My guest again today is director Sheldon Epps, and this is the third and final part of our recent conversation about his long and successful career as he relates it in his new book: My Own Directions — A Black Man’s Journey in the American Theatre... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
About
My guest again today is director Sheldon Epps, and this is the third and final part of our recent conversation about his long and successful career as he relates it in his new book:
My Own Directions — A Black Man’s Journey in the American Theatre.
If you missed the previous episodes it may be helpful to listen to those before joining us for this one.
In 1997 when Sheldon was appointed the Artistic Director of the Pasadena Playhouse he became the first black person to lead a major theater company in Southern California and one of the only three artists of color to hold that position nationwide. And as he writes in his book, “in the words of a song from Hallelujah, Baby! being good wasn’t going to be good enough. Aiming for greatness was required as there were those who were there to support that goal, and there were others who most certainly were waiting for me to fail.”
In the last episode Sheldon shared with us how he met the many challenges of revitalizing what at the time was a somewhat faded theater company and successfully transforming both its audience and its Artistic Mission. And he was able to accomplish all of that despite the severe financial challenges that the Playhouse faced mostly due to a large loan that had be taken out decades earlier. As we ended that episode Sheldon was telling us how those economic problems finally became so overwhelming that it was decided that the Playhouse needed to close down for a time and take what Sheldon called an “Intermission” so that that the debt issues could be addressed. But it was not at all clear to him or anyone else if the PP’s curtain would ever go up on a second act. And that’s where we pick up our conversation today.
Later in the episode we have what I think is a very illuminating discussion about the challenges that Artistic Directors now face, especially in regard to the way that Boards of Trustees of non-profit theater companies have changed over the last 25 years. It 's my favorite part of the episode.
And we also discuss Sheldon's all black production Kiss Me Kate, and his Broadway musical Play On!, which took Shakespeare's Twelfth Night and reset it in Harlem in the 1930's using the the songs of Duke Ellington.
Become A PATRON of Broadway Nation!
This episode is made possible in part by the generous support of"Producer Level” Patron
TRACY WELLENS
If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!
For a just $7.00 a month you can receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussion that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. And you will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast. And all patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast.
Special thanks to our newest PATRON:
ALEJANDRO MEMBRENO
And If you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.
If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:
https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/
Thank you in advance for your support!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:06] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.
[0:47] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and my guest again today is Director Sheldon Epps, and this is the third and final part of our recent conversation regarding his long and successful career as he relates it in his new book, My Own Directions: A Black Man's Journey in the American Theater. If you missed the previous episodes, it may be helpful to listen to those before joining us for this one. This episode is made possible in part by the generous support of producer-level patron Tracy Wellens. And I also want to give a special shout-out to our newest patron, Alejandro Membrano. If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation, I'll have information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a patron.
[1:29] David Armstrong: In 1997, when Sheldon was appointed the artistic director of the Pasadena Playhouse, he became the first black person to lead a major theater company in Southern California, and one of only three artists of color to hold that position nationwide. As he writes in his book, in the words of a song from Hallelujah Baby, being good wasn't going to be good enough. Aiming for greatness was required as there were those who were there to support that goal, and there were others who most certainly were waiting for me to fail. In our last episode, Sheldon shared with us how he met the many challenges of revitalizing what at the time was a somewhat faded theater company and successfully transforming both its audience and its artistic mission.
And he was able to accomplish all of that despite the severe financial challenges that the Playhouse faced, mostly due to a large loan that had been taken out decades earlier. As we ended that episode, Sheldon was telling us how a decade into his tenure at the Playhouse, those economic problems finally became so overwhelming that it was decided that the Playhouse needed to close down for a time and take what Sheldon called an intermission. But it was not at all clear to him or anyone else if the Pasadena Playhouse's curtain would ever go up again on a second act. And that's where we pick up our conversation today. Here we go. Why did you think it was necessary to shut down? What was the effect that was needed?
[2:56] Sheldon Epps: We needed to get rid of an age-old debt load that had existed over many years that frankly had been paid off in interest times and times over. So we needed to go through, and you know, I learned all of this. I knew none of this. You know, all of this business stuff. We needed to go through what's described as a limited bankruptcy process to eliminate that debt load, which was almost entirely of those old bank loans, and or to pay off some specific debts to get those off the books. The other thing we had to do was to honor the subscription debt that was due during the time that we closed. So you couldn't just close and say all that subscription money you gave us, we're just keeping. No, we had to deliver those plays without any more income coming in.
So you had to raise enough money, number one, to produce those plays and to produce those plays without depending on subscription dollars. You could sell single tickets, but the subscribers had to get those plays for free. They'd already paid for them. Now, fortunately, now this was a blessing. This was one of the many good things that happened. You had to go to the subscribers and you had to say, okay, we're going to try to come back, but we're not promising you that you will. Do you want your money back? If you want your money back, we're going to have to find a way to give you your money back. Or you can trust us and stick with us and we'll give you the plays when we come back. Out of thousands of subscribers, only about 50 people said, I want the money back.
The other said, Oh no, no, no, no, no. We want you to survive. We just want the plays when you're ready to do them again. That kind of goodwill, you can't put any kind of price tag on that. And in fact, if the thousands had said, we want our money back instead of we'll wait for the plays, I don't know how we would have dealt with that, frankly. That probably would have put you under.
[4:57] Sheldon Epps: Yeah. But is that kind of loyalty from the audience that was so wonderful? And also answered the question does anybody care? Yes, they did care. They did care about the theater and they did want it to survive. Well, and as you say in your book, part of this was to demonstrate to the community and I guess to the world that people cared about the theater enough to help it to revive it, to bring it back. And this is a good example of that. And then, of course, the other good example was we got some unexpected but major, major donations, which really kept us afloat. Now, my big fear was that we would reopen and be a lesser theater. That to me personally would have been worse. But fortunately, we were able to come out of bankruptcy and quickly became as substantial a theater as we had been before and produced at the same level rather than at a lesser level.
I want to follow up on that, but I also want to talk a little bit more about this dark period, as you call it. One of the horrible aspects of this dark period was the idea that the theater was failing got tied into some racist feelings that were already there about you and your programming.
[6:05] Sheldon Epps: Yeah, that was the darkest of the dark period. Shortly after we announced that we were closing, a number of people, not a small number of people, or rather a substantial number of people started to say that the reason Pasadena Playhouse had to close was because of my black agenda. And all of these black plays that I was doing that I was forcing onto an audience that didn't want them were the reason that nobody was coming to the theater anymore. And you know, nobody was supporting the theater anymore. Well, the fact is that many of those productions were the things that kept the theater alive during some tough times, where some of our biggest sellers and most popular productions. But in the midst of that process, you can't argue with that kind of odious statement.
You can't fight back because then you just sound defensive and you sound like you have something to feel guilty about. What makes it even worse is it wasn't true on two fronts. It wasn't true that those productions were weighing the theater down. They were, as you just said, among the biggest successes that the theater had. And they weren't even anywhere near the majority of the programming. They weren't the majority of the programming. And as I said before, the real reason for the financial problems was a debt load from decades before. So none of it was true.
[7:21] Sheldon Epps: Exactly. You know, and therefore more painful and even more debilitating because you couldn't fight back. And there were certain things that you just couldn't say legally as part of this legal process that was going on. That was really a terrible time. And as I said in the book, that's what set me off and sitting in the dark in the theater with the ghost light in me, just sort of willing the theater back into existence. Well, and you get interviewed by the press during this time, which turns out to be a fateful stroke of luck.
[7:53] Sheldon Epps: Yes. A wonderful reporter named Pat Morrison came to me, fortunately, believing that the theater was going to come out of this intermission. And she said, what is it going to take for the theater to get back up and running? And I'll be honest, that was early in the process, so I didn't really know. But I quickly calculated my head, well, if we can get two million dollars together and present that to our judge in the process, I believe that could get us open again. And for a theater that's closed, raising two million dollars is a lot of money. But she printed that, and it was in the LA Times editorial section, interestingly, not the entertainment section. And about two days after it was printed, I got a phone call from someone who said, Is it true that this is what the theater needs to reopen?
And I said, Yes, it is true. And they said, Well, my wife and I will give you half of that. We will give you a million dollars if you're able to match the million dollars from within the community and other supporters. And this is someone you don't know at this point.
[8:56] Sheldon Epps: This is someone I had met, but I don't know well, and I certainly don't know that they have this affinity for the playoffs. And it's someone who turns out to be quite famous and well known. The man on the other end of the phone was Mike Stoller of Lieber and Stoller, the great songwriters. His wife, Corky Hale Stoller, who is also a great jazz musician. She's the one who read the article and said, I want to do something. I want to help Sheldon and I want to help this theater. And another gracious donor came up with half of that match pretty quickly. And then it was our board. Our board really pulled together and said, okay, we've got another $500,000 to go and we're gonna make it happen. And that is what helped to move us through the process much more quickly than anybody anticipated.
[9:42] David Armstrong: Amazing. And the mystery of it all, because you weren't allowed to reveal who the donors were.
[9:47] Sheldon Epps: Yes, for a while they said that they wanted it to be an anonymous donation. They didn't want credit or praise or anything. Eventually, they did let us announce it and celebrate them at a gala and all of that. But initially, I kept saying an anonymous donation, and of course that made people not believe me.
[10:07] David Armstrong: Yeah, yeah, right.
[10:08] Sheldon Epps: Yeah, sure. There's some anonymous million dollar donor. Yeah, sure. It's a great story. And you call the next chapter coming out of the dark.
[10:17] Sheldon Epps: And you also quote the lyric, the best is yet to come. And I think that's true because you do get back to work in a major way. And as you said before, not in a lesser way. Yeah, there was a little period in there where the theater community, the national theater community that I'd by that time built up quite a good relationship with, was a little skeptical. Well, you know, if we work with them, will they actually deliver the production? Foundations were saying if we give you money, will the theater actually stay open? But goodwill and tenacity turned us around that corner, and we were really solidly back in business very, very quickly, doing big productions again, big ambitious work again, some of it with your theater. In co-productions with Fifth Avenue Theater and Arena Stage in Washington and The Alliance. And so that fear of mine that we were going to come back a lesser producing organization was eradicated pretty quickly.
[11:20] David Armstrong: Don't go away, Sheldon and I will be right back.
[11:40] ♪ Musical number: "The Best Is Yet to Come" — performed by Unknown performer ♪
[12:12] David Armstrong: And what were some of those productions that you produced in the revival of the theater?
[12:17] Sheldon Epps: We did a wonderful production, uh, a musical version of Oliver Twist that Debbie Allen directed called Twist. That was a very big ambitious production. We did Waterfall, which was a production that we did with Fifth Avenue Theater. One of the most exciting things we did was not the first, but the production of A Night with Janice Joplin right before it moved to Broadway. And that was so great, David, because suddenly, after having sat in that dark theater and being the only person sitting there, suddenly the theater was absolutely packed with people cheering and rocking out and dancing in the aisles and this incredible energy coming from the show on the stage and from the audience that really said, okay, this theater is absolutely alive once again in an incredibly exciting and wonderful way.
[13:06] David Armstrong: And you also did one of your dream projects during this time.
[13:09] Sheldon Epps: Yes.
[13:09] David Armstrong: What was that dream project?
[13:11] Sheldon Epps: It had always been my desire to do a production of Kiss Me Kate, primarily with black actors singers, not just as a trick. I sometimes call productions like that dipped in chocolate, but you know, I think you have to have a reason to do that. And I was really doing it as an homage to black touring companies in their 30s and 40s. There was a tradition of taking classical material and applying jazz and you know the rhythm of the African American culture to them. So you had things like a musical version of A Midsummer Night's Dream called Swingin' the Dream with Louis Armstrong and the Hot Makado with Bilbo Jangles Robinson, and even the Voodoo Macbeth that Orson Wells did. But there was a tradition of taking classical material and adapting it to the musical theater.
And people forget that in Kiss Me Kate, they are doing a musical version of Taming of the Shrew. They're not doing the play Taming of the Shrew. So even that was a great compliment and natural fit for this concept.
[14:13] David Armstrong: And you had an incredible cast of dynamic black performers.
[14:17] Sheldon Epps: I did. Wonderful cast, headed by Wayne Brady as Fred Petrucchio, and Merle Dandridge as Lily and Kate, who were just so brilliant and great company leaders. And that's so important to have the people in the leads literally not just play the lead, but lead the company, you know, and establish a spirit for the work and a level of artistry for the work.
[14:43] David Armstrong: So, in spite of this renewed success that you're having, well deserved, you start to, in the back of your head, think I may be time to go on to something else. What was the thinking behind that?
[14:55] Sheldon Epps: Well, in truth, maybe nobody knew it, but I was actually thinking it before the dark period. I'd always said that I was going to stay at the theater in sort of five-year increments, you know, that I would go, oh, this will be nice for five years. And after that, five years, I say, okay, maybe I'll stay another five. Then I say, All right, I'm gonna stay another five to fifteen, but that's it. And around about year 14 or 15, every time I would take a breath to say I'm leaving, something would happen. You know, either a managing director, executive director would announce they were leaving, or we would get a good grant, which had to be worked on over a multi-year period, or some challenge would occur that kept me from leaving.
But I always felt that it was important not to stay around for 35 years as a previous generation of artistic directors had done, to not stay too long at the fair, so to speak, that was just healthy, healthy for me, but also healthy for the organization to have a new vision and a new sensibility. After we came out of the dark, I really decided that it was time to move on.
[15:57] Sheldon Epps: And also the focus in all American theaters became so much about the money and hit making and how do you survive and yet still have some sense of adventure and daring about true theater. And boards seemed less and less inclined to support the daring and the adventure and more inclined to depend on the hits. And it was just tiring, frankly. It got to be just tiring and exhausting.
[16:24] David Armstrong: I'm right there with you. And I think that this may be in some ways the most important part of the book because I think it shines a light on something that hasn't been talked about in the public enough. Among artistic directors, certainly it's been talked about over and over and over again. But this change in boards that happened over what, the last 20 years, maybe not even that long, has been in the way boards think, way the board members think, and who those board members are, has made producing theater very, very hard to do, very challenging, and now is still a big problem, even though we are focusing on other problems at the moment, which are also equally valid.
[17:02] Sheldon Epps: Yeah. The beginning of this movement of resident theater companies or regional theater companies was all about establishing companies that would be about their communities and serving their communities with their art and delivering work that was new and fresh and exciting for the community, and developing art that perhaps would go on to other theaters or New York or around the world or whatever. And that's what the board was there to do. The board was to help serve that mission. Somewhere around the time that the theater went dark, and certainly the years after that, it seemed that the concentration has become all about the money and less about the art. They want the art to be good. I'm not saying that.
But they're not understanding that the art is not self-supporting and cannot be. In the same way that people understand there is no profit university. There is no profit hospital. There is no profit ballet company or opera company. Somehow, and I think it's because there is something called Broadway that is a profit center. People tend to think that theaters can exist by making hits and selling a lot of tickets. Well, that's really impossible. Number one, your runs are not long enough, and there is no way to predict that everything is going to be a hit. You certainly can't predict that if you're trying to do new work and exciting work and different work. So that shift in thinking is very, very dangerous for the American theater as a whole. And boards have started to, I believe, more and more relinquish the responsibility for supporting the dream of making art in favor of becoming fiscal protectors.
[18:48] David Armstrong: You know?
[18:48] Sheldon Epps: Absolutely. And you got a new board chair who came with this philosophy and belief, which made things very, very difficult. He made things very, very difficult and you know, started to say things like, Well, why can't you just do what they do on Broadway? I said, Well, what is that? And he said, Well, they just choose plays that make hits all the time, which of course we know how naive I'll use that word is. The latest figures, I believe, are one out of every five shows makes its money back, even returns its investment on Broadway.
[19:18] David Armstrong: Exactly.
[19:18] Sheldon Epps: So, you know, it came to the point, and this was late in my game as artistic director, when I had to say, You're in the banking business, and I'm sure you're very good at the banking business. I would never assume that I should come into your office and tell you how to run your banking business. Please don't come into mine and tell me how to run the theater. I've been at this a long time and I am fiscally responsible. I do understand the business part of it, but I also understand that it's not a bank. You know, I understand that part of what we do is to support daring and adventure without constantly have to worry about how many tickets do we sell.
[20:01] David Armstrong: Absolutely we share many of those same frustrations. The only thing that was um somewhat comforting about it was I ran into Gordon Davidson right before he retired and he said the same thing. He said, you know, I'm just a little tired of people being suspect of my ability to run this organization. I know what I'm doing. I do know how to do this and I do it very well. But I need that partnership and that's what I constantly have to get the board to understand. I'm not working for them I'm working with them.
[20:34] Sheldon Epps: We are in partnership to keep this noble endeavor going.
[20:38] Sheldon Epps: Exactly you are made to feel like there's no trust you hired me to do this job. If you don't think I can do this job then you should fire me. But in the meantime you should listen to what I'm saying about how this business works. Yes yes you should be there to support my vision and to adopt my vision. And if you don't like the vision change the artistic director exactly.
[21:01] Sheldon Epps: I worry right now with so many new artistic directors being given these positions, which is fantastic, that those burdens on top of every other burden are going to be really challenging for them to handle.
[21:13] David Armstrong: I think so too.
[21:15] Sheldon Epps: Outside of the challenges that we've always had, the extraordinary challenges brought on, number one, by COVID and the people's feeling about even going into a theater, plus the extraordinary expenses brought on by COVID regulations, and then the additional expenses that inflation has brought on with lumber costs, material costs, electric bill costs. The challenges of running a theater now are just overwhelming.
[21:44] Sheldon Epps: I applaud the bravery of anybody who's willing to do it during this particular moment in time and constantly sending them strength that they can hold on long enough. Because I know how hard it was, even without the current contemporary challenges.
[22:00] Sheldon Epps: I applaud anybody who has the bravery or the craziness to try to run a theater company right now.
[22:13] David Armstrong: One of the most successful ventures of your career was again combining these diverse elements, Shakespeare, musical theater. You combined all these elements together to create a new vision that you've gone back to several times over your career. Talk a little bit about Play On!
[22:53] Sheldon Epps: Come in into Grand Central Station, New York, New York. That's just music to your ears. Hey, hey! Just one minute! Just one minute! Just one down home in that. Which way Harlem? Which way Harlow? Don't go downtime. Don't go up time. You must take the A train to go. I'll consider the way I'm behind.
[23:50] Sheldon Epps: So I had seen a production at the National Theatre Company in New York of Time In of Athens that used Duke Ellington's Shakespeare Suite as the underscoring. And I thought it was fascinating and delicious and wonderful. So I said, okay, I'll do my favorite play, Twelfth Night, that way. And that would have been fine, but I thought not quite ambitious enough. I was taking a walk in the woods behind my parents' home in North Carolina and just had one of those light bulb moments where literally I just said, Twelfth Night Shakespeare, Harlem in the 30s, Duke Ellington songs. And that got me started.
[24:27] Sheldon Epps: I went about writing a scenario for a show based on the Twelfth Night plot and the Twelfth Night characters, and told myself that I would only move forward with this if I could validly tell the story and advance the characters with Duke Ellington songs. And I didn't know if I could really find parallel songs to Shakespeare's Twelfth Night. But Duke Ellington was so inexhaustible in his catalog that if I just kept digging, I could always find what I needed.
[25:00] Sheldon Epps: Never screen, sweet and gentle. The way she should. Again, a moment of heaven, theatrical heaven for me to be doing this dream project with all those great people.
[26:16] Sheldon Epps: And this dream project takes you to Broadway. Then you recreate the show at the Pasadena Playhouse at a very key moment as well.
[26:23] Sheldon Epps: Yeah, at one of those moments where finances again were an issue and we were running ahead of that snowball. And I kind of said, Well, if we're going to go down, I want to go down flaming, you know, not just meekly and quietly, but let's do something big and bold. And I went out and found some extra money to do a production of Play On! at Pasadena. Everybody told me that it was far too ambitious and I was being crazy, but I just had an instinct, and it's something I talk about in the book, that sometimes you just got to operate by your instincts, that if we could do it right, and I believed we could, it was really going to take off in Los Angeles.
[27:01] Sheldon Epps: I found the money to put it together and got a great cast out here of Los Angeles musical performers and sweated it out, of course, until the day after opening when you got this really glowing review. And again, this was early in my tenure at Pasadena Playhouse. It was certainly great for the theater, but also a great thing for me early in my tenure at the theater.
[27:24] David Armstrong: I love that you call it this theatrical gut sense that you have to have as an artistic director to make bold choices like that, sometimes, which might seem a little crazy or a little foolhardy, but that's part of the job as I define it as you're supposed to be able to tap into the zeitgeist of that moment to know what to do.
[27:43] Sheldon Epps: No, that's true. I don't think you can be an artist, and I don't think that you can be an artistic director operating only from intellect and logic, even. There are moments when it's got to be about the feeling on something, the instinct, the inner voice, which is just telling you go this way, go down this path, go in this direction. You've got to be a combination of secure enough and crazy enough to listen to that inner voice and know that that inner voice is there to serve you. And fortunately, for much of my career, the inner voice has served me very well.
[28:22] David Armstrong: Well, I think that is what is so wonderfully told in your new book, My Own Directions: A Black Man's Journey in the American Theater. Sheldon Epps, thank you so much for joining us today on Broadway Nation.
[28:33] Sheldon Epps: Thank you, David. This has been a great conversation. Thanks so much.
[29:02] ♪ Musical number: "It Don't Mean a Thing (If It Ain't Got That Swing)" — performed by Duke Ellington ♪
[29:11] David Armstrong: If you're in the swing of this podcast, I invite you to become a patron of Broadway Nation. For a contribution of just seven dollars a month, you can receive exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast. And in fact, I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the podcast version. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on Broadway Nation. And all patrons will receive special on-air shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for this podcast. To join, go to Broadway Nation Podcast. Supercast dot tech. That's S-U-P-E-R-C-A-S-T dot tech. Or you can find the link in the show notes to this episode, or in our Broadway Nation Facebook group, which I also invite you to join.
[30:04] David Armstrong: Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode, to KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
