Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and underappreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Featured Shows
About
Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and underappreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business. This Week: Floyd gets stuck in a cave and Merman gets stuck in a sitcom!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] ♪ Musical number: "My Favorite Things" — performed by Unknown performer ♪
[0:18] Robert W Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W Schneider.
[0:20] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.
[0:21] Robert W Schneider: And this is Our Favorite Things.
[0:22] Kevin David Thomas: Happy Throwback Thursday.
[0:23] Robert W Schneider: Yay, it's that time of the week again.
[0:25] Kevin David Thomas: That time of the week.
[0:27] Robert W Schneider: Kevin and I sit down and we geek out over musical theater.
[0:31] Kevin David Thomas: I figure at some point we're gonna like just run out of stuff.
[0:33] Robert W Schneider: Eventually.
[0:34] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I don't know where we're gonna go.
[0:36] Robert W Schneider: Eventually.
[0:37] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know what we're gonna talk about eventually.
[0:39] Robert W Schneider: Oh my god, I'm so scared.
[0:40] Kevin David Thomas: I'll be like my favorite scene change in The Phantom is scene two to three.
[0:46] Robert W Schneider: That's when they bring on the chair.
[0:48] Kevin David Thomas: Join us next week.
[0:49] Robert W Schneider: That's what we're gonna get into it.
[0:50] Kevin David Thomas: The trumpeter from Gypsy, he's so good.
[0:52] Robert W Schneider: Yeah.
[0:53] Kevin David Thomas: Oh man, how are you?
[0:54] Robert W Schneider: Doing very good.
[0:55] Kevin David Thomas: Now I'm terrified.
[0:58] Robert W Schneider: I'm actually very excited for the one this week, because this is one of my favorite shows.
[1:02] Kevin David Thomas: You start.
[1:03] Robert W Schneider: You start.
[1:03] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, I'm gonna jump right into it.
[1:05] Robert W Schneider: Go for it.
[1:05] Kevin David Thomas: Um, so you're gonna know the show immediately, but this was a this show is never it's a cult favorite. It was written in the nineties.
[1:10] Robert W Schneider: Okay, it's won one by one of those new composers of the nineties.
[1:14] Kevin David Thomas: Um, and uh he it was off Broadway once again, Playwrights Horizons for the win developing a show.
[1:20] Robert W Schneider: It started out at the Prince Theater in uh in Philadelphia, and then it moved over there.
[1:24] Kevin David Thomas: And this writer went on to write other really cool shows based on a true story, my friend.
[1:24] Robert W Schneider: Based on a true story.
[1:31] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I think I know what it is.
[1:32] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, I do.
[1:32] Kevin David Thomas: Is it Floyd Collins?
[1:34] Robert W Schneider: It certainly is.
[1:35] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god.
[1:36] Robert W Schneider: And there's a lot of people out there, fans of musical theater that are like, oh my god, it's my favorite show, because it really is, it's incredible.
[1:41] Kevin David Thomas: It's the score's by Adam Gettle.
[1:43] Robert W Schneider: Now, a little interesting little tidbit here. Adam Gettle, for those of you who may not know, is the grandson of the great Richard Rodgers.
[1:50] Kevin David Thomas: Richard Rodgers had Mary Rodgers, uh she did um Once Upon a Mattress, among many other shows like Mad Show she wrote in.
[1:57] Robert W Schneider: But um Richard begat Mary, who begat Adam.
[2:00] Kevin David Thomas: Exactly.
[2:01] Robert W Schneider: And Mary had Adam.
[2:03] Kevin David Thomas: So talk about a songwriting legacy.
[2:06] Robert W Schneider: And Adam Gettle sounds nothing like Richard Rodgers.
[2:09] Kevin David Thomas: Adam Gettle, I think, has created um unfortunately we don't have a lot of his material. He did Light in the Piazza, he did Myths and Hymns all in the last 20 years.
[2:17] Robert W Schneider: So not writing shows like Julie Stein does.
[2:20] Kevin David Thomas: Um just putting them out every two years.
[2:22] Robert W Schneider: I wish that he wrote more. He was supposed to do uh The Princess Bride with Craig Lucas, but then things didn't work out with that so much.
[2:28] Kevin David Thomas: I uh my buddy did it was in the Berkshires, I think, doing a reading of his new show that's coming out very soon. I hear it's unbelievable.
[2:35] Robert W Schneider: I don't know what it's about. One note's amazing.
[2:37] Kevin David Thomas: So Floyd Collins was one of his first book musicals. He wrote it with Tina Lendau, who also wrote, uh who also directed it.
[2:44] Robert W Schneider: It's based on the true story of Floyd Collins, who was a cave explorer in the 1920s.
[2:50] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, 1925 to be exact.
[2:53] Robert W Schneider: Uh and uh I want to in Mammoth Cave National Park, which exists to this day.
[2:58] Kevin David Thomas: Um, and he was back then, in the in the in that time period, if you found a cave in Tennessee or in Kentucky area, uh you were you were you had it, you made it.
[3:07] Robert W Schneider: Like, because you would charge people like you know a couple cents to go in and see your cave and and you would sell souvenirs and all these other things, and it was a great way to make money out in the out out there in the middle parts of America.
[3:18] Kevin David Thomas: And so uh Floyd Collins was exploring a cave and diving in, going underneath all these rocks and got stuck in it, and uh the part of the cave collapsed, and uh he uh died in the cave, and they couldn't reach him in time.
[3:29] Robert W Schneider: They reached him three days too late when they got the shaft down to him. And but the the interesting thing about this is that it was between World War One and World War Two, it was the biggest media sensation the country had ever seen.
[3:41] Kevin David Thomas: This is pre obviously pre-internet, pre-all of that stuff.
[3:44] Robert W Schneider: We just had radio and telegram.
[3:46] Kevin David Thomas: So uh it was a media frenzy. People came from all over the country to the where the cave was to figure out what's remember.
[3:56] Robert W Schneider: Do you remember in the 90s when that little girl was stuck in the well?
[3:59] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, baby Jessica.
[4:00] Robert W Schneider: Yeah.
[4:01] Kevin David Thomas: And so that went and was like TV was on 24 hours a day and was on CNN constantly, and you were, is she gonna make it out? It was the same thing.
[4:06] Robert W Schneider: But at that time you only had, you know, telegraph and all that, so it was people had to physically be there.
[4:12] Kevin David Thomas: And this is one of the first times I think the media is sensationalizing a tragedy.
[4:17] Robert W Schneider: Exactly.
[4:18] Kevin David Thomas: Just so commonplace now.
[4:19] Robert W Schneider: Yes, that's right. And so this is the musical basically starts with him exploring and him getting stuck, and then it's about his family and the media station that ensues above ground, but also his fantasies going on below ground.
[4:33] Kevin David Thomas: Like he sings a duet with his brother, but it's not really happening in real time, but they are kind of talking to each other through the collapsed cave wall.
[4:40] Robert W Schneider: But what's fascinating to me in this score is is how in 1996, when it premiered in February 9th, 1996 at Playwrights, it was like unheard of.
[4:49] Kevin David Thomas: Like no one had ever heard music like this, I think.
[4:51] Robert W Schneider: We have never heard music as complex and fascinating as Adam Gettle wrote. Truly um the harmonies, the songwriting, is a combination of kind of country folky sound, but definitely complex musicality.
[5:06] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know how else to say it, but it's just it's smart, smart writing. Kind of like Light in the Piazza, which he wrote a couple years later.
[5:12] Robert W Schneider: That you I can listen to Light in the Piazza 20 times, and I'm still getting things out of it that I never knew were there.
[5:17] Kevin David Thomas: Um and Floyd Collins, it it starts with Floyd Collins.
[5:20] Robert W Schneider: You could say it starts with Myths and Hymns, one of the uh song cycle he wrote before that. But to me, Floyd Collins is a real, a real because if you pitch that idea, like, hey guys, I want to write a show about a guy gets stuck in a cave.
[5:32] Kevin David Thomas: It's like, here you go.
[5:33] Robert W Schneider: I mean, that's crazy. Like that's like really.
[5:36] Kevin David Thomas: But um, and and I watched at Lincoln Center years ago, and I have some issues with some of the book writing and getting from song to song, but the story's there, the songs are there, and it's it's a beautiful piece.
[5:47] Robert W Schneider: I'm you know, it's so funny that you mentioned this because I was talking about this show yesterday with somebody. Let me ask you do you if you remember when you saw it, how did they do the cave?
[5:56] Kevin David Thomas: It wasn't a literal cave.
[5:57] Robert W Schneider: No, no, if everything was very he was like literally on a plank, like a like you take down your front door, it's wooden, and you just put it on a put on a diagonal or something.
[6:06] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[6:06] Robert W Schneider: And he was just kind of lay there. And then during like the riddle song, which is like the famous 10 minute song he sings with his brother, he gets up. I mean, he gets up out of there and he and he you know moves around and stuff.
[6:14] Kevin David Thomas: So it's it's fantastic.
[6:16] Robert W Schneider: It's it's a thing. Okay, I'll tell you why I was talking about this yesterday. We were talking about shows that if you it's we everyone's had this experience. I want to just find the best way of articulating it.
[6:24] Kevin David Thomas: You will be exposed to a show in a production, and you will not like the production, yes, and you somehow take it out on the show.
[6:34] Robert W Schneider: And you go, Oh, the show's not good. And then you'll come back to it and you either listen to it or you see another production, you go, Oh, actually, it's not the script and score that are bad, it was actually the production I saw.
[6:45] Kevin David Thomas: I had the same experience with Floyd Collins.
[6:48] Robert W Schneider: Uh I was, I don't know if schools still do this. I think they do. There's the Kennedy Center American College Theater Festival, which is where colleges from all across the United States get together.
[6:59] Kevin David Thomas: Irene Ryan Awards, yes.
[7:01] Robert W Schneider: I was never part of that, but I was always kind of envious of people who got to.
[7:04] Kevin David Thomas: My school was.
[7:05] Robert W Schneider: Oh, wow. And we uh the first time I remember we ever went, you get you go up uh to to uh a town for like a week, and it's just a week-long theater festival, which is really great.
[7:14] Kevin David Thomas: And you see other colleges productions, and there are judges who go around and they pick the best productions, and those are the ones that they bring to your town.
[7:22] Robert W Schneider: Right.
[7:22] Kevin David Thomas: Um, and they had brought somebody brought a production of Floyd Collins, and they built this is why I didn't like it. They built a literal cave on stage.
[7:30] Robert W Schneider: Oh.
[7:34] Kevin David Thomas: And I hope this does not sound inappropriate. It was very clear that the cave, whoever designed it, was inspired by Georgia O'Keeffe.
[7:42] Robert W Schneider: Oh was it a bulbous-looking cage?
[7:46] Kevin David Thomas: It looked, it looked very much like a piece of anatomy.
[7:50] Robert W Schneider: Uh-huh.
[7:50] Kevin David Thomas: And so, of course, we're all freshmen in college, and we're all laughing. And the only way I think his brother could get down to him in the cave was he was this guy was literally trapped in a in they he was this man was trapped in the cave.
[8:06] Robert W Schneider: So even in things like the riddle song, where usually the actor gets up and moves.
[8:10] Kevin David Thomas: He literally just it was like he was just on this diagonal, and there's one part where I think the brother is supposed somebody's supposed to go down and help him.
[8:17] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, Skeets Miller, the the reporter came out.
[8:19] Kevin David Thomas: And it looked like an inappropriate sexual position. Like it was one of those things where you just sat there the whole time and you said, This is the stupidest fucking thing I've ever seen in my life.
[8:31] Robert W Schneider: And so we all left going, Wow, it was so stupid, and that was so dumb, and the cave looked like a vagina, and blah blah blah.
[8:37] Kevin David Thomas: And then years ago, years later, because this was 2002, I no, no, no, when did this show come out? It came in 90s in late 90s, 1960s.
[8:44] Robert W Schneider: Yes, this was 2002, 2003.
[8:46] Kevin David Thomas: And well, years later, I listened to the score and I read it, and I thought to myself, this is brilliant. And it was one of those things where a bad production can just taint your idea of what a show is.
[8:58] Robert W Schneider: And so, not to sound academic and teacherly, but if you if there was a show you saw and you go, I didn't like this thing, I would love for you to go back and try it one more time.
[9:07] Kevin David Thomas: Because it might necessarily not have been the show and the score, it might have been the particular production you saw.
[9:14] Robert W Schneider: You're saying uh in my life that I saw on Broadway a couple years ago, the Joe Brooks musical that ran for the show.
[9:18] Kevin David Thomas: No, that one you're exempt from.
[9:19] Robert W Schneider: Okay, all right.
[9:20] Kevin David Thomas: That one I think we can all agree was just there's a big lemon on the stage.
[9:23] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, okay. We were a little misguided on that one. I don't think that one's a good thing. Yeah, just making sure. But who knows? Fifty years from now, somebody might do it and win the Tony Award for Best Revival.
[9:32] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, and that was my issue with it when I saw it. It was just so literal. And the cave, I mean, it was very impressive physically. It just took up the whole space. But it's a gorgeous score. What really rocks me with Adam Guettel's work in it is that, you know, here's a man, yes, he came from the legacy he came from and all of that. But how he found a voice that he has that is so, like, you know, musical theater writers today, some of them, they love Jason Robert Brown. So a lot of their songs starting out sound a little bit like Jason Robert Brown. Like they write a song at six-four, they write whatever. But this Adam Guettel, to me, came out of nowhere with this sound that is so out there and musical, it's almost operatic and yet always serving the story.
[10:09] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, that's original, and that I can't believe. And please give us more to listen to, Mr. Guettel, because please. I mean, it's too good what you got there. So yeah, so Floyd Collins for me with the win, get that recording, you guys, because it's genius. So timely. That unfortunately, I think that's a show whose themes are never gonna go away.
[10:29] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, which is the sensationalizing of a tragedy.
[10:32] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah. And one little thing at the end. Also, what's incredible about it is that he dies in the cave, right? And he hit in the beginning, he yodels, he does this like the whole yodel thing, and they timed it out so that he would sing to his voice echoing back at him. And I think one of the most beautiful moments of the show is at the very, very end, he, right as he's dying of, you know, exhaustion, hunger, and all that, he yodels and he sings, he keeps yodeling and it harmonizes with himself. They somehow play it back so he can keep yodeling, and he passes away, but his echo keeps going on. Pretty, pretty awesome. I mean, that's pretty beautiful.
[11:01] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, but please listen to it.
[11:03] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, no, actually, I want to just stop recording and go listen to it now so I can have a good cry. I love it. I love it.
[11:09] Kevin David Thomas: So, okay, so I'm a little torn on mine. Uh oh. I was going to recommend something. It was going to be a TV show. And I went on to YouTube to look at it again last night to do some research on it. Uh oh. And it was pulled because of copyright issues. So I'm really torn because I don't know if I want to recommend it, and then nobody can go, nobody can go see it right now. But maybe it'll come back at some point. Maybe they pulled it so they could, you know, like they did with Ed Sullivan on Blue Gobo. Remember they pulled all those Ed Sullivan clips, and you're like, but then they, you know, still sold them on PBS. So I don't know if I want to recommend that or something else. I'm so torn. What should I do?
[11:47] Robert W Schneider: You're teasing me, Rob. Okay, I'm gonna recommend it, and I'm gonna hope it comes back on YouTube. Let's at least talk about it. So I'm going to recommend a TV pilot.
[11:56] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, jeez. So for those of you who don't know what a pilot is, a pilot is the first episode of a television show that gets made with the hopes that the first episode is so successful, it'll be given a green light and approved by the network to do a full series. And then they'll pay for all the other episodes.
[12:13] Robert W Schneider: Yes. And so I'm going to recommend a pilot that did get picked up for a very short amount of time. No, it didn't get picked up. What am I saying? No, it did get picked up, but it got retooled. Never mind. How do you like that, everybody? It is 1977. It was a pilot for the great Broadway star, Ethel Merman.
[12:33] Kevin David Thomas: What?
[12:34] Robert W Schneider: And the pilot was a TV show called You're Gonna Love It Here. So once again, the title is You're Gonna Love It Here from 1977. It was a pilot for Ethel Merman. I'm picking my jaw off the floor. She had stopped making, she'd stopped doing Broadway musicals.
[12:48] Kevin David Thomas: Not disco albums.
[12:49] Robert W Schneider: She kept doing disco albums. Oh, yeah. I had just watched an interview with her. She didn't really want to come back to Broadway in, I think, the newer musicals. I don't think she was so interested in doing the acting per se. And the hope was that she and Jule Styne were going to collaborate on a project together again, and it never got launched. So she went into the world of television. And in You're Gonna Love It Here, she plays musical theater star Lolly Rogers.
[13:13] Kevin David Thomas: What a name.
[13:15] Robert W Schneider: Lolly is a grandma. Okay. And her grandson is now in her custody and her charge. Her parents were arrested for, I think, insider trading. And so she's now responsible for her grandson, and she doesn't want to take care of the grandson because she's going to do a national tour of Maine, and she doesn't want to bring the child around with her everywhere. So she drops the child, her grandson, off at her other son's doorstep, played brilliantly by Austin Pendleton.
[13:45] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my gosh.
[13:45] Robert W Schneider: Whom I love, who, if you don't know Austin Pendleton, a great actor and director, but probably best known to people as the stuttering lawyer in My Cousin Vinny.
[13:55] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my goodness. I forgot about that.
[13:56] Robert W Schneider: He's done, I mean, he's one of these guys who's done everything. He shows up everywhere, but that's usually where I associate him. And so it's one of the, to be honest with you, it's not the best sitcom. It's a little corny. But if you can watch the pilot of it, it's very funny. Watching Ethel Merman acting opposite this kid is pretty genius. And the kid actually grew up to have a great career. His name is Chris Barnes, and he grew up to be, you remember the Brady Bunch movies?
[14:24] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[14:24] Robert W Schneider: He's Greg Brady in the Brady Bunch movie. So it's a very fun pilot. It's a very silly pilot. I think the problem with the pilot is it's like Ethel Merman shows up for a little bit, and then it's mostly scenes between Austin Pendleton and the young boy and their relationship. And Ethel Merman just sort of fades away. And so I wonder if the series were to continue, would she have had as big a part in it? I would love to have seen her raising the kid herself and taking the kid on the road with her. I think that would have been interesting.
[14:52] Kevin David Thomas: Totally.
[14:52] Robert W Schneider: And I think the idea was it didn't get picked up because they felt that her personality just didn't fit well on the smaller screen.
[14:59] Kevin David Thomas: Not really motherly.
[14:59] Robert W Schneider: No, and she's not really motherly. And there's a lot of great sitcom actors, sorry, a lot of great theater actors who you think would have done really well in sitcoms, and they really haven't. Like Dorothy Loudon, Elaine Stritch, and Nathan Lane, God bless him, is a brilliant stage actor, but he really can't seem to keep a television show up for a moment. He had a couple. There was one where he was a congressman, and then there was the one where he was a very famous opera singer.
[15:25] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, you're right. I forgot about that.
[15:26] Robert W Schneider: And I wonder why those performers who do so well on stage, they just don't, for whatever reason, their magic doesn't translate to the screen.
[15:32] Kevin David Thomas: That TV is a crapshoot, though. Because you could get your pilot and you're like, yeah, I got my pilot, and then it's like, well, now you gotta get picked up. I mean, you gotta do that. Every 15 pilots, only like one or two get picked up.
[15:40] Robert W Schneider: So I really, really hope that it comes up, but I clicked it and it said, you know, disappear because Warner Brothers sings on it?
[15:48] Kevin David Thomas: No.
[15:49] Robert W Schneider: Interesting. She sings the theme song, and that's the only time she sings in it.
[15:54] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[15:54] Robert W Schneider: Yeah. So that's, I'm called again, You're Gonna Love It Here. And I'm gonna recommend it. I'm gonna recommend it with the hope that one day Warner, I'm like Warner Brothers, who's who had copyright infringement on the who watched this and was like, I'm gonna go to the show. We can make five dollars on it on the other. I'm gonna make a millions off of my pilot, my Ethel Merman pilot that's going nowhere. It's just the pilot that was made.
[16:14] Kevin David Thomas: Just a pilot.
[16:15] Robert W Schneider: Huh.
[16:15] Kevin David Thomas: The show then got picked up and they retooled it.
[16:17] Robert W Schneider: They got rid of her.
[16:18] Kevin David Thomas: Ah.
[16:19] Robert W Schneider: Yeah. And then it became like a pretty good one.
[16:21] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[16:22] Robert W Schneider: Oh, I love Mr. Belvedere. Don't get me.
[16:25] Kevin David Thomas: Somebody asked me. They're like, they asked actually, they asked us a really good question. They said, you guys seem to be so knowledgeable about musical theater. Is there anything else you're really knowledgeable about?
[16:34] Robert W Schneider: And the answer is yes. I'm a big sitcom buff. It's just not that much different than musical theater. But you can name an 80s sitcom, and I should be able to do the theme song for you just like that.
[16:46] Kevin David Thomas: That's quite a special skill, my friend.
[16:49] Robert W Schneider: Well, I'm happy you say special skill. My parents used to say pathetic, and so I'm very happy that you said special skill.
[16:57] Kevin David Thomas: Special skill. What's yours?
[16:58] Robert W Schneider: And politics. I'm a big history. I love history. I’m a big geography person. I love geography. I love that I live for maps. I have maps in my house. I love maps, like topographical maps. I'm a hiker, so I love the outdoors. And so I do a lot of, every place I've gone, like Acadia National Park or Yosemite, I have those topographical maps in my bedroom.
[17:19] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you, Sutton.
[17:21] Robert W Schneider: Wow. And I do, we joke about sports, but I do love some football and I do love golf.
[17:27] Kevin David Thomas: Two completely opposite sports.
[17:29] Robert W Schneider: I did not know that.
[17:30] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, I do. Like I live for the football season. I'm not a baseball fan. I never, I always think I like it live, but it's to me it's the most boring thing to watch on television.
[17:39] Robert W Schneider: It's hard to watch on television.
[17:40] Kevin David Thomas: But some people say that about golf, and I could watch golf on TV, so I'm weird.
[17:43] Robert W Schneider: See, I prefer watching golf on television because I think you can track the ball better.
[17:47] Kevin David Thomas: Yep.
[17:47] Robert W Schneider: Baseball's a little dull on television. I'd rather be at the park, yeah.
[17:51] Kevin David Thomas: Uh-huh.
[17:51] Robert W Schneider: So, but I live for September, September through January when I can watch some football.
[17:55] Kevin David Thomas: That is so cool. Do you have a favorite team?
[17:56] Robert W Schneider: Oh, 49ers.
[17:57] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, San Francisco.
[17:59] Robert W Schneider: Yeah.
[18:00] Kevin David Thomas: Nicely done.
[18:01] Robert W Schneider: Giants for New York, New York team is Giants.
[18:03] Kevin David Thomas: You're a Giants guy.
[18:04] Robert W Schneider: I'll do that for the night.
[18:04] Kevin David Thomas: Very good.
[18:05] Robert W Schneider: But yeah, so there you go. That's awesome. Well, there we go. So I hope you can see You're Gonna Love It Here. And please, Floyd Collins. Get the Floyd Collins in your life. You'll be happy. It is amazing. Till next time. Bye everyone.
[18:17] ♪ Musical number: "My Favorite Things" — performed by Ethel Merman ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
