Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Izzy McCalla: There is Room For All of Us

She's Jasmine, she's Alyssa, she's the dance captain of the 2012 University of Michigan production of Chicago where Dan and Joe wore mesh shirts and pretended they were Fosse dancers. LOOK IT UP. Actually ... please don't... Read More

From the show: Guys Who Like Musicals

1 h 1 min
5/22/20

Featured Shows

About

She's Jasmine, she's Alyssa, she's the dance captain of the 2012 University of Michigan production of Chicago where Dan and Joe wore mesh shirts and pretended they were Fosse dancers. LOOK IT UP. Actually ... please don't. Izzy has been seen in Aladdin on tour and on Broadway and is best known for her portrayal as Alyssa in THE PROM on Broadway. She was working on the out of town tryout of Jeffery Seller's FLY at the La Jolla Playhouse when the pandemic hit. We are SO STOKED for this one. FLY is a new iteration of the classic Peter Pan story where Wendy – a girl seduced by the mysteries of Neverland, and struggling with her own impending womanhood – is the focus of this singular version of the Peter Pan story that combines stunning choreography and an exhilarating, percussive score. We chat this week with Izzy about how the work never stops (take those voice lessons people), how we limit ourselves, and, our favorite, "you can't move forward if you're looking side to side." WE LOVE YOU IZZY.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Joe Carroll: Start spreading the news.

[0:07] Dan Tracy: Uh just got back today.

[0:12] Joe Carroll: Back in old New York today.

[0:17] Dan Tracy: Wow.

[0:18] Joe Carroll: This place is insane.

[0:20] Dan Tracy: So an actor is saying his lines, and then out of nowhere, he just starts singing.

[0:28] Joe Carroll: Bob 678.

[0:31] Dan Tracy: Live with the song.

[0:36] Joe Carroll: Don't cry for me.

[0:43] Dan Tracy: Yeah, why'd you come home?

[0:44] Joe Carroll: Yo, what we missed home.

[0:46] Dan Tracy: We missed home so much.

[0:48] Joe Carroll: We got back yesterday night late.

[0:50] Dan Tracy: Um and we were just talking about it.

[0:54] Joe Carroll: We just went to I just went on a little jog through Central Park, and I and I, you know, 99% of the people I was passing were jogging or riding bikes with masks on.

[1:03] Dan Tracy: Which is a sight to see because people are not doing that in Grand Rapids, Michigan.

[1:08] Joe Carroll: I will tell you what. For so there's nothing that can't hold New York is down. They're gonna beat the virus, they're gonna put it in a box, and they're gonna smash it with a Yankees bat.

[1:19] Dan Tracy: Go Mets.

[1:20] Joe Carroll: Go socks.

[1:22] Dan Tracy: Go socks.

[1:23] Joe Carroll: Speaking of baseball, what'd you do this week?

[1:27] Dan Tracy: You posted something to our Instagram.

[1:29] Joe Carroll: Oh yeah.

[1:30] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[1:31] Joe Carroll: I was like, uh, what did I do this week? I sat in my apartment, the same thing I did last week and the week before.

[1:35] Dan Tracy: For the last 10 weeks, exactly.

[1:37] Joe Carroll: Um but uh no, you posted uh we got a little Instagram well, that's why I got confused because it wasn't just what I did, it was what we did.

[1:44] Dan Tracy: We did, I know, but you posted it because you're the social media guy.

[1:47] Joe Carroll: I do have access to it. So if you do if you get a weird comment from me on Instagram from guys who like musicals, or if you see guys any weird comments at all, it's Joe.

[1:48] Dan Tracy: Or if you see guys who like musicals liking Joe Carroll's comments on Instagram, that's just me liking my own shit.

[2:03] Joe Carroll: Um Thank you for your contribution.

[2:05] Dan Tracy: Yeah, you're so welcome.

[2:06] Joe Carroll: Um so we made a thing.

[2:08] Dan Tracy: Yeah, we made a thing.

[2:09] Joe Carroll: We wrote it, we wrote a show, um, and Dan posted it to Instagram, and people are like, what's going on?

[2:14] Dan Tracy: And so once we we want to share it. We're we have ideas to share it, and we're gonna hopefully, you know, hopefully people can get an opportunity to hear it, read it, see it, maybe see it.

[2:26] Joe Carroll: Hopefully see it, maybe hear it. Basically, at this point, I spent the entirety of my time on this show forcing myself to do things by telling people on the show that I was gonna do them.

[2:39] Dan Tracy: I'm the same way. I it's just about I'm gonna start a YouTube channel in 2020, and I said it on the show, so then I had to do it.

[2:46] Joe Carroll: You had to do it.

[2:46] Dan Tracy: And that's definitely except for the care packages.

[2:48] Joe Carroll: Yeah, no, oh my god, that's the care packages.

[2:51] Dan Tracy: Oh my god.

[2:52] Joe Carroll: Well, now it's kind of not safe to go to UPS. So, like, we're just not gonna do it.

[2:56] Dan Tracy: We're just not gonna send you anything. Uh, because of actually, you know what, we should get back to that because I do have a lot of we got some swag that needs to be sent out.

[3:05] Joe Carroll: Right now that you're at home.

[3:06] Dan Tracy: Yeah, no, we do. Um also we've gotten a bunch of Patreon love, which has been cool, and a bunch of people but so so you're all gonna get uh um some messages from us.

[3:17] Joe Carroll: Thank you for your support on there. Um this week we have a really fun conversation with Izzy McCalla, our friend Izzy.

[3:24] Dan Tracy: Uh she we went to school together.

[3:26] Joe Carroll: She was a freshman when I was a senior.

[3:28] Dan Tracy: Um uh she was the dance captain of Chicago, where Dan Tracy and I were dancing in the chorus of Chicago.

[3:37] Joe Carroll: If you want that bootleg, it has been destroyed. And I am certain that there are no copies of it anywhere, but we were wearing mesh shirts.

[3:46] Dan Tracy: And uh you know what a reckless time that was.

[3:50] Joe Carroll: We were just trying, man. You and I were just saying we said yes, we are going to try, and we were trying to be Fosse dancers.

[3:57] Dan Tracy: Front and center at Roxy.

[3:59] Joe Carroll: Oh my god. That was highlight for sure.

[4:01] Dan Tracy: Yep.

[4:02] Joe Carroll: Yep.

[4:02] Dan Tracy: It was up there.

[4:03] Joe Carroll: Just us in Posse with RJ and Sam Lips.

[4:07] Dan Tracy: Who else was in it?

[4:08] Joe Carroll: Um, I don't know, but that that's yeah, just a classic memory.

[4:08] Dan Tracy: Oh, Travis.

[4:08] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[4:08] Dan Tracy: Just a classic memory of college.

[4:16] Joe Carroll: And Izzy now, you know, she was this young freshman who Linda Goodrich are um on the faculty of Michigan loved.

[4:25] Dan Tracy: And we were like, oh wow, she's fierce. She can really dance.

[4:27] Joe Carroll: She can really dance.

[4:28] Dan Tracy: She can really dance.

[4:30] Joe Carroll: She just dances her face off for four years.

[4:32] Dan Tracy: She graduates and not a year and a half later is playing Jasmine in the first national tour of Aladdin.

[4:38] Joe Carroll: Exactly. Just like, whoa.

[4:40] Dan Tracy: Just hash, you know, just straight up not dancing at all.

[4:43] Joe Carroll: Um, which is Yeah.

[4:44] Dan Tracy: And so she takes us through that whole story of how she ended up there and how Casey how she got Casey Nicholaw to fall in love with her, which is not hard to imagine listening to the conversation because she's probably one of like the nicest and like friendliest and easiest to talk to guests we've had.

[5:01] Joe Carroll: Um, too. Like if you look sometimes you listen to those people and you're like, is that person really that nice?

[5:08] Dan Tracy: Absolutely.

[5:09] Joe Carroll: The answer's yes.

[5:10] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[5:10] Joe Carroll: Um she works really hard and she can basically do everything.

[5:14] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[5:14] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[5:15] Dan Tracy: And uh you may know her from The Prom on Broadway.

[5:19] Joe Carroll: Yeah, where she actually originated an ensemble role as an understudy for Alyssa out of town in Atlanta, and found herself offered the lead about a year later, which is it's wild.

[5:33] Dan Tracy: One of those crazy stories of you know, just putting the work in and then being in the right place at the right time.

[5:39] Joe Carroll: Absolutely.

[5:39] Dan Tracy: Absolutely.

[5:39] Joe Carroll: And so we go through all of that and it was really fun to hear that story because it is an incredible journey. I mean, from uh, you know, a lot of times like we talked about, understudies don't always get, you know, their shot.

[5:49] Dan Tracy: And not only did she get her shot, she got it um when she opened the show.

[5:53] Joe Carroll: Um and it's so it's really fun to hear all that.

[5:56] Dan Tracy: And I love the Casey Nicholaw stuff, because I don't I don't know Casey Nicholaw.

[5:59] Joe Carroll: Um but man, does he sound he sounds like a cheeky a cheeky dude?

[6:05] Dan Tracy: Like he's kinda yeah, he there's uh Izzy has all these stories of um basically, you know Casey Nicholaw texting her or calling her and being like, Hey, um I'm about to change your life like crazy, but it's no big deal.

[6:17] Joe Carroll: Uh do you want to like be Aladdin uh do you want to be uh Princess Jasmine on Broadway? You know, um and so it's very cool, very fun.

[6:24] Dan Tracy: Um and um God, she's an unbelievable talent. She's working she was working on Fly, um, the new uh Jeffrey Sellers musical uh with Andy Blank and Bueller out in uh San Diego and they were working on that and uh when the pandemic hit and so she's camped out in San Diego still.

[6:41] Joe Carroll: Uh but that was a show that everybody was super duper stoked about and will absolutely hear from eventually.

[6:47] Dan Tracy: Um it's the Neverland story, it's Peter Pan uh told uh sort of revisited and she she she said that she plays Tink and that that her Tink is a rock star, which I love.

[6:56] Joe Carroll: But basically that's about all we know about the show in general. It's kind of a new experimental you know telling of Peter Pan.

[7:02] Dan Tracy: We everybody loves that um uh that story, so it'll be uh really sick to to see that when when all this settles down.

[7:09] Joe Carroll: But um we're so grateful that uh little Izzy Izzy will always be a freshman in in our eyes, I think a little bit, but god she's a full-fledged uh Broadway star, and uh that's sure she sure is and we're so grateful that she sat down with us.

[7:24] Dan Tracy: So without further ado, Dan cue the Aladdin music here.

[7:32] Joe Carroll: No, we can't do that, right?

[7:34] Dan Tracy: No.

[7:35] Joe Carroll: Okay.

[7:55] Dan Tracy: Hi, Izzy.

[7:56] Joe Carroll: Hi, Izzy.

[7:57] Izzy McCalla: Hi.

[7:59] Dan Tracy: Welcome to Guys Who Like Musicals.

[8:03] Izzy McCalla: I'm so good. I'm so happy to be here with the guys who like musicals.

[8:07] Joe Carroll: You know these guys who like musicals.

[8:09] Izzy McCalla: I do.

[8:10] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[8:11] Izzy McCalla: I feel like I learned to like musicals even more around you guys who like musicals.

[8:16] Joe Carroll: Like that's very nice.

[8:17] Izzy McCalla: Is that a Michigan reference or is that just our podcast?

[8:20] Dan Tracy: No, that was a Michigan reference.

[8:21] Izzy McCalla: Also I decided to wear my I have a here.

[8:24] Dan Tracy: Hey, look at that.

[8:26] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, Dan's got a hat.

[8:27] Dan Tracy: I have my hat.

[8:28] Izzy McCalla: She's got a shirt.

[8:29] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[8:30] Izzy McCalla: Go blue, we'll get that out of the way.

[8:32] Dan Tracy: Yeah, we'll get it out of the way.

[8:33] Joe Carroll: Turn it off if you're annoyed, whatever.

[8:35] Izzy McCalla: I know.

[8:37] Dan Tracy: So sorry.

[8:41] Joe Carroll: Um so where are you right now? You were you were working on Fly at the La Jolla Playhouse with um a whole bunch of amazing people.

[8:48] Izzy McCalla: Um, and what what's happening?

[8:51] Izzy McCalla: Um, nothing is happening.

[8:54] Dan Tracy: Nothing is happening.

[8:55] Izzy McCalla: Uh the La Jolla Playhouse was wonderful enough to let whoever wanted to stay in their company housing.

[9:03] Dan Tracy: So there are about, I think, like 12 members of the cast that decided to stay here.

[9:08] Izzy McCalla: And so for the past what, nine weeks has it been? Nine or ten weeks? Crazy.

[9:12] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[9:12] Izzy McCalla: Just I've just been riding it out on the West Coast, which has been lovely because I have access to nature, which has kind of kept me sane.

[9:19] Joe Carroll: Totally.

[9:19] Izzy McCalla: And my best friend, who will you also know Storm lives right below me?

[9:22] Dan Tracy: Oh, great.

[9:23] Izzy McCalla: So I have some plug.

[9:25] Dan Tracy: So it's been a good thing.

[9:26] Izzy McCalla: That's good.

[9:27] Joe Carroll: The worst thing in the world for me.

[9:29] Dan Tracy: Where were you guys in the process?

[9:30] Joe Carroll: Uh in with in you know opening Fly when when all this went down.

[9:35] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, we had just opened.

[9:36] Dan Tracy: So we opened a Sunday night.

[9:38] Izzy McCalla: We had three weeks of previews, and then we were supposed to have three more weeks of a run.

[9:42] Izzy McCalla: And we opened Sunday and then we closed on Thursday.

[9:45] Dan Tracy: It was the same day, March 12th that Broadway closed down.

[9:48] Izzy McCalla: Got it.

[9:48] Dan Tracy: Uh I remember waking up seeing that announcement and knowing in my gut that I was like, okay, this is we're not gonna be around for much longer.

[9:56] Izzy McCalla: And then at like noon on the dot, we got the email saying that the production was canceled.

[10:02] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[10:03] Izzy McCalla: And um wow.

[10:05] Dan Tracy: Yeah, the rest is uh the rest is a waiting game.

[10:08] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, right.

[10:09] Dan Tracy: Well, it was such a cool this, it was such a cool project.

[10:13] Izzy McCalla: I mean, it was so this is a big deal.

[10:15] Dan Tracy: This is a big deal, and I think for people who kind of don't know Fly I and I want you to talk about it, but it was Jeffrey Sellers' directorial kind of uh debut in a way.

[10:26] Izzy McCalla: I mean, you know, the executive producer of Hamilton and in the Heights and Rent and another Michigan graduate, a guy who is really at the top of the game.

[10:33] Dan Tracy: Um, an incredible team, Jeremy Davis and I were working on Frozen at the time when uh he uh left Frozen to to um to head out to San Diego to do uh work on Fly.

[10:43] Izzy McCalla: So what is this process been like? What's what's been what was it going, you know, before everything headed south, it was really you know, we were all really excited about it.

[10:51] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, um it was so much fun.

[10:54] Izzy McCalla: It was it was crazy.

[10:55] Izzy McCalla: I I we got I remember we got to the rehearsal the first day, and uh Jeffrey Sellers was very adamant about he wanted this to be a playground and um he wanted us to like come into Neverland and our version of Let Neverland is told through Wendy's eyes, and it's about her coming of age, and our thesis for our show is growing up is good and growing old is good.

[11:18] Izzy McCalla: And he comes to realize that throughout the course of the story.

[11:21] Izzy McCalla: And um I played Tink, the fairy, uh the impetuous really I she was kind of like punk rocker Tink.

[11:30] Izzy McCalla: I ended up cultivating I flew the entire time.

[11:35] Izzy McCalla: I think there was like two moments where my feet touched the ground, which was that's so sick.

[11:41] Dan Tracy: Have you flown before?

[11:42] Izzy McCalla: No, I never had.

[11:44] Izzy McCalla: And uh actually it was funny, like for the callback for the audition was basically just strength training class because they had to see have the core strength to hold ourselves in the harness.

[11:54] Dan Tracy: Right.

[11:54] Izzy McCalla: Yeah.

[11:55] Izzy McCalla: So we did three weeks in the studio, or f we had four weeks in the studio, but our last week in the studio, they pulled myself and the Wendy and the Peter out into the theater to tech some of the flying earlier.

[12:09] Izzy McCalla: So we like had harnesses melded like shaped for us, and it was a it was a it was a big learning curve.

[12:17] Izzy McCalla: I had to, the hardest part about flying oddly is staying facing front. Because I, you're, we were on a line that spins. Uh-huh. It can go wherever. And it's, it can go this way, and then sometimes they'll have a kick when they swing you forward and back. But for the most part, if you're standing, you're just going side to side. But I would constantly be like trying to do something, and my line would just start turning. And then you kind of have to like swim around. Oh my god. I mean, and there, some of the cast members have videos of like the first day. Like I, there were points when I'd have to sit on top of the door frame or like sit on top of the pirate ship and land and just so clumsy. It was just, I wanted to look like flying was, I've been doing this for five thousand years, and that took some time. But it was really, really fun to do. And the people were so funny and so wonderful.

[13:06] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[13:06] Izzy McCalla: And it was fun to do something funny. That was cool.

[13:09] Joe Carroll: That's so sick. I imagine this, I imagine like flying seems, always seems to be, look so balletic. And I wonder, I mean, you've, you, uh, at Michigan, I mean you were like dancer, dancer extraordinary, and still I rem, I wonder if some of that training came back because you've been, you know, kind of in the acting leading the show. And we're gonna get into all the cool things that you've done, but like did, did dance come back in that way where you're like, Oh yeah, I've been doing this, I actually know this feeling a little bit.

[13:36] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, it definitely helped 100%. So much, especially with ballet, like so much of it is core work and, um, learning how to control your body and stay up, manipulate certain specific muscle groups. Um, so that was helpful, especially in terms of like creating her body language was really fun to play with that and the ballet helped with that. However, I kept getting the note, don't dance up there. I wanted to be free through the air. Uh yes. And so like they wanted to make sure that the fairy was different. She, she didn't live in a ballet company, you know.

[14:12] Dan Tracy: Right.

[14:13] Izzy McCalla: She's, she just happens to be graceful in a different way. So I had to kind of fight my dance impulses, but it helped the balance and, uh, grace.

[14:24] Joe Carroll: Yeah. That's really interesting. And also I applaud them for that level of detail because, you know, musical theater of old is like everyone just points your feet and we all look like we're trained dancers, but that's not necessarily authentic to any story, so like let's challenge that idea, and I think that that's really awesome.

[14:43] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, it was really cool and, uh, fun. I mean, and our, uh, head of the director, his name is Pichon Valdez, and he did this, um, kind of like the precursor to Fuerza Bruta. Um, it was all flying and all acrobatics. And he also choreographed the Tarzan flying too.

[15:02] Joe Carroll: Okay.

[15:03] Izzy McCalla: And he has a fly company in Argentina and they travel around, and so he tells stories through flying. So it was incredible to work hands-on with him and for him to, like, I feel like I didn't find my character until I was up in the air and could—

[15:09] Dan Tracy: How could you, right?

[15:20] Izzy McCalla: Yeah.

[15:20] Dan Tracy: Right. That's awesome. Well, I hope that people get to see that and that the, you know, it stays.

[15:25] Izzy McCalla: Oh yeah.

[15:25] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[15:26] Izzy McCalla: I hope that, I mean, before all of this, that it has legs and it gets to move on and have new life, but also through all of this, that all of that happens too. You, I mean, we're obviously gonna get into Prom and we're obviously gonna get into Aladdin and all of the awesome things you've done. Um, but you have one of, you have one of my favorite stories. You have like one of, I remember when we sat down in that beer garden in Midtown and we got to talk about kind of like this was like before all of this had happened to you and Joe mentioned it briefly earlier that when we were at school, I mean you were a dance captain for Chicago when Joe and I were dancing. Dan and I were in the ensemble dancing centers.

[16:11] Izzy McCalla: No man.

[16:21] Dan Tracy: No.

[16:21] Izzy McCalla: You guys are great.

[16:23] Joe Carroll: Thank you.

[16:23] Izzy McCalla: There was no reason we should have been there. But you've all, I mean you were, you were one of the kids like as a freshman, 18 years old, dancing with the juniors and seniors in ballet class. So you always had that foundation. When did you start dancing? How did you get into that before we kind of move forward through it? Like did you always do musical theater training across the board or did you start in dance? How did that all work for you?

[16:49] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, um, okay, so my mom put me in ballet class when I was in third grade, so it's like eight for the discipline of it because I was very rambunctious. Uh, um, she wanted me to be a nuclear physicist. Sorry, mom.

[17:01] Joe Carroll: Sorry, mom.

[17:02] Izzy McCalla: Some her. Um, and I was bad. I mean, everybody's bad at first when they start dancing because you've just started, you have to practice. And then it was like I started training, and then when I was, uh, I think twelve or thirteen, I started taking more classes like jazz and, uh, hip hop and tap dancing and theater dance, and I just, dance became my life and I was like taking nine hours of dance class a week after school. Um, and then I, yeah, dance was primarily it, but I would do the school shows and the musicals and I loved doing that. And, um, I ended up going to a summer program called Martha's Vineyard Musical Theater Lab and it was at Liz Parkinson's Scott Wise.

[17:42] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[17:42] Izzy McCalla: Um, yeah, when that just started, I, my friend, um, told me about it and so I ended up going there for three summers in a row and it was, that was the first time, I'm so sorry, English, I've lost English in this.

[17:56] Joe Carroll: It's all good.

[17:56] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, um, that summer was the first time that I was kind of encouraged and also told like you could do this. I remember we did, um, America, like the number from West Side Story and I got to play Anita in that number and our, like end of program showcase thing and I was 16 and Charlotte Debois said it on us and she pulled me aside after she said you should be, you should be doing this. And I, like up until that point hadn't considered it as a viable career path because at my academics were super important to me and while I loved it, I just thought I would always, I don't know, like become an investigative journalist. That's what I wanted, but, but at that, okay, maybe if somebody who's doing it believes in me, I can actually do this.

[18:42] Dan Tracy: So, um, you know, then it was time junior, senior year applying for colleges and I luckily got into Michigan and it was the best of both worlds. Like I got to get our amazing conservatory based training that we got as well as taking English class with physics majors, you know, and then going to football. It was the best of both worlds.

[19:03] Izzy McCalla: But dance was the foundation for it all and I would not have gotten into Michigan, done anything further than what I had if I hadn't had that base dance training.

[19:14] Joe Carroll: Yeah, that's fascinating because now you're, you know, a singing ingenue actress leading lady to be like and yeah, and so when did, when did that become part of it? Did you feel like you kind of got that foundation at school or were you always a singer kind of for fun?

[19:34] Izzy McCalla: Like I have such a good voice.

[19:38] Izzy McCalla: I thought I was a singer. I, I had a raw, like I did, it was, I had raw potential, like as most people do, but it was untrained and I didn't have the training. And I remember when I auditioned for college, like I had no clue. I didn't, I was just so confident. I was like, Yeah, I have these two songs and I'll get it. It'll be fine, I'll figure it out. And I sang, oh my god, Gimme Gimme and I'll Know from Guys and Dolls. Those might be the top two don't sing songs for college. You know, like again, my dancing got me in.

[20:10] Dan Tracy: Right.

[20:10] Izzy McCalla: Well, no, that's not the truth. I'm sure you sang them, you killed, you sang them well, but it's like I love, I love that fearlessness that at 18, you're like, no, I got it. I'm good.

[20:17] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, I, I don't, I don't know if I would be like, I would be too scared to audition for colleges now with all of the—

[20:18] Joe Carroll: Yeah, I know.

[20:26] Izzy McCalla: We say that a lot, yeah.

[20:27] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[20:27] Izzy McCalla: Um, but no, I remember I, I didn't have a soprano, I didn't know how to vibrate up higher because I didn't have the training. And I played Sarah Brown, my senior year of high school, and, uh, my mom found the tapes hard here, and it was, I kid you not, the straightest tone soprano, just com, so long, so bad, it was horrifying. Um, so yeah, I think in college was when I started, I knew I want, I loved acting and I knew I wanted to build up to being a, you know, a person who was strong enough to play leading roles. Um, but I didn't have that confidence and I wish I did get better in college, but I wish I practiced more in college than I did. I think I had this kind of like fear that I created in my head that like, okay, well, I'm a dancer, so I'm gonna understudy for a while, so I don't, I, they're always gonna be better singers than me.

Like there's no way. So I just didn't. And I think I was getting rid of people hearing me, and like a lot of, we all have insecurities, but it wasn't until I left college that I really started taking singing lessons seriously.

[21:40] Izzy McCalla: And I worked with Chelsea Wilson, she's my voice teacher.

[21:44] Joe Carroll: Oh wow.

[21:44] Izzy McCalla: Yeah.

[21:45] Joe Carroll: Yeah, and she transformed my voice like a year or two out. She was in my class, uh, at Michigan and started her own voice studio after we graduated and has been killing it.

[21:55] Izzy McCalla: Killing it. She's wonderful. Um, it's amazing what practice will do. Truly. I mean, I, I was the same way, like I don't, I didn't, I didn't really feel like I learned how to sing until two or three years out of school. And I'd, and I'd had this long job, but I came off American Idiot, like kind of working with my raw voice to be able to do that punk rock sound, and then afterwards I was like, had fatigue issues for six months, and then I kind of like relearned how to sing, and the foundation of it was actually practicing. What an idea.

[22:28] Joe Carroll: What an idea.

[22:29] Izzy McCalla: What an idea to actually practice.

[22:31] Joe Carroll: Actually practice and we are limited.

[22:34] Izzy McCalla: We actually just limit ourselves.

[22:36] Joe Carroll: Right.

[22:42] Izzy McCalla: Like that has been like one of the biggest things. Like you can't, like it's a fear thing, it's an insecurity thing totally. That's one of my biggest issues.

[22:49] Joe Carroll: Totally.

[22:50] Izzy McCalla: If there's a style that you're not good at, it's only because you haven't practiced it enough, not because you don't have the ability to do it. Like everyone can sing jazz and pop and legit if you learn how to do those things.

[23:03] Joe Carroll: Yep.

[23:04] Izzy McCalla: And I'm talking about the macro, just about life for sure.

[23:08] Joe Carroll: We limit ourselves, you know what I mean.

[23:09] Izzy McCalla: It's just, that's, that's awesome. I love that for sure.

[23:13] Dan Tracy: Yeah. So then you graduate and was your first job, I mean I know you, you worked at the Muni a lot and you did PCO a lot. So you were equity when you graduated?

[23:22] Izzy McCalla: Yes, yes I was. I got my equity card the summer after sophomore year when I worked at Pittsburgh's Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera, um, doing a season there. And, uh, yeah, so luckily I graduated with my equity card. Um, what was the first thing I did out of, I think I did Spawn.

[23:42] Izzy McCalla: Oh no, it was Mary Poppins. So I sprained my ankle really badly like a couple days after I graduated.

[23:50] Joe Carroll: Oh no.

[23:51] Izzy McCalla: Um, and so I was supposed to, I, I was dance captaining, uh, Mary Poppins at Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera with Clinda and Logan Jones.

[24:01] Joe Carroll: Yep.

[24:01] Izzy McCalla: Um, but I couldn't do most of the numbers because of my ankle. That was like the first thing I did, and then I did 42nd Street at the Muni that summer. And then like my first ever regional job I did was, uh, West Side Story at the Oslo Repertory Theater in Florida.

[24:15] Joe Carroll: Uh, Sarasota, yeah.

[24:17] Izzy McCalla: Which is so fun. And, uh, I was in the ensemble of that as a shark girl. Met a lot of like my best friends, did, and then I did another West Side Story right after that, also in Florida at the Actor's Playhouse.

[24:33] Izzy McCalla: Um, I played Anita in that one.

[24:36] Dan Tracy: Sounds like that's followed you around a bit.

[24:41] Izzy McCalla: Oh, yeah. West Side Story. I was even supposed to do a third production of West Side Story that year, but I didn't because I ended up getting Prom in Atlanta, the out-of-town tryout. Um, and so that I had like a break between, oh, then I did Mary Poppins again with Linda at Tetz. Uh, in March, and then I had like four months off before I started Prom when I went down to Atlanta to...

[25:02] Joe Carroll: And you got cast in Prom in the ensemble out of town.

[25:16] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, uh-huh. Yep. I got cast in the ensemble out of town. Oh, and that was the thing. I couldn't go back to the final. I actually, the day after showcase, Prom was my first audition in the city, and so I went to the audition, did the dance call. I got through to the final callbacks, and it was like the day before final callbacks that I actually sprained my ankle, so I couldn't. I went in and sang for Casey and the team, but I couldn't do any of the materials, so I didn't get cast in the lab that summer. And it was the year after that they ended up doing the out-of-town tryout in Atlanta, and so there were some cast shifts, so then I got to join in the ensemble of Atlanta the next year afterwards because he had seen me in like two other auditions.

I went in for Aladdin and Finding Neverland. No, no, it was Aladdin and Tuck Everlasting. That was it. That's what they were doing. I got it. Didn't get both, but I'd been seen by him enough times where he started to be like, "Oh yeah, I remember her." And that's how I kind of got into the ensemble of Prom.

[26:13] Dan Tracy: Yeah. When I remember, I was with Bill Dimashki when you got cast, when you got bumped to the role.

[26:24] Izzy McCalla: Oh.

[26:24] Dan Tracy: Because we were working on Moulin Rouge at the time. And it came, it was like the po— or maybe you had already been cast or whatever, but then it came, you know, the press release happened.

[26:34] Izzy McCalla: Yeah.

[26:35] Dan Tracy: And I was like, dude, you gotta tell me, tell me the story, you know? Like, and so I want to hear it from you, but I got to hear it from him as we were working on that.

[26:45] Izzy McCalla: And it just, it's like, it's kind of a Broadway dreams story.

[26:49] Dan Tracy: So what happened?

[26:53] Izzy McCalla: Um, I so we started rehearsals for Prom in Atlanta, and that was really fun and really, it went really well. And um, when we were in previews, they were starting to cast the Aladdin National Tour. And I remember I was walking to meet up with a cast after a show to get tacos, and I ran into Casey, Casey and Casey, his associate Casey Heshin, was also named Casey, the Casey's, and um, his husband John Parquette. And they were like, "Hey, you know what? I'm like just going to get tacos." He was like, "Hey, by the way, we're casting the Aladdin National Tour. Would you be interested in like going on the road before we know what happens with Prom? Would you be interested in going on the road and understudying Jasmine?" And I was like, "Yeah, I would love to do it."

[27:38] Izzy McCalla: Come on, not an offer to get tacos. It wasn't a full offer. It was just like, would you be interested? And I was like, "Yeah, great, let's set up an informal audition so I can tell the person I've seen you." That's okay. It's still very cool, like over tacos to be like, "Hey, you know, Casey Nicola, whatever, you know."

[27:55] Dan Tracy: So he always, I mean, the entire— he's so casual and he loves to just like drop little things on you like that, and I'm just like, "Yeah."

[27:55] Izzy McCalla: I mean, in the meantime in your head, you're like, "What the hell is happening?" Um, so yeah, so he I got sent the audition material and I'd gone in for it multiple times before, but like never got through past any other round. So we set up like a 10 a.m. on a Tuesday before rehearsals because we were in previews, an audition, and it was just me, my friend Kevin who read the sides with me and Meg Zervulis, who was on the piano, um, who's our associate conductor at Prom and Casey. And we were like, "Okay, let's just like do the song Palace Walls." And so I sang Palace Walls for him. And we did this, then I did the scene with Kevin, and he was like, "Great. So I think you might be able to actually play the role."

[28:49] Izzy McCalla: Um, would you be willing to come to New York for final callbacks in 10 days?

[28:56] Dan Tracy: Short circuit.

[28:57] Izzy McCalla: And I was like, "Uh, yeah, sure." And he gave me things to work on, one of which was like, I couldn't at that point, it was really hard for me to sustain the final note. I didn't have the stamina for it. And he was like, "Can you do that normally?" And I was like, "Yeah, I totally can." I didn't know I could. He was like, "Okay, well, just work on that." And he gave me like some acting beats to work on, different things. He taught me— he gave me tips on how to dress for the audition. It was just like very, it felt like he was rooting for me.

[29:26] Dan Tracy: That's so cool.

[29:27] Izzy McCalla: So for the next 10 days, I behaved like a nun. I was like doing the show. I went home, I shut up, and I just practiced, practiced, practiced. And then I flew into New York on a Monday at like 6 a.m. I went right to Ripley Greer, rented a studio, got dressed, put my face on, had a work session with the associates, sang and did some scenes, and then I went to another terrible— the worst audition I've ever given, which was for this off-Broadway show called, uh, A Taste of Things to Yet to Come or something. Um, so unprepared. I dropped my pages in the audition, my pay— everything was out of order. I forgot the lyrics. Horrible. Finished that up, went back to Pearl, and had my final callback in front of like the entire Disney team and Casey.

[30:17] Izzy McCalla: And I remember leaving that audition feeling like I'd nailed it. Like, regardless of what happens, I felt really proud of the work. And it was the first time I left everything out there. The entire Disney team is like 40 people. There's like 40, 50 people there. Tom Schumacher and Court, right? Every— all of the creative team from Aladdin, and it's just as scary as it sounds. Casey Nickel was my comforting factor in that audition room. She was like, "I was like, hi Casey, how you doing?" Like, that's in what world?

[30:51] Dan Tracy: Right.

[30:52] Izzy McCalla: Um, I remember like singing, and I remember like seeing him like go like this and like slap the person next to me. And like I could feel his support that he was with me, and I think that gave me the impetus to keep going. Um, and that song is about limits. Palace Walls is a song about like, "Why shouldn't I fly so far from here?" Like that's what she says over and over again. It's about her getting the courage up to be more than she is. And so that was like a really cool moment.

[31:21] Izzy McCalla: I left that audition feeling great. I ended up I was gonna fly back the next day, so I went— Helly Fishman, my roommate and best friend who you know.

[31:29] Dan Tracy: Yeah, we went to get drinks in the village, and at midway through dinner, I get a call and I pick up and it's Casey on the phone.

[31:39] Izzy McCalla: And I start running out of the bar. I'm like, "Hi, hi, Casey." I was like, "Izzy, are you in a bar?" And like, "Ah, yeah, sorry. I just I haven't had a drink in a while." Like thinking that he would care.

[31:50] Dan Tracy: Right.

[31:50] Izzy McCalla: He's like, "Where are you? I'll come hang out, you know?"

[31:52] Dan Tracy: Yeah, for that.

[31:54] Izzy McCalla: And he was like, "Well, have another one, girl, because you're gonna play Jasmine."

[31:58] Dan Tracy: Oh my god.

[32:00] Izzy McCalla: Bawling on the streets in New York City. And you know, I couldn't tell anybody, obviously, and that was— it was so fun. And I went back in and told Ellie and we celebrated. I mean, I told her, but yeah, right.

[32:12] Dan Tracy: Um, and then I went back to Atlanta the next day and just kept doing Prom.

[32:18] Izzy McCalla: Uh, and then I ended up going on tour. I know this is such a long-winded story to get to Prom, but it's just perfect.

[32:24] Dan Tracy: It's our p— it's perfect.

[32:26] Izzy McCalla: This is all we want on our podcast.

[32:27] Dan Tracy: So like we've had— we've actually said very little, and you're telling everything that everybody wants to know.

[32:31] Izzy McCalla: So go ahead.

[32:32] Dan Tracy: We talk the better the episode.

[32:34] Izzy McCalla: So great. Then in that case, um, yeah, I finished up the run of Prom in Atlanta, feeling giddy and happy and thrilled and so excited. And five months later, uh, we started rehearsals for Aladdin in Chicago.

[32:55] Izzy McCalla: And uh, we were in Chicago for six and a half months, and I— that actually it was in that five months when I really started revving up my singing training because that's when I was like, I have to step up to the plate. I've been given an incredible opportunity. I cannot— my nightmare, I would have nightmares about getting fired because my voice would go out or I couldn't sustain it.

[33:17] Dan Tracy: Right.

[33:17] Izzy McCalla: Um, and so I started training with Chelsea hardcore. And throughout the run of the show, and I mean, like, I feel like I still like am getting better every—

[33:22] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah.

[33:30] Izzy McCalla: You know, like it's never-ending practice. But um, that was when I really started training um to be a leading lady because I wanted to go into that rehearsal room feeling confident like I could carry a show.

[33:42] Dan Tracy: Right.

[33:42] Izzy McCalla: Um, so yeah, and then rehearsals were great, and the show was so much fun. We did it in Chicago for six and a half months, and I think Casey got to get to know me and my work ethic as a principal.

[33:56] Izzy McCalla: Um, and he'd be— not that he was around all that much, but he came for a week for rehearsals, and then he would check in on the tour every so often. And then we started the tour in February, in September of the same year. I woke up to a text. We were in Minneapolis from Casey, and he said, "Hey Izzy, it's Casey. Um, give me a call when you can, nothing bad, just want to talk to you about something."

[34:24] Izzy McCalla: And so I was like, "Oh fuck, okay." Sounds bad.

[34:27] Dan Tracy: I know.

[34:27] Izzy McCalla: I'd be like— I remember I was still like fully naked in bed, and I was like, "Oh my god, okay, um," like I was zero to ten, right? Heart pounding, I call him, he's like, "Hi, how you doing? How's tour going?" I'm like, "It's great, it's fine," you know, trying to be cool, rambling because I ramble so much when I'm nervous.

[34:49] Izzy McCalla: Jesus. Um, but he was like, "Cool. So um, here's the thing. We— I don't know what your plans are for the future, you know, post Aladdin, but we have been doing some rewrites for Prom."

[35:03] Izzy McCalla: And here I'm saying, he's thinking, okay, he's gonna ask me to be in the ensemble again. We're kind of going, really, truly. I was like, and I was thinking, "Yeah, I'll do that. I have no problem, I can understudy, that's fine." Um, and he was like, "We've done some rewrites. We're thinking of going to Broadway next fall, and we want you to play Alyssa Green."

[35:25] Izzy McCalla: Another short circuit, wanna.

[35:28] Dan Tracy: And I was like, "Okay."

[35:30] Izzy McCalla: He was like, "Okay, yeah." And um, so and I've kind of worked it out with Disney, so that um, we want to— we're gonna have another lab in January. This was September. And he was like, "We're gonna have a lab in January. Um, and I know we don't want to lose you to the tour, so I'm gonna secure your job, but I also— what we're gonna do is we're gonna switch you and Courtney Reed. So she's gonna play Jasmine in LA for six weeks while you come to New York and play Jasmine on Broadway for six weeks. So you'll work as Alyssa Green during the day in the workshop and make your Broadway debut as Jasmine at night."

[36:05] Izzy McCalla: What?

[36:07] Dan Tracy: What?

[36:08] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[36:12] Dan Tracy: Yeah, yeah.

[36:12] Izzy McCalla: Like many times when I mean the many— because he does this, he drops these bombs that life-changing moments, and I'm just like, "Uh, yeah, yeah, of course."

[36:21] Dan Tracy: He was like, "Would that be okay? Would that be something you'd be interested in?"

[36:24] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, of course it'd be something I'm interested in. No, I'm not available. I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. I— you were giving me the opportunity of a lifetime. And so he— know that he's fucking with people, or does he just like, you know what I mean?

[36:37] Izzy McCalla: I think he does because he loves, he like that's awesome. Um when I knew when he called me for Aladdin, he had asked, he was like, can I tell her? He loves to be the person to tell people.

[36:50] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[36:50] Izzy McCalla: And sometimes he'll tell other people, be like, ooh, this person, I think I have a part for them in my next show, and he gets so excited.

[36:56] Dan Tracy: That's so cool.

[36:56] Izzy McCalla: And so loving and joyful that I think it genuinely brings him joy bringing people together and working with certain people. I was so lucky to be folded into that group. And then to work on an original show, that show really spoils me for the rest of my life in terms of collaboration. I mean, the quality of the actors and the professionals, the humans, it's just like it was a perfect group of humans. It was the first time I was in a room and ego wasn't involved. It was about like how do we tell the story better? So writers were scrapping material, actors were scrapping bits, we were just throwing spaghetti at the wall and volleying off each other and laughing all the time. It was so funny and so wonderful.

[37:40] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[37:41] Izzy McCalla: And so that's kind of how I got to be wearing it. But I mean, there's so much that's one of the greatest stories ever. Um and then as the workshop, so take me up to when you're doing the workshop and you're doing Aladdin, what is that, 2017? Is it 2018?

[37:59] Izzy McCalla: No, yeah, 2018. January of 20—no, yes, yes. I'm so sorry. The dates are—no, it's all good because it would be January 2018 because Prom opened October 2018.

[38:10] Dan Tracy: Yes, right.

[38:11] Izzy McCalla: So then 2018, I made my debut on January 14th.

[38:17] Dan Tracy: With Aladdin.

[38:18] Izzy McCalla: With Aladdin.

[38:19] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[38:19] Izzy McCalla: And I started rehearsals for Prom that Monday, and I made my debut on a Wednesday night.

[38:30] Dan Tracy: Or no, it was January 17th.

[38:31] Izzy McCalla: 17th.

[38:33] Dan Tracy: So cool.

[38:37] Izzy McCalla: January 17th. The 14th, I think, was when we started rehearsals or something.

[38:41] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[38:41] Izzy McCalla: And um, yeah, it was crazy. And I was so tired. But you just—there was no option to get the best tired.

[38:50] Dan Tracy: Right.

[38:51] Izzy McCalla: What was that whirlwind like? Like how did you feel? Did it change for you when you—because you'd done this show now for a while and then all of a sudden you step on Broadway? Was it different?

[39:02] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, there were lots of little changes here. Um we had a different number of ensemble cast members on tour versus the—also our set was different.

[39:13] Dan Tracy: It's a tracking, yeah.

[39:14] Izzy McCalla: The tracking was different. Um beats were different. There was a line that was different that I had, and it was in the marketplace. The original line is when they almost get caught by the guards, she steals the apple. Um and Aladdin's like, oh, my sister's a little crazy, and Jasmine has a line when she plays along. Why is that monkey talking to us? For race-related reasons on tour, we changed it to why is that camel talking to us because of who was on the receiving end. It just didn't read correctly. Um so when I got back to New York, when I got to Broadway, they were like, It's monkey, not camel. Monkey, monkey, monkey. And I could not—I was like monkey, camel. I would be like, Why is that McCamel talk a monkey?

I would say it was so—it felt like I was stepping into a parallel universe where like people were in similar places, but they had different faces. But luckily everybody was so kind and loving. Everybody who am is and your stage door is on 41st Street, or you know, it's like you know, it's a parallel life.

[40:27] Dan Tracy: Right over the McDonald's.

[40:29] Izzy McCalla: Right, and also that dressing room spoiled. Courtney Reed had everything so beautifully decorated, and this is like gorgeous spacious dressing room that she has.

[40:39] Dan Tracy: Did you feel different? Um, was it emotionally different? Was it mentally different?

[40:46] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, uh, kinda. It was—I felt the magic a lot of Broadway. It felt like riding that carpet on Broadway for the first time was so crazy. I'm so full of—but I think actually after the first night, it just felt like a job, and I think that might have been because I was so tired, and I had to make sure I was present in both areas, saying the right words in the right place at the right time.

[41:16] Izzy McCalla: Oh my god, and there was one day I left my wallet at the rehearsal studio in Prom, and I realized that in the middle of my first scene as Jasmine. And so I mean what's supposed to happen is I come off my—and I'm supposed to come right back on for Palace Walls, and I went off stage and started going around the back of the stage to get to my dressing room because I was thinking about, fuck, I have to call, I have to—who can I call, the stage manager? Can I call the landlord? My key is in there, how am I gonna get home? And then all of a sudden I hear silence on stage, and I'm halfway around the back of the theater at that point. I was like, fuck! And I just start rushing past people, and the girls, poor girls who play the attendants, are just—I don't know, where's Jasmine?

Like they started ad-libbing for me because I wasn't there. I was just like, I rushed on. She was like, What happened with the Sultan? And I was like, the same thing he always happens. I just like sat down so aggressive and angry and was just so flustered because my mind was in three places. It was like I couldn't focus and concentrate. That was my big flub in New York, but it was fine. It probably wasn't as long as it felt. You know, I feel better. As somebody who missed—if anybody from Waitress is listening to this, I missed a couple of set changes, and I feel better now.

[42:42] Dan Tracy: Yeah, it happens.

[42:43] Izzy McCalla: It happens in the best. The good thing is like when you can laugh at it, right?

[42:47] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[42:48] Izzy McCalla: Or if you have like a real reason, you know, not just like one of my first performances at Frozen, I called Patty Murin Princess Elsa.

[43:02] Dan Tracy: What did you do?

[43:03] Izzy McCalla: I didn't even know that I did it. I didn't even—I just—I said it and Casey looked at me like she was like, what? And then we just kept going and we walked off stage and everybody was laughing. I was like, what are y'all laughing about? It's like I just blacked out for a second.

[43:18] Dan Tracy: Right.

[43:23] Izzy McCalla: Thank you for listening to our show. As always, you can check us out on Instagram at Guys Who Like Musicals or on Twitter at musical guys. And we just started a Patreon page, which is the best way for you to support our show. If you love our show, check it out. There's tons of cool opportunities for listeners on there. So check it out. Thank you so much. Love you.

[43:58] Dan Tracy: Um, this is a—I this is a horrible question, but I want to get into more of the Prom stuff. And I just like the overarching thing is like what you remember most, what you take away, like that experience from an outsider's perspective just looked as remarkable as you said with you know the creativity in creating it, the room, the team behind it, everybody. Uh and I remember like I mentioned, you know, the press release came out and I was talking to Bill Damaschke about he was in love with you and was like, you know, from the Atlanta production to the workshop to the Prom, he was like she's it, she's grown, she's the person we want in that role, um, and we love her and the whole thing. It was so exciting. I mean, what do you take away from it most?

[44:45] Izzy McCalla: What will you remember the most from that process?

[44:47] Izzy McCalla: Oh that's a very good and difficult question. Um it's way too broad. No, but I mean that's a good thing. In the macro, I yeah. I mean, it's the people. It's the relationships. That's because I learned something from everybody in that show.

[45:09] Izzy McCalla: Yeah. Um you know, Beth and Brooks and Angie and Chris taught me how to lead a show with dignity and humility and humor, not take yourself seriously. I learned that joy—I think I remember in college, like I had this idea that I wanted to be a serious actor and I wanted things to be, you know, I wanted to take all the dramatic roles and be taken seriously. And I think I took myself a little too seriously, and I learned in Prom not to take myself seriously.

[45:40] Dan Tracy: Right.

[45:46] Izzy McCalla: And yeah, trust in that. Um still working incredibly hard, hard. Like you worked incredibly hard, but yeah, it's like the freedom of that.

[45:54] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[45:55] Izzy McCalla: It opens up your dramatic work too.

[45:57] Dan Tracy: 100%.

[45:59] Izzy McCalla: And when I what I also learned in that show during being—it was my first time settled in one place doing a show for, you know, not touring, not boring.

[46:12] Dan Tracy: Right.

[46:13] Izzy McCalla: So I got to cultivate my own personal life outside of the show. I think in that time I went to therapy. This is kind of a different ball game, but being in therapy was incredible for me, and it helped me find purpose outside of my job. And I realized I am so much more than what roles I play and what status I have, or like, you know, that's not—and once I became more confident in who I was and I am, my work became so much easier, and it was easier to drop into those difficult moments in those difficult characters because I was more at peace and let myself let it be what it is, you know.

[46:54] Izzy McCalla: Um I think because I had that example with the people in Prom and because I was actively exploring that every day, um, it gave me a sense of confidence and grounding and um play.

[47:12] Dan Tracy: That was probably really important given that it was your first award season too. I can imagine.

[47:20] Izzy McCalla: Um, and you also have these like established veterans who have dealt with this stuff before. Did you find like what was award season like? What's that like for people who don't really know and how did you manage it? And how did people like Beth help you get through it?

[47:36] Izzy McCalla: Um, she was pretty good in Bandstand if anybody has seen Bandstand. I loved the video, the screener. I'm so glad they did that. That was awesome.

[47:45] Dan Tracy: Oh thanks.

[47:46] Izzy McCalla: Specifically give tell me five things. No, I'm just kidding. Um let's—You Joe Carroll phenomenal on the drums.

[47:53] Dan Tracy: That's great.

[47:56] Izzy McCalla: Um but yeah, award season is hard. You don't understand that until you're in it. And we kind of from the second we opened, we never stopped. I don't think there was one week where we didn't have some sort of press event to go to, whether it was like waking up early for Good Morning America, the parade, the there were various interviews that we were doing. Um there was always something, and then award season rolls around and there are all these events that you have to go to. And I didn't even have the brunt of it as a nominee, but like I was a representative for our show, so I—it was very exhausting. Um like you're constantly waking up early, your day is packed full of press events and or brush up rehearsals and or rehearsals for Tonys and or note sessions and you know, a photo shoot that you're doing to ramp up a marketing because that was another thing.

[48:54] Izzy McCalla: Like while our show was great, it was very difficult because we didn't have brand recognition. We had to continue to sell our show. It wasn't just about the Tonies, it was about keeping our show alive. And that was exhausting. And then there was even after the Tonies ended, it was pride. And so we were nonstop. Um and I'm very grateful for my friends for getting me through it. Um, my roommates for letting me be in my room by myself. And uh yeah, it takes a toll. Caitlin and I would cry together; we shared a dressing room, and there were days that we just every other person would cry every other day. I mean, and she was nominated, and so she had a lot more press to do. Um the Instagram content out of the two of you through that process was just unparalleled.

It was just paralleled. Madness. I think that was what was fun is like we had each other to go through that, and she knew, you know, if she was having a bad day, she would come to me and she'd grab my hand, she'd be like, I'm feeling anxious today. And I'd be like, Okay, I'm here for you, whatever you need, and vice versa. We were we just had very open communication lines. Um same with like Beth and Brooks and I mean Beth would like uh come up after Ladies Improving, which was her basic 11 o'clock number and show, and she'd come up the stairs just like and hold the Lay's chips bag out for her afterwards, and you just come in and get your chips and it was little things, it was just daily check-ins, be like, How you doing today?

What's hard for you today? You good and get through this. What event do you have tomorrow? What do you not want to be at tomorrow? And that's what's so difficult. Is like it's not only that you're yes, they're glamorous events that you get to go to, but you have to be on. You have to it's constant networking and smiling and and meeting new people and making good impressions and representing your show. And that is sometimes more exhausting than doing the actual show. The show's the easy part, right? Like that was kind of the break, oddly. Um that's crazy. I mean it does make sense though. I mean, yeah, like I mean, I I find networking to be like very exhausting. You know, you go to these parties and you're it's not it's not a party for you, even though it's a kind of a party for you.

Yeah question mark, you know. It's it's yeah, to well, and that show meant so much to so many people too. I mean, like coming off of like you said coming from the Tony straight into pride, you know, and then getting, you know, through the summer even then to the the Macy's Day Parade, obviously, like you know, the the famous kiss on NBC and national television, which is the coolest thing ever. I mean, did you feel that responsibility in a in a weird way, I imagine?

[51:37] Izzy McCalla: Percent. I because I I knew that this was for a lot of young girls, this was the first time they were seeing themselves represented on stage. Yeah. So I wanted to make sure they felt authentically represented. I didn't want it to be character caricature. I wanted it um I wanted it to resonate with so many kids, and I'm glad that they had two different or two girls who are both lesbians dealing with it in different ways, one who's very confident in who she is, and one who's struggling and terrified of coming out because of how her mother and society is going to oppress her. Um so I made sure that I did my research. I talked to a lot of of my friends who had gone through coming out stories. Um I also was kind of coming to terms with my own sexuality.

I now identify as bisexual. And if I think about it, I have I've been I've had experiences with both men and women since college. Like for a very long time I've been attracted to both sexes, but uh for a long time I felt like I couldn't identify as bisexual because I didn't feel oppressed by it or um yeah, didn't feel the pressure or you know, I it's like there's a double standard, like girls are allowed to experiment, you know what I mean? And so it wasn't until I had a conversation with someone in the community that was like you a young girl doesn't have to have a sexual experience to know she's a lesbian, she just instinctually does. So like and nobody else can give you your own label. Um so in a way, the fans helped me come to terms with to own my sexuality, which was really cool.

Like connecting their stories, talking with them about it was very lovely and wonderful. Um, so it was like a reciprocal helping, mutual helping situation. The show gave a lot of gifts to a lot of people. Um, like you said, it that I mean that is so cool, first of all, but it's it's you know, being able to see yourself represented. It's the representation both in a character that you were portraying, but also in the representation of the people reaching out to you, the people that were talking to you in the stage door line, and like you know, people quite literally coming out to see and experience this piece.

[53:53] Izzy McCalla: Yeah, I mean, there were a couple times where people came out uh at the stage door to their family. Or as the curtain hit the ground. And I mean, there were so many like mothers and children crying and like the hugs we would get were it was to feel like we were the catalyst for them to feel like they could own themselves a little bit more. Yeah. Um and that was so so special. That's the best part of the show, really, is that like that's so cool. To do work and shows that like help people, and the fact that this one did was really cool. That's so sweet. That's amazing. And also you're spoiled, like you said now. It's like, you know, you're like, yeah, you know. Yeah. Because that's the best work.

Yeah. That's the best work is the work that we get to like actually learn from. I think that's the one of the best parts about how I feel about being an actor is that like I'm a better human being because of what I've learned from acting. I'm listening I'm better at listening, I'm better at communicating, I'm better at hearing people and understanding them, and that has informed my life. And but not every show teaches you as much. And so when you have that privilege, you know, it's it's really something that you'll remember and hopefully isn't your peak. Hopefully, you have more of those ahead.

[55:08] Dan Tracy: Oh yeah. I'm sure you do. You're still so young.

[55:13] Izzy McCalla: Oh yeah. Not like us.

[55:15] Joe Carroll: No, no, we're just long in the tooth.

[55:18] Izzy McCalla: So young, both of you involved.

[55:19] Dan Tracy: That's right. Hey, I could still play Disney Prince Princess.

[55:23] Joe Carroll: Yes, you can.

[55:26] Izzy McCalla: Okay. No, that's I know. That's ridiculous. Uh Izzy, um we've taken so much of your time. Like, this was amazing. You are so light and fun. Thank you for talking to us. We'll let you go. Uh, we do two little questions before we end. Um, Dan can go first and then I'll follow up. Do you have any advice for young people uh in the business at all? Anything that you wish you'd really owned when you were in high school, something that that you think about that you wish you really knew?

[56:01] Izzy McCalla: Um I'm bringing it back to good old Brett Wagner, but it's the it's the main one. You can't move forward when you're looking to the side. It kind of encompasses everything that I wish I had actually believed in terms of like I I think I compared myself a lot to other people. And because I compared myself, I limited myself. Um because you'd say I'm not as good as that person at this, so then yeah. Yeah. So like with I going back to the singing thing, like, oh, well, they're clearly much better than I am. So I'm not I would never be at that level. So I'd stop myself from doing that. Um growing from progressing. And I would just urge people to practice and and celebrate other people because there is room on stage for all of us.

It does not matter, like other people's successes are not your failure, you know, really, really, really, and really believe that. Because it was easy to say, but it's one thing to actually believe. And I think that is a practice. I think believing in yourself enough, you know.

[57:08] Joe Carroll: Yeah, or even just believing in the abundance of the world. Yesterday we were talking about that Martha Graham piece that she wrote about how you don't even have to believe in yourself as long as you believe that you have something to offer artistically.

[57:19] Izzy McCalla: Yeah.

[57:20] Joe Carroll: You may never think that your work is good enough, which is okay, but you still have to commit fully to the thing, you know.

[57:27] Izzy McCalla: Yeah. I totally agree with that.

[57:29] Joe Carroll: Yep. That's awesome.

[57:30] Izzy McCalla: Yeah. That's awesome.

[57:31] Joe Carroll: And then and then my question is I call it the unreachable star question, which is kind of like, what do you see on your horizon, you know, a million years from now? Like things, things you're pointed towards artistically, personally, things you're excited about that you want to accomplish down the road.

[57:49] Izzy McCalla: Um, I would love to be able to continue to tell stories that change and impact people. Um I'd love to continue to be able to work on original pieces um and collaborate and tell new stories. I maybe want to write eventually. I don't know. Let's go. That'd be fun. I there have been times that I'm like reading a script, and like, oh, but what if we did this and switch? It's like I have ideas, like there's a voice inside my head that's like, oh, but what about this? So like maybe I'll explore that avenue.

[58:18] Joe Carroll: Um have you talked to Andy Blank and Bueller about this?

[58:22] Izzy McCalla: No. Because if you're you're hanging out with him and that guy will wants to, but like all the time, he's like, Oh, I kind of want to write write this. What about this? Like, he's got 10,000 ideas, like, and he's inspiring that way. So you're you're working with him, and like he can he could point you in a direction with that too. Cause like he he'll also do like the weirdest shit. It's like you know, his ideas are not always great, you know.

[58:43] Izzy McCalla: But they're really appreciate that. I feel like exactly everything is crap until you like pilfer through it, and you're like, oh, there's something. Totally, right? It takes a while, it takes a bit. So yeah, maybe right. Who knows? We'll see. And then, like, this is such a lofty, ridiculous dream, and it actually is enough with my career. Well, it kind of does, but I think there's like I would love to be on the Graham Norton show. Do you guys watch the Graham Norton show ever?

[59:17] Dan Tracy: Yes, okay.

[59:19] Izzy McCalla: So he has like four people on his couch who drink wine and hang out. And I don't I don't even want to be famous or anything like that, but I just think being on that show would be so much fun. I'm obsessed with that. So it has nothing to do, like that's like a silly, silly stupid dream I have. But yeah, but really I want to tell good stories with good people. But put it put it to the universe.

[59:46] Dan Tracy: Awesome.

[59:47] Joe Carroll: That's so great. Izzy, thank you so much.

[59:51] Izzy McCalla: This was such a dream and uh stay safe and we can't wait to see fly.

[59:55] Izzy McCalla: It it will happen.

[59:57] Izzy McCalla: Yeah. Enjoy the sunshine.

[1:00:00] Dan Tracy: Thanks, guys.

[1:00:01] Dan Tracy: Thanks for listening to Guys Who Like Musicals. I'm Dan Tracy. That's at Dan underscore Tracy on Instagram and Twitter.

[1:00:08] Joe Carroll: And I'm Joe Carroll. That's Joe underscore Carroll M I C Home from the state of Michigan and I went to Michigan on Instagram Twitter.

[1:00:17] Dan Tracy: You can reach us at musical guys on Twitter or at Guys Who Like Musicals on Instagram.

[1:00:24] Joe Carroll: And for the first time, we now have a phone number.

[1:00:28] Dan Tracy: You guys can text the guys who like musicals personally. Our number is two zero three nine zero zero seven nine nine zero.

[1:00:40] Joe Carroll: We will eventually make a bad song that has those numbers in it.

[1:00:46] Dan Tracy: But for now, if you have any questions, be part of our text community and shoot us a text now.

[1:00:51] Joe Carroll: Thanks for listening.

[1:00:52] Dan Tracy: Woo

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred