5,6,7,8.....TONY! Rob and Kevin welcome back Tony Awards historian Bryan Hobgood to discuss the 2016-2017 Tony Award Nominations! This week's episode focuses on this season's musical works. From Come From Away to Groundhog's Day. Hello, Dolly to Sunset Boulevard... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Featured Shows
About
5,6,7,8.....TONY! Rob and Kevin welcome back Tony Awards historian Bryan Hobgood to discuss the 2016-2017 Tony Award Nominations! This week's episode focuses on this season's musical works. From Come From Away to Groundhog's Day. Hello, Dolly to Sunset Boulevard. Josh Groban to Ben Platt, and everything in between that sings, is discussed, dissected, and dismantled. Plus: Who will win? Who will lose? Who cares! It was an incredible season and we are all winners!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Kevin David Thomas: I dreamed the dream of days to come where sponsorship is high and money is forthcoming.
[0:07] Robert W. Schneider: That's beautiful, Kevin.
[0:08] Kevin David Thomas: I really added a voice onto that one too. I really was trying to go for something there.
[0:12] Robert W. Schneider: Listeners, we love creating this podcast, but it does cost money. Please don't make me sell my angel record.
[0:18] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my gosh, the original cast recording of Angel.
[0:20] Robert W. Schneider: Like nobody has.
[0:21] Kevin David Thomas: Nobody has it. If you like what we are doing and want to keep doing more of it, please head over to Patreon.com.
[0:28] Robert W. Schneider: That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com.
[0:34] Kevin David Thomas: I feel Patreon.
[0:36] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, Patreon.
[0:37] Kevin David Thomas: Reon.
[0:38] Robert W. Schneider: Patreon.
[0:39] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, once you're there, search for behind the curtain Broadway's Living Legends.
[0:42] Robert W. Schneider: And of course, we don't expect to give without receiving some great rewards.
[0:46] Kevin David Thomas: Such rewards include behind-the-scenes videos, shout-outs on future episodes or episodes, depending on what part of the country you're from, because I said episodes.
[0:55] Robert W. Schneider: And early access to some of our podcasts. Hell, for the right price, Kevin and I will come to your apartment and act out all of Agnes of God.
[1:03] Kevin David Thomas: So head over, friends to P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com to help us out.
[1:09] Robert W. Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W. Schneider.
[1:10] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[1:12] Robert W. Schneider: And this is Behind the Curtain, Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:15] Kevin David Thomas: It is.
[1:17] Robert W. Schneider: I'm doing really well, my living legend, Rob.
[1:20] Kevin David Thomas: I'm excited.
[1:21] Robert W. Schneider: I'm so excited for this episode.
[1:23] Kevin David Thomas: Me too. We have with us once again from last year, Tony Awards historian Bryan Hobgood.
[1:29] Bryan Hobgood: Good. Thanks for having me back, guys.
[1:30] Robert W. Schneider: We are happy to have you back.
[1:32] Bryan Hobgood: I'm so excited to be here. I can't believe it's been a year.
[1:35] Kevin David Thomas: What a year.
[1:36] Robert W. Schneider: What a year.
[1:36] Bryan Hobgood: What a year.
[1:37] Kevin David Thomas: What a year for many reasons.
[1:39] Robert W. Schneider: But in our little bubble in our own little world.
[1:42] Kevin David Thomas: Our Broadway bubble.
[1:43] Bryan Hobgood: In our private world.
[1:44] Robert W. Schneider: Now saying from on the 20th century.
[1:46] Kevin David Thomas: Our private world.
[1:48] Bryan Hobgood: Thank you.
[1:49] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, that was it?
[1:49] Bryan Hobgood: That was our.
[1:50] Robert W. Schneider: That was your two.
[1:51] Bryan Hobgood: Just a little motif.
[1:52] Robert W. Schneider: That was great. Kevin was known in the auditioning circuit for doing two bar cuts.
[1:56] Kevin David Thomas: That's right.
[1:56] Robert W. Schneider: Which was sometimes one if I could get away with it.
[2:00] Kevin David Thomas: Hi. Thank you very much.
[2:02] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you.
[2:02] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[2:03] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, thank you.
[2:04] Kevin David Thomas: Bring him.
[2:05] Robert W. Schneider: No, thank you.
[2:07] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, that's so terrible. I would give Have you ever been stopped at an audition?
[2:13] Robert W. Schneider: Like you were in a minute song, and people were like, No, I'm fine, thank you.
[2:16] Kevin David Thomas: Uh I have stopped myself.
[2:18] Robert W. Schneider: Stopped yourself.
[2:19] Kevin David Thomas: And I booked the job still, but it was I changed songs because the piano player was so bad.
[2:23] Robert W. Schneider: Uh and I I was gonna this is years ago, and I was gonna sing Lost in the Wilderness.
[2:28] Kevin David Thomas: Terrible idea.
[2:29] Robert W. Schneider: Terrible, terrible idea. Hard piano part.
[2:31] Kevin David Thomas: And I got through the bless her. She was like, if you know the song, it's like she was like, dude.
[2:42] Robert W. Schneider: And I was like, you know what, guy? I'm so sorry. I don't know why I picked this song. I picked the wrong song and I made it about me.
[2:48] Kevin David Thomas: Stopped it, picked a song that was like easy in four, like then went on tour with Les Mis, so it all works.
[2:56] Robert W. Schneider: Oh wow, sure what song that was.
[2:58] Kevin David Thomas: It was She Wasn't You. I went to uh a slower song, still a hard piano part, but it was like easier to for them to play, and she could play that.
[3:07] Robert W. Schneider: Is that on a clear day?
[3:08] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[3:08] Robert W. Schneider: Oh wow. Yeah, they wanted that first.
[3:10] Kevin David Thomas: They wanted to be a little bit of a they wanted songs that weren't like they everyone was like screaming their faces anyway.
[3:15] Robert W. Schneider: This is boring, cut this out.
[3:16] Kevin David Thomas: No. They but uh so I sang a a more simpler song anyway. I don't think it's boring.
[3:21] Robert W. Schneider: But so to stop in an audition, oh have you ever been stopped in an audition?
[3:25] Kevin David Thomas: I have never been stopped. Well, I haven't been on that many, but I when I was auditioning, I was never stopped.
[3:29] Robert W. Schneider: Do you stop people in an audition, Rob?
[3:31] Kevin David Thomas: Um only only if they're really like off key.
[3:35] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, I'll be you're like just saving them. I'll be like you. I said, you know what? Just take a minute.
[3:40] Kevin David Thomas: I said I said it sounds like you're a little bit. Yeah, just go. Uh yeah, I don't I don't like people to suffer.
[3:44] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, right. Especially me.
[3:46] Kevin David Thomas: Same. Speaking of suffering from musicals.
[3:48] Robert W. Schneider: Oh.
[3:49] Kevin David Thomas: Or not suffering in the case of the season.
[3:51] Robert W. Schneider: Well, we're gonna say suffering from musicals.
[3:53] Kevin David Thomas: Well, no, I was gonna talk about one of the musicals this season that had me suffering.
[3:56] Robert W. Schneider: But which one had you suffering?
[3:57] Kevin David Thomas: Oh which ones it's unkind.
[4:00] Robert W. Schneider: No, I was gonna say um I I recently revisited um the the revival of Miss Saigon, and I really, really, really liked it the first time, and I really, really, really didn't like it the second time.
[4:13] Kevin David Thomas: So it's interesting.
[4:14] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, that all happened.
[4:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it was really, really interesting. I it's the only show that I saw twelve well, only musical that I saw twice this season.
[4:20] Robert W. Schneider: You saw Miss Saigon twice this season?
[4:22] Kevin David Thomas: Why did you see it twice?
[4:24] Robert W. Schneider: I don't know. The first time I saw it with a friend, and then I sort of wanted to go back because I I saw it long ago when it first opened. Um based on like some of the awards that we're gonna talk about, and like some of the th, you know, press it's been getting. I was like, I had a very different reaction to that. So like let me go back and look at it for you. I was like, oh yeah, no. No, you were right the first time.
[4:45] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. Okay, okay, interesting. Wow. Have you ever done that? Going to see a show. Well, that you love something, and then you see it again, you're like, ah, I kind of made a mistake.
[4:54] Robert W. Schneider: Huh. No, I don't know. I had to think about that. I I I really don't know.
[5:01] Kevin David Thomas: I know I have. Usually I have the opposite. I I often will not think I don't like this. And then I'm like, oh, Dear Evan Hansen, I have to confess, at first I was kind of like, nah, and then I saw it again, and I was like, oh shit, this is for real.
[5:16] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[5:16] Kevin David Thomas: That's great. Yeah, I was wrong about that. My first impression.
[5:19] Robert W. Schneider: That happened to me with Book of Mormon. First time I saw Book of Mormon, I was like, this isn't funny. I was like, this is stupid. And then I went back and saw it again. I was like, no, I just missed all the jokes. I was like, I just completely was not quick enough.
[5:30] Kevin David Thomas: And no, it's way clever. Sarah Brightman.
[5:33] Robert W. Schneider: Sarah Brightman. Used to love her.
[5:37] Kevin David Thomas: I know you do.
[5:37] Robert W. Schneider: I'm like, what were you? Are you happy? What were you thinking?
[5:41] Kevin David Thomas: You don't like Sarah Brightman?
[5:43] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, she I appreciated her when I was 20, but come on.
[5:47] Kevin David Thomas: What were you thinking, Kevin?
[5:48] Robert W. Schneider: We think you want the hall here again. You could see Rob's face.
[5:53] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[5:54] Robert W. Schneider: The buck teeth coming out.
[5:55] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[5:59] Robert W. Schneider: Never really found her doing song and dance on YouTube.
[6:02] Kevin David Thomas: We didn't know it existed.
[6:03] Robert W. Schneider: Wait. I stayed here and there's a version of her saying unexpected song somewhere.
[6:06] Kevin David Thomas: No, there's a version of her doing all of song and dance, not just a song.
[6:11] Robert W. Schneider: They filmed it when it was in London.
[6:13] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[6:14] Robert W. Schneider: And we were looking up something about song and dance, and it just popped up. It's the full show.
[6:20] Kevin David Thomas: And we were like, what is this sorcery? We have to watch this.
[6:24] Robert W. Schneider: In London, maybe.
[6:26] Kevin David Thomas: I think she replaced.
[6:28] Robert W. Schneider: Oh.
[6:29] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know who the original was in London.
[6:31] Robert W. Schneider: It was because it was um this is a whole other topic to talk about. But it was it was like another one act version, then they expanded it to the dance.
[6:41] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. It was tell me on a Sunday first. And then they expanded.
[6:44] Robert W. Schneider: If you want more information, you can listen to part 103 of our interview with Richard Maltby.
[6:51] Kevin David Thomas: Speaking of Tony Awards.
[6:53] Robert W. Schneider: Alright. Hey, let's discuss that time of year.
[6:56] Kevin David Thomas: Alright, and as we know, there is a difference between who will win and who should win.
[7:01] Robert W. Schneider: Right.
[7:01] Kevin David Thomas: And Hamilton.
[7:02] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, wait, no, that's last year.
[7:03] Kevin David Thomas: That was last year. It's so actually Hamilton is so good, it's been nominated again this year. They just do not want to leave the room where it happens, pretty much.
[7:12] Robert W. Schneider: Um, so and also we have friends that have worked on these shows, and so none of these are comments or criticisms on their work. It's just we're looking at it from a business perspective, from an industry perspective.
[7:23] Kevin David Thomas: So I don't have friends in this show, so I'm gonna be harsh.
[7:25] Robert W. Schneider: No, I'm kidding.
[7:26] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Brian.
[7:27] Bryan Hobgood: Brian's ready.
[7:28] Kevin David Thomas: Brian is ready to dig in.
[7:30] Robert W. Schneider: All right, here we go. So we're gonna start off with orchestrations.
[7:33] Kevin David Thomas: Or category you're so passionate about.
[7:37] Robert W. Schneider: I do care a lot about the orchestrations. I care that we still have this as a category since sound design's out, and so is music directors, which we talked about, I know ad nauseum.
[7:45] Kevin David Thomas: But it still amazes me, it still amazes me that we actually have this category still, and I'm thankful for that. Because I do think these um these men uh and sometimes women deserve to be recognized for their hardware.
[7:56] Robert W. Schneider: Orchestrating is one of the hardest jobs because you're taking basically sometimes the composer just writes a melody or writes a little like a melody and maybe a bass line, and then the orchestrator will go and turn that into magic. They'll make that sound like it's they'll decide what instruments play what, and they'll create counter melodies, and they'll just create the palette and the music that you're hearing when you go see a show.
[8:15] Kevin David Thomas: So the nominees we have this year, um, we have Dave Malloy, who was the composer and writer for Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812, but he also orchestrated his own show, which is sometimes I don't think I think that's a little unheard of. In opera, for instance, it is common for the or uh composer to orchestrate his own opera or her own opera, but in musicals, we don't often have that.
[8:34] Robert W. Schneider: So shout out to Dave Malloy for that himself. I'm sure he had some help. Uh Alex Lacamoire for Dear Evan Hansen, he's also the music supervisor for that.
[8:42] Kevin David Thomas: Um he also won for Hamilton last year.
[8:46] Robert W. Schneider: Uh Larry Hochman, the great Larry Hochman, uh, for Hello Dolly. And then uh I don't know these two. Bill Elliott and Greg Anthony Rassen for Bandstand.
[8:56] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, those are our nominees. Were they also the composers for Bandstand? Or did they I don't know.
[9:03] Robert W. Schneider: I should know that, but I don't. Oh, wait, you know what? I have it right here.
[9:05] Kevin David Thomas: No, no, they weren't. That was Richard Oberacker or something.
[9:10] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, yes. Yes, that's it.
[9:12] Kevin David Thomas: Those are older gentlemen.
[9:13] Robert W. Schneider: The Bandstand folks, which is so cool.
[9:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[9:16] Robert W. Schneider: The writers.
[9:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[9:18] Robert W. Schneider: Uh okay, so Kevin, you're our expert.
[9:21] Kevin David Thomas: Well, uh, so I really appreciate uh Lacamoire. I think that he is going to do wonders for our business in the future. He has already. I think anywhere you look that you see great work being done, he has had his hand in it somewhere, and you don't even realize it.
[9:36] Robert W. Schneider: He was a part of Wicked originally, he was a part of Avenue Q originally.
[9:40] Kevin David Thomas: Um then, of course, he was part of Hamilton, In the Heights, and then um now with Dear Evan Hansen. I think it's kind of amazing that this one man has been a part of all of those amazing journeys.
[9:50] Robert W. Schneider: Pretty cool.
[9:51] Kevin David Thomas: So true. That being said, I I do wonder if it'll go to Larry Hochman because of Hello Dolly. I think those orchestrations are truly stunning. When I heard that album for the first time, but I was having a bad day, and um and I got a recording of it, and it just cheered me up. But it was the orchestrations that did it. It was the sound, it captured that style.
[10:06] Robert W. Schneider: We love.
[10:11] Kevin David Thomas: Uh so I think they might give it to Larry Hochman because it is you when you hear the sound, it's so obvious.
[10:11] Robert W. Schneider: Dear Evan Hansen had a smaller orchestra, and is it's technically I think harder to create that sound for them, but I think it's gonna go to Larry.
[10:25] Kevin David Thomas: Okay, Larry Hochman for Hello Dolly, says Kevin David Thomas.
[10:28] Robert W. Schneider: I think so. Mr. Hobgood.
[10:30] Bryan Hobgood: This is maybe the first year that I don't really have a super strong opinion as what I would want to win, just because they thought they were all very good.
[10:37] Kevin David Thomas: Um last year I I had like very strong opinions about this category, but this year, I like all of these.
[10:43] Bryan Hobgood: Um if I were picking a favorite, I would probably go with Hello Dolly as well, Larry Hochman, just because there's nothing like sitting in the theater and getting that rich sound, and especially in a show like that that you know I don't I don't know, it's just legendary.
[10:58] Kevin David Thomas: Um I I really liked it. So I'd pick Hello Dolly. I'm guessing it'll probably win. Alex Lacamoire might win for Dear Evan Hansen, but um he won last year, so I don't know that they're gonna give it to him again.
[11:08] Robert W. Schneider: I'm going with Dave Malloy.
[11:10] Bryan Hobgood: Are you now?
[11:11] Robert W. Schneider: I am as much as I love Larry Hochman.
[11:14] Bryan Hobgood: Um I really love Larry Hochman. We won him on the show. We're gonna talk to him about it. He's such a funny guy.
[11:19] Robert W. Schneider: Um, and those orchestrations are genius. It's it's a revival. It's it's he's working from something that's pre-existing in some way. Do you know what I mean?
[11:25] Bryan Hobgood: But Dave Malloy, I'm that's incredible what he did.
[11:29] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, because the actors are playing their own instruments a majority of the time. They're spread out all over the theater.
[11:34] Bryan Hobgood: He's provided such a rich texture to it.
[11:37] Robert W. Schneider: He combines with the orchestrations this Russian period flavor with a modern sensibility. I just think he had a lot to work with and did a really good job at it.
[11:45] Bryan Hobgood: So Dave is is is for me.
[11:47] Kevin David Thomas: Uh any of these guys is is fantastic.
[11:49] Robert W. Schneider: Lighting design.
[11:51] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my gosh, we have for lighting.
[11:53] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my gosh.
[11:54] Kevin David Thomas: Are you ready?
[11:54] Robert W. Schneider: Light the lights.
[11:58] Kevin David Thomas: That's the only I can just sing waiting for the light to shine.
[12:02] Robert W. Schneider: Like, really? You don't know the lyrics today?
[12:06] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[12:07] Robert W. Schneider: Light the lights. We've got nothing to hit but the highest starting here.
[12:12] Kevin David Thomas: Yep. Starting now.
[12:13] Robert W. Schneider: Yep. Honey and are you filming?
[12:16] Kevin David Thomas: That was Patti LuPone.
[12:17] Robert W. Schneider: Stop! Stop everything.
[12:23] Robert W. Schneider: That's good.
[12:24] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[12:24] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you, Rob. That you like that?
[12:25] Bryan Hobgood: I just couldn't see you because.
[12:27] Robert W. Schneider: I could do B.
[12:28] Bryan Hobgood: Arthur doing it where we're just talking.
[12:31] Robert W. Schneider: Like the lights. Just end every last word of.
[12:34] Bryan Hobgood: We've got nothing to hit but the heights.
[12:40] Robert W. Schneider: Is that it? Because it's so true.
[12:42] Bryan Hobgood: So true. I could do your friend Elaine singing it.
[12:49] Robert W. Schneider: Don't give it to me.
[12:51] Bryan Hobgood: Don't give it to me.
[12:53] Robert W. Schneider: I'll get it.
[12:55] Bryan Hobgood: Ah. So lighting design.
[12:57] Robert W. Schneider: Hunter. Where's my popsico?
[13:02] Bryan Hobgood: Lighting design. Sorry, who do we have?
[13:04] Robert W. Schneider: I'm sending, I want you to read these names, Kevin, because I fucked up everyone's names last year.
[13:08] Kevin David Thomas: There's somebody on here who's name on the room.
[13:10] Robert W. Schneider: All right. Howl Binkley for Come From Away.
[13:12] Kevin David Thomas: Natasha Katz for Hello, Dolly!
[13:14] Robert W. Schneider: Exclamation mark.
[13:15] Kevin David Thomas: Bradley King for not Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812.
[13:19] Robert W. Schneider: And Jaffy, which, first of all, love the name.
[13:23] Kevin David Thomas: Wiedemann Widemann.
[13:24] Robert W. Schneider: I believe it's Whiteman.
[13:25] Kevin David Thomas: Whiteman.
[13:26] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah. For Dear Evan Hansen.
[13:28] Bryan Hobgood: So we've got a really strong category, I think.
[13:31] Robert W. Schneider: Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 should win best lighting design.
[13:34] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[13:35] Robert W. Schneider: I've thrown down the mic. I have nothing else to say.
[13:37] Bryan Hobgood: Well, the way that they focus where we're supposed to look that entire time.
[13:41] Robert W. Schneider: Once again, for audience, sorry, who hasn't seen it? It's immersive.
[13:43] Bryan Hobgood: It's immersive in a big Broadway house.
[13:46] Robert W. Schneider: They are all over.
[13:47] Bryan Hobgood: And they don't do that cheap shit where it's like we're gonna be immersive, but only for the orchestra.
[13:51] Robert W. Schneider: Exactly.
[13:51] Bryan Hobgood: They're in the mezzanine, they're in the balcony, they are everywhere.
[13:57] Robert W. Schneider: And you're always know where to look.
[13:59] Bryan Hobgood: Yes, that's because of the brilliant direction, I think, as well.
[14:02] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, agree.
[14:02] Bryan Hobgood: Of Rachel Chavkin, which is like genius.
[14:05] Robert W. Schneider: But that lighting design is kind of amazing.
[14:07] Bryan Hobgood: So Bradley King, I'm rooting for you.
[14:09] Robert W. Schneider: I'm done. I'm gonna smoke a cigarette now.
[14:11] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I mean, I think that there's just like no competition in this category.
[14:15] Robert W. Schneider: We all agree, yeah.
[14:16] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, oh yeah.
[14:16] Robert W. Schneider: The only way it goes to somebody else is if Dear Evan Hansen just sweeps everything.
[14:20] Bryan Hobgood: But I don't think that will happen.
[14:22] Robert W. Schneider: I think the design, I think Natasha's gonna win pretty much all the design categories.
[14:26] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[14:27] Robert W. Schneider: And rightly so to an extent, but the lighting is the one for me that it really deserves.
[14:33] Bryan Hobgood: I think that the lighting is stuck.
[14:35] Robert W. Schneider: That opening number is incredible, lighting-wise.
[14:37] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[14:37] Robert W. Schneider: That I mean, if you can watch that opening number on YouTube, my god, please do so because it is incredible.
[14:42] Bryan Hobgood: Incredible.
[14:43] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, costumes.
[14:45] Kevin David Thomas: My favorite category.
[14:46] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, there really is. This particular one, yeah.
[14:48] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, read our nominees.
[14:49] Robert W. Schneider: I had all four of these correct in my predictions.
[14:51] Kevin David Thomas: Not that that's too surprising with who we have.
[14:53] Robert W. Schneider: I'm impressed that you could guess the right nominations.
[14:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I mean, it was the only one of the design categories that I got all four right.
[15:00] Robert W. Schneider: Wow.
[15:01] Kevin David Thomas: We have Linda Cho for Anastasia, Santo Laquasto for Hello, Dolly!, Paloma Young for Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812, and Catherine Zuber for War Paint.
[15:11] Robert W. Schneider: Wow.
[15:11] Kevin David Thomas: And honestly, all four of these costume design, you know.
[15:17] Robert W. Schneider: They're stunning.
[15:18] Kevin David Thomas: They're just all stunning.
[15:19] Robert W. Schneider: I don't even know if I could tell you who I'd vote for, because I'd vote for multiple people.
[15:25] Kevin David Thomas: I think as a whole, I would probably vote for Hello, Dolly!.
[15:32] Robert W. Schneider: Those costumes in "Put On Your Sunday Clothes" are gorgeous.
[15:37] Kevin David Thomas: And I know a lot of the costumes are modeled off of the original costumes, not all of them, but some of them.
[15:41] Robert W. Schneider: So there's the question mark there of what really gets considered like inspired or her obviously her red dress in the scene at the end.
[15:50] Kevin David Thomas: You know, that's iconic, so it's not really speaking of iconic red dresses.
[15:56] Robert W. Schneider: We know this story.
[15:57] Kevin David Thomas: It's a costume design story about Hello, Dolly!.
[15:59] Robert W. Schneider: I have heard this story.
[16:00] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know if it's true or not.
[16:02] Robert W. Schneider: That there was an actress who was doing Hello, Dolly!, an actress of name, who is very method and very into whatever the script says, and unbeknownst to anybody, she hired her own costume designer to design Dolly's dress in the Harmonia Gardens.
[16:22] Kevin David Thomas: Now, if you remember, there's a Bette Midler, you see it. She comes out and she's in this stunning red dress.
[16:27] Robert W. Schneider: That's sort of like the iconic thing of Hello, Dolly!.
[16:29] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah.
[16:30] Robert W. Schneider: They're always in a stunning red dress.
[16:32] Kevin David Thomas: The poster of the red dress.
[16:33] Robert W. Schneider: And the headpiece.
[16:34] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, the album.
[16:35] Robert W. Schneider: And in dress rehearsal.
[16:37] Kevin David Thomas: Here it comes.
[16:41] Robert W. Schneider: Spotlight.
[16:42] Kevin David Thomas: Here she comes.
[16:43] Robert W. Schneider: And the actress is wearing a pitch black dress.
[16:48] Kevin David Thomas: And everyone goes, wait a minute, wait a minute, hold it, hold it, hold it.
[16:52] Robert W. Schneider: What is this?
[16:53] Kevin David Thomas: And she said, Well, Dolly Gallagher is in mourning for her husband and is not allowed to wear anything other than black until the mourning period is over and she's found a new husband.
[17:06] Robert W. Schneider: So literally, she had a designer make her a pitch black dress.
[17:12] Kevin David Thomas: So imagine that excitement of seeing somebody sitting shiva at the top of the stairs at the beginning of the Hello, Dolly! number.
[17:20] Robert W. Schneider: But now, were all of her other costumes black as well?
[17:23] Kevin David Thomas: They were all, yes.
[17:25] Robert W. Schneider: They were all like muted and stuff, and that was a huge fun.
[17:28] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[17:29] Robert W. Schneider: But they thought they could get away with like this is the one fucking iconic moment in the show.
[17:33] Kevin David Thomas: Can she at least do that?
[17:35] Robert W. Schneider: She's like, nope.
[17:36] Bryan Hobgood: Ah, yeah, yeah.
[17:38] Robert W. Schneider: There it is.
[17:39] Kevin David Thomas: Well, that's hilarious, and I'm glad you know it.
[17:42] Robert W. Schneider: I love it.
[17:42] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm glad that I know who you're talking about without you telling me.
[17:45] Robert W. Schneider: Um, but anyway, so I would vote for Hello, Dolly!, I think here, but I think it'll probably be, I think it'll be Catherine Zuber for War Paint.
[17:52] Kevin David Thomas: Really?
[17:53] Robert W. Schneider: I do.
[17:53] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, interesting.
[17:54] Robert W. Schneider: I do. I don't think Natasha will win this one.
[17:56] Kevin David Thomas: Um, Catherine Zuber is she has more Tonys than she knows what to do with.
[18:00] Robert W. Schneider: She's won a million times, but I mean, they did look fantastic in War.
[18:06] Kevin David Thomas: Very high fashion.
[18:07] Robert W. Schneider: She's always like Bart Sher's go-to person for like Light in the Piazza and South Pacific and like all those massive shows that always win design awards.
[18:14] Kevin David Thomas: Um, they're gorgeous costumes.
[18:16] Robert W. Schneider: Anastasia's are gorgeous costumes too, but as you mentioned in a different podcast that we did about the picture that they always use, that bathrobe costume.
[18:25] Kevin David Thomas: Like the gowns are all like the opening scene when all the royal family is in ball costumes, gorgeous.
[18:32] Robert W. Schneider: But um, yeah, I don't know.
[18:34] Kevin David Thomas: It could go, it could go at anybody.
[18:35] Robert W. Schneider: It really could.
[18:36] Kevin David Thomas: I want Paloma to win.
[18:37] Robert W. Schneider: I could see Paloma.
[18:38] Kevin David Thomas: We had her as a guest a couple weeks, months ago, but her work is really stunning on that.
[18:42] Robert W. Schneider: Well, because it's interesting.
[18:43] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, these other three outfits, Anastasia and War Paint, you're really basing it off of a silhouette from a time period.
[18:50] Robert W. Schneider: And Hello, Dolly!, you're kind of basing it off the original designs.
[18:53] Kevin David Thomas: But Paloma, I think it's just it's so unique and it's so new.
[18:56] Robert W. Schneider: It's this hybrid between Russian the period piece plus the modern sensibility.
[19:01] Kevin David Thomas: That really impresses me.
[19:02] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, that's not to diminish at all what any of these other designers have been because they are genius, but I think she had more of a challenge, and I think it's a really great challenge.
[19:09] Kevin David Thomas: I'm a little confused by the choice to have the ensemble in those like leather harnesses and stuff during the party scene.
[19:18] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, okay.
[19:19] Kevin David Thomas: We're still talking about Hello, Dolly!, right?
[19:21] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, yep, that's the one.
[19:23] Kevin David Thomas: I love watching, you know, Kate Baldwin come out with our whip and her cattail.
[19:28] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[19:28] Kevin David Thomas: Ribbons down my back.
[19:29] Robert W. Schneider: Ribbon.
[19:31] Kevin David Thomas: Off she goes.
[19:31] Robert W. Schneider: I can't believe I didn't think of that first.
[19:33] Kevin David Thomas: Um, yeah, no, so the Paloma, I like her work, but there were a few things in there I was a little confused by.
[19:39] Robert W. Schneider: But I she could win very well, you know.
[19:41] Kevin David Thomas: Fingers crossed.
[19:42] Robert W. Schneider: But you're hoping that it's Santo Laquasto.
[19:44] Kevin David Thomas: I kind of want it to be Santo.
[19:45] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, Dolly!
[19:46] Kevin David Thomas: He's genius.
[19:47] Robert W. Schneider: My god, he's worked for years and years and years and is so good.
[19:50] Kevin David Thomas: Scenic design of a musical.
[19:52] Robert W. Schneider: Our nominees are Rob Howell for Groundhog's Day, the musical.
[19:56] Kevin David Thomas: David Korins for War Paint.
[19:58] Robert W. Schneider: Is it Mimi Lien or Leanne?
[20:02] Kevin David Thomas: Lien.
[20:03] Robert W. Schneider: Maybe Lien.
[20:04] Kevin David Thomas: Lien?
[20:06] Robert W. Schneider: The incredible Mimi Lien for Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812, and Santo Laquasto for Hello, Dolly!.
[20:14] Kevin David Thomas: Hello.
[20:14] Robert W. Schneider: Hello.
[20:15] Kevin David Thomas: Dolly.
[20:16] Robert W. Schneider: Who is gonna take over for Bette Midler and Donna Murphy eventually?
[20:20] Kevin David Thomas: Who was gonna do that?
[20:21] Robert W. Schneider: I know what the rumor is.
[20:22] Kevin David Thomas: Sally Struthers.
[20:24] Robert W. Schneider: I would be there. Front row every night if it was Sally Struthers.
[20:30] Kevin David Thomas: Imagine.
[20:30] Robert W. Schneider: As Dolly Levi.
[20:31] Kevin David Thomas: Well, she does it all over the country now.
[20:33] Robert W. Schneider: I know.
[20:34] Kevin David Thomas: And always Patsy Cline.
[20:35] Robert W. Schneider: She's uh she has three.
[20:36] Kevin David Thomas: She has Hello, Dolly!, always Patsy Cline, and Roz in 9 to 5.
[20:40] Robert W. Schneider: Done.
[20:41] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[20:41] Robert W. Schneider: Uh Glonquit?
[20:43] Kevin David Thomas: You're welcome.
[20:43] Robert W. Schneider: Thank you.
[20:44] Kevin David Thomas: You've heard have you heard the rumor of what they're trying to get?
[20:46] Robert W. Schneider: Is it Patti LaBelle?
[20:44] Kevin David Thomas: Barbara Streisand.
[20:44] Robert W. Schneider: No.
[20:44] Kevin David Thomas: They're trying to get Dolly Parton.
[20:50] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, I heard that.
[20:51] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[20:52] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, which I would be there every night.
[20:54] Kevin David Thomas: I think she'd make a great show.
[20:55] Robert W. Schneider: She'd be so good.
[20:56] Kevin David Thomas: So would Reba McEntire.
[20:58] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, I mean, Reba can do anything.
[21:00] Kevin David Thomas: I won't Whoopi Goldberg.
[21:02] Robert W. Schneider: No.
[21:02] Kevin David Thomas: Why do you mean no?
[21:03] Robert W. Schneider: Why?
[21:03] Kevin David Thomas: Because she can't sing?
[21:05] Robert W. Schneider: Because she can't act.
[21:08] Kevin David Thomas: Anymore.
[21:09] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, okay.
[21:10] Kevin David Thomas: I like her.
[21:11] Robert W. Schneider: Okay.
[21:12] Kevin David Thomas: Well, somebody said Patti LaBelle.
[21:15] Robert W. Schneider: I don't.
[21:16] Kevin David Thomas: I've I have no thoughts about it because it's too, it's too soon.
[21:20] Robert W. Schneider: It's too recent for me to formulate thoughts.
[21:24] Kevin David Thomas: Patti LaBelle.
[21:25] Robert W. Schneider: Uh, who's it gonna be?
[21:27] Kevin David Thomas: Um, I think it's probably gonna be Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet for Mimi Lien, but I have an unpopular opinion here, and I want it to be Rob Howell for Groundhog's Day.
[21:36] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, that's okay.
[21:37] Kevin David Thomas: I think you were gonna say somebody else.
[21:38] Robert W. Schneider: That's that's one of the other two.
[21:43] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, okay.
[21:43] Robert W. Schneider: Um, you want Groundhog's Day.
[21:45] Kevin David Thomas: I do.
[21:46] Robert W. Schneider: I think that that set is really awesome, despite the fact that it obviously has problems functioning correctly.
[21:51] Kevin David Thomas: Um, there were some really beautiful moments.
[21:53] Robert W. Schneider: I just think it's so stunning.
[21:54] Kevin David Thomas: I found myself watching the set oftentimes during this production.
[21:58] Robert W. Schneider: And the use of the show.
[21:59] Kevin David Thomas: Because you couldn't hear anything.
[22:00] Robert W. Schneider: Because I couldn't hear anything and couldn't didn't like it.
[22:02] Kevin David Thomas: Um, but I thought the when they would like the it was like a lake with the reflection of the houses, and they were a miniature, yet it still looked real and beautiful.
[22:12] Robert W. Schneider: I thought it was really, really just the chase well done, really well designed.
[22:17] Kevin David Thomas: Um, that being said, it's probably gonna be Natasha Pierre because of what they did to that theater.
[22:21] Robert W. Schneider: They converted that theater into a completely unrecognizable space.
[22:24] Kevin David Thomas: And it looks good.
[22:25] Robert W. Schneider: It does look good.
[22:26] Kevin David Thomas: It's beautiful, it's beautiful.
[22:29] Robert W. Schneider: So let's hope.
[22:30] Kevin David Thomas: Fingers crossed.
[22:30] Robert W. Schneider: All right. Looks like Natasha Pierre's gonna sweep a lot of the design.
[22:33] Kevin David Thomas: Is that a pretty good assumption?
[22:35] Robert W. Schneider: I'm still not sure about the costumes, but I think set and lighting for sure.
[22:40] Kevin David Thomas: Well, it's two out of the three design, so featured actress in a musical.
[22:45] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my god, oh my god.
[22:46] Kevin David Thomas: Oh man.
[22:47] Robert W. Schneider: Kate Baldwin, Hello, Dolly!, Stephanie J. Block, Falsettos.
[22:52] Kevin David Thomas: Jen Kalella, Come From Away, Rachel Bay Jones, Dear Evan Hansen, and Mary Beth Peel for Anastasia.
[23:01] Robert W. Schneider: All right.
[23:02] Kevin David Thomas: What's it?
[23:03] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, well, this is just a wealth of riches.
[23:05] Kevin David Thomas: It really is.
[23:06] Robert W. Schneider: And the featured categories I always find are so, you know, the tough because they're featured in such different ways.
[23:11] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[23:12] Robert W. Schneider: Well, let's talk about it.
[23:13] Kevin David Thomas: Some really cool things here.
[23:14] Robert W. Schneider: First of all, Mary Beth Peel got her last Tony nomination almost 34 years ago, 33 years ago for King and I.
[23:21] Kevin David Thomas: Hasn't had one since.
[23:23] Robert W. Schneider: Since then, she's become a really popular fixture on television.
[23:25] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[23:26] Robert W. Schneider: So what a career.
[23:28] Kevin David Thomas: Career.
[23:29] Robert W. Schneider: Two shows this season.
[23:30] Kevin David Thomas: Two shows.
[23:30] Robert W. Schneider: Lelia is on Dangerous, and now this, good for you.
[23:33] Kevin David Thomas: Then we have Jen Kalella, who, God bless her, is a brilliant actress who's been in like every flop.
[23:38] Robert W. Schneider: She's the kiss of death, normally.
[23:40] Kevin David Thomas: I love High Fidelity.
[23:41] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[23:42] Kevin David Thomas: No, I loved it too, but these things don't run unfortunately.
[23:45] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[23:45] Kevin David Thomas: So now she's in something where she's not only the show's not only a hit, she's brilliant in it.
[23:50] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[23:51] Kevin David Thomas: She gets like the only standout song.
[23:53] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, she really does.
[23:54] Kevin David Thomas: It's like a real through sung night, you know.
[23:56] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[23:57] Kevin David Thomas: Then we have also Rachel Bay Jones.
[24:00] Robert W. Schneider: Okay.
[24:00] Kevin David Thomas: Somebody told me she didn't get a nomination for Pippin.
[24:03] Robert W. Schneider: Is that right?
[24:04] Kevin David Thomas: She didn't, and I'm so mad about it still to this day.
[24:06] Robert W. Schneider: How is that?
[24:07] Kevin David Thomas: I thought she just didn't win, which I'm still upset about.
[24:09] Robert W. Schneider: No.
[24:10] Kevin David Thomas: She wasn't even nominated.
[24:11] Robert W. Schneider: She was nominated for a Drama Desk and Outer Critics.
[24:13] Kevin David Thomas: She and Andrea Martin were both nominated for Pippin.
[24:15] Robert W. Schneider: Uh, Andrea Martin went on to win, obviously.
[24:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[24:18] Robert W. Schneider: But for the Tonys, Rachel Bay Jones missed a nomination because someone else got in.
[24:24] Kevin David Thomas: And I don't remember who it is now, but I remember it being like not okay.
[24:29] Robert W. Schneider: Rachel Bay Jones in Pippin was one of the funniest performances in the world.
[24:32] Kevin David Thomas: It's incredible.
[24:33] Robert W. Schneider: And a revelatory look into that character.
[24:35] Kevin David Thomas: So happy she's nominated for this.
[24:38] Robert W. Schneider: And then we have two people who are stars for us.
[24:41] Kevin David Thomas: Kate Baldwin, who's got this great reputation, does a beautiful "Ribbons Down My Back."
[24:45] Kevin David Thomas: And Stephanie J. Block, whose "I'm Breaking Down" is hysterical and is going to be seen on PBS pretty soon.
[24:49] Robert W. Schneider: I'm glad.
[24:50] Kevin David Thomas: Because they recorded Falsettos. So this is really like any way you go, you'll be happy. But who do we want, guys?
[24:58] Bryan Hobgood: I'd like to see Rachel Bay Jones. I think she also, there's a story of her having been in the business for a really long time. She's away from Broadway for something like 20 years and then is back. And I just think hers is a really good story, but I think that the acting work she does in that piece is breathtaking. Especially the end. I just think she's all I hear Dear Evan Hansen. People always talk about her. She's so it was great, but I mean that's like that's what people come leading out with is how brilliant she is and how her last moments are pretty genius as well.
[25:28] Robert W. Schneider: So you think it's gonna be Rachel Bay Jones and you want it to be Rachel Bay Jones.
[25:31] Kevin David Thomas: I have a feeling though, so if like people have said, if Falsettos was still running, I think Stephanie J. Block would be in the bag. I think she would be a given. But I think Jen Kalella has a strong chance too.
[25:43] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, yeah. I love four of the five performances here. Like love when I say love, I love four of the five performances, and I'm okay with the fifth. I think Rachel Bay Jones is going to win. I think you're right. But I think Jen Kalella has a shot, but it is such an ensemble piece that exactly it almost is hard to give it to her. But then, like you think of like Dan Fogler and Spelling Bee.
[26:08] Robert W. Schneider: That's true.
[26:09] Bryan Hobgood: And oh yeah, so they do it occasionally, but I think Rachel Bay Jones is going to win. But if I were casting my vote, this would be hands down, Stephanie J. Block. Because, as you said, Rob, "I'm Breaking Down" was the moment of that show. Like it really was a standout moment. And seeing Stephanie do comedy is always so good.
[26:25] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah, she's funny. She's really funny. She can belt her face off, and everyone knows that, but she can do comedy. This is a wealth of riches, this category. It really is.
[26:34] Robert W. Schneider: What do you say?
[26:35] Bryan Hobgood: I think it's gonna be Rachel Bay Jones. I think the hype has been around long enough. And although, I mean, like I said, there's I mean, Stephanie J. Block, it's a G. Oh, I can't, I can't. This is too hard for me. This is too hard.
[26:48] Kevin David Thomas: Why don't they just you know? Oh, you know what? I saw did you guys on our one of our other podcasts where we're talking about people that like she get an honorable mention, you know. Stephanie J. Block's, not even her understudy, the swing who went on for her. Do you know this story?
[27:04] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[27:06] Kevin David Thomas: She um Stephanie J. Block was sick. Her understudy was sick, and the young lady who covers the two neighbors, who doesn't even cover um was it it wasn't Stephanie Umo, was it?
[27:18] Robert W. Schneider: It it was wasn't it?
[27:20] Kevin David Thomas: Is that who it was?
[27:21] Robert W. Schneider: I think it was.
[27:21] Kevin David Thomas: Maybe it might have been. She was incredible.
[27:26] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[27:27] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, so she went on. She went on without like with like a like a two-hour rehearsal beforehand with the book in her hand, playing a role she didn't even cover. It was she and she was really fantastic. She was really, really wonderful. There's that and the story of um Gavin Creel being out in Hello Dolly and his understudy having to go on for him without any rehearsal.
[27:47] Robert W. Schneider: Courtney Bayland.
[27:48] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, of course it was. I knew that too because of title of show. What's her name again?
[27:52] Robert W. Schneider: Courtney Balin.
[27:53] Kevin David Thomas: Wait. Sorry, sorry, we have to cut this. No, she was also sick, so it was Stephanie.
[27:59] Robert W. Schneider: Okay, okay, okay.
[27:59] Kevin David Thomas: She's a regular understudy.
[28:00] Robert W. Schneider: Right, right.
[28:01] Kevin David Thomas: And Stephanie Umo was yeah, she she took over. Stephanie, very nicely done. Jesus. She's she on the one. Good job. Featured actor in a musical. Here we go.
[28:11] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[28:12] Kevin David Thomas: Gavin Creel. Hello, Dolly. Mike Faced. Feist? Mike Feist?
[28:16] Robert W. Schneider: Feist, I think it is.
[28:18] Kevin David Thomas: Oh shit. Mike Feist. Oh, he's wonderful from Dear Evan Hansen. Andrew Reynolds from Falsettos. Lucas Steele for Natasha Pierre in the Great Comet of 1812. And Brandon Urinowitz for Falsettos.
[28:31] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[28:31] Kevin David Thomas: All right.
[28:32] Robert W. Schneider: Another good category.
[28:33] Kevin David Thomas: This is also a wealth of riches. I uh I'm gonna have an unpopular opinion in this category.
[28:38] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, are you where I think a lot of people really want to see Lucas Steele win, and I did not care for his performance at all.
[28:44] Kevin David Thomas: Oh I am not alone. I don't get the love. He looks beautiful. Yes, he's I've seen him get better performances. Um he was not off Broadway musical The Kid with Christopher Sieber years ago. It was so moving and beautiful and what anyway. I'm not a fan of his in this show. I think it's uh overrated. But um I I would love to see Gavin Creel win just because he's been in the business so long and has never won, and my heart is with him. But if I were voting, Brandon Uranowitz for the Falsettos, because I think that he played that role in a way that was funny and touching, and he paired so well with Stephanie. I I I really really loved Brandon in that show.
[29:30] Robert W. Schneider: Okay, agreed. But I I think it's gonna go to Gavin Creel.
[29:33] Kevin David Thomas: I think so too.
[29:35] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, Gavin Creel.
[29:36] Kevin David Thomas: Gavin Creel.
[29:38] Robert W. Schneider: All right, um, leading actress in a musical. Our nominee nominees are Dine Benton, Natasha Pierre in the Great Comet of 1812, Christine Ebersol, War Paint, Patty Lapone, War Paint, Bette Midler, Hello Dolly, and Ava Noblezada for Miss Saigon.
[29:58] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, it's the divine Miss M. I mean, there's there's put on your Sunday, clothes your gun win. Uh Tony.
[30:05] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, you're welcome.
[30:06] Kevin David Thomas: Are you she worked her ass off too?
[30:08] Robert W. Schneider: She worked her ass off.
[30:09] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, and I'm gonna say, Rob, I know you and I have like differing opinions about this category. Um I I think Bet deserves to win. Not only is she going to, I think she deserves to I think so too.
[30:18] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, I thought you were like in Ava Noblazata's camp for some reason.
[30:23] Kevin David Thomas: No, I haven't, I haven't seen Russia Group.
[30:25] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, okay.
[30:25] Kevin David Thomas: I for some reason I thought that you had said that you were maybe I'm just gonna be able to do that.
[30:28] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, no, no, no. What I what I was saying was I said I think it's really gonna come down to Bet Midler. And if it's not Bet Midler, it might be Ava Noblezada just because she's new and she's young, and it might be and the performance is I as I've heard is incredible.
[30:42] Kevin David Thomas: Right. So that's that's a thing. It's like I think Bet deserves to win. She is working her ass off. She is so she oozes charisma. And I know a lot of people have kind of said, like, well, she's just playing a like she's playing Miss M as opposed to.
[30:58] Robert W. Schneider: Okay, but like, but that's that's like you're that's more than allowed. And also, if the audience is buying what you're selling, you're doing your job.
[31:06] Kevin David Thomas: That's the whole that's acting, I mean this whole show is it's about the persona of the person that's playing the role, and it's easily malleable. You can have somebody like her, you could have somebody like Andrea Martin, you could have somebody like Leroy Reims who did it in drag, you could have Carol Chan.
[31:21] Robert W. Schneider: Pearl Bailey, yeah.
[31:22] Kevin David Thomas: You pearl Bailey. You can have whatever you want in that role, as and it works.
[31:28] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, it works, but I will say this. I think she's wonderful in the show, but you know where I think she really stands out in all of the monologues to the dead husband.
[31:37] Kevin David Thomas: Mm-hmm.
[31:37] Robert W. Schneider: She is beautiful, yeah. She is touching. She has the audience seating out of the palm of her hand. It's an amazing performance. And I don't know. I don't know if this is if they've talked about this or not, but just a testament to how talented she is. She was rehearsing privately for the show a year before the first rehearsal.
[31:59] Kevin David Thomas: She got her own studio and she worked and she worked and she worked. So that way on the first day, she would know everything backwards and forwards.
[32:08] Robert W. Schneider: That's a leader.
[32:09] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. Think I mean, you hear these horror stories of some of these other like non-Broadway people who come in, they don't know their life. People wearing fucking earpieces. She's coming in a year before the first rehearsal to get her shit in shape.
[32:22] Robert W. Schneider: I think that's amazing.
[32:23] Kevin David Thomas: That's a pro. So but it shows on stage.
[32:26] Robert W. Schneider: It does.
[32:27] Kevin David Thomas: It does. And you said the touching moments, especially, but also the Harmonia end of the Harmonia Gardens.
[32:32] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, sure.
[32:33] Kevin David Thomas: She's eating in the dumplings.
[32:34] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[32:34] Kevin David Thomas: Her Harmonia Gardens is brilliant. She has the I mean stuffing them in her mouth one after the other. She is just the audience eating out of the palm of her hand. She's great.
[32:42] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[32:42] Kevin David Thomas: She's great. And she doesn't. I think if she was just playing a character, if she was just doing the Divine Miss M, then I think those monologues would have meant nothing.
[32:51] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[32:52] Kevin David Thomas: But she she's playing a character. She's having some beautiful moments on stage and she should be recognized. So yes, it should be Bette Midler and it will be Bet Medler. Period.
[33:00] Robert W. Schneider: I can't wait for it.
[33:01] Kevin David Thomas: Exclamation mark.
[33:02] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, and I can't wait for the speech.
[33:03] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, so ready for it.
[33:05] Robert W. Schneider: Totally.
[33:05] Kevin David Thomas: I'm so ready for it. When I first of all, woman gets a standing ovation for just coming on stage, not even entrance applause.
[33:13] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[33:13] Kevin David Thomas: The night I saw it, the audience was up on its feet. She was brilliant.
[33:18] Robert W. Schneider: She was just absolutely brilliant.
[33:20] Kevin David Thomas: She is the leader of that show.
[33:21] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[33:22] Kevin David Thomas: She is the engine behind it. And it's a fabulous production, and I'm sure once she leaves, and you know, Donna Murphy will be brilliant, and I'm sure whoever's Joyce to Wit.
[33:32] Robert W. Schneider: I don't make fun of your religion.
[33:34] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know why you make fun of mine.
[33:38] Robert W. Schneider: I can't breathe.
[33:39] Kevin David Thomas: Okay. If I ever got to direct Joyce to wit, I would just be dead. I would be so happy. Um let's go to leading actor in a musical. The nominees are Christian Borel for Falsettos, Josh Groban for Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812, Andy Carl for Groundhog's Day the Musical, David Hyde Pierce for Hello Dolly, and Ben Platt for Dear Evan Hansen.
[34:04] Robert W. Schneider: And are we pretty much in the same category as we are with Bette Midler on this one?
[34:09] Kevin David Thomas: I don't think so.
[34:11] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, I am.
[34:13] Kevin David Thomas: You think he's gonna be waving through a window to Andy Carl?
[34:15] Robert W. Schneider: I think that there's a ch I'm not saying that he's gonna lose. I think Ben Platt's going to win, but not by the same margin that Ben Midler's gonna win. I mean, like, to me, there is a lot of goodwill in the community for Andy Carl. Especially after he tore his ACL or whatever it is, a detour and continued to perform. There's a lot of goodwill there. I will not be surprised if he wins. I'm I'm predicting Ben Platt to win. I think he will, but I will not be shocked if Andy Carl wins. Versus if like Christine Eversol won, it'd be a shock.
[34:51] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[34:51] Robert W. Schneider: You know, anyone beating Ben Midler is a shock. I don't think Andy Carl beating him is a shock. I think it's like, oh, okay. But I think Ben Platt's the favorite to win, though.
[35:00] Kevin David Thomas: He has to win.
[35:01] Robert W. Schneider: Interesting. What do you think, Kev?
[35:02] Kevin David Thomas: He has to win. He has to Ben Platt. He has to win.
[35:04] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, yeah.
[35:05] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, everyone's been talking about this performance for forever. No, no, no, pun intended on for forever.
[35:12] Robert W. Schneider: He's such a millennial.
[35:13] Kevin David Thomas: I well, I you know.
[35:14] Robert W. Schneider: Do you have the t shirt?
[35:16] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I got the t shirt.
[35:19] Robert W. Schneider: My broken arm. Uh okay, so we're gonna say Ben Platt.
[35:22] Kevin David Thomas: I think so. I will say, I I wouldn't be disappointed if Andy Carl won either, though, by the way. I thought his performance was fantastic. And I think that Ben Platt does border a little bit on caricature. And a shout.
[35:34] Robert W. Schneider: Sacrilege.
[35:35] Kevin David Thomas: Sorry about it. Sorry, not sorry.
[35:39] Robert W. Schneider: No, please. What are you what are you what are you apologizing for? I want to shout out to somebody who's also incredibly um well generous. That's David Hyde Pierce. I love him. You were thinking of upsets, and I was thinking of the year, the upset that he beat. He got the Tony over Rallo Sparzo and Rellos.
[35:56] Kevin David Thomas: So happy.
[35:56] Robert W. Schneider: Me too!
[35:58] Kevin David Thomas: I jumped out of my seat.
[35:59] Robert W. Schneider: Because he really shouldn't have won for Curtains, but did he beat him for Company?
[36:02] Kevin David Thomas: For Company, yeah.
[36:03] Robert W. Schneider: And he won for Curtains, but it was like that was not, he wasn't supposed to win.
[36:07] Kevin David Thomas: No, it was not. That was a big upset.
[36:11] Robert W. Schneider: I liked him in Curtains.
[36:13] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, he's very challenging in Curtain. I mean, the part's not really a but he could have been nominated.
[36:19] Robert W. Schneider: Yes, I know what you're about to say. And he's selfless my level. And he's like, no, I want Gavin to win, so let me go to leading actor. That's that's really uh I love him. His class act. He's a class act all the way.
[36:33] Kevin David Thomas: Um okay, let's talk about choreography. So Andy Blankin Bueller for Bandstand, Peter Darling and Ellen Kane for Groundhog's Day, the musical, Kelly Devine, Come From Away, Dennis Jones, Holiday Inn, the new Irving Berlin musical, and Sam Pinkleton for Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812.
[36:55] Robert W. Schneider: Very quickly. Have you guys seen that video that Laura Bonanti put out? Um it's it's a two-minute video. It's so funny. It's her with her baby, and she's like, I yeah, she's like, I saw every show. She's like, I wasn't like being a mom to a newborn or anything.
[37:09] Kevin David Thomas: I've seen every show, just ask me what it's about, and I'll tell you.
[37:12] Bryan Hobgood: And she runs through like the most like oddest like descriptions, and she goes, Holiday in the new Irving Berlin musical.
[37:18] Bryan Hobgood: She goes, Yes, Irving Berlin came back from the grave to write you a new musical.
[37:22] Robert W. Schneider: Was it on Theater Mania?
[37:23] Bryan Hobgood: I think so.
[37:24] Bryan Hobgood: She did the same thing last year on the show on theater.
[37:26] Robert W. Schneider: So they must have been.
[37:27] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, it was so funny.
[37:28] Robert W. Schneider: She's funny.
[37:29] Bryan Hobgood: Um, when they did uh uh Burgess Madison County, she was like, It's a show about my ex-husband hooking up with Carol Kelly O'Hara.
[37:35] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, is that right?
[37:36] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, I think she's got a good sense of humor.
[37:39] Robert W. Schneider: She does, she's hilarious.
[37:40] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, she's funny.
[37:41] Robert W. Schneider: Oh my god.
[37:41] Bryan Hobgood: Okay, so what do we want for choreography here, guys?
[37:44] Bryan Hobgood: I I have an idea.
[37:45] Robert W. Schneider: What do you do?
[37:46] Bryan Hobgood: I feel very meh about this category this year.
[37:49] Robert W. Schneider: I yeah, I see mostly do.
[37:52] Bryan Hobgood: I love where choreography is going, where it's a full ensemble is doing movement and it's adding to the storytelling, and I love that, and I think Kelly Devine does it beautifully with Come From Away.
[38:01] Bryan Hobgood: Um, but I do not feel strongly about about them really.
[38:05] Bryan Hobgood: I feel meh about four of them, but there's one that I feel very strongly about and deserves to win and won't, sadly.
[38:12] Bryan Hobgood: And that's Dennis Jones for Holiday Inn.
[38:14] Robert W. Schneider: You think he deserves?
[38:16] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, that jump rope.
[38:17] Bryan Hobgood: He should that choreography was outstanding.
[38:20] Bryan Hobgood: Because it's it's tap, but it's tap done.
[38:23] Bryan Hobgood: It's like old school.
[38:25] Bryan Hobgood: It's old school tap, but like done really impressively.
[38:28] Bryan Hobgood: The jump roping with the the strands of lights and uh I and the buckets.
[38:32] Bryan Hobgood: I don't know.
[38:32] Bryan Hobgood: I really was into it.
[38:34] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, it's pretty cool.
[38:35] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[38:35] Robert W. Schneider: So, but who do you think will win?
[38:37] Bryan Hobgood: I I'm worried it's gonna be Andy Blank and Bueller just because of the name because he wins so often, but not that not that his choreography in Van Stand's bad.
[38:44] Bryan Hobgood: Just I I don't want him to win just because he's Andy Blank and Bueller.
[38:47] Bryan Hobgood: Um I think it might be Sam Pinkleton for a great comment.
[38:53] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, interesting.
[38:54] Kevin David Thomas: They dance in it?
[38:56] Bryan Hobgood: No, not and not because I think there should be, but I think I don't think Holiday Inn's gonna win because I think it's gonna be forgotten.
[39:02] Bryan Hobgood: And I think of the other four shows, it's the one that is gonna be the most popular.
[39:07] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, interesting.
[39:07] Robert W. Schneider: Okay.
[39:08] Kevin David Thomas: And we'll just win it because.
[39:10] Bryan Hobgood: Interesting.
[39:11] Robert W. Schneider: I'm I I would vote for Andy Blank and Bueller.
[39:14] Robert W. Schneider: Because I really oh no, oh no.
[39:16] Robert W. Schneider: Not not because of the name.
[39:18] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, come from yeah.
[39:20] Robert W. Schneider: I uh I at least there was some dancing happening there.
[39:23] Robert W. Schneider: I don't know.
[39:24] Robert W. Schneider: I mean, Holiday Inn would be great, but they're not gonna vote for that because it's it's closed at this point.
[39:28] Robert W. Schneider: Although it was pretty incredible.
[39:29] Bryan Hobgood: If Dennis Jones or Andy Blank and Bueller wins, I'll be happy.
[39:32] Bryan Hobgood: The other three, it's fine.
[39:33] Robert W. Schneider: What about you, Kev?
[39:36] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know.
[39:36] Kevin David Thomas: I told you I feel very meh about it.
[39:38] Kevin David Thomas: Uh Groundhog Day had a lot of movement.
[39:42] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, it was the same movement over and over again.
[39:44] Kevin David Thomas: I know.
[39:45] Kevin David Thomas: It still had a lot of it.
[39:47] Kevin David Thomas: I think you absolutely did, and they, you know, and they're the I don't know, does the car chase count as choreography?
[39:52] Bryan Hobgood: I I don't I liked Groundhog's Day, and I know you did not, but I I liked it.
[39:56] Bryan Hobgood: And um, but the choreography to me is like fine.
[40:00] Bryan Hobgood: Uh to me, it's the musical staging, the direction is more impressive.
[40:03] Bryan Hobgood: I don't know.
[40:03] Bryan Hobgood: The choreography is there.
[40:05] Kevin David Thomas: Fine.
[40:05] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[40:06] Kevin David Thomas: Same thing with because I think of that as Natasha Pierre, the that as musical staging as well.
[40:10] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, it was beautiful stage.
[40:11] Bryan Hobgood: Right, exactly.
[40:12] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, you know.
[40:13] Kevin David Thomas: Um, but yeah, I don't I you want some dance and dance up for choreography.
[40:18] Bryan Hobgood: Right, that exactly.
[40:19] Bryan Hobgood: Then it then it probably will go to Blank and Bueller.
[40:22] Kevin David Thomas: Okay.
[40:23] Robert W. Schneider: All right.
[40:23] Robert W. Schneider: So bandstand, that might be your one.
[40:25] Bryan Hobgood: All right.
[40:26] Bryan Hobgood: Out of two.
[40:27] Bryan Hobgood: Best direction.
[40:28] Bryan Hobgood: Ah, Christopher Ashley.
[40:31] Bryan Hobgood: Come from away.
[40:32] Bryan Hobgood: Rachel Chafkin, Natasha Pierre, and the great common of 1812, Michael Grife, Dear Evan Hansen, Matthew Warchis, Groundhog's Day the Musical, and Jerry Zach's.
[40:42] Robert W. Schneider: Hello, Dolly.
[40:46] Bryan Hobgood: No, uh no uh no uh Robert De Niro.
[40:50] Robert W. Schneider: No, no Robert DeMiro for uh The Bronx Tale Bronx Tale.
[40:54] Bryan Hobgood: No Kathleen Marshall for treadmill.
[40:57] Bryan Hobgood: I mean in transit.
[40:58] Bryan Hobgood: Treadmill stop by They were on a treadmill the whole time.
[41:04] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[41:06] Bryan Hobgood: I was on a treadmill the whole time.
[41:08] Bryan Hobgood: That's that's not that's not an insult to anybody.
[41:11] Bryan Hobgood: Um and and none for Pam McKinnon for Amelie.
[41:15] Bryan Hobgood: Uh I wanted it to be so good.
[41:16] Bryan Hobgood: Uh so um I have a Rosberry Fingers These are all very good directors.
[41:21] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, I mean these are this.
[41:25] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, strong category.
[41:25] Bryan Hobgood: And the strength, I mean, they're at the top of their game.
[41:28] Bryan Hobgood: Jerry Zach's, but um it but it all very good.
[41:31] Bryan Hobgood: He's on the top of his game now.
[41:32] Robert W. Schneider: Um yeah, I mean he's he's back.
[41:34] Bryan Hobgood: He is back.
[41:35] Bryan Hobgood: Uh and he is.
[41:36] Bryan Hobgood: I mean, hello, it's a hit, it's a huge hit.
[41:38] Bryan Hobgood: Um I think what Rachel Chafkin did in 1812 is really stunning.
[41:43] Robert W. Schneider: I think what about an 1813?
[41:45] Bryan Hobgood: Uh 1813 was uh just okay.
[41:47] Bryan Hobgood: It was like was a not a great year.
[41:48] Robert W. Schneider: Wasn't a great year.
[41:50] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah Rachel Chafkin's 1812.
[41:53] Bryan Hobgood: And I wonder how much come from away there there.
[41:57] Bryan Hobgood: I really loved Come From Away, and I thought it was seamless.
[42:00] Bryan Hobgood: I I think that the the collaboration between him and Kelly Devine was probably much of it because I thought that the musical staging was really, really well done.
[42:07] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, you know what I mean.
[42:08] Robert W. Schneider: That's a blurry line.
[42:09] Bryan Hobgood: I you as a director may be able to speak about that, but you know, how much does the choreographer do moving the bodies around and it's a collaboration?
[42:16] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[42:16] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[42:17] Bryan Hobgood: And my my feeling is I was so impressed with the environment Rachel Chafkin created for Natasha Pierre.
[42:23] Bryan Hobgood: Yes.
[42:24] Bryan Hobgood: But I found myself being more emotionally moved by what Christopher Ashley did in Come From Away somewhere.
[42:30] Bryan Hobgood: I I really want him to win the Tony Award for best director.
[42:34] Robert W. Schneider: You think Michael Grife has a has a shot?
[42:37] Bryan Hobgood: No, I don't know.
[42:39] Bryan Hobgood: I don't I mean he I I really don't.
[42:41] Bryan Hobgood: It's for many reasons, which I won't get I don't think so.
[42:44] Bryan Hobgood: He's he's literally my fifth on the list in terms of likelihood.
[42:47] Bryan Hobgood: He was the one I thought might get left out of the category.
[42:49] Robert W. Schneider: Oh wow.
[42:50] Bryan Hobgood: I thought there was a chance of Darko Trashnik getting in for Anastasia just because he is he just did obviously uh Gentleman's Guide a few years ago and won for that.
[42:59] Bryan Hobgood: And I think that Anastasia, while problematic, it has some pretty good direction in there.
[43:03] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, Deer of Hansen almost feels a little just kind of like standard, sort of like directs itself a little bit.
[43:08] Bryan Hobgood: Um here's what I'll say.
[43:11] Bryan Hobgood: I'm gonna be super biased here because to me, Come from away was the best musical of the season and just leagues like leaps and bounds above everything else.
[43:23] Bryan Hobgood: Um I was s sort of unimpressed with Rachel Shafkin's direction for Natasha Pierre.
[43:28] Bryan Hobgood: Again, having seen the show off Broadway in a smaller space, I didn't like how it worked in the bigger space.
[43:33] Bryan Hobgood: I thought it was beautiful.
[43:34] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, but to me, beautiful doesn't make good direction.
[43:37] Bryan Hobgood: I want it to be seamless.
[43:38] Bryan Hobgood: I want it to feel like it makes sense.
[43:41] Robert W. Schneider: Sure.
[43:41] Bryan Hobgood: And to me it didn't feel that way.
[43:43] Bryan Hobgood: I was a little distracted, kind of I felt like I was looking all over the place the entire time.
[43:48] Bryan Hobgood: Um almost because of what you were saying before with the lighting.
[43:51] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, yeah.
[43:51] Bryan Hobgood: You know exactly where to look because it the lighting tells you to, and that's great.
[43:55] Bryan Hobgood: It means the lighting is clear, but I felt like I was being directed to too many places too many times.
[44:00] Bryan Hobgood: Like, let's just focus on something.
[44:03] Bryan Hobgood: So I don't know.
[44:04] Bryan Hobgood: It was a little busy for me.
[44:06] Bryan Hobgood: Um I I think that the come from away direction is just gorgeous.
[44:10] Bryan Hobgood: I think it's seamless, I think it's beautiful, I think it's moving.
[44:13] Bryan Hobgood: It's it's um I I was really, really moved by that entire thing.
[44:18] Robert W. Schneider: And maybe that's the content of the show itself more than the direction, but I really thought it was beautiful.
[44:22] Bryan Hobgood: I think so.
[44:23] Bryan Hobgood: Um and honestly, my second choice would would be uh Matthew Worchess for Groundhog's Day.
[44:28] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, and again, I think that's a show that really doesn't work if it's not you know grounded, uh groundhogged, if you will.
[44:37] Bryan Hobgood: Uh but it to me, there's something really magical about the way he does his scene changes and the repetition of the scene over and over again at the beginning of the show.
[44:48] Bryan Hobgood: Um and the Andy Carl's big number at the top of act two, where he like kills himself many times, and the stage magic that happens with him disappearing and having a body double.
[44:58] Bryan Hobgood: It it to me it felt very seamless.
[45:01] Bryan Hobgood: I was at a performance where everything worked.
[45:03] Bryan Hobgood: I know that there have been performances where they've had to stop because of technical difficulties quite a bit, but for my performance, it was really, really smooth and really beautiful.
[45:12] Bryan Hobgood: So that would be my second choice.
[45:13] Bryan Hobgood: I but I I would like Christopher Ashley to win.
[45:16] Robert W. Schneider: Great.
[45:16] Robert W. Schneider: So Chris Ashley, all around.
[45:18] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[45:18] Robert W. Schneider: All right, Chris.
[45:19] Robert W. Schneider: Fingers crossed for you.
[45:21] Bryan Hobgood: Best revival of a musical this year.
[45:23] Bryan Hobgood: We only have three falsettos.
[45:27] Bryan Hobgood: Hello, Dolly and Miss Saigon.
[45:30] Robert W. Schneider: What do we want, guys?
[45:31] Kevin David Thomas: Hello, Dolly.
[45:32] Bryan Hobgood: Hello, Dolly.
[45:33] Robert W. Schneider: Yep.
[45:34] Kevin David Thomas: All right, that was easy.
[45:35] Robert W. Schneider: Hello, Dolly.
[45:35] Bryan Hobgood: Yep.
[45:36] Bryan Hobgood: I actually, this was this was a rough year for revivals, honestly, as far as I'm concerned.
[45:40] Bryan Hobgood: I don't know what was left out.
[45:41] Bryan Hobgood: Sunset Boulevard Cats and Sunday in the park with George took themselves out of it, which is a whole other sort of thing.
[45:46] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, Sunday was Sunday said we're not interested.
[45:49] Bryan Hobgood: We won our free seats to ourselves.
[45:50] Bryan Hobgood: Thank you very much.
[45:51] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, we wanted to be a good thing.
[45:52] Bryan Hobgood: That's pretty much it.
[45:53] Bryan Hobgood: I mean, that's so many seats, they would lose money.
[45:56] Robert W. Schneider: Um, yeah, I didn't even love that production, to be perfectly honest with you.
[45:59] Robert W. Schneider: But I know everybody else loved it.
[46:00] Robert W. Schneider: I thought it was boring as all hell.
[46:03] Bryan Hobgood: Um, but to me, Hello Dolly and Falsettos were the only productions worthy of uh of nominations this season.
[46:11] Bryan Hobgood: They had to nominate a third, so Miss Saigon got in.
[46:13] Bryan Hobgood: But um, I thought Sunset Boulevard was pretty terrible.
[46:15] Robert W. Schneider: I know you really, really liked it.
[46:17] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, I I thought it was I I liked I enjoyed it.
[46:21] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[46:21] Robert W. Schneider: But I saw it with my parents, so that might have colored it as well.
[46:24] Bryan Hobgood: I was bored from start to finish.
[46:26] Bryan Hobgood: And I thought it was other than Glenn, who of course is who you're going to see.
[46:31] Bryan Hobgood: I thought the rest of the cast was pretty uh not bad.
[46:34] Bryan Hobgood: They just seemed kind of like they were walking zombies a little bit.
[46:37] Bryan Hobgood: Like no energy.
[46:38] Robert W. Schneider: And I was at a matinee on a Wednesday.
[46:41] Robert W. Schneider: So No excuse.
[46:42] Bryan Hobgood: Okay, I agree with that, but um, I don't know.
[46:45] Bryan Hobgood: I just really wasn't feeling it.
[46:46] Bryan Hobgood: And cats, as much as I think the cast works their butts off, it's cats, and um there's not a lot to be said about that.
[46:53] Robert W. Schneider: But Tony Award winner for best musical.
[46:56] Bryan Hobgood: Cats.
[46:58] Robert W. Schneider: People love that show.
[46:59] Bryan Hobgood: That's true.
[47:00] Bryan Hobgood: I saw it the night after the election.
[47:03] Bryan Hobgood: And they stepped forward, Grizzabella stepped forward and made a political speech.
[47:07] Robert W. Schneider: Wow.
[47:07] Bryan Hobgood: In a cat outfit.
[47:08] Robert W. Schneider: That was something.
[47:09] Bryan Hobgood: Was it Leona Lewis at the time?
[47:11] Robert W. Schneider: Wasn't she British?
[47:13] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[47:14] Bryan Hobgood: But like, why?
[47:15] Bryan Hobgood: Like what?
[47:17] Bryan Hobgood: And it was all about like healing and you know, you know, thank you for supporting us, and you know, we do an important job.
[47:23] Bryan Hobgood: And I was like, Yes, you dress like a cat.
[47:25] Robert W. Schneider: It was it was very hard for me to take seriously, because I was like, You're dressed like a kid now.
[47:29] Bryan Hobgood: Like, but good for you.
[47:31] Bryan Hobgood: She was crying.
[47:32] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, geez.
[47:33] Bryan Hobgood: It was a very intense one.
[47:35] Bryan Hobgood: But I will say the theater is a healing.
[47:37] Bryan Hobgood: It is it did take me out of my problems for two hours and made me go, how did this win best musical 30 years ago?
[47:43] Robert W. Schneider: I stopped thinking about Trump for two hours, which was nice.
[47:46] Bryan Hobgood: Original score.
[47:47] Bryan Hobgood: Original score.
[47:49] Bryan Hobgood: We have come from away, the husband and wife team of Irene Sankoff and David Hein.
[47:53] Bryan Hobgood: Dear Evan Hansen with Bench Pesek and Justin Paul, Groundhog's Day, the musical, Tim Minchin, and Natasha Pierre's great comment of 1812, Dave Malloy.
[48:01] Robert W. Schneider: Ooh, what do we got, guys?
[48:02] Bryan Hobgood: I got mine.
[48:04] Bryan Hobgood: I mean, I'd be shocked at this point if it's not Passic and Paul for Dear Evan Hansen.
[48:09] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[48:10] Bryan Hobgood: I think the score isn't really stunning.
[48:13] Bryan Hobgood: I'm also biased because I'm friends with Bench, but you know what?
[48:15] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, but no, but let's go.
[48:15] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, there's no bias.
[48:16] Bryan Hobgood: It's it's so good.
[48:18] Bryan Hobgood: It's so well written.
[48:19] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, also, Dave Malloy is coming for uh Lynn Manuel's gig of being nominated in three or four different categories.
[48:25] Bryan Hobgood: Throw down, throw down, throw down, throw down.
[48:28] Bryan Hobgood: Um I yeah, it has to be Dear Evan Hansen, it has to be Pask and Paul.
[48:32] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[48:33] Bryan Hobgood: One, they're a juggernaut, but two, the score is fantastic.
[48:33] Robert W. Schneider: It really is.
[48:33] Bryan Hobgood: The score is fantastic.
[48:38] Bryan Hobgood: Each song, like I was saying another episode, like each song feels like it's a well-written hit song.
[48:42] Bryan Hobgood: I mean, they're all great songs.
[48:43] Robert W. Schneider: Well, the songs move the story forward and give us emotional insight into the character.
[48:48] Bryan Hobgood: I know that's wonky.
[48:50] Bryan Hobgood: Uh call me crazy.
[48:51] Bryan Hobgood: Call me crazy, but I think that's what a musical is supposed to do.
[48:54] Bryan Hobgood: And have some individuality within each song.
[48:56] Bryan Hobgood: I mean, each song is a different person in itself.
[48:58] Robert W. Schneider: What?
[48:59] Bryan Hobgood: I don't believe you.
[49:01] Robert W. Schneider: And they only wrote there's only like 14 songs in the show.
[49:03] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, it's a great score.
[49:03] Robert W. Schneider: It's not like 35 songs.
[49:05] Bryan Hobgood: I mean, it's they're concise, they're there, they tell the story.
[49:08] Robert W. Schneider: And 13 of them are great.
[49:09] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[49:10] Bryan Hobgood: What he says.
[49:12] Robert W. Schneider: The glove song.
[49:13] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[49:14] Robert W. Schneider: Skip song.
[49:15] Bryan Hobgood: That is a skip song.
[49:18] Robert W. Schneider: For Michael Park.
[49:18] Bryan Hobgood: I love him so much.
[49:19] Bryan Hobgood: I love you so much.
[49:20] Bryan Hobgood: Your work in Violet is amazing.
[49:21] Bryan Hobgood: You're different is wonderful.
[49:23] Bryan Hobgood: But the glove song is of skip song.
[49:25] Bryan Hobgood: Not that it's it's a fine song.
[49:27] Bryan Hobgood: And you do a great job on it.
[49:28] Bryan Hobgood: He does a great job.
[49:29] Bryan Hobgood: It sounds great.
[49:30] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, yeah. Book of a musical. We have our same groups from before, kind of Irene Sankoff and David Hein for Come From Away, husband and wife team. Steve Steven Levinson for Dear Evan Hansen. Danny Rubin, Groundhog's Day the Musical, and Dave Malloy for Natasha Pierre and the Great Common of 1812.
[49:48] Bryan Hobgood: Very quickly. This has not happened in quite some time.
[49:51] Robert W. Schneider: Where I was literally just gonna say the same thing.
[49:53] Bryan Hobgood: No, you go for it, Brian. Take it away.
[49:55] Bryan Hobgood: Well, it's just exciting that the four book of a musical nominees, the four score nominees, and the four best musical nominees are the same four shows in all three categories. First time since 2005, I believe, when Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, Light in the Piazza, Spam a Lot, and 25th Annual Putin County Spelling Bee.
[50:11] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[50:13] Robert W. Schneider: That year pisses me off.
[50:14] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, well, Spam a Lot won. Spam a Lot walked away as best musical. But it didn't win either of the other two. Spelling Bee won best book and Piazza won best score. And those should—Piazza should win best musical, probably. But I mean, I'm glad that Spam a Lot didn't win other things.
[50:31] Robert W. Schneider: I agree, but whatever. So here we have it. So what's it gonna be?
[50:38] Bryan Hobgood: I think a lot of people are predicting it to be Dear Evan Hansen, but for me the book is like highly problematic. Steven Levinson's—yeah, I have a lot of issues with the book of—I um, I don't love that they forced in the relationship aspect of it. I don't think it was necessary. I would be much more interested to see Evan's relationship with the mother of the victim, played by Jennifer Laura Thompson, because she is wildly underused, and I think she is such a good performer. And also there's so much more meat there in terms of like attachment when you're the mother. I just—I would be way more interested in seeing that relationship than a forced relationship that's so unnecessary to the plot. Anyway, um, so the book to me is kind of problematic, but—and the fact that he kind of gets off scot-free at the end—um, without giving away too many spoilers.
[51:28] Bryan Hobgood: Uh, yeah, well, to me, the best book is easily Come From Away. Yeah, it's hands down the best book in this category, as far as I'm concerned. And it should win. That's what I have here. Come From Away, best book.
[51:40] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I love Come From Away. I think if I were to be a betting man, though, I might put my money on Dear Evan Hansen.
[51:47] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, I think it will win.
[51:48] Kevin David Thomas: I think you're right.
[51:49] Bryan Hobgood: Ugh.
[51:49] Kevin David Thomas: But I don't want it to.
[51:50] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah.
[51:50] Kevin David Thomas: No, no, that's not—oh, sorry.
[51:53] Bryan Hobgood: Good.
[51:53] Kevin David Thomas: Good. And finally, gentlemen. We're getting closer. This is it. We're almost done. This is it. The 2017 Tony Award for Best Musical.
[52:03] Bryan Hobgood: All right. Goes to our nominees. They are Come From Away, Dear Evan Hansen, Groundhog's Day the Musical, and Natasha Pierre and the Great Commodore 1812.
[52:13] Kevin David Thomas: I'm upset that your musical did not get nominated this year. Joyce, exclamation point, the story of Joyce DeWitt as played by Sally Struthers, which I thought was really good, Kevin. I thought it was really great work.
[52:25] Kevin David Thomas: Well, what they're gonna do in the second half of the season, they're just gonna alternate the roles. So Joyce will come back.
[52:30] Bryan Hobgood: Oh.
[52:32] Kevin David Thomas: They'll just Sally one night, Joyce the other night. It's great. So then everyone wins. I bet you Dan Sullivan's gonna direct that brilliantly. I can't wait to see that.
[52:41] Bryan Hobgood: So best musical. I hate to say this. I think there's a what should win, and I think there's gonna be a what will win.
[52:51] Kevin David Thomas: I agree with you.
[52:52] Bryan Hobgood: I think Come From Away should win.
[52:54] Kevin David Thomas: Yep.
[52:56] Bryan Hobgood: And I think Dear Evan Hansen will win.
[52:58] Kevin David Thomas: Really?
[52:58] Bryan Hobgood: I agree with you 100%. There's no chance we think Come From Away could—I really think they've got a chance.
[53:04] Kevin David Thomas: I do think they have a chance. And here's—I think, especially in the last couple weeks.
[53:07] Bryan Hobgood: I was just gonna say I think that they've had some momentum, and I think that the political climate is gonna help them out quite a bit. Especially if Ben Platt does win for Best Actor and they win best score. I think people will be more willing to vote for Come From Away for Best Musical and feel like they're not taking away something important. Because I think that it's an important musical. I think Come From Away is an important musical. And they just announced the tour. Yep, you know, and it tours to all those towns as well. I think they've—it's a beautiful—it's exactly what theater should do.
[53:40] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[53:41] Bryan Hobgood: Agreed. 100% agreed. Yeah. Dear Evan Hansen is good, and Groundhog's Day is funny, and Natasha Pierre is interesting, but Come From Away does exactly what a musical should do.
[53:52] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[53:53] Bryan Hobgood: Mel Brooks says a musical should blow the dust off your soul, and that's exactly what Come From Away did. And you're right. I actually—you know what's interesting? I don't know if we'd be having the same discussion if it was Hillary Clinton in the White House.
[54:06] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I absolutely agree with you.
[54:08] Bryan Hobgood: Well, I think because of the political climate that we're in, it's actually gonna help Come From Away. I really do. Voters are gonna want that statement.
[54:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I don't know if it would be this—I don't know if we'd be having the same conversation right now.
[54:18] Bryan Hobgood: I wish we were having that conversation.
[54:20] Kevin David Thomas: I wish we were having that conversation. But no, Come From Away is—it's so beautiful, but Dear Evan Hansen is such a juggernaut, and their marketing team has been brilliant about saying that this is the best new musical and it's gonna be the best new. And I think if people just hear that enough times, they just automatically buy into it. And Come From Away is a little engine that could.
[54:41] Bryan Hobgood: Really is. It's come out of no—it's a 9/11 musical.
[54:43] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, who would have thunk it? You know, for the cast and nobody's written by a group—not a cast of nobody, but there's no stars. There's no real big name recognition other than Kelli O'Hara. And by the way, I mean I guess, yeah, but God, it does it in such a way that it's tasteful and without being preachy.
[55:01] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, yeah. You can get—you can border on preachy and sentimental and have it pretty off-putting. But it is—I left that show being like, God, I feel alive. Life is good.
[55:12] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it was agreed. It was a life-affirming evening in the theater from start to finish, and it's—they handle it all beautifully. And going back to the direction, they play 90 million characters, and all they do is take off a hat or put on a jacket, and you know exactly who they are in that moment. Almost to a—and don't even poke fun at it. Like one of them does it twice in a scene or something, but they don't even—they kind of wink at it, but they don't make it a—you know, but it's not—it's not like a 20-minute like 39 Steps or something.
[55:42] Bryan Hobgood: No, no, no, no, no. If everything is right in the world, Come From Away will win Best Musical.
[55:48] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, agreed. And that's no offense to these other three lovely shows. Uh, yeah, totally. Really, Dear Evan Hansen, because Dear Evan Hansen, I think also is trying to tackle some important subject matter which needs to be talked about at some point. But there's something about Come From Away. It's just so damn special.
[56:03] Bryan Hobgood: It's pretty cool that they're original musicals, too.
[56:06] Kevin David Thomas: I know.
[56:08] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, yeah. I mean, all of them but Groundhog's Day, right?
[56:10] Kevin David Thomas: All of them but Groundhog's Day. Because, I mean, you can sort of say Natasha Pierre is like based on a section of War and Peace, but like it's not a good idea.
[56:15] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah, I mean, like that's pretty awesome that we have original shows. This is very exciting. And congrats, and especially to the Come From Away and Dear Evan Hansen, because there's nothing—there's really—well, Come From Away is it based on a true event?
[56:28] Kevin David Thomas: Well, yeah.
[56:29] Bryan Hobgood: Well, it's based on a true event. But the characters are all made up. It's still made up. I mean, that is amazing. To put that story together so seamlessly, unbelievable. By the way, I hope it makes the tourism factor in that town skyrocket.
[56:42] Kevin David Thomas: Oh goodness, it will.
[56:43] Bryan Hobgood: I really hope it does.
[56:45] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I'm gonna go to Gander.
[56:47] Bryan Hobgood: Oh no. We're going on a cruise to Canada at the end of June, and I was like, oh, Gander.
[56:51] Kevin David Thomas: No, darn it.
[56:52] Bryan Hobgood: Oh my god, so much fun. Guys, we should take a trip and do our next podcast from there.
[56:58] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, from Gander.
[56:59] Bryan Hobgood: From Gander. Now, you know, that's what we should do no matter where the show is taking place. We should like go do a like a remote, you know. If next year the show takes place in Paris, we're going to Paris.
[57:10] Kevin David Thomas: There's some places I won't go though.
[57:11] Bryan Hobgood: Okay.
[57:12] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. I can't go back to Mexico City.
[57:15] Bryan Hobgood: Legal reasons.
[57:16] Kevin David Thomas: Legal reasons. You can put me in my eyes.
[57:19] Bryan Hobgood: Well, you can put me in remotely, or I need to stay 20 feet away from all goats.
[57:23] Kevin David Thomas: It's a long story.
[57:24] Bryan Hobgood: Oh my gosh. Even the ones named Sylvia.
[57:27] Kevin David Thomas: That's my ex. Sylvia's my ex.
[57:29] Bryan Hobgood: Okay. Bring that back. That was such a good show. That was such a good—Kevin Kline and Meryl Streep should do The Goat.
[57:37] Kevin David Thomas: The musical.
[57:38] Bryan Hobgood: Goat. The goat. Or Who is Sylvia? Question mark, exclamation mark. And we need some social media in there.
[57:46] Kevin David Thomas: Hey, I have a question. This is a social media question. How come when I go open up a playbill, I can't find any of their social media stuff in the playbill?
[57:56] Bryan Hobgood: Like the show's social media stuff?
[57:58] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. Like the actors.
[57:59] Bryan Hobgood: No, like the show stuff. Like when I go to the title page, like why doesn't it say like hashtag Come From Away or @Come From Away?
[58:05] Kevin David Thomas: Like at the bottom or something.
[58:07] Bryan Hobgood: I don't know. They usually put them like in the lobby. But I'm like, that should be my playbill.
[58:12] Kevin David Thomas: They've just stuck with the format that they've had since before. I think we're like in a transitional time period right now. We'll see that soon.
[58:19] Bryan Hobgood: They should be there. I don't know why I had to bring that up or why that was so important to you. You young at heart tech person, you—I'm trying.
[58:26] Robert W. Schneider: Well, for Bryan, thank you so much for joining us.
[58:28] Bryan Hobgood: Oh my god, thank you for having me.
[58:31] Robert W. Schneider: And I'm assuming we'll see you again next year.
[58:33] Bryan Hobgood: I hope so. If you have me.
[58:34] Robert W. Schneider: And I wonder—oh, always. Bryan brought pastries for us, so he's always welcome back, no matter what the hell's going on. I wonder what's gonna be next year.
[58:45] Bryan Hobgood: Who knows? Maybe we—we know The Band's Visit is coming, and I'm super stoked with that.
[58:50] Robert W. Schneider: It's a little preview. We know The Band's Visit, The Prom.
[58:53] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, is that coming for sure?
[58:55] Robert W. Schneider: I think so. My client's in that, yeah.
[58:57] Bryan Hobgood: Which I hear has got great reviews.
[58:58] Robert W. Schneider: I know nothing about great reviews, yeah.
[59:01] Bryan Hobgood: You're okay. Band's Visit, Prom. What else is there?
[59:04] Robert W. Schneider: I don't know. That's it. Is it only two musicals?
[59:06] Bryan Hobgood: We're still just trying to get through this season.
[59:08] Robert W. Schneider: You're so close.
[59:09] Bryan Hobgood: I know. You're so close.
[59:11] Robert W. Schneider: I know that we have a few plays coming. Well, we just started at the Hudson. Something just opened.
[59:14] Bryan Hobgood: 1984.
[59:16] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, and I think Three Tall Women with Laurie Metcalf and Glenda Jackson.
[59:21] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, we're coming in.
[59:23] Robert W. Schneider: How can I forget? We have the Harry Potter plays coming in.
[59:25] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, Harry Potter is coming in. It's gonna be a juggernaut. Uh, what else? Anything else that's coming in that we're excited about?
[59:30] Bryan Hobgood: Prince of Broadway is gonna be interesting.
[59:32] Robert W. Schneider: How Prince Brought, yeah, yeah, yeah, the Hal Prince retrospective. There's a rumored revival of My Fair Lady happening.
[59:37] Bryan Hobgood: Oh, yes, yes, yes, yes.
[59:38] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah, some good things. So we'll be excited.
[59:40] Bryan Hobgood: Yeah. So we'll see you all next year to talk about the 2018 Tony Award nominations, where hopefully Kevin and I will be nominated for our production of Waiting for Godot.
[59:50] Robert W. Schneider: In rep with God with Agnes of God. Our Waiting for Godot is going to be called Waiting for Leroy.
[59:56] Bryan Hobgood: And it's—we sit on a bench and we wait for Leroy Reams to show up for a podcast interview.
[1:00:01] Robert W. Schneider: And then we listen to him.
[1:00:02] Bryan Hobgood: And we listen to him for eight hours.
[1:00:04] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, I love him so much.
[1:00:06] Bryan Hobgood: It's a three-parter.
[1:00:06] Robert W. Schneider: Yep.
[1:00:07] Bryan Hobgood: So just like Waiting for Godot. It's just like Waiting for Godot, but with, you know, numbers from Hello, Dolly!
[1:00:13] Robert W. Schneider: All right then. I would pay for it.
[1:00:15] Bryan Hobgood: I would.
[1:00:18] Bryan Hobgood: Oh my God.
[1:00:20] Robert W. Schneider: What do you mean? That's brilliant.
[1:00:24] Bryan Hobgood: And halfway through, when everyone gets bored, they can just sing Revolutionary Costume.
[1:00:28] Robert W. Schneider: Right?
[1:00:28] Bryan Hobgood: I love it. Am I right? Am I right or am I right?
[1:00:32] Robert W. Schneider: You're right.
[1:00:32] Bryan Hobgood: I've got a hit here.
[1:00:33] Robert W. Schneider: All right. Till next time, everybody. Enjoy those Tonys on June 11th.
[1:00:37] Kevin David Thomas: June 11th?
[1:00:38] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[1:00:38] Kevin David Thomas: What time?
[1:00:39] Robert W. Schneider: 8 o'clock.
[1:00:40] Kevin David Thomas: CBS?
[1:00:40] Robert W. Schneider: CBS. Hosted by Kevin Spacey.
[1:00:44] Kevin David Thomas: Thank God they found somebody.
[1:00:45] Robert W. Schneider: Oh yeah. We didn't even talk about that.
[1:00:47] Kevin David Thomas: But Kevin Spacey.
[1:00:48] Robert W. Schneider: All right. He'll be fun. Maybe he'll try to sing a song or something.
[1:00:52] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I hope so.
[1:00:53] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, last year was so special, though. That was the best Tony broadcast, I think.
[1:00:57] Kevin David Thomas: Well, he was fantastic.
[1:00:58] Robert W. Schneider: He's a brilliant host.
[1:01:00] Kevin David Thomas: He was great. Tone was perfect. He loves—he loves Broadway. You have to have somebody that loves Broadway.
[1:01:04] Robert W. Schneider: When is he coming back to us?
[1:01:06] Kevin David Thomas: He would have been great in Forum.
[1:01:08] Robert W. Schneider: Which—well, that could still happen.
[1:01:11] Kevin David Thomas: But me and my girl. Can he go do me and my girl an encore?
[1:01:15] Robert W. Schneider: Can he do any? He really is just so talented.
[1:01:17] Kevin David Thomas: He's so talented. I'd watch him do just about anything.
[1:01:19] Robert W. Schneider: And I hear he's a really nice guy.
[1:01:20] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[1:01:20] Robert W. Schneider: Yeah.
[1:01:21] Kevin David Thomas: I hope so.
[1:01:21] Robert W. Schneider: Isn't that nice? I always like when you hear like the night the famous people are nice.
[1:01:25] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I know.
[1:01:25] Robert W. Schneider: I agree.
[1:01:26] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[1:01:27] Robert W. Schneider: Unlike you.
[1:01:28] Kevin David Thomas: Rob Sassy.
[1:01:30] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, he's so sassy.
[1:01:31] Kevin David Thomas: Save it for the stage.
[1:01:32] Robert W. Schneider: I'm gonna leave these two alone for a minute.
[1:01:35] Kevin David Thomas: Okay.
[1:01:35] Robert W. Schneider: Swallow, Kevin.
[1:01:37] Kevin David Thomas: Bye.
[1:01:38] Robert W. Schneider: Oh, bye everyone.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
