Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Songwriter Series: Noah Weisbart and John Sakelos get Broadwaysted!

It's our first Songwriter Series! Play along as Noah Weisbart (@noahthewisebard) & John Sakelos join Bryan for a beer, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and a 10-minute musical. Check out The Great Fall on YouTube... Read More

From the show: Broadwaysted!

44 mins
9/12/23

About

It's our first Songwriter Series!

Play along as Noah Weisbart (@noahthewisebard) & John Sakelos join Bryan for a beer, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and a 10-minute musical.

Check out The Great Fall on YouTube

Learn more about the BMI Lehman Engel Musical Theatre Workshop HERE.

Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:20] Bryan Plofsky: Hello and welcome to the official Broadwaysted Podcast where we're drunk on theater. I'm your host, Bryan Plofsky, and today we're trying something new. This is the first episode of our songwriter series. Throughout the year, we're going to be chatting with some up-and-coming songwriters and featuring some of their work right here on Broadwaysted. Many of them, like today's guests, Noah Weisbart and John Sakelos, are participants in the BMI Musical Theater Workshop in New York City. I've posted some information on that in the description, along with the YouTube link to Noah and John's work. So let's just jump right in with Noah and John and their 10-minute musical called The Great Fall. Enjoy.

[1:05] Bryan Plofsky: Welcome, gentlemen. Thank you so much for joining me.

[1:08] Noah Weisbart: Glad to be here.

[1:09] John Sakelos: Yeah, thank you.

[1:10] Bryan Plofsky: Awesome. So this is something new that we're doing. This is the songwriter series. Um, we're gonna talk a little bit about you know you two as a working um uh composer and lyricist group. We're you know, songwriters. Um, but I specifically want to talk about your uh 10-minute musical that you presented in the BMI workshop. Um, and I'm super excited to talk about it because I was a huge fan of it when I saw it.

[1:37] John Sakelos: Um yeah, of course, of course.

[1:41] Bryan Plofsky: Before we even get there, um I'd love just for you to do a more you know specific introduction of yourself um in terms of you know what you you um what you focus on um and then a little bit about your partnership. I think that'd be awesome.

[1:55] Noah Weisbart: Well we can't give we can't give you all the secrets.

[2:00] John Sakelos: No, no.

[2:01] Noah Weisbart: Well, we'll yeah, Noah, why don't you go first?

[2:03] Noah Weisbart: Uh well, we are uh a musical theater writing team. Uh what would you say we specialize in?

[2:11] John Sakelos: Musical comedy know-how.

[2:13] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[2:14] John Sakelos: So that's a fair to focus on.

[2:17] Noah Weisbart: I'd say that's a fair assessment. But we met at the University of Michigan.

[2:22] John Sakelos: We certainly did.

[2:23] Noah Weisbart: We both were there studying musical theater.

[2:25] Bryan Plofsky: And I didn't realize that you were Michigan alums.

[2:28] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, go ahead.

[2:31] John Sakelos: We are.

[2:33] Noah Weisbart: All right, calm down.

[2:36] John Sakelos: We were at Notre Dame.

[2:37] Noah Weisbart: I'm embarrassed already.

[2:38] John Sakelos: No embarrassment.

[2:39] Noah Weisbart: I was not at Emerson.

[2:40] John Sakelos: I was at some of them.

[2:41] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[2:42] John Sakelos: I was at that Notre Dame game.

[2:43] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, for the halftime shows.

[2:45] John Sakelos: Yeah, that was mainly what I was.

[2:47] Noah Weisbart: There was this like Beyoncé message on the jumbotron.

[2:51] John Sakelos: That was the most exciting part of the game.

[2:54] Noah Weisbart: It was amazing.

[2:55] John Sakelos: Yeah, Noah left after that.

[2:56] Noah Weisbart: After that, I did.

[2:58] John Sakelos: I literally did.

[2:59] Noah Weisbart: I was I was but we met there. I was Noah's RA, sort of.

[3:03] John Sakelos: Sort of, kind of, yeah.

[3:05] Noah Weisbart: While I tell the story. But I didn't want to uh rat anybody out on my floor, so I got fired from being an RA.

[3:12] John Sakelos: But the partnership lasted.

[3:17] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, you were too busy like uh practicing, you know, singing through Sondheim to actually get anyone in trouble for uh That was Noah.

[3:25] John Sakelos: That was me.

[3:26] Noah Weisbart: That was me. I was probably in the library.

[3:29] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah. I can should I tell the story of how we met?

[3:37] Noah Weisbart: I think I should.

[3:38] John Sakelos: No, no, I don't want you to give it a story.

[3:39] Noah Weisbart: No, I don't want you to tell that story.

[3:41] John Sakelos: It's a good story.

[3:42] Bryan Plofsky: Were you performance majors or were you?

[3:45] John Sakelos: Yes, we already were BFA musical theater majors.

[3:49] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[3:49] John Sakelos: Cool.

[3:50] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, I loved uh every minute at Michigan, learned a lot. And I definitely in the writing, we use a lot of what we learn.

[3:58] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah. You know.

[4:00] Noah Weisbart: So it was a great education.

[4:01] John Sakelos: I'm sure.

[4:02] Noah Weisbart: Agreed. Noah, after, well, Noah will tell you what he did, but after I graduated, I left and got a master's degree in Shakespeare. And then I kind of my career kind of took that turn in the professional uh actor realm. I did more Shakespeare than musical theater. I did a fair amount of both though. I always found a niche as the classical actor who could sing. So if they needed a bard to sing a song or something, that was kind of my way in.

[4:30] Noah Weisbart: And John started gigging a lot.

[4:33] John Sakelos: Yeah, you did.

[4:34] Noah Weisbart: Like I did a lot of bandwidth.

[4:35] John Sakelos: You did work with it.

[4:37] Noah Weisbart: I got foot surgery.

[4:38] John Sakelos: Stop lying.

[4:41] Noah Weisbart: I after I graduated from college, I got foot surgery.

[4:44] John Sakelos: Yeah, but then you giggled band for the fish.

[4:46] Noah Weisbart: No, then COVID happened.

[4:48] John Sakelos: But you before that, you can tell your own story.

[4:53] Noah Weisbart: The uh yeah, I had I was born with flat feet. And uh after college, I moved to the city and was living with some friends in Brooklyn trying to like audition and do that kind of you know musical theater thing. And but I it was just such a struggle because I was having a lot of pain, you know, in my feet when I would just like walk around all the time.

[5:18] John Sakelos: Plus my perfect choice to play Tiny Tim.

[5:20] Noah Weisbart: Yeah at my Josh. And then um. But so I decided to have foot surgery in like 2018 uh to correct the problem. And that took two years of my life, during which we wrote a musical. And then I was getting ready to move back to the city, and then in 2020, and then COVID happened.

[5:47] John Sakelos: And yeah, I ended up uh staying in.

[5:51] Noah Weisbart: I was living with my parents to uh to to coalesce, you know, to uh con convalescence.

[5:59] John Sakelos: And uh but they coalesced as a family.

[6:01] Noah Weisbart: We did coalesce.

[6:03] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah, yeah. My uh my parents are musicians too.

[6:07] Noah Weisbart: Um, cool.

[6:08] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah, yeah. My parents were wedding singers for many years. Uh but uh now they had a and they had a horseradish commercial on the radio for a long time. They still it still plays every every Peso Gold's horseradish.

[6:20] Noah Weisbart: Yep, yep, yep. If it's gotta be great, it's gotta be gold.

[6:25] John Sakelos: If it's gotta be great, it's gotta be gold.

[6:29] Noah Weisbart: Um I have definitely heard that.

[6:31] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah. That's my parents.

[6:33] Noah Weisbart: And every time you heard it, Noah's parents made a nickel.

[6:35] John Sakelos: That's my parents.

[6:36] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, yeah. Well, that's great. I'd rather give them a nickel than the cars for kids' kids.

[6:40] John Sakelos: Oh my god, that jingle, that jingle, oh my god.

[6:45] Noah Weisbart: The the miss accent on donate your car today, it kills me every time.

[6:45] John Sakelos: Donate your car.

[6:52] Noah Weisbart: I'm like, but I love it. I I'm obsessed. It's my spirit animal. But so yeah, then uh But the main thing that happened is we wrote a musical.

[7:03] John Sakelos: Right, that's the main thing.

[7:04] Noah Weisbart: We wrote a musical, and we wrote mostly all through college.

[7:08] John Sakelos: So I was gonna ask, you were writing together in college, just kind of like on the side while you got your BFA, and then it kind of turned into something more real and tangible as a partnership, you know, in that time when you decided to write the musical.

[7:21] Noah Weisbart: Not the one we're talking about today, but a different one, correct?

[7:23] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[7:24] Noah Weisbart: Well, there were many failed attempts before that.

[7:26] John Sakelos: Oh yeah.

[7:27] Noah Weisbart: We have quite a few half-written musicals on a show.

[7:30] John Sakelos: Yes, yes.

[7:31] Noah Weisbart: Not even half.

[7:32] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[7:33] Noah Weisbart: Gunga Din the music.

[7:34] John Sakelos: Yeah, that was the first idea.

[7:36] Noah Weisbart: Which is a poem by Rudyard Kipling. I highly recommend it, but not uh not suitable for.

[7:41] John Sakelos: We just figured that we didn't know enough about Imperial India to write a full musical about it.

[7:50] Noah Weisbart: Um then there was uh we had then there was the Hunley, the the which is the first successful submarine launch, uh submarine mission in which was in the Civil War.

[8:05] John Sakelos: Um But unfortunately it was our Confederate side our heroes would have had to be in Confederate You just can't write around just like who was fair who's gonna go see that.

[8:16] Noah Weisbart: So then we decided on a much lighter topic, which was uh the Armenian genocide.

[8:23] John Sakelos: Yes.

[8:24] Noah Weisbart: Of course, when I think of light subjects, yeah. When I think of an easy Sunday matinee in New York, I I think Armenian Genocide music.

[8:32] John Sakelos: And it's what's great about that musical, which I won't give it all away, but it's uh familial story of Noah's. Noah is of Armenian descent. The uh it's it's a story that my my grandfather told me of of how his father escaped the uh escaped the Armenian genocide and then and then came to America.

[8:52] Noah Weisbart: So it's that's amazing. And it sort of follows like, yeah, so it follows like my great grandfather and great grandmother as they escape and then find each other and find love and home and family and rebuild their their lives after the world.

[9:09] John Sakelos: Now they won't see it because you told them the whole story.

[9:12] Noah Weisbart: No, there's so there's a lot more there's a lot more to it than that.

[9:15] John Sakelos: No, no, no. I think that that would make people want to see it more.

[9:21] Bryan Plofsky: Do you want to be a producer, Bryan?

[9:24] Noah Weisbart: Sure.

[9:25] John Sakelos: Great.

[9:25] Bryan Plofsky: Gentlemen, it's called marketing.

[9:31] Noah Weisbart: Um that's fantastic. So then you you basically then you applied for the BMI program, got in, and then I, you know, that's where I got to know you two and your work throughout the whole year. Um, and uh, and then the the as we all know, and and by as we all know, I'm telling you now, at the end that first year workshop culminates in a 10-minute musical that you write. It could be anything. There are no um, there are really no guidelines for it. It just needs to be uh 10 minutes or at least under 12 minutes, and um, so and then we got to see yours. We're gonna play it here, a demo of it in just a moment. Um, but I I do, you know, before we listen to it, it's called The Great Fall. Um, before we listen to it in in its entirety, my question for you is like, where do you start?

Do you start with lyrics? Do you start with um you know music? Uh because Noah, you're you're you're in charge of the music in essence, and then John lyrics and and you both work on story and stuff like that. I guess like where do you start once the idea is formulated, like where do the two of you in your process start from?

[10:35] Noah Weisbart: It's different. We we start with the outline.

[10:37] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[10:39] Noah Weisbart: Um that is always the first the first step after like the idea itself is coming up in the next one.

[10:46] John Sakelos: Which is usually at least a hundred times before we decide, okay, this is what we're outlining.

[10:52] Noah Weisbart: Right.

[10:52] John Sakelos: Yeah, we try to we try to work really based around the hero's journey, you know, just like classic Joseph Campbell type stuff.

[11:01] Noah Weisbart: Um It's like he's like the Bob Ross for storytelling.

[11:06] John Sakelos: Right, exactly.

[11:07] Noah Weisbart: It's like here's the tools now, just like use them.

[11:12] John Sakelos: Very familiar.

[11:13] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[11:15] John Sakelos: Yes.

[11:19] Noah Weisbart: For this one, it was sort of just well, I don't want to say too much off of the Well, we'll give it away if we give it away.

[11:30] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah.

[11:31] Noah Weisbart: We give too much about how the idea was. But it's safe to say we came, we we were like three weeks out, and we were like, okay, we need to decide on an idea right now.

[11:39] John Sakelos: This is we really did, we really did.

[11:42] Noah Weisbart: Um I actually came up with it at uh at Soundbites, the uh the musical theater at the 10-minute musical festival.

[11:50] John Sakelos: Which we'll be applying to with this probably next year.

[11:54] Noah Weisbart: Next year. Well, let's, you know what? Let's uh let's let's play it. I think it'll benefit the conversation if we play it. So um here is uh Noah and John's The Great Fall.

[12:20] ♪ Musical number: "The Great Fall" — performed by Noah Weisbart and John Sakelos ♪

[15:52] Noah Weisbart: Humpty hump the Queen?

[15:54] John Sakelos: Shh.

[15:58] Noah Weisbart: What's that got to do with the price of eggs in China?

[16:00] John Sakelos: Just tailored.

[16:02] Noah Weisbart: Find out if the sponsors is true.

[16:05] John Sakelos: And if it is, whack it.

[16:08] Noah Weisbart: But make sure the queen doesn't find off.

[16:10] John Sakelos: You got it, boss.

[16:12] Noah Weisbart: We're on the case.

[16:26] John Sakelos: What a dump.

[16:27] Noah Weisbart: So what is the queen doing in a place like this?

[16:32] John Sakelos: What can I do for you boys?

[16:35] Noah Weisbart: You see an old boy gentleman come through here.

[16:39] John Sakelos: You mean Humpty?

[16:41] Noah Weisbart: Everyone's scrambling to get a hold of you.

[16:45] John Sakelos: Ratzer room on the second floor.

[16:47] Noah Weisbart: Third door on the right.

[16:48] John Sakelos: We can't miss it.

[16:48] Noah Weisbart: Thanks, Bird.

[16:52] John Sakelos: This is the one.

[16:53] Noah Weisbart: Oh where'd you get that stethoscope?

[16:57] John Sakelos: Oh, my Guma's a PA.

[16:59] Noah Weisbart: A what?

[17:01] John Sakelos: A physician assistant.

[17:03] Noah Weisbart: What's that?

[17:04] John Sakelos: Like uh nurse?

[17:05] Noah Weisbart: It's a mid-level care provider.

[17:12] John Sakelos: Oh humpty.

[17:14] Noah Weisbart: Oh, we cracked the case.

[17:15] John Sakelos: Let's get out of here before we get made.

[17:18] Noah Weisbart: But we're already made.

[17:20] John Sakelos: Not that kind of mage, you idiot.

[17:23] Noah Weisbart: Let's just go and we'll catch up to Humpty when he's alone.

[17:28] John Sakelos: Finally.

[17:30] Noah Weisbart: Some alone time.

[17:33] John Sakelos: Here I am a sittin' on the wall.

[17:37] Noah Weisbart: This is my favorite spot to escape from it all.

[17:41] John Sakelos: Cherishing each moment in the sun.

[17:44] Noah Weisbart: Ignoring all the things I haven't done.

[17:48] John Sakelos: When I'm up here sitting on the wall, down below my problems seems so small.

[17:55] Noah Weisbart: Gosh, I feel so calm and so serene.

[17:58] John Sakelos: Just soaking in the sunny summer sea.

[18:06] Noah Weisbart: So when I'm feeling low, I come up here to clear my head.

[18:12] John Sakelos: Cause it's the highest place I know.

[18:16] Noah Weisbart: Here I am sitting on the wall.

[18:20] John Sakelos: I can almost taste adventures.

[18:22] Noah Weisbart: Call breezes, passing trees and grasses sway.

[18:27] John Sakelos: It's such a beautiful day.

[18:30] Noah Weisbart: Actually, it's getting kinda hot.

[18:32] John Sakelos: Ooh, I'm boiling.

[18:36] Noah Weisbart: Here I am securely on this wall.

[18:39] John Sakelos: This is my favorite spot to escape from it all.

[18:43] Noah Weisbart: Wonder what my future has in store.

[18:46] John Sakelos: But being on this rampart, who could really want for more?

[18:50] Noah Weisbart: When I'm up here lounging on this ledge, I love to let my legs hang off the edge.

[18:57] John Sakelos: I can hear the birds' delightful song.

[19:01] Noah Weisbart: It kinda makes me wanna sing along.

[19:17] John Sakelos: But I am safe.

[19:24] Noah Weisbart: Way up high atop this sturdy wall.

[19:28] John Sakelos: Down below I see the kingdom sprawl.

[19:31] Noah Weisbart: Children are playing, donkeys are praying.

[19:35] John Sakelos: It's such a beautiful day to be alive.

[19:53] Noah Weisbart: Humpty, we gotta talk to you.

[19:56] John Sakelos: Humpty, you gonna explain it to do.

[19:59] Noah Weisbart: Humpty, there's no way to hide.

[20:02] John Sakelos: Tell us the truth of your pride.

[20:05] Noah Weisbart: Humpty, you better listen up.

[20:08] John Sakelos: We know all about what happened down in Goose's palm.

[20:11] Noah Weisbart: The queen was there.

[20:12] John Sakelos: Ahead disguised in a button.

[20:15] Noah Weisbart: Oh, Humpty, there's no way to run.

[20:34] John Sakelos: So he admits this is easier than interrogating Pinocchio.

[20:39] Noah Weisbart: But what's happened to her?

[20:40] John Sakelos: Ah, it's not what's happened to her.

[20:42] Noah Weisbart: It's what's gonna happen to you.

[20:45] John Sakelos: Let's just say it's this situation with gravity.

[20:51] Noah Weisbart: Humpty, you're a no-good bum.

[20:54] John Sakelos: You don't fuck the boss's wife where we come from.

[20:59] Noah Weisbart: We're up really high.

[21:00] John Sakelos: Let's see if it ain't funny.

[21:03] Noah Weisbart: Humpty.

[21:04] John Sakelos: Humpty, you think you're slick.

[21:06] Noah Weisbart: You're out until you call, you know, you make me sick.

[21:09] John Sakelos: Humpty Dumpty, I'll tell you for the um team um day um tea dumpty.

[21:09] Noah Weisbart: You gotta baby a cry it fellas I didn't fuck anybody you guys got this all wrong.

[21:09] John Sakelos: Oh this is funny here wait I can prove it to you.

[21:09] Noah Weisbart: Um I'm still alive I need help please nobody I have a family I fell on the blacktop and it's a particularly hot day I can expire call my mother.

[21:09] John Sakelos: Shh there there it's over Easy bad it was the humane thing to do.

[21:09] Noah Weisbart: You wanna flip anyhow?

[22:52] John Sakelos: Make sure you get all those pieces of shell.

[22:55] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, we really peppered him up.

[22:58] John Sakelos: And the casings, the casings, we can't have this coming back to us.

[23:02] Noah Weisbart: Oh god.

[23:04] John Sakelos: Oh, what a mess.

[23:07] Noah Weisbart: Oh, and and his bag.

[23:09] John Sakelos: Right.

[23:12] Noah Weisbart: What's this?

[23:13] John Sakelos: Oh god.

[23:19] Noah Weisbart: Like it never happened.

[23:22] John Sakelos: I found his phone.

[23:24] Noah Weisbart: Oh jeez.

[23:25] John Sakelos: Okay.

[23:26] Noah Weisbart: Oh, click.

[23:28] John Sakelos: Oh.

[23:29] Noah Weisbart: Hi, Dr. Dumpty. I'm telling you schedule the Queen's next chiropractic appointment, and I'm just wondering what time do you have available?

[23:35] John Sakelos: Also, with the leak in your office fixed yet, she doesn't like meeting at that inn.

[23:39] Noah Weisbart: Oh no!

[23:43] John Sakelos: I've uh gone away!

[23:45] Noah Weisbart: Vacation in the south of France!

[23:48] John Sakelos: Oh a vacation for how long?

[23:52] Noah Weisbart: Can't say for sure!

[23:54] John Sakelos: Well, is Gerald with you?

[23:57] Noah Weisbart: Um uh no really I thought for sure you would have taken your husband with you.

[24:08] John Sakelos: So he never shook the queen?

[24:11] Noah Weisbart: I don't think so, Dummy.

[24:13] John Sakelos: Look, cheat the we did a bad thing.

[24:18] Noah Weisbart: Humpty Dumpty I don't know what to say.

[24:24] John Sakelos: I never knew you was a chiropractor gay.

[24:37] Noah Weisbart: We'll never put you back together again.

[25:12] John Sakelos: That was I don't think people were expecting that based on the title.

[25:15] Noah Weisbart: And I will say that when we presented that in first of all, it's spectacular.

[25:19] John Sakelos: Congratulations.

[25:20] Noah Weisbart: It's such a hard thing to do.

[25:23] John Sakelos: But when you presented it, you handed out a program that really was just a picture of a piano being held by scaffolding.

[25:33] Noah Weisbart: And people didn't know, and your songs don't give anything away to song titles.

[25:36] John Sakelos: And uh and then it starts, and and literally you had the whole entire audience and stitches deeply captivated and very much engaged.

[25:45] Noah Weisbart: So now let's get into the specifics.

[25:48] John Sakelos: How did you come up with this idea?

[25:49] Noah Weisbart: Where the songs come from.

[25:51] John Sakelos: Let's talk a little bit about that.

[25:53] Noah Weisbart: Well, first thing I have to give Noah credit for is the picture.

[25:57] John Sakelos: Because I had nothing to do with the program.

[26:05] Noah Weisbart: He was like, exactly.

[26:09] John Sakelos: And I always I give him credit because so often in the theater you'll look at a playbill and you'll be like reading the songs, and you'll know the whole story.

[26:16] Noah Weisbart: Just based on the song title.

[26:18] John Sakelos: Totally sings them.

[26:19] Noah Weisbart: And it's like, I don't need to be here anymore.

[26:21] John Sakelos: Because I know they're gonna get together, and you know, the denouement is gonna be a wedding scene or whatever.

[26:26] Noah Weisbart: Because they named it wedding bells.

[26:28] John Sakelos: So you know, I have to give Noah a lot of credit on that.

[26:31] Noah Weisbart: It's true.

[26:31] John Sakelos: Like in uh in uh in not to bring it to to another show, but like to in bad Cinderella in the programs, they actually have like Prince Charming listed, and they kind of tease that like he's out there, but like he they think he's presumed dead, but he's listed like in a song, like deep into act two, and you're like, I know that he's alive, like this is ridiculous.

[26:57] Noah Weisbart: So my nerd, my so my nerd example is that um I'm pretty sure before The Phantom Menace came out, the um soundtrack for the Phantom Menace came out, and one of the tracks was called The Death of Qui-Gon.

[27:11] John Sakelos: Oh no, no, it was like I was like, this me as a 13-year-old boy was like, what the like why would you do this?

[27:21] Noah Weisbart: And that's the only good scene in that in that Star Wars is Kai Gonz.

[27:25] John Sakelos: Oh man, it's like the pod race.

[27:27] Noah Weisbart: I like the pod race.

[27:28] John Sakelos: Listen.

[27:29] Noah Weisbart: But yeah, so this idea, it was it was Noah's idea was the initial idea.

[27:34] John Sakelos: And that so yeah, we were so I was at Soundbites, and I was just thinking, like, alright, what are the ones that I'm enjoying the most?

[27:41] Noah Weisbart: And it's just like it came to me like, okay, it's the ones that are just absurd.

[27:47] John Sakelos: And then I thought, like, what's a completely ridiculous story that we could do realistically in 10 minutes?

[27:53] Noah Weisbart: And I just thought, yeah, hump the dumpy work.

[27:56] John Sakelos: Yeah, sure.

[27:57] Noah Weisbart: And I agree.

[27:58] John Sakelos: The the you have to, if you only have 10 minutes to captivate an audience, you really can't be so life true to life, real life.

[28:05] Noah Weisbart: Right.

[28:06] John Sakelos: Because then what's the payoff?

[28:07] Noah Weisbart: You only have 10 minutes.

[28:08] John Sakelos: Yeah, so you gotta go ridiculous.

[28:10] Noah Weisbart: Just go ridiculous.

[28:11] John Sakelos: So you also you also cut down on exposition by choosing an IP that people already know.

[28:16] Noah Weisbart: Right, right.

[28:17] John Sakelos: Exactly.

[28:19] Noah Weisbart: Exactly.

[28:20] John Sakelos: Important.

[28:20] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[28:20] John Sakelos: You don't want to introduce characters, introduce the world.

[28:23] Noah Weisbart: That takes 25 minutes in a in a long form music.

[28:26] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[28:26] Noah Weisbart: But so I pitched this idea to John.

[28:29] John Sakelos: Um, and we're, you know, we're sitting there.

[28:32] Noah Weisbart: He had had this idea that we've been talking about for a while, of like a uh a 10-minute play that you were gonna write about uh a prisoner exchange of dogs between George Washington and General Core Wallis, which did actually happen.

[28:48] John Sakelos: I thought it was General Howe.

[28:49] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, how, how, how it was General Howe.

[28:51] John Sakelos: Yeah, you're right.

[28:52] Noah Weisbart: But yeah, but say, whatever.

[28:53] John Sakelos: Anyway, but the point is we we came up with the idea that alright, so Humpty Dumpty is funny, but nothing.

[29:09] John Sakelos: And from that came the show.

[29:14] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, but it's kind of it's brilliant in that like you choose characters that people already know in terms of fairy tale.

[29:19] John Sakelos: On the flip side of that, you're choosing kind of a sub-genre, if you will, like that like Rundin' Land gangster thing that people already have internalized.

[29:28] Noah Weisbart: Yes. And so, like, you're creating something new while setting the expectations and using their own judgments, you know, in service of the piece.

[29:36] John Sakelos: Yeah, and you only have 10 minutes.

[29:38] Noah Weisbart: So that's yeah, that's that's why you gotta you every line has to pay dividends. Every every bit of text, every song, every melody, it has to pay dividends because you don't have time to frivolously spend. Every line is either the setup to a joke or it's the punchline.

[29:55] John Sakelos: Yeah. Now, when you're going through this, did you write this chronologically? Did you skip around? Did something come too much easier than something else?

[30:04] Noah Weisbart: We wrote an outline and we fill in the outline. So it will know like, okay, scene one, we have to have a scene that accomplishes this with this song that does this. But if we're having trouble writing it, we'll go to scene two or three.

[30:16] John Sakelos: Right, right. The idea was to establish the was to start with the love song, you know, to like to just like establish it.

[30:23] Noah Weisbart: Like, okay, yeah, the queen can establish this whole thing. We can do it really easily. Like, we give her a couple of lines to just like set up the world. Okay, I need this, I need this, I need this, whatever.

[30:34] John Sakelos: And then she sings a love song to Humpty Dumpty. Um, and then uh But I think the first song that we actually like wrote was the duet.

[30:37] Noah Weisbart: The duet.

[30:45] John Sakelos: Our song.

[30:45] Noah Weisbart: Our song.

[30:46] John Sakelos: The yeah, the song for Tweedledee and Tweedledum.

[30:49] Noah Weisbart: Which is just a lot of giggles and improvisation.

[30:52] John Sakelos: Yeah, because it's just like you're threatening Humpty, you know, that was the core concept of the show.

[30:58] Noah Weisbart: So that was like where we started for this one was just like, okay, we're threatening, we're gonna push you off the wall.

[31:04] John Sakelos: And then as it took shape, we realized, well, now the audience is expecting us to push him off the wall. So wouldn't it be more interesting if he actually just falls?

[31:15] Noah Weisbart: Um Sure.

[31:17] John Sakelos: And then we came up with the side.

[31:18] Noah Weisbart: And yeah, there's I don't know. It's it's kind of snowballed.

[31:22] John Sakelos: Yeah, for sure. I guess my question then is, um, uh, so I have two questions.

[31:27] Noah Weisbart: Uh, the first one is did writing kind of that mission song, if you will, like the main idea that you had that kind of blossomed into this entire 10 minutes. Did writing that first song do for you two, does that like light a fuse that like allows you to kind of like be creatively, you know, um excited and and get into the other ones?

[31:49] John Sakelos: Um, or do you still find that like oh wow, we wrote this one so quickly because it was just inside of us and had to come out, but then you get to other ones that's like I'm just like stuck, even though we're excited about this piece.

[32:00] Noah Weisbart: That happens all the time. I mean, yeah, it's like we I mean some songs come out in like 45 minutes, and you're like, all right, let's go grab a slice of pizza and call it a day.

[32:08] John Sakelos: And then other songs will go back and forth uh for weeks, weeks, weeks, weeks, years even.

[32:15] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, yeah. No, not done.

[32:17] John Sakelos: Yeah. And we're also I Noah and I uh we're at a point in our partnership, we've been writing together 10 years.

[32:17] Noah Weisbart: 10 years.

[32:24] John Sakelos: So I mean, all the all the uh frivolous stuff is is put to the side. It's like we we go at it.

[32:30] Noah Weisbart: So it's like, you know, is this in service of the peace? And sometimes we don't agree, and we just have to have many times, yeah, often we don't agree.

[32:39] John Sakelos: Yeah, we just argue until it's done.

[32:42] Noah Weisbart: That's yeah.

[32:43] John Sakelos: Well, with those 10 years, you have to assume that like you know, each year is one minute, and that makes a 10 minute musical.

[32:49] Noah Weisbart: It's exactly correct.

[32:50] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[32:51] Noah Weisbart: So in 60 years.

[32:54] John Sakelos: We'll have our first one act on Broadway.

[32:57] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[32:59] John Sakelos: By that math.

[33:02] Noah Weisbart: And then did you write a list of egg puns?

[33:06] John Sakelos: Or like how like would you have like a master list, or are you just like whenever you saw the opportunity, you just like you worked it out?

[33:12] Noah Weisbart: Whenever, yeah, the second one. We were just like, we just came up with them like just organically.

[33:22] John Sakelos: And then um, you know, they we just sort of figured out like, okay, we can work this in here, we can work that in there.

[33:29] Noah Weisbart: Like, all right, I really want to try to get you know cracked in there somewhere or scramble scramble, like we just figure out you know how it all they were all excellent.

[33:39] John Sakelos: Oh, thank you, thank you.

[33:41] Noah Weisbart: Um yeah, I guess like when it comes to this, um your work is very, very fun, and I think that you have a very specific point of view, and it really captures the energy of the two of you.

[33:53] John Sakelos: Um, you know, what what were you really proud of about this piece?

[33:58] Noah Weisbart: And what is something that you're excited to um edit or or or or reshame?

[34:05] John Sakelos: Well, I'm always most proud of the laughs, yeah.

[34:08] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, because it's instant gratification, and it's it I feel like it is harder to write comedy than tragedy.

[34:16] John Sakelos: I mean, that's just such painting with a lot of broad strokes, but I think comedy is a lot more like a science than people realize.

[34:23] Noah Weisbart: And when it and and you're taking a I feel like a risk because you know what's funny to you, is it funny to them?

[34:31] John Sakelos: Like will they laugh?

[34:32] Noah Weisbart: 30 seconds into the show when the queen says Humpty Dumpty for the first time. If we don't get a laugh there, we're dead.

[34:36] John Sakelos: We're dead in the water, completely in the water.

[34:41] Noah Weisbart: Absolutely fucked.

[34:42] John Sakelos: So, you know, we're like, okay.

[34:45] Noah Weisbart: We yeah, we but but the laughs for me at least.

[34:48] John Sakelos: I I I can't speak for Noah, but they're the most gratified.

[34:51] Noah Weisbart: I would I would say so.

[34:53] John Sakelos: I mean, and we had a good audience that night.

[34:55] Noah Weisbart: We had a yeah, and it's just a great and a great cast.

[34:57] John Sakelos: I'm proud of our cast.

[34:58] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, we had a very I mean I'm very happy with you know everybody's work, and I'm I I'm just very thankful to them to you know do that work for us, you know, completely unpaid.

[35:10] John Sakelos: And we're excited, and we're excited to edit it and then hopefully pay them if we could get it into a festival.

[35:15] Noah Weisbart: That would be great.

[35:16] John Sakelos: Which is next up.

[35:18] Noah Weisbart: Uh and then also uh we were really shopping around for a producer.

[35:23] John Sakelos: So if anybody who's listening to this who has a spare half a million dollars they want to invest in a in a startup musical.

[35:31] Noah Weisbart: I know some people keep that in their sock drawer, so I'm told.

[35:33] John Sakelos: What would we edit on it though?

[35:36] Noah Weisbart: I think our musical or the Humpty Dumpty, Humpty Dumpty.

[35:39] John Sakelos: I I'm thinking like I mean, I have thought about like the possibility of expanding it a little bit into like not like a full, I don't think it would be funny, funny for a feature length thing, but like maybe like 20 to 30 minutes it could work.

[35:56] Noah Weisbart: Maybe you give the queen a little bit more of uh resolution at the end.

[36:01] John Sakelos: I don't know.

[36:03] Noah Weisbart: Unless you incorporate another fairy tale story, like well, yeah.

[36:06] John Sakelos: This would be this would be like the B plot in something much larger.

[36:10] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, right.

[36:10] John Sakelos: You give you give Mother Goose uh, you know, more of a you give Mother Goose a song, you give the king more of a song at the top, you give um, you know, a a resolution to the king and queen plot line, because that was the one thing that you know was sort of unresolved.

[36:29] Noah Weisbart: It's like, oh my god, she's in love with him, but now he's now he's dead and we don't get to see her mourn.

[36:36] John Sakelos: Well, she'll she'll grieve.

[36:37] Noah Weisbart: Like the like I know.

[36:39] John Sakelos: Like the um what's that scene in Death of a Salesman where where Linda's at the grave at the end?

[36:45] Noah Weisbart: It's like Are you comparing Humpty Dumpty to Death of a Salesman?

[36:49] John Sakelos: Well, this is the good stuff.

[36:51] Noah Weisbart: This is what I we look for on Broadway.

[36:53] John Sakelos: Those those very accurate comparisons.

[36:54] Noah Weisbart: I think they could be done as a uh double bill.

[36:57] John Sakelos: If I'm being honest.

[36:58] Noah Weisbart: Well, yeah, I think that like at a summer stock, that's a perfect, perfect um uh two shows to kind of do in rap.

[37:04] John Sakelos: And and obviously Death of a Salesman would open for us.

[37:07] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, yeah, yeah, of course.

[37:09] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[37:10] Noah Weisbart: And actually, and actually they use the same costume, so Willie Lohman's in an egg suit.

[37:16] John Sakelos: Which is fantastic actually a fantastic metaphor.

[37:19] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, it just represents how fragile he actually is.

[37:22] John Sakelos: You know, somebody's gonna do that and win some sort of award after listening to you, and the times is gonna be.

[37:27] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, I know, it's still my idea.

[37:28] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[37:29] Noah Weisbart: The metaphorical allegory of Willie Loman.

[37:31] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[37:32] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, yeah.

[37:32] John Sakelos: It's all just a fairy tale.

[37:33] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[37:34] John Sakelos: Egg attention must be.

[37:35] Noah Weisbart: It's a fairy tale of the American dream.

[37:40] John Sakelos: Yeah, yeah.

[37:43] Noah Weisbart: So yeah.

[37:43] John Sakelos: And then uh, you know, we've got other things going on the pike.

[37:46] Noah Weisbart: We're excited for next year's BMI.

[37:48] John Sakelos: We're we've already started working on that.

[37:50] Noah Weisbart: And um, you know, we're we're chug-a-chuggin' along.

[37:55] John Sakelos: Yeah.

[37:55] Noah Weisbart: That's also so for people who don't know year two of BMI.

[37:58] John Sakelos: Um, you work with one specific person, although you were in a very unique scenario uh where you worked with each other the entire year, where everybody kind of did a round robin with different um uh partners.

[38:09] Noah Weisbart: Um, but for year two, people um, you know, you have one partner that you work with, so the two of you will be working together all year, and you're working to adapt one singular thing, um uh typically a movie adaptation.

[38:21] John Sakelos: Um what what do you can you share what guys are what you guys are uh doing after next year?

[38:25] Noah Weisbart: Yeah, yeah, we could say that well, we could say that it has been uh the the source that we're thinking of has been it uh the source of two films over the course of American cinema, and was is based on a short story written by a very prolific short story writer.

[38:44] John Sakelos: Yeah, that's that's fair.

[38:46] Noah Weisbart: Yeah.

[38:47] John Sakelos: And uh it's it's we're really very, very excited for it.

[38:51] Noah Weisbart: Yes.

[38:51] John Sakelos: Although apparently we have to ask them for permission, so but I don't believe in that forgiveness is to be asked permission.

[38:57] Noah Weisbart: No, but it's you know, it's funny because uh we got into BMI as a writing partnership.

[39:03] John Sakelos: We didn't think that that was so taboo.

[39:06] Noah Weisbart: We thought that surely other people must must have.

[39:09] John Sakelos: We yeah, we didn't know that we were gonna be the only pair that was not uh writing, you know, that was that was not that was working together on everything.

[39:20] Noah Weisbart: And and how we got into BMI is actually kind of uh a funny story.

[39:24] John Sakelos: It's a very like New York story.

[39:26] Noah Weisbart: So I was uh, you know, doing one of the many things artists do as a survival job, and I was um selling and kind of managing a uh an HVAC company in New York City, which is air conditioning as one does.

[39:42] John Sakelos: As one does, yeah.

[39:43] Noah Weisbart: Uh didn't know anything about the business, to be honest with you, still don't.

[39:45] John Sakelos: Uh but but I was there, I was in the office, and a guy called the office line, and his name was Maury Yestin.

[39:54] Noah Weisbart: Mori Estin, and I picked, I saw the yeah, I saw who is a uh on the board for BMI, and we thank him very much because he does a lot for musical theater writers.

[40:03] John Sakelos: So I saw it, and I was like, oh, this is funny.

[40:06] Noah Weisbart: Not actually thinking that it's more.

[40:08] John Sakelos: Yeah, thinking like this guy has the same name as the famous.

[40:11] Noah Weisbart: I say superior H V A C and he's like, you know, you guys installed some units for me, uh, blah blah blah. They're not working.

[40:18] John Sakelos: I'm like, okay, what are they? Mitsubishi's, did you clean the filter?

[40:22] Noah Weisbart: And and I'm like, you know, there's a guy in New York who wrote a musical based on the Titanic. It's pretty good. You should check it out. He has your name. It's kind of funny.

[40:31] John Sakelos: And there was like a little pause and a giggle, and he goes, Well, that's me.

[40:35] Noah Weisbart: And I thought to myself, well, then this is God telling me it's my time to give my two-minute elevator pitch of the musical Noah and I had just wrote.

[40:43] John Sakelos: So I did.

[40:44] Noah Weisbart: And he was very, very gracious.

[40:46] John Sakelos: And he uh He asked for the pitch, as I recall.

[40:49] Noah Weisbart: Well, yeah, he he didn't. There was more chatting and then he asked for the And I did pitch it.

[40:54] John Sakelos: Um, but I did kind of set up the pitch.

[40:56] Noah Weisbart: I he would have been rude if he said, No, I don't really care about musical kid.

[40:59] John Sakelos: What's your sure sure?

[41:00] Noah Weisbart: You know, yeah, come fix my AC.

[41:03] John Sakelos: So I did set him up, but he was very gracious, and he asked uh me to send him some of our work, and he listened to it, and then he said, you know, I really sent us back an email with like praise and very very and like you know, a lot of like he really took the time and like delved into it.

[41:23] Noah Weisbart: He's an educator.

[41:23] John Sakelos: I don't know if people know this, he's a PhD in musicology, yeah, more yesterday.

[41:28] Noah Weisbart: He's uh so he's really an intellectual guy, and he gave us the benefit of uh giving us a really nice analysis, and yeah, we we've taken a lot of his notes, and uh and he was like you should uh apply to BMI.

[41:41] John Sakelos: Yeah, and we did now here we are.

[41:44] Noah Weisbart: That is a buck wild story, yeah.

[41:47] John Sakelos: It's crazy.

[41:48] Noah Weisbart: It's crazy.

[41:49] John Sakelos: Very New York thing, you know, you can't it's like and his ACs were fixed, he got very good Mitsubishi's.

[41:55] Noah Weisbart: I was gonna say the most important thing.

[41:57] John Sakelos: Yeah, his ACs were fixed.

[41:58] Noah Weisbart: I sent somebody there right away.

[42:00] John Sakelos: So, what I what I heard is that you sent in busted ones to start so that you could have a conversation.

[42:06] Noah Weisbart: Listen, you do what you gotta do.

[42:08] John Sakelos: Yeah, show business subject.

[42:10] Noah Weisbart: All is fair and love and war.

[42:12] Bryan Plofsky: Well, thank you, gentlemen, so much for joining me. This is a lot of fun.

[42:15] John Sakelos: Um, I've put all the information you need in the description of this episode.

[42:20] Bryan Plofsky: Um, uh Noah, John, you know, your work is wonderful. Thank you so much for sharing it.

[42:24] Noah Weisbart: Um super excited to see what you all do next.

[42:29] Bryan Plofsky: Um, thanks again for joining me.

[42:32] Noah Weisbart: I really, really appreciate it.

[42:34] John Sakelos: Thanks for having us, channel.

[42:36] Noah Weisbart: We appreciate it.

[42:38] Bryan Plofsky: All right, let's hang up now.

[42:41] John Sakelos: No, you first.

[42:43] Noah Weisbart: No, you first.

[42:46] Bryan Plofsky: Another huge thank you to Noah and John for taking the time to chat.

[42:50] Bryan Plofsky: For more information on them and BMI, you can check out the links in the episode description.

[42:56] Bryan Plofsky: As a reminder, you can find us wherever you're on social media, at Broadwaisted, on Instagram, on Twitter.

[43:03] Bryan Plofsky: We're also on Facebook.

[43:05] Bryan Plofsky: You can also join our Patreon.

[43:07] Bryan Plofsky: You can find this podcast wherever you get podcasts like Spotify, like Apple Podcasts, rate and review us there.

[43:15] Bryan Plofsky: Five stars, please, and thank you so much.

[43:19] Bryan Plofsky: And as we end every episode, we raise a glass.

[43:22] All: Zutu bum.

[43:23] Bryan Plofsky: Cheers.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred