Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#94 - Now Batting: Danny Tartabull

Battles with Roger Clemens paralleled to Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr dueling in Weehawken? That’s what happens when Danny Tartabull steps into The Batter’s Box!.. Read More

From the show: Break A Bat! where Baseball Meets Broadway

43 mins
7/28/21

Featured Shows

About

Battles with Roger Clemens paralleled to Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr dueling in Weehawken? That’s what happens when Danny Tartabull steps into The Batter’s Box! While “The Bull” has largely been out of the public eye since retiring from baseball in 1997, his legacy as one of the best right-handed hitters of the early '90s remains as vital as ever. Over the course of 14 big league seasons, he was selected to an All-Star Game, won a Slugging Percentage title, and knocked in 100+ runs five times. He also had a very memorable tenure as a member of the New York Yankees from 1992-1995. This week, he joins host Al Malafronte for an impartial conversation to set the record straight on his time here and revisit the highs and lows that came with playing on baseball’s biggest stage.

Tartabull’s accomplishments as a Yankee were as strong as anyone’s on a rebuilding team, having posted the squad’s first .400 On-Base Percentage of the decade when the organization began to shift focus under legendary General Manager, Gene Michael. In 1993 he took his performance to the next level, posting the first 30 Homerun/100 RBI season by a Yankee in five years, leading the team in both said categories, as well as Runs Scored and Total Bases. However, his big contract was often a point of contention for owner George Steinbrenner, and the two clashed quite a bit as Tartabull explains. Whether it was landing on the field in a helicopter, threatening to move the team to New Jersey, or ripping Tartabull through the media, The Boss’ theatrics were certainly well-publicized and created quite the backstage dynamic. Tartabull tells it all and then some, as it was fascinating to get such an in-depth look at a truly pivotal chapter in Yankee history from a star player’s perspective.

This is Tartabull's ultimate tell-all interview, and our chat will certainly satisfy not only the most passionate members of Yankees Universe, but all of the theatre fans in our audience as well. Tartabull loved his nights on Broadway and caught nearly every show that ran in the early and mid ’90s. Whether it be Rent or Les Misérables, Tartabull had a front-row seat to the Broadway revolution and has some awesome stories to go along with it. He’s also a bit of an actor in his own right, having guest-starred on Seinfeld twice at the request of the show’s creator and lifelong Yankee fan, Larry David! His behind-the-scenes memories of working alongside David, Jerry Seinfeld, and Jason Alexander were great to listen to and provided some big laughs!

Connect with Break a Bat! on Instagram: @break_a_bat_podcast

Hosted by Al Malafronte

Produced by the Broadway Podcast Network

Edited by Matthew Hendershot

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:08] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to the Break a Bat Podcast, where baseball meets Broadway, an attempt to show that my two favorite mediums don't have to live in such separate worlds and maybe even break some stigmas.

[0:20] Al Malafronte: We're happy to have you with us. Now let's play ball.

[0:27] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to Break a Bat, where baseball meets Broadway and sports meets show business. I'm your host, Al Malafronte, coming at you for the Broadway Podcast Network. Tonight's gonna be some show, as we're lucky enough to welcome someone who I consider to be one of the coolest and best Yankees of the early 1990s.

[0:46] Al Malafronte: I think in many ways, my guest tonight was a key cog in helping build the foundation for what became the Joe Torre dynasty, and did so at a time where a once proud Broadway production needed it most. He embodied the new mentality that the organization began to shift to as far as when they brought him over here to the Bronx Bombers, someone you could count on to get on base and hit the big home run when you needed it.

[1:09] Al Malafronte: He actually recorded the team's first .400 on-base percentage of the decade in 1992, and in 1993, he recorded the first 30 home run/100 RBI season for the team since 1987. In addition to all of his prowess as a big-time hitter, it's safe to say this is one of the coolest guys to ever don the pinstripes, like I said before, and cool to the point that he was asked to appear on Seinfeld, not once, but twice alongside George Costanza, a former Major League All-Star, slugging percentage champion, and the proud owner of 262 career home runs.

[1:43] Al Malafronte: If you'll please turn your attention to home plate, just beyond the marquee. Now batting, the Bull, Danny Tartabull.

[1:52] Danny Tartabull: Well, thank you so much. You're too kind, man. You're really pumping me up real good right now. But I really appreciate it. And I'm glad to be here on your podcast, man.

[2:03] Al Malafronte: Danny, I'm so happy you're here too. I'm not sure if you knew this, but you have more home runs than any right-handed hitter who's ever stepped onto Break a Bat. So I think our podcast lineup just got a whole lot better with you being here, man.

[2:16] Danny Tartabull: Hey, glad to be part of it, man. If I'm part of the team, then I own it. I'm glad to be here.

[2:21] Al Malafronte: Heck yeah, man. How's everything? Where are you joining us from tonight?

[2:25] Danny Tartabull: California. I'm in Los Angeles. And we've been out here, you know, 20 something odd years. And yeah, it's, you know, I miss going back to the East Coast to New York. My family lives out in Florida, so I wanted to make it a point this year at some point to make it back to New York and hopefully catch a playoff game.

[2:48] Al Malafronte: Danny, be it the old stadium or the new stadium, when's the last time you stepped foot in the Bronx?

[2:54] Danny Tartabull: Never been to the new stadium. You know, obviously the last time I stepped on in City was the old stadium, and that's all gone now. But I hear that it's absolutely beautiful. I've heard it's different than the old stadium. Of course, it doesn't have the characteristics of the old stadium, but nonetheless, it's still a beautiful stadium.

[3:10] Al Malafronte: But you're still paying attention to the Yankees. You and I were talking a little before the show.

[3:15] Danny Tartabull: I certainly do, and sometimes I have to go get the Pepsi or something like that, because I gotta tell you, man, it's tough to see sometimes. But yes, I do. When I'm watching a game, it's usually a Yankee game.

[3:26] Al Malafronte: Now, have you kept up with a lot of your Yankee teammates from when you played here?

[3:31] Danny Tartabull: I spoke to Bernie Williams. He's the last one I spoke to, but it was a long time ago. I haven't had a chance to speak to anybody else. I've been kind of in my own thing, doing my own thing out here in LA with my own business, and so I haven't had a lot of time to catch up with the guys, but I hope to.

[3:51] Al Malafronte: Well, good for you. What type of business are you in?

[3:55] Danny Tartabull: What I do is I broker all kinds of commodity deals, whether it be rice or flour, but in large amounts, large companies, and I put the buyers and the sellers together and broker the deal. Semi-precious stones, things of that nature, just constantly doing it. I'm in the sales business, so I'm always constantly moving around and doing it, not only here, but doing it even before the pandemic, doing it internationally as well.

[4:23] Al Malafronte: Wow, good for you, man. So when you retired, you didn't want to stay in baseball; you wanted to distance yourself from it a bit, I'm guessing.

[4:30] Danny Tartabull: You know what? The kids were small, so I got into the whole thing about, you know, the kids were first, and I wanted to be around them since I had not been around them a lot during my career. And so I needed to do something that would allow me to stay nearby then. My youngest one graduated from Cal Berkeley just a couple of years ago. So I decided to go into the world of sales, and that's what I've been doing.

[4:56] Al Malafronte: Congratulations, man. And especially to your youngest who just graduated. That's such a good idea.

[5:01] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, I'm looking to kind of get back into baseball, to be honest with you, because of the fact that, you know, we're empty nesters now, so they're not around as much. My wife and I can move around a little bit more. So I'm looking to possibly get back into baseball. So we'll see how that goes.

[5:21] Danny Tartabull: More so from the front office side than on the field. I don't think I could take the field too much or watch a guy play a shift on the other side of the base and you not being able to hit the ball to left field or right field. I couldn't handle that. But from the front office side, I'd probably be interested.

[5:38] Al Malafronte: You know what's interesting? When the Yankees brought you over here in the early 90s, a large part of it was due to that whole new wave of analytics that, and I'm not talking about the stuff on fan graphs. I'm talking about the high on-base percentage guy, the guy who could bop the ball out of the ballpark. In some ways, I think that someone like you kind of paved the way for that whole mentality that the Yankees had going into the late 90s, trying to bring in guys like that, like a Chili Davis and, you know, Paul O'Neill right after you got here.

[6:10] Danny Tartabull: Exactly. It's pretty interesting because you kind of saw it from the ground up. You know, to me, I've always been that guy that, you know, I always wanted to check in all the boxes. Try to check in all the boxes. Obviously, you can't do it every year all the time, but the whole analytic world, I mean, there's good to it, and then there's stuff that I just don't agree with.

[6:32] Danny Tartabull: I can't have a guy hitting .198 with 25 home runs and 60 RBIs and think that he's gonna be my starting player. But there are organizations that will be okay with that. I mean, when I played, you couldn't do it. You just tried to check in all the boxes and try to be as solid as you possibly can.

[6:50] Al Malafronte: Now, you were coming off your best season in '91 when the Yankees pursued you as a free agent. You had that high slugging percentage that we love to see; you hit over .300, which is kind of a lost art nowadays. What were those negotiations like? Do you feel like you had a lot of leverage? And was there something about New York that made you want to come play here?

[7:09] Danny Tartabull: I've been, to be honest with you, I was a closet Yankee fan all my life. I mean, I grew up in Miami, Florida. The only games that you see in Miami are generally just Yankee games. I grew up, you know, watching Reggie and Thurman Munson; those were the guys that I watched. And my father being a Red Sox fan, I really wanted to be a Yankee then because I wanted to make sure I wanted to stick it to him. You know what I mean? And I still do even today.

[7:34] Danny Tartabull: But the negotiation parts were tough because when you're dealing with Steinbrenner, it's no joke. I was very, very lucky to have a very good team behind me to negotiate. But it wasn't easy. It wasn't easy at all because obviously, a player wants a certain amount; the team wants a certain amount. Once we got together and decided that we were in agreement, I mean, it was heaven. I mean, to me, it was perfect for me because, again, I wanted to be a Yankee all my life. My dad is my hero, but he's a Red Sox fan. I didn't want to be a Red Sox. So I said, I'm gonna be a Yankee.

[8:13] Al Malafronte: I love that, man. And you know, when you got here, the team was so awful, so the fact that you prioritized your rivalry with your dad over the best interest of winning, I give you a lot of props on that front.

[8:25] Danny Tartabull: You know, we had a lot of good players on the team. Paul O'Neill was on the team, and Donnie led the way. We had good players on the team that I felt like, you know, if we could all put it together, we would make some noise. Unfortunately, we didn't do what we needed to do because there were other teams like the Toronto Blue Jays that were better than us, and the A's were better than us. I felt like if we came together and played like we should, we would make some noise, and we did. It just wasn't loud enough.

[8:25] Al Malafronte: Well, the thing is, though, back when you played, there was no wild card. That '93 team, for example, might have had an opportunity to go deep into the postseason because you guys had the talent. You had a huge year; Paulie had a good year; Mattingly was pretty good that season. So people forget in 1994 we were leading our division completely by eight games; nobody was even coming close to us, and then we had the strike. So, you know, things like that happen that you kind of look back and say, man, what could have happened? But we were killing everybody in '94.

[8:25] Danny Tartabull: So when you look back on it now, you think that team had what it took to go all the way?

[8:25] Danny Tartabull: Without a doubt. You know, the biggest thing that we had is that we really cared for each other. We really loved each other as men and as ball players, and it showed on the field. Aside from the talent part, it showed on the field that we really cared for each other, and we gelled. We all got along.

[8:25] Al Malafronte: What was it like playing with Wade Boggs? I heard he's a pretty superstitious guy.

[10:09] Danny Tartabull: Chicken man, chicken man. Yeah, well, you know what you hear is true. Great guy, unbelievable talent skill-wise. I was very, very fortunate to hit and play with guys like Don Mattingly, like Wade Boggs, like George Brett, like Frank Thomas. So I got a chance to really see these guys hit. Boggsy was like a surgeon at the plate. Other guys were just straight-up ability, and they could hit. Frank Thomas just flat-out hit, you know, and so did Donnie and George Brett. But Chicken Man, he could actually, he was a surgeon up at that plate. It was a pleasure to be on the same team watching him hit every day. It was awesome.

[11:00] Danny Tartabull: But he was, by the way, he was very superstitious. What you hear about the chicken is true. I always found it fascinating; he's Italian and Irish, and he would always draw a Hebrew symbol into the batter's box. Go figure, right?

[11:14] Al Malafronte: Yep, yep. Hey, it worked out pretty well for him, right? He hit .320.

[11:18] Danny Tartabull: It worked out really well for him.

[11:21] Al Malafronte: And you know, Danny, I want to tell you something, and I'm not just saying this because you agreed to come on the show, but '92, '93, even '94, you were legitimately one of the best hitters on the team during those seasons. You had Mattingly here, who was obviously super popular, but when you're having that type of success on the biggest stage on the planet, are you living the life of a rock star off the field when it comes to the nightlife in New York City?

[11:48] Danny Tartabull: Well, as far as nightlife is concerned, at that time, you know, I'm married, and so I can't really go out and do the nightlife stuff. But was I a rock star feeling like a rock star? Yeah, because New York does that to you. New York's, you know, they'll lift you up higher than anybody else if you're doing really well. If you're not doing so good, you're gonna hear about it. But when you're doing really well, there's no better place in the world to play than in New York. And it was my way of being the rock star, not the, you know, I wasn't single and out there doing all that crazy stuff. But maybe I wish I would have, but I didn't.

[12:24] Al Malafronte: Now, what's also interesting is when you first got here, the Boss wasn't around as much. He was coming off of that suspension and whatnot. What were your interactions like with him?

[12:34] Danny Tartabull: You know what? He was very demanding, man. I mean, it didn't matter, like, you know, you mentioned some of these years that I had. It wasn't good enough for him. If you had 30 home runs and drove in 100, he was still tough on you. And for some guys, maybe that works; for some guys, it doesn't. To me, I kind of brushed it off because I was doing what I was always doing, you know, driving in runs and hitting home runs. But it was at times difficult because he wanted more than what you were capable of actually doing.

[13:07] Al Malafronte: Well, far more. I mean, I'm all for that guy that pushes you to be the best that you can, but sometimes it got kind of out of hand.

[13:16] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, he did the same thing to Donnie though.

[13:19] Al Malafronte: Yeah.

[13:20] Danny Tartabull: The difference is with Donnie is that Donnie, you know, he was a product of the Yankees, and Donnie had some incredible years. So sometimes he got a hall pass here and there. But he would do that to everybody. He was tough on everybody, especially the managers.

[13:39] Al Malafronte: Yeah, oh, I can't even imagine what Buck had to deal with.

[13:43] Danny Tartabull: He had to endure a lot on a daily basis. Would George rip you through the press, or would he ever do it to your face? Did he have the guts?

[13:50] Danny Tartabull: No, he would do it through the press. You'd find your face in the back page of the news, and that's kind of his way of doing things. That's what worked for him in the past. For some guys, like I said, it works, but for some guys, you have to brush it off. But that's what he would do. He wouldn't tell you to your face. Or he would tell Buck, and then Buck would come over and talk to me or talk to another player. But it was rarely just let's sit down and discuss things.

[14:21] Danny Tartabull: It was rarely that. Yeah, it was rarely that. They would do it through the news, they would do it through the media or through your manager. Now I would have preferred for him to just, let's say if you have a problem with me, just come sit down and let's talk about it. But that wasn't the case.

[14:36] Al Malafronte: And it was like that your whole tenure here?

[14:39] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, exactly. The whole time. And it didn't matter, like I said. It didn't matter whether you were doing good or great, it should be better than great. Or if you weren't doing good at all, you'd hear about it, trust me.

[14:53] Al Malafronte: Did you feel like that type of pressure or undue pressure, I should say, impacted the way you played? Because you had some great seasons, but was it ever tough to brush it off?

[15:02] Danny Tartabull: Sometimes it was tough because, I mean, obviously, if you have somebody, you know, in your face all the time, not approving of what you're doing on the field, everybody's gonna feel a little bit, you know, hey, you know what, what am I supposed to do here? You know what I mean? I'm a team player, I'm playing at the highest level, you know, we're doing well, and if still it's not good enough, you kind of have to throw your hands up and say, okay, let's stay focused, you know, stay true to the course and keep playing.

[15:31] Danny Tartabull: And it makes it more difficult because if you're doing it through the media, then the media has to come over to you and find you, find yourself in front of your locker room with, you know, 12, 15 guys asking me questions that the boss would say.

[15:45] Al Malafronte: Was it tough for you to adjust to that part of it? You know, coming from Kansas City, the whole media landscape in New York is obviously unlike any other city. Did you embrace it?

[15:56] Danny Tartabull: I did. It took me a while. It took me a while to get used to having to talk to media every single day, multiple times, whether you're either in a batting cage or whether you're in the locker or after a game. Obviously in Kansas City you had that, but not to that extent. But at the beginning it was kind of overwhelming, to be honest with you. But then after a while, you just kind of get used to it because you get it, you have it every day, whether you're on the road or whether you're at home. It doesn't matter. The Yankees don't have a road way because Yankee fans show up in Baltimore and they show up in New York and they show up in Oakland and they show up everywhere in Texas. So that's the way we travel, and it took me a while to get used to that.

[16:37] Danny Tartabull: But you know, after a while, you get used to it. That first year was kind of daunting. Overall, there was a lot of, I wanna call it a lot of circusing going on, meaning like, you know, when George would show up in the helicopter and he'd land in the middle of the center field and it was all this, you know, it was a lot of circusing.

[17:02] Al Malafronte: Did he do that during batting practice? When did this happen?

[17:06] Danny Tartabull: We were in spring training and we were playing against the Mets and it was the Yankee-Met thing in spring training, mind you, I'm gonna repeat spring training. And a big old helicopter comes in, props are coming down, I didn't know who it was. Come down in the middle of center field, but right before the game, and out comes George. I go, and when I go, what in the world is going on? What is happening here? And it was George making an entrance. And that's the kind of stuff that you got used to after a while.

[17:41] Danny Tartabull: But I mean, mind you, I didn't, we didn't have any of the Kaufmans in Kansas City come in in a helicopter, land in the middle of a field in a spring training game. But you know, that's his style, that was his thing, and he wanted to make a big entrance, and that was the beginning of my word circusing. And that's how his, this is a circus, man.

[17:59] Al Malafronte: Do you think that Larry David's depiction of him on Seinfeld was pretty accurate then?

[18:04] Danny Tartabull: Yes, I do think so. Larry's very talented that way, and I think he did a heck of a job.

[18:08] Al Malafronte: Was it Larry who came to you to do Seinfeld?

[18:12] Danny Tartabull: Larry came to my agent, and my agent then spoke to the team, and then that's how we got it together. But yeah, he went to my agent.

[18:23] Al Malafronte: Wow. Now I'm just gonna tell you this, and I'm not trying to pet your ego too much, but you look like a big thing.

[18:28] Danny Tartabull: Oh, you're doing a great job. Don't stop, don't stop now.

[18:31] Al Malafronte: Yeah, man, dude, you look like a natural out there. I don't know if you had any acting experience like in high school or something, but how'd you pull that off?

[18:37] Danny Tartabull: You know what? Guidance. Jason Alexander, you know, even Jerry himself, just guidance. They were so professional that I couldn't screw it up. That they're so good that I couldn't screw it up. That's how good they are. And it was just guidance. It was just them just walking me through the whole thing.

[18:56] Danny Tartabull: And it was a lot of fun. We had as much fun on the set as we were off.

[19:03] Al Malafronte: So was it like take after take after take type of thing and they kind of walked you through it, or was it like, you know, going into it when you agreed to do the show where they sat down and talked to you or something like that?

[19:14] Danny Tartabull: Well, you first have to have the table read. So they ask you to come in at a table, do a table read, and then everybody's there and you're going through your lines and this and that and the other. And then after the table read, then you're asked to come in. I remember coming in, we filmed it here in Burbank. I remember coming in with my family and it was around five o'clock, four or five o'clock, and I didn't tape until about nine.

[19:40] Danny Tartabull: So during that time they either have you in one of those camper things or you're able to eat at the craft service. So they just bring you in when they're ready to actually film. You don't just film it and then take off; you have to come in when they're ready for you. So it took a little time, but I was having fun even before that.

[20:04] Al Malafronte: Did you used to see, like, you know, from those two episodes that were in, what was that whole process like? I mean, that's the number one sitcom in television history, not just of 1994-1995. Like, was it surreal to be on a set like that?

[20:20] Danny Tartabull: It was because obviously, you know, I had seen a couple of them, obviously didn't see a whole lot of them, but I saw a couple of them and you know, here I am on studio with Jerry Seinfeld and everybody else and I'm going, this was surreal. It was very surreal, but as I said before, these guys are such pros that you can't, nobody could screw it up. Larry David was so awesome, so patient that you just couldn't screw it up.

[20:32] Al Malafronte: What was your favorite scene that you got to shoot?

[20:32] Danny Tartabull: Probably the one that everybody gives me the most flack about, about cutting the donut with a fork and knife because the one that I did with polyester, by the way, the one that I did in polyester, I didn't do it here, I did it in Anaheim in the clubhouse in Anaheim. So I think that was probably the best one when the guy holds up his finger and he's got a broken middle finger and he's flipping out, flipping us off. I think those are my two favorites.

[21:18] Al Malafronte: Now these days, do a lot of people recognize you strictly from Seinfeld?

[21:22] Danny Tartabull: Sometimes they do, yeah. They do. Yeah, not all the time, but sometimes they do. I go, I've seen you before, that kind of a thing. And that has nothing to do with baseball.

[21:26] Al Malafronte: I've seen you before. You were on that television show.

[21:36] Danny Tartabull: Thank you. Thanks. I'm gonna apologize from the beginning. I'm gonna put from the start. I'm gonna apologize. But yeah, yeah. Lots of times. My wife always looks at it, she goes, she just shrugs, she just kind of shrugs her head and goes like that.

[21:51] Al Malafronte: Yeah, no way. You're a celebrity, man.

[21:56] Danny Tartabull: No, no, no, no, no, no. Used to be.

[22:00] Al Malafronte: Now, how about when you come to New York? Aside from Seinfeld, what do people like look back most fondly on you? Or which moment on the field did they like to bring up?

[22:06] Danny Tartabull: Now there's different. The New Yorkers, that's why New Yorkers are different. New Yorkers know about the Seinfeld, they don't want to talk about it. They want to talk about the baseball part. And that's, you know, when you go to a restaurant or when you're in a store somewhere, they want to talk about, they want to talk about. I remember I took my father to my first Yankee game, and you hit a home run, and it was that, you know, straight away center into the black. Or you know, you drove in a game-winning RBI when I took my son to his first baseball game. It's always like a momentous situation, like first game or a birthday or something like that. They remember that, and that's why that makes Yankee fans so special. Once you're a Yankee, that's the saying goes, you're always a Yankee.

[22:56] Al Malafronte: Now, if you had to pick one game that you played in here, which was your favorite in this stadium or wearing the Yankee uniform?

[22:56] Danny Tartabull: Well, that's a tough one. Not to say that there's too many for me to remember or anything like that. It's a tough one. I'll tell, and it didn't have nothing to do with me. One of the most memorable games that I was part of, I didn't even play that day, was watching, oh my god, it was a no-hitter. It was a no-hitter but Jim Abbott. It had nothing to do with me. To me, that was, I think about it now and actually my eyes well up a little bit because all of the struggles, everything that he had to go up against, I think probably that's probably the most memorable one for me.

[23:17] Danny Tartabull: Me personally, I would probably be in a Yankee uniform, not in Yankee Stadium, probably be the one, the game that I had nine RBIs in one game against the Orioles and I still had an at-bat left.

[23:17] Al Malafronte: That is absolutely epic. Did you save like your own memorabilia from that game? I feel like if I'm you, if I have the best game of my life, I'm saving the jersey, I'm saving the bat, I'm never wearing it again, I'm putting it on display in my living room. Like, anytime I need a little pick-me-up, I look up, look at that bat that drove in nine RBIs a few years ago. Like, did you keep all that stuff?

[24:28] Danny Tartabull: I keep all that stuff, but Teresa will kill me if I put that stuff on the wall.

[24:33] Al Malafronte: You're not as petty as me.

[24:35] Danny Tartabull: Hey, take that crap off the wall, man. Your playing days are over. Let's leave that stuff in storage, okay? We'll bring it out, you know, at some time. But no, I still have the bat that I used for that game. I still have the jersey that I used in that game. The very next day, the actual clipping, I mean, all that stuff for that. But as a Yankee, I wish it would have been more. I wish it would have been playoff time for me. I'd have traded all that stuff for, you know, playing my first playoff game in Yankee Stadium. That would have been super special.

[25:15] Al Malafronte: Now, I mean, you were here for the start of '95, but when you got traded, you were happy about it. I mean, I know that you had a lot of differences with the boss during that period.

[25:24] Danny Tartabull: It was tough, man. It started to wear on me and like, you know, constantly, constantly. It had nothing to do with my teammates. I loved my teammates, it had nothing to do with Bach. It was just constant, and then he took to the back pages of the newspaper, and it was that constant thing. And then the fans got involved with it.

[25:45] Danny Tartabull: And so when I saw what, when I saw early on, when Giancarlo Stanton came over and they started booing him because obviously he's a stud and he's still a stud. They started booing him. I'm going, I remember that. I remember that, but you know, you have to keep going. Heck, Derek Jeter got booed at one point. So, you know, it just comes with the territory, but yeah, at that time, I was for that moment, I had had it off and it was time, it was time to go.

[26:13] Al Malafronte: Now, Danny, there's a lot of Broadway performers that struggle with the idea that there's certain roles they can't just go out for due to Father Time. Not long after you left the Yankees, you decided to retire. And you had a great 1996 with Chicago. How tough was it for you to take that uniform off, especially coming off such a great year for you personally?

[26:35] Danny Tartabull: It was tough, but once again, I had to make a decision. I had been worn so much in New York that when I went on to Chicago, I had a great year. And the following year, I break my foot on opening day with a foul ball. And it just never healed correctly. And I said, listen, I'm happy with it. My kids are starting to grow. They're starting to go to school now. And I started getting into that. I think the time that I had off when I broke my foot and I started, I was being dad more so than the player. I think that I really kind of fell into that, you know, I really want to be dad. I really want to just, you know, be around more. And I think that's when I made the decision that I said, okay, that's enough. I mean, I've started to lose the love for it, but the passion. I started to lose the passion to the game. And when you do that, then it's time to go.

[27:39] Al Malafronte: Now, Danny, regardless of how it ended in New York, you had a phenomenal career. Folks would kill to have the type of success you have. When you look back on it, what do you want your legacy to be as far as your playing career goes? And what are you most proud of?

[27:50] Danny Tartabull: That I was a great teammate, number one. I want to be known because I made it a point to be a great teammate. A great teammate, and then on the field that you could always count on me. As far as, you know, if things got tight and you needed to have somebody, I was always, I want to be remembered as the guy who was clutch. And I did that a lot, and I think that's probably my legacy: a clutch player, he was clutch, played hard, and was a great teammate.

[28:24] Al Malafronte: Now I know your kids are getting a little bit older now, but as far as the way that front offices have adjusted their way of thinking and their minds, do you see yourself clashing with this new wave of analytic nerds?

[28:24] Danny Tartabull: Yes, if you were to get back into baseball, you would clash with them without a doubt. And it would have to be kind of a scenario like what Tony La Russa has in Chicago, which by the way, he's up for manager of the year.

[28:56] Danny Tartabull: Yeah where he's he you know he kind of meshes in that the the new the new way of playing but he still has the old way I mean watching what sometimes watching these games and you're playing a shift and the shortstops playing on the other side of sec on on the other side of second base is playing in and short right and you're going and you can't hit the ball that way what analytics tells me that I can't do that. You should be able you're a major league player you should be you should be able to do that all day long. And um and and and they hit right into it they hit right into the shift and I'm going this is a new way of playing the game man and it's all it's all or nothing. You know you're 0 2 it's you're swinging at it like if it was 3-0.

It's and it's you can't that's nothing I can't I'll never get used to that because that's not that that's not the way our our forefathers played that's not the way I grew up playing um and and I still see a lot of guys that do it the right way. I like the way I like the way uh DJ Lamayhu plays his game. He has he but it shows he he knows how to play the game. Um and so there are other players that that that are out there, you know, that are that are play the game the way it's it's supposed to. But um I I I would clash for sure.

[30:03] Al Malafronte: Who who's a hitter that reminds you of Danny Tartabull that's playing the game right now?

[30:09] Danny Tartabull: A guy that reminds me of me hitting.

[30:14] Al Malafronte: That's playing right now.

[30:16] Danny Tartabull: Yeah.

[30:17] Al Malafronte: Or in recent years, it could be anyone within, yeah, let's say within the past decade of retirement.

[30:24] Danny Tartabull: You know, I I like to see a little bit of me with in Ronald Acunia. And I'll tell you why, not the speed and not the not the way, you know, because he'll he'll hit the ball to right field all day long. He'll pull the ball and hit the ball down down left field line. Heating wise, he has the power. Yeah, he has definitely the power that I you kind of say you could pair it with me. You know, I I I think that he's one of these only guy that I can see that, you know, all these other guys are beasts. Uh Vladimir Guerrero, I can't do it. He's he's like his dad. He's he's a beast. Um, but yeah, I would say Ronald Acunia is probably the only one because he he hits the ball the other way effectively. And I used to do that effectively, hit the ball the right field effectively, pull it every now and then, go to center field every now and then. Um as far as hitting's concerned, as far as a uh players concerned, now he's he's he's he's a he's a much better player than I was as far as speed and defense and all that stuff.

[31:15] Al Malafronte: I love to hear how that's what you pay attention to. Being such a great hitter yourself, those those guys that have the ability to go the other way, like a Lemayhu, like an Acunia. That's that it's kind of like a lost art nowadays.

[31:25] Danny Tartabull: It is. I would be shocked if there's gonna be more than 1,530 hitters in all of Major League Baseball this year. Back when you played, you had to hit 320 to finish top five.

[31:36] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, absolutely. If you're hitting, if you're hitting 305 or three, three, you wouldn't even in the top 10. You you weren't even close to top 10. Um heck, there were times there are times where we had on teams that we had two or three guys in, you know, over over three over 310, 315. You know, so and now you can barely find one. So the game has changed in a way that it's changed. Um uh I I don't I don't approve of a lot of the things that that that's uh being done, but you know, who's to say I'm I'm still a fan though.

[32:07] Al Malafronte: Well, I'm glad to hear that, Danny. And I mean, I think of you so fondly for your time here in New York. And I'm sure a lot of folks at home would like to get to know you a little better. So there's a segment that we do here on Break A Bat, Danny. We call it fastball derby. Um I take it you're pretty familiar with the Raldus Chapman, right?

[32:25] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, absolutely.

[32:26] Al Malafronte: Yeah, uh the reliever. He could throw, he can pitch. Fastest throwing man ever. I want you to think of me as a Raldo Chapman without the tattoos on my neck or a 105 mile an hour fastball. But uh, put yourself back in the batter's box. I'm gonna ask you a question. You tell me what comes to mind. How does that sound?

[32:43] Danny Tartabull: Sounds good. Let's do it.

[32:45] Al Malafronte: Favorite New York City meal.

[32:48] Danny Tartabull: Oh my goodness. This there's a lot of them. Um it would have to be, it would have it would have to be Italian. It would have to be um, oh my goodness, what's the name of that place? I'll come back to that one. Hit me with the next one.

[33:04] Al Malafronte: What foods do you dislike?

[33:07] Danny Tartabull: Um, I'm not much of an Indian. I don't eat much Indian food. Um I know it's it's delicious, but I don't eat much of Indian food. But um Cuban food. I'm I'm Cuban, so I eat Cuban food. Um, and I used to always eat cucci fritos in in um right there in in Harlem. Um and they used to bring Cucci fritos to the ballpark. Uh Georgia didn't like it because it's it's it was fattening, but what can I say about that? He he caught me one time eating a uh uh fried pork chop, and um he says that's not that's not very nutritious. I said, Well, kind of for me it is right now. Watch me eat this. I had rice and beans and bananas, fried bananas, so cucci fritos. So shout out to Cucci Fritos.

[33:48] Al Malafronte: So that's your favorite so that's gonna be your favorite New York City meal, and is the least favorite uh food you don't like, Indian food? Is that is that what I'm hearing?

[33:54] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, we don't eat a lot, I don't eat a lot of Indian food though. But it I love the Italian food though, gotta tell you. Love Italian food.

[34:01] Al Malafronte: Nice. Next time you're back in town, you're gonna take me to one of your Cuban spots.

[34:04] Danny Tartabull: I'll take you to one of my Italian spots.

[34:05] Al Malafronte: Sounds good. That's that's a deal. That's a bet.

[34:08] Al Malafronte: Danny, you could be the lead in one Broadway show. What would it be?

[34:12] Danny Tartabull: Lead in Broadway show, uh Alexander Hamilton.

[34:18] Al Malafronte: Did you watch the movie or did you actually go to see it on Broadway?

[34:21] Danny Tartabull: I watched the I watched the movie.

[34:22] Al Malafronte: Alexander Hamilton. What was your favorite show that you got to see while you were in the city?

[34:26] Danny Tartabull: I saw all of them. Because I'm I'm a I'm a that's one thing that I used to do when I was in New York day off was going to Broadway. So I I saw all of them. Name them when I saw them. I mean, I saw I saw Cats, I saw uh all of them Fiddler on the Roof, I saw um Les Miserables. I saw I've I've seen them all.

[34:47] Al Malafronte: What's your favorite show, tune?

[34:49] Danny Tartabull: Well, out of all the Broadway shows that you song, does is there a certain uh out of all the shows that you saw, is there a certain song that stands out more than the others?

[34:57] Danny Tartabull: Right. Seasons of love guy?

[34:59] Al Malafronte: Seasons of love, yep.

[35:00] Danny Tartabull: That's it. Oh, that's a great one. Yep. That is absolutely I saw Phantom of the Opera. I see I've seen them, I've seen them all. Like that's what we used to do, and you used to go to the Broadway and see what's in them all. But rent is my uh that's my one of my favorites of all time.

[35:17] Al Malafronte: Were you like a Saturday night show guy after a day game or strictly on the off days?

[35:22] Danny Tartabull: It depends. It depended. Mostly on a day off. But you know, I I have been known to go after a game. Um and and with teammates, too. You know, go go to and catch a show with teammates.

[35:36] Al Malafronte: All right. Then I that'll lead me to my next question. Uh, which of your teammates enjoyed Broadway the most?

[35:46] Danny Tartabull: Oh, that's a tough one. Um I said Donnie. Donnie enjoys Broadway. I said Donnie would enjoy enjoyed the Broadway the most. And also Donnie was the always the one uh would always give me the insights to where to go eat. You know, whether it be in spring training or whether it be um, you know, at in New York in the city, he he knew them, he knew them all. And so he's I always went to him.

[36:12] Al Malafronte: Most amazing thing that you ever witnessed on a Broadway stage.

[36:19] Danny Tartabull: Most amazing thing that I ever saw on a Broadway stage. What's the name of I'm trying to remember the name of the um the Broadway show with the with the a Warhorse? So that night is what stands out the most wow. Because you see this enormous contraption coming onto the stage on the stage. And it was it was like it was mind-boggling.

[36:44] Al Malafronte: War horse.

[36:46] Danny Tartabull: Great answer. How about your favorite show that you've seen since you left New York uh as a Yankee?

[36:53] Al Malafronte: In as in retirement, let's say.

[36:56] Danny Tartabull: You say Broadway show? Is it a Broadway show?

[36:58] Al Malafronte: Yeah, Broadway show.

[37:01] Danny Tartabull: Since I retired. I saw I I I have to say, I saw well, I went to went with my with my kids. I went to go see Wicked. And I and I I enjoyed Wicked, and it was, it was pretty cool. That's probably the most exciting one that I've seen since I've since I've retired. Outside of wanting to go see Alex. I wanted to go see Hamilton, but obviously you know what happened. So, you know, we're in a pandemic, and that's cra that put a kiosh in it.

[37:27] Al Malafronte: Well, this September, that means that's when you're gonna come back to New York. You and I are gonna grab some Cuban food and we're gonna go see Hamilton. Because I haven't gotten to see it in person either, but I will tell you, Wicked is one of the few shows that I've seen more than once. So I'm always down to see that one, too.

[37:40] Danny Tartabull: Really? That's surprising.

[37:43] Al Malafronte: That's surprising. That's awesome.

[37:44] Danny Tartabull: Handful of shows, and that one is always up there for me. First time was in eighth grade and saw it as recently as age 27. So go figure.

[37:51] Danny Tartabull: Yeah, yeah. That was probably like my last one right there. But Hamilton's definitely well we'll we'll have to come up to to catch a playoff game.

[37:59] Al Malafronte: Heck yeah.

[38:00] Danny Tartabull: Oh, absolutely, man. Dude, do you know how nuts Yankee fans would go for you if you came back here?

[38:04] Danny Tartabull: I I would love to. I would love to come back, man. I'd love to, I would love to come back. I've always loved New York. Always, always will.

[38:11] Al Malafronte: All right. How about this one? Toughest pitcher you ever had to face.

[38:18] Danny Tartabull: Okay, so you're gonna think that I'm gonna call, I'm gonna say Roger Clemens or Randy Johnson or anybody like that, or Mike Musina, or somebody. Jamie Moyer.

[38:30] Al Malafronte: Lefty pitcher.

[38:30] Danny Tartabull: This is shocking to hear. Jamie Moyer had my number, and it was all that slow stuff and the and all that breaking ball stuff. Jamie Moyer, which he played forever, um was the toughest guy from it wasn't Roger. It wasn't Randy Johnson. It wasn't any of those guys. It was Jamie Moyer. Believe it or not. He was always tough on me.

[38:55] Al Malafronte: Wow. Who's the guy you owned?

[39:01] Danny Tartabull: You want a list? You owned a lot of them. If you could, if you could face one guy right now in their prime, how about a guy like in their prime who you owned?

[39:11] Danny Tartabull: I like Rocket. I enjoyed hitting off Rocket. I like Clemens. Because Clemens was always going to come at you. You know, it was kind of mono a mano. You're going to beat me with, I'm going to beat you with my best, and you're going to either you're going to stand up to the challenge or not. So I would have to say it would it was Roger. That's probably the one that because I didn't know. I'm imagining right now, you as Alexander Hamilton and Roger Clemens as Aaron Burr. The way that you talk about the way you two used to battle. I'm imagining that on stage right now. If we're going to do a little baseball meets Broadway Paradise.

[39:44] Al Malafronte: That's a good analogy right there, because that's probably what you'd have. That's a that's a very good analogy. You know, I I faced I faced Roger the day that he had, I was with the Mariners at the time. I I was I was faced Roger with the day that he set the American League record for strikeouts that night. You you know that, right?

[39:59] Danny Tartabull: Yeah.

[39:59] Al Malafronte: Oh, yeah. That was uh 90, no, it was at 86, 86.

[40:05] Danny Tartabull: 86. He was he was on. I he was on like I've never seen any other pitcher be on. But you owned him otherwise outside of that one night.

[40:15] Danny Tartabull: I got it. I he got me once, and I got it, and I actually got it, I got a hit off of him. Yeah, that that same day. Um yeah, he's he's probably the guy that I'd love to uh that I'd love to face. If I had to face one guy.

[40:29] Al Malafronte: And uh we use this one to wrap every show. But Danny, what's the best piece of advice anyone ever gave you?

[40:36] Danny Tartabull: It was and it came from my dad. I'll remember, I remember what um I was I was in minor leagues and I wasn't uh I was pretty much homesick. And I'll and I took it, I took that all the way up to the big leagues with me. He said, if you're gonna if you're gonna go ahead and and and put on the uniform, then do the uniform with respect. Play hard and and and and and be and play the best. If because if you're not gonna do that, don't go out there and embarrass yourself. And I and that's that's that hardworking kind of mentality that I took from the minor leagues all the way up. And and even till today, whatever I do, I remember that that that piece of advice. If you're gonna go do something, do it right, or don't do it at all. Just don't do it.

[41:13] Al Malafronte: Danny, it served you really well, man. And you had one hell of a baseball career, and you're a super cool dude. I'm like so happy that I got the chance to talk with you tonight, my man.

[41:24] Danny Tartabull: It's my pleasure, man. Anytime, it's my pleasure. I I thoroughly enjoyed myself.

[41:28] Al Malafronte: Well, when we're on the other end of this thing and you come up to New York, you're gonna have to let me know. Well, uh, we're gonna tear up a playoff game and a Broadway show. We just gotta get the Yankees back on track for that to happen.

[41:38] Danny Tartabull: We do, man. We we that we we need to shake them up a little bit. We need to shake them up a little bit. But uh, you know, they they have the talent, it's just a matter of them putting it all together, and I hope they do. I really hope they do.

[41:49] Al Malafronte: Man, I'm right there with you, my man. And uh thank you so much again for coming on the show tonight.

[41:53] Danny Tartabull: My pleasure, my pleasure.

[41:55] Al Malafronte: And let's you know what? Let's like I said, we'll we'll we'll see, we'll see each other again.

[42:00] Danny Tartabull: Absolutely, my friend.

[42:01] Al Malafronte: And uh, thank you so much to all the folks at home who tuned in to break a bat tonight. This is Al Malafronte signing off from the Broadway Podcast Network.

[42:09] Al Malafronte: We'll see you next time.

[42:11] Al Malafronte: Thanks for listening to Break a Bat. This is produced by the fine folks at the Broadway Podcast Network.

[42:18] Al Malafronte: Visit and subscribe at bpn.fm slash break a bat.

[42:23] Al Malafronte: You can find me online at break underscore A underscore bat underscore podcasts.

[42:30] Al Malafronte: And you can also find the Broadway Podcast Network on Instagram at Broadway Podcast Network.

[42:37] Al Malafronte: It's been so great having you here with us today, and we'll see you next time.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred