From October 2020. Joel McHale brings some big laughs to The Batter’s Box in Episode 55! Having made a name for himself in show business as the host of The Soup, and star of Community, McHale has kept as busy as anyone in the industry throughout 2020... Read More
From the show: Break A Bat! where Baseball Meets Broadway
About
From October 2020.
Joel McHale brings some big laughs to The Batter’s Box in Episode 55! Having made a name for himself in show business as the host of The Soup, and star of Community, McHale has kept as busy as anyone in the industry throughout 2020. Whether it be hosting the critically acclaimed Tiger King after-show special, launching his own podcast The Darkest Timeline, or guest judging on The Masked Singer, McHale’s work ethic and passion for what he does is undeniable. He also serves as the host of ABC’s Card Sharks revival, which has its second season set to premiere this Sunday, October 18 at 10/9c.
In addition to everything McHale has accomplished on-screen, he’s also a tremendous fan of both sports and theatre, having participated in baseball, football, and school plays growing up in his hometown of Mercer Island, Washington. After going onto play college football at the University of Washington, and then launching a now 25+ year career in entertainment, his love of both mediums has never wavered.
This week, McHale sits down with host Al Malafronte to not only discuss of all of his exciting recent work, but also his thoughts on life in show business, the possibility of a Community reboot, and his many career highlights. We also rehash McHale’s fond memories of the 1995 Mariners, as his hometown is currently celebrating the 25th anniversary of the team that saved baseball in Seattle. Never one to shy away from the big moment, McHale even touches on what it would take for him to dip his toe into Broadway’s waters, as he remains an avid fan of theatre with some phenomenal insight and stories.
Connect with Joel McHale on Instagram: @joelmchale and Twitter: @joelmchale
Connect with Break a Bat! on Instagram: @break_a_bat_podcast
Hosted by Al Malafronte
Produced by the Broadway Podcast Network
Edited by Matthew Hendershot
Photo used in episode art: F. Scott Schafer
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:08] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to the Break a Bat Podcast where baseball meets Broadway, an attempt to show that my two favorite mediums don't have to live in such separate worlds and maybe even break some stigmas.
[0:19] Al Malafronte: We're happy to have you with us.
[0:21] Al Malafronte: Now let's play ball.
[0:25] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to Break a Bat. I'm your host, Al Malafronte, coming at you for the Broadway Podcast Network.
[0:30] Al Malafronte: Uh this one's a special show for me. As today we're lucky enough to be joined by probably one of my favorite people in show business.
[0:36] Al Malafronte: Uh he originally made a name for himself as the host of The Soup on E. He then went on to star in Community.
[0:42] Al Malafronte: Uh and he's currently the host of ABC's Card Sharks. The second season of the show's revival is set to premiere on Sunday, October 18th.
[0:50] Al Malafronte: And in addition to everything he's accomplished on screen, he's also a tremendous sports fan with a particular love for his hometown Seattle Mariners, as he nods his head along to that.
[0:59] Al Malafronte: So it's a real honor to have him join us tonight. With that being said, if you'll please turn your attention to home plate. Just beyond the marquee, now batting Joel McHale.
[1:08] Al Malafronte: Welcome to Break A Bat.
[1:09] Joel McHale: Great to be here on deck.
[1:10] Joel McHale: It's a very weird background.
[1:12] Joel McHale: It's a very weird baseball field, Ron.
[1:16] Joel McHale: I mean, you've been so busy, man. But I see, you know, I guess LA's rubbed off on you a little bit because you have like one of those uh makeshift Lakers shirts going on.
[1:24] Joel McHale: You jumped on the LA sports bandwagon, I say.
[1:27] Joel McHale: Just a couple days ago, I got on the bandwagon. I decided it was okay.
[1:31] Joel McHale: Uh well, I was celebrating I've been the last few days celebrating the come from behind Seahawks incredible victory on Sunday.
[1:39] Joel McHale: And then of course the Storm, Seattle Storm won the championship uh last week.
[1:43] Joel McHale: And then I was like, where I don't I didn't have like a Lakers scarf.
[1:48] Joel McHale: And so I just decided to find some yellow tape.
[1:52] Joel McHale: And I should have used some purple tape too. So it was uh yes, it was a great sport week for me.
[1:58] Al Malafronte: And you've been pretty busy throughout this whole pandemic. I mean, between the Tiger King special, you launched your own podcast, and you know, you have the second season of Card Sharks coming up.
[2:07] Al Malafronte: I mean, I gotta give you props, man. It's nice that you've been able to stay so busy. I'm sure we're all certainly grateful for it.
[2:13] Joel McHale: Oh, well, that's not true. But um, no, I yeah, no, I am a um workaholic obsessive compulsive person who has ADHD and cannot sit still.
[2:24] Joel McHale: And uh I usually go into like extreme anxiety when I'm on vacation.
[2:30] Joel McHale: So uh this so yeah, I my whole thing was that well, all the A-list celebrities are gonna use this as a vacation.
[2:39] Joel McHale: And the D-lists, um, we will step in and grab some of the attention.
[2:46] Al Malafronte: You say D-less.
[2:48] Joel McHale: Come on, you're not giving yourself enough credit, man. D plus.
[2:53] Al Malafronte: So let me ask you. I mean, you've been in the industry for like 25 years now. You're as great as it they come as far as hosts go.
[3:00] Al Malafronte: Was it challenging to shoot Card Sharks during the pandemic?
[3:04] Joel McHale: Uh well, it shut down. Uh, we were supposed to shoot it in February, and that's when shit got real.
[3:12] Joel McHale: And uh we literally had it, we literally like day before stopped.
[3:17] Joel McHale: And that was um, you know, frustrating, but necessary.
[3:23] Joel McHale: Um, and then we were one of the first shows to come back, which was really cool.
[3:27] Joel McHale: And um we had all so was that we had all these these zones, and now it's kind of just it's now industry practice, but back in July, uh, I don't know who came up with it, but there was all these zones, people weren't allowed to travel in and out, and we had a positive test, a COVID test, we thought.
[3:45] Joel McHale: Um, it turned out to be uh it was inconclusive, and then it was a negative.
[3:48] Joel McHale: But at the time it was like, oh shit, we have a positive test on set.
[3:53] Joel McHale: And Fremantle, the production company was uh they had already, you know, they they were like, we're not gonna shut down, we're gonna figure out how to deal with it.
[4:01] Joel McHale: And this is there was a great plan, and it worked.
[4:04] Joel McHale: They had the whole zone removed. They brought in the news, like the the I don't know what you would call the next squad uh to replace them.
[4:13] Joel McHale: They got contact traced and they found out it was a negative, but at the time, so we were it was like a three-hour delay, and then we were shooting again.
[4:20] Al Malafronte: Now, during the first season, you said how much joy it brings you to see folks win big money like that.
[4:25] Al Malafronte: Was it even more gratifying this season given the times we're in?
[4:29] Joel McHale: We chah. Well, also the rules slightly changed.
[4:33] Joel McHale: Uh, so it's a little bit easier to win more money.
[4:36] Joel McHale: And uh then we the people started winning so much more money that ABC was like, what's going on?
[4:43] Joel McHale: And uh they yeah, I don't know how happy they were, but it made they made a lot of people really happy.
[4:50] Joel McHale: And uh yeah, it's I don't, you know, like I don't have emotions anymore.
[4:55] Joel McHale: I barely get excited about anything.
[4:56] Joel McHale: But um when people are winning that kind of money, you can win up to 700,000.
[5:02] Joel McHale: People's lives are being changed, it's pretty incredible.
[5:05] Joel McHale: And then the heartbreaking like there was some dude he lost out on hundreds of thousands of just a turn of a card, and it was so I felt so bad for him.
[5:17] Joel McHale: Uh, and then I, you know, was like, all right, get the fuck out.
[5:20] Joel McHale: No, I didn't, but it was, yeah, and no, it's I really do.
[5:24] Joel McHale: It's such a simple game in the best way.
[5:26] Joel McHale: It's just turning cards over, and the money just gets higher and higher if you don't screw it up, or if it if the cards fall in your favor.
[5:35] Joel McHale: So uh yeah, it's very simple, but the stakes get really bananas.
[5:40] Al Malafronte: Now the guy who lost out on all that money, it wasn't sort of like a have you ever seen like with Deal or No Deal where these people have the opportunity to walk away with six figures, they yell, no deal, they lose all their money and they're still dancing with like the $50 that they walk away with.
[5:53] Al Malafronte: Not was it kind of like that situation?
[5:56] Joel McHale: No, that guy walked away with nothing.
[5:58] Joel McHale: Uh uh then, but yeah, there is an option, like you can double, you know, you keep doubling your money.
[6:07] Joel McHale: And um there is there is an option at one point to leave.
[6:11] Joel McHale: And a couple people did that, but that's not as fun as take, you know, risking it, but I understand.
[6:17] Joel McHale: Uh so they yeah, so a couple people did opt out, but it's fun.
[6:22] Joel McHale: They with the it's funny to see people like they're on TV, they're gambling, and a lot of people are like, fuck it, let's do it.
[6:29] Joel McHale: And uh it's great.
[6:31] Joel McHale: Uh, it's awesome.
[6:32] Joel McHale: I I think you did such a great job in the first season, and I can't wait for Sunday.
[6:36] Al Malafronte: Um, I mentioned in the intro, by the way, that you're a big Mariners fan, and I gotta give you props, you know.
[6:42] Al Malafronte: Uh, or I gotta give the Mariners props.
[6:44] Al Malafronte: They certainly performed a lot better than people expected this year, but this year actually marks the 25th anniversary of the team that saved baseball in Seattle.
[6:52] Al Malafronte: And you know, when you look back on it now, you know, Edgar Martinez and Griffey and Randy Johnson, what's the lasting memory for you?
[6:58] Joel McHale: Well, you know, the famous one on in the kingdom when they made it when they went, you know, ex went further in the playoffs, and they they all tackled uh and uh each other and Griffey was on the bottom smiling.
[7:11] Joel McHale: And um the city was going bananas, and because the Mariners had always they didn't, you know, like they just a few seasons later, after we lost Rodriguez and Griffey and Johnson, we won 116 games.
[7:24] Joel McHale: I think that was 2000, and um and then we of course got knocked out.
[7:30] Joel McHale: But I Seattle has always been there the I grew up in the Seattle before Microsoft Starbucks and Amazon, and uh, and it was when we had well, we actually had a professional basketball team, and our city was kind of this backwater, and it was you know, like big bands just would go from San Francisco to Vancouver and skip us.
[7:53] Joel McHale: Uh so we always were scrappy and we always fought, and our team, the only championship team we had was the Sonics and 7980, and they got sold, thanks Howard Schultz, and uh and um so we always we always kind of felt like the stepchild of our professional sports teams because we weren't that good.
[8:15] Joel McHale: We got close in the 80s with Dave Craig's Seahawks, I think we got one game away from the um Super Bowl.
[8:21] Joel McHale: But um people, you know, like East Coast sports gets all the attention always, and so no one paid attention to Seattle, and then when teams started doing well, it was so exciting, and the city it's the bet I think it's the one of the I mean I love LA, I really do, and they love their teams, and that's really cool.
[8:40] Joel McHale: And I feel bad for the Chargers.
[8:42] Joel McHale: Uh so uh, but um you know, Seattle really, I mean, our MLS games sell out, all of them, uh, when you could have an audience.
[8:52] Joel McHale: So um, so yeah, I just I have a lot, I'm really happy about hockey.
[8:57] Joel McHale: The name Kraken is problematic because it's how our my friends and I would always say we are about to go take a dump by releasing Kraken.
[9:05] Joel McHale: Uh, but you know, so anyway, it's a very long explanation.
[9:08] Joel McHale: And um it really, you know, I love that city.
[9:11] Joel McHale: I haven't lived there in 20 years, but I love it.
[9:13] Joel McHale: And I go back all the time.
[9:14] Joel McHale: We used to go back all the time.
[9:16] Joel McHale: Uh, but I, you know, it's a very long explanation to say that Seattle is uh should have a basketball team, greatest sports town.
[9:25] Joel McHale: And uh when I hear people from Boston and New York say they're the greatest sports town, just like whatever.
[9:31] Al Malafronte: Now, do you hate the New York teams?
[9:32] Joel McHale: You know, it's like the Yankees and Mets or the Jets and Giants, because I know you love football too.
[9:36] Joel McHale: Like, is there you know, because in Boston, you can't mention the Yankees.
[9:40] Joel McHale: In, you know, in in certain parts of California, you know, if you're up north, you can't mention the Dodgers if you know you're around Giants fans.
[9:47] Joel McHale: So is there hatred for the Yankees?
[9:49] Joel McHale: I know about the Dodgers, but all those other teams you just mentioned, I've never heard of.
[9:52] Joel McHale: What cities are they in?
[9:55] Joel McHale: Who the new the the flushing Mets, I think they're called.
[9:58] Joel McHale: Don't even know who you're talking about.
[10:00] Joel McHale: Uh no, uh boy, no, I hate all other sports teams, of course, uh, except for the ones that I love.
[10:06] Joel McHale: And uh no, it's funny.
[10:10] Joel McHale: I don't, I don't, I I did go to a Yankees game in the late 90s and I wore a Mariners hat before playing the Mariners.
[10:18] Joel McHale: And uh that was my first experience with uh I was like, oh, these are New York fans.
[10:23] Joel McHale: Now I now I understand.
[10:26] Joel McHale: Uh and yeah, I boy, I I don't it's so cool that we live in a country where we can you know root for teams we love.
[10:35] Joel McHale: That's cool, and I love that.
[10:37] Joel McHale: And you know, like when Tom Brady was dominating with the Patriots, people are like, I hate the Patriots.
[10:43] Joel McHale: And it's like you you hate them because they're they're terrific.
[10:47] Joel McHale: And Tom Brady has ice water flowing through his veins.
[10:50] Joel McHale: And so whenever whenever people are like, Don't you hate them?
[10:54] Joel McHale: I'm like, I don't really hate them.
[10:55] Joel McHale: I'm glad we're all playing.
[10:56] Joel McHale: I hate it when guys get injured in during games that are doing well, and then the other team wins.
[11:01] Joel McHale: That's why I'm just like, well, you got the win, but it's not as cool because the guy who was kicking your ass is out.
[11:07] Joel McHale: So um, so yeah, so anyway, I in conclusion, I I watch a lot of sports.
[11:15] Joel McHale: Uh I love the bubble, the basketball was great.
[11:18] Joel McHale: I mean, it was yeah, so I it really sports has been a great way to distract for the pandemic.
[11:23] Joel McHale: Uh so I don't I don't know about college football coming back, but you know, hopefully no one gets no one's getting paid there.
[11:29] Joel McHale: This the guys don't get paid, and they're like, we don't get COVID, but good luck.
[11:33] Joel McHale: So uh yeah, I that that's my yeah, I I can talk about this all day long.
[11:38] Al Malafronte: Yeah, I I know you're such a big fan, so I have to ask you, I know you've accomplished a lot in your career, but a few years ago, the Mariners asked you to throw out the first pitch.
[11:45] Joel McHale: How much pressure are you feeling going to the stadium that day?
[11:49] Joel McHale: Well, I've done it twice for them.
[11:52] Joel McHale: Uh yeah, how do you like that?
[11:53] Joel McHale: Um that's a big deal.
[11:55] Joel McHale: A lot of you do it.
[11:59] Joel McHale: Um, I was a baseball pitcher in uh junior high and one year of high school, uh, or I was on the team, so I can puck it pretty hard.
[12:11] Joel McHale: Um remember Keith Oberman?
[12:14] Joel McHale: The uh yeah, so Keith Oberman taught me he was like, Here's how you throw bait, you know, in these situations.
[12:19] Joel McHale: He goes, just aim it about three feet above the catcher's head because you're on the mound, and you don't want to be that guy that's in front of the mound.
[12:27] Joel McHale: Uh you can't if you're a kid or someone who doesn't know how to throw anything, but um but he was right.
[12:32] Joel McHale: And so I've done that every time, and only one of my first pitches has gone awry.
[12:37] Joel McHale: And that was at a White Sox game because I threw it harder than I was like, I'm gonna freaking throw this thing, and it was not a great throw.
[12:44] Joel McHale: Uh, but uh so it I've been very lucky in that when you aim about I was I'm just staring three feet above their head, and that thing just freaking sinks in there.
[12:53] Joel McHale: And so I got very lucky.
[12:55] Joel McHale: I've been very lucky.
[12:56] Joel McHale: So you but yes, the pressure is ridiculous.
[13:00] Joel McHale: And and you when you stand on that mound, you're like, oh, what a dream it would be to be a major league baseball player.
[13:07] Joel McHale: You see Fauci's first uh first pitch.
[13:10] Joel McHale: That was really bad.
[13:13] Joel McHale: I was gonna say he couldn't do worse than that, but he's obviously got some uh pretty pretty big fish to fry right now.
[13:18] Joel McHale: Um yeah, if that's yeah, I know that Trump made fun of him guaranteed Trump couldn't probably get it across the plate, so I don't even care what your political affiliation is, but uh you can't you can't make fun of a thing that you can't do too.
[13:33] Al Malafronte: Right.
[13:33] Joel McHale: Absolutely.
[13:35] Joel McHale: Now uh you mentioned your athletic background, and I know in the past you've spoken a little bit about uh how school was a little bit of a struggle for you when it came to the academics, but you were a top-notch athlete.
[13:45] Joel McHale: Was there something about sports that you know made you find solace or provided some sort of distraction while you were growing up?
[13:51] Joel McHale: And I mean, because obviously you really crush it.
[13:53] Joel McHale: You went on to University of Washington to play football there.
[13:56] Joel McHale: Well, I was a walk-on, so I wasn't like, you know, I wasn't recruited.
[13:59] Joel McHale: I didn't play football in high school, so other than one year.
[14:02] Joel McHale: So that was kind of it was a very strange convoluted way for me to get on the team.
[14:06] Joel McHale: But um I yeah, no, I love sports. Uh I love playing them, and I think yeah being dyslexic and eight you know like undiagnosed and ADHD and distracted and terrible grades and terrible speller uh sports was a thing I could do and I I would do I mean I would play basketball until four in the morning and I I would I would it was it was all I yeah it was where I got confidence and I was very lucky in in that way and um yeah no I I was really bad I was so I was a very good I played so many different sports that I never really got good at one that's how I like to look at it and of all things I got recruited to be a rower uh in college and uh Harvard look saw that I was pretty fast and I they looked at me and then they saw my grades and they were like no never uh so um but then I left rowing because those guys were assholes and um I had a bunch of football player friends in college and they're like you should come out for football okay and that was that was wonderful two years of my life it really was I love I'll I I look back on it very fondly and I I it was so great.
It was so fun I got very lucky because I didn't break you know anything or break a knee open or anything like that. So I got I came out unscathed uh um other than you know getting hit in the head all the time but other than that I'm I can barely remember anything. Well it helps when you're six four in college.
[15:47] Al Malafronte: I'm sure that goes a long way too.
[15:49] Joel McHale: It does. It does if you're end that's the truth. And now let me ask you this. Jockey Joel McHale, how does he catch the acting bug while he's in college?
[16:00] Joel McHale: I caught the acting bug in second grade. That's the only thing I ever wanted to do was act and play sports. I probably should have gone into professional wrestling. And uh so yeah, that's all I ever wanted to do. And then I did a play in fifth grade, I did a play in seventh grade. I made a decision in seventh grade that this is what I was gonna do with my life. I was like, this is the one for me, God. And I did plays throughout high school, and I probably should have never gone to regular college. I probably because I knew what I wanted to do when I was constantly involved in theater and and comedy, and I did a bit a lot of improvising in Seattle, a lot of plays, and um, you know, I got so so I was so I've always had the buck.
I I in fact in college is when I was doing a lot of other things other than acting, because I was so focused on sports and and screwing around. So uh then I really focused and really got back into it. So uh yeah, so it's one of these things where I'm gonna do this until the bad acting police arrest me. Take me away.
[17:09] Al Malafronte: Now you said that you were acting during school. Were you doing musicals as well?
[17:13] Joel McHale: I did. Oh yeah, singing and dancing. Uh I did, yeah, I did a bunch in high school. Uh I really enjoyed that. And I never thought it's funny, like I never wanted to go to Broadway or anything like that. I didn't have that bug. I really just wanted to be on, I mean, like I want to be, I wanted to act on TV. And uh I and people like, oh, how dare you? I but I, you know, I love Broadway and plays and stuff like that, and I would do them now, but um, I don't know if they'd have me. But uh yeah, I musicals are really fun, they're really fun to do. I and I haven't done one in years, but I it's funny, like when I would do them in high school in college, they'd be like, you know, you guys just do this as much as you can because you know, when you get to the real world, you're not gonna be able to, you know, especially entertainment.
It's like this is not really gonna happen. You're not gonna do a lot of these things. And the first big gig that I got in uh LA, or the when I got this huge commercial uh for a Super Bowl commercial where I'm dancing the entire time. And so that was uh really fun. And I was like, I'm doing the thing. I took dance lessons for a while, so uh I'm not a good dancer, but I can you show me the moves, I can remember them and kind of pull it off somewhat. I think it did a pretty good job. I think it was maybe I think it was 10 years ago. You did that Emmys opening with Fallon and Corey Monty, like the born to run. That was pretty awesome.
[18:36] Joel McHale: Good memory. Shees. Uh yeah, we were full on dancing. Um, and I totally fucked that dance up when we got on the live stage. And I looked at Jane Lynch and she was like, I did too.
[18:45] Al Malafronte: I'm like, now let me ask you, you know, you mentioned the dyslexia earlier. And you know, when you're embarking on the Hollywood career, uh, with everything that you've had to deal with as far as that dyslexia goes, is it like always in the back of your mind when you're reading for these parts, or how do you not let the moment get too big?
[19:04] Joel McHale: Oh, uh well, for when I'm reading for a role, I pr I just memorize it. Uh I'm I became especially, you know, my uh my memorization skills, they for every actor go up when you're on a show where you're constantly memorizing 40 to 60 pages a week. Um and so I got very I'm very I'm pretty good at it, especially it's weird when the writing is good and flows like regular talking dialogue, uh it's so easy for me, it's easy to memorize. And so I usually just get off book. And uh so uh, but when it came to teleprompter, watch out. I didn't know what the fuck to do. Uh so the soup, we would take, you know, when the soup started back in 2005, uh it would take me like three and a half hours, four hours to finally get through 22 minutes of dialogue, you know, 22 minutes of teleprompter.
And I thought, oh, I see, I didn't get never was really diagnosed. They just told they literally told me I was a slow starter, which is not a scientific term. Uh and so yeah, then my sons got diagnosed with it, and I was like, hey, you're describing all my symptoms, uh like what I do. And they're like, Yeah, well, we were which we're just trying to figure out what you we knew it was one of you because that's how it's passed down. Uh so it here's the thing, it took me a long time. So I had a lot of anxiety, and so I would get really, I would I would look at these scripts like freaking like so much. I would practice them. So when I finally got on camera, I could figure out how to make sure that I like there's certain words to get through, but I would you guys didn't see it very much, but I would fuck up the script all the time, and I would just have to compensate by correcting myself.
So uh I there was some takes that I would just be so I got to the point where I'm like, just let I'm just gonna screw it up and let's just keep that. Uh but when it would come to the pressure of something like, excuse me, uh something like when I would host the when I hosted the SBS that was like eight minutes of jokes. And you know, you're in there, my computer's dying. Uh you're in there, and that's when I had to be, I had to be like, take your time. Don't, you know, these words, you know these jokes. And uh it's funny when I would screw up a joke, it became more endearing uh to the audience. They're like, oh, look at him. It's okay. Uh so I yeah, that's why I think the soup ended up working, is because I the under the guise of keeping everything casual, it allowed me to screw up. That was a really long explanation.
[21:59] Al Malafronte: No, I think I very well said. Um, I know you're a Seattle kid through and through. Life obviously changes a lot after the soup. Are you comfortable with fame? Are you comfortable with the Hollywood lifestyle, or did it take some time to adjust to that?
[22:11] Joel McHale: The Hollywood lifestyle, yeah. Look at it all the time. Uh there is there is why is my uh I I uh my I hate my sometimes I love my Apple Watch, but sometimes I fucking hate the sounds. Do you work for Apple Watch? Is that was that a plug right there that you did, Joel? Apple Watch brought to you by Squadcast. Uh so uh what am I saying? What was the question?
[22:39] Al Malafronte: So I was just asking, you know, being a Seattle kid, are you, you know, once the soup happens, obviously life changes and you're comfortable with the fame.
[22:47] Joel McHale: Yeah, I mean, but my level of fame is not, you know, I've uh I'm trying to think of like I've been around people that are insanely famous, and that is that I they're they they can't really go out. Um they can go out, but they're followed everywhere. It's bananas, and they need to have fences up around their homes. So uh so I don't I never experienced that level of fame. I definitely in Seattle, I mean there was a time in Seattle, yes, I would be recognized a lot. It's not as much, you know, when you're on TV, you get recognized a lot. When you're not on TV, it's it drops off as quick. But now, like, since I've been on The Masked Singer and a couple other shows, or like Tiger King alone, I was like, oh, that's what it feels like.
So um, what am I saying? Um, no, but I you know, like, I don't ever want to go back. I like it. And when I see a celebrities that are, I mean, I understand some people are introverts, and that that's and when they talk about them, it's a bummer for them. I I I kind of understand, but if you're so if you're recognized for something you do well, I mean, I'm too bad, I guess, but you congrats. It's a met it's a certain measure of what you're doing. Obviously, if you're a serial killer, it's a bad reason to be famous. But um, but so no, I I don't I don't mind it. I don't think about it. I don't when I go out, I don't, it's not like I'm like, oh boy, I better make sure I look good and you know, and all that. I don't do any, yeah. That that though that I I think people imagine that stuff, and um, yeah, I don't know. It's uh yeah, so I I don't ever want everyone to go back.
[24:31] Al Malafronte: Yeah, yeah. And and I I like the I when I hear people go like, isn't it about who you know? I'm like, I'm like, yeah, every business is that way. You end up knowing people in your business. Like lawyers know, lawyers and surgeons know surgeons and actors and performers know each other. So when people are like, you go to these Hollywood parties, I'm like, with people that work in Hollywood, yes, that's usually how it works. Uh yeah, I don't go to the trying to think, I don't know, like uh like sailboat, you know, rear rigors on sailboats, they have their own parties probably, and everyone knows each other. So anyway, that's my long explanation. Again, cheers.
[25:10] Joel McHale: Cheers to that.
[25:12] Al Malafronte: What are you drinking over there today, Joel?
[25:14] Joel McHale: Well, we got some soda stream going.
[25:17] Al Malafronte: Oh, okay. I raise you with uh water in a nice Yeti, you know, real quick.
[25:22] Joel McHale: Yeah, thank God that thank God you have like a bulletproof cup because you don't wouldn't want that thing to get punctured during the thing. You just never know.
[25:30] Al Malafronte: I know I'm more worried about the uh I have a you know, I live in a studio apartment, you don't have that much room for stuff. I have like a Keurig like right next to the laptop. A little more little nervous about that, but uh the Yeti, nothing's getting through this thing.
[25:44] Joel McHale: Very good problem to have. Now I do want to mention community, obviously, one of my favorite shows. Um you hinted recently that you'd be open to possibly doing a revival. Do you see that revival include including Chevy Chase?
[26:00] Joel McHale: We did not hint at that at all. That is a thing that the cast said they would do uh when we did that uh live read. I don't know. I um Chevy left the show pretty unceremoniously. So uh, and then, you know, we had people like Jonathan Banks and um Padgett Brewster and uh Keith David uh come in and really bring the house down. Uh so I don't know. I don't, I don't I really don't know about that. But it was it, you know, it ended pretty crazily uh with him. So I don't, I don't I can't, I I would be surprised. Uh but stranger things.
[26:41] Al Malafronte: You guys always seem to have a pretty good relationship though.
[26:45] Joel McHale: Uh yeah, no, we I mean he he's Chevy is Chevy, and he is can be pretty tough on set. And so uh, you know, we learn we all learn to work together. Uh, but um, you know, he even said it in a thousand different articles that he didn't like the hours, and he always said he couldn't memorize he said, like, I can't memorize the lines because they're not funny enough. And uh he would say stuff like that. I mean, that's a joking thing he said, but um he really didn't want to be there as far as time was concerned, so that did manifest itself on set.
[27:20] Al Malafronte: Now, was it challenging in any way when you had to portray him in uh a feudal and stupid gesture?
[27:26] Joel McHale: Well, it did help that I knew him, and I called him in advance to warn him that I'm like, I'm gonna play you in a movie. And uh, but he was happy because it's about the about the life of Doug Kenny, who is a was a kind of like the Hamilton of comedy in the 70s, where people didn't realize what he accomplished, and then he died. And uh so he uh Chevy was very close with him and was very happy that he got his due. So I you know, there's a big so I memory, I memorize, you know, I didn't memorize, but I watched endless hours of young Chevy Chase, and uh I mean endless. And I I made sure that it was a young Chevy, and uh and I'll say, like, he was really fun to play.
[28:14] Joel McHale: He was the most confident person on the planet in the 70s and 80s. And that's a fun sort of way to play a character and to be like, I'm the king of the universe. And so that was really fun. And I also mimicked his voice. I was like, he has a surprisingly deep voice. And I had to kind of, uh, I well, I would scream in my trailer to lower my voice. Uh, so it was all raspy. So that it was really fun to play. And, um, it was really, I mean, David Wayne is a great director, so that was great. And Will Forte was knocked out of the park. And so yeah, it was really fun. It was a really fun movie to make. I don't know if anybody saw it, but, uh, but I it was a really fun movie to make. And I certainly enjoyed it.
And I thought your portrayal of him was pretty spot on. It like captured that essence of like the Chevy Chase, uh, like Caddyshack era, like better than anything I've ever seen. Because that's a really challenging guy to try to capture. So my two cents, I really enjoyed that one. Yes, people kept telling me, they're like, don't fuck this up. Not to now let me ask you, you know, you hinted earlier that you know you might be open to doing Broadway one day. Is there like a dream role that you'd either like to create or a role that you'd like to walk into? My Fair Lady, probably maybe her. No, uh, I don't Broadway's not gonna have me. Uh, there I there are way the skill level that it takes, and the development of that skill level is pretty, uh, difficult bar to you know, jump over.
Uh, I would do a play there in a heartbeat. I'd love to do that. Uh, no, I would, I would, you know, it's one of those things like there's not a dream, I don't know, you know, like I'm like play Stanley Kowalski from Street Carnium Desire. I would do that. Uh, no, but, uh, but there's nothing boy trying to think of a role that would just oh there was a play called Fuddy Mirr. Um, way back when in the 90s that I think should be brought back. It was it was an entire play was with a made-up language between these siblings that live that never got out, and it's all kind of English, and it's freaking hilarious. So I'll do that. Futter mirrors. Nice. Now, uh Joel, one thing that we do to wrap every show is a little segment called Fastball Derby. I'd like to do it.
[30:41] Joel McHale: All right. So I'm gonna ask you a question. You say the first thing that comes to your head. Bananas.
[30:48] Al Malafronte: All right. That could actually be the answer to the first question, which was favorite New York City meal. Was it bananas? Is that your answer?
[30:55] Joel McHale: Ooh, favorite New York City meal. Well, that's a very qualified because there's so many different meals. Um, I mean, there's so many different places. I mean, the different levels of, uh, like favorite coffee and favorite pizza. I'll say like kind of favorite high-end, like favorite steakhouse. I got to go to that uh coat C O T E, I think it's a ja uh Korean steakhouse. That was that was amazing. Uh and then Upland is one of my favorite restaurants in um in New York, which if a guy from Upland, California, which is ironic because Upland is not necessarily the greatest. Uh it's it's not it they it they it makes fun of itself, it's so ugly. And um, I mean, like Dominique Ansel's bakery, going there for a croissant, not even for a cronut is one of my favorite things to do.
Um let's see, boy. Uh I don't let's uh uh boy, yeah. Okay, well, I'll say uh I'll say I mean I had great sushi there. I yeah, let's just go with Upland. Upland's great baseball question Bonds and Clemens, do you put them in the Hall of Fame?
[32:12] Joel McHale: Uh um I don't know. I mean, if it there's so many guys that were, you know, doing stuff uh to enhance themselves. Um boy, I'll need to think about that. I mean, hmm. Yeah, I mean, I I don't know. I but look, I think that I think the Astros barely got a slap on the wrist for what they did, and then you know, Pete Rose still can't get in the hall of fame, and an entire team was cheating, and that the response that the fact that they weren't really punished at all was crazy. Uh so boy, hmm. I don't know. I'm gonna have to really think I never thought I guess you know, my first instinct is saying no, but then the other instance is like no, everyone was doing it, and most like I mean, I exceed I guess Griffey wasn't, and uh, so yeah. Boy, yeah, okay, so no.
[33:22] Joel McHale: I like that you bring that up because you know, I'm an I'm a Yankee fan. Derek Jeter even said, you know, people like to say that it's a steroid era, everyone was doing it. Everyone was not doing it. There were a lot of guys who went out there and did it the right way, like a Griffey, like a Jeter or Chipper Jones, you know, guys like that. You know what? Yeah, I mean, I you know what? Ultimately, yeah, then there shouldn't, they shouldn't. Everyone should be playing by the same rules. And I get that people are doing everything they can and they're in desperate situations, but a bunch of millionaires. Uh, yeah. Cheating, yeah, probably shouldn't go. No, I I did steroids for certain acting jobs, so I should be banned.
[34:00] Al Malafronte: Oh, really? Which role?
[34:01] Joel McHale: Not Jeff Wanger. No, no, for Chevy. Chevy Chase. I had to bulk up. So yeah, no, for Spider-Man too. I had to really, yeah. So anyway, um trying to think. Yeah, anyway, that was a good question. Thanks. All-time favorite film.
[34:18] Joel McHale: Okay, that's gotta, it's gotta be categories. I can't just go, well, sorry, comedy or sorry drama. Uh I can give you uh Doctor Strangelove is one of my favorites. Um Back to the Future is one of my favorites. The Holy Grail is one of my favorites. Uh yeah, I love do the right thing. All right, uh, yeah, all over the map as far as like there's genres, and I think Green Room is one of the best movies ever made. Um boy, there's yeah, I there's oh man. Um but yeah, there's a lot. There's a lot. That's good. Between the restaurants and the films, you gave our audience a whole bunch of great options that they can check out. You know, some of some of the we could keep supporting the New York City restaurants because Joel gave you like 10, and he gave you 10 films to watch, you know, during the pandemic. So that's pretty good.
[35:16] Joel McHale: Yeah. Well, I mean, you know, The Godfather is a masterpiece that I can't get enough of. And Requiem for a Dream is a crazy wonderful movie. And um, I love the thin red line. I think uh, and I think um, I guess uh full metal jacket is also in my top three, and one of the greatest endings to a movie of all time. Yeah. How about this one? Most embarrassing onset moment.
[35:52] Joel McHale: Um, oh yeah, in um in uh community when I had to be naked playing pool and I had to lean over my everyone is behind me. I'm wearing what's called a dance belt, which is basically just a thong. I've got a bunch of I've got body makeup on, but everything is exposed. And my butthole is barely covered, and my balls are basically and I had to lean over this table and then lift my leg up. And everybody saw that shit. So that's so it's like I did it and I was happy to do it, but I'm like, oh, this is the most exposed you have ever been on camera. So but like I don't I don't I'm trying to think of the time like, well, I ship my pants, and uh that hasn't happened yet. Insurance to come if I get to do this later later in my life, so um trying to think of an embarrassing. Yeah, that's probably it.
[36:53] Joel McHale: All right, you're on a desert island. Which Broadway cast album are you taking with you?
[37:00] Joel McHale: I will figure that uh maybe you have like one of those. Maybe you have like a stereo that you know just has requires like triple A batteries or something like that. And you could bring the actual C D with you. How many batteries am I have? Uh let's say you're gonna be there. Let's say you're gonna be there for well, quarantine's been like six months, seven months now. So uh let's say you're gonna be there for like you know half a year, you know. You're and you're gonna have 40 batteries, which will get you through that amount of time.
[37:27] Joel McHale: Did I break or was some was I did someone put me there? What's going on? You're not there by choice, but you want to make the most of it. So you really want to find like a good Broadway cast album that's gonna keep your spirits up because you're pissed to be there.
[37:43] Joel McHale: I want to know who put me on this island and how many batteries I'm getting and how I'm going to eat and drink. Well, Gillian Jacobs, let's say she put you there. Um, what you're gonna eat, we're gonna have the power to put me on a desert island. I don't know. Brita certainly had a lot of power over Jeff and community, so I think she's got some something working there. Uh either uh the Book of Mormon or Hamilton.
[38:12] Joel McHale: Proudest moment of your career. Uh that's hard. I mean, there's like moments where I'm like, oh my gosh, I can't believe this is happening. Like when I hosted the White House Correspondence Dinner, or um the first time I, you know, was on Letterman, or you know, like I grew up, you know, and then Conan was all on in the 90s, so I watched Conan. That was, you know, going in his show was very surreal. Uh getting to do a bit like go going on Kimmel and be doing a bit with Matt Damon and being in a movie with Matt Damon, that was thrilling. Uh so and then you know, like laughs on the soup, like certain times on the soup, and I'm like, that was a great joke that I got to tell on television. So that was super fun.
But boy, there's not like this like I got to do a movie with Robin Williams, which was wonderful. It wasn't a great movie, but um it was a really fun month, and I got to hang out with him, and that was just cool. Uh I want being on Sesame Street, that was a huge highlight. So yeah, I mean, there's been I got it's been I got to have all these these cool cool things, and so I count myself as you know, just incredibly blessed that I got to do them. So um yeah, that's like when I got to star in a movie, I just I did I've done a couple, like I did this movie called Happily, which was never really has not been released that I'm very proud of, and and uh so hopefully that will come out, you know. And even with community, I was like every I I swear I would walk in and be like, I cannot believe I'm in a show that's this good. And that's me bragging about the show that I'm on, but I was like, this writing is fucking great, and I knew it was great while we were doing it. So yeah, that's a long answer again.
[40:03] Joel McHale: There you go. All right, lastly, Joel, what's the best piece of advice anyone ever gave you?
[40:11] Joel McHale: Uh I don't know. Uh fuck shit up. Uh yeah. Uh no, I I think it was learning how to uh just work learning a work ethic. And I learned that pretty much in football. And uh just uh for me it's like and it's it's probably too American because I don't relax. Uh, but it was just like, oh, you need if you want to do anything, you need to work hard. Sounds so dumb, but I knew so many actors that were better than me that didn't put in the time and gave up. And I think one of the reasons why I have continued to get jobs is because I am unrelenting. So uh just work hard. That's because it's where you learn who you are and all that while you're in the valleys, while you're while you're work, where you're doing the work to get to the you know the top of the mountain.
[41:14] Al Malafronte: Thank you. Uh thank you, Joel. This was awesome. Uh I seriously.
[41:17] Joel McHale: No, no, I'm just saying yeah.
[41:20] Al Malafronte: No, thank you for having such a pleasure.
[41:23] Al Malafronte: All right, folks. Very much appreciate you listening tonight. Uh, this is Al Malafronte signing off for the Broadway Podcast Network. We'll see you next time.
[41:32] Al Malafronte: Thanks for listening to Break a Bat. This is produced by the fine folks at the Broadway Podcast Network. Visit and subscribe at BPN.fm slash breakabat. You can find me online at break underscore a underscore bat underscore podcast. And you can also find the Broadway Podcast Network on Instagram at Broadway Podcast Network. It's been so great having you here with us today, and we'll see you next time.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
