From Bright Star to Paradise Square! Play along as AJ Shively (@aj_shively - Paradise Square, Bright Star) joins Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for tequila, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and white wine. Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG... Read More
From the show: Broadwaysted!
Guests
Featured Shows
About
From Bright Star to Paradise Square!
Play along as AJ Shively (@aj_shively - Paradise Square, Bright Star) joins Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for tequila, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and white wine.
Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Bryan Plovsky: Did you bring wine?
[0:05] Kevin Jaeger: I got the glasses.
[0:07] Kimberly Coops: You guys, I made a quiz.
[0:08] AJ Shively: I didn't bring anything, but I heard it's a bug.
[0:12] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, and welcome to the visual Broadwaysted podcast where we're drunk on theater.
[0:24] Bryan Plovsky: I'm your host, Bryan Plovsky, and oh Susanna, welcome home.
[0:29] Bryan Plovsky: I'm coming to Paradise Square to find a bright lookout and someone to love.
[0:33] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, gentle Annie, who is true to a country.
[0:36] Bryan Plovsky: Why should I die if I if I if I'd be a soul if I die in spring, not sprint.
[0:43] Bryan Plovsky: Uh if I die in spring, if I'd be a soldier, it's hard times, but wait, is that the ring?
[0:49] Kevin Jaeger: Ring of the banjo?
[0:50] Bryan Plovsky: Just the one match and one man since the day I met you.
[0:54] Bryan Plovsky: Joining us today, the usual Angelina Bakers who love those camptown races, including Kevin, let it burn, Jaeger.
[1:02] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god, I'm all about that.
[1:03] Kevin Jaeger: That's definitely my song.
[1:04] Kimberly Coops: Kimberly, our breathe easy game master, an unofficial babysitter for the hour.
[1:09] AJ Shively: Oh.
[1:11] Bryan Plovsky: And with us is a returning guest who you may have seen in Lakage or Bright Star. He's now in Paradise Square. Let's give a big Broadwaysted welcome to Friend of the Show.
[1:17] Kevin Jaeger: Friend of the show.
[1:22] Kimberly Coops: Friend of the show.
[1:23] Bryan Plovsky: AJ Shively.
[1:29] AJ Shively: Hello.
[1:29] Bryan Plovsky: Oh my god, this is crazy having you back.
[1:32] AJ Shively: I know.
[1:32] AJ Shively: It's good to be back.
[1:33] AJ Shively: It's all fuzzy from before.
[1:37] AJ Shively: I think I'm still hungover.
[1:39] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, it was quite the haze.
[1:41] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[1:43] AJ Shively: The night ended with me stripping Bryan for cab fare.
[1:46] Bryan Plovsky: So I gotta wait, really?
[1:49] AJ Shively: I think so.
[1:50] AJ Shively: I have all this guilt from you.
[1:52] Bryan Plovsky: No, I have no recollection of that at all.
[1:55] AJ Shively: You're good.
[1:56] AJ Shively: We're even.
[1:56] AJ Shively: We came back on the show.
[1:57] AJ Shively: I remember getting to my—we shared a cab uptown, and I got to my apartment and I was like, here I am, and just going upstairs and being like, so anyway, oh wait, Bryan's not here.
[2:09] Kimberly Coops: Oh, that's so funny.
[2:11] AJ Shively: Yeah, I just then I went to Korean barbecue and apparently like sat on my then fiancé's lap like embarrassed in front of his friends.
[2:21] Bryan Plovsky: Did we drink up? Did we go to the bar upstairs too, or did we just right?
[2:27] AJ Shively: I think both.
[2:28] AJ Shively: I think we bookended.
[2:29] AJ Shively: I'm pretty sure, yeah.
[2:30] Bryan Plovsky: We bookended it for sure.
[2:32] AJ Shively: Okay.
[2:32] AJ Shively: And maybe I bailed during the second drinks and went to dinner.
[2:36] Bryan Plovsky: Correct.
[2:37] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[2:37] AJ Shively: When like the dinner was gone too.
[2:39] AJ Shively: Like it was Korean barbecue, and I got there, like all the barbecue was gone, and I was like drunk and starving.
[2:44] AJ Shively: And I was just like, um, I'm gonna need to go home.
[2:48] AJ Shively: I just remember I remember giving Kimberly a pep talk.
[2:51] AJ Shively: We were like, You're fine, you can totally do this.
[2:55] AJ Shively: You got it, yeah.
[2:56] Bryan Plovsky: Well, this is a good one.
[2:57] AJ Shively: We're older now, yeah.
[2:59] AJ Shively: Wiser now.
[3:00] AJ Shively: I just ate a huge thing of pasta.
[3:01] AJ Shively: I'm ready to go.
[3:02] AJ Shively: I've got some water.
[3:04] Bryan Plovsky: We're both prepared for this one.
[3:06] AJ Shively: Amazing.
[3:07] Bryan Plovsky: So you know, let's just start with what are you drinking?
[3:10] AJ Shively: Oh, yeah.
[3:11] AJ Shively: So I uh, you know, as a gift, I got a virtual cocktail making class um for Christmas.
[3:19] AJ Shively: So um I've today made a Manhattan, but in honor of Paradise Square, which takes place in the five points, I've used Kentucky Bourbon, so it's a southern Manhattan.
[3:29] Kimberly Coops: Yes, that's wonderful.
[3:31] Kimberly Coops: Very clever.
[3:32] AJ Shively: I'm very into it.
[3:33] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah.
[3:33] AJ Shively: What are you guys drinking?
[3:36] Kevin Jaeger: Uh I'm drinking a nice cold Chenin Blanc.
[3:39] AJ Shively: That's lovely.
[3:43] Kimberly Coops: Um, I have a natural lime white claw.
[3:46] AJ Shively: Yeah, natural lime.
[3:47] Kimberly Coops: Not even lime.
[3:49] Kimberly Coops: That was the fastest thing I could find.
[3:52] AJ Shively: Did you did you buy that individually?
[3:55] Kimberly Coops: Because there's like a sticker on it from the bodega.
[3:58] Kimberly Coops: From the bodega downstairs.
[4:00] AJ Shively: Amazing.
[4:01] AJ Shively: I love it so much.
[4:01] AJ Shively: Bodega White Claw is the best white claw.
[4:03] Kevin Jaeger: The best white claw.
[4:04] AJ Shively: No question.
[4:05] AJ Shively: Very cold.
[4:06] Kevin Jaeger: No question.
[4:08] AJ Shively: Yeah, that's true.
[4:09] AJ Shively: Well, I'm in my own home.
[4:10] AJ Shively: I'm not hiding.
[4:12] AJ Shively: It's the paradise cab.
[4:14] Kimberly Coops: Oh.
[4:21] AJ Shively: Thank you.
[4:22] AJ Shively: Very rioty.
[4:22] AJ Shively: You gotta love that.
[4:23] AJ Shively: You expect individually.
[4:25] AJ Shively: That's $250 for one white claw.
[4:27] Kevin Jaeger: Amazing.
[4:28] AJ Shively: Uh and I'm just drinking some tequila on the rocks, but the rocks melted.
[4:31] AJ Shively: So now it's tequila with a splash of water.
[4:34] Kimberly Coops: Love it.
[4:35] Kevin Jaeger: I'm gonna buy you an ice maker for your desk.
[4:37] Kevin Jaeger: So you can like the ice.
[4:39] AJ Shively: That would be nice.
[4:40] AJ Shively: I'll add to my uh I'll add it to my registry.
[4:44] Kimberly Coops: Honestly, yeah.
[4:45] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[4:46] AJ Shively: Cheers.
[4:47] Bryan Plovsky: Cheers.
[4:48] All: Cheers! Clinky. Slauncha.
[4:49] AJ Shively: Okay, there it is.
[4:51] AJ Shively: Slauncha.
[4:52] AJ Shively: Um, um, how you been?
[4:54] AJ Shively: I know you're in Paradise Square right now.
[4:56] AJ Shively: Why don't we talk a little bit about—let's just start right off the bat with Paradise Square.
[5:00] AJ Shively: Um, we haven't talked a lot about like newer stuff on Broadway, so I'm super pumped to have you here.
[5:05] AJ Shively: Yeah, I'm excited to be one of the newer things on Broadway.
[5:08] AJ Shively: It's a crazy season, and it's I'm so encouraged at how many new shows are opening with like original music and original story.
[5:19] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[5:19] AJ Shively: I'm like very into this trend on Broadway, and I hope it keeps on going.
[5:25] Bryan Plovsky: Cheers for that.
[5:26] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[5:26] AJ Shively: So this show uh is it's about a piece of American history that I had never heard of, um called uh the amalgamationist movement.
[5:39] AJ Shively: So during Civil War era New York, so this is getting to New York, um, in that same place in the five points in southern Manhattan.
[5:48] AJ Shively: Um there was this group of Americans who were openly living interracially, like interracial marriage.
[5:55] AJ Shively: There were open queer people, there were um uh uh born free black American business owners.
[6:02] AJ Shively: Um it was this—well, we have a line in the play saying it was a group of Americans living in the future.
[6:09] AJ Shively: Um this incredible society, it's the American melting pot.
[6:14] AJ Shively: It's where you know immigrants, it's like the poorest of the poor, but it's immigrants and uh self-liberated um black Americans from the South and born free black Americans and and this just group of people whose only common tongue was kind of music and dance, and uh it's the birth of American pop music in this little corner, it's the birth of American culture, really, in this little corner of Manhattan.
[6:40] AJ Shively: Um, and it all came to a crashing end um in 1863 with the draft riots of 1863, which I had never heard of.
[6:50] AJ Shively: But when Abraham Lincoln instituted a draft for the Civil War, um it was really only gonna affect poor people and and recent immigrants, and uh the rich people could buy their way out of it with a year's salary, basically.
[7:06] AJ Shively: Um, and when they called the names, it was the hottest day in New York, and you all know what New York is like in the summertime.
[7:13] AJ Shively: And people were angry, and people have been drinking, and the protest kind of turned into a riot.
[7:19] AJ Shively: And the riot then over the course of three days got focused.
[7:24] AJ Shively: The anger with pamphlets and kind of newspaper publications, the anger shifted from being socioeconomic to being racial, and it turned into a race riot.
[7:35] Bryan Plovsky: Wow.
[7:36] AJ Shively: In New York City, they were like a dynched, I think in total, 150 people died in these riots in New York City.
[7:42] AJ Shively: It's crazy.
[7:42] AJ Shively: I've never heard of this.
[7:43] AJ Shively: Yeah, so that's kind of yeah, it's wild.
[7:46] AJ Shively: It's like a really important piece of our history.
[7:49] AJ Shively: And the lens through which we learn about this is through this community, this incredible community of, as our dramaturge put it, of survivors.
[7:58] AJ Shively: These people who come and they make a great life out of nothing and lean on each other in new and incredibly impressive, even today, by today's standards, ways.
[8:10] AJ Shively: And uh like it's so it's a heavy piece of history, but it's a really wonderful, light, happy uh sense of community.
[8:21] AJ Shively: It's it's like there's so much dancing, there's so much joy.
[8:25] AJ Shively: Um yeah, and it's kind of gives you hope for for where we could go in the future.
[8:30] Kimberly Coops: Cool.
[8:31] Kimberly Coops: That's awesome.
[8:32] Kimberly Coops: That's a lot, I know.
[8:35] Kimberly Coops: I don't I don't know much about the show itself.
[8:37] Kimberly Coops: Is it told over the course of those three days?
[8:39] AJ Shively: Is it a little bit outside of that?
[8:41] AJ Shively: It's a little outside of that.
[8:42] AJ Shively: So there's kind of it starts kind of like prologue land, and you get to meet the people in Paradise Square Saloon, kind of this one bar owned by a born-free black woman uh named Nellie Freeman, uh, who's married to an Irish immigrant named Willie O'Brien.
[8:59] AJ Shively: Um, and um the events of the place start, I would say like four months before the riots, when my character, Owen Owen Daignan, um, arrives in New York fresh off the boat, and uh a self-emancipated um person named who uh Joa arrives in New York City on the Underground Railroad, and the saloon is a stop on the underground railroad.
[9:24] AJ Shively: Um so it just follows kind of the people who own the bar who live at the bar and um their relationships and their community, you know, all these people, all the patrons of the bar.
[9:36] Kimberly Coops: Now I have two very important questions.
[9:39] Kimberly Coops: The first question is are characters in the show based on like historical people, or is this like a fictional of the historical events?
[9:50] AJ Shively: Right.
[9:50] AJ Shively: So I it's I would say it's probably closer toward fictionalization, but everybody is based on um, you know, the characters are all based on bits and pieces of stories that have are true from the time and place.
[10:04] AJ Shively: So there wasn't a woman named Nellie who owned a bar called Paradise Square, but there were you know female business owners and there were black business owners, and um uh, you know, there's not there's not a runaway or a self-emancipated person named Um Joa, but there was um a born-free black man named Juba who invented tap dance basically in this time and place.
[10:30] AJ Shively: So it's all kind of it's close.
[10:33] AJ Shively: It's not, but it's not quoted.
[10:34] AJ Shively: It's not quoted, it's inspired by it.
[10:36] Kimberly Coops: No, that's awesome.
[10:37] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[10:38] Kimberly Coops: And then my second very important question is maybe a spoiler alert.
[10:41] Kimberly Coops: So if you're really like want to go into Paradise Square blind, maybe skip the next five seconds.
[10:47] Kimberly Coops: But my question is is there a big reveal at the end that you're somebody's secret son?
[10:54] AJ Shively: No, but um, but in the in at the end of the first act, I do get into a suitcase and fly over the audience.
[11:01] Kimberly Coops: Oh, yeah, that that was my question.
[11:06] AJ Shively: Yeah, so no, there are no trains, but I do fly in a suitcase.
[11:10] Kimberly Coops: Okay, as long as as long as there's some kind of connection.
[11:14] AJ Shively: Actually, actually, there is my first entrance, it's kind of the same thing.
[11:18] AJ Shively: I I like walk on stage from the wings holding a big duffel bag, like ready to go.
[11:23] Kimberly Coops: That's amazing.
[11:25] AJ Shively: It would be a comedy moment.
[11:27] AJ Shively: Like, you know how like like directors like Tarantino where people will like put in like homage, just like this character might be from this universe.
[11:34] AJ Shively: It would be really funny if like you in a writer required that each like each character you ever play must be connected in the same universe.
[11:42] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, well, he needs to stop, he needs to stop bringing duffel bags into the audition world.
[11:47] AJ Shively: You know, I just find it more comfortable to carry than the traditional like binder with music.
[11:51] AJ Shively: You just plop that bag down and like yeah, yeah, that's totally totally and serious question.
[11:58] Kimberly Coops: Um, are you how long have you been with Shi?
[12:00] AJ Shively: Were you with it early on?
[12:01] AJ Shively: Did you just join it for the Broadway company?
[12:03] AJ Shively: Like, how did this all jump together?
[12:05] AJ Shively: Yeah, it's similar to Bright Star.
[12:07] AJ Shively: I I started um in one of the first workshops in 2018.
[12:11] AJ Shively: Um, and we were we tried out of town in Berkeley at Berkeley Rep in 2019.
[12:18] AJ Shively: Um, and we were supposed to, we were hoping to come to Broadway in late 2020, but we all know how that worked out.
[12:25] Bryan Plovsky: Why didn't that happen?
[12:27] AJ Shively: Well, it's because Hamilton was still so successful.
[12:30] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, yeah.
[12:31] AJ Shively: It just wasn't room.
[12:32] Bryan Plovsky: Right.
[12:33] AJ Shively: Good answer.
[12:33] AJ Shively: Good answer.
[12:37] AJ Shively: And uh so I'm like gobsmacked that it's come back.
[12:41] AJ Shively: So we were in Chicago over the fall, which is where your song list at the top of the show came from, because we had a nice chunky like two or two months, maybe a little more in between Chicago and New York.
[12:54] AJ Shively: And like they rewrote the entire second act, and there's so many new songs.
[12:58] AJ Shively: It's people who saw it in Chicago, it's a completely new show.
[13:02] Kimberly Coops: It's yeah.
[13:03] Kimberly Coops: Oh, that's cool.
[13:04] AJ Shively: That's a cool thing.
[13:04] Kimberly Coops: Well, it's not a new show.
[13:06] AJ Shively: Was it called Paradise Circle in Chicago?
[13:10] Kimberly Coops: No, but we keep joking that it's it's gonna be called Paradise Triangle if if more people keep calling out of it.
[13:26] AJ Shively: Guys, you will never believe what has happened to me. So I am not a dancer, or well, I can't say that anymore, but I was not a dancer growing up. I went to musical theater school, um, and where I was very kindly and supportively told that I'm like a strong mover. So if they need somebody in the back, that would be great. Um, depth touch. And but you're amazing at the parking bark, yes, yeah. The parking bark is yeah. Get that set off stage and let me go. Oh so Bill T. Jones, our choreographer, his whole kind of professional and creative um point of view is that your best work happens beyond the line of where you think your capability ends. Um, and that's absolutely like I am I am doing things I had I just would never have believed that I was capable of.
Um I am a principal dancer in this show. It's insane. It's insane. Like soloist dancer. It's crazy. Um so and it's a the fact that I'm able to do it at all, is a huge testament to our whole creative team, uh specifically the choreography team. Um my Irish choreographers were Garrett Coleman and Jason Aramis, who are both world champion Irish dancers. Both did, you know, Riverdance. Um that's not intimidating at all to look like. Yeah, not at all. You learn that yeah, regular day. At some point, you like don't know so much that you're like invincible, kind of because they try and teach me something that's apparently really simple, and I couldn't do it. And then I'd see them doing stuff over in the corner, and I'd like mimic them, and they'd be like, How did you do that?
I'm like, I don't know. Um trained for years to be able to do that. And I'm like, oh well, but I can't do the simple thing that like the little babies in the first class can do. It's so funny. You're like it was step ball change? Is that what you step ball change? I always do a heel. I was doing a step. Can you explain all to me? So when a man and a woman that's super cool. Yeah, it's wild. It's wild. I'm I'm proud of myself, which is kind of it's a hard thing to say, but it's like I am, I'm proud of myself. And um, I'm very grateful for the support I've had from our from our team, Chloe Davis, our dance captain and associate choreographer, just everybody, like, and everybody. There's a lot of dancer first in our cast who and just are so supportive and are like, you know, that looks great.
Or like when I if I say I'm feeling nervous, they're like, Oh, well, this is how I handle that. And it kind of goes vice versa for some of the people in the cast who aren't comfortable singers, who are soloists singing soloists on Broadway, you know. I was teasing these guys, these world champion Irish dancers. I was like, Did you ever think you would be a Broadway singer? You know, did you ever think you'd be like a Riverdance champion? I'm like, no. No. And that's it's so cool. It's so cool for you that like like your Broadway careers for so much has been developing new shows. Like that's in a in a market where like revivals are like the bread and butter for a lot of Broadway and regional stuff. Like, that's really, really cool that you've been able to spend so many years creating new work.
[16:52] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah. I it's it's sort of, I mean, it's what I'm most interested in. So I was gonna say it's by design, but it's it's also by like that's just how it's worked out, you know. You know, I'm not like not pursuing the revival or anything like that, but it is what I'm most interested in. The story is why I'm in storytelling is why I'm in the arts in the first place. Um, you know, to just that kind of escapist, like falling into a well-crafted, detailed world from somebody else's brain is just bliss for me. Um so the development process of a new work to be in the room with the writers and the directors and all these smart minds and seeing how the story changes and and what goes into it, it. It's my favorite thing in the world. Rehearsal is always my favorite part. And when you're doing workshops and you know, staying with the show over the course of years, it's like you're rehearsing forever. So it's like my dream. I feel very lucky.
[17:52] Bryan Plovsky: That's awesome. You know where else you can feel really lucky?
[17:57] Kevin Jaeger: Where?
[17:57] AJ Shively: Where?
[17:59] Kevin Jaeger: Tuesdays.
[18:02] AJ Shively: In the corner with Kevin.
[18:07] Kevin Jaeger: All right. Welcome to Kevin's Corner, the best part of the show that sadly didn't exist the first time you came on.
[18:13] AJ Shively: No.
[18:13] Kevin Jaeger: But now it does because we realize there needs to be a place where we put all of my craziness into one corner of the room. And that's where we are now. So welcome to Kevin's Corner where I can do whatever I want because it's my corner. And today I was thinking about like your first name being AJ, which everybody knows stands for Albert Josiah. But um, like I was just thinking about how it would be fun if more celebrities decided to take their entire name and just go by letters. So I'm gonna give you the two letters of the person's name and give you a sentence about that person as a hint, and we're gonna see if you can come up with these big Hollywood celebrities who have decided to use your Albert Josiah uh closing of your name to make it just AJ.
[19:02] AJ Shively: Um is it Alberta Josiah?
[19:05] Kevin Jaeger: Did I say it wrong?
[19:06] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah.
[19:07] Kevin Jaeger: But it's pronounced Arthur Jonathan.
[19:09] AJ Shively: Oh, right.
[19:10] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, that's right.
[19:14] AJ Shively: Okay, so the first one is BW.
[19:18] Kevin Jaeger: B good old B dubs. And uh, this person is the only person who can say yippie kaye and sound cool.
[19:26] AJ Shively: Oh man, well, the only name that's coming to mind is Bradley Whitford.
[19:30] Kevin Jaeger: And he probably could. I mean, he probably could, but did the Peanut Gallery know who I was looking for?
[19:37] AJ Shively: Bruce Willis.
[19:38] Kevin Jaeger: That is correct from Die Hard, Yippie Kaye, Mother F.
[19:42] AJ Shively: Wow. I went straight to uh like West Wing.
[19:46] Kevin Jaeger: Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.
[19:49] AJ Shively: West Wing.
[19:50] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. All right. Uh this person, uh, the letters I'm looking at are A H A H. And this person, the gays loved and then hated, and now we kind of love them again.
[20:05] AJ Shively: Hmm.
[20:08] Kevin Jaeger: A H. And we decided to like really hate this person around the time they won their Oscar.
[20:15] AJ Shively: Oh.
[20:16] Kevin Jaeger: For a musical.
[20:18] AJ Shively: For a musical.
[20:19] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. Which should make us which you would think would make the gays love her more, but we decided to not.
[20:24] AJ Shively: We did it.
[20:25] Kevin Jaeger: We loved her less, a lot less. We're a fickle group. I'm sorry. I what's Lady Gaga's name?
[20:33] AJ Shively: No, that's Stephanie's.
[20:35] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, her name's Stephanie uh Jira Geromino Jamata.
[20:40] AJ Shively: Oh, her name is Gaga.
[20:43] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, yeah.
[20:46] AJ Shively: Um Peanut Gallery. Do you got it for me?
[20:51] Kevin Jaeger: Aldous Huxley is the only name I can think of.
[20:54] Kevin Jaeger: I'm looking for Ann Hathaway.
[20:57] AJ Shively: Oh, that's correct.
[20:58] Kevin Jaeger: That is correct. The gays turned on Ann Hathaway very quickly, but we've all decided to bring her back. And there's now a video going around of her singing since she'd been gone on the Kelly Clarkson show.
[21:07] AJ Shively: So good.
[21:08] Kevin Jaeger: So I think the gays were like, oh no, you're okay now. We've accepted you into the fold.
[21:12] AJ Shively: Okay. She's fascinating.
[21:14] Kevin Jaeger: She's fascinating.
[21:15] AJ Shively: She's fascinating.
[21:17] Kevin Jaeger: Incredibly talented. I saw the uh the uh uh princess diaries recently again.
[21:22] AJ Shively: She's oh isn't it for the first time?
[21:25] Kevin Jaeger: She's really good.
[21:28] AJ Shively: She's really good.
[21:29] Kevin Jaeger: She's very good in Oceans 8 making fun of herself.
[21:32] AJ Shively: That's that's yes, yeah.
[21:35] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, so the next one is uh RM, and I'll give you a hint that we can call her RMC.
[21:46] AJ Shively: Um, and this incredible Hollywood persona can be a Queen B and a Southern girl who didn't receive her letters in one amazing year.
[21:59] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, it's uh mean girls in the notebook, right?
[22:05] AJ Shively: You're correct, you're correct.
[22:07] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, and slings and arrows.
[22:10] AJ Shively: RMC.
[22:12] Kevin Jaeger: RMC.
[22:15] AJ Shively: Regina George.
[22:17] Kevin Jaeger: But I think you mean Regina Mick George.
[22:22] AJ Shively: Who is our who is our second president?
[22:25] Kevin Jaeger: Uh Rachel McAdams.
[22:28] AJ Shively: There it is.
[22:29] Kevin Jaeger: She was our second president.
[22:31] AJ Shively: That's why they had to make the no Canadians rule after that.
[22:36] Kevin Jaeger: Absolutely.
[22:38] AJ Shively: Okay, American history.
[22:39] Kevin Jaeger: You get that one broadwaisted.
[22:42] AJ Shively: History comes alive.
[22:45] Kevin Jaeger: This next, this next, and also it may not have been the same year, but I appreciate you going along with me.
[22:50] AJ Shively: Uh fact-check me if you will.
[22:52] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, so the next one is JC.
[22:54] AJ Shively: Good old JC.
[22:55] Kevin Jaeger: Was he a carpenter?
[22:58] AJ Shively: I was gonna say, he was not a carpenter, but he wore a mask.
[23:03] Kevin Jaeger: Oh uh wore a mask.
[23:08] AJ Shively: Could that be like a superhero movie?
[23:12] Kevin Jaeger: Alrighty then. I'm just uh I'm just uh looking for my mask.
[23:16] AJ Shively: Oh, Jim Carrey.
[23:18] Kevin Jaeger: He wore the mask.
[23:21] AJ Shively: Well done, well done. I should have used the right article, that would have helped.
[23:24] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[23:25] AJ Shively: Um, and then here we go.
[23:27] Kevin Jaeger: Um, the next one is ooh, L.
[23:32] AJ Shively: And this person notoriously had a fight with Bill Murray, which is why Bill Murray wasn't in the second movie.
[23:41] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, oh, I know this. That's from Charlie's Angels.
[23:44] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[23:45] Kevin Jaeger: It is.
[23:50] AJ Shively: Um, Bill Murray was apparently wildly specific.
[23:55] Kevin Jaeger: No, Bill Murray was apparently really mean to her and just looked at her in the face when they were in a scene and said, You're a bad actress.
[24:02] AJ Shively: And she got really mad at him, and uh like rightfully so.
[24:06] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, no bullying anymore. And so, yeah, it was like it was a really bad situation. But I they talk about it all the time on like the stupid YouTube videos about that I watched by Hollywood. So, like, I thought I would bring that one up.
[24:18] AJ Shively: Okay, I'd never heard of that.
[24:20] Kevin Jaeger: Really?
[24:20] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[24:21] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, she really went to Michigan.
[24:23] AJ Shively: That's amazing.
[24:23] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah.
[24:25] AJ Shively: So funny. Go blue is literally everywhere.
[24:29] Kevin Jaeger: Um, okay.
[24:30] AJ Shively: Uh the last one is L D.
[24:34] Kevin Jaeger: And um, this incredible actress had a great career, but then her career became even better with her resurgence, where the gays fell in love with her, and it has culminated in a recent award show where the uh I think it was either San Francisco or New York Mail Gay Chorus sang an entire recount of the year that included this person's name over and over again. The best thing I've ever seen.
[25:00] AJ Shively: Ah, now I know of Jurassic Park fame.
[25:05] Kevin Jaeger: Correct.
[25:05] AJ Shively: Laura Dern.
[25:07] Kevin Jaeger: Yes. If you haven't, if you have not seen that video, it is absolutely insane.
[25:13] AJ Shively: I think I watched that in real time, actually.
[25:16] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, was that Laura Dern kicking off her shoes like that?
[25:21] AJ Shively: Her reaction to the way they just kept going, Laura Dern, Laura Dern. She's like, and it's it's because she genuinely doesn't know what she did to make the gays love her, but like it just happened, and what it does, you just nor do the gays. Like, I don't think anyone knows.
[25:35] Kevin Jaeger: We don't either.
[25:36] AJ Shively: We got a Shia LaBeouf song, you know.
[25:39] Kevin Jaeger: The with the video was like him clapping alone in the audience at the end.
[25:43] AJ Shively: Yeah, 100%.
[25:48] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, and the last one is uh, I gotta give you a good one.
[25:51] AJ Shively: All right, the last one is oh, I had this one. Where was it going with it?
[25:57] Kevin Jaeger: Um I believe in you.
[26:03] AJ Shively: Okay, the last one. Take a sip is BC, and everybody always jokes about how this actor looks like a ferret or an otter.
[26:18] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, an otter. Everyone always jokes. They talk about it so much that Graham Norton brought it up when he was on the show.
[26:27] AJ Shively: Well, he was on Graham Norton's show.
[26:29] Kevin Jaeger: Does he say does he say penguins weird?
[26:31] AJ Shively: Yes, he does say penguins weird. There's actually there's literally a document. He he narrated a documentary and didn't know how to say the word penguins. So he said it differently each time that it they recorded.
[26:44] Kevin Jaeger: So you could hear him say he he said pen wings.
[26:47] AJ Shively: No.
[26:47] Kevin Jaeger: And then penguins, because he just didn't know how to say the word.
[26:51] Kevin Jaeger: It's amazing.
[26:52] AJ Shively: Okay.
[26:53] Kevin Jaeger: How strange of him.
[26:56] AJ Shively: How strange.
[26:57] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, so BC, the only name I could think of was Bradley Cooper, but it can't be Bradley Cooper.
[27:02] AJ Shively: It's not, he has a more Shakespearean first name.
[27:08] Kevin Jaeger: Is it Benedict Cumberbatch?
[27:10] AJ Shively: It is.
[27:11] Kevin Jaeger: I've never heard of this otter thing.
[27:14] AJ Shively: Yeah, he was super embarrassed by the penguins like thing because he couldn't say it.
[27:18] Kevin Jaeger: Because he said the pen wings, and he and it was pretty funny.
[27:24] AJ Shively: Um, but yeah, there's a picture of an otter that they constantly like on the internet, it was like a thing that went viral of him next to this picture of an otter that looked exactly like him.
[27:35] Kevin Jaeger: I see these weird things, and I keep them in Kevin's Corner.
[27:38] AJ Shively: So this has been Kevin's Corner.
[27:40] Kevin Jaeger: It's so cozy in Kevin's corner.
[27:42] AJ Shively: Yeah, it's a cozy place.
[27:44] Kevin Jaeger: Penguins everywhere, penguins all around.
[27:50] AJ Shively: Um, so here's a we we talked a little bit about Bright Star, but I guess you know, uh Bright Star was very very big part of kind of Broadwaysted like coming into its own and like and and starting off. I guess for you, looking back on that, like I guess you know, when we talked to you, you had it had I think it had just closed.
[28:09] Kevin Jaeger: Um, and uh, and you obviously had a very different viewpoint than you do now, what six years later or whatever it is. Like, I guess how do you look back on that time one? And and what are things that you see from fans from the community uh about Bright Star that kind of you know make you realize that it wasn't just like a flash in the pan type of thing that it really affected people.
[28:31] AJ Shively: Yeah, well, it was it it didn't like I think will always be the best of times, just like the best. It's another one. I was with Bright Star from the first workshop all the way through Broadway and then beyond, we did it again uh like a year later in LA. I did it in LA and San Francisco. Carmen and I came back, and a lot of a lot of the cast came back.
[28:53] AJ Shively: Um, and we all did it again. That's so awesome, which was great because my family that lives in LA had tickets to see us on Broadway in like July, which we closed at the end of June.
[29:06] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[29:08] AJ Shively: Um, so they all got to see me in the show. Um, that's that's amazing. And you know, we got and when I finally left that the it was how the tour started. And when I finally left the tour, um it felt like on my terms and like that I was done and I was passing it on.
[29:26] Kevin Jaeger: Um and uh it's better closure.
[29:29] AJ Shively: Yeah, better closure. Um, but it's just the best. Still some of my best friends of my whole life I met in San Diego when we were when we did it out there. Um and I'm so happy that so many high schools are doing it.
[29:44] AJ Shively: And I gotta say, I'm shocked because I thought they would double cast Alice as old and young, but they I don't know how many high schools have done it, but they found that many like 17-year old girls who can do that. And I'm my mind is blown.
[29:58] Kevin Jaeger: Um, I've been lucky enough to see a few that were, you know, in the really New York area, yeah, to go to see it. And it's just like the show holds up, the momentum of the second act like still gets you there.
[30:09] AJ Shively: That score still gets you there. I it's just I feel nothing but love. And like it must be such a cool thing that like you like if somebody says to their machine with a female name that I'm not gonna say, so it doesn't talk to me.
[30:23] Kevin Jaeger: Like, if I'm like, play Bright Star, like the like this is Bright Star, and like the title song is you on the cast album.
[30:31] AJ Shively: Like, that's such a cool thing. Like all these high schools that are like you you know, all the high school students who are playing your part, listen to the cast album to like learn it and get into it, and like they're listening to you.
[30:44] Kevin Jaeger: So, like that must be so like what is that like for like high school you to think that like versions of high school kids now are listening to you as their inspiration to play a part in the world.
[30:55] AJ Shively: They're mimicking your choices, yeah.
[30:57] Kevin Jaeger: Right, yeah, like what you do in the studio that day.
[31:01] AJ Shively: Yeah, that's yeah, it's that's like too big for me to wrap to wrap my brain around like that. It's just I feel yeah, I guess proud again. I feel proud of that.
[31:11] AJ Shively: I um I uh I'm just happy that kids are doing the show and learning the show, and um, you know, we worked so hard on it, and it was such a special thing for me personally that I'm just glad it's it's continuing to go.
[31:27] AJ Shively: There's a really funny story. My cousin just told me. Um, his now fiancé, when they first started dating, um they were driving in her car, and she turned on her her radio for whichever satellite streaming service she does, and she had a playlist set up, and she was like, Oh, sorry, this is my Broadway playlist.
[31:47] AJ Shively: Um, we can change it if you want. And he's like, Oh no, my cousin does Broadway.
[31:52] Kevin Jaeger: And uh Always Have Always Will was the next song that played.
[31:55] AJ Shively: And he was like, Oh, that's my cousin.
[31:57] Kevin Jaeger: She thought he was teasing her.
[32:01] AJ Shively: So wait, so you meet up Broadway with like uh like roundabout wingman for your cousin?
[32:06] Kevin Jaeger: Sure, yeah.
[32:06] AJ Shively: And I'm invited to the wedding.
[32:11] Kevin Jaeger: That's incredible.
[32:12] AJ Shively: You know, that's my cousin.
[32:15] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, well done.
[32:16] AJ Shively: But that's that is really cool. That's such a cool thing. Like you are an original cast album like creator of a like a like a musical that found its niche and is like uh classic.
[32:31] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah, that's great.
[32:32] AJ Shively: That's super cool.
[32:33] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, I didn't realize that many high schools were doing it, and that's so it's exciting, and like what a fun, different show for high schools to be able to do because there's a lot of good parts.
[32:33] AJ Shively: There's a lot of good women in that in there, like that as a senior show, like talk about that moment for that senior girl who gets to do that part.
[32:55] Kevin Jaeger: That's what I'm saying. I don't know how many have like that many high schools have that girl that can do it. It's crazy.
[33:00] AJ Shively: That's a Jimmy Award in the making, is that's like it's great. There are there's a part for everyone, it's great.
[33:08] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, and it's kind of bizarre to see with like a huge dancing ensemble, too. It's like, whoa, oh yeah, that bar scene is probably super cool.
[33:17] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah.
[33:18] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, like the the like picnic at the beginning.
[33:21] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah.
[33:22] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[33:23] AJ Shively: I can't imagine extra people typing at the office.
[33:26] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, like yeah.
[33:26] AJ Shively: That the tr the train is packed, packed as well.
[33:32] Kevin Jaeger: Nobody did anything.
[33:34] AJ Shively: How many, how many like high school gay boys are living their best life playing the Jeff Blumencratz part?
[33:40] Kevin Jaeger: Like, there are so many catty high school gays that are like, I live for this part.
[33:46] AJ Shively: Like, the best part is have a height, like what do the high schools do with the suitcase?
[33:55] Kevin Jaeger: Any good magic?
[33:56] AJ Shively: They just throw it into the audience.
[33:58] Kevin Jaeger: No, we used to do that when we were in when we were in San Diego. The mayor would just throw it off into the wings, and like there was someone there to catch it, you know.
[34:08] AJ Shively: So you just like saw the bag and kind of like it the apex of its trajectory as it's wings, and so you were just like, Oh, but seeing like seeing a bag flying and like spinning in air, you're like, that baby's dead.
[34:21] Kevin Jaeger: There's a hundred percent.
[34:25] AJ Shively: I was just about to say that like the baby died.
[34:28] Kevin Jaeger: No, no, and I just want to say that six years later, we're still talking about the baby toss, and that is amazing, and it's the only true thing in the whole show.
[34:39] AJ Shively: That's the only thing that actually happened.
[34:41] Kevin Jaeger: That's yeah, the great thing is like the true story is that the baby lived.
[34:45] AJ Shively: Yeah, the Iron Mountain baby. That's like the that the baby like really badly beat up baby was found in a suitcase next to the train tracks and survived.
[34:55] Kevin Jaeger: But like, that is like life, though. That like the most absurd part that people are like that could never be real is the only real part of the show.
[35:03] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[35:04] Kevin Jaeger: Like, like yeah, you can't write that stuff.
[35:06] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[35:07] Kevin Jaeger: No, seriously, that's cool.
[35:09] AJ Shively: They wrote around, they didn't. So if we wrote that.
[35:11] Kevin Jaeger: Someone would be like, what happened to you that your mind came up with this insane thing?
[35:15] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[35:16] Kevin Jaeger: And it's like the facts.
[35:18] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[35:19] Kevin Jaeger: And that's cool because like well, like Steve Martin gave that quote or whatever when somebody said what it was like to write a musical.
[35:25] AJ Shively: And he said, I've written 37 musicals or whatever, they've all been called Bright Star, like, or whatever number he used.
[35:31] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, that's so funny.
[35:32] AJ Shively: So, like, that's so cool that like in that process, you got to like do 12 different shows.
[35:37] Kevin Jaeger: Four, probably.
[35:39] AJ Shively: Like every album that he and Edie have released together, and it's multiple.
[35:42] Kevin Jaeger: There's like it's three or four now.
[35:44] AJ Shively: Those are all cut from Bright Star.
[35:46] Kevin Jaeger: All the songs are from Bright Star.
[35:48] AJ Shively: And they're all good.
[35:49] Kevin Jaeger: And they're all so good.
[35:51] AJ Shively: They're all so good. Like they cut a song, we'd be like, oh, and then we hear the new song, and we'd be like, ooh.
[35:57] Kevin Jaeger: Ah, okay.
[35:58] AJ Shively: Ah.
[36:00] Kevin Jaeger: That's so cool.
[36:02] AJ Shively: Yeah, what a good show for high schoolers. Also, the production team, like, that's such a you could do anything with that set.
[36:09] Kevin Jaeger: And like it doesn't have to be, you don't have to have like a billiards room and then like a picnic area.
[36:14] AJ Shively: And like you could just do the house and have it flow fling around like an hour town set.
[36:18] Kevin Jaeger: Like you could totally it's a memory play, exactly.
[36:20] AJ Shively: It's all 100%.
[36:22] Kevin Jaeger: Yep.
[36:22] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah.
[36:23] Kevin Jaeger: That's super cool. Here I square is actually kind of like that too. I mean, it's oh yeah, it's involved.
[36:27] AJ Shively: There's automation, let's be clear.
[36:28] Kevin Jaeger: They're like three-story towers coming in and out.
[36:31] AJ Shively: Um, like our saloon unit circles by itself, not by the cast pushing it.
[36:36] Kevin Jaeger: Right.
[36:36] AJ Shively: Wait, do you have do you have any really fun set moments?
[36:40] Kevin Jaeger: Like, do you get to like enter from the third story and like come down crazy or anything?
[36:44] AJ Shively: I never go up high. I like went up high during tech just to like see what it's like up there.
[36:49] AJ Shively: Um, but I get to it during during the like protest during the like riots, I get a pretty cool entrance climbing through the automation and like being delivered into a spotlight downstage.
[37:01] Kevin Jaeger: It's pretty cool.
[37:02] AJ Shively: Yes, it feels powerful.
[37:05] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, I'm so excited. I'm so excited to see it.
[37:08] AJ Shively: Yeah, when it all lines up. Because there's also we're a cast of 40.
[37:11] Kevin Jaeger: So it's like, and we're on the Barrymore, so it's a tiny little theater.
[37:15] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[37:16] Kevin Jaeger: We were trying out in Chicago.
[37:18] AJ Shively: We tried out at the Niederlander, which is like the Barrymore fits inside the auditorium at the time.
[37:25] Kevin Jaeger: Totally.
[37:25] AJ Shively: So we're just we're like blowing the roof off that place.
[37:28] Kevin Jaeger: It's that's amazing.
[37:30] AJ Shively: It's it's it's a fun night.
[37:32] Kevin Jaeger: It's a fun night.
[37:33] AJ Shively: Oh, we're I'm excited to see it.
[37:34] Kevin Jaeger: That's awesome.
[37:35] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[37:36] Kevin Jaeger: So we have a new question that we ask people, and I'm I'm always very excited about it.
[37:41] AJ Shively: We talked about babies, so I'll that's be my segue.
[37:43] Kevin Jaeger: Um thank you.
[37:49] AJ Shively: We talked about babies, that's fine. Is there a show that you would want to age through?
[37:57] Kevin Jaeger: Meaning you could play every single part of it over the course of your lifetime, and you could even backtrack if there's a younger uh part in there. Is it's a show that you'd like to like go all the way through.
[38:07] AJ Shively: Oh man. Well, I mean, like Gavros is like the one that got away. I've wanted to die as Gabrash, my whole life.
[38:16] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, spoiler sing a song.
[38:18] AJ Shively: Oh, sorry, guys. And like there's this cute kid, and like he'll be fine. Totally fine.
[38:29] Kevin Jaeger: You know, yeah, just yeah, so like maybe like Miz. I'm trying to think like what shows had that kind of scope.
[38:35] AJ Shively: Um you would be such a good Marious, yeah.
[38:40] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah, that's another one that's you'd be a really good Marius for sure.
[38:44] AJ Shively: Um you could definitely like Javere, that's what I want to play.
[38:47] Kevin Jaeger: Like maybe maybe Sweeney Todd, like to go from like Toby to Anthony or Anthony to Toby through like maybe a fun beetle to arrive at Sweeney, yeah, at Sweeney, and then just like later on the judge, and then later on you can be the judge.
[39:09] AJ Shively: That's when you you got to the point in your career where you're the and J Shivley as that's Judge Turkey.
[39:17] Kevin Jaeger: Sydney DuPont who plays uh he's he's kind of he's the uh the other new guy in town in Paradise Square.
[39:22] AJ Shively: We keep joking that we're gonna do the revival as the like the mayor and the the reverend.
[39:29] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, oh that's so good.
[39:32] AJ Shively: Cool. Uh should we play a game?
[39:34] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, please.
[39:35] AJ Shively: Oh, absolutely. Um, I have a very weird game because in a weird coincidence of events, I just finished reading uh the second book in a series called The Diviners.
[39:47] AJ Shively: Um, and it's about ghosts in Manhattan in the 20s, but all of these ghosts are yelling at the main character the entire time. Beware, beware, Paradise Square.
[39:57] Kevin Jaeger: What?
[39:57] AJ Shively: And it is about these ghosts that died in the riots.
[40:01] Kevin Jaeger: No, are like coming out of the subway tunnel and like attacking New York.
[40:07] AJ Shively: I gotta read it. It's called The Diviners, and the second book is about ghosts from Paradise Square.
[40:13] Kevin Jaeger: No, seriously, like when I told Kimberly that I was getting like that we were getting tickets to the show, and I was like, Is it about Paradise Square that was in five points in 1863?
[40:21] AJ Shively: And he was like, Yes, yeah, I was so sure everything. Yeah, I was so shocked. So poor. I was so shocked. I knew about uh the story that's specifically a Chinese immigrant ghost. Right. Okay, yes. Um, but she was with like an Irish immigrant, like it was oh, it's a whole melting pot. Dang, it's very spooky. But then there's also like something that was not true, because I there's like mystical elements that clearly was so prepared to read I was so prepared to read Kimberly, like the website, like little like blurb to tell her what it would be about. But she was like, is it about just Reddit to me? And I was like, Are you are you on the website? Like what's happening right now? Like 1863. Yeah, yeah.
Oh I'm well aware. I just finished reading this book, and then I saw all of the like marketing for Paradise Square, and I was like, What a minute. Truly, I had never heard of this before, and it's such like an interesting moment in American history that it is fascinating to me that not every movie is about this. I had such a good education, I had such a good education, and I have never heard of this before. I actually college graduates, like I trained to be a New York City tour guide, and this was not part of like what I learned to be a tour guide, even like it's insane. It's crazy. They've earned it. But we all know what five points is from Gangs of New York, and like there's so much more that happened there.
Yeah, that's like like one booth at the at the restaurant. Yeah, I thought, yeah, I just thought it was all Cameron Diaz with a bad accent. But a great attitude. Um ready to be in that movie. Yeah, I loved that movie. I haven't watched that in a long time. I haven't seen it since it came out, but I loved it as well. Yeah. Maybe now we watch Gangs of New York and then we go see Paradise Square, and then we read a book about ghosts. Yeah, yeah. Um, okay, so I made up a game called Broadway Ghost Stories. Um it's very silly and weird. So in my mind, how this game is going to work. It's just like a thinkabouts it game. Um, you're gonna get two shows. And the idea is that one of these shows has just vacated a theater, and then the next show has come in.
Um, but the ghost of the previous show is still there toying with it. So just think about how one show could haunt the next. Okay. What would what would those characters do to the others? Got it. Um, I don't know if that makes any sense, but Kevin, would you like to try?
[42:52] Kevin Jaeger: I would like to try. Okay. Uh say when on my pile.
[42:56] AJ Shively: When Miss Saigon.
[42:59] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[43:00] AJ Shively: And say when again.
[43:03] Kevin Jaeger: When?
[43:05] AJ Shively: Dear Evan Hansen.
[43:06] Kevin Jaeger: Great. So Miss Saigon has vacated the building and Dear Evan Hansen has moved in. But the first thing that the uh they notice is it's suddenly extremely hot in the theater all the time. And they don't know why, because they're cranking the AC, but they cannot. The stage is just like a tundra of heat. It is just you say that the heat is on. Correct. So it is just the heat is out of control hot. Um, and then Dear Evan Hansen, whatever the boy uh who's playing Evan. I always want to call him Dear of Enhanced, because I always say if you find out you're the new deer of Enhancement, so I never, but when the boy who plays Evan, he keeps moving out to sing waving through the window. But his voice when he sings is a powerful like female belter.
Because I mean Solonga singing waving through a window sounds the main list. That's what I mean. Because that would be just because that show is just that girl belting for just like two and a half hours. So it's just he can't bring out his man belt because the female belt keeps coming out. And then um And it probably sounds great. And then the final thing that haunts them is that whenever they walk out on stage, there is a child that just shows up and clings around their neck while they're trying to do any acting or singing. Um, because that's my other favorite part of Miss Saigon is that like the child who plays Tam, his like main direction is just cling to this woman for dear life and don't let go.
And like women through the past 20 years have just belted their face off with a child holding on their neck. So like Evan's trying to do all his you will be found with a child holding on to him the whole time. That's wonderful and spooky.
[45:00] Bryan Plovsky: Uh Brian, would you like a target?
[45:01] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, sure.
[45:01] Bryan Plovsky: Say when.
[45:03] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, when noises off.
[45:08] Bryan Plovsky: Okay.
[45:08] Kevin Jaeger: That's good.
[45:09] Bryan Plovsky: Say when.
[45:10] Kevin Jaeger: A really good one.
[45:12] Bryan Plovsky: When.
[45:14] Kevin Jaeger: Pacific overtures.
[45:25] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, I think I think that.
[45:28] Kevin Jaeger: So I'm doing it differently.
[45:30] Bryan Plovsky: I think you do.
[45:32] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, wow.
[45:34] Bryan Plovsky: Wow.
[45:34] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[45:35] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, I think you do.
[45:39] Kevin Jaeger: So I think Pacific Overtures haunts noises off.
[45:44] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, interesting.
[45:46] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. There's just someone in a tree.
[45:49] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[45:51] Kevin Jaeger: I this is what I think.
[45:53] Bryan Plovsky: Okay.
[45:53] Kevin Jaeger: This is what I think.
[45:55] Bryan Plovsky: I think that noises off as rehearsing.
[45:59] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[46:00] Bryan Plovsky: And all of a sudden, like they see shadows on the stage from things that like aren't there. And like um uh like pieces of furniture and sets have moved like a half inch here, a full inch there. Um, and it just like no one sees anything. It's like it's you can't prove anything. It just it just and then the the tech gets mad at the actors because they think they're moving stuff and whatnot. So you have all of that. And then the director and the dramaturg are like, something is off here. Like, like I I trust everybody, like something is really weird here. So they go to the library, um, the music, the the theater library at Lincoln's Center, and they they just do some research on like what shows had been there before because they notice that the only there's a missing poster in the lobby, um, because the that's it, and they don't know what what like why is it so they go and they realize that the only poster missing is the Pacific Overtures poster, and what they learn you're making this like a James Wand movie, and I'm so obsessed with it right now.
[47:06] AJ Shively: Like I'm I'm like invested, I'm really interested.
[47:08] Kevin Jaeger: I know, tell us how it's keep I'm I'm so in.
[47:08] AJ Shively: I'm so in.
[47:12] Kevin Jaeger: So they they find I've been watching a lot of horror movies lately.
[47:15] AJ Shively: So they find out that Pacific Overtures, what happened was is that the Pacific Overtures, whatever whatever theater that was, the theater actually burned down. Um and and and during a performance, but the the actors saved the lives of gave their own lives to save the audience members by throwing down the fire curtain so that everyone would be saved except for themselves. Um and they never got to it was it was it was the first preview, and they never got to do uh Pacific Overtures. So they're actually the ghosts of them, and they look at the set and they realize that the set for noises off has been moving to make room for the the set of specific overtures that used to be there.
[48:02] Kevin Jaeger: So what noises off decides to and and as the movie goes on, as it were or the movie The Real Life, whatever we're doing as another element to the game, yeah, yeah, yeah. Sorry, as it goes, you can see where I head is at.
[48:17] AJ Shively: We're all on the edge of our seats, we're into this.
[48:19] Kevin Jaeger: Like the three of us are like living for this story.
[48:23] AJ Shively: As the as this as the real life story, whatever goes on, they actually start seeing the ghosts of the actors getting ready in the dressing rooms, and like, or they see them in the mirror, like behind them, like putting their makeup on, they turn around and there's nobody there. And then opening night of noises off, the director is like, listen, like the just go out there and do your best, and they're on stage, and then the the ghosts of the actors are on stage with them.
[48:55] Kevin Jaeger: Um, and so what happens is is that they end up doing a and the director like hears the ghost of the original director, and what he ends up doing to honor them is they do this revival of noises off that incorporates being haunted and the ghosts as a part of the story so that they can actually they all work together on the stage.
[49:19] AJ Shively: Um and the audiences love it. Um because only the actors can see them, but like it's so real that the audience like can like know something is like magical is happening on there, and that's that's noises off and Pacific Overtures.
[49:35] Kevin Jaeger: And then also follies, also follies.
[49:37] AJ Shively: Also, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[49:41] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, and then when you die, you can go back to the theater and see the other show that was happening.
[49:47] AJ Shively: There's a whole second audience, too.
[49:49] Kevin Jaeger: Well, that's the sequel.
[49:50] AJ Shively: That's yeah, that's the cutscene at the end of the credits.
[49:53] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, that's the after credit sequence.
[49:56] AJ Shively: Oh, in life, the credits of life, yeah.
[49:58] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, right, the credits of life, right?
[50:00] Kevin Jaeger: We we give Brian a hard time on this show when he plays games, but like that was epic.
[50:06] AJ Shively: That was really, really good.
[50:08] Bryan Plovsky: I'm glad it ended so well because yeah, yeah.
[50:11] AJ Shively: I feel nice.
[50:11] Kevin Jaeger: I feel good.
[50:12] AJ Shively: Oh, yeah, I see.
[50:13] Kevin Jaeger: Side question for AJ. AJ, if you were if suddenly the Barrymore starts being haunted and like you start like putting on your makeup and there's like ghosts in the mirror and stuff, would that freak you out, like make it hard to do your job? Or like, are you one of those people that would be like, no, this is super cool. It's like a fun added thing to this experience.
[50:31] AJ Shively: Oh, definitely that. I mean, I guess it depends what they want. I'd be like, oh, what show are you in?
[50:38] Kevin Jaeger: Can you believe they squeezed 40 actors into these dressing rooms?
[50:45] AJ Shively: That's so good.
[50:47] AJ Shively: AJ, would you like a ghost story?
[50:48] AJ Shively: Yes.
[50:49] Kevin Jaeger: All right, say when.
[50:50] AJ Shively: Okay.
[50:51] Kevin Jaeger: When?
[50:53] AJ Shively: Merrily we roll along.
[50:56] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, that's a okay.
[50:57] AJ Shively: Right.
[50:57] Kevin Jaeger: That's a good thing.
[50:59] AJ Shively: When Mac and Mabel.
[51:05] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my gosh.
[51:07] AJ Shively: You know that show at all.
[51:07] Kevin Jaeger: I do not know.
[51:08] AJ Shively: All right, Mac and Mabel and Marily.
[51:10] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[51:10] AJ Shively: Yes.
[51:11] Kevin Jaeger: So wait, which one is which one is haunting which?
[51:17] AJ Shively: Do I choose?
[51:17] Kevin Jaeger: You choose.
[51:18] AJ Shively: I choose.
[51:19] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[51:19] AJ Shively: I think um, I think Mac and Mabel is haunting a brand new production of Merrily where they do they're trying the concept of this production is they're gonna do it in act in like chronological order instead of backwards.
[51:33] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, okay.
[51:34] AJ Shively: It's avant-garde, you know.
[51:36] Kevin Jaeger: It's like it's like, you know, merrily, but now they're gonna do like it's a long roll merrily, you know.
[51:36] AJ Shively: A long roll merrily.
[51:47] Kevin Jaeger: My favorite line is doing merrily we roll along chronologically is avant-car.
[51:54] AJ Shively: I love it.
[51:55] Kevin Jaeger: I love it.
[51:56] AJ Shively: Uh a long roll merrily slayed me.
[52:00] AJ Shively: So for whatever reason though, every time, you know, we're we're not we haven't opened yet. You're like the show's not opened yet. They had to delay because these problems keep happening. As soon as they moved into the theater, they're doing runs, the tech is done, but they can't start previews yet because every time they start the show, um everyone keeps just like falling, like doing these crazy prattfalls. And it's not necessarily on purpose, it's like it's like they're stepping on banana peels, or like, you know, it's really, really weird. And they're trying to do the right thing, you know? They're like at a big fancy party, and somebody they're all dressed up really nicely, and there's a champagne toast, and somebody's playing a grand piano, and then all of a sudden a ladder falls from off stage, and uh everyone's throwing pies at each other, and nobody knows what happened.
So eventually, eventually, the uh the director comes in and he says, you know what we've got to do here is we've got to just strip everything away. We're not gonna have any more set, we're not gonna do costumes. Everyone, you're just gonna wear a t-shirt and it's gonna say your name on the front, the actor's name in the front, and then on the back, in very small text, it's gonna say all of your lines, and we'll have video footage to zoom in on the lines, and we'll just project that you know on the back wall. And uh they did that, and um for whatever reason the the introduction of the cinematic element quieted all of the troubles, and can I tell you the the theater people at New York loved it? They just loved the technological aspect coming in to like a theatrical setting, and they're like, wow, the technology, and you know, and it's a fantastic score too.
[53:47] AJ Shively: So, you know, critics pick, yay.
[53:55] Kevin Jaeger: That was so good.
[53:57] AJ Shively: All right, do I get a ghost story?
[53:59] Kimberly Coops: Yes, yeah, all right, you got AJ say when you are our guest that one susical.
[54:07] AJ Shively: Oh, yes.
[54:09] Kimberly Coops: Already the best.
[54:10] AJ Shively: Sorry the winner.
[54:11] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, I was just saying one more.
[54:14] AJ Shively: Okay.
[54:16] Kimberly Coops: And omalie.
[54:20] AJ Shively: That's really good.
[54:21] Kimberly Coops: That's incredible.
[54:23] AJ Shively: Oh, I don't know which one to make the ghost.
[54:27] Kevin Jaeger: Also, they're both they're both the ghosts of a new work, maybe.
[54:30] AJ Shively: This game is.
[54:33] Kimberly Coops: However, Amelie, I feel would be secretly the most like inventive ghost.
[54:40] AJ Shively: Oh, yeah. I think you should make them both the ghost of a new uh one woman show.
[54:46] Kimberly Coops: Oh my god, I'm obsessed with that.
[54:48] AJ Shively: Yeah. Absolutely.
[54:50] Kimberly Coops: Um who is doing a one-woman show?
[54:53] AJ Shively: Anyone, really?
[54:54] Kimberly Coops: Okay.
[54:56] AJ Shively: Amelie and Sousical are haunting the new work of someone.
[55:01] Kimberly Coops: Of a famous I love that title, The New Work of Someone.
[55:01] AJ Shively: The New Work of Someone.
[55:13] Kimberly Coops: Yeah, run of ART.
[55:14] AJ Shively: In the history of their ghosts, Susical initially um was haunting Amelie's original run.
[55:21] Kimberly Coops: And um the cat in the hat was just like very mischievous, and he would move all the props around, and then he would, you know, that ghost thing where he can get into the body, and he would just like get into Amelie, and she would like wiggle around in a weird way.
[55:37] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah.
[55:38] AJ Shively: Um, and that I remember hearing about that, Philip Assue constantly wiggling all over the show.
[55:42] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, unfortunately, it's why the show closed.
[55:45] AJ Shively: Yeah, absolutely.
[55:47] Kimberly Coops: And it just like it made for some weird reviews, and the show just didn't run.
[55:51] AJ Shively: And so the ghosts of Amelie have a vendetta against the ghosts of Susical.
[55:56] Kimberly Coops: And so the new show is coming into the theater, and they're both there.
[56:01] AJ Shively: Um, and Amelie's ghost is so mad at the cat in the hat for ruining her shot at Broadway.
[56:09] Kimberly Coops: Um, that her ghost is trying to thwart what the cat in the hat is doing to the new show.
[56:16] AJ Shively: So the cat in the hat will like sever a spotlight to fall down, and Amelie's ghost will like throw a set piece over to catch it.
[56:24] Kimberly Coops: And so she's just like the good ghost trying to save, let's say Kristen Channer's one woman show.
[56:33] AJ Shively: Yeah, as Dolly Parton, yes, Dolly Parton.
[56:37] Kimberly Coops: Absolutely.
[56:38] AJ Shively: 100%.
[56:40] Kimberly Coops: Does the Amelie ghost do things like open a cute parasol to like stop the light from falling on her?
[56:45] AJ Shively: Absolutely. But you can't see the ghost, you just see like a parasol, and it's just and it just like crumbles around, and like Kristen Chen is very in tune with the ghost, and she knows something eerie is happening, um, but she's not sure what, since one is protecting her, and then um she does have a seance live with the audience, uh, to sort of get the ghost of the cat in the hat out.
[57:11] Kimberly Coops: Um, but then she is so thankful for the ghost of Amelie, the musical for helping her, you know, survive this run that she lets them do one final ghost performance of Amelie.
[57:24] Kevin Jaeger: How does it go?
[57:25] AJ Shively: I would go to that.
[57:26] Kimberly Coops: Yeah, it goes well.
[57:28] AJ Shively: All the ghosts from all of your other shows are in the audience, and they all have a good time.
[57:33] Kevin Jaeger: Uh I love that.
[57:35] AJ Shively: I love it.
[57:36] Kimberly Coops: Such happy ghost stories.
[57:38] AJ Shively: Yeah.
[57:39] Kimberly Coops: We love a happy ghost.
[57:40] AJ Shively: We love a happy ghost, you know.
[57:42] Kimberly Coops: That was Broadway ghost stories.
[57:44] AJ Shively: That was silly.
[57:44] Kevin Jaeger: That was fun.
[57:47] Kimberly Coops: So AJ, there's there's somewhere that people can see you besides the Broadway, correct?
[57:54] AJ Shively: Oh, yes, yes, in the comfort of their own home, provided they have the right subscription service.
[57:59] Kevin Jaeger: Um okay, that sounds dirty. Can we explain?
[58:01] AJ Shively: It does. So let me go into further detail here. Um I have uh an episode of uh HBO Max's Julia, the Julia Child series premiering um pretty soon.
[58:17] AJ Shively: Pretty soon. Um I play the Julia Julia.
[58:21] AJ Shively: Well, I I was gonna play Julia, but then I felt like I was really busy with Paradise Square and I couldn't get to do both, right?
[58:30] AJ Shively: Andre Saltner, um, who was one of the like first celebrity chefs. Um and yeah, I play uh Julia comes to eat at my restaurant, uh my Michelin rated restaurant, and I'm kind of rude to her in a French accent, no less.
[58:48] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, hey, yes, what is what is your experience with accent work?
[58:54] AJ Shively: Man, um I have always like I don't know, maybe it's connected to singing or something like that, but I've always been really good with accents. Um and uh so the French accent, you know, I I did the audition and it was kind of you know the American's idea of a French accent.
[59:11] AJ Shively: And when I went back and actually looked at footage of the actual person, I was like, oh, that's what that's what he sounds like. Um but um excuse me, I was talking earlier about rehearsal and the rehearsal process and how much I love that, and learning new skills is a huge part of that for me.
[59:25] AJ Shively: So so putting on finding the new accents and making it authentic, you know. I got for Paradise Square, I have an Irish accent, and um uh and a native Irish person thought I was from Ireland, which is like that is the best compliment you could have ever gotten.
[59:42] Kevin Jaeger: Wow.
[59:43] AJ Shively: So good, and so yeah, I do it all the time. When I was on the show, the Amazon show Hunters, um I my character spoke entirely in German, which I do not speak. Um and it's kind of it's a fun, it's a fun challenge for me.
[59:57] AJ Shively: I don't know why. It's I guess it's masochistic and see you don't like if your agent calls you and is like, I have this really great character for you. It's I need a Dutch accent by Monday, like that's exciting to you.
[1:00:09] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah, Dutch would be hard because I don't know any, like mostly I have people I can call and I'm like, hey, give me the inside scoop.
[1:00:17] AJ Shively: Um Dutch would be hard though. Give me the inside scoop on your accent.
[1:00:21] AJ Shively: Yeah, no, that's what I did. I was like, I have a friend who's who's like a native German speaker. So I was like, can you please make a voice memo of all of these lines? And I will learn them phonetically.
[1:00:29] AJ Shively: So I found out later though, um, for hunters, um, my friend did that for me, and I learned phonetically, and I was cast, much to my shock. Um, because it said native like fluent German speaker, and I was like, well, I need some practice, so I'll go oh and then it cast me in the past.
[1:00:51] AJ Shively: Singers are good at that though, because we've like all sung in different languages and like been able to tell the story, even though we don't really know the words.
[1:00:58] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[1:00:59] AJ Shively: 100%. But I found out when I got on set that um the German I had learned to speak was from a like farming rural area, and my character was like a well-educated architect from Berlin.
[1:01:11] Kevin Jaeger: So I had in my audition basically been like, hi y'all, you won't go down here. Well, maybe I'll take out there.
[1:01:19] AJ Shively: Okay.
[1:01:20] Kevin Jaeger: That's incredible.
[1:01:21] AJ Shively: They're like, they're like, it's so cool that you brought like Southern German to the audition.
[1:01:25] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, you do dialects of German. That's cool.
[1:01:27] AJ Shively: And I was like, yeah, we have the best of dialect coaches.
[1:01:34] Kevin Jaeger: That's so awesome.
[1:01:36] AJ Shively: When you do a show like that, like for TV, do they they provide you with a like a coach on set?
[1:01:41] AJ Shively: I mean, but in TV on film sets, it all happens on the day. So you have to show up like having done a lot of work and ready for like when the dialect coaches says things like um my character um at the end of a climactic moment.
[1:01:57] AJ Shively: Um his lines were like, go get away. Like, go now. And so I was saying, like, go now, you know, like we would like elongating it, like, get and uh after the first take the dialect coach he's like hmm, he's like, so in German culture, uh it's more masculine to be clipped.
[1:02:19] AJ Shively: So when you extend things, it reads in a specific sexual way.
[1:02:25] Kevin Jaeger: Interesting.
[1:02:38] AJ Shively: You were like the RuPaul's shrag race of German language.
[1:02:41] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, I'm like, I'm like, and well, and then it's like I'm helping people escape from Auschwitz, so it's not what we're going for.
[1:02:49] AJ Shively: Yeah, that's not the moment to be like, yes, Queen!
[1:02:51] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yes, girl, um, yeah.
[1:02:56] AJ Shively: Oh, that's so interesting to think about.
[1:02:59] Kevin Jaeger: But I love that part, I love it.
[1:03:01] AJ Shively: And I would never would have thought of that. That like that, like something that like in our culture, like that totally go run. Like, for that to be like to do that in a different language, it has a completely different connotation.
[1:03:14] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, that's so interesting.
[1:03:16] AJ Shively: And that's why they hire dialect coaches.
[1:03:19] Kevin Jaeger: That's a money well spent.
[1:03:21] AJ Shively: Yes. But then it gets you, it like makes you understand kind of well, or that that helped me with Paradise Square, because to understand the immigrant experience when like you're out of your culture, so you're doing things that make sense to you and read completely differently, and you have no idea why.
[1:03:37] Kevin Jaeger: You sort of have to figure it out.
[1:03:39] AJ Shively: Um yeah, absolutely.
[1:03:41] AJ Shively: Yeah, it's wild. I'm speaking, I'm speaking Irish, the language Irish in Paradise Square.
[1:03:46] Kevin Jaeger: And I think I think it's the first time Irish has been used in a Broadway musical.
[1:03:52] AJ Shively: Oh, that's fascinating.
[1:03:53] AJ Shively: I sang a Gaelic song in college in a show.
[1:03:56] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah.
[1:03:57] AJ Shively: Um, I think there have been plays that have used used.
[1:04:00] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, or like little bits of it.
[1:04:02] AJ Shively: Um, but Gaelic also is so regional and like everything that like I met with one a professor who spoke Gaelic, and I was like, this is the song, and I've learned it phonetically, and here it is.
[1:04:14] AJ Shively: And he was like, I don't know what any of that means, but uh, it's probably Gaelic.
[1:04:18] Kevin Jaeger: It's probably you just learned like the northern version, and I'm right.
[1:04:21] AJ Shively: Yeah, exactly.
[1:04:22] AJ Shively: Yeah, that's wild. Yeah, well, yeah.
[1:04:25] AJ Shively: My first, my first the first thing I say is Americo Immacri, which means America in my heart.
[1:04:31] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, and it's I don't know.
[1:04:34] AJ Shively: I'm this is how and when my family came to America.
[1:04:38] AJ Shively: Um well, but my mom's side of the family, my dad's side of the family has been here a long time. Um, but uh like this is I'm honoring my ancestors, you know.
[1:04:48] AJ Shively: You know, this is how they got here at this time. They were fleeing the potato famine. They're fleeing the great hunger. Um, and my people just wound up in the Midwest instead of New York.
[1:04:58] Kevin Jaeger: Otherwise, like I would be playing my however many times great grandfather.
[1:05:03] AJ Shively: Sure.
[1:05:04] Kevin Jaeger: So cool.
[1:05:04] AJ Shively: Really cool.
[1:05:05] Kevin Jaeger: So interesting.
[1:05:06] AJ Shively: That's awesome.
[1:05:06] Kevin Jaeger: So check out a Paradise Square.
[1:05:09] AJ Shively: Check out Julia on HBO Max.
[1:05:11] Kevin Jaeger: There's a lot of opportunity to uh see AJ.
[1:05:14] AJ Shively: Um, but AJ, thank you so much for joining us.
[1:05:18] Kevin Jaeger: That springs up the end of our episode.
[1:05:20] AJ Shively: We really appreciate it.
[1:05:22] Kevin Jaeger: We hope that uh you don't forget about this recording like the previous one.
[1:05:27] AJ Shively: I'm doing better this time.
[1:05:29] Kevin Jaeger: Um but in all seriousness, thank you so much for joining us again.
[1:05:33] AJ Shively: Check out Paradise Square, check out Julia on HBO Max.
[1:05:37] Kevin Jaeger: Um you can uh follow us at Broadwaisted uh on all social media.
[1:05:49] AJ Shively: Um, and then of course you can find us, uh follow Kimberly on uh TikTok, um Kimber Coops.
[1:05:49] Kevin Jaeger: Um, and then of course you can find our podcast wherever you get podcasts like Stitchers, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, rate and review us there.
[1:05:57] AJ Shively: Five stars, please.
[1:05:59] Kevin Jaeger: Thank you.
[1:06:01] AJ Shively: Um yeah, we end every episode with a quote, and today it's Camptown Ladies sing that song, duda do that camptown racetrack five miles long.
[1:06:11] AJ Shively: Oh, the douda day.
[1:06:13] Kevin Jaeger: I get to sing this, I get to sing those words on Broadway every night.
[1:06:17] AJ Shively: That's awesome.
[1:06:17] Kevin Jaeger: Yes, I mostly know it from family matters when Urkel sings it, but you know, that's that's you know, same, same similar, right?
[1:06:24] AJ Shively: Same thing.
[1:06:25] Kevin Jaeger: Um in all seriousness, thank you so much for taking the time, AJ.
[1:06:29] AJ Shively: We really appreciate it.
[1:06:31] Kevin Jaeger: Let's do this again in another six years, yeah.
[1:06:33] AJ Shively: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:06:37] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, but in all seriousness, thank you.
[1:06:39] AJ Shively: We raise a glass and we always end with cheers, man.
[1:06:46] All: Cheers.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
