Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#179 Summer Sale: SUSAN WATSON (Actress), JOHN SIMON (Critic), and CARLETON CARPENTER (MGM Actor)

Today is our Summer Sale here at Behind The Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends. Three for one! In this episode you will hear portions of interviews with three guests whose interviews we have not aired. When we decide not to air an interview it’s for many reasons... Read More

From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast

38 mins
7/1/19

About

Today is our Summer Sale here at Behind The Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends. Three for one! In this episode you will hear portions of interviews with three guests whose interviews we have not aired. When we decide not to air an interview it’s for many reasons. Either the audio quality was not strong enough, or the guest only wanted certain portions aired, but it is never because what the guest had to see was not interesting. Because of their importance to the evolution of the American musical we wanted to give you our favorite portions of their interviews. Up first is Susan Watson. Susan was the original Kim MacAfee in Bye Bye Birdie, Nanette in the 1971 revival of No No Nanette, and was in Ben Franklin in Paris, A Joyful Noise, and many others. We interviewed her over the phone from her home in Los Angeles. John Simon was one of the most controversial theater critics of the 20thCentury. His reviews were vicious, harsh, hysterical, and quite often took the performer’s physical attributes to task. His reviews got him kicked out of the New York Drama Critics Circle. Sylvia Miles dumped food on his head. And, if he gave you a negative review, you can quote it from memory. If you are a big MGM fan then the name of Carleton Carpenter must be familiar to you from the opening credits of such films as Father of the Bride, Three Little Words, Summer Stock, and Two Weeks With Love where, with Debbie Reynolds, he sang the infamous “Abba Daba Honeymoon.” Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Robert W. Schneider: Sit down, John.

[0:01] Kevin David Thomas: Sit down, John.

[0:03] Robert W. Schneider: For God's sake, John, sit down.

[0:05] Kevin David Thomas: Not so fast, John.

[0:06] Robert W. Schneider: I said that last night.

[0:07] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.

[0:08] Robert W. Schneider: No, John needs to show us how much he loves our podcast by heading over to Patreon.com to become one of our sponsors.

[0:14] Kevin David Thomas: How does one do that?

[0:16] Robert W. Schneider: Well, revolutionaries, head on over to Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com and search for Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends.

[0:23] Kevin David Thomas: Set up a monthly donation. Even a dollar a month helps us.

[0:26] Robert W. Schneider: Your contributions help us continue doing what we are doing and bringing these legends and stories to your ears.

[0:30] Kevin David Thomas: Okay, after I do that, can I shoot some fireworks into the night sky?

[0:34] Robert W. Schneider: It's daytime, Rob.

[0:35] Kevin David Thomas: Go back to your throne, King George.

[0:36] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my God.

[0:50] Kevin David Thomas: Hi all. We have a very special episode of Behind the Curtain for you today.

[0:55] Robert W. Schneider: This is our summer sale in which you will hear portions of interviews with three guests, whose interviews we have not aired.

[1:02] Kevin David Thomas: When we decide not to air an interview, it's for many reasons.

[1:05] Robert W. Schneider: Either the audio quality was not strong enough, or the guest only wanted certain portions aired.

[1:10] Kevin David Thomas: But it is never because what they had to say was not interesting.

[1:13] Robert W. Schneider: Because of their importance to the evolution of the American musical, we wanted to give you our favorite portions of their interviews.

[1:20] Kevin David Thomas: We give you three of those folks today.

[1:23] Robert W. Schneider: Up first is SUSAN WATSON.

[1:25] Kevin David Thomas: Susan was the original Kim MacAfee in Bye Bye Birdie.

[1:29] Robert W. Schneider: She was Nanette in the 1971 revival of No No Nanette.

[1:33] Kevin David Thomas: And it was in Ben Franklin in Paris, A Joyful Noise, and many, many others.

[1:37] Robert W. Schneider: We interviewed her over the phone from her home in Los Angeles.

[1:40] Kevin David Thomas: Here's a little portion of our time with SUSAN WATSON.

[1:49] SUSAN WATSON: We're gonna go all the way back. Growing up in Oklahoma, how did you discover musical theater?

[1:56] SUSAN WATSON: Uh well, it wasn't that hard. Uh my family was pretty musical and uh my dad played piano and we all were, you know, grew up in having music around us at all times. But then when I was fourteen my family took us to New York City and we saw the musical Oklahoma and I decided I wanted to sing and dance and be on Broadway. So that's what I'm where I taught the love of music and started singing and dancing classes in Tulsa. Summer stock job at Kansas City Starlight Theater and in the chorus first. And when I was nineteen at Juilliard School of Music in New York City, majoring in voice.

[2:49] Kevin David Thomas: Did you enjoy going to the movies when you were growing up in Oklahoma?

[2:53] SUSAN WATSON: Well, yeah. I did. Yes, I think out there it's well Oklahoma, but you saw all of 'em. Yeah. Yeah, and the musical ones especially.

[3:03] Kevin David Thomas: Were your mom and dad supportive of you going into the arts?

[3:09] SUSAN WATSON: Yes. Yes. I have to tell you, my father was in the oil business, but when he came home he played piano every night and was a musician. So it wasn't that bad at all. They really wanted me to do the music thing. And then were they were Oh good. And my mom was a dancer and not on stage or anything, but she danced and then she also taught dancing in Colorado where she was living.

[3:47] Kevin David Thomas: When you went from taking classes to actually being a performer, they were still supportive of you making this your living.

[3:57] SUSAN WATSON: Yes, absolutely.

[3:59] Kevin David Thomas: Wow, they were very hand they liked it. Were you nervous about moving to New York City from Oklahoma?

[4:07] SUSAN WATSON: Oh no. Oh my gosh. I couldn't wait to get catched. Um did you move by yourself or did you have friends go with you or did you have friends waiting for you in New York?

[4:19] SUSAN WATSON: Hmm. Well yes, I had a few friends who were in the business and I came to study first. Uh Juilliard, yeah. Yeah, Juilliard. That that's what got me here. But I already had been dancing and singing and learning all about that kind of thing to do. So it was Patricia Dowling was a friend of mine and she came too, so we both were there as young ladies.

[4:51] Kevin David Thomas: And so would you sneak off to auditions while you were studying at Juilliard?

[4:57] SUSAN WATSON: Yeah, that's right. And so I never at twenty years old, I um thinking here. Um oh I made an open audition in New York for the London company of West Side Story.

[5:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[5:16] SUSAN WATSON: And I got the job. And I it was understudying, you know, the Maria.

[5:22] Kevin David Thomas: I also read somewhere that when you finished West Side Story, you stopped over in Paris. And then that's sort of how I read that something like that's how you kind of first got connected with Tom Jones.

[5:32] SUSAN WATSON: Yes, Tom and Harvey. I guess they were there. Tom Jones was there, right. Uh his girlfriend we knew and that's how that connection happened. Uh and that was wonderful. When I returned I sang with Backers Auditions and for the Fantasticks and I expected to play the leading role of Louisa. But you know what? William Morris, I had the agent uh the William Morris agent with me, luckily, uh signed me and they got me Bye Bye Birdie Audition.

[6:10] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[6:11] SUSAN WATSON: So I got the show. I was in it, but Gower Champion cast me as Kim MacAfee and my go-to auditioning song was Pick Yourself Up by Kern and Field. Yeah. Nothing's impossible. I have fun, you know. Yeah. And that was great fun that and Tom and Harvey were gracious and they were so nice and then I took the Bertie job and Rita Gardner made the role her own as I left the Sullivan Street Theater to do that. Yeah to get to Bye Bye Birdie. My ingenue image was born. I stayed with me. I was twenty-three years old of course. But I guess I didn't look that.

[7:02] Kevin David Thomas: What's it like being directed by Gower Champion?

[7:06] SUSAN WATSON: Wonderful. Um Gower was he was he was I thought he was a very very good director. But it was he was a little scary 'cause he really wanted you to do it his way. Right. And you know what I mean?

[7:24] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah.

[7:25] SUSAN WATSON: Yeah. We've heard a lot about him. I yes, right. But I must admit that he was not that angry at me, so I watched maybe it got different with others, but I just did my thing and he liked it.

[7:47] Kevin David Thomas: That's fantastic. Um and then we love Paul Lynde. What was it like sharing a stage with Paul Lynde?

[7:53] SUSAN WATSON: Oh, he's so fun. He was nice to me. I must admit that was a g the we had Dick Van Dyke, we had Chi Rivera, we had Paul Lynde, we had Michael Paul, we had oh, just everybody and I love them all. They were really and I learned a lot. Mary Jane Marikle was my mother on the stage and in Bertie and she was just lovely. She took me under her wing. So from number ten bus every night, we would go and acting on the shade, the Berghoff studios to the fashionable practice of seaweed and massages and everything.

[8:34] Kevin David Thomas: What are some of the lessons you took away?

[8:37] SUSAN WATSON: Yeah, I would say work very hard. Yeah. And practice. Yeah. And be ready to do it. You know.

[8:47] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, that's great. Do you have any memories of working with Robert Preston and Ben Franklin in Paris?

[8:54] SUSAN WATSON: Yeah, we were really uh company was really worried that the movie star Robert Preston was gonna be too hard to work with. Oh. But it turned out he was just wonderful, both on the stage and off. He was really dear. We had no problems with him at all.

[9:13] Kevin David Thomas: In nineteen ninety uh nineteen sixty-six, uh you did uh a musical that we don't talk about very much anymore, and yet it got you a Tony nomination and it starred John Wright as well. And this is A Joyful Noise. Uh Michael Bennett, the great Michael Bennett was the choreographer for this piece. And yet today it's sort of been I I don't want to say forgotten, but it's not remembered today the way that Bye Bye Birdie is remembered. Um, do you have any rec do you remember this show? I mean it was a pretty short run.

[9:45] SUSAN WATSON: Though the show only ran for twelve performances. Yeah. I loved working with my dear friends Karen Morrow and John Ray.

[9:53] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yes, we interviewed Karen Morrow.

[9:55] SUSAN WATSON: And I Oh, she's a f and made a new friend in the choreographer Michael Bennett, who was just getting started. I'm ready was the song I sang, uh, to Tony nomination. But I began to wonder if I'll ever get out of doing and you know, I wanted to move up to older ladies, not in but that was that but I am glad that I did it.

[10:23] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. We had a s a wonderful time. Would you tell us a little bit about what was this TV pilot with Ethel Merman?

[10:32] SUSAN WATSON: Yes, well yes, that that came along. It was a big surprise for me too, right? Because, you know, I remember her name and all of that. But it turned out to be really a nice thing because she was just so dear. I always thought of her as, you know, kind of strong and turned out that I was playing her mother. I mean, she was playing my mother in the show there. So we got together just fine.

[11:04] Kevin David Thomas: I was gonna say it was called Maggie Brown.

[11:07] SUSAN WATSON: Yes.

[11:08] Kevin David Thomas: And did you guys sing what was the number that you sang together on the show?

[11:12] SUSAN WATSON: Um I have in my notes that is it uh an admiration society you yes, you guys didn't belong to uh that yeah, that was the song.

[11:24] Kevin David Thomas: That's incredible. This has been so much fun. You know, thank you so so much for sharing your memories with us. And I have to tell you, on behalf of all of our listeners, you know, thank you so much for all the joy that you've given us over the years and all the joy that you continue to give us.

[11:41] SUSAN WATSON: I'm gonna cry.

[11:43] Kevin David Thomas: Um thank you. Yeah, you are you are so beloved by so many. So on behalf of us, thank you for all you have done.

[11:51] SUSAN WATSON: Okay.

[11:52] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, till next time, Susan. Take care. Enjoy that lovely weather out there.

[11:56] SUSAN WATSON: Okay, love you.

[11:57] Kevin David Thomas: Love you too. Take care.

[12:24] Robert W. Schneider: And if he gave you a negative review, you can quote it from memory. John came into our studios at 94 years old. Um and look back on his work as a critic and where he thinks the role of critics are going in the 21st century.

[12:39] Robert W. Schneider: Here's a portion of our time with JOHN SIMON.

[12:47] JOHN SIMON: When do you find yourself writing? Are you a morning writer, an evening writer? Whenever things have changed in my life. At this stage, I spend my mornings reading the Times, which I didn't used to do in my younger days quite so. I used to read reviews, but that was it. But now I have the whole paper in front of me, and I managed to spend several hours. Not that I read everything, but I'm a slow reader, always have been. So I'm with that. And if I write, I start writing in the afternoon usually. And sometimes all the way into the evening, too. Or even the night sometimes. But the time as such doesn't bother me. I don't think my God, it's too early or it's too late. I started writing poetry as a very small child. Oh. In German, no less. And then over the years I have published poetry and some not much, but some. And I like poetry very much, and I'm still very much involved with it.

[13:56] Robert W. Schneider: In totality, John, how many years were you on the campus of Harvard University?

[14:02] JOHN SIMON: Well, quite a bit, you know. Uh because with if you're in graduate school, every year is marked as 1G, 2G, three G. So I think I was a thirteen G by the time.

[14:14] Robert W. Schneider: You uh you liked school, I want to say.

[14:16] JOHN SIMON: Yeah, pretty much. Uh I was I was I was an assistant to various, not to various, but to a couple of professors. Yeah. Uh one of them was Archibald McLeish, and I was his assistant on a poetry course. And the other one was a Canadian, Eric Havelock, who was a classicist, and I was a section man in one of his courses. And I was also a section man in, I guess something else, I forget. But in the yeah, oh yes, uh, that was Harry Levin's course with whom I became very friendly. Except when I had a falling out with Hellman, whom he adored, then I became a bad boy. I had to apologize for what she did to me. Oh, but I got home on that eventually. Anyway, so that was Harry Levin. He was my tutor. But uh I got involved somewhat with the Harvard Dramatic Club.

[15:23] Robert W. Schneider: Did you enjoy being on stage?

[15:25] JOHN SIMON: Yeah. Uh the thing that was interesting is when I was the old Jew, I had a a closing monologue, a closing free verse or blank verse, I forget which it was anymore. Uh gosh. Um, this was at the little theater there in Harvard Square. And at the last moment in the play, the old Jew gets a long and somewhat boring monologue, uh, which I had to deliver. And the lighting person by mistake cut off the light, just as I went into my big speech. And of course, the people in the theater became very upset and nervous and insecure. But apparently, according to the director, I did such a good job that they didn't stir, they didn't panic, they didn't run for the exit. So that but then on other nights when the light wasn't cut, I wasn't all that good.

[16:29] Robert W. Schneider: And then when did you develop your sense of wanting to become a critic? When did you want to start putting to paper your observations?

[16:37] JOHN SIMON: Well, I somehow thought that the transition from writing papers in graduate school to writing criticism in a publication wasn't such a big deal. When you were writing um criticism for academic publications, did you then, when you switched over to more commercial ventures, did you have to switch your writing style in any way?

[16:58] JOHN SIMON: No, I I said I always thought I was I, and whoever wanted it and liked it should want it and like it, and whoever didn't shouldn't. And so I was always I was never aware that I was aiming my criticism at this kind of reader or that kind of reader.

[17:14] Robert W. Schneider: Or were you a film critic first and then I went to theater? I'm curious about the trajectory of that journey.

[17:19] JOHN SIMON: It had to do with Bob Brewstein. Oh, yeah. Anyway, there, there we were at a party, both Bob Roostein and I. And he had been the theater critic for for the Hudson Review, but he was now promoted to the New Republic. So the Hudson Review became open, and he suggested, or I suggested that I should try out for it, and I did, and that was my first critical job.

[17:48] Robert W. Schneider: One of the controversial things about your criticism is that quite often you would refer to a performer's physical appearance. So the first question for you is Is there anything that should be off limits in writing a review?

[18:00] JOHN SIMON: Well, I I don't know. I mean, I think I think if you wrote something inoffensive language like this fucker has got to go. I I have to change my writing style then. Or uh I don't give a shit about so and so that kind of thing one avoids uh and should. But other things I think are open and free and available. But on the whole, I've had some very nice relationships with some actors and and actresses, not very many, but I never had the feeling that because you're a critic, you must never be friends with an actor. Uh you had to be reasonable. I mean, if he if that actor, much as you liked him, did poorly, you had to say it. And in some cases, I I lost I lost my I lost Max Shell that way because I liked a movie that he directed very much and wrote about it, but then another movie that uh that Mr. Shell directed, I didn't like, and then he sort of cut me off completely. That kind of thing happened very rarely, but it did happen, I guess.

[19:14] Robert W. Schneider: When you were starting your career as a critic, which critics did you most admire?

[19:18] JOHN SIMON: Well, we were all I got to be very friendly with Dwight McDonald, and in fact, he wrote the introduction to my first book, which was a funny kind of introduction because it was more like a review than an introduction. It was a fairly favorable review, but with some funny objections, which usually don't go into introduction. But anyway, we liked each other and we and we thought very much the same. In fact, the only major disagreement we had was that he loved Fellini's eight and a half, and I didn't. But I guess he was right. Looking back, I think he was right and I was wrong. Bob Roostin and I got along very good, very well and sort of liked each other's stuff. Stanley Kaufman and I were fairly friendly.

But he got some he got some expensive books about theater from Germany, which he didn't really want. And he couldn't think of anyone else to who might want to buy them except me. So he invited me over to dinner, which he didn't usually do, and he showed me these books and offered them for me to buy.

[20:43] Robert W. Schneider: But he still said he said he liked my pieces in the new criterion very much.

[20:48] Robert W. Schneider: If I'm if you don't mind my asking, is there anything that you've seen recently that you've really enjoyed?

[20:52] JOHN SIMON: Or well, I don't want to see a lot of off-Broadway stuff I don't see because this television show that we do uh uh corner table, uh, which is with a young fellow who used to be a student of my wife, and we have this show in which we discuss plays, but on they only want us to do Broadway, which is wrong because much better things appear afterwards. Yes, yes, but there it is. Um my wife has tried to talk them into doing off-Broadway as well, but so far unsuccessfully. Uh I guess the two last shows that I liked very much of the musical comedy variety were the band's visit, which I'm truly very, very fond of. Yes. Um and that wonderful woman. Oh, Katrina Link. Oh my god. Right, right. Yes. Yes, she's something. I was telling Billy just the way she drops a shoe at one moment has style to it. Uh but of course it's her looks as much as her style. Yeah. Uh and the other thing is the prom, which I like quite a bit.

[22:04] Robert W. Schneider: Okay, that's good. We saw the prom and really liked it as well.

[22:08] JOHN SIMON: That's nice. Yes, yeah, it's very funny. And that's the guy, Brooks Ashnaskas is unbelievable. I mean, without him, it would be only so so.

[22:15] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, yeah. But he makes it extraordinary.

[22:18] Robert W. Schneider: How soon after you see a performance or a film do you then start writing the review? Do you give yourself gestation time or I mean I I I'm always doing it on the basis of the one the one time I see it.

[22:39] JOHN SIMON: Was Persona, the movie by Ingmar Bergman. Oh, yeah, about whom I've written a book. And do you like to write your review immediately after seeing it, or do you like to take a couple of days to think about it?

[22:52] JOHN SIMON: It yeah, I can do it either way. I mean, I I don't feel that I should write write it the very same night or the very next day. But sometimes I do feel like that, and then I do it. But more often I let some time go by. Not a lot of time, but some.

[23:09] Robert W. Schneider: What were some of the most memorable experiences that you've had inside of a theater? Positive or negative.

[23:15] JOHN SIMON: Well, it's interesting. One of my favorite shows of all time has become, it wasn't in the beginning, Follies. I think that's one of the greatest musicals there is. But that all happened when I saw it again at the paper mill. And that was a good production, but it didn't make it to New York because the stupid wife of the Goldman wouldn't grant it unless some other thing of his would be also put on, which nobody wanted to put on. But anyway, I just sat there, I remember in the audience, and these numbers came at me. There was never one less good than better even than the next. Oh, yes. I like that a lot. I love a lot of Shakespeare plays a lot, and I've reviewed them as often as I could. I even like one of the less popular ones. Uh I think Coriolanus is wonderful.

[24:31] Robert W. Schneider: What do you think makes a good critic, a good critic?

[24:34] JOHN SIMON: A good critic? Well, it's this thing. There are several elements involved. First of all, he has to be, he or she has to be a good writer, because you have to read this person. And the reading you want to read a good writer rather than a not good one. So a good writer is the first thing. The second thing is uh a genuine passion for the thing. I mean, a love, a passion, uh deep involvement with the thing. Theater, movies, ballet, whatever it is, literature.

[25:07] JOHN SIMON: I do a lot of book reviewing. Uh that would be the second thing. The third thing would be uh not to get involved with esoteric, crazy schools like structuralism and semiotics and god knows what else. Uh I guess to write what you really believe, not what you think your editor wants or your reader wants, or anybody else wants. It's got to be you, totally and strictly you. And uh the nest takes care of itself.

[25:44] Robert W. Schneider: John, thank you so much for coming in today. This has been such a fantastic experience.

[25:49] JOHN SIMON: It's nice to do. I thank you for having me.

[25:52] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, our pleasure. Uh, check out John's blog and go back and read those books because they're really wonderful works of criticism.

[26:00] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, really special.

[26:01] Robert W. Schneider: Till next time. Bye, everybody.

[26:10] Kevin David Thomas: Hey, podcast listeners. Are you looking for a place to rehearse in New York City that is clean, spacious, and most importantly, affordable? Come check out Shetler Studios and Theatres, our wonderful host for these podcasts. Shetler is centrally located on West 54th Street between Broadway and Eighth Avenue, right in the heart of the theater district. Right in the heart, you'll find music, dance, and acting studios complemented by two black box theaters and six presentation venues. The professional facilities, inspired environment, and expert industry staff combined to provide the New York artist with an unparalleled studio experience. Visit their website at Shetler Studios.com. That's S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. Shetler Studios and Theatres is our home for recording the legends of Broadway, and we hope that you make it your artistic home too. That's Shetler, S H E T L E R Studios.com. See you here.

[27:08] Robert W. Schneider: If you're a big MGM musical fan, then the name of CARLETON CARPENTER must be familiar to you from the opening credits of such films as Father of the Bride, Three Little Words, Summer Stock, and Two Weeks with Love, where, with Debbie Reynolds, he sang the infamous "Abba Daba Honeymoon." Uh, we spoke with Carleton uh over the phone. He's in upstate New York and had so many great and wonderful things to share. Unfortunately, um, he was calling on a landline, and the connection was not the best, but we tried to salvage whatever we could. Um he was such a wonderful, charming performer and is still with us today and is still doing a lot of cool stuff up in upstate New York. So, to talk about his time in the movie musicals of yesteryear, here is our interview with CARLETON CARPENTER.

[27:57] CARLETON CARPENTER: After the war, you came to New York and you met John Murray Anderson, and you did Three to Make Ready with Ray Bolger. Do you remember this?

[28:05] JOHN SIMON: Oh, yeah, got that ran for three years.

[28:09] CARLETON CARPENTER: Yeah. No, that was a long run. Well, no, that was smart. And that's when I I I but I came when we were doing Treaty Make Ready, I I came uh uh up uh I would come up to uh uh to visit the somebody out on uh up here where I am now. And um I know I didn't move up here until uh in the uh seventies at some point. But um but I had the friends, you know, that were and and and I would come up and uh on the weekend and stuff like that and spend time from and I got to love it up there. So then eventually when I uh could move out but I worked all the time in New York 'cause not only were it was it was like stealing for uh for uh well the radio that I did and stuff, it was wonderful. You just go from place to place and then call up uh uh you had special uh whatever the name of it was, I can't remember now.

And you did you call up and they tell you where you're where their next uh uh thing was that day. And then you'd go over and then you'd have uh do a big thing of of uh you know, that was really like stealing. Go in and read a script and and uh and paid and that's it. And then when you then go and get another one and you know, it's it's it's just constant work all the time, which I adored.

[29:35] JOHN SIMON: What was uh John Murray Anderson like?

[29:37] CARLETON CARPENTER: Why how I think he was and he was the brother and he always he had kinda I was it's uh like a like a favorite. So uh yeah, I gotta sing a room in the house now, you know, when he's got got his microphone uh up to his his lips 'cause you're always just screaming at me all the time. But about every show we were doing and he would have me plucked up on the on the stage and at some point I remember the w one thing we were I think we were rehearsing through the night ready. And we were in a in a you know, an empty theater rehearsing. Um not the th not the theater we were gonna be playing in. But anyway that was in uh I was just standing there with uh in the up toward the uh back wall of the the theater.

Yeah, I mean it's got the got the the kids there were the eight dancers who were there were working on the thing in the front and I'm standing there in the back uh loud and in the thing just standing there and if I moved at all or anything, Murray would be screaming on his stuff and I said, Mask up, you moved and just stand right there what you're doing. And then at one point he he screamed out at me, he said, Now turn and face the the wall right in back of you And like an idiot I said, Why? And he said, Because you're wearing a very extensive outfit to this point and I want him to see the back end of it. The other side of it. Okay.

[31:09] JOHN SIMON: How did you get out to California and how did you get into the movies?

[31:14] CARLETON CARPENTER: Well, I never wanted to go to the movies. Uh that was it that was it. I got I had uh offers from uh from I think four uh movie places. And it was uh uh I I I turned them all down 'Cause I said I I didn't want to do a movie. I said I lo I loved going to the movies. I I that I liked. But I didn't care anything about uh being a um movie actor. I loved the stage. I was just nuts about New York and and uh the and then I went from job to job in New York all the time. You know, I could work around the clock. My god if they it some sometimes I would go in there at uh uh a place at at uh in in the noon hour, remember we were broke or something or other and I'd go into one of those places where they had had a the piano up on the bar or there were a lot of them those were long on about ninth Avenue and stuff in places over there in New York. And I'd go in and get jump up there behind the thing and and earn money, you know, that during my my lunch hour. And I think I just loved to work all the time. It was great fun.

[32:30] JOHN SIMON: Now I ha I have to ask you, what was it like working on Summer Stock with Judy Garland?

[32:37] CARLETON CARPENTER: Oh, I loved her uh summer stock was one of the not not for he it was Kelly was mean to me. Uh why I don't know. But I he said that, you know, I he said I saw your show in New York and he d had seen that the thing that was had been kept me from being in the circus because it ran too long. And uh then I ended up there in in the show with with uh that he was the star of and it was Judy's comeback show and she was wonderful to me. And I was supposed to be doing all of all the uh uh the piano s stuff for for second but he would jump in you know and uh he did anything he could to keep me off camera, which was so strange. I couldn't g understand why he would do that. Anyway, it was was was weird with him because she was all over me.

She was just wonderful to me. And I wrote I had written a song for her and then when when the kids when we were doing that show there were like uh there were kids under contract for uh what two months or three months whatever but uh set amount of time. Um and so there was a party with them and then I I uh which I threw for one of the the uh for the all the kids.

[34:00] JOHN SIMON: What was it like working with Fred Astaire?

[34:02] CARLETON CARPENTER: But uh Stare was marvelous. And and certainly I I just like the opposite direction from Kelly. He was interested in anything I was doing and it was it was he w you know it was nice to me.

[34:14] JOHN SIMON: Did you like working at MGM? Did you like working for them?

[34:16] CARLETON CARPENTER: Oh yeah, like it I like living with with them. I'd like all all of the the the people there were were terrific.

[34:28] JOHN SIMON: Do you remember doing uh Lady in the Dark with with Anne Southern?

[34:33] CARLETON CARPENTER: She I was doing the part that Danny Kay had done originally. Yeah. He had left when that's when I went down that's when I went my the gal that I was in in love with that's the lady who lived up the road her one of her kids. That was yeah when she was there. 'Cause then I went down she w when the that was the the show I saw when the first time I was took went down to New York to see everything. And she had uh put me up at the hotel of it on the uh street where she lived and and for for for two days. And then then uh you know, then the next time I was in New York was uh when I went down and got the got the show. You know, just not knowing any better.

[35:22] JOHN SIMON: And how was touring Vietnam with Hello Dolly? I mean, that seems like it doesn't belong together.

[35:29] CARLETON CARPENTER: Yeah, you know, it was uh uh was it was regular stuff. We didn't do a different the show any differently. It was just the uh audiences were for mainly uh troops.

[35:46] JOHN SIMON: What was it like to be on stage with Mary Martin?

[35:49] CARLETON CARPENTER: Uh I did tons of stuff with her. She was wonderful. She was wonderful to work with. And then before this you did Hotel Paradiso with uh Bert Law, Angela Lansbury.

[36:01] CARLETON CARPENTER: That was wonderful show. Yeah. Yeah. That was her that was her first uh uh that was Angela's first show in New York.

[36:09] JOHN SIMON: Oh.

[36:11] CARLETON CARPENTER: That they treated her rather badly at MGM and kept her from from uh moving on and getting her because her parents were both actors. And then I maybe that was part of it, you know, and they did but uh she could have uh moved on to greater glory before she kinda had a chance to.

[36:32] JOHN SIMON: Yeah, right.

[36:34] CARLETON CARPENTER: But that she you know, was she playing that snotty little lady in in the in that at that point in in new uh in that show in the out there in what was that? Gaslight.

[36:46] JOHN SIMON: Gaslight.

[36:47] CARLETON CARPENTER: Gaslight it was.

[36:49] Robert W. Schneider: Carlton, this has been so much fun. Thank you so much for spending time with us today.

[36:54] CARLETON CARPENTER: All right.

[37:02] Kevin David Thomas: We hope you all enjoyed that. Um, and as you know, uh our wonderful co-host Kevin David Thomas uh is now the proud father of a healthy bouncing baby boy, and we cannot wait to get him back on the air and talk about all the wonderful things that he's been doing. Uh always follow us on our Instagram, always take a look at what's going on on our Facebook and Twitter. We thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you all next week. Take care. Bye-bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred