Destination Freedom Presents BLACK with a Capital B. by Lamaria Aminah. After one more young black man dies at the hands of police, a community is shaken. A conversation evolves between two mothers at the vigil – one white and one black... Read More
From the show: Destination Freedom Black Radio Days
About
Destination Freedom Presents BLACK with a Capital B. by Lamaria Aminah. After one more young black man dies at the hands of police, a community is shaken. A conversation evolves between two mothers at the vigil – one white and one black. The cast includes Such as Black, Devra Keyes as white, Kerrie KJ Joy, and Andrew J. Betts. Listen to a community discussion led by donnie l. betts and musical guest Monique Brooks Roberts.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Danielle Betts: Welcome to episode one of Destination Freedom Black Radio Days Podcast.
[0:04] Danielle Betts: I'm your host and director Danielle Betts. Destination Freedom is the radio series recorded live in front of a studio audience, which is then followed by the community discussion about the subject of the play.
[0:16] Danielle Betts: Equality. All we are asking for is equality. We are asking for black to stop being a death sentence. We are asking for you to let our children be free. As we gather here tonight, reflecting on a little boy whose life was taken because of the color of his skin. I want you to remember what it means to be black.
[0:38] Danielle Betts: Destination Freedom is an audio journey through the black experience in America and other unheard voices. Destination Freedom came to be in 1948 and ended in 1950. All the shows were written by Radio Hall of Fame writer Richard Durham. Now I revived this show in 1998, and I have been producing the series ever since.
[0:58] Danielle Betts: When first produced, the series walked the daring line between reform and revolution, and was shut down by its network in 1950 because of its pro-black stance and McCarthyism tightened its grip on American broadcasting. This season, join us as we will examine the intersection of law enforcement and communities of color, exploring police shootings, immigration, and gender bias.
[1:33] Danielle Betts: Black, written by Lamaria Aminah, kind of describes it this way. A conversation evolves between two mothers at the vigil, one white and one black. Through this interaction, Black gets to the heart of the matter on communication between races. We also will hear from Samaria Rice, the mother of Tamir Rice. Tamir Rice at 12 years old was shot and killed by police in Cleveland as he played in a park near his home.
[2:04] Danielle Betts: The cast features performers such as Black, Devra Keyes as White, Kerrie KJ Joy as theme performer on violin, Monique Brooks Roberts, and Andrew J. Betts as the kid. Join us after the performance for a robust community conversation about our subject with law enforcement and community activists.
[2:29] ♪ Musical number: "Oh, Freedom" — performed by Monique Brooks Roberts ♪
[4:26] Andrew J. Betts: Nine one one operator.
[4:29] Andrew J. Betts: Yes, there is a black man with a gun walking throughout the neighborhood. Send someone quick. Please describe him.
[4:37] Andrew J. Betts: He's black with a gun. What's your name and location? Help is on the way. Yes, I'm at... I'm still standing.
[4:58] Andrew J. Betts: Drop the gun. Wait, what? Why? What did I do? Help me. Help me.
[5:16] Andrew J. Betts: Damn, Greg. It's a kid. And it's a baseball bat. Damn. Damn. Damn.
[5:26] Andrew J. Betts: A little later that day. Hello. Are you Miss Black? There was another police-involved shooting today. A twelve-year-old black child was shot and killed on his way home from baseball practice. There will be a candlelight vigil and a rally at the ballpark tonight.
[5:50] Danielle Betts: Setting. A candlelight vigil at an open park for another black life taken by the police. Names of victims of police brutality are being spoken in the air between characters. Characters, Black with a capital B, White, privilege. White is crying hysterically on a bench next to vigil as Black watches her from afar while waiting for her turn on the microphone.
[6:16] Danielle Betts: After moments of watching, Black walks over to White and sits down beside her. She then points to someone in the crowd.
[6:25] Black: We are gathered here today, this evening, to honor young Kyrie. Would you read what's on your card?
[6:37] White: Oscar Grant.
[6:39] Black: And your card?
[6:41] White: Sandra Bland.
[6:43] Black: Your card.
[6:45] White: Tamir Rice.
[6:47] Black: And your card?
[6:48] White: Trayvon Martin.
[6:53] Black: Whose streets?
[6:55] Crowd: Our streets.
[6:56] Black: Whose streets?
[6:58] Crowd: Our streets.
[6:59] Black: No justice, no peace.
[7:01] Crowd: No justice, no peace.
[7:04] Black: He was only a boy.
[7:06] Crowd: He was only a boy.
[7:13] Black: Now your daughter was with Tamir when he was in the park, and when she reacted, she was thrown to the ground by the police officers. Can you talk about your daughter and how she's doing now and what that impact had upon her then and now?
[7:26] White: Her name is Ta Jay. So the two officers then Ta Jay. Tajay was tackled because she did not witness the shooting, but she was tackled trying to get to her brother, so that's how she ended up being tackled, running out the door, running across the grass to be tackled by two grown men and placed in handcuffs and basically forced to watch her brother die.
[7:58] White: Today, Tai Jay is 19 years old, and Tajay is still having difficulty times with the death of her brother, but just also growing up, still have to see that black and brown people are still being shot down with no justice. I mean, kids see social media all the time and things like that. So, you know, she did graduate by the grace of God. All my kids graduated by the grace of God, you know, because I pushed them, of course. But um, so she has her days, you know, she has her days. Could she be doing better? Could all my kids be doing better? Yes.
[8:42] Black: Crying releases pain. Let it all out.
[8:44] White: (looks up with a puddle of tears in her eyes) When your tears run dry, know that you have only released your pain, and that's it. Crying is no longer enough.
[9:02] Black: (sits and waits) That's right. That's right. Let it all out. Clean up your face. You look a mess.
[9:16] White: How are you not crying right now?
[9:18] Black: I have cried my entire existence. My well dried long ago.
[9:21] White: I just don't understand. How could he do this? How could he just shoot like that?
[9:29] Black: I don't know. All I know is that you're here. That says something about you.
[9:35] White: I can't believe he did this. Why are you here?
[9:40] Black: Because I know what is happening is so wrong.
[9:48] White: A child. He was just a child. He killed someone's child.
[9:57] Black: Do you want to understand?
[9:59] White: Yes, of course I do.
[10:02] Black: I don't have much time, but if you truly want to understand, I can help you with that, but only under one condition.
[10:09] White: Okay, what's the condition?
[10:11] Black: You have to promise that you will not make anything about you, no matter what I say. Can you do that?
[10:18] White: I don't think I understand what you mean.
[10:21] Black: If you truly want to understand, it is imperative that you listen with an open heart, mind, soul, and body. In order to do this, you must acknowledge your white privilege and make the decision to be selfless or selfish. Only you can make that choice.
[10:38] White: Okay. I can do that.
[10:40] Black: What you're about to hear is painfully honest. It's honest because it's my truth. You can't defend yourself when you don't agree because there's nothing to agree with. This is my truth. You can't justify or correct anything that I say. My truth can't be corrected. You must simply listen. Listen to my truth for what it is. I'm not asking for your opinion on my truth. My truth is my truth, and no one can tell me otherwise. Do you understand?
[11:14] White: I understand. If I have questions, can I ask them?
[11:19] Black: Yes, please. Ask questions when you need clarification, but please think before you speak.
[11:26] White: Okay. Sounds easy enough.
[11:30] Black: Easy is anything but easy.
[11:33] White: How long?
[11:34] Black: How long? In order to understand your place in all of this turmoil, you gotta put yourself in my shoes.
[11:43] White: But how do I do that?
[11:46] Black: Listen. Please open the book to the first page and read the first line.
[11:53] White: Black with a capital B. Definition, one extreme end of the scale of grays opposite to white.
[12:02] Black: We are opposites. The flesh on our bodies are opposite shades, yes. We are not opposites. We are both very much human.
[12:13] White: Why does it say black needs a capital B? Colors don't need to be capitalized.
[12:19] Black: Please, just remember our condition. Don't correct my truth. Only ask questions for clarification.
[12:27] Black: Black is not a color. Black is the absence of color. Black is light.
[12:32] White: Sorry.
[12:35] Black: Don't be sorry. I simply ask that you speak with intention. Before you speak, listen. Understand the root of your question. Before you ask a question, ask yourself if you'd like to be asked the same thing. You may be surprised how many times you may think again.
[12:54] Black: Let me explain. Black needs a capital B because black is an identity. Black is a name. Black is the name that comes before any other adjective used to describe me. I am black before all else. Please understand this isn't my choice though, but what has been placed upon me?
[13:13] White: How is it not the same for whites as well?
[13:17] Black: Please remember our condition. I guess I could rephrase that.
[13:25] Black: Can you explain how it differs between white and black?
[13:31] White: Please.
[13:32] Black: There you go.
[13:33] White: That's it.
[13:35] Black: Think before you speak. The difference is that white is seen as the norm. The norm doesn't need to be described with specifics because it's the norm, the standard, and everyone knows the standard. In this world, anything outside of normal must be identified accordingly.
[13:53] White: Okay, I think I understand what you're saying.
[13:57] Black: Do you see that lady over there?
[13:59] White: Yes, the woman carrying the baby.
[14:03] Black: What about her? And do you see that lady over there?
[14:07] White: Are you pointing to the black woman wearing a sundress?
[14:12] Black: A woman carrying a baby, a black woman wearing a sundress, a woman, a black woman. Do you know why you didn't use white to describe the woman holding her baby?
[14:27] White: Well, uh I just Please remember our condition. Acknowledge your privilege. Then decide whether to continue using it for yourself or for others who will never receive such a gift.
[14:53] Black: How does it feel for you to say that?
[14:56] White: It feels like I'm admitting defeat.
[14:59] Black: If there is no superiority and inferiority, if all lives truly did matter, one would not have to admit defeat.
[15:07] White: But condition.
[15:10] Black: Turn to the next page and read out loud, please.
[15:14] White: Black lives matter.
[15:16] Black: Do you believe that?
[15:18] White: Well, of course I do, but remember our condition.
[15:21] Black: Using "but" invalidates everything that comes before it. So let me ask you again. Do you believe black lives matter?
[15:29] White: I believe that all lives matter.
[15:31] Black: That's not the question.
[15:32] White: Including black lives.
[15:34] Black: That's not the question I asked you. Do you believe black lives matter?
[15:40] White: Yes, I do.
[15:41] Black: Then say it loud and proud so everyone can hear.
[15:44] White: Black Lives Matter.
[15:46] Black: Again.
[15:47] White: Please.
[15:48] Black: Is that really necessary?
[15:50] White: Maybe, just maybe if we say it enough times, people will begin to listen.
[15:54] Black: So please, again.
[15:56] White: Black lives matter.
[15:57] Black: One more time, please.
[15:59] White: Black lives matter.
[16:02] Black: What does that mean?
[16:04] White: Is this a trick question?
[16:07] Black: No, it's not. It means exactly what it says that black lives matter. In the statement Black Lives Matter, does it say anything about other lives not mattering?
[16:19] White: Well, no, it doesn't say that, but it implies it.
[16:22] Black: Implies it? How so?
[16:25] White: Saying black lives matter is not an inclusive statement.
[16:29] Black: It creates division and it leaves people out.
[16:32] White: What people are left out?
[16:34] Black: Well, you know.
[16:35] White: White people?
[16:37] Black: All people, I think.
[16:39] White: You think.
[16:43] Black: I saw something on Facebook the other day that really hit the nail on the head for me, and I'd like to share it with you.
[16:49] White: Okay.
[16:51] Black: The post read no one goes to a breast cancer awareness walk and says lung cancer matters too. Everyone knows that the awareness walk is simply focused on breast cancer, and that on any other day, there are other walks for other kinds of cancers, including lung cancer.
[17:08] White: Do you agree with that?
[17:09] Black: Well, yes, of course. It wouldn't make sense to combine two cancer awareness walks together.
[17:14] White: Is a breast cancer awareness walk inclusive to all cancers?
[17:17] Black: No, the purpose is to specialize and focus on breast cancer.
[17:22] White: And you're okay with that?
[17:24] Black: Well, yes, of course. Why wouldn't I be?
[17:27] White: Do you think it's fair to say that the purpose of Black Lives Matter is to specialize and focus in on black lives?
[17:33] Black: You said so yourself, that things don't have to be all inclusive.
[17:37] White: Well, yes, but Condition.
[17:41] Black: Black Lives Matter is saying something so simple. Black lives matter. That's all. If you're saying all lives matter or blue lives matter, you're saying black lives do not matter.
[17:56] White: Black lives matter is not an anti-police or anti-white movement. Black lives matter is simply demanding that our black sons and our black daughters need to be treated as human beings and nothing less than. Black Lives Matter is asking for acceptance and equality. Nothing more, nothing less.
[18:16] Black: Let's bring up our next speaker, Black. Show us some love, y'all.
[18:27] Black: Equality. All we are asking for is equality. We are asking for black to stop being a death sentence. We are asking for you to let our children be free. As we gather here tonight, reflecting on a little boy whose life was taken because of the color of his skin. I want you to remember what it means to be black. I want to remember both the glory and the pain that comes with this skin.
[18:59] Black: Say it with me. Black.
[19:02] Crowd: One more time. Black.
[19:04] Black: What a beautifully weighted word. So complex. So divine. So rich. Tonight, let us remember with voices across our nation what being black is. Black is.
[19:24] Black: Black is rich. Rich in depth and creativity and stamina and integrity. Black is the pain of difference and the beauty of culture, the freedom to be. Black is knowing innocent until proven guilty does not apply to melanin rich skin. Black is an inspiring beauty, mocked but imitated by all. Black is fearing your little brother will be shot in the street because his Mickey Mouse snapback says, shoot me, I'm guilty. Black is being labeled a thug no matter where you come from. Black is coming from a lineage of kings and queens. Black is modern day slavery, maths, incarcerations, the new Jim Crow. Black is deep, the core of the universe through which all things were created. Black is burning your child's scalp and telling her her pain is equivalent to her beauty.
Black is taking back your crown and glory, allowing your tresses to be wild and free. Black is inherent strength, ultimate resilience. Black is the mother who does everything on her own for the destruction of our families has never been repaired. Black is light skin, dark skin, forced internal division. Black is knowing my death will be celebrated, mocked, and ignored. Black is so intense, our presence alone forces the privileged out of their comfort zones. A trending topic.
[21:01] Black: She asked me why I was here. How could I not be? Broken hearted spouse of a policeman who's come to realize that the man she loves and adores is the bad guy on the news. A killer cop. Father of my children. My life partner. My best friend. A killer cop. I have watched that video over and over again, trying to understand, trying to justify continuing to support this man. He's an amazing father to our kids. He loves children. But what if this was our boy? I keep asking him why he pulled the trigger. He says he was afraid. It was an accident. How could he be afraid of a twelve-year-old child carrying a baseball bat? How could his death be an accident? He was just a little boy with a bat. He killed a child because he was holding a baseball bat.
Our son plays baseball. But our son isn't black. When he killed my child, he killed my dreams. My boy. My sweet baby boy. We were just starting to plan his thirteenth birthday party. He was so excited to be a teenager, finally. My boy. From the age that he could understand me, I've always told him to be respectful and quiet in the streets. I told him that when police stopped to search you on your way home, kick the anger aside and comply. I told my baby that he must comply. That he must lay his ego to rest so that I, his mother, would never have to. I told him not to be afraid. That mommy would always be here waiting for him to come home. My baby boy, my sweet baby boy. He didn't come home this time.
He didn't come home. I was waiting for him. I wonder if he was waiting for me. As he bled out on the street, I wonder if he knew he was lying beside his killer's feet. When my boy took his final breath, I wonder if he knew that his life mattered. That despite what the world thinks, he was worthy. A week ago today, my son was taken from me by the hands of police brutality. A little black boy with a baseball bat. Guilty. Being black meant that he didn't just finish baseball practice. Being black meant that he was a threat. Guilty. My 12-year old innocent little boy. They labeled him guilty. Guilty. A charge they will never even see.
[24:44] Black: I don't know what my son was waiting for the day he was killed by the police. But I'm done waiting. When he killed my child, he killed my dreams. And I refuse to wait for another mother's dreams to bleed out of holes staining the street. I am so sorry. I don't blame you for your privilege. I know you didn't ask for it just as I didn't ask to not receive it. It's simply the card we were each given. We have no say in that. I know that.
[25:17] Black: To all of you, I do blame you if you continue to choose to live in the dark. White is not equivalent to oppressor if one doesn't want it to be. For there are only three options for you to be my accomplice, my ally, or my enemy. You've acknowledged your privilege, and that's the first step, so I thank you for that. My hope is that whenever you speak, you will always remember our condition.
[26:33] Black: So let us remember. Michael Brown, Michael Brown, Philando Castile, Philando Castile, Alton Sterling, Alton Sterling, Amadou Diallo, Amadou Diallo, Freddie Gray, Freddie Gray, Eric Garner, Eric Garner, John Crawford, John Crawford, Walter Scott, Walter Scott, Deborah Danner, Deborah Danner, Terrence Crutcher, Terrence Crutcher, Laquan McDonald, Laquan McDonald, Charlena Lyles, Charlena Lyles, Jordan Edwards, Jordan Edwards, Rakia Boyd, Rakia Boyd, Ayana Jones, Ayana Jones, Jamel Roberson, Jamel Roberson, Beverly Grant, Beverly Grant, this episode of Destination Freedom was presented by the Robert and Judy Newman Center for the Performing Arts at the University of Denver.
[27:54] The cast for Black with a Capital B included Such as Black.
[27:58] Devra Keyes: Various Voices as White.
[28:04] Monique Brooks Roberts: Music and theme by Monique Brooks Roberts.
[28:07] Ida Gabriel: Foley is Ida Gabriel.
[28:09] Damien Hoover: Our stage manager is Damien Hoover.
[28:12] Dave Aston: And engineer is Dave Aston.
[28:14] Donnie L. Betts: Our producer and director is Donnie Betts.
[28:17] Donnie L. Betts: And now joining Destination Freedom, our playwright Lamaria Aminah, Aurora Police Chief Nick Metz, our Royal Council Member Angela Lawson, Professor Dr. Deborah Ortiz, Denver Police Division Chief Ron Thomas, and Rashawn Blitz, student organizer for Project Voice.
[28:34] Donnie L. Betts: And later, musical guest, Monique.
[28:38] Donnie L. Betts: So I want to start with it, LaMaria, to talk about what was the genesis for bringing this play to us in the first place.
[28:48] Lamaria Aminah: Good evening, everyone. My name is Lamaria Aminah, and I'm the playwright. I wrote this play when I was 20 years old. It was my first play, and I wrote it through the Curious New Voices program at Curious Theater. It was the summer Philando Castile and Alton Sterling were both murdered. And Trump was entering our office and Obama was leaving. And there was just a lot happening in our world. And I was trying to make sense of it all in the best way that I knew how, and that was writing. And so that's how I just poured my heart and pain and you know, my ancestors' pain, my family's pain, all into this play. Thank you so much.
[29:37] Donnie L. Betts: So first let's talk with the impressions that our panel had of the play. Coming in, not really knowing a lot about it, maybe just a little bit of blurbs that I sent you, just anyone can comment. Don't be afraid.
[29:51] Angela Lawson: Well, I'll go ahead and comment. It was very powerful. For me being in a city council, one of the things that the community and the kids that when I do outreach to kids in our community is what are you doing as the leadership? You know, we are we really getting out there and addressing this issue? You know, just me being an African American woman, I have to, I've been told this. When I get pulled over by an officer, keep your hands on the wheel, don't reach. Angela, don't wear a hoodie. A lot of people look at my skin color and they say, well, you have some advantages. No, I'm still a black woman, and I still have to face some of the things that were mentioned in this play when we're looking at race.
When we're looking at our kids, there is some fear in the community. But they asked me when I go out in there, what are you doing, Councilmember Lawson? What are you doing to make a difference and to address our concerns? We work with our police officers, our police chief will expand more, but they're really talking about the leadership in the community. And I don't think, and I'm talking for myself, that we get out there enough to address this issue. And this what this brought to me is more about what I as an individual council member need to do to address these issues of violence in our community, kids in our community, and addressing our police departments and how we're actually relating with each other in the community with kids and with our public.
So that's kind of what it brought home to me. It was very powerful to see the differences. Because I am an African American woman, I do see where there is definitely differences in how people are perceived, even at the leadership position. Some of the things I've faced on this in my community, it's not good, but you have to stand strong and make sure that you fight for these things and stand that we do matter. So thank you.
[32:07] Nick Metz: Good evening. I'm Nick Metz, and I'm the police chief for Aurora. I know I don't really look at it like it right now. I apologize for that. I thought the play was incredibly profound from the standpoint of I've been in law enforcement now for 35 years. My first 31 years was with the Seattle Police Department. And while with the Seattle Police Department, certainly was involved in a number of situations where there were controversial police actions. When I came to Aurora, I came to Aurora in March of 2015, excuse me. And the second day on my job, we had a controversial police shooting. And this was right in the middle of Ferguson, it was right in the middle of Baltimore, it was right in the middle of Cleveland.
And I think what was pretty profound for me as I heard the names that were being mentioned earlier, and then at the end of the play was that I think at least probably 95% of the names that were mentioned, I knew exactly which city they occurred in. You know, in law enforcement, and I know the same holds true with Denver PD, we can never rest on our laurels. We can never say that we have the best policies and we have the best procedures. We're constantly working towards making sure that our training is as best as it can be, our equipment is as best as it can be, that we are screening our officers and new officers as best that we can, but we can never get to a point where we say we've got it down.
Because if we do that, then we realize you know what, we don't. And so we have to constantly be willing to really take critical looks at ourselves. And part of taking that critical look is making sure that we have folks in our community whether it's residents, whether it's lawmakers, whether it's teachers, whether it's young people who we are willing to actually sit down with and have the difficult conversations. I can tell you that a number of the policies and procedures and the trainings and the bias-free training and things like that that we've conducted, a lot of that has come from what the community has stressed as being important. And that really comes down to us being willing to listen and being willing to really again take a critical look at ourselves and being willing to say these are our shortcomings and we have to come and we have to improve on that.
And so I guess where I'm my message to this is that I come to a lot of meetings and events like this where people come, they share their frustrations and then they leave and then we never hear from them again until the next crisis. And it's really important because I can I know for sure it happens in Denver. I can assure you it happens in Aurora, that we want to hear from our community, that we provide avenues to hear from our community, that we're not afraid to have the difficult discussions. We invite them. And because we as law enforcement want to be better. We want to serve our communities better. We want to reflect the makeup of our communities. And to do that, it requires the community to be part of that change. Thank you.
[35:39] Rashawn Blitz: Thank you. My name's Rashawn Blitz. I'm one of the co-founders of a group called the Denver Justice Project. That really arose out of the Black Lives Matter movement and the community's kind of frustration, anger, pain around police violence. And my reaction, I mean, obviously, it was a really deeply powerful play. And I felt a lot of things. I think one, I appreciated the condition that kept coming back up. That we agree not to make that the black woman and the white woman speaking agreed not to make the conversation about the white woman. And I think one of my strongest reactions was that I found myself wishing that collectively we as a community, as a society, could have a conversation about police where the police would agree to that condition too.
I happen to know both the police officers here. I think they're very good men and I respect them. And I think that there's a deeper conversation to be had about the institution of policing in the same way that that play was helping show that there's a deeper conversation to be had about the institution of whiteness. And I think that it hurts to be able to, in the same way that the frustration of the constant interrupting and the constant having to correct and come back to remember our condition, remember the condition happens with black-white conversations. I think that it happens with cop non-cop conversations too. And I think that a real deep examination of the institution of policing and its history, its evolution here in our country will take us to some difficult to discuss places.
It was a slave patrol. And that was, you know, 30 years before the what's often credited as the first police force in London, the Bobbies, quote unquote. And I think that that's that was one of my strongest reactions that we I think we should have a conversation about the facts of that history with that condition that we not make this about, you know, attacking individual police officers or family members who we know who are in the service, but that we could have a conversation about the institution itself, what it means, what it grew out of, and then we could start to see some of the continuity and understand some of the patterns over history and why these things keep happening, and that that might help us have these conversations about the individual incidents that happen in our communities take a different shape.
[38:48] Nick Metz: You know, if I could just quickly add to Rashawn's comments, you know, we certainly do have those deeper conversations. And I think, you know, thankfully, I think the Aurora Police Department, the Denver Police Department, we're now willing to have those discussions. I think we realize that it's necessary. I think we both realize that it's a long time coming. We've got a lot of work to do to regain and earn that trust of the community, particularly the black community. One of the things that resonated the most with me in this piece was just kind of the eloquent descriptions of privilege and explaining the whole, you know, black lives matter. I think that you know when those things are said, white privilege and you know, and black lives matter, I think people tend to bristle at that.
You know, like I have no privilege. But you know, it clearly it's there. I think it was very eloquently explained and detailed in the piece. And you know, just my own experience, you know, I'm not sure I've ever been described by people on my own force as just the chief. You know, I think I'm well recognized as the black police chief.
[40:17] Deborah Ortega: So, first of all, I this is Dr. Deborah Ortega. I'm a faculty member at the Graduate School of Social Work, and I am actually predominantly responsible for a class that all of our students take called Power, Privilege, and Oppression. And I just would really like to thank the playwright one more time. That was amazing. You did in a half an hour what it takes me 10 weeks to do. I should turn in my little professor cap or something. There are a lot of I had actually some physical reactions. So in the part where there's the protests and it's the call and response for the protest, I actually had chills come up the back of my legs. Um because I've been there, right? I have been in those protests around the ways that people are dehumanized because of the color of their skin, or because of their gender orientation, or because of their sexual orientation, or because of all of the above all at once.
So that was really powerful for me. It really set me in that moment. I still think I might need the rest of the 10 weeks to explain to my students. I'm here at the University of Denver, it's a predominantly white university. I still would need 10 weeks to explain often to our master level white students why and how white gets centered, maybe in this moment in this play, but all the ways that white takes up space. And um, and conversely, how when you're white, I often we use the Ferguson report in the class. If you've never read the Ferguson report and you're here, you should. It's an amazing report. And one by the Department of Justice of many that they've done. Um, one of the things I'm really clear about is that when white people benefit from the color of their skin, they don't always know because they're one person among white people.
So in Ferguson, their cases were dismissed dismissed, some 60%, something like that, more right than white people. But it wasn't like the white people whose cases were being dismissed were aware that they were a part of this large group or that black people weren't experiencing it because they didn't have to, because they didn't live in communities together, because they didn't communicate together, because they didn't do the dialogue that was so beautiful, right, in this play. So I just want to say I I have a lot to say about this topic in general, but in terms of a reaction, this was so beautifully done. Um I hope someday that I teach as well as she did this play, you know, when she was what, 20.
So thank you very much. I I would really like to use this actually in our class, in our classes, because I think it so eloquently talks about the dynamics, right, between being afraid of losing power, being afraid to recognize your power, and being afraid to recognize the everyday pain and danger people are in because of the color of their skin. Thank you so much.
[43:56] Harry Clinton: Hi, I'm Harry Clinton. I'm a division chief of the Aurora Police Department. Let's get a little closer to it. I think the play was a perfect example about how we have to talk to each other without defending our position. That listening is actually a skill. And in order to improve our relationship with our community, we actually have to sit and listen to our community, not to defend our position, not defend or juxtapose our position with some other position, but to simply listen to the information that's being given, listen to the pain that's there. That's not easy to accept sometimes. It's a difficult thing to sit and listen to, especially when you are the object of white privilege. When you're being identified as the enemy of whatever's going on.
And too bad. Through many of these kind of conversations, policing has evolved. Certainly in Aurora it's evolved. We don't do things that today that we did when I got on 35 years ago. And quite frankly, we're happy about that. I would hate to go back to doing the things that we did 35 years ago. They were stupid. So I think that that powerful dynamic in the play was was important to listen the requirement to listen without defending. Thank you so much.
[45:23] Harry Clinton: And I wanted to say I appreciated the comments of Rashan and Chief Metz, because um one of the things that they both brought up in different ways is the fact that uh the crisis is there, you react to it, you demonstrate, you protest, or whatever the case may be, and then you do disappear. So that's on us as a community. So one of my questions uh to everyone, and I've been working with um for the last year or so with the Aurora Police, and just Wednesday I spent the whole day at the academy to see what the cadets were going through and just to watch their faces and all these young kids and you know, they are scared, you know, they want to be good citizens and and serve you as the public, but they have issues about how to do that too, just from from watching them and and talking to the trainers there and everything.
But the trainers are opening and open to people from the community like myself and mental health workers and people like that to talk about them how we can make this better. So we in just a few minutes, I want to open it up to the audience, but first before I do that, um I want to make sure that I get any comments from the cast that want to uh to offer anything like that. Today we had a powerful this morning we had a uh performance for um high schoolers, and that was profound. Um many of them were really impacted by that, you know. And the first question I always asked is who in here by the show of hand has been impacted by violence, police violence, um, you know, domestic violence, or whatever the case may be.
That a hand is not raised. It's usually 10, 15 people that raise their hands. So this impacts us all. What's important about this, I wanted to start the play with comments Samaria Rice, who's the mother of Tamaria Rice, when you heard that clip, that's who that was. I wanted to talk about what happens after. We know what happens in the front when the CNN or whatever is out there covering it, but when they'll leave, what happens? As he said, my life has never been a chain, never been the same since I heard the knock on the door. I was thrown into this. I didn't ask for it. I was thrown into this. It's the same when an officer responds to a call and something goes awry. They didn't ask for it.
They were thrown into it. So just at me as a citizen, I have a much more greater appreciation for what the men and women of the police force go through. So we have to have that serious conversation, as you said. The conversation happens on both sides. You know, it can't be a monologue, it has to be a conversation that happens. So if anyone from the cast would like to make a quick comment, we'll go with that before we go to the uh for the audience for just for a couple questions. Anyone?
[48:17] Such: Okay. I know such you had so many things to say today. You want to come out here so we don't get any feedback? Uh so I'm such. I played black. Um this play was very touching for me because I have an eight-year-old black son, and I have, you know, a husband who was black, and um Philando Castillo, I remember watching that Facebook Live uh video and just feeling like my heart was being like just wrenched out of my chest because it just felt so it felt so personal. I was like, oh, that could be me. And I I think for me, I I try to navigate what does it look like as my son grows up? Like what kind of world is he going to live in? And right now he's eight, but at some point he's gonna be 12, he's gonna be 14, and he's going to look big, and he's gonna be a big black man at some point.
And but when he's 12 and 14, he's gonna be possibly a threat. And without the you know, the the maturation of being able to know, you know, walk into a room and look a little bit, you know, smile or whatever else. He might be, you know, going through whatever teenagers go through and just look mean, and and who knows what that looks like. So I feel like for me, I go through this thing of I don't want to take away the essence of who he is, but I also don't want him to die. And and that's something that I'm thinking of for my eight-year-old right now. Um, I think it's it's such an important conversation to have. Um, another thing that I was thinking of, honestly, and and this this is just thinking about how I feel about the police.
I realize that they're not the people that I would call if anything really went down, and that's really scary for me because I feel like I should be able to call the police. So, for example, my neighbor the other day, she had somebody come and bang on her door, and she was terrified, and so she called the police, and then you know, she called me and she's white. And I thought, would that have been like my first choice? Would I have called 911 if I was afraid of my house? And the reality is that I wouldn't have. And I don't want that to be the case. I want to be able to have these conversations. I want to be able to feel like I can because I know that they're here to serve and protect us. So I'd like to be able to feel that. So yeah.
[50:45] Deborah Keyes: Hi, I'm Deborah. I played white. Um, and we talked about this earlier today, but uh a lot of this affected me deeply coming from a white perspective. Of course, when I hear about all the tragedies that happen in the in the shootings, it's it's horrifying and it's devastating, but I can never put myself in the place of a black person and feel that fear because that is not my experience. And I think there are a lot of white people who are well intentioned. That line that you included with, well, I think all lives matter, we don't always realize how that diminishes and just makes that whole black condition minimized. And it's it's with good intention, and yet it is one of the most horrible things that we can do is to say, Oh, all lives matter. And being in this play, that opened my mind to that, and I I realized I was guilty of that thought, and it's really changed my thinking quite a bit. So thank you for that.
[52:00] Deborah Keyes: I I wanted to make a uh just a brief comment to uh something that such said in talking about uh being a black woman with uh with a black son. Um about three years ago I met with a group of of black women, I was about eight or nine, um, at at a salon. Um all of them had uh black sons. And when we met, the discussion came up with the fact that they lived, and we talk about the condition. And I and the condition is that for many, particularly black women with black sons, there's a double-edged sword. They live with a double-edged sword. When they're, particularly with a teenage son, when their teenage son goes out on a Friday or Saturday night, they're worried about two things. Either their son is going to be shot and killed by police, or their son is going to be shot and killed by someone else, a gang member or someone out there just being stupid.
Sadly, one of the women in that group, her son was killed in a drive-by shooting. I believe it was in Denver. I say this not in any way, shape, or form to diminish or minimize the topic that we're talking about here when we're talking about police violence. But the reality is in many ways is that we are picking up bodies of young black men every single day. In Aurora, just the last three weeks, we've had three young men whose lives have been taken away. Just the other day, a 16-year-old male lured another 16-year-old male, shot him in the head.
[53:41] Andrew J. Betts: A week and a half ago at the Aurora Mall, another young man was shot and killed. And again, not diminishing the other side of this, this what we're talking about, but it goes to the condition. And it goes to the issue of the violence that we are dealing with on our streets. And in many, and in many cases, we're seeing the funerals in our city. And unfortunately, when a young man, a young black man, is killed by gang violence or youth violence or whatever it is, the sad part of this is that when I call a community member and say, you know, our community leaders and tell them we just had a homicide and this is what's going on, the typical response is, gosh, that's really sad, thanks for letting me know.
The typical response is that's really sad, thanks for letting us know. And I can tell you that a mother's pain is gonna be no different, no matter how that son died. The dream is lost. We talked about that in the condition. And so when we're talking about issues of police violence, we also cannot forget the issues of violence on our streets. And at some point we've got to get angry about this. And at some point we've got to say no more. Because the level of violence out there right now is absolutely staggering. It's absolutely staggering.
[55:22] Donnie L. Betts: So great. It leads me right into. Thank you. As I said earlier, that's why I always ask the question of people, how have they been impacted by violence? It doesn't have to be police violence, it's violence. What can what tasks would I ask law enforcement up here? What tasks are you going to task the community with? I just said more response, more responsibility. What else can the community do to bridge that gap that's not being bridged now? As you say, you're picking up bodies every day, so you see you're on the front lines. You know, we may hear about it, we may read about it, and um we move on. Guilty of it as anybody else. What can we do? What's our task?
[56:21] Kerrie KJ Joy: You know, I think whether we're talking about um police violence or or youth violence, just violence in our community, I think that um the task is just to keep that conversation going. You know, I think what always happens, you know, I I I've I've sat in, I can't even count anymore the number of uh forums uh related to um various police incidents that have occurred across the country, and that forum is over, and the conversation doesn't come up again until the next incident. Um unfortunately those incidents aren't often very far apart, but uh but still I think that you know the the conversation should not be driven by the next incident. The conversation should be driven by the fact that we've not solved it, we've not come up with answers.
[57:00] Harry Clinton: Hi you guys doing, my name is Carrie Joy. Um I I mean I think it it's it might have been really important that I actually did go after you guys um because I was going to talk about something that you did mention. Um I'm really grateful that we're having this conversation. Um and one thing that struck me when you were speaking, can you remind me of your name?
[57:23] Andrew J. Betts: Harry.
[57:24] Harry Clinton: Harry. When uh when Harry was speaking, um you were talking about the fact that over time, over 35 years, things have changed within the police department. Um and you said that you were happy because at one point in time the things that were you know that were happening were stupid. Um and I don't I'm not 100% sure, you know, what that means from from your perspective and and your experience, but what I what struck me was the fact that um the onus is on us, especially when we are witnessing a lot of these power structures or a lot of these um these situations that are upholding a certain power structure to simply tell the truth about what's going on. And this is not a, oh, it's it's not me, it's you conversation.
This is just us having a conversation about the truth. Um that always bothered me, um, especially when the Black Lives Matter movement begun was this conversation about black on black crime. And I was going to say this before you guys even brought this up. Um so I just think it was it was pretty important that I even went afterwards. But the fact that anytime I would try to have a conversation with someone about it, they would be like, well, what about black on black crime? Trust and believe that we feel that too. And we have to understand and recognize the power structures that are creating this crabs in the barrel type mentality at the same time. And when we're seeing, when we're in these systems that are upholding a certain power structure, um, we have to be willing to tell the truth, just like me as a black woman has to be willing to tell the truth about what's going on in my community and holding my community members accountable for the actions that are taking place and the violence that is that that we are causing to one another.
We all have to be responsible for telling that truth. But we do have to understand that there is a system and there is a power structure that a lot of people within our communities, you know, we we're we're also fighting against that every day.
[59:24] Kerrie KJ Joy: And one thing that always bothers me a lot of times when I go into to community meetings and people are saying, well, community's not showing up, community's not showing up. Um I'm not saying that there aren't community members that aren't present, but there are so many times when they're working, when they're tired, when they have full-time jobs, and then they have to have another full-time job to hold people within within these systems accountable for their actions. And the thing is that there are so many times where the crimes that are taking place from these power systems upon people that um are disenfranchised, there is no accountability. And the pain a lot of times that I'm noticing is so much deeper and so much greater because it seems as if nobody is listening.
Nobody is listening to the fact that yes, my my my child, yes, you know, maybe there was a child that was killed you know by a gang member, and generally there is hopefully there is a uh a goal of you know the police force to go ahead and find the person that is accountable. But a lot of times in these situations where there are police members that are actually the ones causing this violence, there are too many times that there is not this accountability. And what I'm just all I'm trying to say is that the onus is on every single one of us to tell the truth when we are recognizing what is going on. And if if for so many years, you know, we we see the the stupidity, and I'm just using that word because you used it.
We see the stupidity that is happening, and maybe we're not we're not telling the truth, or maybe we're not, you know, we're afraid of the power structure, you know, uh to punish us in a certain way, but we have to be bold because if we're asking community be to be bold, then people that are within these particular power structures that are witnessing this have to be bold as well. And and um, like I said, this is not a it's not me, it's you type of conversation. I just want to make sure that we are all understanding that the truth has to be revealed in every sector. And that's it.
[1:01:26] Donnie L. Betts: Yeah, I appreciate that, Carrie. Um I want to add that a huge part of this question of, so I mean, like, people know me in Denver as a police accountability activist. Um, and I think it's really important for us to understand like what that word accountability means. Um, I think accountability has four parts that it's recognizing the harm as harm and admitting that it was your fault or that you caused it. Uh intentions be damned, that that's what happened. Um two is doing something uh that it's it's acknowledging the harm and and stopping it, stopping the harm is the second part. That like you actually like if you if you stepped on someone's foot, that you get off their foot. Um three is making amends to the extent that that's possible, but the most important part of accountability that we basically never get from our justice system on either side is changing so it doesn't happen again.
That's one of the most important parts of when you know someone's taken accountability for something, they've changed the way that they act so that that the mistake they made, the harm that they did, doesn't happen again. And I think that that is something that because of the way that we have the way that our society thinks about police um and and is so afraid of questioning the institution because it can conflates them with the people, uh helps keeps us from from doing that that changing so it doesn't happen again part. And I think that, you know, the question of what's the community's role when this violence happens, I think that a huge part of it is for us to change so it doesn't happen again.
Um, but I think that a huge part of that is learning that our officers, police are doing some things that in some ways prevent violence, but for the by and large, they're not. They respond to the killing. They show up after the shots have been fired, and they're not actually able to stop the violence that happens in the community. Yet we spend in Denver. I don't know what it's like in Aurora, but I know that in Denver, almost or more than half of our city budget goes to the safety department. And I think that what the pol what the community is supposed to do about this this uh the the violence in our community is get some of that money directed to stuff that works, that actually prevents these problems.
Because I I I should be clear that I am glad that there are police in our communities. I am happy that our society has created a way to rapidly respond to a situation like the Aurora Theater shooting. Please believe that I'm stoked about that. And I think that we give them, frankly, too many responsibilities. Um, and we expect police to be able to do be the when when you're holding a hammer, every problem looks like a nail, and the police are the hammer in our society's hands. Every problem looks like a damn nail, and we send people with paramilitary and legal training to handle a mental illness episode, and a drug overdose, chronic homelessness. What the community needs to do is redirect some of those resources to solutions that actually work. Thank you.
[1:04:53] Donnie L. Betts: Thank you. I know you won't. Thank you so much. I heard this over and over when I was at the academy, that our responsibilities are so great. I be in the police department. Responsibilities are so great now, we don't know what to do. Because we have to be all things to all people all the time. Professor, you're going to have the last word.
[1:05:14] Devra Keyes: So, first of all, I just like to, I want to be witness to the things that you've said. I grew up in LA. I am old, I am 56. I grew up in a very dangerous neighborhood in LA. We're not that old. So here's the deal. I have a PhD and I have smoked windows on my Mercedes because I'm afraid of the police. And I'm just saying that because I just want to witness what you said. But I will say this. I think we're very remiss if we think the racial violence was with the shooting. It actually was with the phone call. And if we forget that, then when we talk community, we only mean the black community in this context. And that is not what this is about, right? This is about our community, even though we tend not to live together, right? So I think that's the place we need to stop and think. Racial violence started with the phone call.
[1:06:26] Donnie L. Betts: Thanks for listening for Destination Freedom. Follow us on Facebook at No Credits Productions LLC, on Twitter at Black Radio Days, and on Instagram at No Credits Productions LLC. Hashtag nocreditsproduction LLC. I'm your host, Donnie Betts. Follow me at Donnie Betts on Twitter. Thank you so much for listening to our first podcast of Destination Freedom, Black Radio Days. Special thanks goes to Bonfree Stanford Foundation.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
