This is the third part of my conversation with author Margaret Hall, whose captivating new book is titled Gemignani – Life And Lessons From Broadway And Beyond. If you missed the first two parts you may want to catch up on those episodes before listening to this one... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
Featured Shows
About
This is the third part of my conversation with author Margaret Hall, whose captivating new book is titled Gemignani – Life And Lessons From Broadway And Beyond.
If you missed the first two parts you may want to catch up on those episodes before listening to this one.
As the title suggests Margaret’s book is a biography of Paul Gemignani who served as the Music Director for more than 40 Broadway musicals including the 3 shows that are the focus of this episode.
The first two are Sweeny Todd and Merrily We Roll Along and Gemignani’s contribution to these musicals and his close working relationship with Stephen Sondheim and Hal Prince has been widely acknowledged but never to the level of detail and insight that Margaret brings to them. However, Gemignani’s enormous contribution to the development of Dreamgirls and his close collaboration with that show’s director and creator, Michael Bennett, has been a closely guarded secret for decades and was revealed for the first time in Margaret’s book. You will hear the reasons for all of this mystery and subterfuge later in the episode.
We also focus briefly on Paul's work on the Broadway musical EVITA and his interactions with Andrew Lloyd Webber and Patti Lupone.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:08] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.
[0:22] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and I call this episode Sweeney, Merrily, Dream Girls, and Gemignani.
[0:29] David Armstrong: This is the third part of my conversation with author Margaret Hall, whose captivating new book is titled Gemignani: Life and Lessons from Broadway and Beyond.
[0:40] David Armstrong: If you missed the first two parts, you may want to catch up on those episodes before listening to this one.
[0:45] David Armstrong: As the title suggests, Margaret's book is a biography of Paul Gemignani, who served as the music director for more than 40 Broadway musicals, including the three shows that are the focus of this episode.
[0:58] David Armstrong: The first two are Sweeny Todd and Merrily We Roll Along, and Gemignani's contribution to these musicals and his close working relationship with both Stephen Sondheim and Harold Prince has been widely acknowledged, but never to the level of detail and insight that Margaret brings to them.
[1:16] David Armstrong: However, Gemignani's enormous contribution to the development of Dream Girls and his close collaboration with that show's director and creator Michael Bennett has been a closely guarded secret for decades and is revealed for the first time in Margaret's book.
[1:31] David Armstrong: And you will learn the reasons for all of this mystery and subterfuge later in the episode.
[1:37] David Armstrong: Here we go.
[1:38] Margaret Hall: We talked about Pacific Overtures being one of the most challenging jobs he ever had or anyone ever had.
[1:45] Margaret Hall: Now he ups the ante even more, at least Sondheim does with Sweeny Todd.
[1:49] Margaret Hall: Oh, yes. And Sweeney is Paul's favorite show.
[1:53] Margaret Hall: He doesn't like to name a favorite that he's done, but if you sort of gun against a wall, it's Sweeny Todd.
[2:00] Margaret Hall: He loves Sweeney. And that really became a family of a company in like every way.
[2:05] Margaret Hall: Everyone's on the top of their game. You will never find a better leading lady than Angela Lansbury.
[2:10] Margaret Hall: The epitome of elegance, but also hysterics.
[2:13] Margaret Hall: This nonchalant of like it's not that serious, but also we're taking it serious.
[2:18] Margaret Hall: But if something happens, it's not the end of the world. And that's okay.
[2:20] Margaret Hall: There's lots of little pranks that are mentioned within the Sweeny Todd chapter.
[2:25] Margaret Hall: Lynn Carey, who is just a feat of nature and a force of personality.
[2:30] Margaret Hall: Victor Garber, who becomes a dear friend of Paul's.
[2:33] Margaret Hall: The entire company just sort of come together in this way.
[2:37] Margaret Hall: I spoke about how Paul has this ability to sort of live with one foot in reality and one foot in magic.
[2:42] Margaret Hall: That entire company had that. And so they're all feeding off each other in this incredible blend of energy and this score falls you over.
[2:51] Margaret Hall: Paul liked to talk about that first sort of whistle into the violins as like a whiplash moment.
[2:57] Margaret Hall: Oh, like he just threw his head back, and when he came back, he was in the world of Sweeney.
[3:22] Margaret Hall: He shaved the faces of gentlemen who never thereafter were heard of again.
[3:27] Margaret Hall: He trod a path that few have trod. Did Sweeney Todd?
[3:32] Margaret Hall: A demon barber of Fleet Street. Talk about that whistle because Paul has a lot to do with that whistle being in the show.
[3:41] Margaret Hall: Oh, yeah, Paul's the reason that whistle exists.
[3:43] Margaret Hall: If Paul Gemignani had not been in that room, it would be a gong.
[3:47] Margaret Hall: So that was the original conception was a gong.
[3:49] Margaret Hall: Yeah, it was just gonna be like a big gong that someone in the pit would just hit, and that would be the start.
[3:54] Margaret Hall: And was that supposed to be the same idea? It was the sound that made people come into the factory or supposed to be a call to attention sound, is what it needed to be.
[4:03] Margaret Hall: But so it was orchestrated as a gong, that's what Steve had thought of it as.
[4:06] Margaret Hall: And again, this is where I don't know many people who've been like, I think you picked the wrong instrument, Stephen Sondheim.
[4:11] Margaret Hall: But Paul was just like, I don't think that's arresting enough.
[4:14] Margaret Hall: Yeah, it gets your attention, but it's not quite the right attention getter.
[4:18] Margaret Hall: And so he and the set designer spent a lot of time digging through the craziest stuff until they found this actual original Victorian factory whistle that like would make your ears bleed if played unmuffled.
[4:33] Margaret Hall: So loud, like could hear it miles away, kind of factory whistle from back in the day.
[4:39] Margaret Hall: They get it and they install it in the set design.
[4:41] Margaret Hall: And they played for Hal Prince the first time. Everyone immediately was like cowering and covering their ears.
[4:46] Margaret Hall: I was like, okay, I like it, but we're going to cause bodily injury.
[4:50] Margaret Hall: So they move it and I like swath it in curtains and things like that, sort of deaden the sound a little bit, at least, so there's not injury to the performers who are on stage underneath it.
[5:00] Margaret Hall: But the thing that was crazy about this whistle is it's an air-activated whistle.
[5:04] Margaret Hall: It's not an electric whistle or a battery-powered whistle like we have today.
[5:07] Margaret Hall: It was an old school pressurized air whistle.
[5:10] Margaret Hall: And so the way for it to be engaged, if you're not sitting there with a giant bellows like it originally was, was to be set up with this crazy sort of rubber tubing system that Eugene Lee built that ran down through the rafters of the Euros Theater, now the Gershwin, through the floor and the stage deck on stage, down into the pit to a tiny little presser at Paul's feet.
[5:34] Margaret Hall: It's like the equivalent of if you ever see like an electric guitarist playing and they have like the little things they can tap to modulate the sound.
[5:40] Margaret Hall: It's like he's yeah, basically. He's got one of these, like just to the side of the podium.
[5:44] Margaret Hall: So Paul can just sort of reach his foot down and tap it.
[5:46] Margaret Hall: But in order for the air to be released, he has to tap it about 1.5 seconds or so before he wants to hear it.
[5:53] Margaret Hall: So he has to see that far into the future of like when exactly do I need to press it for it to time exactly to Lynn slashing the throat or something like that.
[6:00] Margaret Hall: The first one's easy enough, because like it's the first sound. Once it plays, we're going, but if it plays two seconds late, okay.
[6:06] Margaret Hall: We'll go two seconds late. Yeah, we're like, that's not the end of the world.
[6:09] Margaret Hall: It's a bit of an end of the world if Lynn Careyu slits the first victim's throat, the beetle, and then it's like hold duh duh whistle, like that's not gonna work.
[6:20] Margaret Hall: It's a bad sound cue. But Paul got super good at it, and again, this is his ability to see into the future and eyes up out of the book.
[6:27] Margaret Hall: He could see the muscles moving in Lynn's shoulder underneath his shirt.
[6:31] Margaret Hall: He was watching him that close, that he would be able to time Lynn because Lynn didn't do it the same every night, and he didn't demand that of him.
[6:38] Margaret Hall: Other conductors probably been like, okay, we're timing this, where it's like, oh, one, two, three, slice. That's not what they did.
[6:43] Margaret Hall: Paul said, slice his throat when Sweeney's ready to slice it.
[6:46] Margaret Hall: And if it takes you an extra three seconds to get there, okay, I'm watching you, I'll see that.
[6:50] Margaret Hall: And he got so familiar specifically with Lynn Carey's right shoulder muscles that he could see when the tendon was starting to tighten to start the rise, to start the crossover in front.
[7:00] Margaret Hall: And so he'd know, like, okay, the tendon's going, press it.
[7:02] Margaret Hall: Because it took about that long for him to just reach around and do the slash.
[7:05] Margaret Hall: And that's the kind of thing that you do not learn except practical.
[7:09] Margaret Hall: You can't time that. And there's some very funny stories in the book from Jim Coleman, who is who Paul hires to take over the Sweeney production on tour.
[7:18] Margaret Hall: The whistle's not in the orchestration because the orchestration that exists is what Jonathan Tunick did in, I believe, under a month, if I'm remembering correctly.
[7:25] Margaret Hall: This is a case where Paul Gemignani does not have a score in front of him because he has memorized the entire score.
[7:33] Margaret Hall: And in fact, I think you say in the book that they had trouble seeing him on the monitors of the day.
[7:38] Margaret Hall: The TV monitors were not so good because the lighting was so dark in the show, there was not enough light on him for him to show up on the monitors, his hands, especially.
[7:47] Margaret Hall: Instead of having a score, he just lined the top of his podium with white paper so that it would reflect up on him.
[7:53] Margaret Hall: But they could have put a light there on him, probably, but he did the same thing without that.
[7:57] Margaret Hall: He's conducting without a score, and he's the one controlling the whistle.
[8:02] Margaret Hall: This is not something the stage manager is doing or the sound department is doing.
[8:06] Margaret Hall: He's the one who makes the whistle go with his foot as he's conducting.
[8:11] Margaret Hall: He's playing it like an instrument.
[8:12] Margaret Hall: Yeah.
[8:12] Margaret Hall: But that's not in the score, and no one had bothered to tell Jim Coleman of this.
[8:17] Margaret Hall: So Jim Coleman comes in to be the replacement conductor on the show.
[8:21] Margaret Hall: And he's learned the show. He's not memorizing the score.
[8:24] Margaret Hall: He's actually going to play from the score, at least or conduct from the score to begin with.
[8:28] Margaret Hall: But in the score, it still says gong.
[8:30] Margaret Hall: Yeah.
[8:30] Margaret Hall: He knew that it was a whistle now, but he felt like, oh, that's like a stage manager cue.
[8:34] Margaret Hall: The stage manager's like sitting in the wings and he watches and presses a button.
[8:36] Margaret Hall: And that's what everyone thought it was.
[8:38] Margaret Hall: Because Paul also didn't make a big deal out of like, oh, I've got this like super arduous thing to be doing every.
[8:42] Margaret Hall: And he's like, no, I just tap it with my foot. It's whatever.
[8:44] Margaret Hall: I just have to time it right. It's my job, I do it.
[8:46] Margaret Hall: Yeah, it's like, sure. But Jim Coleman had no clue.
[8:49] Margaret Hall: And literally, so he had to basically audition to do the tour because Paul had so built this show with Angela Lansbury that Angela was hesitant to trust it with anyone but Paul.
[8:59] Margaret Hall: Because Paul really was a part of the alchemy.
[9:01] Margaret Hall: But Paul vouched for Jim Coleman, said, I trust this guy.
[9:04] Margaret Hall: Let him play a matinee with you.
[9:07] Margaret Hall: You're here with your Broadway company. I'll be sitting in the pit with him.
[9:10] Margaret Hall: So if like something goes horrifically awry, I can jump up there.
[9:13] Margaret Hall: But you can get a feel for what it's like being conducted by someone that isn't me.
[9:17] Margaret Hall: He's basically got the audition of a lifetime to do this tour with Angela Lansbury as judge, jury, and executioner.
[9:23] Margaret Hall: And Paul's walking him to the subway.
[9:26] Margaret Hall: Jim would like sit and sort of observe Paul conducting for like two weeks before this is coming up, just to sort of get a sense of how the machine moves.
[9:32] Margaret Hall: Paul's walking him to the subway.
[9:34] Margaret Hall: He just sort of mentions offhand, oh, you're ready for the whistle, huh?
[9:37] Margaret Hall: And Jim is just sort of very uh, what are you talking about?
[9:39] Margaret Hall: Paul explains to him, like, oh yeah, no, that's your job.
[9:42] Margaret Hall: You're conducting, but also you need to play the whistle.
[9:44] Margaret Hall: And Angela's gonna notice if the whistle doesn't go off tomorrow.
[9:48] Margaret Hall: Tomorrow. Yes.
[9:50] Margaret Hall: Not even tomorrow, in 12 hours from now. I'm walking you home after the evening show.
[9:54] Margaret Hall: You're doing the matinee tomorrow. So you need to figure that out.
[9:57] Margaret Hall: If Paul had never mentioned it, Jim Coleman would have gotten up there, hands aloft, and just stood there, waiting for the stage manager to play the whistle.
[10:04] Margaret Hall: Yeah, the show would have never begun.
[10:06] Margaret Hall: The audition would have been over before it even started.
[10:08] Margaret Hall: But so Jim Coleman goes home and he pulls out his score, which is already covered in notes, and like he has annotated this thing to hell and back.
[10:15] Margaret Hall: And he's got the brightest red pen you can imagine.
[10:17] Margaret Hall: He circles every time there's a gong cue, like 15 times.
[10:20] Margaret Hall: That's me. I have to do this.
[10:23] Margaret Hall: He gets there like an hour before everybody else, and he's like crawling around the podium, peeling at all of the butcher paper that Paul's placed down, trying to find where this button is.
[10:33] Margaret Hall: He finds it, he presses it. I'm sure the doorman must have been like, What the hell is going on?
[10:37] Margaret Hall: Who's just like playing the whistle over and over?
[10:39] Margaret Hall: Because Jim Coleman just like stood there and hit it like 15 times to make sure he likes knew where it was, and can I find it in the dark? And do I know where it is in muscle memory?
[10:47] Margaret Hall: And he does it. He's not as perfect as Paul the first time.
[10:50] Margaret Hall: It takes about one and a half seconds to travel there. He's getting it maybe one second.
[10:55] Margaret Hall: So he's like half a second off, but that's not really obvious.
[10:58] Margaret Hall: Close enough for the first time you're doing the show. Yeah, it's like Lynn might have felt it, but it's close enough that people aren't gonna be like, what happened there?
[11:06] Margaret Hall: It just sort of like, oh, there's an echo in this gigantic theater. Interesting.
[11:10] Margaret Hall: I'm sure everyone wrote it off who saw it. But Jim's like sweating buckets, and Paul's just laughing.
[11:14] Margaret Hall: He's like, You good? You okay? Jim passes with flying colors, he does the tour, and he ends up being the person who conducts the version of Sweeney that many of us now know as the Sweeney, which is Angela Lansbury and George Hearn as filmed on tour.
[11:27] Margaret Hall: That's Jim conducting. It was supposed to be Paul, but Paul got busy.
[11:31] Margaret Hall: There was a whole mishmash of things he ended up not being able to fly out and do.
[11:35] Margaret Hall: The tour merrily was also starting to happen at that time. Sondheim was very busy in the early 1980s.
[11:41] Margaret Hall: So that version of Sweeney, that is Jim Coleman doing all of that. He's just very impressive, and I appreciate him deeply.
[11:54] Margaret Hall: At the watering holes of the world to do.
[12:22] Margaret Hall: Such is it won? Into our inclusion.
[12:36] Margaret Hall: Now we will call it seeing her off.
[12:43] Margaret Hall: But behind the jewelry counter, not in front.
[12:50] Margaret Hall: So now he's doing another show with Prince without Sondheim, and that is Evita.
[12:55] Margaret Hall: Yes, Evita. He originally was going to open Evita as the opening conductor, but he insisted on staying with Sweeney until it closed on Broadway.
[13:03] Margaret Hall: He basically told Hal, he's like, Sweeney's my baby, please don't make me abandon her.
[13:07] Margaret Hall: I will get you your cast, I will get you your orchestra, I will get you your music director.
[13:12] Margaret Hall: But please let me close Sweeney.
[13:13] Margaret Hall: So in a way, he'd be what they call today a music supervisor on the show.
[13:17] David Armstrong: Yes.
[13:17] Margaret Hall: And then once Sweeney closed and is out on tour, then he comes in and he takes over Evita when they send the original conductor for Evita on, I believe the international tour is where he's sent.
[13:30] Margaret Hall: So Paul takes it over. He is there to finish out Patti Lupone's run and Mandy Patinkin's run. And he and Patti, they have a fascinating relationship because they're both two people who are so strong, but also aggressively Italian. And one of my favorite Paul phrases is what he likes to call an Italian standoff, which is when you're not even fighting. You're both just so passionate in your corner of a situation that isn't even really a fight, that you're just kind of silently staring at each other, waiting for someone to make a move. And there's a great story in the book of him and Patti having one of those, and it's one of my favorite stories. Because they're both just such forces of nature. But clearly they get along, or they like working with each other because they continue to have a lifelong career basically with each other.
[14:13] David Armstrong: Oh my gosh, yeah. They work with each other a ton. Patti's another one. She has a very short list of conductors she requests when she does stuff. And Paul is on that short list. If Paul will do the show, I want Paul. He won't always do the show, but that's who she's calling for first.
[14:28] Margaret Hall: Right. It doesn't seem though that this turns into a relationship with Andrew Lloyd Webber, which is interesting.
[14:33] David Armstrong: Yes and no, in terms of it being interesting. So he actually didn't spend a lot of time with Andrew. Because Evita was pretty much fully formed in London before it came over. That's also part of why he did music supervision. It was always pretty easy just to bring the guy from London with the show instead of replacing him with Paul. Because of that, he's not working with Andrew in the same way that you are when you're creating a new show. You're not really changing Evita once it gets to Broadway. There's like little tweaks here and there, but like you're not rewriting Buenos Aires. It was already a big hit.
[15:02] Margaret Hall: Yeah. So he's not spending a lot of face time with Andrew. And then Evita's also appeared in Andrew's life where if you've read his memoir Unmasked, he's in a lot of personal turmoil. And so he's not spending more time in that rehearsal room than he has to. He's getting home to his wife and figuring out everything that's happening there. Paul also tends toward quieter personalities. His best friends are sort of the people who they're not wallflowers, but they're observers, they're listeners. They're people like Sondheim who take in the world and they synthesize the world. While Weber can do that, that's not his natural mode. He's much more of a showman. He's what I would call an empresario. And that's just not really Paul's vibe. And so, just in terms of like becoming buddy-buddy, they're not the same type of person.
[15:45] Margaret Hall: Evita's really the only show of his that he worked on. He almost did Phantom of the Opera, but that didn't end up happening. If it had, maybe they would have struck up the connection. But as it is, you click with some people and you don't with others. They never had any like big fight or anything. They remained cordial, and when they stopped working together, their relationship ended.
[16:04] David Armstrong: Speaking of relationships ending, this brings us to the fateful Merrily We Roll Along.
[16:09] Margaret Hall: Yes. Where Paul is in the middle of a relationship ending to a great extent.
[16:14] David Armstrong: Feel how it quivers on the brink.
[16:17] Margaret Hall: What? Everything gives you the shivers, makes you think there's so much stuff to sing. And you and me will be singing it like the birds. Me with music and you the words. Tell them things they don't know. Up to us, pal to show. Don't go away. Broadway Nation will be back right after this quick break.
[16:46] ♪ Musical number: "Our Time" — performed by the cast of Merrily We Roll Along ♪
[17:12] Margaret Hall: Something disturbing. Shifting ground is just become. That's just a blurring all around. And yesterday is on. As you said earlier, you devote a whole chapter to this on purpose, even though it's run 16 performances. I happen to have seen the sixteenth of those performances. One of my time machine shows. You know, I have to say, it was very enervating. It just didn't work. It just kind of sat there. The last three numbers worked when they got to Opening Doors is when the show started to work.
[17:48] David Armstrong: Opening Doors is one of the sometimes best songs.
[17:50] Margaret Hall: Oh, it's brilliant. But you just sort of sat there wondering what had happened to your idols because it just didn't click. They've done a lot of work on the show since then, which I think has made it work much better in various versions. But it wasn't terrible, it just wasn't good. That's in some ways the worst kind of thing, because it was kind of dull. Even though it's hard to imagine, once the record came out, it was like, well, this is the greatest score in the world. Why did it not seem that way when you were sitting there in the audience?
[18:20] David Armstrong: Yeah. It just didn't have any effect or very little effect, I'll say. This is just a great place for me to say the advice that I give to any young composers whenever I talk with them. If you're choosing to adapt something, adapt something that works before you're adapting it. Because making something a musical is not going to suddenly make it work. If anything, you risk breaking it further.
[18:38] Margaret Hall: Yeah. And Merrily We Roll Along, the original play, it was not a success. It was a favorite of Hal Prince's, but the play flopped. The biggest problem is it goes backwards.
[18:45] David Armstrong: Yeah.
[18:46] Margaret Hall: And I don't necessarily think that's the problem. I think the book needed help, but the book has gotten help in a lot of productions. The thing that's hard with Merrily is Hal loved that original play. And so he's married to that play, which really needed some massaging. And it's gotten that massaging since. But that was one of the big pitfalls with Merrily. Is sort of don't adapt your favorite flaws because you're not gonna be as sort of brutal as you need to be with it. One of the things that made Rodgers and Hammerstein so legendary is they were brutal with their darlings. There are stories of them out of town on things like South Pacific where they're like, this is my favorite song that we've ever written together, but it's not working, and so we're cutting it. Things like that. Where it was all in service of the story, and they got a little bit too lost in the experience of making Merrily and lost sight of the show itself.
[19:32] Margaret Hall: And that's one of the dangers when a producer and director is the same person. That can be super helpful in terms of communicating a vision without any roadblocks. Something like Sweeny Todd. There's a lot of producers who would have balked at how expensive that was to do, but Hal Prince wrote his own check to do it. But one of sort of the pitfalls of it is there was no one there to say, hey Hal. Tap you on the shoulder here. Yeah, Ruth Mitchell was there, but Ruth also kind of fell down the rabbit hole with Hal on this. Merrily really was a heartbreaking experience for everyone involved because every single person I've spoken to who worked on it loved it with their entire heart. Where the show was the show itself, but it was also representative of so many things that people held so close.
For Steve, it was a representation of who he was when he was 25. He was trying to capture who he was when he was just starting out with West Side Story. And he did a pretty good job of it when you listen to those melodies. Like that's hard to undo those habits. But he got so sort of attached to that exercise. Hal Prince was very attached to that original play. And the cast was so attached to their heroes. Because this cast of kids, some of them literally the kids of the creators. Daisy Prince was Hal Prince's daughter. It's just a heartbreaking experience.
[20:47] Margaret Hall: And for Paul especially, because Paul really does love this score. And Paul was in some ways the keeper of the kids. Paul was the one who was clocking in every day with a smile, talking to the kids, holding up little signs to make them laugh during bows so they wouldn't notice that people were walking out during the middle of the show. He was like the equivalent of everybody's dad in that company, to the point that he became a surrogate father figure for one of the cast members, Donna Marie Elio, and walked her down the aisle at her wedding. And then when it didn't work, and when all of sort of the hustling that Stephen and Hal were doing behind the scenes to make it click, and this is truly a show that I can't think of a show that went through a bigger metamorphosis during previews.
The show on that first preview is not the show that it was on that last preview. They really made major headway. But Hal made the cardinal sin of you never open a new show cold in New York. Do not do it. You are signing your own death warrant. But in that period, that's what so many shows were doing because the economics were so broken.
[21:50] David Armstrong: I know, but you're killing yourself before you even start. You're coming in with a deadly infection.
[21:53] Margaret Hall: So they were sort of set up to fail from that way. I think that if what was the previews of Merrily had been the out-of-town tryout, and then they'd had time to then do a previews on top of it, I think they would have got there. I really do believe in my heart they would have got there, but they didn't have the time. It really broke Paul in like a real way because it didn't just feel like a show wasn't working. That happens. That's a part of the game. But this felt personal, both in that people were really personally attacking his dear friends. People weren't just saying, oh, Sondheim and Prince didn't have a good show. People were just like, oh, were they ever talented anyway? Oh, they're hacks, and that sort of thing.
He's just like, no. And so that hurts on like a personal level for your friends, but he knew that Stephen and Hal could take care of themselves. They're grown. They've been in this industry for a long time. They'll be okay. These kids were young, overwhelming majority making Broadway debuts. All of them sort of thought they had their ticket to the life they'd always dreamed of because they're working with these people that are like their idols. And then when the show doesn't work, they all take it so personally and feel like if they had done something different, it would have been better. In particular, that main three, namely Lonny Price and Annie Morrison, really took it on in a personal way of like, I am the reason the show did not work.
I was the failing. And that's not the case. They were quite wonderful, actually. I went to college with Jimmy Walton. Jim at least had sort of like the out of like I came in halfway through as Frank. Like I did what I could in the time I had. But for Lonny and Annie, it really was like a heaviness of like I have failed in some serious fashion. Annie more so even than Lonny. Because Lonny at least had been around the Prince office long enough to know like flops happen and we will survive this. It was rough. It was not just rough for Annie. That's like goes for the entire ensemble, really. So many people left the business entirely because they couldn't take it. It was the kind of failure that isn't just like a financial failure or oh, it didn't reach what I wanted it to reach.
It feels like you're personally failing someone who means so much to you. And that was what killed Paul is watching these kids labor underneath this just ennui and recording that cast album the day after the closing, probably the most difficult day of Paul's entire career, second maybe only to going to Michael Bennett's memorial.
[24:04] Margaret Hall: And that's really close race. The death of one of his closest friends of his entire life from a horrific disease, as he's watching people he cared for deeply dying all around him, and then watching the spirits and the lives die behind these kids' eyes. And these things don't come right on top of each other, but within a few years, because the next show is Dreamgirls. Yes, where he obviously is working very closely with Michael, and you describe in your book, I think a very different process than he ever had with Sondheim, in that he was in on this show. Of course, Dreamgirls was developed through a series of workshops, like Coruscant had been, and he's really crucial in putting the score together in deciding what's going to be in the score.
[24:46] Margaret Hall: The impression I had is that the composers had written a lot of songs, but it was not put together into a score, and Michael and Paul did much of that work.
[24:54] David Armstrong: Yeah, so they had like around 50 songs that they were given. And I'm telling you, doesn't exist at this point, but just about everything else is in this pile of 50 songs, and sort of like deciding like what where do things go? What fits the moment best? And it's wild to me because Paul's participation in the workshop of Dreamgirls was basically private until we started talking about this book. It was not discussed because Paul hid his work on that workshop so hard to hide it from Hal.
[25:20] Margaret Hall: She was keeping it a secret from Hal Prince.
[25:22] David Armstrong: Yeah, he was literally sneaking to Michael's apartment in the dead of the night, like fully like musical theater espionage style. I always picture with the Pink Panther theme over it.
[25:31] Margaret Hall: And why was that? Because he was doing it at the same time, Merrily We Roll Along was in previews. There was nothing Paul could have done to fix Merrily. When he was there, he was fully committed to fixing the thing. But like there's not much he's gonna be doing at 2 a.m. He can be at Michael's doing this at 2 a.m. But he knew how Hal would take it as another sort of personal slight situation that he would see it as Paul sort of finding a life raft off, which is not what it was. This was Paul helping out a friend who had called on basically every favor Michael Bennett had with him of like, I need you, please. I know I'm asking you the impossible. We don't have to talk to anybody about this. I'm paying you under the table.
Just come to my apartment and help me. And that is what becomes Dreamgirls, which is what's kind of nuts. It only really started being talked about after Hal Prince died. And even then, this book is the first time it's really being laid out how it went down. And now that Bobby's gone, Bob Avian, Paul's kind of the last one from that room. And it's just wild. Where Dreamgirls is such a seminal show. Talk about turning points in the history of the American musical. Dreamgirls is a big deal. And so many people have no idea that Paul was more than a replacement conductor. Because he basically acted as the music contractor for the show. He puts together the pit, he's who picks who ends up becoming the music director and the person who opens the show. He's the one who sets up sort of the run of the songs and where things need to be placed.
[26:49] Margaret Hall: He leaves, he does a handful of flops with the Prince office. Hal Prince thinks nothing of it, doesn't realize anything had happened. Somewhere around the third flop, Michael Bennett comes to visit Paul. They're like hanging out in someone's dressing room backstage. They're like, is there any way to fix this? Because Michael Bennett fully is just like, okay, I visited you at too many of these failing shows. How do we fix one so that you have like a show that works? They spend like 30 minutes trying to make it work, and they're like, we can't. The show is broken. There's no fixing it. Okay. And Michael Bennett comes up with this idea of so when this one closes, before Hal gets another idea for something crazy, I'll call the Prince office and ask if I can borrow you to be a replacement conductor in Dreamgirls.
So you finally get a chance to conduct this outside of workshops in like a locked closet, basically. And so that's what ends up happening. And so everyone thinks that that's Paul's relationship with Dreamgirls. It's like, oh, we conducted it for like six months in 1983. And it's like, no, that was a homecoming more than anything. That was just sort of Michael being like, now you can actually put it on your resume, even if you can't say everything you did. Because the paperwork is still under lock and key. Like Michael Bennett really protected Paul because Paul told him where it's like, if I'm doing this, Hal cannot find out. And basically, our friendship is over if you ruin my friendship with Hal.
And Michael took that seriously, and he protected that. And everyone in his estate protected it. It literally took Paul being like, I myself am giving permission that you can confirm things to her. You don't have to hide it from my biographer. But even then, people were very hesitant to give details on it because Michael was so strict about like, we do not talk about Paul Gemignani being here. He was not in this room. He did not sign on any papers. It was my friend. Michael had a friend here who helped. That's how we talk about it. Michael's friend helped pick things here and there, not Paul. Because if any one person you say that to someone you trust, who then maybe is overheard by someone in like the hallway of somewhere, if it gets back to Hal Prince, there's gonna be Hell to Pay. But now that Hal's passed on, Paul wants to talk about it.
[28:48] ♪ Musical number ♪
[29:46] Margaret Hall: So Michael Bennett, this has been a long relationship they've had, and this leads up to, as you said, the other worst day in Paul's life is Michael Bennett's memorial. Michael Bennett's death and the aftermath of that. It was an awful day. And it's something I literally I can't talk about without tearing up a little bit. Because it was a moment that I think we all need right now, actually, where Michael Bennett's memorial gave everyone permission to grieve everyone they were losing. By the time Michael died, we had reached full epidemic levels. He wasn't like the first wave where we don't really know what's going on. It's no longer called GRID. We have reached AIDS. And there's something about Michael's loss specifically.
Someone who people loved so much and was such a good friend to so many and showed so much promise and was so clearly just getting started with an incredible career to be gone like that. His memorial gave people the space they needed to grieve everyone who was dying around them. For all the chorus boys who had only got one credit in before they were taken from us, before they had a chance to become who they were meant to be, even. And it's something we haven't had an opportunity to have during COVID to mourn all of this loss around us, because we're still in the middle of it. But we need a moment like Michael Bennett's memorial, where it's everyone in one room grieving and mourning in just wild abandon.
If you've ever seen any of the footage from that memorial, there's a video that just eviscerates me of Stephen Sondheim singing a song from Sunday in the Park with George that was one of Michael's favorites. And it's just Steve at a piano with his little hand battered score. And the sound that you can hear release from the audience when Steve finishes, and he just quietly says goodbye, Michael, and you just you hear people's hearts breaking in the audience in the way they exhale. And that was happening on a macro level. You can't even imagine what was going on on a micro level for the people who were close with Michael. Because Michael was Paul's one of his best friends. Steve was his best friend, but Steve was also kind of his boss.
So they had a very interesting sort of thing for a while until they reached the 90s, and then it's just full best friend. But in the 80s, yes, Bennett would ask favors of him, but he didn't really work for Bennett in that same way. Bennett loved him not just because of what Paul could do for him as a musician, sort of thing, but he loved Paul for Paul. And that was not something he had a lot of in his life. That was not a familiar sensation for him. He got that from Michael, he got that from his son, and that's basically where the list ends. And the loss of Michael, especially right as they were sort of working up the courage to maybe become a duo. They were right on the precipice of thinking the Prince Office might never recover from this period.
And if that happens, then Bennett and Gemignani can become a thing. And we'll have each other and we'll go on these adventures together. Because they had always been the two young ones in the rooms they were in. Paul is 83 now, Steve just died at 91. That's a little under a 10-year difference. Which is not a huge difference, but it's a difference. Mm-hmm. And they're 32 than it was later in life. But yes, when they're the young ones in the room doing Follies, that was a big difference. Very much. The loss of Michael was like losing a future in a lot of ways. And that day, that was the hardest part of the entire book to write was Michael with Memorial. It took me three weeks just to write those pages because both Paul and I would just immediately start having a breakdown a couple sentences in.
We had a lot of really good cries. While obviously it can't heal everything, I did my best to construct that section in such a way that I hope that it gives readers even a shadow of the solace that we need after what we've gone through in the last three years. Of even just a second to just sort of drop the shoulders and be like, yeah, it's not okay. And it doesn't have to be. For these seconds that I'm here with this, grief like this has happened, it will happen again, and the only way through it is to feel it and the power of it. And pushing it to the side does not make it disappear, so to speak. And that was very much the case with Michael's memorial. Obviously, even though this relationship with Michael Bennett comes to an end and the relationship with Hal Prince has come to an end, the core relationship with Sondheim continues and actually reaches some highlights over this next period.
Margaret and I will be back next time with a final episode that will cover Paul Gemignani's work on Sunday in the Park with George, Into the Woods, and more. In the meantime, here is the complete audio of the moment that Margaret just described to you. Stephen Sondheim performing Move On from Sunday in the Park with George at Michael Bennett's Memorial.
[34:34] ♪ Musical number: "Move On" — performed by Stephen Sondheim ♪
[39:50] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode, to KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
