Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 36: QuaranStreams (Liza in New Orleans)

In this episode, Ben and Daniel discuss Liza Minnelli's 1980 concert in New Orleans. They also talk about Halston, Judy Garland, Lorna Luft, Kander and Ebb, Harry Nilsson, Melissa Manchester, Barry Manilow, Bill LaVorgna, and Leslie Kritzer... Read More

From the show: Cast Offs with Ben and Daniel

2 h 20 mins
5/25/20

Featured Shows

About

In this episode, Ben and Daniel discuss Liza Minnelli's 1980 concert in New Orleans. They also talk about Halston, Judy Garland, Lorna Luft, Kander and Ebb, Harry Nilsson, Melissa Manchester, Barry Manilow, Bill LaVorgna, and Leslie Kritzer. Tune in to Ben and Daniel's weekly live show on Tuesdays and Thursdays at 10:30am EST on the BroadwayWorld Facebook page and Broadway Podcast Network YouTube channel to vote on upcoming QuaranStreams.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Ben Rimalower: Broken records. The albums you wouldn't shut up about. Broken records. The music our guests can't live without like Judy, Barbara, Liza, Bett, Daddy, Audra, Bernadette. We broadcast this podcast with hopes that someday we might get Patty LaPone.

[0:32] Ben Rimalower: Testies, testies. One, two, three? Three? That's my best Barbara Streisand. Um, three. Um, uh, what's my name? I'm Ben Rimalower. Welcome. That's out of order. Welcome to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World Broadway Podcast Network, and now Broadway on Demand. I'm Ben Rimalower, and I'm here with my lovely co-host Shelly Long.

[0:57] Ben Rimalower: Oh, thank you, Sam. Um, today's guest is Liza Minnelli's. Okay, I am reminding myself right now of Elaine Stritch when she won the Emmy. Uh-huh. I'm like, thank God! I don't know what I would have done if I couldn't have gotten out of me what I have to get out of me right now.

[1:24] Ben Rimalower: Was that the honestly? She's like, I'm so glad. Yeah, I won, and I'm so glad none of them won. I won. Cut to Sarah Jessica Parker. Um, I I um I'm still scared that like the ceiling is gonna cave in and I'm gonna die before we can finish recording this episode. I am I am I am so excited.

[1:48] Ben Rimalower: I have never been so excited in my Christian life. Well, I have to say, uh, okay, we have to give a little backstory of the behind the scenes process we went through to arrive at the conclusion that we were going to do Liza in New Orleans. Yes.

[2:05] Ben Rimalower: And I but I have to say before we do that, there was a comment uh on Instagram whenever we were polling uh the audience and the fans to see which uh diva concert they preferred. Someone replied that they wanted Bernadette because they wanted to hear you do your Bernadette impression the whole time.

[2:26] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, thank you for bringing that up. Honey, if you wanna, if you like Ben's Bernadette impression, you're gonna love his Liza because his Liza is his true forte. I mean it's like it's like wanting your Bernadette and not your Liza is being like, oh, I want to see Barbara Streisand in The Mirror Has Two Faces, but not Funny Girl.

[2:45] Daniel Nolen: You know, it's like your Liza is where your true gifts lie. Am I dreaming? Like, is this the best day of my life that we're gonna talk about Liza for two hours and it begins with you bringing up the importance of distinguishing that however good my Bernadette is, my Liza's even better.

[3:03] Ben Rimalower: Totally, it is true. Like your Liza is my favorite Liza. No one is no, I would rather hear you do Liza than anyone else. And that's that's the truth. That is love.

[3:14] Ben Rimalower: I really appreciate that. Yeah, so don't fuck it up. Well, I'm just pleased as punch that you would say that, darling. I mean, okay, I don't even know. So yeah, we did have a contest uh with our uh all of our fans everywhere, both of them.

[3:33] Ben Rimalower: Um, where uh uh we we asked people watching our live stream Tuesday, Thursday, April, August, and people following us on Instagram and Twitter and Facebook to vote. We gave them the three choices between Liza's New Orleans concert from 1980, Bette Midler's Diva Las Vegas from 1996, and Bernadette Peters live at Royal Festival Hall from 1997, I think.

[3:33] Ben Rimalower: Um, and uh Liza won handily, yes, although it was neck and neck Liza and Bernadette at least on Twitter for a bit. But I have to we have to do a shout out to uh friend of the pod Burnside Gooch on Twitter aka Karen Wilson. Yes, Burnside Gooch really campaigned hard for Liza.

[4:20] Daniel Nolen: Yes, she did. Yes, she did. I mean if we could get that burned might have won were it not for that.

[4:25] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. I'm surprised that Bette didn't do better in the poll. But the good news is that we will get to all of them. Yes, that's right for sure.

[4:36] Ben Rimalower: Um, and it made me realize how excited I am to do so because not only is this um the first diva solo concert that we've covered in the QuaranStreams series, but it's I think this is true maybe I'm wrong but I think it's the first one we've covered that I've watched not only so many times because some of these other videos I have watched many times like Sondheim at Carnegie Hall but um but that I've watched so many times even recently.

[4:36] Ben Rimalower: I mean Liza New Orleans uh is never far from my I was gonna say from my mouth but uh because I'll go there in a minute and have. And what a mouth. Uh but you know, anyway, I I still found the I mean, honestly, I I wish everyone can have in their life the joy that I had last night when I took my CBD drops and I dimmed the lights and I began, and it was a little bit of a gift from the universe because as we've mentioned before, Liza uh her Carnegie Hall album in 1979, of which her Andy Warhol album cover record was that unfortunately was never released on CD or digitally on iTunes or whatever.

[6:02] Ben Rimalower: But that fabulous album, which I do have on MP3s and we'll share with any of our listeners who request it. Ooh, yes. Um, Michael Feinstein, be damned. But uh that album is a great album.

[6:14] Ben Rimalower: And it is the same concert she was touring, which was filmed in New Orleans for uh for uh HBO, which is what this uh concert we're discussing is was. But uh but anyway, that concert was aired on HBO in I think 1982 or something.

[6:34] Ben Rimalower: And it was then released on VHS, and then later on it was released in the 90s on Laserdisc. Never on DVD, but um both the HBO broadcast and the VHS that was sold, and the Laserdisc that was sold all had different cuts of what had been the complete concert as captured live at Carnegie Hall on the LP.

[7:00] Ben Rimalower: And over the years, different versions have been shared by fans and then shared by fans on YouTube. And only last night, for the first time in my career, did I watch what the this most recent upload to YouTube was, which is the complete video.

[7:20] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[7:21] Ben Rimalower: And it represents the entire uncut concert. The only thing missing from this video, which is the link that is now in our Broken Records QuaranStreams playlist. The only thing missing is a stupid bullshit thing she does on the album of like um where she sings, I think it's now I can't even remember.

[7:41] Ben Rimalower: I think it's Someone to Watch Over Me, but it's about introducing the band. You know, she's like, 12 guys to watch over me. And then the band is just like riffing, and she's like, on the drums, Mr. Bill LaVorgna, you know, and like, yeah, Pappy. You know, all that is like that's missing from the video.

[8:03] Ben Rimalower: But everything else is on this video, including for God's sakes, yes. Obba Babatunde's solo of Mr. Cellophane and their dancing duet with her singing uh You Do Something to Me. This is truly complete.

[8:19] Ben Rimalower: So I had never seen the video of her singing some of my favorite songs from the Carnegie Hall album, including, believe it or not, London Town. Yes, brilliant. Including the uh marriage medley that includes the theme for Mr. Chips, you and I, and including um wait, is that it?

[8:41] Ben Rimalower: Or is there one more thing? Um, Marriage Medley. I think that's it. Yeah, those are the I mean the marriage medley really is. Amazing to have those. And I had seen her do uh London Town because she does it in her London concert from 1986.

[8:57] Daniel Nolen: But um, but I'd never seen her do the marriage medley at all. So we'll get to those songs when we get to them. But the point is last night when I sat down excited enough, thinking I was watching something I'd seen before, it was actually more complete.

[9:10] Ben Rimalower: And I just I took the journey of a lifetime. Take the journey of a lifetime. Let's hear it for Mr. Fred, ladies and gentlemen.

[9:20] Daniel Nolen: Um, I took the journey too, honey. I mean, you had uh, you know, a couple uh drops of CBD, I had a couple glasses of Chardonnay, and I uh, you know, it was it was like 11 p.m. I was like, oh shit, I gotta watch this real quick before tomorrow.

[9:36] Daniel Nolen: Like I keep forgetting. So I put it on and and I just really went in. I was, you know, it went by in a flash. I have to say, the listeners probably don't realize this, but Ben and I obviously are in quarantine and we don't watch these together.

[9:50] Daniel Nolen: Not only do we not watch them together, we don't text each other during them. We really we have no com and I one of the things I honestly the number one thing I'm excited about in my life in my weeks right now is watching these videos and then talking to Ben about them here in the pod.

[10:08] Ben Rimalower: And last night I happened to text a group of our friends who are on a text chain together already because we're Fire Island housemates, because I was so into Liza's um people in this video, and it was the surprise to me because in the past I had written this off because I mean I liked it, I respected it, um, and I remember it.

[10:29] Ben Rimalower: But I but I but I my favorite some people and my favorite Liza, some people obviously, is her Radio City version from 1991. And but I suddenly watching this video last night thought, no, this is my favorite.

[10:44] Ben Rimalower: And I literally feel like I'm not getting enough oxygen because I'm talking with too much excitement. I might faint. But but I texted the group thread just to be like, remind me just to take a poll, which of you guys, because I know we had got we had sort of vetted the two choices last summer on Fire Island.

[10:50] Ben Rimalower: Which of you guys preferred 1980 and which of you preferred 1990? And one of the people to text back, no surprise, was yours truly Daniel Nolen. And I immediately was like, no, no, wrong ingredients.

[11:14] Daniel Nolen: And your eyes.

[11:16] Ben Rimalower: For Daniel and I cannot discuss this. I like, I don't know how I forgot Daniel was one of my Fire Island housemates. And um, but I was like, then I texted Daniel. I was like, being on this text chain with you, oh, because not only that, Daniel wrote back that he had just watched it like seconds earlier.

[11:32] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, this is like seeing the bride before the wedding night. I like can't, I can't have this moment of contact.

[11:40] Daniel Nolen: Right, right.

[11:41] Ben Rimalower: Um, that's how excited I felt. So uh let's just dive into the bitch. I will say, first of all, though, I'm mad at the patriarchy and I'm mad at HBO. Why is this not on HBO on demand?

[11:51] Ben Rimalower: Why is this not on HBO Go? Why is this on HBO Max, HBO Now? This should be available to HBO subscribers everywhere. I'm so angry that we have to get this, like, you know, like as if we're like, I don't know what, like, you know, as if we're like watching in Singapore or London or something, you know.

[12:14] Ben Rimalower: We are American citizens, and we pay our HBO dues or our parents do, and we have their password, and we should be able to get it on in beautiful HD quality, not on YouTube. Nonetheless, it's 2020 is a human right. Hashtag Liza Forever.

[12:33] Ben Rimalower: You know what? It's 2020 and it's a pandemic, and we are a global community. Honestly, my best friends right now are Joe Barriers, You're Gonna Love Tomorrow in uh uh Portugal, and Mark, whatever his last name is, Dublin Zotrope in Ireland.

[12:51] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[12:51] Ben Rimalower: And you know, we're a global community of fans, just like we were a global community when I was a freshman in college on rec.arts.theatre.musicals, and I was bonding with Elaine Page's number one fan, June Grand Chan in Singapore and or Hong Kong.

[13:09] Ben Rimalower: And we would um, we would trade bootlegs of Patty and Elaine in Sunset Boulevard. That's beautiful.

[13:17] Ben Rimalower: So it's a global community once again, and we are all equal, and it is all uh it's it's proletariat, you know, and so indeed we are on YouTube. So we have this gift on YouTube of the complete concert, and the first motherfucking oh, and I also have to say that even before the concert started, by I loved having the poll and the votes uh on social media because you got to hear from our fans and also just from our friends, some of whom I don't even think listen to the podcast, like the brilliant Kevin Daly, who uh is is just so smart and has such exquisite taste, even when we don't agree.

[13:55] Ben Rimalower: And um, and he went, he was just like, you know, with such passion, uh, advocating that we choose Liza and talking about the just the artistry of her um and by the way, he's a huge Bernadette fan.

[14:11] Ben Rimalower: And I'm just sure to guess Bernadette, and I'm sure no stranger to the work of Ms. Midler. But he was advocating so this moment, like I'm sure you'll relate, Daniel, when we haven't even begun talking about the song by song, and I'm already getting close to my first pee break.

[14:30] Daniel Nolen: Bad direction. I'm just downing this coke with so much excitement. Wrapping up this section of the preview, I just have to say that you know, Kevin Daly made a case for Liza, and he pointed out how exquisitely the artistry of the opening of this, the entrance of her with no fanfare, coming out with no music, just walking out on stage.

[14:55] Ben Rimalower: No, not even like a hi everybody. You know, she just w I'm gonna make you regret that you ever complimented my Liza impression. That's my goal. I'm gonna overkill you. I'm gonna kill you with Liza.

[15:06] Daniel Nolen: Oh no, I want it. I want it. But that started, and I was just like, fuck me with no lube. This is so genius. Like she just walks out and standing ovation!

[15:19] Ben Rimalower: Standing oh, baby. I mean, it's like she literally is a part of that stage, like she's literally growing out of the stage, rooted in her body, grounded, just being like the earth mother to this gay, thirsty New Orleans audience.

[15:36] Daniel Nolen: Um, it's like it's like a barren post-apocalyptic earth. Yeah, a scorched, scorched earth where nothing can grow, and then as if by a miracle, there's this tiny little sprout, and that's Liza walking out in silence.

[15:52] Ben Rimalower: That's right. And when that standing ovation goes, and she stands there humbly with no music, no musicians, nobody behind her, just her and the Halston. And you're just like Halston. And you just know.

[16:09] Daniel Nolen: I mean, the other thing, the word that I kept coming back to in this concert is edging. Mmm. And it's like that's real, especially right now. It's like I am naked on this table in Koreatown, and like they have just asked me to flip over onto my back. And like, you know, just like their forearm has just gently grazed my private.

[16:42] Ben Rimalower: Right. But chain right now. And just like the winds of change are stirring, and we know. We know where this is going.

[16:53] Daniel Nolen: Oh my god. Oh my god, it's so funny. It's so true. I mean, yeah, we know where this is going. She comes on, everything about her is just so such perfection. I mean, the purple sequin Halston, the eyeshadow to match.

[17:10] Ben Rimalower: Um, and then she sings, How long has this been going on? No, before she sings how long this been going on, she sings this little introductory verse taken with special lyrics written by Fred Ebb, but it's taken from On the Attic into Pika and the Santa Fe.

[17:28] Daniel Nolen: And I just thought, what kind of Judy Garland mind fuck is this? Right. It's like, it's like, it's so it's like, it's like we don't want to talk about Judy. We don't want to talk about Judy. I am my own wife, goddammit. We don't want to talk about Judy.

[17:45] Ben Rimalower: And by the way, she doesn't need to talk about Judy. She's her huge star. She's like the highest paid film star in America. Oh no, no, no, no, let's not get it twisted. Not quite, not anymore.

[17:56] Daniel Nolen: But she's still a number one celebrity in the gossip columns. Like she doesn't need to ride any trains, and yet, it's like, well, I mean, in fairness, you know, Liza is someone that straddles eras, straddles generations. And even though she's doing the blow in the back room, it's in the basement at Studio 54, and she's very much the disco 70s.

[18:21] Ben Rimalower: This concert makes such a strong, strong case for the fact that Liza is the artist who transcends both worlds because she is equally at home in the old school Hollywood musicals and the old time show business.

[18:35] Daniel Nolen: Yes. And it's like, as much as she doesn't mention Judy, in a way, there's the subtle argument to be made, like Liza is a product of old school show business, she's going to use that. And well, if you're talking about old school show business, who was the world's greatest entertainer ever.

[18:54] Ben Rimalower: It's not about Judy being her mother. It's just that you can't swing a dead cat in old school show business. You know, we only have one Judy, and she only had one repertoire. Why shouldn't I want the best? Because you're a poor girl from a poor family, and whatever Yenta brings, you'll take, right?

[19:12] Daniel Nolen: Of course, right. Yeah, I mean, that's so funny you bring that up because I was having this moment. It was very. I felt like I was high or having a stroke or both. But I was sitting here watching her on my TV and just watching her be such a goddamn star.

[19:34] Ben Rimalower: And I had this moment where I was like, wait, I that is she Judy Garland's daughter? Like I had completely forgotten any sort of relation of hers to Judy, you know, because she's such a so singular and so her own person and her own performer.

[19:51] Daniel Nolen: And then when she started singing these songs that we associate with Judy at Carnegie Hall, I was like, oh fuck, that's right. She came out of Little Judy Garland. Like that is Judy Garland's offspring. And that is such a mind fuck to me sometimes because it's like I think of Liza as Liza and Judy as Judy.

[20:10] Ben Rimalower: And I of course, you know, we laugh and we have the footage of them singing together and all those stories and Liza's funny interview questions. But when I really sit down and think about it, it really fucks with my brain thinking Judy Garland gave birth to Liza, and they were both such huge individual, unique special talents.

[20:32] Daniel Nolen: They're so different, and they are so the same. It's like it's such a dichotomy that like my human brain cannot wrap itself around that. Yes, I mean, I it was truly like tripping me up last night.

[20:45] Ben Rimalower: Well, I mean, so the it's when the music, when she does start singing a cappella, I could cry. So did she use. And it's so, she's giving it no gas. It's like, it's like it no, sorry, that's more later. But it's it is so, it is so, it's it's like it's this crazy thing of Liza where it's like both subtle and like completely hit over the head with a like anvil.

[21:15] Daniel Nolen: It's like a subtle anvil. Because it's like she's not, she's not going like you know, she's not the big Liza you think of. She's like taking it slow and like it's like low-key, but at the same time, she's like, if you spelled out phonetically Henry Higgins style, like what the vowels are.

[21:39] Ben Rimalower: It's impossible. It's like she's like, it reminds me of like in Gone with the Wind when like Scarlett O'Hara is at the barbecue with her best friend um uh Kathleen Shalf, not Kathleen Shalfant, what's it? Olivia? Olivia De Havilin? No, Scarlett O'Hara's best friend. She's a bit part in the movie.

[21:56] Daniel Nolen: Her Kathleen Calvert. Is that her name? Oh and they're like on the stairs, and like Scarlett's like, who's that like nasty dog looking man? And it's like Rhett Butler. And she's like, my dear, that's Rhett Butler. He's simply not rechaped.

[22:12] Ben Rimalower: And like, I can't remember her fucking name, but I think it's Kathleen Calvert. But um, but like that, like Liza sh talks like Kathleen Calvert.

[22:20] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But she uh it's so crazy. But and then so the songs she's getting into it, and it's like uh the first thing I thought is when the camera pulls away and we get this whole stage shot. I was so angry at HBO for not releasing this because it gets so fuzzy, and I'm watching it, you know, this is a YouTube upload.

[22:38] Ben Rimalower: I'm watching it on my 55-inch TV, and it becomes like you know, a pointless painting that I can like barely make out. And yet, nobody but Liza Minnelli's could cut through.

[22:51] Daniel Nolen: Yes. I'm sorry. Not Judy Garland, not Elaine Stritch, not Ethel Merman, not Harvey Feierstein, not Zero Mostel, not Carol Channing. Liza! Like a fucking disco ball.

[23:05] Ben Rimalower: It was like, I was I was thinking that as well. I was like, oh god, it's so fucking fuzzy. And then it was like the Halston of it all, uh, the Liza, it was just face. And then right when she's like, um uh uh what it what what is what's the last part she sings of how long has this been going on right before miracle?

[23:24] Daniel Nolen: Where she's like how long how long, how long has this no no that's later, that's like the end. Um that's miracle. No, but what but when she's uh the she's like uh uh oh she's like uh no how Columbus felt uh finding another No sorry kiss me once and once more says I was before heaven say how long is this?

[23:57] Ben Rimalower: I don't know, but I guess it is into uh um yeah, it is just uh to the case. Yeah, I think that's right. Not the world it's a minute. Yes, so right before she right before she modulated there, I like I was like, I have to pause right now, and I just want to appreciate the fierce chill that she is nailing.

[24:24] Daniel Nolen: Because at this moment, we're basically at a jazz concert, okay? Like, there is like smooth saxophone happening, okay? She is standing in place, and she is like, uh no. How Columbus felt. And it's just like the lighting, and it's just, we are in the for all we know, she's about to pull out a fat blunt, take a big hit and pass it to the drummer.

[25:00] Ben Rimalower: And we are just gonna sit here all night enjoying live music, okay? We're gonna order like a red wine or like some heroin or whatever is your poison. And we are just gonna like just like feel the candles glow on our faces.

[25:16] Daniel Nolen: Like that is what's happening right now. And if you don't know, then you don't know. Like, and so I just wanted to celebrate that this beautiful thing has been cocked and it is about to be shattered completely. And I and and speaking of that transition, uh, I think it's right when she's like, it's uh miracle.

[25:38] Ben Rimalower: On that ah vowel, she sounds so much like Judy. Her voice is like like uh she's like channeling Judy's uh open belt voice on that a vowel. It's so chilling. She when she goes into like music hall, like her doing Al Jolson, her singing on the palace stage, belting for the gods, when she's a full throttle entertainer, that's when she's Judy.

[26:12] Daniel Nolen: When she is like a jazz singer, she's somebody else. She's like Charles Asnivore or Kay Thompson, or I don't know who she is. You know, but but it's not like Judy had a lot more like head voice and like beauty and cream when she cooned. Liza is more of like a spoken word artiste, you know.

[26:29] Ben Rimalower: But when she's belting for the gods, that's when it's pure Judy. She really opens it up. But the crazy thing I noticed here that I never noticed before is in that transition, she's like, she actually like I had to go back and watch it a second and then a third time because I kept I kept thinking that can't be what I think it was.

[26:52] Daniel Nolen: Because at first I was like, oh, she just looks down and then looks up again. But no, it's not only that, she actually lets her chin drop lifeless to her chest before she picks her head up in the new song. It's almost like she's a puppet, and Fred Ebb, like they do not justify an acting beat transition here.

[27:17] Ben Rimalower: She literally is like, she's like, new song. It's so crazy. They do not have a transition. There is no segue. She's like, complete dead, like a scarecrow. Her head falls lifeless to her chest and then pops up.

[27:37] Daniel Nolen: It's a miracle! A true blue spectacle, miracle come true. We're together. And it's like, I mean, I think somebody snuck her a bump of coke in that second. It's a complete, a complete left turn. It's 180 degrees. It's zero to 60. There's absolutely no effort made to justify the acting beat. It just flies, and she goes so fast, you have nowhere to go but with her.

[28:06] Ben Rimalower: That's right.

[28:07] Daniel Nolen: And that modulation at the end, uh, kiss me once then once more. It is so good.

[28:12] Ben Rimalower: And I was uh, yeah, I that's when I refilled the wine. I was screaming.

[28:18] Daniel Nolen: Wait, we are not I am not there yet. I have to keep going through the minutia of this song.

[28:23] Ben Rimalower: I mean, the uh the she sings the first verse of Miracle, and then there's a very, very, very, very short instrumental where she just after standing dead still and being that jazz singer, that like Troubadour in the beginning. Now in this first version of Miracle, it's like this is Liza with a Z. It's like that she does a little box step or something and does her signature walk down stage where you know that her inner monologue is like, I must tell you.

[28:58] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally, totally. It's like it's so, it's just I I don't know what it is. It just it works so brilliantly.

[29:04] Ben Rimalower: And it's I also remembered that the first time I ever saw this concert, my uncle made me a VHS of his laser disc, my Uncle Mitchell. Thank you, Uncle Mitchell. For all the gifts, but perhaps none greater than this one. This VHS of a laser disc in 1997. And I was a huge fan of Liza with the Z, which is of course a great Fosse film.

[29:24] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[29:29] Ben Rimalower: And he made me a VHS of this laser disc, which is a live capture of a great Fred Ebb stage spectacular. And I think I was judging it along the lines of Liza with the Z. And because, you know, the same way we were talking, I don't remember, no, I don't think it was on the pod. I think it was on the live stream about like those like yeah, it was because oh, exactly. It was well, I don't know what we were. I th uh what was your what would Oh with the Goldie Han Goldie and Liza together. When Goldie sang um YMCA with the boys in the short shorts and the tall striped socks.

[30:07] Daniel Nolen: And I was saying how the 70s disco aesthetic was so spat upon during my childhood in the 80s and 90s. I was so like, it was so ingrained in me to disown that that here I was in college, like the biggest fag living for Liza Manelli. But my uncle gave me this video, and as I was feeling her singing, How Long Has This Been Going On? And then when she goes into this Barry Manilow, by the way, speaking of Copa Cabana, this this 70s disco moment of Miracle. I was like, oh, this is cheesy. This is not good and artistic and cool, like Fosse's film Lies with a Z. This Fred Ebb Fagatry is not cool. And I like, I didn't like it. You know, I judged it. I felt like it was a piece of tacky show business from the generation before me that I didn't appreciate, you know.

[31:00] Ben Rimalower: And so watching it, and of course, now for years I've loved it. I mean, you know, I don't know if people necessarily know this, but I actually launched a project. We were gonna do Liza 79 as uh a solo cabaret theater piece at Joe's pub. Um, not for me, it was gonna be Larry Owens and a couple other people, but anyway, but I mean I I worship this piece, but I didn't when I was 21 and I first watched it. And so watching it last night, I was just thinking about like it's the exact same moment, 1980, as Laney Kazan doing her hideous, disastrous Copa Cabana, also Barry Manilow, on the MDA telethon. And here's Liza in her own sequence doing a different Barry Manilow song that same year, and yet it's the epitome of artistry. You know?

[31:46] Daniel Nolen: And this is the period we talk about so much on this pod about that weird section of time after disco died, uh, kind of before the real 80s began, before AIDS, when there was that it was right in the early 80s. It was a weird patch of time, but there's so much content that we're consuming and talking about from that time.

[32:08] Ben Rimalower: Yes, totally. And it's and Liza is is the the quintessential performer who straddled both sides of that. She did not straddle the um, excuse me, she didn't really transition successfully necessarily into the 80s, although she did, in a way, she kind of uh she kind of beat the odds when you think about the successes that she did have in the 80s, considering how out of date and out of fashion what she has to do became. But but in terms of this moment, right before that happened, you know, she really can encapsulate the disco. I mean, she was a disco star, even though her disco album uh Tropical Nights was not a success. She was a star of the disco era. She was literally a star at Studio 54, and she was this old school show business. And um, it's uh it's just thrilling.

[33:00] Daniel Nolen: I mean, the the uh I don't know, do you have anything more to say about the opening number?

[33:04] Ben Rimalower: No, no, just yeah, that modulation at the end is is everything.

[33:08] Daniel Nolen: Everything.

[33:09] Ben Rimalower: And it's such a fabulous, it's such a full throttle modulation that it actually changes her hairstyle. Like, I mean, she goes into the second song, well, second Medley, but it starts with my ship. And when the spotlight and the close-up goes on her for the top of that song, there's no banter in between. She just just scraped, how long, how long has this miracle been going? Uh and sorry, I'm so sorry. I apologize for that.

[33:35] Daniel Nolen: No, it's um, but uh, and you know, huge applause because people's minds have been blown by this thrilling open thrilling opening, and the next thing we know, this the spotlight on her with those fucking doe eyes. Honey, her hair has been completely restyled just by her belting. The force of her belting, the force of her belting. Her eyes, looking into her eyes at this moment, I wrote down, it's like looking into the Greek comedy and tragedy masks.

[34:05] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[34:05] Daniel Nolen: It's like Liza Minnelli's's eyes. Because literally the two eyes don't match. Her fucked up face, her Picasso of a face, the eyes do not match. They are they're a pair, they're yin and yang. They are comedy and tragedy.

[34:20] Ben Rimalower: That is genius, Daniel.

[34:22] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean. And this is where I thought, what the fuck? She's not even singing. It's it's exactly what I was talking about, but the by it not being Judy. And of course, this is a Kurt Weill tune. It is appropriate. But she's literally like, if this is the smallest thing in the world, my ship has sailed that um made of wax, whatever. Shilk. And rupees, fill it, deck. And it's so conversational.

[34:48] Ben Rimalower: And of jam and spice. There's a paradise in the hold. And as it starts to build, when it's a low note that's comfortably enough in her conversational chest register, she will allow that resonance to infuse the vocal line. But only if it is done effortlessly in the conversational chest register. She will allow no belting to happen. And when it goes above that musically, when the notes get higher and it is no longer in that range, even though it's a very, very comfortable place for Liza's belt placement in this point in her career, she does not do it. She goes, of jam and spice. She will not, she keeps her chill. It stays low key. It is so and and you know that it is an edging, but it is the slowest, is the slowest possible edging.

[35:54] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, well, and you know what, you know when you finally get a little the first little spurt from the edging is whenever she she slides into that someday he'll come. You know, but even before that, even before that, when she's like, ship I sing, doesn't also bring my own true love to me. Inflowship, uh there she goes, my true love. And you're like, you're like, fuck me, fuck me. What's happening? She gets her little hell. Why is she doing that? And then she goes in, someday he'll come along. And it is so mind-blowing.

[36:38] Ben Rimalower: And that moment is like, is is I I was jumping around my apartment screaming because Dante will come along. It's like she's uh, I don't know, it's it's it yeah. It is the brilliant edging. It's that moment in the blowjob when you're like, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, I'm gonna come, I'm gonna I I I yeah, stop, you know, and Liza's like, Liza's like, I know Brady, I got you. I got you. She's just she's just letting you get that spine tingling thrill that you think you can't take it, and then she backs off. And the audience goes so crazy for that transition, and it feels like Judy and Carnegie Hall, like when Judy goes into Over the Rainbow or when Barbara uh on the end of Funny Girl, Barbara goes into that.

[37:25] Daniel Nolen: But it doesn't make any sense. New York, New York was a flop, okay? And this song that she sang thrillingly in New York, New York, it's not her song. I mean, she had in that movie New York, New York, or sorry, the theme from New York, New York. She had and the world goes round. This was a standard that everybody and their fucking mother sings, okay? Literally, everyone sings this song. Liza did not have a hit record with with uh my with what's it called? Not my man, what's it called? Uh uh When My Ship Comes In. No, no, no. My Man I Love, The Man I Love.

[38:00] Ben Rimalower: But they clap literally as if it's cabaret.

[38:04] Daniel Nolen: Right.

[38:04] Ben Rimalower: They clap as if it's Judy singing over the rainbow or Barbara singing people. It's because honestly, I can't think of any other moment in any other Diva where the sheer just vocal authority and show business gravitas and the stage theatrical prowess. The way she the way she how do you pronounce that word? Essays or essays.

[38:30] Daniel Nolen: The way she essays, yeah.

[38:32] Ben Rimalower: The way she essays, this transition is so masterful. It's like, you know, it it's so we talk about like the shifting molecules in the room. It's like she's a scientist, and and we're all a part of this experiment, and she suddenly put a little drop of like some chemical in the mix, and we're all like, oh fuck, what is happening? We don't know, but we're feeling it. Honestly, like I wanted to go find random straight people on the street and be like, come up to my apartment for a minute, you gotta see this.

[39:02] Daniel Nolen: It's like it's and by the way, the only tell that she has, it's so masterful, and she's so just like slowly fucking you. She's sliding that cock inside you, just she's not breaking eye contact for one second. Her face is not betraying the ginormous monster meat that's going into your hole. Except she does take one quick second to flip her hair, as if she's like, Mama needs a sip of air for this baby. Like she mean it's just so crazy.

[39:40] Ben Rimalower: And yeah, I just honestly, and and then I started thinking, like, as she was just bringing me to the heights of ecstasy in this number, the heights, because she because then it backs off, right? You think you're about to come and you fucking can't take it from this transition, but then she backs off and she's like, Maybe I will see him Sunday. Maybe Monday, maybe not. It's like, okay, so now it's gone back to a lower level of energy where you're like, I can take it. I'm still throbbing, I still don't know how much longer I can go, but I'm no longer in like the red lights flashing, like amber alert, like we've got, you know, this is all about to crash, you know.

[40:25] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.

[40:25] Ben Rimalower: So, like, now you can just kind of like enjoy the ride for a minute, like look in her eyes and like trust her that she's gonna be like a loving top, you know. And like, while you're having this experience, like, so you have a little time to process what you're enjoying. And I was thinking, like, okay, now she's singing The Man I Love, and it is wonderful. It is 10, 10, 10 across the board. But you know what? Other people have sung this song at a 10, also, or at least, or at least at a nine. You know what? And Liza has sung lots of other songs. As a matter of fact, I was like, comparing this 1980 performance of The Man I Love with Liza's performance of lots of songs on some of her albums that are my favorite albums, which are her albums from the early 70s that are released later in the AM collection.

[41:17] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[41:17] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[41:17] Ben Rimalower: But it includes the album New Feeling and um, I forget what the other LPs were called, but there was a a four-disc, uh a two-disc for LP collection called the AM collection, right?

[41:30] Ben Rimalower: And it has a lot, as a matter of fact, it has The Man I Love. And I'm like, it's not so much that her skill as a singer or a vocalist or a song interpreter. It's not so much that it's grown between 1973 and 1980. That's not what makes this so spectacular. And I was like, what's making this so spectacular is how she has arrived at as a theatrical performer. It's not, it's not what she's doing with the man I love. It's how this experience has been layered from the way she walked on stage to the way she sang the thing from on the Atches and Topeka, into how long is this been going on, the way that built, the crazy left turn transition to the way she went straight from that into my ship, the way my ship built, you know, and this that is an art form that not anyone does it as well as her, I don't think.

[42:36] Ben Rimalower: And certainly no one is doing that now. And I don't think I don't think she ever had much competition, even at the, you know, and and even in the glory days, I mean, I didn't get to see Joelson at the palace, you know, and I didn't see Judy at Carnegie Hall. But it's it's a very, very, very special, special, unique gift that Liza has.

[42:58] Daniel Nolen: And it's anachronistic. It's anachronistic. Even when Liza was doing this in 1980, it was already something that nobody else was doing and was no longer in vogue, you know, and it's like yeah, that's a really good point. I just, I just was like, that's what this is. This is like the art, the art of what she has done, the craft of how this last 11 minutes or 14 minutes or 16 minutes, whatever it has been from curtain up until this moment.

[43:28] Ben Rimalower: I was like, this has been done with absolute perfection. And the crafting.

[43:34] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[43:35] Ben Rimalower: It's like Liza's not just a charismatic personality with, you know, uh energy and a good dancer, but she is an artist who right now is expressing her uh in her in her chosen medium is expressing herself to us in a way that is all the stars are aligned, and she's doing it perfectly to the best of her talents and abilities in a way that is so focused and streamlined, and it's uh you know, thrilling and inspiring.

[44:04] Daniel Nolen: And that's the difference between this and Liza with the Z is that Liza with the Z was a Fosse film, and Liza was a performer in it, and her talent as an actress and a singer and a dancer, and even to extent as a stage uh perform, you know, a live performer, an audience captivator, was utilized. Those were elements in Fosse's creation.

[44:28] Ben Rimalower: This, however, is just a video capturing of the greatest live performer of our time at her peak.

[44:37] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally. I mean, this is like uh, you know, Liza with a Z could be like um uh Joni, like let's her like Joni Mitchell blue, and then like uh, which is wonderful, and that's it's great, and it's what brings her all this uh uh uh justifiably so attention and praise. But then when you get to Liza uh Carnegie Hall, Liza New Orleans, it's like that is like the court and spark, the hissing of summer lawns.

[45:05] Ben Rimalower: It's like the work is maturing, yes, it's it's getting different, but it's it's uh it's it's building on what she's given us and and it's taking us to a new level. And then we take yet another uh not really a left turn because after The Man I Love, there is um uh, you know, there is no logical next step because we could all just go home.

[45:30] Daniel Nolen: But it did feel to me there was a definite uh that section was over.

[45:34] Ben Rimalower: Yes, now it's released to the rest of the show.

[45:38] Daniel Nolen: Yes, totally. And it and I mean, in a sense, that was the opening number, you know.

[45:42] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yes, exactly. And so, and what do we do? We go straight into some people, and it is fucking musical theater.

[45:49] Daniel Nolen: It is musical comedy. I mean, it's like, lest anyone forget this is also the greatest musical theater star of her generation. By the way, fuck you, Barbara Streisand, you know.

[46:01] Ben Rimalower: Because, by the way. Like, you know, uh, this Patty and Bernadette, those kids, you know, like they could learn it. This is a musical theater. This is the star. This is it. This is the sun and the moon.

[46:13] Daniel Nolen: And she goes into some people, and it's like right from the beginning when she's singing and she's like, I had a dream. I'm like, oh my god. Like, she is a belter on the level of Ethel.

[46:26] Ben Rimalower: Merman.

[46:27] Daniel Nolen: Yes. Like, I was like, how could I have ever preferred, how could I have ever preferred her Radio City, some people? You know, I mean, that is a thing unto itself, and I always will love that on its own terms. But this is literally like that is like a Liza Ism. This is actually a performance of some people.

[46:47] Ben Rimalower: Yes, one. This is actually the song.

[46:50] Daniel Nolen: And she's actually singing it. And like, you know, that merman belt rips out. And then when she goes into um, all about June in the Arphium circuit, give me a chance, and I know I can work it.

[47:00] Ben Rimalower: I haven't, I realized everyone else does this kind of as a don't rant on my parade type, you know, don't tell me don't thing, you know.

[47:11] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, uh, but this was like pathos to me.

[47:16] Ben Rimalower: Mmm.

[47:17] Daniel Nolen: Yes. This was like Liza talking to like Vincent and Judy when they were like, kid, don't go into show business, you know, like, and she's like, Don't you know understand, mama? I've got to, you know. You know?

[47:28] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[47:29] Daniel Nolen: And it reminded me of speaking of Liza with the Z, of those crazy medleys he had her do, like, Mama wakes up and she's alone.

[47:37] Ben Rimalower: Not your dad.

[47:39] Daniel Nolen: That's too bad.

[47:41] Ben Rimalower: You know?

[47:41] Daniel Nolen: Yes. Baby, baby bunting. Daddy's gonna hunting.

[47:46] Ben Rimalower: Daddy's gone.

[47:47] Daniel Nolen: You know, this was like, I was like seeing all that anguish in her eyes during this like crazy patter part that's usually.

[48:00] Ben Rimalower: Um not that.

[48:01] Daniel Nolen: Yes, exactly. And that's something that I was so aware of throughout this whole concert. Uh, the whole time I was like, who is she talking to? Because it's so obvious there is someone she's talking to, and and telling the either telling the story to or having this interaction with.

[48:16] Ben Rimalower: You know, in in music theater uh training, they always talk about like sing to your other. You know, who's the other? Who are you having the conversation with? What are they saying?

[48:24] Daniel Nolen: And this is how you're you're responding with the lyrics of the song to some sort of um, you know, their side of the conversation. And and in so many of these songs in this uh evening of Liza, you are so aware of that, and it's you're like uh whoa, fuck. Like, who who's she talking to?

[48:40] Ben Rimalower: Like it's yeah, you know, is it is it Vincent? Is it Desi Arnaz Jr.? Is it Judy?

[48:47] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah. Well, um brings the house down, you know.

[48:53] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, and speaking of. And you feel kind of like she invented some people in a way, because it's like the you know, now I think we think of that as such like an out-of-context show tune.

[49:04] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[49:05] Ben Rimalower: But there's I feel like this audience, they're like, oh, right, that's from Gypsy. Like, I you know, and by the way, when you go back and listen to like the Merman Gypsy, it's like a ballad.

[49:16] Daniel Nolen: Like, you know, it's it's really like, you know, she's like, a song people can get a thrill.

[49:25] Ben Rimalower: You know, and yeah.

[49:26] Daniel Nolen: It's like, you know, and this, which is not nearly as fast as Liza was about to do it years later, but it's still so much fast.

[49:34] Ben Rimalower: You know, it's like, and you know, and of course, Angela's like, some people can get the thrill. Knitting sweaters, I'm sitting still.

[49:43] Daniel Nolen: You know, but this is like uh a full vocal and at a quick clipped tempo.

[49:49] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[49:49] Daniel Nolen: And it's um, I think the audience experiences this song as like a don't rate on my despite what I said about the pathos in the subtext. I think they experience it as a don't random my parade type, you know, show tune up up number in a way that they that they're not expecting.

[50:10] Ben Rimalower: And and the and it gets it really stops the show yet again right away after it was just stopped.

[50:15] Daniel Nolen: And this is something I think we've talked about last week on the live stream, but we definitely should do an episode uh maybe over Gypsy or something, and we need to go through and really dive into like which ladies sing which songs the best from Gypsy because there is uh yeah, so much work to be done there.

[50:34] Ben Rimalower: Yes, but so much work to be done. One more thing about some people, you were talking about the the merman-esque belt.

[50:39] Daniel Nolen: And um the the way my favorite part for that is whenever at the end she's singing um uh goodbye to blueberry pa, and she like her voice, it is kind of like a merman flip.

[50:54] Ben Rimalower: It's like her voice kind of breaks, but like intentionally, and and it's her it's so powerful, and that is the moment where I was like, Oh yeah, this is my favorite, Liza.

[51:04] Daniel Nolen: Some people, and that's when you I got your message, and I was like, Yes, I agree. Because I love that other one from the 90s as well, and that's the one that is more available on YouTube and pops up more.

[51:14] Ben Rimalower: But this one is is restaurant quality, and and this like Jimmy Durante ending. I mean, it's like but not raws.

[51:24] Daniel Nolen: The only the only complaint I have about this one is that she doesn't give us the girls.

[51:29] Ben Rimalower: Well, I don't it's like I I think she saved her cocaine for like after this concert, you know.

[51:34] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[51:35] Ben Rimalower: Um but uh anyway, and then she finally does banter like f four songs in, or if it depends how you're counting, you know, seven songs in. And I'm like, right, this is when you fucking do banter.

[51:49] Daniel Nolen: Like, I hope the girls out there are taking notes for their don't tell mama shows, you know.

[51:52] Ben Rimalower: Yes, no, I I totally uh I wrote that down too because I was like, this is uh genius banter.

[52:01] Daniel Nolen: And it's so I mean, I you almost worry that it's too um, it's too Fred Ebb.

[52:09] Ben Rimalower: Like scripted, yeah, you know, and and scripted like almost like not, you know, it's like I don't want to say his voice, not her voice, because he has done such a good job of creating or helping create her voice, but it feels like it leans a little bit in his voice, but she really pulls it off in this instance, you know, like this idea about doing research.

[52:31] Daniel Nolen: Like, like we all know Liza doesn't do research, you know.

[52:34] Ben Rimalower: Right.

[52:35] Daniel Nolen: Even if she actually does research, certainly, like, she knows that we think she doesn't, you know.

[52:41] Ben Rimalower: Right, it's very that though. The tone of it's very, like, jokey, and she even makes that Studio 54 joke at her expense. She's like, you know, that's not my idea of a good time.

[52:50] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[52:50] Daniel Nolen: Yeah. And um it's uh, but you know, I I will say I regretted the um uh oh sorry, wait, this is yeah, this is the thing about um the Ballads.

[53:04] Ben Rimalower: The Ballad, yes.

[53:06] Daniel Nolen: Right before the end in town. I mean, and it's I have to say this number, and it's maybe just because it's the version that I knew first. I think I prefer the one from London in 1986.

[53:18] Ben Rimalower: Um she's heavier in that uh incarnation.

[53:23] Daniel Nolen: And um she's dressed crazy dressed. I mean, it's like a Kirsti Alley look, speaking of cheers.

[53:30] Ben Rimalower: I mean, she's she's heavier, and in this section of the concert, she's wearing what I can only describe as a glittering red mohair sweater with a leather mini skirt, black tights.

[53:44] Daniel Nolen: Oh, yes, another one.

[53:46] Ben Rimalower: And and her hair is like frosted blonde with great big flipped bangs, and like uh, and I think that she kind of does.

[53:59] Daniel Nolen: Well, I feel weird about saying this because one thing I've noticed listening to the pod and watching our videos is I feel like I can be kind of misogynist when I talk about women's bodies and clothing.

[54:10] Ben Rimalower: And um, I really don't want to be that.

[54:14] Daniel Nolen: I mean, especially considering not that it's okay for a straight man to be misogynist, but like at least they like are getting a boner out of it.

[54:22] Ben Rimalower: Like, what's my horse in the race?

[54:24] Daniel Nolen: It feels really pointless. Um, like, I I really like I don't know, I just want to at least say it out loud.

[54:33] Ben Rimalower: But I so I'm not sure what the like um you know woke way to like express this idea would be, or rather, what's the you know, what's a non-misogy perspective on you know, or if if if there isn't one, but I do feel like in the 86 concert, like quote unquote fat Liza, like uses that the in her physical comedy in the song London Town in a way that I really enjoy.

[55:02] Daniel Nolen: And I feel like that's missing from me in this performance.

[55:07] Ben Rimalower: Like seeing her like all slender in Halston, uh, I mean, I'm that's probably Halston too, but who knows?

[55:13] Daniel Nolen: But but like, you know, in this like um uh archetypal Halston, like it feels it I I don't know, it like didn't make me laugh as much.

[55:26] Ben Rimalower: Um she does like the weird little like it's almost like a Bet Midler, like you know how Bette does that thing where she kind of like not like not waddles, not shimmies, but no, it's like that quick little bet walk.

[55:26] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I know.

[55:26] Ben Rimalower: That quick little bet walk. Liza kind of has a version of that that she does in this number, and like when she's like a bigger girl in London in '86, I think it's like comedic genius.

[55:47] Daniel Nolen: And here I kind of like didn't it didn't make me laugh.

[55:49] Ben Rimalower: No, I totally get that.

[55:51] Daniel Nolen: And and I was thinking during this song, this this the style of the song, you know, it's a little like madrigal. It's like a little flute thing.

[55:57] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, this really makes me want it the comedic aspect of it, the storytelling aspect.

[56:05] Ben Rimalower: It really reminded me of Once Upon a Mattress, and I was like, I really wish we would have had Liza as winner.

[56:11] Daniel Nolen: Yes, oh, the house down, yes.

[56:13] Ben Rimalower: I'm sure if we Google that, like in like message boards and discussion groups, or even just tweet about it. I bet some will say, well, actually, like in although I it's possible that with that particular role, there might have been a little sense of like, but that's Carol's part.

[56:29] Daniel Nolen: You know.

[56:29] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. I mean, because like she, even though she's younger than Carol, I think because you know, their careers didn't start, like, wasn't Once Upon a Mattress like only like a year or two before like Flora the Red Menace?

[56:42] Daniel Nolen: Like, yeah.

[56:43] Ben Rimalower: I mean, as a matter of fact, I'm pretty sure they probably both were in the running for both of those roles. I mean, you know, so I've a it's a little like Patty and Bernadette. Um but uh hashtag Patty for the Witch and Into the Woods in concert 2021.

[56:58] Daniel Nolen: Um, is that a thing?

[57:02] Ben Rimalower: No, let's have it.

[57:02] Daniel Nolen: Let's start it.

[57:03] Ben Rimalower: Let's start it. Okay, great, great. Um also uh just uh like even the magical thing, like I don't know whether this is a completely different. I mean, it's not a com this is not a completely different orchestration from London Town in London in '86. But I do maybe it's just my gilded memory, but I should re-watch it.

[57:23] Daniel Nolen: We should rewatch it.

[57:25] Ben Rimalower: But I feel like in London in '86, it's a little more madrigally. And like, I feel like the London '86 concert is so crazy trying to be 80s pop that this song they were just like, ah, fuck it, do a madrigal. Whereas here I feel like they're trying to keep it a little more in the vibe of the rest of the concert, and it's like not as fun magically.

[57:46] Daniel Nolen: Oh, just one more thing I'll say about it, is that I feel like the ballad joke is maybe a little beaten to death here.

[57:52] Ben Rimalower: Hmm.

[57:53] Daniel Nolen: And I feel like maybe she says it one or two less times in London, one or two fewer times, and it makes all the difference in the comedy landing.

[58:02] Ben Rimalower: Yes, yes.

[58:04] Daniel Nolen: But I don't know. This might just be me being in love with the one that I saw first, you know.

[58:09] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Well, I do remember I was watching this, and I do remember getting more of a kick out of this bit on the recording, on the audio recording.

[58:17] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.

[58:18] Ben Rimalower: Well, the next then the next song with zero, yeah, bitch, crack that open.

[58:23] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, Sunny, I'm having Coke in honor of Liza. You know the Leslie Kritzer story about that, right?

[58:26] Ben Rimalower: No.

[58:30] Daniel Nolen: I mean, we really need Leslie to come on the pod and tell it. But I'll just highlight that um when Leslie was starring to great acclaim as Fanny Brice um in the Paper Mill Playhouse production of Funny Girl in 2000, Liza came to the show and came back afterwards, and then they went out together to the diner, Liza and uh Sam Harris and Leslie. And uh the waitress came around and Leslie was like, I'll have a diet coke. And Liza was like, Why do you get a diet? Why don't you just don't you ever just want to have a Coke? And uh and Leslie was like, you know, my mom always told me that sugar makes me hyper. So she would make me drink diet. And Liza's like, well, why don't you get a Coke with me and we'll get hyper together?

[59:17] Ben Rimalower: It's so good. I just realized that my Liza is stolen from Leslie.

[59:22] Daniel Nolen: Oh.

[59:23] Ben Rimalower: Just like my Carol Channing is stolen from Forbidden Broadway, and my Bernadette is stolen from Cola Scola.

[59:31] Daniel Nolen: Of course.

[59:32] Ben Rimalower: Um, oh it's funny. I mean, that that line, let's get hyper together, is just perfectly Liza. I mean, there's no one, first of all, there's no one I'd rather get hyper with than Liza. But also the desire to get hyper is just perfection. Really says it all.

[59:48] Daniel Nolen: Anyway.

[59:49] Ben Rimalower: Anyway. So it's zero perfection. Zero transition and zero banter. We go from the London Town Special Material Comedy Number in to a uh Come In From the Rain by Melissa Manchester.

[1:00:05] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:00:05] Ben Rimalower: And this, honey, the kids are talking about Gaga and Ariana. This is the rain-related music the kids need to be standing. And I'm like, oh, so much for this like mellow jazz concert. We're now in a full 70s easy listening pop moment.

[1:00:22] Daniel Nolen: And it's uh, although I I now the other this was the first version of this song that I heard, but the first version that I really sort of fell in love with was Barbara Cook's, which she sings.

[1:00:32] Ben Rimalower: Yes, I love that one. Preceded by um Harry Nilsson's um uh Remember.

[1:00:41] Daniel Nolen: Remember, what's it called?

[1:00:42] Ben Rimalower: It's called Remember.

[1:00:43] Daniel Nolen: No, it's called Christmas.

[1:00:46] Ben Rimalower: Weirdly. Um But uh this um uh and so I was like, I always do kind of miss that. Like, there's really no reason that Liza couldn't start that was with like long now. I guess there is a reason because that song sounds old fashioned, and this song sounds of the moment of you know this, yeah. No, never I take it back. She just she doesn't need to sing out, but um, but it is just so uh well, okay. Can I tell my Melissa Manchester story about Liza?

[1:01:19] Daniel Nolen: Please, all of them.

[1:01:20] Ben Rimalower: So uh my Uncle Mitchell, I mentioned earlier, um, when he uh is a uh editor, a publisher of books, and and um one of the great books that he edited was Lorna Luft's memoir, Me and My Shadows. And he and Lorna became very good friends. And Lorna was performing her one woman show uh Me and My Shadows, where she performed uh uh song, sorry, songs my mother taught me, where she performed all these Judy Garland songs in their original arrangements with a big uh band. And it uh, and back in the day when she was starting this concert in 1999 and 2000, Lorna really still had her voice, and it was thrilling to see Lorna with this great big belt. I mean, when Judy famously said that Lorna's got more talent than the rest of them put together, you know, people scoff because she's so inferior of a performer to Judy and Liza, and possibly Joe.

I mean, I've never seen his work, but um, thank you. I was waiting for the laugh on that, Danny. But um, but just vocally alone, back in her day, I mean, Lorna's voice, you know, she made Patty look like Katrina Lang, you know. I mean, it was it was just a big, enormous rich belt with just no limits and any note she wanted, any way she wanted it, you know, and just as rich as Judy and Liza at their richest, except with that richness, evenly, top to bottom, effortlessly, you know. And that's all she had to offer, but she had it to offer in spades. And when she sang these Judy songs with the band playing those arrangements, it was absolutely thrilling. And um, anyway, she was doing a run of the show at the uh it's no longer there.

Is this great theater in Beverly Hills called the Canon Theater? Um I was gonna say on Rodeo Drive, it's right near Rodeo Drive, it's on Canon Drive. Um anyway, she was doing the show there, and it was had a nice run, and uh I was in LA working on a uh project, I think was was I living? Yeah, I was living there for a few months. I was directing this thing called the Shine.

[1:03:39] Daniel Nolen: Oh, right, of course.

[1:03:40] Ben Rimalower: I was directing this thing called the Shine Awards that was a benefit to honor uh healthy portrayals of sexuality on television. And uh Lorna opened the show for us. And uh so I I had met her and everything and done that with her. And so Uncle Mitchell came to LA to visit from New York, and we all went to see her do her show at the Canon Theater. And it was me and my uncle and my parents and my brother and sister and whatever. And uh who else happened to be the audience, by the way, that day was Nancy Reagan.

[1:04:10] Daniel Nolen: Oh so we all waited in the hallway while Nancy Reagan had a private audience with Lorna in her dressing room, and then Nancy left, and then we went in, and then we went out to dinner with Lorna afterwards, and somebody else that had been at the show uh was Melissa Manchester, and so she came to dinner too. And so, uh, or I think Melissa Manchester went to dinner with Lorna, and we came too. But anyway, we're at dinner, and so at one point Melissa says that she has a Liza.

[1:04:42] Ben Rimalower: Some they were wound up talking about Liza.

[1:04:43] Daniel Nolen: Melissa says she has a Liza story. So Melissa says that um uh Liza was being honored by mothers against drunk driving. Mm-hmm. Which I know sounds incongruous, but uh in fairness, I do not believe Liza ever had a DUI. Um, but you know, all nonprofits, you know, you you they give a gala to honor somebody so that people will come, you know, they you know, that way that person comes and you can sell tickets based on them coming, whatever. So Liza, so Liza was being honored. So Liza calls Melissa in advance of the event uh and and says, uh, you know, I want you to perform uh at this uh benefit for me, you know. Uh and she goes, and I want you to sing um I I want to say it was Don't Cry Out Loud, but I think it actually was uh Coming From the Rain.

But she goes, uh, and I want you to say that you had written the song when you were struggling singer-songwriter, and that uh the performer, the voice was your muse and your mind was me. And you never dreamed someday you would get to hear me sing it, and what a dream come true it was like you knew you'd arrived when you heard me sing this song.

[1:06:11] Ben Rimalower: Oh my.

[1:06:16] Daniel Nolen: Okay, I will say that. And so Melissa has uh gets on stage and sings the song, and then I guess she was presenting to Liza immediately after the song, and she goes, ladies and gentlemen, I just want you to know that I was a string struggling singer-songwriter. This voice that was so iconic to me and was in my mind when I wrote the song, and I, you know, it was such an honor when I got to hear her actually, you know, perform it. And Liza stands up in the audience and goes, Oh my god! I had no idea. That is so funny. I don't know what to say. I'm so surprised.

[1:07:00] Ben Rimalower: It's just like that's so Liza, though. It's like she she enjoys just revising history willy-nilly and then acting shocked, you know, when someone calls her on it, or or when there's any sort of um or or switching it up at will whenever she chooses to do so again. Also, in fairness, I mean, how many times have I gone to see an age fit starring Patty LuPone or Shana with or Shaka Khan or you know, whoever, and it starts before anybody even sings, before a note of music is played. Somebody comes out who's not a performer and does a 20-minute boring ass speech about the charity. Now Liza says the people are donating a lot of money to mothers against drunk driving, which is so important. And they deserve a show. So let's write them a great show. And that's what she did. What she did and what she does is what she does.

[1:08:01] Ben Rimalower: So speaking of, yes, coming uh Coming In From the Rain, which it was raining out here a moment earlier. I don't know if it still is, but um.

[1:08:11] Daniel Nolen: Oh, then we have a monologue about how I like songs about particular characters and particular situations. And this is old chestnut. This monologue survived through London '86, Radio City 91, the Pantages Theatre in 96. I mean, it's like I you know I'm like, girl, I love that outfit more every time you wear it.

[1:08:38] Ben Rimalower: It's like, oh, you like the monologue? I always have. But a monologue I do not like that she goes into here where I feel it's a little too Fred Ebb and not enough Liza, uh, is where she goes, which is inevitably a lugubrious experience.

[1:08:52] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, the lugubrious is it's a little uh it doesn't quite fit.

[1:08:57] Ben Rimalower: It does not quite fit. And um, and it actually kind of is always my problem. So maybe they know something I don't know. What a shocker. Fred Ebb knows something I don't know. Because it's actually very much in keeping with the verse of Arthur in the Afternoon, which is like um she uh, which by the way, I don't think Arthur in the Afternoon is on the Carnegie Hall album. Now I'm like, let me check that fact. I think for I think I mistakenly believed when I was a young man that um London Town was not performed in New Orleans, and that Arthur in the Afternoon was not performed at Carnegie Hall. And now I am pulling up the Carnegie Hall album to see if I'm correct about yeah, it's not on the record.

Well, we thought we thought that people might enjoy music that was more like regular pop music like the rest of my stuff. Um anyway, uh, but uh the introductory verse to Arthur in the Afternoon, I never like that. Like when Karen Ziemba does that in But the World Goes Round, you know, that stuff like that this heartling, startling, or what is it?

[1:10:14] Ben Rimalower: Startling, startling. I don't like that, you know. Um and but you know, so if they do that in the intro and in the intro, maybe Fred Ebb is up to something that I'm just too much of a claw to understand. Um clawed. But it does thank you. It doesn't matter how awkward it is for Liza to make it through that egg on your face intro. Because when she does that fucking lascivious giggle, all of a sudden, you know, it's almost where I mean it's not uh I don't I wouldn't accuse her of doing it as a trick because it feels so earned.

[1:10:56] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:10:57] Ben Rimalower: But you know those moments when you're performing and like you need something that kind of just like makes you relax into it.

[1:11:04] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:11:04] Ben Rimalower: You're like, ah, and now I'm good. You know, it's just like you sh it's like a dog when you pet a dog and then the dog feels too dominated, so it shakes it off.

[1:11:13] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:11:14] Ben Rimalower: You know, it's like Liza shakes off the Fred Ebness, and then she's with that laugh, and then she's in it. And if I complained about her sachet in London town, her sachet in Arthur in the afternoon is just right. Just right. I mean, this this number, I thought this seeing her do this makes me really want to see her in MAME because there's a very MAME quality to what she's doing here.

[1:11:39] Daniel Nolen: I mean, certainly in this pant, this uh Halston does not hurt pajama suit.

[1:11:44] Ben Rimalower: Although I have to say, I still just don't enjoy this number that much. I don't like it. Yeah, it's my least favorite of the jokey 70s sexual innuendo. Uh but the suspender work is top notch.

[1:11:59] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, maybe I'd enjoy it more if it was like Jason Gote, you know, and I just like wasn't attracted to this famously our intern Jason Goate.

[1:12:07] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, or um our penis' name Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[1:12:14] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, don't he would be good. He'd be good in this bit.

[1:12:17] Ben Rimalower: Um actually, I would love to see Alicia Umfris and Jay Armstrong Johnson do this number.

[1:12:22] Daniel Nolen: Yes, boots the house down, Mama.

[1:12:25] Ben Rimalower: Yes. Uh so okay, so Liza's wearing the Halston, and then this is when she goes off. This is when she leaves to change clothes.

[1:12:30] Daniel Nolen: And then into another purple sequinter Halston pantsuit.

[1:12:38] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, it's so I'm trying to think of the. But I do not need to see him sing fucking Mr. Cellophane in the middle of this show. And by the way, just FYI to everyone, I really don't ever need to see Mr. Cellophane except in Chicago and possibly in And the World Goes Round.

[1:13:03] Daniel Nolen: Although I'm also convinced if you revise The World Goes Round with a couple of numbers from Scottsboro Boys and Curtains, you could cut that number, but whatever.

[1:13:11] Ben Rimalower: But I do not need to see it in the middle of a Liza concert unless it's Liza singing it, okay? But she comes back on and I immediately wrote back, why has she my the little bitchy queen in me?

[1:13:22] Daniel Nolen: Um, but not the normal bitch in me, a different bitchy queen, not that you're not used to.

[1:13:27] Ben Rimalower: Said, why did she come back to the stage in the same outfit? And then I was like, oh no, wait, it's a different outfit. It just looks the same.

[1:13:35] Daniel Nolen: Well, it is worth the wait because uh what happens now are the greatest moments in Shobin history.

[1:13:46] Ben Rimalower: Her story.

[1:13:47] Daniel Nolen: Yes, god.

[1:13:49] Ben Rimalower: Um, okay, so let's get into it. She comes back. Uh the monologue is genius, although I miss the LA joke from Carnegie Hall.

[1:13:57] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, well, she talks she again, she says, I love research, which made me think of our friend of the pod, uh, Pixie Aventura being a research queen.

[1:14:06] Ben Rimalower: Yes. And this is when she I actually would give both testicles to see Pixie Aventura sing and dance this entire number with J. Armstrong Johnson and uh our intern.

[1:14:21] Daniel Nolen: No, no, no, no.

[1:14:23] Ben Rimalower: He's he he's no Jay and Jay Jason Gote.

[1:14:27] Daniel Nolen: Jason Goate, yeah.

[1:14:28] Ben Rimalower: Jay and Gote.

[1:14:29] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.

[1:14:30] Ben Rimalower: Uh totally. Pixie would be so good at this. And yeah, so this is she talks about the the different uh towns and and the cities and and the songs that have been written for them and all the research she's done, but that one town that has 300 whatever the fuck songs written about.

[1:14:46] Daniel Nolen: Oh, and she says it, she says it in the most adorable way, like like your three-year-old nephew when he's still learning to talk and he says words funny, you know.

[1:14:55] Ben Rimalower: Like, I remember my sister, uh, if she listens to this episode, I'll know because she'll mention that she got this shot up. She was dating this guy when she was in her early 20s, and they visited his family, and she played with his niece, who was like really cute and three, and she loved to go to the beach, and they'd be like, What do you like to go to the beach for? And she'd be like, collect shells.

[1:15:15] Daniel Nolen: Aww.

[1:15:15] Ben Rimalower: And like the way Liza says, New York has had the most songs written about it more than more than any other city, and it it's had 311.

[1:15:26] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:15:27] Ben Rimalower: So specific. Well, in her verse, whenever she says, uh, we can't sing them all or we'd be here for 37 years. That's like her version of Judy's uh we'll sing them all and stay all night.

[1:15:37] Daniel Nolen: Yes, it is.

[1:15:38] Ben Rimalower: Yes, it is. It is the it is the Liza to we'll s we'll stay all night and sing them all as Judy.

[1:15:45] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[1:15:45] Ben Rimalower: Mm-hmm. And I mean, first of all, this was the first version I knew of this song, I guess the Lord Must Be in New York City, was this version by Liza. And even this version by Liza, where she sings just the first verse of it, uh, was enough to make me fall in love with this.

[1:16:06] Daniel Nolen: Oh, by the way, ironically, this song not ironically, but fittingly, this song is by Harry Nielsen, who wrote the song Remember that comes before Barbara Cook's version of Coming from the Rain.

[1:16:17] Ben Rimalower: So clearly in 1980, when they both when Liza did this and Barbara Cook did that, Harry Nielsen and Melissa Manchester were the important songwriters for theatrical entertainers to pay attention to. But um, and then I also fell in love with this song all over again when Sherry Renee Scott did it in um Everyday Rapture.

[1:16:38] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:16:39] Ben Rimalower: But even here, this little version that she does was enough to make you fall in love. And it's impressive that the this gets tune recognition.

[1:16:46] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it's such a great arrangement, and the way she starts strutting down that stage, I mean, it's hard for me to remember the me that ever said I don't like dance, because I live for the dance.

[1:17:01] Daniel Nolen: The donts in this number.

[1:17:02] Ben Rimalower: Yes, same. But they clap.

[1:17:06] Daniel Nolen: They clap as soon as it starts.

[1:17:07] Ben Rimalower: Doo do do do. I'll say goodbye to all my sorrow. Come tomorrow. I'll be on my way.

[1:17:17] Daniel Nolen: Do do do do do.

[1:17:19] Ben Rimalower: I guess the Lord must be in New York City.

[1:17:26] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, uh, brilliant.

[1:17:28] Ben Rimalower: I mean, this this whole medley, I I just wrote down, it's a star being a star. She is in her this is her famous song, especially New York, New York.

[1:17:37] Daniel Nolen: We get into her famous songs.

[1:17:39] Ben Rimalower: Hold up, hold up, hold up. I mean, we just have to live a little longer in everything before New York, New York, because uh she sings so many New York songs that aren't New York, New York first.

[1:17:50] Daniel Nolen: Right.

[1:17:50] Ben Rimalower: And they're so wonderful and so crazy and different. So, I mean, I can literally do it. I guess the here I am, Lord, knocking at your back door.

[1:17:58] Daniel Nolen: Oh, ain't it wonderful to be where I've always wanted to be.

[1:18:02] Ben Rimalower: For the uh take me back to Manhattan, don't don't take me back to New York.

[1:18:09] Daniel Nolen: Um just longing to be once more, my little home on the hundredth floor.

[1:18:16] Ben Rimalower: Uh I miss the day of we'll have but they don't say the words we'll have. It just goes, Manhattan, Staten Island 2 is lovely going through the doot do do do do do do do do do I mean, and uh I mean I I I I won't sing them all.

[1:18:40] Daniel Nolen: We'll be here all night.

[1:18:41] Ben Rimalower: It's uh lullaby of Broadway somewhere in there. But yeah, I mean, crazy shit. I mean, you know, um uh what they do, I don't know what that 70s rock or disco song is it got to be the New York City reason in my life.

[1:18:56] Daniel Nolen: Do do do do do do do do and then it goes into that like salsa, Nueva York, Nueva York.

[1:19:05] Ben Rimalower: And then and then it's in counterpoint there. Nueva York, come on along and listen.

[1:19:11] Daniel Nolen: And then it's this amazing false uh they psych you out because everybody knows surely New York New York is coming.

[1:19:21] Ben Rimalower: So it comes to this close and there's dead air, and you're ex you're so 1000% confident it's about to go um doot doot do-do-da-da.

[1:19:33] Daniel Nolen: And instead it's uh every streets a boulevard in old New York.

[1:19:41] Ben Rimalower: And it's like it gets you so that you're actually surprised when the inevitable does happen and she sings New York, New York. And all I have to say before we go into New York, New York, is that I literally wrote down this is the best musical ever.

[1:19:57] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:19:58] Ben Rimalower: Oh, and then when the doot doot do do do, I mean, that crazy iconic vamp starts, the most amazing thing happens, which is that this fabulous set she has been in front of, which is um kind of lies with a Z-esque, uh with this um, what would you call it? Like it's uh there's just like these different platforms, these different level platforms that the band is on behind her.

[1:20:25] Daniel Nolen: What's been behind that all along has just been a scrim with different lights and colors.

[1:20:30] Ben Rimalower: Suddenly, there's a New York skyline behind her. A nighttime, a glittering New York, New York nighttime skyline.

[1:20:39] Daniel Nolen: And that happening at the exact moment this vamp starts.

[1:20:44] Ben Rimalower: I believe in God. This is like getting a glimpse of God.

[1:20:48] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:20:49] Ben Rimalower: Uh okay, so well, this I mean, it's good, good you brought up the set because to me this was such a moment of like walk watching Bette Midler descend the Hello Dolly staircase.

[1:21:01] Daniel Nolen: It's that same thing of the moment we've been waiting for, we finally arrived.

[1:21:07] Ben Rimalower: This is the Act One finale, and and all the elements come together. The audience is waiting with breath that is baited, and then when you finally hear that straight through to the end of the number in Act One, it is uh yeah, it's heaven.

[1:21:24] Daniel Nolen: Seeing a star, being a star.

[1:21:27] Ben Rimalower: Now, one thing that took me down from the ecstasy, unfortunately, as soon as I had that moment of glory, I remembered that she didn't yet add that extra chorus at this point in her.

[1:21:41] Daniel Nolen: Oh, like the early encore bit.

[1:21:44] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:21:44] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:21:45] Ben Rimalower: Like, and I I felt, I was trying to think of what the analogy would be, and I didn't come up with it. But I felt like like, like it's like um I don't know.

[1:21:59] Daniel Nolen: Like it's it's like your parents being like, it's Christmas morning, you can open half the presents, but the other half are for next Christmas.

[1:22:07] Ben Rimalower: Like, I was like, how, like, it just felt so um, it's like to me, that's like over the rainbow without the like if happy little bluebirds tag.

[1:22:20] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, if happy little bluebirds tag.

[1:22:22] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, uh, I get that. Although I didn't, I have to say I was so in this, and I had had three glasses of wine, so I didn't even notice that.

[1:22:29] Daniel Nolen: Ugh, I miss drinking.

[1:22:32] Ben Rimalower: E so yeah.

[1:22:35] Daniel Nolen: No, sorry, that wasn't related to you.

[1:22:37] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I thought you were like, I don't want to touch that with a 10-foot bowl.

[1:22:43] Daniel Nolen: Um, but at the end of this song, also, she is has given you everything, the audience on her feet, and she is sweating, honey, like the late great Whitney Houston.

[1:22:53] Ben Rimalower: And by the way, it's intermission. And when the I have never before in my life enjoyed so much audience intermission shots. And seeing the programs, I said, this is honestly, it's I swear to you, this is the first time in three months that I have actually missed live theater.

[1:23:15] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:23:16] Ben Rimalower: Like when my parents asked me if I was sad about like Broadway not coming back until like, you know, next year or whatever. I was like, honestly, as long as I get to watch like Bernadette and Betty and Donna and Carol Lee like sing Sunday clothes in a Brady Bunch for some.

[1:23:30] Daniel Nolen: Like, I do not give a shit if like dear Evan Hansen is on hiatus longer, you know?

[1:23:35] Ben Rimalower: But like watching like these 1980 Liza Minnelli's fans read their programs, I was like overwhelmed by a desire to be in a live theater.

[1:23:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:23:47] Ben Rimalower: No, I'm not sure. I just felt that excitement. I imagined, I suddenly was like, I remembered, I craved the feeling of a diva sending you out into intermission with the thrills of a perfect act one closing, and knowing that it's only halfway over, but you get to like pee and have a diet coke.

[1:24:07] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, by a by a t-shirt.

[1:24:09] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I just really, I really felt that.

[1:24:13] Daniel Nolen: Um also, um, and then what the crazy ass backstage filming before she comes out.

[1:24:23] Ben Rimalower: Who are those women and why did Liza not have a cigarette?

[1:24:27] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and she's like having like a full conversation with them.

[1:24:30] Ben Rimalower: So bizarre.

[1:24:31] Daniel Nolen: And what the fuck was going on on that stage before Liza came out?

[1:24:36] Ben Rimalower: I don't know, but I did not need that.

[1:24:38] Daniel Nolen: I was just like, no, bring on Liza.

[1:24:42] Ben Rimalower: Well, she finally did come out.

[1:24:44] Daniel Nolen: Even though when she comes on, it's in my least favorite part of the show, which is this lime green outfit, which I did not care for.

[1:24:53] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it reminds me of what she wore to sing Everything's Coming Up Roses on the Muppet Show.

[1:24:59] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:24:59] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it might actually be that.

[1:25:02] Daniel Nolen: Um, but I just had to keep reminding myself it's a Halston.

[1:25:02] Ben Rimalower: It's a Halston, it's a Halston.

[1:25:07] Daniel Nolen: It's nine, it's 1980.

[1:25:08] Ben Rimalower: And like, um, I mean, I don't know that this is the exact same monologue she said in Liza with a Z when she introduced that song You've Really Let Yourself Go.

[1:25:18] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[1:25:19] Ben Rimalower: But I swear to God, I could watch that monologue and then watch this monologue back to back 20 times, and I still wouldn't be able to tell you whether or not they're the same.

[1:25:29] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:25:29] Ben Rimalower: There's something about when she starts talking about, you know, and we wanted to find songs about a marriage, about two people who are learning to love each other, and who are loving to learn each other.

[1:25:48] Daniel Nolen: I just do not care what Liza has to say about relationships.

[1:25:52] Ben Rimalower: Right, right.

[1:25:54] Daniel Nolen: I don't mind her singing the song about it.

[1:25:56] Ben Rimalower: Go ahead and sing the song.

[1:25:57] Daniel Nolen: But I do not want you.

[1:25:59] Ben Rimalower: It's like she's coming out being like, ladies and gentlemen, just like you.

[1:26:03] Daniel Nolen: I'm a normal heterosexual woman who's married to a normal heterosexual man, just like you.

[1:26:09] Ben Rimalower: And our problems are the same as yours.

[1:26:12] Daniel Nolen: Honey, you forgot to pick up your socks.

[1:26:15] Ben Rimalower: That's the same shit that we deal with.

[1:26:18] Daniel Nolen: I don't want that from her.

[1:26:19] Ben Rimalower: I do not want that from her.

[1:26:21] Daniel Nolen: It's the one thing Fred Ebb never understood.

[1:26:24] Ben Rimalower: We do not want that from Liza.

[1:26:26] Daniel Nolen: I don't know why Fred Ebb didn't get that.

[1:26:28] Ben Rimalower: I think because he met her when she was 16 and she was like sleeping on somebody's couch.

[1:26:33] Daniel Nolen: So I think in his mind, he was like, you've got to make the audience see that she's just like all your other girlfriends who are struggling musical theater actresses.

[1:26:42] Ben Rimalower: But she's not.

[1:26:43] Daniel Nolen: What is it that Lucille Ball said about her?

[1:26:45] Ben Rimalower: Like Liza can't be domesticated.

[1:26:47] Daniel Nolen: She sure as fuck can't.

[1:26:50] Ben Rimalower: Um, that said, I love Badley.

[1:26:55] Daniel Nolen: I love the theme from Mr. Chips, that song You and I.

[1:26:58] Ben Rimalower: And I love it when Barbara Cook sings it, and I love it when Shirley Bassey sings it, and I love it when Nancy Lamotte sings it.

[1:27:04] Daniel Nolen: And don't tell people out there, but I even like it when Judy Kay sings it.

[1:27:12] Ben Rimalower: Oh my.

[1:27:14] Daniel Nolen: Oh, you've gone too far.

[1:27:16] Ben Rimalower: I get upset when Barbara Streisand sings her You and I on widescreen because it's not this, and I still.

[1:27:21] Daniel Nolen: But that's a different song, yeah.

[1:27:22] Ben Rimalower: I know, but I really wish Barbara would sing this.

[1:27:25] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, this will be a good song for Barbara.

[1:27:27] Ben Rimalower: I also really love the Patula Clark original, excuse me, I have to add that.

[1:27:31] Daniel Nolen: Um, and I've always liked thought the Liza one was fine, but like I didn't love the other songs in the medley, and so I just like skipped that track.

[1:27:41] Ben Rimalower: But here, watching her do it, I have to say, I was really loving it.

[1:27:46] Daniel Nolen: But what was bothering me was knowing what was coming after it.

[1:27:50] Ben Rimalower: Mm-hmm.

[1:27:52] Daniel Nolen: Then when that second piece of shit, I mean, song came.

[1:27:56] Ben Rimalower: The honeymoon is over.

[1:27:58] Daniel Nolen: I did notice watching her do it, watching her face.

[1:28:02] Ben Rimalower: I was like, you know what?

[1:28:04] This song may be crap, but this is a thrilling vocal.

[1:28:09] I was like, why didn't they just let her do Rainbow High from Evita?

[1:28:13] Like, she's literally like doing like alphabet-esque belting here.

[1:28:18] Daniel Nolen: You know, not alphabet, but like, it's like, it's like serious, like well-placed high belting, you know.

[1:28:26] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, she's in very good voice for this whole show.

[1:28:29] Daniel Nolen: Like, I just really wanted her um to um to do that.

[1:28:36] Ben Rimalower: And then I was surprised seeing her do the third song, but getting to watch her do it.

[1:28:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:28:43] Ben Rimalower: I realized, oh, I actually love this.

[1:28:45] This is two things I love.

[1:28:47] Daniel Nolen: It's Liza doing Charles Aznavour, and it's not what makes a man a man.

[1:28:56] Ben Rimalower: No laugh.

[1:28:57] Daniel Nolen: Wait, I didn't get it.

[1:28:58] Ben Rimalower: I don't get it.

[1:28:59] Daniel Nolen: Oh, because she sings that fucking, she loves to like it's one thing when she did it, I don't know when she first did it, whether it was 86 or 91, but like for decades upon decades, she's been because she loves Charles Aznavour and they did concerts together, and he's a big inspiration to her.

[1:29:15] Ben Rimalower: This great singer-songwriter, Troubadour from France in the 60s or whatever, you know.

[1:29:21] Daniel Nolen: So that's all great.

[1:29:22] Ben Rimalower: So she has sung much of his music over the years, you know, since I don't know who first introduced her to him, Kay Thompson or Peter Allen or whoever, you know.

[1:29:30] Daniel Nolen: So she loves him.

[1:29:31] Ben Rimalower: That's all great.

[1:29:31] I love her, I love Charles Aznavour, I love them together.

[1:29:34] Daniel Nolen: But so she in the 80s or 90s, she started doing this song of his, What makes a man?

[1:29:39] Ben Rimalower: And she does this long introduction about it's about a female impersonator, like in Saint-Tropez or France, or I don't know where the fuck, you know, somewhere in Europe, right?

[1:29:49] Daniel Nolen: And so she tells a long story, and then it's a very talky talkie song about like, you know, it's like I walk down the alley from the club.

[1:29:59] Ben Rimalower: The cats walk across my path.

[1:30:03] Daniel Nolen: I come home and I see my mother, and I think, did I remember to take off my lash?

[1:30:12] Ben Rimalower: Oh, what makes a man a man?

[1:30:17] Daniel Nolen: I don't know, it goes on forever and ever.

[1:30:19] Ben Rimalower: And like when she did it in 1986 or 1990 or whatever, yes, it was indeed the LGBTQ anthem she thought it was, and we all needed it, you know what?

[1:30:33] Daniel Nolen: And like I didn't feel that way so much over the years, but by the time she got to it at the palace, I was like David Guest in 2002, except not talking about some people.

[1:30:43] Ben Rimalower: I was like, Well, you for Christ's sake, stop singing that song.

[1:30:48] Daniel Nolen: So here I get to hear her do a different and much more obscure Charles Aznavour song, and I get to watch her face, and I love it.

[1:30:57] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, it was like watching a play.

[1:30:59] Daniel Nolen: Yes, it was.

[1:31:00] Ben Rimalower: Like an Edward Albee play.

[1:31:01] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes.

[1:31:03] Ben Rimalower: And it was so good.

[1:31:04] Daniel Nolen: I mean, and she's really perfected that speak singing thing, but she also sounds great.

[1:31:09] Ben Rimalower: And um, I was just really in heaven.

[1:31:12] Daniel Nolen: I just felt like I was watching The Master at Work.

[1:31:15] Ben Rimalower: And um I was just realizing I was so happy, but I started to have a really dread dreading feeling in my stomach.

[1:31:24] Daniel Nolen: Uh-oh.

[1:31:25] Ben Rimalower: I didn't remember how many numbers were coming first, but I knew that very soon she would be putting on tights and doing a weird Sally Bowles monologue end quote.

[1:31:38] Daniel Nolen: Uh-huh, uh-huh.

[1:31:39] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, oh God, I don't want that to happen.

[1:31:43] Daniel Nolen: But I did not realize because on the version of the video I had always grown up on, when she sang City Lights, it just began immediately with just her, all of a sudden it was just like cut to the audience, cut back to the stage, and there she is going like the little old lady sat outside at the farmhouse.

[1:32:02] Ben Rimalower: But here she has a whole the Judy Garland show, you know, sitting standing behind the trunk, changing God knows who was like crouched down behind that thing, like adjusting her garters and like injecting her with liquid coke or whatever, you know.

[1:32:17] Daniel Nolen: But she keeps talking to the audience through the costume change, and like I was loving her like introduction.

[1:32:25] Ben Rimalower: I love that she acknowledged that the act was a hit, except that it um had um had a rocky road pre Broadway.

[1:32:36] Daniel Nolen: I had never heard that before.

[1:32:37] Ben Rimalower: I was absolutely loving it.

[1:32:40] And I mean, that song is so vulgar.

[1:32:47] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it's a Fred Ebb commentary on a Fred Ebb song.

[1:32:51] Ben Rimalower: Mm-hmm.

[1:32:52] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[1:32:53] Ben Rimalower: And I am just here for it.

[1:32:57] Daniel Nolen: And like, I just felt like if loving this is wrong.

[1:33:03] Ben Rimalower: Honey.

[1:33:04] Daniel Nolen: I don't want to be around.

[1:33:06] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[1:33:07] Daniel Nolen: I really, I uh, I really just, and then I was just loving watching her do it.

[1:33:15] Ben Rimalower: But I suddenly got really sad because uh, and I listen, I was living for the performance.

[1:33:21] Daniel Nolen: Like, every time they're like, and this side, you know, unlike the New York New York medley or whatever, where you're surprised, you know, or you don't know what's coming.

[1:33:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:33:31] Daniel Nolen: I mean, City Lights is just one telegraph after another.

[1:33:35] Ben Rimalower: City lights.

[1:33:37] Daniel Nolen: I mean, you could show me webcam footage of Liza in a limousine boarding a helicopter, boarding an airplane, getting on the space shuttle, landing on Saturn, and I'd still sit there in my seat in New Orleans being like, no, no, there's another chorus, it's a false exit.

[1:33:53] Ben Rimalower: You know, like there is just no limit of her being a bum bum bum city lights.

[1:34:01] Daniel Nolen: I love them.

[1:34:05] Ben Rimalower: It's never gonna end, you know.

[1:34:07] Daniel Nolen: So, and I was living, living, living, but I thought, oh, this was a this was a bad career move the act.

[1:34:18] Yes.

[1:34:18] Ben Rimalower: In 1978, on the heels of the failure of New York, New York, which by the way, had already been too many flops in a row.

[1:34:29] Daniel Nolen: Cabaret was a big hit, and then she did um uh I forget what order they came in, but A Matter of Time and Lucky Lady at New York, New York, and it was bomb bomb bum bomb.

[1:34:44] Ben Rimalower: And now, if somebody had written her a real Broadway show, even a bad Broadway show, well, I you know I love it, I don't want to offend anybody, but you know, even a problematic Broadway show like The Rink, but that's actually a real show, like Terrence McNally and like Candor and Ebb, like and you know, AJ Antoon or whoever produced it or whatever, you know, like they all like really wanted to do The Rink, and maybe they hoped Liza would say yes, but like, you know, they would have done it with like Patty or Bernadette or like somebody.

[1:35:15] Daniel Nolen: That was a Broadway show that was going to happen for real artistic purposes.

[1:35:20] Ben Rimalower: But this thing that she created for herself, I feel like it was a little bit of like career suicide, you know.

[1:35:27] Daniel Nolen: But I don't know.

[1:35:28] Ben Rimalower: Then I was also like, well, but maybe like it was her Yentl because Liza was in charge of the act.

[1:35:35] Daniel Nolen: I don't think she was actually a producer.

[1:35:37] Ben Rimalower: I think she might have actually been a producer, but regardless, she was in charge, you know, and she was instrumental when they had to replace Martin Scorsese, even though she was sleeping with him, like she had to approve it and everything, you know, and whatever.

[1:35:50] Daniel Nolen: You know, and Liza was responsible that show was built around her, you know, even more than a star vehicle is built around a star.

[1:35:57] Ben Rimalower: I mean, that show was only about her, you know.

[1:35:59] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes, so much.

[1:36:01] Ben Rimalower: And like, so maybe she needed to learn from the mistakes of that and then do her Prince of Tides next, you know.

[1:36:08] Daniel Nolen: But you know, maybe she was on too many drugs and too wild and crazy for that to happen.

[1:36:13] Ben Rimalower: You know, I don't know, but also like Broadway shows are different than films, and like I don't think Liza is, and I don't say this with any pleasure, but I don't think she's as smart as Barbara.

[1:36:25] Daniel Nolen: I mean, for all I have against Barbara, which is a lot, I do believe Barbara is very intelligent, you know?

[1:36:31] Ben Rimalower: Yes, very smart.

[1:36:32] Daniel Nolen: You know, and um, so I don't know, I don't know, I don't know.

[1:36:37] Ben Rimalower: But like also, I wonder if I um did I miss one of my favorite notes that I took all night.

[1:36:44] Daniel Nolen: Um, yeah, where did I have this note?

[1:36:46] Ben Rimalower: Somewhere else watching this, I guess it was earlier, where I had this realization that I was watching this and I was like, oh, her film career is already oh yeah.

[1:36:56] Daniel Nolen: It was when she oh yeah, it was back when she was singing Come In From the Rain.

[1:37:01] Ben Rimalower: It was like amazing to look at Liza in 1980 and think her film career is already dead in the water and she doesn't know it.

[1:37:09] Daniel Nolen: Oh yeah.

[1:37:10] Ben Rimalower: You know, I mean that's not entirely true.

[1:37:12] Daniel Nolen: She did still make um well, she made a few movies, but she still made Arthur, which was a bit which was a hit.

[1:37:19] Ben Rimalower: But it was really the end.

[1:37:21] Daniel Nolen: You know, she was the girlfriend in Arthur, it wasn't a Liza Minnelli's movie.

[1:37:25] Ben Rimalower: Arthur too was a bomb.

[1:37:27] Daniel Nolen: Rent a cop, although I'm insisting that we're going to watch it this summer, was a bomb.

[1:37:32] Ben Rimalower: The only other real movie she had after that was not even a real movie.

[1:37:36] Daniel Nolen: It was basically like an independent gay porn film, Stepping Out, you know, Stepping Out.

[1:37:41] Ben Rimalower: I mean, you know, what what was it?

[1:37:42] Daniel Nolen: Strand releasing or what, you know, I don't know.

[1:37:44] Ben Rimalower: The budget for that.

[1:37:45] Daniel Nolen: It did not open wide, you know.

[1:37:47] Ben Rimalower: Right.

[1:37:48] Daniel Nolen: Anyway, a film which did open wide and which was fabulous and and made a name for her was Cabaret.

[1:37:57] Ben Rimalower: But why it gotta be this way, Daddy?

[1:38:01] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I was basically just waiting for her to drink a prairie oyster.

[1:38:05] Ben Rimalower: I was like, what is happening?

[1:38:07] Daniel Nolen: Wait, sorry, two more things about City Lights.

[1:38:10] Ben Rimalower: Like watching her do a number that is literally about nothing.

[1:38:13] Daniel Nolen: Like only City Lights can make New York, New York sound like a really substantive, like meaty dramatic song.

[1:38:21] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, you're you're right.

[1:38:23] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it's like, well, it's not specific about a city.

[1:38:26] Ben Rimalower: You know?

[1:38:26] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it is witty.

[1:38:28] Ben Rimalower: I do love the lyric.

[1:38:29] Daniel Nolen: Um, uh country air means zilch to me.

[1:38:32] Ben Rimalower: I won't breathe nothing, I can't see.

[1:38:36] Daniel Nolen: That is good.

[1:38:37] Ben Rimalower: That's so genius.

[1:38:39] Daniel Nolen: That's Fred Ebb at his best.

[1:38:40] Ben Rimalower: But like, but you know, I was like, this is a song about nothing, and Liza is selling it for all it is worth.

[1:38:47] Daniel Nolen: And I was just like, nobody does this anymore.

[1:38:50] Ben Rimalower: And then I was just so impressed, thinking about the fact that she's dancing up a storm and belting up a storm at his li and it's live.

[1:38:58] Daniel Nolen: Like, I would really love to know, like, Brittany or Christina or Shakira or whoever.

[1:39:04] Ben Rimalower: Like, I don't know who the equivalent person would be.

[1:39:07] Daniel Nolen: Like, you know, Ariana Grande, I know you laugh when I say her, but like, honestly, like, is there anybody that can like belt and dance at the same time anymore?

[1:39:17] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I mean, you know, Gaga, I mean, she's she's someone who has a lot of choreography in her shows and a still a powerful voice.

[1:39:25] Daniel Nolen: I mean, Brittany lip syncs mostly.

[1:39:28] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Ariana Grande doesn't really have the vocal chops that someone like Gaga has.

[1:39:32] Daniel Nolen: Maybe like Christina Aguilera.

[1:39:34] Ben Rimalower: But like, can Gaga, like I know Gaga's can sing her fucking face off at a microphone, but can Gaga do that while she's like dancing up a storm?

[1:39:43] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.

[1:39:44] Ben Rimalower: I mean, may I I mean it's certainly different style of choreography.

[1:39:48] Daniel Nolen: I mean, part of the genius of this too is that like Liza is out of breath.

[1:39:52] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Liza is a fucking like Donna McKechney hoofer.

[1:39:56] Daniel Nolen: Like, she is work, she's using her voice.

[1:39:59] Ben Rimalower: She is figuring out when you have to be like sit lots.

[1:40:04] Daniel Nolen: I love them sit all.

[1:40:07] Ben Rimalower: I mean, you know, she's budgeting it and she knows how to make it last.

[1:40:11] Daniel Nolen: And it's just so genius.

[1:40:13] Ben Rimalower: And I thought of, I feel like if Richard J. Alexander were sitting and watching with me, he would have been like, I miss show business.

[1:40:19] Daniel Nolen: Yes, it's so that.

[1:40:21] Ben Rimalower: Well, and then the fact that she has to do this seated monologue after, and she's not just like panting her ass off.

[1:40:27] Daniel Nolen: She does pant a little.

[1:40:28] Ben Rimalower: She does pant a little.

[1:40:29] Daniel Nolen: She does pants a little.

[1:40:30] Ben Rimalower: But the fact that she's now expected to deliver this Sally Bowles monologue.

[1:40:35] Daniel Nolen: It's and do the cards.

[1:40:36] Ben Rimalower: First of all, I do not call it a Sally Bowles monologue because I really don't think Joe Masteroff wrote this, and it is certainly not based.

[1:40:45] Daniel Nolen: Well, I guess it is based on material from Christopher Isherwood and John.

[1:40:49] Ben Rimalower: I why do I hate this so much, Daniel?

[1:40:52] Daniel Nolen: Oh, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.

[1:40:55] Ben Rimalower: What are we talking about?

[1:40:56] Daniel Nolen: The beginning of the monologue is lip-synced.

[1:40:58] Ben Rimalower: She sings City Lights live, but then the beginning of the monologue is lip sync.

[1:41:04] Daniel Nolen: She doesn't start speaking live until halfway through.

[1:41:07] Ben Rimalower: Is it is it lip sunk or is it just uh voiceover and then she takes over?

[1:41:12] Daniel Nolen: I don't remember.

[1:41:13] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, no, no, no, I think you're right.

[1:41:14] Daniel Nolen: It's just voiceover and she takes over.

[1:41:16] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, but that's what it is.

[1:41:17] Daniel Nolen: She pants for like a full minute while we hear the voiceover.

[1:41:20] Ben Rimalower: That's that's well that you know, that was that was But I don't begrudge her that.

[1:41:23] Daniel Nolen: I do not begrudge her that one little bit.

[1:41:25] Ben Rimalower: I just begrudge her everything else about this monologue.

[1:41:28] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:41:29] Ben Rimalower: Um, but she you see her putting on, I mean, it is kind of cool to see her putting on like the famous Sally Bowls costume.

[1:41:37] Daniel Nolen: Like you're like, oh shit, oh shit.

[1:41:38] Ben Rimalower: Oh shit.

[1:41:39] Daniel Nolen: Okay, no, okay.

[1:41:39] Ben Rimalower: This is the part where maybe I'm misogynistic, but I also feel that I'm like, that ain't my Sally Bowls.

[1:41:44] Daniel Nolen: Hashtag not my bowls.

[1:41:46] Ben Rimalower: But like, uh, you know, Bob Fossey did not approve that costume.

[1:41:49] Daniel Nolen: Uh the one in this concert?

[1:41:52] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:41:52] Daniel Nolen: Is it is it different from the other Sally costume?

[1:41:56] Ben Rimalower: It is different.

[1:41:57] Daniel Nolen: And and even if it's not as different as I think it is, it certainly doesn't fit the same.

[1:42:02] Ben Rimalower: But no, and and she was wearing, I mean, she puts it on right over this sequin break.

[1:42:07] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, no, it's not the same.

[1:42:08] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's in it's in the spirit, but it's not the same.

[1:42:11] Daniel Nolen: But it's, you know, uh it's not from the Fosse film cabaret.

[1:42:16] Ben Rimalower: It is from like a Ron Lewis directed, you know, concert tour.

[1:42:20] Daniel Nolen: And like, I don't like the way it fits her, and I I don't what I don't I don't want to see a monologue.

[1:42:27] Ben Rimalower: I to me the character, you know what I realize it is?

[1:42:32] Daniel Nolen: When Liza sings cabaret, I'm not watching Sally Bowls.

[1:42:38] Ben Rimalower: I'm watching Liza.

[1:42:40] Daniel Nolen: Now, in the movie, in Bob Fosse's film Cabaret, maybe I'm watching Sally Bowls, or maybe I'm watching some fusion, but I promise you, after that, it's not.

[1:42:51] Ben Rimalower: As a mat and in in fairness, I also don't really like when she sings cabaret in Liza with a Z.

[1:42:59] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:43:00] Ben Rimalower: Wait, actually, does she do this same monologue in Liza with a Z?

[1:43:04] Daniel Nolen: I do not think so.

[1:43:05] Ben Rimalower: No, no, no, no, no.

[1:43:06] Daniel Nolen: I think she might.

[1:43:08] Ben Rimalower: Does she?

[1:43:09] Daniel Nolen: Wait, let's find out real quick.

[1:43:11] Ben Rimalower: I certainly was shocked when it happened last night, but I have not watched Eliza in a Z in a while.

[1:43:18] Daniel Nolen: Liza and a Z.

[1:43:20] Ben Rimalower: Liza in a Z.

[1:43:21] Daniel Nolen: I've only listened to the recording.

[1:43:25] Ben Rimalower: Uh, wait a minute.

[1:43:26] Daniel Nolen: I'm finding this out right now.

[1:43:27] Ben Rimalower: We just must know.

[1:43:28] Daniel Nolen: I must know.

[1:43:31] Ben Rimalower: Um, where did it just go?

[1:43:34] Daniel Nolen: Well, and while you're doing that, I will say uh, you know, the we talked about the vocal prowess that she's displaying this whole time throughout the whole show.

[1:43:43] Ben Rimalower: And the fact that she goes from City Lights, does her little monologue, and then goes directly into this cabaret, uh arguably the 11 o'clock number, and her voice is not going out and it's still holding strong.

[1:44:00] Daniel Nolen: Oh no, no, of course you're right.

[1:44:01] Ben Rimalower: It's not in Lives with a Z because in Liza with a Z, she does a medley of songs from Cabaret leading into Cabaret.

[1:44:07] Daniel Nolen: That's it.

[1:44:07] Ben Rimalower: Um but the thing I love when Liza does cabaret in concert after this, you know?

[1:44:14] Daniel Nolen: And I don't care if it's I'm not going like Elsie, or I am going like Elsie, or like I'm lying about going like Elsie, or frankly, we all know I went like Elsie 20 years ago and now I'm coasting on fumes.

[1:44:26] Ben Rimalower: Not coasting, but you know, driving on fumes.

[1:44:28] Daniel Nolen: Either way, I love I like Liza getting up there and being like, this is my statement of life, and we all know Elsie was my mama, slash also me.

[1:44:36] Ben Rimalower: You know?

[1:44:37] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:44:37] Ben Rimalower: But I don't like her being like, well, you know, I auditioned for this show 12 times, and Harold Prince didn't think I was British enough, you know?

[1:44:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:44:46] Ben Rimalower: And like, I don't, I don't want that.

[1:44:48] Daniel Nolen: And so I don't like the introduction.

[1:44:50] Ben Rimalower: I will say though, once she finally starts singing it, yeah, finally, not a moment too fucking soon.

[1:44:58] Daniel Nolen: I do think it's one of the great versions of cabaret because she really is so fully matured as a performer.

[1:45:04] Ben Rimalower: You know, all the vocal choices, like whether you're gonna go, you know, how long she holds the note of like, when I go, you know, and the um only a cabaret old chum, you know, and like, you know, do you do you want to be very like musical theater like superstar, you know, and be like cabalae, you know, or are you like a live concert performer and you want to hold the note longer?

[1:45:33] Daniel Nolen: So you're like cab you know, just hold, hold, hold, hold, hold longer than the orchestra plays that out and done, you know.

[1:45:44] Ben Rimalower: Like, I think I think all those choices here are the right choices, and she certainly has voice to spare to do it however she thinks best.

[1:45:52] Daniel Nolen: And and she, you know, and she's just so at home in the song.

[1:45:57] Ben Rimalower: She knows how much storytelling to do, but how much belting to do, and where to pick up the tempo, and which notes to belt and which notes to throw away, and you know, I just think it's a kind of you know, where to strut and where to stand still, and where to use arm gestures and where to not.

[1:46:14] Daniel Nolen: It's just the best combination of all her tricks, but all her voice still there, you know.

[1:46:20] Ben Rimalower: But I also thought to myself, oh wow, this is like the end of an era.

[1:46:25] Daniel Nolen: Like, I mean, there is the next time she videotapes or records the song cabaret after this, is gonna be different.

[1:46:33] Ben Rimalower: She's already gonna have gone to rehab, she's already gonna have started to lose little tiny nooks and crannies of her voice.

[1:46:42] Daniel Nolen: You know, it's all gonna be different.

[1:46:44] Ben Rimalower: This is the last of you know.

[1:46:49] Daniel Nolen: It's like there's phase one of cabaret is like cabaret is a musical by her best friends that she auditioned for and didn't get cast in, but she sings it all the time because she sings better than the girl that got the part.

[1:47:01] Ben Rimalower: And then phase two is she won the Oscar, and this is her big song from her movie, and here's this, you know.

[1:47:07] Daniel Nolen: And then phase three is like she's an aging diva in you know, various decreasing, you know, uh increasing states of vocal disrepair, and it's an anthem, you know.

[1:47:19] Ben Rimalower: So this is in a way the last real moment of stage two, you know.

[1:47:23] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, well, like we always say, peak career concert.

[1:47:27] Ben Rimalower: I mean, the the word peak implies there was a climb up to this point, and now there's gonna be a descent back down.

[1:47:35] Daniel Nolen: Yes, so that's all coming after.

[1:47:37] Ben Rimalower: Well, speaking of a descent, I don't know what happens in this transition, but she drinks something out of a mysterious mug that somebody winks on top.

[1:47:44] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, what is in that mug?

[1:47:46] Ben Rimalower: But like you can't really pay too much attention to the mug because at the same time, she is enwrapped in black floor-length sequins.

[1:47:56] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:47:57] Ben Rimalower: And I just thought, wow, I have been edging for so long, and I haven't come yet, but I can see the light at the end of my penis hole.

[1:48:09] Daniel Nolen: And that light.

[1:48:11] Ben Rimalower: Those city lights.

[1:48:13] Daniel Nolen: Alright, so moving right along.

[1:48:15] Ben Rimalower: Yes, moving right along.

[1:48:16] Daniel Nolen: So, um, oh, but one more thing about uh, oh no, this is Shine.

[1:48:20] Ben Rimalower: So, okay, so she put the black sequin robe on her.

[1:48:23] Daniel Nolen: She's taking her sip from the mystery mug.

[1:48:25] Ben Rimalower: And spotlight comes, and we get little maid was kind of afraid of darkness.

[1:48:31] Daniel Nolen: So she said, I guess I'll go.

[1:48:35] Ben Rimalower: And she's telling the story, and I'm like, this is this is for you, Daniel.

[1:48:40] Daniel Nolen: Music theater acting.

[1:48:43] Ben Rimalower: Like, I don't spec even Donna Murphy could do it any better.

[1:48:49] Daniel Nolen: This is like literally like subtext and layers and objectives and obstacles.

[1:48:56] Ben Rimalower: This is playing the opposites.

[1:48:58] Daniel Nolen: This is knowing who you're talking to.

[1:49:01] Ben Rimalower: This is all the acting beats, all the segues, all the Ubers.

[1:49:06] Daniel Nolen: This is acting.

[1:49:08] Ben Rimalower: Oh, this is when I actually I said she's a Broadway star, goddammit.

[1:49:12] Daniel Nolen: Fuck you, Barbara Streisand.

[1:49:14] Ben Rimalower: This is what it's about.

[1:49:15] Daniel Nolen: And it's crazy because it's at the same time 100% simultaneously Donna Murphy musical theater acting and also like Mel Tormé jazz singing.

[1:49:26] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.

[1:49:31] Daniel Nolen: Shine on the sky.

[1:49:39] Ben Rimalower: And it's like, oh right, remember that chill jazz vibe we started on?

[1:49:44] Daniel Nolen: Here we are again.

[1:49:45] Ben Rimalower: Like full circle around.

[1:49:47] Daniel Nolen: The red sequin dance number of like city lights seems a million miles away.

[1:49:54] Ben Rimalower: A whole planet away.

[1:49:56] Daniel Nolen: We've gone from Saturn to back to the moon.

[1:49:59] Ben Rimalower: It's just so fucking thrilling.

[1:50:01] Daniel Nolen: I mean, and this song, this song that used to be Shine on Harvest Moon.

[1:50:08] Ben Rimalower: Yes.

[1:50:09] Daniel Nolen: Somehow it got put into the Fred Ebb-inator.

[1:50:14] Ben Rimalower: The Ebb-inator 2000.

[1:50:16] Daniel Nolen: I don't know what ungodly things happened to this poor song.

[1:50:20] Ben Rimalower: But and I'm not mad at it.

[1:50:22] Daniel Nolen: Don't get me wrong.

[1:50:24] Ben Rimalower: I want to live and die completely within the walls of this song.

[1:50:31] Daniel Nolen: It's so crazy.

[1:50:32] Ben Rimalower: It has nothing to do with Shine on Harvest Moon.

[1:50:36] Daniel Nolen: Well, and just previously, uh, in the day yesterday, I was cooking and I was listening to Rosemary Clooney sing this, and so I was really in for some whiplash.

[1:50:44] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:50:45] Daniel Nolen: At what point does Rosie Clooney go light up?

[1:50:49] Ben Rimalower: Right up.

[1:50:51] Daniel Nolen: Fast or slow come cast that glow and shine on this moon up in the sky.

[1:51:05] Ben Rimalower: And then when she does the come on, come on.

[1:51:08] Daniel Nolen: I can't even think of how it goes right now, but it very it feels very like come through New York New York.

[1:51:13] Ben Rimalower: So New York, New York.

[1:51:15] Daniel Nolen: Um, uh, uh, uh for me for me and my gal, for me and my gal, what?

[1:51:24] Ben Rimalower: Cast that light, harvest cast that light, fair and fine, harvest bri, moon of mine, shast that light.

[1:51:39] Daniel Nolen: No, that's what it is.

[1:51:41] Ben Rimalower: Uh harvest moon of mine, come on, come on, yes, that's right.

[1:51:47] Daniel Nolen: And then a busted high note.

[1:51:50] Ben Rimalower: You know, when she sang this note at the winter garden in 1974, it was like a Shoshana Bean belted F, okay?

[1:52:01] Daniel Nolen: And she literally was like, shut.

[1:52:03] Ben Rimalower: I can't, I truly do not have it, and I especially don't have it after doing whatever I just tried to do just now.

[1:52:09] Daniel Nolen: But like, you know, but it was like a pingy, belted, crazy high note that most girls cannot sing.

[1:52:16] Ben Rimalower: And then by the time she got to Carnegie Hall in '79, it was like a Lorna Luft, Judy Garland, end of "Hello Bluebird," Mr. Blue Bluebird, Hello, where it's like, well, she did hit the note, you know.

[1:52:34] Daniel Nolen: She hit it all right.

[1:52:34] Ben Rimalower: But here, she doesn't even hit it. She's like, come on, come on, shut. But I am good with it. Oh, I truly, I didn't even think about that in watching it. I was just like so completely taken. I was so happy to give it to her for all that she had just given me. That's 100% true. However, it felt a little bit like a premonition. I mean, talking about this concert being the beginning of the end of something, like I think it's safe to say this is the first time in Liza's recorded career that she ever didn't have a note. And it's obviously not a problem. I mean, she has just given us more notes than anyone ever dreamed. But it's, but you know that what's to come is years and years and years. I mean, nowadays, not nowadays you don't see her at all. You know, but for years, not having the note became part of the game.

[1:53:46] Daniel Nolen: Part of the bit.

[1:53:47] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, well, and it's haunting to think about it that way because hearing her now in 1980, and then our first QuaranStream, the leading ladies' concert, where she truly has none of the notes, but yet she, as you say, pulls out all her Liza tricks to somehow get around it and distract you from the fact. I mean, here it's like really apparent because this concert is such a display of vocal prowess and power. Which by the way, there's still vocal prowess and power yet to come after that "Shine on Harvest Moon."

[1:54:22] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[1:54:23] Ben Rimalower: Because, okay, then I love that as she's taking her bows, and then as she goes off stage and the audience is screaming and clapping and praying for her to come back.

[1:54:34] Daniel Nolen: Pissing, yeah.

[1:54:35] Ben Rimalower: Pissing, literally. What's the Judy Garland line from "I Could Go On Singing"? Like, there, but they're like, what's her name in "I Could Go On Singing"? Not Esther, that's a "Star is Born."

[1:54:44] Daniel Nolen: I was literally gonna say Esther.

[1:54:46] Ben Rimalower: I do not know. It's very Esther-esque. But they're like, you know, whatever her name is, they're like, um, oh wait, I should know this because I feel like it's on a thing. Like, um, god damn it. Anyway, I'm sure all our biggest fans know the answer.

[1:55:01] Daniel Nolen: Increaming into the phone right now.

[1:55:03] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[1:55:04] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:55:04] Ben Rimalower: But she's, um, they're like, they're like, they're rioting. Or they're like, you know, they're sh, they're stamping their feet, and she's, and she goes, I don't care if they're fasting. So, but you know, so the audience is fasting, and I'm so happy because in this moment, what do they play? It goes back to what they've been playing since, and this is also the beginning, this is the final moment of this. But because after this, it would always be "New York, New York."

[1:55:33] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[1:55:34] Ben Rimalower: Um, but this goes back to earlier in her career when she had didn't even have cabaret, let alone "New York, New York." What was the theme? What was the bow music for a Liza Minnelli's concert was the Gershwin song "Liza."

[1:55:46] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[1:55:47] Ben Rimalower: And it's a great arrangement because again, of course, Judy sang it as the ballad that it was. Um, but you know, but this, but this is some weird up-tempo version for her bow music, and it's like du-da, duh, you know, "Liza, Liza, skies are gray, then you start kissing me, and the bad things go away," you know, and it's just like I don't know, it just always makes me so happy, this up-tempo Liza bow music. I get so happy. So this is, you know, it's very much what they play at the Winter Garden and at the Olympiad, and you know, all those concerts in the '70s. But here this is the final moment. So they play that, it makes me very happy. Um, although then I'm like, I love that they're actually going to the trouble of pretending the encore is not planned. Do you notice that she literally goes and has whispered conversations with three different people in the band?

[1:56:43] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[1:56:44] Ben Rimalower: Like, not only does she have to go talk to Pappy at the drums, Bill LaVorgna, but she also talks to like two or three others, like as if he's not capable of informing them. Like just in case the people in the cheap seats somehow miss that it's like, well, we didn't have anything, and we just had to think on our feet.

[1:57:00] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, Liza Eva, yeah.

[1:57:02] Ben Rimalower: When she's doing her signature little committing to the lie, committing to the bit, she does it for the balcony.

[1:57:09] Daniel Nolen: She really does.

[1:57:10] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Liza truly has no qualms about lying. I mean, there's so many stuff. I mean, there's other stories we could tell. I love how she just lies. I mean, I just I feel like if you were, uh, the okay, so the other Liza story, can you handle one more story?

[1:57:28] Daniel Nolen: Yes, of course.

[1:57:29] Ben Rimalower: So, um, the other, I hope our listeners can. The other time Uncle Mitchell took me to see Lorna was prior to the one we mentioned in 2003, 2004, 2003. The first time was in um 2000. And um, Lorna was performing the very first, I believe, or one of the very, very, very first performances of "Songs My Mother Taught Me." And it was at the West Hampton Performing Arts Center in West Hampton. And um, my sister was visiting, actually, oh my god, it was exactly 20 years ago.

[1:58:03] Daniel Nolen: Oh wow.

[1:58:04] Ben Rimalower: It was Memorial Day weekend, and my sister Lucy was visiting me from LA, and as a special treat, uh Uncle Mitchell and his boyfriend Mark took me and Lucy to the Hamptons to see Lorna. Uh huh. And uh we went to the concert, and at this time, the history with Liza and Lorna was that they'd had a rocky road of their relationship together and apart, together and apart, and there had been a failed intervention on Liza's sobriety in the late '90s, after which they had not spoken. But then when Liza had a particularly um brutal setback, uh she was about to go on tour in "Minelli on Minelli" after it had closed on Broadway, and she was hospitalized for encephalitis. And she was just in terrible shape, just the fattest she ever was.

You know, just for context, this is about like nine months after um what do you call it? Uh, uh my favorite Broadway. No, it's sorry, it's a year and a half. No, no, it's a year and a half after my favorite Broadway, the leading ladies. Anyway, so she'd been hospitalized for encephalitis, and uh people thought she was maybe even gonna die, you know, but she didn't, and then she was being nursed back to health, and famously Lorna had gone to visit her in the hospital and they had reconciled. And anyway, so here Lorna was debuting her concert in the Hamptons, and who has a home in the Hamptons, but uh I was gonna say friend of the pod, but uh the woman who I am as big a fan as I am of Lorna, Liza, or Judy, Arlene Lazar.

[1:59:48] Daniel Nolen: Mm-hmm.

[1:59:48] Ben Rimalower: Arlene Lazar is not a performer, she is a dentist's wife. And she and her husband Alan Lazar, Alan and Arlene were close, close friends with both Liza and Lorna in the '70s in the height of the Studio 54 days when they were just a rich Jewish dentist and his wife who did a lot of cocaine and went dancing at the disco. And they were best friends with both Liza and Lorna and stayed best friends with Liza and Lorna for decades upon decades. Even when Liza and Lorna were apart, they always were still both friends with Alan and Arlene. And I think Alan and Arlene were a non-show business couple who loved show business and loved the gum girls and always stood by them and they could lean on them when they needed a, you know, stable home environment.

I mean, you know, Lorna got her shit together in the early '80s, and you know, all that. But you know, I think the Alan and Arlene meant a lot to Liza all those years as a couple who were, you know, normies in a way, you know. And uh also I met Alan and Arlene years later in a different context because Alan and Arlene live on the Upper East Side and are very close friends with Ramona Singer from "Real Housewives of New York." And as friends of Ramona's and cabaret fans and friends of Michael Feinstein, they became big supporters of the Countess Luann Cabaret show. So I spent some time with Alan and Arlene years later in that context. But that's another story. That's a different story. Anyway, um never mind anyway.

[2:01:32] Daniel Nolen: Exactly.

[2:01:32] Ben Rimalower: Liza is the witch. So um anyway, but so Alan and Arlene, Liza was staying with their house in the Hamptons, and we were sitting in the theater waiting for Lorna's concert to begin, and the entire audience as one with whiplash whips their necks back to look at what is the gigantic thing coming down the center aisle. And it was like 300 pounds of Liza Minnelli's in a hot pink silk knee-length blouse, black velvet pants, a crazy jet black Patty Duke flip wig with a hot, with a hot pink headband coming down the aisle, basically carried on either arm by the Lazars. The whole audience watches them, they go down to an obscenely low row number. Because, you know, as Patti LuPone said to me when she came to see "Patti Issues" at the Duplex, put me in the back.

[2:02:39] Daniel Nolen: Sorry, I did, I did Liza.

[2:02:41] Ben Rimalower: She said, she said, put me in the back. Um, you know, but here were Liza and the Lazars, like in like row C. But I think Liza cool. You know, probably someone said, well, you know, should we put you in the back, Liza? And Liza said, well, I don't want people to have to hurt their necks. Just put me in the front. Because she knew. Take one for the team. She knew, you know, we were gonna watch her no matter what. So Lorna does the concert. First time seeing Lorna live, and she could not have been in better voice, and it was thrilling, and it was a fabulous show. And so we go backstage with Uncle Mitchell afterwards, and we're about to go into Liza's to Lorna's dressing room, and who is sitting there on a chair in the dressing room? Liza Minnelli's.

[2:03:27] Daniel Nolen: Liza Minnelli's.

[2:03:28] Ben Rimalower: And so Liza says, um, Lorna says, uh, Liza, I want you to uh meet my friend Mitchell. He was actually the editor of my book, and he did such a wonderful job. And so Uncle Mitchell wanted to tell Liza that in the '60s, his parents had taken him and my mom to the Catskills when Liza was performing there, and they had seen her. And I guess my grandparents maybe had taken them, had gotten taken them to see Liza one show, but Uncle Mitchell went to see the matinee the evening, because of course he did. And in between shows, he had gone to the stage door and you know, told her how much he loved her, and he had walked her dog for her. Like I think he had been like, oh my god, that dog is so cute, what's her name?

And you know, she asked the assistant and found out the name was Terry. And uh, no, I'm just kidding, I think she loves her dogs, but whatever. You know, um, I don't know why I tried to do material. This is not the time or place. But anyway, so uh, you know, I don't for whatever reason he walked her dog. Maybe she was like, well, I just don't have time between shows on the schedule here, you know. And he was like, I'd be happy to walk your dog, Liza. And so he walked the dog. So now uh Lorna says, Mitchell, my editor, and did such a great job on the book, and Mitchell says, and Liza reaches out her hand, and Uncle Mitchell says, well, actually, Liza, we've met before. And what does Liza say to Uncle Mitchell?

[2:04:54] Daniel Nolen: I was just gonna say classic, just committing to the revisionist history of her own.

[2:05:03] Ben Rimalower: Just no problem with just the most absurd lie. Like, I mean, I don't know what she thought his story was gonna be, but it was not anything where it was implied that she should have remembered him, you know. But she already had that answer prepared.

[2:05:18] Daniel Nolen: Oh, I'm sure that comes out of her like kittens to cream, you know.

[2:05:22] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah.

[2:05:23] Daniel Nolen: That doesn't make sense.

[2:05:24] Ben Rimalower: But so then we all go out to dinner. Liza and her husband Colin, who's her musical director, sorry, Lorna and her husband Colin, who's her musical director, and Liza and the Lazars, and some mafioso type looking guy who I guess was Lorna's tour manager, but also Frank Sinatra's tour manager. Maybe one or two guys from the band, also, I'm not exactly sure. And um, me and Lucy and Uncle Mitchell and Mark. And we go to this restaurant, and we sit at this great big table, and um, what are the things that Liza said? Uh so at one point, um well, I finally got the courage up to say something to her, and uh I was I was like, um I was like Liza when is Liza with a Z gonna re-release on DVD and as soon as I said it I regretted it because I was like she doesn't know what a DVD is, you know.

[2:06:27] Daniel Nolen: I mean this was only the year 2000, and but sure without missing a beat, Liza says, Well, just as soon as I can finish going through all the footage, I don't know, I guess they had special footage, special features, and then um at one point uh Liza goes to the bathroom and Arlene suddenly turns to Lucy and goes and goes, go with her doll.

[2:06:51] Ben Rimalower: Do you mind?

[2:06:52] Daniel Nolen: Oh shit.

[2:06:54] Ben Rimalower: So Lucy had to like awkwardly follow Liza into the bathroom and then out of the bathroom back to the table.

[2:06:59] Daniel Nolen: Then just to make sure she wasn't like doing drugs or something.

[2:07:02] Ben Rimalower: I have no idea, but Lucy just followed her into the bathroom.

[2:07:06] Daniel Nolen: And then um uh we were talking about um the movie of Lorna's book starring Judy Davis, and everybody was saying how brilliant Judy Davis had been, and how she really captured Judy Garland, and everybody was agreeing, and Liza who'd been pretty much silent the entire time chimes in with, oh, absolutely, you know, and she really captured mama's double breaths, and everybody kind of everybody kind of looks around like WTF, and Liza goes, Well, you know how she'd be like and she does this like double breath in between, and it was so Judy, it blew my mind.

[2:07:52] Ben Rimalower: I never thought of it.

[2:07:53] Daniel Nolen: And Judy Davis did do it.

[2:07:55] Ben Rimalower: It's almost like a hiccup.

[2:07:57] Daniel Nolen: It's so genius.

[2:07:58] Ben Rimalower: And um, oh, and then at one point they were talking about how great the arrangements are in Lorna's show, you know, how great the Judy arrangements are.

[2:08:06] Daniel Nolen: And they got on the subject of Judy's arrangement of Justin Time.

[2:08:11] Ben Rimalower: Oh, sorry, this was uh sorry.

[2:08:13] Daniel Nolen: And um, so she Liza tells this really, really long story about they were at the house on Bridgecrest Hive, and Kay Thompson was fooling around at the piano and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

[2:08:27] Ben Rimalower: And this whole long story about how just in time came to be.

[2:08:31] Daniel Nolen: And when she's finished, she goes outside for a cigarette, and Lorna goes, By the way, none of that was true.

[2:08:40] Ben Rimalower: And then finally, um, the check comes at the end, right?

[2:08:46] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[2:08:46] Ben Rimalower: And somehow the waiter puts it down like right near Liza, and like within within like less than a half a nanosecond, Liza's like, I'm so embarrassed, but does anybody have any money I can borrow?

[2:08:59] Daniel Nolen: Oh, bless her.

[2:09:00] Ben Rimalower: And Lorna was like, Liza, I have this. Don't be ridiculous, or no, maybe Lazarus picked up the check. I don't remember, but like, you know, all no worries.

[2:09:08] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.

[2:09:08] Ben Rimalower: And sure enough, as I would later hear in Leslie Kritzer's story of uh, because Liza had come to her dressing room at um Funny Girl, and then Liza had been like, Do you want do you want to go to the diner? And Leslie's, because there's a diner basically in the parking lot of the Paper Mill Playhouse, and everybody goes there. And Leslie said, sure, and Liza said, I'll meet you in the parking lot. And sure enough, when Leslie like quickly got changed and came out to the parking lot, there was Liza sitting on the curb with Sam Harris smoking a cigarette. And sure enough, when we walked out of this restaurant, Liza was sitting on the curb of this restaurant in West Hampton smoking a cigarette.

[2:09:47] Daniel Nolen: On the curb.

[2:09:47] Ben Rimalower: Where she feels at home.

[2:09:48] Daniel Nolen: Where she feels at home.

[2:09:50] Ben Rimalower: Anyway, that was a very good story.

[2:09:53] Daniel Nolen: Alright.

[2:09:54] Ben Rimalower: Our listeners really really got uh special to talk about special material, a little special.

[2:09:58] Daniel Nolen: Seriously.

[2:09:59] Ben Rimalower: So she does then the final the actual encore that they teased us with.

[2:10:04] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[2:10:04] Ben Rimalower: And to quote uh the song from God, it's Candor and Eb. What's it from?

[2:10:14] Daniel Nolen: I couldn't be I couldn't be happier.

[2:10:18] Ben Rimalower: Oh, wait, are you talking about from Wicked?

[2:10:20] Daniel Nolen: No, that's a different tune.

[2:10:23] Ben Rimalower: No, what's like a the Candor and Ebb song that sounds like that?

[2:10:27] Daniel Nolen: Um, I can't remember it. Um, I'll figure it out.

[2:10:32] Ben Rimalower: From what?

[2:10:33] Daniel Nolen: I feel like um is it possible Liza sings it, but I'm thinking about is it maybe in and the world goes round. Anyway, it doesn't matter. But I couldn't be happier that she sings and the world uh but the world goes round, and um I've always said like when forced to choose my favorite song in the world, a couple choices come to mind, which are obviously Meadowlark, and um people might be surprised to know all the things you are, and um a couple other songs are on that list, but for sure, the number one song I come up with, if I have to choose one song that's my favorite song, it's But the World Goes Round.

[2:11:16] Ben Rimalower: And this might be the best version.

[2:11:18] Daniel Nolen: I mean.

[2:11:19] Ben Rimalower: It totally for me it is. I mean, Molly Pope's comes close because I love hers, but I mean, this Liza's version in this uh concert I wrote, it feels like Rose's turn. I mean, it feels like Liza's Rose's turn. It's so amazing.

[2:11:34] Daniel Nolen: Um, it's like a Phoenix rising from the ashes. You know, it's it's that moment for her where you see things happening, you see the change that of her character or whatever she's doing. She tells that story.

[2:11:50] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.

[2:11:52] Daniel Nolen: Fuck.

[2:11:53] Ben Rimalower: Fuck.

[2:11:54] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it's just everything.

[2:11:56] Ben Rimalower: And um, one, this is so off topic. Uh, I mean, not off topic, but it's just as a side note. This reminds me also of losing my mind. I love songs where in the interlude between the first half and the second half, when the there's a couple of stray vocal, you know, like the way it's like um of the planet spins and the world goes round and round, and then the band goes bum bom bum, Liza.

[2:12:24] Daniel Nolen: But the world goes round.

[2:12:33] Ben Rimalower: But the world goes round back to the normal part. Sometimes your dreams, you know, and it's like in losing my mind, it's like um uh uh uh in the middle of the uh you said you love me, you were just being kind, or am I losing my mind? Da da dun da da da da da da da da da da da.

[2:12:54] Daniel Nolen: I want you so it's like I'm losing my mind. You know, it's I love that. And there's I are there, I'm sure there's many examples, and hopefully some of our listeners will remind me. Because I was trying to think what other songs have that. And I just really enjoy that. Um, and this is such a great anyway, but but I I don't even have anything to say about it. It's just a 10 plus performance of a 10 plus song, and it's just the perfect, perfect, perfect moment of life.

[2:13:22] Ben Rimalower: Well, and it's also seeing Liza sing it, and like you said, the foreshadowing of knowing what's to come makes it so powerful because it's about resilience, you know, it's about um pressing on against adversity, uh persevering, and so that just makes it all the more uh, you know, uh white hot.

[2:13:44] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I will say for you know, I mean, I've always said about Liza in contrast to Patty, for example, you know, where like uh if how I feel about an individual Patty Lapone performance on a scale of one to ten, I enjoy a Patty Lapone 10 performance, I don't know, 10 times more than I enjoy a Patty Lapone one performance, you know? Whereas Liza Manelli, I enjoy 1000% across the board, no questions asked. I just have no horse in the race of whether it's her best or her worst or whatever. That's not exactly true because I was definitely in Nirvana last night, but nonetheless, like I really just always enjoy Liza, and that is never more true than in this song. Like, I that's why I'm sad Liza's not singing right now, because I don't care if she's coughing up blood and doesn't know her own name. If Liza can burp, I'd be happy to hear her.

[2:14:41] Ben Rimalower: I always love this. I've seen her in the worst possible voice, and I've seen her with barely any mental coherence, and nonetheless, she has poured this song out from her soul, and it has been high art. I always love it. Love, love, love, love, love, love, love.

[2:14:57] Daniel Nolen: It's like um uh Paul Iacono says when he's sitting at the booth with you at the Carlisle in the Elaine Sturge documentary. Uh, it's watching her get there is part of the fun. You know, watching her uh arriving, it doesn't have to be perfect, but watching her do it is is what's so thrilling.

[2:15:14] Ben Rimalower: Yes, friend of that. Friend of the pod, Paul Iacono.

[2:15:17] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[2:15:18] Ben Rimalower: Um, okay, one more thing I have to say. The credits when they roll the credits, it's the same font that was used in Anis Behaven. Which is the Golden Girls font. I don't know, like if it was just whatever uh whoever that wherever this aired on TV, like if it was the same uh network. Well, no, you said this was HBO, right? Maybe yeah, no, it was definitely HBO. So that wouldn't have been Golden Girls. I don't know. But whatever it is, it was a very popular font at the time.

[2:15:48] Daniel Nolen: Um, all right. Well, we finally got through.

[2:15:51] Ben Rimalower: I can't believe we did.

[2:15:52] Daniel Nolen: I truly cannot believe it.

[2:15:53] Ben Rimalower: It was three hours.

[2:15:55] Daniel Nolen: Three hours.

[2:15:56] Ben Rimalower: Two and a half, two and a half.

[2:15:58] Daniel Nolen: Two and a half. When we edit it down, it will be two hours and twenty nine minutes.

[2:16:01] Ben Rimalower: 25 minutes.

[2:16:02] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, exactly. This has been so wonderful for me personally. So thank you, Daniel.

[2:16:06] Ben Rimalower: Me too as well.

[2:16:09] Daniel Nolen: Thank you, listeners. Thank you, Burnside Gooch for really. He really gave us a gift with his with his election fixing. And um, and and I remember it. Thank you for caring. Uh with that said, we will have another.

[2:16:25] Ben Rimalower: Oh, well, sorry, one more thing. We loved the um, we love the that speech that I mean, now it was later in her career when she did the sort of after having so movingly in this one be like, oh, ladies and gentlemen, thank you so much. You know, I'll remember this the rest of my life, you know. And then years later, by wrote in some concert, I don't even remember which, she's like, thank you so much, and I'll remember it. And it's almost like, you know, you know, like how like at CVS or Dwayne Reed, like at some point, customer service must have decided corporate wide that they're not supposed to go, next. You know, we want you to give a good customer service experience. We want you to go, will the following guest please step down? But what's come to pass is that now they just go, following, following. And it's almost like that's Liza now, and she's like, and I'll remember it. So that's why Daniel and I always say, and I'll remember it.

[2:17:17] Daniel Nolen: Well, and the thing I know it from is when she was on QVC.

[2:17:20] Ben Rimalower: Yes, exactly.

[2:17:22] Daniel Nolen: Never more, never more dazed and confused was Liza than on QVC. I mean, we could do the whole episode.

[2:17:29] Ben Rimalower: I'm calling in from Georgia.

[2:17:31] Daniel Nolen: Hi, Georgia.

[2:17:32] Ben Rimalower: Hi, Georgia.

[2:17:33] Daniel Nolen: But the reason I what I wanted to say was that everybody that listened to this must listen to the Encore track. I guess it's before she sings um Shine on Harvest Moon, or is it right after Shine on Harvest Moon? Anyway, from the Carnegie Hall concert. Because what she says there is really, really, I mean, I'm sure it's partly false and lying, but it's the most charming, adorable, like you just want to pinch her cheeks and give her a hug and bake her cookies, Liza ever. When she's like, she's trying to do that speech. Thank you so much. Oh, this has been an incredible night for me. You've given me a gift, and I'll remember it the rest of my life, right? So she keeps trying to start that, but they're really clapping and screaming so much. I mean, they're pissing, you know. And she's like, Thank you, thank you. And finally, at one point she's like, she goes, please, I must tell you. It's like she literally pleads with them to stop.

[2:18:32] Ben Rimalower: Stop worshipping her.

[2:18:33] Daniel Nolen: Yes.

[2:18:34] Ben Rimalower: I totally know that. It is so lovable. I can't even. Like, I if that must be what the baby Jesus felt like.

[2:18:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, please.

[2:18:43] Ben Rimalower: I beg you. I must tell you. Uh, okay, so on our uh live stream Tuesday, Thursday, April, August, on uh BroadwayWorld Facebook page and BPN YouTube, we will talk about our next category for corn streams, and we will, of course, hold a vote.

[2:19:02] Daniel Nolen: Yes, we will.

[2:19:03] Ben Rimalower: And um, three options. So until then, we will uh, you know, the world goes round, as as Liza sang.

[2:19:12] Daniel Nolen: Come on!

[2:19:13] Ben Rimalower: Two blueberry pie!

[2:19:17] Daniel Nolen: Ooh, that sounds delicious.

[2:19:19] Ben Rimalower: Oh yeah.

[2:19:20] Daniel Nolen: Alright, bye, honey.

[2:19:21] Ben Rimalower: Bye.

[2:19:24] Daniel Nolen: Thanks for listening to Ben Remelauer's Broken Records on Broadway World. For more episodes, visit Broadway World, iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever podcasts do be. And be sure to check out our new twice-weekly live stream video chat. Tuesday, Thursday, April, August. Available on the BroadwayWorld Facebook page and the Broadway Podcast Network YouTube channel, Tuesdays and Thursdays at 10:30 a.m. This episode was edited by me, Daniel Nolen. Thanks to Emmy winning composer and lyricist Lance Horn for the broken records theme song. Follow us both, Ben Remelauer and Daniel Nolen on all y'all's socials. That's Ben Remelauer, B-E-N-R-I-M A-L-O-W-E-R. And that's Nolan with an E, not Nolan with an A. Because Nolan with an A isn't it.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred