum up feature coverage in the newspapers for it. And Sabinson goes to Boston, comes back to Philadelphia and said, "I placed the piece, but by the way, the first string critic of the Boston Globe isn't covering the show."

And Merrick said, "What do you mean?" "Well, he's sending a second stringer, Kevin Kelly, who had later become the chief critic there." And clearly, Merrick says, "Well, clearly he heard the reviews in Philadelphia, and that's why he's covering something else instead, more important than this." He said, "I've got an idea." And the idea was we will ban this second stringer, Kevin Kelly, from the opening in Boston and get publicity. And so a couple of weeks pass, they go up to Boston. It's a snowy night, and Kevin Kelly, having been told that he was being barred from the theater, turns up at the theater, and this ritual before local news and local TV, he's turned away into the night in the snow by Merrick.

And they say, "Why won't you let him cover the show?" He said, "Because he's a second stringer and he's an idiot." The next morning, so the show opens without Kevin Kelly. The next morning, Merrick is in a suite at the Ritz in Boston. Stevenson walks in with the papers and said, "David, you're a genius. You're on the front page of the Boston Globe, all about how you barred Kevin Kelly from the theater, and there's a sidebar by Kevin Kelly, what it was like to be barred by David Merrick." And he said, "But David, sit down. The best is yet to come. You go inside to the jump, and there's a review of Subways of Are Sleeping by Kevin Kelly." And Merrick says, "What do you mean?" He said, "Well, he wrote an introduction saying, knowing he was going to be banned, he bought a ticket to the last performance in Philadelphia and reviewed it on the basis of that. And he says, and Sabin says, and David, it is a rave." To which Merrick says, "Didn't I say he was an idiot?"

[5:42] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my god, that's a great story. I've not heard of that. That's a great story, yeah. That, yeah, it's one of the, there's so many great stories. I, you know, I alas, my own career as a drama critic barely intersected with Merrick.

[5:59] FRANK RICH: Yeah, at the beginning of my career, but that was it, essentially. I had some innings with him, but he was a sooner stroke victim and out of the picture.

[6:07] Robert W. Schneider: Right, right, right. Have you ever thought about writing a book on Merrick?

[6:12] FRANK RICH: Mm-hmm. I, there's a not very good biography that was done of him. I just feel I don't, first of all, I don't really want to, I know I wouldn't want to write a biography of anyone. I also don't think there's a materialist in saying that I think he's absolutely fascinating. But the one obituary I wrote for the Times the entire time I was there was of Merrick. It was his front page obituary.

[6:38] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, I poured that story isn't in it, but tons of other stories are.

[6:46] FRANK RICH: I really poured my heart and soul into it, with a fondness, I mean I didn't know him, I met him, but a sort of an appreciation for what he represented. It's long gone even then in the theater. And I'm sure you can just find on the Times archive if you search for my name and David Merrick and obituary. It was a front page, it was quite a lengthy obituary, so it's a mini biography of him.

[7:10] Robert W. Schneider: Great. Then we will post that for our listeners. I have to ask you, who was Clayton Cook?

[7:16] FRANK RICH: Clayton Coots was a guy I met. A little bit of background, and I should say that much of this story I've told both in my memoir Ghost Life and in a subsequent piece about Clayton that I wrote for New York magazine a few years ago. When I was a teenager growing up in DC, Washington was a huge tryout town in the days when there really were routinely Broadway tryouts, you know, something that barely exists now. 'Cause it was essentially replaced by previews in New York when it became too expensive to do it. And when shows became also too heavy to just jump from city to city. So Washington was on the circuit that included Philadelphia, Boston, and New Haven in particular. And I went there so many times as an adolescent buying standing room and second balcony seats to see shows that were trying out that, in some cases, the manager took pity on me and became and gave me a job as a ticket taker on Saturday matinees, which I did through high school essentially before going off to college.

And it was an incredible period because it was the period of, you know, I saw shows try out like Fiddler and the Odd Couple and Hello Dolly and, you know, also big flops like Irving Berlin's Mr. President. Strange things like Peter Brook's The Physicists, all of that came through Washington. Part of my job, besides taking tickets, was in the days of hard tickets, pre-computer, sorting them by price range and sitting in a back office behind the orchestra floor of the theater what was called the count, where essentially the manager of the theater and the company manager of the touring production would do the receipts of the day and settle, you know, who was owed what. The company managers were by and large, Damon Running types, old theater types, wonderful characters that toured for years, but occasionally there'd be someone who was younger, and Clayton Coots was one and he befriended me.

I got to actually got to know a number of them, but I particularly really hit it off. He was probably fifteen years older than I was. And through a fluke I saw him, he came through with a touring company of the first national company of Barefoot in the Park with Myrna Loy, I remember playing the mother. And he was about to go and sit down for a year in Chicago with the first national company of The Odd Couple, under the same management, obviously. And I was going to Chicago the summer after my junior year to go into a journalism summer program for high school students at Northwestern. I sort of had a girlfriend that came out of that program who actually lived in Chicago and I was able to keep visiting her during my senior of high school because my stepfather was an airline lawyer and I could get free plane tickets.

And so Clayton was there, he said, "You know, look me up," and my girlfriend and I spent a lot of time with him and often we'd go out to dinner with him when I was in town. He'd do the count at the Blackstone Theater where The Odd Couple was with a company with Richard Benjamin and Dan Daly, and then he'd take my friend and I out to dinner and I often stayed with him because her mother was, she was a single mother and disapproving of the boyfriend even in those sort of simple times staying in close quarters in an apartment in the north side of Chicago. So he remained a, and I remained friends with him and had a correspondence with him until sort of the tail end of college and then sort of we drifted away from each other.

[11:35] FRANK RICH: He drifted out of the theater, and ultimately I just learned after the fact that he had died at a fairly young age. But he was a very influential figure on me, not so much even about the theater, but about life. Although I learned a lot. I felt the theater was very glamorous. He didn't really. But I didn't believe him, and you know, I saw a lot of the theater from the inside through his eyes, and he was just a kind of charming pied piper guy, very lovely, very interesting, very smart, very witty, from a sort of show business lineage. His father, who was then still alive, who I never met, was a songwriter named J. Fred Coots, who had made a lot of money writing in the twenties, particularly he wrote "Santa Claus is Coming to Town" and "You Go to My Head," among other standards. And so he was sort of a surrogate parent to me and just made me love the theater that much more than I could know someone like him I thought was extremely glamorous and just great.

[12:57] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you for sharing that. One of the things we love to do on this show is celebrate mentors. It sounds like so thank you for that. When did you realize that being a critic was a viable option for you in terms of a career path?

[13:10] FRANK RICH: I really, it's weird because when I look back on it, of course, it's not really a viable career path for anybody. I mean particularly now with what's happened in journalism, it's nothing you really aspire to do. In my case, I did a lot of it in college for the school paper, the Harvard Crimson, and it was again reviewing shows that were trying out. My senior year, Sondheim's "Follies" tried out at the Colonial in Boston, and I reviewed it for the school paper. Incredibly, a copy of it made its way to "Follies," which I don't know how that happened actually, because it wasn't something you could buy in the newsstand in Boston at all. I mean, it was something distributed in Cambridge. But it led to Sondheim writing me a letter in the days of letters at the Crimson that he was taken with my review, felt the show had gotten mediocre reviews and worse in Boston, including from the aforementioned Kevin Kelly.

I'll just be this ten years later after somebody's oversleeping, and I guess he didn't like it as much as somebody's oversleeping. But I loved the show. I had written about it, I guess with a lot of passion. And so I got this letter from Sondheim asking to meet me, so I had a drink with him in Boston, and of course, I was out of my mind that it was an incredibly nice thing of him to do. He reached out to you; you worshipped him. And it gave me, feel God, well, maybe I actually know something about this. But I didn't think I would be able to make a living at it, and even at the time on the Crimson, other students, friends of mine on the paper were saying if you want to be a critic, you better start writing about movies because there's no interest in theater or theater criticism.

But it was true, it was a declining industry at that time, and it wasn't something you do. In any case, it sort of planted the idea in my head that maybe I could do something with it. That said, I sold my first piece that summer. It was to Esquire. It had nothing to do with the theater. It was a piece about, I got an exclusive interview with Dan Ellsberg, who had just released the Pentagon Papers. I wrote a long profile of him for Esquire. And then I began a career that involved everything from sort of muckraking journalism in Virginia to writing film criticism but mainly editing at a political magazine in New York, which is what brought me to New York. And I didn't have a career as a critic professionally for about another, I don't know, four or five years.

I was a film critic at the New York Post and a film intelligence critic at Time. I didn't write a theater review professionally until I was hired by the Times in nineteen eighty. So it was nine years after I'd written that review of "Follies."

[16:31] Robert W. Schneider: Oh wow, that's a long period, right? But certainly that was a huge encouragement to me, but it had no direct effect on my career. A very generic question, but what is the function of a critic? What do you feel that a critic should accomplish after a reader has finished reading the review?

[17:03] FRANK RICH: My idea was very simple; it came entirely out of being a theater nut as a child. Growing up not in New York, wanting to know everything about the theater, and while I was able to see a lot of shows as a kid in Washington, both on touring and trying out, I didn't see most shows that I wanted to see in New York because it was pre-Kennedy Center Washington, and it was just one touring house, an arena stage, which at that time did almost entirely classics, not new plays. And what I loved about the critics that I discovered young as a young reader, even, you know, I would say beginning at around ten years old, nine or ten years old, were those that could make me see what I was missing, could bring, with really good writing and some wit, bring to life for me in a way beyond photographs or Hirschfeld drawings or even original cast albums or play scripts what it was like to be in the theater on a particular night and see that performance.

And two critics in particular really did that for me. One was Walter Kerr, who was then with the Herald Tribune, and the other was Kenneth Tynan, who spent a year writing for the New Yorker. He was a British critic, obviously, but it was a year that happened to coincide with when I was falling in love with the theater. It was like the fifty-nine, nineteen sixty, sixty-one era, and I loved reading them, and it just gave me that. And as a result, that sort of became what I aspired to do as a critic, to give—because let's face it, many New York Times readers as a national paper were people like me, they were stranded elsewhere in the country where they didn't have access to every show that I was seeing.

And I felt that was the most important thing. And the opinion expressed in the review was secondary. And I feel that, you know, no one agrees with a critic all the time. There'd be something wrong with you if you did. You get to know a critic's, you know, what you consider the critic's strengths and weak spots. You know, you might agree with this critic about performances or drama, but you might not agree with him or her about musicals or comedy or whatever. And indeed when I look back, my own taste and what I like in the theater, I would say that neither Tynan nor Kerr were as close to it as say Brooks Atkinson. But Atkinson was to me a much more pedestrian writer, and I read him, but it just didn't thrill me the way their pieces did.

And so to me, it was about that. It was about trying to write and create that sensation the best I could, and also in terms of analysis, I always started with a gut reaction to whatever I saw. So if I was moved or if I was bored or I was angered or I was made to laugh or to cry, I'd always start with that and almost like solving a mystery about myself and about the play, try to figure out how I got to that reaction from what I saw in the theater that night. So that's what I regarded as the assignment.

[20:44] FRANK RICH: Because you were such a theater buff growing up, if you could go back in, you know, the good old time machine and attend a performance that you were not able to attend, what would it be?

[20:56] FRANK RICH: I would have loved—I mean, I can't say a single performance. I think that's probably way too hypothetical, but I was actually having a conversation with one of my sons just this weekend sort of about this issue. He's someone who writes for show business, not in the theater, but unfortunately for him, saw a lot of bad theaters in childhood like "Red." But I really am taken by the period that I missed, the post-war period. I would have loved to have been alive and gone to "A Streetcar Named Desire," "South Pacific," and "The Iceman Cometh." They all happened within a few years of each other after World War II.

[21:49] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.

[21:49] FRANK RICH: But it's also a great period to be in New York City if you wanted time travel by all accounts.

[22:00] Robert W. Schneider: Hey, podcast listeners, are you looking for a place to rehearse in New York City that is clean, spacious, and most importantly, affordable? Come check out Shetler Studios and Theatres, our wonderful host for these podcasts. Shetler is centrally located on West 54th Street between Broadway and Eighth Avenue, right in the heart of the theater district. Right in the heart, you'll find music, dance, and acting studios complemented by two black box theaters and six presentation venues. The professional facilities, inspired environment, and expert industry staff combined to provide the New York artists with an unparalleled studio experience. Visit their website at ShetlerStudios.com. That's S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. Shetler Studios and Theaters is our home for recording the legends of Broadway, and we hope that you make it your artistic home too. That's Shetler, S-H-E-T-L-E-R Studios.com. See you here.

[22:53] Robert W. Schneider: In terms of writing a review, is there anything that should be off limits for the critic to include in the review?

[23:01] FRANK RICH: Uh such as if an actor was fired before the production was reviewed, or the fact that it might have taken, you know, 30 workshops for the show to actually get on stage.

[23:10] Robert W. Schneider: Is there anything that you feel is off limits in a review?

[23:14] FRANK RICH: I really feel a lot of that background is irrelevant. I really do, and I feel um I I I made a point, you know, not that I'm necessarily correct, but I made a point of not it was easier pre-internet, of course, not knowing that stuff before a show opened, I wouldn't read Arts and Leisure Advanced Pieces about a show I was reviewing uh in the Times. If nor when I look at a script in advance, um, I could always send for a script after I, you know, seen that seen something I was reviewing. I I really, really felt it was important to have the experience of actually seeing the show without knowing the production history, gossip, uh uh what audiences were saying uh during previews, the out of town reviews.

I was really I I felt that very strongly. I felt I wanted to recreate what I had as a child, which was to come in uh not knowing what was going to happen when the curtain come up and see came up, went up and seen something fresh. And I feel you know, the the only time you know, if somebody died or something in the in in previews that was replaced, you'd you'd mention it. But you know, even when I was reviewing Forty Second Street, where um famously Merrick announced during the curtain call and opening night the performance I attended uh that the that Garrett Champion had died, the director and choreographer of the show, I originally didn't put it in my review. I felt it was irrelevant to considering the show to which I had had a very mixed reaction.

Right. Uh uh and then Arthur Gelb, the managing editor of the paper, said you really kind of have to put it in because it's a front page news for you you have to acknowledge that it happened. And so I did at the very last minute. But that's how strongly I felt about it. And and um uh in part because I felt that shouldn't influence one's judgment, which is what Merrick w Merrick withheld as we'd later learned, withheld the the news of Champion who died a day or two earlier precisely to influence the critics. And I never wanted to be part of that game. And I feel now too the two too many reviews I read were where critics are reacting to the scuttlebutt, reacting what they heard about in previews, and that's oh that lay lies madness.

The c the classic example when I was reviewing was Sunday in the Park with George it was it was I you you couldn't help but it was postponed two or three times the opening as they were working on it. Which meant obviously things weren't going well because you're the the gate kept changing. Uh but I didn't but I hadn't seen a workshop. I didn't know anything about it uh beyond uh that it was about George Seurat. And um when I went to see it, usually when critics go to a press performance, it's completely um uh uh full of sycophants and friends and investors and family over responding to even you know, everything gets huge standing ovation and and is is wonderful. Because they've had to postpone the opening so many times, they didn't con they weren't able th uh the one of the critics' nights that one I attended fell into what had been previously so uh uh sold theater parties.

They didn't have that kind of control over the house. And the audience um didn't like it. And in fact there were lots of walkouts. Um and I I love the show. I was very moved by it, and I I didn't let that influence me any more than I would have let all the gossip I'd learn after it opened about what was going on in previews influenced me. But I'm telling you, a lot of critics who panned it, and most did, uh, including Variety, for instance, uh had heard all the gossip, had been influenced by apparently negative response in previews, and and it I think it I the show's become a classic thing since, and I think what uh the fact that everyone was absorbing all the scuttlebutt and the and whatever was messed up in the show and previews, um uh it colored the reaction to the show.

They wanted to be uh, you know, sort of w where the news was rather than judging the show on its own merits. And the critic is is not a pulster. That's why I also feel never report audience response, because whatever it is, good, bad or indifferent, it's gonna be bogus.

[27:59] Robert W. Schneider: Um when you were writing a review, did you have a certain structure that you would follow in the composition of the review?

[28:06] FRANK RICH: Not really. I mean, I think I I think anyone would say you or most critics who take it seriously would say writing pieces, you probably want to lead with the strength of the production. Even if it's not great, like not a great show, you want to start by talking about what's good. Uh uh and we'll say that most things you review are mixed. They're not great or terrible. Uh but on the other hand, if something is really great or really awful, you probably begin with a feeling and an overall picture expressing that emotion. Um one of uh one of the things we like to do on our show is celebrate artists that are no longer with us. And um one of them you knew very well and I would love to hear some memories or thoughts about Wendy Wasserstein, FRANK.

[28:52] FRANK RICH: Well Wendy Wendy was someone that I loved. I met her before I was a drama critic and I never reviewed her. Right. She was one of two friends that I had that were off I I assigned other critics to review. And and um she uh what can I say she was one of my best friends she was someone who often went with me to see plays she went with me to and never asked what the show was she's the one I was murders with. Uh uh and she was a funny warm uh person as her her public persona was pretty much who she was lovely generous generous to people um uh young people coming up in the theater generous to her colleagues devoted to the theater how'd you get to know her in the first place?

[29:46] FRANK RICH: I think I'm pretty sure I met her I've often wondered that. I'm I I'm pretty sure I met her through Andre Bishop. Just to explain Andre was someone I went to Harvard with. He was a not a close friend but but an acquaintance um who was a year ahead of me and was uh peripherally involved a in in the Harvard Theater and would grow up to be a producer of course now is for some years run Lincoln Center. Right. But at the very beginning of his career he ran Playwright's Horizons. And uh Wendy's one of Wendy's first plays, not her first, but an early play was produced there and I and I I think it was even before I was a drama critic and I went to the opening night I think 'cause Andre must have invited me and I think that's how I met her.

And um but I'm not quite sure. But we had other uh also she wrote sometimes with Christopher Drang who had also been at Harvard with me whom I I didn't know well but but it's just a s something in the late seventies that's just sort of a a a bit foggy. Um but you know she rem you know it's been a number of years now since her tragic death um but she you know I still very I still very much feel very much surrounded by her aura and for one thing she had she had nephews um and a niece uh her brother Bruce's children who were contemporaneous with my kids and went to school with them and I would see them through that context uh uh as well. And one of them, Ben Wasserstein is actually an executive at HBO who a couple of years ago started being working on on Veeep from the HBO side, and her her last assistant uh as it happened, her last assistant at the time of her death, who literally was as much caregiver as assistant, right up until her last opening, a play called Third at the Metching New House, which was the last time I saw was the opening of that play, saw her alive.

Um her assistant um was a young guy just out of yellow named Jeremy Strong, who's actually a star uh by coincidence, but star of um became an actor and as a star of uh Succession, a television show, I produced. Yes. A brilliant young actor. Wow. And I hadn't seen him until we cast him, and at first I wasn't even sure it was the same person because I remembered him mainly as this kid, Jeremy, not with a last name. Yeah. And so anyway, um yeah, so uh she's very much around uh around me. And actually her niece, uh Pam Wasserstein, is the s is the CEO of New York magazine, so right.

[32:42] Robert W. Schneider: Wow. Thank you for sharing that, Rich.

[32:45] FRANK RICH: Thank you.

[32:45] Robert W. Schneider: Keep it in that circle. That's marvelous. What was the most surreal experience that you had while being a critic at the New York Times?

[32:53] FRANK RICH: It seems like a very heady job to have.

[32:56] FRANK RICH: It is that it isn't. It is work. You know, it is it is work under deadline pressure, and a lot of it can be very, you know, it was exhausting. Basically if you're doing it's a high of the season doing four shows a week and you know, writing on deadline, not the night of anymore by the time I did it, but still within twenty-four hours, and then going to the next play. I would say I would say I the most surreal, you know, were th were weird things that just happened. One was, of course the opening of Forty Second Street where really no one saw it coming that Merrick was going to announce Car Champion's death. Right on opening night. Um I've seen uh a uh uh there was a uh very unsuccessful play, I think it ran on one night maybe called Teaneck Tansi.

Yes. Um th that uh I'll never forget the critics performance I was at because Andy Kaufman, the comic, played a ki a kind of uh boxing promoter and it was an environmental setting on Broadway and when you arrived he was like roaming the the audience and making wisecracks and one of my older colleagues, uh drama critic colleagues, um having no idea who Andy Calvin was or that he was a comic provocateur, practically got into a fist fight with him before the show started.

[34:25] FRANK RICH: That was things like that you can't to tre treasure you'd see critics arrive drunk. You'd see people fall asleep. Oh my gosh, you know, so all those kinds of things made m but often it was not that roman you know um but people should understand in my day and now you don't go on opening nights and so it is it's not some clique like exciting experience. Forty Second Street was an exception because Merrick cancelled all the previews to force the critics to go opening night, but that was a very rare exception. Um and so it's you know, it's it's it is a job, an enjoyable job at its best, but it is um you know it's it's but it's it's a it's a job like any other in a way. It's just you're it's a it's a wonderful job if you if you love the theater, but it is surreal not not that often.

You know, and even you know the biggest even the biggest failures. Moose Moose Murders was an exception because literally someone covered in vomit was sitting in front of me and Wendy when I was reviewing it and we had to move our seats. Totally tragic and bizarre. Oh my goodness. Yeah but otherwise um you know it's it's it's it's a l it's it's work and I've recently been spending a fair amount of time in London on on Succession, going back and forth a bit um pre-production on it and as I walk through the West End I what I remember so vividly is in the days before you could file electronically going over to London and seeing you know ten plays in seven days filing reviews of them sometimes having to dictate those reviews and phone to New York to the Times in New York at weird hours from phone booths, it was hard.

That's why it was hard work. Tremendous it's nice to be a little bit more carefree and not have to see everything all right about it, you know so Yeah true. Ha you know you do so many things outside of the theater world now. You've got your uh you know working in a lot of television with Veep and you've uh the amazing political essays you do for New York magazine, which I love. But how how has being this sort of what we call quote unquote theater nut has that helped or informed your career now that it's not in musical theater.

[36:55] FRANK RICH: And how absolutely when people yes, I mean it first of all it informed my career as a political journalist because I think that growing up in Washington uh and I grew up in the city of Washington um beginning at around age nine, we moved from the Maryland suburbs into the city. Um I was vi and I went to public schools in DC. I was very as I was falling in love with the theater, I was extremely conscious of the fact that there was an on stage and backstage to Washington that there were all these glamorous sets, the Capitol, the White House uh uh you know, the the the Supreme Court, the National Archives, that were where tour buses of kids my age came and saw them, but they didn't see the other Washington that I saw uh living there as a as a native, which was a a a segregated city with with extremes of poverty, with people living in alleys, um, that would explode right after I graduated high school, you know, in the riots 1968.

And so I was very conscious it sort of informed my idea of politics, which was is that whatever's happening um in front of you is probably not what's actually happening. And the one book I wrote about politics, the greatest story ever sold was about essentially how the Bush administration s used showmanship and PR and and lying to sell the war in Iraq uh as a kind of show and it's very much and meanwhile what was really going on no weapons of mass destruction, no connection between Saddam Hussein and and 91 was in the shadows. And uh and indeed only after I wrote the book did I realize it was almost structured like a a Broadway musical and that the first act the first part of that book ends with Bush uh miss mission accomplished uh uh uh spectacle you know on the aircraft carrier and uh and the s part two of the book opens with that sort of quiet number but wait a minute where are the weapons of mass destruction?

[39:15] FRANK RICH: Um in terms of actual practical ability both to reviewing and then and then to being a producer in television, I learned everything uh from my days as a ticket taker in Washington. I had an education you could not get today because today shows particularly in the commercial theater, um they're heavier physically, they don't try out in this way. Changes cannot be put in quickly um uh over a short period of time visibly in front of an audience whereas what I could see was almost every two or three weeks, because that's how long the runs would be a show would come in. I could go repeatedly for free, so you know, and stand in the back as I did, uh to this day I sort of almost prefer standing in the back of a city mouse to watch a show.

Um and I would see the show come in and then I'd see people work on it and I I'd see changes go in every other night. And it was absolutely uh uh an incredible education because you'd see a classic example was um the odd couple. The odd couple opened to Washington, it was last stop before New York. It got great reviews in Washington, it was an immediate hit. Um but I saw I didn't know them, but I saw Neil Simon and Mike Nichols come in every night and continue to work on the show. And you know, they kept changing things. They kept at one point they kept they never could figure out what to do with the Pigeon Sisters in the second act. At one point uh they were not in the second act. Uh by the time it was ending in Washington they figured out the ending of the play where Felix would go and m move in with them.

But that literally was thrown in the last night. I saw uh Hello Dolly, which was also was an immediate hit in Washington. I saw uh American champion work on it and and take a number out that was a Davy Burns um production number, uh a penny in my pocket, which it turned up in another context pointlessly in my view in the new revival and replace it the last weekend with before the parade passes by when they didn't even have any costumes or sets built for it yet. I saw Jerry Robbins with Fiddler constantly tweak a show that also again was very strong and didn't you didn't think it needed fixing. It was a audiences loved it, the Washington critics loved it, but he put in Anna Tefka uh in Washington in place of a much uh a much lesser song.

He took one song away from one character who couldn't sing it and gave it to an actor who could, even if it was nonsensical. Uh uh took the song that Now I have everything was originally sung by uh uh Model. It was given to Bert Convi who could sing it as Perchuk and they got another they wrote Miracle of Miracles for uh the Pen Austin Pendleton could sing as as Model. They uh and and Robbins also called in the cast every non matinee they try to create a dance for the second act and never did. There's no choreography ex except for that little piece of Havela. Uh then I saw things like uh uh Mr President which was uh this was before I was a ticket taker but I went to see it repeatedly it was a huge sellout before it opened Kennedy went to the opening in Washington.

It was the co return of Irving Berlin for the first time in a decade after uh uh Call Me Madam and it was Josh Logan and Lindsay and Krause and it was inert and even as an eleven or twelve year old um I could see that but I watched these brilliant theater people come in every night and move things around and rewrite and try to change it to no avail. So all of that I am channeled in without question into my work you know uh in television. You know and trying to look at you know part of a producer's role is to look at what look at the scripts, look at scenes, look at cuts, what's working, what isn't working what can you contribute to this discussion that might make it better. What you know, w what can't be improved, what could be improved, what casting went astray, uh, all of that. Um I learned it all there. I learned it all as a teenager, basically.

[43:53] FRANK RICH: That's amazing. Yeah. Frank, thank you so much for spending so much time with us and on a personal note. I'm delighted to do it. Thanks again for your patience with me. And um uh thanks for doing this. I look forward not to hearing myself, but to hearing um hearing others. And very quickly on a personal note, I must say that um I was living in Los Angeles, and I was in high school when Ghost Light came out, and it really changed my life.

[44:18] FRANK RICH: Um, that's so kind of you. Yeah, well, no, it's it's so kind of you, and um, now that I teach, I make it required reading for my freshman class. I just want you to know your stories are continuing. Thank you. And thanks very much. Good luck to you, and thanks for doing this.

[44:34] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you, FRANK. Take care.

[44:36] FRANK RICH: You two.

[44:40] Robert W. Schneider: Today's episode was recorded at Shetler Studios on 244 West 54th Street. Visit Shetler Studios to book your room today, and you could be as cool as us.

[44:49] Robert W. Schneider: That's S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. And a big thanks to our sound editor Daniel Schwartzberg and social media manager Bethany and Solecki. And friends, don't forget we want more folks to hear these incredible stories, and that's where you guys can come in and help us out.

[45:05] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, in order for people to find out about us, we need lots of ratings on iTunes. The more ratings, the more they'll come up in search us. So head on over to iTunes, search for behind the curtain Broadway's Living Legends, click on our logo, click on ratings and reviews, then write a review and leave us five stars and make us feel as special as Eliza Doolittle on Eliza Doolittle Day.

[45:27] Robert W. Schneider: Or you can leave us one star and make us feel as bad as Annie did in that weird production in Boston where Annie dreamed about being adopted and then ended the show back in the orphanage. True story, Rob was there.

[45:40] Robert W. Schneider: I saw it. So head on over to iTunes and make us feel even more special than we already do.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred