Tommy John steps into The Batter's Box for Episode 40! John's big-league career spanned 1963-1989, and remains one of the most important figures in baseball history... Read More
From the show: Break A Bat! where Baseball Meets Broadway
Featured Shows
About
Tommy John steps into The Batter's Box for Episode 40! John's big-league career spanned 1963-1989, and remains one of the most important figures in baseball history. In 1974, he pioneered ulnar collateral ligamental reconstruction, since nicknamed "Tommy John Surgery," which he underwent after damaging the ligament in his throwing arm.
Despite a poor outlook initially, he returned to being an effective pitcher, as more than half of his career wins came after his surgery. It has since become a common procedure among baseball pitchers. Throughout his 26-year Major League career, he cemented a legacy for both the New York Yankees and Los Angeles Dodgers as one of the greatest left-handed pitchers of all-time, as he retired as a 4-time Major League All-Star with prominent rankings in baseball's record books that include 700 Games Started (8th all-time), 4710.3 Innings Pitched (20th), and 288 Wins (26th). This episode not only rehashes some of John's career highlights, but also his candid thoughts on today's game, the grooming of young performers, pitching under the bright lights of Broadway, and his overall love of musical theatre. His son even appeared on Broadway in Les Misérables while John pitched for the Yankees! John has a real affinity for showtunes which is prominently displayed in this very special (and blatantly honest) chat.
Hosted by Al Malafronte
Produced by the Broadway Podcast Network
Edited by Matthew Hendershot
Connect with Break a Bat! on Instagram: @break_a_bat_podcast
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:08] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to the Break a Bat Podcast where baseball meets Broadway, an attempt to show that my two favorite mediums don't have to live in such separate worlds and maybe even break some stigmas.
[0:20] Al Malafronte: We're happy to have you with us. Now let's play ball.
[0:26] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to Break a Bat. I'm your host, Al Malafronte, and tonight we're joined by someone who's particularly special to the baseball world, not only for what he did on the field, but the impact he's made off of it.
[0:38] Al Malafronte: My guest today pitched in the big leagues for 26 seasons, the second most ever played by anyone in baseball history, and did so while performing at an all-star caliber level.
[0:49] Al Malafronte: He made four all-star teams, he pitched in three World Series, and he retired with 288 lifetime wins, a number that's still good for 26th all time in the Major League record books.
[1:02] Al Malafronte: The UCL surgery in which he pioneered as a player in 1974 has paved the way for countless injured baseball players to continue performing, and that surgery has since been renamed in his honor.
[1:15] Al Malafronte: He's one of the true good guys in baseball. If you'll please turn your attention to home plate, just beyond the marquee, now batting Tommy John.
[1:29] Tommy John: Oh, I missed.
[1:37] Tommy John: God, it's good to be just asked to do anything. And I don't want you to think that we discriminate against pitchers with the now batting thing, as you probably figure that pun just suits our show title.
[1:50] Tommy John: I think pitchers should be able to hit. They should be able to bunt, they should be able to run bases, slide at second base instead of just pitch.
[2:09] Tommy John: It's taken away. Well, it's added one more slot for the players' association to put a player in making big money. But the whole game is you pitch, you hit, you run.
[2:27] Tommy John: If you want to throw up high and tight to somebody, okay, fine. Then you gotta have the stones to stand in there and get it back at you. That's my opinion.
[2:38] Al Malafronte: Now, Tommy, you may or may not know that our show is all about celebrating great performance on the grandest of stages. You primarily pitched for the Yankees and Dodgers, two of the most prestigious franchises in baseball history.
[2:49] Al Malafronte: Stones throws from Broadway and Hollywood certainly have different vibes in both places. Which stage did you enjoy performing on the most?
[2:57] Tommy John: Ownership wise, the Dodgers. The O'Malley family treated you like you were their son. And that's that was their thing. You're part of the Dodger family. Organizationally, fans and all that, no question, Yankees.
[3:16] Tommy John: I remember my first game as a Yankee. We lost on Friday, good Friday. Gidry lost to Milwaukee. Ed Figueroa lost Saturday, so I'm pitching Easter Sunday.
[3:33] Tommy John: And I come to the ballpark, and as I'm going in to my the clubhouse, I cut through where the manager's office is. And right as I get through that door, out walks Steinbrenner. This is it. This is why I got you. I got you for this. This is the most important game of your life.
[3:54] Tommy John: I said, George, it's the third game of the season. If we lose this game and then win all the rest, it's 159 and three. No, that's not. And I went, whoa, this is what it's like to be a Yankee.
[4:10] Tommy John: Now I go out to the game, I start the game, ball one, ball two, ball three, ball four. And the fans are booing. Robin Yount is the second hitter, ball one. Now I pitched five pitches as a Yankee, five balls. John, you suck. Go back to LA. You know, I mean, I was throwing the ball like Britney for Pete's sake.
[4:36] Tommy John: And I mean, I couldn't hit a bowl in the butt with a base fiddle. And yeah, some of it was nerves wanting to perform. Well, I got out of that inning with only giving up one run.
[4:50] Tommy John: And they took me out in the seventh inning. We were up two to one or three to one, and they brought Gossage in to pitch 7-8-9. A closer pitching three innings. My God, you can't do that. The goose went seven, eight, nine, boom. We win the ball game.
[5:11] Tommy John: And I go on to win like the next four, five, six games. Now I'm six and oh. And the same people that were yelling, you suck, are now my the guys that want to buy me a beer in the restaurant where we're eating, you know. And but the fans in New York are the best, the absolute best.
[5:32] Tommy John: They'll let you know if you're good or you're bad or what they're thinking. I loved it. Now you were here right in the heart of the early Steinbrenner years. The Bronx Zoo was the strongest ever.
[5:44] Tommy John: I like to equate George to a Broadway producer with a huge personality. What do you remember about the free agent negotiations when he took you out of LA and brought you over to the Yankees?
[5:57] Tommy John: He was pretty direct. I never had any conversation with him. My agent did. We flew in to New York right after Thanksgiving, right before Christmas, and we were going to do the contract.
[6:16] Tommy John: He meets us at LaGuardia. My agent, his wife, my wife and me. We fly from LA, LaGuardia. George comes in. Hi, George Steinbrenner, George Steinbrenner, George Steinbrenner. And he turns and walks, and he leaves us with Al Rosen.
[6:36] Tommy John: And Al said, Don't worry about George. That's the way he is. And but that was George. George was just in his Broadway. I think was it No No Nanette, the play that he owned. I think it was. He liked star quality.
[6:55] Tommy John: That's why he went out to get good players. He wanted that star because that brought people to the ballpark. It's funny, you mentioned that Broadway parallel there. When you were pitching here, there were a lot of great shows on Broadway that premiered.
[7:08] Al Malafronte: I mean, Evita, Les Misérables, there was a lot of the Lloyd Webber stuff. You know, my son, my late son Taylor, was Gavroche in Les Misérables.
[7:22] Tommy John: Is that right? He was there for two years. He was on the road for one, and then he was one year on Broadway. And he did something that a 10-year-old kid would never ever do. He quit.
[7:37] Tommy John: Yep. He said, I want to go down to Florida. He said, I want to go down to Florida with my brothers and play baseball. And so he walked away. So when you were pitching for the Yankees, did you have a lot of guys in that clubhouse that used to like to catch their fix of Broadway?
[7:56] Tommy John: I don't know very many did. I think that I know I did. I love to go. When we were with the Angels or the White Sox, there was a guy that I can't think of his name now.
[8:22] Tommy John: But he would we would call him up and say, What's what's good on Broadway? Oh, I got tickets for this show, Saturday night. Okay, and he would give us free tickets to go to these shows, and God, it was fun. I mean, man alive. Fun.
[8:40] Tommy John: Oh, gee, whiz. What are some of the shows that stand out to you?
[8:44] Tommy John: Cats. I love Cats. Because we're a cat, we were a cat family. Loved them. And Evita, I love musicals. I didn't like plays, you know, but I love music. I love to listen to them sing and the orchestras and all that.
[9:05] Tommy John: It was, and then when Taylor was on Broadway, you know, you got to meet the guys doing the music. And my God, were they good. And they, you know, Saturday night, Sunday afternoon, Wednesday afternoon, they would tee it up and go for it.
[9:25] Al Malafronte: I can't even imagine what that period must have been like. And you know, fortunately, we still have a lot of we only have I'd like to think that we only have the best out there representing Broadway in the orchestra, and it really is such a great experience.
[9:37] Al Malafronte: And you know, obviously Yankee Stadium in the late 70s was no different. And when you came over here, it was such an interesting time because you came over in 79, it was fresh off the back-to-back titles. Most of that nucleus of that 77, 78 team was still together.
[9:52] Al Malafronte: There were certainly a lot of big personalities that had to mesh in order to win. You being the type of guy you were, you had obviously had some big success prior to your time here. How do you acclimate yourself to a clubhouse like that?
[10:03] Tommy John: They're teammates, they're just they're buddies, and you know, it was funny. When I was with the White Sox, I went over, everybody was going out and play golf, and I never got invited. And then my first start in spring training, I pitched three innings, shut out ball.
[10:25] Tommy John: The next day they were having more golf. I get invited. How'd I get invited? Because I pitched well, and I found out the better I pitched, the more invitations I got.
[10:43] Al Malafronte: You know, Tommy, there's quite a few demanding directors here on Broadway who sometimes irk their cast in the ways they try to drive results from their team. Is it safe to say that your manager, Billy Martin, was one of those guys?
[10:55] Tommy John: Billy didn't have a clue. I was not a Billy Martin fan, and Billy wasn't a Tommy John fan. That I can tell you. I got a report during spring training. He was sitting there with Cleet Boyer and Ark Fowler, the erstwhile pitching coach that couldn't teach pitching to anybody.
[11:16] Tommy John: But he's sitting there and he said, How the F does this guy win with the shit he throws? Now here your manager is saying that. So what does he think about you? He thinks that you can't pitch. But that was Billy. He was I thought I didn't have good vibes with Billy, and Billy didn't have them with me.
[11:45] Tommy John: I like Bob Lemon. I love Dick Hauser. Dick Hauser was outstanding. And unfortunately, Mike Ferrara waived Willie Randolph home on that throw from left field, and he got thrown out and Steinbrenner filed for Ferrara and Hauser says, you're going to fire him, you might as well fire me.
[12:05] Tommy John: And George says, Okay, you're gone too. You know, but that's the way it was. It was just um but I love I love I love pitching on the road. When I was with the Yankees, I loved pitching at Fenway Park. Loved it.
[12:23] Tommy John: I love pitching with the Angels out there, big crowds. When I was with the Dodgers, I loved pitching in Cincinnati and Philly. Big crowds, boisterous, yelling at me, telling me I couldn't pitch, and I was this, I was that.
[12:46] Tommy John: I love that. It made it fired me up, actually. It fired me up that I got a chance to play a little better.
[12:58] Al Malafronte: That's so fascinating to me. Um, you know, Tommy, there's a lot of Yankee fans here in New York. Um there are that I think yes, there are, but there's a lot of them that are still pained by that loss to the Dodgers in the '81 World Series. And you certainly did your part to help the team win. You gave up all of one run in the two games you started. It was George Frazier lost three.
[13:17] Tommy John: Yeah, they still kept trotting him out there. Well, that's when Bob Lemon, um, I get a call from my internist out here. Uh, he texts me and my phone goes bing bing, and I looked on it, and it was Eddie Pacino. And how you like to have an internist with the last name of Pacino? So he said, Hey, I'm watching you pitch an '81 World Series, and I went back, I said, we already taped that. Uh, it was on the week before, and we taped it, and people that have never saw me pitch got a chance. I pitched four innings at game four, gave up one run. That's the only run I gave up in like 13 or 14 innings, and Lim comes up and he says, uh, I'm taking you out for a pinch hitter.
[14:21] Al Malafronte: What?
[14:22] Tommy John: I said, Who you bringing in? He said, Frazier. I said, he had some pitch good all series. Don't tell me how to manage. And I go, I'm not telling you how to manage. I must tell me, you know, if you're gonna take me out, bring Gossage in. Uh, we can't bring him in. He he's gotta be for the save. Well, there is no save because Frazier gave up five or six runs, whatever it was. But be that as it may, I found out later through a guy named Doug Melvin, who was the Baltimore Orioles general manager. Steinbrenner with his football background, and um he had a meeting every day before the game with his coaches, manager. Game plan. This is my game plan. Okay. In baseball, there is no game plan. The score is the game plan, you know.
You say, and George's was get a lead early and then go to your bullpen and win it out of the bullpen. Okay, all right, we'll do that. But um, then that's what Lim, being a good soldier, he tried to do what George wanted, and it just doesn't work that way.
[15:40] Al Malafronte: You think there's any truth to the story that Steinbrenner got into a fist fight in the elevator after that?
[15:46] Tommy John: Yes, yes. There's whole truth to that. Did you guys ever reconcile in the years after your time with the Yankees?
[15:56] Tommy John: Oh, I never got in a fight with George. George was okay. Um, I remember I came back, I got released by Oakland in '85. Angels let me go because I was embarrassing Mrs. Autry and Gene Autry. I was embarrassing both of them with my pitching. Okay, all right. And I told her, I said, Jackie, I'm embarrassing you. I said, I'm embarrassing myself. And she said, Well, Gina and I are just appalled. And why don't you quit? And um we'll put you up in the booth and you can do TV or whatever you want to do. So, Jackie, I want to pitch. I want to pitch. So I must have perturbed her to the point that she um let me go about June, middle of June, something like that. And I signed with Oakland. Okay, I go with Oakland, and then they released me, and I said, Um, I wanted to pitch.
There wasn't any I I sent out letters, so I sent a letter. I called uh Clyde King, who was general manager for the Yankees, and uh I said, look, all I want to do, I'll probably get released out of spring training. All I want to do is retire from baseball as a Yankee, and he said, Well, give me a chance, I'll talk to the boss, and we'll see what it is.
[17:37] Tommy John: So about 10 days, two weeks, he calls me back and he said the boss said you could come back, but you had to keep your mouth shut. I said, Well, you tell him that he's the reason I act like this. I said, When I came in, I said I was Mr. Doubtfire for Pete's sake. I said, I was the biggest wimp, I wouldn't say squat, and being around George for as long as I was, um I said, he's the one that made me like this. It you know, well, so I came back and um I pitched a good game against the Mets. And Dallas Green, if you recall, was the manager then, and Dallas, uh no, it wasn't '85. I forget who the manager was in '85. Now my memory's gone. Pini. Yeah, Lou was. And Lou just says, hey, you know, do what you want to do, and we'll go from there.
I said, okay, that's fine. And son of a gun, I made the ball club out of spring training, but they didn't take me with the team. I had to stay down in Fort Lauderdale, and then every fourth day I would fly over to Tampa and I would pitch. Then I'd fly back to Fort Lauderdale. Yankees had spring training in Fort Lauderdale. The minor league teams had spring training in Tampa. So I flew over there. I got myself ready. Um, I pitched a couple of um intersquad games in Fort Lauderdale against the minor league team there, and they send me up to New York. This is how I walk into the clubhouse. I said, Hey Lou, how you doing? He said, What are you doing here? I said, I'm coming up to pitch. You are?
He gets on the phone. What's going on? You didn't tell me this. And I said, uh, uh-oh. Uh there's been a breakdown in communication. But uh I went up and I pitched, and I pitched, and all of a sudden, I did good in '86. '87, I did even better. And then '88, '89, I started losing losing interest. Um there, you know, there were things that I wanted to do with my kids that I couldn't do. And um, so I just uh, you know, when you lose interest, you lose that zest. And I lost the zest.
[20:28] Al Malafronte: It's so interesting, Tommy. I've had a number of Broadway performers on here, and obviously it's a little bit different because in baseball, you know, quite often there's an expiration date. And we've had some performers on here like Kate Rockwell and Robin Herter, who have talked about, you know, kind of losing that juice, uh, you know, what they're doing, and they've gone on to have some of their greatest career milestones since after they rediscovered their passion. You're in a position that I find particularly interesting, especially in the sense that you have a legacy that goes beyond just what you did on the field. Um, obviously, because of you know, the injury that you experienced, the surgery that you did to overcome it.
And I know that you and your son have done quite a bit of research in hopes of calling attention to arm injuries among younger players. Right. There's been such a rise in the number of Tommy John surgeries over the years. What do you make of the way they're grooming kids who want to grow up and be major league pitchers?
[21:28] Tommy John: Well, the kids need to spend more time climbing trees and doing things like that than going to baseball camps, pitching camps, and all this. The parents want to see little Johnny be an all-star, and they send him to the uh Lupinella hitting camp down in Tampa. Well, that may be okay, but the kid's a kid. Let him let him be a kid. And then as he starts getting older and you start seeing, hmm, he's got pretty good stuff. Uh, then you go for it. But um parents are the problem. It's not the kids, it's not baseball, it's the parents. The parents want the kids to be uh all around all-star ball players, and they'll pay anything to get the kid to play and be good, but you know.
[22:30] Al Malafronte: Here on Broadway, that's become a thing too. And you have some wonderful institutions that are teaching kids, and the pros are teaching kids. Um, and quite often it's more the parents' dream than it is the kids' dream.
[22:43] Tommy John: That's right. And you know, another big issue, and I want to get your take on this, that we've had, especially in the theater industry, is how there's become less focus on craft and technique. When you have a lot of hopeful up and coming performers who are more focused on their brand rather than how effective they are as performers, that's a big issue. And I feel like in baseball, with the young kids who get called up to the big leagues, there's often a notion of I can throw 95 or this turbo sink. I'm 21. Be damned if what I'm doing with my pitch selection is yielding the most effective result. And I should probably throw this change up to this hitter here with two strikes. But I'd rather get myself on Sports Center tonight by striking him out with a spectacle pitch and maybe gain a few extra thousand followers on social media because of that. Have you noticed that around baseball as well?
[23:34] Tommy John: Well, the game now is being managed and coached with radar guns. It doesn't make any difference. And I said, I asked somebody, I forget who it was. I said, why don't we go back to the days when you were a good pitcher if you got batters out? If you didn't get batters out, it doesn't make any difference how hard you throw. You're you aren't any good. Let's get batters out. Let's teach them sinker, changeup. Look at Greg Maddox. He was a hard thrower. And then he went over to the Cubs and they taught him the sinker and the curveball and that awesome changeup of his. And he was uh he was tough. I mean, God, he'd stand out there and throw strike after strike after strike on the uh out if you're a left-handed hitter on the outside black, and then he'd throw that change up and then he would bust a fastball in and strike you out.
But um I just think we've gotten to the point in baseball that um it's all about how hard you throw, how fast you run, how much do you weight lift, you know? Um and I think that has a lot to do with the injuries.
[24:56] Al Malafronte: What do you make of these bat flips these days? And the and the you know, this different brand that baseball is in some ways trying to embrace, but purists like you and I would probably scoff at.
[25:09] Tommy John: It's just those guys wanting to be studs and they don't know how to be, and so they flip a bat and think that they're awesome.
[25:19] Tommy John: How would you have handled that? You know, in with your generation of players. Me, I wouldn't throw at them unless they did it to embarrass me. But if they hit the ball out of the ballpark and they hit it 450 feet, mm maybe they should flip the bat. And I'm the one that somebody should take a swing at because I was the one that gave the gave the ball up. But um uh it's just yeah, guys being guys that they haven't been. If I would have done that when I was a kid, my dad would have taken me and yanked my butt back on the bench and set me down, and I wouldn't have played again until I learned how to play baseball.
[26:11] Al Malafronte: Tommy, do you still enjoy watching the game?
[26:14] Tommy John: I don't watch baseball.
[26:15] Al Malafronte: When did you stop?
[26:17] Tommy John: When I got out of the game and I went back and I managed, I managed in the minor leagues. I managed in the expo organization for two years, or coached, I mean, and then uh I coached in the Yankee organization for one year. Uh I manage Staten Island and they had so many rules on pitching. I was out of pitchers 10 days into the season. I'm done. I'm out of pitchers. So I call up Mark Newman, head of the minor leagues, and Mark, I'm out of pitchers. Ah, throw your first baseman. I said, throw my first baseman. I said, Mark, this is the New York Yankees. This is the Staten Island Yankees. This is not some Bush League team. No, I said I won't do it. I said, I'll pitch before that. And um they just all these regulations and stuff, and it never made them better.
That's the thing. It never made the players better. And look how far it got the Yankees when they had Jabba, Hughes, and Ian Kennedy as these prime prospects and all these rules and shifting them back and forth to the bullpen to watch their innings. Look at how it blew up their careers. None of them fulfilled the potential that they were hyped to. It's crazy.
[27:45] Al Malafronte: Exactly right.
[27:47] Tommy John: I don't know. That's why I got out. I tell you the most fun I had managing in baseball. I manage in the Atlantic League, uh, Bridgeport, Connecticut. I had more fun with that, and those kids, they're going no place. They're going no place. And um, but they they were out there playing hard, trying to get back into organized baseball, and it just it just doesn't work. It just didn't work.
[28:17] Al Malafronte: Tommy, there's a rumor going around that there's a Tommy John movie in the works. Break some bats and break some news for us tonight. What do we got on that front?
[28:25] Tommy John: Well, that's easier said than done. Um it's you're trying to get funding. We've we've got two or three people. Donnie Most. Remember Donnie Most? Oh, uh Pot's, no, not Potty, uh, Ralph Mellon. Right, yeah, yeah. And uh he wants to do the show. I mean, do the movie, and uh we just have to get the funding and get everything in place. But um, you know, uh hopefully somewhere down the line, maybe they can get it out before I die. You know, for the Broadway fans at home, Donnie Most actually did an episode or two of Glee uh is uh Emma's father, I believe. In the uh that that was that was a fun episode. Uh so yeah, there's definitely some Broadway ties there. Uh we'll uh we'll definitely provide the folks at home with some links in our uh episode description, you know, as far as uh some of the great causes.
[29:20] Al Malafronte: And uh, you know, Tommy, we do one final segment to wrap the show. It's called Fast Ball Derby. Uh we ask you a question, and you say the first thing that comes to your head. How does that sound?
[29:31] Tommy John: Okay, lay it on them.
[29:34] Al Malafronte: Favorite New York City meal.
[29:36] Tommy John: Um fresco by Scato.
[29:40] Al Malafronte: If you could star in one Broadway show, what would it be?
[29:43] Tommy John: Le Mezzerab.
[29:45] Al Malafronte: Which role would you play?
[29:46] Tommy John: Valjon.
[29:48] Al Malafronte: What is it about that show that's so special to you, Tommy?
[29:51] Tommy John: Because my son was in it, and I only saw it about 75 times, and I just there's there wasn't a bad song in it. There was not a bad song in it. And uh I got to know Richard J. Alexander, uh, who was the George Steinbrenner of Le Miz. And um he ran a tough ship, a tight ship, a good ship, but uh I like the show. I I like the music. It was it stayed in your mind, you know.
[30:27] Al Malafronte: That's me to my next question. Your all-time favorite show tune.
[30:31] Tommy John: How do you do my name's Gav Rush? These are my people. Here's my patch. Not much to look at, nothing posh, nothing that you call up from scratch, here we are time on high society.
[30:48] Al Malafronte: I don't know. That was great. We would have to uh we gotta contact Broadway Records here. This is awesome. Keep going, Tommy.
[31:01] Tommy John: Oh that's a great one. How about um let's leave the Le Miz uh universe for a minute? Do you have a favorite Broadway actor or actress?
[31:11] Tommy John: I like the girl that I'm trying to think of her name that played in cats.
[31:15] Al Malafronte: Les Callaway.
[31:18] Tommy John: No, she made golf clubs, didn't she? Wait, uh, no, no, she's a big Mets fan, though. We're not gonna. No, she's a Mets fan. Yeah, she's a friend of the show, too, actually, okay, no, I don't. Um, I like uh uh the gal that played Evita.
[31:38] Al Malafronte: Okay, don't cry for me, Argentina.
[31:43] Tommy John: This is awesome, no, no, no, no, no.
[31:47] Al Malafronte: All right, David, my best.
[31:50] Tommy John: Tell me, you got some voice.
[31:52] Al Malafronte: I love no voice.
[31:54] Tommy John: That's why I pitched.
[31:58] Al Malafronte: Well, I'm not sure if you saw CeC and Mark Dechera have uh done a couple synts in Rock of Ages. Maybe he'll be the next guy.
[32:04] Tommy John: CC who?
[32:06] Al Malafronte: Sebatia.
[32:07] Tommy John: He sings.
[32:09] Al Malafronte: I don't think he had a singing part, neither did Tex, but uh okay, okay. How about that body?
[32:18] Tommy John: All time favorite film, all time favorite film, Field of Dreams.
[32:24] Al Malafronte: You know what? All the guy wanted to do was have a catch with his dad.
[32:31] Tommy John: That was the essence of the show, and when that came out, Tommy started crying, and I had tears running down my face. I said, I would love to bring my dad back and just play catch with him one last time. I'd nail him in the chest, but you know, it's such a father and son game, and that's how it is, it is, yeah, special in that way, yeah.
[32:56] Al Malafronte: Toughest hitter you ever had to face.
[32:59] Tommy John: Well, statistically, it was Ned Yost, and I never recall Ned Yost getting a hit off of me, but he was 12 for 14, and um, but the guy that I hated to face, I could never make a good pitch to King Griffey Senior. I said, I could get Junior out. He's he was a piece of cake, but he was only 12 then, so that uh but uh senior, but the best hitter I ever saw was Wade Box.
[33:30] Al Malafronte: How about a guy you owned?
[33:32] Tommy John: Well, Pete Rose. Pete Rose had me in the top three of the toughest pitchers he had to face. Jim Brewer, Tommy John, Randy Jones. And we all pitched the same. Balls down and away, down and away, down and away. Pete didn't like that. But I own Pete.
[33:55] Al Malafronte: Proudest moment of your career.
[33:57] Tommy John: Proudest moment of my career is when Steinbrenner let my son Travis in 1981. Uh after the strike, we're back out playing. And he fell out of a third-story window down at Point Pleasant. And he was in a coma for 17 days. And he came back out of it, and Steinbrenner asked him to throw out the first pitch of the first game at Yankee Stadium. Who's pitching the first game at Yankee Stadium? We had two on the road, came back to Yankee Stadium. T-Bones pitching. And I told the umpire, I said, you'll have to excuse me. He said, why? And I said, because I can't see home plate. I'm I've been crying so hard. And he said, I can't either. I've been crying too. I said, okay, just give me some strikes and then let me pitch myself into it.
And I didn't pitch real well, but that was the proudest moment to hear 56, 57,000 Yankee fans. Reggie Jackson came out to be with him and uh my pregnant wife and he lifted travis up like this and put him around and the people started going Travis Travis Travis and I went I'm sitting on the bench I'm I'm ready to go out and warm up and I hear hear that and I go oh can't uh this you know and I'm crying like a baby but I go out I pitch the best I could and then we beat Oakland and uh get to the World Series and that's when the Dodgers beat us.
[35:48] Al Malafronte: Unbelievable Tommy and um lastly what's the best piece of advice anyone ever gave you?
[35:48] Tommy John: My dad remember who you are and where you come from he said whatever you do in baseball you will forever be Tommy John from Terre Haute Indiana. That's who you are those that's your roots that's awesome Tommy and um first of all I can't thank you enough for joining us tonight.
[36:07] Al Malafronte: You're welcome, you're welcome. I've got to know um what shows on Broadway do you want to see? Because I think once we're on the other end of this uh quarantine I think we got to get you over uh to eighth avenue and uh catching some shows with me and Brittany.
[36:21] Tommy John: Well, my daughter and granddaughter have seen Hamilton about 10 times 10 times okay I'm still waiting for they're Hamiltonites um I don't know I out here in Palm Springs, uh, the biggest show out here is the Nancy Pelosi strip show that they have it at one of the clubs there when she comes in and takes her clothes off. You can't make this stuff up.
[37:06] Al Malafronte: Well, Tommy, thank you so much again for joining us tonight.
[37:10] Tommy John: Thank you.
[37:11] Al Malafronte: Thanks for having me.
[37:12] Tommy John: God bless.
[37:15] Al Malafronte: Thanks for listening to Break a Bat. This is produced by the fine folks at the Broadway Podcast Network. Visit and subscribe at bpn.fm slash breakabat. You can find me online at break underscore a underscore bat underscore podcast. And you can also find the Broadway Podcast Network on Instagram at Broadway Podcast Network. It's been so great having you here with us today, and we'll see you next time.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
