Skip to main content
BPN Logo

Featured Shows

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:16] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[1:11] David Armstrong: In addition, she is the host of the podcast series Stage Door Sessions on Broadway Direct, and she's also reviewed music for VH1 and NPR. This is the first of two episodes in which Elisa joins me to discuss the now 50-year history of Pippin, including its unique origin story and of course its legendary backstage power struggle between a then 23-year-old Wunderkind named Stephen Schwartz, fresh off the overwhelming success of Godspell, and the masterful Broadway show produced one of the most popular, long-running and influential musicals of all time. A show that most certainly has been a tremendous inspiration to now several generations of Broadway showmakers, and which led the way to the pop music-inflected musicals of today. I hope that you will join us for what I guarantee will be a fascinating discussion.

[2:53] Elisa: Oh, thank you, David. It's thrilling to be here. I really appreciate your having me on. How did this book come about? What was the inspiration for doing the incredible amount of research that you obviously had to do to create this book?

[3:05] David Armstrong: Well, um, part of the inspiration was COVID. All the shows shut down, nothing was going on. I'd been thinking about doing a book for a while. My agent had been sort of pushing me very gently in that direction because I'd written chapters for books previously, but never a full book. We started kind of thinking about anniversaries coming up. I realized that Pippin at that point, it was about two years ago, so Pippin had a big anniversary coming in a couple of years, and it's a show I've always loved. It was kind of a gateway from the world of musical theater, which I was immersed in from the time I was a young child, to pop music for me, which became my obsession when I was a little bit older and as a teenager.

It's just a musical I've always loved. I didn't see the original production. I was alive, I was very, very tiny. So I did not get to see that wonderful Bob Fosse production. My parents did and loved it and had the eight-track cassette, I'm dating myself here in the car. And that's how I became fixated on the score.

[4:02] Elisa: You and so many others. I am lucky enough to have seen the original production. It was my very first trip to New York. I was in high school and was completely blown away by that show. I still can remember what it looked like, what it felt like. I saw the original cast, except Dorothy Stickney had already replaced Irene Ryan at that point.

[4:20] David Armstrong: Right. But I think everybody else was in it. Was Jill Clayburgh still in it at that point?

[4:25] Elisa: You know, I thought so, but then when I read your book, it made me question whether I'd seen her or Betty Buckley. My memory was I saw Jill Clayburgh, but you know, it was a long time ago. And then I've had the opportunity to direct Pippin several times. I did an early summer stock production right after it closed on Broadway, and then was pleased to find my most recent production of Pippin mentioned in your book, which was a production that was done at the Fifth Avenue Theater, I don't know, about 15 years ago, maybe at this point.

[4:50] David Armstrong: Yeah, and that has a little scene set at that production in your book, which was fun to see.

[4:55] Elisa: Yeah, with John Rubinstein's ex-wife was in that production.

[4:58] David Armstrong: Is that right?

[4:58] Elisa: Yeah, Jane Lanier played Festrada for us, and she was fantastic. And John and their children came to see the show. I guess John got to see the new ending for the very first time that had been created post-Broadway and had some strong reaction to it, which was interesting to see.

[5:14] David Armstrong: Yeah, well, I guess that different people had different reactions to the new ending. The Theo ending is what it was called, started by Mitch Sebastian Across the Pond. But Stephen Schwartz was very happy with it. He told me that Bob Fosse, he believes would have been happy with it as well.

[5:29] Elisa: Yeah, he came out to work with us on that because I think we were one of the first theaters to institute that ending. And he said the same thing then. He thought Bob would have it would have eliminated at least one point of conflict between the phone.

[5:39] David Armstrong: Oh God. Yeah, that was sort of the ultimate point of conflict from what I gathered. I mean, that was kind of the straw that broke the camel's back, the ending, their disagreement over it.

[5:48] Elisa: So let's work our way there. You tell the entire story of the creation of Pippin from the very, very beginning. And what was that beginning? Where did this all start?

[5:56] David Armstrong: It was at Carnegie Tech, which became Carnegie Mellon, which is where Stephen Schwartz was an undergrad. There was a sort of student-led drama organization called Scotch and Soda, and he became involved with it very early on. I believe as a freshman, he started writing for them and directing. He co-wrote this production of Pippin initially. It was called Pippin Pippin. And it was conceived by another student there. And I'm completely blanking on his name right now. But it was literally a matter of Stephen overhearing him playing this wonderful music and saying, Hmm, what's that? And going in and saying, you know, I think you should make this musical, and I think that I should make it with you.

[6:33] Elisa: Of course, the origin of the musical, the basis was to do it about Charlemagne's eldest son, who was not legitimate, although I spoke to a Princeton medieval history professor, and what was legitimate and what wasn't legitimate back then, there's a little bit of a question about that. But in any case, they took a lot of license with the show. You know, Pippin is not a hunchback as he supposedly was, although there's question about that as well. His story is just completely an invented story, pretty much. And then it became a different story. The story evolved again when Stephen graduated from college and decided to take the show independently because the co-creator at that point did not want to pursue it any further.

[7:13] David Armstrong: And this is the 1960s we're talking about.

[7:16] Elisa: Yes, the late 60s, yeah, like 1968. And then by the time Stephen started pursuing it as an alumnus. At that point, it was maybe around 1970 that he was working on it. 69, 70. First, he got a job as an AR man at a record company, but the whole time he had this show in his head and he had an agent. Leonard Bernstein's sister was his agent, Shirley Bernstein. And he worked with Leonard Bernstein on a show called Mass and also had Godspell. There was Godspell, then there was Mass, and there was Pippin. That was the chronology. Steven is still in his early 20s when this is happening.

[7:59] David Armstrong: He comes to New York with Pippin as his project. Pippin is the show that he has in his pocket, I guess. He has songs that he's written for, he has an idea for a show, but he comes to New York with the idea that that's what he's gonna do. And along the way, Godspell happens.

[8:15] Elisa: That's right. I should point out, and you know this as well, that Pippin was completely original. It was completely distinct from Pippin Pippin. Because his co-creator did not decide to pursue it with him. Stephen decided to write an entirely new score. He wanted an entirely new book, which he got with Roger Hirson eventually.

[8:34] David Armstrong: And how did he find Roger Hirson? Because they come from very different generations and different worlds. How did that match come together?

[8:40] Elisa: He was looking at several different collaborators, and I think Shirley Bernstein might have been in some way connected. Stephen had been interested in experimental theater, and Roger had a sort of sensibility that he liked. Roger had success on television with anthology series, and so they met and it was a good match, even though Stephen was quite a bit younger. Roger was about Fosse's age. They were both in their 40s. Roger Hirson was not a flower child. He was not a member of Stephen Schwartz's generation. Although politically and many other aspects, they seemed to share a lot of sensibilities.

[9:13] David Armstrong: Oh yeah. Well, you know, politically and even creatively in many ways, Bob Fosse and Stephen Schwartz shared a lot. They both were hugely appreciative of the contributions that black artists had made to pop culture in the United States and dance and music. They were both big Fellini fans. They were both vehemently opposed to the Vietnam War. But somehow, all that notwithstanding, the personalities did not mesh.

[9:38] Elisa: So let's take another step toward that. How does Bob Fosse come into the picture? In the meantime, Stephen Schwartz has become one of the most successful creators of musical theater in the world with the success of Godspell.

[9:51] David Armstrong: Yeah, even though he had not had a Broadway show yet. But yeah, he was a rising star.

[9:56] Elisa: Absolutely, a prodigy, really. Which I assume then brought a lot of attention to him. What do you want to do next, Stephen? And what he wanted to do next was Pippin. And that puts him now in a league where he can find the top producers, the top directors. It puts him in a league with Bob Fosse at this point.

[10:13] David Armstrong: Well, yeah, I mean, it certainly puts him in a position at least where you know Bob Fosse could look at this and listen to it and say, oh, maybe I could collaborate with this up-and-coming young artist. And I believe Stuart Ostro, the producer of Pippin, this was back in the Dark Ages when they actually had one main producer of their show. And Stuart Ostro had known Bob Fosse socially. They'd sort of overlap here and there in terms of their work. I know that Stuart Ostro had done a lot of work with Frank Loesser. They knew each other, and the way that Stuart Ostro told this to me was that basically Bob did not like the Bob Fosse. I can't call him Bob because I don't know the guy, you know, he died years and years ago. Never met him. But according to Stuart Ostro, Bob Fosse's reaction to the show was it's a piece of S-word.

[10:59] Elisa: It's a podcast, you can say whatever you want.

[11:01] David Armstrong: Yeah, yeah. Well, in case my parents are listening. And that's actually something where John Rubinstein told me as well. That that's the way he referred to the book. Now, understand this is the book. From what I understand, the irony is that Bob Fosse quite liked the score of Pippin, even though he and Roger Hirson got along quite well. Because Roger Hirson, from what I understand from speaking to people, was kind of like going along to get along. You know, he realized this was a big Broadway show. He'd had one pretty well-received musical before, but this was something on a new scale for him, and he did not want to mess it up. Whereas Steven, he was younger, it was just as big a break for him. But he's also on the top of the world at the moment as well.

[11:41] Elisa: That's right. That's right. He's the young rising creative star of the moment in musical theater.

[11:46] David Armstrong: Which is a dangerous combination to be 23 years old and the new big thing.

[11:52] Elisa: Yeah, and just fresh off of working with Leonard Bernstein, getting a lot of praise for an off-Broadway show that scored a top 10 hit. I think that was the first time that it happened since Some Enchanted Evening. It was definitely a good time to be Stephen Schwartz.

[12:56] David Armstrong: So ironically, the part of the show Fossey falls in love with or is most attracted to is the score. And agrees to do it, presumably because of the score, assuming they'll fix the book along the way. He didn't have any problems with the score. That's something that Stephen Schwartz told me that, you know, they didn't argue over the score. That whenever he told Stephen, you know, maybe we need something else musically here, or went in another direction with the song musically, that that was not an issue. That was never the kind of thing that they thought about. It was really the book that he and Stephen disagreed about and the concept to a certain extent.

[13:30] Elisa: The concept. I mean, Steven spoke a lot about how he thought that there was a crassness, a crudeness to some of the humor that Bob Flossey wanted to bring to it, that there was a cynicism. He didn't trust the audience that they would make an emotional connection with these characters. And with Pippin in particular, because when the musical was conceived, the leading player was not nearly as big a character as he became once Ben Vereen was cast, in part because of Ben Vereen's just extraordinary talent, but also because of Bob Fossey's vision for the show.

[14:02] David Armstrong: He very much wanted this sort of, I guess today you would call him a frenemy, you know, not really an antagonist as much as a foil. Ben Vereen described him as sort of the devil posed on his shoulder, but not in a really awful demonic sense, but in a little bit more of a playful sense. Until the end, of course.

[14:20] Elisa: Until the end, right. Oh, wh yeah, yeah. I guess maybe in the leading player's mind, suicide could be playful, but yeah, no, it's dark stuff in there. But Steven was very keen on making the point that he and Roger Hurston wanted it dark. They liked the darkness. It wasn't the darkness that he objected to. It was more the cynicism. What Stephen Schwartz said about Pippin after rereading it again when we were doing interviews, is that he realized the show needed to be rescued by Bob Fossey to succeed on Broadway, but it needed to be rescued from Bob Fossey to have a long afterlife.

[14:56] David Armstrong: And he said that he realized the main issue was the undercutting of the characters, especially Pippin. And the undercutting of emotion and keeping an aesthetic distance from the audience. So the idea was the audience would really enjoy this and be titillated by it and be thrilled by it. But you know, it was more important to Stephen Schwartz, or I should say as important to Stephen Schwartz, that the audience members care about these characters and about Pippin's journey. And Fossey was very concerned about being seen as being sentimental.

[15:25] Elisa: Yes. In any way. This was hot on the heels of the movie Sweet Charity, which had been a substantial hit, but had not done as well. Certainly the critics were very mixed on it, and nothing stuck in Bob Fosse's craw more at that point in his career anyway, than being accused of sentimentality. He saw, you know, in this leading player figure, I'm sure, you know, I didn't know Bob Fossey, but it's not hard to imagine that he saw it in this showman who is constantly flirting with danger, who is just incredibly seductive, who can be dangerous to himself and to others. I'm sure that sort of resonated with Bob Fosse personally on some level.

[15:42] David Armstrong: It's not hard to see the leading player as Bob Fosse and Pippin as Steven Schwartz.

[16:09] Elisa: That's correct. And a lot of people have said that, but I want to be clear that people I interviewed for the book also thought that that was simplistic. Chet Walker, who we just lost, who was a longtime collaborator of Bob Fossey, said that he would always have this gleam in his eyes, Bob Fossey, like a boyish gleam in his eyes. And I think John Rubinstein compared little Pippin to Little Bobby. There was an eagerness, there was a restlessness, and there was a desire for perfection, of course, in Bob Fosse. He wanted to be extraordinary, as Pippin did, and Bob Fosse certainly was. And he went to all kinds of lengths to make that happen.

[16:45] David Armstrong: So in that reading, Bob Fossey is both the leading player and Pippin. I mean, there are elements of both. I don't know, with Stephen Schwartz, he, by his own admission, was very idealistic, very green at that point. But would be hard pressed to sort of see the leading player as much in Stephen Schwartz, to be honest with you. But he certainly wasn't just Pippin.

[17:09] Elisa: Well, and like any writer, you have to get into the heads of all the characters in order to write them successfully. And he did very well.

[17:15] David Armstrong: That's correct, yeah. Glory.

[17:37] Elisa: Don't go away. Broadway Nation will be right back.

[17:41] ♪ Musical number: "Blood" — performed by Elisa ♪

[18:08] David Armstrong: Let's backtrack a minute. You in your research got to read all the versions of the show, it seems like from your book.

[18:15] Elisa: Well, not whole college version. I got to listen to the college cast recording. Steven gave me a few songs, and then a colleague of mine had a bootleg or something that he slipped to me. I don't even know if you call it a bootleg. It was a CD with all the songs on them. So I got to really hear how different they were. I mean, some of the intention was the same. Texturally, it was just very, very different. And the tone was different. The main thing is that the tone was different. The songs were not nearly as pop as they would later become, which is interesting because they're in college at the time. You'd think they'd be writing the most pop version of it, but they're actually more influenced by traditional musical theater as they're writing it, it sounds like.

[18:55] David Armstrong: Yeah, I think at that point Steven was already heavily influenced by pop music and also by musical theater. Certainly, as structurally, he was very well aware, very well schooled. So his partner in college is Ron Strauss, and they are co-writing the music or trading off on songs. Were they writing the songs together, or some songs written by Ron and some songs written by Stephen?

[19:17] Elisa: I believe the songs were written separately. There was a division of labor. I think that's the term that Stephen used. Because Ron Strauss had already been working on songs before Stephen got involved. His songs tended to be more ballad-like, whereas Stephen, I think he said they were more like musical theater 101 songs. There would be a big dance number or choral number to kind of you know propel the story along. He very much had that musical theater structure in his mind.

[19:44] David Armstrong: And in terms of the book, which they collaborated on, that was a little more of a melodrama. They wanted it to be very witty, very sharp. The Lion in Winter was a very, very popular play at that time, and that was a source of inspiration for them. They wanted to replicate that kind of snappy dialogue that that show has.

[20:02] Elisa: Yeah, they wanted a combination of the snappy dialogue and the sort of family drama. And it was not really about one young man's personal journey. The focus was not as much on Pippin. Pippin was the central character, but it was more about the family drama, the family dynamics, and there was not a leading player at that point. That was not an issue, but it was a very, very different show.

[20:25] David Armstrong: So let's talk about that next draft. After he teams up with Roger O'Herson and the script, presumably that was given to Bob Fossey. You got to see that.

[20:33] Elisa: Right. The fourth wall was sort of broken a little bit, or certainly pushed, and that Stephen had been very inspired by The Seventh Seal, the Ingmar Bergman film. He's a huge Bergman fan, as am I. Interestingly, Death is very prominent in that work as well. And in this case, he had a caravan of players come on, and Pippin was sort of introduced in that way, and then they reappeared at the end. And that iteration went through several revisions in itself. Characters came and went, or characters that had been retained were eventually left aside. But the idea of a troop of traveling players is there from that stage.

[21:14] David Armstrong: Absolutely. It's sort of a framed work in the sense that there's an old man leading the caravan. The old man is the character that evolved into the leading player. Because at first the old man appeared at the beginning and the end. And certainly if he appeared in the middle, he was not the driving force that Ben Vereen's character would become.

[21:33] Elisa: So this old man framing device gets expanded into the character of the leading player.

[21:39] David Armstrong: That's correct. Yeah. Partly that happens during the casting process, doesn't it?

[21:43] Elisa: It does. It does, because they discover Ben Vereen, and I think Bob Fossey had always wanted a dancer for the role of the old man. But you know, to find an older actor who dances with that much dynamism might have been challenging. But it was more, I suspect, just the combination of talent that Ben Vereen had as a singer, as a dancer, the charisma. They knew this was someone who could really carry a show.

[22:07] David Armstrong: And Ben Vereen had worked for Fossey prior to this.

[22:09] Elisa: Yes, he had. Ben Vereen had first come to the attention of Bob Fosse when he auditioned for a tour of Sweet Charity and eventually appeared in the film as well. So Fosse was quite familiar with him. And anybody who'd been really following musical theater at that point, Ben Vereen was on their radar. He'd just been Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar. He wasn't the type necessarily. It was supposed to have been an older character and a smaller character. Then he came along and they just fell in love with him, and understandably so.

[22:38] David Armstrong: And of course, when Ben Vereen's in the room, you're gonna give him more to do.

[22:41] Elisa: That's correct. Yes. If you're not crazy or stupid, yes.

[22:45] David Armstrong: Exactly. That's right. Ben Vereen spoke about at one point being at a reading and looking at the script and thinking, oh my gosh, I have nothing to do here. And Fosse's just sort of looking at him and laughing and saying, Don't worry, we're gonna fix this. You're gonna be very happy with your part. In your book, you talk about this casting process, and at the same time, the work on the show is happening between Fossey and the writers. They're developing the show at the same time they're casting it. And it's always interesting to read who was considered for parts.

[23:16] Elisa: I love that in any of these kinds of books where you get your hands on the casting sheets or the callback sheets, and you get to see who was considered to play these roles, which is always fun. Yeah, there were a number of people who either were at that point rising actors or were established actors, even, or who would become established actors. John Travolta auditioned and Stephen Schwartz loved him, but said, not this show, but he really encouraged him to pursue a career, and obviously he was on to something there. But lots of big familiar names.

[23:47] David Armstrong: As Elisa tells us in her book, other actors that were auditioned or at least considered for the title role included John Denver, Arlo Guthrie, Peter Noon, Davy Jones, Mickey Dolans, David Cassidy, Richard Gere, Christopher Walken, and Michael Crawford. And of course, the cast that they came up with created several major stars. Jill Clayburgh became a big movie star out of that.

[24:10] Elisa: That's right. John Rubinstein would go on to a lot of acclaim, and these were really early first jobs for the two of them.

[24:16] David Armstrong: Yeah, yeah. And certainly propelled Ben Vereen even further and Anne Ranking as well. And the big established star, in a way, or at least the star of the moment was Irene Ryan, who was such an incredible sort of casting coup.

[24:31] Elisa: Well, you are as old as I, my dear, and I hope that you never are. You will woefully wonder why, my dear, through your cataracts and Qatar, you could squander away or sequester a drop of a precious year.

[24:54] David Armstrong: Or when your best days are yesterday, the restored twice as dear.

[25:02] Elisa: Yeah, from the Beverly Hillbillies.

[25:05] David Armstrong: You're a little too young, but anybody who remembers that, that was the biggest show on television.

[25:10] Elisa: Yeah, in fact, her character was named Granny, is that right?

[25:13] David Armstrong: Granny Clampett, yeah.

[25:14] Elisa: Granny Clampett, because Steven Schwartz was afraid that because her big song, Just No Time at All, there's a lyric, A Man Who Calls Me Granny. And he was afraid that that would seem like he was making a very obvious reference.

[25:27] ♪ Musical number ♪

[25:56] David Armstrong: He had written that lyric prior to her cast, and then he thought people would think he just put it in to play on her TV show.

[26:08] Elisa: Oh, they didn't care. She got a standing ovation every night, and she stuck around for it.

[26:14] David Armstrong: Now say just weak, the age is sweet. Good deeds and good work earn you laurel. But what can make you feel more obsolete than being noted for your moral?

[26:28] Elisa: Here is a secret I never have told. Maybe you'll understand why. I believe if I refuse to grow old, I can stay young till I die.

[26:43] David Armstrong: Now I've known a peers of 66 years. I've had troubles and tears by the score. But the only thing I trade up for is 67.

[26:57] Elisa: She has one song in the show, as people who know the show know, and she completely stopped the show cold.

[27:04] David Armstrong: Now I have to say that when I saw the show, Dorothy Stickney did the same thing. So part of it is just a terrific performer in that number in that show.

[27:13] Elisa: But I love that anecdote you talk about. She was so happy to be back on Broadway. And of course, the way the number staged, they take her off at the end. She's not on stage when the audience applauds.

[27:25] David Armstrong: That's right. But she would not want to go to her dressing room.

[27:28] Elisa: Nope. She was like, I'm staying right here.

[27:31] David Armstrong: And a couple of original cast members told me about that. Pamela Sousa was one. And why didn't she want to go to her dressing room?

[27:38] Elisa: Because she wanted to hear the applause. She wanted to hear every bit of that applause. She did not want to miss a single second of it, a single millisecond of it.

[27:47] David Armstrong: People just thought she was adorable. The whole cast who were at that point in their 20s and 30s, most of them, a couple in their forties, but mostly very young, got a real kick out of it.

[27:56] Elisa: And watching her play before.

[28:01] David Armstrong: Makes me feel the older in just no.

[28:17] Elisa: You had a chance to speak to all of the surviving members of the cast?

[28:21] David Armstrong: Most of the surviving cast members, I did not speak to the boy who played Theo. I tried desperately to find him, but he has changed his name. And I actually found this out about a month after the book was at the printer. One of the cast members was like, I found him, I found him. I think he sort of moved in a very different direction with his life.

[28:41] Elisa: And the other person I did not speak with was Walter Willison, which was entirely my fault, because he's still very much around. And he was Pippin's standby and could have told me, I'm sure, a few stories of his own.

[28:53] David Armstrong: But we have to sell enough copies of this book that there will be a second edition, and his stories will be in that. In fact, he is producing and directing a sort of reunion at 54 Below for the 50th anniversary.

[29:12] Elisa: That's right. Now they're happening. They're permanently pushed. They're on a different timeline now.

[29:18] David Armstrong: What was interesting to me is that so many of the cast members look back on this as an incredibly important, meaningful, almost magical time in their lives. That company was very tight. By Broadway standards, it was a relatively small cast for the time. Now it would be a big cast, but in those days it was a smaller group of people, and it seems like it was a very intense experience.

[29:39] Elisa: It was, and I mean, you have to remember that these actors were essentially playing members of a cult. Fossey called the trio, the big trio that does the number in the middle of glory, the Manson Trio.

[30:08] David Armstrong: And that was something that was very much in his mind. It was on everybody's mind at that time. It was only a couple of years after the murders had happened. And Vietnam was lurking in the background. There was a lot of stuff going on in the bigger culture. Music was changing, theater was changing.

[30:25] Elisa: And in terms of music changing, a chapter I also found very interesting was the show's relationship to Motown.

[30:30] David Armstrong: Oh, yeah, yeah. I remember that the album came out on Motown Records. I mentioned that to my I teach a history class at the University of Washington about the history of the Broadway musical, and I mentioned that it was the first and I think only cast album to ever come out on Motown Records.

[30:46] Elisa: And then I had to explain what Motown Records was.

[30:49] David Armstrong: Oh no!

[30:50] Elisa: How is that possible?

[30:52] David Armstrong: That's awful. 20-year-olds today does. They have the internet. How can they not know Motown?

[30:59] Elisa: Well, I could have assigned them to go figure it out, but they asked me what's the significance of Motown.

[31:03] David Armstrong: So tell us how did Barry Gordy come into the picture? How did that match get made?

[31:06] Elisa: Stephen Schwartz fell in love with Motown music early on because it was groovy. It was just beautiful, impeccably produced, melodic, rhythmic, soaring pop music that appealed to white and black fans that cut across racial divides.

[31:25] David Armstrong: Barry Gordy was a leading black entrepreneur. So in addition to having black artists, including black writers and producers, you had this black businessman. And that was a huge thing at the time.

[31:37] Elisa: And like George Gershwin, like Leonard Bernstein before him, Stephen Schwartz was really heavily influenced by black music, as American music is at large. He was very much a fan of Dozier Holland, the great producer songwriting team behind many of the Motown hits.

[31:54] David Armstrong: You can hear it in the music for Godspell. You can even hear, I think, more of a soulfulness, more of a grooviness in his musical scores than you can in a lot of rock-influenced musical scores, which are more sort of arena rock informed, I would argue, in some cases, more bombastic, less graceful.

[32:14] Elisa: Maybe that's the word I want. There's a grace and a theatricality and a muscle that Motown's music had that really made it, I think, a good fit.

[32:23] David Armstrong: And it turned out that there was a backers audition. And one of Barry Gordy's executive assistants or creative assistants, somebody who worked very closely with him, Suzanne DePas, who was very young herself at the time, about Stephen Schwartz's age, went to listen, was just completely knocked out by the score, and told Barry Gordy about this.

[32:42] Elisa: And eventually Barry Gordy went and listened to the music himself, apparently loved it.

[32:46] David Armstrong: Didn't Stephen Schwartz perform it for Barry Gordy at some point?

[32:50] Elisa: He did, that's correct. Once Barry Gordy expressed interest, a meeting was set up. It was in a hotel, I believe, in Beverly Hills, and he just sat at a piano, played the music for Barry Gordy, and Barry Gordy said, I'm in and wound up investing.

[33:04] David Armstrong: I think he was the single biggest investor in the show when Motown Records also got to release the original cast album. That was their first original cast album.

[33:12] Elisa: Barry Gordy making great use of this investment that he made, brought Pippin into the entire Motown organization.

[33:18] David Armstrong: That's right, and brought along some of its biggest names for the ride. You've got the Jackson Five, you've got a young Michael Jackson, and you've got The Supremes shortly after Diana Ross left the group, performing songs from the show on their own.

[33:31] Elisa: And the album was produced more like a pop album than a show album.

[33:36] David Armstrong: Yes. They brought in ringers, as you call session singers to kind of buff up the sound because another big point of contention between Stephen Schwartz and Bob Fossey was that Stephen had wanted more really strong voices in the show, where Bob Fossey wanted the dancers. He cared much less about the singers.

[33:50] Elisa: So when it came time to record the album, Stephen and Phil Ramone hired singers to kind of come into the studio and really beef up the sound.

[34:27] David Armstrong: And in fact, one of the cast members I spoke with remembers hearing the album and listening with another cast member and thinking, huh, is that us?

[34:37] Elisa: Wow, we sound really amazing.

[34:39] David Armstrong: And then realizing, all right, well, maybe there's a little bit of extra help. Maybe there's some special sauce added there.

[34:47] David Armstrong: Elisa and I will be back next week with even more of the behind-the-scenes story of Pippin, especially how that simmering conflict between Stephen Schwartz and Bob Fossey finally came to a head during the rehearsals and out-of-town tryout as Pippin headed for its opening on Broadway.

[35:23] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong.

[35:37] David Armstrong: Special thanks to Powell's Mox for his help with editing this episode, to KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred