Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 221: The Founding Fathers gets Broadwaysted!

Dear Theodosia, what to Zoom to you? Play along as Aaron J Albano (Newsies, Hamilton), Hayley Podschun (Hello, Dolly, Hairspray) and Nikisha Williams (Hamilton, The Color Purple) join Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly via video chat to break down 1776 and Hamilton... Read More

From the show: Broadwaysted!

1 h 45 mins
7/10/20

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Dear Theodosia, what to Zoom to you?

Play along as Aaron J Albano (Newsies, Hamilton), Hayley Podschun (Hello, Dolly, Hairspray) and Nikisha Williams (Hamilton, The Color Purple) join Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly via video chat to break down 1776 and Hamilton. Come for the bad puns and wine but stay for the musical talk and Buttonwood Grove wine.

Extended cut and full video is on Patreon. Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Bryan Plofsky: Did you bring wine?

[0:05] Kevin Jaeger: I got the glasses.

[0:07] Kimberly Cooper: You guys, I made a quiz.

[0:08] Hayley Podschun: I didn't bring anything, but I hear it's a bug.

[0:20] Bryan Plofsky: Hello, and welcome to the official Broadwaysted podcast where we're drunk on theater. I'm your host, Bryan Plofsky, and Happy Father's Day, sort of. But who gives a John Adams? So grab a beer. Maybe a Sam Adams. Bust out your Benjamins and a Hamilton and Cheese Sandwich, and we'll pat Henry you on the back. Don't get James Madison because you're not a U.S. John Marshall. Just be happy you're a George Mason worker. And go Washington and dry your clothes. Then listen to most Jefferson.

[0:55] Bryan Plofsky: Joining us today are the usual right-hand men and women who should have been included before the sequel, um, who waited for it, including Kevin Sit Down Jaeger.

[1:07] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, sit down, Kevin.

[1:10] Bryan Plofsky: Kimberly, our violin playing game master and unofficial babysitter for the hour.

[1:14] Kimberly Cooper: I wish I played the violin.

[1:17] Bryan Plofsky: Uh and with us uh are two people who are typically in the room where it happens, and somebody else was in Hairspray. Um let's give a let's give a let's give a big Broadwaysted welcome to friends of the show. Friends of the show. Hayley Podschun, Aaron J. Albano, and Nikisha Williams.

[1:43] Hayley Podschun: I was not ready for that.

[1:46] Aaron J Albano: That was uh that was top nine. That was incredible.

[1:49] Hayley Podschun: I really want like every benefit, every like big like concert I do. I want to be introduced as, oh, and someone who is in Hairspray.

[2:00] Aaron J Albano: Someone who was in all the Hairsprays except live, but yeah.

[2:03] Hayley Podschun: Fair.

[2:04] Bryan Plofsky: Um uh welcome back, Hayley.

[2:07] Hayley Podschun: Thank you.

[2:08] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, well. That's okay. Uh so today uh we are gonna be talking 1776, the original film. Um, and uh the uh live cap of Hamilton came out. If those of you don't know, um kind of under the radar. No marketing, no Twitter, you know, trending crazy. Oh hi. No, is it a musical? No, it's just uh Lynn Manuel reading the Max Thernoff book or Dan Turner, whatever his name is. But um and uh so um before we do that, what are you drinking? What are you drinking?

[2:42] Bryan Plofsky: Uh I'll go in order my screens. Kimberly, what are you sipping on?

[2:48] Kimberly Cooper: I have my new favorite random cocktail, which is mostly gin, and then a little bit of mango LaCroix. Oh then just a splash of mango margarita mix that's been hanging out in my fridge.

[3:03] Bryan Plofsky: Nice. Oh, let's move down, Aaron.

[3:08] Aaron J Albano: I am back to my old standby of Dark Horse Cab Sal.

[3:12] Bryan Plofsky: Nice.

[3:17] Nikisha Williams: Oh, thank God Nikisha in your Harry Potter uh under the stairs house.

[3:17] Nikisha Williams: Under the stairs house. So I just got home 30 minutes ago after driving about nine hours. So I literally you just just got home.

[3:34] Bryan Plofsky: Yes, got home.

[3:36] Nikisha Williams: Why are you here?

[3:37] Nikisha Williams: Because I love you guys so much.

[3:41] Nikisha Williams: So I currently am not drinking anything, but I'm happy to be here.

[3:44] Bryan Plofsky: It might have a forever.

[3:51] Kevin Jaeger: Uh so I just started an eight-week intensive with Bill for the stage, so I can't drink anything.

[3:57] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[3:58] Kevin Jaeger: So um I am drinking uh what I call gay water, which is just a Berry LaCroix.

[4:05] Hayley Podschun: Absolutely.

[4:14] Hayley Podschun: Beautiful. Um I just got back from Ithaca, New York, and uh I am drinking the Ithaca Beer Company's Lakeside Lager. But more importantly, I went to visit our friends at the Buttonwood Grove uh winery around Cayuga Lake.

[4:31] Bryan Plofsky: Just tell us about it.

[4:32] Hayley Podschun: And we did I did a uh one of one, first of all, it's gorgeous. Like it was truly beautiful. Um, but we did a tasting of some wines, and my favorite that we tasted were the uh was the Pinot Noir. Um I bought a bottle of it um because one I like to support them, and two, um, it's really good. It's like you could like look right through it. It's so it's so light, um, but it's really really good. Um, and so I wanted to shout out Buttonwood, the uh great service. It was outdoor tastings, masks and everything. Um, and that was their first night of doing um outdoor music. So they they socially distanced with the music and like people were just sitting tasting wines. Um it was just nice to see get their economy going, and it was I felt very safe there. If I because obviously that's a big part of everything now. Um, but uh had a wonderful time. The wine is excellent, so you can find them online on Instagram and stuff.

[5:27] Bryan Plofsky: So uh but before we do our uh our cheers, um I did want to raise a cheers today to Nick Cordero, who passed away of complications due to the COVID virus. Um I I don't know if anybody here knew him personally, um, but what I uh can say is that he was one of those actors who I accidentally saw in everything, and like was one of those things where like I kind of like tracked his career because I had enjoyed him so much in Bullets Over Broadway, and I saw him in Waitress and Kevin and I and Kimberly and I saw him in Bronx Tale. Um and uh was always um I've always heard wonderful things about him uh as a person, uh but his talent definitely did that. I've been listening to Bronx Tale a little bit today and yesterday.

Um, but I I did want all of us to raise a glass uh to him. Uh and uh we're thinking and and uh of his obviously his family um and and and the community because uh as Hayley and Aaron pointed out uh before we started recording, regardless if you knew him or not, um it's a big hit to the community. Um and the community has taken a lot of hits lately. Um, and uh this is just probably one of the more devastating ones um because the economy can always find its way back, but lives cannot. Um so raise the glass to him um and his family. Uh cheers. Uh Nick.

[6:44] All: Cheers.

[6:46] Bryan Plofsky: Um so let's uh let's move off of that somber note and talk about musicals. Um but uh we're covering two again, as we mentioned, 1776, uh as well as um Hamilton. Uh, we're gonna start with 1776, um, so we're gonna know chronologically, but I'm gonna pass this over to Kevin, who uh is uh a big uh fan of 1776.

[7:20] Kevin Jaeger: Sure is like banger in. Um Kevin, take it away.

[7:25] Kevin Jaeger: Cool. So I am hosting this little segment just because my family watched this movie every 4th of July for I I would count at least 15 years of my life. Oh my gosh. I've literally seen it. It's it's on it was on TV, but then when it would stop being on TV, we would just watch it because we just owned it. Um and then also even it was on TV, my dad would start screaming that he hates commercials, and we would just watch it on the DVD anyways. Um I'm excited to talk about it. Um before we get into our discussion about the movie, I just want to share some fun facts with everybody about this production. Um so this 1776, the musical appeared on Broadway. It uh premiered in 1969, and it ran for 1,217 performances.

It won three Tony Awards, including Best Musical that year. Uh during its three-year run, it played in three different theaters on Broadway. It first started at the Richard, what is now called the Richard Rogers Theater, and then it moved to the St. James Theater, and then they moved finally into the Majestic, and that's where it closed was at the Majestic.

[8:35] Kevin Jaeger: Um that's like Pimpernel. Pimpernel moved, I think three times, right? I thought that doesn't happen as much anymore.

[8:43] Bryan Plofsky: Uh I mean it doesn't happen at all now, but like it's as much before, but it seems like something that happened much more in like the set like 60s, 70s, in that kind of 80s, even.

[8:56] Kevin Jaeger: Um, so well, the Richard Rogers is a very founding father's theater.

[9:00] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, right.

[9:01] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. I think when it was there, it was called, I think it used to be called like the Playhouse Theater or something.

[9:06] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[9:07] Kevin Jaeger: No, it was the 46th Street Theater.

[9:09] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, right, yeah.

[9:10] Kevin Jaeger: Thank you, thank you. Yes. Um, so it was uh a different name at the time. Uh the music and lyrics are by Sherman Edwards. It was also his idea, and he had been working on this idea, like building it out for years before a producer introduced him to Peter Stone to write the book. Um this is the musical that Betty Buckley made her Broadway debut in. Betty Buckley played Martha Washington or Martha Jefferson. Um and it was her very first show on Broadway. Uh so the film adaptation that we watched came out in 1972, and it could it uh retained almost the entire original Broadway cast. The rights to this musical were bought by Jack uh Jack Warner, who's like the famous like Warner that we've all heard of. Um he bought the rights for the theme school for 1.25 million dollars, which was a huge amount of money at the time to be buying in these, like in this late 60s, early 70s.

[10:08] Aaron J Albano: Um what was what was the number, Kevin?

[10:11] Kevin Jaeger: 1.25 million compared to the 75 million that Disney bought Hamilton for?

[10:16] Aaron J Albano: Yeah, right.

[10:20] Kevin Jaeger: Wait, 75. I thought it was a 17.

[10:23] Aaron J Albano: No, still a lot of money though.

[10:25] Kevin Jaeger: 75.

[10:26] Aaron J Albano: Where?

[10:27] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. And um Jack Warner actually insisted that the entire that they keep the entire original cast because he thought he had made a mistake uh a few years before when he turned down Julie Andrews for the film adaptation of My Fair Lady, it was his decision not to use her to use Audrey Hepburn, and he regretted that forever and thought it was a bad idea. So he when he did this musical, he was like, No, we're bringing literally everyone we can onto this movie. So a lot of these people are original casts, like William Daniels, who played John Adams.

[11:00] Aaron J Albano: I think you mean Mr. Feeney, Kevin.

[11:04] Kevin Jaeger: As we all know him, Mr. Feeney. Uh Howard DeSilva played Benjamin Franklin. And a fun note about that is Howard DeSilva is actually not on the original cast recording, even though he was the original Ben Franklin, because he had a heart attack during the run of the show, right when they were filming, they're gonna do the uh cast album. So his understudy did the cast album, and then when he recovered from his heart attack, he went back into the show, which I think and then he's also in this movie, which is insane. And then uh Thomas Jefferson is Ken Howard, Virginia Vestoff, who I'm obsessed with is the original Abigail Adams, and then uh Ron Holgate, who plays Richard Henry Lee, the Virginia is my home, like the silly guy. Uh, he actually won the Tony for Best Supporting Actor in a musical that year.

[11:52] Hayley Podschun: Good job.

[11:53] Kevin Jaeger: That's such a supporting actor win. Like you're heavy in the first act, huge song that's a standing ovation, and like you're just like not in it the rest of the time.

[12:02] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, yeah.

[12:03] Kevin Jaeger: What a goal. Um obviously Blythe Danner is playing the role that Betty Buckley played. From what I could tell from like research, it was basically due to scheduling because Betty Buckley literally blew up in the theater scene, and so she just was doing everything, and they were like, you don't have time to make a movie. Um, and then the only the only other person who is not original, or one of the only people who's not original cast is uh the character of Edward Rutledge, who's the guy who's from South Carolina who sings the molasses to Rum to Slaves. Oh, the guy who played the original left the show almost immediately after the show opened. And then they he was replaced by this guy named David Cryer, and then he David Cryer was then replaced by this actor named John Cullum, who is the actor that you see in this film.

John Cullum holds a record for being what one of the only Broadway replacements in history to create the role in the film. So I think it's kind of cool that instead of hiring an act, a random actor, they went with the second replacement on Broadway to do the movie. I will also say Broadway doesn't matter.

[13:12] Bryan Plofsky: That actor John Cullum is hilarious because he is quite famous now.

[13:16] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[13:16] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.

[13:18] Bryan Plofsky: This was his only film.

[13:21] Kevin Jaeger: The only time he was ever in a movie because he has done a crap ton of Broadway.

[13:27] Aaron J Albano: He's won like three Tonys, right?

[13:32] Kimberly Cooper: But like the film didn't know him.

[13:34] Aaron J Albano: Um, a couple other fun facts. So good the fountain that you see in that scene when he's Richard Henry Lee is singing the thing about Virginia and he almost falls in the fountain.

[13:43] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, where is that?

[13:44] Aaron J Albano: That is the same fountain that is in the opening of the very famous TV show Friends that they're different in.

[13:54] Kevin Jaeger: It's definitely not in Philadelphia.

[13:55] Aaron J Albano: No, it is not in Philadelphia, but it's the same fountain from Friends. Um, and then another fun thing that we'll well, I'm sure we'll bring up this song later. But there's a song called Cool, Cool, Considerate Men, which is the song where they sing about like to the left and always to the right, never to the left. We'll talk about that song, but the fun the cool uh fun fact about that song is the song specifically depicts Revolutionary War era conservatives as power-hungry wheedlers focused on maintaining wealth. And this the this song was actually removed from the original cut of the film that was put in theaters um by Jack Warner himself at the request of Richard Nixon, because Richard Nixon, president at the time, was a good friend of Jack Warner, and he didn't like that this song was bad about conservatives because Richard Nixon thought that it was mean to conservatives since he's a conservative, so he insisted removed from the film, and the director said, No way, shove it.

This song is important to the movie because the director also directed the Broadway show, so he was like, absolutely not. This song stays in. And the producer was like, Yeah, yeah, okay. And then they finished filming. The director went on a two-week vacation to relax after filming, and while he was on vacation, the producer cut it out of the movie.

[15:12] Kevin Jaeger: Do you know when they put it back in?

[15:15] Aaron J Albano: Uh, it came back into the uh it was it was like 10-15 years later that they put it back in because Jack Warner had ordered that the cut of the song be completely destroyed, like all film and everything of it destroyed. And the editor was like, I don't want to do that. So the editor hid it in their own storage like situation, so then it was able to be brought back because the editor saved it. What's also fun all of the previews for the film that had gone out to movie theaters to like play like like coming attractions were all built around this song. So this song was the background of all of the previews, so they had to then scrap all of the previews and like recut a brand new trailer, all because Richard Nixon didn't want conservatives to look bad.

[16:04] Kimberly Cooper: Well, because it's also like the only it's the only production number, isn't it?

[16:09] Aaron J Albano: Right.

[16:09] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.

[16:10] Aaron J Albano: It's one of the only production numbers. I mean, the opening numbers are kind of a production number, I guess.

[16:14] Kimberly Cooper: Sure, sure.

[16:14] Aaron J Albano: But it doesn't have choreography, so that would be exciting. Even more than production number, to me, it's like the thesis of the movie.

[16:21] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.

[16:22] Aaron J Albano: And the direct the producer Jack Warner on his deathbed actually apologized to the director for cutting the song because he realized that that was like the centerpiece of the story, and that he thinks he's responsible for like ruining part of the movie by cutting it out. Um also, in fact, the Broadway show went to the White House and performed 1776 in its entirety for Richard Nixon and some like members of his cabinet and stuff. And Richard Nixon's uh staffers basically told the producers if you're doing this, there's no way you're performing that song. You can't perform that song. And the entire company and the director said, uh, respectfully screw yourself. And they did the song like right in the White House in front of Nixon to kind of be like Word.

So I thought that was really crazy because that song has a lot for us to talk about. Um then last thing I'm gonna bring up is just some historical accuracy things before we get into just the movie. Uh since Congress was held in secrecy and they didn't really keep contemporary or like journals of what was happening there because they were afraid of what would happen if people found out. Um, this is all basically based on later accounts of what people wrote happened and educated guesses. But some of the dialogue is actually lift, a lot of the dialogue on the show is lifted from letters actually written by these people recounting to like their family and friends what happened. So a lot of the dialogue is directly from that.

Um, and then also the the actual separation from Britain happened in two steps. They first voted for independence to happen on July 2nd, and then they spent three days actually talking about the declaration. So for dramatic purposes, they put that all together into one thing where it was like all happening in one big vote. Um, also John Adams is a composite character of himself and his cousin uh Samuel Adams, who was also in Congress at the time, but they didn't want to confuse But they mention him beer, you mean the beer.

[18:26] Kevin Jaeger: The beer, yes.

[18:27] Aaron J Albano: So Sam Adams was also part of it, but like most of these things uh those are like the major discretions, but they're mostly done for dramatic effect, and no one at the time really cared what the changes were because they enjoyed the movie. Um, okay, so those are some fun thoughts about 1776. And so now let's go ahead and uh go around in a circle and everybody give your high-level thoughts of watching this. Well, first, let's say uh tell me what your experience is with this movie previously before now, and then on top of that, tell me just some quick high-level thoughts. And we will start with uh Nikisha.

[19:03] Nikisha Williams: So I never heard a song anything from 1776, was never really interested in watching it. But after I watched it, I was a big fan of it. I enjoyed it. Um, I thought it was quirky. I liked how they were making fun of themselves in the art of you know, striving for independence. So uh, and Mr. Feeney can absolutely do no wrong in my eyes. So I stand with him forever and ever. Hashtag saltpeter forever.

[19:35] Hayley Podschun: Yes. Uh, I'm looking over my notes to see if there's like a recap I can give. I had never seen it. I only knew the actual lyric he plays, the violin. That's it, because someone had told me in the past, you could play that part. And I was like, I don't know what that is. So I had YouTube that section of the movie. That's the only part I've ever seen. And um I had a difficult time getting through it.

[20:08] Kimberly Cooper: Okay. We'll get to more of that soon.

[20:10] Aaron J Albano: Yeah. Um, I had never seen it in its entirety before. I had watched parts of it in like high school history class. You know, when they tell you this.

[20:24] Kevin Jaeger: Good for your teacher for showing a musical.

[20:27] Aaron J Albano: Yeah. Um, but to like just little bits and pieces. Um, however, my parents did live across the street from Independence Hall for the past five years. And so I've been in and around where this entire movie takes place many, many, many times. And that is so cool.

[20:49] Bryan Plofsky: Awesome. Uh Aaron.

[20:56] Aaron J Albano: Um prior to this viewing, I had never watched the movie in its entirety. I knew that Mr. Feeney was in it, and that was the extent of my knowing about it. I had seen, I think the one clip that I had seen prior to this viewing was the waiting for the chirp, trip, chirp song. Okay. Because that's I don't know why. I think I just know that song. So good. I remember seeing that clip over and over again. I don't know how. Um and I think I really enjoyed I liked it. I think a big reason why I did like it was the fact that we watched it in tandem with Hamilton. Sure.

[21:50] Kevin Jaeger: Right. Um, I had never seen the movie, Kid Like Kimberly had never seen the movie in its entirety. I think I had seen every single um every single song and musical number. I know that during the election, uh cool, cool considerate men went around because of certain lines in there. Um so I definitely had seen that. Um, but um I movies like this have a bad rap because they look old and they look boring, kind of puts that like hesitancy in you. And like, I know, I know what this is about. I could tell you exactly what happens in this, but then like watching it is a totally different experience, and I really enjoyed it. And like I like I said, I had seen this movie hundred like dozens and dozens of times with my family.

Uh, it holds a special place in my heart, and I actually haven't watched it in quite a few years. Um, so it was really nice to revisit it. I think it's really a fantastic musical. Um, I think this is a great adaptation of it, um, and I really enjoyed it, and so we'll get into a lot of those thoughts later. Um, I also the like I also one thing that contributed to my experience of it is I was texting everybody. I had a hard time starting it because I think where we are culturally, I really didn't want to watch the movie, subconsciously or consciously. And so when we got when I finally did, because I had to, because I have to do my homework, um, it pleasantly surprised me that I liked it so much.

[23:28] Kimberly Cooper: Well, even why do you mean just because like it's like like having to do with the birth of a nation that we're all kind of like unhappy with what it's acting like right now?

[23:36] Aaron J Albano: Correct.

[23:38] Kimberly Cooper: I I I had a very hard time like wanting to watch anything related to America right now.

[23:46] Kevin Jaeger: I agree.

[23:47] Kimberly Cooper: I was kind of the same way, and I know that like this is historically what it is, not to like get that into the conversation, but like again, I know that this is what happened, but watching a bunch of white men discuss like the birth of our nation, I was like, I I actually don't enjoy watching this, and I had a really difficult time um getting into it the whole time because of that. And even though it is historically what it is, this is what happened. I was like, I I'm uncomfortable and I don't I don't like this.

[24:22] Aaron J Albano: And I think that that was part of it too, where it's like the way everyone, every colony, because it would they weren't even states yet. The way every colony was like, Well, I don't want to do it. Well, I don't want to do well. I don't want to do well. If if you do it, then I like it was so polarized in that room that I was like, even like, wow, from the get, we are a selfish nation. And I was like, and I mean, like, and it was a good artistic delivery of that, uh, artistic expression of that, but it was it was hard to watch because I was like, oh, this was always in our DNA. Like South Carolina wouldn't have been wearing masks, like it's not wearing masks now.

[25:09] Kevin Jaeger: Like, right.

[25:11] Kimberly Cooper: I think it's interesting to pay attention to when you look at America's history. Um, there's a lot of like us being the greatest nation and us being like all together as like proud, strong nation together. But if you look at it, like we from the get-go had like a series of wars within the first 200 years of us being a night, a nation, and like nothing unifies a group of people or makes like the oppression of unity more than having like a giant enemy and you're at war and fighting. So, like a lot of the war effort kind of I think like created a lot of the like feelings in our country of like this being this perfect, lovely, amazing, everyone's welcome, everyone loves each other and nation is that kind of a thing.

Um, and I think like it's interesting to see though that this movie depicts the creation of a nation when it's like well, the first war we were ever gonna face, and it is a divided nation of people fighting for their own specific politics and economy, basically over the like no one in the there's very few people in this movie who have like utopian ideas of a perfect nation.

[26:24] Aaron J Albano: Like every like a lot of them are just fighting for their own conceits and what they can get out of it, um, and I find that very fascinating that this musical does not shy away from the bad side of these people. So that's what I was most surprised about. I was most surprised about this musical because it was written in the 60s. I assumed that this musical would be very patriotic, very jingoistic in the way that it portrayed the founding fathers. I made the assumption that this movie was gonna be very much like look at these white men go like we did it everyone, but like I was pleasantly surprised by how non-generic and how flawed every single character is in this, inclusive of John Adams. Um, and the end of this movie, to skip to the end a little bit, was more sad to me than happy, and I think the music depicts that.

I think that the musical actually says like we're in for a roller coaster, but this is how it got started. Like I don't think the musical is, at the end of this musical, I really, really, really, really don't think that the feeling that it wants you to feel is of pride and excitement. I think it wants to make you feel really tired and that the work hasn't even started yet. And that was what surprised me the most about it, especially in act two. I did not expect this musical's act two to be about the slavery clause. I just didn't. I just expected them to wash right over that and like just be like, you know, like how do we all sign this? Let's do it. I really did not expect that to be about that. And um, and I mean, we can talk about other things, but like I think that that was like I was to me, act two of this is so much more engaging than act one.

[28:18] Kimberly Cooper: Where's the split? Do you know? Do you guys know when act two would be like in the actual stage show?

[28:24] Aaron J Albano: Yeah.

[28:25] Kevin Jaeger: Because I had commercials, so I don't know what splits would be.

[28:31] Hayley Podschun: I didn't see that.

[28:32] Aaron J Albano: Oh, I didn't even try because they were so short.

[28:35] Kevin Jaeger: Just play one.

[28:36] Aaron J Albano: That's fine. Hold on. I haven't pulled up just one second.

[28:39] Hayley Podschun: Sure.

[28:40] Aaron J Albano: Um, so while I'm looking to see where act two is, uh, I want to talk about how this, so your experience growing up in school. Did you feel like what you were watching was what you had learned about what happened in this time period specifically, or did you feel that you were hearing a lot of stuff that you were like, wait, what?

[29:01] Hayley Podschun: Well, I watched this musical in school.

[29:04] Aaron J Albano: Okay, well you really kind of got it.

[29:09] Nikisha Williams: Uh, Nikisha, did you feel like this was similar to your education of what happened?

[29:14] Nikisha Williams: Absolutely not. Growing up in the South, everything is pretty much whitewashed, and so um, a lot of the things that were being spoken of in the musical, I was like, this is really what happened, because everyone just likes to get to the fact that we have our independence, and now look how great we are, and not much of the internal struggles that happened. So it was um very nice to see that juxtaposition of all those opposing sides. Um, I also want to just piggyback on what Aaron and Hayley were saying as far as it just being hard to watch, especially in this time, because I specifically remember there was a moment in the movie where they panned to the Continental Congress all together, just in a group, and I was just like, all of these older white men that are about to just tell everybody what to do.

Like, I can't. But like I said before, I think some of the more redeemable qualities, and sorry, I'm getting like sidetracking what you actually asked me, but there's just so much. Um, of the redeemable qualities that made me like the movie in turn was what Bryan was saying about how human they all were. Um, especially with uh John Adams and him just kind of like consulting with his wife and you know, having like the realizations of like, okay, yeah, maybe I am wrong, or like, okay, yeah, maybe I might be aggressive, but like this is like how I want to present myself. And um, one of my favorite parts was when they were trying to go to what was it, New Brunswick, and John Adams was like trying to get Benjamin Franklin to go, and he's like half asleep listening anyway, and he was like, I'm not going.

And then they're like, well, he was like, 'What's what's there? What's in New Brunswick for me?' And they're like, 'Hor is in drinking.' He's like, 'All right, I'm in, let's go.' It's like, okay, yes, like you're making me like these people because I see them as people, not as founding fathers. I see these people making mistakes and decisions like we all make, and I think that's what the movie does a good job of, which made the turnaround for me to like it. I also feel like this wasn't a musical, it was a play with music. Because how I was watching it with the movie, it just um seemed to work better at like the, I don't know, this is a hot take for me, but I didn't really feel like the music added to the story or what was happening.

It was just like, we're gonna put a musical number here, and here you go. Like he plays the violin. Okay, great. Also, Seth Redesky has a deconstruction of Betty Buckley doing that. Uh, but it's like, but why did we need to know that she loves her husband? Great. What does that have to do with the story? But anyway, so that was a lot, but y'all said a lot of things. I was like, yes, yes, yes, yes, I agree with these things. They're all great.

[32:02] Aaron J Albano: I do so Kevin, I looked it up. Um, Mama Looks Sharp.

[32:06] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, I was gonna say Mama Looks Sharp is the end of act one, which is the bad song about the soldier singing about like his dying. Um, that's how they end act one of the show on Broadway. I think they moved some of it around.

[32:17] Aaron J Albano: What when you said it uh doesn't feel like a musical, there were multiple songs and a lot of underscoring that was cut by the producers of this film.

[32:28] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, because they thought there was too much music.

[32:35] Aaron J Albano: Um, I also think uh just jumping on the thing about Abigail Adams, uh, John and Abigail Adams have one of the most well documented relationships in history because they literally did write each other letters to each other all the time. And also they have one of the most progressive married couple relationships of anyone at that time ever, because John Adams really did treat her as an equal and ask her like her advice about like stuff like so a lot of what we know about what happened in Congress is because John Adams wrote it to his wife when like no one else a woman's idea was in there. That's why. Because a woman's voice was heard. That's why. So, like, she was very, very involved in like his decision making, not just in Congress, but like his entire life.

She was very much his equal and partner. And if you ever get a chance, there's a book that like a historian compiled all of their love letters. And some of the most beautifully touching things I have ever read. Like the yours, yours, yours thing at the end of all of their songs is from their letters. They literally wrote like yours, yours, yours over and over again, because they're the sweetest people in the world.

[33:46] Hayley Podschun: Yes.

[33:47] Aaron J Albano: Um, I will say, uh oh, go ahead.

[33:50] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, I was gonna say, uh, Aaron, jump in.

[33:53] Aaron J Albano: I will say, like, from the musical standpoint, not the historical standpoint, but the musical, like, standpoint. I will say that relationship was so well developed for two characters who were never in the same room together. I think it's so like because they now like they we never see them together, and yet such a beautiful romance. That's a could that's a concept on stage that's probably gorgeous, but with the wrong filmmaker, it it doesn't read or doesn't feel genuine. It really works in this. Like, even the way it's shot, how he's still where he's standing, and it's like this like hazy fade. It's beautiful. The cinematography in this is gorgeous.

[34:40] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[34:41] Aaron J Albano: For looking dusty, it looks beautiful.

[34:44] Kevin Jaeger: Very seven feet at a few times.

[34:48] Kevin Jaeger: Aaron, was this similar to what you learned in school? Would you say?

[34:51] Aaron J Albano: Um, I don't think so, but I can't tell if that was just me as a teenager not caring, or if it was because I do think that like we heard it, but none of it, all of it was sort of glossed over in like big brush strokes. Like, this is what you need to know to pass the AP exam. Like, yeah, that's it. Like, like I didn't know, like I don't think there was ever a moment where I like learned any of this in depth, as in depthly, as in-depthly, as in-depth as this movie portrays, either of these movies portray. But yeah, it was big broad stroke, so I could get a five on my AP US history.

[35:38] Kevin Jaeger: Totally.

[35:40] Aaron J Albano: That's why one of the moments I love in this movie is when Ben Franklin says to John Adams and Thomas Jefferson, like, who do they think we are? Like, we're not demigods, we're men, just like everyone else. We have like we make mistakes, and I think this movie does an excellent job of highlighting the humanity of these people creating this musical.

[36:02] Hayley Podschun: Right, was this similar to what you learned?

[36:04] Nikisha Williams: Whether or not I learned it this way, this is not what I took away from my learnings. And I think that in America, you are treated like these people are gods, they're on Mount Rushmore. They're like, it's a part of our, it's a part of the fabric of our society that we treat these people, we get their birthdays off, or we at least they're on the calendar. Like, regardless of if I learned what actually happened during that um that independence hall, um, like the independence um vote and things of that nature, like it definitely did not stick with me. Um, and I am so used, even in Hamilton, to be totally on, I'm so used to these characters um being presented as larger than life. Um, and this one totally gave me like whiplash in terms of treating them like flawed men, and and not writing them like demigods being flawed men, but actually just as people, and I think the actors get a lot of the credit on that too, playing them like people, as opposed to none of them had a chip on their shoulder in terms of historical context.

They all had chips on their shoulders because of the situation that they were in within the confines of that, you know, of those colonies. Um, that kind of that honestly that blew me away uh more than I I didn't expect it. I just very unexpected.

[37:30] Kevin Jaeger: Great. Um, let's just go quick in every give me like your favorite moment from the movie. It can be a song, it can be a scene, it can be anything, just something that you really loved if you had to pick something, Kimberly.

[37:42] Kimberly Cooper: And they call on Josiah Bartlett, which is the president's name in the West Wing.

[37:50] Aaron J Albano: Oh, I didn't know that one.

[37:51] Kimberly Cooper: I think I'm related to him because my mom is a Bartlett.

[37:55] Aaron J Albano: Really?

[37:56] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[37:57] Bryan Plofsky: Um, I, I my favorite part is the line: don't forget that most men with nothing would rather protect the possibility of becoming rich than face the reality of being poor. Um, that um combined with Kuku, I think that's during Kuciderate Men. It's right before, or like it's I think it's in it's in the middle. I forget it's somewhere where that just hit me like a ton. That hit me like a ton of bricks. Um, and I um, and then I think that rum and molasses is a spectacular number. Um, and uh holding northerners with chips on their shoulder accountable for being a part of the slave trade and all of that and bending things, even if they're not the ones who who own the slaves, even if they're not the ones who like are are the ethically wrong or right, they are benefiting from it because it's all interconnected.

And I thought that was one of the more powerful moments of that because that sent um uh John Adams a little bit of reeling out of that. Um, I think to me, those are the thesis statements of this. Um, and those before it was just like a really good rendition of um of the uh first continental congress, and then after that, like those like made this like that those are the those are the parts that made me lean in.

[39:25] Hayley Podschun: Uh, Haley.

[39:27] Nikisha Williams: Um, if I'm gonna be honest, my favorite part of this was Blyth was Blythe Danner's waist. She was really tiny. Um show. They're twins. I um my favorite, favorite, I'm gonna adjust the favorite and not like my like favorite in terms of my love it, but the favorite in terms of like it haunted me and it stayed with me after even watching it, was the idea that I'm used to watching movies like this where I just hate the South and they just aggravate me and they just annoy me and it they piss me off. But the fact that the main antagonist of this movie, antagonist, if one of many was from Pennsylvania, like very solidly in the north, and then on top of the fact that my like the colony that I consider home, it was a joke, but every time I would yell at my screen when he would abstain courteously, I know it's supposed to be like humorous, but I wanted to throw things at my TV. I was like, do something, New York.

[40:42] Aaron J Albano: Yeah, that's a good point. The things that are supposed to be like comic relief and funny, I did not find funny this time. I had the same reaction as Aaron, like, like, this is important. Don't like pretend that this isn't important. Like, oh, I had a lot of those similar feelings. I'm glad you said something like that.

[41:00] Kimberly Cooper: Agreed. And so it was was it my favorite in terms of like, I loved it. No. Was it my favorite in terms of like it stayed with me? Yeah.

[41:08] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, I've I enjoyed any humor in it because it's, you know, we need humor right now. So any back and forth with uh John Adams and Benjamin Franklin, I enjoyed. And anytime they showed their humanity, um was something that I liked because like like you all had said before about um them being put on pedestals, and uh I just think how real uh they portray the characters like Thomas Jefferson just wanted to get some, honestly, and they had a whole song about it. It's like it's like I will do my job after I spend time with my wife. And it's like, okay, yes, you are a human being person, and now I'm invested more in you because I'm seeing your humanity in all of this. Um of course, everything having to do with the South always hits especially hard being a black female and be growing up in the South, the deep, deep South.

So um, but again, it's things that I'm I'm used to and accustomed to. So those things are like, yeah, that's how people were, and that's how they think, and that's how they still think now. So it's just like, okay, let me get to another like funny part that I can like laugh at. But overall, I definitely enjoyed it way more than I thought I was.

[42:32] Aaron J Albano: So my favorite part is always the Abigail Adams, John Adams interactions. Um, when I was little, I played Abigail Adams around my house and sang just her lines. And my dad was like, Don't you want to sing John Adams part? And I was like, no. Um, but I will say I can just imagine Kevin in a healthy mix of it.

[42:53] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, I was working it.

[42:55] Aaron J Albano: Um, and also uh the song Mama Looks Sharp. I watching it this time too. I get but I bubble up with anxiety because growing up, every year we watched it, my mom cried through that song. And I it made it's like that little kid feeling of your mom's crying and you don't know how to handle this and it makes you uncomfortable. So, like, even watching it myself as a 35-year-old man by myself alone, like that song started, and I was like, I have to call my mom, is she okay? She she would just sweep through that song, and I didn't get it. Like, I feel like I didn't really understand until now, this evening, like how sad that song is. Um, and like I also love that they threw that in because we're watching these men make all these decisions in this room that are just like ideological thoughts for them.

But like this young kid gets a second to sit in this big room and he just shares about how his two best friends died, and his one was like literally calling out, wishing his mom and finding him as he was bleeding out. Like to show like this show does a really great job, like Bryan said. It like it starts out making you think you're watching a show that's like this is the founding fathers, but it really shows you the harsh reality of life and war and the fact that it ends on like a somber bell ring as they sign a document where like the 11 o'clock number is basically them deciding to cut out the thing protecting slaves and like making like making them free and like like the fact that that's like the big final thing before this is like it's really powerful.

[44:28] Kimberly Cooper: Um so let's anybody have any final thoughts before we do Rotten Tomatoes.

[44:34] Nikisha Williams: I really love this.

[44:36] Aaron J Albano: Yeah, I would like to see a stage version of it. So fun fact when Broadway comes back in 2021, there is going to be a revival at Roundabout that is a all female revival of every person, every character we played by women, and it's being directed by Diane Paulus.

[44:54] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, I'm so sorry.

[44:55] Aaron J Albano: It's not an all-female revival. I want to fix that. It's all female or gender non-binary performers.

[45:02] Kimberly Cooper: So it's it's basically just every gender that encompasses not being a cis male.

[45:07] Aaron J Albano: So Rotten Tomatoes for this movie. There is no critical consensus, but there is a rating. Um, let's start with uh Nikisha.

[45:17] Nikisha Williams: I'd say 80%.

[45:19] Hayley Podschun: 76 because 17.

[45:27] Kimberly Cooper: Um, I don't know. I feel like the people who go on to Rotten Tomatoes to review 1776. Love it so much.

[45:32] Aaron J Albano: But this is critics.

[45:35] Kimberly Cooper: Huh?

[45:36] Aaron J Albano: This is critics, not like people.

[45:38] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, not people. Well, I mean, it's 90. I'll stay.

[45:43] Nikisha Williams: 92.

[45:55] Aaron J Albano: Uh, I'm gonna say uh I'm gonna say a solid 70.

[46:02] Kevin Jaeger: 83.

[46:06] Aaron J Albano: Um, so you all are over. This movie got a 69%. There's no critical consensus, but Roger Ebert, who's a famous filmer, hated this movie so much. He basically said in his review that the there's some amazing actors in this movie who have been trapped by a director who's forcing them to do pomp and circumstance and all this, like postulating performing instead of acting. And so he like he and he all like the music got torn up as being forgettable, and like like the critics all hated this, but I I also think that during the Nixon administration, people were kind of in the conservative pocket, so like I also I will say I don't know. I think my enjoyment of this was enhanced with the couple, like Aaron said, my enjoyment of this was enhanced by the coupling with Hamilton, um, as opposed to just kind of like casually watching this on my own. Um, because I was thinking in the context of of that.

[47:13] Kimberly Cooper: Um, so I was that my my viewing was definitely enhanced because of that. I still loved it, but my viewing uh and and my thought process and how I how I viewed these people, the situation, how it was presented, was definitely uh my mind was the gears were grinding there.

[47:29] Aaron J Albano: And what a good segue, Bryan. Because now we're gonna start talking to Hamilton.

[47:34] Kevin Jaeger: So I will pass the baton to my buddy Aaron to take over and run the conversation about uh this musical no one's heard of called Hamilton.

[47:41] Aaron J Albano: Yeah. Hamilton, Hamilton, haha. Um, so this is oh my gosh. Sorry, my mom keeps calling. Um this is so we also watched another Founding Fathers movie called Hamilton. This is the we're referring to the 2020 film released on July 3rd, 2020, which was five minutes ago. Um fun fact, it was originally originally slated for October 15th, 2021 as a theatrical release, but because of COVID-19, it was released earlier on Disney Plus for everyone to see for $6.99. Um it was directed by Tommy Cale, who also directed the musical. Um, and it was written by Lin-Manuel Miranda and choreographed by Andy Blankenship.

[48:33] Aaron J Albano: Um it starred the majority of the original Broadway cast. The two exceptions were it was uh Woman 2 was played by Hope Easterbrook. These are both two women in the ensemble. Woman two was played by Hope Easterbrook, who was the first replacement for uh Woman Two, uh, who was originally played by Betsy Struxness, and Elizabeth Judd, who was the first replacement for Woman Five, who was originally um played by Emmy Raver Lampman. Um and yeah, this is a movie and a show that we all know very well. So let's go around the um the the the square the rectangle the screen and let's go with first experiences of the show slash music slash we um let's go Kimberly.

[49:09] Kimberly Cooper: I saw the show at the public because I had a friend who worked at the public and he said you are going to want tickets to this and so it sold out because I was like sure I'll get them soon and then he told me the day before it officially got extended um my parents always like to talk about this because I took my parents and well they took me and we sat next to Rosie O'Donnell so our first experiencing Hamilton was Rosie telling my dad um are you gonna like this it's hip hop and my dad goes I know it's Lin-Manuel Miranda he wrote in the heights and so my dad she's the best she is the best does Rosie still follow her on Twitter yes Rosie followed her on well because my dad said that to Rosie and then like Rosie and my mom struck up my mom just had to reach over and say thank you so much for your show it was my favorite and so then Rosie and my mom have a Twitter relationship.

[50:34] Kevin Jaeger: Rosie is the truly the best she's the best yeah um so I saw it then and then I saw it the night I got engaged on the Broadway.

[50:46] Aaron J Albano: Yeah and did you watch the movie?

[50:51] Kimberly Cooper: How many times? When did you watch the movie?

[50:54] Aaron J Albano: And how many times have you watched it? I guess.

[50:56] Kimberly Cooper: I watched it on Friday night with my parents and my husband and my aunt and her granddaughter who were here.

[51:03] Kevin Jaeger: Nice.

[51:05] Aaron J Albano: Oh.

[51:06] Kevin Jaeger: And the five-year-old in the room put on headphones and watched something else the whole time.

[51:10] Aaron J Albano: But then apparently watched Hamilton all night instead of going to bed.

[51:17] Nikisha Williams: What were you guys watching?

[51:18] Kevin Jaeger: So then she watched it later.

[51:20] Nikisha Williams: Babysitter's Club.

[51:26] Kevin Jaeger: I'm so excited.

[51:34] Aaron J Albano: Thanks to Matt Doyle and this podcast.

[51:38] Kimberly Cooper: Oh yeah.

[51:41] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god, remember all of this, Kevin?

[51:43] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, the Kev for Ham.

[51:45] Aaron J Albano: Um when I was begging Lynn.

[51:47] Kevin Jaeger: Recap it because some of our some of our listeners might not know.

[51:49] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, I don't know.

[51:52] Kevin Jaeger: So when the podcast originally started Broadwaysted in 2000 and oh god, 2006, 16.

[51:58] Aaron J Albano: 16.

[51:59] Kevin Jaeger: I almost said 17, but that's the when I started dating Jay.

[52:02] Aaron J Albano: I put them together. So in 2016, when we started the podcast, Hamilton was like a thing.

[52:07] Kevin Jaeger: And um, you couldn't get tickets unless you spent a lot of money, and I didn't want to do that.

[52:12] Aaron J Albano: So um, because I didn't have any.

[52:14] Kevin Jaeger: So I started this thing called hashtag Kev for Ham, where uh every there was a segment on every episode where I begged Lynn Manuel Miranda to give me a ticket so I could see the show.

[52:26] Aaron J Albano: Yes, and we basically continued until Matt Doyle's episode when he was like, Um, I know the company manager, I can get you in.

[52:33] Kevin Jaeger: And I was like, oh.

[52:35] Aaron J Albano: So I got to see the show on Broadway.

[52:37] Nikisha Williams: I was in like a house seat, so I was in like the fifth row on an aisle. It was incredible to see the show that close. And then I watched the show on Friday night at the same time as Kimberly. She said we're doing an 8 p.m. curtain. So I was like, okay. So I just had my first in a long time 8 p.m. curtain on Broadway watching Hamilton on Disney Plus.

[52:58] Nikisha Williams: Uh, so my students introduced me to it because I was teaching at the time when it came out, and they were like, Miss Williams, you have to listen to this. This is like epic and amazing. I'm like, absolutely not. I do, I will not like what you Gen Zers like. So I was like, absolutely not, not gonna listen to it. And it was a lot of hype. And so eventually I listened to it and fell in love with the soundtrack. And, uh, fun fact, "Satisfied" was my go-to diner song that I sang. Um, so yeah, I did not see the show until I got hired for the show. Um, so it was like a total surprise, and I was in awe when I actually um saw it on my first day when I met the Philip Company in uh South Carolina. Um, but yeah, I so I didn't know anything about it, and or I didn't see it until I got the job and perks of having uh being a part of the Hamilton cast, we got an early uh a link to watch it early, a day early.

So we watched it a day early, and I literally called and texted like everyone in my cast, and I was like, oh my gosh, I miss you guys. Can we go back to work, please? This is absolutely amazing. And fun fact, Nakeisha is woman five. If you ever need to watch, need to come and see her when we come back in 2034.

[54:39] Hayley Podschun: I only played it once. And then I was working at Flywheel. I was the um person who checked you in to and like spared your shoes. Like if you went cycling, I spared your shoes and whatever. And uh I got a text uh saying we got tickets standing room tonight. And I was supposed to babysit um this girl that I babysit all the time that I love so much. And I called her mom and said, I can't do tonight. I just got tickets to Hamilton. Luckily, she's in the business, and she was like, I get it go. So I saw the original cast, except uh David. I did not see him. I saw Andrew go on for him. I don't even know Andrew, but um, he was on. And um friend of the show, Andrew Chappelle. Yeah, indeed. And um, I was obsessed.

I stayed up all night talking about it, and um I think it's the best thing, like next to what I say, like Hades sound is the next best, the new best thing compared to Hamilton of all the elements combined of the best. You have the best lighting designer, costume, choreography, set, orchestrations like literally everything that involves to be a musical. You have the best people of the best coming together to create something magical, and I think that's what I took away from Hamilton.

[56:06] Hayley Podschun: I'm going sideways, but um, that's why I love the show so much. And that's when I saw it, and I watched uh it on Disney Plus on the 4th of July with my parents. They had never seen it. Um, I know, and they loved it, and I'm so happy they did. My dad, or sorry, my mom was like, Can we turn on the um closed captioning? And I was like, No, you just have to listen because I didn't have like I had I went in when I saw the show as a complete virgin. I had never heard any of the songs, nothing. I wanted it to be completely clean, and um, I'm so glad I did because you just sit there at the front of your seat, like you don't blink, your ears have never been wider, and my dad, even at the end of it, was like, I really had to listen like hard. And I'm like, isn't it fun? Like, you gotta like get in it. Clean in, yeah. That's my history, Brad.

[57:06] Aaron J Albano: Um, I listened to the cast album when it first came out, loved it. Um, and then for my 30th birthday, my mom gave me some money uh to use for Hamilton. So what I did was my sister and I had dinner at Mexi Q in Midtown. Um, and 30 minutes before the show, we went on Stub Hub when uh sellers get nervous that they're not gonna sell their tickets. Um, so my sister and I kept refreshing, and about 15 minutes before the show, we got like at price tickets for the original cast, like in center orchestra, because the whoever this seller was got super nervous, so we ran to the Kinkos, printed those bad boys out. The Kinkos is like a block away from the Richard Rogers, and then we got right in and we saw the that was the plan to do it. And if it didn't work out that night, we would have done it like the next night, you know. But that's how we ended up seeing it.

[57:55] Hayley Podschun: Um, the only person that's a good plan.

[57:55] Aaron J Albano: That's incredible.

[57:55] Hayley Podschun: That's a good plan.

[58:00] Aaron J Albano: Um, the uh only person I did not see was uh Leslie Odom Jr. I saw his understudy um Austin, uh, who was spectacular. And I um um so that was really wonderful. Um, and uh um so that's when I saw it. Um, and um we watched it on July 4th that night. Um, and uh I watched it with my sister again, who was there who saw it with me the uh first time we saw it, but then we watched it with her fiance and my girlfriend, who both of those had never seen it. My girlfriend Jamie had never even heard any of the songs on purpose. Um didn't listen to it, and then um my sister's fiance, um, he had listened to it because my sister listens to it. So we had four very different people in the room watching it.

[58:50] Aaron J Albano: I think I'm the only one involved you like or I mean Nikisha as well. I did not see the original cast when I saw it that pretty much uh by the time I saw it, I saw it like a couple like a few months after the Tony's and like a lot of them had left. Um, so I might I saw some of the ensemble members that were in it from the original cast. I think some of them are still there, but like I saw Manny Gonzalez was playing um at the time, and so I saw like a this is my first time, like I heard the album, but this is my first time seeing the original cast.

[59:23] Hayley Podschun: Oh, nice.

[59:23] Aaron J Albano: Oh fast for most of the original cast. So I my first experience with Hamilton was A was I auditioned for Hamilton mixtape back when it was a is a workshop, and it was just kind of just another and the audition where it was all cool hip hop and we all wanted the job. Um, but fast forward, I was closing Here Lies Love when Hamilton was moving into the Newman.

[59:47] Aaron J Albano: So there was a split second when all of us sort of like passed in the dressing rooms. Um because I because I've known Lynn for a while and I knew all those people, I sort of was being a dick and was like too cool. And I was like, I'm sure it's fine. I didn't want like I probably could have seen it at the public, and now I regret not seeing it at the public. Um but I just didn't because I was too cool for some stupid reason.

[1:00:19] Aaron J Albano: Um like I remember there was a I was cut seeing a concert at Joe's pub one day, and Lynn saw me over like the balcony of the lobby of the public, and he was like, Erin, and I'm like, hey, he's like, Are you coming to the show tonight? And I was like, no, and that was it. And they're giving us and that was our interaction.

[1:00:39] Aaron J Albano: And then the show blows up, and I'm like, cool, great. And then I didn't see it, and of course, and I've seen the show three times, but the first time I saw it was like a week after opening. Um, and of course, still like too cool, and being like, I mean, I hear it's great, but is it that great? And I'm watching it like so like my nose turned up and like jaded actor, but then I'm watching the show and it's fantastic, and then when "Satisfied" hit, I was like, okay, this is different.

[1:01:13] Aaron J Albano: This is different. So good. Fast forward, yeah, and I and I watched it, I watched it twice in New York beyond that, and then um the last time watching it before I went out on tour, um, to which that's where I am now. Well, that's where I was now. Um, and I watched, and like Nikisha, we got an early an early link, and so I watched July 2nd at 7 p.m. um with some chips and salsa and a bottle of wine, and like and a couple of socially distant friends came over and we watched, and it was fantastic. It was wonderful.

[1:02:07] Aaron J Albano: And having nothing to do with the movie, I was very proud of it. It was wonderful. Um, so I think I was thinking of how to frame this, and I think the best way would be to split this up sort of into two, and if they inter if they intersect, then that's fine. But I'd say the first would be to talk about it as a movie slash the show. Um, and then the second part can be more historical and especially in comparison to the first movie.

[1:02:39] Aaron J Albano: Um just to sort of like segment it that way. Um, and I'll kick us off with both. The first move, the first section, I would say, like I said, my f like if you want to go like high-level thoughts, favorite moments, um like examinations on brilliance of storytelling, la la la la. Again, my favorite segment from my first watching and continuing on, even having known the show very intimately for the past two years. "Helpless Satisfied" is my favorite sequence of the show. I think it's the most brilliant storytelling device I have ever seen in recent theater, if not all theater.

[1:03:28] Nikisha Williams: Who else wants to start? Because you can either take off of that or Maisie agrees.

[1:03:39] Hayley Podschun: Yeah.

[1:03:40] Hayley Podschun: I mean I'll I'll start.

[1:03:43] Hayley Podschun: Um so the first time that I saw this when I got the job was the I had the same thought as when I watched the movie, and that was that the ensemble makes this work. The ensemble, the ensemble, the ensemble, and then next to it was Leslie Odom. Um, because he is absolutely brilliant in his storytelling, he is so distinct in his tactics, and it just showed so well on uh in movie form to me.

[1:04:19] Hayley Podschun: Um, I think that I guess high-level thoughts would be that every everything that was standalone, like costumes, like Haley was saying, like costumes are brilliant, the music by itself is brilliant. Just listening to the soundtrack from start to finish, you just know that the show is amazing, even if you have never seen it. Um, but then when they all come together, it just explodes your mind because uh it's so everything is so detailed, and you can tell the time and precision that each person took in order to make this happen and uh to make it be as unified as it is to tell this uh story.

[1:05:01] Nikisha Williams: Um, and piggybacking on just like the um historical elements of seeing all of these people of color tell this story in a way that you don't look and say, Oh, this is people of color, you just see that it's it's important that it's people of color, but that's not the premise of the story, which is what I like. Um, and that's what makes it makes it work because you're just seeing people of color telling a significant storyline, and it's not like oh, black people are doing this, it's like no, these are the founding fathers, and uh there was an interview um way back when this first started in Lin Mill was just basically talking about how he wanted to tell the story of America, how America looks now, and so I think that's why it all worked for me.

[1:05:50] Nikisha Williams: One of my favorite moments in the show, and watching it, is always the Battle of Yorktown, just because that's one of the moments where everyone is on stage aside from the first number, and so that camaraderie, I just feel that bleeding off of the screen as I watch it. And then another moment that I didn't really realize, because in it, it's a little boring, but Hurricane, when the lights drop and the slow motion happens, I audibly gasped when I saw it. Because in the moment, as Woman Five, you're in the balcony and you don't really see everything that's happening, but when I got to see a full frontal visual of it, I was just like, this is fantastic, and I want to cry right now. But yeah, I think that the two takeaways from just watching it in movie form were how the storytelling and the ensemble really made it work for me and how brilliant Leslie Odom Jr. is, and his voice is literally gold, and I need it to just see through my body every day.

[1:06:57] Bryan Plofsky: Can we talk about, because we've seen a lot of live caps just in our lives and even on this podcast? The cinematography for this live cap is fantastic.

[1:07:10] Kevin Jaeger: I think.

[1:07:11] Nikisha Williams: But I would also say it's as good as, I mean, not to compare, but like, especially because it's not OG, but I think the Newsies recap is just as wonderful.

[1:07:21] Hayley Podschun: Oh, you think?

[1:07:22] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, and She Loves Me. Like, I really think that they figured out the formula and the quality of film that it takes to let you feel like you're in the theater, but also experience the up-close moments. I don't know, that's just my personal opinion.

[1:07:45] Kevin Jaeger: I would argue that I think that the Newsies and She Loves Me live cap, like cinematography-wise, are better than what this was. I was actually very surprised at how much they did close-up shots. I feel like I didn't see any of the choreography of this show because in Hamilton, they were so in everyone's faces, and like all these small shots instead of showing wide shots, that I really didn't feel like I experienced much of the choreo of the show. And when I did, it felt like they were showing me disjointed parts that didn't show why they were doing things. I felt like I got a way better understanding of the choreo and the movement language of this show from watching it in person because I felt like this live cap really cut off the choreo at like the athanese. Like it was just like a full example of what it was.

[1:08:41] Hayley Podschun: I'm gonna agree with Kevin. I thought that this, my one critique of this, I agree with all of you about like it's amazing, it's magical. I mean, that's almost like a given at this point. It was very claustrophobic. I think it's a very tough line to straddle in terms of are we making a movie or are we presenting the show that was on stage? And I think some moments it gets really well. I think the fast editing from Helpless and Satisfied amps up that energy. But then you have other parts where there are just these weird side angles that's trying to be very artistic, but like also I lost Woman Two and Three and Man Four and Five. I wanted to see all of this together. I think that one of the only cast members who the editing puts forward, it's almost like they cut around Ariana.

[1:09:53] Kevin Jaeger: Because I noticed that too.

[1:09:55] Hayley Podschun: She's great by cutting around. I don't mean cutting around, I mean like she's a very big focal point. She has a very big part on the bullet track and is a part of major scenes. But I feel like I lost a lot of the other ensemble because of the claustrophobic nature of it. But the flip side of that is like some of these close-ups of Lynn and David, and to echo Nikisha, I think the close-ups of Leslie Odom Jr. were where it really works. Where like The Room Where It Happens or Wait For It, where there's no one else on stage anyway. And even if there are, I mean, they're all in the shadows and stuff like that. But like, I don't know, even in those, you get his facial expression, but you miss the energy of the other people on stage feeding him. And like Wait For It, it's like a miracle watching in the wings for what he does next.

[1:10:51] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, and I definitely lost a lot of the theatricality of it. I will say I was agreeing with that in the moment, and then halfway through, I was like, oh, I just wish I was in a theater.

[1:11:07] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, totally miss being in the theater so much and being able to choose who I look at.

[1:11:15] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, being forced to follow someone. I was just like, but I want to see how they're moving the chairs, like I want to see everything.

[1:11:26] Nikisha Williams: But the one thing that it did is the people watching and waiting in the wings, I thought was more prevalent in this because there would be a close-up, and then just a scary person in the background.

[1:11:42] Bryan Plofsky: That's what the ensemble does. They creep in the background the whole time.

[1:11:46] Hayley Podschun: Like, oh my god, like it reminds me when you do like really old school scene study classes, and like when you're not on stage, you're just like off to the side with your head down.

[1:11:56] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, I'm not here. Just soft focus about acting.

[1:12:00] Hayley Podschun: I think—oh sorry, go ahead, Nikisha.

[1:12:03] Nikisha Williams: Well, just really quickly. When Bryan was talking about Helpless and Satisfied, I would say that when I watched that, the close-ups of Renee made me not like her so much because how expressive that she is, I thought that the close-ups just kind of overdramatized, and I thought maybe wider shots could have softened that up a little bit. Because I mean, everyone is for the most part just playing like it's a theater, you know, and it's just being filmed. And I think that was especially true every time there was a close-up on Renee, which I love her and I love her work and I love her voice, but just in those moments, I didn't feel like the close-ups benefited her. It just seems like she was working very hard when we know she's not, but the close-ups just kind of overshadowed the interesting thing.

[1:13:01] Bryan Plofsky: So I'm gonna continue to backpack on what you said about Leslie and now Renee combining with Bryan. When I saw the show, I was in standing room, but I'm still like at the back of the orchestra, and I'm like, I can't hear Leslie Odom Jr. at all, and he is mic'd. I cannot hear him, I cannot understand him, and I think he is, I don't know him at all. I assume he's a soft-spoken person because of just his nature and his vocal box of how it's built. So I think that the film helped him a lot, and this is just for me seeing the show in standing room. I enjoyed his performance more on the film because to me, he is more of a film actor. He's small, and everything is very tiny, and even with Renee, I thought that I didn't get anything when I saw her on stage, and I think she is brilliant. I think both of them are brilliant, but I got more from them on camera because they are so small, but that's just I was standing at the back of the orchestra, so I don't know.

[1:14:12] Nikisha Williams: But no, I felt the same thing about Philippa, Philippa Soo.

[1:14:17] Hayley Podschun: Yes, Eliza.

[1:14:18] Nikisha Williams: I thought she was fantastic in the movie, and I thought she was fine in the show, but yeah, something about this movie, I appreciated especially during Quiet Uptown. I appreciated her performance more on film than I did in the theater. I thought the filming of this benefited the women a lot more than it benefited the men.

[1:14:38] Hayley Podschun: Yes, yeah, yeah.

[1:14:39] Nikisha Williams: I will agree with that.

[1:14:41] Kevin Jaeger: Actually, to also put in one more thing about Helpless and Satisfied, because that's my most favorite part of the show.

[1:14:47] Hayley Podschun: Oh, me too.

[1:14:48] Nikisha Williams: There's a part when they start to rewind. When I saw the show, I was like, what's happening? What's happening? Because again, with the lighting, the set design, the choreography, the direction, the sound design, everything is at its best. And what I felt like, I even turned to my mom and was like, this is my favorite part of the show. Like, get ready. I didn't see any of it on screen. And I was like, you see them rewind, but it's like this much. And I'm like, yeah, you're missing the best part. Like it's the whole stage. Like you have to see it, you have to see it move, and like everyone is moving, and then the whole, like when the girls are going in and oh my god, it's just all backwards and I'm like, you're not seeing it. So Tommy Kail had a really hard job, but yeah, I was really bummed that I, as a stage production, I was like, I want to see the stage and not the movie version of that section.

[1:15:25] Bryan Plofsky: Tommy Kail had a really hard job, like a really, really hard job, and I think that most directors of these have a really hard job. Like, what do you do? Are you making a movie? Are you trying to convey what the stage is? I mean, and then I wonder if there's a little piece of them—I don't know, this is me totally guessing—but it's also like you still want to sell tickets. Do you not show them everything? You know what I mean? Like, I wonder if there's like a bit of that, even though this is the thing that's gonna be on there in prosperity for however long they keep it up, maybe until Broadway comes back, whatever it is. But like how much do you keep, how much do you give? It's a very interesting line to kind of toggle.

[1:15:26] Nikisha Williams: Whereas if you're recording, going back though to the Newsies film, and I'm like, I watch that and I'm like, I want to go see that. Like, I'm jumping out of my seat wanting to be in that audience and feel that energy of those dancers. And I don't know if it's because I'm a theater nerd, but I'm like, I don't want you to hide anything. I want to see it, and not because, you know, speaking as someone who's, you know, not a theater person, because people are like, oh, I want to save that $400 and not see the show. It's like, great, but you see it and now you're like, maybe I want to see it because you've seen it. Does that make sense?

[1:17:13] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, absolutely.

[1:17:14] Nikisha Williams: And do you feel though, like with Helpless and Satisfied for continuity's sake that they didn't show much of the rewind because in Helpless they don't show much of what's happening, so you don't really know what's being rewound?

[1:17:27] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, that's interesting.

[1:17:28] Nikisha Williams: Do you know? Like, because there's so many close-ups on Philippa.

[1:17:32] Hayley Podschun: That's really interesting.

[1:17:33] Nikisha Williams: I never thought of it that way. I was just thinking that I knew this was supposed to be a theatrical release, so I assume they decided, nope, we're doing more movies. And so that's why I thought the claustrophobia of the filming was they weren't trying to do a live cap, they were doing a live capture of a movie version of Hamilton.

[1:17:51] Bryan Plofsky: Interesting.

[1:17:52] Nikisha Williams: So for me, that was why I excused that, is I was like, because they wanted this on a big screen, just show the open stage the way that Newsies was a live cap to be a live chat. Like, Newsies was released on certain days in theaters, but this was supposed to be like a full movie.

[1:18:08] Kevin Jaeger: So you think of that?

[1:18:11] Nikisha Williams: That's interesting.

[1:18:12] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, more film than they decided to be staying.

[1:18:15] Nikisha Williams: I think there's probably also a lot of stuff that would happen for continuity's sake because they filmed what, three performances and then did close-ups. Because there were definitely times where you could tell something was slightly off in use, like Wednesday's performance and then cut to Thursday's and they're using the audio of Friday, and they were like two seconds. God bless as a performer, if you have a better match, like use it.

[1:18:47] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, maybe they were like, listen, Renee sounded good, I'm satisfied on this night, but maybe the ensemble were not, you know, whatever. So we're just gonna zoom in on her.

[1:18:56] Hayley Podschun: Yeah. You know, like that's true.

[1:18:59] Aaron J Albano: I could feel that happening a few times because it would like cut from a close-up to a wide shot, and in the wide shot, the mouth was a little wrong.

[1:19:13] Nikisha Williams: Oh everyone looked better that day.

[1:19:17] Hayley Podschun: Um yeah, it was interesting.

[1:19:20] Aaron J Albano: It was also interesting to see because Jay brought this up while we were watching it, that some people's line reads felt really big, or just like something felt bigger than when we saw it.

[1:19:29] Hayley Podschun: And I was like, does it feel bigger because it's on film, or were they bigger because they knew they were being filmed?

[1:19:37] Aaron J Albano: I think I think that at the end of the show, I was like, I feel like it's usually like a breath.

[1:19:43] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, it's not that see like that for like she gulped that air, she was like, I would agree because that I remember seeing it and it being way more up for interpretation of what it was really amazing.

[1:20:00] Nikisha Williams: This one was just like a full play, and that was the word last breath when you're Eliza.

[1:20:09] Aaron J Albano: That's like dying.

[1:20:13] Hayley Podschun: That's all you need.

[1:20:15] Nikisha Williams: That's why Bryan was saying it's up to interpretation because even when they teach the Elizas, they're like, This is your moment. Are you going to heaven? Have you seen the light? Are you seeing Hamilton? Are you seeing the orphans? You decide and just take a breath and take it off.

[1:20:31] Hayley Podschun: Oh god, I love that.

[1:20:33] Aaron J Albano: Well, Kevin's choice.

[1:20:35] Kevin Jaeger: So actually, Kevin just saying the orphanage.

[1:20:38] Aaron J Albano: I'll say I was not a I was excited to see this.

[1:20:41] Kevin Jaeger: I was amped up, it always gets me excited. I love it.

[1:20:43] Aaron J Albano: I was not emotionally connected to this review at all.

[1:20:48] Nikisha Williams: The orphanage got me because the orphanage always gets me a little bit almost because of like an ingrained thing.

[1:20:53] Aaron J Albano: But like I had zero emotional connection to watching it.

[1:20:57] Hayley Podschun: And I 100% understand that I am and all of us are coming from a place of privilege where we have seen this live in the room where it happens.

[1:21:05] Nikisha Williams: Like you guys are in it night after night, connecting to I and I I think that the magic of Hamilton on Disney Plus is everyone gets to see it and like don't have to imagine what's happening on stage.

[1:21:19] Aaron J Albano: They can actually see what's happening on stage. I mean, despite some edits, but um I definitely did not connect to this emotionally at all.

[1:21:28] Hayley Podschun: And I'm and one, I think it's because of the I know it, it's the edit, it was nice to see it again.

[1:21:33] Kevin Jaeger: But if we once we get to the other half of it in terms of like watching in a historical context and all of that, like I had very different feelings this time than the first time I watched it on stage.

[1:21:43] Aaron J Albano: Like it's amazing what five, four degree, whatever many years can do to a piece.

[1:21:50] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, I thought you were doing the dueling countdown.

[1:21:57] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, I was opposite, Bryan.

[1:21:59] Aaron J Albano: Well, because if you look in your history books, he wasn't wearing his glasses.

[1:22:02] Hayley Podschun: So let's oh, Haley, what were you gonna say?

[1:22:09] Nikisha Williams: No, I'm just saying I I'm love that you have that, and I was opposite, like things have happened in my life.

[1:22:16] Hayley Podschun: Like I've lost someone in my family after I saw this show, and like listening to um Quiet Uptown.

[1:22:24] Aaron J Albano: Is that the actual song title?

[1:22:25] Hayley Podschun: I don't even know.

[1:22:26] Nikisha Williams: Quiet Uptown.

[1:22:27] Hayley Podschun: Oh good God.

[1:22:28] Nikisha Williams: So listening to the I like live uptown.

[1:22:31] Hayley Podschun: So like listening to that through my loss of like, I was like, what?

[1:22:37] Nikisha Williams: And I I was not okay.

[1:22:40] Hayley Podschun: So but I but I love that we all have these because that's what theater is, and that's why we need to come back.

[1:22:52] Aaron J Albano: So let's go ahead and transition into the um into watching it with the movie.

[1:22:58] Hayley Podschun: I mean, with the other movie that we saw.

[1:23:00] Nikisha Williams: I mean, let's just dive right in.

[1:23:03] Aaron J Albano: I'll start with let's go ahead and say what order you saw these movies in, and how, if at all, that might have hit how you viewed each movie.

[1:23:16] Hayley Podschun: The one thing that really hit me was I watched Hamilton first, and watching 1776, the thing that stuck out to me most about both of the movies was the character of Thomas Jefferson, and watching how he is almost villainized in one, and like heroicized.

[1:23:36] Nikisha Williams: Is that the word?

[1:23:37] Hayley Podschun: Is that a word?

[1:23:38] Aaron J Albano: Like romanticized sure.

[1:23:40] Hayley Podschun: Let's go, yeah, that that where he's the A, the same guy, B, we acknowledge that he is a slaver in both.

[1:23:48] Nikisha Williams: And yet both have very different perspectives on him.

[1:23:55] Aaron J Albano: I mean, from who lives, who dies, who tells your story. It's all about point of view.

[1:24:01] Hayley Podschun: I was gonna say, I think I I watched uh I watched Hamilton first and then 1776, and the big thing that stood out to me was the insane amount of like god hero worship in Hamilton as opposed to like the reality of humanity in 1776.

[1:24:21] Nikisha Williams: I felt like, and I think you can see that in the Jefferson character because like Hamilton chooses to make a villain out of Jefferson because he was Hamilton's opponent.

[1:24:30] Hayley Podschun: But I felt like there were a couple scenes that I was watching as a film when it's up in my face that I was actually kind of shocked at how much like worship of Hamilton as a person goes on in this show.

[1:24:43] Aaron J Albano: Um, so that kind of stood out to me, especially when I watched 1776 and then saw that I was like, oh, like John Adams is like the hero in this story, but we're seeing what's wrong with him.

[1:24:54] Nikisha Williams: And like Thomas Jefferson is like more of a hero in 1776, but like the the guy in the south calls him out as like, you have slaves.

[1:25:02] Hayley Podschun: Like don't come at me when you have slaves.

[1:25:05] Aaron J Albano: And like this show seemed like it was trying to make a lot of like gloss Hamilton sometimes glosses over the reality of what these people were.

[1:25:14] Nikisha Williams: For I think one for like the the because you can tell that Lynn read the book and was like so obsessed and moved by like Hamilton's story.

[1:25:25] Hayley Podschun: So there is like some hero worship in there, but it also felt like it was it was like to go along with like the the narrative of why he did the show the way he did the show.

[1:25:36] Aaron J Albano: It seemed like they didn't want to go too far into like the bad sides of these people because they were trying to like tell like the narrative that they wanted to tell, which I think it's a great message.

[1:25:48] Hayley Podschun: The show obviously is brilliant, but like watching these two side by side, I noticed how much less Hamilton holds these people accountable for who they really were, as much as I think 1776 does.

[1:26:00] Nikisha Williams: I had a very similar experience.

[1:26:03] Hayley Podschun: Um, 1776 made me think maybe because they were white, um, but 1776 made me grapple uh with um what what things happen to get our country with because the piece uh deals with it, um, and how disappointing and sad and horrifying and they're all calling each other out.

[1:26:27] Aaron J Albano: I definitely had more in my group that have watched all of these, I have had more conversations springing from Hamilton about like why did what's the like what, who, what, when, where, and why, historical accuracies, all that stuff.

[1:26:42] Hayley Podschun: But 1776 made me like sit down and think to myself, like, what did I learn in history class?

[1:26:48] Nikisha Williams: Did I learn that they actually were the thing they were debating was the actual slave um clause?

[1:26:54] Hayley Podschun: Like it was a very I did not expect for this to happen, like in terms of my feelings on that.

[1:27:00] Aaron J Albano: Who lives, who dies, who tells your story, the final song really hit me hard this time because I had seen 1776 first.

[1:27:09] Hayley Podschun: So I'm like, oh, Lynn told this story about Hamilton, but those guys in the 60s told this version of like the time before that, and and that's what stuck out to me the most.

[1:27:22] Nikisha Williams: What's it sorry?

[1:27:22] Aaron J Albano: Max Chernobyl, Ron Chernow.

[1:27:24] Hayley Podschun: Ron.

[1:27:25] Nikisha Williams: Ron.

[1:27:26] Hayley Podschun: I don't know why I say Max.

[1:27:27] Aaron J Albano: Ron Chernobyl, that's his version of Hamilton, and it was distilled into this version of Hamilton.

[1:27:32] Hayley Podschun: You read another book about Hamilton, you're hearing a totally different perspective.

[1:27:36] Nikisha Williams: Lynn took what he wanted from it, and I don't mean that in a bad way.

[1:27:39] Aaron J Albano: What he connected with.

[1:27:41] Hayley Podschun: The guys who wrote 1776 could have easily written a musical that had nothing to do with the slave clause.

[1:27:47] Nikisha Williams: And it was just John Adams trying to like get everyone to like sign this piece of paper.

[1:27:52] Aaron J Albano: Um that is what stuck out the most to me and to my ends are.

[1:27:57] Hayley Podschun: I think that narrative of like telling the story through the people who were oppressed at the time of this story being created, like is what makes Hamilton powerful, and it is why, like, even though like I have these issues with like some of like this the historical accuracy and why they made these changes.

[1:28:16] Nikisha Williams: I think like that message is so powerful that and the show is so brilliant in its writing that like it had it, they're both two different sides of a coin.

[1:28:24] Aaron J Albano: Like Hamilton's not trying to make you sad, it's more trying to empower people in an audience who can look on stage and be like, I've only ever heard this story told to me about a story about a bunch of white men in a room, and now I'm seeing all these people who look like me.

[1:28:38] Hayley Podschun: That's why they made those decisions.

[1:28:39] Nikisha Williams: I'm not saying that like Lynn Manuel Miranda like purposely was like, I'm just gonna worship people and make things weird.

[1:28:46] Aaron J Albano: Like it was because he was going with that narrative, so that's why that happened.

[1:28:49] Hayley Podschun: I think like the musical of 1776 coming out in the 60s with like the Vietnam War and like everything happening at that time, that's why they were like at that time more interested in like damning their the founding fathers in a way and kind of like showing the humanity and also the bicentennial was coming up, yeah.

[1:29:09] Nikisha Williams: Right.

[1:29:10] Aaron J Albano: You're right.

[1:29:11] Hayley Podschun: Wow.

[1:29:11] Nikisha Williams: Because in seven, there was also in a weird Philly side note when the bicentennial came up is when they started actually restoring all of those old buildings that had kind of gone for naught for years.

[1:29:25] Aaron J Albano: Um, so like the psyche of the country around like the bicentennial coming up is also an interesting lens to look at how that musical came about of just like gearing up to celebrate the bicentennial and coins were coming out and like all of this stuff was happening, and so like, yeah, turn to the arts to be like, yeah, but look how this started.

[1:29:48] Hayley Podschun: Like look at yourselves, everyone, while you're thinking of this.

[1:29:52] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, it's so interesting.

[1:29:54] Aaron J Albano: You guys like talking about this because it made me realize um how much I held accountable the actors and the storytelling in 1776, like when Thomas Jefferson was like doubting over like wanting his wife, and I'm thinking to myself, like in actuality, you had this slave woman, Sally Hemings that you were sleeping with and all these things, but then like looking at Hamilton and and um Mariah Reynolds, like I didn't have you know, I wasn't thinking along those lines because I guess it was like what Kevin was saying.

[1:30:24] Hayley Podschun: The point of it was just seeing diversity on stage first.

[1:30:29] Nikisha Williams: And 1776 is like we're like you all said, we're we're telling exactly what happened and how dirty and gritty it was to actually get to to where we are.

[1:30:39] Aaron J Albano: So I did subconsciously that's how I was watching them, like 1776.

[1:30:44] Hayley Podschun: I was like, all these inaccuracies and blah blah blah.

[1:30:47] Nikisha Williams: And Hamilton is just like, oh, this is entertainment.

[1:30:50] Aaron J Albano: I'm enjoying seeing myself on stage.

[1:30:52] Hayley Podschun: So it's it's really interesting.

[1:30:54] Nikisha Williams: Definitely more like historical fiction watching it like against 1776.

[1:31:00] Aaron J Albano: Yes.

[1:31:00] Hayley Podschun: I thought of it at the time when I first saw it.

[1:31:03] Nikisha Williams: I was like, oh, how interesting.

[1:31:04] Aaron J Albano: And then you go through and like reading it, you're like, oh, he then acknowledges that they had plenty of sons, the Skylers and Lightning, and like all of like that stuff.

[1:31:14] Hayley Podschun: But like sometimes you throw stuff away to make it more entertaining.

[1:31:18] Nikisha Williams: And also like have a powerful message.

[1:31:21] Aaron J Albano: Like it's not just this fun happy go lucky show.

[1:31:26] Hayley Podschun: There is still something like very important.

[1:31:28] Nikisha Williams: Like obviously, it's what order did you watch then?

[1:31:32] Aaron J Albano: Is what we learned from these two shows.

[1:31:34] Hayley Podschun: Yeah.

[1:31:35] Nikisha Williams: You can go sort of like literal, but also like skewed to the left, if you might say.

[1:31:45] Aaron J Albano: And go like true, like historical fiction and really get into like let's take all the liberties we want, but still make you feel how you want we want you to feel at the end of the show.

[1:31:56] Hayley Podschun: Not like you went to a lecture that had some songs.

[1:32:01] Aaron J Albano: Right.

[1:32:01] Kimberly Cooper: Kimberly, what order did you want to watch them in?

[1:32:03] Hayley Podschun: Hamilton first.

[1:32:05] Nikisha Williams: Hamilton first.

[1:32:09] Hayley Podschun: I did 1776, like an hour and a half first. Then I did Hamilton.

[1:32:14] Bryan Plofsky: Oh wow.

[1:32:18] Hayley Podschun: I couldn't, you guys, I can't. I don't like school. Like, I don't like learning.

[1:32:25] Nikisha Williams: I agree.

[1:32:26] Hayley Podschun: I can't. And then I finished it this afternoon while I was making masks.

[1:32:32] Nikisha Williams: I do want to throw the quick out that there have actually been articles written in the past few days since Hamilton came up.

[1:32:40] Hayley Podschun: No, specifically about uh uh what's his name?

[1:32:40] Nikisha Williams: Uh what's his name spitting?

[1:32:47] Hayley Podschun: Oh Jonathan Groff.

[1:32:49] Nikisha Williams: Oh, Groff. He's always been a spitter though.

[1:32:51] Hayley Podschun: He was just I mean like, there's now articles like in Vulture and like all these other like magazines and publications are writing articles specifically about how much he spits in this movie. I was my best friend—

[1:32:51] Nikisha Williams: No go for it sorry.

[1:32:51] Hayley Podschun: My best friend from high school we saw Spring Awakening together on stage and she texted me after she saw this and she was like so he hasn't figured that out yet huh?

[1:32:51] Nikisha Williams: Yeah it's a thing.

[1:32:51] Hayley Podschun: It's like it's a well-known thing. Well, thing that's flash zone is real. The filmed parts of the King George stuff in this are excellent. I'm so jealous that people got to watch this again for the first time. Like not again, like hearing it and then all of a sudden like I can't even imagine what that little kid or that 15-year-old or that 45-year-old or that 70-year-old who lives in X, Y, and Z have been listening to the album for years and they got to see it for seven, nine, $6.99, seven dollars. Like what an amazing thing that Lin and the company did to like release it now. Like I mean just there was so much hope wrapped up in it regardless of like how you interpret it or whatnot. Like there was so much hope wrapped up in it.

[1:32:51] Nikisha Williams: And not even from the themes within the show itself but just the gesture that like Lin and company, whether however the decision came about, like just the gesture of giving it to during this time was just like so much bigger than the piece itself if that makes sense. That really affected me a lot just like here you go everyone.

[1:32:51] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, I did also have the feeling like halfway through, I was like, oh no, this is the only production of Hamilton anyone can see right now.

[1:34:41] Nikisha Williams: Yeah.

[1:34:41] Hayley Podschun: Because usually, like if I watch a live gap or something and I start it at eight, I'm like, and people around the world are sitting in the theater watching it right now.

[1:34:48] Nikisha Williams: And it was this weird, bittersweet thing to be like, oh no, those people are also sitting at home watching.

[1:34:54] Hayley Podschun: Yeah, where you're no, and the best, oh yeah.

[1:34:57] Nikisha Williams: Well, I mean the very part was also one of my really good friends who is a very active racial justice activist reached out to me. She had never seen Hamilton before, and she was like, yo, Hamilton's great. Like, I didn't realize how much I needed to hear black and brown people singing about freedom.

[1:35:22] Hayley Podschun: And like, and she was just like, this is hitting way harder than I ever expected it to hear. Even just the simple act of a representation, just hearing these voices speak these words.

[1:35:38] Nikisha Williams: I forgot oftentimes being in the show, I was texting Nikisha about this. I was like, oftentimes it's easy to forget that that in itself is revolutionary.

[1:35:49] Hayley Podschun: And I'll tell you, the ensemble is the magic of the show, in my personal opinion.

[1:35:54] Nikisha Williams: Yep.

[1:35:54] Hayley Podschun: I walked away from the set like, oh, the show, the show is the ensemble.

[1:35:59] Nikisha Williams: Speaking of that, how awesome was it that every, I think Ensemblist tweeted this, that every ensemble member got their own title card, like like end of Lord of the Rings.

[1:36:10] Hayley Podschun: Yeah.

[1:36:10] Nikisha Williams: Like I expect and he has like may it be playing.

[1:36:14] Hayley Podschun: So uh even though this came out five minutes ago, there is a Rotten Tomatoes.

[1:36:18] Nikisha Williams: So there is a critic census.

[1:36:22] Hayley Podschun: So let's go around. Uh let's start with Bryan.

[1:36:26] Bryan Plofsky: I can't imagine it not being 99 or 90. I'm gonna go with 99%.

[1:36:34] Hayley Podschun: 96.

[1:36:36] Nikisha Williams: I was gonna say 98.

[1:36:38] Kevin Jaeger: Uh, Kevin.

[1:36:39] Kevin Jaeger: 91.

[1:36:40] Hayley Podschun: Kimberly?

[1:36:41] Kimberly Cooper: 92.

[1:36:43] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, rude.

[1:36:44] Hayley Podschun: Bryan wins with 99.

[1:36:46] Nikisha Williams: The critics consensus?

[1:36:48] Hayley Podschun: The critics consensus, get this. The critics' consensus is look around, look around at how beautifully Hamilton shines beyond Broadway, and at how marvelous Thomas Kail captures the stage show's infectious energy.

[1:37:02] Nikisha Williams: Separately, it does bring up the question of moving forward. How do unions make contracts that will allow for this?

[1:37:13] Hayley Podschun: Like you can't just release the library stuff because there's so much that goes into that. But like now that people have had a taste of something, like how do you fulfill that need depending on what the world situation is?

[1:37:27] Nikisha Williams: Because well, you don't it I we all agree that it does not capture the magic of live theater, but it gets really freaking close.

[1:37:34] Hayley Podschun: Um but like you know, unions might have to start to redo contracts for live caps, and like live caps might have to be like a more viable option, not just for a show closes and then you put it on Broadway HD, but it had to recoup first.

[1:37:49] Nikisha Williams: You know, like it's gotta be. I'm very interested to see um the future of this business model.

[1:37:57] Hayley Podschun: You do.

[1:37:58] Nikisha Williams: Yeah.

[1:37:59] Hayley Podschun: Should we rank them?

[1:38:06] Kevin Jaeger: Why Kevin, do you like 1776 better? Like but I wouldn't hear everybody's thoughts. Kevin, you suggested it. You should go first.

[1:38:15] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. Okay. Um I'm gonna say 1776 is number one, just because it means a lot to my family and is something I've known since a little kid. Um and then Hamilton is a very close second because it's a obviously a brilliant show.

[1:38:31] Nikisha Williams: They're in two different worlds to me.

[1:38:34] Kevin Jaeger: They are.

[1:38:34] Nikisha Williams: I can't rank one over the other because their thesis statements are different, are wildly different. So and they're both equally important for that.

[1:38:45] Kevin Jaeger: So I don't you make me rank it and then all of you.

[1:38:49] Nikisha Williams: I'm sorry, I can't. I don't think I can't, they're different meetings.

[1:38:52] Hayley Podschun: So yes, so it did happen.

[1:38:55] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, it didn't happen once, but and it's happening now because no one else is going.

[1:39:00] Hayley Podschun: Well, I mean Hamilton, well, Hamilton obviously holds a special place in my heart, but that doesn't negate how much I enjoyed 1776.

[1:39:09] Kevin Jaeger: So it I guess I have to choose it would be Hamilton and then 1776.

[1:39:15] Hayley Podschun: Haley?

[1:39:16] Nikisha Williams: Yeah, Haley?

[1:39:17] Kevin Jaeger: No, we know Haley's What do you mean?

[1:39:21] Hayley Podschun: Um I paid attention to Hamilton.

[1:39:27] Nikisha Williams: So I'm gonna say she's ranking it in terms of finished and not finished.

[1:39:35] Hayley Podschun: I did finish 1776. Did I pay attention to it? Um, so I'm gonna say, although I do have to say, Kevin, I love that you guys have this um tradition of watching it on the 4th of July.

[1:39:52] Hayley Podschun: Like that makes my heart so very happy. Now it makes me want to watch it again and actually watch it. Um so I would say Hamilton and 1776.

[1:40:05] Nikisha Williams: I said I actually knew William Daniels as John Adams before Miss Feeney.

[1:40:10] Hayley Podschun: Oh I was like, what is John Adams doing in this show on ABC?

[1:40:15] Nikisha Williams: Wait, that's so funny.

[1:40:17] Hayley Podschun: Very fun and sweet. He was always Kit on Knight Rider.

[1:40:21] Nikisha Williams: I feel I'm gonna rank him, don't worry.

[1:40:24] Hayley Podschun: But I feel very similar to Nikisha in that like I say, I said it once, I'll say it again. The who lives, who dies, who tells your story, like really affected me during this because they are so they're just told by different people from different points of view.

[1:40:39] Nikisha Williams: Um I'm gonna say, I'm going to say that Hamilton edges out 1776, truthfully only because I got to watch people watch it for the first time.

[1:40:53] Hayley Podschun: And like that experience was very special. Um, where like I didn't have to like, I was very you know me. I didn't talk, I paid attention, like that's there was no like all that, but like to just like feel the energy from people who get to see it for the first time was like incredibly special.

[1:41:12] Nikisha Williams: Um, but I will say that 1776 surprised me.

[1:41:16] Hayley Podschun: Um it exceeded all expectations, and it has me thinking more about history and how it's taught and like and and all of that even more than Hamilton did when it came out.

[1:41:29] Nikisha Williams: Um and that goes a long way, but the watching people watch Hamilton, I love musicals. Watching people watch Hamilton for the first time was like so freaking cool.

[1:41:39] Bryan Plofsky: Me, um Hamilton.

[1:41:43] Hayley Podschun: 1776.

[1:41:45] Nikisha Williams: I mean, and again, 1776 is fantastic, and especially after this conversation.

[1:41:49] Aaron J Albano: Oh, Aaron, just own it. I had to just give my ranking, and all of you are giving your like no, no, no.

[1:41:56] Kevin Jaeger: You said you give your whole thing about nostalgia reasons.

[1:42:01] Aaron J Albano: Yeah. Uh-huh. True.

[1:42:06] Kevin Jaeger: And this was your game. You wanted to do this.

[1:42:09] Aaron J Albano: I wanted to see if anybody else was on my team.

[1:42:12] Kevin Jaeger: I guess not.

[1:42:13] Aaron J Albano: I mean, I was close.

[1:42:15] Kevin Jaeger: I was close, but I was not close.

[1:42:18] Aaron J Albano: I was almost on your mind, but I was so close, Kevin.

[1:42:26] Hayley Podschun: And I will say I do love like do like 1776 for all the visceral reasons that it like affected me.

[1:42:33] Aaron J Albano: But Hamilton the same reason, Nikisha, like it holds a special place in my heart now.

[1:42:38] Hayley Podschun: I have I've had to invest for two years. That investment holds a lot of weight.

[1:42:42] Nikisha Williams: Absolutely.

[1:42:43] Hayley Podschun: Yeah.

[1:42:45] Nikisha Williams: Really?

[1:42:46] Hayley Podschun: Well, I agree with Haley. I paid attention to Hamilton.

[1:42:51] Nikisha Williams: I like 1776, but it got to a point where they were just still talking, and I was like, where's the song?

[1:42:56] Hayley Podschun: Where's the song? The middle of that movie is tough.

[1:42:59] Nikisha Williams: That's definitely true.

[1:43:00] Hayley Podschun: In a time when I wasn't feeling very patriotic, these were two really good things to watch.

[1:43:05] All: Yes.

[1:43:06] Hayley Podschun: Yes. Agreed wholeheartedly.

[1:43:08] Bryan Plofsky: Um, you know, because we've got laughs coast to coast to make you smile. A real life look at each of you to capture all that style. You're the red, white, and blue.

[1:43:17] All: Oh, the funny things you do. America, America, this is you.

[1:43:22] Hayley Podschun: Stories from your friends next door. They never told you might be a star tonight. So let the camera roll.

[1:43:27] All: You're the red, white, and blue. Oh, the funny things you do. America, America, this is you.

[1:43:33] Bryan Plofsky: Ladies and gentlemen, Bob Saget.

[1:43:36] Nikisha Williams: Bob Saget.

[1:43:38] All: America. America. This is you.

[1:43:41] Bryan Plofsky: That was the America's Funniest Home Videos.

[1:43:48] Hayley Podschun: So that was our quote. The uh lyrics of America's Funniest Home Videos.

[1:43:53] Aaron J Albano: Um these were both great movies. Like we didn't have a dud this week.

[1:43:57] All: Yeah.

[1:43:58] Bryan Plofsky: No, that was nice.

[1:44:02] Hayley Podschun: Um on that note, um, thank you all so much for joining us.

[1:44:09] Bryan Plofsky: Um if you were listening on the podcast, um, we edited down a little bit. Um on Patreon, you got the full thing and the video.

[1:44:18] Hayley Podschun: Um, but um again, you can follow us all at um at Broadwaysted. You can uh find us on Instagram, Twitter, you can find join our Facebook group.

[1:44:27] Kevin Jaeger: Um, we're doing some 30 therapy stuff there.

[1:44:29] Hayley Podschun: Um, and of course, um uh you can find us on Spotify, iTunes, rate and review us there. Five stars.

[1:44:40] Bryan Plofsky: And thank you. Uh again, another shout out to Buttonwood Grove Winery. If you're ever up around the Finger Lakes, check it out.

[1:44:47] All: Um, but uh we'll end every episode uh by raising our glasses, and we say zoo doers.

[1:44:58] All: Thanks, everybody.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred