Girl From The North Country and Waitress star Caitlin Houlahan is with us this week!! This was such a fun conversation. Dan and Caitlin worked together at Waitress for over a year. Caitlin graduated from the prestigious Baldwin Wallace University and quickly took NYC by storm... Read More
From the show: Guys Who Like Musicals
Featured Shows
About
Girl From The North Country and Waitress star Caitlin Houlahan is with us this week!! This was such a fun conversation. Dan and Caitlin worked together at Waitress for over a year. Caitlin graduated from the prestigious Baldwin Wallace University and quickly took NYC by storm. Her first credit out of school was Peter Pan Live! followed by The Bridges Of Madison County, the final season of Girls, and, her dream role, Dawn in Waitress. She has one of the most interesting stories of getting to Broadway.. listen in .. sometimes the thing that changes your life is in your backyard.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Dan Tracy: Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals.
[0:01] Joe Carroll: Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals.
[0:03] Dan Tracy: No, I'm not.
[0:05] Joe Carroll: Welcome to Cash Light Musical.
[0:06] Dan Tracy: So an actor is saying his lines, and then out of nowhere, he just starts singing.
[0:14] Joe Carroll: Boxing Simony.
[0:22] Dan Tracy: Don't cry for me.
[0:35] Joe Carroll: Yo, I had to sing. I had to do a self-tape. I had to do an audition. It was very exciting. My singing is really at an all-time low. I need to stop with the spicy foods and the alcohol. I need to get more sleep. I need to start singing every day because Broadway's gonna reopen and I'm not gonna be ready.
[0:56] Dan Tracy: Yeah.
[0:57] Joe Carroll: I get that. I've been trying to sing 20 minutes every day.
[1:00] Dan Tracy: That's a really good thing.
[1:02] Joe Carroll: Usually when I shout out.
[1:03] Dan Tracy: How are you?
[1:03] Joe Carroll: Oh, I'm good.
[1:04] Dan Tracy: You okay?
[1:05] Joe Carroll: Yeah, I'm good. I saw there was something very cool this morning. Shout out to the Broadway Briefing. If you guys don't know what the Broadway Briefing is, you should sign up. It gives you Broadway news every morning in your inbox. This Strange Loop won the Pulitzer Prize.
[1:21] Dan Tracy: Yeah.
[1:22] Joe Carroll: The show that we love this show. Get to see it at Playwrights this past season. It is remarkable, and it is only one of like 10 musicals to ever win the Pulitzer Prize or something like that.
[1:37] Dan Tracy: The first musical ever written by a Black man, is that correct?
[1:41] Joe Carroll: I think so. I wanna just... And like how many shows has he written before?
[1:49] Dan Tracy: Not many, and we were trying to get Michael R. Jackson on here, and I'd still really love to talk to him because the show is remarkable. There is a cast album on Spotify. Check it out. But that was some super cool news for sure.
[2:05] Joe Carroll: You know, and like there's so much bad news.
[2:07] Dan Tracy: There is a lot of bad news. And last week I meant to talk about too the Sondheim Suntime's birthday livestream on YouTube concert.
[2:16] Joe Carroll: Which was awesome.
[2:19] Dan Tracy: Yep.
[2:19] Joe Carroll: Yep.
[2:20] Dan Tracy: I don't know if you watched it, but it was awesome.
[2:22] Joe Carroll: I would love to have a phone call with some people about how to put themselves on tape, but I did see that somebody tweeted that like, you know, it's clear that Annaleigh Ashford knows how to make a self-tape, and Jake Gyllenhaal has never made a self-tape, which because of the lighting that he chose.
[2:41] Dan Tracy: Oh man.
[2:41] Joe Carroll: Mandy Patinkin was in the middle of a walk with his dog. You know what I mean? He's like out, he's like out in a long shot, his dog's next to him, and he's just singing acapella.
[2:51] Dan Tracy: Man, it was good. But like meanwhile, Elizabeth Stanley gave us like an Oscar-winning performance. I've been thinking about just doing a review of that performance for a YouTube video because it was that good.
[3:03] Joe Carroll: That's so badass.
[3:04] Dan Tracy: Yeah.
[3:05] Joe Carroll: So can we still watch it? Is it still existing? Can you like buy it somewhere?
[3:09] Dan Tracy: It should still be on YouTube. Go look for it.
[3:10] Joe Carroll: There were 90,000 people watching live when I watched it.
[3:16] Dan Tracy: That's crazy.
[3:17] Joe Carroll: That's crazy.
[3:18] Dan Tracy: Isn't that crazy?
[3:19] Joe Carroll: So that's some good news. That's some good stuff.
[3:22] Dan Tracy: Yeah. It was your birthday.
[3:24] Joe Carroll: Yo, it was my birthday. I just got a bottle of scotch in the mail from my friend Dan.
[3:29] Dan Tracy: It showed me how was your birthday late?
[3:31] Joe Carroll: It was amazing. So my wife threw the world's coolest 30th birthday party for me. On Friday, I got to sit down to a Zoom little happy hour thing with my buddies, with Dan and a whole bunch of guests that we've had. I realized I was looking at every... It's like Will Burton, RJ Brown, Reed Campbell, Dan Tracy, and then Jordan, who has not been on the podcast. But we all sat down for cocktails, and then we went on a... Alex had put together a tour through my life around the house.
[4:04] Dan Tracy: So we started in one room and it was Joe's favorite things from zero to five. So it was like action figures and toy trains and we had chicken nuggets and apple juice boxes, and then we went to the sports phase, which we played wiffle ball in the front yard and had orange slices because you have orange slices at halftime of your little league soccer games or whatever. So we played wiffle ball. Tom Carroll, my dad, hit a walk-off grand slam in the bottom of the... We played three innings in the bottom of the third inning to win the game.
[4:41] Joe Carroll: That's funny.
[4:41] Dan Tracy: Which was so exciting and a lot of there was a lot of screaming, and I think that the neighbors probably thought that someone was being murdered. We then we did a chipping contest in the front yard, and then we did like the theater years where we had a champagne toast and Alex put together like a trivia of Joe's life in the theater. So it was like we played celebrity, you know that game where you put the name of somebody on your forehead and you have to guess what it is like in Glorious Bastards. And so we played like, you know, roles that I've played, places that we love, you know, things like that. And then we had a badass meal, unbelievable dinner and made martinis. One of my favorite drinks is the Vesper, which is the James Bond drink, which is... So I had a martini bar going, and then she made a video.
All of my friends and people I never thought would respond in a million years made like a happy birthday video. So I had everything from my grade school best friend, you know, to your ex-best friend. Great listen to me. Your current best friend, Dan.
[5:49] Dan Tracy: There is a best friend from elementary school. You know there's a best friend from high school. Okay, they're all represented. You were the best man at my wedding. Stop yelling at me. And you know, it made these, you know, like happy birthday things. Gavin Creel sang me a song, wrote me a song and sang it, which is just for me. Well, unbelievable. So well, there you go. It was an unbelievable gift. Like at one point my aunt walked to my grandfather's grave with her phone and did a selfie video of her like in front of my Grampy's grave. There's a block M on his gravestone, and she said a bunch of nice things about how he loved musicals and it was just like this unbelievably sweet thing. So that's just for me.
[6:33] Dan Tracy: Well, that's really... That's a really nice story to tell.
[6:36] Joe Carroll: Thank you. It was so cool. And so I had a great birthday. I was horribly hungover the next day. We had a wonderful party. And frankly, the best thing to come of quarantine so far. I don't think we would have done something like that had we not been locked up together, you know. So it was the best of a bad situation for sure.
[6:58] Dan Tracy: Good.
[6:59] Joe Carroll: So yeah.
[7:00] Dan Tracy: Yeah, I'm 30 and wise now.
[7:01] Joe Carroll: I love it. Come at me.
[7:03] Dan Tracy: And who are we talking to this week?
[7:05] Joe Carroll: So this week we're talking to Caitlin Houlahan.
[7:08] Dan Tracy: Yes, we are. Caitlin and I worked together on Waitress the Musical. She made her Broadway debut in Waitress as Dawn and killed it.
[7:17] Joe Carroll: She was in the show for a little for on and off for three years. You know, it was like some kind of estranged boyfriend relationship, but she was... I was so glad to get to know her, and like the day she came into the building, somebody came up to me afterwards and was like, "You seem different." Like, 'cause I interact with that track a lot, and we just really kind of connected as friends, and yeah, she's really awesome. You know, she went to Baldwin and her first job out of school was Peter Pan Live, which we get to talk to. And I loved her story.
[8:00] Dan Tracy: Such a good BW.
[8:02] Joe Carroll: So unique, super unique. She has a really interesting experience. Her start kind of in performing is really interesting compared to a lot of us. She did that parade concert at Lincoln Center with Jeremy Jordan, which was amazing. And she starred in the Bridges of Madison County tour. We just call it Bridges. We all just know that it's Bridges. So and then she went on to do Girl from the North Country at the Public and Waitress on Broadway. And is, you know, had just opened Girl from North Country when this all went down.
[8:39] Dan Tracy: Yeah.
[8:39] Joe Carroll: Neither of us really realized that the timeline of her... They had opened, had two days off to record the album, and then Broadway closed four days later.
[8:49] Dan Tracy: Just crazy.
[8:52] Joe Carroll: Like, so we get to talking about that, and just please, please send your thoughts and prayers to the Broadway community that like everybody gets to see Girl from the North Country. You know, these are these... This is a prime example of actors who are on the cusp of something really special. And it is small in the grand scheme of things. We need everybody to be healthy, yeah. Get well and stay home and do all the things, but man, do I want to see Girl from the North Country?
[9:16] Dan Tracy: Yeah, and we want to see everything. And thankfully, you know, there's a cast album coming, so look out for that, and um let's jump into it. What do you say?
[9:25] Joe Carroll: Yeah, this is awesome. Here we go.
[9:46] Dan Tracy: Caitlin.
[9:48] Caitlin Houlahan: Hi!
[9:48] Dan Tracy: Good morning.
[9:49] Caitlin Houlahan: Hello.
[9:50] Dan Tracy: Hi guys. It's so good to see you.
[9:53] Caitlin Houlahan: Are you at your parents' house in Ohio?
[9:55] Dan Tracy: I am. I'm like where you are in a suburb of Cleveland, Ohio right now. I've been at my parents for a little over a month now.
[10:06] Joe Carroll: How's that?
[10:07] Caitlin Houlahan: Honestly, it's been great.
[10:09] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[10:10] Caitlin Houlahan: I kind of feel like a kid again, but yeah, it's been really nice. We have like family meals together every night, and we don't do anything during the day, so it's been awesome.
[10:22] Dan Tracy: Is your fiancé Ryan there with you too?
[10:25] Caitlin Houlahan: He is. He's here with me.
[10:27] Joe Carroll: So that's when it says that you're on his Zoom on the bottom, like we're talking to you.
[10:31] Caitlin Houlahan: I saw that and I was like, whoops.
[10:35] Dan Tracy: Yeah. Listeners, Caitlin is engaged to a man named Ryan Vaughn, who is a very talented human being who made his Broadway debut in Once. We should have had him on here with you, but we wanted to give you all the attention we could at this time.
[10:49] Caitlin Houlahan: We'll talk to him. Maybe later.
[10:50] Dan Tracy: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, sign him up for later. What a voice that guy has.
[10:55] Caitlin Houlahan: You should check him out.
[10:56] Dan Tracy: Stupid voice.
[10:57] Caitlin Houlahan: So you're living with your parents at home and you feel like a kid again.
[11:01] Caitlin Houlahan: Yes.
[11:02] Dan Tracy: Yeah. I can imagine.
[11:13] Caitlin Houlahan: And it's crazy. Like, you know, I feel like no 30-year-old is supposed to live with their parents for as long as I've been living with my parents. But you know, it's like we're making the best of it.
[11:22] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[11:22] Caitlin Houlahan: You know, we never... You never would have had that time.
[11:25] Joe Carroll: Yeah, exactly.
[11:26] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, you never would have done this if it weren't for what's happening. So I guess that that's good.
[11:31] Dan Tracy: It's good.
[11:32] Caitlin Houlahan: I feel the same way. We're having family dinners and watching movies and you know, spending a lot of time together.
[11:38] Joe Carroll: So yeah, yeah.
[11:39] Caitlin Houlahan: There's definitely like those moments where you're like, ooh, okay, this is why I live in New York. And like I'm so happy to be here right now, but I'm also glad that like I got out, you know, like I moved out when I was young, and that I feel like it just makes like now so much more enjoyable to be here.
[11:59] Dan Tracy: Did you ever live anywhere else? Did you always... Did you grow up in Ohio?
[12:03] Caitlin Houlahan: I'm literally in the house right now that I grew up in. Like I've... I'd never moved before I went to college and then I went to New York and I moved like nine times in five years.
[12:14] Dan Tracy: So let's start in the beginning then.
[12:17] Joe Carroll: What did you... A very good place to start.
[12:20] Caitlin Houlahan: How did you... God help me.
[12:21] Dan Tracy: Sorry, sorry, Dan podcast. This is a Broadway podcast.
[12:24] Caitlin Houlahan: How did you get into performing and how did you find yourself on a stage for the first time?
[12:33] Caitlin Houlahan: So it was kind of just by chance because I was in a Girl Scout troop. My mom was the leader of the troupe, and it was like third grade, and a bunch of the girls were skipping the Girl Scout meeting to audition for The King and I, which was gonna be done at the high school. So they were looking for kids. None of like no one at my school was Asian, so like we should not have been doing The King and I. But it was like the year 2000, and uh...
[13:08] Dan Tracy: Exactly.
[13:10] Caitlin Houlahan: So all these girls were auditioning for it, and I was like, well, I don't want to be left out because I was like not one to be left out. And so I went in and you could sing two songs, one of two songs you could sing, Doe a dear.
[13:26] Joe Carroll: What is the real name of that song?
[13:28] Caitlin Houlahan: Doray Me.
[13:29] Joe Carroll: Don't rain me.
[13:30] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, yeah. So, you know, very good place to start. Bringing it back around. So you could sing Don't Ray Me, or you could sing My Country, 'Tis of Thee. And they had the lyrics written like on a board, so you didn't even have to like face the room. You could face the board and just sing a song. And um, I say I wish they still did that.
[13:54] Joe Carroll: I know, right?
[13:55] Caitlin Houlahan: You can just turn around and sing. That's fine.
[13:58] Joe Carroll: Exactly.
[13:59] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, right, right. So I sang Don't Rain Me, and I booked it.
[14:06] Joe Carroll: Booked.
[14:06] Caitlin Houlahan: Booked, booked it, blessed as a third grader, and I was the second smallest, so I didn't get all of the like cool features that the smallest child got. That was pretty sad. But for my first show, it was pretty awesome. And I met my best friend who currently lives in Florida, but that was where I met her, and she was homeschooled at the time, so it's kind of a nice little moment that we had. And then how does that track as... So then you just like you're a theater kid and you're obsessed, and you're just like... I wish, but also like no, like I basically did a theater camp the next year, but I had to choose between soccer and theater.
[14:54] Caitlin Houlahan: And so that summer I chose theater, and then pretty much never again. So um, and I don't know why it was like I don't know, it was really fun, but for some reason I just kind of felt like I was better at like other stuff, which like I was not better at soccer, but I enjoyed it more. Um and then I think I got to middle school and I just figured I would do the shows, and I like didn't make it the first year, I like was an ensemble the next year, like that kind of thing. And then my eighth grade year, I had like we did um Alexander and the Terrible No Good Very Bad Day, and uh I was the shoe sales lady, which doesn't sound like much, but she had a song, and it was like this jazz song, and that's like where I established myself as like oh like she can sing, yeah, and then I did the shows in high school, but it was never something that I was like, Oh yeah, I'm gonna make a career out of that. Like it was definitely something that I was like, I'll just do this, it's fun, it'll look great on my like application for college. And uh yeah.
[16:04] Dan Tracy: So so then how did it change? When when did you go from that girl can sing to like you're going to Baldwin Wallace? Like, why did you end up?
[16:11] Caitlin Houlahan: Well, yeah, I so my initial plan and like dream was to go to Notre Dame because that's where my brother went. So that was like it was a dream that was very much like there for me, yeah. And so I really wanted to go there, so I did like every extracurricular activity I could, did everything, didn't get in. So then I was like, all right, we gotta figure out a new plan. Um and so I uh I applied to three schools, and I didn't know what I wanted to do. I knew I wanted to do like music in some way, but at this point I was like, there's no way I would ever make it professionally, so I was like, maybe I'll do like music therapy or like music psychology, like something that has to do with music, but also with like the brain and kind of like helping people.
So I looked at um Ithaca, which didn't have either of those programs, so I would have just gone like as like a generic like music major and like figured it out. Um, and then I applied to BW, but it's like in my backyard, and that like was a huge turnoff for me. I was like, I want to get out of the state, like I've never moved before, I don't want to like go somewhere that's you know 35 minutes away. Um, but that's what I ended up doing. Um but it was because they had a music therapy program, and so I was like, okay, this is my path, like this makes a lot of sense for me. I really like psychology, I really like music, let's put them together.
[17:50] Caitlin Houlahan: So I went to BW, and like my second year in, I had gone to all of the music theater like events. So I went to their masterclasses, like I would sit in the audience and watch, and I would go to all their shows, and I was so mind blown with what they were doing, and it became like an obsession of like I really like this now, and I didn't realize that there was much more to it than like your high school shows, which like my high school shows were like anything goes, Greece, bye-bye birdie, like all the like traditional ones that everyone does in high school, or at least like the regular high schools, not the like intense really good.
[18:33] Dan Tracy: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
[18:35] Caitlin Houlahan: So I just like learned so much more about theater, and I was watching these master classes, and I was like, I think I can do that, but I was also like aware that like maybe that's a terrible thing to say.
[18:50] Dan Tracy: Um so no, I don't think that's a bad thing to say at all. You you see something and you're like, I I I can I can do this. This is this is something I want to do, but also like I might be able to hang with these people.
[19:01] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, I definitely like I was like, I hope that I'm not having like delusions of grandeur here, but like I felt like I saw myself doing that, and I was like, I think I can like play the game of like getting through this and like doing all the right things and saying all the right things. Like, I don't know, I just like kept like gathering information and I was like, all right, I think I can like get through an audition here, and so I didn't tell anyone um but like two years in I was like all right I'm gonna I switched to arts management as like a backup plan and I like saved up and I not saved up but like got all my information I needed and I auditioned and uh I ended up getting in um and they told me it would take me two extra years so that I'd have to be in school for six years and I was like I'm I can't do that like I was already in the conservatory of music so I had taken two years of all music classes um so when they said I would have to start over as a freshman when I was like going to be a junior I was like I just like I can't afford to stay here.
[19:21] Dan Tracy: Yeah yeah yeah exactly so basically I like walked away and then they called me and they were like okay you can start as a sophomore and I was like okay I can do that. Um my dog just got into the room by the way um so basically I got in I had to double up on classes so I was in the freshman class and the sophomore class for the first year so I was taking two workshops at once which was like pretty intense um and I just like trained my butt off and I blacked out most of it I don't remember.
[20:27] Dan Tracy: Dan blacked out for a different reason.
[21:03] Caitlin Houlahan: You know it's funny that this story though, like it you it almost sounds like you started as a musical theater major as a psychology experiment.
[21:08] Caitlin Houlahan: Basically. You were like you know, you're like like watching these people as like a case study and you're like, you know what? I'm gonna I'm gonna try this. And now all of a sudden, you know, now it's your whole life and your career it was, you know, yeah made made by a decision you made when you were nineteen or something.
[21:25] Dan Tracy: Yeah, I feel like a total imposter.
[21:28] Caitlin Houlahan: No, but you're not. It's interesting 'cause there was like there's I've always been I've always admired like your your humility and and you're you're just like a normal person who I when I first met you at Waitress, I was like, Oh well I know exactly who that is. I could tell you exactly what your resume was, I could tell you when you were cast and what and I was like totally enamored by you, but then you had this like this approachability, you know, which it seems like you had at that time where you were just like a high school kid and you're like, Well, I'm just you know, I'm just me. But then you kind of like watched these people in the program and you said, you know, actually I think I can do this. I think that you like made that calculated decision and then you went for it and you know, good thing you did.
[22:12] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah. But I think more often than not, we're we're s we talk to people who, you know, I speaking for myself, I was like, Oh, I'm gonna be famous. Like I am great. And then I got to college and I was like, holy shit. I'm screwed. And I had to like kinda readjust and like actually like, you know, and and and improve and get better, but but you kinda had the opposite approach, which is refreshing because I think there are also a lot of people out there who are in high school and a bit uh intimidated by the idea of this business, and it's like, no, like with a lot of hard work for the next 10 years, you can get there too.
[22:54] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, you know. I think it's really interesting too that like in our field, everyone got to it in different ways. And so you've got like the people who did theater their entire lives, and they went to the right school and they went to the best school and they got to New York, and like that's like what got them on Broadway, or that's what got them where they wanted to go. But then you've got people who like were like, I was choosing between playing basketball professionally and going to Broadway, and you're like, Maximum.
[23:20] Dan Tracy: Yeah. Well, and those are the people that we love. I mean, those are the those are the interesting stories. That's why I love your story so much. It's just not the the traditional, you know, traditional model. You found it, you know, you got you found like I almost luckily one of the best conservatories in the country was in your backyard. I mean, what if you had lived somewhere else and oh my god, you know, yeah, had not gone there.
[23:42] Caitlin Houlahan: I definitely feel like it I don't sometimes I look back and I'm just like some of the thoughts that I had, like the thought of like I'm just gonna like do this. Like that's like not something that I think I a person that I was, someone who just like chose to do things without like talking to everyone first and like getting everyone's advice. Like that's why I think like sometimes I feel like an imposter because I'm like, I don't know how I got here. Like I just feel like it was really like laid on my heart that like this is what you're gonna do, because like I had no backup plan. Like even after graduation, it was like I told my mom, I'm moving to New York, and she kept going, like, okay, yeah, you're gonna move to New York.
And I was like, no, really, I'm I'm going. And they're like, okay, like up to the point where they like dropped me off in New York. And I was like, bye. Like, I'm here, and then, like, somehow made it work. Like, I I truly like I don't understand it. But so yeah, I just feel like it was that's awesome.
[24:42] Joe Carroll: Yeah. Don't you feel like that though, Joe?
[24:44] Joe Carroll: Constantly.
[24:45] Caitlin Houlahan: I also feel like an imposter. I think everybody feels like an imposter, you know.
[24:49] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[24:49] Caitlin Houlahan: So that's the most relatable thing. And we talked to other people about it too. Like, you know, imposter syndrome and the the fear of that and everything. And I just think if we can all agree that, like, hey, nobody knows what the fuck we're doing. We're all just like figuring it out as we go. I think that's a really cathartic experience.
[25:08] Joe Carroll: Yeah. I totally felt the same way too. Like, because I only got into Michigan.
[25:13] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah.
[25:14] Joe Carroll: And so like that was my absolute pinnacle top choice. And I didn't get into any other program in musical theater. So then I'm there and I'm like, wait a second. You guys were wrong. I'm not supposed to be here. Like, I'm not, you know, I can't do it. But it's that's that's just your own mind of like getting in your way because anybody can do it.
[25:35] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah. And I feel like you just like you're always gonna go where you need to go, whether or not you realize it at the time. So even if you like end up at the school and you're like, I don't, you know, if you're a college kid who had to pick a school right now, and you weren't able to visit anywhere, and you're not even sure if you're gonna go in the fall because of the pandemic, like they're gonna be at the right school for the right reason, you know.
[25:56] Caitlin Houlahan: So whether or not it's like the school that of their choice, like one day they'll be able to look back and go, like, wow, I'm really glad that I didn't end up going to my dream school, or like that I didn't go to that place.
[26:07] Joe Carroll: So, yeah.
[26:08] Caitlin Houlahan: Exactly. I was listening to uh just I'm it's it's amazing when you hear stories from people who can track a career move 15 years later to this like really terrible decision they made 20 years before that, you know, like there's so many times you can track that in in the careers of people and it's and in people's lives yeah and the pillows end up being one for a while in like college school who could have planned this journey like you can't you totally can't compare yourself to anybody else now because who who would have ever thunk this and no one's ever been in this place you know from so go ahead then so your your parents are driving away you they've left you in New York they still don't believe that you're gonna move there um and then what was that transition like I mean did you did you guys you guys do do a showcase and do that the the whole thing as well?
[26:08] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah so we showcased in like uh April um and I mean putting together BW's showcase like you can I don't know if it's like this at Michigan but you can easily tell like when you're not the uh the star of the of your class like based on what like where you're put in the showcase. So I was like third. So I was like cool like you're not saving me for the end. I'm not first I was second yeah yeah exactly I was second too so you're like cool that's fine I'm just gonna have to do it myself and so um so we picked these songs and whatever so basically we went into it and I did not think I was hoping for like a couple agents to maybe be interested um and potentially ones that had been at BW when they came for a master class.
So like I had it my eye on a couple. And then there was like the one that I like really wanted, but like didn't even think they knew I existed, kind of thing. And um after our showcase with BW, I don't know if we can put this on here or not. It's probably fine. But so basically, after you showcase a BW, everyone goes up to um a hotel room and uh they read off the results to everyone, and you have to write down it's like a friendship ruiner for sure. Like all that like progress you made, like for the four years that you're together, and like you're really banded together, and then they just like rip you apart. So they basically tell you in the room, uh they name the agency, and then they tell everyone who they were interested in, and then you have to like write them down if they were interested in you, and um it's they need to fix it.
It's torture. Um so I ended up having a ton of interest, which was like absolutely mind-blowing to me because I went through BW not really as a favorite, not really getting cast like in things I wanted to be casted. Um, so it was a big surprise to me. Uh, and I think to everyone else in the room. So uh I still hadn't heard the one that I wanted to hear from, and then the following day they called me, and so I was really excited and I got to sign with the like with these people that I was really interested in.
[29:42] Joe Carroll: I think you're with them too.
[29:44] Caitlin Houlahan: I was gonna just gonna say artisan reps, yeah. And actually, I love hearing that story because I had basically one offer, and it was from them. Um, and it was I was so I didn't have a lot of interest out of showcase, and I thought it was the end, and I you know, I was I was really upset, and we got to uh I had a meeting with them, and I basically walked in and was like, Hey, I want to work with you guys. I'm ready, let's go. Like, you know, and they were like, Oh, oh, okay, okay, great. You know, um, I'm sure my agent, I'm sure Ben would tell that story differently. But I just remember I tell people all the time, like, you just need one, yeah, you need one. You need you need somebody you need one person to believe in you, and they have believed in me, you know, come hell or high water for the last eight years. And so I'm I'm very grateful.
[30:35] Joe Carroll: So that's awesome. You graduate, you get to this city, you're figuring out your life, you sign with this agent you really wanted.
[30:40] Caitlin Houlahan: Yes.
[30:40] Caitlin Houlahan: And your first big job is that national tour of Bridges, right? I mean, I know you did that Theory of Relativity and you did the Parade concert.
[30:47] Caitlin Houlahan: I did, but my first thing is actually Peter Pan Live was my very first job. Yes, so it was pretty crazy because I was working as a waitress in Chelsea at this top us restaurant, um, like wine bar place. Top us. If I say it too fast, people think I'm saying topless, so it wasn't a topless restaurant. Um, I was working at this restaurant and it all happened within like a week. Like I remember I have this very vivid memory of um I worked late and then I went home and I woke up because someone was calling me and I answered, and I swear to God, I know that this isn't what happened, it was someone from the Telsey office, but I swear to God, they said, This is Bernie Telsey, and we'd like for you to come in and audition for Peter Pan Live.
And I was like, okay. But I don't think it was him, but in my mind, he called me personally. And so that I went in and I heard nothing. And it was like months later, and they called me back in, and I was going in for like Wendy and Jane, and like just back and forth, like they had me coming in for this stuff. And I ended up booking Jane, and um, which was insane because one of my best friends at the time, he still is, but um, Chris McCarroll.
[32:17] Joe Carroll: Chris McCarroll, I was just gonna say Chris was in that you guys went to BW together.
[32:20] Caitlin Houlahan: We well, we also grew up in the same town, so like we went to like middle school and elementary school together.
[32:27] Joe Carroll: Oh my god.
[32:28] Caitlin Houlahan: And then we went to BW together, and then uh we did Peter Pan Live, and then we lived together, and now we live like really close to each other, just like up in Westchester.
[32:38] Joe Carroll: Yeah, so we keep following each other, but um, it was really exciting because I knew that he had it, so it was like we just kept waiting and waiting. The night before my final callback, he came over with a six-pack of like I think it was like Goose Island or something, and we had this really cool balcony at the time, and we just played cards, and he was like, You need to not be nervous about tomorrow, and you need to not freak out. So we're gonna drink these play cards. So, like I went in and I was like definitely hungover. But I but it really I guess it worked.
[33:13] Joe Carroll: So yeah, so I feel like I had to like credit him for helping me get that job, but I love uh yeah, that was my first card.
[33:24] Joe Carroll: Um what was that experience like? Like, how do those work?
[33:28] Caitlin Houlahan: I think that was the that was the second one.
[33:31] Joe Carroll: I was just gonna say, and it was one of the I think it was still one of the most effective. You know, like it was so good.
[33:35] Caitlin Houlahan: It was so good. It was like really good.
[33:39] Joe Carroll: And still, you know, some of them have not, but that one was really good. Can you remember anything that does anything stick out about that, like the actual production and filming of that?
[33:49] Caitlin Houlahan: Oh, for sure. I mean, uh like so many of my friends that I still have today in New York are from that production, like Henry Gottfried, who was also a waitress, you know, like so it's nice when you like meet those people and then they keep coming back into your life. Um it was very strange because it's like this medium that they haven't figured out. So but at the same time I was getting like Rob Ashford was the director, so I was getting this like incredible direction from this guy who I was like, he's done so much. And you know, like he just like this like legend of a director. So I got to watch him work. I also understudied Wendy, so I got uh I learned a lot about understudying. Um but then there was also the camera stuff, which like was more so um you didn't learn too much about it other than like how a set worked, basically.
Um but they were pretty much like we would block everything out and then the cameras would come in. So it wasn't like I was learning too much about TV, um other than like being able to watch on monitors and stuff like that. Uh but the day of the show was just like really exciting, but you're also like on Long Island in this like airplane hangar, so like no one's out there, you know.
[35:26] Caitlin Houlahan: It was um the Grumman studios.
[35:30] Joe Carroll: Grumman.
[35:31] Caitlin Houlahan: I don't even know. I think it's Grumman. Uh but um it was electric and exciting, and I got to like fly like in like a harness at the end. I mean, I was in the very last few minutes, but right before, right before I go on, I'm like in this hallway, like that is literally part of the set. And they're like, okay, so the camera's gonna do like a 360, and once it gets to this side, we're gonna tap you, and you have to like crawl over the beds and like get in the bed and like you know, cover yourself, and then it's gonna come back to you. And I was like, okay. And then the uh the TV director, because there was the theater director and the TV director, he said to me, We're uh we're running late, uh, don't take any dramatic pauses.
He's like, we're like, it's like a hard out at 11. So my god. So I was like, cool, my uh acting debut, and any pauses and literally you're worrying about union overtime. Yes, you know, they're like this guy's like, we're gonna have to pay everybody three times as much if you take any dramatic pauses. Exactly.
[36:38] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, and I like we never were like I rehearsed my scene like a couple times because uh Wendy, all grown up was going to be Minnie Driver, and she didn't show up until like three days before we filmed. And like, and like so the first rehearsal I had before like she still has the script in her hand, and I was like, Are you kidding me? Oh my god.
[37:01] Joe Carroll: Oh my god.
[37:02] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, but that all turned out to be fine. Um so basically, like I got in the bed, I'm like waiting, my heart is like pounding, and it's like weird because there's like no one watching you, but there's also like millions of people watching you, or at least you hope. Right. Like I think a lot of people went to bed at this point because it was like four hours in, but um I basically like got out of bed and they did another like 360 camera, and there was a guy laying beside the bed who would jump up and hook me in to the harness and then like tap me to make sure like you're safe to go. And then like the ending shot was like me and Allison Williams just like flying out of the window. So it was like really exciting, like one of the most exciting, like high energy things I've ever done.
And then there was this huge party on the set, and it was amazing, and then we like checked our phones. It was like like a balloon deflating because the you know how harsh Twitter can be like times a million.
[38:09] Joe Carroll: Oh it was really rough.
[38:11] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, and that's where I learned that like you really can't if you that stuff bothers me a lot, like it just gets under my skin, which I think a lot of people it does, like you just think about it all the time. So I kind of learned to like not go looking for what random people think of you and of um yeah of your art. So that was like a huge lesson. Don't look at Twitter, don't read the YouTube comments, don't read the YouTube comments like it's just you we all learned that lesson the hard way that that sucks yeah but I honestly still have like such wonderful memories and uh it's I mean it like to this day for that to be like my first thing that I worked on it was it was definitely a big like uh kind of in your face to all the people who like didn't cast me in the past.
[38:40] Joe Carroll: Yeah yeah god yeah I do love that because we're all competitive you know and there's a little chip on your shoulder about stuff like that which is really that's fantastic yeah so I will I am we're gonna spend a lot of time talking about Waitress but I would love to hear because I know you made some great friends on that Bridges tour so I'd love to just hear like one of your favorite memories from that or what that was like you took out the first national tour of Bridges of Madison County which is such a beautiful show.
[39:38] Caitlin Houlahan: Still one of the best scores ever. Yes truly 100% um oh god just like something that sticks out in your mind you know I know Dave Thomas Brown was out there with you and you guys became really good friends from that.
[39:51] Caitlin Houlahan: Yes Dave Thomas Brown and his uh fiancée Amelia Bay who did the wigs they're two of like my closest friends um Elizabeth Stanley was uh Francesca right Andrew Savansky was um what's that role?
[40:07] Joe Carroll: The dude thank you did his name I don't know what his name's a character's name um yeah I know because he he says Francesca 10,000 times when he says, No, we all know that her name is Francesca. We don't care about it.
[40:22] Caitlin Houlahan: It's so true.
[40:23] Caitlin Houlahan: Um I mean, there's so many good memories. I think most of my I think probably one of my favorite memories, um, which was kind of like twofold. We were in Kansas City, which has the theater under the stars, I think. Not the one in Kansas City Starlight.
[40:41] Joe Carroll: Yeah, City Starlight, that's right.
[40:42] Caitlin Houlahan: City Starlight, that's right. And so everything's outside, and uh the sun was setting as um the guy. I wish Robert, Robert is his name.
[40:53] Joe Carroll: Robert, yeah, Robert King.
[40:55] Caitlin Houlahan: Okay. And Robert singing the song about um about like light and capturing like the light in his own. And uh the sun was setting like in the sky, and it was like, you know, the lighting didn't matter on stage because like it literally was a sunset all around, and it was like it was chilling in the most beautiful way.
[41:20] Caitlin Houlahan: Um but another good memory I have there was that was the first year that uh Cleveland the Cavaliers won the championship. So it was really exciting because it really felt like we like broke the curse. Didn't end up happening, but it was very, very exciting. So I feel like there were a lot of really good memories in Kansas City.
[41:44] Joe Carroll: Basketball people.
[41:45] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, I love it.
[41:47] Joe Carroll: Uh that's very so yeah, yeah, it is cool.
[41:50] Caitlin Houlahan: So you come back from that national tour and you did what?
[41:59] Caitlin Houlahan: Because it was then like oh no, it's right away that you got cast in in Waitress, huh?
[42:04] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, it was I think it was a couple months after, but right before then. I mean, you know, everyone like goes through like right after you're done with the job, and you're like, I'm never gonna work again.
[42:15] Joe Carroll: Right.
[42:15] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, so I kind of had that feeling, and then randomly I booked an episode of Girls, and it was like in its final season, and um, it was just like this really small role, but it was my first like real TV gig. Like, this is really cool. Um, so I booked that then like following week it was being filmed in Montauk, and so they took me out to Montauk, and it was like during the week. Uh, I was filming like Monday through Thursday, and Friday I was leaving for Disney for the weekend. I was gonna go down to Disney World with my family.
[42:54] Caitlin Houlahan: And uh Friday, I headed back to the city and got the audition for Waitress. And I'd been waiting for this audition, like when I was on tour, I came back to see Waitress. I saw like Dawn, I fell in love with her. Like I loved Kamiko. I thought that she was fantastic. Like, I was just like, I see myself in that role. If it ever opens up, like let me know. And my agent Ben was like, it's probably not gonna open up, but okay.
[43:23] Caitlin Houlahan: And uh, and then it did, and he so he emailed me, and um I basically was like, cool, like, all right, I already know all the materials because I'm a freak and I love this show.
[43:35] Joe Carroll: And you learned it, which is genius.
[43:37] Caitlin Houlahan: Exactly. And so I went to Disney and like forgot about it for the weekend, and then I came back. Um, and I think it the audition was like on a Tuesday. And I went in in the morning, auditioned. I came back in the afternoon for Diane Paulus, and then I think the next day or the day after they called and they were like, You booked it, and they want you to go out immediately. So it was like it was a whirlwind.
[44:01] Joe Carroll: You Dan, you have a kind of similar thing about the starting tomorrow thing with that show.
[44:07] Caitlin Houlahan: Oh yeah.
[44:07] Joe Carroll: Why they can't give you like a little heads up that like less than a Broadway show and go have a nice week off.
[44:14] Caitlin Houlahan: No.
[44:17] Joe Carroll: Thank you for listening to our show. As always, you can check us out on Instagram at Guys Who Like Musicals or on Twitter at Musical Guys. And we just started a Patreon page, which is the best way for you to support our show.
[44:30] Dan Tracy: If you love our show, check it out. There's tons of cool opportunities for listeners on there. So check it out. Thank you so much. Love you.
[44:48] Joe Carroll: You were a waitress for a really long time, right?
[44:50] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, I was there like on and off for three years.
[44:53] Dan Tracy: For three years, which is amazing. And you played Dawn with so many Jennas. And now what do you feel like was your favorite part about being Dawn, about doing Waitress? Like what was that experience like for you?
[45:13] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, it's so much a part of my life and a part of my career because it's definitely the longest show I've ever done. Um, it's funny how you have a show that you're like, I mean, that's the only dream role that I think I've ever had. Anytime people ask me, like, what's your dream role? I have no idea. I I don't really have any, like, I don't feel like I'm uh like I know enough musicals to like have that. Um, so that was my first ever and probably only like real dream role. And so going into a show that's like your favorite show at the time and your dream role, and like I just remembered being up there because I I was I think the second uh principal to be recast. Um, so first it was Earl, so Nick Cordero left to do Bronx Tale, and excuse me.
And um William Pop came in to play Earl right after. So he was the first replacement. Okay, we're in, we're in, we're back. Just acid reflux in the morning. So I was at the Kamiko had been replaced by Jenna Urshkowitz. Um, and she was there, I think for like eight weeks, and then I came in. She might have been there for a little longer. So I did the show with most of the original cast. Um, and I always had that like feeling of like feeling like I was in the original cast because I was with all of these people that I had watched. And so I just remember uh being, it was the end of the wedding, and Chris Fitzgerald's putting the ring on my finger, and I just remember being like, I cannot believe that I'm right here.
Like I just I was just in the audience watching him do this, like to another Dawn, and now I'm like right here. And I it it's like the most bizarre feeling. Um, I I had a few of those moments during Waitress, and I'm like trying to really hold on to that because we all know that like when you're in a show for a really long time, like you start to just like not enjoy it as much as you did when you first started totally um how do you with that oh sorry go ahead no finish your thought no go ahead how did you how did you manage that pressure or that like the stress that would come from uh okay here we are in this place uh doing this thing and now all of a sudden I'm I'm up here like was that daunting to you or did you just kind of go with the flow?
[48:02] Caitlin Houlahan: No like hell yes it was it was the scariest thing I've ever done and I was like there's no way that I can possibly actually do this. Like I think like even though we've you've done like a million shows before like you get there and you're like well I can't do this one like I can't get through this. I definitely didn't handle it well going into it especially when they said okay like you're gonna start right away and then it was like in two weeks you're gonna learn everything and you're gonna go on and make your Broadway debut and like you're only rehearsing with like the stage manager. Like I was so foreign to all of that. So I feel like there was there was such a huge learning curve um and my like my brain when I get anxious or when I get really nervous about something the first thing that goes is my appetite and so I like was not eating because I was every time I would go to eat I'd be like you're gonna be on Broadway in two weeks and like couldn't eat.
So like I like lost weight. And um it was I just remember like being really lightheaded all the time because like I was not eating. Eating right, you know, so I'm like, how am I gonna do this? Um and I mean the first night, so I had my put-in. Oh, and everyone was warning me about Diane Paulus, and everyone like people were calling me and saying, like, you know that you're gonna be having a rehearsal with Diane, like, you know, she can be rough sometimes, like she can be kind of intense, and I was like, I think I'll be okay. Like, I had Vicky Bussert for four years, so like you know, like she was the you know, the BW. Yeah, so and she's like she's very uh she's like tough love is like her big thing.
Um, so I was like, I think I'll be okay. I had like a great rehearsal with Diane, I was feeling good about it. The only thing that I wasn't feeling good about was when he sees me because uh it's really hard uh to sing in general, but then also to be thrown around, like on top of that, like I just couldn't get my breath underneath me.
[50:15] Joe Carroll: Yeah, it's very hard to sing in general.
[50:17] Caitlin Houlahan: I agree with that.
[50:18] Joe Carroll: It really is.
[50:19] Caitlin Houlahan: Just singing.
[50:20] Joe Carroll: No, Joe, not generally.
[50:22] Caitlin Houlahan: We're talking about that song.
[50:23] Joe Carroll: No, I think I think singing it just did in general is very good.
[50:28] Caitlin Houlahan: Um no, but totally, and like every Dawn has that experience, like the first time. I remember we had some Dawn put-ins and things like that, and it's like every Dawn's the same way. It's a really tough song to sing when you're like kind of running around the stage, and it is like props, the musical. Yeah, like there's so many things you have to do with props in that show. It was crazy.
[50:47] Dan Tracy: Oh, yeah.
[50:48] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, so I mean, basically, my put-in happened, and after when he sees me, like, I could not hold the last note out to save my life, and I was just like, oh my gosh, like everyone here is probably like, why did they cast her? Like, you know, I had like all the self-consciousness of like I don't know anyone here, they don't know me. I've never done Broadway before, so like I was afraid that there were all these, like, you know, like just thoughts going around. And uh Sarah Bareilles came up to me and she was like, I'm really sorry when I wrote that song. I didn't know that Dawn was gonna be thrown around. She was like, if you need to take extra breaths, like take them. And I was like, what about this?
Like, what if I like try to make it funny? And like if I run out of breath, I'll just take like a really big breath in the middle of the note and like keep singing. And she was like, Yeah, like that would be cool. And so my first night, my Broadway debut, couldn't get through the last note, and I took a huge breath in the middle, and it was not funny, not successful. It just like looked really, really dumb. So, and like my family was there, I had all these friends there. It was um it took me a while to get to like a point where I felt like confident. And I mean, Dan, you can attest to this. Like, before that scene, I'm like behind the curtain with you and with whoever uh and like Tyrone weren't getting ready to come out, and like there were just days that like my anxiety would get the better of me, and I'd be like, Okay, like I'm really nervous today, and I don't know why, and like I gotta, you know, breathe, and like there were just days where it was like it would just hit me, and I couldn't, I didn't feel like I could do it, and I would start just like, okay, I can't even get a full breath in now, and like it never really like fully went away.
[52:43] Dan Tracy: Yeah, it's really interesting how your brain uh creates this like wall in a Broadway theater. Like I've spent my entire life in theaters, and then I toured three times, so I've played 300 venues, not that many, but so many venues, and they just become theaters, and you don't think about them as like any you're like, I'm in a theater, that's what I'm doing. And then all of a sudden you're in a Broadway theater and your brain is like what you're so scared by this. Suddenly it's like you're you know, you're like in a in a fishbowl and you feel like you're being watched in a way that's isn't helpful. Is there a moment when that like shifted for you and and it became like you felt like you took ownership over the space, or or was it always kind of scary?
[53:34] Caitlin Houlahan: Um was it just horrible for two years? I mean, I can attest that like by the time I ever saw you, you you I thought vocally were the most consistent Dawn I ever saw. I mean, you you sounded incredible, you had such a brilliant understanding of like how the character could be really funny and really very real, and you didn't put a lot on, it wasn't too character-y, it was very grounded and normal. I thought you were phenomenal. So was there a point when that like all clicked in for you, or did you always just kind of manage your anxieties?
[54:04] Caitlin Houlahan: Thank you, Dan. That was really nice. Um I mean, it I think it just always like it was like rolling hills. Like I think there were some times that I like really had a hold on it, and uh I felt really confident. Um I mean, I also like I mean, I constantly go to therapy, like, and so that was something that we talked about, and like how I, you know, the mental block of like, why is this happening like I know I can do it because I've done it before so why is it that when this person's there or you know I'm thinking about these three things like why does that make it any different um right and like coming back into the show even though I had done it so many times I was still so nervous like to come back into the show and there were new people in the show um so I think it just there were like a few breakthrough moments like I think I had a lot of uh mental gymnastics during this show because of what it entailed like anytime I got past when he sees me I was like good to go like then like okay the show's over I totally get that completely and so I was like thankful that the song was like right in the beginning and I could just like be done and be like good you know whatever um it was interesting because when Sarah was Jenna I don't feel like I had any issues because I was singing her song at her so like what could possibly be worse and more scary than that awesome that is amazing so I feel like that's like when I thrived like I feel like we we were all the same page and like especially because Sarah went from being like this like person who was way up here to being like on the same level as everyone else yeah she was just a person who was doing theater for the first time and like making her Broadway debut as the lead uh actress of the show that she wrote.
[56:08] Dan Tracy: Right, right.
[56:09] Caitlin Houlahan: Like no big deal. So like I I felt really confident when she was there. So I don't know. I don't know really what would make it like flip-flop. It really sometimes there is no like rhyme or reason. Um yeah, it's just something you kind of constantly were negotiating, which I think is interesting because you know, this idea that it never feels like you really arrive.
[56:33] Dan Tracy: Yeah, this life is not a like you don't just get to a place and then all of a sudden you like all of your insecurities go away, right? Or you're suddenly happy or you're suddenly rich. Like it's not like none of those things kind of happen. It just like you're kind of constantly negotiating, and I think it's interesting to hear people's perspectives on that.
[56:52] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, and just that it's hard all the time, you know, like it is Broadway's hard and songs are hard, and just like that you you know you you try different things, but actually just for three years off and on, that song was hard, and it was like that's that's awesome.
[57:07] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[57:09] Caitlin Houlahan: I don't know how you guys feel. Um, but do you feel like it it gets harder as you get older? Like, do you feel like you get more nervous about auditions or like more nervous about like performing as you get older? Because I think that I had a lot more confidence when I first got to New York and I was like pretty fearless, and like now I'm like becoming like fearful.
[57:30] Dan Tracy: Interesting.
[57:31] Caitlin Houlahan: We were just talking about that, yeah. I feel like I had blind confidence, yeah.
[57:35] Joe Carroll: Like I wish I could go back to high school where I just like thought I was amazing and wasn't.
[57:40] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah.
[57:41] Joe Carroll: Because now I'm like very aware when I'm not amazing.
[57:45] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, yeah.
[57:47] Joe Carroll: But most of the time, actually, I have a lot more. I don't know, my my preparation has changed so drastically that like I didn't really prepare enough, and now I'm like going into auditions, like memorized and staged.
[57:59] Caitlin Houlahan: Right.
[57:59] Joe Carroll: And that's not something I used to do. And so that has helped my anxieties a bit. But I feel like just with the long-running shows that that the biggest misconception about long-running shows is they get easier. When you're in a show for a long time, it only gets harder. Your body starts to hurt, your voice, you know, you get bronchitis and you can't get over it. You lose your voice and it's never it doesn't really, you know. Those are the things that happen on these long-running shows. It's not just like, oh, now it's easy.
[58:25] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah.
[58:25] Joe Carroll: It's like, no, things start to get harder.
[58:28] Caitlin Houlahan: Right.
[58:29] Dan Tracy: I think. Yeah. Caitlin, I know you did um you did Waitress for a long time, and I feel like we could have spent hours and hours just talking about that. And maybe we will have you back on and talk about it someday. But I want to talk about North Country.
[58:41] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah.
[58:41] Dan Tracy: Just because I know that that's where you would be right now. And and we were really excited to have you on to talk about it if it were happening and now it's kind of in flux. Were you guys in previews when uh the shutdown came?
[58:55] Caitlin Houlahan: No, we opened Thursday night. Uh we had Sunday and Monday off where we recorded our cast album and then Wednesday we shut down. So we were open for like basically a week.
[59:10] Dan Tracy: Uh which honestly wait, is that cast album out yet?
[59:13] Caitlin Houlahan: It's not, but it's coming out.
[59:15] Caitlin Houlahan: Can't wait.
[59:18] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, yeah, it's interesting because traditionally Bob Dylan shows do not do well on Broadway. Uh, you know, there were historically times they are a change.
[59:30] Caitlin Houlahan: Exactly. Um, and my dressing roommate, Kimber Lane Sprawl, we went all out because it was our first time like being in the original casts of something, and we had our room, and so we made it beautiful, and we spent a lot of money on making it gorgeous. And I said to her, like, I really hope we're here for a long time. And then like a week after opening, we, you know, this happens. So I really hope that we can get back and enjoy our dressing room.
[1:00:01] Joe Carroll: Um, you know, we put a lot of effort into it, but we hope you can get back too.
[1:00:08] Caitlin Houlahan: Do you guys have any info on that?
[1:00:12] Caitlin Houlahan: They keep telling us, the producers keep telling us, like when it comes back, we're gonna be back. Um, they feel really adamant that it's a show that is really parallel to what's happening right now because, um, if you guys know or not, it takes place during the depression. Um, and the whole message is to keep pressing on.
[1:00:33] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, and so I think that it could be a really important message for people to see when we come back. Um, I mean, I think we have all the same fears that everyone else has about how do you come back? Uh, how do you have people in a theater sitting by each other? And if you don't have people sitting by each other, how do you financially survive? And, uh, so the producers have told us we're coming back, we have no idea when that will be. You guys will probably hear before we tell you because we're just gonna go by what the Broadway league says, what the government says.
[1:01:16] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[1:01:16] Caitlin Houlahan: Right.
[1:01:16] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[1:01:18] Joe Carroll: What was the process like at the public? Because I think it's every actor's dream to work at the public and to also be in a hit at the public, which is like about the coolest thing that anyone can ask for as an actor, you know, that's what Hamilton did. And like you're like down at the public, like, you know, downtown theater, grimy, like doing a cool Bob Dylan show.
[1:01:38] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah. Singing a great song, playing a great role. It was pretty cool. Um, first of all, the thing that I love about my role in Girl from the North Country is it is so much easier than Waitress. So it's been that part's really nice. Um, and the song is much easier to sing. It's one of those songs that you can sing when you're sick, which I feel like is every actor's dream. Um, love that. So yeah, I lived in Brooklyn at the time, so the commute was amazing. It was like 15, 20 minutes. Um, down to the downtown area is just so cool, and it's not midtown. Um, you know, so there's not a crazy amount of tourists, but working there, everyone is warm and kind and helpful, and um, it's like going into work every day is a joy, and it feels like you're walking into a warm hug.
[1:02:33] Caitlin Houlahan: And like there are a lot of things about the theater that I remember fondly, like all six of six, seven of us girls were in one dressing room. Um, and so it just kind of like evened people out, you know. We all kind of felt like equals, and um, not that we don't feel that way on Broadway, but there's definitely more of like a hierarchy. Um, you know, we were the amazing thing about the public is it's a good paycheck, and you also like the work week is um, you have evening shows all week and then you have two Saturday, two Sunday, um, which honestly you don't mind. I feel like I didn't mind the five show weekend as much because it was all like we had every day during the week open.
[1:03:21] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, but playing to sold out audiences, like we knew we were this hit, but like there were also like people who would come to see it who would leave at intermission because it was like ticket holders who like didn't know what they were getting into. Um, but it was kind of cool because I've never been a part of a theater show that people felt really strongly one way or the other about. We had a lot of people who would come in and just say, like, I don't understand, I don't get it, it's not my cup of tea, and other people who are like this is the best show I've ever seen.
[1:04:00] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, totally the point. It's awesome. It's like art is supposed to make you feel something, and if it's making you feel uncomfortable, like that reflects on yourself and like what you need to look at in your life.
[1:04:17] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah.
[1:04:18] Caitlin Houlahan: So that part was really cool. Um, and like occasionally, like, I mean, we the people who came to the public, like the names, like um, Paul McCartney came to see the show.
[1:04:30] Joe Carroll: Um, like no, we didn't.
[1:04:35] Caitlin Houlahan: Yes, and I accidentally told someone that John Lennon came to see our show, and they were like, Are you sure?
[1:04:44] Joe Carroll: You're like, you're like a lot of people are season ticket holders of the public. John Lennon is not one of them, unfortunately.
[1:04:53] Caitlin Houlahan: A lot of famous people, but it was Paul McCartney. But we what is yeah, that's really funny to me that the ghost of John Lennon is the only person who can get a ticket to see Girl from the North Country at the public. Yep, he stood in the bath and yeah, um, but um, yeah Bob came one night and we weren't sure if he was gonna come or not. Um, I don't think he had ever seen any of the other Bob Dylan shows. There was like always a seat available for him like every night just in case he showed up.
[1:04:55] Caitlin Houlahan: My god, it's waiting for Goffman literally waiting for Guffman waiting for Dylan. So we uh, we knew he was there one night because uh Oscar, who like runs the public, Oscar Eustace, the artistic director, yep he was sitting on the stairs like anytime he would come to see the show like he wouldn't sit in a seat he like would sit on the stairs but he was sitting like really close to the front so we could all see him and he's just beaming and like he's like a really tall like big guy like he's a big dude.
[1:04:55] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, he took up the whole staircase like because he was like lounging because he was like in heaven that like okay the show's going Bob Dylan's here he's like so excited that like the energy was amazing. Um, and we didn't get to meet him but he uh allegedly they were trying to like pull him out while we were doing our bows and he like wouldn't go because he wanted to like stay and like watch the bows and he had cried because he just loved it so much.
[1:06:26] Caitlin Houlahan: So that was huge like that that was amazing really cool.
[1:06:31] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[1:06:31] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, and I feel like it would have had a totally different feel had that been a Broadway experience.
[1:06:38] Joe Carroll: Totally.
[1:06:38] Caitlin Houlahan: You know, when you only have like 500, 600 seats, like you can see everybody, right? Um, so it just feels really intimate and feels more like uh like you're really like creating art and sharing it with people.
[1:06:56] Joe Carroll: Yeah. Had you felt like had you been a part of anything else that had that type of buzz to, I mean, like we do things, you know, different readings and workshops and stuff, but that feels like it must have been really special, just a special audition, a special, you know, project from the beginning.
[1:07:11] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, yeah, I've never been a part of something like that. Um, I went into it not sure how it was gonna go, but having a good feeling about it. Um, especially like it being a Connor McPherson show. I didn't know him before I went in, but of course I like talked to my fiancé Ryan. He was like, he's like one of my favorite playwrights. He's Irish, like the director, also, yeah, and he and he directed, and so and he ended up being there, and it was just like uh it was just really awesome.
[1:07:44] Caitlin Houlahan: And I got called back and they were pairing us with people, and I uh went to school with Colton Ryan. Uh, he also went to BW. And so and I was sitting in the hallway thinking to myself, like, I wonder if Colton went in for the show, and he like walked around the corner. And so it was like very like weird, and we went in like together, and he kept telling them, like, we went to school together. Like you can't keep trying to, you know, like we've done shows.
[1:08:14] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, that whole experience was like really nice and going into a show, already knowing your scene partner and not having to really go through the like, where are you from? Like, do you have a girlfriend, boyfriend? Like, you know, it just like we already knew each other, so we kind of like skipped past that and we were able to just like be really real with each other with like the text and yeah.
[1:08:38] Joe Carroll: That's amazing. Cool. We've taken up a lot of your time. Um, I want to wrap up here. We have two questions we ask everyone, so we're gonna launch into those.
[1:08:47] Caitlin Houlahan: Okay.
[1:08:47] Joe Carroll: Um mine is what piece of advice would you give to a young Caitlin Houlahan, somebody who's starting in the biz now, maybe something that you wish you'd known when you were 13, 14, 15, 16.
[1:09:04] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, so I have a like stock answer for this, but I really like it. So this is a generic question.
[1:09:12] Joe Carroll: No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
[1:09:13] Caitlin Houlahan: Not at all.
[1:09:14] Joe Carroll: Well, first of all, it is a generic question.
[1:09:14] Caitlin Houlahan: It is.
[1:09:20] Caitlin Houlahan: Okay. I have a I have like a phrase that I feel like encompasses what advice I would give to people, which is work your quirks.
[1:09:31] Caitlin Houlahan: Um, if I work your quirks, work your quirks. And uh, I just think that if I would have tried to find out about myself and had those parts shine rather than try to be like other people I saw, I think I would have uh gotten a lot farther. And when I kind of discovered that and realized that that's like what was getting me jobs or like making people like smile or laugh, then uh that's when I feel like I started like really succeeding.
[1:10:02] Joe Carroll: I love that.
[1:10:03] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah.
[1:10:04] Joe Carroll: Ooh, that's really good.
[1:10:05] Caitlin Houlahan: That's really good.
[1:10:06] Joe Carroll: I couldn't agree more.
[1:10:08] Caitlin Houlahan: Totally.
[1:10:09] Joe Carroll: I couldn't agree more. Um, and then my question that I ask is the it's called our um impossible dream question, which is kind of like, what do you see for yourself a million years from now? What do you what do you what's on the horizon for you? What do you what do you point it towards?
[1:10:25] Caitlin Houlahan: Does it have to do with theater?
[1:10:27] Joe Carroll: Like does it.
[1:10:28] Caitlin Houlahan: Not in the slightest.
[1:10:29] Joe Carroll: Okay, cool.
[1:10:30] Caitlin Houlahan: I don't really know where I see my theater career going, so I'm just gonna like let that happen.
[1:10:35] Joe Carroll: Um, that's also perfect.
[1:10:36] Caitlin Houlahan: That's a perfect answer.
[1:10:37] Joe Carroll: And that's all the time we have to draw today.
[1:10:41] Caitlin Houlahan: It really is, because like I'd love that too, just let it happen, you know.
[1:10:44] Joe Carroll: Yeah, the career stuff. But I think if it wasn't career, like if I could really do anything I wanted to do, I really would love this.
[1:10:51] Caitlin Houlahan: Is like a new dream that I'm having. That's why I'm so excited about it. I would like to own a farm someday and like, you like farm animals and like just let them like live and take care of them all in.
[1:11:03] Joe Carroll: Yeah, that's my new dream.
[1:11:05] Caitlin Houlahan: So we want to have we want to rescue owls.
[1:11:08] Joe Carroll: Ooh, that's really cool.
[1:11:11] Caitlin Houlahan: Uh, how is how is how is well you you haven't been home, but I wanted to tell you that we're thinking about moving to Western.
[1:11:20] Joe Carroll: Where?
[1:11:21] Caitlin Houlahan: When?
[1:11:22] Joe Carroll: Well, I can't say that on air.
[1:11:23] Caitlin Houlahan: Oh, I'm not allowed to talk about it.
[1:11:24] Joe Carroll: Well, you're not gonna okay, got it, got we should we should yeah, check in.
[1:11:27] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, we will.
[1:11:28] Dan Tracy: Dan wants to move to the country.
[1:11:29] Caitlin Houlahan: He was like, he was like, Okay, here are the things we gotta talk to Caitlin about. One was, you know, moving to the country for those who are like what the hell are they talking about? Caitlin doesn't live in Manhattan anymore. She and her fiancé live in Terrytown in Westchester, which is like 50 minutes from the city, and um I've always like you've been the emblem for me. I've been like, okay, cool. So I could do a theater and like live out there because like the city life is not for me.
[1:11:59] Caitlin Houlahan: You're also like in the heart of the city too.
[1:12:02] Caitlin Houlahan: Yes. And I have a beautiful apartment and we have outdoor space, and we're so lucky to have that. And there's financially it's a great place to be, but like Yeah, for your happiness, I definitely recommend it. It was really scary to make the move, especially because we didn't the only people that we knew who lived up there were either like, you know, Audra McDonald, who like has her own, you know, like a ranch.
[1:12:25] Caitlin Houlahan: Yeah, like it's crawling land, and like friends who like had kids, and we were like, okay, like is this crazy for us to do? And it was it was a really scary move to do, but I honestly would never take it back. Um, we would love to eventually move into a house if that's even possible because it's absurdly expensive, but um, you know, one day.
[1:12:49] Joe Carroll: I love it. Well, we'll see you there.
[1:12:50] Caitlin Houlahan: Great. Thank you so much for taking the time this morning to talk to us.
[1:12:55] Caitlin Houlahan: North Country's coming back. We know it's gonna happen.
[1:12:56] Joe Carroll: North Country's coming back, and we will be plugging that cast album away.
[1:13:01] Caitlin Houlahan: We'll be in my ears.
[1:13:03] Caitlin Houlahan: Hopefully soon. I think I mean they said spring, so spring's here, you know.
[1:13:09] Joe Carroll: Yeah.
[1:13:09] Caitlin Houlahan: So hopefully, I hear.
[1:13:12] Joe Carroll: Spring is here.
[1:13:13] Caitlin Houlahan: That's all the time we have for Jesus.
[1:13:16] Joe Carroll: Sorry, sorry, Dan.
[1:13:17] Caitlin Houlahan: Thank you, Caitlin.
[1:13:18] Joe Carroll: I was thinking you're gonna go spring is here.
[1:13:20] Caitlin Houlahan: I'm a fool.
[1:13:21] Joe Carroll: Damn it. You know that song, Spring is Here, I'm a Fool If I Fall Again.
[1:13:25] Caitlin Houlahan: You say you love me, then then it's the ad lib verse of some classic golden age song.
[1:13:30] Joe Carroll: Oh.
[1:13:31] Caitlin Houlahan: You guys love musicals.
[1:13:33] Joe Carroll: I know.
[1:13:34] Caitlin Houlahan: That's true.
[1:13:35] Joe Carroll: Caitlin, thank you so much.
[1:13:38] Caitlin Houlahan: Oh, it's been a joy. Thanks for thinking of me.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
