Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Birthday Candles

Debra Messing (WILL & GRACE) returns to the stage in BIRTHDAY CANDLES as Ernestine Ashworth, who spends her 17th birthday agonizing over her insignificance in the universe. Soon enough, it’s her 18th birthday. Even sooner, her 41st. Her 70th. Her 101st... Read More

From the show: Critics' Table

21 mins
6/1/22

About

Debra Messing (WILL & GRACE) returns to the stage in BIRTHDAY CANDLES as Ernestine Ashworth, who spends her 17th birthday agonizing over her insignificance in the universe. Soon enough, it’s her 18th birthday. Even sooner, her 41st. Her 70th. Her 101st. Five generations, dozens of goldfish, an infinity of dreams, one cake baked over a century. What makes a lifetime… into a life? A writer of "freewheeling ambition" (Charles Isherwood, The New York Times), Noah Haidle makes his Broadway debut with a poignant new play as fearless in scope as it is tremendous in heart.

Hear from critics Juan Michael Porter II, Bedatri D. Choudhury, and Christian Lewis as they review BIRTHDAY CANDLES.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Juan Michael Porter II: Hello and welcome to the Critics' Table.

[0:02] Christian Lewis: Every episode we are joined by three luminary theater critics as they review the latest shows on and off Broadway.

[0:10] Juan Michael Porter II: You may agree with one, all of them, or none at all, but we ask that you listen first and ask questions later.

[0:17] Christian Lewis: Let's join the table, shall we?

[0:20] Juan Michael Porter II: Hello, I'm Juan Michael Porter the Second.

[0:23] Christian Lewis: I'm Christian Lewis.

[0:25] Bedatri D. Choudhury: And I am Bidatri D. Choudhury.

[0:27] Juan Michael Porter II: And this is The Critics Table, where we discuss the hottest shows on and off Broadway and give you our hot takes.

[0:36] Christian Lewis: But first, let's talk about where we write.

[0:39] Juan Michael Porter II: I freelance at a number of publications, including Did They Like It, Theaterly, and American Theater.

[0:44] Christian Lewis: You can follow me at Juan Michael Porter II for the second on Twitter.

[0:49] Christian Lewis: I'm Christian Lewis. I also freelance all over the place, including Did They Like It, Theatre Mania, Theaterly, and American Theater Magazine.

[0:58] Juan Michael Porter II: All of my writing can be found on my Twitter at C Lewis Reviews.

[1:02] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Hi, I'm Bidatri, and I also write all over the place, but mostly on film and documentaries.

[1:08] Bedatri D. Choudhury: But when I'm writing about theatre, it's usually for Did They Like It.

[1:11] Bedatri D. Choudhury: And you can have access to all my writing on my Twitter, which is at Bidatri, my first name.

[1:18] Juan Michael Porter II: Now let's jump into our show today, Birthday Candles.

[1:23] Juan Michael Porter II: Um, Christian, I'm really excited about this because you are a star baker, of course, but first a quick synopsis.

[1:30] Juan Michael Porter II: Emmy Award winner Debra Messing from Will and Grace comes home to Broadway in the poignant and funny new hit play about the extraordinary moments that make up one woman's ordinary life.

[1:41] Juan Michael Porter II: Messing leads a remarkable cast as Ernestine Ashworth, who spends her 17th birthday agonizing over her insignificance in the universe.

[1:50] Juan Michael Porter II: Soon enough, it's her eighteenth birthday, even sooner, her 41st, her 70th, her 101st.

[1:56] Juan Michael Porter II: Five generations, an infinity of dreams, and one cake, baked over a century.

[2:02] Juan Michael Porter II: This true gift of a play, according to Variety, will take you through the highlights and heartbreaks of 90 years in 90 minutes.

[2:10] Juan Michael Porter II: As the Daily News says, Messing is extraordinarily moving.

[2:14] Juan Michael Porter II: It's truly a must-see show.

[2:17] Juan Michael Porter II: I know that Chris Jones wrote that, and I was sitting behind him at the show where he was bawling next to his son, and it was fairly touching.

[2:23] Juan Michael Porter II: First thoughts. I'm curious. What did you think? I want to hear from you, Bidatri.

[2:28] Bedatri D. Choudhury: It's one of those, it's very much like TV. It draws you in. Like you just want to see what happens. And I really like the pacing. I know it's a hundred years fit within like a very short play. I mean, relatively short given like the long runtimes this season on Broadway. Uh, but you know, it was very engrossing. I was and the set was, and I'm sure we'll talk more about that. The set was so beautifully designed. And uh, so it really sucks you in. But then later, when you sit back and think about it, I was just like, well, it was fun, but you know, that's about it. I I don't think it was particularly profound. I'll get into the baking, but it's funny for me even to like hear the like very crazy pull quotes from Chris Jones and others, and to hear people crying, because I was sitting there like not affected by this play at all.

I found it hollow, cheesy. I wrote a review of it for Theater Mania, and I think I called it like R Town fanfiction. Was definitely like not. I'm not very into this play, and my biggest. Well, I have several critiques, including I was not a fan of Debra Messing's pretty overactive performance. But as a star baker, my biggest issue is the central birthday cake of this production. The whole point is we're supposed to watch Debra Messing bake a single cake over 90 years and 90 minutes. And uh I don't know who trained her, but fire that baking consultant and get another person because she literally couldn't even like measure flour properly, let alone like mix anything, and then the cake she makes is a boring one-layer eight-inch round birthday cake that she throws out.

I was I it was the cake part of this was so disappointing. And we, as critics, we get the script, and there's an entire like page-long note in the script about how important the baking on stage is. And I was like, Did the director and everyone just completely ignore this? Because in this production, the baking is not that important, but I will end my baking-related rant there so we can move on.

[4:36] Christian Lewis: No, I said this. I came out of the theater and I said this to my friend that if I were the playwright, I would definitely make that woman sit and eat a slice of cake after like she spent a hundred years baking it. It would have been more compelling than throwing it out undecorated. Also, the play is called Birthday Candles, and they never put damn candles on the cake.

[4:56] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Yeah, and oh, but also my South Asian childhood, you know, rung through my head with my mom's words like, don't waste food, what are you doing? Don't waste food. You know, I I think it's the the the show did not take the cake, and more than that, it didn't offer us any. It it was very sweet. I was moved by the people around me who were crying, and what it reminded me of was being in Colorado where I worked for a year, with very with people who are not running around like we are in New York City all the time. And so in my mind I thought, are tourists who come here to see this pleased with seeing a slice of their life? Does this actually fulfill them? Or is this just talking back to them what they think about themselves?

And this isn't to say that people in other parts of the uh country are simpler, but I do think that there was something a bit trite about this. And that didn't bother me because I didn't think that the play was reaching for much. I know that um the playwright, Noah Haidle, he'd actually suffered a bit of mental unwellness and had gone home and spent time with his family who took care of him, and so I kept thinking maybe this is a tribute to them, a tribute to the people who nurtured him, even though it's supposed to be about this caretaker who we learned very little about. So that that's a bit of a problem for me. That this woman who's on stage the entire show ends up being an unknown and in the hands of Messing, almost a sort of uh caricature of what a an aging woman is.

[6:26] Juan Michael Porter II: What did we think about the production itself, the design, the costumes, the lighting?

[6:31] Bedatri D. Choudhury: But I mentioned I think the set design is certainly like uh pretty beautifully done. It's a very realistic rendered like kitchen. Above it, it has like floating props that are all important in this woman's life, and I found that nice. I I like the lighting design. Costumes are pretty innocuous, but the sound design, in my opinion, is just like unforgivable. And if there's a moment when characters die and there's like this wind chime noise, and it's like the cheesiest thing ever, and I'm gonna be haunted by that wind chime noise for a while.

[7:03] Christian Lewis: I don't know about you, but I was just like, about the sound, there's that little gong that goes on, you know, with every year passing.

[7:12] Christian Lewis: I mean, by the tenth time, I was like, I get it. You know, I was just like, do it the first five times. Trust your audience, they'll know after that, right?

[7:20] Bedatri D. Choudhury: But that gong, like Christian and the wind chime, it's the gong in me. One thing about that is when you mentioned the cake coming out, I remember smelling it and having this moment of like, oh, and now we're going to get the cake, and then like you've said, it's just thrown away.

[7:37] Bedatri D. Choudhury: And I I was very impressed that the kitchen worked, that it was a functional kitchen, that I didn't feel like there was much about it that was integrated into their daily lives. It seemed to be almost like a TV show thing that's there, but that doesn't really affect everyone, um, regardless of how beautiful it is. I'm wondering, would you all have preferred to have seen them using the set more?

[7:59] Christian Lewis: I actually, you know, one thing I thought about like this is a hundred years of a woman's life, and all we see is her kitchen, you know, and then she talks about her travels for a bit with her son. She's uh sharing the photo album. And I wish we saw a little more beyond the kitchen. I mean, I was very impressed that it's a working kitchen. I love a good oven as much as the next Christian. But uh, but um I do think I wish I had seen more of her world outside of the kitchen because we hear so much about it.

[8:31] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Yeah, I'm also convinced that there's there's some theater magic happening with that oven because that cake that came out of the oven is not the cake that Debra Messing mixed together. It's not, it's just not. But it did smell nice, so I'll give you that.

[8:44] Christian Lewis: Were there any particular performances that stood out to you?

[8:47] Bedatri D. Choudhury: I I'm going to make one comment that I was particularly annoyed with this sudden old lady voice that Debra Messing started to put on as she got older, and that I when it was happening, I thought, is she really doing this? And I hate to trash on anyone, and I I'm just going to come out and say that I think she was miscast, and I wish that Jane Howdy Shell had been in the part because the part can be ageless, uh uh uh which is a note in the script. And I think that Jane Howdy Shell, who is phenomenal in Corleone and who has seen both sides of life, would have brought something true to this that would have elevated the text and the entire experience.

[9:20] Christian Lewis: Yeah, I mean, I really liked uh Ernestine's friend Kenneth, uh played by Enrico Colantoni. I hope I'm saying that right.

[9:27] Christian Lewis: He's adorable, and like, you know, he's the kind of, you know, as a straight woman, I'm just like, oh, I wish I met someone like that when I was 17. I mean, I don't know, I probably curse my luck, but uh but you know, one thing that really did not sit well with me is Matt, Ernestine's husband played by uh John Orlx, and he's fantastic throughout the play, but there is that bit where he like play acts in a way that we're supposed to assume he's had a stroke or something, and it's just not nice the way he does it. It's like you know, it's like one of those things we used to do in like when we were kids in middle school, like middle school bullies used to do to make fun of someone who walks a little different, who talks a little different, or like you know, just makes uh fun of someone with a lisp, you know, like the lowest hanging fruit kind of acting. I really did not appreciate that, and I think the play could have gone on very well without those few seconds of him acting like that.

[10:29] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Yeah, I likewise I was really put off by the fact that both a lot of the jokes about like the daughter-in-law, uh, that's like very anxious and like maybe neuroatypical, and then each of the other actors had a moment where they were like dramatically dying of some like very tragic Dickens melodramatic thing on stage, and I was just like, don't know why they had to do that.

[10:56] Juan Michael Porter II: It felt kind of ableist and it's melodrama and it's comedy, and did not like that.

[11:02] Christian Lewis: And Juan Michael, I really agree. I was like really shocked when I read that note in the script that said that like any actress of any age can play Ernestine, and there's actually an iteration of the show where she doesn't perform age at all.

[11:15] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Would have loved to see that. Also, this will come up in a later episode probably, but also on this season we have Mary Louise Parker performing a lot of ages and showing how subtly that can be done.

[11:28] Juan Michael Porter II: So I think to your point of Debra Messing was probably just not the actress for this role. Christian, you brought up a term that I don't know everyone is familiar with, ableist. Could you actually speak to that? Because it's so important for everyone to be aware of this.

[11:41] Christian Lewis: Yeah, thank you for stopping me to define that for everyone. Ableism is a prejudice stigma against disabled people, very akin to like a homophobia or a racism of people discriminating against for various reasons. And so when I say that a play is ableist, I'm saying that it's like taking a bad view and misappropriating and being inconsiderate towards actual disabled people by treating disability in the show to be something to be laughed at or to cry at. I wouldn't say that our director, Vivine Binesh, was doing this purposefully, but at this level, one has to think about all the angles about how this is received, particularly by the communities who are affected by that representation.

[12:25] Juan Michael Porter II: And a lot of times I know people who aren't in the theater who would say, "Well, how else were they supposed to do it?" And they sort of think that we as critics are giving people a hard time. And I would say that this was a solution. Instead of play acting it, just acknowledge it and speak to the person. When these transformations occur, they occur within seconds. And the nuance that we all know that goes into someone acquiring dementia or suicide ideation or a stroke, it happens over the course of years. It's not this sort of jarring thing which becomes almost mean to observe. And I don't think it was necessary, I think is what we are all saying to have indicated that.

[13:22] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Yeah, it felt like by doing it that quick it was like insensitive. Where do you think that this show would play well? Like it let's say that Broadway is not the place for it.

[13:32] Christian Lewis: At the time, my take, which I want to say with as much love and kindness as possible, is that this is a really great play for a high school to do. It has themes that people are gonna love in a high school audience. It has some nice acting challenges for high schoolers. You can cast it in a couple different ways, because here it was cast where the ensemble was all like triple casted, but you could just have everyone play their one character if you needed a bigger cast for a high school. But also, really based on Bedatri and while Michael, you're talking about the kitchen. I'd love to see this like maybe like in the round at a very small off-Broadway theater where we can like really see that baking happening. Like that might be very cool in a very hyper-realistic or even site-specific thing, like in a kitchen, give us a full real working kitchen that we can see close up.

[14:22] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Yeah, I'm just I'm just really glad and fortunate that three absolute sugar fiends are discussing this play. But I agree with Christian that I also think because this play explores like, you know, the themes of feminism, even like feminist thought, family. I do think it, you know, it does it in a very broad strokes kind of manner. We've talked about how it's not very nuanced. So I do think it, you know, it's a very good play for young women to watch to think, you know, to get those ideas, you know, when we first start reading Virginia Woolf, you know, that age, you know, where you like your kitchen is not your world, there's a world that lies behind it, you know, that kind of thing. So I'd definitely like to see how a young audience of women would react to this play.

[15:13] Christian Lewis: Also, both Bedatri and I have been talking about the sets, and I just wanted to name the person behind it, Christine Jones, so just shout out. About the stars above that you all mentioned, that felt like I love that those objects weren't in the daily business of what was going on on stage, because it's very tight, it goes by very quickly. And it felt like, oh, these are the things that make up a person's life that sort of revolve around them. And that felt really beautiful and very well realized.

[15:43] Bedatri D. Choudhury: I think something about the feminism within this play, the fact that I mentioned earlier that we don't really get Ernestine's voice or perspective, that she's essentially a servant for other people. And there is a moment where she starts to travel and live for herself and start her own business, but it seems to actually occur within only a few gongs or a few years or and therefore a few minutes, and then she's back to serving people. And for those who don't, when we mentioned that the show is triple cast, the actresses who play her family members go from being maybe a lover to a child to a grandchild to a neighbor later on. And so you see things being passed on down through the lineage. And while that is really profound and beautiful to observe, because there was nothing grounding it that made you think, well, why are we coming back to this particular woman aside from the fact that that's the conceit of the play? I started to think, well, I'd rather go follow those other people. I don't really care about this woman anymore. And I'm curious if you all found the essential performance lacking as well.

[16:45] Christian Lewis: Yeah, I mean, like, you know, and I brought up Virginia Woolf for a reason. It's, you know, the feminism is very white first wave. You know, this whole idea of a caregiver but with a little ambition, but enough to not like ruffle feathers, you know. Vote, you know, let's find a way to vote. But like, let's not talk about what's happening at home. You know, that's what I mean by, you know, the feminism in this is very first wave, and which is why I brought in Virginia Woolf, and why I think this would resonate with younger women who need that introduction into feminist thought and female agency. But once you've worked past that, you've grown past that. I think this play's feminism is a little outdated, which is why I think it doesn't kind of like sit a little wonky with the times.

[17:38] Bedatri D. Choudhury: I was even surprised to hear anyone talk about the feminism of the play. Because I was like, oh, she mentions wanting to be like Queen Lear in a play. Like, is that what we're like is that is that our bar now for what counts as feminism? Because like it's a really low bar for me.

[17:54] Christian Lewis: I don't know if I necessarily find the character very underwritten. I think I was just so kind of like put off by Debra Messing's performance where when she was a teenager, she was like hand on hips, pouty, like I wanna be Queen Lear, and then by the time she was an old lady, she was like bent over and like doing this old lady voice, and I was like, oh boy. But like that's why like I before I can even judge if that character is underwritten, I just would love to like see someone else do it, 'cause I think maybe someone else could make a lot of that part. But on the other hand, I would love for Debra Messing to play Lucille Ball. Because when she cries, I'm like, that's I love Lucy. You know, I shouldn't be thinking that way, but I did, and I was like, that's a missed opportunity. Somebody should cast her as Lucy Ball. Move over Nicole Kidman.

[18:47] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Agreed, agreed. I love this. Well, um final thoughts. Hmm, final thoughts. I don't think I would recommend people to go see Birthday Candles, but if you want if you're a tearjerker kind of person and you want to have a little tear jerk of a play, go see it. And I hope that this play has some kind of future in high schools and community theaters, in other castings and other imaginings. I don't think this version is this version's definitely not for me, but I don't think the play is useless in the world.

[19:16] Christian Lewis: Yeah, I mean, I agree with Juan Michael. I do think, you know, if you want to watch it, if and it's it is it is a good play in the sense of its spacing, its production design, we've talked about it. So, you know, if that's your thing, then yeah, sure, go ahead and watch it. Watch it with your mom and grandmom, perhaps. Like people next to me were crying. So, I mean, if that's your shtick, then maybe you should watch it. Sumptuous Productions, saccharine center makes people cry. If that's your jam, if you're coming from out of town and you want to feel something, then I think that this play might be for you. And I know that not everyone is looking for war and peace. And so I would actually suggest it to people who maybe find Les Mis to be a little too complicated for them. And I say that lovingly.

[20:07] Bedatri D. Choudhury: Yeah, and it's Mother's Day, so this is a nice I think it's a nice Mother's Day play. Absolutely. Not too challenging, not gonna fight with each other, gonna say, see, that's you. Go have some mimosas with your mom after.

[20:20] Juan Michael Porter II: Thanks for joining us on this episode of the Critics' Table Podcast. We would like to thank Jose Solis and the BIPOC Critics Lab team who have generously partnered with us on this project. You can find out more about the BIPOC Critics Lab at BIPOCcriticslab.com. Also be sure to subscribe to this podcast so that you never miss a review and learn more about our critics at BPN.fm/criticstable. The views or opinions expressed by the critics in this episode are solely their own and do not necessarily represent views or opinions of the Broadway Podcast Network. See you next time.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred