Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Our Favorite Things #80: Barbara Cook (1927-2017)

Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and under appreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business... Read More

From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast

34 mins
8/10/17

Featured Shows

About

Every week director Robert W Schneider and actor Kevin David Thomas pull back the curtain on neglected, forgotten, and under appreciated musicals, as well as bizarre performances, endearing television appearances, and all things show business. This Week: Remembering Barbara Cook. Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask the legends your own questions. Go to: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] ♪ Musical number: "My Favorite Things" — performed by Barbara Cook ♪

[0:17] Robert W Schneider: Hi, I'm Robert W Schneider.

[0:19] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.

[0:21] Robert W Schneider: And this is our favorite things, episode 80.

[0:25] Kevin David Thomas: Episode 80, and yet this is the first episode we've recorded like this, Rob.

[0:29] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, we should tell our listeners what's going on.

[0:31] Kevin David Thomas: Kevin and I are on a trial separation.

[0:36] Robert W Schneider: Don't worry, it's not permanent, kids.

[0:38] Kevin David Thomas: It's not permanent.

[0:40] Robert W Schneider: You better sit down, kids.

[0:43] Kevin David Thomas: Do you ever hear Liza Minnelli sing that song?

[0:45] Robert W Schneider: I don't know, no, I haven't.

[0:47] Kevin David Thomas: But I have. Oh, it's from Liza Minnelli at Carnegie Hall. She sings "Married," the Candor and Ebb song, and then she goes into "You Better Sit Down Kids," which is a story of a woman telling the kids that she's leaving.

[1:01] Robert W Schneider: And someone was like, that'd be a great song to musicalize. Um, much like Ethel Merman's disco album from the 70s that we were just talking about before the air.

[1:13] Kevin David Thomas: We um, Kevin and I were just on a wonderful podcast called "N Scene Podcast."

[1:19] Robert W Schneider: Like and scene, yes.

[1:22] Kevin David Thomas: Like, oh yes, like, and there's more to come. Um, and we were talking about Ethel Merman's disco album, and we were like, what could we do? What would be the equivalent of that? We were saying if Liza Minnelli did a contemporary album of like only contemporary musical theater songs.

[1:37] Robert W Schneider: So I came up with, I thought it'd be funny if we heard "Waving Through a Window."

[1:45] Kevin David Thomas: And you know who was waving back at me? Donald O'Connor!

[1:48] Robert W Schneider: That's right!

[1:49] Kevin David Thomas: It was Donald O'Connor, and I saw him do a flip, and I said, Wow!

[1:54] Robert W Schneider: We start with stars in our eyes, just like Mama did it, MGM.

[1:58] Kevin David Thomas: Lots of stars.

[1:59] Robert W Schneider: And then we're just like, "Sincerely Me."

[2:02] Kevin David Thomas: Just cause, just cause.

[2:04] Robert W Schneider: Because it's me!

[2:05] Kevin David Thomas: And it's sincere!

[2:06] Robert W Schneider: It's sincerely me!

[2:09] Kevin David Thomas: But no, you also did "Satisfaction!"

[2:12] Robert W Schneider: Cause it's the last three years, so Liza will be like, "I'll never be satisfied."

[2:17] Kevin David Thomas: I just never be satisfied.

[2:20] Robert W Schneider: Are you satisfied?

[2:21] Kevin David Thomas: I'm gonna be satisfied.

[2:25] Robert W Schneider: Oh my god.

[2:33] Kevin David Thomas: What the fuck do?

[2:34] Robert W Schneider: What a bit's gotta do!

[2:35] Kevin David Thomas: A bit's gotta do it!

[2:37] Robert W Schneider: Just like Baby, just like Bobby thought it did.

[2:41] Kevin David Thomas: But we were in keyboard.

[2:43] Robert W Schneider: Oh, what a channel.

[2:46] Kevin David Thomas: Oh Rob, I'm loving it.

[2:48] Robert W Schneider: Um, well we need, uh, I gotta be honest, we need some laughter because, uh, yes.

[2:55] Kevin David Thomas: Totally got off.

[2:57] Robert W Schneider: So I'm in Lancaster, Pennsylvania right now, working on a new show, and Rob is back home in New York, and we realized we didn't have a Thursday episode.

[3:04] Kevin David Thomas: It's literally Wednesday, 10:01 before our Thursday episode.

[3:09] Robert W Schneider: And I think this is definitely the closest we've actually ever recorded to release time.

[3:15] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, we cut it pretty close to the deadline, which, uh, we are sad about and happy about.

[3:23] Robert W Schneider: I mean, there's a lot of things that we could be discussing today. We could be discussing "Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812."

[3:30] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, or as my friends are calling it, "The Oak Mandy and the Great Choice of 2017."

[3:37] Robert W Schneider: Which I heard go by today on the streets, and I'm like, my god, what a city.

[3:37] Kevin David Thomas: What a city.

[3:43] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, I know. Um, yeah, uh, "Bandstand."

[3:47] Kevin David Thomas: So Natasha's closing, "Bandstand" is closing.

[3:50] Robert W Schneider: Oh, I didn't see that.

[3:51] Kevin David Thomas: I actually didn't see the—I feel like, yeah, "Bandstand" announced that they're closing today, which is really a shame.

[3:56] Robert W Schneider: But you've seen, I feel like you've seen that like 30 times, Rob.

[4:00] Kevin David Thomas: I've seen it four times because my best friend is in it.

[4:05] Robert W Schneider: But um, on Sunday night I had the "Bandstand" group over at 54 Below, and they sang um, Sinatra songs. And do you know who's in the audience?

[4:12] Kevin David Thomas: I saw the thing, uh, Clive Davis.

[4:12] Robert W Schneider: Clive Davis.

[4:19] Kevin David Thomas: And was he not wearing sunglasses?

[4:22] Robert W Schneider: Thoughts.

[4:23] Kevin David Thomas: He was wearing sunglasses and a big smile on his face, and I thought he must have like been a producer on "Bandstand."

[4:29] Robert W Schneider: He wasn't, he just came to see the show and was so nice and took pictures.

[4:33] Kevin David Thomas: Seriously, took pictures with everyone and shook everybody's hand and complimented them. It was really sweet.

[4:38] Robert W Schneider: It was really, really nice. But unfortunately, they're going to shovels.

[4:43] Kevin David Thomas: That's um, a sad note. But speaking of a sad note, this is the first time that we've ever done this.

[4:49] Robert W Schneider: Um, this week, our favorite thing is something that we are going to share together.

[4:55] Kevin David Thomas: So there are not two favorite things, there is one favorite thing.

[4:58] Robert W Schneider: And our favorite thing this year.

[5:00] Kevin David Thomas: What a good one, Rob, a really good idea, too.

[5:03] Robert W Schneider: You know, and I, we, I know this is like a—gosh, I feel like we say this every six months, but when we lose someone that we should have had, it feels—and yeah, I mean, everyone's sad that she's gone, but I just feel like I really, I would have liked to have chatted with her about her childhood and her upbringing, and she had a really interesting upbringing.

[5:23] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, and uh, I, I'm just, oh man, I just wish we got her story.

[5:27] Robert W Schneider: I just thought—and her story has been written, and you can get her biography and all of that. But um, uh boy, what a legend.

[5:34] Kevin David Thomas: What a, what a, what a legend.

[5:37] Robert W Schneider: And the biography is quite a bit.

[5:40] Kevin David Thomas: Well, you read and she, she pulled no punches. I mean, like she goes, she goes out for it, right?

[5:48] Robert W Schneider: No, she's very open about her struggles with weight and with alcohol and with depression. Um, it's a really fantastic, fantastic book.

[5:57] Kevin David Thomas: One of the things that I really appreciated about her was she really was in every sense of the word a survivor. Um, and I think that the pain that she suffered, she was able to so effortlessly turn it into her art.

[6:11] Robert W Schneider: Nobody, I don't think there's anybody who rivals her interpretation of a song from the American songbook or from the golden age of musical theater.

[6:22] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, even before she passed, she was still bringing new life to some of these old, old works.

[6:29] Robert W Schneider: Indeed, uh, had you ever seen her live?

[6:30] Kevin David Thomas: Contemporary and could break your heart.

[6:35] Robert W Schneider: I did.

[6:37] Kevin David Thomas: I um, yeah, in 2004 in London, she was playing in London, and I grabbed a ticket, and uh, the night—the week before she canceled a bunch of performances because she was really ill.

[6:51] Robert W Schneider: And she came out and she leaned against the crook of the piano and she said, I just want you all to know I'm still sick.

[6:59] Kevin David Thomas: Um, I felt really bad about canceling another week of performances.

[7:05] Robert W Schneider: And she did it, and she was still in beautiful, fine voice.

[7:09] Kevin David Thomas: And one of the things I'll never forget was because I had just seen Elaine Stritch at Liberty a while back.

[7:15] Robert W Schneider: Like she does. There was a moment where Elaine went up on a lyric and she didn't know.

[7:19] Kevin David Thomas: No, no, I know.

[7:20] Robert W Schneider: No, but I first hand, I know, yeah, totally.

[7:22] Kevin David Thomas: And it's not—that's not a criticism. It was, you know, that was the event.

[7:26] Robert W Schneider: That was the event.

[7:28] Kevin David Thomas: Um, and you know, broke character and made jokes and did this and did that.

[7:32] Robert W Schneider: Uh, the audience is on the floor laughing. Barbara Cook went up on a line and was in the middle of a ballad, and with outbreaking concentration with laser focus, she just whispered to Wally Harper, "One more time from the top."

[7:47] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, wow, Rob.

[7:48] Robert W Schneider: And just beautifully started over again.

[7:52] Kevin David Thomas: Um, but the focus was she wanted to make the music shine.

[7:57] Robert W Schneider: But it wasn't about, "Isn't this funny? I forgot a word." It was really beautiful.

[8:02] Kevin David Thomas: It was really beautiful.

[8:03] Robert W Schneider: So, yes, I did get to see her live, and then I became obsessed with her.

[8:08] Kevin David Thomas: And I had to get every single album and find out everything about her.

[8:12] Robert W Schneider: I had no—I had no idea who she was beforehand.

[8:16] Kevin David Thomas: I really didn't. I knew her—that she—I knew that she was in "Follies in Concert."

[8:22] Robert W Schneider: Right.

[8:22] Kevin David Thomas: And she was Sally. And then people were like, oh, she was the original Marion. And I'm like, really?

[8:28] Robert W Schneider: Truly sensational, what a correct one.

[8:32] Kevin David Thomas: I have a—I had a couple times.

[8:33] Robert W Schneider: Uh, what's interesting about you comparing her to Stritch is one of the two times that I saw her live.

[8:40] Kevin David Thomas: I'm not gonna get the dates right, but I know that it was in the late 2000s.

[8:44] Robert W Schneider: Uh, Lincoln Center did a benefit concert with Stritch and Barbara Cook together.

[8:50] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, and I will just side note, I love that you mentioned Wally Harper's name, her arranger and pianist for so many years.

[8:57] Robert W Schneider: Decades.

[8:58] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, Wally Harper, who was, uh, you know, my mentor, Jack Lee, he was his, you know, they were, you know, musician friends together, and they did a lot of shows together.

[9:07] Robert W Schneider: Wally Harper was a very special music director who will unfortunately, uh, not be remembered the way that he should be remembered, uh, and I'm just glad to mention his name.

[9:16] Kevin David Thomas: Um, but I saw them in concert at Lincoln Center, and Stritch had her piano player, Rob Bowman, and I cannot remember who Barbara Cook had, she had another piano player, but it was fascinating to see them back to back.

[9:31] Robert W Schneider: I—you know what? I have the playbill at home, and I'll have to go check, Rob, but I cannot say for sure.

[9:36] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, I honestly can't say for sure.

[9:38] Robert W Schneider: It was on the Vivian Beaumont stage. It was literally piano, and that's it.

[9:43] Kevin David Thomas: It was after her show. It was—I want to say it's like 2006, 2005, that around that time.

[9:48] Robert W Schneider: Um, and it was unbelievable because you saw two of these ladies of the same age-ish, um, and they were just apples and oranges.

[9:59] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, you know, you can't say one is better than the other, I think, because—and I'm not—this is not what the podcast is about, is comparing.

[10:07] Robert W Schneider: But what was fascinating is that Stritch came out and Stritch does her Stritch thing, and obviously this is before I knew her, but it was, you know, and then having done "A Little Night Music," it was like, oh yeah, I get how she is. She's always in the moment.

[10:19] Kevin David Thomas: She all she cares about is just being real and reacting or whatever.

[10:24] Robert W Schneider: She misses a lyric, she's gonna react to it.

[10:27] Kevin David Thomas: Uh, but Barbara Cook, there was something sacred that she brought to the word, and when you start a song as you are in that world, and it is a special place.

[10:41] Robert W Schneider: Not to say that Stritch doesn't feel that way, but Stritch's special place is different than Barbara Cook's was.

[10:49] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, both were sublime in their own regard.

[10:52] Robert W Schneider: James Levine, the famous Metropolitan Opera conductor, is obsessed with Stritch.

[10:56] Kevin David Thomas: He was upset.

[10:57] Robert W Schneider: He saw "A Little Night Music" like five or six times.

[10:59] Kevin David Thomas: And this is when he was not conducting at the Metropolitan Opera.

[11:02] Robert W Schneider: He came to see her because of her—that moment where she does mess up and she goes up.

[11:08] Kevin David Thomas: But Barbara Cook had a grace and a calmness to her that was just sublime, truly magical.

[11:20] Robert W Schneider: And I will, and the other thing I wanted to mention is that so many Broadway leave the business. They go out and do television and film because let's just be honest, that's what's much more lucrative, and you only have to work three days and get paid twice as much as you get paid for your year-long run.

[11:39] Robert W Schneider: But Barbara Cook made a living in the arts singing musical theater her entire career.

[11:46] Kevin David Thomas: And I think that is um pretty spectacular, pretty special.

[12:02] Robert W Schneider: Absolutely. And I, you know, you mentioned this, and I want to go further with it, which was I cannot think of a concert where she did not praise the lyricist of the song she was singing to the heavens.

[12:14] Kevin David Thomas: Burden Lane, Yep Harvard, uh Stephen Sondheim.

[12:19] Robert W Schneider: The word, like you said, was sacred.

[12:21] Kevin David Thomas: The word was sacred.

[12:23] Robert W Schneider: Um I wish there's so there's something so wonderful. If you buy the DVD, Barbara Cook, mostly Sondheim, one of the extras is her teaching a master class.

[12:35] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.

[12:36] Robert W Schneider: And she goes over with uh two students. One is Barb from the Home I Love, and the best is is William Finn Sailor.

[12:45] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Barbara.

[12:46] Robert W Schneider: And the young man gets to the lyric, you know, sex is nice, but I'd rather be sailing.

[12:51] Kevin David Thomas: I like that.

[12:52] Robert W Schneider: And she goes and goes, You'd rather be sailing. And you're so I I just I just like that because I think it's a little dig of contemporary lyrics, I think is what she's doing there.

[13:04] Kevin David Thomas: Um Wally Harper, like you said.

[13:06] Robert W Schneider: She did for a long time.

[13:08] Kevin David Thomas: That's correct.

[13:09] Robert W Schneider: She didn't go to LA like some of her contemporaries did.

[13:13] Kevin David Thomas: You know Caramoro, Dancy DuSol, even though she's a little older than them.

[13:17] Robert W Schneider: She didn't she didn't take that road.

[13:20] Kevin David Thomas: Until that.

[13:24] Robert W Schneider: Yep.

[13:25] Kevin David Thomas: No.

[13:25] Robert W Schneider: No, no, no, no, she didn't.

[13:33] Kevin David Thomas: But then she got the discovery in the 70s back to Carnegie Hall.

[13:36] Robert W Schneider: And she got, and first of all, before we even talk about her return, let's talk about what she had done.

[13:41] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my, okay, so we have her Broadway debut in Flahooly, which is a great title on its own.

[13:49] Robert W Schneider: And I I'm gonna give this away, and I'm very excited.

[13:52] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I love that.

[13:54] Robert W Schneider: On Wednesday, August 16th at 7 o'clock at 9 30 at Feinstein's 54 Below, we're doing a centennial celebration of the Broadhurst Theater where Flahooly first played.

[14:06] Kevin David Thomas: And we're doing a Barbara Cook tribute in there, and the two.

[14:10] Robert W Schneider: I don't want to tell you who the two singers are that are gonna sing from Flahooly to honor her, but it's a very special thing.

[14:17] Kevin David Thomas: And she created it.

[14:18] Robert W Schneider: I mean, she literally RH roles.

[14:21] Kevin David Thomas: But then, okay.

[14:22] Robert W Schneider: Has there ever been a better glitter and be gay than Barbara Cook's?

[14:30] Kevin David Thomas: You're totally correct.

[14:32] Robert W Schneider: Has there been a better Till There Was You from The Music Man?

[14:38] Kevin David Thomas: Has there been a better vanilla ice cream?

[14:40] Robert W Schneider: Has there been a better Will He Like Me?

[14:44] Kevin David Thomas: And as wonderful as Kristen Chenowith is, and as wonderful as Laura Bonanti is.

[14:50] Robert W Schneider: Oh, I love the Follies concert of that DVD.

[14:53] Kevin David Thomas: Remember 1984?

[14:54] Robert W Schneider: What is it?

[14:56] Kevin David Thomas: Um 85.

[14:57] Robert W Schneider: And you know, and there's like it's sort of a it's a weird DVD because it's kind of a documentary concert.

[15:03] Kevin David Thomas: It's not the whole concert.

[15:06] Robert W Schneider: Sometimes I'm like, where's that DVD, you guys?

[15:08] Kevin David Thomas: Like, give me the give me the concert.

[15:11] Robert W Schneider: Not just, although I love the drama that leads into it and all of that.

[15:16] Kevin David Thomas: That's fascinating.

[15:17] Robert W Schneider: I just want them to show me the concert.

[15:25] Kevin David Thomas: Can't imagine.

[15:26] Robert W Schneider: Can't imagine.

[15:27] Kevin David Thomas: She's like, it's my diabetes.

[15:29] Robert W Schneider: I know.

[15:30] Kevin David Thomas: Well, well, it's our favorite.

[15:32] Robert W Schneider: It's where she it's where Carol Burnett's singing, I'm still here.

[15:35] Kevin David Thomas: Yes!

[15:36] Robert W Schneider: Oh my gosh, I forgot about that.

[15:38] Kevin David Thomas: In the background throughout it.

[15:42] Robert W Schneider: And the com and the Comden and Green, no, the uh the Adolf Green Carol Burnett shade throwing in the hallway.

[15:49] Kevin David Thomas: Which which we love.

[15:51] Robert W Schneider: But anyway, yeah, no, I heard Mark Sendroff from our former guest was saying that he was at that.

[15:58] Kevin David Thomas: That feels like an urban legend that's because like eight people did it, but I believe it.

[16:03] Robert W Schneider: I believe that everyone was just like, I got nothing.

[16:05] Kevin David Thomas: Couldn't they even applaud?

[16:07] Robert W Schneider: So they just threw their programs in the air.

[16:11] Kevin David Thomas: Seriously.

[16:13] Robert W Schneider: To well, you listen to it and it's magical.

[16:22] Kevin David Thomas: But you know what I think is amazing?

[16:24] Robert W Schneider: Um my god.

[16:28] Kevin David Thomas: Oh.

[16:29] Robert W Schneider: Oh, I just wanted you to keep going, Rob.

[16:30] Kevin David Thomas: I was actually gonna just sit here and listen to some level.

[16:33] Robert W Schneider: Now, folks, we bring you direct from Purse live from Phoenix Live.

[16:37] Kevin David Thomas: Sally Durant.

[16:38] Robert W Schneider: What's that so called?

[16:38] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.

[16:38] Robert W Schneider: Here she is, at last sprinkler.

[16:40] Kevin David Thomas: All right, that's a moment.

[16:41] Robert W Schneider: No, don't look at me.

[16:41] Kevin David Thomas: Don't look at me, sorry.

[16:46] Robert W Schneider: But you can also listen on that recording on that song where George Hearn comes in a little bit early and just stops singing.

[16:53] Kevin David Thomas: So you're both so I think she's only supposed to sing so and sustain it.

[16:59] Robert W Schneider: And he's like, so oh, and he just like backs off real fast.

[17:05] Kevin David Thomas: Um, but I think that version of Don't Look At Me is beautiful.

[17:10] Robert W Schneider: Listen to the way she calls Ben's name right at the beginning.

[17:13] Kevin David Thomas: And listen to the emotion that she puts behind it.

[17:16] Robert W Schneider: Um really, really wonderful.

[17:18] Kevin David Thomas: 74 was the concert.

[17:20] Robert W Schneider: She went away for a bit.

[17:21] Kevin David Thomas: Um got it.

[17:22] Robert W Schneider: And if you read the autobiography, you'll know why.

[17:24] Kevin David Thomas: But then that concert coming back, coming back.

[17:28] Robert W Schneider: And I wonder how big.

[17:30] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know that now, and we've talked about cabaret a little bit um with uh a couple of people, but yeah, I wonder where Cabaret was and its gestation.

[17:38] Robert W Schneider: And did she enter at a good time?

[17:40] Kevin David Thomas: Was it a good time for people to sort of reinvent themselves in the cabaret scene?

[17:44] Robert W Schneider: If you know what I mean, Rob.

[17:46] Kevin David Thomas: Like, you know, because she did do a lot of other shows after that.

[17:49] Robert W Schneider: I mean, I s I the other show I saw her in was Sondheim on Sondheim at Roundabout Theater, of course, in 2010.

[17:58] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[18:00] Robert W Schneider: We Yeah.

[18:08] Kevin David Thomas: If I under if I understood what Lee Because Leroy Reims talked about this a lot, uh what he was saying was that it I don't think it was a place for people to be rediscovered.

[18:17] Robert W Schneider: I think it was a place for people to be discovered.

[18:20] Kevin David Thomas: I think it was a place for Marsha Lewis to be discovered.

[18:22] Robert W Schneider: I think it was a place for Michael Feinstein to be discovered.

[18:26] Kevin David Thomas: But you know, it an on genuine from the fifties coming back.

[18:30] Robert W Schneider: That's not, you know, no, you're not gonna be rediscovered.

[18:33] Kevin David Thomas: You should still be working, or you should be on a sit-back.

[18:36] Robert W Schneider: That's a really good question.

[18:38] Kevin David Thomas: Like those those three are on the show.

[18:39] Robert W Schneider: I'm kind of a sucker and I know this is gonna sound a little crazy.

[18:43] Kevin David Thomas: Um I really enjoy The Gay Life.

[18:48] Robert W Schneider: Um Magic Moment, I think is a really beautiful, beautiful piece.

[18:53] Kevin David Thomas: Um the show itself, no, I'm not gonna say Encore, please do that tomorrow.

[18:58] Robert W Schneider: But um Magic Moment, uh I I don't know why.

[19:02] Kevin David Thomas: Maybe it was because that was a show that resonated to me when I was younger and I it was one of the first experiences I ever had listening to her.

[19:08] Robert W Schneider: Um, but I truly think that that's a gorgeous rendition of of her voice showcasing it.

[19:15] Kevin David Thomas: Um uh I just that burp was beautiful, Rob.

[19:19] Robert W Schneider: I could hear that perfectly.

[19:20] Kevin David Thomas: Did you?

[19:21] Robert W Schneider: Oh my god, I I totally thought we'll have to edit this out.

[19:24] Kevin David Thomas: I thought uh when you go back and listen to this, just please listen to what just happened five seconds before that, because it's so like brrrr.

[19:32] Robert W Schneider: No, I really did.

[19:33] Kevin David Thomas: I really thought you were like.

[19:36] Robert W Schneider: Um, alcohol Oh, she struggled with depression, obesity, and alcoholism in the 70s.

[19:41] Kevin David Thomas: She eventually quit drinking in 1977.

[19:43] Robert W Schneider: Oh, fascinating.

[19:44] Kevin David Thomas: Sorry, I'm just looking at her uh yeah, I might be.

[19:48] Robert W Schneider: Oh, that's disgusting.

[19:50] Kevin David Thomas: You do it.

[19:50] Robert W Schneider: I learned from the best.

[19:51] Kevin David Thomas: Okay, I'm gonna clock back in now.

[19:52] Robert W Schneider: I'm gonna imagine.

[19:54] Kevin David Thomas: Um yeah, magic moment is definitely one of my favorites.

[19:57] Robert W Schneider: Um here's a confession to you, and I and I can't believe I'm gonna say this, but I music man was not a big a big epiphany for me in my listing.

[20:08] Kevin David Thomas: Uh for some reason I I know it well, but I never was like a big diehard music man fan.

[20:14] Robert W Schneider: I recently listened to it and really and I love it, and it's amazing.

[20:17] Kevin David Thomas: And I just listened to the original cast recording about a week and a half ago.

[20:21] Robert W Schneider: Uh uh, yeah, I I I I I guess I just never really connected to it when I was younger.

[20:27] Kevin David Thomas: So it's more of an appreciation now, but not a deep seated love of it.

[20:33] Robert W Schneider: But I I like it.

[20:34] Kevin David Thomas: I just I've never seen it.

[20:35] Robert W Schneider: I've only seen the movie, I've listened to the original cast recording, and that's it.

[20:38] Kevin David Thomas: Oh and so I really can't say.

[20:55] Robert W Schneider: Oh wow.

[20:57] Kevin David Thomas: I wasn't a huge fan of this show until um my mentor, Susan Shulman, who's gonna be a guest on this podcast soon.

[21:06] Robert W Schneider: She was going to direct the Music Man, and she said to me, She goes, You know what the Music Man's a baby down and I was snarky.

[21:12] Kevin David Thomas: I'm like two hours too long.

[21:13] Robert W Schneider: The kid with the little she goes, it's about a community of outsiders trying to get in.

[21:22] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I like that actually.

[21:24] Robert W Schneider: And she's wrong.

[21:25] Kevin David Thomas: Harold Hill is an outsider.

[21:27] Robert W Schneider: Marion is an outsider in the community.

[21:30] Kevin David Thomas: The kid Winthrop is an outsider, and they all find they're all united by this music.

[21:37] Robert W Schneider: And then once I heard that, I'm like, I really want to direct this.

[21:41] Kevin David Thomas: Now I really want to go in.

[21:43] Robert W Schneider: So I have a couple.

[21:45] Kevin David Thomas: Um, I mean, it's very obvious to be like, oh, you know, glitter and be gay or in Buddy's Eyes, but I'd like to our listeners to listen to a couple.

[21:52] Robert W Schneider: One is Among My Yesterdays, which she sings on Barbara Cook's Broadway album.

[21:59] Kevin David Thomas: Oh.

[22:00] Robert W Schneider: Which is uh from The Happy Time, uh, Candor and Ebb.

[22:03] Kevin David Thomas: And uh also on the Barbara Cook web.

[22:05] Robert W Schneider: Well, you know what's interesting?

[22:06] Kevin David Thomas: She does a comedy.

[22:08] Robert W Schneider: I love those Robin.

[22:09] Kevin David Thomas: Um, you know, she's really career.

[22:14] Robert W Schneider: Uh Jerry Herman's time feels everything.

[22:16] Kevin David Thomas: Up until the, you know, well, I guess the grasshopperly kind of sealed the deal.

[22:21] Robert W Schneider: But she was in these traditional musical theater pieces, and yet she's associated as the foremost interpreter of Sondheim, and yet she never really had done a Sondheim full-on musical.

[22:36] Kevin David Thomas: An original.

[22:37] Robert W Schneider: You know what I'm saying?

[22:38] Kevin David Thomas: Like, she did Follies in Concerts, she did Sondheim on Sondheim.

[22:41] Robert W Schneider: She's known as like the interpreter of Sondheim's music, and yet, like she didn't do any of them.

[22:49] Kevin David Thomas: Like, I'd love to have seen her Joanne.

[22:52] Robert W Schneider: I mean, that would have been fantastic.

[22:55] Kevin David Thomas: No, no, she never did.

[23:04] Robert W Schneider: Oh man.

[23:05] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[23:06] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, totally.

[23:07] Kevin David Thomas: No, she didn't.

[23:09] Robert W Schneider: And I.

[23:12] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, I think her Joe Man would have been epic.

[23:14] Robert W Schneider: I think.

[23:15] Kevin David Thomas: It's very strange.

[23:16] Robert W Schneider: Oh my god.

[23:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[23:17] Robert W Schneider: I think when she can you imagine if they wrote Sunday in the she would have played Dot.

[23:22] Kevin David Thomas: Why not?

[23:23] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, sure.

[23:24] Kevin David Thomas: She would have been a great Mary.

[23:26] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, her Joanne would have been great.

[23:29] Kevin David Thomas: She never played Sally fully, did she?

[23:33] Robert W Schneider: Or um What?

[23:35] Kevin David Thomas: She also would have been a good Mary in Marily.

[23:39] Robert W Schneider: No, not Mary.

[23:40] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Mary.

[23:41] Robert W Schneider: She would have been a good Mary.

[23:43] Kevin David Thomas: Her favorite songs.

[23:45] Robert W Schneider: Oh, the other one.

[23:47] Kevin David Thomas: I forgot, which I thought was genius.

[23:49] Robert W Schneider: You know what has not been one of our favorite.

[23:52] Kevin David Thomas: And I feel like it should be.

[23:54] Robert W Schneider: Do you remember when Saundy wrote that article for the New York Times?

[23:58] Kevin David Thomas: Frank Rich interviewed him.

[24:03] Robert W Schneider: I love that song so much.

[24:07] Kevin David Thomas: Well, whenever I play it, I'm always at a loss because I always think.

[24:11] Robert W Schneider: And she sang the song.

[24:12] Kevin David Thomas: This is just such a beautiful movie.

[24:13] Robert W Schneider: One of them.

[24:14] Kevin David Thomas: Which I think is so amazing is her rendition of Icon Ross and his arms.

[24:18] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, I have to confess that I I don't I haven't scratched the surface on her, really.

[24:23] Kevin David Thomas: I mean, I I only have had a peripheral knowledge and what I've seen, you know, but yeah.

[24:34] Robert W Schneider: Oh, I love it so much.

[24:37] Kevin David Thomas: Well.

[24:43] Robert W Schneider: Yes, because we tweeted out something, Rob.

[24:46] Kevin David Thomas: I don't know if you noticed this, but we like you were so good, and you sent out a very sweet little like you know, rest in peace, we shall be missed.

[24:54] Robert W Schneider: And do you know who was one of the people?

[24:56] Kevin David Thomas: Not that I'm like, oh my god, so and so liked our tweet.

[24:58] Robert W Schneider: But Lindsay Hatley.

[25:00] Kevin David Thomas: Um, did you notice that she completely Oh yeah, she like she interacted with us, and and I was like, I remembered that Barbara Cook played the Betty Buckley role.

[25:13] Robert W Schneider: Yes.

[25:14] Kevin David Thomas: Or Betty Buckley played the Barbara Cook role.

[25:20] Robert W Schneider: Oh no, I didn't.

[25:22] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.

[25:23] Robert W Schneider: Um I was just going to ask, I was just gonna say Scott Wise would be the person to ask because he would be able to tell us.

[25:32] Kevin David Thomas: Barbara Cook was kind of like Puff Puff, I'm good, I'm gonna pass.

[25:36] Robert W Schneider: I think I'm gonna.

[25:37] Kevin David Thomas: Well, then what happened?

[25:38] Robert W Schneider: Like apparently Barbara Cook almost got decapitated.

[25:40] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, like you know what, like, guys, but can you imagine telling us this?

[25:45] Robert W Schneider: Like, I'm looking at her her her resume, you know, Candy Music Man, PK Life.

[25:51] Kevin David Thomas: Showboat, she loves me, The King and I, Grass Harp, and then I almost got my head cut off.

[26:00] Robert W Schneider: So talk about a jump into contemporary musical theater land.

[26:04] Kevin David Thomas: Um she was like, this is what the world that I'm of course.

[26:14] Robert W Schneider: Sorry, Barbara's.

[26:22] Kevin David Thomas: Well, I think after her concert work, she plays.

[26:25] Robert W Schneider: Do you know what no one ever does?

[26:26] Kevin David Thomas: No one ever imitates Barbara Cook's singing.

[26:28] Robert W Schneider: Because you really can't catch what they sent her.

[26:30] Kevin David Thomas: You can't be like Stritch.

[26:32] Robert W Schneider: You can't be like Bernadette, you Patty Lapone, all of them.

[26:36] Kevin David Thomas: You can't, you really, how are you gonna make fun of Barbara Cook?

[26:38] Robert W Schneider: There's nothing to make fun of.

[26:40] Kevin David Thomas: Not even make fun of no one's making fun of them.

[26:42] Robert W Schneider: I'm sorry.

[26:42] Kevin David Thomas: But there's not even like a uh a caricature that you can you can bring out.

[26:48] Robert W Schneider: Like we've we've done Liza, we've done Carol Channing.

[26:51] Kevin David Thomas: Like, what are you gonna do with Barbara Cook?

[26:53] Robert W Schneider: You're gonna mix everything and make your mix sound as good as possible.

[26:57] Kevin David Thomas: Hi, I'm Barbara Cook.

[26:58] Robert W Schneider: I mix everything and I'm really good.

[27:00] Kevin David Thomas: And P.S.

[27:01] Robert W Schneider: Into my 80s, I still have a soprano and a mix, and you're welcome.

[27:05] Kevin David Thomas: Barbara Streisand, eat your heart out.

[27:16] Robert W Schneider: You're gonna be brilliant.

[27:17] Kevin David Thomas: That's amazing.

[27:18] Robert W Schneider: That's amazing.

[27:25] Kevin David Thomas: Well my god, if you listen to like Will He Like Me from one of her most recent concerts, and you listen to the original cast, you can't tell the difference.

[27:34] Robert W Schneider: You really can't seriously, you cannot tell the difference.

[27:39] Kevin David Thomas: But you know, a bit I mean, and like I said, you know, she wasn't alone in all this.

[27:42] Robert W Schneider: I mean, there was Wally Harper who was helping her, there was David Zippel who was helping her.

[27:47] Kevin David Thomas: There is so many people who helped get Barbara Cook back on track, and and God bless them for it, because I'm so happy that this beautiful legacy of work is left behind, and and what a great inspiration.

[27:59] Robert W Schneider: Just so many out there.

[28:01] Kevin David Thomas: But thank goodness that so much of what she did is preserved.

[28:04] Robert W Schneider: I will say that, and I'm thankful for that.

[28:07] Kevin David Thomas: Um I just, yeah, I wish that there was more film work of hers.

[28:12] Robert W Schneider: Um, and I I I wish that you know she would be around for you know another 80 years or so, but oh well.

[28:22] Kevin David Thomas: Well, I'm gonna I'm gonna watch that.

[28:24] Robert W Schneider: I'm gonna watch that after I watch Liza Manelli.

[28:27] Kevin David Thomas: I'm losing my mind that we talked about earlier on that other podcast that we interviewed.

[28:32] Robert W Schneider: I would suggest starting the mostly sawn time DVD.

[28:36] Kevin David Thomas: Um the mostly sauntime actually a DVD, I would say do the Sontime DVD.

[28:40] Robert W Schneider: So that way you can see her in action.

[28:42] Kevin David Thomas: Because it really was something incredible and special.

[28:53] Robert W Schneider: Oh yeah, we also we just discovered that Liza Minelli and the Pet Shop Boys did an MTV music video of losing my mind, which I actually kind of just wish that they just you know put a camera on Barbara Cook, just had her sing it, and that could have been the music video itself.

[29:07] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, good one.

[29:08] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, it's true.

[29:09] Kevin David Thomas: You're right.

[29:09] Robert W Schneider: You're totally right.

[29:12] Kevin David Thomas: What a beautiful, beautiful, um, to our business and to uh the world, really.

[29:17] Robert W Schneider: You're exactly right, Kevin.

[29:18] Kevin David Thomas: We're very close to getting her, and uh unfortunately time beat us to it.

[29:25] Robert W Schneider: Time does heal everything, but I think it's gonna take a long time to heal this one.

[29:29] Kevin David Thomas: Oh Rob!

[29:31] Robert W Schneider: Good.

[29:38] Kevin David Thomas: And I'm Kevin David Thomas.

[29:40] Robert W Schneider: Yeah, and so we raise our glasses to Barbara Cook, and I think it's actually more appropriate.

[29:47] Kevin David Thomas: We should probably raise our little scoop of vanilla ice cream to her.

[29:51] Robert W Schneider: So if you're if you're listening after you listen to this, go and grab a little scoop and turn on some Barbara Cook.

[29:57] Kevin David Thomas: And that's actually what we're gonna leave you with right now, is one of Barbara Cook's songs.

[30:00] Robert W Schneider: So and we will see you next week, hopefully with happier news.

[30:05] Kevin David Thomas: But until then, here's Barbara.

[30:06] ♪ Musical number: "Will He Like Me" — performed by Barbara Cook ♪

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred