Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 291: Jay Armstrong Johnson gets Broadwaysted!

Welcome to Season 2 of Broadwaysted! "I got a little Broadwaysted one night and starting dreaming a little bigger..." Play along as Jay Armstrong Johnson (@jay_a_johnson - On The Town, Phantom of the Opera, Hands on a Hard Body) returns to join Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for beer, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and wine... Read More

From the show: Broadwaysted!

51 mins
8/24/21

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Welcome to Season 2 of Broadwaysted!

"I got a little Broadwaysted one night and starting dreaming a little bigger..."

Play along as Jay Armstrong Johnson (@jay_a_johnson - On The Town, Phantom of the Opera, Hands on a Hard Body) returns to join Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for beer, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and wine.

Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG

Check out Jay's Feinstein's/54 Below Birthday Show: Stream | Live

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Bryan Plofsky: Did you bring wine?

[0:05] Kevin Jaeger: I got the glasses.

[0:06] Kimberly Cooper: Hey guys, I made a quiz.

[0:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I didn't bring anything, but I'm here to have fun.

[0:20] Bryan Plofsky: Hello, and welcome to the official Broadwaysted podcast where we're drunk on theater.

[0:26] Bryan Plofsky: I'm your host, Bryan Plofsky, and T for two is two and four.

[0:30] Bryan Plofsky: Listen, if we're going two by two to Two Heads Park, then two Kingsman is all I need to match with two ladies.

[0:38] Bryan Plofsky: D Lady D.

[0:39] Bryan Plofsky: The two Musketeers have two little words for you.

[0:43] Bryan Plofsky: Two people in love.

[0:44] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, I mean two sleepy people.

[0:46] Bryan Plofsky: I mean, uh, two-player game.

[0:48] Bryan Plofsky: I mean, I mean two a day.

[0:49] Bryan Plofsky: I mean us two chitty prayer.

[0:52] Bryan Plofsky: No, I mean two worlds.

[0:54] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[0:55] Bryan Plofsky: That'll do.

[0:56] Bryan Plofsky: I mean, you've got to pick a pocket or two.

[0:58] Bryan Plofsky: Joining us today are the usual two lost souls, aka two nobodies in New York, including Kevin, torn between two lovers, Jaeger.

[1:08] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, it's such a hard place to be, and I'm always there.

[1:11] Bryan Plofsky: Kimberly, our act two finale game master and unofficial babysitter for the hour.

[1:17] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, yeah, okay.

[1:19] Bryan Plofsky: And with us is a returning guest who we dearly love to help us kick off season two of Broadwaysted.

[1:28] Bryan Plofsky: Was season one five years?

[1:30] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.

[1:31] Bryan Plofsky: Is season two not five years?

[1:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't know.

[1:34] Bryan Plofsky: We'll see.

[1:35] Bryan Plofsky: Um, well, you've had a break.

[1:37] Bryan Plofsky: We've had a break, but now we bring you one of the favorites.

[1:40] Bryan Plofsky: You may know him from some of his highlights like Hair, Phantom of the Opera, On the Town, Catch Me If You Can, A Chorus Line, Scotland PA, and his incredible Halloween specials.

[1:50] Bryan Plofsky: Let's give a big Broadwaysted welcome to Friend of the Show, Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[2:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What's up, you wasted weirdos?

[2:04] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[2:05] Kevin Jaeger: Welcome.

[2:06] Kimberly Cooper: Cheers.

[2:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, cheers.

[2:08] Bryan Plofsky: Clinkies, clinkies.

[2:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I forgot how.

[2:13] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, right.

[2:14] Bryan Plofsky: Um, well, welcome to season two of Broadwaysted.

[2:18] Bryan Plofsky: We are so happy to have you kick off this season of Broadwaysted.

[2:22] Bryan Plofsky: This is gonna be super fun.

[2:23] Bryan Plofsky: Um, we love you.

[2:25] Bryan Plofsky: We know that our listeners love you, and I know we have a lot to talk about.

[2:29] Bryan Plofsky: So let's just get started with what are you drinking?

[2:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What are we drinking?

[2:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am drinking Maker's Mark on the rocks.

[2:39] Bryan Plofsky: Beautiful, wonderful, beautiful, delicious, delicious.

[2:44] Bryan Plofsky: Kevin, what are you drinking?

[2:45] Kevin Jaeger: I am drinking a Pinot Noir because my wine-loving dad texted and said that today, the day we're recording, is actually Nashville Pinot Noir Day.

[2:55] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, Pinot Noir, had just some sticking with the theme.

[3:00] Bryan Plofsky: Beautiful.

[3:01] Bryan Plofsky: Kimberly, what are you sipping on?

[3:04] Kimberly Cooper: I have some Hudson baby bourbon.

[3:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, so good.

[3:09] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, beautiful.

[3:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm uh I'm trying to keep summer going.

[3:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I have a Shipyard Brewing Company's summer ale.

[3:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, straight from Maine.

[3:19] Bryan Plofsky: So good.

[3:21] Kevin Jaeger: Delish.

[3:22] Kimberly Cooper: I love Shipyard.

[3:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Me too.

[3:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Their pumpkin head, if we're talking about like the fall as well, their pumpkin head is delicious, is why we really enjoy that.

[3:30] Bryan Plofsky: Um, but here we are.

[3:31] Bryan Plofsky: We're talking to Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[3:34] Bryan Plofsky: How have you been?

[3:35] Bryan Plofsky: What's new?

[3:36] Bryan Plofsky: You know, I think the last time we talked to you was last Halloween.

[3:40] Bryan Plofsky: Um, I know you have your birthday and a show coming up.

[3:44] Bryan Plofsky: There's so much to talk about, but um, I mean, how have you been?

[3:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I've been good.

[3:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I've kind of been traveling a lot this summer, which has been fun and exciting.

[3:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I went out to LA for all of May um because Todrick Hall invited me to come be a producer on a few of his new music videos in conjunction with his latest album that he dropped called Femulin. Stream it wherever you can hear music now.

[4:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's a really incredible, very queer album.

[4:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and we shot some really awesome music videos.

[4:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So um, I learned a lot and worked really hard with him out there.

[4:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and then I went to Texas for all of June to direct a new musical theater camp with my best friend Amanda Williams Ware, who's also one of my Sanderson sisters in my Halloween show.

[4:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, but that was a blast as well um to kind of lead a theater camp.

[4:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I hadn't been to theater camp since I was like 15 years old.

[4:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So leading up there, leading the pack was really awesome.

[4:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I took all of my knowledge that I've gleaned from all of my music video making over the last year, and we made it like a really cool um multi-dimensional camp.

[4:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So it wasn't just about singing and acting and dancing for the stage.

[4:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We also taught acting for the camera and we shot camp-wide music videos, which made the kids feel really cool and gave them like the tools that they needed to know about what it means to be on a set.

[5:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so that was really fun.

[5:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There's a lot of kids in Texas who are now like, "This one time at theater camp."

[5:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Exactly.

[5:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Exactly.

[5:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, but I've mostly been teaching.

[5:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I have some private acting students that I see on Zoom um every week.

[5:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and I got two new baby kitties um a few months ago.

[5:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, that has been fun being a new cat dad.

[5:32] Bryan Plofsky: What are their names?

[5:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Barnaby and Gus.

[5:36] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.

[5:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's literally perfect.

[5:40] Kimberly Cooper: I love it.

[5:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They're cuties.

[5:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We rescued them from Puppy Kitty NYC, which is an awesome rescue organization here in New York.

[5:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and they just got neutered a couple of days ago.

[5:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so you might be able to hear them yowling in the background as they hate these cones that have been put into little straight jackets.

[6:00] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, little kitty straight jackets.

[6:02] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[6:05] Bryan Plofsky: Um, you said you were back in Texas, like doing theater camp.

[6:09] Bryan Plofsky: Like, what did you learn from the kids?

[6:11] Bryan Plofsky: What did you hope to instill and imbue on the kids in terms of like the lessons that you've learned, especially growing up in Texas and coming out to the— and this may roll into your cabaret or show, but like I don't know, like what when somebody goes to a camp that you are running, a theater camp that you are running, what do you want them to take from it?

[6:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, what was really cool is the kind of um diversity that our camp had in terms of gender representation.

[6:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We had one kid um come out to us as trans in the middle of camp and um he cut his hair off like a couple days into camp and he was really nervous about it, but we made sure to lead with introducing ourselves with our pronouns, and so we had our— we had our finger on the pulse in terms of what it meant to know that we had some kids that felt the need to really be accepted, and that's kind of how I found and loved theater was that I found a community of people that loved me and accepted me and lifted me up, even for my weird theater love.

[7:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, so that was something that was really kind of cool, and I learned a lot.

[7:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: These kids these days, they're so modern, honey.

[7:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, it's wild um how much they taught me about acceptance and how um comfortable they feel in their skin, and we really hoped to give them that space um to feel accepted, like I felt when I was at that same theater camp.

[7:40] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.

[7:40] Kimberly Cooper: So that was cool.

[7:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, another thing that we really focused on as a team was this idea of like mindfulness.

[7:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I think when we were growing up learning theater, it was like eat nails, like go, go, go, don't rest until it's perfect.

[7:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And you know, after being in a few Broadway shows and figuring out what it is to do an eight-show week and how kind of grueling and taxing it is on the mind and the body and the spirit, like it's work that we really wanted to teach the kids um what it means to practice mindfulness just as important as practicing your acting or your singing or your dancing.

[8:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So that you know, if and when they choose to make the arts their career, that they have that as a part of their foundation to move forward because I feel like if we would have had more of that, maybe we wouldn't have, I don't know, um, fallen down a few times along the path.

[8:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, but you know, hindsight's 20/20.

[8:38] Kimberly Cooper: That's beautiful.

[8:38] Kimberly Cooper: That sounded like a lot of fun.

[8:40] Kimberly Cooper: That was very cool.

[8:41] Kimberly Cooper: Do you find that the kids are like— like how you said you introduced it, like acting on film?

[8:47] Kimberly Cooper: Do you find that these kids nowadays are more comfortable being in front of the camera because of their like social media and like filming like their lives with their phones?

[8:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Or do you think it's just as jarring to be in front of a camera as an actor no matter what?

[9:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, I think it kind of depended on the kid.

[9:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There were some kids that like thrived in that environment and were super, super excited.

[9:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And there were some kids that just refused to get behind that camera.

[9:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So they were kind of just watching from the outside, or you know, maybe were in the back doing a little dance during one of our music video shoots.

[9:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But yeah, I do think that kids gravitate toward what it means to be on camera just because of social media and because of the kind of, I don't know, overload of media that is out there, especially video content with TikTok and Instagram.

[9:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so um, I don't know.

[9:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think that that's just kind of where our industry is going with Broadway HD and the filming of Broadway shows being streamed on platforms.

[9:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so we're just trying to, you know, keep up with the Joneses, as Mark Fisher likes to say.

[9:49] Bryan Plofsky: So um, so you were in Texas, and your show coming up to celebrate your birthday, um, is that's uh uh 54 Below.

[10:00] Bryan Plofsky: Um, and you can get tickets online, go to 54below.com.

[10:03] Bryan Plofsky: You can also— it's also streaming at the same time, which is super, super cool.

[10:07] Bryan Plofsky: So you can actually buy tickets to just have access to stream it, so making it super accessible for anyone who does want to see it.

[10:13] Bryan Plofsky: But um, I know that it relates a lot to your roots, how country music influenced you growing up in Texas.

[10:20] Bryan Plofsky: Um, talk a little bit about your show and kind of how you conceived it.

[10:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, I mean, my first solo show at 54 Below was like a musical potpourri.

[10:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was like I wanted to kind of showcase all of my music loves, which is like, you know, Whoopi Goldberg's monologue in Sister Act 2, where it's like eclectic.

[10:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love rock and roll, rap, jazz.

[10:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, that was kind of my first foray into what it means to put on like a solo show.

[10:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So now I am kind of wanting to take a deep dive into each genre that I love so much.

[10:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And since country was kind of the music I was born into, um, it felt like the right place to start.

[11:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I've been pretty nostalgic with country music lately, uh, especially during the pandemic.

[11:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I've been listening to a lot of music.

[11:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I turned on like a 90s country music Spotify playlist, and it was wild that I think I knew every single word to every single song.

[11:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because that's what I grew up in.

[11:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I'm excited to revisit that music that I know and love and that I always heard on the radio every single waking hour of every single waking day and loving Country Music Television.

[11:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And you know, I mean, it's just who I was growing up, really.

[11:35] Kimberly Cooper: That's awesome.

[11:36] Kimberly Cooper: Um, do you have any sneak peeks of some— somebody that's gonna be at your show or shoot people or songs or anything?

[11:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Will, um, I would— I would my girls, my um, my two best friends, my favorite singers on the planet, Amanda Williams Ware and Allison Robinson will be there.

[11:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They're Texas girls themselves.

[11:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We grew up doing theater together.

[11:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They're my Sanderson Sisters every year for my Halloween show.

[12:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So they will be there alongside of me singing backup and taking some solos as well.

[12:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So they will absolutely be a part of it.

[12:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, Will Van Dyke is my music director.

[12:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's currently music directing um and Grammy nominated for Little Shop of Horrors off-Broadway.

[12:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yeah.

[12:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And he has an incredible career that spans from Kinky Boots to Rent to Pretty Woman.

[12:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, he's unbelievable and he's creating all of my um musical arrangements.

[12:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and I'm currently looking for a possible um guest artist to join me on a Reba McEntire song.

[12:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So if I find the right artist, then I think that um we'll execute that song.

[12:45] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, so that's that's September 1st at 54 Below. It's at 9:45 p.m. You can go in person or you can stream it through 54below.com, check out all the information is there, and I'm sure that you can follow Jay on Instagram and all of his social media to get a little bit more.

[13:06] Kevin Jaeger: Um, but you did mention that you traveled a lot this summer, but there's a place where we haven't gone to in quite a while, and I think we should go there. Tuesdays in the corner with Kevin.

[13:22] Kevin Jaeger: It's Kevin's corner. Welcome to Kevin's Corner, Jay.

[13:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, thank you, Kevin.

[13:27] Kevin Jaeger: No one's been here in a long time. It's a little dusty. I try to do my best, but then I put out new doilies.

[13:33] Kevin Jaeger: So good to go there. Um, so today I wanted to play a fun game because your name is Jay, which is also, wait for it, a letter.

[13:43] Kevin Jaeger: So if it's a letter and a name, I'm gonna ask you a series of normal interview questions, but you have to answer every question with your answer, it has to be from the letter, like starting with the letter J.

[13:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, Jesus.

[13:56] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, that's a good one already. Well, I would say, well, Jay, so nice to be sitting with you today for this interview of very important questions.

[14:09] Kevin Jaeger: And the first question I have to ask you is what is your favorite food?

[14:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Jelly, actually. Um, if I was being specific, it would be raspberry jelly. I know that that doesn't start with the J, but at least it's jelly.

[14:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: In the encyclopedia, it'd be jelly, comma raspberry.

[14:28] Kevin Jaeger: Right.

[14:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There you go. And who is your favorite pop singer?

[14:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Jesse J, of course. She's simply the best, and that's a double J baby.

[14:46] Kevin Jaeger: And what do you think is the perfect song to sing to someone as a lullaby at night?

[15:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Jack be nimble, Jack be quick, the musical song. It was definitely such a music sometime.

[15:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I will look it up.

[15:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Jack Be Nimble, Jack Be Quick. That's a great song.

[15:13] Kevin Jaeger: That's a great song.

[15:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I look it up on Spotify.

[15:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I really love it. I don't know if it's actually on Spotify.

[15:21] Kevin Jaeger: I bet it is somewhere. There are nursery rhymes.

[15:24] Kevin Jaeger: And what is your favorite animated film?

[15:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Jurassic Park is not an anime from Juno is not an anime from y'all know one.

[15:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Are y'all like saying why can't he think about the I can't think of any.

[15:47] Kevin Jaeger: So Gavin, did you have examples in mine?

[15:50] Kevin Jaeger: Technically, Jumanji does have animation in it, but it's not an animated film.

[15:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just around the riverbed, and that's pronounced.

[16:00] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, I can only think of one.

[16:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, well, can you give me a hints, Kim?

[16:05] Kimberly Cooper: Well, I wonder if your favorite might be Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius.

[16:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, very good. That's actually very, very good.

[16:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a really, really good one. What other one?

[16:14] Kevin Jaeger: I think we'll take that one. That works.

[16:16] Kevin Jaeger: Do you have any others, Kevin?

[16:18] Kevin Jaeger: No, of course not. This isn't my interview.

[16:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, great. Just set me up for failure.

[16:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I just picked things that would be funny to ask you, and maybe you would come up with something that I didn't know.

[16:29] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, great. What now?

[16:31] Kevin Jaeger: I know you're a dancer. You're quite the dancer, actually.

[16:34] Kevin Jaeger: The first time I ever encountered you on the stage, I saw you in a show called On the Town.

[16:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yes.

[16:40] Kevin Jaeger: And you were quite the dancer. So what is your favorite dance move?

[16:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's a jet, of course. It's spelled J-E-T-E with a con assento and la the second E.

[16:52] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.

[16:53] Kevin Jaeger: And if you didn't, if you couldn't pick Jete, what would you pick as your second favorite dance move?

[16:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The jiggle.

[17:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I love the jiggle.

[17:08] Kevin Jaeger: I love that.

[17:27] Kevin Jaeger: And what is your favorite drink at the end of the night?

[17:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Jumba juice.

[17:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: My kitchen is a jumba juice, just so you know.

[17:26] Kevin Jaeger: Really good double one.

[17:27] Kevin Jaeger: And what is your favorite country song that you're not singing at your concert?

[17:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: How dare you?

[17:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, Jingle Bells as performed by Dolly Parton.

[17:46] Kevin Jaeger: This is why won't you be singing that in September?

[17:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, that was good. See, I thought I was setting you up for Jesus Take the Wheel, but Jingle Bells by Dolly Parton was way better.

[17:59] Kevin Jaeger: See, Jesus Take the Wheel is actually a very good song.

[18:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So speaking of country music, because I'm from Florida, so like I grew up like I love me some country music too.

[18:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, especially the like pop country, like the like Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, like that kind of era of country.

[18:17] Kimberly Cooper: Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

[18:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know for a lot of people who are not from where we grew up, they get this like weird nose upturned at country music sometimes.

[18:26] Kevin Jaeger: So, what would you say to like all a lot of your fans who love you and want to see you, but we're like a country concert?

[18:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like, what do you think that your show is bringing that like I love how you said a country concert with a twang to it?

[18:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I would say that there's so many tunes out there in the world that started out as country tunes, but because they're so great melodically and lyrically that they became pop tunes that you might not know.

[18:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That I Will Always Love You by Dolly Parton is actually the song that Whitney Houston sang, or that I Swear was also done by John Michael Montgomery as well as Boyz II Men.

[19:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so, you know, it's actually a genre that does like translate very easily because of the chord progression and because of the lyricism of it, it's storytelling.

[19:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I think that's why I'm kind of drawn to country music as well as theater, because just the storytelling that happens in those songs are so darn good that a lot of times, you know, even some Beyoncé songs are like have like five lyrics in them, and you're like, okay, well, this isn't really a story, it's just a good beat with five words, right?

[19:38] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, as opposed to like my mom.

[19:40] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, sorry. I was gonna say my mom went through a country phase when I was young, and I remember like really enjoying it because I was like, they tell a story like Broadway.

[19:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Right.

[19:49] Kimberly Cooper: And it was just like Amy Grant and Show Tunes on the way to school.

[19:53] Kimberly Cooper: Like I keep wondering why Broadway hasn't seen like a country jukebox musical yet.

[19:58] Kimberly Cooper: And I feel like they're so right for it.

[20:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it's I know they're like story songs, like they're like great, like little soliloquies moments.

[20:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like you take a song from Ederson Drive talking about like the guy he met on the bridge who like changed his life so he didn't kill himself.

[20:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like it's just like wait, what isn't there a Dixie Chicks musical coming out or Goodbye Earl? Am I making that up? Did I envision that in my mind?

[20:25] Kimberly Cooper: Oh well, they're called the Chicks now, Kimberly.

[20:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: True, sorry.

[20:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But what's what's crazy is that my friend Chastin Harman, who is one of the swings on Hair with me, we would sit backstage at Hair and we would like dream up the Dixie Chicks musical.

[20:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She had this like idea in her head that was freaking genius about actually taking the Chicks' music and putting it into a musical.

[20:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I hope you're right, Kimberly. I'm not sure.

[20:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think you are.

[20:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I don't know if it's a jukebox musical or if they're writing something specifically for a musical, but I absolutely remember reading something to that effect.

[20:57] Kimberly Cooper: Wow.

[20:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And a while ago, there's a workshop of a country jukebox musical called Fancy.

[21:03] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.

[21:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: With the song Fancy.

[21:05] Kevin Jaeger: I do remember that one.

[21:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I remember it all very well.

[21:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Looking back, it was the summer I turned 18.

[21:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Actually, we lived in a one-room rundown shack on the outskirts of New Orleans.

[21:18] Kevin Jaeger: I can't tell if you want to stop me, I promise.

[21:21] Kevin Jaeger: Will we be hearing that on September 1st?

[21:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: As a white, as a white Jewish boy from New North Jersey, New York area, this is all just like a foreign language to me.

[21:35] Kevin Jaeger: Well, baby, get on, but we're going to be a good one.

[21:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm gonna have to stream it on September 1st.

[21:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You sure will, honey.

[21:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm actually super excited that they're streaming it because most of my friends and family from Texas can't actually make it up to New York for this show, which makes me super sad.

[21:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But when they actually reached out to me for a live stream, which they don't do too often for their shows there, um, it really made me happy because then I was able to reach out to my family and be like, guess what?

[22:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You only have to pay $15 and you could just sit on your couch.

[22:08] Kevin Jaeger: That's so fun.

[22:09] Kevin Jaeger: That's cool.

[22:10] Kevin Jaeger: I would have killed for like concerts to be live streamed, like Broadway concerts to be live streamed when I was in like college and high school.

[22:17] Kevin Jaeger: Like I talk all the time about my obsession with our early 2000s YouTube for like Broadway concerts.

[22:22] Kevin Jaeger: But if I could have just like sat in my dorm and watched them live, oh every day, every day of the week.

[22:28] Kimberly Cooper: Are you talking about the concert with Jay?

[22:29] Kevin Jaeger: When Jay had the big pro to leave Ruger Wild.

[22:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Actually, what's funny is my friend Morgan Carr, who's actually just blown up in the last couple of weeks or so because he has that new single with Sara Bareilles.

[22:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, we've been talking on the internet, and he's reminding me of the concerts that we did back in like 2009, 2010.

[22:51] Kevin Jaeger: Did you do halfway together? Was that the two of you?

[22:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, totally.

[22:55] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And then we so we have a picture of the thumbnail.

[22:59] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, yeah, he's got that crazy high voice.

[23:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Doing this somewhere in a quiet little name.

[23:06] Kevin Jaeger: Two strangers.

[23:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[23:07] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.

[23:07] Kevin Jaeger: Should we play a game?

[23:09] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.

[23:10] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, sure. We haven't done that in a while.

[23:13] Kevin Jaeger: I'm trying to figure out how to pitch this game with people who don't know what I do all day.

[23:17] Kevin Jaeger: Um, but as Jay and I ran into each other the other day, and I was like, oh, a social interaction with people that are adults.

[23:23] Kevin Jaeger: Um, because I spend my days in a children's dance studio.

[23:28] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, and so we have a game that's just entitled Country Song title or quote from a child at work.

[23:39] Kevin Jaeger: I think these are pretty hard, but I don't know about I don't know how much you like country.

[23:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Honestly, I don't even care about playing the game at this point. This concept and title is already good enough.

[23:50] Kevin Jaeger: This is like spectacular. This was a new game for season two.

[23:53] Kevin Jaeger: Is it this or is it a quote from a child at work?

[23:56] Kevin Jaeger: Because boy, do we have some kids say the darndest things just every day of our life?

[24:01] Kevin Jaeger: And especially we've been doing summer camps, and so they're with us for so long that eventually these children will say something.

[24:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm so obsessed that is hilarious.

[24:12] Kevin Jaeger: So basically, when it is your turn, I will say a phrase and you tell me if it's the name of a country song, or if like a four-year-old said it to me at work today.

[24:20] Kevin Jaeger: So Kevin, do you want to go first?

[24:25] Kevin Jaeger: I'd love to.

[24:27] Kevin Jaeger: Great. Um, my uncle used to love me, but she died.

[24:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is something that a kid at work said.

[24:37] Kevin Jaeger: Incorrect. That is a country song by Roger Miller.

[24:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This shit is genius, Kimberly.

[24:47] Kimberly Cooper: It's genius.

[24:49] Kevin Jaeger: Hey, would you like a turn?

[24:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Of course.

[24:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm feeling a little famous.

[24:59] Kevin Jaeger: Feeling a little famous.

[25:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I hope it's a kid at work, truly.

[25:04] Kevin Jaeger: This was a child at work.

[25:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, thank God.

[25:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was like, if that's a country song that's sung by Kelly Pickler.

[25:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Like there's nobody else.

[25:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She was wearing the same color skirt as her teacher.

[25:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so when she said, like, how's everyone feeling today? She goes, I'm feeling a little famous.

[25:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We match.

[25:26] Bryan Plofsky: Brian, would you like a turn?

[25:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I would.

[25:31] Bryan Plofsky: I still like baloney.

[25:36] Kevin Jaeger: Uh, I'm gonna say that's a child.

[25:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is a country music song by Alan Jackson.

[25:41] Bryan Plofsky: No fucking wild.

[25:46] Kevin Jaeger: You're gonna have to listen to all of these afterwards.

[25:49] Bryan Plofsky: All right, Kevin, would you like a turn?

[25:50] Kevin Jaeger: Of course.

[25:52] Kevin Jaeger: I like bananas because they have no bone.

[25:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a kid.

[26:00] Kevin Jaeger: The country music song.

[26:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What?

[26:04] Bryan Plofsky: Who's your hot shots?

[26:06] Kevin Jaeger: You're definitely not selling my concert very well right now.

[26:11] Bryan Plofsky: Did you only pick all these songs?

[26:14] Kevin Jaeger: Did you only pick songs from Jay's set list?

[26:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He still doesn't like bologna.

[26:22] Kevin Jaeger: I don't know what to tell you.

[26:25] Bryan Plofsky: Oh my god.

[26:27] Bryan Plofsky: All right, Jay, I have one for you. Ready?

[26:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hit me.

[26:30] Bryan Plofsky: I'm not here to listen.

[26:35] Kevin Jaeger: That's a child.

[26:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That is a child.

[26:40] Bryan Plofsky: What a good song would that be?

[26:58] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, yeah. That's a really good song time.

[26:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: All the ones Jay's got that he knew as a child.

[26:58] Kevin Jaeger: I was like, I can hear that song in my head.

[27:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, totally.

[27:01] Kevin Jaeger: Like, like the music stops, and it's just like, I'm not here to listen, or something like that.

[27:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right.

[27:01] Kevin Jaeger: Oh yeah, that's a Carrie Underwood song.

[27:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, totally.

[27:07] Bryan Plofsky: Also, a four-year-old ballerina that just doesn't want to stand up straight.

[27:11] Kevin Jaeger: I'm not here to not here to listen.

[27:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: God, I wish I had the balls to say that when I was a kid.

[27:17] Bryan Plofsky: Forget about it as a kid right now.

[27:21] Bryan Plofsky: You walk into a meeting. I'm sorry, I'm not here to listen.

[27:27] Bryan Plofsky: Oh my goodness, Brian, would you like a turn?

[27:29] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, I'm not, I'm just no nervous.

[27:32] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[27:33] Kevin Jaeger: Everything about this dress is good.

[27:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a kid.

[27:38] Kevin Jaeger: That's a child, yeah.

[27:40] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, okay.

[27:40] Kevin Jaeger: But I could still hear the sound.

[27:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[27:42] Kevin Jaeger: Huh?

[27:43] Bryan Plofsky: Absolutely.

[27:45] Kevin Jaeger: Everything about this dress is good.

[27:50] Kevin Jaeger: And then it's like a list. It's like a list.

[27:51] Bryan Plofsky: It's like the hem, the belt, the straps that fall off the shoulders.

[27:59] Kevin Jaeger: And then it ends with like it's like it goes really.

[28:02] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, or like and then it ends with boom.

[28:03] Kevin Jaeger: What I love most of all is the way he looks at me.

[28:10] Bryan Plofsky: That's part two of this game. We're just gonna write these songs.

[28:14] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god.

[28:16] Bryan Plofsky: Oh my goodness, Kevin. Would you like a turn?

[28:18] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, please.

[28:21] Kevin Jaeger: My head hurts, my feet stink, and I don't love Jesus.

[28:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a country song because it says Jesus.

[28:30] Kevin Jaeger: That's a Jimmy Buffett song.

[28:32] Kevin Jaeger: I know it well.

[28:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Do you really know that song?

[28:37] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, absolutely.

[28:38] Kevin Jaeger: And it was featured in the Broadway musical Escape to Margaritaville.

[28:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god, it was.

[28:43] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[28:46] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, I think I have a few more. Jay, let's see.

[28:50] Kevin Jaeger: You can't roller skate in a buffalo herd.

[28:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, if that's a child, where are they from?

[28:59] Kevin Jaeger: So I'm gonna guess it's a country song.

[29:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It is a country song.

[29:04] Kevin Jaeger: I teach children in Manhattan. They don't know the buffalo.

[29:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: If they do, they're referring to like Buffalo Wild Wings.

[29:13] Kevin Jaeger: That's correct.

[29:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's right, that's right. Which is delicious.

[29:16] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.

[29:17] Bryan Plofsky: So fair.

[29:19] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, Brian.

[29:22] Bryan Plofsky: I have my crown on for Easter.

[29:26] Kevin Jaeger: I'm gonna say a country song.

[29:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That was a child.

[29:30] Kevin Jaeger: Oh okay.

[29:30] Bryan Plofsky: Nowhere near Easter time, but I asked why she was wearing a crown.

[29:35] Kevin Jaeger: Well, it's for Easter.

[29:37] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[29:39] Kevin Jaeger: The same child that says, My head hurts, my feet hurt, and I don't love Jesus.

[29:39] Bryan Plofsky: All right, I think we have one more. Kevin, you ready?

[29:49] Kevin Jaeger: Oh no, I have two more.

[29:50] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[29:52] Kevin Jaeger: I get to watch a show when I go on the toilet.

[29:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's a kid.

[29:59] Kevin Jaeger: That's a child.

[30:00] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[30:01] Kevin Jaeger: Thank God.

[30:02] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[30:03] Kevin Jaeger: That really shouldn't be a country song.

[30:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's one of the songs you can't hear.

[30:08] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, I'll do the last one, and you can all guess.

[30:11] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. I'm feeling destructive.

[30:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: This is a really good last one.

[30:19] Kevin Jaeger: Thank you.

[30:20] Kevin Jaeger: I'm proud of it.

[30:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Because it would be a fantastic song.

[30:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It also would be a really like emotive and amazing way for a kid to communicate how they feel.

[30:30] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, it's also sounds like something a kid stole directly from their parents' mouth.

[30:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: For sure.

[30:35] Kevin Jaeger: And it's definitely says I'm feeling destructive.

[30:38] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[30:38] Kevin Jaeger: And I feel like also but song.

[30:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, exactly.

[30:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It would be a Carrie Underwood song, but it was like it would be like a sexy video.

[30:47] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, 100%.

[30:48] Bryan Plofsky: So what are we going with? What are you going with, Jay?

[30:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm gonna say it's a child because I love this child.

[30:57] Kevin Jaeger: I'm going it's a country song.

[31:00] Bryan Plofsky: Uh, I'm gonna say, I'm gonna say.

[31:05] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, country song, country song.

[31:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Child.

[31:09] Kevin Jaeger: Uh, you can hear the song she was writing in her head.

[31:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: One a hundred percent.

[31:16] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[31:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You honestly destructive.

[31:19] Kevin Jaeger: Honestly, we should write a country musical with brand new songs based on the titles of children.

[31:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes.

[31:27] Kevin Jaeger: And that toilet one's a hit.

[31:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That opens that oh, you can either that opens act two, where it's just like maybe it's the narrator, or maybe it opens act one.

[31:39] Bryan Plofsky: It's the device.

[31:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's the show he's watching on the toilet.

[31:45] Kevin Jaeger: Oh so it's man on it's man on throne.

[31:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[31:49] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[31:50] Bryan Plofsky: Or Michael in the bathroom by himself.

[31:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Love it.

[31:55] Kevin Jaeger: George Salazar.

[31:57] Kevin Jaeger: I guess watch a show on the toilet.

[31:59] Bryan Plofsky: The bathroom number two.

[32:01] Kevin Jaeger: It's great.

[32:03] Bryan Plofsky: No.

[32:04] Bryan Plofsky: Oh my god.

[32:05] Kevin Jaeger: That's been.

[32:05] Bryan Plofsky: Was that a country song or a quote from a child at work?

[32:08] Kimberly Cooper: A really fantastic game, Kimberly.

[32:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm very impressed.

[32:14] Kimberly Cooper: Really good.

[32:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know this is a like a hard left turn, but let's talk about Halloween.

[32:20] Kimberly Cooper: Um kids love Halloween.

[32:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, kids love Halloween.

[32:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So last year you did your incredible Sanderson Sisters Halloween spectacular um as a video, as if people could stream it, rent it, watch it, all that stuff.

[32:35] Kimberly Cooper: Um I know it was like wildly successful.

[32:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So from us at Broadway to do like congratulations.

[32:41] Kimberly Cooper: That's amazing.

[32:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um we only talked to you beforehand.

[32:45] Kimberly Cooper: We'd love to hear a little bit of like, you know, leading up to whatever you're gonna do this Halloween.

[32:49] Kimberly Cooper: Tell us about like the reaction to that, the response to that.

[32:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, what's crazy is that um I've been trying to get Broadway cares on board for this show. I mean, uh, this year will be our sixth year of doing it.

[33:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I've been doing it as a concert for the past five years or for the first four years. We're two years at 54 Below and two years at Le Passant Rouge down at the West Village.

[33:16] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.

[33:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and so I really was super interested in bringing Broadway cares on board as our like benefactor and our presenter.

[33:24] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And back in January, um, two Januaries ago now, um we had a meeting and they said, yeah, let's do this.

[33:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And that was before the pandemic actually knocked us out.

[33:36] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I thought that like my fifth anniversary was gonna just be a thing that wouldn't happen.

[33:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But then I got a little broadwaisted one night and started dreaming a little bigger.

[33:47] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I heard that like television and film production was being allowed back in New York with phase four of reopening during the pandemic.

[33:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so I had a wild idea to actually do this virtually, but not do what we'd been seeing in virtual performances, which is like, you know, performances in front of our Zoom cameras, right?

[34:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And so I thought, well, what if we could maybe overproduce like a visual album, a nod to Beyonce's Lemonade, or a nod to Toddrick Hall straight out of Oz, but make it Hocus focused.

[34:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um so we ran with it, and Broadway Cares gave us the thumbs up, and um it was wild.

[34:33] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, you know, we'd all been sitting on our butts for six months, all of us as artists and creative spaces were shut down.

[34:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So every pretty much everyone that I asked to come on board to do it um said yes, and they literally brought their A game.

[34:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They gave 110%. And I just remember walking on set of each day and just feeling like there was magic in the room and creative people were being creative again for the first time.

[34:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I wasn't quite sure what it would end up being. Um, but what it did end up being fully exceeded all of my expectations.

[35:05] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I had genius directors of photography, genius editors, genius costume designers, genius performers, genius musicians that all just kind of like rallied together, and we were able to pay a little bit of everyone.

[35:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Something because Broadway Cares was very um in touch with the fact that artists needed work and they needed money to sustain.

[35:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So we were able to pay artists at least a little fee for their work.

[35:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And we ended up um raising a quarter of a million dollars for Broadway Cares that night.

[35:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and it was just really well received.

[35:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I anytime I'm having a down day, I just go back to the YouTube video and read the comments section, and it instantly makes me just so happy because it really was received really well.

[35:50] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And we we submitted for the Telly Awards, which is an online content awards show, and they gave us nine awards.

[36:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We placed gold for art direction, silver in four categories, and bronze in um three categories, four categories.

[36:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, so yeah, it was um it was my favorite thing I've ever done.

[36:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I've never been more stressed, I've never been so sleep deprived, and I've never been so proud, actually.

[36:20] Kimberly Cooper: That's awesome.

[36:21] Kimberly Cooper: That's so cool.

[36:22] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And it was amazing as people who watched it.

[36:24] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, it was so fun.

[36:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: You're well.

[36:28] Kimberly Cooper: So, whatever you're whipping up this Halloween, we we can't wait.

[36:32] Kimberly Cooper: And uh, I'm sure if you if everyone of you follow Jay, um, there'll be some announcements in the next couple of weeks.

[36:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So we're super excited to see what you do.

[36:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, we're keeping our fingers crossed.

[36:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, we're not sure if we can do a live event this year with the looming Delta variant, very spooky, very Halloween.

[36:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, so we're we're seeing what we can produce.

[36:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, but you know, um keep your fingers crossed for us because we as a producing team are a little like, oh God, what's gonna happen?

[36:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But we really do hope we can pull up on this.

[37:01] Kimberly Cooper: I love what I love what you said before. We got a little broadwaisted and when we dreamed a little bigger. I love that.

[37:06] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's true, we did.

[37:09] Kimberly Cooper: Absolutely.

[37:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So um I'm I'm thinking we play another game that was so fun.

[37:14] Kimberly Cooper: Oh yeah, absolutely.

[37:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, since we have you here and we haven't played this in many moons, we can play a little dirty hands on a hard body.

[37:25] Kimberly Cooper: Oh my god.

[37:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I like to tell you actually was in the show.

[37:31] Kimberly Cooper: That's what I mean.

[37:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I was like, oh, I guess we can play.

[37:33] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, that was funny.

[37:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, we have to, yeah.

[37:36] Kimberly Cooper: I mean, absolutely.

[37:37] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Will you be hearing a song from Hands on a Hard Body on September 1st?

[37:40] Kimberly Cooper: Maybe.

[37:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Even better.

[37:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, if everyone has forgotten how to play since we are now in season two of Broadwaysted.

[37:52] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, season two.

[37:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Congratulations, y'all.

[37:56] Kimberly Cooper: You're a genius.

[37:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you.

[37:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So happy to have been picked up after a five year season one.

[38:05] Kevin Jaeger: Can we just call season one the last five years?

[38:10] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, yeah, we probably should.

[38:12] Kevin Jaeger: Very good, Kevin, very good.

[38:14] Kimberly Cooper: Um, dirty hands on a hard body.

[38:16] Bryan Plofsky: You have two hands, they're on your table or somewhere that is your hard body. It is a category game. We all go around rapid fire in a category. Um, if you stutter, repeat, take too long to think of an answer. One hand goes up. That is, oh, I'm like my camera's over here. That is your dirty hand. Um, if you have two hands up, you're out. And we play till someone wins. Since we are on Zoom and all of our screens look different, I'm gonna tell you what order we're in on my screen, and then that's what we'll do. Um so on my screen, it goes me, then Jay, then Kevin, then Bryan, then back to me. So remember in what order you are. Um, if you get out on a round, you get to pick the next category for everyone else and yourself if you are still in. And first category.

[39:04] Kevin Jaeger: Literally just wanna be like things that have happened in the last five years, but that's too broad.

[39:09] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[39:10] Kevin Jaeger: Um, so Kevin, you get to pick the first category.

[39:13] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. The first category is um female Sondheim characters.

[39:21] Bryan Plofsky: Wonderful.

[39:23] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. Kevin, you begin, then Bryan, you're next, then me, then Jay, and onward.

[39:27] Kevin Jaeger: Uh Mrs.

[39:28] Bryan Plofsky: Lovett.

[39:29] Kevin Jaeger: Dot.

[39:32] Bryan Plofsky: Am I next?

[39:32] Kevin Jaeger: Brian goes after Kevin.

[39:34] Bryan Plofsky: I'm so sorry. Um, I'll uh who I'll I'll let him have Dot for his next one. I'll go the witch.

[39:40] Kevin Jaeger: Dot.

[39:41] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. You should wait for Kimberly, then you.

[39:44] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, Jesus.

[39:45] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, so it's Kevin.

[39:46] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, sorry, I didn't listen to the rules. I'm a little broadbusted. Um, Kevin, then Bryan, then Kimberly, then me.

[39:52] Kevin Jaeger: All right, I'm on board now.

[39:53] Bryan Plofsky: Yes.

[39:54] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. Bosca.

[40:00] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. Um can I say uh like Mama Rose?

[40:09] Kevin Jaeger: Technically, because he did do lyrics.

[40:11] Bryan Plofsky: Yes. Right. Now, did he create the character or was that the book writer?

[40:15] Kevin Jaeger: Who's to say?

[40:17] Bryan Plofsky: Who's to say? Or is she a real person?

[40:19] Kevin Jaeger: So you can say that.

[40:19] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, so that. Um, well, if we're doing that, I'm gonna say uh Maria.

[40:27] Kevin Jaeger: Oh Cinderella.

[40:30] Bryan Plofsky: You took mine. Um good.

[40:36] Kevin Jaeger: Um Sally.

[40:43] Bryan Plofsky: Uh Rapunzel.

[40:46] Kevin Jaeger: Gussie.

[40:47] Bryan Plofsky: Little red.

[40:51] Kevin Jaeger: Um the pretty one in passion.

[40:58] Bryan Plofsky: You have to know her name.

[40:59] Kevin Jaeger: I do know her name.

[41:01] Bryan Plofsky: I think that I think you just lost the hand kind of.

[41:04] Kevin Jaeger: It's fine.

[41:05] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, but you also now get to pick the next category.

[41:07] Kevin Jaeger: So is it hands or is it fingers?

[41:11] Bryan Plofsky: Hands.

[41:11] Kevin Jaeger: So you have two hands.

[41:13] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[41:13] Kevin Jaeger: So you only have two chances.

[41:15] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[41:15] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. Oh well. The next category is Disney animated feature films.

[41:28] Bryan Plofsky: That start with a J.

[41:32] Kevin Jaeger: So that um that have nothing to do with Pixar. So we're just talking like just Disney animation studios.

[41:40] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. I'm gonna get that wrong.

[41:43] Kevin Jaeger: I'll go first with the black cauldron.

[41:47] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, um, the sword and the stone.

[41:51] Kevin Jaeger: No white. Little mermaid, uh Cinderella, the Lion King, Beauty and the Beast.

[42:01] Bryan Plofsky: Aladdin.

[42:03] Kevin Jaeger: Sleeping Beauty.

[42:05] Bryan Plofsky: Aristocats, Pocahontas.

[42:14] Kevin Jaeger: Oh no, that's a hand.

[42:19] Bryan Plofsky: What's but there's like a caveat to it, you just can't think of anything else.

[42:24] Kevin Jaeger: I know. What's crazy is that I just talked about like Disney animated films with my student today, and I was like, oh, there goes that.

[42:32] Bryan Plofsky: You already spelled it. Perfect.

[42:33] Kevin Jaeger: You used it all up.

[42:35] Bryan Plofsky: Used it all up. Well, you get to pick a category now.

[42:38] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, that's exciting. Um, my category is songs written prior to 1970.

[42:56] Bryan Plofsky: Musical theater.

[43:00] Kevin Jaeger: Wonderful.

[43:04] Bryan Plofsky: Do I start?

[43:05] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.

[43:05] Bryan Plofsky: Quick, quick, quick, quick, great.

[43:08] Kevin Jaeger: Anything goes.

[43:11] Bryan Plofsky: If I loved you.

[43:13] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, what a beautiful morning.

[43:17] Bryan Plofsky: What's the use of one drinks?

[43:20] Kevin Jaeger: Younger than springtime.

[43:22] Bryan Plofsky: Bewitched, bothered, and bewildered.

[43:26] Kevin Jaeger: The way you look tonight.

[43:28] Bryan Plofsky: Mr.

[43:29] Kevin Jaeger: Snow.

[43:31] Bryan Plofsky: Soon by Kershwin.

[43:35] Kevin Jaeger: Uh, this was a real nice clam bake.

[43:43] Bryan Plofsky: Uh uh, if ever I would leave you.

[43:51] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, yeah.

[43:52] Bryan Plofsky: Um, I could have danced all night.

[43:55] Kevin Jaeger: Oh fuck, you took mine.

[44:02] Bryan Plofsky: Someone said Mr. Snow already, didn't they?

[44:04] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[44:05] Bryan Plofsky: Me.

[44:05] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, is that two hands then?

[44:08] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[44:10] Kevin Jaeger: It was my categories.

[44:13] Bryan Plofsky: Oh no. I feel like a lot of these categories have been like, it's like a fire hose where like you know so much, but it gets clogged, so you can't think of anything.

[44:23] Kimberly Cooper: Totally.

[44:24] Kevin Jaeger: That's why I was just like, all the songs from Carousel.

[44:27] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. Say them all. In order.

[44:30] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dang. Well, you get to pick a category for the three of us.

[44:37] Kimberly Cooper: Um, oh, I have to pick a category.

[44:39] Bryan Plofsky: Oh yeah, I'm a loser.

[44:41] Kimberly Cooper: Um shows that won best musical at the Tony Awards.

[44:50] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, Kevin Starts.

[44:53] Bryan Plofsky: Uh Passion.

[44:55] Kevin Jaeger: Hamilton.

[44:57] Bryan Plofsky: In the Heights.

[45:00] Kevin Jaeger: Uh uh Avenue Q.

[45:03] Bryan Plofsky: Deer of Enhanced.

[45:04] Kevin Jaeger: Spring Awakening.

[45:07] Bryan Plofsky: Uh My Fair Lady.

[45:11] Kevin Jaeger: Hades Town.

[45:14] Bryan Plofsky: The Lion King.

[45:17] Kevin Jaeger: Inky Boots.

[45:22] Bryan Plofsky: Will Rogers Follies.

[45:24] Kevin Jaeger: I was gonna say.

[45:34] Bryan Plofsky: I have no idea.

[45:37] Kevin Jaeger: South Pacific?

[45:39] Bryan Plofsky: Sure.

[45:40] Kevin Jaeger: Um come on the poll, sir.

[45:45] Bryan Plofsky: Best musical goes to Next to Normal.

[45:52] Kevin Jaeger: Already been said.

[45:54] Bryan Plofsky: No.

[45:55] Kevin Jaeger: But I don't think it won. I think Billy Elliott beat it, didn't it?

[45:59] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, well.

[46:00] Kevin Jaeger: Really?

[46:00] Bryan Plofsky: Even if it wasn't said, you're wrong. Next to normal is like on the list of like musicals that won the Pulitzer without winning Best Musical, right?

[46:07] Kevin Jaeger: Oh wow.

[46:08] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, let me see. Can you double check that, Kimberly?

[46:12] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.

[46:13] Bryan Plofsky: Um, oh yeah. It won best score and then a Pulitzer. Not the best musical.

[46:18] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, so it didn't win, so it's YouTube.

[46:22] Kimberly Cooper: Do you either have a hand up?

[46:24] Kevin Jaeger: I do not.

[46:24] Bryan Plofsky: No.

[46:25] Kevin Jaeger: Sudden death.

[46:26] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[46:27] Kevin Jaeger: So sudden death. And your category is musicals that have starred Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[46:38] Bryan Plofsky: Well, you're gonna run out sometime, so someone's losing.

[46:43] Kevin Jaeger: All right.

[46:45] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, Bryan starts.

[46:46] Bryan Plofsky: Sure, I'll start. One of my favorite Jay Armstrong Johnson uh performances was in Scotland PA.

[46:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So good.

[46:57] Bryan Plofsky: Fair. Uh on the town.

[47:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Catch me if you can.

[47:05] Bryan Plofsky: A chorus line.

[47:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hands on a hard body.

[47:09] Bryan Plofsky: Ah, that was a good one. Uh Phantom of the Opera.

[47:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Candy.

[47:19] Bryan Plofsky: Oh. Good one. Um, we've seen him in so many shows.

[47:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know, I know.

[47:27] Bryan Plofsky: Uh remember when we stand him and just went to every single one of his shows.

[47:37] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, like your regional credits.

[47:40] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah.

[47:41] Kimberly Cooper: Uh oh, uh newsies.

[47:44] Bryan Plofsky: Said that out loud.

[47:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um September 1st at 54 Below.

[47:53] Bryan Plofsky: That counts, Bryan.

[47:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh the Halloween Bash show.

[47:57] Bryan Plofsky: Sorry, that doesn't count, Bryan. Not what it's got.

[48:00] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, Kimberly wins.

[48:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'll take it. Good job.

[48:06] Bryan Plofsky: Oh man. Season two already sabotaging me, Kevin.

[48:09] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, I'm sorry, Kevin. Season two, we know to just memorize our guests' resumes.

[48:14] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um there will be a quiz.

[48:19] Kimberly Cooper: Well, that brings us to the end of our episode. Uh, thank you so much, Jay, for kicking off season two with us. This was so fun. It was really wonderful to catch up with you. We really enjoyed it.

[48:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, thank you for having me. Congrats on season two. It's always a pleasure.

[48:35] Bryan Plofsky: Of course. You know, um, you can excuse me, again as a reminder. Um, you can catch Jay's show um September 1st, 54 Below. It's at 9:45 p.m. But of course, go to 54below.com, grab tickets for in person, um, and then, or you know, stream it um from their platform as well. You can find all that on 54 Below.

[49:00] Kimberly Cooper: Um thank you so much for joining us. Um, you can always follow us at things like uh Twitter, Instagram, at Broadwaysted. You can find us on social media with uh Facebook or Facebook group. You can follow. And then our our Patreon has been going strong through, you know, even our our season breaks. So you can find us there. And then of course, um, you can find us on things like Spotify, wherever you're listening to podcasts, Apple Podcasts, rate and review us there. Five stars, please. Thank you.

[49:32] Kevin Jaeger: Um, but uh, will a paycheck mean that we're sellouts? And if we sell out, will they yell out me and you to nobodies in New York?

[49:41] Kimberly Cooper: Um, thank you so much for for to the fans and the listeners. Thank you so much for listening to season one. We hope you enjoyed um we really energized during that break.

[49:52] Bryan Plofsky: Just do a quick binge of season one before you pick up season two, though.

[49:56] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, okay.

[49:59] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. Um easy, binge it in a weekend.

[50:02] Kimberly Cooper: Totally super easy. You need it to understand season two, obviously.

[50:06] Kevin Jaeger: There's a big cliffhanger.

[50:09] Bryan Plofsky: So many black threads, you'll never understand.

[50:12] Kimberly Cooper: Totally quantico.

[50:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's Jay prison.

[50:17] Bryan Plofsky: Is he not? Is he a bad guy?

[50:20] Kevin Jaeger: Who knows?

[50:21] Kimberly Cooper: Who knows?

[50:22] Bryan Plofsky: Well, Jay, thank you so much. And as we end every episode, we raise a glass and we say Zudu uh Cheers.

[50:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Cheers, y'all.

[50:32] All: Hooray.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred