This is the second episode of my three-part conversation with author, historian, researcher, and archivist, Michael Owen, whose recent book, Ira Gershwin — A Life in Words, is the first full-length biography devoted to that outstanding artist who penned the words for many of the greatest songs of the 20th Century... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
About
This is the second episode of my three-part conversation with author, historian, researcher, and archivist, Michael Owen, whose recent book, Ira Gershwin — A Life in Words, is the first full-length biography devoted to that outstanding artist who penned the words for many of the greatest songs of the 20th Century.
If you missed part one, you may want to catch up with that before listening to this one.
Michael Owen is also the author of Go Slow — The Life of Jule London and the editor of The Gershwins Abroad.
Become A PATRON of Broadway Nation!
This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our Patron Club Members such as Alan Brodie.
If you are a fan of Broadway Nation, I invite you to become a PATRON!
For as little as $7.00 a month you can receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussion that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. And you will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast. And all patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast.
And If you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.
If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:
https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/
Thank you in advance for your support!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:25] David Armstrong: Welcome to Broadway Nation, the podcast that explores the remarkable history of the Broadway musical with a particular focus on the immigrant Jewish queer and black artist who invented it.
[0:37] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and this is the second episode of my three-part conversation with author, historian, researcher, and archivist Michael Owen, whose recent book Ira Gershwin, A Life in Words, is the first full-length biography devoted to that extraordinary artist who penned the words for many of the greatest songs of the 20th century.
[0:58] David Armstrong: If you missed part one, you may want to catch up with that before listening to this one.
[1:02] David Armstrong: Before we begin, I want to thank the many patrons of Broadway Nation whose generous contributions are crucial to my ability to produce this podcast.
[1:10] David Armstrong: With a special shout out today to longtime patron Alan Brody.
[1:15] David Armstrong: If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation, I'll have information at the end of the episode about how you too can become a patron.
[1:23] David Armstrong: Here we go. Let's talk a little bit about Porgy and Bess, because of course that becomes, I guess, the biggest event of their career.
[1:41] Michael Owen: As opposed to DuBose Hayward, who wrote the lyrics for the recitative in the show and the dialogue in the show, and many of the songs.
[1:51] Michael Owen: Everyone can recall that famous Sondheim editorial when they came out with the Gershwin' Porgy and Bess, and how incensed he was about that.
[1:59] Michael Owen: But you paint a much more complicated story.
[2:02] Michael Owen: Not that Sondheim was entirely wrong, but there's much more involvement from Ira in the lyrics throughout the show.
[2:09] Michael Owen: That is true. Ira was an integral part of the creation of Porgy and Bess.
[2:14] Michael Owen: From the beginning.
[2:15] Michael Owen: Debose Hayward had written the novel, Porgy, and DuBose and his wife Dorothy had written the successful play a couple of years later.
[2:21] Michael Owen: And George had approached DuBose Hayward many years back in the twenties about writing an opera or writing a work based on the novel.
[2:29] Michael Owen: It was just Porgy. So when eventually George got down to writing the opera, DuBose Hayward was not a lyricist.
[2:42] Michael Owen: He was not familiar with how singers need to be able to breathe at certain points. It's going to be really hard for somebody to sing that vocal combination right at that point with that note and all that.
[2:52] Michael Owen: So maybe we're going to adjust this. But the working history of Porgy and Bess was such that a lot of it was done by mail, you know, George being in New York, Hayward being in the Carolinas.
[3:02] Michael Owen: Ira for much of the time was actually working on other shows with the composers because George was working on the score.
[3:09] Michael Owen: But Ira was always on hand.
[3:10] Michael Owen: Yes, I mean Ira was responsible. If you look in Robert Kimball's complete lyrics of Ira Gershwin, you'll see the songs that Ira is credited with writing the lyrics for, which in many cases were the numbers for "Sportin' Life," the more referred to as the Broadway songs.
[3:24] Michael Owen: The standalone songs.
[3:25] Michael Owen: Yeah, there's about the statement for New York and necessarily so. Ira was not responsible for "Summertime," but he worked so closely with George that when Hayward's lyrics came in, for the songs that Hayward was going to write, you know, Ira was involved in not necessarily rewriting them, but reworking them so that they would be singable and audible to audiences.
[3:48] Michael Owen: His role, though, is somewhat looked on, you know, as being lesser than DuBose Hayward's. And there are people who would say that.
[3:56] Michael Owen: You know, and it wasn't my point to try to argue the case of whether DuBose Hayward's lyrics were better than Ira's or whether they were more appropriate, but to give Ira his due for the work that he did do on making the opera what it was in 1935 and what it still is today.
[4:12] Michael Owen: And the fact that it's now called the Gershwin' Porgy and Bess, as I point out, you know, Dorothy Hayward, who was his wife's widow, you know, was concerned that her husband's name would eventually be sort of removed from the opera.
[4:24] Michael Owen: And it turns out, yeah, she was right, but that was something that wasn't sort of agreed upon later in.
[4:30] Michael Owen: And Ira did over the years, in the years after George's death, agree to having his own name removed from the publicity for the opera, if for some reason there just wasn't enough room in the ad to put it there, but he was willing to do that because he knew the value of what his brother had written, regardless of whether his name was actually attached to a specific comment about it.
[4:53] Michael Owen: You know, that was my task here, I thought was to tell people, you know, not to say that it was to debunk necessarily what other people had written, but to look at it from his point of view.
[5:02] Michael Owen: And then obviously what he subsequently did to keep it alive and not let it just disappear into, you know, the bottom of a trunk somewhere.
[5:10] Michael Owen: That's sort of a subplot of your book, is the story of Porgy and Bess, because initially it's not a huge success.
[5:18] Michael Owen: It's acclaimed but not financially successful in its initial production.
[5:22] Michael Owen: Correct. You know, some people liked it and some people didn't. Some of the theatrical critics didn't understand it. Some of the music critics didn't understand it.
[5:28] Michael Owen: Yeah, it wasn't financially successful for the Theater Guild and the other producers or investors, including George and Ira.
[5:34] Michael Owen: I think George was very disappointed that it wasn't.
[5:37] Michael Owen: So after George's death, it was one of those works that Ira was eager to try to keep alive.
[5:43] Michael Owen: You know, the producer Cheryl Crawford came around in the nineteen forties with a version, the first sort of cut-down version of it, which made it a little more of a Broadway show than an opera.
[5:53] Michael Owen: It was Ira who steered the work to the point where eventually through the nineteen fifties and the very successful production that toured around the world into the sixties and seventies and then eventually to the Easton Grand Opera, which occurred just before Ira's passing that restored the opera to how it was originally heard in Boston prior to the cuts that were made to it prior to Broadway, which brought the opera back to world opera stages and eventually the Metropolitan Opera and all of that.
[6:17] Michael Owen: And it was Ira who felt this and his brother's magnum opus. He needed to keep it alive if nobody else was going to.
[6:23] Michael Owen: And he had to try to protect what his brother had intended, what he had written at the time and not let it be changed too much.
[6:29] Michael Owen: He spends large parts of his life keeping that opera negotiating for Broadway productions, for touring productions, for the movie version, which goes on seemingly for years.
[6:40] Michael Owen: But I didn't really understand how much it was produced throughout the fifties and the sixties around the world.
[6:48] Michael Owen: It had this world presence that I don't know that we fully appreciate today.
[6:53] Michael Owen: Yeah, I think the opera and George, as a writer of concert works, had more of a positive reputation in Europe and elsewhere than he did in the United States.
[7:03] Michael Owen: You know, George's reputation for that and not for his songs came in the more recent decades.
[7:09] Michael Owen: But yes, I mean, the production that I mentioned that happened in the nineteen forties, and then particularly the production that happened in the fifties, the Robert Breen version that traveled around the world, I mean, many times around the world, you know, during the fifties to South America and through Europe and behind the Iron Curtain into Egypt and to Israel, and then did play in New York as well and toured around in the United States.
[7:32] Michael Owen: And it was under the auspices at one time of the State Department as a political tool during the civil rights, early civil rights era.
[7:39] Michael Owen: You mentioned the negotiations for the movie, which did take the best part of half a decade from all the different offers that came in from every corner of the film world.
[7:48] Michael Owen: It was surprising, you know, how popular it actually was in areas that wouldn't necessarily think of.
[7:54] Michael Owen: But it just never seemed to not be successful, whether it was being done in summer stock production somewhere in the fifties.
[8:02] Michael Owen: It became a little less successful in the sixties when there was some backlash against the portrayal of African Americans.
[8:08] Michael Owen: But it was still there, you know, even though the movie wasn't successful financially and a lot of people didn't like it otherwise, still kept the idea of Porgy and Bess out there, and it continued to run.
[8:19] Michael Owen: And that was one of the things that Ira always argued about with the other parties who were involved in Porgy and Bess was that having the opera be booked, you know, in different venues would be more financially worthwhile to all parties than any one payment that they would ever get from a movie.
[8:36] Michael Owen: And he was right.
[8:37] Michael Owen: There's a boat that's leaving soon for New York.
[8:48] Michael Owen: That's where we belong.
[8:52] Michael Owen: Sister.
[8:56] Michael Owen: You and me can live a high life in New York.
[9:03] Michael Owen: Come with me.
[9:07] Michael Owen: Yeah, you can go ride.
[9:11] Michael Owen: Sis, dad.
[9:15] Michael Owen: I'll buy you the swellest at shape on Upper Fifth Avenue.
[9:24] Michael Owen: And you highlight we go stopin.
[9:26] Michael Owen: We go a stock.
[9:28] Michael Owen: And there'll be nothing too good for you.
[9:33] Michael Owen: I'll dress you in silks and satins.
[9:37] Michael Owen: In the latest caristyles, and the blues you'll be forgetting.
[9:37] Michael Owen: You'll be forgetting.
[9:45] Michael Owen: There'll be no fretting.
[9:47] Michael Owen: Just nothing but smile.
[9:50] Michael Owen: You have a very interesting section involving when it played the Soviet Union.
[9:55] Michael Owen: And Ira for once made the trip because he was famous for staying home and not going to anything.
[10:01] Michael Owen: And his wife actually toured with the production of Porgy and Bess for quite a long time all over the world.
[10:08] Michael Owen: And in every country they would go to, she would be the dignitary who would be meeting the local dignitaries.
[10:14] Michael Owen: That is great.
[10:15] Michael Owen: And Lee Herschel and Lear's Drunsky Hershen, I should say, was the worldwide ambassador for Porgy and Bess.
[10:23] Michael Owen: Ira did not like to travel.
[10:24] Michael Owen: He didn't like to travel out of his own house.
[10:26] Michael Owen: So the fact that he actually got on board a rickety bunch of airplanes and flew into the Soviet Union.
[10:31] Michael Owen: With Harold Arlen, right?
[10:33] Michael Owen: With Harold Arlen, yes, and would spend 10 days or whatever it was in freezing temperatures.
[10:37] Michael Owen: And be the representative was totally out of character for him.
[10:41] Michael Owen: But the producers of that version of the opera, and Ira's wife had pleaded with him many, many times to, you know, come to Egypt, come to here, come to there.
[10:49] Michael Owen: And he would always say, No, perhaps the fact that you know his family was originally from that part of the world was an incentive for him to do it.
[10:56] Michael Owen: Perhaps he just finally felt that he had to be on the scene.
[10:59] Michael Owen: But you know, Mrs. Gershwin was the face of the Gershwin family for that production in the 1950s.
[11:06] Michael Owen: And she did travel around the world, South America, and on those different places we mentioned before, and would keep Ira abreast of what was going on in terms of how the show was being produced and changes that were potentially being thought of for staging.
[11:19] Michael Owen: At one point, eventually Ira would become the last of the creators who would remain alive.
[11:24] Michael Owen: So he had the most to say about it still, even though he wasn't there.
[11:28] Michael Owen: And so she was his eyes and ears and you know, very valuable for that.
[11:32] Michael Owen: But she was also the ambassador who was happily out there shaking people's hands, whereas Ira would run.
[11:37] Michael Owen: Their relationship is very interesting and again, sort of almost like his brother, but very contrasting personalities.
[11:44] Michael Owen: And we'll get to this in just a moment, but he falls in love with Hollywood, with Beverly Hills, with California, and doesn't want to leave there.
[11:52] Michael Owen: And she, in contrast, is a little bored with California and wants to go back to the East Coast and sort of a compromise.
[11:59] Michael Owen: She goes off around the world while he stays at home.
[12:04] Michael Owen: She had a traveling bug.
[12:05] Michael Owen: She also didn't feel that Southern California was artistically, socially where she wanted to be.
[12:13] Michael Owen: She grew up in a very politically active family in New York, whereas Ira was pretty apolitical.
[12:19] Michael Owen: She just felt that there wasn't the thrill of New York and the thrill of Manhattan.
[12:23] Michael Owen: Yes, absolutely.
[12:24] Michael Owen: Again, a completely different personality.
[12:26] Michael Owen: Uh when they met, she was a flapper, basically, of the 1920s, somebody who spoke her mind freely.
[12:33] Michael Owen: At times that was something that a lot of people didn't like.
[12:36] Michael Owen: But they had a relationship that was very warm, but it wasn't one that necessarily everybody quite understood because of their completely different personalities.
[12:45] Michael Owen: So, in a way that takes us back to after poor Porgy and Bess and the failure of that initially, but the Gershwin' return to Hollywood.
[12:55] Michael Owen: And this is really when Ira begins to fall in love with the lifestyle there.
[13:01] Michael Owen: And if Gershwin had lived, it probably would have ended up with them living on opposite ends of the country.
[13:08] Michael Owen: That's the take I have on it.
[13:09] Michael Owen: I think some people have tended to disagree with that idea and say that wherever George went, Ira would have followed.
[13:15] Michael Owen: But I think at this point that we're talking about in 1937, or if George had lived when they would have finished the third of the scores that they were writing at that time.
[13:24] Michael Owen: Ira loved the Southern California lifestyle, the warm weather, even though he didn't drive.
[13:29] Michael Owen: So Southern California seems like an odd place for somebody to drive.
[13:32] Michael Owen: But he loved that relaxed lifestyle.
[13:34] Michael Owen: George was more, you know, it made him a little anxious, I think, to be away from the thrills of New York City and other places that he wanted to go around the world.
[13:42] Michael Owen: So Ira had planned to buy a piece of property in Southern California that perhaps would have a little studio or something for George, and he would be there, and George would be in New York or wherever, and they would come together to work on different projects, but they would live finally separate lives.
[13:59] Michael Owen: But of course, we don't really know that.
[14:01] Michael Owen: But that's the way I looked at it.
[14:03] Michael Owen: And initially they go there with a movie contract, and it ends up being three movies in a row.
[14:09] Michael Owen: Yes, they had a contract with RKO for one movie with an option.
[14:12] Michael Owen: And RKO took up that option.
[14:14] Michael Owen: So the first movie became Shall We Dance with Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers.
[14:18] Michael Owen: And because the studio was happy with the songs that they were providing for that, and no surprise there, they were on their best.
[14:25] Michael Owen: RKO took up the option for the second movie, which became A Damsel in Distress.
[14:29] Michael Owen: Fred's first movie went out Ginger.
[14:30] Michael Owen: And then during the time of working on the second movie, Samuel Goldwyn came along with an offer for a third movie.
[14:37] Michael Owen: And although they were reluctant, I think, in some ways, to do it, three movies in, I mean, they arrived in Hollywood in June of '36, and George died in July of '37.
[14:47] Michael Owen: So we're talking about a year or so, and they wrote the scores for three movies, not quite three movies, but they did it.
[14:53] Michael Owen: You know, they were planning to head back to New York at that point because there was a show that was sort of in the works at the time with George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart.
[15:00] Michael Owen: Their careers are tied to Fred Astaire to a great extent.
[15:04] Michael Owen: And I love that anecdote that you had at the beginning.
[15:07] Michael Owen: When they were kids, they went and saw Fred Astaire and Adele as children performing in Vaudeville.
[15:13] Michael Owen: And I just was struck by that idea that unbeknownst to any of them, they would then have this long association.
[15:20] Michael Owen: It's hard to imagine, you know, seeing somebody at the young ages of that they all were, all four of them at the time, and then to think that they'd be writing songs for Fred and Adele, you know, eventually for Fred, and then you know, it would continue into the movie Funny Face that Fred Astaire did with Audrey Hepburn in the 1950s, and even into the '70s with the TV special that Fred Astaire did with Jack Lemmon of all Gershwin songs and Fred Astaire's Gershwin recordings that he did for Norma Grant's Verve label.
[15:46] Michael Owen: And yeah, there was always a connection with the Astaires, you know, even though Adele retired and wasn't working anywhere, there was always that Gershwin stair, stair Gershwin.
[15:55] Michael Owen: It was Fred's recordings of some of those last songs that Ira said was one of the things that perked him up after George's passing to feel that his brother was still with him because he could hear him in what Fred was singing.
[16:07] Michael Owen: Holding hands at midnight neath the starry sky.
[16:13] Michael Owen: Nice work if you can get it, and you can get it if you try.
[16:19] Michael Owen: Strolling with the one girl, sighing sigh after sigh.
[16:25] Michael Owen: Nice work if you can get it, and you can get it if you try.
[16:30] Michael Owen: Now just imagine someone waiting at the cottage door, where two hearts become one who could ask for anything more.
[16:42] Michael Owen: Loving one who loves you, and then taking that vow.
[16:47] Michael Owen: Nice work if you can get it, and if you get it, won't you tell me how?
[16:53] Michael Owen: Don't go away. Michael and I will be back with more Broadway Nation right after this quick break.
[17:18] Michael Owen: You say either and I say either.
[17:23] Michael Owen: You say neither, and I say neither.
[17:27] Michael Owen: Either, either, neither, neither.
[17:32] Michael Owen: Let's call the whole thing off.
[17:35] Michael Owen: You talked about this packed year three movies.
[17:38] Michael Owen: Of course, they have no idea that George is going to die, and it comes as an incredible shock to everyone.
[17:45] Michael Owen: Talk us just a little bit about and especially how this affected Ira.
[17:49] Michael Owen: I was sort of in denial, it seems, as George starts to suffer from some of the symptoms of what's going on.
[17:55] Michael Owen: Right.
[17:56] Michael Owen: It was a painful subject to write about.
[17:58] Michael Owen: I felt like I didn't want to dismiss Ira's feelings about what happened when it was going on, but it was hard to actually find what Ira's feelings were when it was happening.
[18:07] Michael Owen: Just, you know, it's for a little historical perspective.
[18:09] Michael Owen: So George Gershwin was known as somebody who had what he referred to and other people were as a composer's stomach.
[18:15] Michael Owen: And he was always somewhat of a hypochondriac and was always interested in his health and eating certain foods or not eating certain foods and sort of alternative medicine.
[18:35] Michael Owen: If you read George's letters from the months prior to his death, and you look at the writing on them, you would have no sense that there's anything wrong in the fact that certain things were happening.
[18:46] Michael Owen: You know, he stumbled up during rehearsal when he was conducting and kind of almost fell off a stage in Los Angeles.
[18:52] Michael Owen: He missed some notes in a performance of Concerto in F.
[18:56] Michael Owen: These things could have been attributed to, you know, any number of things, whether they were real or psychosomatic or psychological.
[19:03] Michael Owen: The final deterioration in his brother's condition that would lead to his quick death had to have been so utterly shocking and unbelievable that it was hard to grasp.
[19:15] Michael Owen: That somebody who was so physically active, I mean, they had a tennis court at the house in Beverly Hills, and there's movies of him playing tennis and Arnold Schoenberg and other people, and he led an active lifestyle and dated a lot of women, and he was just this amazing personality.
[19:31] Michael Owen: So it's for him to all of a sudden, in the course of just a few days, it seemed, decline so rapidly.
[19:38] Michael Owen: You know, he went to the hospital and had some tests, and you know, all the tests basically came up negative.
[19:43] Michael Owen: There was nothing that could be seen.
[19:45] Michael Owen: And one has to remember that we're talking about 1937.
[19:47] Michael Owen: So the sort of tests to diagnose certain things were not available.
[19:51] Michael Owen: And even the X-rays didn't reveal anything.
[19:54] Michael Owen: No, you know, it was only eventually when the final events happened where he was actually in surgery and they were able to see physically, you know, opened him up and see what was going on.
[20:05] Michael Owen: None of the doctors had been able to figure this out before.
[20:08] Michael Owen: And he saw very well-known doctors in the Los Angeles area, you know, who did every test at the time.
[20:14] Michael Owen: And I know, you know, there have been retrospective looks at Gershwin's care by various people over the years, you know, in the last decades.
[20:21] Michael Owen: And I'm not the person who's going to argue with a doctor about his reverse opinion about what these doctors did in 1937.
[20:28] Michael Owen: You know, all I can say is that from the extant material that was contemporary, this is what was done.
[20:33] Michael Owen: This is what they saw or didn't see.
[20:35] Michael Owen: This was the conclusion that they came to.
[20:37] Michael Owen: And what exactly was wrong with him?
[20:39] Michael Owen: In the end, he had a glioblastoma at the base of his brain, which was so big that they said it was like the size of a grapefruit or something.
[20:46] Michael Owen: So the conclusion of the doctors was that even had they been able to save George physically, I mean, if they had been able to keep him alive, he would not have been George Gershwin the composer.
[20:56] Michael Owen: And you said he would have been paralyzed, the whole left side of his body would have been paralyzed.
[21:00] Michael Owen: He would have been paralyzed.
[21:01] Michael Owen: His career would have been over and his life would have been drastically changed.
[21:05] Michael Owen: The end came very quickly, and Ira's family, his wife and his friends who were there could see the unbelief and the pain in Ira's face about what was happening to his brother.
[21:17] Michael Owen: And so they tried to protect him by not telling him actually what was really going on.
[21:21] Michael Owen: When Ira got home from the hospital after George's surgery, he was under the impression that his brother was going to survive.
[21:28] Michael Owen: And it was only a few hours later that the phone call came from the hospital telling that it wasn't true.
[21:33] Michael Owen: There was a sense of a man who was shrouded in a shadow for many years.
[21:38] Michael Owen: It certainly took him two and a half years from the time of George's death to actually start to really work again.
[21:43] Michael Owen: I'm sure that part of that just had to do with the fact that he just couldn't really believe that his brother wasn't with him.
[21:50] Michael Owen: Well and a sense of survivor's guilt as well.
[21:52] Michael Owen: I think you quote him saying, I'm gonna paraphrase it here, but why am I alive and is he dead?
[21:58] Michael Owen: And should have been the opposite way.
[22:00] Michael Owen: Right.
[22:00] Michael Owen: If somebody had to go, why wasn't it me?
[22:02] Michael Owen: People aren't gonna miss me as much as they're gonna miss George. I mean, it had to be just unbelievable for the whole family and that whole world of friends. There was a tight-knit world that they existed in. Just overnight he's gone, and what could we have done and what did we not do, and all those questions that come up when anybody dies suddenly and tragically that way. Yeah, it was a very tight-knit world of all these songwriters who had grown up together basically in the decades of the 20th century, had come to find all this success, but yet we're still all very friendly with each other. You know, there was a professional rivalry, but I think in terms of personalities, I think they were all pretty friendly with each other. And so, you know, the fact that one of their league and one of the brighter lights in their league just was kind of snuffed out so quickly, you know, it came as a shock to everyone. And it's 38 years old.
[22:53] David Armstrong: Right. I mean, he was in the prime of his life. There are stories of you know the things that George wanted to do next, you know, write another opera, write a symphony, write string quartet, do this, do that, and go back to Europe, which he hadn't been in many years, and just see where the next part of his life was going to be taken once he got through with these things in Hollywood. And there was also from Ira's standpoint, well, what do I do now? How do I turn the page from you know a decade plus all of this work with this great composer who happens to be my brother, to finding, you know, somebody new to work with, or is that even possible? You know, do I really even want to do that? And my career is my career over.
[23:32] Michael Owen: Right. And this is coming right off this tremendous success that they've had in Hollywood with giant hit songs and in a way the height of their career to a certain extent. Yes. I mean, I think some of that is, you know, it's certainly due to the fact that George's death caused a, you know, increase perhaps in the popularity of those songs because people felt like, well, these are the last songs of George Gershwin and we need to treasure them. But saying that, they also are by any standard amongst the greatest songs that the team ever wrote. And you know, to have them happen in such a short period of time and in a period of time where retrospectively we know that George was ill during part of it, to be doing it under the pressure of the studios, and particularly Samuel Goldwyn, who they were not particularly enamored of.
But it makes it even more amazing that among all the songs that George and Ira wrote, those songs, Foggy Day and They Can't Take That Away from Me, Love's Here to Stay, etc., are among the most popular songs still of the Gershwin canon.
[24:30] David Armstrong: Yeah, it's hard to imagine then what might have happened after that, because they did seem to have reached their peak at that point of the words and the music just really merging together in a way that they hadn't always necessarily done before. And again, you help us understand what's going on with Ira at this moment and this combination of what had to be grief and loss and just the rug completely being pulled out from under him and being completely at sea. Just talk a little bit about that.
[25:00] Michael Owen: He kept the diary frequently through his life. I don't know if it was consistently, but you quote a lot from his various diaries. What did he have to say about it? Or is this a place where he just doesn't reveal much? There's not a lot of material by Ira that directly refers to the period of George's illness and the years after. He did not keep a diary, or at least not a diary that we know of. He kept diaries not that frequently. He kept the diary in the nineteen tens, he kept a diary in 1928, and he kept some diaries in the fifties and smaller ones in the fifties and sixties. But when he and George were working together, darn it, there is no diary. But you can get a sense in his correspondence, you know, up to the point of George's death, Ira was not a very big letter writer.
And he admitted as such. He would say that if he wasn't actually working on something, he wasn't interested in writing anything at all. But the amount of his letters just expands exponentially after George's death. And a lot of it is business related, but because he's on the West Coast and remained on the West Coast, and his family and most of the business people he was involved with were in New York, a lot of correspondence. You know, in between the discussions of contracts and this, that, and the other thing that are not personal in nature, you do get an impression at times of how he was feeling, particularly in some of the letters he wrote to his mother in the late 30s, during that period of time when he wasn't actually working about depression.
[26:21] David Armstrong: So sense of where do I go from here? You know, maybe I just need to get some sleep and I'll be better. I mean, we do know that he did do some writing between George's death in 1940 when he started working on Lady in the Dark with Kurt Weill. He wrote some songs with Jerome Kern, he wrote a few songs with Harold Arlen, but these were not for any purpose. They weren't written for a show, they were working for a movie, so they never led anywhere. And it was basically just trying to keep his hand in. You know, there wasn't overwhelming sense for him, both of grief, but then also just the purpose, on the other hand, of making sure that his brother's works are protected, that all of his memorabilia, George's letters and papers and all that are protected and collated and preserved. And that's enough to keep anybody pretty busy, I would think.
[27:07] Michael Owen: And he had to do a lot of, you know, he'd spent a lot of time going back and forth to New York during the period of time to deal with all these issues. And as you said before, to deal with the estate, George dies without a will. So there's a lot of uncertainty about exactly what's going to happen with the estate and some disagreement with his mother about next steps, I guess.
[27:28] David Armstrong: Yes, there wasn't even a sense of what exactly were George's copyrights. People didn't know that. I mean, probably Ira didn't even know that exactly, but certainly Rose Gershwin, their mother wouldn't have known that. That wasn't her world. Ira had originally filed to actually manage George's estate on the West Coast, and then Rose's attorneys filed for it on the East Coast, and they had to come together about that and come to some sort of agreement about what Ira's responsibilities were going to be to the estate, how things were going to be divided financially in terms of, you know, if he did certain work for the estate that provided income to it by the creation of this or that, you know, how much would he get paid for it?
And you know, those are issues which are dry, and it doesn't necessarily provide a really happy-go-lucky story. But to me, it was part of the point of trying to show that this is what he faced at this point in time. His career as a lyricist almost necessarily took a back seat, and he was not entirely unhappy about that to a certain period, you know, of time where he started to get a bit antsy about well, I haven't done anything in a while, and so when the offer came along to do Lady in the Dark, you know, he unexpectedly said, Yes, I'll do it. And you know, off he went to you know to a new phase of his career as a lyricist with new music.
[28:43] Michael Owen: And that's where we'll pick up the conversation on the next episode of Broadway Nation when Michael Owen returns to tell us more about his new book, Ira Gershwin, a Life in Words.
[29:56] ♪ Musical number: "They Can't Take That Away from Me" — performed by Michael Owen ♪
[30:55] David Armstrong: If you love this podcast and want to delve even deeper into the world of Broadway musicals, I invite you to become a patron of Broadway Nation. For as little as seven dollars a month, you can receive exclusive access to never before heard unedited versions of many of the interviews featured on this podcast. I often record twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited public episodes. And you also have the exclusive opportunity to hear additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans. And all patrons will receive special on-air shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast. Supercast dot tech. That's all one word, Broadway Nation Podcast. Or simply click the link in the show notes to this episode. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
