Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Our Favorite Things #48: Rags & The Scottsboro Boys

Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and under appreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business... Read More

From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast

20 mins
12/29/16

About

Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and under appreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business. This week: Rob and Kevin look back to look forward!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] ♪ Musical number ♪

[0:25] Robert W Schneider: Happy throwback Thursday.

[0:27] Kevin David Thomas: Happy throwback Thursday and soon to be happy new year, everybody.

[0:27] Robert W Schneider: New Year.

[0:32] Kevin David Thomas: Oh man, what a year.

[0:34] Robert W Schneider: God, what a year.

[0:36] Kevin David Thomas: What is gone by year?

[0:38] Robert W Schneider: I will say this though. Well, once again, we don't espouse any specific political philosophy.

[0:44] Kevin David Thomas: Absolutely not.

[0:45] Robert W Schneider: Love who you love, do what you do, live your life.

[0:45] Kevin David Thomas: Live your life, live your dreams.

[0:49] Robert W Schneider: But this year has been a rough year.

[0:52] Kevin David Thomas: I feel like our whole life has been a reality show.

[0:54] Robert W Schneider: I mean, like your whole life was a reality show for a very long time.

[0:58] Kevin David Thomas: Last year, the year before.

[1:00] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, I mean, but for real, it just feels like every episode of this year has been so in the news and everything, just dramatic and epic and like is this real? Is this really real life?

[1:12] Kevin David Thomas: You know, I would between all the people we've lost and all the things going on in the world.

[1:16] Robert W Schneider: I would like to just take a moment and say one thing. If everything else has been so negative for us, the bright spot I think this year has really been Broadway.

[1:25] Kevin David Thomas: Well put.

[1:27] Robert W Schneider: I mean, if nothing else, we have that to cling to. If nothing else, this is the year that gave us such things as Bright Star, Waitress, Shuffle Along, Hamilton, Hairspray Live, an amazing Tony Awards broadcast.

[1:44] Kevin David Thomas: What else am I forgetting?

[1:45] Robert W Schneider: No, and there's well, there's countless humans, yeah. Uh oh, not to mention like the David Yazbek musical that's at Atlantic Theatre Company. I mean, like, just everything is thriving, it feels like, right now.

[1:56] Kevin David Thomas: In our art form.

[1:58] Robert W Schneider: Yeah.

[1:58] Kevin David Thomas: And I feel quite proud to be a part of it. Um, or just in some small way to be a fan of it and to be a part of it, but to love it the you know the way we do.

[2:08] Robert W Schneider: I agree. And the I mean the way that our community rallied around Orlando, the way our community rallied around the election results. So if nothing else, if nothing else this year, we at least have our theater to cling to. So thank you so much, everyone who's created something this year, regardless of if you were doing it in New York or London or Tulsa, Oklahoma, no matter where you were, if you were in a community theater, school production, Broadway. We thank you so much for sharing your art with us because we really did need it this year.

[2:39] Kevin David Thomas: Well, you know what? Art is therapy, right?

[2:42] Robert W Schneider: You know, art is therapy.

[2:43] Kevin David Thomas: It is. And I love those, you know, reading in the last two months when people say, All right, time to get back to work, time to make the art, you know, get back to work, you know.

[2:52] Robert W Schneider: And I think that's a really good point. Were you a West Wing fan?

[2:56] Kevin David Thomas: Oh yeah.

[2:57] Robert W Schneider: You were?

[2:57] Kevin David Thomas: I am. I can tell you that I'm in the midst of watching it again. I never actually finished it. I always get to like the fifth season or sixth season, and then I kind of then he left Aaron Sorkin.

[3:08] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, and then I can always tell. And I'm I don't but I will tell you the first three seasons to me, I um it's like watching Murder She Wrote, Golden Girls, Friends, Family Guy, Bob's Burgers at night. You know, those are like the go-to. Like you know how you I don't know if you guys out there do that, but you you have your shows you watch when you like don't need to think, but you just want to be entertained. But for me, West Wing is it.

[3:32] Kevin David Thomas: Those characters are friends to me. I feel like I know them. CJ Craig is like my friend. I remember working at 42nd Street Studios, I was assisting on a Tale of Two Cities, the musical. Remember that? And we I was in the stairwell going up, and Alice and Janny came down because she was doing nine to five, and I was like, I was like, CJ Craig. I didn't in my mind, I'm like, oh my god, I know you! You're CJ Craig. No, you're not. You're Alice and Janny, you're awesome. You're you're a human being outside of that. But I but I was so dumbstruck because I feel so close to her.

[4:05] Robert W Schneider: Yeah.

[4:05] Kevin David Thomas: Because they are so relatable as their characters. So anyway, yes, I love West Wing. But the in the end of the first episode, the last line that Martin Sheen has is he's heard all this these horrible things happen, and he goes, All right, what's next? And I feel like that's what 2017 should be about. What's next?

[4:22] Robert W Schneider: That's good, Rob. Let's moving forward. Let's keep moving forward. And my favorite thing this week.

[4:29] Kevin David Thomas: Bring it actually is about, I think, moving forward.

[4:32] Robert W Schneider: That's funny because mine is too.

[4:34] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my god, I'm a thing. Yeah, we and again, you guys, we do not we we do not plan, we don't tell each other our favorite things, we don't talk about it beforehand.

[4:42] Robert W Schneider: No, we don't even had try to come up with a theme for like anything that happens is purely coincidental.

[4:49] Kevin David Thomas: It's inspirational.

[4:51] Robert W Schneider: That's right. Um musical.

[4:54] Kevin David Thomas: Oh 1986 for performances.

[5:02] Robert W Schneider: Okay.

[5:03] Kevin David Thomas: All day seeing them all day, smelling them all day, listening to peddler selling them.

[5:10] Robert W Schneider: Rags.

[5:11] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my where Judy Kune in one Tony season had to not only be Cosette and sing a high C and floating. Well, actually, it's probably like a high B because it wasn't a reprise, but she's floating this high note, and then she's like, one more Rags, and she sings the title song to Rags.

[5:31] Robert W Schneider: And then she's she's cosette first, right?

[5:33] Kevin David Thomas: And then she comes back on.

[5:34] Robert W Schneider: Yes. So Rags is a musical that is one of my favorite musicals.

[5:40] Kevin David Thomas: Go ahead.

[5:41] Robert W Schneider: No, Charles Strauss, who wrote the music.

[5:43] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[5:43] Robert W Schneider: If you were to be, I always say this like this man Charles Strauss, who we've got to get on the podcast.

[5:48] Kevin David Thomas: Oh god, yes.

[5:49] Robert W Schneider: Charles Strauss, if you're like, hey, here's a song from Rags, and then you're like, hey, here's a song from Bye Bye Birdie.

[5:55] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, yeah.

[5:56] Robert W Schneider: And here's another, you know, what in the middle of his career. What's another, like, you would not believe this is the same writer. This man, I cannot believe that he wrote the score to Rags. Bye bye Birdie. Applause. Annie. Rags. Nick and Nora. Dance a little closer. Dance a little closer. Nobody's Charlie and Algernon. Broadway musical. All right. Mayor.

[6:19] Kevin David Thomas: No, no. Nobody loves Mayer.

[6:22] Robert W Schneider: I oh, I like Mayer. I don't love Mayer. But but but but Rags is really, really special, Rob. I think you're right.

[6:28] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[6:29] Robert W Schneider: I will concur with that.

[6:32] Kevin David Thomas: Please. So for those of you that don't know, Rags is a four-performance-only musical from 1986.

[6:37] Robert W Schneider: Wow.

[6:38] Kevin David Thomas: Music by we have Charles Strauss, we have Steven Schwartz.

[6:42] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, he was working with Steven Schwartz.

[6:45] Kevin David Thomas: We have a book by Joseph Stein from Fiddler on the Roof. So we're entering territory that Mr. Stein knows quite well. And listen to this cast before I tell you the plot synopsis. I mean, all this automatically sounds like a hit. Teresa Stratus, famous opera singer, like mega. Like mega, mega, like a Merrill Streep of Opera.

[7:02] Robert W Schneider: I would agree.

[7:03] Kevin David Thomas: Right. Larry Kurt, our original Tony from West Side Story. Lonnie Price. You know him pretty well. Lonnie, Judy Kune, like who you just mentioned, our original cosette.

[7:13] Robert W Schneider: Who I'm obsessed with.

[7:14] Kevin David Thomas: Dick Latetha Wilbur from Hairspray of Nothing Else. Marsha Lewis, Matron Mama Morton. And Terrence Mann from Beauty and the Beast. So this this is.

[7:30] Robert W Schneider: To the United States.

[7:36] Kevin David Thomas: Specifically, it's about a woman named Rebecca and her son David, Rebecca's husband Nathan, has gone ahead of her.

[7:43] Robert W Schneider: Right.

[7:43] Kevin David Thomas: And as soon as he landed in New York City, has never wrote back to her in Russia. So he has gone MIA. And she is now coming over to New York to see if she can find her husband.

[7:54] Robert W Schneider: It's a great setup for a musical.

[7:56] Kevin David Thomas: It's a great setup for a musical. And on the ship over, she befriends Avram and his daughter Bella, that's the Contessa and Judy Kune. And it's really about the immigrant experience. It's about celebrating what immigrants bring to this country. It's about celebrating our history. It's about celebrating our heritage, and it's celebrating how this country was really built, especially in the early part of the 20th century, on the foundation of what these immigrants have provided to us.

[8:23] Robert W Schneider: Totally.

[8:24] Kevin David Thomas: My relatives, your relatives, our listeners relatively. The experience through Ellis Island, like you know, post Hamilton, those immigrants that created the union that we have America today, but we're talking like the actual people that came to our country that filled out our country that are the reason why we are so great as we are today. And that's what Rags covers.

[8:44] Robert W Schneider: Now, and there, I mean what a topic for them to go after. And what a topic immigration. I mean, come on.

[8:49] Kevin David Thomas: And the song and the songs, I mean, the score, I think, is Charles Strauss's best score.

[8:56] Robert W Schneider: Definitely.

[8:57] Kevin David Thomas: I really do. And that's no offense. I mean, the other stuff is great. That's like saying, Do you want gold or more gold? That's the most challenging score that I think he's done.

[9:03] Robert W Schneider: Well, I mean, the versatility, because it covers every single ethn this ethnic music that's imaginable that you're hearing at this time.

[9:10] Kevin David Thomas: Yep.

[9:10] Robert W Schneider: And some of the songs that you might know, and if you don't know them, you should look them up Children of the Wind, Blame It on the Summer Night, Brand New World. The issue that people had with this show, this is why the show apparently wasn't very successful, was because it was trying to cover so much. They had gone through a number of directors, things really weren't working in rehearsal, and nobody was really there to save it. But ideally, the main issue was nobody was there to streamline this story.

[9:38] Kevin David Thomas: Right.

[9:38] Robert W Schneider: It was just too much. And the story though was very passionate, and the cast believed it so much that on the fourth performance, the day before they closed, they all as a cast in costume marked from the marched from the Mark Hellinger Theater to TKTS and handed out flyers begging people to come see their show.

[9:57] Kevin David Thomas: So that can you imagine theirs Teresa Stratus and Lonnie Price and Terrence Mann handing out flyers saying, please come see us, and unfortunately it didn't help. There have been plenty of revisions of it. I am hoping at some point that Encores is willing to take it on.

[10:13] Robert W Schneider: It's totally an encore show. I will not confirm or deny anything, but I have heard that it's not a favorite amongst those making the decisions at Encore, so that's why it might not be done at some point. Who knows whether or not that's true? But I'm hoping at some point. I hope that we see it though with its full orchestration. I hope that we do see it in its epic fullness because the story really is epic in scope. Um, and like you said, if you want to see a clip of it, go to the Tony Awards in nineteen eighty-seven, because it was nominated for Best Musical. And what's really funny, like you said, is Teresa Strat, not Teresa Stratus, uh Judy uh Kune sings from Lame is and then she does Rags.

But she actually went up on her lyrics in Rags? In the Rags number. So if you listen, she repeats a little bit of a section. I never even realized it. Well, go, you know, I can't wait till we interview Judy because it's like, oh my god. And she, uh, but like come on, you're, you're, you're, can you imagine being, you know, in one show that's up for a Tony Award, and then you're actually where you sing soprano and then another show where you're belting your face off and you gotta do both numbers and how many people have done two different numbers on a Tony Award? I would like to know that statistics.

[11:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, you know listeners, if you know that answer, that's it. Hey, that's a really good one. Who else has done two different numbers, not including the like the host?

[11:23] Robert W Schneider: So it's not like Hugh Jackman did like a song and dance number where he bounced up and down the whole time and then like another one.

[11:29] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, musical.

[11:30] Robert W Schneider: Like where you were nominated for that is fascinating.

[11:32] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[11:33] Robert W Schneider: And I'm blown away that she performed in two different numbers that year. I really hope we get, um, there is a cast recording of the show. There is, but to be aware, it does not feature Teresa Stratus in it. She missed a lot of performances, and people said it was she was not the happiest having this experience. And it was made quite a couple years after it, too. The cast recording was made in the 1980s.

[11:55] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, so it was like way after it closed.

[11:58] Robert W Schneider: Um, I'm like I said, if you want to get Rags done, please get it done. And but also if anyone out there has any sort of contact information for Charles Strauss, we are trying to get him, and we keep running against roadblocks on him.

[12:11] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[12:11] Robert W Schneider: So if anybody knows any way to get to Mr. Strauss, we would love to have him celebrate him and everything he's given us.

[12:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[12:18] Robert W Schneider: So hopeful, optimistic, looking towards our future. What's next?

[12:23] Kevin David Thomas: Rags.

[12:24] Robert W Schneider: I like that. And so to transition, mine is also a musical that isn't it the musical itself, the subject matter is not hopeful, but it is meant to remind us of why it's important to remember certain episodes of the past. And my musical is a musical and a cast album written by a very famous songwriting team, just like Charles Strauss and Steven Schwartz as well. But this show was also a quote unquote flop. And this show was done in 2001.

[12:54] Kevin David Thomas: So very recent.

[12:56] Robert W Schneider: 2010?

[12:57] Kevin David Thomas: That's right.

[12:58] Robert W Schneider: Um, and this show to me is, uh, I would say it's on my top ten list. It's a show that I was so completely undone by this show and by this piece of theater that I had to see it again when it closed just like we talked a couple weeks ago about High Fidelity and how, you know, when I saw the, I saw his closing and I thought I gotta see that again. Well, this show did the same thing to me, and I thought I need to see this again. This is such important theater making. I think this piece was ahead of its time. I think that audiences weren't prepared for it. I think that even if it came out this after Hamilton this year, it would do better in the theater than it did in 2010. I'm even saying six years is all the difference it makes. This is a, it's based on a true story. You know the songwriting team because they always use a theme to showcase their vehicles. For Cabaret, they used Weimar Germany.

[13:47] Kevin David Thomas: Scottsboro Boys, Scottsboro Boys, the musical.

[13:53] Robert W Schneider: Oh my god, Kevin, what a great choice. This piece is so important to me, and it has the problem that like Mack and Mabel has in that it ends sad. This is based on the true story of nine African American men, boys, really, who were on a train in 1931 in the South, and that two girls said they were raped, two white girls said they were raped, and they accused the nine black boys of doing it. It wasn't them, but they were accused and convicted. There was an overturn that the trial was hung, or the trial did it was it was a hung jury. Four of them were eventually released, but like the lead guy, Hayward, he died in prison. One of the guys killed himself when he was released. I mean, it was truly the most despicable, you know.

We're still dealing with this today, for the love of God. And I, this is not a politics, this is not all of that, but you know, this is a very important story that needs to be told. And John Kander and Fred Ebb, who wrote Chicago, who wrote Cabaret, who wrote countless others, you know, musicals that you all know. This is, I would say this is one of their very final collaborations. Yes, The Visit was on Broadway a couple years ago, but The Visit was done back in 2000. I saw it in Chicago in 2000.

[15:18] Kevin David Thomas: With Angela Lansbury?

[15:19] Robert W Schneider: Uh, Chita Rivera was still in it then. But um, but at the Goodman. But uh, but this Scottsboro Boys was done in 2010. It was, they started in around 2004, and then of course Fred Ebb died, unfortunately, but then John Kander finished it. But it was one of their last, you know, collaborations together. It was, it was the show I find it a tragedy when a brilliant show does not last because it can't find the audience. Or the audience doesn't find the show, however you want to say it. And there's a lot of controversy because, as my listeners may know, um, you know, the Kander and Ebb often frame their storytelling with a device with Chicago. It's vaudeville. So it's like all everything is framed underneath this sort of vaudeville show.

Well, you remember that the original production was not a hit. You know, it it wasn't until the revival that Walter Bobby directed that it became a hit. I think the same is going to be true about Scottsboro Boys. I think it's going to be revived someday, and everyone's gonna be like, what the hell were we thinking at the time? Were we just not ready for this yet? Because the music and the score is perfection. It is truly perfection. So they frame this story under a minstrel show. Now, the minute you say minstrel, everybody, you know, you get a little like, okay, yeah, we gotta deal with this part of our history.

[16:41] Kevin David Thomas: But you as you are a professor of musical theater history.

[16:44] Robert W Schneider: A major part of our industry.

[16:46] Kevin David Thomas: No, yeah, when we teach our students that the minstrel shows are a part of the reason why we're singing musical theater songs today. Vaudeville, Operetta, Minstrel Shows. It's the first entertainment form that is created by the in the United States. It's inherently American.

[17:04] Robert W Schneider: It is inherently American. It has racial undertones, just like everything that it's American did back then and still does to this day. Um, and so, uh, so anyway, this musical has one white actor and then all black actors. The white actor is the interlocutor, he's the host of the evening, John Cullum plays this role. How awesome is that!

[17:13] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it's perfect.

[17:13] Robert W Schneider: And then all black actors who play all the other parts, they often the two black guys play the two white girls, and they've written all the songs, they go in and out of minstrelsy, but then they'll be really serious. And then there's always an undertone, there's an edge on every part of this score. And let's give a shout out really quickly to the brilliant direction and choreography of Susan Stroman.

[17:47] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, it's exactly right.

[17:48] Robert W Schneider: So, full disclosure here. My best friend, my best man in my wedding, his name is Derek Kobe, and Derek was in the cast. He played one of the, there's two brothers that are in it, Andy, and I forget the other name, and he played the brother. And so he would tell me he was the show started at the Vineyard Theater off Broadway, and then it transferred to Broadway in 2010. And Derek was in it, and he would tell me all about it. And he said that the process with Stroman and David Thompson, who did the book, and all of the writers, everybody, it was a labor of love. They worked together. If Stroman was like, hey, what do you think we do this? And the set, the set was chairs and planks.

[18:23] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[18:23] Robert W Schneider: Period. Chairs, planks. They made a prison, they would rearrange it. They made, you know, the courtroom, they'd rearrange it. Chairs and planks, you know. When the show started, lights, you know, you see a stage with 10, 11 chairs in a V, and then the music starts, and they come down the aisles of the theater and walk onto stage. And it was to this day, it's like one of the best pieces of theater I've ever seen in my entire life. Because of that, in the collaboration process that she brought, you can see, you can see that it's not just you do this, you walk there, you hit your head on, you know. No, no, no. You can tell that they are, it's so organic within all of them. It's beyond special. I mean, it was the experience of watching that history and watching that, so you know, full disclosure, yeah, it doesn't end happy.

Like they don't, they don't get off well, but the point of it, the point to me of the musical is don't forget. Don't forget these Scottsboro boys. Like, don't forget that, like, that's our history. Like, we have to celebrate that and we have to honor that, and we have to learn from that. These immigrants and these Scottsboro boys.

[19:35] Robert W Schneider: And as we're moving forward and looking into a bright, wonderful future, let us not forget our past. And what better way to celebrate our past than by listening to both Rags and the Scottsboro Boys? We will see you all in 2017. Thank you so much for making 2016 such a wonderful year for both of us. Happy New Year, everybody.

[19:40] Kevin David Thomas: So 2016, welcoming into 2017.

[19:52] Kevin David Thomas: Thanks for spending a year with us.

[19:54] Robert W Schneider: Happy New Year.

[19:55] Kevin David Thomas: Take care.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred