Skip to main content
BPN Logo
S3 EP2 - Consider Yourself(Tape) - Part 1, with Andrew Fem

All auditions have changed in a big way since Covid! I found casting director Andrew Fem‘s Instagram and LOVED their content! Andrew breaks down the do’s and don’ts of self tape auditions from the casting director’s perspective... Read More

From the show: Breaking Broadway with Kerry Butler

24 mins
3/14/23

Featured Shows

About

All auditions have changed in a big way since Covid! I found casting director Andrew Fem‘s Instagram and LOVED their content! Andrew breaks down the do’s and don’ts of self tape auditions from the casting director’s perspective. Whether it is for TV, film or theater, Andrew discusses the differences and shares how to nail the self tape.

Learn more about Andrew Fem on Instagram @castingbythem and at castingbythem.com.

You can find me on Instagram @kerrybutler1 and TikTok @kerrybutlernyc.

For coaching and teaching, visit my website at kerrybutlercoach.com, follow @kerrybutlercoach on Instagram, or email me at kerrybutlercoach@gmail.com.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Kerry Butler: Once I played a penny who just couldn't stop the beat. Yes, with rather skates on her feet. Although it's recently to see. A real quo. Tina. Tina. Now come with me, I'm alive.

[0:40] Kerry Butler: I am your host, Miss Kerry Butler. Together, you and I are breaking Broadway. Hello, everyone. Welcome back to Breaking Broadway. I am super excited about our guest today. Andrew Fem is a casting director who uses their platform to demystify the casting process. In casting, they work in television, theater, film, commercials, and whatever other medium you need. Some of my favorite things you've worked on, Andrew, are Hamilton, obviously, and Russian Doll.

[1:36] Andrew Fem: Yeah, that's such a cool show.

[1:37] Kerry Butler: Okay, so anyway, I found Andrew on Instagram because your posts are amazing. Not only is it great information on the casting process, but also like you're hilarious, and the way you edit your posts is really good. Like I can tell you put a lot of time into it.

[2:01] Andrew Fem: Yeah, thanks. I sure do.

[2:06] Kerry Butler: So wait, before I'm just gonna tell, I'm just gonna tell everybody what is your Instagram handle? Because you absolutely have to follow them because I learn stuff from your posts all the time.

[2:18] Andrew Fem: Well, thank you. It's just @castingbythem. Keeping it simple.

[2:22] Kerry Butler: Andrew, tell us about your journey to becoming a casting director. What did you want to be when you were little?

[2:29] Andrew Fem: What did I want to be when I was little? Um, did you love theater?

[2:35] Kerry Butler: Did you love?

[2:37] Andrew Fem: I did love theater. My parents are from here. They grew up in Brooklyn.

[2:40] Kerry Butler: Oh, me too. Where did you grow up in Brooklyn?

[2:42] Andrew Fem: No, my parents did. I grew up in New Jersey.

[2:44] Kerry Butler: Oh, oh, okay, okay. My mom's from Bushwick, and my dad grew up actually in Glendale, Queens.

[2:51] Andrew Fem: Oh, okay. But they were high school sweethearts. It's deeply embarrassing. I think they still like each other, even. Um, but yeah, they really loved theater, and so we got to grow up. We grew up like an hour away in New Jersey, which was really lucky. And so we had access to New York, and they really loved theater, and so we grew up seeing theater. Like growing up, the only cassette tapes in my dad's car were it was like the original cast recording of The Who's Tommy, the original cast recording of Phantom of the Opera, which was like a two cassette set.

[3:23] Andrew Fem: Was it four even? It was like so many tapes. That show is really long. And then like Martha and the Vandellas' number ones. And so I always say, you know, like my parents tried to raise at least one gay kid, and um, they did it.

[3:36] Kerry Butler: Congratulations.

[3:38] Andrew Fem: We just like grew up with theater and like uh 1960s girl group music. So they did it. The Marvelous Wonderettes huge for me. I know that's so random, I feel like.

[3:49] Kerry Butler: I mean, it's a great show, but that's very random for...

[3:49] Andrew Fem: Yeah, they made that one for me. I was like, wow, thank you.

[3:56] Kerry Butler: Did you go to school for theater?

[3:59] Andrew Fem: I did not, which is pretty rare for people who work in casting. Cause I feel like a lot of people's entry points to casting, like getting to know people who work in casting is as an actor. I didn't. I went to school for Spanish and linguistics.

[4:12] Kerry Butler: Oh, wow.

[4:13] Andrew Fem: Just because I liked them. Uh, but I never had any intention of like pursuing that professionally, much to my parents' dismay. It's okay. I went to state school um on a scholarship. And so yeah, I did not go to school for theater. I just grew up loving theater, loving actors, loving musical theater especially, and then graduated, had no idea what I wanted to do, worked like a really silly job that my cousin hooked me up with.

[4:38] Andrew Fem: And then one day I was at dinner with my best friend, and she was like, What was a silly job?

[4:42] Kerry Butler: Well, my dad's family's Italian, so I know how it sounds, but it's real. He owns a dessert manufacturing company, which is real. You can find them in stores. They're real desserts. I'm not tipping anything off. So I was my job was answering phones when the woman who answered phones couldn't. So I was like backup phone answerer.

[5:00] Andrew Fem: Okay.

[5:02] Kerry Butler: At a factory. So like nobody was calling. It wasn't like a storefront where people would be like, How later are you open today? Or like, oh, do you have this? It was like, no one would ever call. The phone would ring maybe twice a day, which was great. So yeah, I was at dinner with my best friend one night and she was like, girl, what are like what are you actually gonna do though? Because answering phones for John is not it.

[5:20] Andrew Fem: And um, I didn't didn't know. I said I didn't know, but she didn't really believe me. So she pressed and I was like, I don't know, like casting. She was like, great, look into that. And I didn't know what it was at the time. I'm like the, I think, like the last generation of casting directors who got into it before we knew it was like a thing, kind of.

[5:37] Andrew Fem: And I put that in context because the summer I started in casting in March. And that summer was when the Legally Blonde Search for the Next Elle Woods show came out on MTV. Which, like, you know, is not it's a reality TV competition show. It's not the casting process, but it was about the casting of the next Elle Woods. And Bernie Telsey was on there, and it was like, oh, there's this person who's called the casting director. And like, who is that? And what is their interaction with the process? And again, like that's not what the casting process is. But it was like there was a person there, and then there was the Grease one. And I think like I think Jay Binder was on there at some point. And it was like casting directors started to appear on things as themselves, not as like the cranky characters that we see them as, where it was like, oh, these are like real life people who, if you Google them, it's like, wow, they have credits and they've cast things.

[6:21] Andrew Fem: So yeah, I started just before that. So I always say, like, I just I guessed and I happened to be right. Like I got really lucky my first day as an intern at Jim Carnahan casting. Um, it was exactly what I thought it would be, and or you know, it was like exactly what I hoped it would be. And I was like, oh yeah, this is great. It was like we get to talk about actors and like who's great and what they can do and just champion actors. Awesome. So I got really lucky that I just took a wild guess and it happened to be right and it worked out.

[6:45] Kerry Butler: Oh, good. You know, when I was little, I was already in the business, but so I would force my friends to play this game where we would cut out pictures. I would be like the agent trying to cast. I played casting director as a kid. No one wanted to play this game with me.

[7:01] Andrew Fem: I was gonna say, how was that for your friends?

[7:05] Kerry Butler: You're like, I had a lot of friends, not the same ones, though. It turned over a lot.

[7:09] Andrew Fem: Yeah, either I was either playing that game or forcing them to be in shows in the backyard that they did not want to be a part of.

[7:16] Kerry Butler: Yeah. Now, post-COVID, how has the business changed? Do you feel like?

[7:20] Andrew Fem: Yeah, it's very different from my point of view in casting. Virtual auditions are so much more a thing.

[7:25] Kerry Butler: Right.

[7:28] Andrew Fem: I don't think I had ever done a virtual audition before COVID.

[7:33] Kerry Butler: Yeah.

[7:34] Andrew Fem: Oh God, especially for theater. Yikes. But like even Yeah, no. Self-tapes were always a thing. But I mean, even that wasn't like huge always because the technology just wasn't as good. You know, not everybody had an HD video camera sitting in their pocket all the time. So I've noticed that's a big shift. But also it's like that creates a lot more accessibility to opportunities for performers. So it's like it's good and bad. I don't think we get to see more actors and we get to like audition more people because in an audition, you know, we'll do the scenes and like we'll give adjustments. You know, casting directors will give adjustments, and so we'll try it a couple different times. And so that takes, you know, that might take like 15 minutes to get what ends up being three minutes worth of audition.

And so with self-tapes, we end up with just the three minutes of audition. So it's like, oh, you can see so many more people because we're not doing all the in-between. However, of course, like the in-between stuff is very important because now actors are just like guessing at everything, which is not helpful to them. I don't think it's very challenging to set up actors to win in the same way in virtual auditions or like self-tapes, especially.

[8:38] Kerry Butler: Yeah, you give great tips on that. Like, um, how you say to research the tone of the project?

[8:46] Andrew Fem: Yeah, there's just like a lot more prep that has to go in for actors, I think. And yeah, researching tone, especially, because like you don't, you know, you don't have a person in the room telling you, like, oh no, actually, it's like a little bit more sort of this point of view. So there's just a lot more responsibility on the actors on the front end, which is challenging. And there's not, we can't change course in the moment. And so sometimes it's like even if it makes sense for like everything you know about the show and that director and everybody else involved, it's like, oh no, this thing's actually like a little bit of a departure from that. There's nobody to tell you when you're in your little vacuum recording the audition. So that's challenging.

[9:17] Kerry Butler: So when we get an audition, like how would we research the tone?

[9:21] Andrew Fem: Yeah. Well, what a great question. Go, I mean, well, if it's a thing that already exists, just look it up. And that's uh, you know, if you can see the if it's like a theater thing, go see the show if you can. If not, there's press reels of stuff or people perform on the Macy's Thanksgiving Day parade or talk shows. And so there's always clips of something, or you know, there's the other stuff that's on YouTube that exists.

[9:46] Andrew Fem: So unofficial B-roll. Shh. That's which I don't know exists. Neither of us knows anything about that. But I've heard tale from people. And if it's not something that exists, which happens a lot, I work a lot in television also. And so it's pilot season right now for the networks. And so if it's not something that exists, just look up, you know, who the director is and I mean, mostly who the director is and who wrote it, and look at the other stuff that they've done. Because you know, people have particular styles that they work in, and that's a good thing because it means that like, you know, they leave a mark on their work and that it's very identifiable. And so it's always important for people to do that because sometimes somebody will come in and not have I worked on a very popular show, and somebody came in to audition for it and it was just like completely out of left field.

And I heard such a I was like, Hey, did you um have you have you seen the show? Like literally everyone has seen the show. I was like, hey, have you like seen the show or what's what's going on? And he was like, oh no, I decided to um I def I specifically didn't watch it because I wanted to just have a fresh take, but I'm pretty sure I know uh what should be done. And it was like, um, you you don't is the thing. So help me help you. So yeah, for sure research. Like, just watch it. And you don't have to watch the whole, like, watch an episode, just cause it's so different.

[10:58] Kerry Butler: Yeah, sometimes I get an audition and I can't tell, like for a pilot, and I can't even tell if it's a comedy or a drama. And so then the only way I can tell is by looking at, you know, like the uh what the writer has mostly worked on and things like that.

[11:14] Andrew Fem: Yeah, and also like look at the other actors in it, because it's like, oh, if it's like, why do I always think about Daniel Day-Lewis? I love comedy, and so he's like, I think like my go-to very serious actor. I'm like, yeah, so it's like Daniel Day-Lewis, it's probably not gonna be like a lighthearted family comedy. Right. Although who knows, you know, Mark Rylance loves to keep us guessing. But yeah, look at the other people involved. All these people. Ugh, also all white men. Next. No more men.

[11:42] Kerry Butler: Um, okay, also when we are um putting since we're putting ourselves on tape so much now, what kind of um background do we need? All of that stuff, all the technical stuff. What do we need?

[11:55] Andrew Fem: Yeah, the opposite of what's behind me right now. And if you ever watch my videos, true the opposite of what's there. But I did that.

[12:02] Andrew Fem: I was trying to figure out what to do. I talked to a friend of mine, Mary Paige Nance, who's in A Beautiful Noise, right? On Broadway. Yeah, that's the name of the show. But she and I chat a lot about social media, and so I was trying to figure out a background for it. And I was like, Oh, like what's something that like feels like me and it'll be fun and give people like a sense of my personality. And I had a hot pink um backdrop at one point because I thought that would be fun. But then it was just like a little too, it was a little too serious and intense because it was like a little too polished in a way that I didn't think like was me ultimately. And I was like, oh, what if I use like my actual apartment and my little wall of art that I've made and all these picture frames I spray painted.

So the opposite of this. What background do you need? Just something like plain and simple. It can be a lot of people use like that really rich blue tone just because it makes a lot of people pop against it.

[12:41] Kerry Butler: Yeah.

[12:41] Andrew Fem: A lot of people look good against it, which is great. You know, if you have like a darker skin tone, you could think about shifting more toward purple because that's a little bit more complimentary. A lot of people use like a gray, and so you can do like a gray with a little bit more of a blue in it or whatever. But yeah, something just plain and simple because you don't want uh distractions from the work. And also, oh God, right. Something that I think used to be more the trend is like those ones with a little bit of like a pattern to it, like the sort of tie-dye-y kind of feel. You would know it if you saw it. If you look up like old self-tapes, like auditions from like 20 years ago or something, you'll see that used to be like the style was this weird, it's like not tie-dye, but sort of tie-dye pattern. So for the love of God, use a solid.

[13:30] Andrew Fem: And we should have a ring light, is it you should have some kind of light for sure, because yeah, I mean, not every camera is great. You know, there's so much light on me right now to look like I think there's not really light on me. But yeah, that's the thing I always encourage people to play around about. And a million years ago, I taught a class on how to self-tape. And I wanted to remind people like casting only sees the finished product, I only see what it looks like. I can't see what's going on behind the camera. So, like by any means necessary, make sure it looks good. And so if that means like moving, you know, some people don't have like a light kit, great. If you have a bunch of lamps in your apartment and you can move them around and make it work, like great.

And if that feels unsustainable at some point and you decide you want to invest in a light kit to make your life easier, do that. But yes, have lights on you. Definitely look at what it looks like before you get started. And always like a good little barometer is like we just have a little catch light in the eyes. Like, is there a little bit of light in my eyes? There is. Great. That's always like a good thing. Because otherwise, like if I turn all these off, my eyes are black.

[14:31] Kerry Butler: I know.

[14:32] Andrew Fem: And I ended up using like a super cheap ring light that seems to do the trick. So I didn't I don't I didn't buy anything like super expensive for my setup.

[14:41] Kerry Butler: Yeah.

[14:41] Andrew Fem: Nor should you. There's no need. It's like if it looks good, it looks good. Who cares? And I've had friends truly do like the move every lamp in my apartment around to get it done. It's like, I would never know. It looks great. Cool. Are there any um traps that you've seen actors fall into?

[14:55] Andrew Fem: No. Uh yeah. Plenty. I think one of them is just focusing on the wrong thing and thinking that like the wrong things matter. Like you mentioned background. And I think people will stress about like what kind of background to use to the point of just being frozen or think it, you know, or stressing that, like, oh no, I use this one that's like a slightly deeper blue, less that, you know, instead of like the slightly lighter blue. Like, does that and I wanna say that that's hyperbole or an exaggeration, but like it's not. I'm friends with a lot of actors. You guys really torture yourselves. So just focusing on the wrong stuff. It's like it's literally just about saying the lines, and that's it.

You know, like if we can hear you okay and see you okay, great. Like there's so I booked people off of so many different kinds of self-tape. Like when they're on vacation somewhere and just like shooting on a phone in a hotel room with like no there, no plain wall, but like, you know, with something like this behind them. And it's like, it doesn't really.

[15:48] Andrew Fem: Yeah, it's like if you're good, you're good. It'll be fine. You know, and also I think a thing a lot of people maybe don't know is that, yeah, a lot of times now, less so for theater, because there's a longer callback process, but for like TV, there's not often a callback process. Oftentimes you'll get booked from your self-tape. Like you will send in your one audition and be done and then be like, hello, you got the job. We will see you on set. And so, yeah, like that's why the stakes are a little bit. This might sound counterintuitive, but the stakes are a little bit lower, just because like there's not gonna be a callback process. So it's like you're good, like you're gonna get the role or you're not gonna get the role.

Like it's not gonna be whatever's going on. You know, of course, you want all those things, like you know, you want us to be able to like see you and hear you and have sort of a plain background, but like it doesn't matter. And I think people focus a lot on that, or they'll just get really in their heads about slight differences in a line reading that don't make any it's like if it's motivated and it's grounded and it makes sense for the character and what's going on in the scene, your relationship with the other people, like it doesn't matter.

[16:44] Andrew Fem: Like I've never been watching an audition, especially if it's, you know, like two or three, like a couple pages where it's like you're thinking about one line in a scene that's this big, like it doesn't matter. But I think people get really stressed about that. They're like, oh no, that was such a good take. But the way I said that one thing, it's like, no, a good take's a good, like, do your auditions holistically. And just because I think that's helpful, just so you don't get hung up on like any one particular detail. Cause like if the whole thing is good, that little, that one little, even if it's like forgetting a line or you know, oops, I sort of forgot the line, so I kind of paraphrased like so often it doesn't matter. I mean, I guess if it's Shakespeare, someone's probably gonna notice, but like, I don't catch Shakespeare.

[17:17] Kerry Butler: Oh, good to know.

[17:18] Andrew Fem: Good to know. Um what about like, are there any people that come in and just like every audition, it's they just really know what they're doing? And is the is there something to that?

[17:30] Andrew Fem: Yeah, there's I think a lot of people that do that who we audition often. But I do think that's a thing that definitely takes time because auditions are like auditions are very high stakes. It's so weird and unnatural. I mean, first of all, it's like right, we're all playing pretend. So even on that level, it's like, okay, so you're walking into a room with like not me, and maybe we've never met each other before, and then you're gonna do a scene where you're not you and I'm not me. And I also might be like a few different characters, and there might be like this big world and a lot of stuff going on. So it's like baseline, it's weird. What we do is very silly. And like you want to get the job because sure you want to be in the show, but also like you need to pay rent, you need to keep your health insurance. So like there's a lot of stakes in auditions, which is why I think it's like very important for caster directors to work overtime to try to make actors feel at ease.

[18:20] Andrew Fem: But you know, people who are good at auditioning, I think are able to actually Lisa Coudre, there's an episode of RuPaul's podcast. It's episode 62, Lisa Coudreau, and she talks a lot about when she was coming up and she says at one point, she's like, you know, I got really good at auditioning is the phrase she uses. And he's like, Okay, well, what does that mean to be good at auditioning? She's like, you know, I just learned to like not take it personally and just to show up and like say the lines and then leave. And she makes a big point about she's like, she had um these two teachers, and one of them would drill like it's a business. So none of this is personal. And he would say, like, if you walk in a room and somebody's eating, they're like, they're not eating at you, like they're not eating to be rude to like get in your head.

They're like, you know, they're eating because maybe they haven't had a break all day and they've been in auditions for like six hours and they have two hours left and they're hungry, but they want to keep at like, you know, but they don't want you to be stuck out there waiting because something else happened.

[19:11] Andrew Fem: Like, so I think that's a lot of what makes people like good at audition. Like, yeah, of course, be really prepared and all that stuff, but also just like just be present and don't take it personal and just which is all so much easier said than done, and just like and listen, you know, if somebody gives you an adjustment, like really try to take that on because we're trying to help. We always say it's so cliche, but it's true is that like we're rooting for you. To quote Tyra Banks, we're all rooting for you. And like we really are. First of all, because you know, we like actors, and that's why I work in casting. If you don't like actors, you can't work in casting. It's definitely not glamorous. You have to just like want to be there to champion actors. But also, you know, on a personal level, it's like, I want you to book the job so I can be done.

[19:53] Kerry Butler: Totally.

[19:55] Andrew Fem: If you book the job, I can I can go take a nap, I can go get lunch with my friends after it's like gr I don't have to keep stressing, like, oh no, we didn't find it today. I have to have more auditions tomorrow. Who's it gonna be? We've seen all the people that I can think like. So there's nothing better you can do than walk in and like be the solution to the problem. So I think embodying that is what helps people just feel more self-assured in auditions. It's like prepare as much as you can and then have fun. The other thing Lisa Coudreau says is one of her teachers would say, like, you guys all complain about how you don't. I think it's easy for people to conceive of having a job as your opportunity to be an actor and to like do acting.

And her teacher said, like, you all complain that you don't get opportunities to act. You got this audition, that's three minutes of like uninterrupted acting. So, like, remember that's a good thing. That's the thing that you want to be doing. So, if that's a way that's helpful to reframe it, I think that's a good thing to remember.

[20:43] Andrew Fem: That's like, oh, right, you get to like do the thing that you love right now for three, you know, even if you don't get the role, like you got to be alphabet for those like 25 pages of sides.

[20:50] Kerry Butler: Yeah, yeah. I always say that too. I'm when I'm teaching them, I'm always like, you know, think of your audition as like, I can't wait to show you what I could do. I'm doing a mini performance for you.

[21:01] Andrew Fem: Yeah.

[21:01] Kerry Butler: Um it's fun. It's fun then, yeah. And and don't focus on the outcome because so many times you might not be right for that part, but then you'll be right for the next part. So if you do a good job, they'll remember you for the next one.

[21:13] Andrew Fem: Yep. I think a lot of people say it's like, don't worry about booking the job, book the room, which is like, you know, just make fans of the people in the room. Cause there's so many times, right? It's like, you don't know who else is in the room and what they're working on or what they have in the pipeline. There are so many times, especially working on high maintenance, people would be frustrated a lot that they had never auditioned for the show. And there were so many times, like, if I went through the God, hundreds of people we cast on that show, so many of them booked their first time coming in the room. And it's just because we had such a clear sense of what we had been making the show for so long before it moved to HBO.

And like we all spoke the same language, like being the creator, like we all knew each other for so long before we made the show. And so it was like, oh no, it's just because I'm like really locked in. Like we'd be able to bring, you know, there were so many times we bring in exactly one person for a role because I would read it and be like, oh, it's this person. And they would come in and nail it.

[22:00] Kerry Butler: Wow.

[22:01] Andrew Fem: Oh my gosh. Yeah. I mean, that was a very special experience. But it was like, because we were true, we were, we had known each other so well. We knew the show so well. So it was like, yeah, so don't read, like, if you're not getting in for that show, it's like maybe it's because I know you and you're just not right for it yet. Maybe you're not gonna be right for it ever. But it's also like, maybe you just need a little time to like cook a little bit more. Maybe you're not quite old enough. Maybe you don't have like enough life experience to inform that role. So yeah, like don't read into anything. Also, sometimes the last thing I'll say about that is don't worry about the reaction you're getting, because you don't know what it means.

Sometimes people in the room might not be reacting very much because you're doing amazing. And I'm like, well, thank god there it is. Jesus. And like I don't even, you know, it's not like you're amazing, and I'm like, ooh, yay, this is exciting. It's just like maybe I'm relieved, or maybe I'm like, oh thank God, I thought this person was gonna be great and they are. Whew. And so that's not gonna look on the outside like what you're hoping it's gonna look like when you're nailing this audition. But it's like, no, it's good, like, try not to read anything into anything. It's a really hard skill to develop, but I always encourage people, I'm like, take things at face value. If somebody says you're doing a good job, great.

If somebody's not saying anything, don't put their opinion on top of that. Don't be like, ugh, they didn't like me because they, you know, didn't smile on this one. It's like, you don't you don't know. There's so many times my friends have book jobs where it's like, I thought I've, you know, totally bombed out audition and then I booked the job. It's like, yeah, you never know.

[23:12] Kerry Butler: Yeah, that's happened to me a lot too. And I definitely do try and read the room, so I'm guilty of that.

[23:17] Andrew Fem: Yeah.

[23:17] Kerry Butler: Oh, so much easier said than done. Please. On that note, let's take a pause, and everybody tune in next week to hear more of Andrew's amazing tips.

[23:30] Kerry Butler: Thank you so much for listening. If you like this podcast and want more episodes, please take a second to rate it. Check out my website, Carrie Butler Coach for more info on private coaching and teaching at schools. You can follow me on Instagram, Carrie Butler1, and visit bpn.fm slash breaking broadway for all ways to listen, follow, subscribe, hear past episodes of Breaking Broadway, and find out more information. Together, you and I are breaking Broadway.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred