Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#24 STEPHEN COLE, Writer

There are three types of musical theatre lovers: Fan, Obsessed, and Stephen Cole. Stephen, who has had a wonderfully varied career as a lyricist and librettist, invited Rob & Kevin over to the musical theatre mecca he calls his apartment to talk about the craft of writing, meeting Merman, and how social media sites, like Facebook's Forgotten Musicals page, is uniting musical theatre fans from across the globe!.. Read More

From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast

48 mins
7/11/16

About

There are three types of musical theatre lovers: Fan, Obsessed, and Stephen Cole. Stephen, who has had a wonderfully varied career as a lyricist and librettist, invited Rob & Kevin over to the musical theatre mecca he calls his apartment to talk about the craft of writing, meeting Merman, and how social media sites, like Facebook's Forgotten Musicals page, is uniting musical theatre fans from across the globe! Also, Stephen goes to Qatar, dances for Bob Fosse, and answers musical theatre's most important questions!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Robert W. Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.

[0:01] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.

[0:02] Robert W. Schneider: And this is Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends.

[0:05] Kevin David Thomas: Don't forget to follow us on Twitter at Broadway Curtain and on Instagram at Broadway Curtain Podcast.

[0:11] Robert W. Schneider: And make sure to join our Facebook page at Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends.

[0:15] Kevin David Thomas: A person's passion for musical theater can be divided into one of three categories: Fan, Obsessed, or STEPHEN COLE.

[0:23] Robert W. Schneider: That's right. Stephen has not only written the book and lyrics for such musicals as After the Fair, The Night of the Hunter, The Road to Qatar, and most recently Merman's Apprentice. He is also one of the world's foremost experts on the history of the American musical.

[0:37] Kevin David Thomas: Now, if you don't believe us, just go to the Facebook page, Forgotten Musicals, and see STEPHEN's brilliance firsthand.

[0:43] Robert W. Schneider: So without further ado, here to talk about all things musical theater is lyricist, librettist, historian, musical theater super fan, STEPHEN COLE.

[0:52] STEPHEN COLE: Well, hello.

[0:53] Robert W. Schneider: Hello, I love STEPHEN COLE.

[0:54] STEPHEN COLE: I didn't get nominated today for any of those things.

[0:58] Kevin David Thomas: Absolutely.

[0:58] STEPHEN COLE: Because I don't have a Broadway show on now.

[1:00] STEPHEN COLE: I mean, what do they think it is?

[1:01] Robert W. Schneider: Technicalities.

[1:02] STEPHEN COLE: Yet. Yet, yet, I have to say, every musical theater aficionado must be jealous of us because we are conducting this interview under a huge poster of Grind.

[1:11] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, right, friends of Grind.

[1:13] STEPHEN COLE: And there is a beautiful, is that an oil portrait of Ethel Merman?

[1:18] STEPHEN COLE: A young 38, yeah.

[1:20] STEPHEN COLE: Also found in an antique store in Nyack.

[1:23] Robert W. Schneider: You're killing me.

[1:23] STEPHEN COLE: I always think, I always thought when I saw this and they didn't know what it was, I said, Oh, this must have been in Helen Hayes' house.

[1:29] Kevin David Thomas: Right.

[1:30] STEPHEN COLE: I don't know why. Because it was in Nyack.

[1:33] STEPHEN COLE: And she lived there.

[1:34] STEPHEN COLE: And Rosie O'Donnell bought the house and threw it out.

[1:36] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know.

[1:37] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah, totally.

[1:37] STEPHEN COLE: But it's a gorgeous portrait of her, yes.

[1:39] STEPHEN COLE: And it's by a portrait artist who did celebrity portraits in the 1930s.

[1:46] STEPHEN COLE: Actually, more society people.

[1:48] STEPHEN COLE: A guy named Trephillis.

[1:50] STEPHEN COLE: I've done my research.

[1:52] STEPHEN COLE: But I have to go on Antiques Roadshow, and they'll tell you.

[1:54] STEPHEN COLE: Oh, you restore that damn thing because it's a mess.

[1:57] Robert W. Schneider: How did your relationship with Ethel Merman develop?

[2:00] STEPHEN COLE: Well, my God, that's a long story. But I've always been a huge fan of Ethel Merman. So when I was an actor when I started out, and I wrote a show when I was 15, which I got on at 16, but all that's beyond. And my acting career ended sort of by my own hand at 21 because I stopped looking 12.

[2:21] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah.

[2:21] STEPHEN COLE: And that's when I was tired from acting. I was heavily veiled. No longer a juvenile.

[2:26] STEPHEN COLE: I was not 12 years old anymore. And I didn't know quite what to do, whether to go back to writing, or so I was going to produce.

[2:33] STEPHEN COLE: Why not? And it was so easy. And so I decided I wanted to produce Ethel Merman's symphony concert on cable TV. It was the early days of cable. And I had friends who were in the TV business. We did a budget, we did promotion.

[2:49] STEPHEN COLE: Well, I called up her manager after a concert, and I said, Hey, I want to do Ethel Merman on TV. And he said, Sure, she's going to be playing Carnegie Hall next year. Why don't you start peddling that? We got Kraft Cheese to sponsor it. It's going to be a Kraft Music Hall on CBS Cable.

[3:07] STEPHEN COLE: And two months before the concert, CBS Cable went under. No more. They're doing the concert at Carnegie Hall. I go to see it with my friend now her manager, Bob Godner. And he takes me backstage and she says, I'm coming to your house because I had all this video of her, and she wanted to see it.

[3:27] STEPHEN COLE: Two days later, she was here in this very living room, right here, sitting, and we watched videos of her from 1930 shorts from the 60s with her son, with Anna Sosenko, who was a producer of her concert, and she started coming over frequently and bringing her friends.

[3:44] Robert W. Schneider: I'm picking my jaw up off the floor right now.

[3:46] STEPHEN COLE: It was really, I was told, don't act like a fan. So I didn't. I was just her friend.

[3:52] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. And I was this kid of 20. I can't believe the tenacity you had.

[3:56] STEPHEN COLE: And it was amazing. It was amazing to open the door, and there was Ethel Merman to look out the window when she was coming up the stairs.

[4:02] Kevin David Thomas: Incredible.

[4:02] STEPHEN COLE: But so we started to get really friendly. She would bring all her friends over to watch these videos. She brought Benet Venuta, her best friend. She brought Maria Karnilova, who was thrilling to meet.

[4:14] STEPHEN COLE: And she and Karnilova would talk about Gypsy sitting on my couch, you know, talking about, oh Ethel, I would cry every night you did Rose's Turn. I go, Oh my God, oh my God. And we would watch stuff, and she would sit cross-legged on the floor and talk.

[4:26] STEPHEN COLE: Just old clips of her performing. Oh, major stuff from the 60s. She would say, You see me over there? That's 1964. That dress I wasn't wearing a bra. Today, if I didn't wear a bra, they'd hit the floor.

[4:40] STEPHEN COLE: But that was Ethel. She was so funny. This was all before YouTube.

[4:43] Robert W. Schneider: So how did you imagine?

[4:45] STEPHEN COLE: I had it was a thing called VHS.

[4:48] STEPHEN COLE: VHS. We had VHS tapes and film, actual film. And actually, when she passed away, she had left me some of the kinescopes, which were the films from her TV shows from the 50s. And a couple of things. One of them, Anything Goes, with Frank Sinatra and Bert Lahr, I was able to lease to a company it's out on DVD.

[5:09] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, fabulous.

[5:09] STEPHEN COLE: Which is really exciting. And she would have loved that. But she loved watching her stuff and commenting and saying, at one point she's watching an old short from the 1930s she made in Astoria, Queens. And she said, Oh my god, my voice is so tinny. I sound like Ann Miller.

[5:28] STEPHEN COLE: And we would say, No, Ethel, it was the recording. She said, No, no, that was how I sounded. Oh my god.

[5:34] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, how funny.

[5:35] STEPHEN COLE: It was very funny. And she became, which is why Merman's Apprentice, the show going way for fast forward now, exists is because I knew the real Ethel. She was just a regular New York dame who walked the streets of New York and, you know, couldn't get a cab, and we, you know, had to put her on a bus and things like she was a great, she was really fun and vulnerable and nice.

[5:57] STEPHEN COLE: And she'd call me up. I remember getting answering the phone, she said, I'm gonna be on the Tonys and the Oscars, and I go, Of course you are, you're Ethel Merman.

[6:08] STEPHEN COLE: But she was like she was 12.

[6:10] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[6:10] STEPHEN COLE: It was still exciting.

[6:11] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, yeah.

[6:12] STEPHEN COLE: And so that was the great part. So that's how I knew her.

[6:15] Kevin David Thomas: Wow, you know, it's I can understand why she'd really care to see herself perform. You nowadays I feel like we take for granted that everything's recorded.

[6:22] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah.

[6:22] Kevin David Thomas: But you know, in her day, she didn't get to see herself very often.

[6:25] STEPHEN COLE: Exactly.

[6:26] STEPHEN COLE: And I love it. That literally they would send the kinescopes that would be put away in a closet for years, and she'd never thought about it again.

[6:35] STEPHEN COLE: It's incredible. And it was really fun to do and to see the people in the show. She would watch movies, as I said, from 1930, and she would say, Oh, yeah, he went out with Dorothy Hammerstein before she met Oscar.

[6:46] Kevin David Thomas: What?

[6:47] STEPHEN COLE: You knew that kind of stuff.

[6:49] Kevin David Thomas: What began your sort of knowledge of Merman? Like how, what did anything trigger it when you were a kid?

[6:55] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah, I mean, I had records. Remember records?

[6:58] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah.

[6:59] STEPHEN COLE: Real records. I had the records. I had Annie Get Your Gun from Lincoln Center. It knocked me out.

[7:04] STEPHEN COLE: I didn't know, all right.

[7:05] STEPHEN COLE: All right, I belonged to in those days, you belonged to record clubs. I was a little kid, belonged to the RCA Record Club, which meant you could not get Columbia Records.

[7:13] STEPHEN COLE: So I had no idea there was such a thing as the original cast album of Gypsy because I had the movie.

[7:19] STEPHEN COLE: Ros Russell. And I had Ros Russell, who was dubbed by Lisa Kirk. Of course.

[7:23] Kevin David Thomas: And one day I listened to a radio show just like this. And I heard Ethel singing Rose's Turn instead of Lisa Kirk or Roz Russell. And I was just knocked out of my...

[7:40] Kevin David Thomas: Because you grew up in Brooklyn, right?

[7:41] STEPHEN COLE: I grew up in Brooklyn, so I'm lucky. My mother took me to shows.

[7:44] Kevin David Thomas: And your first one was?

[7:45] STEPHEN COLE: Hello, Dolly.

[7:47] Kevin David Thomas: With Betty Grable.

[7:48] STEPHEN COLE: But Betty Grable is then and Merman was the first time I went back to a show, you know, where I would see somebody else in it because I just kind of had this feeling this isn't going to happen again.

[8:00] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah.

[8:01] STEPHEN COLE: And I was right.

[8:02] Kevin David Thomas: Now, besides Hello, Dolly, what else did you see growing up?

[8:04] STEPHEN COLE: Oh, Mame.

[8:06] STEPHEN COLE: Mame was the second show. And that killed me. That was the best.

[8:09] Kevin David Thomas: With Janice Page.

[8:10] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. Lansbury was gone. I got to tell Janice Page, you were my Mame.

[8:15] STEPHEN COLE: I was so excited to meet her. And it was that was the first time I sat in the orchestra at the Winter Garden.

[8:21] STEPHEN COLE: And so it was much better than the third balcony of the St. James. And it was it knocked me out that show. Just Mame killed me.

[8:29] STEPHEN COLE: Oh, but I saw I was lucky I was in that era. And the 70s came, and there was Company and there was Follies, and there was A Little Night Music, and there was specific overtures. And those shows just I knew I was seeing incredible shows then.

[8:44] STEPHEN COLE: And cheap, two dollars.

[8:47] Kevin David Thomas: And did you always know, because you were producer, young age, actor, young age, book writer, writer. Did you always know that you were going to be in the arts in some way?

[8:56] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah, I was that kid who wanted to be a performer, you know, didn't get enough love. The whole baloney. So I performed early, and I was I was in summer stock at 14.

[9:06] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[9:07] STEPHEN COLE: And I was it was it was me and Chuck Bush.

[9:11] Kevin David Thomas: I love.

[9:11] STEPHEN COLE: So you wrote, because I read somewhere that you wrote one of your first songs.

[9:15] STEPHEN COLE: I wrote my one of my first songs. No, because Chuck and his friend Andy Halliday, who was Andy Cohen then.

[9:22] Kevin David Thomas: Uh-oh.

[9:24] STEPHEN COLE: Andy still works with Charles and his shows. And they had written the book of a show, and they had no score. And they I don't know why they came over to me and said, maybe you want to write songs. And I just went off on the corner and wrote my first song.

[9:36] Kevin David Thomas: That's incredible.

[9:37] STEPHEN COLE: And I thought, well, if they can do it, I can write a show.

[9:40] Robert W. Schneider: That's right, STEPHEN. That's exactly right.

[9:42] STEPHEN COLE: What the hell? I can write a show too.

[9:43] Kevin David Thomas: Now, what else in Brooklyn did you grow up?

[9:46] STEPHEN COLE: Where?

[9:46] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah.

[9:46] STEPHEN COLE: Way out in Canarsie.

[9:49] STEPHEN COLE: The last stop on the L.

[9:51] Kevin David Thomas: Randy Graff territory. That's where she's from.

[9:53] STEPHEN COLE: The last stop on the L train. It used to be called the L train.

[9:58] STEPHEN COLE: Not a good line. An hour. But it was close enough to keep coming in and seeing shows. And that was that was the best.

[10:05] Kevin David Thomas: Now you named all the big ones that you saw. What about some of the forgotten ones?

[10:09] STEPHEN COLE: I think the first flop I saw on Broadway.

[10:12] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, we can use the word flop. That's good to know.

[10:13] STEPHEN COLE: Okay, good. It was a flop. It was a flop.

[10:15] STEPHEN COLE: Lovely Ladies, Kind Gentlemen. Which I thought was as good as any other show I saw.

[10:20] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know.

[10:20] STEPHEN COLE: I don't know. You guys, I know.

[10:21] Kevin David Thomas: You don't know Lovely Ladies, Kind Gentlemen?

[10:23] STEPHEN COLE: I'm ashamed.

[10:23] Kevin David Thomas: Steven shaming right now.

[10:29] STEPHEN COLE: Yes. Showed us some of the YouTube clips from it.

[10:31] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, that's right.

[10:32] STEPHEN COLE: That's what I'm saying. It's a musical version of the Tea House of the August Moon. And it starred David Burns.

[10:41] STEPHEN COLE: Because he was friends with the bigger thing. Because that's right.

[10:45] STEPHEN COLE: Ruby David Burns, exactly. Ron Husman was in it. And Ray MacRamsey. Who did the music? It was Stan Freeman and Frank Underwood.

[10:54] STEPHEN COLE: And Stan Freeman had written I Had a Ball. He's had two big. And to be clear, Frank Underwood, the lyricist composer, not Frank Underwood from House of Cards.

[11:02] Kevin David Thomas: Correct.

[11:02] STEPHEN COLE: Thank you. Just so we're clear.

[11:04] STEPHEN COLE: I know in the time I've watched everything. But you didn't write Lovely Ladies, Kind Gentlemen.

[11:08] STEPHEN COLE: I would love if he did. I don't even know. I don't know where Frank Underwood is now.

[11:14] STEPHEN COLE: But there was a time that he was playing at a piano bar in Greenwich Village, and he would play songs from the show. And I'd go, Oh my God, it's right. I remember that.

[11:22] Kevin David Thomas: Go to Maurice Crisis.

[11:24] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[11:27] STEPHEN COLE: And I knew Stan Freeman a little bit later on, so it was kind of nice. But it was a good show. It was it was one of the first controversial shows on Broadway where they had Asian characters not played by Asian actors.

[11:43] Kevin David Thomas: And so they're 1970.

[11:47] STEPHEN COLE: Because Merman was across the street in Dolly. And it was at the Majestic.

[11:51] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.

[11:52] STEPHEN COLE: And but that was one of the first flops. I love going to things like that. You know, I didn't I did not get to see Aree. I always regretted that. Because it had the concentration camp ballet, and I missed it.

[12:05] STEPHEN COLE: That's a regret in life. I missed that. I also missed Jimmy. I wanted to see Jimmy, which was at the Winter Garden, and I didn't get to see that. And my biggest regret that my mother made me miss was I Do I Do, which was not a flop, of course. And because she would not go see that show because it only had two actors in it. And it was two of them. It wasn't worth running and Mary Martin. So we saw Golden Rainbow with STEPHEN E. Stephen Edy, which was great. I loved it. You know, that was the thing. When you're 12, you love everything. It was great.

[12:38] Kevin David Thomas: And your parents were supportive of this?

[12:42] STEPHEN COLE: Going to shows, sure. Absolutely. Were they supportive of me as a performer? Eh. You know, they didn't think that was a good idea. They wanted me to make money. Sure. Sure. And that wasn't gonna happen, really. I mean, I did Summerstock for three years in a row as an apprentice.

[12:58] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. You know what you make as an apprentice.

[12:59] STEPHEN COLE: Of course. Nothing.

[13:01] Kevin David Thomas: No. What did your folks do for a living?

[13:03] STEPHEN COLE: My father was a salesman in men's hats. And my mother was a housewife, but she also was a bookkeeper. Just average, normal people who in those days, average normal people lived in New York, all went to the theater.

[13:18] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[13:18] STEPHEN COLE: Because it was affordable.

[13:20] Kevin David Thomas: Because you could.

[13:21] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. I remember them sitting around looking in the newspaper going, oh, we'll see cabaret, we'll see fiddle. You know, we went to Fiddler, we did all. I wasn't allowed to see cabaret till later. That was a pretty dirty show.

[13:30] Kevin David Thomas: That was a little racy.

[13:34] STEPHEN COLE: Oh, that was naughty. They came home just laughing about the two ladies' numbers. That was naughty. But that's great. I mean, to see so many things that were affordable.

[13:44] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, at that when it was affordable.

[13:46] STEPHEN COLE: And then I had all the records, which you know, just made me imagine the shows. And isn't today Happy Sixties to most happy fellas?

[13:56] Kevin David Thomas: 60 years ago.

[13:58] STEPHEN COLE: Happy 60, most happy fellow. Do you see that at Encores?

[14:02] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I loved it.

[14:03] STEPHEN COLE: I loved it. It was gorgeous. It was really gorgeous. That was a beautiful production.

[14:07] Kevin David Thomas: I did you know what I did not see? And thoughts on this? The two piano version.

[14:11] STEPHEN COLE: I did. I didn't see it. I saw it. It was fine. It was two pianos.

[14:15] Kevin David Thomas: I didn't hear to it.

[14:17] STEPHEN COLE: I just listened to it a week. The orchestra, the orchestra is very important to that show. Yeah. And I did it was okay. It was an okay cast, but the Encores was pretty lush, and you heard it. And Laura Benanti deserved a Tony for that. She was that good.

[14:29] Kevin David Thomas: She was so very special in that.

[14:33] STEPHEN COLE: So I'm glad she's in. She loves me because I'm not sure.

[14:36] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, absolutely. She's wonderful in that as well. She can do no wrong in my book.

[14:40] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. Now you did a lot of background acting in films.

[14:46] Kevin David Thomas: Background artist, I think as well as it was.

[14:47] STEPHEN COLE: Oh, extras we called them.

[14:48] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, sir. Background America.

[14:50] STEPHEN COLE: But of course, my most famous one, you know, which I have photos now because I have sneak snapshots from All That Jazz. I'm in the opening number of All That Jazz. And that was the most fun I had, I think, because it's such a brilliant movie. And we had to learn Bob Fosse's audition. Period. So we did the tap. We did the ballet. And I was at the Palace Theater for a week shooting with all these other people. We were all the rejects, and then they brought in the real dancers.

[15:20] Kevin David Thomas: And but you've seen that number. It's spectacular.

[15:22] STEPHEN COLE: It's you know, took a week to film.

[15:25] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[15:26] STEPHEN COLE: Our part of it. We were there for a week. And it was great. I thought I never met Bob Fosse, but now I've seen this little documentary on YouTube, and I see him sitting up on a ladder, and there I am, very close to him dancing, which is what made me laugh.

[15:41] Kevin David Thomas: So we can add dancing to the book.

[15:45] STEPHEN COLE: When you're a background artist, okay, here's the rule of what it was then. And I was in maybe 50 movies. You don't want to be seen because you're there to make money. That's all. And I was hiding in the back on the stage at the Palace.

[16:00] Kevin David Thomas: No, no, no, because you want to come back the next day.

[16:02] STEPHEN COLE: And they'll ask, were you seen on camera? And you go, no. Okay, come back the next day. Oh, that's what it was about. I learned that from the old extras. You want to make that SAG money, and that's what I was doing. And it was just all about that. So, but that one, you know, I do get seen. I think if you go to YouTube, it's three minutes and fifty-nine seconds in. There I am. I go on and I freeze it constantly.

[16:31] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.

[16:31] STEPHEN COLE: Sometimes I just play back. I have hair, it's really great.

[16:36] Kevin David Thomas: What else did you do besides All That Jazz in the other?

[16:38] STEPHEN COLE: Raging Bull, Superman.

[16:41] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my God.

[16:41] STEPHEN COLE: What a going in style.

[16:43] Kevin David Thomas: No one remembers that.

[16:44] STEPHEN COLE: George Burns.

[16:45] Kevin David Thomas: George Burns, yes, very good.

[16:46] STEPHEN COLE: My butt is walking down the street. People laugh. But it's that kind of thing. If your butt is seen, it's okay, but not your face. Come back again. You can come back again.

[16:56] Kevin David Thomas: There were movies that I remember the experience, and I don't know the movie.

[17:01] STEPHEN COLE: There was one that we went to the Concord Hotel in the Catskills in the winter and did an indoor. It was we were at the indoor pool also for a week doing a luau. They were roasting a pig over the pool. It was a singles weekend. I have no idea what movie this is. Somebody found it for me recently, and it was still a movie. I don't, I can't remember the name.

[17:24] Kevin David Thomas: I know there was one where I was I was a student in a classroom and it was it was Penny Marshall and Rob Rock Rob what's his face?

[17:32] STEPHEN COLE: Reiner?

[17:33] Kevin David Thomas: No, yeah, her husband.

[17:34] STEPHEN COLE: Oh, Rob Reiner, yeah. They were married then.

[17:36] Kevin David Thomas: They were married, yeah.

[17:37] STEPHEN COLE: And I remember because I was I if you looked, I would the people would call me up and say, You still look 12.

[17:42] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah.

[17:42] STEPHEN COLE: I used to look 12, that's right.

[17:44] Kevin David Thomas: Well, you really kept the 12 thing over the board.

[17:47] STEPHEN COLE: Kept it on the baby face, and that's why I said it's 21 over. I'm a producer and then he becomes producer. It's because I was doing things on stage like to kill a mockingbird playing Dill, who's six in the show. Right, and and then I remember I did it in Indiana Rep, and then I came back to New York, and they were gonna do it in another theater, and they said, Oh no, you're too old.

[18:08] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, it's oh my career is done.

[18:10] STEPHEN COLE: Peaked at 12.

[18:12] Kevin David Thomas: Peaked at 12. Now, this might be hard, but I'm gonna ask you, favorite Cole Porter song.

[18:17] STEPHEN COLE: God, that is hard. Really hard. But I've been thinking about that one of his my favorite songs.

[18:24] Kevin David Thomas: I concentrate on you because the lyric is so specially constructed, the way the rhymes fall in different sections, and it's so unique.

[18:36] STEPHEN COLE: And I think when I even I knew that even then that it was unique to connect how things rhyme, and it wasn't a normal song. And yet it's very simple, 32 bars and gorgeous, and so I wouldn't say it's my favorite, but I've been thinking about that song a lot. It's great.

[18:54] Kevin David Thomas: And it's just great.

[18:55] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. Did you grow up on movie musicals as well?

[18:57] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah, that's what I saw first.

[18:59] STEPHEN COLE: I didn't know there were stage shows until I went to Hello Dolly. Hello, Dolly was a fluke. My mother and I would come and see shows, movies, never shows, at Radio City and things like that. And there was nothing to see one day. And we're passing underneath this theater, and I said, Why can't we see that movie? And it was Hello Dolly. And she said, That's not a movie. She got tickets, and I went, Oh it's amazing. I looked down from the third balcony and I saw live people. And I saw, and they did an encore to the title song, and I never knew there was such a thing.

[19:31] Kevin David Thomas: But movie musicals were Mary Poppins and Sound of Music, and those were the records I had first, too.

[19:37] STEPHEN COLE: I always had the soundtracks because I saw the movies. My Fair Lady. I saw those in reserved seats.

[19:40] Kevin David Thomas: Star.

[19:43] STEPHEN COLE: Talk about Star Sweet Charity. Paint Your Wagon. All the theaters that used to be on Broadway. Clint Eastwood. They're all gone. You know, the Lowy State and the Rivoli and all those. They were reserved seat movies. You would get your seats, and they had Demons and they had souvenir books. I still have them all. I have all my souvenir books.

[20:03] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I think a younger generation doesn't know about that era where you would go, movies would be playing all day long. You kind of go in and hang out and come, you know.

[20:12] STEPHEN COLE: But reserved seats was I took a girl on our first stage Paint Your Wagon, she never saw me again.

[20:23] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, it was a wagon the movies.

[20:25] STEPHEN COLE: You see, no, it wasn't because of that, it was because they were selling the souvenir book, and I didn't have enough money, and I had to borrow money from her for the souvenir book. And so she didn't think that was a good change. We were 13.

[20:38] Kevin David Thomas: I think it's like, oh, I love it.

[20:39] STEPHEN COLE: I had a two of them. Where else to go besides Paint Your Wagon?

[20:44] Kevin David Thomas: I love it. Now I have to ask you, I love obscure films. And this was one when I was doing research on you I had never heard of before. Electric Grandmother?

[20:54] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. I this is this is not I never knew this, so I feel like I'm out of the loop. And that's what, and one of my shows is based on that. One of my early shows. It was a story by what's his name?

[21:08] Kevin David Thomas: Ray Bradbury.

[21:09] STEPHEN COLE: Ray Bradbury, right? But I had seen the TV film starring Maureen Stapleton as literally an electro grandmother. She's a robot grandmother. And it was so an electrical. Yes! She's Grammy, it's about these two little kids who lose their mother, and the father takes them to a factory to get a replacement. And they figure, I like those eyes, I like those arms. And they put together a robot grandmother, the perfect grandmother.

[21:36] Kevin David Thomas: And it's Maureen Stapleton, wouldn't it be? Cuddly, cozy.

[21:40] STEPHEN COLE: And she is a robot. And she comes to live with them. And the little girl, there's a boy and a girl. The boy loves her madly. And the little girl refuses to love her. And we find out the whole crux of the story is that since she lost her mother, she thinks she'll lose her too. And the grandmother says to her, No, I can't die. I'm a machine. And that's what it is. So it's real Ray Bradbury. And I had to write a song for that moment. We so I got together with that was my collaborator Matthew Ward, who I also wrote After the Fair with. And we wrote the 11 o'clock song, it was called I'm Forever. I Won't Leave You. I'm Forever. And it was all about how I'm a machine. I mean, there's some of the most sorry notes are on that.

[22:25] Kevin David Thomas: And the we didn't get the rights to that from Ray Bradbury.

[22:30] STEPHEN COLE: It was a mistake was made. Agents said we had stuff, and I spoke to him on the phone, and he said, Oh no, I'm writing my own musical. Because he did have a like a four-way into musicals for a while, I feel like.

[22:42] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, but he didn't do that one.

[22:43] STEPHEN COLE: And then little by little, and I would talk to him again years later, and he would say, Oh, you can have the rights now. And then he'd call me up and say, Oh no, we sold the movie rights again. So it just went away. But as it went away, Matt and I were writing After the Fair, which was a public domain story, Thomas Hardy. And we took, we purloined many of the best tunes. And that was one of them. I'm Forever became your words of music. Oh. That was that melody. I went, I'm not losing that melody. So I did it.

[23:12] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.

[23:12] STEPHEN COLE: So that was the Electro Grandmother. It's a lovely film. I think it might be out on DVD. I don't know. I'm dying to see it. And it was also it was also a Twilight Zone before that.

[23:23] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, really?

[23:24] STEPHEN COLE: Because it is wacky. I mean it makes sense. And it actually blends itself well. It was not a musical musical. There were some great stuff that's still there that we didn't reuse. And we did this unbelievably great demo with Beth Fowler.

[23:37] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah.

[23:39] STEPHEN COLE: And she was she was heaven. And so there's still stuff I I've read it recently, and once again I went, Oh, I could rewrite this.

[23:47] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[23:47] STEPHEN COLE: I'm better now. The lyrics are still good.

[23:51] Kevin David Thomas: What was the writing process with Clayb on that?

[23:53] STEPHEN COLE: He was he was not the easiest guy to write with, oddly enough. Really he was he was very exacting. I dragged him out of retirement, which I didn't really know. He's like 20 years older, but I we would sometimes have huge fights, which he told me, he said I used to have huge fights with Ken Word on the Crass Harper, and I'd go, Well, we'll never fight.

[24:15] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah, Kenwood Elmsley. And we did, and I would leave there sometimes. I always rode my bike back and forth, he's on the upper west side, and I would go, think of the music, think of the music, because it was so gorgeous. But he kind of part of not having the great success he deserved, I think he was afraid of success. And so it was one of those fear of success things. And then we would do these incredibly wonderful things together. And we were writing two shows at the same time, also. We wrote a show called Gross Singers, and which I was brought in on. He had been writing that for years with other collaborators, including Ronnie Graham, the famous comedy writer. And Ronnie threw his hands up and said, I can't do this anymore.

And she said, Oh, do you want it? I got the job, and it was a commission. And so we were doing, we were writing this Jewish show in the Catskills, and then at the same time as the preacher, you know, I'm writing The River Jesus. Oh my gosh. And about Borscht and at the same time. So it made him a little crazy. I was fine. I was used to doing two things at once. And at one point he said, We're not doing this show two things at once. I said, slow down, slow down. Would you guys write together? Yeah, I would I the the big question, what's always the big question? Which comes first? The words or the music, as Sammy Kahn always said, the contract. And the Goliath merely. But in my I usually write lyrics first, but it goes back and forth sometimes.

I enjoy getting I would get melodies from him sometimes, but mostly I would write a complete lyric. I would go over there and do it in rhythm for him in his tape recorder. And by the time I rode my bike home, he sometimes would have full things. He was really adept and fast and brilliant. Brilliant, brilliant music. And sounded like no one else. That's something that's hard to come by. People who have their own sound. You listen to Harvey Schmidt, and he has his own sound. The fantastic sounds like nobody else. And Clayb was like that too. And I think some of it is regional. It's the fact that it's the regionalism of. I mean, he would could write the Jewish music easily, but that wasn't him.

The Knight of the Hunter and the Grass Harp and the just the way he talked. You know, it just and then he played the piano brilliantly and he sang brilliantly. He could sing but when I sang, I sang pretty well. And we would sing together, but he had a great voice. In fact, he told me Julie Stein was his sponsor to get into ASCAP when you had to have sponsors. And Julie said, I put you in any chorus of mine. Because he just had this big wonderful voice. Wow. And I have demos of him singing stuff from Grasshop, including our show stuff. And but he would write, we were writing the score for prodigious voices, and Ron Reigns was it. And we would go into the studio and do demos with Ron, and Ron would go, Oh my god, it's go so high, Clayb.

And Clayb would go, It's thrilling. And it's true, you know, because he has that Barry tenor thing going way up. And so we and we were lucky enough to make that CD. You did. There was a cash recording, concept recording. This was all because of Bruce Kimmel. He loved the show from the first demos we gave him, give him like three songs, and he said, I'll do it. So he was like the producer of the city. He produced it, it was it was with Varese Saraband then, he was with that company, and he said, I wanted, I've always wanted to do a concept CD before it was ever a show, and we handed it to him. You had Dorothy Loudon? Oh my god, yes, Dorothy, who was a great pal after that. And we had the greatest orchestrations by oh my god, you'll think of it in a second.

Because we had 26 pieces playing on that CD. I didn't realize that. Yeah, it's gorgeous. And Todd Ellison conducted it, and then he became my collaborator later on. That's right. And Dorothy Loudon and Marshall Lewis and then Sally Mays. Yeah, it's an incredible cast. Oh, yeah. Incredible. We asked Barbara Cook first to do Dorothy Loudon's role because she had been in the Grass Harp. And she said, she called up Clay and said, it's not for me. He never spoke to her again. And so I said, let's call Dorothy. And I did. I knew Dorothy from drama league shows. So yes, why? So I called her up and she said, Oh yes. Oh yes. And she was she was a blast. It's fun to hear her. It's really fun to hear her.

She's great. If a theater company wanted to do the Night of the Hunter, are the rights available? They are they are. They are with me and my agent. Absolutely. So just contact you or the agent. We're looking for that new production of Night of the Hunter. We did it in San Francisco, premiered there. We did it in the New York Music Theater Festival, which was the best. And Beth Fowler played Dorothy Loudon's role, and she was fantastic, and Dee Hody was in it. It was a wonderful production. We did it then in Texas with the full 26 piece orchestra at Lyric Stage, where I've done lots of my shows. And it was it was great. But the New York one with even with the five only five pieces rather than 26, it was glorious.

It was one so I want to do the show again. In fact, I have it out to a famous director right now, who I think would be fabulous for it. Fabulous. Who is Tony nominated today? So now you can guess who it is. I like that. You know what's interesting is that there is no set path on how to bring an original musical to the masses. Yeah, there is no like do follow these steps, boys and girls, and you will have your show on the show. Boy, wouldn't that be great? Wouldn't it be nice? You know, and I'm sure every single one of your shows has had a different gestation or a different process. Absolutely. And it's changed drastically since I first got shows on. It is much harder now. Now it really is about bring the money.

It's all about the money. All about the money. It's always been sort of all about the money. But you when I got Dodsworth on in 95, starring Hal Linden at Casamaniana and D. Hody. Oh, yeah. It was because the director, Bruce Lumpkin, just brought it to them and said, Hey, why don't we do this show? And they said, Well, yeah, it's good, but nobody knows the title, nobody knows the authors. And I think I was the one who said, get a star. And they got Hal Linden. And he's, guess what? It sold tickets. And people came and they saw the show and it moved on from there. So, you know, Dee was not a star star then, but Hal was a TV star. And we did the same thing with Gross Singers in the same theater.

We had we had Ruta Lee, who is a star in Fort Worth, Texas. Let me tell you. You put Ruta Lee on a marquee in Fort Worth, and they come for weeks. But we also had Gavin McLeod, who the great captain stooping. And that was a great experience. It was that was the non-Jewish Gross Singers. We just gonna ask what the sort of story of Gross Singers. Well, it's about it's about Jenny Grossinger, the woman who created the hotel in the Catskill Mountains and and the whole how how the Jews came to the Catskills. And it's a very Jewish show. And when we did it in Fort Worth, they they said, Oh, nobody's gonna get it here. No one knows what a blintz is. And they were wrong. Because every because all of a sudden the Jews came out of the woodwork.

They all had accents, but they came out of the woodwork. And we also had a fabulous lobby display with all the photos of Jenny Grossinger and every star that played there. Smart and ran This Is Your Life, Jenny Grossinger on a Loop, which was from the 50s, and on a TV screen. So it all worked out really great. But we did take out every reference. There wasn't an oi in sight. Funny. It was very funny, yes. And then we put it back, we put it all back, and it became a show called Saturday Night of Gross Singers, which is the same show with only six people. And that ran in LA in Florida. So that where in LA was it? Uh, Betty Garrett's Theater in the Valley. Yes. Okay. Which it ran for four months, which is a lot for LA.

They don't go to the theater there. Not like that. But everyone came out to see it because Gross Singers to a certain generation who is dying out now, you know, represented this great place where they all went for the summers and saw every star. It's kind of like friends, young people. When you watch the movie Dirty Dancing, it's like that. It's like it was like family. Not only is it like that. And put on shows. And it was all about food and big stars and dancing and going there to find husbands and and the pool. And they they were open all year round. They had skiing, they had everything. It was Las Vegas before Las Vegas. And Dirty Dancing, you know, was supposed to take place at Grossingers, and it sort of does, but they weren't allowed to use the name Gross Singers because we owned it.

The ladies who bought the rights to Gross Singers, we still had the I once got a call from somebody said, Well, could I use Gross Sing's in a movie? I said, How much? Funny. They didn't, but they weren't gonna pay enough. So it didn't happen. No. So we still have the killerman. Yes, I guess I was Michael. Hey, I know. I've watched Dirty Dancing enough. But it's so close to the case. Grossing is so is so famous. And it was the Cadillac of all those hotels. It was the Mecca and the top. And the woman, Jenny Grossinger, was an interesting character. And I got to know her daughter, and it's very interesting because she was a female entrepreneur in the early part of the 20th century and ran the place.

So it definitely lends itself to it. It was a great time. And the song for Dorothy Loudon that I'm so curious if she ever recorded, Am I Too Broad for Broadway? Right. That came because of that show, Comedy Tonight. So there we are, they're in previews on Broadway. And by this point, it's not three acts, but four, because Dorothy's understudy when they were out of town, went on for her once, and her name was Joy Behar. And Joy Behar went on and did her comedy act, not Dorothy's comedy act, and couldn't sing, but she did her thing. And she was such a hit, and no one knew who she was that they put her in the Broadway show. And the others were Mort Saul and that guy who juggles and does comedy.

And Dorothy's actually had a puppet, a Dorothy Loudon puppet. It was very funny. But it wasn't good. This was not a good show. Let me have it at the Lund Fontan. So they said, Dorothy, we should get an opening number for her. And so Jeff Saver and I wrote this song, Am I Too Broad for Broadway? Which actually came from a monologue that someone else had written. And I loved writing it. It was a blast. And we all right, so the story goes, we go to Alexander Cohen's office, which was also his apartment, and we sing it for him, and he loves it. And it was like a movie. And he calls his wife in and says, Come on in, you have to hear this song. And this is Hilde Parks, who wrote all the Tony Awards with him.

And she says, Oh, I love it. Call in the whole staff. They all listen, we're all singing the song. And there's there's Peter Howard who's playing the show. And so they love it. And I said, This is it. This is my dream come true. I'm gonna have a song on Broadway. We go to John Cander's house and play it for Dorothy a day later. And I'm singing it and I'm doing my dar best Dorothy Loudon. And she's they applaud and they all look at her and she goes, I'm not singing that. And I went, Oh she's like, We're in previews. I'm not learning anything new. That's too hard. And that was the end of that. And our dream went couple away. We went into the recording studio and recorded it with Mary Testa, who's brilliant on our demo.

And it's just basically was so so Darth. It was all about how she was too broad for Broadway, and she couldn't get into any shows. Like she couldn't be in Sunset Boulevard because she was scared of heights, and the and the room kept going up and down. And and they she did get cast in beauty in the beast as the bidet. So it was that kind of shtick. It was very funny song. And I'm very proud of that song, but she never sang it.

[36:14] STEPHEN COLE: And there is a recording of it.

[36:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Mary Tesla recorded it.

[36:17] STEPHEN COLE: And so that's our demo. One of these oh, she was brilliant, just brilliant. And if I were to do the song again, every year there's new shows. And these were these were old shows. Sunset Boulevard and update. Even she hadn't even done, she hadn't even done Showboat yet, because we Showboat that revival Showboat had just happened. And we had something about her shimmying on the cotton blossom and singing it. That kind of stuff. It was very funny stuff. Why I like writing that that's special materials, and that's fun to do. And she was gonna do Gross Singers at one point. That was that was she we were gonna do this concert in LA, which we wound up doing with the Los Angeles Jewish Symphony Orchestra.

You didn't know there was such a thing, did you? The Los Angeles Jewish Symphony Orchestra. And they we had fabulous symphony orchestrations made for the show, and Dorothy was going to play the lead, and we were going to record it. And that was all excited. Other great people were going to be in, and she rehearsed and got sick. And then she didn't do it. She wound up not doing it. But we decided we were going to keep everything in the same key that she sang in, which meant the basement at that time. And the poor woman who was going to do it in the concert would sing in those keys. We would record the orchestra and then go back and put her into it. Well, the orchestra wasn't good enough. And so it never really happened.

That was another Bruce Kimmel thing that we were going to do. But we did the we did the concert. And so I some of the some of it sounds okay. It was the the I hope the woman's not listening, but I remember she had her baton and she got up and she raised her baton and it flew out of her hands and hits one of the composer claims went, Well, we're dead.

[37:58] Kevin David Thomas: Yep.

[37:58] STEPHEN COLE: Yep. Oh my god. Sarah Styles was a very good thing. Sarah Styles was genius. Sarah Styles was genius, as was Bruce Warren, who played opposite her. They had a scene in the show, which is a translation scene, which, if you look on the script, it maybe takes a half a page. It was five minutes of hilarity because every night they would improvise. It was translating but physically. And and it's what really went on there. Trying to get anybody to understand anything. It was hilarious. And she was she was just genius. We tried to, we she auditioned for us when we were going to do it in Texas first. And interestingly enough, we didn't pick her. And then I was like, what are we crazy? And that wonderful, wonderful, funny voice, and she was sexy as hell.

[38:45] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[38:46] STEPHEN COLE: And yeah. I had a blast. I had so much fun doing that show there. And we we produced it ourselves, did this concert version. Anita, Anita Jallette plays our mother. We incredible. Elizabeth Teter, who is now one of the the main witches in the Crucible, and was was young Queen Elizabeth last year in the audience. She so yes, Elizabeth Teter plays Merman's Apprentice, Muriel Plackenstein. And uh she she came in and auditioned for us. She's she's brilliant, just brilliant. You know who her father is?

[39:18] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, I do Lara Teeter, who started in On Your Toes in 1983, Tony nominee.

[39:24] STEPHEN COLE: And now he runs a musical theater program, right?

[39:26] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, in St. Louis.

[39:27] STEPHEN COLE: St. Louis. And they have he has this wonderful family, and uh I think Elizabeth's the oldest daughter. There are other daughters. We we keep hoping because the girl's 12 years old, and Elizabeth's now 14-ish. We go, Well, who got any younger sisters because she's so talented and so good.

[39:43] Kevin David Thomas: Because procrastination is the name of the game.

[39:47] STEPHEN COLE: One of the things Kevin said, oh, hold on for one second. So one of the things Kevin was saying before, which is that people on there have very strong opinions. Um, so we're gonna ask you a series of questions, musical theater questions. You can either say your opinion, or you can say I decline to comment.

[40:03] Kevin David Thomas: Okay, but as he is STEPHEN COLE, and that's the highest level you can go in musical theater family.

[40:08] STEPHEN COLE: It's true, it is true.

[40:09] Kevin David Thomas: That is the apex, the acme of the city. We were talking about you know the big musical theater questions, and here we go. Are you ready?

[40:14] STEPHEN COLE: Okay, all right.

[40:16] Kevin David Thomas: Best Sweeney Todd, Len Cariou, or George Hearn?

[40:21] STEPHEN COLE: Hmm. I saw both. Definitely. And I don't remember Len as well, because George did the video. So I love George. And I saw George do it with Judy Kay at Paper Mill. And that was the best. That was one of the best productions. Judy Kay was stupendous. And he, my my one of my collaborators, Jeff Saver, was the conductor, and he told me that when George came to rehearsal, he said, teach me the notes. I never got to learn the notes on Broadway. He was a replacement. He said, I want to do it right. And boy, did he do it right. So that was a thrilling. So I like George.

[41:01] Kevin David Thomas: George.

[41:01] STEPHEN COLE: Yep.

[41:02] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah. Greatest score from a forgotten musical is What's Forgotten?

[41:10] STEPHEN COLE: Is Folly's Forgotten?

[41:13] Kevin David Thomas: It's kind of one of the forgotten musicals.

[41:15] STEPHEN COLE: Folly's was the greatest production, by the way, I ever saw in my life. I am so lucky to have been alive.

[41:19] Kevin David Thomas: You saw the original, yeah.

[41:20] STEPHEN COLE: Yeah. And and uh and it still holds. But I would say, but if I had if we're on greatest Sondheim, you know, that's harder. Because Night Music is is better in many ways, because Night Music's a better show.

[41:35] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, and and the score is great.

[41:37] STEPHEN COLE: Music in the air. How's that?

[41:39] Kevin David Thomas: Good.

[41:39] STEPHEN COLE: That's a current.

[41:41] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[41:42] STEPHEN COLE: Because no one ever thinks way back. That's a I I adore music in the air. I'm on a real music in the air kick. Love it.

[41:50] Kevin David Thomas: The best mama rose was.

[41:53] STEPHEN COLE: Well.

[41:55] Kevin David Thomas: Well, you know what?

[41:56] STEPHEN COLE: Isn't that sad that I the only one I've never actually seen is Merman. I saw every single other one from Lansbury on. But because Merman had the fabulous tapes in her closet of her closing night, and I'm the one who got them out of that closet, I can say Merman, because just listening to her performance is spectacular. When I saw Tyne Daly, I said that she heard the tapes. Because I thought Tyne Daly really gave a Merman performance.

[42:26] Kevin David Thomas: Oh interesting.

[42:27] STEPHEN COLE: And because it's all about the comedy. And that's kind of gone by the wayside lately. The comedy. If you're not funny and charming, why should we care? Then you're just a monster from WordGo. And Merman always said, and she said it to me, she said, she was a good mother. Rose was a good mother. I have to play her that way.

[42:38] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[42:38] STEPHEN COLE: She said, she was taking care of her girls. It was all for them, not for me. And that's true. Think about it. She only says it's for me at the very end. And so she's got two hours of it's all for them, not for me. And that's how she played it. The positive, funny, charming, I'll do anything for those kids.

[43:02] Kevin David Thomas: Good answer.

[43:04] STEPHEN COLE: Good answer. Ready for your next one?

[43:05] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, doing good so far.

[43:07] STEPHEN COLE: The most overrated musical in the canon is ever.

[43:14] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.

[43:14] STEPHEN COLE: The most overrated musical.

[43:16] Kevin David Thomas: I choose to decline.

[43:17] STEPHEN COLE: Great.

[43:20] Kevin David Thomas: The most underappreciated musical in the canon is.

[43:25] STEPHEN COLE: Mmm. The Night of the Hunter.

[43:28] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, that's it.

[43:30] STEPHEN COLE: Doing a few more. You're doing good. Who should star in a Mack and Mabel revival?

[43:35] STEPHEN COLE: Nobody. I saw the original show. I saw it on the second night, and it was as good as it was ever going to get. And it was it was a good show. But let me tell you, there was Bernadette Peters was incomparable. She knocked Robert Preston off the stage. She was that good. And if Bernadette Peters and Robert Preston and Goward Champion couldn't get it right, no one's gonna get it right. That's the answer. That's my feeling about that show.

[44:01] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[44:04] STEPHEN COLE: Uh blank. This musical deserved to win Best Musical, but didn't.

[44:10] Kevin David Thomas: Follies.

[44:11] STEPHEN COLE: Great.

[44:12] Kevin David Thomas: Is the revival of Chicago truly better than the original?

[44:16] STEPHEN COLE: No! I saw the original. I not only saw the original, but I saw it with Liza Minelli twice. Gwen Verdon, of course. Interestingly, Liza was fabulous. It was such an event to go see Liza and Cheetah. And she was stupendous. But when I went back and saw Gwen, I went, that's the show. Because it's the older woman. And she was a brilliant actress. But some of the numbers were changed for Liza for the better. Me and my baby became the baby number with with uh all of them dressed as babies and her as Eddie Cantor. And it was much better than what wound up in the show. So yeah, I like the revival very much. Don't get me wrong. And I'm glad it's so long run and everything. And when I saw it at Encores, I thought I I died and went to heaven because I hadn't seen the show in so long. But the original had sets and costumes, and it was better.

[45:03] STEPHEN COLE: The greatest leading man in musical theater history is Alfred Drake.

[45:10] Kevin David Thomas: Nice answer.

[45:12] STEPHEN COLE: Uh we teach three forgotten musicals that you wish all musical theater students knew about.

[45:18] STEPHEN COLE: The Cat and the Fiddle, Music in the Air. They are totally experimental shows, both of those. When you think about it, it's 1932 and 1933, and Kern is doing an experiment. Showboat has book songs and song songs. There is not a song in each of those shows that is a book song. They are all have a reason for existing as songs in the show. Every someone is singing all the time. Interesting experiment. And they both work on their own level.

[46:13] STEPHEN COLE: I love the score, too.

[46:14] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I like Kismet.

[46:14] STEPHEN COLE: How could they not like Kismet? I mean, we're talking, we're talking major, major music here for singers.

[46:20] Kevin David Thomas: Which is the more influential rock musical?

[46:24] STEPHEN COLE: Hair or Rent.

[46:26] STEPHEN COLE: I think Rent.

[46:27] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[46:28] STEPHEN COLE: I mean, Hair was not influential at all. Hair was just one thing that happened. It influenced a lot badly at the time. It influenced it influenced Clive Barnes to say, I don't think any musical is a musical without a rock score. And it influenced him to give uh Follies a terrible review and Company a terrible review. He thought all shows should have rock scores. So that was a very bad influence. And most of those shows that poor Galt McDermott wrote after were disasters. And I mean Via Galactica and these shows, they were disasters. Whereas Rent has been a little more influential.

[47:10] Kevin David Thomas: Great.

[47:10] STEPHEN COLE: A little more. Last question.

[47:12] Kevin David Thomas: Okay.

[47:13] STEPHEN COLE: Greatest overture to a musical.

[47:15] Kevin David Thomas: You cannot say Gypsy.

[47:17] STEPHEN COLE: Well, Candy then.

[47:20] STEPHEN COLE: Or 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.

[47:22] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I love you for saying that.

[47:24] STEPHEN COLE: Good showing that gorgeous overture.

[47:27] Kevin David Thomas: It is.

[47:27] STEPHEN COLE: And and it's not on the C D that they released of the recording. Because they never released 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. They did uh White House Cantata and opera singers. But they left off the opening number and the overture. And the overture should be take its place with Candide as a great uh concert piece. Brilliant.

[47:51] STEPHEN COLE: So yeah. And I saw 1600. Ha! I was there. And I believe David Crane was a rehearsal pianist.

[47:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yes, that was his first show.

[47:58] STEPHEN COLE: That was his first show. And he was he was a Leonard Bernstein product.

[48:03] Kevin David Thomas: Full circle.

[48:04] STEPHEN COLE: Full circle.

[48:07] Kevin David Thomas: Join us next week when we interview Broadway and television icon Nancy Dessault.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred