Skip to main content
BPN Logo
ANNIE (Off-Broadway) - A Post Show Analysis

In this episode, we take you backstage to the Theater at Madison Square Garden for a fresh look at the classic musical "Annie," starring Whoopi Goldberg. We dive into this touring production, exploring how the show's timeless themes of hope and family resonate in today's world... Read More

From the show: Half Hour with Jeff & Richie (Post-Show Broadway Discussions and Interviews)

37 mins
1/13/25

Featured Shows

About

In this episode, we take you backstage to the Theater at Madison Square Garden for a fresh look at the classic musical "Annie," starring Whoopi Goldberg. We dive into this touring production, exploring how the show's timeless themes of hope and family resonate in today's world. Does Goldberg's star power elevate the show, or is it just another day in the hard-knock life? We'll dissect the performances, from the plucky orphans to the conniving Miss Hannigan, and debate whether this production lives up to the Annie legacy. Plus, we'll share our hot takes on the challenges of staging a Broadway classic in a non-traditional venue. Is the sun really coming out tomorrow for family-friendly theater? Tune in for our candid conversation and insider insights on this beloved musical.

Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, and YouTube. Share your thoughts with us on "Annie" on our podcast cover post on Instagram.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jeff Malone: Welcome to Half Hour with Jeff and Richie, the podcast where we explore the latest shows we see, sharing our insights and opinions on the performances, storylines, and everything in between.

[0:09] Richie Grasso: In today's episode, we're discussing the touring production of Annie, featuring the legendary Whoopi Goldberg as Miss Hannigan at the theater of Madison Square Garden in New York City.

[0:18] Jeff Malone: Whether you cannot catch the show in person or you want to expand your thoughts after seeing it, this episode is for you.

[0:23] Richie Grasso: And as always, we want to inform you that this episode will contain spoilers.

[0:27] Jeff Malone: So if you're ready to dive into this production, stick around with us.

[0:29] Jeff Malone: I'm Jeff.

[0:30] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie, and we're thrilled to be your host for today's episode.

[0:33] Jeff Malone: But before we start the conversation about Annie, here are a few words from our advertisers.

[0:41] ♪ Musical number: "Annie" — performed by the cast ♪

[0:52] Richie Grasso: Holding on to hope when times are tough can take an awful lot of determination, and sometimes an awful lot of determination comes in a surprisingly small package. Little Orphan Annie has reminded generations of theatergoers that sunshine is always right around the corner, and now the best beloved musical of all time returns in a new production. Just as you remember it, and just when we need it the most. Annie is directed by Jen Thompson and features the iconic book and score written by Tony Award winners, Thomas Meehan, Charles Strauss, and Martin Charnin. The celebration of family, optimism, and the American spirit remains the ultimate cure for all the hard knocks life throws your way. So in today's episode, we're discussing the national tour of Annie.

[1:30] Jeff Malone: So let's start with our hot take.

[1:32] Richie Grasso: You try first.

[1:34] Jeff Malone: Okay. This was a fine production of Annie. It was nice. There was some talent on stage. I thought the addition of Whoopi Goldberg was nice. And I looked at this and I said, okay, I don't think anything groundbreaking or new is happening here. I thought it was basic in the best way and pleased audiences. It did what it needed to do, and there wasn't anything that seemed extremely outlandish or lavish or heightened any more than just your, I don't want to say run of the mill production of Annie, but your basic production of Annie. And I left there pleasantly happy, not wowed, like, oh my gosh, this is the best thing I ever saw. Just like, okay, nice. So I was basically content.

[2:14] Richie Grasso: Yeah. My Broadway hot take on this is that Annie's Madison Square Garden run was cute. Um, but it highlighted something different for me in realizing that it is kind of a stale Broadway in terms of family-friendly shows, uh, in terms of new content. And that's really how I feel after kind of leaving this show. So this is something I definitely want to discuss in this episode.

[2:42] Jeff Malone: Let's do it. So when we talk about this overall show, I don't think we really need to tell people too much about the plot. Most people know this show. I've seen many movie adaptations of this. Um, I think when people hear Annie, they know what they're gonna get. So nine out of ten times, this is a show that sells. It sells well, it's in New York, it's family friendly. It's I wouldn't say it's a Christmas show. It has Christmas theming to it, especially with the ending.

[3:10] Richie Grasso: Right. And I would say overall, people enjoy it.

[3:14] Jeff Malone: Yeah. Well, I feel the same way because it's like I don't want to knock this show in any way. I feel that this is one of those shows that is really timeless across like all different generations, and like we continue to see this over and over again. So that's why I'm like, I'm not gonna knock this show in any way. But you know, it kind of leads me to a bigger question about like what do you think makes this show so timeless and why we continue to see it over and over again.

[3:45] Richie Grasso: I think you have classic musical theater villain, you have classic musical theater leading character, the I want, the hope, the dreaming of a terrible time in American history, the Rags to Riches story, the Christmas morning story. There's a lot of joy and beauty in that about having a child, a child wanting a parent, um, but also really fun, catchy songs. I don't think, you know, you have to remember where Annie came in the history of musical theater. Annie is probably one of the first shows to ever be a family friendly musical. Musicals before it certainly came. I guess the Sound of Music would be another one that was family friendly-esque, even though that deals with some really difficult and dark subject matter.

There's also children in that. This came in the 70s at a time where musical theater was exiting its golden age phase, and it didn't quite hit the like turntables of Les Mis and the falling chandeliers of Phantom yet. We were still in this like sound time, dark musical theater, and Annie has its dark moments, but it was really joyous, and it came at a time where kids on stage, kids can go to the theater, bring the joy in the family friendly excitement. And I think that because of where it landed in history, it's just always lived on. It had a classic 80s film adaptation, which wasn't perfect, but it was well received. The 90s version in the Disney production. We had another musical movie version a few years ago. It was revived on Broadway in, I want to say 2012, and it kind of reimagined production. So we're always gonna see it. We're just always gonna see it.

[5:24] Jeff Malone: Yeah, I find the actual concept of it to be a little interesting as well because it's like we're taking these themes that are happening around the Great Depression, but also like growing up as an orphan and getting adopted. And I look at this and I say, okay, uh, we're moving farther away from this kind of time and era. And you know, I even look at this show, and I think one of the things I said to you was does this show feel really dated? Because there's parts of this that like I don't think kids get at all, and it's turned into this family-friendly show because why there's kids in the show, you know, that's always like an interesting thing. Like, is this actually a family-friendly show or is this more for adults? The humor lies more with the adults.

[6:12] Richie Grasso: I don't think this was ever written for the intention of, oh, let's get tons of kids in the theater. I think this was written for like this is a classic cartoon. Don't forget that the cartoon was from a long time ago and that it's set in the 1930s, and this musical came in the 70s. So we're talking about a musical set almost 100 years ago at this point. So references to um FDR and references to artwork and um Harpo Marx, and these people who that and then the jokes that land it's difficult to explain some of these people, but in the 70s, that was only 30 or 40 years prior. Most people would have understood those jokes.

[6:51] Jeff Malone: Right. So the references may seem a little dated, but the joy of New York and the joyous music of "Never Fully Dressed Without a Smile" and the dancing, and you see so many children's theaters and community theaters around the world doing this show all the time. So the message and the energy of it is certainly timeless, but the specifics of the book and the score could fall into a little bit of, yeah, do kids understand this? You know, I don't know if they understand it the specific jokes or references, but as much as they are really there to enjoy the musical theater art form itself of the piece.

[7:26] Richie Grasso: Yeah, and it also kind of ties two things in as well of like in your opinion, does the show do enough to tackle the social issues of the time? And also how do those social issues currently still kind of relate to what we're going through today?

[7:42] Jeff Malone: I think a song like "We'd Like to Thank You Herbert Hoover," which is always cut from the film versions, is so important because other than Hamilton or maybe 1776, when do we ever like talk about a president in a song and how a community of people didn't like that president and thought that that president caused the Great Depression, and then reference FDR and the New Deal, it's like a history lesson in and of itself. So I think that does a nice job of referencing history in that way. But way before the days of shows like 1776 came, well, it was around when 1776 came, but Hamilton obviously much later. I think American history told through the musical theater lens is good. That's fun, and that's where I definitely think it has like the adult part in here.

You know, I think any child watching this is probably like what's going on. But if you look at it, like how many times do we see shows written today, and we say, Oh, this is lagging, this is this filler, there's a there's this plot moves pretty quick, and I think there's some nice movement of character development. "Little Girls" doesn't develop the plot, but "Little Girls" is like Miss Hannigan's song, you know. So you're waiting for that. "You're Never Fully Dressed Without a Smile," it doesn't really further the plot, but it's like a great act two opener. So there's definitely moments of joyous occasion, and Charles Strauss, who wrote Bye Bye Birdie and Annie wrote some of the greatest music. I think some of the most like fun, upbeat musical theater, golden age stuff, you know.

[9:04] Richie Grasso: Yeah. And you know, it has a really great theme of, you know, having optimism and like not wanting to give up and really persevering through this whole thing. It just that I think is the beauty and why I think people really resonate with this still, too. Is like this here, you see this little girl that doesn't want to give up. She either wants to find her parents or she wants to get out of that orphanage, and she does, you know.

[9:33] Jeff Malone: Well, she doesn't find her parents, but you know.

[9:33] Richie Grasso: Right, or she gets adopted.

[9:37] Jeff Malone: Yeah, she gets adopted. And there's even reference to like the whole song "NYC" is about her going to the movies. How many kids today say, I'm gonna go want to go watch a movie, I'm gonna go sit in my own, I'm gonna go to the movie theater. But at the time it was a really big deal to leave your house and go to a movie theater, and I think that's the charm of the whole piece in and of itself, yeah.

[9:56] Richie Grasso: Totally, you know. So I think we should get ready to move on to some direction and some actor performances here and some design concepts of this production of Annie that we saw.

[10:05] Jeff Malone: So let's go there now. But before we do, here's a few messages from those that make the show possible.

[10:10] Richie Grasso: Okay, and we're back. So this it was an interesting thing. Well, at the end of the episode, we'll talk a little bit about our experience at this and like what brought this to New York and being in this venue, right? New York City. But to bring a national touring production of Annie to New York City, probably needed a star put into it. I think it would have sold, but I think Whoopi Goldberg's name was selling this. I think for to see Whoopi Goldberg hosting The View as long as she has, and to not seen her in a she's an EGOT winner, yeah. You know, so to not have seen her in many TV or film productions in a while, and then for her to return to the stage in this way, to me, I thought that was iconic, and I thought that was really cool. I know some people who went to the show and said, Oh, I'm really just going for Whoopi Goldberg. When would we have seen Whoopi Goldberg live on a stage like that?

[11:01] Jeff Malone: Yeah.

[11:01] Richie Grasso: So I think there was just that element of, oh, we're going to New York City to see Annie and Whoopi Goldberg's playing Miss Hannigan. When we told a few people that they were like, Oh, that's so cool. You know, and um, so I thought that element of it was cool. I think Whoopi did a nice job with the role. Sometimes the role is really overacted. And I don't really think she overacted. I think she actually found her own in the physicality of it. And the line delivery seemed a little lagging at times, like she was almost milking the scenes a little bit. The singing was okay. I don't think it was the greatest singing I've ever heard, but I think she had a few one where her strength lied were the one-liners.

[11:40] Jeff Malone: Right.

[11:40] Richie Grasso: The deliveries of anything listen, who wouldn't want to play Miss Hannigan? It's like the coolest role for like um basically a middle-aged woman to be playing on a stage. And she did it. She showed up finishing filming in December of The View, going to do this show sometimes twice a day, all the way up till January 5th. It's pretty impressive, I think, for someone of her age and her stature to do that. And it definitely sold tickets. And I think she was fine in the role. It wasn't anything like groundbreaking, but it was cool to see her up there.

[12:10] Jeff Malone: Right. They needed to put a star in here. I do think Whoopi Goldberg was a great choice to have in here.

[12:16] Jeff Malone: I did think that some of the line delivery was funny. It did feel a little like line. Um, line. And yeah, the music was just fine. You know, I wonder, would we have gone to see this show if she wasn't at MSG? I don't know. I don't know. And I also don't know if a lot of people would have or not.

[12:35] Richie Grasso: Right. Because there has been times where national tours of, you know, I think The Grinch or something else have like stopped at the theater at MSG. But I always remember that Christmas Carol in the 90s and early 2000s, every year played at the theater at MSG. But they put like Frank Langella in. They always kind of put a star in as um the lead in that. So I think putting a star there does help them.

[12:57] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And I, to me personally, I don't quite understand why there wasn't another star with her. There wasn't even Broadway names in this. No offense to the cast because a lot of them are making national tour debuts or New York City debuts. So good for them. Um, but there was no like, oh, Tony nominee blank, or like Broadway is blank. There was like nobody in this. And so it felt like here's Whoopi, and then like everyone else is sitting below her.

[13:23] Richie Grasso: Yeah. And it seemed like a little odd because she was such a name compared to everyone else who was not. I think this leads to a bigger conversation around Broadway versus tours versus off-Broadway. And when you look at something like this, this gets categorized as still being in the Broadway kind of realm. I mean, you're right down the block. Um, you're at Madison Square Garden. This is a big deal. This is a national tour coming in.

[13:54] Jeff Malone: And I look at this production overall and I say to myself, okay, it feels like that. There's nothing wrong with tours. But when you're in New York City and Broadway's all around you, and it's high budget, this didn't feel like that for me. And it's something to talk about because we had the same conversation about The Wiz, which actually went to the Broadway stage, and we were like, wait, this feels like a tour. So the tours coming to New York are feeling like tours. And like you said, no disrespect for tours. But if I'm sitting in Midwest America and I'm going to see a tour, I think there's this idea of I'm going to see professional live theater, and that's enough for me.

[14:36] Richie Grasso: Right. But there is an expectation when you go to London and when you go to New York that you're gonna see something that's maybe a little more elevated than a tour, maybe just a little bit. Listen, bro, Carolee Carmelo is on the Kimberly Akimbo tour right now. It's not like probably people don't go on the tours. Betty Buckley went and did the Dolly tour. I mean, like, that totally happens. But I think if people are, yeah, this was touring and it's really not just about the casting, because I will say this. This set looked small in this space. I counted 10 people in the orchestra.

[15:10] Jeff Malone: Yeah. When the average pit orchestra down on Broadway, right up the street, it's got 15 to 20 people in every pit. It sounded like a 10-piece orchestra. It seemed just tin canny, like there was almost like a glass wall in between us. You're in the big theater. The theater of Madison Square Garden, thousands of seats. It's bigger than most Broadway houses. Yeah, it's huge. And the production wasn't like, where was to me, the producer saying, We're gonna make all this money? Why don't we bust out the scenery a little bit more here? Why don't we add some more? No, they don't want to do that because people paid for the tickets anyway.

[15:42] Richie Grasso: You know, this show was directed by Jen Thompson, and I felt that there were moments in this production that just lacked. There and we see set pieces coming in that felt very thin. You know, one door flat for a whole orphanage. See, I mean, in a huge bare stage, it just seems bare bones for a large-scale production like this. Right. And when you look at this cast, though, it felt really small. I'm watching this and I see the orphanage, and there's like six other girls in with Annie. And I'm like, where's the choreography? Where are these girls belting this song out? It just felt very thin.

[16:23] Jeff Malone: You have, I want to say, maybe what, six men in the ensemble and six women in the ensemble. So out any large ensemble song, there were 12 people up there. I mean, this could have easily had a 25-person male ensemble, a female and male adult ensemble and a 25-person kid ensemble. You could have 50 people up there. Yeah, and it's a big stage. And I look at something like that, and I think you and I both said this too. I'm like, or I said this to you. I was like, um, wait, it actually looks like in this orphanage, all of the kids are getting adopted.

[16:51] Richie Grasso: Yeah, right, right, exactly. And I just because the 80s movie had a hundred kids in that orphanage, and it looked like maybe at the time in the 1930s, there was a packed orphanage of a hundred girls. I don't know, you know. But I think even when you have these large-scale ballads, the music just sounded thin. It just didn't seem to hit the elevation of the theater of Madison Square Garden. Right. When you're in the lobby and there's all this merch and all these snacks and this huge entryway with the billboards of photos, and it seems grandiose.

[17:27] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And you get in and you see, I think I had said to you, look, there's the proscenium, and there's where the show set is starting. I think watching them walk off stage to then walk to the proper off stage took a long time. It's a huge space. We sometimes forget this theater is here on the city. And that's where I felt like there were some amateur moves of like bringing in the cast on and off, doing silly kind of like moments, didn't feel next level for me. It felt almost a little um community theater, you know, in a place that it should not be.

[18:07] Richie Grasso: Especially when you're just like I said, it was fine. It was a content piece of theater. It wasn't at the level of what people are paying the New York City prices to go to dinner, park your car, go buy merchandise, get a snack, come sit a lot more money at MSG than doing it in the middle of a theater in, you know, Kansas City or something, right? I would think. But you're still getting in the same show. And now, which actor performances, besides Whoopi, which we've already talked about, really stood out to you?

[18:33] Jeff Malone: I thought Hazel Vogel as Annie was very strong. She sings the ball, the uh, the Sun will come out tomorrow really strong. Her relationship with her and the dog. There's some, what is more iconic than watching Annie and a dog sing the Sun will come out tomorrow on the stage? Like, I'll take that any day. You know what I mean? That was really strong. The other two people that stood out to me, Christopher Swann is Oliver Warbucks, who's very strong. I thought he was really, really wonderful. And I really, really was very, very impressed with Julia Nicole Hunter as Grace Farrell.

[19:01] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Really impressive vocal, really gorgeous gowns and look. And I just thought she, I don't think she's been on Broadway yet. And I really hope that one day we see her. Yeah, looking at in the playbill, I said, Oh, wait, she hasn't done any Broadway yet. You know, she was feisty and fine. She's a gorgeous voice. Gorgeous, gorgeous voice. You know, I look at her and I say, You need to do Broadway. And that's another question about some of the actors that are in this for you. Is it traditional that when you kind of are in a touring cast, you kind of stay there? Or how do you get yourself over to Broadway?

[19:36] Jeff Malone: I think, and everyone's got a very different story. What I've seen a lot of is summer stocks lead to tours lead to Broadway. But there's been plenty of times when people have done Broadway, the show is closing on Broadway, they don't have another show lined up, and they go on to the tour. That's not moving backwards in your career at all. I think that's just an opportunity to say, you know what? Hey, I'm gonna get to see the world a little bit and travel. So, no, most a lot of times the people on the tours are also the people from the Broadway companies. I don't think that one stands higher than the other, other than you get to stay in New York and live in an apartment or whatever, versus having to be on the road in hotels.

[20:16] Richie Grasso: Yeah, no, it wasn't more, it was more that I looked at a lot of the credits of the cast and I said, Oh, the tour, tour, tour, tour, tour, but I didn't see Broadway. So I was curious to see. Maybe they just want a tour. Maybe they like traveling and seeing all the different venues, and they don't want to stay um put in New York City. Who knows?

[20:33] Jeff Malone: Right, right. I was just curious there. Totally. And what did you, I actually will say another part of the design? Well, I wasn't really blown away with the scenic design. I did think these costumes were really nice.

[20:45] Richie Grasso: Yeah. And I thought they fit the period really well. And I thought they was it was visually stunning to look at from a period piece costume design. I didn't know.

[20:52] Jeff Malone: Yeah, I mean, I thought they were pretty standard. I didn't think there was anything like completely over the top in terms of costume or really reimagined, but yeah, they were nice.

[21:00] Richie Grasso: Yeah, yeah. You know, uh, and we kind of really talked about the scenic design here. It just again, it felt like there were things that we were seeing in this that we shouldn't have seen, especially when there are either you're in Miss Hannigan's office or you're in the um orphanage or you're in Daddy Warbucks. We're still seeing the same backdrops in certain areas, and it doesn't make sense to me. You know, uh I would look at the Warbucks mansion, and I would not think we were in that mansion. And not to mention like the act curtain was like a bridge, and I just didn't understand. Like, are you just taking what is it, the Brooklyn Bridge or one of the bridges in New York? Are you just taking a bridge and just making that your act curtain? If anything, make it like the Annie logo. If you're gonna go, like concept with it. I don't know. It was a it was an odd scenic design for me in that way.

[21:54] Jeff Malone: But yeah, yeah. All right. Well, let's move into our own personal experience at the show. Um, but before we do that, here are a few messages from our sponsors.

[22:05] Richie Grasso: All right, and we're back. So now let's get into our own experience here. This was a little fun and different for us because we brought um our nieces and nephews to see the show. And if you want to go check out their hot take uh we did on Instagram, we did a Jeff and Richie on the street with our featured nieces and nephews. Um, and they gave their opinions, which they all said, more Sandy.

[22:28] Jeff Malone: Yeah, I know. We don't get much of the dog in act two. The dog was great. And I think a lot of people actually forget about that within the production anyway, because on the stage production, Sandy's really not in the show. But in the film and at the end of NYC, Sandy is alone on the street looking for Annie. She's lost him essentially, and he's lost her. And then at the end, they bring Sandy back in in the present.

[22:47] Richie Grasso: Um, but in the film productions, the dog is in there much more.

[22:52] Jeff Malone: Yeah, yeah. I actually think Sandy's like with her in the mansion throughout.

[22:56] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Like she almost got to the mansion with the, I, someone could correct me if I'm wrong. I thought in one of the film productions, when she's getting adopted, she says, Can I take Sandy with me?

[23:04] Jeff Malone: Like, oh yeah. And was it, was it the Anne Ranking, the Carol Burnett, the old 80s film? And she goes, Of course you can take Sandy. And they give her, don't they give the dog a bubble bath in the movie? I think there's a whole thing.

[23:12] Richie Grasso: So I think that's a thing that's very nice. And I think people forget that in the stage production. But um, in terms of this, okay, we're not at a Broadway house. We're at the theater at Madison Square Garden. When I go see a concert at or a sporting event in Madison Square Garden, I understand the whole like you're in and you're out, and you're getting snacks in the lobby, and you're and it's loud, and people are kind of just like around, and it's a concert, it's an event.

[23:40] Jeff Malone: I don't understand why the ushers and the staff at the theater of Madison Square Garden aren't treating this like I'm at a Schubert Theater or like I'm at a Nederlander theater. And there was this like late seating was kind of just happening whenever you're able to eat whenever you want, wherever you want, kind of like you're at a circus, or you're at an event where popcorn pretzels and drinks and people are just kind of in and out, and yeah, it didn't seem like a, you know, this is a theater still, and it's kind of seemed disrespectful to the performance of it.

[24:09] Richie Grasso: At one point, there were people way down in the front row. There was ushers sitting down there too, maybe for security reasons. People just like walking into the front with all their snacks, and Whoopi Goldberg's right there. I think she was singing Little Girls or and she's right there acting, and there's these people walking right in front. Like that doesn't happen at Broadway spaces, you really can only sit during specific times.

[24:29] Jeff Malone: And it seemed to me like the ushers did. I even went to the usher and showed my ticket, and they were like, okay, over there. And I was like, and they had the playbills. Oh, can I get a playbill? Oh, yeah. You come on, how many times do you probably show? And they instantly hand you the playbill. So I'm not saying anything disrespectful towards these ushers. I'm just saying this didn't feel like I was at a theater, even though we're at the Theater at Madison Square Garden, it felt like I was at like a circus arena.

[24:51] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Well, I think that's where it comes down to like how they're billing the show and how it feels like it's supposed to be on Broadway, but then you get there and it's not a Broadway experience. And this theater venue is usually used for like the Sesame Street Lives and the I think wrestling matches and like there's other events here besides theater. So I saw actually saw Kathy Rigby in the National Tour of Peter Pan come through there. That was a big spectacle show where she was flying. Christmas Carol ran here forever, but I will say this about the experience. It would behoove them and these producers to put a holiday themed show in there every year. It doesn't have to be Annie. Maybe it's Christmas Carol next year. Maybe it is Grinch. Maybe it is something. There's something about going with kids. This is the place to bring kids that might be a little loud and they need to versus like a Broadway house.

[25:41] Jeff Malone: I don't know the grosses of this. I'm sure this made a lot of money because there was a lot of people there.

[25:46] Richie Grasso: Oh, definitely. And this is clearly a smart move for producers like I said on the ELF podcast. It doesn't just have to be the Rockettes. We can bring other holiday shows into the city, and clearly it will sell.

[25:57] Jeff Malone: Well, when you look at this, and this is why I wanted to kind of raise this question earlier on from like when I brought it up in my hot take, is I see Annie, and now we've seen Elf, and the Lion King is still running, and Aladdin is still running. And you know, maybe we've kind of talked about this before, but when it comes to family-friendly and children's shows, why does it feel like there is nothing really to go to as a family? There are those few staple things, but you wonder why I know well, I will say this about a holiday show. When a holiday show comes in, there's it's a very short period of time it's running. So to build scenery to hire casting directors, to book a venue that may only be free for those few months, it's much more expensive than if, oh, let's just have the tour stop here.

There's already a set built, the cast is already cast, they'll come here. So there's a lot of perks to doing something like that, or like what Paper Mill did with My Christmas, they always put a show in at that time of year anyway. So versus let's just get a theater and from scratch build up a musical. That is expensive.

[27:06] Richie Grasso: And I think that's right. But I feel like what I'm trying to say is like we're lacking in content. Christmas or just family-friendly content in front of you. Family friendly, because I don't really look at Annie as being a Christmas show. Like uh it's like saying it's a Christmas movie because there's a Christmas scene and it's not really a Christmas. Um I'm talking more about like they brought Annie here for a specific reason. It's New York City. New York City's packed at the holidays, and it really worked. They packed out that theater and they made a probably a lot of money without having to do anything to the production. So, and guess what? A lot of tourists probably went and saw this show and they had no problem with it, like us because we're just being nitpicky because we want the best for anything that's happening in the New York City space. I'm talking about here how why do you feel like we don't really capitalize on actual family-friendly shows?

[28:01] Jeff Malone: Because uh what we were saying about Annie is I don't really think Annie was made for families and kids. It's an adult um theme show. Well, I'm gonna start with the top, and I will say DreamWorks Theatricals puts Shrek on stage, and I haven't seen another show since Shrek from DreamWorks Theatricals. Disney has not opened a new show in years since Frozen closed, and they have more money than anyone. And so what I don't understand is like I understand the whole concept. If it's not broke, don't fix it. So if Lion King is just working and Aladdin's just working. However, how many times have we read Disney's working on Dumbo? Disney's working on Hercules, Disney's working on uh um Coco, Disney's working on all these things for how long?

For years and years and years, and the theme parks keep putting new stage shows in, seemingly, or updating their shows. And yet Disney has the stories, has the composers, has the budget to do what are what are most children's themed shows and family-friendly shows gonna have high elevated costumes, flying, magical special effects. That's what c prices go up. But I'm not saying Disney needs to close one of their shows, but Disney could very, very, very, very easily book another empty theater, like we constantly see the Long Anchor Theater empty, or we constantly see these theaters empty and go put a show in, and they don't. I don't know why when Lion King is pulling in more money than anything other than Wicked.

And so I it is very interesting to me that Disney doesn't their shows more, or or I should say rather than run Aladdin for 10 years, run Mary Poppins for 10 years. I get it, like those worked and it's working, but there's so many titles of Disney shows. I don't understand. I'm not saying it's only about Disney. An independent producer can put a family-friendly show on, but Disney seems to lead the charge of family-friendly theater.

[29:52] Richie Grasso: Well, I do find it interesting though, with Disney because Disney always had three shows running on Broadway since Beauty and the Beast, basically, right? And after that, after Frozen closed, we have not had another Disney show open on Broadway, besides keeping Aladdin and Lion King open. And I look at this though because people have asked me, what do you think is a good show that has recently come out that you can take kids to? And there really isn't anything other than them retaking the kids to see Lion King, Aladdin, Wicked. And I don't even really think Wicked is a kids' show. I'm talking about like a true made show that's for both parents and children. Which is why I just don't understand why, like, when you see like Lincoln Center, why are they not doing a sound of music revival?

It's so family friendly for the most part. And uh it could totally go like there's there's their shows out the Annie. Where is like instead of the tour rolling in for two months and rolling out, where is there that we had it in 2012? It's now 2025, right? You know, and I think it makes it a bigger question because I think it's kind of why like the Great Gatsby is doing so well right now. I don't think that there is enough out there for people to take um kids to. And like uh what I've been trying to say now is like maybe happy ending should just be billed as a kid show. Let's get families in to see that and like boost up the sales of that show because you know I think it's probably the closest thing to like a Pixar film right now, which is usually adult themes, but children can see it.

[31:33] Jeff Malone: Right. And it does, if you look follow history, a lot of times children weren't going to Broadway shows 100 years ago. There wasn't really the locale for children to be. Right. And we've changed that certainly over the years, because look at the highest grossing shows are the family friendly shows. So that's what's so I understand what you're saying. That's so juxtapose each other. Like, uh, the shows that do the best are these family shows, and there's only two or three of them. So like but then I think something's tradition. How many families might go and bring their children to Lion King every year? Or the Rockettes every year. It's become a tradition. Right. And some people like that. I don't know. Right. You know, so it is very interesting.

[32:11] Richie Grasso: But one thing I also wanted to kind of get your last little uh bit on here is um Annie's launched a ton of careers in the Broadway space from like the original production to also the films or whatever. But who would you say your top favorite like star to come out of Annie is?

[32:30] Jeff Malone: Oh my gosh. Um well, to come out of Annie or to have played a role throughout Annie. They kind of got their start in Annie, and then they went on to do something big after. Like there is that a hard question.

[32:42] Richie Grasso: No, because I think it's interesting how Andrew McArdle, who is the original Annie, didn't really get too far with it, but like Sarah Jessica Parker was uh Danny in the 70s and then went on. Um and then you had Sutton Foster as like a star to be in that clip is something I always go watch, a young Sutton, like as the Star to B is always such a great, like it's obviously meant to be the launch in the show itself, but it also does launch careers for well, it's so we always talk about that moment of Sutton Foster, you know, doing the star to be and then going to do thoroughly modern Millie after, which we always find like if you kind of look at the Millie character, it's so star-to-be. It's almost like you could do a crossover and you could have like Millie's starting where Annie is happening NYC, some like awesome hybrid of like that's Millie, actually, NYC and Annie or something.

[33:34] Jeff Malone: Like, yeah, there's like this random crossover. You would see it in cut some sort of like a parody musical or whatever. But also, I will say this. Um there to me, uh talking about all the casting of Annie in general, there's nothing like Carol Burnett, Bernadette Peters, and Tim Curry playing that trio. That is the ultimate to me. I don't, I just thought that was and I also did like Audrey McDonald in the 90s as Grace. And I also liked Anne Ranking as is great. I mean, there's some just highlight people, but to me, no one. Yeah, Kathy Bates, right, and Victor Garber, right? Was in the butt to me, I will I still think there was no one like Carol Burnett doing the role. I don't know if any but even Whoopi's great, but I don't know if anyone really got Miss Hannigan.

Not Jane Lynch. I saw Jane Lynch, it was okay, and Dorothy Ludin, I think is her last name, was the original Miss Hannigan in the original. She, if you listen to the recording, was great. But to me, Carol Burnett got the whole, she added the darker element of Miss Hannigan with like the drinking. Whoopi had the whole like drinking moment too, but like that's what's comedic, but also dark is this woman's life is kind of really crazy.

[34:43] Richie Grasso: Yeah, there was something really scary about Carol Burnett.

[34:46] Jeff Malone: Oh, it was especially used. I was so scared of the fact when she opens the door and she's like there and all the kids, and she's like, Oh, and she just she delivers the line so great. And then when she does little girls and oh my gosh. I Carol Burnett, we love you. But anyway, Whoopi was really, really wonderful in this too. I will say I did have a good time with it. Just seeing her up there.

[35:05] Richie Grasso: But anyway.

[35:08] Jeff Malone: Oh my gosh. Final thoughts on Annie at uh theater from Madison Square Garden, Jeff. Well, listen, you can't go see it anymore because it's closed as well as us of there. Yesterday. Um, but it was fun. I don't it I don't actually know if it is still touring. I want to say this was the final stop, I want to say.

[35:26] Richie Grasso: Okay.

[35:26] Jeff Malone: So guess what? You can just listen to this episode of Annie, and maybe we'll see Annie again on a full Broadway revival in the next one. Five to ten years, it could be there. And I wonder, you know, what is next for Annie in terms of modernizing it even more to current times. You know, we've seen so many different um takes on this work. And yeah, I mean, it was fun. It was a cute thing to go to. Wonderful thing to bring the nieces and nephews too. Some of our nieces and nephews saw this for the first time, so to see it through our their eyes was one of the more special moments for me as their uncle. Um, but uh I did over overall enjoy the experience. It was nice. I was content, it was it wasn't anything groundbreaking. I didn't I think there were so few things wrong issues with it, but it was fine.

[36:11] Richie Grasso: Right.

[36:12] Jeff Malone: And it was a nice holiday moment in New York City, you know.

[36:14] Richie Grasso: So yeah, very, very nice.

[36:16] Jeff Malone: Well, that does wrap up our discussion on today's episode. We hope you enjoyed our deep dive into Annie. And remember, we want to hear from you. Continue the conversation with us on Instagram at Half Hour Podcast and let us know your thoughts on Annie. If you enjoyed our show, please leave us a review. Your feedback helps us bring more theater to you. And remember you can listen to past episodes and stay tuned for the many upcoming ones as well. Until next time, I'm Jeff.

[36:36] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie Sangta, and happy new year.

[36:36] Jeff Malone: Happy New Year.

[36:40] Richie Grasso: Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred