Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and underappreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
About
Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and underappreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business. This Week: A book that needs to be revised and a musical that needs to be revived!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] ♪ Musical number: "My Favorite Things" — performed by Unknown performer ♪
[0:18] Robert W Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W Schneider.
[0:19] Kevin David Thomas: And I am Kevin David Thomas.
[0:21] Robert W Schneider: And this is our favorite things.
[0:24] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know why I said it like that.
[0:25] Robert W Schneider: I like it like that.
[0:25] Kevin David Thomas: That's true.
[0:26] Robert W Schneider: Do you like it like that?
[0:26] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, no, we should do it like that every time.
[0:28] Robert W Schneider: My favorite things.
[0:30] Kevin David Thomas: Do you know?
[0:30] Robert W Schneider: Oh, I was just gonna say, you know, I still giggle.
[0:32] Kevin David Thomas: You know, we ask for people to do our ratings and stuff, and we have that little tag in the front of it.
[0:36] Robert W Schneider: Yeah.
[0:36] Kevin David Thomas: I still, because I do listen to our third, you know, throwback Thursdays.
[0:39] Robert W Schneider: I still laugh at you doing the Paul Lynde doing Shicks the Goddess, Paul.
[0:43] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, Rob, I'm like dying.
[0:44] Robert W Schneider: I called you Paul just now.
[0:47] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you very much, Kevin.
[0:51] Robert W Schneider: I used to do a really good one, and I do not know what happened.
[0:53] Kevin David Thomas: I'd like to see your one-man Paul Lynde show, actually.
[0:56] Robert W Schneider: I think that would be really, really good.
[0:57] Kevin David Thomas: Well, actually, I'm going into Hamilton as Paul Lynde.
[1:01] Robert W Schneider: I would give anything for a wrap of that.
[1:04] Kevin David Thomas: I want you to work that up, workshop that, and give me like a nice, you know, the opening number.
[1:08] Robert W Schneider: Well, I'm actually going in for Peggy.
[1:10] Kevin David Thomas: Oh.
[1:10] Robert W Schneider: It's just one lyric I have, and I walk away.
[1:12] Kevin David Thomas: They go Eliza and Peggy.
[1:15] Robert W Schneider: And then I just walk off stage.
[1:17] Kevin David Thomas: He could be in the room where it happens.
[1:19] Robert W Schneider: Good.
[1:19] Kevin David Thomas: He should be.
[1:20] Robert W Schneider: He should be in the room where it happens.
[1:22] Kevin David Thomas: Always, every room.
[1:23] Robert W Schneider: How does a bastard orphan?
[1:26] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[1:27] Robert W Schneider: That's how.
[1:28] Kevin David Thomas: God do I love me some Paul.
[1:30] Robert W Schneider: You do.
[1:31] Kevin David Thomas: I really do.
[1:32] Robert W Schneider: Center square all the way.
[1:34] Kevin David Thomas: Center square.
[1:36] Robert W Schneider: Speaking of, I mean, can we mention that?
[1:38] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.
[1:40] Robert W Schneider: Yes, actually, yeah, we can.
[1:41] Kevin David Thomas: One of our upcoming guests, we just secured him.
[1:44] Robert W Schneider: I'm so excited.
[1:45] Kevin David Thomas: Is Peter Marshall.
[1:47] Robert W Schneider: Best known probably for hosting Hollywood Squares, but has had a long theatrical career.
[1:53] Kevin David Thomas: And has worked with some incredible legends himself, in addition to himself being a wonderful legend.
[1:57] Robert W Schneider: Um check.
[1:58] Kevin David Thomas: I can't I want to ask him about Paul Lynde.
[2:00] Robert W Schneider: I want to ask him in the world.
[2:01] Kevin David Thomas: And Charles Nelson Reilly wasn't Charles.
[2:02] Robert W Schneider: Oh, Charles Nelson Reilly.
[2:05] Kevin David Thomas: No, Charles Match Game.
[2:07] Robert W Schneider: Dumb Doro was so dumb.
[2:10] Kevin David Thomas: How dumb was she?
[2:12] Robert W Schneider: Gene Rayburn's real long, thin microphone.
[2:15] Kevin David Thomas: I love that.
[2:16] Robert W Schneider: Cable just out to here.
[2:18] Kevin David Thomas: You know what I heard on those shows?
[2:20] Robert W Schneider: That they would film them all in one day.
[2:21] Kevin David Thomas: So what they would do is they would do Monday, Tuesday, when they would film Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday show, take a huge dinner break, and across the street was a bar, and they would all go over and get plastered and then come back and tape Thursday and Friday shows.
[2:37] Robert W Schneider: So somebody was saying if you watch the show, the later in the week it gets, the sloppier they become.
[2:43] Kevin David Thomas: I love it.
[2:44] Robert W Schneider: And it's because they were drinking on their bag.
[2:48] Kevin David Thomas: Like just real, like hanging out.
[2:50] Robert W Schneider: Well, I always feel bad because then they start to like shoot the contestant in the foot because they're drunk and they just want to make each other laugh.
[2:56] Kevin David Thomas: They don't care.
[2:57] Robert W Schneider: This poor like nurse from Pacoima is hoping to get $500 and they're making jokes about Betty White to her expense.
[3:04] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm like, God bless them.
[3:05] Robert W Schneider: So anyway, yeah, that's it.
[3:06] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, so Peter Marshall's gonna come off.
[3:08] Robert W Schneider: It's very exciting.
[3:09] Kevin David Thomas: Circle gets the square.
[3:11] Robert W Schneider: All right, Kevin, what's your favorite?
[3:13] Kevin David Thomas: I have a book today.
[3:14] Robert W Schneider: I have a book.
[3:15] Kevin David Thomas: Now I must confess that is.
[3:16] Robert W Schneider: I wish I could read.
[3:18] Kevin David Thomas: I don't think a lot of people are gonna hear this, and I don't think a lot of people are gonna go run out and buy this book because it's a very specific book.
[3:24] Robert W Schneider: I would call it a reference book.
[3:25] Kevin David Thomas: Reference book.
[3:26] Robert W Schneider: Per chance.
[3:27] Kevin David Thomas: Not even a coffee table book, it's a reference book.
[3:29] Robert W Schneider: Okay.
[3:29] Kevin David Thomas: Now I have definitely read it cover to cover when it came out.
[3:32] Robert W Schneider: It came out in 2004.
[3:34] Kevin David Thomas: It needs an update.
[3:35] Robert W Schneider: Definitely needs an update because there have been many cast recordings since 2004.
[3:39] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yes.
[3:41] Robert W Schneider: We have to thank Theater Mania for in 2004 putting and Michael Portantiere, who is a pioneer of you know the news and Broadway information getting to the masses.
[3:53] Kevin David Thomas: Um, and it's the Theater Mania Guide for Musical Theater Recordings.
[3:58] Robert W Schneider: How specific is that?
[4:00] Kevin David Thomas: I'm obsessed with this book.
[4:02] Robert W Schneider: I love this book.
[4:03] Kevin David Thomas: I literally oh gosh, I'm gonna push my glasses up on my nose and nerd out on you.
[4:07] Robert W Schneider: But I when I was on tour with Le Miz, I bought this book and it was like 2004, right when it came out.
[4:12] Kevin David Thomas: Definitely I bought it right away.
[4:13] Robert W Schneider: And back then I had some money, so I would just buy cast recordings right and left, especially the older stuff.
[4:18] Kevin David Thomas: And this book had they had like something like over a dozen people, but people like Ken Bloom, Gerard Alessandrini, the guy who did you know Forbidden Broadway, Peter Felicia, who we're gonna interview very soon.
[4:27] Robert W Schneider: Um, they had a whole roster of legitimate cast recording, I would say aficionados, who would then they divvied out all the recordings out there, and they had them all listen to it and review them.
[4:38] Kevin David Thomas: So you'd get like a paragraph review, one to five stars, only a couple five stars in there, and of their opinions on these cast recordings, and you had multiple, you would have all of the Jesus Christ Superstars and all of the you know Oklahomas and all of that.
[4:52] Robert W Schneider: So it wasn't just the one, you know, Broadway production, it was all of them.
[4:55] Kevin David Thomas: And you get little opinions on these recordings, and I read it cover to cover and I would star all the I would check the ones that I had.
[5:03] Robert W Schneider: I'm not kidding you, I would check the ones I had and I would star the ones I'd like.
[5:07] Kevin David Thomas: And I still in my wallet to this day, oh my god, I cannot believe I'm gonna say this.
[5:10] Robert W Schneider: I still I wrote a list out on a file card of the all the five-star ones, because if I didn't have the five-star a five-star recording, I thought like Grass Harp, you know, and stuff like that, or like Most Happy Fella, I was like, I need to get this.
[5:22] Kevin David Thomas: So then I would I would make that list, so I always had it on me.
[5:25] Robert W Schneider: So if I ever I you know, if I was ever at a because I used to go to stores and just look through all the cast albums, of course.
[5:30] Kevin David Thomas: And so I wouldn't know, of course.
[5:31] Robert W Schneider: And then I would know which ones I didn't have.
[5:33] Kevin David Thomas: So I would cross it off my list, and I still have it in my wallet.
[5:36] Robert W Schneider: I don't look at it very often anymore.
[5:38] Kevin David Thomas: But um yeah, I think that is incredible.
[5:44] Robert W Schneider: I'm 35 now and it still does.
[5:47] Kevin David Thomas: It is it is really a fantastic book, and I do think it should be updated.
[5:52] Robert W Schneider: It's a really cool book.
[5:53] Kevin David Thomas: And what they also do at the beginning, if you remember, they alphabetize it by um show title, but then at each like A B C D E F G, each chapter, like chapter A, it would have like Jerry Herman's favorite shows, and they interviewed all these people, and they would have um their favorite ones.
[6:10] Robert W Schneider: And so you would get to see, you know, Jerry Herman loves A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, just like me, you know.
[6:15] Kevin David Thomas: And they but they even include shows like Choo Choo Chow, everyone's favorite.
[6:15] Robert W Schneider: Everyone's favorite.
[6:21] Kevin David Thomas: I love that show.
[6:22] Robert W Schneider: I don't know that show.
[6:25] Kevin David Thomas: It was all about Choo Choo Chow.
[6:27] Robert W Schneider: But everything from that to Carousel.
[6:28] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, it was it was all of them.
[6:29] Robert W Schneider: And it's a thick, it's a great book.
[6:31] Kevin David Thomas: It's big, it's very chronicles everything.
[6:33] Robert W Schneider: Now, anything past 2004, no, you're not gonna get it.
[6:36] Kevin David Thomas: It's not in there.
[6:37] Robert W Schneider: Um, and I would love for them to update it, but there's so many cast recordings now.
[6:40] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, it might be hard to, but they did it to begin with.
[6:43] Robert W Schneider: And it was quite an it quite an undertaking, I have to say, for them to have truly as a whole, all you know, 16 of them listened to every single recording that for the most part there.
[6:54] Kevin David Thomas: Now they narrowed it down to Broadway productions.
[6:57] Robert W Schneider: It could have it like in other words, if it only stayed in London, they didn't re-like spend spend spend was not in there, or like I'm trying to think that wasn't heard of that.
[7:05] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it was like 2003 or four that that came out.
[7:08] Robert W Schneider: But um, or I'm trying to think of other shows like maybe Love Love from Judy, that that show, like so that never came to Broadway, they don't include per se.
[7:17] Kevin David Thomas: And movie musicals, of course they don't as well.
[7:19] Robert W Schneider: But anything on Broadway or Broadway too.
[7:21] Kevin David Thomas: They do off-Broadway recordings.
[7:22] Robert W Schneider: That's really interesting.
[7:23] Kevin David Thomas: So yeah, it's it I you know, is it something everyone's gonna go on Amazon right now and buy? Probably not.
[7:27] Robert W Schneider: But if you're a fan of the musical theater and you're a fan of cast recordings, or if you just want to learn a little bit about some shows that you thought, I didn't even know this show existed.
[7:36] Kevin David Thomas: What's Choo Choo Chow anyway?
[7:37] Robert W Schneider: This will tell you.
[7:38] Kevin David Thomas: And what I also like is that they included shows that never made it to CD.
[7:43] Robert W Schneider: They did like Donnie Brook.
[7:46] Kevin David Thomas: Donnie Brook, they review that, and now it's only on record.
[7:48] Robert W Schneider: Just a record, never been on C.
[7:50] Kevin David Thomas: Maybe now it's been changed. Like a time for singing, that's now digital.
[7:54] Robert W Schneider: You can get that, but that used to be a show that you can only get on record.
[7:57] Robert W Schneider: I don't know if they review Angel. I'm gonna say no, because it was not a commercial release. The Angels are little, uh, our holy grail of cast recordings because you can't find it anywhere. I should have it on display on the case.
[8:08] Kevin David Thomas: I thought you used to.
[8:09] Robert W Schneider: I used to, but I was aware somebody was gonna steal it, so I've locked it up.
[8:13] Kevin David Thomas: Namely me.
[8:15] Robert W Schneider: Kevin comes, I have to hide my angel album. Kevin's here, put it away. Oh god. Yeah, so it's a really fun little book, and it was really important to me as a collector, you know. I think it's a wonderful resource. And if you're a student of musical theater and you're listening to us, I think it's essential for you to have.
[8:28] Kevin David Thomas: Agreed, agreed.
[8:33] Robert W Schneider: And some of the opinions I may agree with and may not agree with, but I still think it's really fun to read about them. You know, like for example, like for Merrily We Roll Along, they'll list every album that of Merrily We Roll Along that's ever been produced, and they'll usually say that this one is better than the other two.
[8:48] Kevin David Thomas: Exactly.
[8:49] Robert W Schneider: And that's where the debate comes in. And that's what's exciting. I love it. You know, we love debating this stuff the same way people who love sports, you know. Who was the best baseball player?
[8:56] Kevin David Thomas: Totally.
[8:57] Robert W Schneider: You know, and I would say Joe Hardy.
[8:58] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, good. I just listened to Damn Yankees.
[9:01] Robert W Schneider: Did you really?
[9:02] Kevin David Thomas: That's so good. Every song's a hit tune.
[9:04] Robert W Schneider: Yeah. I feel I know more about sports through musicals than I do about actual, you know. Thank God for Damn Yankees. I would know nothing about baseball. Strike three, ball four. Okay, there we go. Got it. I know what's happening. Now I know what's going on. I know what's happening. Good for the Senators this year.
[9:20] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god. So what do you have?
[9:22] Robert W Schneider: Oh, mine. Mine this year. Mine this year. Are you kidding me? Mine, mine this year, and then I'm gonna retire. I hibernate until I can get a ticket to Hamilton, don't wake me.
[9:32] Kevin David Thomas: Exactly. 1997.
[9:34] Robert W Schneider: So we're getting a little bit of 90s now. Get out my, you know, denim and frosted tips.
[9:40] Kevin David Thomas: I had frosted tips.
[9:41] Robert W Schneider: John Kander, Fred Ebb.
[9:43] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah.
[9:44] Robert W Schneider: You know what it is? Steel Pier.
[9:45] Kevin David Thomas: Absolutely. Steel Pier.
[9:47] Robert W Schneider: Forgotten. I would say a score that maybe people don't associate always with Kander and Ebb. You know what? It never gets produced anywhere.
[9:54] Kevin David Thomas: I think it'd be hard to, right? Because it's so many dance shows.
[9:56] Robert W Schneider: It's very difficult. For those of you who don't know, Steel Pier is one of the last Kander and Ebb shows where John Kander was, uh, Fred Ebb was still alive for. We didn't really have—
[9:57] Kevin David Thomas: That's right, because the ones since 2004 on the Scots World Boys, but he was just one of the—
[9:57] Robert W Schneider: We'll talk about that another day.
[10:14] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, deceased to visit deceased.
[10:16] Robert W Schneider: That's right. So Steel Pier is one of the last where he's still around to witness what's going on. It's John Kander, Fred Ebb, and it's a musical about 1930s dance marathons, which it was originally based on a movie called They Shoot Horses, Don't They, which is a fantastic movie.
[10:33] Kevin David Thomas: But a title.
[10:34] Robert W Schneider: Which was about these individuals who, in order to earn some extra money during the depression, would go to these all-night dance marathons.
[10:41] Kevin David Thomas: Which existed?
[10:42] Robert W Schneider: I mean, I don't know much about—
[10:42] Kevin David Thomas: It's a good idea.
[10:43] Robert W Schneider: They totally existed. And the rules would be the contestants must dance for 45 minutes every hour, followed by a 15-minute break. If they fall, collapse, or for any reason stop dancing, they will be disqualified. And it was great. You would get a nice checkout of it. And so in the depression, it was a good way to earn money, but you needed to have stamina. And these things would go on twenty-four hours, forty-eight hours.
[11:10] Kevin David Thomas: So there was no sleep, there was no eating.
[11:12] Robert W Schneider: You had to constantly be on your feet. And it wasn't just like waltzing and tangoing, it was every single energetic dance you could think of. And so they made a movie about it in the 70s. And the movie, if you've never seen it, it stars Jane Fonda. It's really good.
[11:27] Kevin David Thomas: It's a really good movie.
[11:28] Robert W Schneider: So Kander and Ebb tried to get the rights to that. They were denied the rights to that. So they created their own movie, their own musical with a similar concept, except they added an otherworld element to it, which is there is a pilot whose plane was down, and the ghost of this pilot returns to make amends with the girl that he stood up years ago.
[11:51] Kevin David Thomas: And the young woman's played by Karen Ziemba.
[11:54] Robert W Schneider: Uh, the pilot was played by a really, really wonderful actor named Daniel McDaniel, who's since passed.
[11:59] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I don't know.
[12:00] Robert W Schneider: Um, he passed a few years ago. And it's a really wonderful show. Karen Ziemba plays this girl who was called Lindy's Lovebird. She was supposed to be the first girl that Charles Lindbergh kissed when he returned back from his trip, and that's her notoriety and her fame.
[12:18] Kevin David Thomas: Just decide Karen Ziemba.
[12:19] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, a great, fantastic dancer in her own right, and a singer actress.
[12:23] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[12:23] Robert W Schneider: She can do no wrong. She can also do no wrong. Her performance on the recording is heartbreaking. And you can sense the pain, you can sense her ache, you can sense her loneliness. It's the first musical Kristin Chenoweth was ever in.
[12:37] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[12:38] Robert W Schneider: Deborah Monk is in it. She sings a song called Everybody's Girl. Everybody loves that song. Gregory Harrison, TV star, he's been in a few musicals as well. He plays the guy who presides over the dance marathon.
[12:50] Kevin David Thomas: He's very sadistic.
[12:51] Robert W Schneider: Right. It's a really, really good, good musical. Choreography was by Susan?
[12:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Susan Stroman.
[12:57] Robert W Schneider: And the choreography, that's why I think it's complicated, which is you need about thirty people. They all need to be incredible dancers. And they have to go through every single dance vocabulary style from the 1930s imaginable. And it's a really, really good show. Songs that you might know would be First You Dream, Everybody's Girl, Second Chance, Willing to Ride.
[13:18] Kevin David Thomas: Willing to Ride, which is Karen Ziemba's big song at the beginning of the show.
[13:23] Robert W Schneider: The problem they say with Steel Pier was it was just coming off of Chicago.
[13:28] Kevin David Thomas: So Chicago, the revival of Chicago.
[13:30] Robert W Schneider: Right. So which was very dark, which was very cynical. And then the revival of Cabaret was starting to percolate, which was also very dark, very cynical. And so in the middle of all this comes Steel Pier, which is actually a very optimistic show in a lot of ways.
[13:47] Kevin David Thomas: Same songwriting team for those who maybe—
[13:53] Robert W Schneider: And the idea, the, uh, most of the reviews kept saying was when they stick to cynicism and they stick to exposing society's flaws and humanity's flaws, they're great. We really don't want to hear their cheery stuff. And I think they were unfairly compared to their own work.
[14:03] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[14:09] Robert W Schneider: And I think that's why the show didn't really succeed the way they were supposed to. And also I had heard this, and I don't know if this is true. And if somebody out there knows the answer to this, I would love to know. Apparently, in previews, you did not know that the pilot was dead. And it was only until at the closing curtain of Act One did they reveal he was a ghost the whole time.
[14:30] Kevin David Thomas: So next to normal.
[14:31] Robert W Schneider: And so next to normal. And as I understand it, the creative team was concerned, and they made it very clear at the beginning he was a ghost. So there really wasn't any tension. And there really was nothing to get you back. You know, at the end of Act One, you always want to have something that takes you into Act Two, a cliffhanger, and they didn't really feel there was a cliffhanger at the end of Act One, so why come back? And that was the issue that was going on.
[14:54] Kevin David Thomas: So mine this week is Steel Pier. It only ran seventy-six performances. I'm hoping it'll come back at some point. I think it's a great show. It's a great score. You know, if you love Kander and Ebb, I think this is a great one to look at. Check it out.
[15:08] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[15:09] Robert W Schneider: So that's mine. Steel Pier. TheatreMania Guide to Musical Theater Recordings. What a fun, you're gonna have a fun week ahead. So get that book and look up Steel Pier.
[15:18] Kevin David Thomas: I'm Robert W Schneider.
[15:19] Robert W Schneider: I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[15:20] Kevin David Thomas: We'll see you guys next week.
[15:21] Robert W Schneider: Take care.
[15:21] Kevin David Thomas: Bye.
[15:22] ♪ Musical number: "My Favorite Things" — performed by Kevin David Thomas ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
