Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Carolyn, Dorothy, David, and More: Cy Coleman's Lyricists with special guest David Zippel

During an incredible Broadway career that stretched from 1953 to 1998, composer Cy Coleman created the music for 12 Broadway musicals. Unlike most Broadway composers, however, he was never part of an ongoing songwriting team but instead worked with seven very talented but very different collaborators... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

45 mins
4/4/24

Featured Shows

About

During an incredible Broadway career that stretched from 1953 to 1998, composer Cy Coleman created the music for 12 Broadway musicals. Unlike most Broadway composers, however, he was never part of an ongoing songwriting team but instead worked with seven very talented but very different collaborators. My guest today is one of those esteemed lyricists -- David Zippel who partnered with Cy Coleman on the score for the 1990 Tony Award winning "Best Musical", City Of Angels the hit musical that altogether received 10 Tony Awards including Coleman and Zippel’s win for Best Score. That show launched David on his own stellar career which has honored with two Academy Award nominations, two Grammy Award nominations, and three Golden Globe nominations. His songs can be heard on over twenty-five million CDs around the world that include recording by Stevie Wonder, Christina Aguilera, Mel Torme, Ricky Martin, Cleo Laine, Barbara Cook, Nancy LaMott, and include the Original Broadway Cast and Soundtrack recordings of The Goodbye Girl, The Women In White, The Swan Princess and Disney’s Hercules and Disney’s Mulan.

David and I first met shortly after we had both arrived in NY in the early 1980’s and have remained friends and colleagues ever since. Today we begin our conversation talking about Coleman’s Russian-Jewish heritage. So many Broadway songwriters -- Irving Berlin, George Gershwin, Richard Rodgers, Harold Arlen, Leonard Bernstein to name just a few were the children or grandchildren of Russian-Jewish immigrants.

If you enjoy this podcast, I invite to join my Broadway Nation Facebook Group where there is a large and lively community of musical theater enthusiasts. We have a great deal of fun and I feel certain that you will too!

And If you would like to hear more about Carolyn Leigh, Dorothy Fields, Betty Comden and other women who invented the Broadway musical, you may want to check out Episode 7 and 8 of Broadway Nation.

Special thanks Special thank the Julia Murney and David David Burnham, everyone at KVSH 101.9 FM the voice of beautiful Vashon, Island Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation.

[0:18] David Armstrong: The podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:29] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and I call this episode Carolyn, Dorothy, David, and More: Cy Coleman's Lyricists.

[0:42] David Armstrong: During an incredible Broadway career that stretched all the way from 1953 to 1998, composer Cy Coleman created the music for 12 Broadway musicals.

[0:53] David Armstrong: Unlike most Broadway composers, however, he never was part of an ongoing songwriting team, but instead worked with seven very talented but very different collaborators.

[1:03] David Armstrong: My guest today is one of those esteemed collaborators, David Zippel, who partnered with Cy Coleman on the score for the 1990 Tony Award-winning Best Musical, City of Angels, the hit musical that altogether received 10 Tony Awards, including Coleman and Zippel's win for Best Score.

[1:20] David Armstrong: That show launched David on his own stellar career, which has been honored with two Academy Award nominations, two Grammy Award nominations, and three Golden Globe nominations.

[1:30] David Armstrong: David's songs can be heard on over 25 million CDs around the world that include recordings by Stevie Wonder, Christina Aguilera, Mel Tormé, Ricky Martin, Cleo Laine, Barbara Cook, Nancy LaMott, and include the original Broadway cast and soundtrack recordings of The Goodbye Girl, The Woman in White, The Swan Princess, and Disney's Hercules and Mulan.

[1:53] David Armstrong: David and I first met shortly after we had both arrived in New York City in the early 1980s, and we've remained friends and colleagues ever since.

[2:02] David Armstrong: Today we begin our conversation by talking about Coleman's Russian Jewish heritage.

[2:07] David Armstrong: So many Broadway songwriters, Irving Berlin, George Gershwin, Richard Rodgers, Harold Arlen, Leonard Bernstein, to name just a few, were the children or grandchildren of Russian Jewish immigrants.

[2:19] David Armstrong: David, what is it about this Russian Jewish heritage that seems to make Broadway songwriters? Did Cy ever say anything about his heritage in that regard?

[2:27] David Zippel: Not really, but I share that heritage. My grandparents were Russian Jewish immigrants on both sides.

[2:34] David Zippel: I maybe it was something that happened in the Shtetl. There's something in the water there, clearly, that created Broadway genius.

[2:43] David Zippel: And good bagels.

[2:44] David Armstrong: And good bagels.

[3:00] David Zippel: So he has this classical music background, and then he has this incredible jazz music background where his trio was quite successful. And then he also said he was very influenced by the Yiddish theater, which his parents took him to when he was a kid. How do you see any of that affecting his writing for the theater?

[3:17] David Zippel: It's interesting. Right before Cy died, he told a story. He was about to go back and perform as a pianist in a jazz club in New York. And he said that he started out as a classical pianist and said he wanted to be a jazz writer.

[3:30] David Zippel: And everyone says, "Oh, you're a classical pianist. You can't do that." And then he became successful as a jazz performer. And he said, "I want to write pop songs." And they said, "Well, you're a jazz performer. That's not what jazz people do." And he said, "I'm gonna do it."

[3:33] David Zippel: And then he became a very successful pop writer and decided he and Carolyn Leigh wanted to write for the theater. And when everyone said, "That's another muscle, you shouldn't try that," he did and became extremely successful.

[3:56] David Zippel: And here he was at the end of his life, going back to a cabaret. He didn't know it was the very end of his life, but in his 70s, and people were saying, "I didn't know you could do that."

[4:04] David Zippel: I think Cy never liked to repeat himself, which is partly why his music is so varied. The man who wrote Little Me and City of Angels sound like different writers.

[4:15] David Zippel: And then to write Witchcraft and On the 20th Century seemed like completely different worlds.

[4:19] David Armstrong: Light years apart, exactly. In order to be a songwriter for the theater, you actually have to be a dramatist in addition to being a composer and a musician.

[4:28] David Armstrong: How did somebody who comes from a music background but then ends up being drawn into the theater? How did that affect his approach to writing a show? How much did he think like a playwright as opposed to a songwriter?

[4:39] David Zippel: I think that's one of Cy's great strengths, is that he was a dramatist. I was gonna say first, but certainly his first approach was how are we telling the story? How will music tell the story?

[4:47] David Zippel: And that's one of the reasons he was always looking for an interesting way into each show that would allow him to tell it in a fresh and exciting way.

[4:58] David Zippel: I found a quote from you that says, "Cy never wants to do the same thing twice. He's always looking for a fresh, original way to tell a story or write a song. He is always looking for a creative challenge."

[5:10] David Zippel: Each lyricist, and I'm happy to be one of them, sparks a different chemistry. So I want to talk about each of those lyricists, and we'll work our way up to your collaboration.

[5:20] David Zippel: And I have to say, it's an extraordinary group of lyricists.

[5:24] David Zippel: Those fingers in my head. That strips my conscience back.

[5:35] David Zippel: It's witchcraft. We start off with Carolyn Leigh, who wrote two Broadway shows with Cy, Wildcat and Little Me, and a number of amazing pop songs, some of the greatest ever, most of them recorded by Sinatra.

[5:51] David Zippel: What are your impressions of Carolyn Leigh's lyrics? And do you remember Cy speaking about her at any point? And did he pass anything on to you from her?

[5:59] David Zippel: I do remember a lot about Cy's thoughts about Carolyn, and also I met her once, probably a couple of months before she passed away. There was a revival of Little Me, and there were two new songs.

[6:11] David Zippel: One was called "I Wanna Be Yours," which is a beautiful song with a terrific Carolyn Leigh lyric.

[6:16] David Zippel: I wanna be tied with velvety strings.

[6:27] David Zippel: Give your beauty rest springs a reason to sigh.

[6:33] David Zippel: I wanna be all the cream in your dairy.

[6:40] David Zippel: Your favorite tooth fairy, the lump in your throat, the light in your eye.

[6:51] David Zippel: I wanna be tried and terribly true.

[6:56] David Zippel: Take oceans of pride in all that you do.

[7:01] David Zippel: Be there nightly when you come home from the war.

[7:08] David Zippel: Cause can't you see? Everybody needs some security.

[7:15] David Zippel: When the going gets scary. Please say you'll be mine.

[7:22] David Zippel: I want to be yours.

[7:25] David Zippel: And I happened to go for the second time to see the show to the closing of the show. And I was on stage, and there was an older woman who turned out to be Carolyn Leigh.

[7:34] David Zippel: And I was in awe of her. And so I told her pretty much that. And I told her particularly that there's a reprise of "I Wanna Be Yours" that is so funny, and the lyric is so outrageous.

[7:46] David Zippel: And I showered some praise on her, probably a little effusively. And the way she accepted the compliment touched me because she seemed so really, "You really liked it."

[7:56] David Zippel: And I was amazed that either she was a pretty good actor or very humble and not as secure as you would think she might be, given her amazing output over her lifetime.

[8:07] David Zippel: Did she know you were an aspiring lyricist at that point?

[8:10] David Zippel: She did. I'm trying to think if I had written with Cy at that point. I know that City of Angels hadn't happened, so no reason that she would have a clue who I was or what I did.

[8:20] David Zippel: But I did tell her I was inspired by her and that her lyrics were important to me. And everything I do owes a little bit of a debt to Carolyn Leigh because she was probably closer to Cole Porter than anyone else, I think.

[8:32] David Zippel: Incredibly sophisticated with great internal rhymes and rhymes across lines. Really smart. I tip my hat to her always.

[8:41] David Zippel: The other song I remember from that revival was "Don't Ask a Lady What a Lady's Doing Now." It was a fantastic new opening number that she wrote, or that they wrote together.

[8:49] David Zippel: With great jokes and right in character.

[8:52] David Zippel: Don't ask a lady what the lady did before.

[8:59] David Zippel: Ask what the lady's doing now.

[9:02] David Zippel: Don't poke around inside the lady's bureau drawer.

[9:07] David Zippel: What's it thrill you? Ain't memorabilia that you are willing to enter into the core.

[9:18] David Zippel: But make it fast before my facelift hits the floor.

[9:23] David Zippel: Don't ask a lady what the lady did before.

[9:29] David Zippel: Ask what the lady's doing before it all needs gluing.

[9:34] David Zippel: Ask what the lady's doing.

[9:39] David Zippel: Don't ask how well I'm doing what others well I'm doing.

[9:45] David Zippel: Ask what the hell I'm doing now.

[9:49] David Zippel: Yeah. She was brilliant and funny. Really funny.

[9:52] David Zippel: And being funny as a lyricist is a hard thing to do. You and Carolyn are in that elect group where the jokes really land.

[10:00] David Zippel: You mentioned Cy talking about Carolyn. Can you share any of those stories with us?

[10:02] David Zippel: They had a fairly contentious relationship, and they fought a fair amount. My favorite story was that they were out of town with Little Me, and Bob Fosse decided he was going to cut one of the songs.

[10:16] David Zippel: And Carolyn was not happy about this. And she went out in the street and she found a traffic cop.

[10:22] David Zippel: And she dragged him back to the theater. And she pointed to the producer Abe Burrows and said, not Abe Burrows, Cy Fur.

[10:29] David Zippel: And she pointed at Cy Fur and she said, "Arrest that man." And she pointed to Bob Fosse and said, "Arrest that man."

[10:35] David Zippel: And she looked at Cy and she thought, "I needed him," so she didn't have him arrested. She was trying to have them arrested for theft because they were cutting one of her songs.

[10:43] David Zippel: And Cy was just standing there, his jaw hit the floor. She was quite a character.

[10:50] David Zippel: All reports are that she was a very brilliant and talented woman, but not an easy collaborator by any means.

[11:00] David Armstrong: So let's talk now about Dorothy Fields, who was the next lyricist that Cy chose to work with.

[11:06] David Armstrong: The miniature walked in the joint.

[11:10] David Armstrong: I could see you were a man of distinction.

[11:15] David Armstrong: Her real big spender.

[12:54] ♪ Musical number: "I Can't Give You Anything But Love" — performed by Dorothy Fields ♪

[12:54] David Armstrong: It's interesting that Cy had those two really creative partnerships with women. Do you think that was just about talent, or was there anything else to the fact of those partnerships?

[12:54] David Zippel: That's a very good question because he also wrote with Betty and Adolph, and Betty was one of the great golden age women lyric writers, too. I'm sure there wasn't an accident there, but I'm not sure the reason for it. Dorothy Fields has already had a legendary career, and I know that she thought her career was over when Cy approached her about writing Sweet Charity, and it added this whole new third act to her career, an incredible third act that most people never get.

[12:54] David Armstrong: Did you ever get to meet her? And what are the songs of hers that influenced you?

[12:54] David Zippel: I regret that I never got to meet her because I admire her enormously. And Dorothy Fields, as you say, early on in her career in the 30s, in a man's world, was a huge force. And she wrote maybe the best love song of all time, "I Can't Give You Anything But Love," at a very young age. She was remarkable and then went on to write the book to Annie Get Your Gun with her brother and worked with Irving Berlin. Quite an amazing career. What I think is particularly remarkable about her is that later in her life, late in her life, in fact, when she was writing with Cy, her ear for the vernacular, her ability to capture the current era never left her. She was always up to the moment. Sweet Charity has such a hip score, and the lyrics like "Big Spender," and even in a ballad, charity's big song at the end.

That was very much of that moment, and it locks you into the 60s in a good way, I think. I admire her enormously. We don't talk about Seesaw very much because it was not nearly the big hit that Sweet Charity was, but again, even a little bit later, she still feels contemporary. And that was her last show.

[13:00] ♪ Musical number ♪

[16:01] David Armstrong: Don't go away. Broadway Nation will be back right after this quick break.

[16:27] David Zippel: So then I'm assuming because Dorothy Fields passes away that Cy has to look for other partners, and he ends up connecting with Michael Stewart, who was most famously a book writer. And I've never quite heard this story about what made him decide to write lyrics somewhat late in his career, and then doing it so brilliantly, and then Cy deciding that was a partnership that would work for him. Do you have any insight into that?

[16:51] David Armstrong: Only that Michael was the dean of Broadway Book Writers, and suddenly he started writing lyrics, and right out of the box he was terrific. They had two big hits. I Love My Wife and Barnum, which are somewhat forgotten. Neither one has been revived, but those were giant hits.

[17:49] David Zippel: When you and I moved to New York, those were the big hit shows of the moment, and both of them have great songs. Really terrific. Up out of your seat. Up out of your seats. Down off of the stand. Down off of the stand. So sweet in your ear. Hear those hip parades. The happy laughter when the music plays. And when you see the leader proudly raised his hand. Just follow the band.

[18:26] David Zippel: So then Cy, as we mentioned a minute ago, starts to collaborate with Betty Comden and Adolph Green. And they do On the Twentieth Century. I was a law student when On the Twentieth Century happened, and I happened to be living in Boston. They were trying out there, and I went to see it three or four times in previews just to see how they would change it. It was quite exciting. That was 1977, I think. And you haven't met Cy at this point.

[18:52] David Zippel: I have not. So that's interesting that you're studying his work in preparation, unbeknownst to any of you for this collaboration that's gonna happen. Even in the 60s, our community theater in my little town in Eastern Pennsylvania did Sweet Charity, and I saw that and was just blown away by the score. He was one of my heroes right from the start. And if someone had whispered in your ear at that moment that you were gonna collaborate with him someday. Would you have believed that? Would that have been anywhere in your world of possibility?

[19:22] David Zippel: It didn't seem impossible to me, but I was also realistic enough to know that it was a long shot. Anything else about On the Twentieth Century? Any observations as you studied them putting it together? One of the things I remember was at the first performance, because I went to the very first performance, and this isn't a story about Cy as much, but Kevin Klein, who was totally unknown at that moment, was so extraordinary that I was sure that he was going to win a Tony Award and become a huge star.

[19:49] David Zippel: By the curtain of the first act, it was clear. He just jumped off that stage. And I didn't see it until the show got to Broadway, but it was one of those very few performances where you feel like they should just hand him the Tony Award at the curtain call because why wait? There's no possibility that anyone else will win the Tony that season. They could have done it in an intermission.

[20:08] David Zippel: So Cy for the next show writes his own lyrics for Welcome to the Club, one of his biggest failed shows. Do you have any insight into how that happened? Could he not find anybody he wanted to work with? Did he always want to try his hand at lyrics? What led to that moment? I don't have a lot of insight into that, but I know that there's some beautiful songs in the show. And of course the infamous "Don't fuck around with your mother-in-law." Lyrics by Cy Coleman.

[20:35] David Zippel: Indeed. And I was at the opening night, I remember at that point, Cy's assistant, who was a terrific woman named Terry Curran, is a terrific woman named Terry Curran. We were hanging around when the reviews started to come out. We ended up just spending most of the evening together. And I don't think Cy had ever had anything like that. Everyone was shocked and blown away by the bad reception to the show. But the music is fantastic. Song after song is just wonderful.

[21:01] David Zippel: And the vagaries of the theater, it's alchemy. You just never know if the combination of the book writer and the idea and the composer and lyricist is going to take root. And the timing of when it gets to the stage. Is it not at the right moment for that show to happen? There's something Cy taught me, which was you never know when something is going to happen. And so keep as many pots boiling on as many burners as you can because best laid plans.

[21:04] David Zippel: You just never know. Often you think, oh my God, I have three things I'm working on. They're all going to happen at the same time, but they almost never do. A star isn't available, a theater isn't available, or a producer passes away. You just never know what's going to happen. So you're in Cy Coleman's world by this point. You're already working on City of Angels. How did that happen?

[21:46] David Zippel: That took longer than I thought it was going to take. I went to law school, and one of my law school classmates was the son of a very prominent theater attorney. And my friend introduced me to his dad, and his dad was impressed and said, I'll represent you. And he also represented Cy Coleman and Larry Gelbart. And I had read about a project they were working on. There was a column in the New York Times called News of the Rialto, and it used to talk about future projects. It was not snarky. It was just a news report. But they talked about a new show called Death is for Suckers by Cy Coleman and Larry Gelbart that was going to be a jazz-based film noir kind of Mickey Spillane musical. And I thought, wow, I would be such the right person for that. I can't imagine that they're going to hire me, but I would be the great person for that.

[22:35] David Zippel: Meanwhile, Albert DeSilva, my attorney, and his wife started pushing Cy to meet with me. You should really meet this kid. He's really talented. They were very lovely and encouraging. And they also were acting like my press agents. And Cy liked for things to be his idea. So he wasn't particularly eager to meet with me. And then I did this off-Broadway show called It's Better With a Band. I started my career with a career retrospective, which is a kind of weird way to begin. But I'd written a few songs, one of which had been recorded by Barbara Cook, who was the only thing I had ever written that had any acclaim. I like to sing, but it's better with a band. I like to play the piano, but it's better with a band.

Ask any bass on soprano from the Met to Texas Land. Singing. Maybe swinging, but baby, it's better with a band. It was the title song of one of her albums. She recorded live at Carnegie Hall. So I worked on putting together a review of my songs with that title, called It's Better with a Band. And they really tried to get Cy to come. And the reviews for that were really good. I was very fortunate. And he finally came, but he still didn't meet with me. And the producer of Barnum, one of his partners, Judy Gordon, another Broadway producer, had seen Barbara Cook's show at Carnegie Hall, and she was calling Cy and said, You really should meet this kid. And I think he felt worked over a little bit.

So he was very resistant. But between that and the success of the review, he finally called me one day to meet. I didn't know why he was calling me, I was just thrilled. And he was proposing that I take a look at the beginning of a book about a musical about cross-dressers. It was a very strange show. And as he pitched it, I was like a little crestfallen because I didn't think I wanted to do it, but I really wanted to work with Cy Coleman. But I didn't say no on the spot. I figured I'd meet with him a couple of times and see what he was proposing. And finally I said, Cy, Lacage Fall has already been done, and this feels a little repetitive. I was hoping that you were calling me about death is for suckers.

And he said, Oh, we're talking to a lot of heavyweights for that show. And I said, Would you consider me for it? And he said, Let me see. We have to pursue a few people, but give me a little bit of time. And about three months later, he called me up and he said, Larry and I talked, and why don't we write three songs together? After which we'll stop and look at them and decide whether we're all going to move forward together, which was a very polite way of saying whether or not I was fired. So I met with him, and the first song he played for me was Music First. And it was very languorous, and it was for the film noir part of the story. Actually, at that point, there only was a film noir part of the story.

The show ultimately became about a writer creating a film noir. So there was a real life element and a fictional element. But at this point, there was only the film noir. And that part of the story had been fleshed out. So I wrote a lyric to that song, which ultimately became Lost and Found.

[25:45] David Zippel: Lost and F. You've earned your salary. Searching for Mallory. Wanna play Lost Ever. Well, then I'm the And they were really very enthusiastic about it and encouraging. One of the things about the project that appealed to him so much was it was going to be what we thought, and I think in fact was the first truly jazz score for a Broadway show. And because, as you mentioned earlier, he was a very successful jazz pianist. This was basically going back to his roots and allowing him to use a side of his talent that not only had he not used in the theater to a great degree, but no one had really tried. We were trying to use vocalese. We had the Angel City 4 that was a jazz quartet that they weren't really narrators, but they were a huge part of the storytelling.

And so by using them, we could take jazz riffs like a trumpet riff, not unlike what Lambert Hendricks and Ross did, and write lyrics, and he would create a jazz feel by using soloist moments, and then we would take them and make them vocal moments. An example of that was the cadenza at the end of Stein's first song. I'm here when nothing's how it looks. No, I'm a stranger in the strangest complex. This mad adventure I've begun. It's gonna be a lot of fun and lots of boo. Another example of using jazz to tell the story was everybody's gotta be somewhere, which is pretty much what would normally be an orchestral moment that I then took and set lyrics to. Try to track your turn. That was very much Sai's intention to write a jazz orchestral moment and then I would set it.

And actually, that was one of the reasons that I was so excited about doing this show, because I grew up listening to Lambert Hendricks and Ross and later other jazz groups. Take a little look, see those rounds there's an underground Crowd Scout. Give a little intuition into a shirt that shouldn't you get it. Keep it up and air, just your bath, let's gonna but cross your mind. If you're not an innuendo round the band or you should get your fine. And the second song, I went into his office and he was about to go on a vacation, and he played me with great pride what he thought was the ballad. It was a moment in the show where the film noir Chanteuse is in a nightclub and she sings this sad song.

And the minute he played it, I thought, this is spectacular. And if I can write a good lyric that pleases him, not only will I have gotten this job, but I will have written a Psy Coleman standard because I thought the music was so good. And while I was in the room, I pitched the title with every breath I take, and he loved it. So I thought, wow, that's a good start. And then he left me with the music, which I recorded on a little uh walk man, and went on a vacation for about 10 days. And during that time, I wrote my first version, which I really liked, and then I thought, this is so important. So I kept rewriting it. And I wrote 12 or 13 different versions of the same song, the same title. And I went to see him into his office, and I put them in a pile on the top of his piano.

He sat down and he said, Let me play through this. And he played through and sang the first version. There's not a morning that I open up my eyes and find I do dream of you. Without a warning, though it's never a surprise. Which was all he saw because he didn't realize that there were 13 versions behind it. And as he finished it, he said, This is terrific. Let's call Larry and play it for him. So while he went to the phone to get Larry's number, I slipped away the other 12 versions. And from then on, I was their partner, and we finished the show together. You were the one who said forever from the start. And I've been drifting since you out on a lonely sea that only you can chart. I've been going on that my heart will be breath.

[31:39] David Zippel: So now you're in this world, you have to be just blown away by realizing this opportunity and having it all come true, as the song says. What then is this process? As you said, the show is still in a very early stage. Only the black and white half of the show exists at this point, not the color part of the show. What was your interaction in the development of that? At that point, after we had written about three or four songs, we flew out and met with Larry. And Larry said, I love what you guys are doing. I'm feeling like you're creating something really original and new. And all I'm doing is writing a parody of a film noir. I want to come up with something that's as fresh as what you're doing.

Give me a few weeks, which turned out to be a few months. He said, I want to think this through. And when I have something that I'm excited about, I'll call you. So everything stopped for a little bit. And then Larry said, come to California. And Cy and I flew out there for one of the most exciting eight or nine days of my life. Larry had the idea of telling the two stories, and we sat down, and the three of us, together with Larry leading the way, outlined the entire story. He had the characters, and we talked about when they sang, what each scene was supposed to accomplish. First, we did the plot, then we added the songs. And by the time those nine days were over, we had a complete outline, and the show changed almost not at all from that.

[33:00] David Zippel: So you've got the outline, you've got the show ready to go into the final phases of writing and into production. What developed next? Because we lived on opposite coasts. Larry lived in Beverly Hills, and Cy and I were New Yorkers. We would meet on the phone. We would fax things back and forth to each other. And in those days, there was no way to email a song. So those were played over the phone whenever we were ready. And every two or three months, we would meet mostly in California, which I always welcomed the opportunity. It was sunny and lovely. And we would fly out there and integrate the scenes and the songs and polish everything together. When I got the job officially, I was so excited and a little unnerved at the enormity of the opportunity. And I just wanted to deliver for them. And Cy, who was wonderful, treated me like a gifted protege that you might pat on the head.

[33:51] David Zippel: And Larry, right from the start, treated me like an equal. I don't know that I deserved it, but I like that. Eventually, Cy and I became great friends and I was promoted to a full partner. I think we were all giddy about how it was turning out. We were in love with the project and with what each of us had created, that it was a very exciting atmosphere. And it took three years to actually get on. But I don't know that I would have traded a moment. One of the things that was amazing, Cy had a house in Southampton, and there were times when he would want to work in the summer, and so he would say, just come out for a few days. And I would come out and we'd write all day. And then at night he would have guests come to dinner.

And so one night it was Bob Fosse, and another night it was Betty and Adolf. It was just dazzling to me to be in the middle of all these Broadway greats. And I kept pinching myself because it was a dream come true. And so then in a similar vein, City of Angels opens, it wins six Tony Awards, including Best Musical and Best Score. So you and Cy win Tony Awards together for the show. Which now puts you in this world of Broadway Tony Award-winning writers. It was just a thrilling time to be a part of something that I had loved and longed to be a part of all of my life. Cy used to talk about having a show running. The best part about having a show running, he said, was having a place to pee in the middle of the Times Square theater.

[35:20] David Armstrong: That's so funny. I think you are one of the rare people that is a crossover between the Golden Age of Broadway and the modern era, right up to today. Not that you personally go back to the Golden Age of Broadway, but you had this opportunity to collaborate with several figures from that era and at least for a period while they were still around, be a contemporary of those writers. I find this fascinating because you will pass this on to somebody else. And that legacy chain, I think, is unequaled in any other business.

[35:51] David Zippel: It's interesting that you say that because in many ways, my relationship with Cy was analogous to his relationship with Dorothy, because she was considerably older than he was and had an illustrious career before working with him. But Cy had already had great success by then. I was completely fresh off the boat when I started working with Cy right off the farm. But I think your point is right. She was of an earlier era. She's of what I call the Silver Age of Broadway. She's one of those rare people that crossed from the Silver Age into the Golden Age very successfully and had her biggest successes in this new kind of writing. And Cy is somebody who crosses from the Golden Age into the modern era very successfully.

And that's also rare. So I do think the analogy is very appropriate. And Dorothy, not unlike her collaborator Irving Berlin, also had his great successes in the Golden Age, although he was iconic in the Silver Age, as you dubbed it. I think that's a great naming, actually. To me, it just helps people understand what's the difference between the two things. And really the difference is the focus on the book. The Golden Age is about the story is going to drive the show. And the Silver Age is the songs drive the show. And that's why we don't do those shows anymore. They didn't have a story that compelled them to be remembered and revived. A lot of the Silver Age Broadway guys were most successful on the silver screen.

[37:09] David Armstrong: Yeah, where it was all about the songs. They could just focus on writing a song and not have to worry about the story. This was not the only show that you worked on with Cy, unfortunately. It's the only one we've all gotten to see. Tell us a little bit about the other projects that you worked with Cy on over the years.

[37:25] David Zippel: There were two more. One what we were about half written when Cy passed away, called N, simply the letter N, which stood for Napoleon.

[38:26] ♪ Musical number: "Only the Rest of My Life" — performed by David Zippel ♪

[40:15] David Zippel: And based on that, we were going to go to Palo Alto to Theatreworks, who had done a lot of Wendy's premieres and start the show. We were just so excited about going back into rehearsal and trying to put the show together. And Cy passed away really suddenly, had a heart attack. And so Wendy and I and Cy's age and everybody said, What are we going to do? And we decided that the show was in good enough shape that we could actually go into rehearsal. So we decided to wait a year and do it the following year. And then Wendy got sick, and not too long after that she passed away. So I thought that was a lost show. But Graziella Danielle, the director and the choreographer, didn't want to give up, and neither did I. And we did a concert version for Broadway Cares, and we thought that would get it off the ground and nothing happened.

And then out of the blue, a producer from the small theater in New Jersey called us. He had been working at the public theater when we presented it to them many years before and had never forgotten it and said he'd love the show and he'd love to do it. And we did a world premiere there about a year and a half, two years ago. And we finally, after 15 years, got to do the show that we had always hoped to do. And it was a really happy experience. I think there could be a life for it after that. I think it goes back to Cy's advice to you about the ephemeral nature of writing for the theater. Do you never know what's going to happen when these projects are going to come together, when they're not going to come together?

In terms of contemporary theater, COVID has had a devastating effect on so many shows. The City of Angels was in previews in London and was going to open the following week and had been extremely well received by the audiences. And COVID just closed it like so many shows, cold in the middle of the week. When we recorded this episode, David's current project was also on hold because of COVID. That show is, of course, Andrew Lloyd Webber's new version of Cinderella, for which David has created the lyrics. But over the last few weeks, Cinderella finally opened to rave reviews in London. Nothing would make me happier than for us all to be able to take a COVID-safe trip to London to see Cinderella and City of Angels on the same day would be my dream.

[42:23] David Armstrong: I would love to be there with you, hopefully soon.

[42:26] David Zippel: Absolutely. Thank you, David Zippel. This has been an absolute pleasure. There's so much more we could have covered, and we'll have you back at some point to talk about your many other projects with other great composers. But I think this has been fantastic to look at Cy Coleman's career through the eyes of David Zippel.

[42:41] David Zippel: Thank you, and I've enjoyed talking to you so much.

[42:44] David Zippel: It all begins with Make Believe. A sudden spark of inspiration. And every note of everything started with a dream.

[43:14] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. If you enjoyed this podcast, I invite you to join my Broadway Nation Facebook group, where there's a large and lively community of musical theater enthusiasts. We have a great deal of fun, and I feel certain that you will too. And if you'd like to hear more about Carolyn Leigh, Dorothy Fields, Betty Comden, and other women who invented the Broadway musical, you may want to check out episodes seven and eight of Broadway Nation. Special thanks to Julia Murney and David David Burnham, to everyone at KVSH 101.9 FM, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

[43:53] ♪ Musical number ♪

[43:57] ♪ Musical number ♪

[44:05] ♪ Musical number ♪

[44:13] ♪ Musical number ♪

[44:18] ♪ Musical number ♪

[44:22] ♪ Musical number ♪

[44:37] ♪ Musical number ♪

[44:45] ♪ Musical number ♪

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred