Skip to main content
BPN Logo

Featured Shows

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:03] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation.

[0:06] David Armstrong: Come along, get ready with brand brand new gas.

[0:12] David Armstrong: Well, there's going to be a meeting in this good, good old town.

[0:18] David Armstrong: When you know everybody, and they all know you, and you get a rabbit foot to keep up with them who do.

[0:29] David Armstrong: The podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:41] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and this is the second episode of a new Broadway Nation miniseries that explores what I'm calling the Other Broadway.

[0:50] David Armstrong: My baby, when you hear them bells go dang a lane.

[0:57] David Armstrong: All dine around, and sweetie you must sing, and the first them too.

[1:05] David Armstrong: In the courts we'll all dine in, there'll be a hot time in Old Tales tonight.

[1:19] David Armstrong: And in the very first lecture of each quarter, I ask my students how they would define the word Broadway.

[1:25] David Armstrong: What does it mean to them?

[1:26] David Armstrong: The responses usually boil down to one of two answers.

[1:30] David Armstrong: Either they say it's a geographical location, New York's Theater District, with its 41 theaters nestled in and around Times Square, or they say it's the work that was done there, those great plays and legendary musicals that originated in those theaters, but now are produced around the world.

[1:48] David Armstrong: And I think both answers are correct.

[1:50] David Armstrong: But there is an equally valid third answer.

[1:53] David Armstrong: During the first half of the 20th century, those five decades during which Broadway was at the very center of American culture, the word Broadway meant even more.

[2:03] David Armstrong: It was pretty universally understood to refer to not just the plays, musicals, and reviews that you could see in a Times Square theater, but also, and perhaps even more so, to the nightlife that surrounded them.

[2:16] David Armstrong: From 1910 through at least 1960, there were hundreds of cabarets, speakeasies, and nightclubs all crammed into the theater district.

[2:24] David Armstrong: And they exemplified Broadway just as much as what was happening in the theaters.

[2:29] David Armstrong: Last week, in the first episode in this series, we began to explore the origins of New York nightlife, and we journeyed back in time to America's first restaurant, Delmonico's, where we dined in high style with Mrs. Astor and her famous 400 on Steak Delmonico, Chicken A la King, and Baked Alaska, which by the way, Delmonico seems to have invented in 1867 to celebrate America's purchase of the Alaskan territories from Russia.

[2:57] David Armstrong: Then we strolled a few blocks down fashionable 14th Street to Luchows, where I suspect we had a much better time rubbing elbows with the prosperous immigrants, Jews, musicians, songwriters, and the other show folk who hung out there and who would never have been welcome at Delmonico's.

[3:13] David Armstrong: And by the end of the episode, Delmonico's had made its final move north to 44th Street, where nearby both Fifth Avenue and Broadway had become lined with other fashionable restaurants that were inspired by Delmonico's success.

[3:27] David Armstrong: But that's only half of the story.

[3:29] David Armstrong: Just one block west of Broadway, there was a whole other world to explore, the area known as the Tenderloin.

[3:36] David Armstrong: Now, this neighborhood expanded and contracted over the years, but the heart of it was roughly where Macy's, Penn Station, Madison Square Garden, and what's left of the Garment District are today.

[3:47] David Armstrong: From about 1870 to 1910, this was New York's largest entertainment and red light district.

[3:54] David Armstrong: It was teeming with bars, dance halls, concert saloons, gambling casinos, bordellos, and clip joints of every kind.

[4:02] David Armstrong: It was a lot like the infamous Storyville district in New Orleans, or San Francisco's Barbary Coast during the Gold Rush era, or rough and ready towns like Tombstone, Arizona, or Deadwood, South Dakota, the way you've seen them portrayed in countless films and television shows set in the wild, wild west.

[4:19] David Armstrong: Religious conservatives and social reformers declared the tenderloin to be an abomination, a modern day version of Sodom and Gomorrah.

[4:28] David Armstrong: And the sensational newspapers of the day dubbed it Satan's Circus.

[4:32] David Armstrong: Hundreds of impoverished Irish, Italian, Jewish, and other immigrants lived in the tenderloin, packed into crowded tenements.

[4:40] David Armstrong: And it was also home to New York's largest black population during this period.

[4:45] David Armstrong: After dark, the streets of the tenderloin hosted a sexy, boozy, nonstop party where people of every class, race, and color mixed and mingled, all in search of a good time.

[4:57] David Armstrong: Officially, those at the very top of New York society would never even consider visiting the tenderloin.

[5:03] David Armstrong: They viewed it as a dark and dangerous blight on New York City.

[5:07] David Armstrong: However, on the down low, countless wealthy young bachelors went slumming there on a nightly basis, along with quite a few married men who otherwise were considered to be pillars of society.

[5:18] David Armstrong: And according to various reports, they were joined there by merchants, bank clerks, bookkeepers, stockbrokers, insurance brokers, city, county, and state officeholders, reverend judges, college boys, sailors, firemen, pimps, and thieves.

[5:34] David Armstrong: As you can see, the clientele was mostly male, but in addition to the performers, prostitutes, barmaids, and other working women, quite a few lower class and even some middle class women came there to eat, drink, and be entertained.

[5:49] David Armstrong: The Tenderloin's most famous dance hall was the Haymarket on 6th Avenue and 30th Street.

[5:54] David Armstrong: There you could experience three floors of rowdy, racy, raucous entertainment and amusement.

[6:00] David Armstrong: Again, picture a wild west dancehall in a movie western with high-kicking saloon girls dancing the can and a brass band blaring out tarara boom die.

[6:39] David Armstrong: Nicknamed the Prostitutes Market, the Haymarket was a veritable sin shopping mall.

[6:45] David Armstrong: Ladies luring men to tables to buy them champagne, shower them with presents, and quite often making their way to curtained rooms in the balcony and upper floors.

[6:54] David Armstrong: If you preferred male prostitutes, you simply made your way to the back entrance.

[6:59] David Armstrong: In the 1890s, the Tenderloin's reputation grew as New York's liveliest party, a flashy, fleshy dive, thumbing its nose at society.

[7:09] David Armstrong: Women drank for free and were allowed to carouse and drink freely with the men who paid a one-quarter entrance fee for the privilege of joining them.

[7:16] David Armstrong: Naturally, the Haymarket thrived with the help of police corruption and bribery.

[7:21] David Armstrong: $250 a week greased the palms of law enforcement who looked the other way.

[7:26] David Armstrong: In today's money, that 25 cent entrance fee would be the equivalent of nearly $8, and that $250 bribe would be the equivalent of nearly $8,000.

[7:38] David Armstrong: But the Haymarket was far from your only option.

[7:41] David Armstrong: It's estimated that there were more than 200 dance halls and concert saloons in the Tenderloin.

[7:46] David Armstrong: Many of them were operated by black owners and catered to black customers.

[7:51] David Armstrong: These included several that were called black and tan saloons, because whites and blacks of both sexes mixed and mingled there.

[8:03] David Armstrong: Music was everywhere in the Tenderloin, so it was perhaps inevitable that the newly emerging music publishing industry would make its home there as well.

[8:12] David Armstrong: All of those dance halls, concert saloons, gambling casinos, and even the houses of ill repute were perfect venues for sheet music pluggers to push their wares and get their latest songs heard.

[8:23] David Armstrong: In those days, of course, success in the music business wasn't measured in album sales or concert tickets, but rather in the number of copies of sheet music that were sold.

[8:32] David Armstrong: It's been said that more popular music was created in the first decade of the 20th century than in the entirety of human history before then.

[8:41] David Armstrong: This is the era when popular songs began to sell millions of copies of sheet music.

[8:46] David Armstrong: And in fact, one of the few remaining remnants of the Tenderloin is a line of small row houses on 28th Street, where many of the most beloved tunes in the great American songbook were written.

[8:57] David Armstrong: That is, of course, the legendary Tin Pan Alley, which just last month, April 2022, was finally designated an official New York landmark and historic district in honor of its contribution to American culture.

[9:10] David Armstrong: How exactly Tin Pan Alley got its ironic name is not entirely clear.

[9:15] David Armstrong: The most commonly told story is that a reporter for the New York Herald was walking down 28th Street on a hot summer day when the windows of the dozens of music publishing houses that were crammed into that one block were all wide open, and he was assaulted by the dissonant sound of dozens and dozens of pianos all banging out tunes at the same time.

[9:34] David Armstrong: And he declared that for all their effort it sounded like nothing more than a bunch of tin pans clanging together.

[9:57] David Armstrong: Not to mention the mixing of the races that could be found there.

[10:01] David Armstrong: They were constantly pressuring the police and elected officials to clean up the Tenderloin.

[10:06] David Armstrong: This was the inspiration for Bachenharnick's 1960 musical Tenderloin. In one of its most memorable songs, a group of working girls reacts to a clergyman's campaign to put them out of business.

[10:19] David Armstrong: Why can't this damn do-gooder keep his hands off? Little old New York is planning. Good enough for me. Good enough for me. Good enough for me. Little old New York is planning. Good enough for me. Keep your hands off, little old New York. Don't want no Bible spouting, the gospel shout. Preacher nosing around, drying everything up, closing everything down. Don't want no rolling poly, holy moly, purifying the time. Not my little New York.

[11:06] David Armstrong: But of course, the tenderloin was big business, and a significant portion of the money that flowed into it then trickled up to all levels of New York City's political machine. And in the second act, the denizens of the tenderloin explain exactly how the system works.

[11:29] David Armstrong: Yes, it's grand how the money changes hands. Everybody's happy. That's the way she stands. Just as long as the money changes hands. So the men pay the girls. And the girls pay Liz. And Liz pays the cops. And the cops pay Fry. And you pay Schmidt. And Schmidt pays the Alderman. And the Alderman pays the mayor. Everybody's happy. That's the way she stands. Just as long as the money changes her. Just as long as the money changes her.

[12:16] David Armstrong: But in the end, it wasn't the reformers that shut down the tenderloin. It was gentrification. Just after the turn of the century, much of the area was condemned, and 500 buildings were torn down to make way for the original Pennsylvania station. This, of course, displaced thousands of residents, including a large portion of New York's black population, who now began to move into Harlem.

[12:39] David Armstrong: The construction of Penn Station took five years, and during that time, another building boom was underway. This time it was in the blocks above 42nd Street in the area soon to be known as Times Square. And a new era of New York nightlife was born when a number of spectacularly designed before and after theater restaurants opened all along Broadway. They were known as the Lobster Palaces.

[13:04] David Armstrong: One observer called it an age of mammoth hotels, restaurant parties, and ragtime tunes. Don't go away. Right after this quick break, I'll take you on a tour of the lobster palaces of Broadway.

[13:58] David Armstrong: These included Churchill's, Martin's, Maxim's, Murray's Roman Gardens, Shanley's, Risenweber's, and Rectors. They created an opulent and slightly naughty experience that catered to the theatrical crowd that surged nightly in and out of theaters in search of a pre-show dinner or an after-theater supper.

[14:18] David Armstrong: And these restaurants appealed to the growing ranks of prosperous nouveau riche city dwellers, many of whom lived in luxurious but not exclusive apartments on the Upper West Side, and the Lobster Palaces provided them with a somewhat more democratic version of the socially exclusive dining rooms that lined Fifth Avenue.

[14:36] David Armstrong: The Lobster Palaces pioneered a slightly racy, celebratory style that was showier than the Waldorf's or Delmonico's. Here, theatrical successes and sporting achievements were toasted with the popping of champagne corks. As George Rector said, Sherries and Delmonico's served the 400. But Rectors not only attracted the 400, it also served most of New York's 4 million.

[15:01] David Armstrong: While the Astor's and other white establishment families had been the money behind the hotel restaurants of Fifth Avenue, it was Irish, German, Swiss, and French immigrants that created the restaurants of Broadway. Most of them started at the bottom of the restaurant business before working their way up and becoming wildly successful.

[15:19] David Armstrong: In 1902, three brothers from the Basque region of France, Andre, Jacques, and Louis Bastonaby, opened their Café des Beaux-Arts at 40th Street and 6th Avenue. It was an instant sensation with its orchestra, French menu, and sexy young European waiters. Churchill's, which opened at 49th and Broadway in 1909, had 300 employees and could seat 1,400 customers.

[15:44] David Armstrong: It was rumored to have cost $3 million to build. And $3 million in 1909 money would have the buying power of more than $90 million today. Much like a modern Las Vegas hotel and casino, no expense was spared in outfitting these restaurants with lavish and spectacular decor. Their immersive fantasy environments gave everyone the chance to feel like they were one of the 400 on a grand tour of old world Europe or as if they had been transported by a time machine back to the ancient past.

[16:17] David Armstrong: Murray's Roman Gardens on 42nd Street transported diners back to ancient Rome with a main dining room that was built to resemble the atrium of a Roman villa. Rectors was decorated in the green and gold furnishings of Louis XIV, the Sun King. The Hotel Martinique at Broadway and 32nd Street had a main dining room modeled after the Apollo Gallery at the Louvre.

[16:40] David Armstrong: Julius Keller, a Swiss immigrant, opened the Café de France at 38th Street and Broadway, but it failed to catch on until he dressed his waiters like servants to Louis XIV, hired an orchestra, and most importantly, borrowed the name of the most famous restaurant in Paris and probably the most famous restaurant in the world, Maximes.

[17:01] David Armstrong: This name change was almost certainly inspired by the international smash hit operetta The Merry Widow, which had recently taken Broadway by storm. That show's third act is set entirely in Maxim's, and its first act finale is this hit song.

[17:38] David Armstrong: The atmosphere is places, my dear Os. I'll write rice champagne. Where wine and women rain, I'll send my troubles chasing my lovingly embracing. No, don't you? Glocklama go through fru. Their experts are relaxing. My dear. Who wouldn't want to go there?

[18:12] David Armstrong: And all of the lobster palaces employed the most up-to-date cutting-edge technology of the day: electric lights. It was the use of thousands of light bulbs to decorate the exteriors of these restaurants as well as the theaters that gave Broadway its enduring nickname, the Great White Way.

[18:30] David Armstrong: And the lobster palaces also pioneered the use of electric lights to provide interior spaces with theatrical drama and romance. Murray's featured a painted sky filled with twinkling electric stars and a silvery moon. Service had to be exquisitely courteous and perfect.

[18:49] David Armstrong: George Rector wrote: Not one of our patrons has ever had to remind one of our waiters that he was a waiter, or myself that I was there to look after his comfort. It was essential to have a staff that could take orders. In Rector's opinion, American boys did not make good waiters because they considered themselves to be just as good as the guests. Immigrants made better servants.

[19:11] David Armstrong: Whenever possible, restaurants obtained their help from Europe, because as Rector continued, they were polished, subservient, and of handsome appearance. We had one motto: the guest is right, right or wrong. This was an era characterized by large meals. And here, Diamond Jim Brady makes another appearance.

[19:31] David Armstrong: He was a symbol of the businessman of his day who could conspicuously consume more than a lesser man would be able to do. A regular now at Rector's, he would start a meal by drinking three or four carafts of orange juice. Then he would eat two or three dozen oysters before moving on to a dozen hard shell crabs. Often he would follow this with six or seven lobsters and then some steaks and chops.

[19:56] David Armstrong: He finished off with coffee, cakes, pastry, and bonbons. And then, after attending the theater, he would return to Rector's for a midnight supper. Unlike the following generation that would crave action and activity, this generation gloried in the sedentary behavior of large, long, elaborate, multi-course meals that demonstrated that they had risen above the hustle and bustle that working class people were subjected to.

[20:22] David Armstrong: However, unlike the exclusive Fifth Avenue hotels, Broadway restaurants were always open to the fast crowd from the expanding fields of show business and music publishing.

[20:33] David Armstrong: In fact, one of the major attractions of dining in the lobster palaces was the opportunity to see at close range the leading Broadway figures of the day.

[20:42] David Armstrong: You might catch a glimpse of the vivacious star Anna Held and her husband Florence Ziegfeld, or you might be seated at a table next to Faye Templeton, Nora Bays, George M. Cohan, or one of those famous Floridora girls, all of whom married millionaires.

[20:58] David Armstrong: It was here that actors and actresses perfected the art of the entrance.

[21:02] David Armstrong: All heads would turn to see them gliding down magnificent staircases like the one at Rector's for a late-night supper.

[21:09] David Armstrong: It was in the lobster palaces where Broadway stars invented and perfected the art of the entrance.

[21:16] David Armstrong: All heads would turn to see them gliding down magnificent staircases like the one at Rectors for a late-night supper.

[21:23] David Armstrong: Here is how those entrances were described.

[21:26] David Armstrong: The time is somewhere between 11:30 and midnight.

[21:29] David Armstrong: The orchestra is playing when it is suddenly called to a halt.

[21:33] David Armstrong: The leader has caught sight of a star just about to enter.

[21:37] David Armstrong: If she is not a star recognizable on sight, he has probably been tipped off in advance as to her identity.

[21:44] David Armstrong: There is a pause of silence during which all conversation ceases.

[21:48] David Armstrong: Then the orchestra strikes up the song currently associated with the star, who blushing faintly glides swan-like to her table, skin dazzling, diamonds winking, profile at the proper tilt.

[22:02] David Armstrong: Her escort, probably hidden behind the blanket of violets that are her evening's tribute, knows his name will go down in history.

[22:10] David Armstrong: Yes, I agree.

[22:12] David Armstrong: It sounds a lot like Dolly Levi's entrance at the Harmonia Gardens.

[22:16] David Armstrong: And Rectors itself became something of a Broadway star.

[22:20] David Armstrong: In the 1908 play The Easiest Way, produced by David Belasco, the heroine grows weary of trying to live a virtuous life and finally declares, I'm gonna dress up my body and paint my face.

[22:33] David Armstrong: Yes, I'm going back to Rectors to make a hit, and to hell with the rest of it.

[22:38] David Armstrong: The following year, a sex farce titled The Girl from Rectors opened at Weber's Music Hall, and the Ziegfeld Follies of 1913 introduced a hit song titled If a Table at Rectors Could Talk.

[22:50] David Armstrong: There is a tavern in our town, in our town.

[22:54] David Armstrong: There at night I sit me down, sits me down to dine and wine with lots of free.

[23:02] David Armstrong: For laughter is the only thing that's free at Rectors.

[23:06] David Armstrong: I was sitting at my table laughing all that I was able when I thought, I thought a funny little thought.

[23:14] David Armstrong: What a funny thing would be in the year 1913.

[23:18] David Armstrong: If a table at Rectors could talk.

[23:23] David Armstrong: What a lot of things you'd hear through your conversations here.

[23:27] David Armstrong: If a table at Rectors could talk.

[23:32] David Armstrong: You'd hear what someone's Adam said to someone else's ease.

[23:37] David Armstrong: You'd hear some men don't have to wear a mustache to deceive.

[23:42] David Armstrong: You'd hear how wise a tailor made your poker partner sleeve.

[23:47] David Armstrong: You'd hear a party that's losing a walk.

[23:51] David Armstrong: You'd hear how Susie Butlight does it on eighteen per week.

[23:56] David Armstrong: You'd hear who made the manager give her them lines to speak.

[24:01] David Armstrong: And a lot of men would pony up a lot of alimony.

[24:07] David Armstrong: If a table at Rectors could talk.

[24:43] David Armstrong: Many of these prosperous young and not so young men viewed the lobster palaces as a bohemian opportunity to meet and mix with the charming actresses and actors of the theater, especially the vivacious chorus girls of the musical comedy stage, who would be invited to late night after theater dinners of champagne and lobster, which were dubbed bird and bottle dinners.

[25:06] David Armstrong: This interaction and interplay between these rich sugar daddies and the primarily working class chorus girls would become one of the defining obsessions of the era.

[25:16] David Armstrong: And these so-called gold diggers would continue to be the subject of numerous plays, novels, movies, and songs up through at least the 1950s.

[25:25] David Armstrong: And that's a subject that probably rates a future episode of its own.

[25:29] David Armstrong: Most of the celebrating happened within the propriety of the public dining rooms.

[25:33] David Armstrong: However, many restaurants offered private dining rooms as well.

[25:37] David Armstrong: We see echoes of these in both Funny Girl and the Curtain Dining Rooms of Hello Dolly.

[25:42] David Armstrong: We also get a glimpse of this world, if not of a lobster house itself, in the musical Ragtime.

[25:48] David Armstrong: In Ragtime's opening number, the scandalous Stanford White murder case is declared to be the crime of the century, even though it's only 1906 and there were 94 years to go.

[26:00] David Armstrong: Among Ragtime's featured characters is Evelyn Nesbitt, who in 1900 made her Broadway debut in the musical sensation Floridora.

[26:10] David Armstrong: She soon began an affair with the married society architect Stanford White, who often wined and dined her at Rectors.

[26:17] David Armstrong: Your honor.

[26:20] David Armstrong: I was once the lady friend of Stanford White.

[26:23] David Armstrong: He's a famous architect.

[26:25] David Armstrong: Yes, that's right.

[26:26] David Armstrong: He put me on a velvet swing and made me wear, well, hardly anything.

[26:34] David Armstrong: Ruined at the age of 15.

[26:36] David Armstrong: Then in 1905, she married Pittsburgh steel heir Harry K. Thaw.

[26:40] David Armstrong: The following year, Thaw became deranged and shot and killed Stanford White for deflowering his wife before their marriage.

[26:48] David Armstrong: Your honor, then I went and married Mr. Harry Thaw.

[26:51] David Armstrong: Eccentric millionaire.

[26:56] David Armstrong: Oh, ah!

[26:57] David Armstrong: Harry's a jealous man.

[26:59] David Armstrong: Bang! Bang!

[27:00] David Armstrong: That was the end of Stan.

[27:05] David Armstrong: My Harry went crazy, I swear!

[27:07] David Armstrong: His trial became a media sensation.

[27:12] David Armstrong: Crime of the century, giving the world a thrill.

[27:17] David Armstrong: Harry's in trouble, and Stan is in heaven, and Evelyn is in Vodeville.

[27:29] David Armstrong: Fortune fame and a ruined man.

[27:32] David Armstrong: And now I'm a girl on the swing.

[27:35] David Armstrong: The Thaw White case was only one of many that were heavily covered in the newly popular Sunday newspaper supplements, themselves an innovation of the 1890s.

[27:44] David Armstrong: Stanny's in heaven and Evelyn gets publicity.

[27:49] David Armstrong: And the press reveled in the theme of the defilement of innocent womanhood by pleasure hungry men.

[27:55] David Armstrong: Stanny's killed, but my mother's thrilled, because now I'm the girl on the, now I'm the girl on the swing.

[28:05] David Armstrong: This kind of national attention on the public and private misbehavior of the rich and powerful provided shocking and dramatic evidence that urban life was changed.

[28:15] David Armstrong: And the rigid mores of the Victorian era were starting to crack.

[28:25] David Armstrong: And on the next episode in this series, that crack will widen as the music, performance styles, and especially the public dancing of the Tenderloin and other black and immigrant neighborhoods will begin to invade the lobster palaces and transform them from restaurants into cabarets.

[28:45] David Armstrong: I'm happy to say that the audience for Broadway Nation just keeps growing and growing, and I love to hear from my listeners.

[28:52] David Armstrong: Whether this is your first time listening to Broadway Nation or you're a longtime fan, I would love to hear from you.

[28:58] David Armstrong: You can find me on Instagram at David at Broadway Nation, on Twitter at Podcast Broadway, or message me on the website, Broadway-Nation.com.

[29:09] David Armstrong: Or best of all, join the more than 2,000 fans of this podcast in our extremely fun and interactive Broadway Nation Facebook group.

[29:18] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong.

[29:23] David Armstrong: There are two books that were immensely informative and helpful in creating this episode.

[29:27] David Armstrong: The first is called Steppin' Out: New York Nightlife and the Transformation of American Culture by Lewis Ehrenberg.

[29:35] David Armstrong: The second is Inventing Times Square, Commerce and Culture at the Crossroads of the World, which is a collection of articles and essays edited by William Taylor.

[29:44] David Armstrong: Both are terrific, and I highly recommend them.

[29:48] David Armstrong: Special thanks to KVSH 101.9, The Voice of Beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred