Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 85: RETURN OF THE MONSTER MUSICAL!

This is the second half of my conversation with Adam Abraham, author of the engaging new book Attack Of The Monster Musical – A Cultural History Of Little Shop Of Horrors. If you missed the previous episode you may want to catch up with that one before listening to this one... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

54 mins
11/3/22

Featured Shows

About

This is the second half of my conversation with Adam Abraham, author of the engaging new book Attack Of The Monster Musical – A Cultural History Of Little Shop Of Horrors. If you missed the previous episode you may want to catch up with that one before listening to this one.

Last week Adam shared the unlikely behind-the-scenes story of the making of Rodger Corman’s original low budget horror film The Little Shop Of Horrors, and then how that inspired a young writer and director named Howard Ashman to transform it into the stage musical, Little Shop Of Horrors, which quickly became a long running Off-Broadway smash.

This week Adam takes us inside the creation of the hit movie adaptation of the musical -- which opened which opened while the original Off-Broadway stage production was still playing. And we discuss the incredible legacy of Little Shop and its impact on American culture over the past 40 years. Most especially, how it kept the flame alive for American musical comedy during the “British Invasion” of Broadway in the 1980s. Perhaps most importantly we explore the significant influence that Howard Ashman, Alan Menken and Little Shop Of Horrors have had on the several generations of musical theater writers who have followed in their footsteps.

Adam Abraham is a Postdoctoral Teaching Fellow at Auburn University, and he also has taught at Virginia Commonwealth University, NYU, and Harvard. His previous books include When Magoo Flew: The Rise And Fall of Animation Studio UPA, and Plagiarizing The Victorian Novel: Imitation, Parody, Aftertext. He has also written for film, television, and theater.

Attack of the Monster Musical provides a fascinating, in depth, look into the dynamic partnership of Howard Ashman & Alan Menken and their creation of what I believe is one of the best and most perfectly crafted musicals of all time!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:15] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and this is Return of the Monster Musical.

[0:38] David Armstrong: This is the second half of my conversation with Adam Abraham, who's the author of the new book Attack of the Monster Musical, A Cultural History of Little Shop of Horrors. If you missed our previous episode, you may want to catch up on that one before listening to this one. Last time, Adam shared the behind-the-scenes story of the making of Roger Corman's original low-budget horror movie, and how that inspired a young writer and director named Howard Ashman to transform it into a stage musical, which quickly became a long-running off-Broadway sensation. Today, Adam takes us inside the creation of the hit film version of the musical and demonstrates the significant impact the musical has had on our culture, especially how Little Shop kept the flame alive for musical comedy during the 1980s, as well as the tremendous influence that Ashman, Mencken, and Little Shop of Horrors have had on several generations of musical theater writers who have followed in their footsteps. Here we go.

[1:36] David Armstrong: So now let's jump to the movie. Of course, because of this big hit, and also because David Geffen is involved with it, the idea of making a movie of it comes forward fairly quickly.

[1:47] Adam Abraham: Yeah, because the film was not until 1986, four years after the show opened in New York. But Ash was working on it as early as '82, the year in which Little Shop opened in New York. You know, when something is a success, Hollywood people are gonna be coming to look. Steven Spielberg saw the show, Martin Scorsese was interested. There were different kinds of conversations. Different people were mentioned for Audrey, like Madonna, like Cyndi Lauper, which would take it in interesting directions. But David Geffen was the one who took it most seriously. That's what Ashman felt. Geffen also had the film background. He worked at Warner Brothers and he was just starting to produce films on his own. He'd made Risky Business starring Tom Cruise, and he had an overall deal at Warner Brothers, where basically they would make anything he wanted because they loved him so much. He was the natural person to help transfer Little Shop from New York into a Hollywood production.

[2:37] Adam Abraham: But as it progressed, it became a bigger and bigger film. Little Shop was always small. It's in the title. Corman's film made in maybe three, four days, shot for pennies, the original WPA production, Off-Off Broadway, cost $25,000, not very much. The Off-Broadway show with the Orpheum, also modest, still a cast of eight or nine. Now suddenly it's a movie for Warner Brothers. Now they think this could be a summer blockbuster. Now they're spending millions and millions of dollars. And the next thing you know, you're on a sound stage in London, the same soundstage you used to shoot James Bond films, and you're making this mega epic film, now directed by Frank Oz, who came up through the Jim Henson organization and worked on many of those projects like Sesame Street, The Muppet Show, and The Dark Crystal. So the thing kind of grew, perhaps out of proportion, not the original proportions that existed.

[3:29] Adam Abraham: So it's funny to see that progress from the Corman film to the off-Broadway show to this elaborate production that's now happening in the UK. And you tell us that Ashman and Mencken were only marginally involved in the film by their own choice.

[3:42] David Armstrong: That is the thing that is very hard for me to fathom, but this is what I have been told that they really did not want anything to do with it.

[3:49] Adam Abraham: Now, to be clear, Ashman wrote the script and he gets sole screenwriting credit, which is a big deal because in Hollywood there's always 20 writers and they go to the writers' guild and they fight for credit. He was the one and only writer of the screenplay from beginning to end, even with all the trauma that the film had once it was trying to get into release. But Ashman just had this feeling the film is a filmmaker's medium, it's a director's medium. He didn't want to sit around on set drinking tea and chatting with people and being the third wheel or the fourth or fifth wheel or whatever the image would be. I should also mention that as the film went into production in London, Ashman had his own project to work on, which I guess in his mind was more important.

He was going to write his first Broadway musical. Now here's someone who grew up listening to the cast albums, loving musicals, loving Rodgers and Hammerstein and Gypsy and all that. Now he's going to do a musical with music by Marvin Hamlisch, the composer of Chorus Line. In his mind, I guess that was the most important thing in 1985. He kind of kept his distance in part because he felt that that's their thing. If they need me, they'll call, and because he was focused on his own project.

[4:52] Adam Abraham: Mencken told me he went to the set once. He flew to London, looked around and left. They essentially chose someone to be their deputy. They chose Robbie Merkin, who was originally the orchestrator of the off-Broadway production. He then rose to music director at the Orpheum after the original music director, Bob Billig, went on to other projects. So Robbie became the person who was going to go to London, sit on the set, work with Frank Oz, babysit the production, and look after all the music and make sure that Ashman and Mencken are not unhappy. So that became his task. He went up doing a lot. He did orchestrations, his voice appears throughout the film. So he was given this great opportunity in part because Ashman and Mencken did not want to go.

It seems strange to us. I would think any one of us given that opportunity would definitely take the flight to London and live in a hotel and hang out on set and just say, hey, I wrote this. But they didn't want to be that person. They also probably didn't want to sit there and not be able to have it be what they wanted it to be without having the power to do it. Ashman directed the show at the WPA off-Broadway at the Orpheum for the national tour. He knew how the show works. To sit there and watch another director do something different would probably be somewhat painful to him. So maybe he thought it was better to have an ocean of distance between him and whatever Frank Oz wanted to do. Ashman was happy with much of the film, but he somehow sensed it's better to remove himself from the process. It's in their hands now, they've paid me. Let's hope for the best, and I'm gonna work on my own musical, which was called Smile.

[6:15] Adam Abraham: Yes, ladies and gentlemen, tonight is the last hour of my reign, but don't worry. There are 24 of this state's best and brightest high school about to be seniors waiting in the wings. It's a real privilege to introduce them to you this year's young American Best Contest. Take the picture of Shot that shows every one of us wings and clothes. Illuminates his sunlight too. Don't forget it's only right too. Then it's for a while. So hold this in while we say for this special chill, and the man with the camera.

[7:25] Adam Abraham: Which I saw it was a heartbreaking show because it just didn't quite work, unfortunately, even with that incredible talent that was involved in it. I think unlike Little Shop, they chose a subject that just didn't have any teeth to it. I don't mean that as a bad pun, but by that point, a Miss America style pageant we didn't take seriously to begin with. So to satirize it had no real effect. I mean adaptation is an interesting topic. Why that? Why choose that topic? You could say, why do that horrible Roger Corman film with the wild? It's so dumb. You could say, why do this Michael Ritchie film from the 70s with a beauty pageant in California? It's not even Miss America, it's some sub-sub, I don't even know what Miss California, I don't know what Miss Teen.

So I guess maybe that project was flawed from the start. It doesn't seem like a great idea. It doesn't seem like what people wanted to watch in 1986, in the same season in which Les Mis opened. I think it was also part of the timing of the film was actually quite engaging and funny. I remember when that came out and seeing it. But by the time you got almost ten years later, the world had changed and that subject matter no longer seemed bold or engaging or interesting. But the mood of the country changed. There was a certain kind of 1970s satire, like Network, like The Candidate, like Smile, your film of MASH, that would not have played in the 80s, would not have been successful in the same way, even though just ten years had passed.

[8:54] Adam Abraham: So, in a way, Little Shop, as an older project and as a period piece benefited. It's twice removed now, it's not the 70s but the 60s, and it was produced on stage as a period piece, whereas Smile, as I recall, was essentially contemporary. So it doesn't have that historic move where you're looking back, oh, remember what music was like when we were younger. Little Shop benefits from that critical distance. It's the imagined or remembered past.

[9:18] David Armstrong: Absolutely. You said that Howard was generally pleased with the film with both Mencken and Ashman. What did they say about the film then? What did they say later? What was their opinion of the movie that got made?

[9:30] Adam Abraham: I guess ultimately have to be mixed. For them, it was a big opportunity. Again, it's hard to remember because we know who Alan Menken is now. This was Alan Menken's first motion picture. This was Howard Ashman's first motion picture. They did not write 17 screenplays that did not sell. They did not pitch ideas to various studios and get no response. They wrote a show off off-Broadway, and it was acquired by Warner Brothers and made. It might not have been made. You know, many things go into development that don't get made. It is such a huge leap that it has to be very exciting. If the film is not everything they hoped for, they understand it's a different medium. The musical exists, you can enjoy that, and the film exists.

And for many people, the film is how they found Little Shop of Horrors. There are many people who saw the movie, not the stage musical that you saw in New York, but that movie with Steve Martin and Rick Moranis on cable, on video. And for many people, when they hear the words Little Shop of Horrors, they mean that. It caught them at a young age, just as Howard Ashman was caught at a young age by the Little Shop of Horrors. So the movie works to a large extent. I mean, Ashman did like the way a lot of the numbers were staged. He really did admire that opening number with the girls singing as they moved through the streets. Obviously, the famous debated point was the ending of the film because the ending is not the ending of the staged musical because it did not test well.

Hollywood films, as you know, would have a test audience that watches an early version of the film, a recruited audience of whatever the producers imagined would eventually go to the mall and pay to see this movie. And I suppose they had a room full of 13 to 17-year-olds who sat watching a movie, and each is armed with little note cards in which the viewer can say what works and what doesn't work. And what the audience said does not work is the ending because all the good people die and the villain wins, and that they could not take.

[11:10] Adam Abraham: So the ending, of course, changed. And Ashman gave them the ending they want, you know, begrudgingly, maybe with clenched teeth, but he thought, if I don't do it, someone else will. And if I do it, at least I can make it the best version of something I don't want, rather than some Hollywood hack coming along and making something worse. So he did write every draft, and he did give the studio everything they needed right through the reshoots. They did some reshoots in 1986, prior to release with the new ending in which Seymour wins. He kills the plant, and Ashman did write and develop that. So he stuck with the project to the end. Again, many writers could have been fired. It's typical of Hollywood.

It was his first experience in the movies, and I would like to think it informed what he would do when he got to the Disney studio because he certainly seemed to have mastered the art of the motion picture by the time he was working on his next films just a few years later.

[11:58] David Armstrong: Absolutely. I was not crazy about the ending. I remember sitting in the theater watching it and thinking, oh, what are they doing? But he did have that plant growing in the grass there at the end, the little baby Audrey, to at least convey a little bit of the idea of the original.

[12:14] Adam Abraham: Yes, it's a little cute button. But I would just say to your listeners that if you want to find the original ending, it's quite remarkable, and you can find it on YouTube or different Blu-ray and DVD releases. They spent five million dollars, this is 1980s dollars, on this very elaborate ending in which Audrey II and some of her other fellow creatures destroy a cityscape with miniatures, all this remarkable special effects work sung to the song, Don't Feed the Plant. So it exists, it's been restored, you can watch it. This is the ending, pretty much that the recruited audience saw, did not like, but it is available.

[13:20] Adam Abraham: Perhaps one of the misfires of that ending is that it actually became sort of horrific. I wonder if there was a way to do that ending that would have been charming and funny and campy that would have fit better with the movie. It's a different medium as well. On the stage, you know it's a puppet, you know it's not a shop, you know it's not real.

[13:39] Adam Abraham: And at the end, as many people pointed out to me, the actors come out for a bow. So even though they're eaten by a plant, they still come out and take a bow, and we know they're okay. We know it's make-believe, we know it's just a story. In the photorealistic medium of film, you see an actual store with props and calendars from 1962 on the wall, and there's a realism. And the plant is more realistic. The effects of the plant in the film still look great to this day. It's remarkable what they could accomplish. In the moment just before CGI computer effects would have come in, they're making, you know, this thing that's 10 tons sitting on a stage and its lips are moving and it's talking to Rick Moranis.

It's there. It's still an accomplishment. The other thing that happened right before the curtain call in the original production was those tentacles dropping from the ceiling on you. And I remember the whole audience screaming and then laughing harder than they'd laughed anywhere in the show, and the show was hilariously funny. And that right there is giving you an experience that is both you were scared and it was hilarious at the same time.

[14:56] Adam Abraham: So there are all those gimmicks done in the 60s to get people to leave their home, not watch television, but go watch some horror film at the local cinema. So the way Ashman's effect at the end is in keeping with that sensorama 1960s experience, and something that the film in 1986 lacked, it did not reach out and touch you, as they used to say. So yeah, that was definitely a thrill for the original audiences. Many people remember that detail. The tendrils fall and literally grab you as you're watching the end of the show. Subsequent to the events you have us witnessed.

[15:38] Adam Abraham: And that's we talked into feeding it. Don't go away, there's more Broadway Nation right after this quick break. That's the plans for the terrible win. Finding just who would feed them their film. And the plants proceeded to grow. And grow. And we get what they came here to do. Which was the central middle.

[16:29] Adam Abraham: So the release of the movie actually reinvigorates the box office for Little Shop of Horrors, which is still running at the Orpheum Theater. It's always interesting when a stage musical can survive the movie version because there's a tricky challenge there. You know, many times the producers want to hold off the film version with the idea that you kill the golden goose. You don't want that film to be made. We're making money in New York, we're on the road, we have first national tour. Don't do the film yet, because then it's on cable, then it's done. So there is that resistance. And a few years passed, as we said. But yeah, as far as I can see, there was an increased box office in 1986, 87. Because even if people didn't see the movie, they just knew about it.

Now the movie is advertised, it's a major motion picture from Warner Brothers. It's advertised coast to coast, it's on television, it's in the newspapers. So there was a boost in sales. By a year later, it was pretty much done, but there was a little bit of a boost just because people who either saw the film or simply heard about the film wanted to see the original. So yeah, the off-Broadway producers did get a benefit of that. But then the show, like all shows, closes. But after an incredibly long run, I don't know where it stands in the history of off-Broadway musicals, but it's certainly one of the longest running off-Broadway shows. Not as long as The Fantasticks.

[17:41] Adam Abraham: Not as long as The Fantasticks, of course, that's at the top, and I'm not sure about The Threepenny Opera that ran a long time as well. But I'll look that up and see where it stands in that pantheon. Well, I did look it up, and Little Shop's original off-Broadway run of 2,269 performances was indeed longer than a number of blockbuster off-Broadway hits, including You're a Good Man Charlie Brown, Jacques Brel is Alive and Well and Living in Paris, Forever Plaid, and it even edged out Godspell by a few performances. However, there were a number of musicals that ran even longer, including The Threepenny Opera, the original edition of Forbidden Broadway, Nunsense, I Love You, You're Perfect Now Change, and of course The Fantasticks, which ran for 42 years.

Little Shop claimed to be the highest grossing at the time, just because the ticket price had gone up. So that was an accomplishment. I mean, it made millions and millions of dollars. In addition to off-Broadway, it had multiple productions at the same time around the world. I talk about this in the book because as you know, there are a number of books on the making of an individual musical. It's kind of its own genre now. This year alone, there's one in Greece, there's one on Pippin, there may be others. But one thing that I definitely wanted to do for Little Shop was look what happens after opening night. Because a lot of making of the musical stories tend to close on opening night. And I think that's a misfortune because that's really when it begins.

[19:04] Adam Abraham: But then it begins. So you have cast replacements, you have understudies, you may have a national tour, you may have a film version, you may have London, and so on. So I spent a lot of time trying to learn about these different productions. And Little Shop in the 80s went to Japan, South Africa, went to most of Scandinavia, played in all sorts of different places. And it seemed to work most everywhere, even in translation. So Ashman, of course, is a little less involved in these subsequent productions. He directed New York, Los Angeles, London, and the National Tour. That takes him up to 1984. By that point, he's pretty much done, and he hands it over to his successors like his longtime assistant director, Carnegie Grappo, and the original stage manager Paul Mills Holmes.

They directed some of the international productions thereafter, and others took on the task as well. But yeah, the show played everywhere. And I learned about some different versions. I emphasized some more than others. Ashman was especially interested in the production in Paris because he was a Francophile. He studied French in high school with a teacher who was much beloved. And he did seem to be more involved in that one. And in his papers in Washington, DC, I found multiple versions of the French translation because Ashman could actually read it, and there's handwritten notes and corrections. So it seemed like he was interacting with that one quite a bit. And there was an original translator who was essentially rejected.

And it seems that he was not meeting Ashman's standards for what a Little Shop in French would look like. A new collaborator, a new translator was brought on. He in fact traveled to New York City to see the show at the Orpheum and to kind of get it into his bloodstream before working on and putting on the show in Paris. So Ashman was a bit more involved in that one, but the show just plays. And then it goes into stock and amateur and then high school and college and university. And I learned this year that Little Shop is still in the top 10 high school productions. This includes plays and musicals, public domain or otherwise, with William Shakespeare and everyone else. So it's still in the top 10 all these years later, which is just amazing. And it's running again in New York.

[20:58] Adam Abraham: It is. I had the good fortune to see it three times. I have not seen that production yet. What was your reaction to seeing it? Tell us a little bit about the current production.

[21:06] Adam Abraham: Well, this is pre-pandemic. If you can remember the old days. In 2019, I saw Little Shop and was getting remounted off-Broadway. It may be worth remembering that there was a Broadway revival in 2003, directed by the same Jerry Zaks, who directed Nathan Lane and Faith Prince in Guys and Dolls. And this version for many did not seem to work. It didn't seem like the right house was in the Virginia. And for some it felt like just a mismatch of the show, the material, and the meter. But there are many good performances. The cast was terrific, but I remember seeing that production as well and thinking, well, Howard was right. This shouldn't have ever gone to Broadway. So when the topic came up again, this time the Ashman estate said, we're doing it off-Broadway.

This is where it belongs. This is what Howard always said. He was right, we were wrong. Now we're gonna see it off-Broadway. And they found an economic way to do that at the West Side Theater, which is actually a really good venue for it. Not exactly the Orpheum because it's nicer, but it's 270 some seats. Every seat feels pretty close and involved. You feel like the plant is right there with you. So it has a lot of advantages.

[22:08] Adam Abraham: $5,000 worth of African violets. $2,000 worth of baby blue eyes, the pink. And I interviewed a number of people who worked on that, including the director Michael Mayer and the original Seymour and Audrey, Jonathan Groff and Tammy Blanchard, and then I got to see them do the show. I got those battle bees to Elizabeth Taylor Sweet, Mr. Mushnick, she's real pretty. Come on, sir, come again. Now you were saying, Flowers for a prom corsage. Flowers for an entourage! Flowers to the funeral home from St. Andrew's Roman Catholic Church at 9th and Vine. And $40 hold the mine. First thing in the morning. I'll be there in the morning. Can you hold the Rose Bowl? See more the Rose Bowl. You know that big and played it's done that we love shine.

Well, it's so both bowl. It seems they want to buy the flowers here for every single float. Well, you can't keep the tournament waiting. Please hold. Can you just ask the plant for tone? Just a minute. It's business like who'd have everything Mushnick and Sons could be. Please wait. On channel three. So why am I feeling so depressed? I get two tickets to the game. Mushnick and Sons, Rose. And it's really good, in part because what Michael Mayer said, what he told me was that he wanted to get into Howard's mindset. And he wanted to not completely reproduce, but reimagine the kind of production that it would have been, kind of experience you would have had at the Orpheum, but now in the 21st century.

So it really does feel like it's honoring the original production without being a carbon copy. He reinvents certain things, but it's a lot of fun. And it's just amazing. I sat there. Obviously, I know the show better than some. And there's children sitting there who are just enjoying this thing and just delighted by it. I don't remember the first time I saw the new production. Audrey sings about her big enormous 12 inch screen in Somewhere in the Screen. There was a little girl sitting in front of me who says to her mom, That's not big. Years later, this thing just works. And you have to think there are many artworks from 1982 which would not play today. They would require some framing, some context, some rewrites, something or other.

Many classic Broadway musicals get revived, but somehow it's always a new book. We have to hire a new book writer and redo this and that. Somehow, Little Shop did not need any of those improvements. It just works. The show that's playing in New York right now is what Ashman and Mencken wrote. And it just kind of plays. And there are people who are obviously not born then who are watching it and just enjoying it.

[25:09] Adam Abraham: When you mentioned children in the audience, and then that's also one of the transformations of the show. What started off as an off-off-Broadway, off-Broadway, late night sort of hip experience for young adults, has become a family show in a way I think that might have surprised the original creators and cast of the show.

[25:28] Adam Abraham: Yeah, it was not the intent. I mean, the one thing that Ashman consciously did was he avoided curse words. In some earlier drafts, they do say some of the words that George Carlin said you're not allowed to say. And Ashman avoided that, but I don't know if it was thinking about children, they aren't so much as just if there are better words, why not use them? But otherwise, there was no idea that this is a kids or family show. It did not occur to them. The reviewers, even in 1982, started to mention this. And I think you can see it in the New York Times around Christmas of '82. It's mentioned as a possible family show, take your kids to, again, in the year in which the show opened. So I was trying to understand how this happened.

Albert Poland, the general manager, also talked about how it went from being a cult show to a family show. He described this transformation. And it doesn't make total sense because nothing changed. The story, script, songs are the same. They did not change a word or note to make it kid-friendly or family-friendly. So I kind of thought through what happened. And I do think that in this period, as I argue in the book, that children's entertainment actually grew in sophistication, became a little bit more raw, a little bit more edgy, a little bit more modern in some ways, so that by the time the show was running successfully in New York, we sort of caught up to it in terms of what a family audience could enjoy.

It's like a Shakespeare play. Any audience can enjoy that in different ways. You can enjoy it for the poetry, you can enjoy it for the swordplay, you can enjoy it for its insight into human nature. Little Shop plays on different levels as well. There's a level in which it just works for kids. I mean, I guess it is a puppet show, so we shouldn't be surprised. But it was not meant for children, and lo and behold, it worked really, really well as a family show.

[27:04] Adam Abraham: The one principal creator we haven't talked about yet is the creator of that puppet. Talk a little bit about Marty Robinson. Well, one of the thrills of this process of writing with a book was that I got to meet many who worked on the show, including Marty Robinson, who created and performed the Audrey Two puppets at the WPA at the Orpheum, and then in Los Angeles.

[27:23] Adam Abraham: I got to go to his workshop where he makes his monsters, and he actually still has an original Audrey II from the WPA. There was one that was not quite big enough for the Orpheum, so he kept that one, and I think physical contact with the original puppet. So that was a nice piece of the past. Marty has been on Sesame Street since 1981. He is larger than life. He played the character of Mr. Snuffleupagus and many favorite characters, and it was really a thrill to meet him. And he really described the process in some detail. And I was very happy to hear that. And as you may know, he also dated Ellen Greene for roughly eight, nine years. So they fell in love on Little Shop pretty much from the start, and they were together for most of the 1980s. So he had a lot of insight, a lot of fond memories of their time together as well.

So the fact that it's a giant Muppet is in the DNA of Marty Robinson; he came from that Jim Henson world. He was a puppeteer. I mean, that was Ashman's idea. We're gonna make it a puppet because it's not obvious what you could do. It was Sarah Ashman's husband suggested making the plant invisible, like the character in Harvey. And no one sees it, but we all just talked acknowledging. It's a very economical solution, but that's not what Ashman had in mind. He had the idea that he was going to have a gigantic gimmick. That was his word, right in the middle of the stage that no one could miss. And it was going to be a singing and dancing puppet. So Marty Robinson was trained as a puppeteer, found his creative expression through that.

You know, he wanted to be an actor, but felt that he was limited. He could only be cast as the six-foot-tall, affable white boy, I think was his phrase. As a puppeteer, he could do any character from a four-inch creature to a large in-life monster. So he really fell for puppetry. He did audition for Sesame Street in 1981 when they needed someone to replace Jerry Nelson, the performer who was doing Mr. Snuffleupagus because Jerry Nelson had injured himself climbing into this gigantic creature, whatever Snuffleupagus is. Marty was already doing Sesame Street. That was his day job. I think it was in a hiatus and shooting that he had the time to create the puppets. But once Little Shop was running, he basically shot Sesame Street by day.

He would go to the theater and then embody these four different Audrey II puppets. And for pretty much the second act, he's just stuck inside this plant. He doesn't get to go off stage, he doesn't get water, he doesn't get a bathroom break. He's in this plant the entire second act. So at the end of the night, he's just drained. He's had these long days. And he told me after a performance of Little Shop, after performing also a Sesame Street, he would go to the local bar and order two beers. He needed two entire beers just to get his body functioning again. So that's a detail not in the book, but I thought that was rather charming.

[29:58] Adam Abraham: Well, one detail you did include, which I thought was fascinating, is it could have been Julie Tamore instead of Marty Robinson creating the original puppets for Little Shop.

[30:07] Yes.

[30:07] Adam Abraham: So there were a number of meetings in New York in Ashman's calendar for '82. I saw he wrote down Julie Tamer. He actually misspelled her name. She was not as famous then, but I'm pretty sure it's the same Julie Tamer. And Marty recalls that she recommended him. She didn't want to do it for whatever reason, but she had worked with Marty Robinson on something called the Hagata, which played at the public. I think it was done twice, so they knew each other. So when she met with Ashman, it seems, she recommended Marty Robinson. She also knew that this was perfect for Marty's taste because he loves monsters. And as coincidence would have it, he also grew up on the Roger Corman film, The Little Shop of Horrors from 1960.

So when Ashman first met Marty Robinson at the old WPA Theater, they found that they both had a childhood obsession, as Marty called it, the same project. So I think it was meant to be. Let's talk about the legacy of Little Shop. This is a big hit show that has had a big impact. And as you detail, there were many incarnations. What are the various versions of Little Shop that either happened or almost happened?

[31:06] You know, we live in a world in which IP intellectual property is valued. So something is a hit, something is success. In one medium, why not try another? So Roger Corman technically retained the rights to the original 1960 film, even though, as I mentioned, he never actually copyrighted it. But nothing will stop Roger Corman. So he thought now this thing's running, now this thing's a hit. I'm going to make some money off of it. So he negotiated quite a few good deals for himself. One of which he negotiated a deal with Warner Brothers, since in theory, Warner Brothers was incorporating his rights. He got himself a good deal based on that, and he thought I can exploit this title once again because I own, I suppose he owned Little Shop of Horrors as the core concept.

So he tried to make a television series in the early '90s, and it was going to be broadcast by USA Network, which was just getting into scripted programming and like many producing entities, looking for a known quantity. So I got to meet the two writers who were developing this through many, many, many drafts. Somehow that version never got on the air. So I just make a note, save everything. That's my advice. To everyone out there, save all your papers, you never know. There was a cartoon version of Little Shop. It went on the air roughly at the same time in 1991. But to be clear, this is not based on the musical, this is based on the Corman property. It was called Little Shop, but technically has nothing to do with the Ashman Mencken musical. Although the cartoon is kind of sort of musical because the plant sings, which is to say raps, because it's the 1980s, so the plant does a couple of raps.

[32:37] Oh writing time for me to bust the raps. Sit back and chill for a while. I'm coming at you like Tomstown. So get ready for a funny bone overload at the little shop. Yeah, boy. In full effect. Yo, the little shop is gaining respect. So breakout before I put you in shape. Now when you go to the shop, what you see tells us be careful. Did it both of me? Take me to the shop in the shop. I want to go to the shop. Word little shop.

[33:16] Adam Abraham: And this played on Fox Network. It only lasted for one season, but Corman was involved in that. He's just, you know, selling this work any which way he can. And the original screenwriter, Charles Griffith, also thought, why can't I get into the act? And he wrote a would-be sequel called Son of the Little Shop of Horrors. Also unrealized, unproduced, but in theory, he would have written and directed that for Corman. One of the intriguing things about Son of Little Shop of Horrors, besides the fact that magically no one is dead, all the characters survive. Seymour and Audrey are well and surviving into the future, so they can be in a sequel. But the curious thing is that in the Charles Griffith version, Audrey is married to Mr. Mushnik, not with Seymour. So it's a different reading of the piece. And there was a graphic novel as well.

[34:01] It was, yeah.

[34:02] Adam Abraham: There were a couple things that were done to tie into the film. So that's more closely associated with the Warner Brothers film. There were a couple of book tie-ins. I guess there were three that I found. One was a graphic novel by DC, the makers of Superman and other robust heroes. And it's great to kind of read the graphic novel version of Little Shop because the first thing they do is they take out all the songs. Now I don't know if it's because they didn't want to deal with Ashman and Mencken's rights, or they simply thought that you can't have a musical on the page, it wouldn't work. And then they redraw all the characters in sort of muscular DC style. So as I think I say in the book, Seymour looks like a Clark Kent who never becomes Superman.

But they're also careful not to draw the actors in the movies. So you're not looking at caricatures of Steve Martin and Ellen Greene, even though the comic book, the graphic novel, was a movie tie-in. I think because there'd be some rights issues. As you said in the book, some of the lyrics are sort of morphed into dialogue in the graphic novel.

[34:56] Yeah, it's a paraphrase. I think it's for the reasons I mentioned, but yeah, and they use thought bubbles. One of my favorites is when you first meet Orin Scrivello, he's riding on his motorcycle, just as Steve Martin does in the film. But rather than sing, they're thought bubbles. And his thought bubbles are prose paraphrase of Ashman's lyrics. Sometimes he's in the exact words, but without the rhyme scheme, without the meter. So he's kind of reminiscing about his childhood when he used to torture animals. And it's interesting, that's how he found his career today. So yeah, the graphic novel. It's a curious amalgam of kind of the musical without the songs, kind of the movie, but not looking like the stars.

And one fascinating little tidbit in the graphic novel for the real aficionado of aficionado. There's one song that was cut from the musical called Audrey II, a very cheerful, charming Ashman Mencken song, never produced on the stage, never appearing in any version, which somehow wound up in the graphic novel. So it's this weird artifact. The writers must have an earlier draft of the screenplay. So for a moment, this cut song was gonna appear in the motion picture, the '86 film. Didn't make it into the film, but somehow made it to the graphic novel. So that is for your ultimate trivia night of Little Shop of Horrors. You can use that one.

[36:06] Adam Abraham: Fantastic. Another legacy is this new genre of off-Broadway musical that Little Shop seems to spawn. You can see the temptation. Why not take something terrible and make it into a hidden musical? What could be better? And the counterintuitive is often quite intuitive. Tim Rice talks about this. He says often the best idea for a musical is the worst, and the worst idea is the best. I mean, Cats is probably not a very good idea. Evita doesn't sound very promising, and yet they work. If you can take a bad or unpolished movie like Little Shop of Horrors, why not something else? So I observed in the '90s there was this attempt to kind of reconstruct the Little Shop DNA, either by finding a B movie or B movie scenario, or using the setting of the '50s and '60s. Bat Boy is probably one of the stronger examples of this.

And I'm not saying they ripped off Little Shop, but it's kind of in the same milieu. And Nancy Nodle Gibbs, who was a company manager of Little Shop, did work on Bat Boy. I believe she's one of the producers. And she told me that she was trying to produce something in the Little Shop model, at least an economic model, of something quirky that could run off-Broadway. And Bat Boy is actually quite fun. There are others that I never got to see, like Zombie Prom. You could also think of Reefer Madness, which was a hit in LA, played New York, became a TV movie. Again, you find a movie that's terrible. You add singing, you add a talented cast, and you sort of see it with our own snarky late 20th or early 21st century point of view, and it's kind of refreshed in a way.

I think there's a bunch where they're not Little Shop per se. They seem to be operating under a similar premise. Return to the Forbidden Planet is one of the ones that you mentioned. I never saw it. I read it, but it seemed to be hit in London. I'm not sure if it was as successful here, but does seem to be putting together again Little Shop of Horrors. It's a classical narrative. It's kind of stolen from a B movie. There was a movie with a similar title made by MGM. It's essentially The Tempest in Space, which is a good idea. But this writer chose to use songs of the '50s and '60s, like Great Balls of Fire. Now we'd call that a jukebox musical, and they're telling the story of The Tempest in a kind of B movie science fiction scenario.

So that one was a genuine hit in London, as I understand. I never got to see it. I've seen productions of it. I agree with you completely. They are clearly inspired by the success of Little Shop, and they're looking to replicate the same formula. They had limited success in doing it. It was actually harder to do than I think anybody thought, even when they got fairly close, like Bat Boy. It didn't have all of the same, it didn't have Howard Ashman writing it, is probably the real issue. And Alan Mencken. But you also mentioned Bucket of Blood, which has been adapted to the stage. Again, why not go back to Roger Corman, Charles Griffith? They wrote other films. So you can see the temptation. But of course, you're going to get compared to Little Shop every time you do it. It's a positive and a negative in a way. If you can pull it off, it would be a great positive, but it's always going to be, well, it wasn't quite as good as Little Shop.

[39:01] Adam Abraham: Well, as I read in the book, success spawns imitation. When there's a winning formula, others will try to reproduce it. If a cop buddy movie works, other people are going to make cop buddy movies and it'll keep happening and keep happening. You can try different pairs. One could be an alien from outer space, whatever you want to be, and there'll be new permutations of the same thing. This podcast is all about connecting the dots throughout the history of the Broadway musical. What do you see the impact of Little Shop on the Broadway musical being?

[39:28] Well, it's not just because I'm talking to you, but I think there's a connection to Hairspray. And I make this connection. It's not completely obvious, but Howard Ashman, like John Waters, came from Baltimore. Somehow Baltimore gives us these iconoclasts like H. L. Mencken. And they both were looking at their pasts. Both Little Shop and Hairspray are kind of memory stories to some extent. John Waters is remembering Baltimore in the early '60s. Ashman is remembering the experience of watching the movie of Little Shop on television in the '60s. And both are set in roughly the same period. Whereas I think it's rather precise in Hairspray, it's 1962. The Little Shop period is a little less defined.

It seems to be the late '50s, early '60s, although Ashman told people privately that it is 1962. It's curious that he thought in his own mind, although it's not published, it's the same time frame. And both are kind of an outsider art. They're both looking at people who should not be a star of a musical, who perhaps should not sing and dance, whether it's Tracy Turnblad or Seymour Krelborn, who seem to be kind of misfits and outsiders who, through some mechanism, find love and achieve to some extent their dreams. I would also add that Ashman really admired the films of John Waters. They did eventually meet in John Waters, went to see Little Shop when it premiered in Baltimore in 1984, and Ashman just adored Waters' films.

So there's some connection there about Baltimore, about looking back, about this period in one's life when you're a little bit younger and impressionable, and finding a way to revoice that in the 1980s because Hairspray was also a movie in the '80s before it became the success that you know about in New York.

[41:04] Adam Abraham: So that's one. I mean, you could do others, but since we're talking, I did want to mention Hairspray because it's also, as you know, an anniversary year.

[41:10] David Armstrong: Absolutely.

[41:10] Adam Abraham: And I can speak, I think, for Mark Shaman and Scott Whitman that when Little Shop of Horrors was happening, they were around in New York getting started. So clearly the impact of that show had to affect them.

[41:23] Adam Abraham: And then Mark Shaman, probably second to or maybe ahead of Alan Menken, is one of the most talented people at creating pastiche, at being able to write a song in the style of the 50s and the 60s, really of any era, and making it stand on its own. It doesn't feel like an imitation.

[41:39] Adam Abraham: And that's one of the great things about the score of Little Shop and the score of Hairspray, is those songs have their own legitimacy in addition to being pastiches that really replicate and convey the era that the show is set in. It can simultaneously convince you that you're hearing 1962 or the early 60s and be new and fresh, like a song from today that you want to hear over and over again.

[42:02] Adam Abraham: And Mencken and Shaman both can do this. It is a remarkable talent. And they both somehow found a way to channel the music of that period to write new scores that work as a Broadway score that tell stories and yet convince you that they're grounded in the sound and the harmonies of that time.

[42:20] Adam Abraham: The other thing I would say about Little Shop and its legacy is that it kept musical comedy alive during a period where people would say to you, "Oh, the musical comedy is dead. There's never going to be another musical comedy that isn't ironic or that isn't just purely comic, but that we can't take musical comedy seriously anymore." This is, of course, during that era of the British mega musical, 10 years without a musical comedy on Broadway. It's quite remarkable.

[42:47] David Armstrong: It was definitely a fallow period.

[42:50] Adam Abraham: Yeah, except for Little Shop is keeping it alive during that period and sort of demonstrating how you could do it. Now every song in Little Shop is funny. Even the ballads are funny. People sometimes would say, "Well, sure, Little Shop, but you don't take any of that seriously. It's all for laughs." So that's the only way you could do it. And of course, then we get to that period with The Producers and Hairspray.

[43:13] Adam Abraham: And to me, the most important one actually is The Full Monty because it really takes the characters seriously in a musical comedy for the first time in 10 years. And all of a sudden everything's a musical comedy again, and the musical comedy has been reborn. But I think Little Shop had still kept the flame alive and demonstrated to those people who would write those new shows how to do it.

[43:32] David Armstrong: Yeah, there's kind of a dark age or interregnum in the 80s. And it's worth noting that the American musical seemed kind of dead. It was the British musical that was really dominating the Broadway stage, whether through Kugler Schoenberg or Andrew Lloyd Weber, and the musical comedy was dead, as you say, but also I would add in the animated musical was kind of dead. So all of these things which had thrived in earlier generations and earlier times were kind of really looking finished and done.

[44:02] Adam Abraham: And here's the Orpheum Theater, a little beacon, a little light, showing that you can still do musical comedy, you can still write songs that tell a story that move an audience that are funny, as you say. The songs are genuinely funny, and it kind of keeps the light in the window so that one can come in the 90s and thereafter and say, "Oh yeah, musical could be funny. There can be an American musical, there can be a musical based on different things."

[44:24] Adam Abraham: Because there are also the revivals. I think that's a missing piece in the 1990s. The revivals like Crazy for You and Guys and Dolls, which I mentioned, also showing how to do an American musical again, not the British way. And then that leads to the period you're talking about in the very beginning of this century with The Full Monty, The Producers, Hairspray.

[44:43] David Armstrong: Yeah, the revival of Chicago is another one that relights that demonstrates again what they could be and what could happen. I do see the idea of just holding a torch, holding a candle, which is really, it seems what Ashman and Mencken did and what Little Shop did in that period.

[44:58] Adam Abraham: And you're right, they then continued to demonstrate that through the movies, through the Disney movies of how to write a musical comedy in a very traditional way that still felt modern and up to date. Somehow the Disney animators just forgot how to do that. And Howard Ashman came and literally told them how to tell a story with songs.

[45:15] Adam Abraham: I guess because enough years had passed that people had lost the knowledge of that, knowledge that any person in America would have known better in the 30s and 40s and 50s when operetta and musical comedy were still a thing. Somehow that knowledge got lost. So Ashman's role at Disney was to some extent to teach them how to make a musical and how to write a story that can be told through songs and how to use songs to advance the story and to deepen and enrich the story.

[45:40] Adam Abraham: In my opinion, Ashman was demonstrating that to them for the first time because if you actually go back and look at most of the classic Disney movies, which are delightful, they have songs in them, but they're not really using those songs to tell the story. They're sort of in a more what I call the silver age style. There's sort of songs that amplify the story but don't really tell it. And Ashman is actually bringing the musical play, Rogers and Hammerstein game book to Disney for the first time, other than I would say the other example of when they did do that very successfully was Mary Poppins, which was of course not animated, but that has a fully integrated musical theater score.

[46:19] Adam Abraham: I would say this. The Disney movies that Ashman cited the most were Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and Pinocchio. And those are the two where the songs actually tell the story more than some of the later films. They actually feel more like bona fide musicals. Snow White definitely has that kind of integration. Some people argue that Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs even influenced the 1940s musical because, of course, that came before Oklahoma. There's a scene between Snow White and the Prince with speech and song that seems to be pointing towards some of the stuff that Rogers and Hammerstein would do.

[46:49] Adam Abraham: So it's interesting that he saw those films more so than maybe the ones from the 50s and 60s, where they had songs for production value or entertainment value or charm. There was something in those first two Disney animated features that feels more like a genuine musical.

[47:02] David Armstrong: I think that's a great observation. Part of the reason we had this dark age, as you said, or this dark decade is because of the same reason we don't have Howard Ashman. Talk a little bit about the impact of his death.

[47:14] Adam Abraham: Let me start by telling you what a producer Tom Curdehy told me. He moved to New York in the 80s, and he knew at a young age that he was gay, and he wanted to live in New York City and he wanted to go to NYU and he wanted to work in the law. And he was basically working with AIDS patients at the very beginning of this crisis, trying to help them in any way he can. Eventually, he gave free legal aid. At the same time, he went down to the Orpheum and he saw Little Shop of Horrors, and it just lifted him from his everyday experience from this crisis, from this disease that was devouring people around him.

[47:46] Adam Abraham: So it's interesting as he told me in his mind, these two things were kind of connected in his own experience in New York in the early 80s. I find that to be a curious connection. Many years later, as you know, he got to be one of the producers of the now Off-Broadway revival, which began in 2019 and is still playing. Ashman died in 1991. There was a memorial. It happened at the Orpheum Theater where the show had played for many, many years. They sang songs and told stories, and I mentioned the cut song "We'll Have Tomorrow" that was sung at that event by Lee Wilcoff and Alan Green, the original Seymour and Audrey.

[48:21] Adam Abraham: I mean, I can't I can't even imagine.

[48:28] David Armstrong: Is that a song we can hear?

[48:29] Adam Abraham: Yes. There is a really nice demo recording of Ashman and Mencken's on the cast album from 2003 as a bonus track.

[48:36] Adam Abraham: Don't you be frightened.

[49:13] Adam Abraham: What they don't know. We'll have to trust me it's true, we'll have to get through clouds will be part, sun will shine bright, we'll have to morrow if we make it through tonight.

[50:03] Adam Abraham: I love you, Seymour.

[50:05] Adam Abraham: I love you too. Just go home now, Audrey.

[50:07] Adam Abraham: I can't leave you with this condition.

[50:09] Adam Abraham: I'm fine. I'll come for you after Life magazine, take your way to that development and dream about. And once we're there, everything will be happy ever after. I promise we'll have a family.

[50:45] Adam Abraham: Weddings are white. We have to roll if we just get through tonight.

[51:03] Adam Abraham: Now go Audrey, please. You're sure you're all right. Don't worry about me. Don't worry about anything, okay? Okay.

[51:12] Adam Abraham: So that was sung on that occasion. Other songs by Ashman, other stories were told. You know, it's a healing for those who survive. He was just a part of so many people's lives. So many people in theater were just denied what he might have done on stage, on screen. I have no idea what. Who knows? The possibilities are truly endless of what he could have done at 40 years old.

[51:33] Adam Abraham: Don't you be frightened. Don't be afraid. If we see tomorrow.

[52:09] David Armstrong: This has been terrific. Where can people find you if they want to hear more about what you're up to next?

[52:14] Adam Abraham: You can find me on Instagram. So go to Abraham.author, Abraham.author. I've got many, many, many pieces that could not make it into the book. A book is finite. The publisher allowed me only 12 images. So I'm gonna post some costume renderings which did not make into the book. Some lyrics and sketches, some photographs, all sorts of fun stuff. So check that out. If you need more Little Shop, that's a good place to go.

[52:38] David Armstrong: Fantastic. And I'm also will invite you to join us in our Broadway Nation Facebook group where we have two thousand very enthusiastic theater fans. And maybe you can share some of those things there as well.

[52:50] Adam Abraham: I will. Thank you.

[52:51] David Armstrong: Thanks, David.

[52:52] Adam Abraham: Seymour was in a funk. He was number zero who the funk. He became a hero, just a punk. He was a forgotten soul and so. Then one day Crash Kerplunk. Don't it go to show you never know?

[53:13] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode. To KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

[53:31] Adam Abraham: I just cut my hand and did a snap. Something out of Edgar Allan Poe.

[53:41] Adam Abraham: Don't shine never know. One day you're slinging hash. You can resurrect it, make a splash. Now you rate the big puppy symbol. And with a thundercrash.

[54:15] Adam Abraham: Look out below. Don't be caught enjoying L.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred