Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 12: Laura Benanti (Tori Amos's Little Earthquakes)

In this episode, Ben and Daniel talk to Tony-winning Broadway star Laura Benanti about Tori Amos's 1992 album Little Earthquakes. They also discuss Patti LuPone, Arthur Laurents, Joni Mitchell, Elaine Stritch, Liza Minnelli, Marni Nixon, Lizzo, Brandi Carlile, and Julie Andrews... Read More

From the show: Cast Offs with Ben and Daniel

1 h 8 mins
12/9/19

Guests

Featured Shows

About

In this episode, Ben and Daniel talk to Tony-winning Broadway star Laura Benanti about Tori Amos's 1992 album Little Earthquakes. They also discuss Patti LuPone, Arthur Laurents, Joni Mitchell, Elaine Stritch, Liza Minnelli, Marni Nixon, Lizzo, Brandi Carlile, and Julie Andrews. Laura talks about her starring roles in Broadway hits such as The Sound of Music, Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown, Gypsy, She Loves Me, and My Fair Lady. She shares stories from her career, including her "up-the-octave" portrayal of Dolly Levi in high school. In addition to the theater, Laura has appeared on TV in Supergirl, Nashville, and The Sound of Music Live opposite Carrie Underwood. She is also a regular on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, and has tickled viewers nationwide with her hilarious portrayal of Melania Trump.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Ben Rimalower: Broken records, the albums you wouldn't shut up about.

[0:06] Daniel Nolen: Broken records, the music our guests can't live with.

[0:10] Ben Rimalower: Barbara, Liza, Beth, Batty, Audra, Bernadette.

[0:14] Daniel Nolen: We broadcast this podcast with hopes that someday we might get Patti LuPone.

[0:25] Ben Rimalower: Broken Wreck, Broken Wreck, Broken Wreck, Broken Wreck, Broken Wreck.

[0:32] Ben Rimalower: Well, welcome to Ben Rimalower's so too funny put that on the podcast.

[0:37] Ben Rimalower: Welcome to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World.

[0:40] Ben Rimalower: I'm Ben Rimalower, and I'm here with my co-host, Daniel Nolen.

[0:45] Daniel Nolen: Lovely co-host.

[0:46] Ben Rimalower: Oh, sorry.

[0:47] Daniel Nolen: Hey y'all.

[0:47] Ben Rimalower: Today's guest is Tony Award-winning Broadway and TV star Laura Benanti, here to chat with us about Tori Amos's's Little Earthquakes and My Fair Lady.

[0:56] Ben Rimalower: I think I wrote that wrong.

[0:57] Ben Rimalower: It sounds like Tori Amos's has an album called My Fair Lady.

[1:00] Ben Rimalower: You live long enough, kids.

[1:02] Ben Rimalower: Anyway, Laura be double dipping with those two albums.

[1:05] Daniel Nolen: We would have to double-dip Laura Benanti.

[1:07] Ben Rimalower: Is that a thing?

[1:08] Daniel Nolen: I didn't think that was a thing.

[1:09] Ben Rimalower: Are you laughing?

[1:10] Daniel Nolen: Just read your line.

[1:11] Ben Rimalower: Absolutely.

[1:12] Daniel Nolen: She's fierce.

[1:14] Ben Rimalower: Thank you for reading that line without complaint.

[1:16] Daniel Nolen: I got you, girl.

[1:17] Ben Rimalower: Well, we just love Laura Benanti. Since her Broadway debut as Rebecca Luker’s understudy and then replacement in The Sound of Music when she was fresh out of high school, she's been electrifying audiences and critics and become one of the brightest bold-face names in New York.

[1:33] Ben Rimalower: She was nominated for Tonys for her star turns in She Loves Me, Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown, Into the Woods, Swing, and Gypsy, for which she won, playing the title role opposite Patti LuPone's legendary Rose.

[1:46] Ben Rimalower: But this isn't about Patti, for once. I'm obsessed with Laura because I think she's the only musical theater soprano who's got that diva edge.

[1:56] Daniel Nolen: Did you see her as the Baroness in the TV version of Sound of Music Live with Carrie Underwood?

[2:00] Ben Rimalower: Yes, I did.

[2:01] Daniel Nolen: It was like Vivien Leigh.

[2:02] Ben Rimalower: Absolutely. First of all, she's so beautiful.

[2:04] Daniel Nolen: Gorgeous.

[2:05] Ben Rimalower: But better than that, bitch can arch an eyebrow. You know what I'm saying? And also just the dresses did it.

[2:10] Daniel Nolen: But it's the attitude. I mean, to me, Laura has. She walks in and she owns the fucking. She has so much X Factor. I mean, it's part of what made her She Loves Me and her My Fair Lady so almost surprisingly incredible. Not that I didn't think she was gonna be incredible, but she really has that musical comedy sparkle that just galvanizes the scenes.

[2:35] Ben Rimalower: I mean, I buy her as Patti's daughter, right? Because even though she has such a different singing voice than Patti, she walks onto the stage and she just kind of commands, you know, and I live for that.

[2:45] Daniel Nolen: And she's very, you know, it's very, you know, Streisand-y, like she has that equal mix of like spark and power, but also vulnerability, and you know, yeah one minute she's singing "Let Me Entertain You" as a strip tease, and then she's singing, you know, "Will He Like Me" in She Loves Me, and you're crying.

[3:04] Ben Rimalower: So truly a star. And the thing I will say about the Sound of Music Live after that, she got the receipts. It was so crazy because I remember after, you know, that was the first of the big TV live musicals, and everyone couldn't stop talking about Laura Benanti, and they were talking about how she really overshadowed, you know, others, my girl Carrie, whom I love.

[3:29] Daniel Nolen: But it was interesting because Laura, at the end of that, I was like, oh, I wanted the captain to end up with the Baroness.

[3:37] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I know, right? How crazy.

[3:39] Daniel Nolen: I know. So anyway, but in fairness, I just want to say for anyone listening who remembers the Rebecca Luker revival of The Sound of Music, and then subsequently the Laura Benanti revival of The Sound of Music, I didn't see that production with either one of them, sad to say. But I have it on good authority that Jan Maxwell as the Baroness would have had similar charismatic effect on the audience, the late great Jan Maxwell.

[4:04] Ben Rimalower: But anyway, continue.

[4:05] Daniel Nolen: Anyway, please go on. But Benanti's wonderful. I try to think one of the first things I saw her in, actually it might have been the first thing. I think it was before She Loves Me. I saw her in the City Center production of Most Happy Fella.

[4:19] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I wish I had seen that.

[4:21] Daniel Nolen: Was she "My Heart is So Full of You"?

[4:22] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[4:23] Daniel Nolen: Yes. And it was wonderful. Her and J. Armstrong Johnson.

[4:28] Ben Rimalower: Oh yes, we've discussed this production before. J. Armstrong Johnson is what you call your um...

[4:35] Daniel Nolen: Um anyway, so that was my first introduction to Laura and Laura Rosabella.

[4:42] Ben Rimalower: Rosabella, that's her name.

[4:44] Daniel Nolen: And after that, of course, I never my heart was so full of her, and then of course, you know, I let her entertain me and she became my little lamb. Well, you know, I saw Gypsy on Broadway.

[4:57] Ben Rimalower: Well, we'll get into all this with Laura. Um, well, let's talk about Tori Amos's because I'm curious what someone of your generation has to say about Miss Amos.

[5:07] Daniel Nolen: I uh, about Tori Amos's. You know, Tori Amos's.

[5:11] Ben Rimalower: I kind of dove in with our Michael Jackson interview, Michael R. Jackson and the R Michael's like our Corey Hay, the publicist.

[5:22] Daniel Nolen: What? There's a publicist named R, period, Corey Hay.

[5:26] Ben Rimalower: Oh, that is like R magazine.

[5:28] Daniel Nolen: You mean like our Michael R. Jackson?

[5:30] Ben Rimalower: Our Michael R. Jackson. Yeah. I dove in on Under the Pink, and then of course Little Earthquakes and Under the Pink.

[5:39] Daniel Nolen: To your rosebud.

[5:40] Ben Rimalower: To my J. Armstrong Johnson. But those aren't even like the most celebrated Tori albums, I don't think.

[5:47] Daniel Nolen: Well, they're very celebrated. I mean, they're the big ones from the beginning.

[5:54] Ben Rimalower: What did she do after the girls?

[5:55] Daniel Nolen: First and second was Songs for the Choirgirl Hotel.

[5:57] Ben Rimalower: Boys for a Page.

[5:58] Daniel Nolen: Boys for Boys for Catholics. Songs in the Choirgirl Hotel. I mean, those came right after that and they were really huge.

[6:03] Ben Rimalower: I don't know. The Tori fans are rabid. It's like Darren Criss and Mayor Pete. Like, you know, they like, they um, like I ask a Tori fan like their favorite Tori album.

[6:14] Daniel Nolen: Like it happened with Michael Jackson too. He's like, I said that was my most influential. That was my favorite. You know, they're really because I mean, because the albums are I think it's funny to like a non-Tori fan because you'll be like, oh, they all sound like Tori Amos's. But like to a Tori fan, which I have been one for many years, they each one is like so different.

[6:34] Ben Rimalower: Like, you know, it might as well be like, you know, Gypsy and Sweeney Todd.

[6:38] Daniel Nolen: Right, right. What could we call it a Tori fan?

[6:40] Ben Rimalower: To name two random examples of an artist's work. The artist being Stephen Sondheim.

[6:45] Daniel Nolen: Right.

[6:46] Ben Rimalower: Stephen Sondheim. What would we call Tori fans? Like, you know, Gaga fans are like the Little Monsters, Joan Rivers called her Joan Rangers. What would be Tori?

[6:56] Daniel Nolen: Like I well, I feel like they already have a name.

[6:58] Ben Rimalower: What is it?

[6:59] Daniel Nolen: I don't know. I don't want to like culturally appropriate the Tori Amos's.

[7:03] Ben Rimalower: Um like the Tories.

[7:03] Daniel Nolen: Well, I went out with this guy when I was in college named Jimmy.

[7:11] Ben Rimalower: Went out or like went out in quotes or like...

[7:11] Daniel Nolen: No, no, we dated for a little bit. I mean, we dated for like a couple of months. It's actually like my longest relationship to date.

[7:20] Ben Rimalower: But I mean, to this date.

[7:22] Daniel Nolen: But anyway, he was obsessed with Tori, and he used to play me. He later on became a very successful drag queen in San Francisco named Suppository Spelling.

[7:36] Ben Rimalower: Oh, that's I've heard of.

[7:37] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, she's like a big deal, like Tranny Shack and all that, and but I'm still obsessed with Tori. But I remember Jared playing for me like bootlegs of Tori singing, I want to say "Evergreen," like at like weddings, like when she was like the Academy Award-winning Barbra Streisand.

[7:57] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[7:59] Daniel Nolen: Um yeah, so but Tori is the voice. I mean that we get into that, I guess a little bit with Laura, but it's like I think part of what you often find, like someone like our friend Brian Nash, who's a brilliant musical director, and composer and lyricist, and he is obsessed with Tori Amos's. He's even done a solo show where he does the whole album of Boys for Pele, just himself.

[8:24] Ben Rimalower: Anyway, but Brian studied voice and you know opera and stuff in college and has an amazing singing voice. And you know, he clearly is someone who gravitated to Tori, well obviously for her piano, but also for the singing.

[8:39] Daniel Nolen: And I think you find a lot of musical theater people, and I remember in high school, like my same friends that I would obsess about Patti LuPone and Andrew Lloyd Webber with were the ones that got me into Tori Amos's, you know.

[8:50] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean shout out to Jamie Stern, Miss You Girl.

[8:54] Daniel Nolen: Shout out. Um, um yeah, Tori, the thing that struck me was her voice because it is so like um I'm gonna think of who I would compare her to these days.

[9:07] Ben Rimalower: You mean in musical theater?

[9:09] Daniel Nolen: Um no, just like a contemporary singer. Almost like I want to say like a female Ben Folds, like it's very like piano-based, like almost a little music theater-y.

[9:22] Ben Rimalower: Um in like the structure of the songs or like I don't know, but the voice is very uh, it seems very healthy.

[9:22] Daniel Nolen: Very healthy.

[9:32] Ben Rimalower: She is not afraid to mix in the head tone mix. But she will go for a full belt when she wants it.

[9:38] Daniel Nolen: A full yell.

[9:39] Ben Rimalower: Really?

[9:40] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah. I like a yell, you know that about me.

[9:43] Ben Rimalower: Um, and I will Yelp review a yell.

[9:47] Daniel Nolen: Um, I won't give you hell for a yell.

[9:51] Ben Rimalower: No, girl.

[9:53] Daniel Nolen: Um, I won't tell you not to yell. If you yell, duh, I fell.

[9:59] Ben Rimalower: Come out of my show. Thank you.

[10:01] Daniel Nolen: Oh no, enough about that. Your J.R. Johnson doesn't belong in this conversation.

[10:07] Ben Rimalower: Um, well, let's talk about My Fair Lady.

[10:11] Daniel Nolen: So yes, let's do that.

[10:12] Ben Rimalower: And just real quick, because something about My Fair Lady that I think is important is the journey. It's like a hero's journey that Eliza takes, you know?

[10:25] Daniel Nolen: Please continue.

[10:27] Ben Rimalower: For instance, you know, she starts out on the streets, she's, you know, selling, you know, flowers for a shekel.

[10:33] Daniel Nolen: Please tell the listener about my air quotes on flowers.

[10:37] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, selling her quote flowers or Rosebud. I mean, has there ever been a production where she's just like a flat-out hooker?

[10:44] Daniel Nolen: Um, not to my knowledge.

[10:46] Ben Rimalower: Not yet. I mean, like Sweet Charity, like taxi dancer, everybody knows that's like a euphemism.

[10:52] Daniel Nolen: Well, it's like why are we so quick to say Tottenham Court Road is all, you know?

[10:57] Ben Rimalower: That's what I call it.

[10:58] Daniel Nolen: Not my Tottenham Court Roads, uh Breakfast at Tiffroids.

[11:03] Ben Rimalower: Speaking of Audrey Hepburn vehicles, it's the same thing with Breakfast at Tiffany's, you know.

[11:07] Daniel Nolen: Well, people do say that about Breakfast at Tiffany's, right?

[11:09] Ben Rimalower: Right, but it's like very euphemistic. It's like, but like, am I the first person to ever say that about My Fair Lady?

[11:14] Daniel Nolen: No, no, I don't think so.

[11:15] Ben Rimalower: Well, I would like you to find some.

[11:15] Daniel Nolen: I'll get our intern on that.

[11:20] Ben Rimalower: Um, who would your ideal intern for us be? Like if you could choose any chorusman or...

[11:23] Daniel Nolen: My first thought is just J. Armstrong Johnson.

[11:29] Ben Rimalower: Sure. But he's a little overqualified.

[11:31] Daniel Nolen: Who's like a dumb twink?

[11:34] Ben Rimalower: I'm allowed to answer this.

[11:35] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[11:36] Ben Rimalower: The listeners are dying to know.

[11:38] Daniel Nolen: If you're listening, dumb twink.

[11:40] Ben Rimalower: Um, I don't even know this guy, so I'm just saying it because I think he's so cute. But the guy that played Shea in Evita at City Center.

[11:49] Daniel Nolen: Oh, the guy that we saw at the Ice Palace?

[11:52] Ben Rimalower: Oh, right, yeah. What's his name?

[11:53] Daniel Nolen: What is his name?

[11:54] Ben Rimalower: I'm sure I can't remember.

[11:55] Daniel Nolen: That's interesting, though. He'd be a good intern.

[11:58] Ben Rimalower: Probably not. I mean, maybe he has a good work ethic.

[12:00] Daniel Nolen: He seems very energetic.

[12:03] Ben Rimalower: That's true. He does seem energetic. But I don't know, and a lot of energy might scare me. I might need somebody more chill.

[12:08] Daniel Nolen: Like, what if we just like had Pixie? And I'd just be like, Pixie, can you look that up? And you'd just be like, no.

[12:14] Ben Rimalower: Although Pixie is a research queen, you know.

[12:16] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, but like that's like for their own projects.

[12:19] Ben Rimalower: Anyway, César.

[12:20] Daniel Nolen: Cesar. Uh anyway, I don't know what we're talking about.

[12:23] Ben Rimalower: My Fair Lady and Turn.

[12:24] Daniel Nolen: Oh, Breakfast at Tiffany's. Uh oh, by the way, intern's not a euphemism.

[12:30] Ben Rimalower: Oh, right. Well, of course. I just wanted them to be attractive.

[12:33] Daniel Nolen: Right, right. For my aesthetic pleasure.

[12:36] Ben Rimalower: But no, we are a safe work environment.

[12:39] Daniel Nolen: Yes, we are.

[12:40] Ben Rimalower: We practice um, what is it? Uh not sexual harassment.

[12:45] Daniel Nolen: Yes, we practice not sexual harassment.

[12:48] Ben Rimalower: It's in our mission statement.

[12:49] Daniel Nolen: Yes, in our mission statement. Uh that this same song.

[12:54] Ben Rimalower: Broken records. The album you won't shut up about broken records.

[13:00] Daniel Nolen: We won't sexually harass your ass.

[13:03] Ben Rimalower: If you could brush that up a bit, then we list like famous sexual harassers.

[13:09] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, like Harvey Weinstein, Billy...

[13:11] Ben Rimalower: Donald Trump.

[13:13] Daniel Nolen: Bill Cosby.

[13:14] Ben Rimalower: All those pigs who grabbed your rump.

[13:17] Daniel Nolen: We broadcast this podcast. Oh, who's our dream sexual harassment guest?

[13:22] Ben Rimalower: Um, with hopes that we someday might get Woody Allen.

[13:27] Daniel Nolen: Oh, okay. Woody Allen's better than Kevin Spacey.

[13:30] Ben Rimalower: This is terrible. We're gonna just kick off the broad...

[13:32] Daniel Nolen: Oh, we have an announcement.

[13:33] Ben Rimalower: This is probably already gonna be out there. We're gonna be joining the Broadway Podcast Network.

[13:37] Daniel Nolen: Yes, VPN baby. So that's right.

[13:40] Daniel Nolen: Someday when the advertisement bucks start rolling in, we'll not only be splitting them with Broadway World, but also with the Broadway Podcast Network.

[13:48] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[13:49] Daniel Nolen: And if you're anyone's listening and you have connections to what are like the top three products we want to get out of here?

[13:54] Ben Rimalower: Gerald Steiner, Gerald Stein all the way, Dickinson's wipes.

[13:59] Daniel Nolen: Listen to our Santino.

[14:01] Ben Rimalower: And those calm, those calm lavender pillows that we like.

[14:04] Daniel Nolen: Everything.

[14:04] Ben Rimalower: I eat them like Flintstone vitamins.

[14:06] Daniel Nolen: But Flintstone vitamins don't give you those interesting burps.

[14:10] Ben Rimalower: Lavender bursts, baby.

[14:12] Daniel Nolen: Broken wreck, broken wreck.

[14:17] Ben Rimalower: And she was like, I want a snack.

[14:18] Daniel Nolen: I want to watch a song.

[14:20] Ben Rimalower: And it's like me.

[14:22] Daniel Nolen: I know.

[14:22] Ben Rimalower: I was like, same.

[14:24] Daniel Nolen: And then we just like ate Madeline's.

[14:26] Ben Rimalower: And then she came back into bed with us.

[14:28] Daniel Nolen: But I never sleep well when she sleeps in bed with us because she's just like I cannot believe how much she just rolls around.

[14:34] Ben Rimalower: It's crazy to me.

[14:35] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[14:36] Ben Rimalower: She's three.

[14:37] Daniel Nolen: Two.

[14:38] Ben Rimalower: Two.

[14:38] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, two and a half.

[14:40] Ben Rimalower: She seems very she's mature.

[14:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[14:42] Ben Rimalower: She's in the threes program at school.

[14:44] Daniel Nolen: Oh wow.

[14:45] Ben Rimalower: Because they went, she would they so they like you have to basically like audition for preschool, which is insane.

[14:51] Daniel Nolen: And we were in the twos, and Ella turns to the woman.

[14:55] Ben Rimalower: She goes, excuse me, are they babies?

[14:59] Daniel Nolen: The woman was like, do you want to go upstairs?

[15:01] Ben Rimalower: And then she just was like, and they were older than her at that point.

[15:08] Daniel Nolen: That's fascinating to me.

[15:09] Ben Rimalower: Kids who like, you know, a lot of kids have like their baby dolls and they push their strollers and they don't see themselves as babies, you know.

[15:17] Daniel Nolen: I remember that when I was a kid too.

[15:18] Ben Rimalower: It's like I was so fascinated by babies when I was like, you know, three.

[15:21] Daniel Nolen: Totally.

[15:22] Ben Rimalower: But she doesn't see herself as a baby because I've had to say lately, like, Ella, I am the mommy. And you are the kid. Like, you can't talk to me like that.

[15:29] Daniel Nolen: And she's like, you can't talk to me like that.

[15:32] Ben Rimalower: Wow.

[15:32] Daniel Nolen: She's so sassy.

[15:34] Ben Rimalower: What's her um zodiac?

[15:36] Daniel Nolen: She is an Aquarius, but she's not an Aquarius at all.

[15:40] Ben Rimalower: She's the least Aquarius Aquarius I've ever met.

[15:42] Daniel Nolen: She like, she seems honestly more like a like a Virgo, maybe even a Scorpio.

[15:48] Ben Rimalower: Wow, Scorpio.

[15:49] Daniel Nolen: Maybe that's her um rising horizon.

[15:51] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[15:52] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[15:52] Ben Rimalower: I mean, did you do her whole chart?

[15:54] Daniel Nolen: I should. I need to do it.

[15:56] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[15:56] Daniel Nolen: What are you?

[15:57] Ben Rimalower: I'm cancer.

[15:58] Daniel Nolen: Oh.

[15:58] Ben Rimalower: But everything's cancer.

[15:59] Daniel Nolen: And I it's I love a cancer.

[16:01] Ben Rimalower: Me too.

[16:01] Daniel Nolen: We're both tourists, so like.

[16:02] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I love a tourist.

[16:04] Daniel Nolen: The love is strong.

[16:05] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, my sister's a tourist.

[16:06] Daniel Nolen: Cancers are so like sensitive and just caring and just homebody.

[16:12] Ben Rimalower: Home body's the best.

[16:15] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[16:15] Ben Rimalower: Alright, so we're rolling.

[16:16] Daniel Nolen: We'll just launch.

[16:17] Ben Rimalower: I will.

[16:18] Daniel Nolen: I loved all that conversation.

[16:19] Ben Rimalower: We can use all that.

[16:20] Daniel Nolen: All gold.

[16:22] Ben Rimalower: But we're here in the beautiful home of Laura Benanti.

[16:25] Laura Benanti: Could not be more overjoyed to be here.

[16:28] Ben Rimalower: Thank you. Laura, I have loved you for so long. I was just thinking, I remember the first time I ever saw you was like, it might have been while you were in the Sound of Music.

[16:36] Laura Benanti: Oh my god.

[16:37] Ben Rimalower: But it was um a reading at the York uh um Summer?

[16:41] Laura Benanti: Summer, yeah.

[16:44] Ben Rimalower: Yes. Um, and I just remember I like I knew your name, I think, from like headlines about maybe you had already like taken over even. Um and I so I knew you were like this really talented, like really young, you know, soprano, and that was all I knew. And but you came out and you were so beautiful, and you were such a good actress, and you were just like so charismatic, and you know, you were just such a star, and it was like I'm dying, you know.

[17:10] Laura Benanti: That was such a dark project. Mark Jacobi played my dad, who likes I feel like he R's me in that. Is there like a isn't there a uh maybe I feel like there's some incest happening?

[17:22] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god.

[17:23] Laura Benanti: No, I mean I was so young too. I was just like, ah yeah, I remember being like, and then there's this part that's really horrible. But the rest of it's amazing. The music's gorgeous. But I do remember.

[17:35] Ben Rimalower: Was Melissa Erico in that?

[17:37] Laura Benanti: No.

[17:37] Ben Rimalower: No. Did but oh, but you know what else? Did I also see? Did you do a like a reading of uh Anna Karenina where she played Anne Crumb's part and you played her part, or maybe I'm conflated?

[17:50] Laura Benanti: I don't know.

[17:52] Ben Rimalower: I have done so many readings. And I'm so old now.

[17:55] Laura Benanti: I thought about it on the way I was like, I'm gonna tell her about summer, and then I was like, like I don't even remember the readings I've done, I'm so sure Laura. I do remember that one though, because I remember it being like very dark.

[18:06] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[18:07] Laura Benanti: And being like, wow, I'm crying really hard on stage.

[18:10] Ben Rimalower: Well, it informed how I like thought of you. I was like, she's this like dark soprano. Like this emo, you know.

[18:18] Laura Benanti: Like, I mean, when you said Tori Amos's, I was like, of course.

[18:22] Ben Rimalower: The best. Um, but uh, well, we we've already we actually just we interviewed um Michael Jackson, who wrote A Strange Loop the other day.

[18:29] Laura Benanti: Oh my gosh.

[18:30] Ben Rimalower: And Tori Amos was his too.

[18:32] Laura Benanti: He did um Under the Pink.

[18:34] Ben Rimalower: Yep. I mean, I think for so many people, I mean you guys are a little bit younger than me, but that was such a big um, I mean, she was big for everybody, but especially I feel like for musical theater people of our like generation, yes, because Tori's stuff was so performative and so vocal and and piano complicated too. It wasn't just like grunge guitar because it wasn't just like growling and playing the guitar, she was like telling a story, she was emotive.

[19:00] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I can hear that what if I in these jeans of his with a name still on any, but I don't care because sometimes I said sometimes I hear my voice, and it's been silent all the gym Yeah trained because her voice is so like um mixy sometimes yeah I mean she used to play in piano bars when she was like a kid when she lived Superfan played me like tapes of her at a wedding singing like Barbara Streisand songs and stuff from that era her dad was like a pr a preacher they lived in Virginia like outside of DC and then I this is how much I love her um and she when she was like a very young person she was playing at piano bars because she was going to like a super prestigious music school and they basically like kicked her out for being improvisational and not just sticking to like buff and all of that.

[20:10] Ben Rimalower: Wow.

[20:10] Laura Benanti: So yeah, and then she just started like doing her own thing. I just I love her.

[20:13] Ben Rimalower: I love her.

[20:17] Laura Benanti: She's the one person that if I met, I think I just would like to never met her.

[20:21] Ben Rimalower: I'm surprised I wouldn't I was thinking that I would have expected them to try to get you to do her um uh musical.

[20:28] Laura Benanti: I would have done that in a heartbeat.

[20:30] Ben Rimalower: But I it hasn't been done in New York though.

[20:32] Laura Benanti: It has not.

[20:33] Ben Rimalower: No, they did it in London. But I mean, I've we've tweeted at each other, like the day that she tweeted at me, I literally had like a mental breakdown. My husband was like, Are you okay? Are you a grown woman having like a total like a like a true meltdown, like hyperventilating? I couldn't believe that she even like knew who I was. And then um Laura Haywood went to see her show and got her to sign her. Broadway girl NYC program for me saying that she wished I was there and it might be in my bedroom. I don't know. I'm not sure where it is.

[21:01] Daniel Nolen: The shrine.

[21:04] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[21:05] Ben Rimalower: Well, so what was she you? I mean, were did you were you into other uh like pop music and stuff as a kid too? Or was Tori more?

[21:12] Laura Benanti: I mean, I was so I was super into musical theater like all growing up. And then when I got to like middle school, I was like, if I want to have any friendships at all, I gotta keep this more on the DL. Um I was very like Tori Amos's was my my A number one, but I really loved the Beatles. Like I'm super into the Beatles. And then of course I got into Dave Matthews band because of course, of course. You have to play.

[21:37] Ben Rimalower: I have to.

[21:37] Laura Benanti: Um but I actually genuinely did like them. And then like I loved Joni Mitchell, um I loved Kat Stevens. I loved more of like the sort of 70s. Right, Harry Chapin.

[21:49] Ben Rimalower: Harry Chapin.

[21:50] Laura Benanti: I love Harry Chapin. Yeah. Anything that's storytelling. Yeah, I'm like pretty into. But um, I was also very into Pearl Jam. I was like kind of in love with Eddie Better.

[22:00] Ben Rimalower: But I had a crush on Eddie Vetter.

[22:02] Laura Benanti: And so I cut my hair to look like his hair.

[22:05] Ben Rimalower: Wow.

[22:05] Laura Benanti: In high school, where I'm like, that's not the move.

[22:08] Ben Rimalower: Junior never like to do school in high school?

[22:10] Laura Benanti: No.

[22:10] Ben Rimalower: No.

[22:11] Laura Benanti: How many, how many?

[22:14] Ben Rimalower: 89 kids in my graduating class.

[22:15] Laura Benanti: I knew everyone.

[22:16] Ben Rimalower: I knew every single person.

[22:17] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I was the president of my class, but only because nobody else wanted to. Um and I was like, I and I was just like, I need to be doing things at all times. Like I really definitely thrive when I'm doing a lot of things. So I was like, I'll be in the musical and I'll be president of the class, and I'll like I just turned everything into a production. We had to do color day, where it was like everybody wears yellow, and I and I was like, We're all sons, and we walk into here comes the sun, and you're gonna dance. Everyone was like, called down.

[22:46] Ben Rimalower: What were your like high school musical roles?

[22:49] Laura Benanti: So when I was a freshman in high school, I played Golda in Fiddler on the Roof. And my sophomore year, I was um Fiona in Brigadoon. Okay, and my junior year, I played Dolly Levi in Hello Dolly, but Up the Octave.

[23:04] Ben Rimalower: No.

[23:04] Laura Benanti: And then Patrice Manzelki, because I'm a Soprano.

[23:07] Ben Rimalower: Oh, so she did that before.

[23:08] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[23:09] Ben Rimalower: Okay. And was your director like super gay and was knew about that?

[23:12] Laura Benanti: No, our director was the science teacher. Her name was Doc. And she was awesome. I loved her.

[23:17] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[23:19] Laura Benanti: Our science teacher was named Doc. I mean, aren't they all?

[23:21] Ben Rimalower: I guess they are.

[23:23] Laura Benanti: Um, but yeah, we did not have like, I would not call it a strong like arts program. I was just like, video of your album.

[23:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, so of course.

[23:33] Laura Benanti: Of course there's. I'm gonna raise the roof. I'm gonna I don't know. I mean, it's kind of magic. It's like but it's ridiculous. I also I look like a 50-year-old woman. Like I really do.

[23:44] Ben Rimalower: And just also my face. Like I was born with this face. I've always looked, I came out like this.

[23:50] Laura Benanti: Yes. And Ella, my daughter's the same way. I was like, oh my god, it's little Laura. She's like a 45-year-old gay man. Like we both were born that way. Um, and and I feel like now I'm just like growing. People are like, you look so much younger now. I'm like, I'm just growing into myself. I've always looked like this, and it was just creepy when I was 11.

[23:52] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god.

[24:07] Laura Benanti: Um, but I won the the Paper Mill Playhouse Rising Star Award for that.

[24:12] Ben Rimalower: Oh wow.

[24:12] Laura Benanti: And that's how I got into the business because I won their award. Then they um So you were 17, 18.

[24:18] Ben Rimalower: I was 16.

[24:19] Laura Benanti: Oh my god.

[24:20] Ben Rimalower: I was 16, and then I sang, I could have danced all night at their like New Year's Eve show.

[24:24] Laura Benanti: Oh and then I did um oh, what was the play? Uh Jane Eyre, but the play, not the musical. And Anne Hathaway was my understudy.

[24:34] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god.

[24:35] Laura Benanti: I know. So funny. And then the next show I did there was um uh Man of La Mancha.

[24:43] Ben Rimalower: Were you the niece of exactly?

[24:46] Laura Benanti: And then they was that um oh what's her name? Yes. Uh from uh Judy Judy McLean. Yeah she's in she's incredible.

[24:53] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[24:54] Laura Benanti: Um and then they recommended me for the sound of the sound of music to audition for Liesel and I auditioned for Liesel, and then they cast me as the understood.

[25:01] Ben Rimalower: And were your parents like this is all great, but you need to go to school or I mean your mom's a voice teacher, right?

[25:07] Laura Benanti: Yeah, and but so my my both my parents were actors. Yeah, and when I was like a year old, they got divorced. I'm fine. Um I'm fine. Nobody worried about um just thousands of dollars worth of therapy. And then my mom remarried my dad Sal, who's a psychotherapist. So like I watched my dad, Marty Vidnevic, um, growing up. I watched his performances. Certainly my mom sang all the time in her studio, her voice studio was in our home. So I would like sit with her while she would give voice lessons. She started giving me voice lessons super young just because I wanted her to. But um, they were very insistent that I not be like a professional actor as a child.

[25:45] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[25:45] Laura Benanti: They told me that when I turned 18, I could basically do what I wanted. Yeah. When I was 17, I auditioned for the sound of music. And at that point I'd gotten into NYU. Yeah. And I planned to go there. And then what I got, um To what like Cap 21?

[25:59] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[25:59] Laura Benanti: Wow. Yeah. And I went for two weeks. I didn't go to a single class.

[26:03] Ben Rimalower: I went for two weeks to like the whatever it's called.

[26:06] Laura Benanti: The orientation.

[26:07] Ben Rimalower: Orientation. Yeah.

[26:08] Laura Benanti: Yeah. And then you were on Broadway.

[26:12] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. You're like, sorry guys, Broadway calls.

[26:14] Laura Benanti: I was like, sorry about it. And then every time I was like, I'm gonna go back to school, and I got into Columbia, and like I would just get another job, and finally I was like, I'm just gonna I like this. You know, I'm gonna keep doing it.

[26:28] Ben Rimalower: Right. I mean, you got nominated for teeny right away pretty much, right?

[26:28] Laura Benanti: Yeah. I mean, uh, okay, so just going back a little, because I know it's one of your other albums, My Fair Lady. Um, so was that I mean you said you sang the what the paper mill rising stars award, they were like the where did they say you can sing whatever you want?

[26:42] Laura Benanti: I didn't sing it at the award show. They I won the the award and then they invited me to sing like part of the Oh that's even more special. Yeah, part of the like win was getting to sing at their like New Year's Eve. And were they like, you're Soprano, you're singing this, or were they like, what would you like to sing?

[26:57] Laura Benanti: No, I I Patrick Parker was has been like a huge mentor of mine over there, and he he knew my dream role was Eliza Doolittle, and he was like, Do you want to sing this?

[27:08] Laura Benanti: I mean, was that no, that was after the previous revival, I guess. Cause that no, it was before. Oh wow. Because uh because uh no, I think it was before because I feel like I was a senior in high school when Melissa because I mean you must have just been like part.

[27:24] Laura Benanti: I mean, you could almost have been, I mean, if you were playing Maria, and that's it. I think I was like 16. Yeah, I can't. I think it was like 16 when it was happening. I know, but I looked 50, so it would have been fine.

[27:34] Ben Rimalower: Mrs. Higgins.

[27:35] Laura Benanti: Oh my god, totally, totally missing Higgins. Um, I mean having seen you as Eliza, I can understand, you know, and I could have understood before seeing you how great you were in it, but you're great in lots of roles. What was it specifically about that that was um such a passion for you?

[27:55] Laura Benanti: Well, I love a transformation, like it's the same for me with Gypsy. Like I love someone who's like A to Z, and then you have to hit all the letters. Yeah, I just think that's so interesting because so often female roles, especially in sort of classical musical theater, excuse me, can be very like one-dimensional. And you end up playing, and certainly when you're like an ingenue, you're sort of limited in terms of your range, what you're allowed to show. And like pathos is not one of those things.

[28:13] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, sure.

[28:24] Laura Benanti: And so what I love about Eliza Doolittle had always been her um her sort of courage, how smart she is. I love playing intelligent characters starting tough. Sorry. Um, and just what she sort of gets to go through. Um, and there's always something lost and something gained in those transformative roles. And I sort of love the double-edged sword of that. I love showing like the pain of it. That even if you get what you want, it still can be really painful.

[29:00] Ben Rimalower: You played that so beautifully. I mean, when I think about My Fair Lady, and I don't even know the first time I saw it, I definitely grew up with the movie and just have always known it. But I wouldn't have described it two years ago as Eliza having lost something in the end.

[29:15] Laura Benanti: Right.

[29:16] Ben Rimalower: My memories of it and the way I think of it is only a win. And I saw so much of that loss in your performance. I mean, it was so um, I mean, the pathos was a part of the end too, you know. But although what I loved most about your performance was the just kind of musical theater comedy. Well, that not just the comedy, but like the oomph, you know. I mean, just the way you walked around that house, and you know, even on the street, it's I mean, it reminds me of Patti LuPone because it's like that, just that kind of owning the ground, you know.

[29:48] Laura Benanti: It's just that something about in your body, it just I noticed in She Loves Me too, just the way you cross the stage. It's just this sort of it, it's like you're going over there, and you're kind of owning the distance between you and that spot before you even get there. We're just aware everyone else on stage is aware of your intended just the force.

[30:12] Laura Benanti: Um, and it you know, it's not something that people can probably learn to do. As I'm telling you this, I'm noticing the Tony award on top of the TV.

[30:23] Ben Rimalower: It's like oh, it's on top of the piano.

[30:26] Laura Benanti: Yeah, it's not the other piano. But underneath the TV, yeah, just with other lint crap, a bobblehead, whatever. I used to actually drape my husband's like intramural like soccer trophies over it, and he was like, please don't do that. He's like, not only is it weird for you, it like makes me actually feel terrible about myself that you're like these two things are equal.

[30:46] Ben Rimalower: Oh, it's but that is I will say that's something that I learned from Patti. I think before I met Patti, I used to apologize for myself a lot. And she beat that out of me.

[30:59] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[31:00] Ben Rimalower: In the most loving way. And you said you were really taken aback by, I think it was Arthur Laurents, the way he was treating you guys. And Patti was just so calm and just like responded with such grace, and you she taught you that. Can you talk about that?

[31:18] Laura Benanti: It was unbelievable. He like, so we sat down for our first table. Yeah, this is for City Center. I didn't I had not known him other than my audition. We sit down for the table read, and I think my first line is like good morning, or something like that.

[31:37] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[31:38] Laura Benanti: And I was like, Good morning, and he goes, No. I am the first line of the show.

[31:45] Ben Rimalower: Oh yeah.

[31:46] Laura Benanti: And it's just no. And I was like, okay. Oh my god. And then he just wrote me so hard. He wrote everybody really hard. And where I truly began to crumble and like fall apart. She was like, thank you.

[32:01] Ben Rimalower: Oh, that's so interesting.

[32:03] Laura Benanti: Thank you. Oh, great. Oh, perfect. Thank you so much. Like, she just showed what it is to be like a collaborative woman who is also very confident.

[32:15] Ben Rimalower: But I mean, sh where that's so I mean, I've known Patti for 20 years. I'm shocked to hear that story. I mean, I think of if anyone remotely infringes upon what she wants to do, her coming down like the you know, fury of hell.

[32:30] Laura Benanti: I mean, I yeah, but I think she had wanted to play this part for a really long time. I think she knew it was a like a sort of a tenuous situation.

[32:37] Ben Rimalower: Right, so she knew what she had to do.

[32:39] Laura Benanti: Yeah, she knew that she had to make this work, and so she was going to make it work.

[32:44] Ben Rimalower: And she did. That's amazing. I mean, that's not at all what I think of her doing, but it makes sense that that's how these those two personalities.

[32:51] Laura Benanti: She is extremely collaborative. Look, I I didn't I do think of her as collaborative. I think I don't think of her as taking crap at all.

[32:57] Ben Rimalower: She did, you know, I think or even minor minor infractions.

[33:01] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I think it depends on who it's from.

[33:02] Ben Rimalower: You know, I think in this case it was Arthur Laurents. He was like 90 years old. He wrote it.

[33:06] Laura Benanti: He wrote the book, yeah. And he was gonna be directing it, and if she wanted to be good in it, she had to like navigate that relationship.

[33:15] Ben Rimalower: And she did it beautifully. I mean, I've heard you both talk about how, and maybe even other people from the production, he had this idea of how Tyne had done it, how Angela had done it, how that those productions had been, and at a certain point, him giving way to being open to what you guys were bringing to the table, and that being kind of what led to this, you know, really beautiful and originally authentic that you created.

[33:40] Laura Benanti: Do you what am I trying to ask? Like, do you think on the other side of that that you still got something good out of his sort of starting off not like that?

[33:52] Laura Benanti: Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, as hurtful as it was, he did sort of break me down in a way that was kind of helpful for that character. Because he brought me to Louise. You know, I started just so fragile, so wanting to be loved and accepted.

[34:12] Ben Rimalower: And he brought me to that place in a real way.

[34:15] Laura Benanti: And I also will say, like, so after two weeks, I basically quit. And I said, I can't do this. You are you don't want me. You are cruel.

[34:23] Ben Rimalower: To him you said that you are cruel to me.

[34:26] Laura Benanti: And I don't need this. I mean, that's big balls.

[34:30] Ben Rimalower: I mean, did you have uh agents and managers supporting you in that?

[34:35] Laura Benanti: No, no, I I just was like, I can't take this anymore. It wasn't big balls, it was actually like fragility, I think.

[34:40] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[34:40] Laura Benanti: You know, if I had if I think if I had been in a different time in my life, I would have just done what Patti did. But it's like I did I couldn't.

[34:48] Ben Rimalower: Had you told her you were quitting?

[34:50] Laura Benanti: I, you know, I it's not like I was like, I quit. I was just like, hey, you clearly don't want me, so like let's call it. And I went home thinking, well, this is it. And then Patti spoke to Arthur and was like, Laura is not a person you need to break down. Laura is a person you need to build up.

[35:08] Laura Benanti: And she's like, I don't know her very well.

[35:10] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[35:10] Laura Benanti: Because we'd only known each other for two weeks. She's like, but I can tell you that. And he called me and he apologized. He said, I'm I spoke with Patti and I'm sorry. You know, he was like, you know, I see you as like I don't see myself as this, but he's like, I see you as, you know, very beautiful and successful and young. And I assumed you would be sort of cocky.

[35:29] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, no.

[35:31] Laura Benanti: Yeah. I'm not. I'm if anything, I'm like extremely insecure. And when you say hurtful things to me, it's hard for me to get back up.

[35:40] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[35:41] Laura Benanti: And he was like, I am sorry. And from that day forward, he's continued to help me, but he did it in a way that I could hear. And I really appreciated it.

[35:49] Ben Rimalower: It sounds so My Fair Lady.

[35:51] Laura Benanti: Yeah. I mean, honestly, yeah.

[35:54] Ben Rimalower: But you know, to your early Patti as um, what's her name as Mrs. Higgins?

[35:57] Laura Benanti: As Mrs. Higgins, yeah. Exactly. But to your early your earlier question, I think basically it's because Patti said yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes to everything he tried. And then it still wasn't quite right.

[36:10] Laura Benanti: Then he was able to say yes to her. And once he was able to say yes to her, then he was able to say yes to the rest of us.

[36:17] Ben Rimalower: But she was the captain of that ship from day one.

[36:20] Laura Benanti: And we built these authentic relationships off stage, which I think really my stomach curling, I which I really think informed our on stage relationships.

[36:30] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[36:30] Laura Benanti: Oh, they were so rich. I mean, I mean, I saw the show on Broadway 10 times, and I saw it at City Center three times. And I mean, and um, that was true always. I mean, even toward the end of the run, Patti seemed like some of her scenes with the groups and everything was it was getting faster and faster and faster.

[36:54] Ben Rimalower: Sure.

[36:54] Laura Benanti: But always when she was on stage with Ewan Boyd, yeah, um, and and in her numbers, yeah, you know, sh she was alive. And the scenes with you guys really were always. I mean, in that final dressing room scene, yeah.

[37:07] Ben Rimalower: It seemed to me as a multiple audience member that that scene was never the same.

[37:13] Laura Benanti: It was never the same. It was never the same.

[37:15] Ben Rimalower: It was dangerous and exciting.

[37:17] Laura Benanti: I could have imagined it going 12 different ways at any second. I mean, and it would. I mean, that's what was really amazing. I it was like two people who just were like, I trust you, I love you. Let's let's go.

[37:31] Laura Benanti: And and it was it will remain it makes me want to cry. It will remain, I think, the greatest experience of my life to be on stage with a person that I really genuinely love. Like family, like the way you love family, you know, and to feel safe in their presence, safe enough to really explore all the damage in this relationship, you know, and it was cathartic in a way, too.

[37:56] Ben Rimalower: You know, yeah, it's cathartic just to watch. I mean, you know, it was amazing, but you know, they for me, I really, you know, when she sh when she says to me, you know, what did I do it for? And I say, I thought you did it for me, mama, you know, I wanted the audience to feel the loss of Louise.

[38:16] Laura Benanti: Yeah, you know, that like Louise was gone, yeah. And here was now this like almost Frankenstein creation.

[38:24] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, that's a great word.

[38:25] Laura Benanti: And who like is not the permeable wanting little girl that she had been, and that that's sad in a way.

[38:32] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.

[38:33] Laura Benanti: So I talk about that in my show actually, Patty Issues, which is that which I swear I don't mention on every episode of this podcast. But um, uh, but it's about my relationship with my father, who um is crazy. I was adopted by my stepfather when I was a kid because my father was a mess and out of the picture, but gay, and so we obviously had like a wow difficult but you know uh intense uh connection.

[38:57] Ben Rimalower: Um.

[38:57] Laura Benanti: And um after not seeing him for 10 years, I ran into him at Gypsy, where he was sitting l on Broadway, literally in the seat behind me. It's so insane. I mean it's it sounds so made up, but it really has.

[39:10] Ben Rimalower: No, I believe you.

[39:11] Laura Benanti: Um, but I but it's exactly that moment. I mean, that's the final moment of my show. I talk about I thought you did it for me, mama, and you know, and then um I say the line in my show is like Gypsy now a success, starring in her own show, holds her and says, It's okay, mama, it's okay, Rose.

[39:30] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, and that's literally my moment with my father, like calling him by his name, you know.

[39:35] Laura Benanti: Um and uh, so you know it was it was so I I think that but I think that experience was shared by you know, because everyone has that, you know.

[39:45] Ben Rimalower: Um but uh but what's what is it like to go from something where you're literally I have to get out of this, you don't want me, this is a disaster, I'm failing. This you know, through to this is the greatest theatrical experience, I won a Tony Award, this is a joy and a triumph, these people are my family.

[40:06] Laura Benanti: I mean, that's such a huge it was a really big leap.

[40:09] Laura Benanti: Well, it took, you know, I think it took all parties sort of agreeing on what is meaningful to each other. And for me to say, like, I can't handle the way you talk to me, and for him to say, okay, he could have been like, go fuck yourself, you know um and was it really just like does it turn on a dime I mean is it after that it's a good experience yes he could be very cruel to people yeah you know I I remained very close with him through to the end of his life yeah but he and I would have really big arguments yeah about the way he would speak to other people.

[40:46] Ben Rimalower: Oh interesting in in during Gypsy yeah one in particular a cast member's mother died and she did the show that night and then he came in the next day and like reamed her out for how out of it she seemed on stage and I was like stop no you go away you don't get to talk to her like that right now.

[41:12] Laura Benanti: Um, well that's incredible that you were not only empowered enough to do your work and get through your path but that you could even be protective and I've always been better at that with other people. I'm always better at being a champion for others than for myself. It's like my lifelong journey and boundaries and things that I'm working on.

[41:33] Ben Rimalower: Well now you're a mom now that you have a relationship where that's appropriate.

[41:37] Laura Benanti: Totally, totally. But yeah, so like, and he and I, we would he would sometimes say things to me and he'd be like, well, you know, I love you and I'd be like, yeah, but I would hate to hear how you speak to someone you don't love.

[41:48] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, because that was just horrible.

[41:50] Laura Benanti: Yeah, um, but he knew it. It's like he knew that he had this cruel side to him and it's like he didn't love it.

[42:00] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[42:01] Laura Benanti: Um, so yeah, I had our relationship was I loved him, but I also saw him for who he was.

[42:09] Ben Rimalower: But that I guess that relationship in your life would be more unique than in his.

[42:13] Laura Benanti: I mean, to say that it I think probably anyone that was in his life had some way of getting through that that he's famously crusty or whatever you want to call it.

[42:25] Ben Rimalower: Well, I feel like that whole generation like of men in power at that time were all cruel.

[42:33] Laura Benanti: They were cruel to the actors, they were cruel to the dancers, to each other. There's this like you hear about Jerome Robbins.

[42:40] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean I think that's how they all were.

[42:42] Laura Benanti: Yeah. Um, I'm glad it's not like that anymore.

[42:46] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Have have you found, I mean, um that that's the exception to the rule in terms of people you've worked with and that being a woman, um, especially as a leading lady now, you know, in this business.

[43:01] Laura Benanti: I mean, we're hearing so much of this like alleged um supposedly that New York Times story that was gonna come out about all the sexual harassment that somebody's lawyer, you know, crushed it, but um, you know, but necessarily not necessarily getting into you know details or names, but do do you find that in general you've had a good experience of being in that dynamic?

[43:25] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I mean, look, I definitely had my fair share of like older men in power propositioning me. Um and I wish that I as a young person didn't think, oh right, okay, well, this is what happens.

[43:41] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[43:42] Laura Benanti: You know, I wish that there had been a sense of like, no, what why would you say that to me? And now you're in trouble, instead of like, oh, this is just part of it.

[43:49] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[43:50] Laura Benanti: But that was the time.

[43:51] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, you know. You know, I've been in this business since I was 17 years old.

[43:57] Laura Benanti: So 1997 was a different time.

[44:04] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[44:06] Laura Benanti: And so I would say in every show that I've been in, there's been one or two instances where I felt very uncomfortable or had to set a boundary, which I'm uncomfortable with.

[44:19] Ben Rimalower: Or when I was much younger, just kind of go along with it.

[44:23] Laura Benanti: Because I felt like I didn't know. I didn't know that I could say no.

[44:28] Ben Rimalower: Right.

[44:28] Laura Benanti: I'm not saying like, you know, sexually, but like I but just in terms of an uncomfortable dynamic. I didn't know that I could say like, don't say that to me.

[44:36] Laura Benanti: Um, look, I couldn't tell you if it's getting better. I'm getting older.

[44:41] Ben Rimalower: So I'm sure that it's like I think that men in power tend to um seek out younger women.

[44:51] Laura Benanti: A, because they're very beautiful, and B, because they don't know better.

[44:55] Ben Rimalower: You're the most beautiful woman in the world.

[44:56] Laura Benanti: But maybe, but maybe it is won't attack someone who is more established and who has, you know, has more experience.

[45:05] Ben Rimalower: Right. I heard a funny quote from you the other day.

[45:10] Laura Benanti: Was I reading an interview where you were like, I'm this um uh but by a small group of people, I'm the most famous person in the world, and then I'm in LA and nobody knows how to yeah, yeah, it's just funny that like growing up, I you know, I never wanted to be famous.

[45:30] Ben Rimalower: I like wanted to be on Broadway.

[45:32] Laura Benanti: Yeah. And I thought I would work my whole life to get to that.

[45:36] Laura Benanti: And instead, it was like handed to me, yeah, like the luckiest girl in the world when I was 18.

[45:41] Laura Benanti: And I was like, oh, wait a minute. Like, like so I'm not so being Broadway famous is different than being TV or film famous.

[45:51] Ben Rimalower: So it is really funny to me that to some people they are like, You have changed my life. I love you so much.

[45:55] Laura Benanti: Yeah. And then I literally, right after I won the Tony, I had um a like a general meeting with a producer, and she was like, So you live in New York. Do you do plays?

[46:10] Laura Benanti: And I was like, Oh my god, this was set up by my agents. Like, you didn't even bother to Google? Like, what is wrong with you?

[46:17] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[46:17] Laura Benanti: So, but in a way, I wouldn't be a good, like, super famous person.

[46:24] Laura Benanti: I'm too sensitive. I really enjoy my autonomy.

[46:27] Laura Benanti: Like, I really love being able to walk down the street and maybe have one or two people be like, I love you.

[46:32] Laura Benanti: Yeah, you know, and be like, Thank you, and keep moving.

[46:35] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah. The idea of like walking into some place and not being able to function and having like my child have her life altered, just feels really not what my personality can recall.

[46:48] Laura Benanti: Right. But still, I think that you know you're good on screen, and that you know, you keep getting cast in these things, and you know, in the throwing the dice craps game of Hollywood, it's just a matter of time until you know you have something that is a long running show or a big movie or something.

[47:06] Laura Benanti: I mean, who knows? I you know, I definitely um have put I'm putting my attention more toward like TV and film right now, just because I, you know, I love Broadway and I will always come back to it.

[47:19] Ben Rimalower: Sure.

[47:20] Laura Benanti: Um, but I do want to sort of stretch my muscles in a different way.

[47:25] Ben Rimalower: Well, we want you to, you know, be a big hit bear and bring it back and have a bigger, you know.

[47:31] Laura Benanti: I mean, and you've done a lot of theater.

[47:33] Laura Benanti: I mean, you know, it's sometimes I was thinking about like um Sarah Ramirez the other day, who's so fabulous on Broadway.

[47:39] Laura Benanti: I mean, just such a huge talent, and then just disappeared.

[47:42] Ben Rimalower: I know, you know, and has never come back.

[47:44] Laura Benanti: I mean, and I'm sure there are things that she would want to do, you know, that haven't happened.

[47:48] Ben Rimalower: Um, but uh, you know, we've gotten we've gotten as as much Laura Benanti as we paid for.

[47:55] Laura Benanti: Yeah, there's I've been around a lot.

[47:57] Laura Benanti: So I feel like, you know, I did this movie with Michael Keaton, I'm doing a movie now with Billy Crystal.

[48:02] Laura Benanti: I Tommy Cale and I have a project that we're working on together, a television project that we're going out to.

[48:07] Ben Rimalower: Is this something with Rachel Schucher?

[48:08] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[48:09] Ben Rimalower: Yes, that sounds can you can talk about that.

[48:11] Laura Benanti: Probably.

[48:12] Laura Benanti: Well, it sounded very cool and very theatrical. I'm really excited about it.

[48:15] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[48:15] Laura Benanti: So it like combines all my loves, which is great.

[48:17] Ben Rimalower: Love it, love it.

[48:18] Laura Benanti: Um, so you know, I'm really and that's the project that you are one of the creative forces behind as well.

[48:23] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[48:23] Laura Benanti: How did that is that your first time doing that?

[48:26] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, I have definitely over the past like however many years tried to like create more, like even silly little like online funny videos and like hosting the drama desks and writing them.

[48:38] Laura Benanti: Yeah, sure.

[48:38] Ben Rimalower: You know, I'm trying to like well, it's been an it seems like it's been a very natural progression for you that's come kind of organically out of what you're doing.

[48:45] Laura Benanti: And like my cabaret shows, you know, it's like I don't have a director, I don't have a writer.

[48:49] Laura Benanti: I do all that with Todd Almond, my musical collaborator.

[48:53] Ben Rimalower: Brilliant, yeah.

[48:53] Laura Benanti: He is brilliant.

[48:54] Laura Benanti: So I'm just trying to, as I get older, you know, create my own stuff more instead of just sort of waiting for someone to bring me the perfect right.

[49:03] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's like we when we talk so much on this podcast about the divas and you know, artists that we've um that have inspired us, and you know, for I know for a lot of us it's like these big ones are like Barbara Streisand and Bette Midler and Liza Minnelli.

[49:17] Laura Benanti: And so often when I think about the tragedy of Liza is that she didn't do that, you know, and and Barbara has gotten a lot of shit for it, and you know, some of her choices questionable.

[49:28] Ben Rimalower: But she's been a creative force in a time when women, you know, were not given that opportunity.

[49:32] Laura Benanti: And Bette Midler, you know, is a powerhouse who made so much happen and made so much money, you know.

[49:38] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[49:38] Laura Benanti: And Liza lives in a condo, you know, she didn't for all her great artistic triumph, and you know, she didn't step behind the scenes in that way, and she didn't have a um, she wasn't at the steering wheel in her own career.

[49:58] Ben Rimalower: And yeah, and she didn't, you know, and that hurt her financially and creatively, and you know, it she's in a very different place than those other women are that at one point were exactly her peers.

[50:09] Laura Benanti: Yeah, it's you know, I think in a weird way, it's like going back to the high school part of me that I was telling you about where I was like, everybody's you know, a son, and we're like making everything a production, yeah.

[50:24] Laura Benanti: That's always been a part of who I am, but at some point I learned that like good and nice girls don't do that, and they just follow rules.

[50:32] Laura Benanti: And I do think that that is one place where musical theater is a little backwards, yeah.

[50:36] Ben Rimalower: Totally um, in that it's like it's like insta performance, you're supposed to like be off book and there's no room for like failure, which is really where you learn the most stuff is like when something doesn't work.

[50:47] Laura Benanti: Totally um, and so sort of allowing myself moments to fail, allowing myself to try things, you know, to do straight plays, to do television, to do film, and to like and to create my own stuff.

[51:02] Laura Benanti: It's like it's scary, but I want to put myself out there in that way because I think that's actually who I am.

[51:08] Ben Rimalower: For sure.

[51:09] Laura Benanti: Yeah. I mean, and also not only can you give us more of who you are that way, but the more the creative other people see who you are, the more they can do things that serve that.

[51:19] Laura Benanti: I mean, you know, I think sometimes with like Tina Fey movies, I won't even remember which ones she actually wrote or which ones she was just casting because she's created a sense for us of what she brings.

[51:31] Laura Benanti: And other people can then fill in some of the blanks.

[51:34] Laura Benanti: Yeah, and weirdly, I because I'm having such like a complicated relationship with social media right now, but I do credit Twitter with because people thought of me like you did as like in sort of emo soprano when really still that until they were like, who's this very funny person?

[51:51] Ben Rimalower: No, I mean I remember you doing videos for theater mania, yeah.

[51:54] Laura Benanti: Was it theater mania?

[51:55] Ben Rimalower: Theater mania.

[51:56] Laura Benanti: Yeah, and they were hilarious.

[51:57] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, who created this for her?

[51:59] Laura Benanti: And I I think Jamie McGonagall said, Oh no, Laura's doing all that.

[52:03] Laura Benanti: And I was like, okay Laura.

[52:05] Laura Benanti: I mean, my friend Ashley Van Buren, who was working there at the time, she and I collaborated on those things, but like we wrote that.

[52:11] Laura Benanti: I don't know if you saw that um feminism video shampoo video that I wrote for Connie Britton.

[52:15] Laura Benanti: So like we wrote it and I directed it, and like just trying to do more things like that.

[52:21] Ben Rimalower: It's so important.

[52:22] Laura Benanti: I mean, I it's wonderful for Ella to have a mother who does that because it's such a it's such a natural thing that is modeled for men that we don't even we take it for granted.

[52:31] Laura Benanti: Of course, a guy can do that. If a guy wants to start writing or directing or producing, it's like good for him.

[52:36] Ben Rimalower: It's not breaking through any um imposed barrier.

[52:41] Laura Benanti: Right.

[52:41] Ben Rimalower: Well, it seems like, you know, going back to the high school thing about you saying, well, no one else is gonna do it, so I guess I'll be president.

[52:47] Laura Benanti: Yeah, you know, I'm uh choreographing this, you know, we're all dressed as sons.

[52:51] Ben Rimalower: It sounds like you have such a director's eye.

[52:53] Laura Benanti: Yeah, for sure.

[52:53] Ben Rimalower: You know, and that's such like speaking of Barbara Streisand.

[52:56] Laura Benanti: It's like you have such an interesting point of view and you're so smart.

[52:59] Ben Rimalower: Thank you.

[53:00] Laura Benanti: And I think that's so that speaks so much to your character and and your wisdom.

[53:06] Laura Benanti: Even, you know, you got into the business in a big way when you were 17, you know, and you were able, you're you know, you have reached a point now where you're like, it's okay to fail.

[53:14] Ben Rimalower: And it would have been so easy just to not do that and to be swept up in it and you know.

[53:20] Laura Benanti: Talking about that in musical theater, the the no room for fail, even beyond necessarily like the gender thing.

[53:25] Laura Benanti: Like I was thinking about another show, you were incredible in Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown.

[53:29] Ben Rimalower: Oh, of course.

[53:31] Laura Benanti: It's me again, my angel picking up the phone.

[53:34] Laura Benanti: It's like my brain is gonna melt if I don't talk to you.

[53:36] Laura Benanti: I've got a problem in the shower, and I've only got a minute because the problem in the shower is this guy that I've been thinking the Malik.

[53:43] Laura Benanti: He's watched the word swarthy like a desert chic.

[53:46] Laura Benanti: And he's been here in my apartment for about a week.

[53:48] Laura Benanti: I met them down like Cathy Sombra, and I know you think I'm overly romantic, but it's one really the collection.

[53:54] Laura Benanti: Like immediately, I was ready for him to meet my mom.

[53:56] Laura Benanti: Like I could feel my heart exploding like some kind of bum, which is ironic because actually I think he literally has some kind of anyway, grandpa, happy birthday.

[54:03] Laura Benanti: Say I love the grandma and be sure and think, oh, that was him.

[54:06] Ben Rimalower: I maybe just do you think in a different process, not a Broadway theater, yes, that show, you know, if it had been a regional, you know, somewhere safer, could have gone the distance.

[54:19] Laura Benanti: Absolutely.

[54:19] Laura Benanti: I mean, ooh.

[54:20] Laura Benanti: Um, you know, we we had very little time to put it together.

[54:25] Laura Benanti: I think the show that Ben Brantley saw was the second time we'd ever done it that way.

[54:33] Laura Benanti: Right.

[54:33] Laura Benanti: So we froze the show on a Saturday matinee and he came and saw the Saturday night.

[54:37] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[54:37] Laura Benanti: No. That's never gonna be good.

[54:39] Laura Benanti: Right.

[54:39] Laura Benanti: You know, and especially when you're talking about something like Pedro Almodóvar, which is like the tone is so specific to try to bring that to stage and to an American audience.

[54:48] Laura Benanti: I just wish we had gone out of town.

[54:50] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[54:51] Laura Benanti: You know, I really do. I think it because people who saw like the show in the beginning and then saw it at the end were like, this feels like a completely different show.

[54:58] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, you know.

[55:00] Laura Benanti: Um, so yeah, I think that I get it, there's a lot of money at stake.

[55:04] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[55:05] Laura Benanti: And for the audience too, Broadway is so prohibitively expensive.

[55:09] Ben Rimalower: If you were going to spend your money to see something, you want it to be something that you know you're gonna have a good time, you know.

[55:16] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I mean, it really is so it's such it's so problematic.

[55:16] Ben Rimalower: It really is.

[55:20] Laura Benanti: It's theater for a rich audience.

[55:22] Ben Rimalower: And they're not the best uh arbiters of taste.

[55:26] Laura Benanti: The rich people in our country should not be in charge of anything.

[55:29] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, um, okay, another thing creative that you've done um that I'm interested in how it got started is playing Melania Trump.

[55:36] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[55:36] Ben Rimalower: Um speaking of the evil rich people in our nation.

[55:38] Laura Benanti: I know.

[55:39] Ben Rimalower: Um how did that come about?

[55:40] Laura Benanti: So I was on Steven's show just promoting She Loves Me, and he like put up a picture of me and a picture of her and pointed out our resemblance, which like I still actually don't really see, um, unless I'm making the face.

[55:52] Ben Rimalower: Right.

[55:52] Laura Benanti: Well, the face, right?

[55:55] Ben Rimalower: And so then I sort of made the face, and then that was it.

[55:57] Laura Benanti: And then like months later, it was the Republican National Convention, and she did her famously plagiarized Michelle Obama speech, and I woke up to like a flurry of emails and phone calls from Colbert's show being like, Do you want to put together an impression?

[56:12] Laura Benanti: Oh and I was actually five hours away at my grandma's house in Delaware.

[56:15] Laura Benanti: I'd just gotten there the night before.

[56:17] Laura Benanti: I literally like got there at like midnight, went to sleep, woke up at seven, and was like, What?

[56:22] Laura Benanti: Um, and then went all drove back five hours to New York.

[56:26] Laura Benanti: And it was live, so it was a live show.

[56:28] Laura Benanti: So we were like, it's not even like if it doesn't play, we can cut it.

[56:32] Laura Benanti: Um, and then it ended up being this like very zeitgeisty sort of viral sensation.

[56:38] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[56:39] Laura Benanti: Um and it's like it's a double-edged sword for sure.

[56:43] Laura Benanti: Where on one hand I'm like, oh, I feel like it was finally the thing that made people go, she is a comedian.

[56:48] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.

[56:48] Laura Benanti: Um, but also now I'm people refer to me as like Melania Trump impersonator, and I'm like, oh man, no.

[56:55] Laura Benanti: That is just like a tiny fraction of like what I'm capable of.

[56:59] Laura Benanti: So I'm so grateful for it.

[57:01] Laura Benanti: I love doing it, it's really fun.

[57:04] Laura Benanti: But I also like don't want that to be the first line of my obituary.

[57:07] Ben Rimalower: Yes, well, I do not expect that to be the case.

[57:11] Laura Benanti: Um that's so funny.

[57:13] Ben Rimalower: What what about um Stephen Colbert?

[57:16] Ben Rimalower: Like, he's somebody that has a little bit of a Broadway um bent to him.

[57:20] Laura Benanti: He's amazing.

[57:21] Laura Benanti: Like, do you um do you could you see him like stepping in to like actually like do a musical?

[57:27] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I mean, didn't he do one at City Center?

[57:29] Laura Benanti: He did come with at um at Philharmonic with Patty, right?

[57:33] Laura Benanti: Um, but um, but you know, that was like a week, yeah, two weeks of rehearsal.

[57:37] Laura Benanti: I mean, he's certainly he's so busy right now, you know.

[57:40] Laura Benanti: I don't think it's gonna happen anytime soon, but I don't know.

[57:42] Laura Benanti: I mean, he he's so multifaceted, yeah, that I think anything he wanted to do, honestly, he could do.

[57:48] Ben Rimalower: He's he's so right.

[57:49] Laura Benanti: He came to see my fair lady, and he was could not be more generous.

[57:53] Laura Benanti: He was like crying, and he was like, I can't believe I get to do anything with you.

[57:58] Laura Benanti: It was really, really nice.

[57:59] Laura Benanti: He's a very generous person.

[58:01] Laura Benanti: He's a very kind man and so smart.

[58:03] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god, he's so smart.

[58:05] Laura Benanti: Yeah, he is smart.

[58:06] Laura Benanti: I love being in the room with people like that.

[58:08] Ben Rimalower: So going back to like then my fair lady and your musical influences, like what for you is the overlap besides just you of Tori Amos's and My Fair Lady?

[58:17] Laura Benanti: Like, I mean, you know, it because I hear those things both in your voice.

[58:22] Ben Rimalower: Thank you.

[58:22] Laura Benanti: Um, but do you find a middle ground, or is it just kind of like a subliminal osmosis kind of thing?

[58:30] Laura Benanti: In in my singing voice?

[58:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, well, or even just music for you, even as a fan, like do you know, do where where's the where do you connect, or what what is it in common with those things?

[58:40] Laura Benanti: I don't really know what I'm asking.

[58:41] Laura Benanti: I I feel like it's the heart in the voice.

[58:43] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[58:43] Laura Benanti: You know, Tori Amos's has her heart in her voice.

[58:46] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[58:46] Laura Benanti: When you gonna make a beau mind, because things are gonna change so fast.

[58:57] Laura Benanti: All the way to send in bed until you get a no way.

[59:06] Laura Benanti: Smell in union.

[59:08] Laura Benanti: You say the things smile.

[59:21] Laura Benanti: You know, Brandi Carlile has her heart in her voice.

[59:24] Laura Benanti: A clown to cross the mountain tops.

[59:29] Laura Benanti: Swarm out across the ocean blue, across all the land and out of the room.

[1:00:07] Laura Benanti: Anybody who's really like giving me their soul through their singing, I'm into whatever genre it is.

[1:00:14] Laura Benanti: You know, it's like Lizzo.

[1:00:24] Laura Benanti: Go on, take it out and come back when you grow.

[1:00:46] Laura Benanti: Lizzo has her heart in her voice.

[1:00:48] Laura Benanti: So I'm not so much into like I'm not a genre snob really.

[1:00:53] Laura Benanti: But for me, like if I hear like super auto-tuned or somebody who's just like slick too perfect production, I'm not interested in it.

[1:01:01] Laura Benanti: You know, I want something that feels like art.

[1:01:04] Laura Benanti: I want something that feels like someone's like laying their soul out for me.

[1:01:08] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:01:08] Laura Benanti: Well, you mentioned Joni Mitchell earlier, and you know, I love Joni, and I love all eras of Joni, you know.

[1:01:15] Laura Benanti: She starts out with that pure kind of like crystalline soprano.

[1:01:20] Laura Benanti: I've loved it, clouds from both sides now.

[1:01:24] Laura Benanti: Now still somehow we're cloud illusions.

[1:01:32] Laura Benanti: I recall I really don't know that.

[1:01:45] Laura Benanti: But then like I also just as much love like her most recent stuff, which is like just like a smoker's cough, you know.

[1:01:51] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, it's just like this um this weathered voice, but it just tells so much story, and it just talk about A to Z.

[1:01:59] Laura Benanti: Yeah, totally.

[1:02:00] Laura Benanti: It shows the journey, and I'm like, I eat it up.

[1:02:02] Laura Benanti: Like that that later version of both sides.

[1:02:04] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I was just thinking of that.

[1:02:06] Laura Benanti: Yes, yes.

[1:02:07] Laura Benanti: Oh my god, it's so good.

[1:02:16] Laura Benanti: From in the blues, and still somehow it's lives you lose I recall.

[1:02:30] Laura Benanti: I really don't know.

[1:02:36] Laura Benanti: Hello.

[1:02:46] Laura Benanti: Which you know, both sides now is is so it's a delight of that.

[1:02:50] Laura Benanti: You know, it's like everything we've been talking about.

[1:02:52] Laura Benanti: I sing that in my concert.

[1:02:53] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, perfect.

[1:02:55] Laura Benanti: So do are you are you looking to do more of that kind of work?

[1:02:58] Laura Benanti: Do you do it?

[1:02:58] Laura Benanti: I do concerts all over the country.

[1:03:00] Laura Benanti: Actually, oh, do you do like Symphony kind of thing?

[1:03:02] Laura Benanti: Yeah, I do symphonies, but Todd Almond and I go with our show all over the place.

[1:03:05] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:03:06] Laura Benanti: Uh we have two shows.

[1:03:07] Laura Benanti: We had one called In Constant Search of the Right Kind of Attention.

[1:03:09] Laura Benanti: That's the album.

[1:03:10] Laura Benanti: And now we have one called Um Tales from Soprano Isle.

[1:03:14] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I've got that.

[1:03:16] Laura Benanti: Have you done that one in town yet?

[1:03:17] Laura Benanti: We've done it for like two years.

[1:03:18] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:03:19] Laura Benanti: Now we have to do a new one.

[1:03:20] Laura Benanti: We did one at the Carlisle when I was pregnant.

[1:03:22] Laura Benanti: That's where we debuted it.

[1:03:24] Laura Benanti: And it's my favorite show that we've done for sure.

[1:03:27] Laura Benanti: But now we're actually talking about doing something maybe a little bit more scripted.

[1:03:34] Ben Rimalower: Right.

[1:03:35] Laura Benanti: Um, for our next one that feels a little bit more like a show.

[1:03:38] Ben Rimalower: Sure, yeah.

[1:03:39] Laura Benanti: It would be great to see you do something like that.

[1:03:41] Laura Benanti: Yeah, so we're we're in like the phases the Did he do Sherry Renee Scott's show?

[1:03:45] Laura Benanti: He did.

[1:03:46] Laura Benanti: He did.

[1:03:46] Ben Rimalower: Oh, perfect.

[1:03:47] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:03:47] Laura Benanti: Yeah, and the one with Norbert as well.

[1:03:50] Ben Rimalower: I didn't see that one.

[1:03:50] Ben Rimalower: I heard it was incredible.

[1:03:51] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:03:52] Laura Benanti: That was they like sold out like two months if it's formulated.

[1:03:56] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:03:56] Laura Benanti: What what are there shows like that that have been especially meaningful to you?

[1:04:01] Laura Benanti: Cabaret shows or solo pieces like that.

[1:04:05] Laura Benanti: Um, you know, I love Patty's show, obviously.

[1:04:08] Laura Benanti: I haven't, I Cheetah Rivera has an incredible show.

[1:04:12] Laura Benanti: Um did you see any of that like stuff when you were when you were just starting out?

[1:04:17] Laura Benanti: I didn't.

[1:04:18] Laura Benanti: I didn't because I was always working.

[1:04:19] Ben Rimalower: Sure.

[1:04:20] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:04:20] Laura Benanti: You know, I was like literally always working.

[1:04:22] Laura Benanti: So like you do you ever get see Elaine Stritch?

[1:04:25] Laura Benanti: No.

[1:04:27] Laura Benanti: No.

[1:04:27] Laura Benanti: I did a reading with her when I was 20 of um of uh what's it called?

[1:04:33] Laura Benanti: So the Royal Family.

[1:04:34] Laura Benanti: Yes.

[1:04:34] Laura Benanti: Oh, this Bill Finn adaptation of the common heart.

[1:04:38] Laura Benanti: And I have a thing where if I see blood, I faint.

[1:04:40] Laura Benanti: And I walked in and she was checking her glucose and I passed out.

[1:04:44] Laura Benanti: That's how I met her.

[1:04:46] Laura Benanti: That's how you go.

[1:04:47] Laura Benanti: She was so pissed.

[1:04:48] Laura Benanti: I was sure.

[1:04:49] Laura Benanti: It was she terrified me.

[1:04:51] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, she's so scared of her.

[1:04:53] Laura Benanti: Scary.

[1:04:54] Ben Rimalower: That's so funny.

[1:04:56] Laura Benanti: And I was like, nice of uh.

[1:04:58] Laura Benanti: And I remember waking up and Jerry Zach's just looking at me like.

[1:05:01] Laura Benanti: It's over.

[1:05:04] Laura Benanti: She's gonna hate you now.

[1:05:05] Ben Rimalower: Oh god.

[1:05:06] Laura Benanti: I've been so curious about that show all these years.

[1:05:08] Laura Benanti: I mean, it was so good.

[1:05:10] Ben Rimalower: Was it good?

[1:05:10] Laura Benanti: It was so good.

[1:05:11] Laura Benanti: I think it was a rights issue.

[1:05:12] Ben Rimalower: See you guys and Carolee Carmelo.

[1:05:14] Laura Benanti: Is that right?

[1:05:14] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:05:14] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:05:15] Laura Benanti: Brian Bat, yeah.

[1:05:17] Ben Rimalower: Amazing.

[1:05:18] Laura Benanti: I love her.

[1:05:19] Ben Rimalower: Um, well, this is a good uh transmission.

[1:05:21] Ben Rimalower: We play a game with our guests.

[1:05:23] Laura Benanti: Okay.

[1:05:23] Ben Rimalower: Um, which is a variation on Maryfuck Kill.

[1:05:27] Laura Benanti: Okay.

[1:05:27] Ben Rimalower: But it's Dolly Concert Kill.

[1:05:29] Laura Benanti: Okay.

[1:05:30] Ben Rimalower: So we'll give you three performers.

[1:05:32] Ben Rimalower: Um, and you can choose one of them to see as Dolly Levi.

[1:05:32] Laura Benanti: Okay.

[1:05:32] Ben Rimalower: One of them to see in concert, and one to kill.

[1:05:38] Laura Benanti: Oh, okay.

[1:05:39] Laura Benanti: Um, so should we do Julie Andrews, Patti LuPone, and Elaine Stritch?

[1:05:44] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:05:44] Laura Benanti: I kill Elaine Stritch.

[1:05:46] Laura Benanti: I um I watch um Patty do Dolly.

[1:05:53] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:05:53] Laura Benanti: And then I watch Julie Andrews in my concert.

[1:05:55] Ben Rimalower: Did you ever see Julie do anything?

[1:05:57] Laura Benanti: No.

[1:05:59] Laura Benanti: So before you came here, Ella likes to scroll through all the Elizas and listen to all of them.

[1:06:05] Laura Benanti: She's like, she's like, I want to hear mommy singing Loverly.

[1:06:07] Laura Benanti: And then I put it on and she's like, now Julie Andrews.

[1:06:10] Laura Benanti: And I put on Julie Andrews, and she's like, now Audrey Hepburn.

[1:06:13] Laura Benanti: And I'm like, you mean Marni Nixon?

[1:06:16] Laura Benanti: And then she and she goes, That is Julie Andrews.

[1:06:20] Laura Benanti: And I'm like, well, no, it's Marni Nixon, but she's two, so I'll let I'll let it slide.

[1:06:25] Ben Rimalower: But but Pat was like, Who's your favorite singer?

[1:06:27] Laura Benanti: And sort of begrudgingly, she was like, Mom.

[1:06:30] Ben Rimalower: Oh I know.

[1:06:32] Laura Benanti: I know.

[1:06:33] Laura Benanti: But that's so good.

[1:06:33] Laura Benanti: You're raised in a right with Marni Nixon.

[1:06:35] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:06:35] Laura Benanti: I didn't know about that until college.

[1:06:37] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:06:37] Laura Benanti: I mean, I knew about it, because my mom.

[1:06:38] Laura Benanti: But like it's just so funny to me.

[1:06:41] Laura Benanti: Like, I don't push this on her.

[1:06:42] Laura Benanti: I try to put on like kids' music like Rafi or whatever.

[1:06:46] Laura Benanti: She's I'll put on pop music and she's like, no, Echo, off.

[1:06:51] Laura Benanti: She hates it.

[1:06:53] Laura Benanti: She only wants to listen.

[1:06:54] Laura Benanti: Echo.

[1:06:55] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:06:55] Laura Benanti: Yeah.

[1:06:56] Laura Benanti: And it's today.

[1:06:57] Laura Benanti: Echo kept playing something, and she was like, you need to listen to me.

[1:07:01] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god.

[1:07:02] Laura Benanti: I love her.

[1:07:03] Laura Benanti: I love her.

[1:07:04] Laura Benanti: She's so funny.

[1:07:04] Ben Rimalower: Um, well, that's incredible.

[1:07:06] Ben Rimalower: I'm sure she's gonna be a force whenever she gets involved in.

[1:07:10] Laura Benanti: Look out.

[1:07:11] Laura Benanti: And uh, you're a force.

[1:07:12] Laura Benanti: And thank you so much for doing this.

[1:07:14] Laura Benanti: I love you guys, thank you.

[1:07:16] Laura Benanti: This is so much fun.

[1:07:17] Ben Rimalower: This was fun.

[1:07:19] Ben Rimalower: Thanks for listening to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World.

[1:07:23] Ben Rimalower: For more episodes, visit Broadway World, iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever podcasts do be.

[1:07:30] Ben Rimalower: Come back next week for four-time Tony winning lighting designer Kevin Adams, here to talk about the Jesus Christ Superstar soundtrack.

[1:07:37] Ben Rimalower: Other upcoming guests include America's coast-to-coast Dolly Levi Broadway superstar Carolee Carmelo, and our special Winter in a Summertown mini-season, featuring the most fabulous talents from Provincetown and Fire Island, including Faith Prince, Pixie Aventura, and Varla Jean Merman.

[1:07:55] Ben Rimalower: Oh.

[1:07:56] Ben Rimalower: This episode was edited by me, Daniel Nolen.

[1:07:58] Ben Rimalower: Special thanks to Emmy winning composer and lyricist Lance Horn for the broken records theme song.

[1:08:03] Ben Rimalower: Follow us both, Ben Rimalower and Daniel Nolen on all y'all's socials.

[1:08:07] Ben Rimalower: That's Ben Rimalower.

[1:08:13] Ben Rimalower: And that's Nolen with an E, not Nolen with an A.

[1:08:16] Ben Rimalower: Because Nolen with an A is an absolute.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred