He created the role of Big Deal in the original West Side Story. He changed the face of musical theatre, and pop culture, when he wrote Annie. And, now, Martin Charnin is sitting down for a two part interview with Rob and Kevin to talk about how he went from being an actor, to a lyricist, to a director... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Featured Shows
About
He created the role of Big Deal in the original West Side Story. He changed the face of musical theatre, and pop culture, when he wrote Annie. And, now, Martin Charnin is sitting down for a two part interview with Rob and Kevin to talk about how he went from being an actor, to a lyricist, to a director. In this interview, Martin talks about why his kept his career in musical theatre a secret from his father, what the West Side Story audition process was like, and Martin reveals the greatest musical theatre idea that never was. Hint: It starred Norman Bates and Princess Winnifred!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Kevin David Thomas: Hey listeners, Kevin and I need your help.
[0:02] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, we need your help.
[0:03] Kevin David Thomas: Please, please, please.
[0:04] Robert W. Schneider: We need your stars.
[0:06] Kevin David Thomas: We need your reviews, you guys, on iTunes, so we can start to climb those iTunes rating charts.
[0:11] Robert W. Schneider: It's simple.
[0:12] Kevin David Thomas: Open iTunes, click on the iTunes Store, search for Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends.
[0:19] Robert W. Schneider: Then click on ratings and reviews.
[0:21] Kevin David Thomas: Under the customer reviews, click write a review, and then let us know what you think from one to five stars.
[0:29] Robert W. Schneider: If you need some help, think of one star being Carol Channing and Paul Lynn in the road company of The Last Five Years, and five stars being free front row tickets to Hamilton.
[0:38] Kevin David Thomas: Although when you think about it, I actually would give five stars to the road company of Carol Channing and Paul Inn in The Last Five Years, because I think that would be awesome.
[0:45] Robert W. Schneider: I would love to hear.
[0:46] Kevin David Thomas: Can I hear moving too fast as Paul?
[0:49] Robert W. Schneider: That's the really that's the one I really want to do.
[0:51] Kevin David Thomas: Jesus Shakespeare!
[0:55] Robert W. Schneider: Erica Schwartz and Danica Weiss.
[0:58] Kevin David Thomas: And the Handleman Twins.
[1:00] Robert W. Schneider: So there you go.
[1:01] Kevin David Thomas: You can also leave a comment if you like.
[1:03] Robert W. Schneider: That's it.
[1:03] Kevin David Thomas: Your reviews.
[1:04] Robert W. Schneider: Send us your reviews, friends.
[1:06] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[1:06] Robert W. Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.
[1:07] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[1:09] Robert W. Schneider: And this is Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:12] Kevin David Thomas: Don't forget to follow us on Twitter at Broadway Curtain.
[1:16] Robert W. Schneider: And make sure to join our Facebook page at Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:20] Kevin David Thomas: And follow us on Instagram at Broadway Curtain Podcast.
[1:23] Robert W. Schneider: Plus, you can always listen to our podcasts on Broadway World and Stitcher.
[1:28] Kevin David Thomas: Congratulations for those non-iPhone users who are.
[1:30] Robert W. Schneider: I don't even know how Stitcher is.
[1:31] Kevin David Thomas: You can now hear our dulcet tones.
[1:34] Robert W. Schneider: When we first started this podcast, this guest's name was right at the top of our lists because he is the epitome of a theatrical renaissance man.
[1:42] Kevin David Thomas: As an actor, he appeared in the original West Side Story.
[1:45] Robert W. Schneider: As a lyricist, he gave us Annie, I Remember Mama, and Two by Two.
[1:49] Kevin David Thomas: And as a director, his award-winning work has been seen not only on stage in such shows as Annie and Cafe Crown, but also on television with the Emmy Award-winning S Wonderful, S Marvelous, Skurshwin to tell us what it was like to work with such legends as Jerome Robbins, Judy Holliday, and Dorothy Loudon.
[2:05] Robert W. Schneider: Plus how he created some of the most memorable moments in musical theater history.
[2:09] Kevin David Thomas: Here is our idol, MARTIN CHARNIN.
[2:12] MARTIN CHARNIN: Wow.
[2:14] MARTIN CHARNIN: Oh my, I've never had an introduction like that ever.
[2:18] MARTIN CHARNIN: I'm glad we got Cafe Crown in there right off the bat.
[2:21] Kevin David Thomas: Me too.
[2:21] Robert W. Schneider: I loved that show.
[2:22] Kevin David Thomas: It's come up in a lot of our interviews, actually.
[2:24] MARTIN CHARNIN: Yeah.
[2:25] MARTIN CHARNIN: Walter Bobby, I went to the show.
[2:26] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, we had Walter Bobby there.
[2:27] MARTIN CHARNIN: Yeah.
[2:28] MARTIN CHARNIN: Someone took over for David Carroll.
[2:30] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[2:30] MARTIN CHARNIN: Oh, that's because I we I'm obsessed with David Carroll.
[2:34] MARTIN CHARNIN: Anytime I can bring him up to anybody who worked with him or knew him, I always try to hear just I don't know, a little information about him.
[2:41] MARTIN CHARNIN: David was a terrific actor.
[2:43] MARTIN CHARNIN: He had I think just done Chess.
[2:46] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[2:47] MARTIN CHARNIN: I think that was the job that he had had.
[2:51] MARTIN CHARNIN: We were at the Public Theater, Joe Papp, and he had always wanted to do Cafe Crown, which was a play in the full from the forties written by a guy named Highcraft, and revived once, and then turned into a musical, which didn't work, unfortunately.
[3:10] MARTIN CHARNIN: But he brought it to me.
[3:12] MARTIN CHARNIN: I was working with Joe on a couple of projects at the time, and he brought it to me and said, Are you interested?
[3:18] MARTIN CHARNIN: Well, being very Hebraic, I agreed immediately.
[3:23] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I said, I really wanted to do it with Eli Wallach and Anne Jackson.
[3:28] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[3:29] MARTIN CHARNIN: I had just done a show with them off-Broadway called In Persons, and I brought them into the project.
[3:36] MARTIN CHARNIN: They were dying to do it because they had known the piece.
[3:40] MARTIN CHARNIN: And then I said, Well, Joe, I think what we should do is hire as many Yiddish theater actors as we possibly can find who are around.
[3:50] MARTIN CHARNIN: And we got the late great Fyvush Finkel, who just passed away, I think a couple of weeks ago.
[3:57] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[3:57] MARTIN CHARNIN: I'm not sure.
[3:58] MARTIN CHARNIN: To be that notorious waiter at the Cafe Crown who had all of those great one-liners that took him an hour to get from stage left to stage right.
[4:11] MARTIN CHARNIN: He shuffled.
[4:12] MARTIN CHARNIN: I mean, we had to slow him down on occasion.
[4:16] MARTIN CHARNIN: Fyvush, you're going too fast.
[4:20] MARTIN CHARNIN: Anyway, he was just brilliant.
[4:22] MARTIN CHARNIN: Bob Dishy was in it.
[4:23] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.
[4:23] MARTIN CHARNIN: Oh, wow.
[4:24] MARTIN CHARNIN: And David Carroll played the son of Eli and Ann.
[4:29] MARTIN CHARNIN: Well, that was the plot of the piece.
[4:32] MARTIN CHARNIN: But he was the only, basically the only non-Jew in the company.
[4:37] MARTIN CHARNIN: However, he fit in brilliantly.
[4:39] MARTIN CHARNIN: He really took it to heart.
[4:42] MARTIN CHARNIN: And Walter Bobby replaced him.
[4:44] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[4:45] MARTIN CHARNIN: David then went on to do, I don't know, something else before he unfortunately.
[4:50] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah.
[4:51] MARTIN CHARNIN: I guess it was Grand Rally, maybe before he left us.
[4:54] Kevin David Thomas: Growing up in Manhattan, were you exposed a lot to Yiddish theater growing up?
[4:58] MARTIN CHARNIN: I yeah, actually a lot to Yiddish culture and theater.
[5:03] MARTIN CHARNIN: My father was a singer and he was a basso profundo at the Met and he was also a cantor at a congregation on Ninety-Fourth Street.
[5:17] Kevin David Thomas: Now is it true your dad was not a fan of musical theater?
[5:20] MARTIN CHARNIN: Loathed it.
[5:21] MARTIN CHARNIN: Loathed, loathed, loathed it.
[5:24] Kevin David Thomas: How did he respond to your getting into it?
[5:27] MARTIN CHARNIN: Well, truth be told, he really didn't know I got into it on a creative writing side until he had passed away.
[5:35] MARTIN CHARNIN: I was a painter.
[5:37] MARTIN CHARNIN: I went to Cooper Music and Art High School, Cooper Union.
[5:41] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Cooper Union, right?
[5:43] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I was a pretty good painter, actually, sort of Chagall in my approach to paint.
[5:50] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, in my approach to paint.
[5:53] MARTIN CHARNIN: Chagall used to say he was chartaning.
[5:55] Kevin David Thomas: Oh right, right, right.
[5:57] MARTIN CHARNIN: I met Robert.
[5:59] MARTIN CHARNIN: I met Chagall once at the Plaza Hotel.
[6:05] MARTIN CHARNIN: I had an agent at the time named Abe Newborn, who worked for CAA, I think it was.
[6:11] MARTIN CHARNIN: And he took me to lunch at the Plaza, and in the corner table, Chagall had come to New York for an exhibit, I believe.
[6:21] MARTIN CHARNIN: I don't remember anyway.
[6:22] MARTIN CHARNIN: Abe spent the entire lunch looking at Chagall and telling me about him, and I knew, of course, a lot about him, but Abe said we have to get his autograph.
[6:34] MARTIN CHARNIN: I said, okay.
[6:35] MARTIN CHARNIN: I took the menu over to the table.
[6:38] MARTIN CHARNIN: I really didn't have anything else for him to write on.
[6:41] MARTIN CHARNIN: I took the menu over to the table, and he was having lunch with an agent, I think, and his wife.
[6:49] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I took the menu to the table and I introduced myself and I introduced Abe Newborn and I said, um, in sort of semi-Yiddish, which is one of he which was the language he really understood.
[7:06] MARTIN CHARNIN: Yeah.
[7:06] MARTIN CHARNIN: Um, basically translated into could you please sign my menu and his wife grabbed the pen out of my hand and said five thousand dollars and I went uh thank you very much.
[7:26] MARTIN CHARNIN: It was a pleasure to meet you and I left with my head between my feet, but he he he did he didn't do things like that.
[7:38] MARTIN CHARNIN: That's a he did he wouldn't sign anything.
[7:43] Kevin David Thomas: What a wife, too.
[7:44] MARTIN CHARNIN: I know she was his agent, yeah.
[7:46] MARTIN CHARNIN: Clearly, she was in the business.
[7:47] MARTIN CHARNIN: Anyway, well, but anyway, so my father was, as I said, a singer at the Met, basso profundo, the C below low C.
[7:58] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.
[7:58] MARTIN CHARNIN: Right.
[7:59] MARTIN CHARNIN: He was great friends with Hiopinza.
[8:01] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah.
[8:02] MARTIN CHARNIN: And when Pinza left the Met to do South Pacific, my father stopped talking to him.
[8:08] MARTIN CHARNIN: He was literally picking my job off the and Pinza was somebody who had dinner with at our home, who we knew.
[8:18] MARTIN CHARNIN: My father just was so angry and upset with him.
[8:22] MARTIN CHARNIN: So I grew up in a culture in which and why because he deserted the high art of the Met of opera for the musical theater.
[8:33] Kevin David Thomas: What was your mom an artist as well?
[8:35] MARTIN CHARNIN: No, my mom was a Jewish homemaker.
[8:39] MARTIN CHARNIN: But my father got ill in about 1955.
[8:44] MARTIN CHARNIN: He had my father was a perpetual smoker.
[8:47] MARTIN CHARNIN: I mean, I do not have a recollection of him ever not smelling of cigarettes, and or having one not in his hand.
[8:58] MARTIN CHARNIN: And he smoked Shalyapans, which were black Russian cigarettes.
[9:04] MARTIN CHARNIN: They and named after Feodor Shayapin, who was one of the great bassos of the opera world.
[9:12] MARTIN CHARNIN: So he sings all over.
[9:14] MARTIN CHARNIN: But my father had a heart attack and was bedridden.
[9:19] MARTIN CHARNIN: And in my last year at Cooper Union, I got a fellowship to go to Guggenheim to go to Rome to paint.
[9:29] MARTIN CHARNIN: Because I was really not bad.
[9:32] MARTIN CHARNIN: And a friend of mine in the summer that before my last year said, Well, what are you doing this summer?
[9:40] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I said, Nothing.
[9:42] MARTIN CHARNIN: Getting ready for my last year of school.
[9:44] MARTIN CHARNIN: And he said, Well, why don't you come with me to this adult camp that I'm working at called Timberland in the Adirondacks?
[9:53] MARTIN CHARNIN: And if anybody ever read Marjorie Morningstar, they would know what those adult camps were like.
[10:00] MARTIN CHARNIN: They were places where people would come for a week or two, but they had a staff, and the staff would be waiting on tables in the daytime and at night be rehearsing for the one week show that they would put on.
[10:12] MARTIN CHARNIN: And my friend Bobby said to me, Well, come on, you'll come up, you'll paint sets and you'll do a walk on in The Mikado or Damn Yankees or whatever we're doing.
[10:23] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I said, Okay, I had nothing to do.
[10:25] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I went up there, I was bit really badly bit by I painted scenery.
[10:32] MARTIN CHARNIN: I did indeed end up in the last year of that summer playing The Devil in Damn Yankees.
[10:39] Kevin David Thomas: Nicely done.
[10:40] MARTIN CHARNIN: You bet.
[10:42] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I just loved it.
[10:45] MARTIN CHARNIN: I really loved it.
[10:46] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I came back and I said to my mother and to my great advisor, I'm terribly sorry.
[10:51] MARTIN CHARNIN: I cannot go to Rome to paint.
[10:54] MARTIN CHARNIN: I have to give it all up and I have to go into the theater.
[10:58] Kevin David Thomas: And they just freaked out.
[11:00] MARTIN CHARNIN: Particularly my great advisor, Mrs. O'Sheridon.
[11:04] MARTIN CHARNIN: I still remember her and the look on her face when I told her.
[11:08] MARTIN CHARNIN: And indeed, I kind of just got through my last year and graduated barely.
[11:15] MARTIN CHARNIN: And a week after I had graduated, there was an ad in the New York Times in the column written by Sam Zoloto, which was called News and Gossip of the Rialto.
[11:29] MARTIN CHARNIN: So the New York Times had a gossip column back in and in and the first paragraph said that Jerome Robbins was looking for authentic juvenile delinquents who could sing and act and move a little, and they could all come down to the lobby.
[11:51] MARTIN CHARNIN: Actually it was the alley of the Broadway Theater on Fifty-Second Street.
[11:56] MARTIN CHARNIN: And they had to come down that day.
[11:58] MARTIN CHARNIN: The audition was at 10 o'clock.
[12:00] MARTIN CHARNIN: And I went and there were two thousand people.
[12:02] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[12:00] MARTIN CHARNIN: There were two thousand people.
[12:05] MARTIN CHARNIN: And Ruthie Mitchell, who was a wonderful stage manager for Hal Prince, Hal who Hal was with the producer of West Side, which at that time was called Gangway.
[12:16] MARTIN CHARNIN: It wasn't even called West Side.
[12:18] MARTIN CHARNIN: And the show had gone into rehearsal weeks before, but Jerry had not completed the casting of the Jets.
[12:25] MARTIN CHARNIN: And uh I'm I was there with all these people. I had I had flicked my hair back, so I kind of looked like James Dean. And I rolled up my uh T-shirt and put a pack of cigarettes in it. You know how that you had to look like one of the authentic juvenile. I put on my tightest jeans. I was much skinnier then. And they they were all right. My butt was okay, I guess. And lined up with 2,000 other hopefuls of all shapes, sizes, creeds, colors. I mean, it was astonishing the turnout. And Ruthie would go around going, thank you, no, no, no, no, stay. Thank you, no, no, no. And like that. And 2,000 became 200, and I was still there. And ultimately 200 became 20. Were they dancing you the whole time? They were doing nothing.
They just literally typecasting. They were type purely and simply typecasting. Wow. And I uh made it to the last 20. And we were brought then, brought into the theater. Now this was a good three hours of standing around being pointed at and told you were in or you you were out. And uh I the first person I met at the door on my way in was Larry Kurt. Wow. Uh and he looked at me and he said, You'll never get it. That was the first thing he said to me. We ultimately became the closest of friends. Yeah. Uh, and I really mean close, but he was kidding, kidding beyond belief, which is what Larry was. Um, and he walked out to go and have his lunch and I was still there. Uh and the first person who actually auditioned me was Peter Jennero, who simply asked me to walk from stage left to stage right.
We weren't actually on the stage, we were in the lobby, left to right, and snap my fingers as I walked. And I could do that, and I could do that without licking my finger. Yeah. Because a lot of people were licking their fingers in order to make the sound. But I passed the snap test and boom, I was on I was there. Uh, and the next person I saw was a young man uh in a shirt and a tie, white shirt and a sort of a black tie, I remember, looking a little bit like what the characters in the Book of Mormon look like right now. Yeah, totally. Uh and he made me sing. He said, Do you have a song? And I said, Yeah, I have one song that I really knew, and I knew it because it had four notes in it, and I could really handle those four notes.
It was um I wish I were in love again. The Rogers and Hart thing I had done it in uh, yeah. I had done it in a uh variety show that we did up at Timberland at this and the sh the song is Da da Da da Da da Da da da da I mean that was it. Yeah, totally. That's the melody of that song, uh, which I had a good lock on. And then, quite simply, the young man said, Can you do it faster? So I went, okay. And the pianist gave me a new tempo, and it was Daily Fights, Sleepless Nights, Quick Tab, and Reside, blah, blah, blah. And then he stopped and he said, Can you do it faster? And the third time I really took a deep breath and became very consonant conscious and spit it out, the daily fights to sleep, and so on and so forth.
I can't do it now. But I did it then, and again I passed the that part of the audition and became one of the 12 that were left from the 20. Eight were cut. I later determined, discovered that it was Sondheim who was asking me to do that and sing quickly. Lenny was certainly on from television. You knew Bernstein. You didn't really know Steve. There had not been a lot of publicity about him. I don't know that there were photographs floating around anywhere. And that was Sondheim. And the reason, of course, was because ultimately I ended up singing Officer Krupke. And singing Officer Krupke, one needed to have a great command of consonants and whatnot, lyric. And then the next piece of the audition was for uh they took us downstairs, and a stage manager person gave us a sheet of paper, and it was script.
It was some part of the script that we were supposed to read. And everybody read the three lines that were out were underlined, they weren't even highlighted, they were underlined for us to read, and I got a laugh on the on my reading. Nobody else did, and I thought, oh my god, that's gonna wipe me out, and I'm done. And it turned out that that was exactly what Arthur Lawrence, who was conducting that audition, really wanted, and he really wanted it because I ended up being the only jet who had any jokes in in Westside. And which jet did you play? Big deal. I played big deal, and I was allowed to wear a hat and my glasses, which Jerry loved. And then the last thing was was uh This is all in one day, by the way.
Oh, yeah, yeah. This is one day, just making sure uh and then at the end of it all, uh I met Jerry who made me walk stage left to stage right and snap, and now I you know I guess he liked my look. Uh, and then finally we we were taken into another room, and in that other room there was Bernstein, and he made us sing some serious notes. Maria, because in Westside there are four voices in the wings doing vocal echoes to Larry singing, Tony singing Maria. And I'm one of I'm the third guy on that whatever. Yeah. And I then went upstairs and Carl Fisher, who was the general manager, said sign a contract for 265 bucks and be here tomorrow morning you go into rehearsal. That's how you were cast in that type of story.
And all the dancing you had to do was walking across the stage and snapping. That's I'm amazed. One marathon day. Jerry was desperate. I mean, he really had two more jet roles to fill. The other guy who got a part that day was Frank Green, who was the Tony understudy. Uh so I got hired and Frank got hired on that on that. Absolutely amazing. And we went into rehearsal. And then I, of course, had an issue because I couldn't tell my father who was ill, uh, about the fact that I was uh in a Broadway musical. Yeah. I did, however, confide this information to my mother, and between the two of us we invented this story, uh, which is that I was getting up every morning at eight o'clock to go downtown to look for a job in as a graphic designer or something related to art.
And um we kept it up until I suddenly realized, oh goodness, it's July or August or whatever, and we have to go out of town. And how can I explain how can I explain out of town artwork jobs being called for, particularly in Philadelphia and Washington? Uh, and I would be gone for ten weeks, five weeks in each town. And so I finally bit the bullet and I went in and I told my father, and I sat him down. He was it was an evening, it was a Sunday night, I remember, and I said, Pop, I gotta tell you, I am in a Broadway musical. But listen, everybody who has anything to do with it is Jewish. It's Bernstein. I mean, like And of course, I told him Arthur and Lenny and Steve, and I and then I told him about Lenny, and Lenny was of course the piece de resistance.
I mean, he was in both worlds and legitimately firmly entrenched in both worlds. So it made it all right. My father did write to Lenny while I was on the road and told him to take care of my son or I'll come and get you. Oh dearing. That's well. That's how I got into the theater. That's how you got in. Now, when you're when you're on stage and you're in the rehearsal process for West Side Story, you have all of these great people at the top of their game around you. Are you observing their process? Totally. Totally. As it turned out, the funny thing was that only two people decided to stay at the Jefferson Hotel in Washington. And they were me and Steve. And we had breakfast every morning together.
We would and we talk. And I learned an awful lot, and I listened an awful lot to the way that uh these four giants conducted themselves and what they were doing. But in the final analysis, it was Jerry who who had uh the final say, the directorial say, uh, and who really knew he knew that show in a way that uh encouraged me to know everything that I had to know about whatever project I was doing. I couldn't just isolate something and say, Well, I'm the lyric writer, and all I care about are how the words are being sung. No, Jerry knew about Sheriff's costumes. Jerry knew about Oliver Smith's set. Jerry knew about the orchestrations. Jerry not only knew about the details of whether your pinky was extended properly in the dance hall or not.
So it the lesson was to learn, learn, learn, listen and learn and learn and learn. So it was not only a course in how to put a show on, because it was, I mean, there was an immaculateness, if that's a word, to Westside. Did the show change a lot in the rehearsal process? It changed from what, from a blocking standpoint. There were two or three numbers that had preceded me. I didn't take part in them that had been written but were uh were thrown out. But by the time I got into the show, only one musical, new one new musical number surfaced, and that was Something's Coming, which was written late and was first performed for the Gypsy run through before we went out of town by Larry at on the stage of the Broadway Theater.
And to this day it's one of the great moments. None of us had heard it. None of the cast had heard it. There's been rehearsed in private. And uh, well, obviously with Steve and with Jerry and whatever, but it was a very private rehearsal because it was only a two scene, Doc and Tony. And on a on a stepladder. We w they lugged out a stepladder in the gypsy run through, and he walked up the ladder and sang it. And it it was a standing ovation that he got from the audience and from us, we were screaming and yelling, because imagine hearing something's coming for the first time.
[24:48] MARTIN CHARNIN: And only on a piano, only on a piano, and it was still stirring and stunning.
[24:54] Kevin David Thomas: Have you always been into lyric writing? Have you always had a knack for poetry?
[25:00] MARTIN CHARNIN: Well, I don't to begin with, I don't think lyric writing and poetry are the same thing. Uh I think lyric writing, if you were a lyric writer, you're writing with a melody in mind. Whether or not that melody ultimately gets used is not the point. But you're writing with cadence, a whole other kind of cadence. You're writing if you know anything about music, and I knew a little bit about music, you know you're writing couplets or quatrains or whatever you're writing, and you're knowing you, I mean, poetry does not necessarily have to rhyme. Whereas in my opinion, in this old fashioned body of mine, I believe that you know, time and mine don't rhyme. And so I'm a real purist about that, and it bothers me beyond belief today when people get away with rhyming together and forever, they don't rhyme.
And I think it was even Steve in an article who recently said, not recently, but maybe a year ago, I don't know, said that there is something really satisfying by it, with a rhyme that is an honest rhyme, a true rhyme, even if it's a made-up word. And I mean, Yip Harburg was a genius at making up words or having them, you know, cutting a something sweet, something sort of grandish, and cutting off the grandish at the ish part or whatever and making it a word that worked that rhymed. And I was always a fan of Ogden Nash, so I knew about a lot about, and he was a poet, yes, but he was a prankster writing. And I ended up, you know, finding myself very enamored of writing. I in school I was the editor of a very short-lived magazine called Tom Thumb at Cooper Union.
We did a little, I think we had two issues of this humor magazine. That was about it. And I wanted to write lyrics. And I always would, I would always write quatrains or couplets to people in responses to their birthdays or to a present I would got. It would be easier to tell them how I felt or what I liked or disliked or what I thought about in four lines that rhymed. I figured if the intention wasn't there, at least the service that I attended in terms of doing it turning it into a little poem was do I still, oh it's the only way I answer less.
[27:45] Kevin David Thomas: So you'd be great at Twitter. I mean Twitter's perfect, Mario. We should put you on Twitter. Now you did a lot of review work, and you still continue to do a lot of review work. How does your work in crafting a review shape how you're going to write or direct a piece of musical theater?
[27:59] MARTIN CHARNIN: They're totally different. And at the same time, they're exactly alike. I mean, exactly the same. It's a question of structure, it's a question of sequencing, it's a question of you don't put three ballads in a necessarily in a row, one right after another. Um review you can get away with murder in a review because basically, in a review, for the three minutes that the, and I'm talking really about old-fashioned reviews. I'm not talking about what things are now being called reviews, which are the jukebox musical kind of things. Because in point of fact, you could have done Jersey Boys by just doing Frankie Valley. But they interpolate, I mean the same thing with Mamma Mia. They made the songs theoretically fit the script, so there is a continuity and a structure there.
But in the reviews that we would do were doing early on, like at Julius Monk. Julius Monk, yeah. Um, who was a master of putting these little cabaret shows together on a place called Upstairs at the Downstairs, and I did three reviews with him, and there were wonderful performers who were doing my material, Kay Ballard and did a couple of things that I wrote, and Marsha Lewis and Charles Nelson Riley. I mean, these were all people who worked we were all beginning, we were all beginners. My first review that I ever had done was done in Provincetown before Julius, had Ruth Buzzy, Dom Delouise, and Charles Nelson Riley in it. They were, you know, they didn't exist.
[29:50] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[29:50] MARTIN CHARNIN: Yeah. Uh and we did it, we did a show, and then I did a review in the last year that I was in West Side. I decided to stay in Westside for a thousand performances. Which I did. I closed for one, I did one thousand performances on Broadway, and then we went out on the road and we came back. So I did played West Side for a thousand performances. And then left and, oh, I did get another job as a writer, as a lyricist in a show called The Girls Against the Boys. But that was all very weird kind of thing. Bert Lahr and Nancy Walker?
[30:27] Kevin David Thomas: Nancy Walker.
[30:28] MARTIN CHARNIN: I was hired, actually, to be the guy who did rewrites on the funny numbers that weren't getting laughs for Bert Lahr and for Nancy Walker.
[30:40] Kevin David Thomas: How did you get that back then?
[30:43] MARTIN CHARNIN: It was very complicated, and they said you really can't we really can't hire you that way. So what if we put you in the show and call you Dick Van Dyke's understudy? That's how we were curious how you got to be Dick Van Dyke's standby.
[30:58] MARTIN CHARNIN: I was Dick Van Dyke's standby. I never went on. I don't know if I ever saw any of the show because what I was doing was writing lines for Bert Lahr and Nancy Walker for songs that ultimately ended up in the show. I mean it didn't work, it wasn't necessarily a good idea or a funny idea, but that was how I got into the case.
[31:21] Kevin David Thomas: But good practice, too. I mean, to have to deal with a personality like that and find his comedy for him.
[31:27] MARTIN CHARNIN: I have to ask you about a musical of yours that I don't know anybody has ever seen, which is inspired by a Life magazine article.
[31:34] MARTIN CHARNIN: Yeah, that was a show. The first person that I really had a serious collaboration with was Mary Rogers. Once upon a Mattress. She had done Once Upon a Mattress. I didn't do Once Upon a Mattress, but she did it. She did it. She wrote Russell Bear. And with Marshall, right, who was a genius, was a genius writer, lyric writer. Crazy, but a genius. It goes hand in hand. And I met Mary through her connection to Steve. I mean, they were close, close friends. And I was brought into that community because I guess I was presentable and funny. I don't know. Um, but the point is that Mary and I began to write. The first thing that we wrote was this musical. She had found an article in Life magazine. There was a credit card back in the 60s called Carte Blanche.
The carte blanche card. Oh, yeah. Well, it existed. It was one of the first, if not the first. Okay. And a guy, some guy, a young man of about, I don't know, 20, 25, 25, stole a card and charged about a hundred thousand dollars worth of equipment, of things. I don't know. I mean, I don't know what you steal, what they were specifically, but there were things, stereo sets, television sets, whatever. And an article appeared in Life magazine with him sitting on top of this mountain of stuff that he had bought with the fake with the stolen credit card. And he had this incredibly self-satisfying look on his face, a big grin from ear to ear. And the caption was, "Why is this man smiling?" And then you find out that Life magazine, in order to get his story, paid off his debt to the credit card company. And Mary thought that was a really neat idea for a musical. And we were writing at the time.
[33:57] MARTIN CHARNIN: And they loved it. And they said, okay, guys, write it and we will do it. So we began to write it. We wrote a part for Tony Perkins, Psycho Tony Perkins.
[34:08] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah, of course.
[34:08] MARTIN CHARNIN: To play Green Willow Tony Perkins.
[34:11] Kevin David Thomas: Green Willow, sorry.
[34:13] MARTIN CHARNIN: No, no, no, you're right. Just to prove that he could sing. So we were and we were able to, and we, and because of her connection to Mattress, Mary got Carol Burnett to agree to be her the female lead in the thing. So we had a really neat package. Burnett, Perkins, Griffin and Prince, George Abbott, and Bobby passed away. Bobby died of a heart attack, and the whole thing fell apart. The entire thing. We've written four songs for it by the time when that had happened. Four of them ended up in Hotspot.
[34:50] Kevin David Thomas: So I mean your next collaboration.
[34:52] MARTIN CHARNIN: Which was the next thing that I did with, no, it wasn't the next thing I did with Mary. Next thing I did with Mary was a show for television, one of the first musical original musicals for television called Feathertop.
[35:03] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[35:04] MARTIN CHARNIN: Based on a Nathaniel Hawthorne short story for the Halloween of I don't know, nineteen sixty two.
[35:13] Kevin David Thomas: What makes Mary Rogers so good?
[35:16] MARTIN CHARNIN: Oh, Mary had the world's greatest sense of humor. She was so smart and she was bright beyond belief. And also here was a girl, and ultimately a woman who was surrounded by, let us face it, folks. I mean, if you turn your to the left, there's Oscar Hammerstein. If you turn to the right, there's your father sitting at the piano, and it was Richard Rogers. It wasn't just some guy sitting at the piano plunking away heart and soul. So she learned a lot from him. Ultimately, she didn't want to write anything like him, but she was clever and she was witty and she was funny and she was she had a very sharp sense of humor. And everything made Mary laugh. Everything made Mary laugh. You could just simply say, I saw a guy walking down the street. Before you finished the sentence, she was on the floor laughing. She was great. We wrote a television show together with Woody Allen as the sketchwriter.
[36:20] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, my God.
[36:21] MARTIN CHARNIN: That never got on the air, interestingly enough, for the U.S. Steel Hour. Um, and then we wrote we wrote the Fear Feathertop, and then we wrote Hotspot.
[36:32] Kevin David Thomas: That is so cool. Now tell us about Hotspot, which is a show that not a lot of people know, and it's one of the things that we'd like to expose our students to.
[36:39] MARTIN CHARNIN: Judy Holiday, hello.
[36:40] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah. Well, why is it that there's a story about everything? Is that how it is with everybody you've talked to?
[36:49] MARTIN CHARNIN: Yeah, there is, and we love it. But you're drilling in in weirdly uncharted territory. Join us next week for part two of our interview with MARTIN CHARNIN.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
