"All I did was make a few phone calls." Agent/actor extraordinaire Richard Seff might say humbly but here are some of the results he got from picking up the phone: Jerry Herman composing Hello, Dolly, John Kander working with Fred Ebb, and Hal Prince directing his first show... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Featured Shows
About
"All I did was make a few phone calls." Agent/actor extraordinaire Richard Seff might say humbly but here are some of the results he got from picking up the phone: Jerry Herman composing Hello, Dolly, John Kander working with Fred Ebb, and Hal Prince directing his first show.
Richard pulls back the curtain on his career to discuss how he became Julie Andrews' tour guide, what it was like at the out of town tryouts for My Fair Lady, and why you should always be reinventing yourself!
Also, Richard shines the spotlight on Bob Fosse, Gwen Verdon, and Rex Harrison!
Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Kevin David Thomas: What are you thankful for this month of November?
[0:02] Robert W. Schneider: Well, Rob, I'm thankful that we have so many great Behind the Curtain listeners, and that so many of them financially support us so we can continue to capture the stories of Broadway's most legendary performers.
[0:12] Robert W. Schneider: And support my Herve Villages habits.
[0:14] Kevin David Thomas: I'm not gonna do it.
[0:15] Robert W. Schneider: I won't do it.
[0:16] Kevin David Thomas: Want to help us?
[0:17] Robert W. Schneider: I'm just kidding.
[0:18] Kevin David Thomas: Want to help us be even more thankful this November?
[0:20] Robert W. Schneider: Head over and head on over.
[0:22] Kevin David Thomas: I've had too much cranberry sauce.
[0:24] Robert W. Schneider: Head on over to Patreon.com.
[0:26] Robert W. Schneider: That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N dot com and search for Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends and set a monthly donation.
[0:34] Robert W. Schneider: Even a dollar a month helps us.
[0:35] Robert W. Schneider: We are entirely self-funded.
[0:37] Robert W. Schneider: So please help keep us on the air.
[0:39] Kevin David Thomas: I feel like PBS.
[0:40] Robert W. Schneider: Your contributions help us continue doing what we are doing.
[0:43] Kevin David Thomas: Here is a tote bag.
[0:44] Robert W. Schneider: Uh, what are we doing this November, Rob?
[0:46] Kevin David Thomas: Why being thankful that we can interview legends, eating stuffing, and singing Turkey Lurky Time.
[0:51] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, I know it's a Christmas song, but it's about Turkey.
[0:54] Kevin David Thomas: Go lay down, Rob.
[0:56] Robert W. Schneider: We are thankful for all of you, and we will be even more thankful if you can head over to Patreon.com.
[1:01] Robert W. Schneider: That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N dot com.
[1:04] Robert W. Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.
[1:05] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[1:06] Robert W. Schneider: And this is Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:09] Kevin David Thomas: Don't forget to follow us on Twitter at Broadway Curtain.
[1:12] Robert W. Schneider: And make sure to join our Facebook page at Behind the Curtain Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:16] Kevin David Thomas: And follow us on Instagram at Broadway Curtain Podcast Plus.
[1:19] Robert W. Schneider: You can always listen to our podcasts on Broadway World and the Broadway Podcast Network.
[1:24] Robert W. Schneider: I do not think there is an aspect of the theatrical world that today's guest has not inhabited.
[1:28] Kevin David Thomas: This man wears 90 million different hats in his career.
[1:31] Robert W. Schneider: He has been an actor, a writer, an agent, a librettist, a production associate, an agent, a producer.
[1:39] Robert W. Schneider: The list goes on and on and on.
[1:41] Robert W. Schneider: His book, which I you all need to read, is called Supporting Player, My Life Upon the Wicked Stage, and it is a mesmerizing exploration of his 80-plus year journey in the arts.
[1:50] Robert W. Schneider: He had a front row seat to just about every era in musical theater history and the ear of the theatrical community's most influential artists.
[1:59] Robert W. Schneider: To tell us what it was like to work with such legends as George Abbott, Lerner and Lowe, Rex Harrison, Bob Fosse, Gwen Verdon, Ethel Merman, Hal Prince, Ron Field, Chita Rivera, Julie Andrews, and that's just scratching the surface, and so many more.
[2:11] Robert W. Schneider: Here's the agent to the stars, the one and only RICHARD SEFF.
[2:15] RICHARD SEFF: Wow, I don't know who he is.
[2:18] RICHARD SEFF: When you say my 80-year career, I was only 12 when I started.
[2:22] Kevin David Thomas: Exactly.
[2:23] RICHARD SEFF: I wasn't 20 or 30 or anything like that.
[2:27] RICHARD SEFF: And when I say 12, I wasn't really acting in there or doing anything except I saw my first play ever in my life at 12.
[2:36] Kevin David Thomas: At 12 years old. What play was it?
[2:38] RICHARD SEFF: It was a comedy by Clifford Goldsmith called What a Life.
[2:43] RICHARD SEFF: And George Abbott directed it.
[2:45] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[2:45] RICHARD SEFF: And someone my mother knew was a friend of somebody's who got us tickets.
[2:49] RICHARD SEFF: We'd never, I'd never been to the theater.
[2:51] RICHARD SEFF: And uh we see this thing, and I didn't know what a play was.
[2:55] RICHARD SEFF: And I was surprised to go into the Biltmore Theater, and um, unlike the movies, which I was already nuts about, there was no MGM Lion roaring at the beginning, and there was no trumpet blast from 20th Century Fox.
[3:09] RICHARD SEFF: The lights went down, the curtain went up, and suddenly I really felt I was in another sphere, another world.
[3:16] RICHARD SEFF: And the play happened to be about a high school boy, Henry Alrich, and his problems.
[3:21] RICHARD SEFF: And so I certainly identified with it, being a young person myself.
[3:25] RICHARD SEFF: And I said to myself, before I left the theater that afternoon, I really think I have to spend my life in a building like this.
[3:32] RICHARD SEFF: And I kind of have.
[3:34] Kevin David Thomas: That's incredible.
[3:35] RICHARD SEFF: And until it took all of them until I was 18, I guess, before I ever got paid to do it, but um those views were spent seeing all of those wonderful, wonderful plays and musicals, and many of them were, not all of them were in the 40s.
[3:51] RICHARD SEFF: And uh then I got my first equity card at in 1946, and so began this journey, which seems to be continuing now that I enter my eighth career, you know, in the theater.
[4:04] Kevin David Thomas: And what is your eighth career now for our lesson?
[4:07] RICHARD SEFF: I've been with the Art Critics Circle for almost 10 years now as a critic.
[4:11] RICHARD SEFF: And it's a joy for me because when I see a musical or a play, I do have one advantage over other critics in that I have been in all of those roles.
[4:21] RICHARD SEFF: I've been on both sides of the footlights.
[4:24] RICHARD SEFF: I know what it means to write a play, to write a musical.
[4:27] RICHARD SEFF: They'll or succeed, doesn't matter, is that you've done it.
[4:30] RICHARD SEFF: And I know what the author, nobody sits down to write a flop or a bad play, but they sometimes make a mistake.
[4:38] RICHARD SEFF: And so I bring to it, I don't want to be sentimental or or Pollyanna-ish about it.
[4:44] RICHARD SEFF: Some plays are very bad, but I always try to see what he was trying to say, the author, or what the actor was trying to do or to play, and did he succeed, or where did he not quite achieve what he hoped to achieve?
[4:58] RICHARD SEFF: But I think I'm one of those who doesn't know what he was trying to do, yeah, because I've done it myself.
[5:04] Kevin David Thomas: So you approach your reviews from that angle of trying to understand what they were attempting to understand.
[5:09] RICHARD SEFF: I think it's important for a theater uh a critic to love theater, and some of them seem that not to.
[5:13] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I quite agree.
[5:15] RICHARD SEFF: And some of them are very patronizing, superior, intellectually superior, and they may be, but the reader is not in the same league.
[5:23] RICHARD SEFF: And I have critics I really don't pay much attention to, some yeah, some I admire tremendously.
[5:29] RICHARD SEFF: Walter Kerr was a great critic.
[5:31] Kevin David Thomas: True, yeah.
[5:32] RICHARD SEFF: Because he loved the theater.
[5:33] RICHARD SEFF: He wasn't a uh a major playwright, and he wasn't an actor.
[5:37] RICHARD SEFF: But he understood what was going on up there.
[5:39] RICHARD SEFF: And boy, that's very useful.
[5:42] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[5:42] RICHARD SEFF: Constructive.
[5:43] RICHARD SEFF: Even when he disliked something, I think the people whom he disliked understood what he was saying.
[5:49] Kevin David Thomas: Absolutely.
[5:50] RICHARD SEFF: And responded to it.
[5:51] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[5:51] RICHARD SEFF: I've just finished reading Neil Simon's incredible memoir, which is very long and very detailed and very unself-serving.
[6:00] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[6:00] RICHARD SEFF: I was delighted to see how tough he is on himself.
[6:04] RICHARD SEFF: But he would be one of those who would quote a critic who didn't like a play of his, and he would try to understand what he had not achieved.
[6:13] RICHARD SEFF: That I think is terrific.
[6:15] RICHARD SEFF: That's maybe why he lasted so long.
[6:17] RICHARD SEFF: You just live with the hits and the flops, and you just try for the best you can do.
[6:22] RICHARD SEFF: And it's so interesting to think that, you know, back in the golden age of theater, quite often, if a show was out of town in Boston, the playwright or the writers would get together with the local critic over there and discuss the review and you know, try to figure out what was working, what wasn't working.
[6:35] RICHARD SEFF: That doesn't happen so much.
[6:37] RICHARD SEFF: Some of the old pros, the old really greats, the the Roger Rogers' and the Alan Lerners and what have you, those people began to respect certain critics.
[6:46] RICHARD SEFF: I I know I think it was Hal Prince, among others, who always wanted to go to Boston because Kevin Kelly, the critic in Boston, would tell him or tell the world what he thought was lacking.
[6:58] RICHARD SEFF: And very often he was more on the nose than the director was.
[7:01] Kevin David Thomas: It would be very useful.
[7:03] RICHARD SEFF: Yeah.
[7:03] RICHARD SEFF: On the other hand, there were times when uh uh someone as as talented and visionary as Hal was, would not listen to a critic.
[7:13] RICHARD SEFF: I remember when Cabaret opened out of town.
[7:17] RICHARD SEFF: It had very good reviews, but they didn't, as a general rule, like the performance that Jill Haworth was giving as Sally Bowles.
[7:25] RICHARD SEFF: And Prince was determined to keep her.
[7:28] RICHARD SEFF: They did see a few other girls while they were out of town, but he wanted what she offered.
[7:34] RICHARD SEFF: And she remained in it right through the opening and then the next year.
[7:38] RICHARD SEFF: The point is that because the one critic in New York didn't care for her work either.
[7:44] RICHARD SEFF: And because of that, I think the public coming to see it, because there were so many other good reviews that they did come to see it in droves, gave her the opposite reaction to, oh gee, she's not supposed to be so good.
[7:59] RICHARD SEFF: Because they thought she was much better than that critic did, she would get the biggest hand of the night, even over Joel Gray.
[8:05] Kevin David Thomas: It was so fascinating that they adopted her because she was very good in it.
[8:09] RICHARD SEFF: Yeah.
[8:10] RICHARD SEFF: But that just shows how those critics can be uh right or wrong.
[8:14] RICHARD SEFF: In some cases, I know Neil Simon's book tells you of the third act of the um play The Odd Couple.
[8:21] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.
[8:22] RICHARD SEFF: Which he didn't know why, but he knew something was wrong.
[8:26] RICHARD SEFF: It was going downhill.
[8:27] RICHARD SEFF: It worked right through the second act, but somehow it didn't build from there.
[8:31] RICHARD SEFF: He didn't know what to do with it.
[8:34] RICHARD SEFF: Well, I don't remember, you'll have to read the book because I've forgotten who it was who said to him, I think it was the director, Mike Nichols.
[8:34] RICHARD SEFF: I think it was Mike Nichols on that one.
[8:44] RICHARD SEFF: He did so many plays with him, it may have been uh Gene Sachs, but I think it was Mike Nichols, who said, You know what's missing?
[8:52] RICHARD SEFF: Those wonderful girls from Act Two, the Pigeon Sisters.
[8:56] RICHARD SEFF: This act needs them back.
[8:58] RICHARD SEFF: We miss them.
[8:59] RICHARD SEFF: And they put them in the third act.
[9:02] RICHARD SEFF: He wrote a new scene for them.
[9:04] RICHARD SEFF: And it went like gangbusters.
[9:06] Kevin David Thomas: So he didn't think of that.
[9:07] RICHARD SEFF: Were your parents supportive of you?
[9:09] RICHARD SEFF: You know, yes.
[9:10] RICHARD SEFF: Yes, in a word, yes.
[9:12] RICHARD SEFF: But my parents were not theater people.
[9:15] RICHARD SEFF: My father was a businessman, a small businessman, but he had a very nice small business, which supported us very pleasantly through the depression years.
[9:23] RICHARD SEFF: And my mother was just an interesting lady who loved to go to the theater, but we didn't have anybody in show business in my very large family.
[9:31] RICHARD SEFF: So I was kind of the odd one out.
[9:34] RICHARD SEFF: But they knew I loved it, so they were totally supportive in that they always saw everything I ever did, even from the time I was an amateur back in camp, you know, school plays, yeah.
[9:34] RICHARD SEFF: School plays.
[9:46] RICHARD SEFF: Um my father used to say, I don't understand what you like about it all, but you you know, if you do it, do it well.
[9:54] RICHARD SEFF: That was all.
[9:54] Kevin David Thomas: That was encouraging.
[9:55] RICHARD SEFF: That's good advice.
[9:56] RICHARD SEFF: You know, he didn't help, but he didn't hurt at all.
[9:58] RICHARD SEFF: And I didn't feel guilty about it.
[10:00] RICHARD SEFF: So I've never had second thoughts about going into something more sensible, if you want to call it that.
[10:06] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah.
[10:07] RICHARD SEFF: Yeah.
[10:08] RICHARD SEFF: Uh it's interesting though that I've ended up in so many aspects of it because I started out the way you should end up.
[10:16] RICHARD SEFF: I was really quite successful in the beginning.
[10:19] RICHARD SEFF: I was only um 21 or so by the time I got my first part on Broadway.
[10:26] RICHARD SEFF: It turned out to be a hit.
[10:27] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[10:28] RICHARD SEFF: Which was Darkness at Noon, with Claude Rains, whom I adored and respected.
[10:33] RICHARD SEFF: And I had a decent role, it wasn't large, but it was key.
[10:36] RICHARD SEFF: I had some nice reviews.
[10:38] RICHARD SEFF: It ran eight, nine months on Broadway.
[10:40] RICHARD SEFF: Then it closed for the summer and went on the road across the nation for nine months.
[10:46] RICHARD SEFF: And I was offered the role again, this time with Edward G. Robinson playing the starring role.
[10:51] RICHARD SEFF: So I was having a good beginning.
[10:53] RICHARD SEFF: I had two years of work, some recognition.
[10:56] RICHARD SEFF: I had an agent by the time it closed.
[10:59] RICHARD SEFF: But I had that next summer after I was finished with it totally.
[11:03] RICHARD SEFF: I thought to myself, you know, I've lost this, but I don't know that I love the life of it.
[11:08] RICHARD SEFF: The work I adore, but you can't work all the time.
[11:12] RICHARD SEFF: And in between, when you close, unless you get stardom, you begin again.
[11:17] RICHARD SEFF: What's next?
[11:19] RICHARD SEFF: You start auditioning all over again.
[11:21] RICHARD SEFF: I found that instability a little tough to take.
[11:25] RICHARD SEFF: So I thought, I've got to remain in the theater.
[11:27] RICHARD SEFF: I love it.
[11:28] RICHARD SEFF: But I don't have to act.
[11:30] RICHARD SEFF: So I look around and see what can be made available.
[11:33] RICHARD SEFF: And the one thing that came along after about eight months was a job with the talent agency run by Audrey Wood and Bill Liebling, her husband.
[11:42] RICHARD SEFF: So I started as a television agent.
[11:46] RICHARD SEFF: And I didn't want to work in television as much as I did in the theater, but it's in a way in.
[11:51] RICHARD SEFF: And I was working with all these theater people I knew to get them jobs in TV series.
[11:56] RICHARD SEFF: And I had a good year with them.
[11:59] RICHARD SEFF: But when they sold their agency after one year to MCA, an international dynasty of an agency.
[12:07] RICHARD SEFF: And then I'm suddenly in a company.
[12:09] RICHARD SEFF: They took me with them.
[12:10] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[12:10] RICHARD SEFF: But they couldn't place me where I was before.
[12:14] RICHARD SEFF: So I was stuck in an area called TV sales, which meant I was now taking cans of film of pilots to the ad agencies to see who'd buy a series.
[12:25] RICHARD SEFF: I didn't want to be in business.
[12:27] RICHARD SEFF: Salesman, basically.
[12:28] RICHARD SEFF: That had nothing to do with the artist.
[12:41] RICHARD SEFF: I said, I love this company and I'm very comfortable, but I don't like what I'm doing. I want to be in the theater. And he said, Well, be patient because these things do come up. There's nothing open now. Within months, David Hocker, who had the department of musical theater, needed an assistant. And I got the job. That changed everything because I loved what I was doing. And he would sign the stars, and then I would sort of help service them, as they said. But he was kind enough to say to me, in addition, I want you to have your own little list of people that you find from the beginning and build them. Oh wow. And that was wonderful because I could go to every black box theater in New York.
I could go to every off-off Broadway anywhere. I could go to colleges. In fact, one college was Princeton. And I went to see the Princeton show, which was just done by amateurs. And it's just delicious. It was written by a kid, 19 years old, whose name is Clark Gessner. So I went back and said, you know, if you ever decide to stick with this when you get out of school, I would love to represent you. He did. He wrote Charlie Brown, and my agency was established. Exactly. Ran for eight years. But the point is that uh that's how I would find talent. And one day I would go off off Broadway to see a little show that had no advanced sale and was playing in a little black box down three steps on East Fourth Street, called the Shoestring Review, which, you know, was just new new kids doing nothing on no money.
That's why they called it the Shoestring Review. And in this show is a girl called Be Arthur, who was 12 or something. And this little girl called Cheetah Rivera. At that time, she was called Cheetah O'Hara because she admired Maureen O'Hara, you know. And uh I couldn't get over her. She was so incredibly unique. That I went backstage, and I think backstage meant the toilet. Yeah. She was behind a curtain somewhere. And I said, You don't know me, and I don't know you really, but I love what you did tonight. And if you ever decide to have an agent, because she didn't have one, I would love to be it. Well, she nobody had ever asked her yet. So I got her. And I stayed with her for the next 20 years of my life when I was remained an agent.
And that's why I was grateful that I knew I I had to work in the theater. It didn't matter at what. I think if if someone had asked me to become a box office treasurer, I probably would have done it. Uh but that was the only job I could get in the beginning was this agency job. I hadn't thought of being an agent. You know, to an actor. No, and to an a to an actor, an agent is sort of the other side of the footlights. You don't pay much attention. But I'm wrong because some of the agents were very creative, some of them were just booking agents. They just wanted to get you a job, they didn't care about your career.
[15:37] RICHARD SEFF: What makes a successful actor-agent relationship, or what were some of the most fruitful ones? Well, there are two ways to go about it. I mean, there are very successful agents who simply are very good at finding you work, and they're not interested in your life story or your career, but just to keep people working. Yeah. And that's called a booking agent. But Bill Liebling was more like that. He didn't build relationships with actors, he just got them jobs. He would send them on the road for a year or two, and then commissions come piling in. But my favorite agents were those who, like Audrey Wood, would take on a client like Tennessee Williams before he was anyone, but recognize the talent and say, I'm going to make this happen with you.
And stay with them through their whole careers as a rule. And that's the kind of agent I wanted to be. I wanted to have 12 clients rather than 50. But I should really stay with them and try to create situations where they would be able to flourish. That was very satisfying, especially with someone like Cheetah. And there were others. There was Linda Lavin, who was beginning with a chorus job in a family affair. There were others of Phyllis Newman, who made her name mostly in television, but who was very good on stage as well in one at Tony for her first Broadway show. It takes more than talent. You have to have the guts and the drive and the ambition and the sticktuitiveness and the ability to be to take flops as part of the course.
They all had them. Yes. But uh there are always problems, even with shows as good as Gypsy. I remember with Dolly, Hello Dolly, which I also loved, and and was well, it's gonna sound awfully self-serving, but I can't help it. It's the way it happened. Jerry Herman was a lifelong friend of my partner, Leo Bookman. They were kids together. And so was Phyllis Newman. They were like three who wanted to come to New York and make it. And Jerry wrote when Jerry started writing for the theater, he had an agent at William Morris because Leo wasn't his friend Leo Bookman was not handling writers at all. He worked with movie people. So Jerry was with William Morris. But there came a time when he came to us and said his agent at William Morris had left.
And he was now working with her assistant. And that was, he had no relationship with that assistant. So now he would be available to come to us because I made it clear I wanted him. This is after Milk and Honey, but before Dolly. So he said, Well, look around and see what you can find for me. My contract with the Morris office is over, expires in December. And this was in October. So I start canvassing around town. And one night at poker, I played poker once a week. And he was new too. He'd done Carnival and he had done Birdie, but he hadn't become big, big, big yet. And he said, Well, I'm working on one called Hello Doll, based on the matchmaker. We don't have a composer for that. And Jerry Herman sounds like he might be someone I could work with.
They were contemporaries. So he met him and he liked him, and he suggested him to Merrick. And Merrick said, No, I've got to have a name for this. I don't want to, I can't, I don't take a chance. But Milk and Honey was fine, but it doesn't show me anything that I need for Dolly. It isn't funny, and it's, you know, whatever. But I'll tell you what, you can write some songs on spec if you want. Let me hear some stuff of yours for this. Jerry went home, and I swear to you, in one weekend, he wrote four songs for Dolly. One of them was actually the melody of a song he'd written for a musical that never got produced. That was called The Spirit of the Chase. And that was the title song in The Spirit of the Chase.
And it went bum bum bum bum bum bum. Note for note it became put on your Sunday clothes. And that's one of the four that he brought to Merrick on Monday. And he, I don't know what the other three were, I forgot. Could well have been Hello Dolly, the song itself. And he got the job. He called us from Merrick's office and said, I'm going to do this. So we brought champagne out and we celebrated our new client. And the day later, his lawyer, Bob Montgomery, called me to say I have the saddest news in the world. It's not Jerry's fault. He thought the contract with the Morris office ended in December. It ends a year from December. So he's committed to they represent him. You can handle him, but they have to be paid.
Well, what could we do? I mean, we'd only made one phone call, but still it's the phone call that changed his life, you know. So what Jerry did, believe it or not, was he said to Bob Montgomery, look, they got me the job. I want to pay them anyway. And pay the women Morris office too, 10% to each, right? And we couldn't do that. I mean, not for one phone call. As much as we needed it in our little business, we said we'd be very grateful for half of that. So for the next eight years, we got half the commission. And Morris never knew it. They'd know it now.
[20:58] RICHARD SEFF: I love hearing these, because we don't all we don't get to hear these stories of what went on behind those closed doors. That's why it's called Behind the Curtain, your show. That's right. It's just fascinating because we don't know what you're doing. No, a lot goes on. A lot goes on. Yes. Just how Hello Dolly, you could argue that it almost happened because of a poker tournament. Well, for him, maybe, yes, that's true. It can be as fluky as that. And you know, your life takes a turn, your lives will too as you go on. Because when I was at MCA for eight and a half years, I was happy there because I was doing exactly what I wanted and being paid well enough. But we the the agency closed overnight.
The government said it was a monopoly, that MCA owned a studio, a movie studio, as well as a talent agency. You can't be the buyer and the seller. So they have to choose. Well, they chose the movie studio. So suddenly the agencies closed overnight. And all the agents are free, and all the clients are free. So we had about 10 minutes to decide what to do. And Ted Ashley, who was another big agent, bought up all the name agents at MCA, Audrey, Kay, Jay Sanford. He just took them all in to Ashley Famous. And he couldn't take all of us second-tier people. My level, Leo Bookman's level, Stark Heseltine, who handled actors' level. So the three of us got together and said, why should we go to work for someone else and stuff?
We're beginning, we can take all our clients with us if we hurry up. Because they're free to go anywhere. But we worked with many of these clients for seven and eight years at the MCA agency. Redford. Uh Stark saw Redford in a play at school at the American Academy and asked him to become a client. So he was with him from day one. And other people, Elizabeth Ashley, Stark had found somewhere, before they had any Broadway credits. So we had invested years into these people, and they were now about ready to really happen. And we were able to open Hazeltine, Bookman, and Seth, our agency, within weeks, uh, with this client list of about 60 people, none of whom were stars, but about to be. And that's was what gave us a good beginning. But you never you couldn't have planned that. No.
[23:25] RICHARD SEFF: And now, funnily enough, after after we had when we opened the agency, we were a big success for about eight years. We got up to 1962, and I have to get the years straight. 54 to 62. Yeah, um, oh yes, cabaret was uh uh it was not 62, it was 69. I've lost I've lost a decade here. It was 69, and Cabaret had opened in 66, a show of mine that I handled the office of. Oh, Abraham Cander, anyway. William Morris handled the other half of the show, uh, Joe Masteroff, the book writer, and the source material, John Van Duten, the play, and uh Christopher Isherwood, the stories. So the deal was a big one. Though someone was ready to pay a million bucks for this movie rights, and that was a big thing for our little agency to have that kind of client getting half of that.
Um the Mars Office said to me, their lawyer said, Listen, you've not done a movie deal before, and this is complicated. So why don't you let me make the deal, and I'll give you half the commission on Ebencander as well. Thanks a lot. I put eight years into them to be giving you the commission for something. No, thank you. So I didn't allow it. And he did make a very good movie deal. But oddly enough, there was one thing missing. Well, he showed me the draft of the contract. I said, you know, the way this reads, they have the rights to the material, but if they want to use any other material in the movie, they can. I don't want anybody's music in that movie except theirs. I don't think there's any reason for it to happen, but it could. So I said, I want a clause that says, oh, any music in this movie must be written by Kandra and Ebb.
[25:19] RICHARD SEFF: There was no Jack, uh no love story between the, you know, Lada Lenya and Jack Gilford. But there was music occasionally when somebody Eliza as uh Sally Bowles would turn on a radio. Music would come out. They could have played God Bless America. They had to play something from that Candron Ebb wrote. But when we were, when we got to be, and when it was, I'd been at it for um, oh, so CMA came along because of that movie sale. They were representing the buyer buying it. And they suddenly noticed us, us little three guys, and said, you know, instead of us arguing with you or negotiating with you, we should own you. Would you like to join us at CMA? Which was Beagleman and Fields and Sam Cohn. And I didn't, none of us really ever wanted to be with a big company again.
We were none of us married, we didn't have children to build a legacy for. And so that wouldn't be any fun. We were going back to meetings and copies and memos and but they made us a deal we couldn't refuse. They offered us a certain number of shares of stock in a CMA, which was publicly traded, and a five-year contract at a much higher salary than I was paying us, you know. So I had to take the, and we all agreed we'll do it. But we'll remain an autonomous unit within CMA. And that's how it worked for the first year of our term. And we had to sign a five-year employment contract. We had to give them five years' guarantee that we'd be there. After the first year, they didn't like us anymore.
They didn't like us because they didn't have any room for us. So they left us in our old address, which suited us fine. And the clients didn't feel they were now with a huge agency. So we were there a year, but then they made room for us because they wanted us on the premises, which means keeping an eye on us and coming to meetings with us and all the rest of that. And that's when I began to think, I don't like this anymore. I know it's another change of career, but I don't want to be an agent this way. Because now most of my deals, my clients were stars. I had Cheetah, I had Cantor and Ebb, I had Clark Gessner, I had a number of other people who were under my wing who were names, you know, uh not as big as Merman, but but stars, Stephen Douglas, that kind of thing.
Um Robert Goulet. And uh I didn't enjoy that as much. It wasn't like the fun of finding and developing. Now you're just meeting with lawyers and tax accountants. It's very different. I'm not a businessman. So I went to Sam Cohn and I said, I want to go back to what I love most. Now I can afford to. I don't have a lot of money, but I have enough to pay my rent and feed me if I don't make a nickel. But I want to go back to the theater as an actor. And maybe as a writer.
[28:15] Kevin David Thomas: How old were you when you made that transition?
[28:18] RICHARD SEFF: In my early 40s, it was 19. It was I have to think because there's so many decades in my life. Yeah, yeah, yeah, sure. But I was about 45, something like that. A strange way to come back to acting. I was 25 when I left, yeah. Right, right. And now I'm 45. And I thought, well, I'll begin an acting career the way John Houseman did. He was 70. And he'd begun his life as a very important director, producer, introduced Austin Wells to the world, produced a lot of things there with Austin Wells. But at 70, he took a job in this thing called the Paper Chase, which was just a two-hour film. And then it became a series. He became a star. He began his acting career as a star. I thought that would be the way I'd like to do it.
Didn't work that way. I was making the rounds, doing extra work in television, extra work in film, then bit parts in film, and then off off Broadway and showcases, and finally I got be an agent as an actor because one of the showcases worked. It was uh a play of um it was played by Arthur Lawrence. No, oh God, it was Big Fish Little Fish. Is that Arthur Lawrence? It was a play that had Hume Cronin in it and Jason Robards originally. And I got to play the Hume Cronin role. So I got an agent out of that. And suddenly I'm a working actor, not doing great, but I'm making a I didn't need to make a lot of money because I had my income from the agency years. I wasn't in this to be a star. I really just wanted to be an actor. And that's a God's honest truth.
[29:56] Kevin David Thomas: Well, I suppose when you when you chew, you know, when you're 21, it's one thing, but when you're 45 and you have this successful career as an agent, but you say, no, this is what really makes sense. I want to do this, yeah. You're doing it for the right reasons.
[30:06] RICHARD SEFF: Absolutely, because you love the work. Exactly. And I did love the work. And I was doing films as well. Very small roles in very big pictures. When you return to acting at 45, and then going into casting offices were people like No, they didn't know me because I'd been out of it for so long. Oh, that's 20 years. The whole new world was there. Now, I have to ask, before we move on to your acting career, um, not only did you get Jerry Herman, Hello Dolly, and I'm gonna I'm gonna Well, don't put it that way. Well, I'm gonna I'm gonna blow your horn a little bit. Submitted it for it. The way you submit okay. How did um Hal Prince get his first directing job?
[30:41] RICHARD SEFF: Well, his very first, I don't know, because he did direct a road company of uh maybe for the Phoenix Theater or something of the matchmaker. So we'll say Broadway. How did he get his first Broadway director? He got it by my being the agent for Evan Cander. No, this was Candor and the Goldman's, the first musical Cander wrote called A Family Affair. My cousin Andrew produced it because nobody else would. And we were in Philadelphia trying it out, and it was in some trouble. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't good enough. And the direction was not right. The the director was the one who'd done the fantastics, and he had done a great job on that. Word Baker. Word Baker, but it was not his material really.
He wasn't just wasn't in good casting. So we had to get rid of him. And uh try another viewpoint. There was very little money left, but enough to spend two or three weeks in Philadelphia. And I and I brought down Teak DeCosta and Carol Haney, and at least one other, maybe Bob Fosse, I forgot who the third was. They'd come down to Philadelphia. They liked it, but nobody wanted to make a commitment to take it over. So we had nobody. And I thought, you know, Prince is a big producer by this point. He's done three shows that are hits, four maybe with West Side Story, but he has never directed on Broadway, and he wants to. And we all knew that. But nobody was offering him jobs. He didn't offer David Merrick jobs to direct, you know.
So he didn't have any offers and no agent to get him one. So I asked if he'd be interested. He said I sure would. I love Candor and uh Candor, and he knew the Goldman's. And um, so I suggested him to Andy, and he came down and he took the job. And that was his first job, and he did enough work on it to say he would be willing to be billed as the director because he it was up to him because Word was not any longer, and he was being paid off whatever that deal was. But uh so it says directed by Harold Prince, and that's the first time. So he he was so grateful to me that years later, when he was directing and I was acting again, you know, we're going 20 years later, and I auditioned for this play.
Uh I had auditioned for him before. Pacific Overtures was to be a play before it became a musical. It didn't have a score. And I read for one of the roles in it, and I got a very nice report from the agent saying he liked your reading very much. We'll see. But it didn't remain a play, it became a musical, so that was forgotten. A year or two later came End of the World, and he wanted to see me about a part, and I would love to go in and read for it. But I happened to be on one of my rare vacations out of the country, and I didn't want to come home four days early on a two-week trip just to read. Right. So vague. And he said, okay, I know Dick Seth well enough to know that he would get through to the finals, so he can come in just for the finals. So I came in a week later for the five final and I got that part.
[33:47] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my goodness.
[33:47] RICHARD SEFF: And he said to me, I finally got to say thank you.
[33:50] Kevin David Thomas: Oh.
[33:50] RICHARD SEFF: Is that sweet? That's class.
[33:52] Kevin David Thomas: What was it like being at the first public performance of My Fair Lady?
[33:57] RICHARD SEFF: Oh, that's oh, that's that needs a whole book. That can I know every moment of the day. Because I was it was a Saturday night. It was snowing. Right. We were in New York, David Hawker and I, planning to come down on Monday for the opening night. This was the Saturday night preview. In New Haven at the Schubert Theater. And David's in the office Saturday morning, making a contract for Ethel Merman to do Happy Hunting next season. He's there with the producer Joe Malziner, etc. I'm home. And he gets this call from either Moss Hart or probably from Herman Levin, the producer of My Fair Lady. David, we need you here. Rex is a problem. He's terrified. He's just rehearsed with the orchestra for the first time in his life.
He's used to the piano. He's never been in a musical. He says, I can't hear them, they can't hear me. I can't do it tonight in front of an audience. That's ridiculous. So let's cancel the preview. We'll get this fixed up by Monday. But the he couldn't do that because New Haven was, first of all, it was snowing. Right. And secondly, the theater manager wasn't buying that at all. He anyway, David had to go to New Haven immediately. So he called me up and said, Go to my apartment, get a pair of pajamas or whatever, and come with me. So we take the train. By the time we got to New Haven, it was about six o'clock. And it was snowing hard. So hard we had to walk to the theater, which is quite a distance.
And we get there and they pounce on him on David. And everybody's kind of calm except the theater manager. Says, I'm not calm. I can't tell 1,100 people who just paid the babysitter for the evening that they have to go home because the star is nervous. You've got to do something about this. I can't, well, because they were going to put on Chris Hewitt, who was the understudy. Yes, he was. He played uh, you know, uh the teacher. Yeah, yeah. Uh whatever his name is. Um, and he understudied Harrison. Right. And uh David Hocker had to go backstage and see Rex Harrison and tell him the facts are that if you don't do it, there could be some press that you don't need. Um he was furious. He said, I want someone up here representing me, not him, not them.
But he was he calmed him down and he agreed he'd do it if Moss would make a speech before the play, just say they weren't ready. It's a crazy business we're in. And uh really, uh so uh we all went off, David and I, and had a little dinner and came back and at 8 30 it begins. And Moss Hart came out and said, ladies and gentlemen, relax. Mr. Harrison's never been better, health, Miss Andrews is in lovely condition. They all loved that because they were sure he was announcing somebody was out. But all he said was we have some very nasty turntables that are misbehaving terribly and they're not turning when they should. So we'll probably stop four or five times during the night. But you're New Haven people, you're you're used to premieres.
I'm sure you'll enjoy it. And please now relax and enjoy My Fair Lady. And off he goes. Well, it lasted until 1 a.m. Famously, yeah. But it didn't the turn tables didn't stop turning. It was just too long. He never missed a beat or a note or anything. Of course. And when he finished the evening, he was preening a bit. I mean, he was rather pleased with himself, as he should have been. And Hocker was there with me at one o'clock in the morning. And now he's very hungry. So we went over to Casey's, which is usually closed at one o'clock in the morning, because they stayed open for him. And he sits down, and the waitress comes over and he says, I'd like it to soft egg two or two minutes, just two minutes.
I don't like three minutes, and very specific. And she said, I could put her in a movie, she'd steal the movie. Mr. Harris, I've been here since eight o'clock this morning, and I'm very tired. I'll give what I can, but please give me a break, you know.
[38:02] RICHARD SEFF: And she left.
[38:06] RICHARD SEFF: Hey, podcast listeners, are you looking for a place to rehearse in New York City that is clean, spacious, and most importantly affordable? Come check out Shetler Studios and Theatres, our wonderful host for these podcasts. Shetler is centrally located on West 54th Street between Broadway and Eighth Avenue, right in the heart of the theater district. Right in the heart, you'll find music, dance, and acting studios complemented by two black box theaters and six presentation venues. The professional facilities, inspired environment, and expert industry staff combined to provide the New York artists with an unparalleled studio experience. Visit their website at ShetlerStudios.com. That's S H E T L E R Studios.com. Shatler Studios and Theatres is our home for recording the legends of Broadway. And we hope that you make it your artistic home too. That's Shetler, S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. See you here.
[39:05] RICHARD SEFF: How did Candor meet Abb? Two ways. Two ways. We're both responsible, really. I give Tommy Belando full credit, too. Tommy Fred and the and the and and uh Jim and Paul Klein were collaborators for a number of years. They had written a musical called Simon Says, which was an original. They had written It Gives Me Great Pleasure, based on a book of Emily Kimbrose, and they'd written um there was a third one. Well, Golden Gay, but that was with John. No, wait a minute. Uh there was a third musical. I can't think what it was. But, oh yes, of course, Morning Sun, which was produced at the Phoenix. Um, so they worked as a team. And John wrote a musical with Cand with the Goldman brothers called A Family Affair.
And that was what we got on with my cousin and Hal Prince took over, but that wasn't a hit. Neither one, neither one of them had a hit. I can't remember if they were the same season, but they were very close. So each was without the partner because after the three or four shows that they wrote together, Fred, his partner was married with a baby coming, and he just couldn't go on speculating any longer in a career that wasn't really paying very much, if anything. So he had to leave. And he needed a composer. The Goldmans weren't planning to be book writers the rest of their lives. They wanted to write plays and books, which they did. And so John needed a lyricist. So I handled both teams, and Tommy Volando, a very pardon me, enterprising publisher of music, who loved theater writers.
He had quite a monopoly on young writers, hoping they'd happen. And one team was Ebbs and one was Canders. So he they actually said, How do you do, Mr. Livingston, to each other in his office? But I introduced John, Fred to John's work by playing him the score that I had on an LP. And I loved Fred's comment on hearing John Candice's music for the first time in his life. I could work with him. I swear to God, that's all he said. And then they met through Tommy.
[41:19] Kevin David Thomas: Were there any writers that you know you had your eye on? You were cultivating them, helping develop them, and for some reason it just...
[41:27] RICHARD SEFF: Absolutely. I had a boy named Barry Grail who wrote with a man named RICHARD Shodosh, and they Barry had written a musical which ran off Broadway for about a year, based on, oh, I'm losing my mind, but it was a hit based on another work before I knew him. That's when I asked him to sign with me. I handled people in all areas that didn't quite happen, like Buddy Schwab, uh choreographer, uh, several uh Ralph Beaumont. They all worked on Broadway, but they weren't all big names. Ron Field was the big one. And I was with him from day one. Did a potential client ever come to you and you said, Nah, this isn't gonna work out, and then that person ended up having a fabulous career?
[42:14] RICHARD SEFF: Yes, there were two. The ones that got away, we'll say. Well, they didn't get away. I wanted to kick the bout, but it didn't work. Uh, one was Elaine Stritch, whom I adored as an actress, but I couldn't take her as a client. There was never enough, you know, never. Um, she was difficult. She requires a lot. She certainly did, and she was worth it, but to uh to from an audience point of view, but she was tough. I remember she was in uh Showboat for with Hal Prince directing, playing Party Anne, and I was her agent, and uh she was on the road, it opened in Toronto. She'd call me every day. She said, I'm not living with those kids. They're all on the shaft to whatever hotel it was in Philadelphia or wherever they were, that wasn't good enough for her.
She wanted to be somewhere grander, so she moved to someplace grander. Then she called me home and said, I'm all alone here. I got no one to talk to. And the other was Charlotte Ray, who I adored too. She was so great, but she was a whiner. Oh yeah, she was a whiner. She'd always say, I don't know. Doesn't like anything. But the others were all heaven, people like Linda Lavin and Virginia. Um they weren't all big stars. Nancy Dusso. Oh, yeah. I was with her through her first three shows. There were a number that didn't happen, and I may have been wrong about some of them too. For instance, I handled Stuart Damon through his whole career, and he was attractive, and he was a good singer, and he had a very good beginning, you know, playing The Prince and Cinderella with Julie Andrews and many things on Broadway.
But there wasn't any magic there, really. He ended up in television. Not under me, he moved west and became a doctor on Hot Doctor's Hospital or something forever. Lovely boy. Hot Doctor's Hospital. That was funny because Stuart came in to see me and sang for me. I had a little room on Tuesdays. I'd see people every Tuesday, writers or actors. He'd come in, he sang. I said, Yes, this is a very talented young. His name was Stuart Zonis. I said, but you don't look like a Stuart Zonis when you, you know, you're a long leaning man. Well, my father won't mind. I guess I could change it. So I said, Well, well, what do you call yourself? He didn't have a clue. I said, I don't know why I look at you and I think of Damon and Pythias.
I swear to God, you'll be Stuart Damon. That's how it gets created. What a business. Oh, you know how I met him? His father came to see me. His father, Mr. Zonis, came in one day before I met him. Right. Said, I got a boy, you wouldn't believe he's so beautiful. He talked just like that. And he sings like an angel. He's got to have an angel. I hear you're good. Would you take a look, take a chance with him? And the kid comes in and he's everything his father says he is. Oh, that's great. So I signed him up. So there were those people that were with me, Danny Meehan, who played a lead in Whoop Up for Sai Fuer. But it didn't, you know, they don't always go on for whatever reason. Some of them are personal, some of them go to television.
Some of them just disappear. It's a never ending business, except now I am concerned that it doesn't seem like my theater anymore. Because of the jukebox musicals, which to us were anathema in our day. You didn't ever do a musical that had not an original score. You know, you could do uh Ain't Misbehavin' was one oddity, but way back then, but everything was new. And uh I don't like this, and I don't think it's healthy because you're gonna run out of pop writers. Now we're gonna get Michael Jackson's life, you know, in all pop tunes. And um and then, of course, the revivals, which are for the older generation, and we get five and six and eight a year now. We used to get one.
[46:09] Kevin David Thomas: Uh when did you so you've written some plays?
[46:11] RICHARD SEFF: Yes, while I was still an agent, I wanted to write. So that you you got the urge to write when you were an agent.
[46:18] RICHARD SEFF: Yes, well, I was I'd always had it. Oh, you know. I wrote a play when I was 18. Oh. But acting took over, and you can't do everything at once. And I obviously wasn't driven the way the young Terrence McNally was or the younger Alfred Wilson was. That's what they did. And I was sort of mostly an actor. But I started to write in 1965, and I was only, well, I was I was probably about 35, 38. But I wrote a play called The Whole Ninth Floor because it was all about MCA, right? Oh, the ninth floor, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And I and it was liked and it was optioned by Norman Twain for Broadway, and he wanted to try it out in stock. So we did it in Paramus at the Playhouse in the Park with Alan Holden, a wonderful cast, uh David Rounds was in it.
So many lovely people were in it, and uh, and it worked well enough, but it wasn't really quite strong enough for Norman to bring it in. So it didn't go anywhere. It got published by French, but it didn't get uh didn't get a life. That one didn't. Then I started another one, but because I was a full-time agent, it took me four years to get the next one on, and that was Paris is Out. And that one again was David Black producing, but he wanted to see it in stock, so he did. Expedience, I was wrong, but you can do that when you're young.
[47:38] Kevin David Thomas: And how long did your your play run on Broadway?
[47:41] RICHARD SEFF: Three and a half months. Yes. It it may it was the it was interesting. I have all the variety headlines because it ended, it started out with a very small advance. And every week of the 20 weeks I think it ran, or maybe 15 weeks, every week the gross rose to the point where the headline over the column was Broadway Down, Paris Up. I love that headline. I have a great in my scrapbook. But we just got to like the break-even point, and the house manager said to me, if you can get through Passover and Easter, which are coming up in April, you'll be here all summer, because this is an audience play. And we got to Easter Sunday, and we had a blizzard. Oh. And ever and three plays that were nervous hits like mine closed on that day.
Three plays. It was The Private Lives with Tommy Grimes and The Sheep on the Runway. Book Wolf play on Book Wolf. All of them having run about three months. So that I don't get bitter about that. That's just bad luck. Neil Simon in his book talks about uh Come Blow Your Horn with very mixed reviews. But it did have an audience. It never sold out. It made a very small profit, but it managed to squeak through with the uh the orchestrations with the um overhead for about a year, and also he had two lucky breaks. Two very chic people. One was Noel Coward, he tells you this, and one was I've forgotten who, some society lady of prominence, saw it, and thought it was adorable. And they quoted this this big, and that gave it a little class because it didn't have much class around it, and therefore the the house seat people would begin to come and see it.
So that's just lucky. He would have written another play anyway. What I should have done is what Terrence McNally did. He had a play that ran a week called And Things That Go Bump in the Night on Broadway, and he wrote another play a week later. And I took a few years off to recover, you know.
[49:46] Kevin David Thomas: You're doing other things.
[49:47] RICHARD SEFF: Doing other things. That's right, that's right. Now, how did you fall into your current role as a critic?
[49:52] RICHARD SEFF: That I fell into, actually. It was completely by chance. I was standing. It seems like a lot of things happened to you. In a great way, I mean, in a beautiful way. I love that. But you gotta be out there to have chance hit you in the face. I was standing in front of the um what we used to be the Biltmore Theater and is now the uh whatever the Manhattan Theater Club. There was a marquee up, Love Music was playing there, uh, the Kurt Weill. Oh, Love Music, yeah. Yeah, yeah. I was looking at the poster, and someone was standing next to me who was looking at the poster, and he started to chat, and we chatted, and he was very galulous like me. Before we got through, he knew my name from other things I'd done. And he said, You love the theater as much as I do, and you should be working for us.
[50:39] RICHARD SEFF: I said, Who's us? He was a critic for the Washington Theaters um DC Theatre Scene.com. He wasn't the editor in chief, but he was a writer. And he said, You should be with us, you should be reviewing, you know everything about the theater. And he introduced me to Lorraine Trainer, his producing boss, and she took me on. I was there for several months when he left to go to DC Metro Theatre Arts, which he founded. And he became the editor in chief. He took me with him. And I was there a year or two when he died. Poor darling died of a cancer of something that came on very suddenly. Terrible. He was my real mentor. He adored me and he was very kind to me. And so I stayed on after he died, but when they replaced him with another editor, eventually it wasn't right for me.
And then by sheer chance, because now at least I had credentials of a few years and a lot of reviews to show. This woman at the um Shoreline East heard of me and asked me if I'd be interested. So that's even better for me because I have a newspaper now that's in print. And to make sure, because it's only Shoreline East, it's only the Connecticut Shoreline that gets the paper every week. They have about a hundred thousand people that get it in the mail. And um, so I started my own site so that I could print every review because she can't print them all. It's only a weekly newspaper. So that's how it became a critic, and I joined the uh critic circle, out of critics, when you have to have had any number of things published. So I submitted the reviews to them, and they made me a member. So now I have another union.
[52:30] Kevin David Thomas: Good for you. Another career. Can you tell us a little bit about uh the musical you wrote?
[52:33] RICHARD SEFF: Yeah, that's a labor of love. I started this completely from scratch. My mother used to, when she was a girl, she was born in America and born in New York, but her mother came from Europe, and somehow when my mother was a girl, she was given a lot of these Horatio Alger books. People of her generation at the turn of the century, he was very popular. The best selling author in American history, like 20 million copies of his books. You know, Strive and Reach and uh go with all those titles were brave and bold. Yeah. Very positive immigrant images of the kid who has nothing, who's usually an orphan, lives in a box under the on the sidewalk, is a boot black or a newsboy dealer, and makes a living and believes in if you have guts and you try, you can do anything.
This is America. It was very much in the hearts and minds of young immigrants like my mother. She was not an immigrant, but a new first generation American. And I always loved the idea of that, because I've kind of lived that way myself. If you want something badly enough and you try hard enough and stop fetching, you can accomplish miracles. Um so I decided to do it, and I read a few of the books. They were childlike, they were simplistic, but they all have the same theme. And there's one book called Silas Snobden's Office Boy, and there's another one called I think Ragged Riches. And I read those two interested me most because the plot of one, but the characters in the other. So I he's all in public domain.
So I did one just called the Horatio Alger musical. And it was based on Ragged Dick. That was the name of one of the books as well, Ragged Dick, because he wore rags all the time. Um because Ragged Dick can be a useful uh not a very attractive term, uh, we just called it Shine, because that's what he was. He was a boot black, you know. And uh I wanted to use one of the big name composers, but who knew me? I mean, I was an agent who was now writing a book at whatever age I was. It was 1980. How old was I? I was in my 50s, late 50s. So they I couldn't go to Kander and Ebb and Bach and Harnick and all of those. I may have asked them, but I probably didn't, because I didn't think that was realistic.
So I looked for someone young and like I used to as an agent, and someone sent this man, Roger Anderson, to me, as an ex-agent, thinking I could help him still, and he played me the score to a musical he'd written only the music to, not the lyrics or the book, but his music was exquisite and theater. And I and he was 28 years old or something, so I immediately latched on to him. I would have signed him as a client if I'd been an agent. But I really became his agent without without uh papers. And so I let him take a chance, and I said, Who would you write lyrics with? He didn't know, because the one he was working with was not good enough. So I had had a client named Lee Goldsmith, who had written many things, including a musical based on Sheba, come little, come back little Sheba.
Which Kay Ballard did somewhere. In in not in New York, I don't think. And Lee wrote a lot of things. He wrote a musical called Sex Tet, which had a brief run on Broadway. But he was a very clever lyricist. In the school of Fred Ebb, they were good friends in the beginning of time. He even wrote a lot of one of Fred's songs with him, without credit. But he that doesn't mean Fred wasn't great, but they did work. They were very much alike, New York Jewish boys. And Lee was good. And very well read. He could do Shakespeare or Shaw and find lyrics for them. So I took a chance on a generation gap between Goldsmith and Anderson, sent Anderson to Florida to meet him. He lived in Florida. Now Lee, after trying a few musicals as a youngster, found a boyfriend that he's lived with forever.
And he was strictly a businessman. And Lee didn't want to have to be in New York, and Larry wanted to be in Florida. So he took another tack. He he wrote cartoons. He wrote the dialogue for famous cartoons. I can't remember which ones. And he made a good living at it. And he'd write lyrics occasionally for some Saturday night in Florida, some event, you know, that kind of thing. I think he even wrote a couple of reviews that were done in Florida theaters, you know. But he was delighted to be attached to someone and me for a Broadway musical this time. And he wrote a damn good score. And we had very little trouble in finding a Broadway producer for it. It was kind of the buzz of the town. And the second or third person who heard it said, yeah.
So we sold it to 20th Century Fox, which was pretty fancy. And it came along with not only a dramatic skill contract, but a uh an option on a movie. And you should read the terms, you know. If it runs this long, you've got a million dollars. It was if, if, if. And so uh we sold them the rights, and for the next year, we worked under that contract. They used a line producer in New York, because they're a Hollywood studio, named Henry Gettle, who's Adam Gettle's father. Oh, Mary Roger's husband. And Henry loved it and bought it and was the mentor. And we put together a team. We had uh a set designer and a costume, Florence Klotz was going to design it. And it was going beautifully. And director, I don't know how it happened, but he was hot that week, was Vivian Matalon, who had just done um Mornings at Seven and had won a Tony Award.
And then he did Brigadoon, a revival, which was mezzo mezzo, but okay. And um he adored it. I could have kicked his ass because he said it's enchanting. I love it. And then he's then he signed the contract to be the director, and then said second act doesn't work, you know. So we did it in Virginia, and it was not a disaster. Did business, but it wasn't well received. And nobody came from New York to see it. Nobody. My agent, who was Biff Liff, God rest his soul, but he was not helpful. He said, I like it, very nice, needs work. See ya. And and I never saw him again in my life. So that wasn't good. So he sort of died there, and I went on for the next ten years trying to get it on at Goodspeed and all those long warfare, all those theaters.
We've come very close, but it was tarnished. It was a musical that didn't make it, you know. We've gone through phases of this with workshops and NYMF where it won a prize. But it very hard to get people to come and see these things. We did it at NYMF with Danny uh uh, you know, um what's his name? Oh, yes, oh yeah. He was wonderful in it. He won a NYMF prize for that. But anyway, that's that's the story of Shine and how I got to do it. I started that one. Yeah. Because of the I still love the Alger philosophy of you know good guys win in the end.
[59:52] Kevin David Thomas: Well, it seems like you've you've done that. You've lived you're living proof of it.
[59:55] RICHARD SEFF: Yeah, I'm not unhappy with my life. I don't consider it a failure because Shine didn't get on one, but no, absolutely not. You you're an integral part. And please, uh friends, you must read this book. Um Supporting uh Supporting Player.
[1:00:05] Kevin David Thomas: Supporting Player.
[1:00:09] RICHARD SEFF: Uh it is it is so good. Uh I'm reading it and I'm halfway through it now, but I it feels like it's a uh like the the next generation of like act one, you know, the Moss Hart book. It because it what I really appreciate is how personal you are. You don't just talk about the the people you met and the people you worked with, you talk a little bit about what relationships were like.
[1:00:30] RICHARD SEFF: Oh, yeah. And I really respect that because a lot of times we just I want to know what was what was it like to go on a date in the 40s? What was it like to go see shows? And you really go into the you must have have great notes of of this time period of your life.
[1:00:46] RICHARD SEFF: Oh, mostly up in my head. But I do have a million scrapbooks, and I have given them to the library of uh performing arts. Yeah, they have all that stuff, and they will have the rest of it when I go. Um because it is interesting. There are it's history. There are letters from people that uh many of them are thank you for your opening night wire. They don't count, but some of them are substantive. This has been so so fantastic. Um I cannot thank you enough for coming and joining us today.
[1:01:13] Kevin David Thomas: I loved it. You know, also don't forget you have to buy RICHARD's book, um, which is available at um Theatre Circle.
[1:01:19] RICHARD SEFF: Theater Circle, if you go to it.
[1:01:21] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, if you go to Theater Circle, it's always in the window. The book is called Supporting Player, My Life Upon the Wicked Stage. Um, we both own hard copies, but I also have a version on uh Kindle. It's a fabulous book. And once again, a big thank you to our good friend Mark Sendroff, who sent RICHARD our way. We've been trying to get you for a long time, and I'm happy this happened. Um, so buy the book, read the book. Thank you, RICHARD, for sharing so many wonderful memories with us today.
[1:01:45] RICHARD SEFF: I loved it.
[1:01:46] Kevin David Thomas: Good. I'm happy you're happy. Um till next time. Bye, everybody.
[1:01:51] RICHARD SEFF: Today's episode was recorded at Shetler Studios on 244 West 54th Street. Visit Shetler Studios to book your room today, and you could be as cool as us. That's S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. And a big thanks to our sound editor Daniel Schwartzberg and social media manager Bethany and Selecki. And friends, don't forget, we want more folks to hear these incredible stories, and that's where you guys can come in and help us out.
[1:02:16] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, in order for people to find out about us, we need lots of ratings on iTunes. The more ratings, the more they'll come up and search us. So head on over to iTunes, search for behind the curtain Broadway's Living Legends, click on our logo, click on ratings and reviews, then write a review and leave us five stars and make us feel as special as Eliza Doolittle on Eliza Doolittle Day. Or you can leave us one star and make us feel as bad as Annie did in that weird production in Boston where Annie dreamed about being adopted and then ended the show back in the orphanage. True story, Rob was there.
[1:02:23] RICHARD SEFF: I saw it.
[1:02:23] Kevin David Thomas: So head on over to iTunes and make us feel even more special than we already do.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
