Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Oratorio for Living Things

ORATORIO FOR LIVING THINGS unfolds the complex layers of what it means to be alive and our relationship to time. The experience surrounds and uplifts, celebrating our curiosity, our wonder, and what we're capable of becoming when in communion with each other... Read More

From the show: Critics' Table

19 mins
5/8/22

Guests

About

ORATORIO FOR LIVING THINGS unfolds the complex layers of what it means to be alive and our relationship to time. The experience surrounds and uplifts, celebrating our curiosity, our wonder, and what we're capable of becoming when in communion with each other. The resulting music-theater event heralds Heather Christian as an undeniable artistic force.

Hear from critics Christian Lewis, Juan Michael Porter II, and Ayanna Prescod as they review this spellbinding theatrical experience.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Juan Michael Porter II: Hello and welcome to the Critics' Table.

[0:02] Christian Lewis: Every episode, we are joined by three luminary theater critics as they review the latest shows on and off Broadway.

[0:10] Ayanna Prescod: You may agree with one, all of them, or none at all, but we ask that you listen first and ask questions later.

[0:17] Juan Michael Porter II: Let's join the table, shall we?

[0:20] Juan Michael Porter II: Hello, I'm Juan Michael Porter II.

[0:22] Christian Lewis: I'm Christian Lewis.

[0:24] Ayanna Prescod: And I'm Ayanna Prescod.

[0:25] Juan Michael Porter II: And this is The Critics Table, a fabulous podcast where we talk about the hottest shows on and off Broadway and give you our hot takes.

[0:34] Christian Lewis: But first, let's talk about where we all write.

[0:37] Juan Michael Porter II: I am a freelancer at many places, including Did They Like It, Theaterly, American Theater, and you can follow me on Twitter at Juan Michael Porter II for the second.

[0:46] Christian Lewis: I also freelance all over the place and at tons of the exact same places: Did They Like It, Theaterly, Theater Mania, American Theater. I'm glad they all hire us.

[0:55] Christian Lewis: You can find me on Twitter at C Lewis Reviews.

[0:59] Ayanna Prescod: And I am also a freelance theater journalist, but not at the same places. I am at Variety, New York Theater Guide, Today Tix. I'm so excited to be here with you.

[1:10] Juan Michael Porter II: Today we are discussing Oratorio for Living Things, and let's give a quick synopsis of the show for those who don't know it.

[1:18] Ayanna Prescod: The event fuses music and theater, surrounding the audience with 18 virtual singers and instrumentalists.

[1:25] Juan Michael Porter II: Oratorio for Living Things runs March 15th through May 15th, 2022 at Ars Nova at Greenwich House.

[1:33] Christian Lewis: Let's dive in. Can I get a quick uh thoughts? What were our first responses?

[1:43] Ayanna Prescod: I don't know what to call it. I don't know what the visceral experience I had there. I literally had an out-of-body experience at the theater. I know when the press agent, John, great press agent, reached out to me, he said that it would feel like church. And I've been to church a lot. And it felt more than what I've ever experienced in like a Catholic church. And so I don't know what I saw. I couldn't tell you what this show is even about, but I know the feeling that I got was something that I've never received in a theater before.

[2:21] Christian Lewis: And so uh totally agree. This piece is this piece. Yeah, I don't I don't know what to call it. It's a musical, it's a piece with music, it's not a music, there's no characters, there's not a plot in a traditional sense. I think just it's an experience. That's what I've been telling everyone. Don't go to try to understand it, just go to experience it, and you will have a great time. It's a mix of like a Catholic mass and like a hippie meditation circle, and like I love it for that.

[2:51] Ayanna Prescod: It is a very moving musical experience piece. I loved it. I wish I could see it again. They give you a little libretto script book for it. You can like read along, and I've read it several times since then. There are like quotes from it that I will like live my life by. I wish I could see it more times. I cannot recommend it enough.

[3:11] Christian Lewis: I have to agree that if anyone were to ask me what was the show you had to see in that particular season, this would be that show. Our very good friend Jose Solis told me that it was the final show that he saw before the pandemic and before he moved back to Honduras. And he said, if I died, and that was the last show I'd ever seen in my life, I would have been very happy.

[3:32] Ayanna Prescod: And I have to say that it took me. Ayana, to your point that it was like being in something more than church, particularly because the piece draws on so many different references of the mundanity of everyday life, what you do, of how many seconds of sitting even on a toilet to like these profound quotes from I think I saw something from the Epic of Gilgamesh at one point and these Greek histories, and you just feel like wow, this is the entire world. This isn't just like our Western slice of it, this is everyone.

[4:06] Juan Michael Porter II: Were there any specific moments that you recalled or you like really were like the moment they started stomping and clapping? This has happened before in a theater, and I've never felt this, but also because it's an around. I feel like the acoustics of that room with everyone around there was music at every inch of you. And so no matter where you sat in that theater, you were gonna feel something, you were gonna see something totally different.

[4:34] Ayanna Prescod: It was the moment they started stomping, clapping, and I don't know, like it was a it was just a feeling that I'd never felt before. And I know that that happens in the theater a lot. I've been to, I can't even tell you how many musicals that has that has happened, but this was just like I don't know, out-of-body experience. It tugged at my heart for sure.

[4:56] Christian Lewis: For me, it was the last five minutes, which made me like emotional, and I would say was like perhaps some of the best five minutes I've ever spent in a theater. There's this very touching monologue because a lot of the show is about a relationship to nature. There's this very touching monologue about a child feeling bad about pencils and wanting to like save the rainforest with the wood from these pencils, and it was so moving. And then the very last part of the show is like they have everyone stand up if you can, and they do like a prayer for all of us, and it starts with this line that says, like, this isn't gonna be perfect, and we're just gonna try, and this is just gonna be a draft, not the final draft. And like, I'm gonna like live my life by this is a draft, not the final draft.

[5:43] Ayanna Prescod: And then something that like totally changed my whole world view, they talk about the whole history of the universe in this play a lot, it has a very big scope. And they say, if we charted the history of the universe onto a calendar year, humanity doesn't even come into play until December 31st at like 11:59, and like everything that we know of the earth has taken place in like a one hundredth of a millisecond within the last second on New Year's Eve. And it just like changes the way we think about scope and scale and humanity and like how maybe not as important as we think everything is, and it really like felt very like meditative and centering to just like acknowledge and understand the very, very, very, very small part of the history of this universe that we're part of.

[6:33] Christian Lewis: Absolutely meditative, like so much so. Something that really called out to me was when uh Quentin Oliver Lee, who is this very tall man and this huge bass voice, or just a huge range, what he starts singing in this big bass that just reverberates, reverberates, and I felt it in my chest, and it actually lifted me up more than I thought. I nearly stood at like one of those moments. If you've ever been in a traditional black church when they say, Can you testify? Can you stand up? That like I was like, I gotta stand up at this moment. My friend was like uh um John Um Chavez at American Theatre Critics Association, like, whoa, you okay? Like, it was really a moment.

[7:12] Ayanna Prescod: And what I loved about it is that the performers themselves make eye contact with you, that they are there with you, and in that moment, I'm making sure that I'm saying his name correctly. Angel Lazada like looked at me and he was like, I see you, I saw you, I felt that too. And it was like, so I'm not the only one. He's like, No, you're not the only one. That was so wonderful, and that it is a chorale. Those of us who grew up doing choirs and oratorials, you will find yourself very much so at home. That every single person has a specific solo moment, so that it's not just the ensemble is supporting you all, and you're a part of it, but people will speak to of different circumstances, and I'm not sure how that was assigned, but I think that every single person who was cast was perfect for the moment that they spoke to.

[8:01] Christian Lewis: It just felt so right, and I wonder how they workshopped that and were like, Oh, yeah, this is your part, this is your part. And nor did it feel like I never I didn't feel like I wasn't getting enough someone. Everything was so well balanced.

[8:14] Ayanna Prescod: Could we talk about the experience of actually sitting in the pews and the construct of that space which was seen as a traditional almost auditorium stage to suddenly being converted into this round with pews? And it was very a very, very, very tiny space. Part of the reason why this show is so sold out, but there is a good rush policy, but so sold out is because it's a very, very small capacity because they have us in a tiny space in the round in these seats that Juan Michael said, like are very much like pews, which helps give it a religious vibe, but in a space that probably feels unfamiliar to so many of us.

[8:51] Christian Lewis: But I loved it. I loved it being in the round. Ayana already mentioned the acoustics in there, the sonic quality of that space is very cool. The musicians are like behind you and it really echoes in you. The costume designs are very chill. They're all in these like very casual, bluey, earthy tones, which I love. I could have, I would have wanted maybe a little more light design, maybe a little more set design, but it felt beautiful and it didn't need it, but I would have loved to see what maybe a different lighting and set designer might have done.

[9:24] Ayanna Prescod: Yeah, I kept thinking of the light, the singular light shade that comes down in the center of the round as this like shade that they just got from Crate and Barrel. But it works. It's just like it's like we're gonna get this cheap shade because we actually don't need anything. Um, we have the power of these massive voices, these musicians that are like otherworldly. It's just they didn't need anything for me to be for me to literally say this is the best show that I've seen all year. And what a way to come back into theater with a show like this. Like after the year we've had of no theater and to have this church experience. And for people who don't even go to church, I sat next to a woman who says, I've never gone to church before, and feel what she felt in that it was just exhilarating.

It was important. Also, I was in the same audience as Lynn Nottage and watching her experience this show was very crazy. Um, I will say that there were people who raised their hands. There were people who just felt it was a very, it was a show that's important to watch the actors around you, but also watch the audience and how they are taking in something like this. Um, and it was just I mean they didn't need any for me they didn't need anything but those musicians because it was just yeah this was like a life sustaining show. I wish I could have seen this right before the pandemic because I feel like this this would have gotten me through some hard times. But regardless of when I saw it and when other people see it like I will never forget this show.

And I don't think I say that very frequently like I will viscerally remember my experience of this show forever. It makes me think about you know the original storytelling was around campfires. We we didn't have all this meta of incredible technology. We just had ourselves our bodies in the place and that very much so took us back to that simplicity and that awareness that you are enough that we are enough to get through anything together.

[11:30] Christian Lewis: I think about what could have been done differently with it. I wonder could you imagine this in a larger space or do you think that it only works within the intimacy the confines? Yeah, I thought about that when someone said I need a cast recording it's not going to feel the same. There's no way that you're going to have that experience of I don't care how good your sound system is you need those people around you you need um the company of your seat neighbor around you you need that audience engagement because it's not it won't be the same experience and so it needs to be in a small space. I'm sure because this show has gotten rave reviews from literally everyone that there's going to be that producer who says, let's do it bigger.

And they have to uh a producer has to be really smart and say that we need to make sure that this stays small, maybe extend it for where it is because it's it's just that damn good. But I I I don't think it will have the same impact or give the audience the same experience if it was in a bigger, larger capacity.

[12:38] Juan Michael Porter II: Hot take, but I actually totally disagree. I want to see this play in a huge marble Catholic church. I want it to like echo through a like religious space, and I want them to like be using a church that has a very specific uh set design dramaturgy, not to sound sacrilegious, but a very way that that's the space is supposed to be used, and I want to see it done in a very different way. Part of my obsession with this piece is that I actually can imagine so many different ways to do this play, this piece. I could actually even imagine this piece being done as like text without music. I can imagine it in different spaces, larger casts, smaller casts. Like I d I think this is such a flexible document.

I already emailed it to some of my drama performance studies, performance art professors from college, and was like, do something with this with your students because like this is just a very cool piece, and I think it is actually pretty malleable, and I would like to see it in other kind of spaces, but I I don't think I ever need to see it in a proscenium stage.

[13:43] Ayanna Prescod: I certainly agree with you there. This is not like a put it on Broadway at the booth kind of show. Sounds specific. And you know, thinking about that, uh I felt similarly about Hadestown, which I saw many times at New York Theater Workshop. I I just couldn't imagine it um anywhere else. And to see what they did with it, while very different, was in equally moving. I I can sort of, when you say that, Christian, think about it perhaps uh um St. John, the Divine Um Cathedral, a space like that. Um, because I heard Mahler's A Thousand Voice Choir there, and that was it had that exact effect you're talking about, the echoing. But I do sort of, I am always going to cherish, and I think that I'm curious about it happening, but I don't know that I would want to watch it happen because I'm now attached to what this was in that moment. If that I don't know if that sounds weird or not.

[14:35] Juan Michael Porter II: That makes sense. Who would you suggest this show to? I I know that we're saying everyone, and I'm of the opinion that if you don't like the show, you might be a bad person. No, um, if you were to say, like, who is this show for? I I think it's I literally think this show is for everyone. And just for from my perspective, I am spiritual but not church going. I was raised in the church. Um, and then obviously you guys know that my mother is like always my plus one. So she she's like a pastor on certain days, like she's she she gets it. So we're two different people, and we both enjoyed it. Um, and then the woman next to me who said she's never walked into a church herself. And so I think I think everyone will get it. It's just an experience that you have to have, and you just have to go and experience it. I I I couldn't pinpoint a single person, but I think it can be for everyone.

[15:32] Christian Lewis: I'd say, like, I I'm slightly wary. I'm like an experimental theater practitioner by training, and I know that it's very much not for everyone, and there are a lot of people who like will enter an experimental performance and be like turned off just at the very start, and they're not gonna like take it in.

[15:47] Ayanna Prescod: Really?

[15:48] Christian Lewis: But yeah, trust me, plus ones I've brought to things. People who have come to see shows that I've been are like, Christian, what what was this? Uh and so like I get that, but I think this show can and should be for everyone. I just need Aris Novata to hire me, and I will stand outside as everyone walks in, and I will give them a little like one-minute spiel about like this is not for you to understand. This is for you to just experience and just take it in, and you will love it. Just like let it happen. You have to take it in, you have to accept that this is a thing that's happening and that this is for you.

[16:20] Ayanna Prescod: Oh, actually, I I want to piggyback on that because the day I saw it was the day that you told me we saw each other at Glasshouse, and you gave me that same synopsis. You said, Ayana, just go and experience it. It's not for you to understand. And I swear I walked into that theater with that in my head. And so I I'm pushing for you to do that. Because I get that some audience members could see this and get frustrated when the show starts and there's a chorus of 12 singing counterpoint in Latin, and they're like, you know what? Nope. But like, if you just if everyone just had a slight little preamble of like best practice to enjoy the show, I think it's for everyone in that sense. You know, I can imagine um, because I do my own hyping up when I produce concerts and I say to people, like, you may not get the movement, but you're gonna love the music.

Um, and some people come to me afterwards, like, yeah, I didn't get it, but I love the music. And these are footballers. I think that if they heard that, they would feel safe and they wouldn't feel as if they are somehow not getting it, and understand it's not to be received in a specific way, it's just to be experienced.

[17:25] Juan Michael Porter II: Well, I feel like that tells us everything we need to know about this show. And like, and like if you have an extra ticket and you want to sell it to me, I will gladly buy it for any amount of money. I am that person. This is how good that show is. And John, if you're listening, really. Thank you for this amazing conversation. For our wonderful listeners at home, I'm Juan Michael Porter II.

[17:49] Christian Lewis: I'm Christian Lewis, and I'm Ayanna Prescod.

[17:52] Juan Michael Porter II: And be sure to follow us on Broadway Podcast Network. Thanks for joining us on this episode of the Critics Table Podcast. We would like to thank Jose Solis and the BIPOC Critics Lab team who has generously partnered with us on this project. Also be sure to subscribe to this podcast so that you never miss a review and learn more about our critics at bpn.fm slash critics table. The views or opinions expressed by the critics in this episode are solely their own and do not necessarily represent views or opinions of the Broadway Podcast Network. See you next time.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred