Website: https://jeffblumenkrantz.com/ Jeff Blumenkrantz is a man who wears many hats. As an actor, he was in the original companies of Into the Woods, A Class, Act, Murder for Two, and the revivals of Damn Yankees and How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Featured Shows
About
Website: https://jeffblumenkrantz.com/
Jeff Blumenkrantz is a man who wears many hats. As an actor, he was in the original companies of Into the Woods, A Class, Act, Murder for Two, and the revivals of Damn Yankees and How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. Behind the scenes he was one of the most celebrated songwriters of the early 2000s, having written songs for the musical Urban Cowboy (Tony nom), as well as for Audra McDonald, Victoria Clark, and Megan Mullally. And, in the kitchen, he is a fabulous chef!
Jeff pulls back the curtain on his career to discuss how he reduced Stephen Sondheim to fits of laughter, what lessons he leaned from the BMI Workshop, and why Walter Bobbie doesn't like criers.
Also, Jeff shines the spotlight on Alysha Umphress, Audra McDonald, and Steve Martin!
Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Kevin David Thomas: Well, you guys, the time has come.
[0:03] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, uh, so uh Behind the Curtain is uh gonna go off the air.
[0:08] Kevin David Thomas: What?
[0:08] Robert W. Schneider: April Fools!
[0:09] Kevin David Thomas: Kevin, you made my heart leap faster than Gwen Verdon and Redhead.
[0:13] Robert W. Schneider: Richard Kiley from me.
[0:15] Kevin David Thomas: Okay.
[0:15] Robert W. Schneider: Look who's in love.
[0:16] Kevin David Thomas: Sorry.
[0:17] Robert W. Schneider: You guys, we aren't going anywhere. And in order to ensure that, friends, we need your help.
[0:21] Kevin David Thomas: Our podcast is entirely self-produced, and like I said, we need your help.
[0:25] Robert W. Schneider: If you can, our little Easter eggs, head on over to patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com and search for Behind the Curtain's BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS.
[0:34] Kevin David Thomas: I think I know the title of the show, and set a monthly donation. Even a dollar a month helps us.
[0:40] Robert W. Schneider: Your contributions help us continue doing what we are doing and bringing the legend stories to your ears.
[0:46] Kevin David Thomas: Have a great June.
[0:48] Robert W. Schneider: April.
[0:50] Kevin David Thomas: April.
[0:52] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you.
[1:06] Kevin David Thomas: Well, hi everybody. Welcome to Behind the Curtain, Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:09] Robert W. Schneider: It's Robert W. Schneider.
[1:10] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, I'm Kevin David Thomas and Robert W. Schneider. We're back with you.
[1:13] Robert W. Schneider: It's been a couple months since we've been away, but we're uh we're held up, uh, all three of us with our special guest today, JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ. Hi, Jeff.
[1:20] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Hey, you guys.
[1:21] Robert W. Schneider: The one and only brilliant genius JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ. Jeff, how are you doing in this quarantine? How are you keeping yourself busy?
[1:28] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Huh. Well, I do Yeah, I mean, like me it's funny. I I have found there have been days, many days during this quarantine where I I've gotten to the end of the day, and I'm like, God, I I I meant to do like three other things and I couldn't squeeze them in. But I I'm not really sure exactly what I'm accomplishing other than like a ton of cooking.
[1:54] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Good. Um, a daily yoga class. That's my little corner of sanity. Um, I'd be lying if I said I didn't do a certain number of New York Times puzzles every day.
[2:08] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, and they're free now.
[2:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: They're all they're all free listeners.
[2:11] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, are they?
[2:12] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I've been paying.
[2:13] Kevin David Thomas: I'm the dummy.
[2:14] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, no, they just announced that they were gonna let them uh be free.
[2:17] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, good. That's uh that's very nice. Um let's see what else I do my Duolingo.
[2:24] Robert W. Schneider: What language?
[2:25] Kevin David Thomas: What language are you learning, Jeff?
[2:27] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Europe well, they don't have European Portuguese on there. They only have Brazilian Portuguese, but I'm learning European Portuguese.
[2:34] Kevin David Thomas: Oh wow, impressive.
[2:36] Robert W. Schneider: This is very thank you. Jeff is very accomplished.
[2:39] Kevin David Thomas: I I I ate two bags of cookies, so congratulations, Jeff.
[2:43] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Ah Jeff is the only difference is I cook two bags of cookies and then I eat two bags of cookies.
[2:50] Kevin David Thomas: Great, we can work out a trade system. I love it.
[2:53] Robert W. Schneider: So, Jeff, first of all, I have to say we're so excited that you're joining us today. Uh, you know, you you have been an inspiration to so many for so long, and and just want to say thank you for joining us. So, my first question for you is is what came first for you, which is was it the love of songwriting or was it the love of performing?
[3:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Hmm, I guess it all kind of happened at the same time. Uh I I was uh I was introduced to theater through my mother who was a community theater performer slash director slash conductor.
[3:22] Robert W. Schneider: And then what was the name of the community theater?
[3:25] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Senta Drama Workshop.
[3:28] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[3:29] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: At the well, now we call them JCCs, but at the time it was called the Why, but like the Jewish Why.
[3:34] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[3:35] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um in um Ocean Township, New Jersey. Actually, I think it was called West Deal. Anyway, on the Jersey shore. And uh so I I would tag along and but uh so that was my introduction to theater, but then my mother was a music teacher, so she had a closet full of music books, and I was an early piano player. So I sort of I was spending, you know, all day, every day at the piano from a young age, and then so the they were both both building at the same time.
[4:14] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: By the time I was 11, I was spending every summer at Stage Door Manor where I would just do show after show after show.
[4:22] Kevin David Thomas: Would you run us through some of your credits on your resume, please, Jeff?
[4:26] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Please. I mean, six or five or five or six shows times five summers. That's a lot of parts. But my I would say my highlights were Albert and Bye Bye Birdie, Cornelius and Hello Dolly. Um, I played Herbie and Gypsy. I mean, it's it's ludicrous. I was Frank Butler and Annie Get Your Gun. I mean, it's I was Lunta in King and I. I mean, it I it gets more and more ludicrous the deeper we dive. But um, and I did just see a picture of myself as Mr. Bumble, but uh um, yeah, so there was Stagedoor Manor, and then there was a you know, there was a lot of piano playing happening. So I started writing songs when I was I'm gonna say 13 or 14.
[5:10] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yes. So when it came time to applying to college, it was a toss up. I was, you know, I love it. I was choosing between uh theater program at Northwestern and uh music program at Oberlin, and I ended up choosing theater, but it could have gone either way.
[5:30] Kevin David Thomas: Did you continue your music studies at Northwestern while you were still doing your uh the the acting studies? I mean I assume you probably were playing for lots of people and playing for yourself and all of that.
[5:40] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, I mean the way my music love uh manifested itself at Northwestern was uh through writing for the Wamu show, which if you don't know is this like big splashy all student written extravaganza. And um I also took some classes, you know, things like choral arranging or orchestration or jazz arranging and I th that kind of stuff. But at the time I went to Northwestern, there was no musical theater program per se. There was, you know, one class in musical theater. So I took it.
[6:13] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[6:13] Robert W. Schneider: Right. And then we yeah, we've interviewed a lot of people who uh Northwestern in throughout the sixties and seventies especially, that was sort of like the the beacon of training for uh for theatrical studies at least. Um and did you did you enjoy it? Did you have a good time? I mean, was it good for you?
[6:27] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I loved it and it was amazing for me. However, I should confess that it was not remotely my first choice. I didn't get into any of my top choice schools. I really wanted to go to a conservatory. I wanted to go to Carnegie Mellon Musical Theater Program more than anything. Wow. And I didn't get in. I got um actually they accepted me to the music school and I think I made a strategic mistake when I auditioned for them, which was they, you know, they asked me at my audition if, you know, would you also be interested in the music program? And I said yes, but it was a lie. I was not interested in their music program. Clearly, I didn't go there. Um they're loss. But yes. I really wanted to go to a conservatory.
Uh I would have gone to any conservatory before I went to Northwestern, but um I didn't get into them. And so I went to my fallback school. Ha ha, which was Northwestern, and it ended up being an amazing choice. I had the I I'm really glad I in the end that I didn't go to a conservatory, because I think that kind of education I got there, which I would describe as liberal arts with a heavy emphasis on theater, um, was invaluable. Um yeah, I got I got to learn a lot of things and meet a lot of different kinds of people versus just the people who were into what I was into.
[7:53] Kevin David Thomas: Exactly. What were the Wamu shows like? What what is for those of us who may not know, because you know, a lot of universities like Yale and Harvard, and they have like these student written run shows, and a lot of composers have you know, you know, cut their, you know, flex their muscles on that. What were they what keep take us through what some of them were like?
[8:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, the Wamu show has evolved a lot since I went to Northwestern, but when I was there, it was purely a um skit and song review. It wasn't there was no book uh to it. It was just uh skits and songs, and a lot of the songs were uh topical about things that were either happening in the city or the country or the university. You know, there was a remember a song about the the library the new library computer system or a song about the the school newspaper and or the song about the freshman 15, you know, it was all very um light and um it had the uh it had the feeling of like a Carol Burnett show.
[9:02] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[9:03] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And also the clothes. Uh a lot of the clothes were rented from these Hollywood stocks, you know. We were wearing Bob Mackey costumes. I mean, it was very extravagant. We had a 30-piece orchestra. I, you know, I was a freshman and I was a young freshman because I skipped a grade. So I was like 17. Um, having written songs for Wamu, my freshman year, and I actually appeared in it that year too. And, you know, sitting on the stage at a at the Zitz probe listening to a 30-piece orchestra play songs that I wrote that were orchestrated, not by me, by a professional, like my head exploded.
[9:43] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, yeah.
[9:44] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So that was you know that pretty pretty formative for me.
[9:49] Kevin David Thomas: And then were you still doing music? Was there like a musical program on campus anywhere? Was like an independent group doing shows so you could keep those muscles flexed?
[9:57] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: As an actor, you mean?
[9:59] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[9:59] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um, yes, lots of musicals. There were, you know, there were there was this there was this thing called the Dolphin Show where they would produce one giant musical every year, like pretty much the size of a big, you know, theater department musical. And then the theater department would do a handful of musicals a year also. So yeah, I got I had I got plenty of time on stage and doing musicals at school.
[10:21] Robert W. Schneider: And when you graduated, did you know that you were gonna go to New York? Did you know that was always gonna be the goal for you?
[10:27] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, that was a no-brainer for me. I in fact, in you know, I graduated in 1986, and I think there were two of us who went to New York. I mean, a class of a hundred. I'm gonna say 50 of them went to LA. 20 of them didn't pursue theater. 25 or 28 stayed in Chicago, and two of us went to New York.
[10:37] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[10:52] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Now, so when you went to New York, did you was this your first time there? Had you been there before?
[10:56] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I grew up on the Jersey Shore. So um I had spent, you know, I felt like a pseudo-New Yorker. You know, I was in the city a lot as a teenager, taking classes on the weekends, and you know, my parents would bring me, or I should say my mother would bring me in to see shows a lot growing up.
[11:14] Robert W. Schneider: So what do you remember your first Broadway show?
[11:17] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um my first Broadway show was either, and I can't remember which came first, but it was either Grease or The Wiz.
[11:23] Kevin David Thomas: Oh both fabulous choices.
[11:27] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[11:27] Kevin David Thomas: What other shows did you see in your teenage years on Broadway that were, you know, had a transformative effect on you?
[11:33] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Hmm. Transformative. Or or a big impact, we'll say. You know, I saw so many. I mean, I saw like everything from Sweeney Todd in previews, which I didn't really go for. I didn't I guess I didn't have very good taste back then. Um I saw Shenandoah, the magic show. I saw Charlie and Algernon. I mean, I saw my God, you you were the one. That's amazing.
[12:00] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[12:00] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I mean, I, you know, so I I saw a lot of a lot of random stuff. I used, you know, like I said, I would come into the city on the weekends, and if I had a theater slot available to me, I would just go to the half-price booth and or a second act, yeah, a show or two.
[12:16] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[12:17] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And um, yeah, so I I saw a lot, but um formative? Uh that that's hard. I mean, you know, there were some splashy shows that it were interesting, like sophisticated ladies or Ain't Misbehaving. I remember that was Oh yeah. That was so well done. Um Day in Hollywood.
[12:38] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I love that show.
[12:39] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: That's such a fun one.
[12:41] Kevin David Thomas: And as far as your songwriting skills, like were there what composers really like turned you on? Like who were who were you listening to that you said, Oh man, I uh gosh, I'm obsessed with that writer.
[12:51] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, it's hard to it's hard to separate the teenage me from the today me. I mean the teenage me just wanted to listen to Barry Manilow and Donna Summer and Billy.
[13:02] Kevin David Thomas: Nothing wrong with that.
[13:03] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Nothing wrong with that, Jeff. Thanks. But you know, my theater um idols have always been the same. It's always been Sondheim and Bock and Harnick, Kander and Ebb, um you know, the golden agey.
[13:24] Kevin David Thomas: How did you know what to do when you got to New York? How did you know how to, you know, tread the boards and find the right auditions and find the right audition song and all of those those those business type things?
[13:34] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, finding songs was never hard for me because of my um musical abilities. I could just go to the library and I'd pull out books and I would flip through and I always pick my songs based on the lyrics, you know. I if the text appealed to me, then I would figure out if the music worked. So uh we also got a lot of kind of well, I shouldn't say we. It wasn't everybody at Northwestern. North when you're a theater major at Northwestern, you sort of end up in a in an acting teacher's chorale, at least that you did at the time. And the chorale I ended up in, which was Bud Byers' class, um, he was very very business minded. And he would, you know, he gave us a lot of strategy. And I remember just talking a lot about how to do the business in his acting class, which was really helpful.
I, you know, one famous story I remember. Um is uh, you know, he said, How okay, so you're gonna get to new, you know, you're gonna get to wherever you get, LA or or New York or Chicago, and you're gonna need an agent, and you're gonna want to get an agent's attention. How are you going to do that? And he threw that out to us, and people started pitching uh possible techniques. And Craig Bierco was in my acting class, and Craig was like, Well, you could send an agent a pound of locks every week until they like took your call.
[15:00] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I mean, that would, you know, that would just, you know, be such a weird gesture that they would have to pay attention to it. And I remember that, and so like this thing, I remember doing this thing when I first got here, and granted, it was a very different time. It was pictures and resumes, and you know, everything through the mail or delivered by hand. And so I sent my picture and resume to like a hundred agents whose names I pulled out of the Ross reports. I don't even know if that still exists. And I put a cover letter in my picture and resume, and then I put a self-addressed stamped postcard in there. And the choices were, you know, I was like, please, please check one box. And the first box was, um, I can't wait to meet you.
Please call me as soon as possible. I can't wait to meet you. Please come see me on this day at this time. Uh, I'm not interested in meeting you right now, but please feel free to contact me again. Or the last box was, you know, please fall off the face of the earth. And um, I got a lot of those cards back. And you know, I met a lot of people through that mailing, and I, you know, it was, you know, and I had Craig's voice in my mind. I'm like, do something kind of ridiculous. And that was that last box, you know.
[16:25] Robert W. Schneider: So that's great.
[16:26] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[16:26] Robert W. Schneider: Well done.
[16:26] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, well done. Smart way, a smart way of doing it. Um, what was your go-to audition song when you were making the rounds?
[16:32] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, the truth is I have been singing the same audition song since I was 16 years old. I mean, I literally sang it, you know, at my last audition. I have not stopped using this song, and you know, I guess there's no reason why I shouldn't say what it is, because you know, we're all so different, and no two people are gonna sing the song the same way. But that's right. My go-to audition song for all time is "Where Was I When They Passed Out Luck" from Minnie's Boys?
[17:04] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my god, that's great.
[17:06] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: It just slots in really well with my sensibility and with my like kind of Jewishness and my, I don't know, my sense of humor. It just like I just, and I have a lot of like variations I can do depending on the room. So I've like fine-tuned this.
[17:26] Robert W. Schneider: That is awesome.
[17:27] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: That is awesome. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
[17:30] Robert W. Schneider: Exactly.
[17:31] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: That's right.
[17:32] Robert W. Schneider: And so then when you, so you got to the city, were you also, were you going out on the road a lot? Were you doing a lot of summer stock? Were you doing a lot of, you know, regional gigs before the first big Broadway break happened?
[17:43] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I had an insane string of luck when I got to New York, and it like just happened in five seconds. The first thing I did when I got here was I was, and I came to New York with my equity card because I got cast in a show in Chicago like the day I graduated. I literally, like a week after graduation, I started rehearsals for a production of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat at the Drury Lane Oakbrook Theater. And um, so that ended, and I moved to New York at the end of the summer after graduation. And the first thing I did was this, um, again, people are not gonna know what this is, but there was a thing called the Equity Library Theater.
[18:27] Robert W. Schneider: Oh Jeff, we talked about the Equity Library Theater all the time.
[18:31] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: We, we, our listeners are definitely aware of ELT for sure.
[18:36] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Okay, great. So the first thing I did was an ELT production of The Pajama Game, and I hesitated accepting it because my role was literally second helper, like that was my character's name. And um, that involved like I think two lines of dialogue. But um, I ended up saying, you know, oh well, you know, I have nothing else going on, so I might as well do it. I ended up meeting two of my best friends for all time, and randomly got a shout-out in the New York Times review, which, yeah, which was crazy. I mean, I had like these two lines, but you know, there was this thing called The Pitch. Did you have you talked about that when you talk about ELT?
[19:19] Robert W. Schneider: You know, no, tell us if I know what it is, but tell us about The Pitch, please.
[19:23] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So The Pitch was a, how do you say, like a montage? You know, uh, what do you call, God, I'm spacing. What do you call a bunch of songs put together?
[19:34] Robert W. Schneider: Um, medley.
[19:34] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Thank you. So it would be performed at intermission by the ensemble. Oh, and everybody would get like, you know, 16 bars basically, and there would be a theme. And in Pajama Game, the theme was, you know, songs about sleeping, or you know, nighttime. Because we all came out in our pajamas, and there's a can, like you literally are looking for donations from the audience. So that's why it's called The Pitch. And uh, so I had a very sweet little piece in The Pitch, and I think like between The Pitch and like my two jokes in the show, I like got a random shout-out in this review, and got, you know, got a lot of attention from this, you know, ensemble role. That turned into, like, so that was the fall I got to New York. Then I think by January, I was starting rehearsals for South Pacific at City Opera, which was kind of like, you know, when they were doing those City Opera shows, they were like sort of Broadway-ish, Broadway-sized.
[20:35] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And then out of, I mean, this is a crazy story, which I feel like I should probably tell you.
[20:41] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, please.
[20:42] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So the reason I got South Pacific was when I was at Northwestern, they had um, a professional team of writers and director brought a show to develop with students, and that was Gerald Friedman directing um, a show called America's Sweetheart, which had a book by Alfred Urey. No, I'm lying. A book by John Wideman, lyrics by Alfred Urey, and music by Bob Waldman. Um, Bob Waldman and Alfred Urey gave us Robber Bridegroom and John Wideman, you know, gave us uh Pacific Overtures and Assassins. He was a guest. So anyway, a very, uh, you know, high-level team. And I was the swing in America's Sweetheart at Northwestern. So I was barely involved, but I was in the room. And Jerry Friedman directed South Pacific at City Opera, and he just, I can't remember if I had to audition or if he just offered it to me.
Anyway, I ended up in South Pacific, and while I was doing the show, you know, I played Professor, you know, the CBs have like so much time off stage, as do the nurses, and I struck up a friendship, not just with Marcia who played Nellie, but also with Ivy Austin. Do you guys know who Ivy Austin is?
[22:00] Robert W. Schneider: I don't.
[22:00] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Ivy Austin had the distinction of playing the title role in the musical Raggedy Ann.
[22:00] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my gosh, of course, of course.
[22:08] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um, she's also featured in the movie Grease 2. But anyway, um, Ivy, um, Ivy and I became friends, and we used to go down to one of the practice rooms at City Opera during the show and like sing for, you know, we would have this 45-minute break, and we'd just go down and goof around. I would play for her and she would sing, or I would help her with her audition material. And so I sort of became her accompanist for a minute, and she asked me to play for her for her um Into the Woods audition. And so I went as her accompanist, and while I was there, Paul Geminiani, who was the conductor of South Pacific, said, "Well, Jeff, you're here. Do you just do you feel like singing?" And so I worked out a song with the accompanist. And, you know, he played "On the Street Where You Live" for me. And then I got a call.
[23:05] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, this is such a long story. Can you bear it?
[23:07] Kevin David Thomas: No, this is so good. I love it.
[23:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Okay. So the day after, or a day or two after that like random spur of the moment non-audition for Into the Woods, um, I get a call, or I think my agent got a call, uh, requesting me for a session where uh they needed actors for a core they were auditioning choreographers for Into the Woods, and they needed actors to basically learn the choreography to do, you know, for the choreographers who were auditioning. So I was like, uh, really, uh, how much? I was like testing the limits of like how much they were willing to pay. And then they, I think they were paying like, I don't know, at the time was 15 or 20 an hour or something. So I was like, okay, I'll do it. And I like go to this thing thinking it's gonna be, you know, some lame thing, and I walk into the room and it's Joanna Gleason, Chip Zien, Kim Crosby.
Um, you know, like all the people who would be in the cast of Into the Woods, and I recognize them from their work. You know, I'd seen Chip in Falsettos, and I'd seen Joanna in I Love My Wife, and I was like, holy shit, this is for real.
[24:26] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, and um, so I was gonna be playing Jack in this um, we were gonna learn the opening of Into the Woods. So I don't remember who the choreographer was, but I do remember that after we learned it, that Sondheim and Lapine came in and watched us do it, and I was like, holy shit. I mean, like, I am now in the room with everybody.
[24:52] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[24:52] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And I did that for them a couple of times, I think, and then around the second time, maybe Lapine was like, "Hey, you guys, I'm wondering, would you do a favor for me? I'm like chairing this benefit, and I thought it would be cool to premiere some songs from the show at this benefit. Would you all sing some songs?" So then I was learning, you know, the opening, and I was learning "Agony," and I was singing this in front of people at a benefit. This is like months before the show was even opening on Broadway. Now, the reason this was the reason I was doing it, any of these things was because Ben Wright, who was gonna be playing Jack on Broadway, was still in high school in Indiana, or I can't remember exactly where he's from, but you know, he was not available, so I was sort of the Jack stand, and but I also got to do "Agony."
I remember singing "Agony" with Howard McGillan at this benefit called um, it was called A Night with Stars of Broadway, and because of the alphabetical order, I was the first star of Broadway on that list.
[25:56] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[25:57] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Meanwhile, you know, one minute out of college. And so um, so I did that benefit, and then the next thing I did for them was a group sales presentation, and then they just offered me the show, like without ever having really auditioned for it.
[26:17] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[26:19] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Unreal. I mean, it's so crazy. So now I was the, I was an understudy. Oh, and by the way, I also did the workshop as Rapunzel's Prince because I was, my gig was covering Jack, Rapunzel's Prince, and the Steward. And Ben was able to do the workshop, but um, Bob Westenberg was not able to do the workshop. So the person who was playing Rapunzel's Prince got bumped up to Cinderella's Prince, and I played Rapunzel's Prince in the workshop.
[26:52] Robert W. Schneider: What was it like being in this workshop?
[26:54] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Unbelievable. I mean, I have stories about the workshop too.
[26:58] Kevin David Thomas: Please, please.
[27:01] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I mean, no, I can't remember. Who was the witch?
[27:03] Robert W. Schneider: He says I can't.
[27:10] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: The witch was to be played by Betty Buckley, but she was only available for the second week. So Suzanne Douglas, who was gonna be one of the witch covers, played The Witch for the first week, and then Betty played The Witch for the second week. And I mean, there are stories about Betty, but I can't tell those.
[27:37] Kevin David Thomas: I think we've heard them before, so I think we're okay.
[27:40] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I will give you a free pass on that one.
[27:43] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[27:44] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: But hearing, I mean, what is it like to be sitting in the room and in comes Mr. Sondheim and is like, can somebody try this out for me? I want to hear what this sounds like. And you're, and you're the first ones getting to hear this music.
[27:56] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: It's, I mean, there are really, you know, maybe like two people in the world where I uh stopped being able to uh process logical thought around. And he is one, and I think, uh, I believe Meryl Streep would be the other if I ever had to sit down and talk to her.
[28:16] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, of course.
[28:17] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So yeah, it was terrible. I mean, he was there and you know, I found myself in conversations with him occasionally and it's, you know, it's terrifying like you just cannot, cannot perform. I don't mean perform like sing, I mean perform like as a person in a conversation.
[28:34] Kevin David Thomas: How did the, how did the show change from the workshop phase to what was eventually seen on Broadway?
[28:40] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Massive changes, minor changes?
[28:42] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, it was pretty significant. Um, I'm trying to remember, I mean like the Baker's wife had a lot of different ends. Sometimes she lived, sometimes she didn't. Um, I'm trying to think what else, I mean there were whole other songs in the show at that point. Um, I mean a lot of the stuff, uh, was I think was developed at the Old Globe and stayed. The narrator and the baker's wife had the biggest like changes, the, you know, the mysterious old man becoming the narrator or not, or I mean no, he was always both, but sometimes the narrator got killed and sometimes the narrator didn't get killed. You know, stuff like that.
[29:29] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah, they were playing around with um, I will tell you this so there were so um, there was, there's no ensemble in Into the Woods so it requires a lot of off-stage covers.
[29:46] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So there were, I'm gonna say eight or nine of us in the Broadway production. And we had, you know, a whole society up there at the Martin Beck Theater. Just, you know, there were rooms of us, you know, like hanging out. A whole floor of understudies. And so we spent a lot of time together. We were very tight. And in previews, we were so sure that the song that had to go was "No One is Alone." Because we were all against this song. And I, you know, I maintain that, you know, that there are two ballads back to back in Act Two, and it's, you know, it's dark and it's rough. And we just thought that that song was kind of extra. And we were, you know, we were sure it was on the chopping block. And then I think it was like the week before the show got frozen. A big article came out in the Arts and Leisure section about how the centerpiece of the show was this song, "No One is Alone." And we were all went, crap, crap. Now they'll never cut it.
[31:01] Robert W. Schneider: What an incredible experience for you. I mean, how old are you at this point? You're just a couple of years out of college, right?
[31:07] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I was offered that show on my 22nd birthday.
[31:10] Robert W. Schneider: Oh.
[31:11] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[31:12] Robert W. Schneider: Jeez. And at the same time, I'm assuming you were auditioning for film and television as well, or was the primary focus just theater at that point in your life?
[31:19] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I couldn't get arrested in film and TV. In fact, I had an agent at the time who said that he wasn't even pushing me for that because I just wasn't a film or TV person.
[31:30] Robert W. Schneider: Oh.
[31:31] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, then I had to quit that agency.
[31:34] Robert W. Schneider: I was gonna say, because you've done so much film and television work.
[31:37] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, I mean, like a decent amount. And yeah, that was hard to hear, but you know, screw him.
[31:44] Robert W. Schneider: Good for you. That's I was gonna say, I mean, how do you keep your mental health throughout this? I mean, in this process of, you know, the beginning stages of your career when you hear things like that, how do you just not crumble?
[31:55] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I mean, there's a lot of ways to answer that question. I mean you, you know, you do crumble for a second, and then you get back on, you know, on the horse, and you keep a solid clan of friends around you, and you keep a lot of things in your life that interest you that are not your job.
[32:24] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And that you think that comes a lot from like what you were studying at Northwestern, this idea of there's another world out there besides show business.
[32:30] Robert W. Schneider: Well, I think that's available to anybody regardless of their education. I mean, that concept.
[32:33] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah. I think people, you know, in a business like ours that seems or feels so all-encompassing, they forget that they can have an existence outside of it.
[32:49] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah. When you're acting, what do you look for out of a director? To you, what's the ideal actor-director collaboration?
[32:54] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, that's an interesting question. I will say that when I graduated from college, I thought that the directors were just going to give me everything, like that I would show up at a kind of blank slate, and that the good director would effectively like paint the performance onto me. And what I learned right away was it's all you have to do everything, and that the best directors are gonna pick you because they trust you or they see something in you that you know they trust that you're going to deliver, and then it's on you to bring everything and to deliver. And in fact, a lot of directors aren't even good at the directing part, and they don't even know how to edit you and or, you know, make the whole machine work, and then you have to kind of be thinking of that too. I know I go into acting jobs very much with a director's hat on.
[34:02] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So I think the best directors are really good at editing and letting you explore.
[34:12] Robert W. Schneider: And if you don't mind my asking, I'm sure there's many that you could mention, but is there one director specifically you could cite that you know, you go, that's a fantastic director. I love being in the room with that person.
[34:20] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, it just so happens that I so remember I was talking about "Pajama Game," I met two of my best friends. Yes. One of those people was Casey Nicholaw.
[34:34] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, the previous guest. And Casey, so Casey and I have been friends since, you know, 1986, and but we have not worked together very much. I did a couple of quickies with him, but I just got to do a workshop of a new musical with him, and I just can't believe how good he is at it. He is so skilled in so many ways. Not just, I mean, his choreography is incredible, his global mind, like the way he's able to think of a moment, a scene, and the whole show all at the same time and, you know, figure out what's important and what are the things to deal with and how to interact with people, and you know, he's so good at it. So yeah, Casey, I'm gonna say Casey.
[35:09] Robert W. Schneider: That's pretty awesome. Tell us a little bit about doing "Damn Yankees," this very exciting production of "Damn Yankees."
[35:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh yeah, yeah, that was fun. That was, you know, I did, I did it at the Old Globe and then opened it on Broadway, and then I was done by Labor Day because I was going to do "How to Succeed," but it was a very sweet experience. I really thought everybody was working at the top of their game, and by everybody I mean Jack O'Brien as the director, Rob Marshall as the choreographer, and James Wait, who is one of the great losses of the AIDS epidemic. He was such a gifted arranger and conductor, and I just loved the texture he gave to that show with all the kind of transition vocals and, you know, rejiggering some of the songs. I thought that that show, unlike a lot of revivals, balanced the then of it and the now of it very well.
[37:07] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah. It's a beautiful production. Just, I mean, it was so funny and filled with such heart, no pun intended.
[37:15] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Hey podcast listeners, are you looking for a place to rehearse in New York City that is clean, spacious, and most importantly, affordable? Come check out Shetler Studios and Theatres, our wonderful host for these podcasts. Shetler is centrally located on West 54th Street between Broadway and Eighth Avenue, right in the heart of the theater district. Right in the heart, you'll find music, dance, and acting studios complemented by two black box theaters and six presentation venues. The professional facilities, inspired environment, and expert industry staff combine to provide the New York artist with an unparalleled studio experience. Visit their website at ShetlerStudios.com. That's S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. Shetler Studios and Theatres is our home for recording the legends of Broadway, and we hope that you make it your artistic home too. That's Shetler, S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com. See you here.
[38:13] Robert W. Schneider: So now "How to Succeed in Business"? Let's talk about this. This is a huge one for you.
[38:20] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[38:21] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah. How did you first get involved with it?
[38:24] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I had done a show with Des earlier in my career. I actually played Hero in "A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum." And that was at La Jolla Playhouse. And just anecdotally, because I'm not a typical choice for Hero, but the concept, I know from having been at the callback, was to either hire an idiosyncratic Hero and a typical Philia, or an idiosyncratic Philia and a typical Hero. And so the choice that the pairs were me and Pam Winslow, the original Rapunzel in "Into the Woods," or Annie Golden and Evan Pappas.
[39:11] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my god, and oh my gosh.
[39:13] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And he ended up picking Pam and me. And so I had worked with Des, and so I went into that audition as a known quantity, and I don't know, it was just kind of a nice fit. I also knew Joe Lesser a little bit because when I was at Northwestern, I did a production of, oh my god, I'm, oh, perfectly Frank, that Frank Lesser review, which she at least was at least a little involved in because Emily Lesser was a classmate of mine at Northwestern. So yeah, I went in as a known quantity from the director, the choreographer, and the widow of the writer. So I think that increased my chances of being cast. And it was a really, I mean that was an embarrassment of riches, I think that cast.
[40:13] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, tell us, I mean, this was an amazing, I mean tell us who all was in the show.
[40:16] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh my gosh. Well, obviously Matthew Broderick as Finch, and then the supporting cast was Mia's Frump, Megan Mullally as Rosemary, Vicky Clark as Smitty, Luba Mason as Hetty, Jonathan Freeman as Bratt, Jerry Vicky as Twimble, Ron Carroll as Bigley, and Lillius White as Ms.
[40:49] Robert W. Schneider: Oh god, I can't remember her character's name. Do you remember?
[40:52] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Ms. Jones.
[40:53] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[40:54] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yes. Did I do everybody?
[40:58] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, it's a crazy cast. I mean, that's a good thing. This is a home run across the board.
[41:01] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, and but we had there were other people hovering too. You know, Adrian Lennox did Lillius's break and other fancy people. I can't remember. We had Sarah Jessica. Actually, she was she came in after I left. I was replaced by Brooks Ashmanskas. So yeah, it was a very incredible cast. And surprisingly unacknowledged, like awards time cast, it was very weird, like award season. I remember thinking like "Smokey Joe's" was the same season, and they got a lot of performance love, and our cast just got like no performance award love.
[41:47] Robert W. Schneider: That's it, it is so bizarre to me.
[41:49] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, that is so bizarre. Because that cast was like genius across the board.
[41:54] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah. So I have to ask Jeff, because this, I mean, this role, I mean, was so associated with Charles Nelson Reilly for so many years. Did you feel like, oh shit, I got big shoes to fill, or do you just let that go and go we're creating something new in here?
[42:07] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: You know, I guess it, you know, it maybe didn't hang over my head as much as it might now in the YouTube generation. You know, it wasn't a super popular movie. So his performance was you maybe known from the cast recording, and he was a known quantity, you know, by virtue of what he did after that on "Match Game" or on "Bewitched" or wasn't he on "Bewitched" too? Or something anyway. He was, you know, he was a famous thing, but I don't feel like him as Frump was that famous. So I didn't, you know, I didn't think about it. I didn't think about it a lot.
[42:49] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, you put such a beautiful stamp on it. Such a fab, and it was so funny. You know, I mean I'm sure you get asked this question a lot, but is there any secret to doing comedy? Or how do you approach a comic role versus a dramatic role? Is there any difference?
[43:04] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Initially, no. I mean, I think what's important, at least, you know, everybody has a different approach. My approach to comedy, I, you know, I try and always come at it because I am a total pragmatist. So I really try, you know, I come at things logically and, you know, through reason and reality. And so I'm always, you know, 99% of the time I'm making comic choices because I believe them. And they're funny, but I don't just do things for the sake of being funny. I try and do things because they make sense and they're funny. And you know, that goes for my writing too. I'm not like just trying to crack a joke for the sake of the joke. I crack a joke if it serves the character story, etc. So, you know, the one exception I can think of is, you know, I did this show called "Murder for Two" that was, oh yeah, that was sort of like a, I mean there were a lot of jokes in that show that were kind of nonsensical you could say slapstick.
It was slapstick humor, I mean I think some of it definitely yes. And so, but you know, even so I tried to give all those characters a reality that I could at least I could buy into and that I was, you know, I was doing. I only did things that I believed. So that's my, I guess that's my, that's the most important thing I have to say about my comedy is that I only do it joke jokes that I believe in.
[44:46] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And so who makes you laugh? Yeah, I mean I can't think of anybody off the top of my head that is just like, oh my comedy spirit animal is... yeah, I mean I love a lot of the people on Saturday Night Live through the years. I think they're also so funny. Kate McKinnon is a genius. Oh my god, so many of them. I mean, uh, Kristen Wiig, I did see, I remember at the opening night of Book of Mormon, I found myself standing with Kristen Wiig and Jack McBrayer, and I was just like, I think it would be irresponsible of me not to take this opportunity to tell you how much joy you have provided in my life. That is awesome.
[45:30] Robert W. Schneider: That is absolutely awesome. Jeff, how are you balancing? Because you were doing a lot of performing. How are you balancing your writing side of your life while you were performing so much?
[45:40] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um, I would say I just follow the opportunities that inspire me. So if it's a performing opportunity and it sounds intriguing and exciting, I pursue it. And if it's a writing opportunity that sounds intriguing and exciting, I pursue it. And sometimes that happens at the same time, and sometimes that happens at different times. And so that's really the theme, is just following the inspiration.
[46:15] Robert W. Schneider: And were you writing throughout the 90s and the entire time that you had so many Broadway shows under your belt? Were you constantly writing, always?
[46:26] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: No, I was... so when I came to New York and I got into Into the Woods quickly, at the same time I joined the BMI workshop. And so I did my first year and second year, so what that would have been like '87, '88, '89. And um, it was a very active time for me, and I would write here or there, you know, I had some writing partners and we would do a little bit of this or a little bit of that, but it really wasn't a primary focus. And I think what really kind of pushed it to the foreground was when Audra McDonald recorded "I Won't Mind," which was I think around '99 or 2000, and so I was getting some attention as a writer, and that's when I started doing it more concertedly. And it also happened to coincide with the time that I thought, you know, maybe I don't need to act that much anymore.
I spent the last few years of the millennium in Los Angeles pursuing TV and film work. And while that was, you know, I did a decent amount of work, yeah, but it was very unsatisfying and ultimately frustrating. And at the time I thought, I don't even want to act anymore. And then Audra recorded the song, and I came back to New York, and at first I was like, I just want to work in the nonprofit arena, and I had a quick job at channel 13. I was like the office assistant around the telecast of The Man Who Came to Dinner, starring Nathan Lane. Oh, and I was like, oh, this is silly. I could just as easily be in that show. Like, why do I think it's a job worth doing if I'm sending faxes for the show when I could just as easily be in the show?
So I was like, okay, that's dumb. Okay, so I gave up on my nonprofit career, but I ended up, you know, coming back to acting in a different way, you know, in a more like, I'm only gonna do things that inspire me way. And um, and also writing.
[48:52] Robert W. Schneider: Now, how did Audra become aware of your song? Did you submit it to her? Did she just hear it and go, oh, I really like this? How did all that come to be?
[49:00] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, the song was written in like 1988, maybe, and Vicky Clark, who has been one of my best friends since then, had been singing it with her other best friend of hers, Ted Sperling, who was always her musical director. So Ted, you know, had played the song for Vicky one million times, and Ted became Audra's musical director, and he pitched the song to Audra, and she liked it.
[49:32] Robert W. Schneider: That's amazing. That's great. And when you say, you know, projects that inspire you in some way, I'm assuming A Class Act fits into that category.
[49:41] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Totally. I mean, in fact, they were doing A Class Act at Manhattan Theater Club off-Broadway, and they were having to replace like half the cast who weren't going to be available for the Broadway transfer. And Lonnie Price, who I didn't know at the time, reached out to me and he said, uh, I'm doing this show off-Broadway. It's closing this weekend, but I want you to audition for what I think you'd be great for this role of Marvin Hamlisch. Would you come see it? And I was like, oh, thanks. I'm not acting anymore, but thank you so much for thinking of me. He's like, just come see it. Just come see it. And I went to see it, and I was watching it, and then they sang the song "Better," and I was like, oh, I like that song.
And then it, you know, it's about musical theater writers. And by the end of the show, I was sobbing so hard, going, I have to do this show. And so I did the show. And that, you know, that was a crazy show in that like with I didn't even have to try. Every night in the like reading of the will scene, I would burst into tears like clockwork. It was so like that show touched me so deeply.
[50:57] Robert W. Schneider: And what do you do you have a favorite Ed Cleban song?
[51:02] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Uh, probably "Self-Portrait."
[51:03] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah. Um, and that show it was only on Broadway for a couple of months, right? And then how did you get involved with Urban Cowboy?
[51:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, you may or may not know that coming out of A Class Act, Lonnie and I were a couple for a few years.
[51:19] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[51:20] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And um, so Urban Cowboy was a project that had been shepherded along by a director. Uh, I'm spacing on his name. I think it might have been Phil Osterman.
[51:37] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, I think it is Philip Osterman, yeah.
[51:41] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yes. But he'd write the book as well. Uh, or maybe collaborated on it. You can't...
[51:46] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, because he's got he's he's credited with the book.
[51:48] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I mean, as a co-collaborator.
[51:50] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[51:51] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Okay, so um, so the Urban Cowboy was being shepherded along by its director Phil Osterman and Chase Mishkin, who was one of the producers of A Class Act, and um, Lonnie and Chase had become very close and were collaborating on many projects, and um, Phil Osterman died, uh, was like a matter of weeks, maybe like eight weeks before the show was supposed to start rehearsals for Coconut Grove pre-Broadway. And um, so Chase asked Lonnie to step in at the last minute to direct it. And the original concept Phil had was to do Urban Cowboy as a pre-existing songs only musical. And so when Lonnie inherited the show, he felt that the pre-existing country songs were not getting the story told well enough.
And so he started requesting custom songs for the show. And I think I was one of the first people to start writing songs because I had, you know, I had the inside track. I knew they were looking, and they had gone out to a bunch of people. And you know, it started out with I think an opening number. They, you know, a bunch of us wrote opening numbers. Mine didn't get picked for the record. It was um Bob Stillman's song. And then early in the process, they also replaced the musical director, and Jason Robert Brown became the musical director. So Jason started writing songs. I was writing songs. We were sort of getting, we were kind of divvying it up. Like I would get an, you know, I would get an assignment, Jason would get an assignment.
And you know, if they liked the song, it went in the show. So it was amazing. I mean, you know, you know that the gestation period for a musical from start to Broadway is, you know, seven years or something, typically, and I was writing songs on Thursday and hearing them on Broadway on Tuesday, you know, it was like crazy.
[53:58] Robert W. Schneider: That's wild.
[53:59] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[53:59] Robert W. Schneider: I actually loved Urban Cowboy. I had just moved to New York and I saw it twice as it were. Uh, and I really, yeah, and um, yeah, it actually, and in fact, we actually went to dinner once, Jeff. I didn't tell you, I wasn't gonna tell you this, but me, you, Lonnie, uh, Vicky Clark came, and my mentor, who was Jack Lee, an old music director who passed away a couple years ago.
[54:20] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh my god.
[54:20] Robert W. Schneider: And uh, we went to Joe Allen's together, and that's how and I remember hearing all about the process of this Urban Cowboy, uh, 'cause I'd already seen it, and Lonnie was like, oh, you should drop your resume off at the stage door. So and I thought and I thought, oh, this is so we're at Joe Allen's and I'm with these famous people. This is so old. I just, oh gosh, it was, yeah, it's a sweet little show.
[54:43] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, thanks.
[54:43] Robert W. Schneider: And uh, just for the record, Jack Lee made a huge difference in my life. He, I feel like he taught me how to act and sing at the same time.
[54:51] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Same, exactly. In fact, he 'cause I went to Baldwin Wallace College, which is where he went, uh, and when I came to New York, he took me under his wing and I think he did this for a lot of people, but he didn't charge me and he would just, and he's the first person that said, stop being so phony, you know, act like, come on, you know, be honest with this lyric, you know.
[55:10] Robert W. Schneider: I I'm so happy to hear that, uh, almost exact same thing with someone else. That's really special.
[55:16] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[55:17] Robert W. Schneider: Those uh, those kind of mentors, I think, uh, every uh, listeners all have the mentors like that, but those kinds of mentors are I think are so special. Do you, uh, mentor people as well? Um, have you ever as a composer or in the musician side of thing or acting?
[55:31] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I can't say I've ever taken like a person under my wing, but I do coach people. Um, I coach singers who act, and I coach some writers too, yeah. So I've done a little bit of both.
[55:46] Robert W. Schneider: I want to talk about it. 2005, the JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ songbook came out. What the f... I mean, I'm sure I hope you know how influential that songbook was for so many people that were in college at the time. And I mean beyond that, but I know specifically at all the musical theater programs I was familiar with, everyone just went to that book.
[56:08] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um, thanks. What was it like putting this together?
[56:12] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I'll tell you the story. So um, Marcy Heisler and Zina Goldrich had published their big first book of songs, and they gave me one. I think maybe because I was a friend and I had sung for them and on demos and whatnot. And I just, I looked at this gorgeous, beautiful book and I was like, oh, that's sweet, but who's gonna buy it? I mean, they don't have any shows on Broadway, and who's gonna buy this book? And then they were telling me, yeah, they sell a lot of books, and I'm like, wow, I guess you don't have to be a famous Broadway writer to have a songbook. So I was like, all right, I'm gonna have a songbook, and so I picked their brains about how they got theirs done, and I basically self-published my songbook.
And uh, I think my ahead of my time idea was to do the podcast alongside the book, which was a way for... I wanted people to be able to hear my songs because I knew there weren't recordings of them out there, they weren't, you know, they weren't from shows that people could go see, and I wanted a free way for people to be able to listen to the songs without, you know, so they could know that they did or didn't want the book. And uh, and these singers, like you had like Broadway's Who's Who for this podcast, which listeners, this pod you talk about ahead of your time. This started in like 2010.
[57:49] Robert W. Schneider: No, or even five.
[57:51] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Isn't even five, yeah. 2005, see that's like this is way ahead of the game, yeah. And it's great. Listeners, go, go, go to... I mean, I'll feature this in the favorite thing at some point on our other podcast. But the JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ songbook podcast is so fantastic because you talk about the songs, you set them up, and then this you either you or Broadway singer performs them. Uh, and it's... I loved it.
[58:12] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Thank you.
[58:13] Robert W. Schneider: So Jeff, I'm just curious. I just want to play a game with you. So if you could take any singer who's no longer with us and have them sing one of your songs, who would the singer be and what would the song be?
[58:24] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Uh, well I have a kind of complicated response to that. The singer who I'm gonna say is no longer with us is 1960s Barbara Streisand.
[58:33] Robert W. Schneider: 1960s Barbara Streisand.
[58:42] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: It counts.
[58:42] Robert W. Schneider: It counts.
[58:44] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: And let's see, what would I make sixties Barbara sing? I don't know anything. I mean, I just thought sixties Barbara was nailing it in every department.
[58:57] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[58:58] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: But uh, I can't think of a specific song of mine. I just, because you know, the songs I feel like my songs are kind of, I don't know, kind of of their time, and so it doesn't line up with sixties Barbara, but that's the person who I think is no longer with us.
[59:23] Robert W. Schneider: It's funny. We'll take it. We'll take it. And then you did it, then you did a second podcast, and you did the BMI workshop songbook podcast.
[59:30] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Now, was this your idea?
[59:31] Robert W. Schneider: It was.
[59:32] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I wanted to um, you know, find a way to take this, you know, formula I had invented for myself and give it to uh community that I loved.
[59:42] Robert W. Schneider: It's great.
[59:43] Kevin David Thomas: What now what's it like being in the BMI workshop? What do you gain from that?
[59:46] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I had an amazing exper I I you know I learned most of what I know about musical theater writing from that experience. It's great because it you know you're not only getting the kind of education uh firsthand, but you're also listening to a lot of other people's attempts and you're hearing what works, what doesn't work for any number of people. And you get, you know, in the first year you get uh a lot of different collaborators, so you learn about collaboration and you learn about you know attacking different kinds of uh assignments and um it's designed really well, it's executed really well, it is free, it's um it's a little competitive to get into. I know I I coached a writer through a failed application and then a successful application.
[1:00:31] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, that's interesting.
[1:00:40] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: So um I know it's not it's not a no-brainer getting in, but it's really worth it. God, I don't know how they're gonna do it now in uh in this coronavirus era. But um, yeah, I I found it to be invaluable. I'd love to talk to you about somebody you collaborate with a lot, and that's Alicia Umfris. Um how how did that collaboration come about?
[1:01:04] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: She is a genius, but I'm sure you knew that.
[1:01:06] Robert W. Schneider: I do know that, and uh I agree a hundred percent.
[1:01:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um I met Alicia and one of my other newer best friends through an organization called Raw Impressions, which does not exist anymore. But Raw Impressions was a group that produced these kind of gorilla creative ventures. Um, you get together, and uh people get together and create 10 minute musicals in a weekend kind of thing. It's not as ridiculous as the 24-hour musicals, which I've also done. So you would uh they would put people together to do uh either uh 10 minute musicals really fast, or movie musicals really fast, or dance pieces really fast, or plays, or you know, it each festival would have a different theme. And I met Alicia. This is a funny story. Um so what happens is on the first day, everybody gets put in the same room, and you've got the writers, the composers, the directors, the choreographers, the performers, and you don't know who's gonna get put together with whom.
So the first thing that happens is all the performers get up and sing. And I walk in the room, and I see the first person I see is Alicia, but I don't know her yet, and she's just she's wearing these ridiculous snow boots, they look like abominable snowman boots, like furry up to the knee, and she's wearing like 10 pounds of makeup, and I'm just like anyone but her. I'll take anyone but her.
[1:03:10] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: She sings it like a stalker, and it's so funny and it's so witty and original. And after she finished singing, I was like, I must have her. And they assigned me randomly to write for her. So it was an amazing uh stroke of luck. And we ended up writing a stalker role for her because it was she was so inspired in her performance. So that's how we met Alicia, and we just you know couldn't get enough of each other and just kept being friends and kept wanting to work together, and so to this day, you know, we still concertize, and I you know, I long for the day when we'll be cast in a show together.
[1:03:57] Kevin David Thomas: Oh well, I'm I'm sure that will happen. I'm keeping my fingers crossed for that.
[1:04:01] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, and I should mention that uh she she recorded a uh a CD of my jazz songs and arrangements, so it's it's gorgeous, and the two of you work so beautifully together.
[1:04:12] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you. What a fortune for all of us in the audience to get to watch that. Um would you talk a little bit about Bright Star, which is one of my favorite shows within the past 20 years, and I Kevin I know feels the same way, and I know a lot of other people feel the same way. What was that process like?
[1:04:28] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: It was a gorgeous production.
[1:04:31] Robert W. Schneider: Thanks.
[1:04:32] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: I came to it very late. I you know, it had had many iterations before I joined, which was in the Kennedy Center pre Broadway, and um, so I don't know that much about how it developed in the early stages, but I will say that um I think that the um the contribution that I was the most in awe of was that of Josh Rhodes. Oh my god. The way he built the movement. And it was most yes, it was most evidenced by um what happened with the song Asheville. When we were performing the show at the Kennedy Center, and I think as it had been performed in every production leading up to the Kennedy Center, Margot, um, Hannah Ellis would just stand on the stage by herself and sing this beautiful song, Asheville.
And evidently there was a production meeting after um the Kennedy Center production closed where they said, Okay, well, we think we could we're gonna have to cut Asheville. It's just not, you know, moving the story along, it's not, you know, doing it's not serving the show well. And Edie was gonna, I think maybe Edie had even written a song to replace it, and Josh was like, wait a second, no one has ever let me stage this song. So I insist that you let me stage Asheville, and then if you don't like it, you can cut it. And so in the rehearsal period between Kennedy Center and Broadway, he staged Asheville, and I remember like going stepping in to watch it in the rehearsal room, and I literally like burst into tears, and I thought, like everything everything in the show that made me burst into tears was either Josh's contribution or the amazing performances by um uh Carmen Kisak and Paul Nolan, who every time in the rehearsal room were like reducing us to tears.
In fact, the director, um, Walter Bobby had to make a speech once, and he was he he said, if you can't control, like if you can't watch the scenes before yours and like have your shit together for you to come on for your scene, like don't watch them.
[1:07:02] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[1:07:03] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Because we'd all come on with like running noses and tearing eyes. So Josh is a genius. I really think Josh is a genius. Everything I've seen of his, I'm just always over the moon by. He is incredible. Um, and now you also did a couple of really unique projects at Lincoln Center. You did their Candeed and you did their Sweeney Todd, which is like getting shot out of a cannon, right? I mean, there's like no very little rehearsal time. Is that correct?
[1:07:29] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah, wait, who's who was that Kevin or Rob?
[1:07:32] Robert W. Schneider: Rob.
[1:07:33] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um, you were there, weren't you?
[1:07:36] Robert W. Schneider: Yes.
[1:07:37] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yes, but nobody wants to be able to do that. I'm like, you're being called to do it.
[1:07:42] Robert W. Schneider: No, nobody wants to hear my version. They want to hear your version.
[1:07:45] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, well, um, yes, I have to say, watching those videos, it's like crazy. You're like, I did that. Because, you know, you're you rehearse so quickly, and in in many cases, not even with the people you're gonna end up doing the show with. You're rehearsing, everybody's rehearsing in their own little vacuum, and then you get thrown together for three magical nights where you know you pull it out of your ass and it gets filmed. And so, you know, imagine like a cabaret show that you did three times in 2004. Like, that's how well you remember this thing. Except it got filmed and people watch it, and people say, Oh, you know, you I saw you in Candide, I saw you in Sweeney Todd. I'm like, wow, I like I can't be held responsible for my work in those shows because one of my fate one of my favorite memories of working on that Sweeney Todd was um it was the day that Mr. Sondheim came to watch everything, and he was sitting there and taking notes, and Jeff came on, and Jeff had a line. Um, it was Mother's Favorites when he's explaining the song to Mrs. Lovett. And the way Jeff said it, Mr. Sondheim laughed so uproariously he almost fell out of the chair.
[1:09:04] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Well, I actually I I Rob, I have a different interpretation of that, which is like I think it I think what he was laughing at was I don't think the Beatle had ever tried to come on to Mrs. Lovett before. Like that was the choice that that was the turnoff I made that I I think he had never seen, and he did. He he laughed for he laughed like outrageously loud for like a solid minute, and like oh yes, I came off from that scene, and people were like, What was going on out there? And I was like, I think Sondheim was laughing at my choice.
[1:09:39] Robert W. Schneider: He he was he was and it was it was there was a very magical moment that Jeff provided for everybody.
[1:09:47] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Thank you. And so now so now Jeff, I mean, what's what's coming down the pike for you? What's next?
[1:09:54] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Gosh, I you know, I did that workshop with Casey that could turn into a production, but uh you know, I hesitate to say what it is because of course, of course, you know, who knows when we're gonna have theater again.
[1:10:08] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah.
[1:10:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Um, I have a writing project that's dancing in my um dancing on the horizon. I'm awaiting uh being assigned a collaborator for that. So again, I d I hesitate to get more specific than that. And otherwise, um, uh nothing.
[1:10:27] Robert W. Schneider: Good. You get get a little break for yourself.
[1:10:29] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, I'm making this really bizarre bread right now. Um, so I've been baking my way through this book called The Rye Baker. I got I'm like uniquely interested in in the grain rye. But I needed to take a break from rye, so I'm making this sourdough. I mean, it's crazy. Sourdough masala chai bread. It has like coconut and chai spice in it. It's gonna be it's gonna be crazy. It's gonna, it's not gonna make any sense, but I'm gonna try it anyway.
[1:11:01] Kevin David Thomas: Well, Kevin and I will send you our addresses.
[1:11:01] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Uh-huh.
[1:11:01] Kevin David Thomas: And we look forward to to sampling. Jeff, I I cannot tell you how much we appreciate you taking time out to talk to us today. This has just been fantastic.
[1:11:09] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, it's my pleasure. Thank you for asking.
[1:11:11] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you. And I don't know, maybe Lonnie told you, I can't remember, but we're doing a class act in September um in the city. And I hope if you know, if you want, I hope you'll come see it.
[1:11:20] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, amazing.
[1:11:22] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[1:11:23] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Thank you.
[1:11:23] Robert W. Schneider: I can revisit.
[1:11:24] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Yeah.
[1:11:25] Robert W. Schneider: But this has been just a joy, Jeff. Thank you for everything.
[1:11:27] JEFF BLUMENKRANTZ: Oh, thanks for having me.
[1:11:29] Robert W. Schneider: All right. Till next time, everybody. Take care.
[1:11:33] Robert W. Schneider: Today's episode was recorded at Shetler Studios on 244 West 54th Street. Visit Shetler Studios to book your room today, and you could be as cool as us. That's S-H-E-T-L-E-R-Studios.com.
[1:11:46] Robert W. Schneider: And a big thanks to our sound editor Daniel Schwartzberg and social media manager Bethany and Selecki. And friends, don't forget, we want more folks to hear these incredible stories. And that's where you guys can come in and help us out.
[1:11:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, in order for people to find out about us, we need lots of ratings on iTunes. The more ratings, the more they'll come up in searches. So head on over to iTunes, search for behind the curtain Broadway's Living Legends, click on our logo, click on ratings and reviews, then write a review and leave us five stars and make us feel as special as Eliza Doolittle on Eliza Doolittle Day.
[1:12:20] Robert W. Schneider: Or you can leave us one star and make us feel as bad as Annie did in that weird production in Boston where Annie dreamed about being adopted and then ended the show back in the orphanage. True story, Rob was there.
[1:12:34] Kevin David Thomas: So head on over to iTunes and make us feel even more special than we already do.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
