Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 124: Jay Armstrong Johnson gets Broadwaysted, Part 2!

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! Play along as Jay Armstrong Johnson (Phantom of the Opera) joins Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for candy corn, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and candy pumpkins. Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG... Read More

From the show: Broadwaysted!

54 mins
10/30/18

Guests

Featured Shows

About

HAPPY HALLOWEEN!

Play along as Jay Armstrong Johnson (Phantom of the Opera) joins Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for candy corn, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and candy pumpkins.

Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG

This episode is brought to you by Goldstar! Get $10 off already discounted tickets by using the code BROADWAYSTED at checkout.

goldstar.com/broadwaysted

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Bryan Plofsky: Did you bring wine?

[0:05] Kevin: I got the glasses.

[0:06] Kimberly: Hey guys, I made a quiz.

[0:08] Bryan Plofsky: I didn't bring anything, but I heard it's a bug.

[0:20] Bryan Plofsky: Hello, and welcome to the official Broadwaysted podcast.

[0:25] Bryan Plofsky: Where we're drunk on theater.

[0:26] Bryan Plofsky: I'm your host, Bryan Plofsky.

[0:28] Kevin: What's this?

[0:29] Bryan Plofsky: Don't be lock shocked and barreled.

[0:31] Bryan Plofsky: We're gonna put a spell on you.

[0:32] Bryan Plofsky: No, it's not my werewolf bar mitzvah.

[0:34] Bryan Plofsky: Spooky scary.

[0:35] Bryan Plofsky: This is Halloween.

[0:36] Bryan Plofsky: It's a Monster Mash thriller.

[0:38] Bryan Plofsky: It'll be a graveyard smash.

[0:40] Bryan Plofsky: There's a nightmare on my street, so we'll do the time warp and dress up as rock lobsters, werewolves of London, and purple people eaters with the Bad Moon Rising, of course.

[0:49] Kevin: Is that a Halloween song?

[0:50] Bryan Plofsky: It's on the best of Halloween.

[0:53] Kevin: I used to own that on cassette.

[0:54] Bryan Plofsky: It's like rock lobster.

[0:56] Kevin: And it's like, okay, sure.

[0:57] Bryan Plofsky: Sure.

[0:58] Kevin: Yeah, that's terrifying.

[1:00] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[1:00] Bryan Plofsky: Uh, it's the season of the witch, and we've got sympathy for the devil.

[1:04] Bryan Plofsky: Who are you gonna call?

[1:06] Bryan Plofsky: Of course, you're gonna call the people joining us today.

[1:09] Bryan Plofsky: Who are the usual Pum King and Pum Quenie Oogie Boogies who want to kidnap the Sandy Claws, including Kevin, Maboo, Jigger.

[1:17] Kevin: Hey girl.

[1:19] Bryan Plofsky: Kimberly, our What a Ghoul Master.

[1:24] Kevin: An unofficial hand that rocks the cradle for the hour.

[1:27] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[1:30] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, ominous.

[1:31] Kevin: Yeah, that got scary.

[1:32] Bryan Plofsky: Evil babysitters.

[1:34] Bryan Plofsky: Um, and with us today is our returning guest.

[1:36] Kimberly: Yay!

[1:37] Bryan Plofsky: But it's the first time he gets his own episode.

[1:43] Kevin: That's a spooky twist.

[1:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was like, really?

[1:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yeah, I guess so.

[1:48] Bryan Plofsky: He's been in many things, but highlights include Hair, Hands on a Hard Body, Catch Me If You Can, On the Town, and in The Amazing Candy.

[1:56] Bryan Plofsky: He's but we're calling it The Amazing Candy.

[2:00] Bryan Plofsky: He did magic in this production.

[2:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[2:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[2:02] Bryan Plofsky: It's good.

[2:03] Bryan Plofsky: It's like illusionist.

[2:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And The Amazing Candy.

[2:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yeah.

[2:08] Bryan Plofsky: He's currently rowing it up on Broadway in Phantom of the Opera.

[2:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Rowling.

[2:14] Kevin: Do you rowl your R's in the show?

[2:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You don't, because that would be the Spanish version.

[2:17] Bryan Plofsky: Right in the French.

[2:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Absolutely.

[2:21] Bryan Plofsky: They're in Paris, Spain.

[2:23] Kevin: Paris, Texas.

[2:25] Bryan Plofsky: Let's give a big Broadwaysted welcome to Friend of the Show.

[2:25] Kevin: Friend of the show.

[2:29] Bryan Plofsky: Jay Armstrong Johnson!

[2:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What up, you drunks?

[2:35] Bryan Plofsky: We are actually in his dressing room at the Majestic Theater.

[2:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right.

[2:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Pretty fun.

[2:39] Bryan Plofsky: Thanks for letting me have the couch.

[2:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, and um, it's you have a corner dressing room.

[2:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I do, it's lovely.

[2:44] Bryan Plofsky: Foreshadowing.

[2:45] Bryan Plofsky: Um let's just let's just let's just start with what?

[2:50] Bryan Plofsky: Halloween treats are you snacking on?

[2:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Halloween treats are you snacking on?

[2:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because we don't want you to drink before shows.

[2:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, absolutely.

[2:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, I just had this amazing pumpkin muffin made by ours truly right here.

[3:02] Kimberly: Yeah.

[3:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A little bit of candy corn.

[3:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[3:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: About the candy corn.

[3:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Do you actually like candy corn?

[3:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I do.

[3:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And the fact that you brought like the pumpkin version too is really quite a twist.

[3:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because I in my mind I wasn't thinking the pumpkin version, but it's actually I think they're better, even though I think it's made of the same shape.

[3:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think they're because there's a little more of them.

[3:22] Kevin: Maybe so.

[3:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And they have like more ridges.

[3:24] Kevin: Yeah, maybe so.

[3:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I also like the pumpkins, but I never think to buy them.

[3:27] Bryan Plofsky: I think Brian and I are in the camp that we question the validity of candy corn.

[3:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Shall we do a live taste test?

[3:32] Kevin: Yeah, I think so.

[3:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm also anti-peep.

[3:38] Kevin: Oh, I'm not sure.

[3:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am anti-peep all the way up.

[3:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And we have peeps for every season.

[3:42] Kevin: Yeah, yeah.

[3:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There were Halloween peeps when I went to the Duane Reade and pumpkins and I am all about the Reese version of Halloween.

[3:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like holiday candies, like the Reese pumpkin.

[3:52] Kevin: Yeah, but those are the things.

[3:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But those are just the best.

[3:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The regular candy, but just shaped differently.

[4:01] Kevin: Exactly.

[4:02] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[4:02] Bryan Plofsky: Let's let's so let's all take a regular candy corn.

[4:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't know if I can do this.

[4:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just regular.

[4:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There's two different kinds in one bag.

[4:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just the autumnal mix.

[4:11] Kevin: Yeah, so what's the brown one though?

[4:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh chocolate.

[4:13] Kevin: Oh, okay.

[4:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So that doesn't look like corn anymore.

[4:18] Kevin: Yeah.

[4:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Do any of them?

[4:21] Kevin: Oh no, not really.

[4:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It looks like a candy corn.

[4:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Alright, so everybody try the normal candy corn.

[4:27] Kevin: Okay.

[4:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, I eat the chocolate one.

[4:30] Kevin: Whatever.

[4:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Failing.

[4:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Failing.

[4:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So it tastes like pure sugar.

[4:34] Kevin: Yeah, or rain.

[4:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Fantastic.

[4:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so should we all eat?

[4:39] Kevin: Which one should we eat next?

[4:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The pumpkin.

[4:41] Kevin: The chocolate one.

[4:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The chocolate one.

[4:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because that's what I already did.

[4:46] Kevin: We should all do the pump corn together because this is terrifying.

[4:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A lot of sugar.

[4:53] Kevin: Do I taste chocolate?

[4:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I barely taste chocolate.

[4:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was very, it was very good.

[4:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There it is in my molar.

[4:58] Kevin: Really?

[4:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just one.

[4:59] Kevin: You had to go in for seconds.

[5:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm gonna bite the butt off of it just to see if I could actually taste it.

[5:04] Kevin: Okay, sure, sure, sure.

[5:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[5:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, if you just focus on the butt, you can taste the chocolate.

[5:10] Kevin: Yeah, it gives you like a Tootsie.

[5:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It gives you a Tootsie.

[5:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Halloween candy tasting one-on-one.

[5:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're welcome.

[5:15] Kevin: Alright.

[5:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and we should we all like the pumpkin?

[5:17] Kevin: Yeah, I eat this in two bites.

[5:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Maybe that's more I like it better.

[5:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It just tastes like decorations on cakes.

[5:25] Bryan Plofsky: I will say the pumpkin is light years ahead of the actual candy corn.

[5:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There's less crust to chew ratio, I think.

[5:37] Kevin: Interesting.

[5:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So you're getting more of the texture you enjoy.

[5:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The innards.

[5:41] Kevin: Yeah.

[5:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It tastes more like a baked good and less like plastic.

[5:44] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, that's fair.

[5:46] Bryan Plofsky: So we're all in agreement that the pumpkin wins.

[5:48] Kevin: The pumpkin wins.

[5:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I will judge a baking show tomorrow.

[5:53] Bryan Plofsky: Dreams.

[5:54] Bryan Plofsky: Right?

[5:54] Bryan Plofsky: Well, you can follow Jay at J underscore A underscore Johnson, but as Kimberly reminds us every week, you just look him up and go find them.

[6:02] Kimberly: Google.

[6:03] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[6:05] Bryan Plofsky: Search someone's name.

[6:06] Bryan Plofsky: But let's see.

[6:10] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, how do you know?

[6:11] Bryan Plofsky: We'll find out.

[6:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh Jesus.

[6:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I got a repatching.

[6:15] Bryan Plofsky: But let's just start with what have you seen this week?

[6:15] Bryan Plofsky: What have you seen this week?

[6:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What have I seen this week?

[6:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Have you seen any shows lately?

[6:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The Jonathan Larson Project at Feinstein's 54 Below.

[6:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[6:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um blew my freaking head off.

[6:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It really did.

[6:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: One of my most favorite nights in a theater-esque setting.

[6:33] Bryan Plofsky: And like for anybody out there who doesn't exactly know what you're talking about, what can you explain like what the event was or what the evening was?

[6:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, I mean, so it's the composer of Rent and Tick, Tick... Boom.

[6:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and they kind of um Jennifer Ashley Tepper, who's actually a college buddy of mine.

[6:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Friend of the show.

[6:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um friend of the show.

[6:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yeah.

[6:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, over the last god knows how many years, years and years she's been working on this project.

[6:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She's been compiling uh recordings of songs on her Jonathan Larson songs and turning them into a song cycle of sorts.

[7:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A la Songs for a New World, or Brian Scott Oliver's 35mm.

[7:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And um got a I've seen YouTube videos of you in there.

[7:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And got a star cast together.

[7:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, it was Andy Mantis and Christa Rodriguez and George Salazar and Lauren Marcus and Nick Blameyer.

[7:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And it was truly one of the rotating guests each night.

[7:23] Kevin: Do you know one of them?

[7:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was one of the rotating guests the very last night.

[7:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was their closing evening.

[7:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Twist.

[7:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um and all of Jonathan's like family and friends and close loved ones were there and they were up with us in the dressing rooms.

[7:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And you know, they gave this really beautiful speech at the end.

[7:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I really do think that it should go other places because it was mind-bogglingly good how current his material still is, even though he wrote it like some in the 80s and mostly in the early 90s.

[7:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was also one of the most effective uses of that space I've seen in a while, where like there was a mood conveyed just in very simple implied costumes of just like 90s.

[8:05] Kevin: That's cool.

[8:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And then one single image on either TV for each song.

[8:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[8:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was just like a mood setter.

[8:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Totally.

[8:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was oh it was incredible.

[8:14] Bryan Plofsky: So so good.

[8:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, Kevin and I have this is like the best things we've ever seen podcast.

[8:20] Kevin: Because we saw The Ferryman last night.

[8:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, really?

[8:23] Kevin: Next door.

[8:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There are there are neighbors.

[8:25] Kevin: Yeah.

[8:26] Kevin: Holy crap.

[8:27] Kevin: That was possibly the best play I've ever seen on Broadway.

[8:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Can you explain it for me who doesn't know what it is?

[8:32] Kevin: So The Ferryman is a it is a study of uh Northern Ireland in the uh early 80s, uh when like the IRA was taking over kind of like and building up like their strength.

[8:45] Kevin: Uh a bunch of people in Northern Ireland like went missing.

[8:49] Kevin: And it was basically that like the IRA was taking people hostage and then making them disappear, and families like wouldn't talk about it because they were afraid of being the next one taken.

[8:59] Kevin: Whether they were working for the IRA or not.

[9:02] Kevin: Yeah, they were just being taken because of certain different political reasons here and there.

[9:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you.

[9:10] Kevin: So it basically focuses on one family who is a farming family.

[9:14] Kevin: And it's like it's just oh god, it was so good.

[9:16] Kevin: It is the most massive cast I've ever seen in a play on Broadway.

[9:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What?

[9:22] Kevin: Yeah.

[9:22] Kevin: Including like there was an actual baby on stage.

[9:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There was it was one of the most insane things I've ever seen happen on a Broadway stage, and it was it was a over three hour play that I felt was an hour and ten minutes and I wanted more.

[9:36] Kevin: Like it was just it was everything.

[9:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And this is a Weston transfer, correct?

[9:40] Kevin: Yeah, correct.

[9:40] Kevin: One the Olivier.

[9:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh wow.

[9:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um it's incredible.

[9:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It feels like a more calm, grounded Martin McDonagh play, but with a slower burn with no like big surprises, like Martin McDonagh always has these like big twists and turns.

[9:53] Kevin: Um I mean, this is up for me.

[9:55] Kevin: This is up there with like seeing The Pillowman on Broadway and like that's like a August: Osage County.

[10:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't know, this is leaps and bounds better than August: Osage County.

[10:04] Kevin: It's my favorite show of all time.

[10:05] Kevin: Like it's I went into it thinking that it was gonna be something like that.

[10:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[10:10] Kevin: And when I left, I was like, that was so much more visceral and real than even August: Osage County.

[10:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah!

[10:18] Kevin: It was it was gripping.

[10:19] Kevin: The audience was like I I feel like nowadays a lot of people do the standing ovation because it's kind of become like a normal expected thing when you enjoy something that you stand.

[10:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[10:29] Kevin: But this it was like I haven't felt an audience so anxious to leap to their feet in the moment the lights went down in a really long time.

[10:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And this was just regular adult older people theater goers who were just so appreciative of what an incredible roller coaster this play was.

[10:45] Bryan Plofsky: Very cool.

[10:46] Bryan Plofsky: So gotta get my ticket.

[10:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh yeah.

[10:51] Bryan Plofsky: Speaking of Halloween, and since you're a returning guest, I have a would you rather Halloween?

[10:56] Kevin: Yes.

[10:58] Bryan Plofsky: This is from like an elementary school website that I pulled this from.

[11:04] Kevin: That's awesome.

[11:06] Bryan Plofsky: Would you rather walk through a graveyard at midnight or spend a night in a spooky abandoned house?

[11:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Spend the night in a spooky abandoned house.

[11:13] Bryan Plofsky: Why would you rather do that?

[11:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I just feel there's more to discover, like attics and like secret passageways, and um it feels more scary to me because you're um trapped in a trapped as opposed to like outside cool.

[11:29] Bryan Plofsky: Spooky.

[11:30] Bryan Plofsky: Would you rather dunk for apples or carve jack o' lanterns?

[11:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Carve jack-o'-lanterns.

[11:34] Kevin: Yeah duh.

[11:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Have you done many other species?

[11:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I haven't.

[11:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I had a really good one last year.

[11:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I gotta I gotta up myself.

[11:40] Kevin: Yeah.

[11:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, you're all wolfing around.

[11:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Do you use one of those things that's like a like a a uh like you draw on it like a specific image and then you carve it?

[11:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or do you just like free hand?

[11:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I usually um have like the whole pumpkin carving kit thing.

[11:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I made my own design yesterday, but I used like the techniques that the pumpkin carving kids usually taught me as a child.

[11:59] Kevin: Sure, sure, sure.

[12:00] Bryan Plofsky: So it's like using like a felony.

[12:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like the Pokey man, yeah.

[12:03] Bryan Plofsky: Would you rather be a vampire or be a werewolf?

[12:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Vampire.

[12:07] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[12:08] Bryan Plofsky: Um would you rather read a spooky story or see a spooky movie?

[12:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: See a spooky movie.

[12:13] Bryan Plofsky: Do you have a favorite spooky movie?

[12:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um are you a spooky movie person?

[12:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am.

[12:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: My boyfriend is really a spooky movie fan.

[12:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I would say the spookiest one as of late that I'm really enjoyed was oh crap, what's the name?

[12:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um it was uh oh, this is the worst.

[12:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She uh United States of Terror and also Millie.

[12:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, her um hereditary.

[12:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I watched it two weeks ago.

[12:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god.

[12:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There's one scene in that movie that I will never forget, and it involves a telephone pole.

[12:38] Kevin: Sure.

[12:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I will never forget that rest of my days.

[12:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And it was Millie.

[12:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She won the Tony for the little girl.

[12:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She was one of the original um Matildas on Broadway.

[12:53] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, really?

[12:54] Bryan Plofsky: She won a Tony.

[12:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Millie Shapiro.

[12:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was the little that's the little.

[12:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh I didn't realize that.

[13:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, she's a Broadway girl.

[13:01] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, damn.

[13:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Her performance was like startlingly good.

[13:03] Bryan Plofsky: Yes.

[13:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wow.

[13:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're like, I'm terrified of her.

[13:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hereditary.

[13:08] Bryan Plofsky: Would you rather do you like horror movies?

[13:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes, but like campy ones.

[13:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like I love Scream.

[13:16] Bryan Plofsky: Yep.

[13:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[13:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So like I'm into that stuff.

[13:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Anything that I need to like check my closets when I come home from the movie theater, not as into.

[13:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I like the like supernatural or like the like the like psychologically scary.

[13:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm not very good at the like dairy, gory, very like the saw, like the very like So what's one that you really like?

[13:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So like I loved like like the Babaduke.

[13:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or like it follows.

[13:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like things like that.

[13:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It follows is really good.

[13:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It follows the ladder of the Oh my god, it's so good.

[13:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, would you rather have a costume that is really amazing but also very uncomfortable?

[13:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or have a costume that is not anything all that special but is like crazy comfortable to wear?

[13:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Real amazing and and like not so comfortable.

[13:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I do it every Halloween.

[14:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Would you rather go trick or treating with a group of friends or get paid twenty dollars to take a little kid trick-or-treating?

[14:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Group of friends.

[14:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The other one just seems like not a good idea.

[14:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[14:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Would you rather get 20 of your favorite treats on Halloween or get 50 treats that are not your favorites on Halloween?

[14:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yes.

[14:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Why would an elementary school kid pick the 51?

[14:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, because they're just like, that's more quantity.

[14:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, that was a math question.

[14:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yeah, right.

[14:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um would you rather go to a really great Halloween party where you don't really know anyone, or go to a kind of lame Halloween party where you know everybody there?

[14:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Probably really lame where I know everybody because we're gonna make it chill and awesome.

[14:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wouldn't that be the great party though?

[14:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[14:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: When is a party great?

[14:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Maybe you have to like question your life choices if you know everyone and it's still lame.

[14:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Imagine being like, I went to this awesome party.

[14:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was alone.

[15:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It looks like everyone else is having so much fun.

[15:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So this one I think I know your answer, but I have to read it out loud.

[15:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god.

[15:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Would you have to wear your Halloween costume to school every day until Thanksgiving?

[15:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or have to wear a jack-o'-lantern over your head to school for the first three days of November?

[15:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm obsessed with whatever website built.

[15:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm gonna say jack-o'-lantern just because it's a twist.

[15:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Look, and you don't explain it, you don't say anything.

[15:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like people are like, what are you wearing?

[15:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're like, what do you mean?

[15:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like it's against dress code.

[15:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Don't make me take it off anyway.

[15:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sir, your face is rotting up.

[15:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So here's an we have two more, but I'm gonna ask you this random one.

[15:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Would you rather eat all of your Halloween candy or trade your Halloween candy for 10 bucks?

[15:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Probably trade my Halloween candy for 10 bucks.

[15:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'll go buy some more candy.

[15:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or like a big table room.

[15:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, right.

[15:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I spent Sunday.

[15:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Soda pop.

[15:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Alright.

[16:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Would you rather be chased by five zombies or be chased by one werewolf?

[16:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Five zombies.

[16:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Maybe we'll break out into the thriller dance break.

[16:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, well since they are.

[16:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That one werewolf will get you.

[16:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[16:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The zombies, like you can outsmark.

[16:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Unless you have like a zombie marathon runner, like that would be like bad.

[16:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Those zombie marathons are super cool.

[16:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They're really cool.

[16:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because if they get you, then you have to put on makeup and become one of the zombies.

[16:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Have you seen those?

[16:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That takes away from your time.

[16:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it's like people do like a road over time with zombies, and when they tag you, you have to then put a makeup and finish the marathon as a zombie.

[16:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's cool.

[16:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[16:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, and I also feel like they write books for like how to survive a zombie apocalypse.

[16:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm not sure if they've written a book about how to survive a apocalypse.

[16:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're a werewolf now.

[16:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You are a werewolf.

[16:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're a werewolf, Harry.

[16:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um would you rather and then final, would you rather?

[16:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Would you rather dress up as a devil or dress up as an angel?

[16:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh no.

[16:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a good question.

[16:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And you can put sexy before either of those.

[16:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It can be a sexy devil or a sexy angel.

[17:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm gonna have to say devil because I'm a Virgo and so I'm an angel on a regular basis.

[17:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So Halloween gotta be something different.

[17:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was really sweet.

[17:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was a good one.

[17:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just like this sugar we're eating.

[17:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know.

[17:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: My stomach hurts.

[17:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, are you jittering?

[17:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, yeah, I'm like shaking, but while while we kind of come down from the sugar, let's play a game.

[17:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[17:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This game is called All I Ask Of You.

[17:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I get it.

[17:23] Bryan Plofsky: Do you?

[17:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I hope so.

[17:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So on today's little slips of paper.

[17:29] Bryan Plofsky: Sure.

[17:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I have some typical icebreaker questions that I also got from a silly website.

[17:33] Bryan Plofsky: Yes.

[17:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's the same one, same elementary school.

[17:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They're like grown-up questions.

[17:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[17:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But for like team building, I think.

[17:42] Bryan Plofsky: Great.

[17:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We're building a team.

[17:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They're under like the wacky category.

[17:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, this is basically a questions round of kings.

[17:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So one person is gonna take the question.

[17:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay, and then ask that question to someone who then has to answer the question with a question to someone else who answers as a question.

[17:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like you have to speak in questions.

[18:00] Bryan Plofsky: Alright, okay, sure.

[18:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The first person to not speak in a question will get a point.

[18:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And in this game, the more points, the loser.

[18:09] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, this is golf.

[18:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[18:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I also planned it, and I know that I'm terrible at this.

[18:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And also when you start, you can't get out.

[18:17] Bryan Plofsky: So it's the only one that give you a question.

[18:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I didn't think of that, but I'm glad I did it.

[18:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm dressing up as a devil.

[18:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um Jay, what is one article of clothing that someone could wear that would make you walk out on a date?

[18:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: How many cocksocks do you own?

[18:38] Bryan Plofsky: Well, have you thought about how many is too many?

[18:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Is there ever too many?

[18:43] Bryan Plofsky: Are there ever too many?

[18:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Grammatically correct?

[18:48] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, there you go.

[18:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Should we ask Jay?

[18:53] Bryan Plofsky: Should we ask someone else?

[19:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So we also big laughter can end.

[19:03] Bryan Plofsky: Brian's out.

[19:04] Kevin: No, Kevin!

[19:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This is his question last.

[19:06] Bryan Plofsky: No, I don't know.

[19:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh here, you pick one.

[19:08] Kevin: Okay.

[19:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You is Jay.

[19:11] Kevin: That escalated very quickly.

[19:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That escalated quickly?

[19:15] Bryan Plofsky: What fruit or vegetable would you most want to be?

[19:20] Kimberly: Kimberly, is the tomato, a fruit, or vegetable.

[19:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, that was so good.

[19:27] Bryan Plofsky: Brian, have you ever had a tomato and mayonnaise sandwich?

[19:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What's that?

[19:38] Bryan Plofsky: Alright.

[19:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's like going, why?

[19:42] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, what was I just watching?

[19:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You probably the worst at King.

[19:46] Bryan Plofsky: What was the Oh, it was Good Place, where you had a who, what, where, when, and whine shirt?

[19:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh.

[19:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yes, that's so good.

[19:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's really cute.

[19:56] Bryan Plofsky: Great episode of television.

[19:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Alright, Kimberly, you're starting.

[19:58] Kimberly: Jeremy Barramie.

[19:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Anyway.

[19:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was that's one of the best Good Place episodes ever.

[20:01] Bryan Plofsky: Yes, absolutely.

[20:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[20:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: If you had a late night talk show, who would you invite as your first guest?

[20:09] Kimberly: Have you ever had Heather Hedley on this show before?

[20:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh.

[20:16] Bryan Plofsky: I don't remember.

[20:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What a do you know what?

[20:19] Kevin: is a good question.

[20:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, you're not doing that.

[20:23] Bryan Plofsky: Depends on the sentence.

[20:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't remember.

[20:25] Bryan Plofsky: It's not a question.

[20:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I said, I don't remember.

[20:27] Bryan Plofsky: What about you, Kevin?

[20:28] Kevin: There's a comma in there.

[20:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh.

[20:30] Kevin: I mean, maybe, I mean, maybe.

[20:32] Bryan Plofsky: No, no, this is Kevin making a great semi-code.

[20:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, no, no, no, no, no, no.

[20:35] Kevin: It's your turn now.

[20:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're just trying to make games sound.

[20:37] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, what was the question part of your statement?

[20:40] Kevin: Do you remember?

[20:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Do I remember?

[20:44] Bryan Plofsky: I'm not answering.

[20:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't have a question for that.

[20:47] Bryan Plofsky: That's right.

[20:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I like how you just put Jay on the spot, so I'll ask Jay.

[20:52] Bryan Plofsky: Jay.

[20:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[20:54] Bryan Plofsky: If you could rename yourself, what name would you pick?

[20:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What do you think about the name Jaron?

[21:08] Bryan Plofsky: Do you remember the band Evan and Jaron who sang that song Back Here, Baby?

[21:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, that was BB Mac, but they sang some song.

[21:16] Bryan Plofsky: Part of that was a question.

[21:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Somewhere.

[21:22] Bryan Plofsky: Are they similar to 98 degrees?

[21:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Is it 98 degrees and rising?

[21:31] Bryan Plofsky: Have you ever done a production of One Tin in the Shade?

[21:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh.

[21:38] Kevin: Do you remember those big musical theater anthology books?

[21:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes, I do.

[21:48] Kevin: They always had a one-to-end shade.

[21:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Did you know that Jaron is actually um to sing in the language Teutonic?

[21:55] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, really?

[21:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Kevin, what is your most used emoji?

[22:00] Kevin: Um, what do you call the emoji that is like the eyes that are hearts?

[22:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Are they hearts?

[22:16] Kevin: I got nothing.

[22:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I've got nothing.

[22:19] Bryan Plofsky: I guess I will.

[22:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay, cool, cool.

[22:21] Bryan Plofsky: That was that went really well.

[22:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yep.

[22:24] Bryan Plofsky: This is gonna be the last one.

[22:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[22:26] Bryan Plofsky: Kimberly, what's your favorite sandwich?

[22:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And why?

[22:31] Kimberly: Tomato mayonnaise.

[22:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Seriously, have you ever seen Harry at the spy?

[22:38] Bryan Plofsky: Is that the same as spy versus spy?

[22:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Did you just ask me a question?

[22:42] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, I didn't mean to look at you.

[22:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I meant to look at uh Jay.

[22:44] Bryan Plofsky: Haha, I got you.

[22:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's real this time.

[22:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm good at guys.

[22:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This is going really well, but I gotta stop you for a second.

[22:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I just need to Oh no, not this again.

[22:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, it's just that it's not what you think.

[22:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm just getting so sleepy.

[22:59] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, that's weird.

[23:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So am I.

[23:01] Bryan Plofsky: I'm actually getting sleepy.

[23:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wait.

[23:04] Bryan Plofsky: Kevin, what are you doing?

[23:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You can't steal my dream sequence.

[23:07] Bryan Plofsky: No.

[23:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Open your eyes.

[23:17] Kevin: Wow.

[23:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So this is what it's like in these dream sequences.

[23:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hi, spooky version of Kimberly.

[23:26] Kevin: Kevin, this is Future Kimberly.

[23:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I come with a message.

[23:30] Kevin: Something you must do with Kimberly because it sounds really freaking cool.

[23:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What?

[23:38] Kevin: What is it?

[23:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Madame Morbid's trolley tours.

[23:44] Kevin: Sounds intriguing.

[23:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What's that?

[23:47] Kevin: Madame Morbid's trolley tours explore the haunted past and unsolved mysteries of Brooklyn.

[23:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Relive over 400 years of history as you ride in a vintage 22-seat trolley outfitted with chandeliers, curtains inspired by Gone with the Wind, and a TV monitor screening mini documentaries about the area.

[24:05] Kevin: Learn about alien abductions, notorious murders, battlefields, bloody accidents, mob hits, and more from a knowledgeable guide attired in Victorian Go.

[24:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You'll leave the tour a bit of a history buff after riding through this fascinating New York neighborhood.

[24:22] Kevin: Wow, that sounds incredible.

[24:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But how do I take Kimberly on Madame Morbid's trolley tours in Brooklyn?

[24:28] Kevin: Just check out Goldstar.com backslash broadwaisted.

[24:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I should have known I'd be dreaming about something as great as Gold Star.

[24:35] Kevin: Their customer service is the best.

[24:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know.

[24:38] Kevin: Dream, Kevin.

[24:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, I'm just regular Kevin who happens to be dreaming.

[24:43] Kevin: Your your dream, Kimberly, because you're actually our you, your dream you.

[24:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Anyway, our friends at Goldstar always give you best access to affordable tickets to all the greatest live events like Broadway shows, Broadway tours, comedy, concerts, dance, and live experiences like Madame Norbit's trolley tours in Brooklyn.

[25:01] Kevin: And now, if you log on to Goldstar.com slash broadwasted and use code Broadwaisted all uppercase at checkout, you'll get an additional ten dollars off your order.

[25:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love that part.

[25:11] Kevin: So check out all the great live events on Gold Star and make sure to tweet us your what have you seen or experienced this week photos on social media.

[25:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a really long hashtag.

[25:20] Kevin: Hashtag what have you seen or experienced this week?

[25:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I didn't say to use that hashtag.

[25:24] Kevin: And should they share it on dream social media or real social media.

[25:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Kevin, you're fired from doing the dream sequence.

[25:32] Kevin: No.

[25:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wait, seriously?

[25:37] Kevin: You stole my dream sequence, and then I didn't even get to play Dream Brian in it?

[25:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's bullshit.

[25:42] Kevin: Sorry, man.

[25:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Whatever.

[25:44] Kevin: Let's move on.

[25:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Can we ask you a couple questions about things and stuff?

[25:47] Kevin: More questions.

[25:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No.

[25:48] Kevin: Okay.

[25:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I don't do questions.

[25:52] Kevin: Tell us about a chorus line.

[25:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, congratulations.

[25:55] Kevin: That's amazing.

[25:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thanks.

[25:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I'm so uber excited.

[25:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This is my second encore show.

[26:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Sure.

[26:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and what else should you do?

[26:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I did uh the most happy fella a few years back with the colour.

[26:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: In a whole Napa Valley?

[26:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[26:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was with like Laura Bonanti and Schuler Hensley and Cheyenne Jackson and never heard of Heidi Blick and South.

[26:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, it was like an embarrassment of Riches, the kind of people that I did it with.

[26:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But um it's also an embarrassment of Richards this time around because it's Tony Yazbeck and it's Robin Herder and it's Ryan Steele and Tommy Broccco, and uh it's uh it's so fun.

[26:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh I got my equity card doing a course signed back when I was 18 years old, and it was my first job out of college.

[26:36] Bryan Plofsky: That's what your Wikipedia page says.

[26:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh yeah.

[26:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[26:41] Bryan Plofsky: What um what what role what role are you playing again?

[26:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm playing Bobby.

[26:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right.

[26:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Which is different from um previously.

[26:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Ten years ago on the tour, I was Mark.

[26:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[26:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I have grown up five years on the line, but ten years in real life.

[26:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hello 13 solo.

[26:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm trying to remember who Bobby is.

[27:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um Bobby has a lot of people.

[27:02] Bryan Plofsky: Bobby's like the gay dancer with the monologue about, right?

[27:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: About like his parents coming and no, that's Paul.

[27:10] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, okay.

[27:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was thinking.

[27:11] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, Paul is that one.

[27:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Bobby's like, we he's we're pretty sure he's gay.

[27:15] Bryan Plofsky: He doesn't ever really say it.

[27:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's just like the weird dude on the line.

[27:19] Bryan Plofsky: I can do that, right?

[27:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's Mike.

[27:21] Bryan Plofsky: That's Mike. We should all re-watch a chorus live, I think so.

[27:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, Bobby has no songs.

[27:27] Bryan Plofsky: Honestly, this is how I know. What does he wear in the original cast?

[27:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, he has like a yellowish shirt on that's like a knit yellow sweater with like the horizontal stripes, which is not great for a damn subject.

[27:37] Bryan Plofsky: You hope you get it.

[27:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Every time God, we hope you get it.

[27:43] Bryan Plofsky: And I do get it. Bobby gets the line at the end of the show, too.

[27:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Spoiler alert.

[27:47] Bryan Plofsky: Spoiler alert. But also November 15th through the 18th at City Center. Go see him play Bobby!

[27:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's gonna be fun, you guys.

[27:55] Bryan Plofsky: Congrats, man.

[27:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay, thanks. So you're in Phantom right now.

[27:59] Bryan Plofsky: I am.

[27:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're sitting in my dressing room.

[28:00] Bryan Plofsky: We are.

[28:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I see top hats.

[28:03] Bryan Plofsky: It's a it's a very long-running show.

[28:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Some say it's the longest.

[28:07] Bryan Plofsky: It is. What's it like coming into it?

[28:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, it's completely different from anything I've ever done before.

[28:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, but it's it feels just like a solid piece of theater.

[28:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like, I'm not worried about Tony voters. I'm not worried that we're not selling tickets.

[28:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's the first time that I've like been on Broadway and not like been scared that I won't have a job next month or next week.

[28:29] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, which is kind of a cool feeling.

[28:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Weird different feeling than everyone else.

[28:34] Bryan Plofsky: Exactly. And that's why they call it a government job, like the Lion Kings and the Phantoms and like the Chicago's of the world, you call them government jobs because some dude has been here for 17 years, another guy's done it for 25 years on the tour and here and places.

[28:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So it's that's what you get a watch after 20 years of doing it.

[28:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like literally.

[28:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But uh what's crunny is that people in the ensemble um were like a Christine back in the day, or were like a Raoul or a Phantom back in the day, and then they always come back to the family PHA, M I L Y.

[29:08] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, that's so cool.

[29:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So 20 years you can come back.

[29:11] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, bring it on, and you'll get your watch.

[29:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I'll get my watch.

[29:15] Bryan Plofsky: What's what are the audiences like? This must be a very different audience experience than you've had before.

[29:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it's like mostly tourists, which I think there's a bit of a language barrier, so they don't really get any of the jokes, but they know the product, they they know the iconic songs, you know, so they it's something they come back to often because a lot of people our age have never even seen it.

[29:36] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, yeah.

[29:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So many people have been like, You're in Phantom, I'll see it for the first time.

[29:39] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, yeah.

[29:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So for something to have been running for 30 years and theater people have never seen it, yeah.

[29:44] Bryan Plofsky: Um I well that goes with the government job.

[29:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like it's always it's like it's always and it's just gonna be here.

[29:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like I'll see it when I see it.

[29:50] Bryan Plofsky: Right, it's like the Statue of Liberty. If you live in New York City, you don't go visit the Statue of Liberty, but it's still there.

[29:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yeah, you know.

[29:55] Bryan Plofsky: I guess I was gonna say, can we talk about um the social media that you've been doing when you come off stage in your old man outfit?

[30:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because I live for those videos.

[30:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't even know who started hashtag BroadwayScares.

[30:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um but it was like maybe I feel like the people that have been doing it lately are mean girls, but Ali Ewold's been really into it lately.

[30:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And when like the big orchestra, like starts, that's when they scare me because there's a lot of sound happening on stage, and I can scream as loud as I can and do, and they don't get in trouble when they s when they scare me.

[30:29] Bryan Plofsky: So good.

[30:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So good. And it's fun.

[30:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, those videos and like the view coming off in like the old man outfit, and then be like, what are you doing today?

[30:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just randomly saying and then it in comes Ben and he scares the pieces out of me every single time.

[30:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And they come up with different ways to do it every time, too.

[30:46] Bryan Plofsky: So you're on your toes.

[30:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am on my toes.

[30:48] Bryan Plofsky: Is there a stage door culture here?

[30:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um ish.

[30:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, the weird thing about this stage door is that it's on an uh it's on a different block than the theater exit slash entrance.

[31:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so you have to really be a solid fan to know to go around the door.

[31:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You've got to go around the block to get to the stage door.

[31:07] Bryan Plofsky: Um, but there I mean, summertime was pretty crazy.

[31:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We had a good like 20 to 50 people at the stage door, but it's been pretty chill.

[31:16] Bryan Plofsky: That's cool.

[31:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's nice.

[31:17] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, it's lovely.

[31:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I get home sooner.

[31:20] Bryan Plofsky: Well, um, we're in your corner.

[31:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We are dressing.

[31:24] Bryan Plofsky: Yes.

[31:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, but uh we're gonna we're gonna do a little redecorating.

[31:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know this is Jay's corner.

[31:29] Bryan Plofsky: Thank God, it's like a jail cell in the camera.

[31:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We're gonna we're gonna spruce it up a little bit.

[31:34] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, just a little bit.

[31:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: With Tuesdays in the corner with Kev.

[31:41] Kevin: It's Kevin's Corner.

[31:42] Kevin: Shane, welcome to Kevin's Corner, where I have three highly researched questions that I spent a lot of time on Wikipedia and Google to come up with these.

[31:51] Kevin: So let's see if you can follow along because they're super smart.

[31:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm I'm terrified actually.

[31:56] Kevin: Okay.

[31:57] Kevin: And uh because your name is Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[32:00] Kevin: This week's of Kevin's Corner is the name game.

[32:02] Kevin: So we're gonna start off each fact. We'll start with something about your name.

[32:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Great.

[32:06] Kevin: So your first name is Jay.

[32:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Correct.

[32:08] Kevin: Like Jaywalking.

[32:09] Kevin: The term for when a pedestrian walks in or crosses a roadway that has traffic that originated with J drivers, people who drove horse-drawn carriages and automobiles on the wrong side of the road.

[32:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What?

[32:21] Kevin: That's where you that's where we get a jaywalking term from.

[32:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But where did we get J driving from?

[32:25] Kevin: That's what they called the people that used to do that.

[32:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[32:28] Kevin: So there's no history on that term.

[32:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, because they were all named Jay.

[32:31] Kevin: So the answer.

[32:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Spoken old.

[32:34] Kevin: The Road 2 movies are a series of seven comedy films starring Bing Crosby, Bob Hope, and Dorothy Lemoore that were a combination of adventure, comedy, romance, and music, where the minimal plot often took a back seat to gags, many of which of them were reportedly adlibbed by Crosby and Hope during filming.

[32:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Brian often says to Kimberly and me that we'll be doing some uh doing something when we're filming.

[32:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And Kimberly and I always giggle because we don't actually film a podcast, we record.

[33:02] Kevin: That you know of.

[33:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're welcome.

[33:05] Kevin: Before we had cassette tapes and CDs, people listened to their favorite music on records with a record player.

[33:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Also, that was my favorite part so far.

[33:15] Kevin: You're welcome.

[33:16] Kevin: When I was younger, we had an original PlayStation, and I was the best at playing Crash Bandicoot.

[33:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I used to say, I'm not a player, I just crash a lot.

[33:25] Kevin: Crash Bandicoot's my favorite.

[33:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love Crash Bandicoot so much.

[33:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um a phrase that also very aptly describes my driving abilities, which contributes to my mom loving the fact that I live in a city where I don't drive a car.

[33:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So uh yeah, I crash all my cars.

[33:38] Kevin: So my question is

[33:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Go on.

[33:41] Kevin: What are some normal day-to-day things that you're especially terrible at?

[33:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just um like picking up after myself.

[33:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Really?

[33:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Actually, like um I'm a messy dude, not a dirty dude.

[33:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right, right.

[33:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But just a messy one.

[33:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so in order to clean my house, I invite people over.

[34:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm like, all right, it's time to clean the house.

[34:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Let's invite someone over.

[34:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like, who wants to have a bottle of water to me and clean my apartment?

[34:07] Kevin: Oh, was it?

[34:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because it's like you walk you walk from the subway and it's a 10-minute walk, and like if it's winter time, you're sweating.

[34:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: If it's summertime, you're sweating, and it's getting and you just like throw everything on the ground, and you just want to veg out on the couch, and you don't want to do anything.

[34:19] Kevin: You know, totally is your boyfriend messy as well?

[34:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's not.

[34:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's actually like a little OCD, and so he he's like Mr. Clean, which is lovely.

[34:28] Kevin: Does he like follow behind you and like pick up the shirt that you just dropped on the floor?

[34:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, not really.

[34:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We don't live together yet.

[34:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um he is clean.

[34:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He can be messy every now and again, but it's cleanliness that really gets him as well.

[34:47] Kevin: Oh, there is a difference.

[34:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There's a difference.

[34:48] Kevin: Oh, for sure.

[34:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yeah.

[34:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Totally being untidy and being like unclean are totally different things.

[34:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Correct.

[34:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I can accumulate a lot of clutter.

[34:55] Kevin: Are you are you like a good cook and all that stuff?

[34:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, on certain dishes, like cereal.

[35:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I can pour things into bowls, roll out.

[35:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, uh, I I'm good at like coming up with stuff though.

[35:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like if I'm like, oh, what do I have in the kitchen?

[35:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Let's make something, you know.

[35:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You know, cereal.

[35:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A waffle and some yogurt and some honey and some nuts and just like eat it.

[35:18] Bryan Plofsky: And the case.

[35:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, it's great.

[35:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was like, wow, yes.

[35:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know it works.

[35:22] Kevin: Perfect.

[35:22] Kevin: You can sell that in Chelsea for $25.

[35:26] Kevin: All right, question two.

[35:28] Kevin: Your middle name is Armstrong.

[35:30] Kevin: As in Stretch Armstrong, the action figure in the shape of a short, well-muscled blonde man wearing black trunks that was most notably featured, or whose most notable feature was that it could be stretched from its original size of 15 inches to four or five feet.

[35:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Do you remember those things?

[35:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh yeah.

[35:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They were amazing.

[35:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I remember that commercial vividly.

[35:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And each original thing that used to come with like a patch to fix it when you ripped it because you ultimately would rip it by stretching it too far.

[35:54] Kevin: Totally.

[35:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I remember doing that.

[35:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yep, it was everything.

[35:57] Kevin: I have size 14 feet, which can be very frustrating when shopping for shoes because a lot of men's styles stop at size 13.

[36:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wow.

[36:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Did you know that?

[36:05] Kevin: I didn't know.

[36:05] Kevin: It's the worst.

[36:06] Kevin: Like you go to stores and they're just like, we have up till 13.

[36:08] Kevin: I'm like, oh, my butt is huge.

[36:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Damn.

[36:10] Kevin: Um so yeah, it really doesn't work.

[36:12] Kevin: So that 13 Ghosts is a 2001 Canadian American supernatural horror film starring Tony Shaloub, F. Murray Abraham, Matthew Lillard, and American Pie actress Shannon Elizabeth in the central role.

[36:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Did you ever see that movie?

[36:26] Kevin: No.

[36:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I did in the theaters.

[36:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I've seen it.

[36:28] Kevin: Yeah.

[36:30] Kevin: I saw in the theaters.

[36:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Roll it up and mark it with a B and put it in the oven for baby and me is how I always knew the words to the popular patty cake rhyme, but I found out today that it's actually pat a cake, not patty cake.

[36:47] Kevin: Did you know that?

[36:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No freaking way.

[36:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This blew my mind today when I'd researched.

[36:51] Kevin: I don't believe it.

[36:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Pat a cake, not pat e cake.

[36:54] Kevin: That's wrong.

[36:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I have no words.

[36:55] Kevin: And the other thing I found out was that some people say roll it up and mark it with a B.

[36:55] Kevin: Some people say roll it and pat it and mark it with a B.

[37:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Roll it and pat it.

[37:05] Kevin: And some people say pat it and prick it and mark it with a B.

[37:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, what kind of cake are they making?

[37:12] Kevin: Sometimes are they making bread?

[37:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: All of it broke blew my mind and the pat it and prick it, I do not like it all.

[37:19] Kevin: Okay.

[37:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What I do like is the movie Bridesmaids, which I think would be actually a really fun fantasy musical to cast.

[37:28] Kevin: So casting director J. Armstrong Johnson.

[37:30] Kevin: Okay.

[37:31] Kevin: What Broadway actress would you cast in the fantasy musical version of Bridesmaids in the following roles?

[37:36] Kevin: The first one is Annie Walker, the Kristen Wig part.

[37:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um Annalie Ashford.

[37:43] Kevin: Perfect.

[37:43] Kevin: Uh Lillian Donovan, the Maya Rudolph part.

[37:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, uh Asmeret.

[37:48] Kevin: Oh, okay.

[37:49] Kevin: Who would you cast as Helen Harris the third?

[37:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The Rose Byrne part.

[37:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love Roseburn so much.

[37:56] Kevin: I love Roseburn.

[37:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I do too.

[37:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She's so good on damages.

[38:01] Kevin: She's so good on damages.

[38:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I would cast.

[38:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Who would I cast as Rose Byrne?

[38:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Rose Byrne?

[38:08] Kevin: Could she come to Broadway?

[38:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Her husband does it.

[38:14] Kevin: Roseburn, final answer.

[38:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Fine.

[38:16] Kevin: That works, but she knows the words.

[38:18] Kevin: Who would play Megan Price?

[38:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Melissa McCarthy.

[38:21] Kevin: Melissa McCarthy.

[38:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you.

[38:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um Calicettle.

[38:25] Kevin: I just got very overwhelmed.

[38:28] Kevin: Officer Rhodes, the Chris O'Dowd part.

[38:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Andy or Faye's husband.

[38:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Andy Carl.

[38:35] Kevin: Carl.

[38:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[38:35] Kevin: Or Fay.

[38:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Andy or Faye.

[38:37] Kevin: Who would you?

[38:37] Kevin: And then these are the the fun ones.

[38:39] Kevin: Uh, Ted, the John Hamm part.

[38:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, okay.

[38:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh god.

[38:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The sexy but sleaze ball.

[38:48] Kevin: Sexy but sleaze ball.

[38:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I almost want that to be Andy Carl.

[38:54] Kevin: Could he play both?

[38:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That would be a double page.

[38:59] Kevin: They'll love it.

[39:00] Kevin: And then the last one is the roommates who are Rebel Wilson and Matt Lucas.

[39:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god, they're so funny.

[39:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I have to watch this again.

[39:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I haven't watched this in a while.

[39:09] Kevin: You can't live here anymore.

[39:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh no.

[39:17] Kevin: Does anyone help to hop in and help Jay?

[39:19] Kevin: Who would you guys cast as Rebel Wilson and Matt Lucas?

[39:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I'm thinking you go, you could definitely do Beanie Feldstein.

[39:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Beanie Feldstein and um Christopher Fitzgerald.

[39:30] Kevin: That would be great.

[39:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Beanie Feldstein, Christopher Fitzgerald.

[39:32] Kevin: That's pretty good.

[39:33] Kevin: Or Beanie and James Corden.

[39:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: James Corden would be so good.

[39:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I do love a Julia Madison though for that role.

[39:41] Kevin: Oh, that's what I did, too.

[39:42] Kevin: She's so funny.

[39:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[39:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She is really good.

[39:44] Kevin: Okay, those are all good.

[39:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Boom.

[39:46] Kevin: You ready for the third one?

[39:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[39:50] Kevin: Your last name betrays your obvious relation to Dwayne the Rock Johnson.

[39:54] Kevin: Actor, wrestler, entertainer, and Vin Diesel fighter.

[39:57] Kevin: Fighter kites are kites that are used for the sport of kite fighting.

[40:02] Kevin: Traditionally, most are small, unstable single line flat kites where the line tension alone is used for control, an abrasive line is used to cut down the line or string of other kites.

[40:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Whoa.

[40:16] Kevin: Kite fighting is done in many countries, which is particularly associated with Afghanistan, Bangladesh, India, Indonesia, Nepal, Pakistan, Vietnam, Korea, Brazil, and Thailand, where hosts of the show, Brian Plofsky, has traveled with his friend that I call Hot Joe.

[40:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Shoeless Joe, of course, is from Hannibal Moe.

[40:36] Kevin: Nothing to say.

[40:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Which is a song from Damn Yankees, though it was only recently that I figured out that Hannibal Moe meant Hannibal, Missouri, and not just a crazy place called Hannibal Mo, which is all just one word.

[40:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And it also was only today doing research that I realized that Shoeless Joe was actually a real person.

[40:53] Kevin: Yeah.

[40:54] Bryan Plofsky: What?

[40:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Shoeless Joe Jackson.

[40:55] Kevin: Yeah, that was a thing.

[40:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But so fast his shoes fell off.

[40:58] Kimberly: What are you talking about?

[40:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But that's what I thought it was.

[41:02] Kevin: No, I know, but I thought it was just like a continuation of the Damn Yankees character into Field of Dreams.

[41:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Wait, what?

[41:02] Kevin: I thought it was just like the name of like a fictitious baseball character.

[41:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I just thought that he was a fictitious baseball character. I was like, I like this name, and then all different fictions.

[41:18] Kevin: It's kind of like how 555 is the phone number for everyone in movies.

[41:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like Shoeless Joe is the name of the baseball player.

[41:25] Kevin: This is the most saying.

[41:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You knew he was real?

[41:30] Kevin: No, I had no idea.

[41:31] Kimberly: I don't even know who Shoeless Joe is. I don't know Damn Yankees.

[41:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So yeah, but you know this Shoeless Joe from Hannibal Mo.

[41:38] Kevin: Go, go.

[41:39] Kimberly: No, that's all he knows he didn't know Shoeless Joe is a real year.

[41:42] Kevin: I don't know Damn Yankees like literally at all.

[41:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Lola once Lola gets.

[41:47] Kimberly: No.

[41:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're gonna be in that show.

[41:49] Kevin: Well, it blew my mind that Shoeless Joe is a real person.

[41:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's really what it is right now. I also thought today that Shoeless Joe could have used a hand from Kinky Boots Charlie Price to give him a good pair of shoes.

[42:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So my question is, what character from another musical could have entered the following musicals and been helpful to the protagonist?

[42:11] Kevin: Ooh.

[42:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So Christine and the Phantom of the Opera. Who could have stepped in from a different musical and been like, let me help you out?

[42:18] Kevin: The angel from Rent could have stepped in and given her a little more confidence to not be, you know, manhandled so much by two men, you know.

[42:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh, what about Aida and Aida?

[42:32] Kevin: Hmm.

[42:35] Kevin: Well, she could have had like somebody step in and tell her, like, hey, don't fall in love with the man that's killing everyone in your family.

[42:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think a lot of people told her that throughout the course of the show.

[42:45] Kevin: Like, what like that's the show.

[42:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is the show. But like, what character from a different musical could have like made her wake up and realize what they were saying?

[42:54] Kevin: Um who could have helped the rest of the country.

[42:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[42:57] Kevin: Or the acceptance of their love.

[42:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[43:00] Kevin: The teen angel from Greece.

[43:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think you've used up all the angels.

[43:10] Kevin: I'm looking forward to them.

[43:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh no, there's one more big angel.

[43:14] Kevin: Sorry, there's genocide.

[43:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There's genocide.

[43:24] Kevin: Oh, who could have stepped in? The angel from Perestroika and this person would come in to keep her away from Warner?

[43:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Maybe like, yeah, like, or like to show her that she can be confident that she doesn't need a man.

[43:41] Kevin: Like before Vivian does.

[43:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[43:43] Kevin: Before Vivian does. But then we wouldn't get Legally Blonde.

[43:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like the Mega Mix?

[43:47] Kevin: Or anything.

[43:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So your questions are: who could come into one show to make it no longer have a plot?

[43:54] Kevin: Yes.

[43:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[43:55] Kevin: Yeah, yeah.

[43:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just solve the plot from where you go.

[43:57] Kevin: Resolve the plot from the get-go.

[43:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[44:00] Kevin: Yes.

[44:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's basically the question.

[44:02] Kevin: Sorry.

[44:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Who makes other musicals null and void?

[44:09] Kevin: I think we made that harder for him.

[44:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Now I'm just confused.

[44:14] Kevin: He's like, but I love Legally Blonde. I don't know what to cancel it out. Like Regina George just comes in and just ruins the whole thing.

[44:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or like who could do like a sick duet with Vivian explaining that she's awesome.

[44:25] Kevin: Hmm.

[44:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Effie from Dreamgirls.

[44:29] Kevin: Great.

[44:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Love it. She walks straight off the stage into Legally Blonde.

[44:34] Kevin: And your last one is Jean Valjean and Les Mis. Who's gonna help out Jean Valjean?

[44:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hmm.

[44:42] Kevin: It's gonna be Herod from Jesus Christ Superstar because he's rich and he won't have to steal anything at the beginning.

[44:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So like the two and a half hour musical is just him being like, Well, I didn't go to jail.

[44:58] Kevin: Yeah.

[44:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This is great. Don't steal that bread. I got plenty of bread back at my palace.

[45:04] Kevin: And this has been Kevin's corner.

[45:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well done.

[45:09] Kevin: You can have your corner back.

[45:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So we're back in Jay's corner now.

[45:12] Kevin: Oh wow.

[45:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I just learned a lot. I think we should play a game.

[45:15] Kevin: Yeah.

[45:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So Lights of Broadway. Backstory on the game. Go on.

[45:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A Halloween tradition in St. Louis, Missouri.

[45:24] Kevin: Sure.

[45:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Is once you have said trick or treat, the person at the door will ask you to tell them a joke.

[45:30] Kevin: Oh.

[45:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So this is something that we're learning with my nephews.

[45:34] Kevin: Oh.

[45:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's a tradition in St. Louis. And so I got to FaceTime with my sister-in-law while she was trying to teach her son Tommy how to tell a knock-knock joke.

[45:44] Kevin: He's two and a half.

[45:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So wait, you say trick-or-treat, like you're threatening. If you don't give me treats, I'm gonna do a trick on you, and then the person goes, no, you tell me a joke.

[45:53] Kevin: Correct.

[45:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And this is all very complicated. Or it's like trick-or-treat or tell a joke. Jade was not very helpful on exactly how this tradition works.

[46:02] Kevin: But basically, you have to tell a joke. So the joke that my nephew is learning how to say goes something like knock knock.

[46:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Who's there?

[46:10] Kevin: Boo.

[46:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Boo-hoo.

[46:12] Kevin: Don't cry, it's Halloween.

[46:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Very good. That's good. Great for a two-year-old as well.

[46:16] Kevin: Perfect. Great.

[46:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's almost got it.

[46:18] Kevin: Okay. But I think he still needs his mom in his ear telling you what to say.

[46:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Repetition is key.

[46:24] Kevin: Yeah.

[46:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, he's gonna have his mom like off with a voice the little headset. He's just prompting in the bushes next to the door.

[46:31] Kevin: That's correct.

[46:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I have some Lights of Broadway show cards.

[46:35] Kevin: Okay.

[46:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The entirety of the spring 2017 collection.

[46:37] Kevin: Yep.

[46:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, pick one from here, and then try and create a joke worthy of a two-year-old or older.

[46:46] Kevin: So what you're saying is just do what I always do.

[46:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Well, like try and make like a traditional, like a knock-knock joke.

[46:54] Kevin: Why did the chicken joke?

[46:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[46:56] Kevin: Um in St. Louis.

[47:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't know what a Halloween and meet me in St. Louis.

[47:07] Kevin: Very good.

[47:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Meet me in Halloween.

[47:10] Kevin: Yeah, you fixed it.

[47:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Halloween?

[47:11] Kevin: No.

[47:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, I know. We're working on me with this.

[47:13] Kevin: No, oh, I'll be right back.

[47:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, I'll do it.

[47:18] Kevin: Great.

[47:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Halloween in St. Louis.

[47:20] Kevin: Yeah.

[47:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh and then St. Lou based on the trend.

[47:24] Kevin: There it is.

[47:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Kevin got it.

[47:27] Kevin: Halloween in St. Louis.

[47:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Louis.

[47:30] Kevin: Okay. And then based on the joke, we just have to guess who your show card is if you want to make your joke that way.

[47:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: For sure, sure.

[47:35] Kevin: Yeah.

[47:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay. Bryan, do you want to start? Because I feel like you might be better at it than I'm going to do.

[47:40] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. Um.

[47:41] Bryan Plofsky: Who is Frankenstein's favorite actor?

[47:44] Kevin: Um.

[47:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I feel like Kevin has assumed the role of person at door.

[47:49] Kevin: I don't know. Who is his favorite actor?

[47:51] Bryan Plofsky: John Bolt in candy.

[48:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yay! That was actually pretty good.

[48:06] Kevin: Oh god.

[48:12] Bryan Plofsky: Um, okay. Uh what is this is awful. Um, what is the transformation called when a vampire changes into a bat?

[48:25] Kevin: I don't know. What is it?

[48:26] Bryan Plofsky: Finishing the bat.

[48:30] Kevin: Oh, we're guessing you have?

[48:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[48:31] Kevin: Mandy would take it.

[48:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No.

[48:34] Kevin: Jake Joan Hall?

[48:35] Bryan Plofsky: I do.

[48:36] Kevin: Oh.

[48:37] Bryan Plofsky: I didn't really say a card.

[48:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a really good card.

[48:41] Kevin: It is a really good card.

[48:42] Bryan Plofsky: Oh.

[48:43] Kevin: What a great beard.

[48:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, right.

[48:45] Kevin: It's a sexy beard.

[48:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Oh, did Kevin get candy?

[48:50] Kevin: I don't think I did.

[48:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was a rough one.

[48:52] Kevin: Okay.

[48:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay.

[48:53] Kevin: You just that was your decision.

[48:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was rough. I still would have given you candy.

[48:58] Kevin: I had a plan for it, but it didn't execute well.

[49:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Alright. That's true. I got what you were going for.

[49:04] Bryan Plofsky: Why did the chicken cross the Atlantic?

[49:11] Kevin: Which way is he going?

[49:15] Bryan Plofsky: We're coming to America.

[49:18] Kevin: And then cross over land again.

[49:23] Bryan Plofsky: Was he coming from away?

[49:24] Kevin: No, he wasn't.

[49:27] Bryan Plofsky: Um to get to Pacificovich.

[49:36] Kevin: You definitely get candy.

[49:39] Bryan Plofsky: Cross Atlantic and then cross more lands.

[49:45] Kevin: Oh, that was so good.

[49:47] Bryan Plofsky: I got it.

[49:48] Kevin: Okay. Why couldn't the cobbler fix your shoes?

[49:55] Bryan Plofsky: Because they were on your feet.

[49:56] Kevin: Yeah!

[49:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. That was great.

[50:04] Kevin: That was a good one. You definitely get candy for that one.

[50:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's really good.

[50:07] Kevin: That was fun.

[50:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was awesome.

[50:08] Kevin: Halloween insane.

[50:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Why do you need to do that?

[50:13] Kevin: You just said it would be spooky.

[50:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because it's the Halloween episode question mark.

[50:17] Kevin: Spooky.

[50:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, that brings us to the end of our episode.

[50:22] Kevin: Alright.

[50:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you so much for taking time between shows to hang out with us.

[50:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Are you joking? I adore you, people.

[50:31] Kevin: Thank you.

[50:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A lot of people question what you call us and just settle up people.

[50:37] Kimberly: Before we leave, what's the best Halloween costume you've ever had?

[50:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Winifred Sanderson, are you joking?

[50:43] Kimberly: Why he wears it every year now?

[50:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Did you ever do it before the show?

[50:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No. Um I always wanted to as a kid, but I was afraid that I didn't have the means to like do it really do it.

[50:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. And I needed like sis, I needed two sisters to do it, you know.

[50:57] Kimberly: Yeah.

[50:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So once I had the means.

[51:00] Kimberly: Yeah, one besides that. What was like your f your best costume as a kid?

[51:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: As a kid, probably. This is really weird. Actually, for like six years in a row, I was a clown.

[51:14] Kimberly: The same clown?

[51:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Kind of.

[51:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, like it progressively got. It was like four to like ten.

[51:24] Kimberly: Okay, so a little bit of that was like not your choice.

[51:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I really was, though. Yeah, I guess it is. I was a very, I was a very like Ronald McDonald clown as a kid. And then when I got up to be like eight, nine, ten, I was being like the bloody clown because it wasn't cool to be a clown anymore.

[51:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But I would just have this weird obsession. I had to be a clown. I'm a clown, but like scary this time.

[51:46] Kimberly: Yeah, right?

[51:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. But that was the thing. And I I love this. This is I have a weird smirk on my face, but I think that's a good idea.

[51:52] Kimberly: No, I have a weird feeling in my stomach as I tell you.

[51:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's from the candy corn.

[51:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's very sugary candy. But um, thank you so much for joining us. You can obviously follow him at J underscore A underscore Johnson, or as Kimberly says.

[52:08] Kimberly: Just look it up!

[52:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yep. Um don't forget, November 15th or the 18th at City Center. You'll be able to see him play Bobby in A Chorus Line.

[52:17] Kevin: We have to go because we need to because we think it's company.

[52:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[52:21] Kevin: Um obviously the Majestic Theater has him every day.

[52:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, except for Sundays.

[52:29] Kevin: Except for Sundays doing um doing this.

[52:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, they Sundays off Monday night, one again. You can follow us on at Broadwaysted. Join our Facebook group. Kevin does some really theater nerdy stuff.

[52:40] Kevin: Yeah, be have some fun times.

[52:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you so much to Gold Star. Get your tickets at Goldstar.com backslash Broadwaysted.

[52:47] Kevin: Oh, lowercase. There's a ton of cool fall stuff there.

[52:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And there's there's a ton of shows now on there.

[52:53] Kevin: There really are. There's a lot of great shows for this season. So if you want to catch up on the shows that are happening, especially during the holidays, as it's like a fun, mix exciting thing to come to the city and come see a show. Check out Goldstar.

[53:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And uh ten dollars off your order by using an all caps Broadwaysted when you check out.

[53:08] Kevin: Yeah.

[53:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um so thank you to Gold Star. But we end every episode with a quote. And our quote today is black cat, black cat. What do you think of that scat? I'm just kidding. That's not really it. It's it's been 300 years, right down to the day. Now the witch is back, and there's hell to pay. I put a spell on you, and now you're mine.

[53:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um yeah, thank you so much for hanging out with us. Are you joking?

[53:33] Kevin: Yes.

[53:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And as we end every episode, oh, just a case.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred