Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 1: Joe Iconis

In this inaugural episode, Sam and Ilana interview composer/lyricist Joe Iconis as he walks us through the origins of the Be More Chill journey - all the way from the nexus of the idea of writing the musical leading up to to the opening night of the world premiere at Two River Theater in Red Bank, New Jersey and then the making of the triumphant original cast recording of the show... Read More

From the show: How To Be More Chill

1 h 10 mins
3/9/19

Guests

Featured Shows

About

In this inaugural episode, Sam and Ilana interview composer/lyricist Joe Iconis as he walks us through the origins of the Be More Chill journey - all the way from the nexus of the idea of writing the musical leading up to to the opening night of the world premiere at Two River Theater in Red Bank, New Jersey and then the making of the triumphant original cast recording of the show.

Part of the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Ilana Levine: Hey everyone, I am Ilana.

[0:08] Sam Maher: And I'm Sam.

[0:09] Ilana Levine: And we are two people who had a mutual love for a show called Be More Chill.

[0:16] Sam Maher: And we decided that we would like to find a place where we could bring others who love Be More Chill as much as we do.

[0:25] Ilana Levine: All of the behind the scenes with all of its creatives, and we thought a really great way to do that would be to have a podcast.

[0:32] Sam Maher: And we have called that podcast How to Be More Chill.

[0:36] Ilana Levine: Never hung with a girl like you before.

[0:39] Sam Maher: I don't know if you know it, but I am sure that for me, you are an up-rain.

[0:48] Ilana Levine: I have a podcast called Little Known Facts with Ilana Levine.

[0:52] Sam Maher: I have a media company called Yes Broadway, which is a media company that tries to introduce a new audience to Broadway and New York City theater.

[1:01] Ilana Levine: And the reason this is such a perfect segue is that there is a whole new audience coming to see Broadway now because of this show called Be More Chill.

[1:11] Sam Maher: The story of Be More Chill and why it's such a miracle, as far as we are both concerned, is that this is coming to Broadway in really unorthodox way.

[1:20] Ilana Levine: Totally fan-driven.

[1:22] Sam Maher: It's not like a New York Times Review that was really great, got a show to Broadway, or producers with a lot of money got a show to Broadway.

[1:30] Ilana Levine: This is a show that is arriving on Broadway because the fans demanded it.

[1:34] Sam Maher: So this was a show that was done in a regional theater in 2015, and a cast recording was made by Ghost Light Records of Be More Chill, written by Joe Trace and Joe Iconis, based on Ned Vizzini's YA novel by the same name.

[1:48] Ilana Levine: And everything just kind of goes away, and life continues for everyone involved in that show until me how it's been described.

[2:04] Sam Maher: If you fed Dear Evan Hansen to the plant in Little Shop of Horrors, the love child would be Be More Chill.

[2:12] Ilana Levine: Sam and I thought, what if we could harness all of the goodwill, fandom, talent, and remarkableness of all the people involved in bringing the show to Broadway and have a place where they could come and tell their stories and we could share them with you, our listeners, and it's happened.

[2:32] Sam Maher: So we're gonna dive in and tell you how to be more chill.

[2:36] Ilana Levine: Our first interview is with Joe Iconis, who is the composer lyricist for Be More Chill.

[2:43] Sam Maher: We wanted to start with his interview because we wanted to orient everyone with the idea of what happened when this idea to turn Be More Chill, which was a YA novel from the 90s, going from idea to the production at the Two River Theater in Red Bank, New Jersey.

[2:59] Ilana Levine: He's told us stuff neither of us knew, and we kept lots of stuff.

[3:03] Sam Maher: Ilana and I look at each other during the interview.

[3:05] Ilana Levine: Like, did he just say this?

[3:07] Sam Maher: Is he saying this?

[3:09] Ilana Levine: It's so wild.

[3:10] Sam Maher: Incredible, and it's emotional and it's funny, and uh, we are off to an incredible start.

[3:16] Ilana Levine: Let's do this, Joe Iconis.

[3:30] Joe Iconis: Hey Joey J.

[3:31] Ilana Levine: Connis.

[3:32] Joe Iconis: Hey, Ilana.

[3:33] Sam Maher: Hey Sam Maher.

[3:34] Joe Iconis: Hi, how's it going, guys?

[3:36] Ilana Levine: We're really excited to have you, and Sam and I were talking a little bit about sort of where to begin for your episode and what will be chapter one of what I like to think of the criterion version of the Be More Chill experience.

[3:53] Sam Maher: So I would ask you this. When did you first become aware of the following? A book called Be More Chill and a writer named Joe Trace.

[4:05] Joe Iconis: I first became aware of a book called Be More Chill in I think it was 2011. And my agent at the time, Scott Cheloff, he had read the book and he liked it a lot, and he gave it to me.

[4:27] Joe Iconis: And it, you know, it wasn't like a, it wasn't like a, you know, here take this book to adapt it into a musical for such and such company. It was more of like a, I read this, it reminded me of you. I think you'd like it, you might be inspired by it in some way.

[4:41] Joe Iconis: And at that time in my life and career, I was kind of in this in-between place. I had just done a whole bunch of shows, sort of one after another, and they all were sort of disappointing professionally for one reason or another. And so I was kind of in this place of wanting to try some new things, and I was just, I was, you know, I've always been so like in my own head about my art and about my inspirations, like where things come from, that at this time in my life I was trying to force myself to just be open to sort of receiving things from other people, you know.

[5:20] Ilana Levine: Was this the first time you had thought about adapting another person's work?

[5:26] Joe Iconis: I had adapted a children's book called The Plant That Ate Dirty Socks for Theatre Works USA. And so I had had that experience and that was sort of a strange fraught experience where the author of the original book was very involved and was very sort of upset about her character's singing. She just sort of didn't like the whole idea of these characters she created singing, it was very off-putting to her.

[5:56] Joe Iconis: Which made me feel like why, why on earth did you, I don't understand anything that is happening right now except she's wrong on so many levels I think so too.

[6:05] Ilana Levine: All right.

[6:05] Joe Iconis: So that was like a strange experience, but that was sort of its own weird beast. I had never adapted a novel as a sort of full-length musical before. And so I read the book and I loved it and it just made so much sense to me, both as material that was right for musicalization, but just as a piece of art.

[6:32] Joe Iconis: You know, I thought that Ned Vizzini's voice was so strong in a way that was really exciting to me. And you know, in previous, you know, before that, there was a part of me that was always a little bit nervous about adaptation because I myself have a voice that, you know, whether you like it or not, is fairly strong in my work. And so I always felt like, oh, I don't know, you know, what would that be like to adapt something where I feel like I have to sort of mesh with someone else's voice. Would that just be this strange sort of battle or, but for, you know, for some reason when I read Be More Chill, it just felt like, oh yeah, I know exactly how I would do this, and I know exactly how this would sound and how it would feel, and it just kind of felt like, yeah, I love this and I actually do want to make this into a musical.

[7:22] Ilana Levine: Was that part of the experience of reading the book? What during it was some percolations like tell me about reading the book. Or are you laying in bed? Are you at home? Are you out and about? Like you remember reading the book?

[7:36] Joe Iconis: Yeah, I um so I'm a terrible reader. Like it's, I just, it takes me so long to read anything. Because I'm always like sort of distracted and my mind's in a million different places. And so anytime I have to read something, even things that I read, you know, for fun, I have to like force myself to sit down and read like it's homework.

[7:59] Joe Iconis: And so Be More Chill, I read it in a few sort of sittings, right? And so I don't remember the first time I picked it up, but I read the bulk of Be More Chill at this place called the Cupcake Cafe on 9th Avenue, which isn't there anymore. And I never went to the Cupcake Cafe prior to that. I have no idea why I went there to read Be More Chill, and that's the only time I was ever there in my entire life.

[8:30] Joe Iconis: The Cupcake Cafe, which is now not there anymore by Port Authority. And I read Be More Chill, and it was actually, it was December. It was December because I was going to a Christmas party later that night, and I said to myself, you need to finish this book before you go to this Christmas party. Your reward for finishing will be you get to go to the Christmas party.

[8:53] Ilana Levine: Yes, exactly.

[8:54] Joe Iconis: I get to eat peppermint bark in Brooklyn.

[8:58] Sam Maher: I do too.

[8:59] Ilana Levine: Was the thought ever that you would write the whole thing?

[9:07] Joe Iconis: No. And that was never the thought because at that time in my life I had just, I had written, I'd written Black Suits, Book Music Lyrics, and Blood Song of Love, Book Music Lyrics, and Plant Lady Dirty Socks, actually, Book Music Lyrics, and the show called Rewrite, Book Music Lyrics. And so I was looking to collaborate with someone who was not myself.

[9:26] Sam Maher: Because you were exhausted.

[9:29] Joe Iconis: I was exhausted, and I felt a palpable sense from industry people around me that people were sort of rolling their eyes at me as someone who was like, oh, he thinks he can do it all. Like, you know, it sort of had this connotation of like, you know, it's no one is successful writing book, music, and lyrics. Like, you know, of course, there are exceptions to that. But that the sort of musical theater thing, or at least, you know, years ago was very much like you would never write all three by yourself, and if you think you're gonna write all three, you're just this ego maniac.

[10:02] Ilana Levine: Right.

[10:02] Joe Iconis: Even Bernstein worked with Sondheim.

[10:04] Sam Maher: Right, exactly.

[10:05] Joe Iconis: Just by the way.

[10:06] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[10:10] Joe Iconis: And in fact, every time listeners you hear Sondheim, just take a shot.

[10:14] Sam Maher: Of anything.

[10:15] Joe Iconis: Of anything.

[10:15] Sam Maher: Of yes, literally, of anything.

[10:18] Joe Iconis: So the Joe Trace connection, I know this, and maybe listeners, new listeners or new lovers of Be More Chill and die-hard fans may know that you and George Salazar, who plays Michael in Be More Chill, had a friendship that grew even before this show.

[10:38] Sam Maher: Sure.

[10:38] Joe Iconis: Talk to me about how you knew Joe Trace. Had you seen Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief? Was that a piece of theater that you were aware of of his?

[10:49] Joe Iconis: No, I mean, this, my first meeting of Joe Trace predated Percy Jackson. I knew of him, and I read a play of his. My gosh, I can't remember the name of this play. I think it's Boy Wonder. And so I was aware of his work, and so many people had told me that I would love this other Joe, who was sort of writing similar things to me, and that he was writing about young people, and he was writing these plays that were really influenced by film and were very genre, and he had sort of come through Arsnova where I had also come through.

[11:31] Joe Iconis: And so I, you know, was so, so aware of him, I had just never met him. And when I went back to my agent and said, you know, I actually really love this book, and I think I might want to make this into a musical, he said, um, okay, great. Have you thought about a book writer? And I was like, I don't, you know, I don't know, I'm not sure. Is there anyone who you think? And he was like, I think Joe Trace, this playwright, would be a great person. And I was like, oh my God, I love Joe Trace, and I've heard he's great and I want to meet him.

[11:59] Joe Iconis: And so we met and it was just, it was just the easiest meeting. You know, I've been on so many like sort of blind dates with artists over the years, and sometimes, you know, the blind date goes really well, and then the actual collaboration is a catastrophe. And sometimes the blind date goes horribly. But my meeting with Joe Trace, we met at the Cornelia Street Cafe, which is gonna close in a month.

[12:28] Sam Maher: Um so apparently anything that starts with a C and anything that it right, we have Cornelia Street Cupcake.

[12:36] Joe Iconis: And if you've been there, you're blowing it up, man.

[12:38] Sam Maher: I just am.

[12:39] Joe Iconis: I'm so sorry.

[12:40] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[12:40] Joe Iconis: It's cool, they become legendary.

[12:44] Ilana Levine: We've got Joe Iconis here. Now we can close.

[12:45] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[12:47] Ilana Levine: We've set our piece and counted to three.

[12:50] Sam Maher: And that's that.

[12:51] Ilana Levine: And that is that.

[12:51] Sam Maher: Mm-hmm.

[12:52] Joe Iconis: And so we had this meeting, and it was, I feel like by the end of the meeting, we just sort of said, okay, great. So you want to write the show together? It's like, yeah, let's do it.

[13:03] Joe Iconis: So he had read the book in the meantime.

[13:05] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[13:05] Joe Iconis: Yeah. And Joe was more familiar with the book than I was because he worked at Barnes and Noble through and past college and was super aware of the sort of YA lit scene, which I wasn't really.

[13:06] Sam Maher: He probably likes reading.

[13:22] Joe Iconis: He loves reading.

[13:23] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[13:24] Joe Iconis: It's not homework for Joe Trace.

[13:24] Sam Maher: He does not need little prizes at the end of a chapter to keep him going.

[13:29] Joe Iconis: No, no. So you got Joe Trace kind of like you, you were almost the impetus because you tell your agent, yes, I want to do this. And then Joe Trace becomes involved.

[13:39] Ilana Levine: What was it for you that made that really resonated with you that said yes, I do want to turn this into a musical?

[13:45] Joe Iconis: It was a few things. The first was the characters. I really loved the specificity of all the characters. I loved how surprisingly complex they, I thought they all were.

[13:59] Joe Iconis: You know, I um I had I had written the black suits before this, and so I had sort of done the like, you know, teenage angst thing, uh, and had written, you know, a bunch of songs, standalone songs about young people, and I I love writing young people, but um when I when I, you know, started getting into Be More Chill, I felt like, oh, these characters, these characters are are are so they're they're in the same world as characters that I've I've written, but are so specific and so unique. And the weirdness of them was the thing that made me um sort of perk up immediately, you know. And I what I loved about them is that they sort of they all the characters started from a um uh a more uh archetypal place um than uh than characters that I was sort of used to writing.

And I love that it uh the book was sort of playing on these archetypes. So it's you know, it's you have the what you would who you would perceive to be, you know, the jock, and you have who you would perceive to be the like stoner best friend, and then the deeper you get in the story, you see all these shades of these people and you realize, oh, these people who, you know, high school you movies uh or you know, books or plays or whatever, uh typically sort of boil down to, you know, a couple buzzwords, they're actually more complicated than that. And I loved that so much. And did Joe Trace sort of also have a very um intensely uh excited and I can see myself writing this really easily and adapting this from the time he read it as well.

Like we both sort of had that same we could do this. Yeah, we just right, exactly. It just felt like, oh yeah, this is something that would be really good for us, and we both just liked it so much. And the thing that we both really got excited about, once, you know, you sort of get through like the, you know, the characters and the the story, which is so cool, was just this um the sci-fi element of it was something that both of us was like, how cool would it be to tell this story and really through the lens of the experience? Yeah, like dive into that, uh, even more than the book, you know. And that was the other thing where it felt like the book was so so fantastic as a as a book, but um it would, you know, just because of the the the way it's written and and the end of the book is sort of you know it becomes kind of about itself, and it's like you're sort of reading this this log that um that the Squip has sort of downloaded for Jeremy to get to Christine.

Um so it's like you know, you we knew you we have to change that for the stage anyway, so it felt like you know, let's really deviate um from the from the book and the final third and just go like whole hog sci-fi, which is something that I was sort of itching to do anyway, and Joe loved to do, so it just kind of you know made so much sense.

[16:47] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah. And what's so funny is that meaning the first thing he saw. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Um I didn't write Little Shop of Hears, contrary to popular opinion. Uh I what's so funny about that too is that I uh I truly never thought about Little Shop as I was writing Be More Chill. And and Joe Trace is also a huge Little Shop fan. We never talked about it, we never it just never came up. And then as soon as we you know did like the first full real reading of the show, everyone was like, Oh, it's like Little Shop, it's like Little Shop. And we were so like, oh yeah, it's actually exactly like Little Shop. Um and it is, you know, and I and we love that it is, but it was so is not an intentional like you know, homage in any way.

[17:31] Ilana Levine: Tell us about the process of collaborating. Uh did he go off and start writing the book and you start writing songs? Did he have to write the script of the play first so that you could then know when to insert the songs? How did that go?

[17:46] Joe Iconis: Yeah, so we um we started the whole process by talking a ton and and uh really getting on the same page about the story we wanted to tell, the characters we wanted to sort of, you know, let loose in our story, just because the book has so many characters. It's s it's a sort of more sprawling um, you know, landscape and when you're working on a you know musical, or at least, you know, we felt like this wanted to be a show that didn't have, you know, 35 people in it. Like it wanted to be a you know, a tighter experience. Where's Dustin Croft?

[18:16] Ilana Levine: Yeah, so one mentioned fire.

[18:20] Joe Iconis: So is he big in the book?

[18:21] Ilana Levine: Um Dust no Dustin Cropp I made up.

[18:23] Joe Iconis: Oh, you made up.

[18:24] Ilana Levine: Yeah, I made him up.

[18:25] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[18:28] Ilana Levine: No, no, no.

[18:28] Joe Iconis: I made him up 'cause his name rhymed.

[18:30] Ilana Levine: That's a terrible, a terrible secret.

[18:32] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[18:33] Ilana Levine: But um kind of secrets we're looking for.

[18:36] Joe Iconis: And so um we talked a ton, talked a ton, and then we had a couple sessions where we uh we did the outline of the show together. And that actually kicked off with uh this thing that Joe Trace did that um I've never had another collaborator do before and I loved so much, which was he said, let's just both write down um ten things each on ten index cards, just moments from the book that we love that we think should be in the musical. And so we both did that and then sort of like, you know, laid 'em all out and and talked about it.

[19:10] Ilana Levine: How many were the same?

[19:12] Joe Iconis: I have no memory.

[19:13] Ilana Levine: Okay.

[19:13] Joe Iconis: I wish, yeah. We have to like go back in the notes and figure out what was on the index cards, you know.

[19:19] Ilana Levine: I'm sure I have them somewhere.

[19:21] Joe Iconis: Yes.

[19:21] Ilana Levine: At the bottom of the box.

[19:24] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[19:25] Ilana Levine: Borderland hoarder.

[19:27] Joe Iconis: Um but yeah, so we so it's, you know, it's the the process. I I I'm I'm super collaborative uh in everything that I do, but this process in particular was so collaborative. And it was it was such an amazing way to work because we we both sort of set off, you know, in our own worlds, Joe and the the the book and and me and the score, um, with the same idea of the show that we were making. We both were like, this is what the tone is, we both knew where the story was gonna go, and you know, and things of course sort of change and grow and and all that, but we both we both knew what we were going after. And so that meant that we could kind of both, you know, work separately and then come together.

[20:11] Joe Iconis: And so Joe would sort of go off and write a scene, I would go off and write a song, then we would, you know, kind of, you know, meet up and like put and see how they fit together. Um, you know, the first thing that I wrote for the show was uh more than survive, the opening number. And even with that, you know, we had talked about oh, we want it to be this kind of you know, sprawling, starting in Jeremy's bedroom and taking him through the whole first day of school, and we w want to meet every single character in the show and sort of get it all out of the way so the story can, you know, can can start. Uh and so I, you know, I wrote the song and it would be the kind of thing where I would, you know, I would I would uh write, you know, up through Jeremy singing, you know, come on, go go, co-come on, go, go.

And then, you know, in parentheses, Jeremy speaks to his dad. Maybe it's something about this, you know, and then and then, you know, goes to school, and then uh Jeremy runs into this person at a locker. Perhaps they'll talk about something like that, you know. You know, so uh and then Joe Trace would come in and be like, oh, what about this? What about this? What are this? So it was truly uh um truly a collaboration in every in every way.

[21:13] Joe Iconis: And these collaborations are usually like in person, at a coffee shop, in uh in your houses. It's sort of it it sort of depends, you know. Um I I'm so funny in that I am I am so I'm so collaborative as soon as I have have something to bring to the table. But I my my my my process is like I need I need to be I need to just be like left alone uh when I first start writing something. I just need some I just need some like alone time. And that can mean, you know, me at a piano in a rehearsal room with 30 people where I'm just not speaking to anyone and I'm just like focused on the piano and just sort of tuning the world out, or it can mean me, you know, in my apartment for three weeks and trying to work on a song.

And then as soon as I have something, whether that's like you know, the first verse of a song or a kernel of an idea or a full song, then it's like all I want to do is like get in a room with you know a million people and start ripping it apart and and doing something with it. And so with um, you know, with Trace, we worked a lot. We worked a lot in my apartment, we worked a lot in coffee shops, and then at a certain point he um became uh a very successful television writer, and so he uh he left me behind and went to LA, as many people have, um, and he just left me to pick up the pieces of our love in New York.

[22:34] Ilana Levine: Cash checks.

[22:35] Joe Iconis: Let me snick it checks over here, bulldozer.

[22:38] Ilana Levine: Just bring them right to the front of my house.

[22:40] Joe Iconis: Yeah, exactly. I could the only way I could get him to write something was to pretend the script was a check.

[22:45] Ilana Levine: Neil Harris.

[22:46] Joe Iconis: Telegram from Neil Patrick Harris.

[22:49] Ilana Levine: Yeah, exactly.

[22:50] Joe Iconis: So so we buried the lead, but that is what Joe Trace went off to write.

[22:54] Ilana Levine: Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

[22:55] Joe Iconis: He went off to write Lemony Snicket. But but because we had such a great collaboration, and because we really were so in sync, and so you know, we were we both wanted to make the same show, which truly isn't always the case in a collaboration on a new musical. Um, you know, I've I've certainly been in collaborations where you sort of find out halfway through, oh, the show that this um this other collaborator wants to make is just literally not what I want to do.

[23:19] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[23:19] Joe Iconis: Yeah. Uh it's you know, perfectly great show. It's just not the one that I'm making.

[23:23] Ilana Levine: Right.

[23:23] Joe Iconis: Uh but it was so not that with Trace and I. And so we were able to do the long distance collaboration thing really easily.

[23:30] Ilana Levine: So it kept going.

[23:31] Joe Iconis: Yeah. I mean, he left town, but you were able to do it.

[23:34] Ilana Levine: Oh, from from kind of that first Cornelia Street Cafe landmark moment uh to we are presenting our agent with a finished script. How long was that process?

[23:46] Joe Iconis: So the first and the first kind of presentation that we ever did was um it was in 2012, and so it was probably like half a year after we first said, okay, we're gonna work on this thing and and actually write it, maybe a little bit longer. Um Joe Trace and I are are also both huge procrastinators because we're so uh we're so busy. Talented.

[24:10] Ilana Levine: Uh I was busy.

[24:12] Joe Iconis: And yes, and because talented, yes, that's a better better word.

[24:15] Ilana Levine: Um and so even though, you know, we were, you know, uh uh uh air quotes working for six months.

[24:22] Joe Iconis: Very focused work.

[24:23] Ilana Levine: Yeah, we it was the kind of thing where you know, I wrote the opening number and then I wrote I wrote the squip song uh I think after that, and then you know, there was kind of a hiatus until like right before two songs, I must rest now.

[24:36] Joe Iconis: Exactly.

[24:36] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[24:37] Joe Iconis: Two months later.

[24:38] Ilana Levine: I need to feed the talent some more.

[24:39] Joe Iconis: Absolutely. Um, and so then uh, so you know, we I I feel like Be More Chill was sort of written in spurts, you know, where it was like there would be like these very sort of productive, you know, few weeks at a time. Um where we were turning out a lot of material, usually right before we were doing some kind of presentation.

[24:55] Ilana Levine: Sure.

[24:55] Joe Iconis: Deadlines are helpful.

[24:56] Ilana Levine: Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure.

[24:58] Joe Iconis: Um, and so and so the first, you know, presentation we ever did was the just a completely casual read-through of uh most of the first act of the or actually it was like m like the first half of the first act or something, and that was at um the the William Morris uh offices, which is our our our our agency, Trace and I. Um, and it was just like uh uh I'm gonna just grab some friends to you know read the script and uh and then I sang all the songs and just to show a couple people from Two River and my agent and stuff the the the script and in that reading um Will Rollins played Michael uh Lauren Marcus played Christine, uh Eric William Morris played the Squip.

[25:44] Ilana Levine: Um because you were at William Morris.

[25:46] Joe Iconis: It's yeah, exactly.

[25:47] Ilana Levine: So it was mandatory.

[25:48] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[25:49] Ilana Levine: Um so yeah, yeah.

[25:51] Joe Iconis: And I think I forget who else.

[25:54] Ilana Levine: And this is you on the piano.

[25:55] Joe Iconis: Me on the piano, yeah.

[25:56] Ilana Levine: Seth Ellis or Jeremy.

[25:58] Joe Iconis: Yeah. Um, so it was sort of my you know, gang of actors who were like are the people who always, you know, read stuff for me when it's you know when it's new.

[26:07] Ilana Levine: It's when it's new.

[26:08] Joe Iconis: Um, yeah, and it's uh, you know, I love that so many of them ended up in the actual show.

[26:13] Ilana Levine: So beautiful.

[26:14] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[26:14] Ilana Levine: Wait, so you just mentioned the Two River theater reps were present at this first presentation of some of the show.

[26:22] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[26:22] Ilana Levine: Why were they there?

[26:24] Joe Iconis: They were there because Two River is technically commissioned to be more chill. And so how that happened was I uh I had had had a relationship with Two River.

[26:35] Ilana Levine: Um Platonic.

[26:36] Joe Iconis: Uh Platonic, yes, very much so.

[26:38] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[26:38] Joe Iconis: Pre-Bore Chill Platonic. Uh I I had performed there a couple times in these sort of new songwriter nights. You know, uh Two River has a really strong connection with the NYU graduate musical theater writing program, uh, where I went. And so I did uh I did a couple a couple nights uh as you know, one of many writers in these concerts, and they really liked uh these two songs that I did, which were uh Helen Um Things to Ruin and uh Run Away from You, which is my song about uh a werewolf. And uh both songs were sung by uh Jason Sweet Tooth Williams and uh and Two River, you know, made it really clear that they wanted to do something with me. I wanted to do something with them.

[27:19] Ilana Levine: Like let's develop something on these two songs.

[27:24] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, exactly. They're like, oh, let's actually, you know, make a make a new musical if we can. And so that was sort of ongoing, separate from Be More Chill. Joe Trace was really close with John Diaz, who is the artistic director of Two River Theater, because he knew him through uh I think through the public through some sort of you know, um uh playwrighting program that Joe had done at the public. And so uh when we first started working on Be More Chill, um our agent said, Why don't we see if Two River is interested in commissioning the show and and and developing it?

[27:56] Joe Iconis: And uh and that's what happened. And again, sort of like in in the same way that uh Trace and I just really easily slid into writing the show. Uh it was we really easily slid into writing it for Two River. You know, we we told them the idea, and they said, Great, we like it, we like you, let's do it. It was just the most no drama uh birth of a show I've ever experienced. Was Ned Vizini the author of the book, Be More Chill?

[28:24] Ilana Levine: Yeah. Alive at this time?

[28:26] Joe Iconis: He was alive, yeah. And so I spoke to Ned uh on the phone probably uh I think we spoke three times. Okay. Um, and he he was so kind, he was so nice, he uh uh uh really loved Be More Chill. Um it meant a lot to him. He had spent years trying to get it made as a movie and it fell apart, and so he was a little bit, you know, sort of scarred from that, but was really excited about the idea of it becoming a musical. He was like really upfront about um not knowing anything about musicals, and so every time we spoke, you know, any time he sort of you know gave an opinion about the script or character, whatever, he um he would always uh you know say preface it with yeah, yeah. But I don't I don't know anything about musicals. I don't know anything.

[29:18] Ilana Levine: But you weren't sending him material along the way, nor did you have to.

[29:22] Joe Iconis: No, so we didn't have to, and so it was decided that we were gonna wait to send him anything until he could come see a reading of the full show, because you know, a lot of times with uh with with authors or you know, people who are sort of rights holders of of um of property um who aren't theater people, it's hard for them sometimes to wrap their head around the process of making a new musical. And so a lot of times people are really careful about when in the process they uh will show, you know, the original author, the original, you know, director, whoever this material. Would he have had the right to shut it down if he didn't like it?

[30:03] Ilana Levine: I am I think, yeah.

[30:05] Joe Iconis: I mean, I I imagine he would, but it's um, you know, he didn't have like approval over things. It wasn't that kind of thing. He he didn't he did not want to be uh involved in that way. He was totally excited by it and was totally um I think I think um he I think there's a world where he would have been a a real presence in our process, but he wasn't, you know, he wasn't an author who was like, you know, I need to be there every moment, you have to, you know, have this character and this character, you must include this. Um he really respected the process.

[30:35] Ilana Levine: Yeah, yeah. That's incredible.

[30:37] Joe Iconis: Yeah, he liked us a lot. And he um what our our first conversation uh, you know, I was sort of talking about what I thought the music would sound like, and you know, I talked about how I thought it the vibe was gonna be John Hughes meets John Carpenter, and he loved that. And and I said, you know, I think the music will be kind of like a geek rock pop, it's really Synthie experience, like um, like you know, like Weezer or something. That was the example I used. And he was like, like, oh, I love Weezer. You know, maybe maybe we should see if we if we could get Rivers Cuomo, the lead singer of Weezer, to to write some music for this. And I just remember thinking, like, um, we will not be doing that because I am the one who is writing the music for this. Let me explain what I'm saying to you then.

[31:21] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[31:22] Joe Iconis: What I meant was just it will hark in a uh back and a feeling too.

[31:26] Ilana Levine: Right, right, right. We're just gonna summon or you're gonna say.

[31:30] Joe Iconis: Yeah. But Weezer, if you're listening, right? We hope you come see the show.

[31:34] Ilana Levine: Yes, please. Please, Rivers.

[31:35] Joe Iconis: Yes. Um, and the other thing on that first phone call that that Ned said that I loved and always think about is that he so he had seen two musicals, he saw Wicked and he saw Hairspray. And um he uh he did not love Wicked, but he loved hairspray. And he really loved and hairspray the moment when the poster um comes alive. Like there's uh this moment where like this, you know, the the backup group, the dynamites, the other on a poster in the street in Baltimore, and then uh it sort of comes alive and like the it becomes this like real life backup group. And he really liked uh liked that moment a lot. I always think about that.

[32:10] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[32:11] Joe Iconis: Yeah. So this reading happens at the agency.

[32:14] Ilana Levine: Yeah. Is there magic in the air? Like what's the reaction the moment you sort of play the final note?

[32:19] Joe Iconis: Um and no no magic. It was sort of it was the first that first like the first reading was so in process. It and it very much felt like, oh, there's there's something here. It was like there's a glimmer of something. There are some nice songs and there's some.

[32:34] Ilana Levine: Glimmers of magic.

[32:35] Joe Iconis: Glimmers of magic, yeah. Nothing more than a glimmer. And then um this is this is very insane, but we after that reading, we went as a group, all of and Tepper was there and you know everyone was there. We went to uh to get a drink at this bar vintage on ninth Avenue, and it was their last night and they were closing.

[32:52] Ilana Levine: Sure they were.

[32:53] Joe Iconis: Yeah. Because iconists are like this is back here. I'm like a steamroller. Yeah, don't come over to my house. Yeah, geez. So you continue on your way. But Two River is like, we want we're we're still in.

[33:06] Ilana Levine: Still in Yeah, still in, and they they were very committed to take it to production, which also isn't the case uh all the time. You know, a lot of theaters will commission something, but never actually do it. You know, but Two River was like, no, we think that there's a lot of promise here. Wanna keep working on it. So um we, you know, developed it, which just means that we, you know, kept writing it and reading it. Reading it, and like, oh yeah, and getting, you know, a lot of notes, so many notes, notes and notes and notes. Um, and uh we just kept working on it. And so then we did our first like official 29 hour reading, um, which is where it's the full show and there's a full cast of people, and you do it from start to finish, and everyone learns the music, and it feels like a you know, like a like a uh an uh it it it feels like oh, this is what the show is without it being staged. Is there at any point a director?

[34:00] Ilana Levine: Um Yes.

[34:00] Joe Iconis: There is there so we had we had a director who was with Be More Chill uh pre Stephen Brackett.

[34:09] Ilana Levine: Okay, and for this 29 hour workshop, is there a director that is not Steven Brackett?

[34:14] Joe Iconis: There was a director is not Stephen Brackett. And the director uh who was totally totally great, very wonderful. Um he was a very uh sparkly credentialed uh sort of classic musical comedy director. And um, and and initially the the idea was that uh how how cool would it be to have this, you know, this show that felt like so young and hip and edgy, directed by this dude who is known for just doing like you know, classic musical theater with like a capital C. Um and so he was the director of this this you know reading that we did in um did he cast it or did you bring in the people you wanted for the workshop?

[34:58] Joe Iconis: Um a little column A, a little column B. So I had uh I had some people who I um you know who I brought with me. Um You're like, I'd love these guys to do the 29 hour workshop. Of course. And then there was a couple people that he was sort of like, oh, what about this person, this person? And so it was sort of a mixture, but I will say that it was it was a majority of my uh my people also because this director just wasn't as familiar with um the type of actor that we were all looking for. And he, to his credit, was very much like, listen, I don't like I don't know like young weird people. So I'm open.

[35:31] Ilana Levine: Yeah, so let's like you know, bring some people in.

[35:33] Joe Iconis: Great. Uh which was great. And so um and so we uh set about doing this, and it was in uh January of 2014. Great. Uh on 49th Street.

[35:45] Ilana Levine: So it was winter.

[35:46] Joe Iconis: It was winter. It was cold. Yes, in a building that no longer exists.

[35:49] Ilana Levine: Of course not, because you were there.

[35:51] Joe Iconis: It was in the Davenport Studios. You just burn everything down.

[35:56] Ilana Levine: Whatever.

[35:56] Joe Iconis: Joe said a fun. Okay. I'm worried about this podcast.

[36:01] Ilana Levine: Yeah, sorry.

[36:02] Joe Iconis: Let's all evacuate. It's okay. Yeah. Because it means something great has also happened at the same time.

[36:08] Ilana Levine: That's right for art in general.

[36:10] Joe Iconis: That's right. Um, and so we had we had this reading. It was the first ever reading of of the show, you know, from start to finish. And it was crazy because Ned Vizzini um he he he committed suicide. He died right before that reading. He um he committed suicide on December 19th, 2013. And I was at my uh I was at my Christmas show, it was at 54 below. It was the day of the Christmas show, the day of our tech, and um, and my agent called me and said that Ned had killed himself, sort of, you know, uh it and uh obviously unexpected. Um but it was so it was so uh horrible horrible, obviously, um for so many reasons, but uh the thing that I just still cannot believe is that he never heard any any anything from the show.

And at that time we had a few demos, like we had like Michael in the bathroom and and stuff like that. And everyone uh was so insistent that he not hear anything until he could come to the reading and see the full thing. And uh and we knew and he was invited. He was coming like we knew when the reading was it was a month later, you know um but yeah it's uh it was just the the the most insane horrible thing. So we did that reading and Two River said, okay, we're gonna commit to doing the show. We're gonna make it happen. And so then we were in um sort of development stuff for a year and then our original director uh we ended up um parting ways with him just because he was super busy he was working on 10 million shows um and he just it the schedules just didn't line up.

And so then we found ourselves in need of a director that the and this all kind of went down like um uh this went down like late fall early winter of two thousand and and fourteen and and so we were just about to go into production for Be More Chill at Two River uh which happened in the spring of 2015 and um that's when we hooked up with Stephen Brackett who was a director who I uh I had loved for years and I had worked with on lots of little things like he directed this crazy play that I wrote some songs for um uh that Nick Jones wrote uh and he directed uh the one uh one woman show of um this great uh actor writer named Katie Shore, who's the wife of Lance Rubin, who's one of my best friends who I wrote a musical with.

[38:40] Joe Iconis: And so Steven had always sort of been in my in my world. Um and he uh he came on board the project and it was just kind of like shot out of a canon from there. He helped drive it forward. He was the perfect person at the helm.

[38:56] Ilana Levine: You cast up for Two River.

[38:59] Joe Iconis: Yep. Uh do you use a casting director? Are you still able to kind of harness the the goodwill and on both sides of performer and you loving these people?

[39:09] Ilana Levine: Yeah, we uh we did use a casting director. Um, you know, there were some people from our first reading uh who everyone loved, like George Salazar, um and Eric William Morris, who played Squip. And um, and in that first reading, Lauren Lauren Marcus was still reading Christine. Uh and um and everyone loved her, but sort of felt like, oh, I don't know if that role is like, you know, if that's like the best, if that's like the best idea for that role. Um and so uh and so the cast ended up being uh a collection of people who had been with the the show, people who I knew who had worked with me for years, um people who I was a fan of but had never gotten a chance to work with, um, you know, like Gerard Caronico and uh Will Connolly, and then a few people who I was not familiar with who kind of came in and um did they audition?

[40:07] Ilana Levine: Yeah, oh my gosh, yeah, yeah.

[40:08] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[40:08] Ilana Levine: Yeah, even the people you knew.

[40:10] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah. Because artistic directors and Stephen Brackett and everyone needed to see them. Everyone needed to see them, and it's you know, and it's just it's just the way it's just the way it is, you know. And and so all of these, all of these people who, you know, I work with for years and years, like when when we do something like this, they they they have to audition. And for me, it's like I don't ever want I don't ever want anyone to say that I'm like you know, sort of forcing these people in or anything.

[40:36] Ilana Levine: And so um are you playing the piano for people's auditions or are you behind the table watching?

[40:36] Joe Iconis: Behind the table watching.

[40:42] Ilana Levine: So when everyone comes in who's your friend, yeah. By the way, Lauren Marcus is also your wife.

[40:46] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[40:47] Ilana Levine: Did she have to audition?

[40:48] Joe Iconis: Oh yeah. Okay, that's the craziest thing ever.

[40:51] Ilana Levine: Yeah right? Sure. So how do you talk about that?

[40:54] Joe Iconis: Okay, uh let's pretend we don't know which does she ask you to leave when you're so weird. When she comes in, like just for mine. It's just the weird it's just the weirdest thing.

[41:04] Ilana Levine: And it's the hardest part.

[41:05] Joe Iconis: Yeah, it's the hard part, and it's just uh it's a necessary evil. And you know, from the very beginning when I first started doing this and I first started, you know, sort of doing this whole family thing, right? I I said, I'm never gonna put someone in something um who I who I wasn't a hundred percent behind artistic. For that part. For that part, right? Who I would not lay down on train tracks for. I just won't, I won't do it. And that's just the promise that I've made to myself. And so because of that, um, I feel like, you know, I it it it sucks, but I I you know, I can be honest with people and it's just it's it it just is what it is, you know. Um and then having said that, I will also fight, you know, vigorously and viciously for people who I truly believe deserve to have a part.

And I feel like it's I I refuse to accept that someone's not gonna get a part because of the perception of them being friends with me or you know, or knowing me in some way because also theater is so small, it's like everyone knows.

[42:04] Joe Iconis: Of course they know you're gonna be able to do everyone, it's like and I everyone's married to everyone. Of course, or you know, or everyone's doing something with everyone, and I feel like, you know, I'd be for me, it's like I have the relationships I actually have with these people are they're real relationships. And so I'm not gonna I'm not gonna not bring someone up because my relationship is real as opposed to you know whatever. Not even a okay I will just say though the the the even one spouse auditioning that is that is a little unusual. That's super weird. That's super weird. That is above and beyond weird and all hail uh Joe and Lauren for getting through those moments. Yeah and but you know we're really uh we're really good about not we're really good about not being like you know again uh finger quotes married like in the room you know both of us hate the idea of anyone being like oh you know of course she's gonna be in it or like oh you know of course she's doing that show with him right um and so we just like people to sort of you know meet we want to be we want people to meet us on our own terms and then you know along the way when someone's like wait you're married that's our favorite thing you know and someone's yeah no idea um and so uh yeah but her her audition her audition was hilarious because she you know she was auditioning for a part that she didn't play in the reading right and so um and so it really it I didn't know if she was gonna get it you know and it's like as much as I you know can fight for people at a certain point to be right they have to be right you know um but she was so amazing and everyone's like there's it would be hard I'd be hard pressed to imagine anyone else yeah as Brooke um at this point.

[43:39] Joe Iconis: Anyway so you go to True River uh you have assembled your cast, you have your director um do songs change or new songs added at that point? Yeah, yeah. I wrote a few songs in uh during the rehearsal process for Two River. I write a lot, I write a lot in the room. I um obviously am very inspired by uh actors. And so as much as I write a show before we ever set foot in the room, um I I invariably rewrite so much as soon as people are you know performing the material. Um and I, you know, I like to sort of wrap the the roles and wrap the material around the human beings who are performing it. And so that just leads to you know new yeah new discoveries and it leads to sometimes new songs or uh and so I wrote um I wrote uh two player game in rehearsal uh because watching Will and George you were like I see what this relationship is.

Yes and two player game used to be this song called Level Up and I uh and the only the thing that it uh shares in common with the current two player game is just to find the bad guy push him aside then move on forward that that sort of rap thing um that was in level up but then the rest of level up was different and I I just and people people always liked the song it was actually a really popular song in the show anytime we did readings and I just hated it. I said the song's like not it doesn't work this isn't correct. And it sounded a lot like another song but I won't say what it is.

[45:16] Joe Iconis: In the show or a song in the world? A song in the world. Okay. It's song yeah it's uh like a a like a uh a rock song from the the 70s uh and it just and as soon as I heard it I was like I could never unhear it and it's like I'm not letting the song like be in my musical. So it would just drive me crazy. Uh and so um, and so I I tried to rewrite it, but I just couldn't. And then as soon as you know, sort of Will Connolly and and George Salazar were doing their thing uh in rehearsal, uh, I was like, Oh, I I know, I know what this what this should be. And that's when the whole um, you know, guys like us are cool in college idea kind of came into the song. And I wrote it really fast. I wrote it in Ripley Greer, where this was just the rehearsal studio that we rehearsed for Two River at um You rehearsed in New York City for the Two River, which is a New Jersey theater production. Yeah, we rehearsed in New York City for I think a either one or two weeks, and then we finished rehearsals in New Jersey.

[46:09] Joe Iconis: Okay. Um, but yeah, I wrote it in the in the New York City uh piece of the the rehearsal process um and wrote it really quickly. I it was like uh they were doing the scene in one room, I went into another room and just kind of like just wrote it. What do you mean? What do you mean? Sam and I, I mean I I just blew my mind. I love you, Sam, but I'm not aware, and I know something about you, but I don't think of you as like a songwriter. No. Right. Right. So most people like what you just said, like, and then I went to the moon and then I came back and we showed everyone comfortable to the moon. Can you just explain how the muse in Joe Iconis works? It works. Uh it works differently depending on the the circumstances. Um I tend to do very well when I'm in a highly pressurized situation, and I tend to do very well when I'm uh sort of fully immersed in an artistic process.

[47:09] Joe Iconis: Okay. And so I um, you know, my my process is always I just I obsess over things. I think about whatever, whether it's the you know, the song lyric or the music or both, uh, I think so much about what I'm going to write before I ever actually sit down to write. Um, and so I think when I'm that that same sort of thing happens um uh when I'm you know in rehearsal for something and and write something but uh it's because there's this like this deadline because I know that oh in three weeks we're gonna be on a stage whether I like it or not whether I write the song or not we're gonna you know we're gonna be there and and it's this sort of like really stressful highly pressurized situation um that just sort of I think accelerates my my creative process and just you know like kicks the muse up to 11 and um and you know allows me uh to um be I kind of you know three steps ahead of myself when I actually sit down to to write.

[48:10] Sam Maher: And generally speaking if you had like if if I was a betting man in Vegas do you generally start with playing a tune out on a piano do you generally hear the words or or is there no like is there not it it's a constant in that way.

[48:27] Joe Iconis: It's usually lyric driven. It's like 90% of the time. And did you hear like one of them say to the other, you know what, but like I was cool in college. Like are these things that like sometimes you'll hear someone say and then be like oh oh yeah it's I mean it's it it usually comes out of conversation uh with my collaborators you know and so I I'll just like talk something to death with them and I'll you know we'll talk about um uh you know like for for example like the um you know like the the pants song in the show um you know that was a song that didn't exist for a long time and um and a song that I wrote for that that first reading in 2014 and that came out of all these conversations with Joe Trace and and just being like, what is this song wanna be about?

Like, what is he trying to say? And um Joe Trace, you know, said like, oh, well, it's like, you know, he's like showing them that, you know, when you love someone, you know, you put your pants on. And I was like, okay, yeah, that's what that song is.

[49:18] Joe Iconis: You know, did you have any idea what that means? Um not at first, but then you know, then I figured it out. What what he meant by that, like what the metaphor is. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Because like when you love someone, you can also take your pants off. Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. But not in this one. Right, not in this one. No, quite the opposite. Right. Um, so that was a thing he said, and it sparked a creative idea for you, and they were like, I know what you mean. Yeah, and in that, in that instance, it was, you know, a almost a literal, you know, sentence fragment that then became the song. But in something like, you know, to play your game, I I uh I I the the conversations were, you know, about the character of Michael and what what he's trying to do for Jeremy and what he's hoping to get out of Jeremy.

[50:04] Joe Iconis: And um, and then I, you know, just sort of thinking about him and thinking about why is Michael so um why is Michael so uh the confident in a way that other characters in the show aren't confident and um you know arriving at this idea of like oh he is you know aware, he's more aware of how he sort of fits into the world um and has this, you know, he he knows that his forward thinking nature. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, you know, and that was sort of the thing that like got me to to guys like us are cool in college. Are you a video game guy? Nope.

[50:36] Sam Maher: So that's just like I have a sense that there's a bad guy and push him aside.

[50:42] Joe Iconis: Oh my gosh. It's just all made up. Made made the fuck up. I um I'm just not I'm not a gamer, and so many fans of Be More Chill are gamers. And Joe Trace is, you know, he's he's he's he's not like full-blown gamer, but he's like a lot more aware of the world. Yeah. And I love I love the culture of it. I love you know the gamer type person. I just don't know it at all. And so for me, when I was writing that song, I was like, I'm like making up this you know game called Apocalypse of the Damned because it fit into our our sort of larger, you know, zombie um thing in Be More Chill. Uh and uh but yeah, it's just me. It's just me faking.

[51:22] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah. But for me, you know, I'm so obsessed with in things like that. Um having it having anything that's sort of dealing with anything that's like you know, technological or any um like sort of nuts and bolts thing, I always feel like it's not it's not actually about that, it's about the people. You know, and so for me, um it's not it's not it's not a song about a video game. It's they're they're playing a video game and it's and it's and it's a song about life, isn't it? Yeah, yeah, for sure. You know, it's just like this is them surviving. Exactly, exactly. And it's like they just they're you know, they're there are two boys who like the roles that they have to play in their lives, are like they're two boys who sit in a bedroom and they play a video game, and then they have to figure out how to have a conversation around that video game, but it's not about the actual video game in the same way that like the smartphone hour isn't actually about texting, it's you know, it's about the information that is passed.

[52:10] Joe Iconis: Um and so uh with things like like that, I always feel like it's better that I don't know, you know, the gaming terms because it's not you know, I would hate to write a song where it's just like you know, in jokes and and laugh lines that are you know clever, you know, turns of phrase based on like specific references from you know it's Zelda's mean now. I mean now you can listen to this show 20 years from it doesn't matter. Right. There will be some kind of game. Right. And no one would actually know what you know, Mario Kart is at that point. Exactly. Or I guess Mario Kart is very tame and adorable, but you know what I mean.

[52:46] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[52:46] Joe Iconis: Um did the did the show continue to evolve and change throughout the production at Two River in terms of material? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, we kept working on it all through our previews, and it definitely definitely felt like uh we didn't finish it, we just put a pause button on it. You know, when we when when we froze the show there, everyone involved thought like, okay, we did we did our best mounting this very ambitious you know new American musical uh at this gorgeous regional theater and let's open this thing and then let's keep working on it and see what happens next.

[53:19] Joe Iconis: So it definitely felt like um we were giving people the best show we could, but there was more to do. And were you thrilled with it? Um yeah, I thought it was not to leave the witness, but did you feel like you like this is in great shape? I'm proud of this. Oh yeah, I was really I was really happy with it, and I thought there were moments that were um everything that I would want from a musical that I was uh uh involved with. Um yeah, I was really happy with it. You know, and then there were moments that were not my favorite, but I it it felt like uh yeah, that's you know, we did the best we we did the best we could with the time we had.

[53:54] Sam Maher: And is Joe Trace able to be at rehearsal?

[53:56] Joe Iconis: And uh so yeah, 100% there. Writing in LA at the time. No, no, no, no, no. No, no, no, Joe Joe Trace is very involved in the process. I just like to harass him for moving to LA. Well, we will we'll have him on the podcast and he'll be able to weigh in on what it was like to be harassed.

[54:14] Sam Maher: Okay.

[54:14] Joe Iconis: And the suit that's trying to bully him back. So when the something really remarkable happened, which is maybe unusual, maybe not, uh, which is a cast recording was made of this production.

[54:28] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[54:28] Joe Iconis: How did that come to be? So what happened was there was a ton of um momentum going for Be More Chill when we were in How?

[54:38] Sam Maher: How did that happen?

[54:39] Joe Iconis: It just sort of, you know, word of mouth and and people, you know, seeing the show in previews and hearing songs and you know, people talking. And it was we opened right after the right after the Tony Awards in 2015. And so, you know, it was like that's like a you know, this time in the theater community when there's just parties and everyone's talking to each other.

[54:57] Joe Iconis: And so everyone was like, Oh my gosh, be more chill, be more chill, be more chill. So I've heard it's great. I've heard it's great. Coming from Jersey to the city, there's like a buzz in New York City in the community. Yes. And then how I, you know, how that how that reaches me is, you know, people, you know, emailing me being like, Oh, I've heard the show is great, I'm gonna come, and then you know, the theater being like, Oh, this producer requested tickets, this uh you know, amazing theater requested tickets, you're gonna come to see the show. And so we uh so we it was feeling really good, and it was feeling like, oh my gosh, this could be the one that you know moves on for me, because I had sort of had a whole bunch of shows leading up to this that um also had this kind of momentum, um, and then for one reason or another didn't didn't happen.

[55:40] Joe Iconis: And so we opened and uh we uh we got uh we got a very uh mixed apathetic uh dismissive review from the New York Times.

[55:54] Joe Iconis: Um yeah, for sure. I read the Times review, um just because for, you know, for my whole career, the future life of my shows has hinged on that. Um and I, you know, it happened to me multiple times and then happened again with Be More Chill. So what is that for you? Um it's really, really difficult. You know, and I, it's hard because I am someone who, you know, I grew up going to musicals. I was such a theater kid. I was so aware of the theater scene. So I was a kid who would like, you know, I would read reviews of every single show that came out and I would take them so personally if it was a show that I loved that did not get the review that I thought it deserved, you know, they were robbed.

[56:41] Ilana Levine: Exactly.

[56:42] Joe Iconis: Yeah, and I, and I saw, you know, from I've seen literally from seeing Little Shop of Horrors in 1987, I was just so aware of the theater, you know, seasons and how little shows get to go to Broadway. And, you know, I had known that you, unless you have a show that's based on a huge property, unless you have a star, unless you have a, you know, a star producer backing you, whether publicly or secretly, if you have a little show, the only way you're gonna get it off Broadway and then on Broadway is from a great New York Times review. Like that's just, that's what happens. That's how it works.

[57:17] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[57:17] Joe Iconis: And so, you know, and for me, I'm probably been overly obsessed with that in my career, but it just has happened to me many times. And so, uh, and so are you at like an opening night party? Does it happen in the traditional sense of the way it does in New York? Like does the review come out the first night of your performing?

[57:35] Ilana Levine: No, so it does, so in New York it'll come out the night of, and uh, when you do a show regionally, it'll be like a couple days later, which is had your opening night, you've had the great party.

[57:46] Joe Iconis: Yes.

[57:46] Ilana Levine: And then three days later, yes, you get this like sucker punch.

[57:50] Joe Iconis: Yes. And it's just, I mean, it's just the worst because, you know, for me, I'm like, you know, I'm, it's all I can think about. It's like being in the worst, you know, purgatory. Like, how do you, what's the setup for you?

[58:08] Joe Iconis: Every time, every time this has happened to me, I have, um, I have, you know, had a cell phone, and I've just been obsessively refreshing the page on my cell phone. So no matter where I am.

[58:19] Ilana Levine: Right.

[58:19] Joe Iconis: And you know the day it's coming out generally. Sometimes for Be More Chill, I did not.

[58:23] Ilana Levine: Okay.

[58:23] Joe Iconis: We just knew it was kind of gonna be like these few days. Um and so I, I was with, uh, I when I read the review, I was with my, uh, my good buddy Jeremy Morse. Um it was, yeah, he, we were at Sardi's and, uh, I was getting a drink with him because he, he was doing Waitress at the time and out of town, and, uh, and he knew, you know, he knew because we had, he had done Blood Song of Love. We, he's, he's, you know, he's like a good friend, he's very aware of my, and he's been in the trenches with you before.

[58:55] Ilana Levine: Oh yeah, yeah.

[58:56] Joe Iconis: And so it came out as we, as we were there, and he was just like, Oh god, oh god, oh no, oh no. And I was like, I have to go. I have to go to Jeremy.

[59:03] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[59:05] Joe Iconis: And he was like, go, go, man. I'm so sorry.

[59:07] Ilana Levine: Of course you do.

[59:07] Joe Iconis: And then truly, you know, and you walk home, like you just walk home gutted. Yeah, and just, you know, just crying and like truly because it sounds literally.

[59:17] Ilana Levine: Oh, literally, oh please, yeah, yeah.

[59:19] Joe Iconis: Yeah. It's, it sounds so ridiculous, but it really is, um, it's the death of the dream. It's like a death. It's something that I've been working on for years and years and years that I, I knew was over. I just knew it. And I, I've, you know, my whole career I've tried to be so positive, and I'm, I will never, you know, anytime I've gotten a review that has stopped the process of a new musical that I've, I've worked on, I have done every single thing I possibly could to see if I could get around that. Um, and I was never able to do that. But with, um, with Be More Chill, uh, yeah, it was just such a, just such a bummer. And you know, like, wait, I tried it a new way. This is adapted material.

[1:00:00] Ilana Levine: Exactly.

[1:00:01] Joe Iconis: Adapted material. So nothing.

[1:00:03] Ilana Levine: So nothing.

[1:00:04] Joe Iconis: Right, right, right, very much, very much that. You know, it was my karmic path in this lifetime.

[1:00:08] Ilana Levine: Yes, yes.

[1:00:09] Joe Iconis: You know, and then it just casts such a, it's, it's just, it, it's so challenging. You know, then after the review, then all, you know, anyone who's gonna come see the show, most people were gonna come see the show, they don't, and then they, you know, and I, and I totally get it. I get it, you know, and then there's all, uh, reasons, 10 million reasons that are not in the review, but it, it happens, it happens every time. It's just, you know, you're already trying to get them to come to New Jersey.

[1:00:31] Ilana Levine: Exactly.

[1:00:32] Joe Iconis: They're not gonna come for, you know, a show that already has the New York Times has said like no.

[1:00:36] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[1:00:37] Joe Iconis: Um and so then, you know, it's the kind of thing where I'll be like watching, you know, I would watch Michael in the bathroom the week after, you know, that happened, and the week when it was clear the show is not gonna ever move on. And I would just think like, I think this is so good. I think it's so good. This, this theater of people who don't, who don't really care about, you know, that they're just seeing something like that.

[1:00:58] Ilana Levine: Actual audience members, yeah, like they're loving this, like loving it, and it's, and, and you know, with something like that, I, I, I because I, you know, I, I love, I love actors so much, like I, I look at George Salazar's performance and think like this is, it is a crime that people are not gonna get to see this after, you know, two weeks.

[1:01:17] Ilana Levine: Well, how ironic.

[1:01:18] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, yeah. How ironic. Because that very thing, someone or two, uh, had a phone and they started filming it, yeah, and someone filmed it professionally when you made the cast recording.

[1:01:32] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[1:01:33] Joe Iconis: And I know Kurt Deutsch and others at Ghost Light Records had been fans of yours before. So together with Two River, they made the cast recording.

[1:01:41] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[1:01:41] Joe Iconis: And so the cast recording happened, uh, really because yes, Ghost Light and Two River paid for it, which is also unheard of.

[1:01:50] Ilana Levine: Thank you, Two River.

[1:01:51] Joe Iconis: Thank you, Two River. Like that's extraordinary that they did that. This is not a huge, this is not a huge producing theater.

[1:01:57] Ilana Levine: No, no, no, no, no.

[1:01:59] Joe Iconis: I mean, it's a beautiful theater.

[1:02:00] Ilana Levine: It's gorgeous.

[1:02:01] Joe Iconis: But their budget does not allow and we're gonna make a recording after the show.

[1:02:05] Ilana Levine: Right, right, right, right, right.

[1:02:06] Joe Iconis: And cast recordings are so expensive. I mean, extraordinarily expensive.

[1:02:11] Ilana Levine: And you gotta bring in the bathtub.

[1:02:12] Joe Iconis: It's a lot, tubs alone.

[1:02:16] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[1:02:16] Joe Iconis: Um, but Two River said, We are very proud of the show. We love the show. We, uh, think that it deserves to be preserved, and we're gonna do it. And they, they did it, and Ghost and Ghost Kurt Deutsch came to the show and he was like, This is amazing, this needs to be preserved. It just does. And so they just made it happen. And I have to say that I, if it was up to me, that cast recording wouldn't have happened. Um, not for me wanting to get in the way of it, but I was so, uh, disappointed and sort of broken by the experience and knowing that we were gonna close and nothing was gonna happen with it that I just kind of felt like whatever, who cares? Like fine, yeah, you know.

[1:02:51] Ilana Levine: Exactly.

[1:02:51] Joe Iconis: Yeah, it's like you want to do it, great, awesome. I'll get excited about it. But I just felt like what is, what is the point of spending years working on these musicals?

[1:03:02] Joe Iconis: Exactly, exactly. Um, and so they did it, and we recorded very soon after we closed. And, um, and it, uh, and it, you know, it was great, uh, the recording, and I loved the album. I thought it sounded beautiful and, um, you know, was very involved with myself, self and Charlie Rosen and, and Kurt and everyone.

[1:03:06] Ilana Levine: The engine for this as well. Like you've been the engine for everything.

[1:03:19] Ilana Levine: He was the musical director.

[1:03:20] Joe Iconis: Uh yeah, the musical director and, uh, well a musical arranger, right? So you did the orchestrations and he supervised and, um, and so we released it, uh, we released it on Halloween of 2015, and I was doing a Halloween concert at the Laurie Beachman Theater, and I was like, we should have, we should make that like a release party, right? You know, and everyone's like, if you want to, sure. Fine.

[1:03:40] Joe Iconis: Uh and so I, you know, I essentially, so you did the concert and then you did, you then play, was the concert at all connected to Be More Chill music or was it totally other?

[1:03:40] Joe Iconis: It was totally other. It was like a Halloween concert that I was doing anyway, and I was like, we should have a, it was like we should have a party, right? You know, yeah. Um and so I was like, why don't I make my concert a little party for, it was like very much like throwing myself my own birthday party, you know.

[1:04:05] Ilana Levine: Um so you had a listening party.

[1:04:07] Joe Iconis: Essentially, yeah, yeah.

[1:04:08] Ilana Levine: Did you guys after your concert, did you play through the whole album?

[1:04:11] Joe Iconis: At the Beachman, yeah.

[1:04:12] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[1:04:12] Joe Iconis: Or, uh, at the West Bank upstairs, you know, at the bar afterwards. Um, but I, uh, yeah, I don't, I don't listen to my own stuff a lot. And, um, but when Be More Chill, uh, came out on Halloween, on Halloween morning, I was like, oh, I wanna listen, I wanna listen to it to and pretend I'm like someone who's, you know, like hearing it for the first time. Uh and I was going to Party City to get, uh, supplies and like decorations for my Halloween show that night. And I left my apartment and I was walking to Party City on 34th Street, and by the time I got to 34th Street, it was the end of More Than Survive, um, with the, with the Nanas, and I have such a vivid memory of, um, again of, uh, just hysterically crying on 34th Street, listening to the end of More Than Survive, and thinking, like, I genuinely think this is really good.

Like I think, I think this is very, very good. And I don't understand what people want if it is not, if it is not this, or if this is not allowed to be given the same opportunities that so many other things have, because I don't know how to do better than this.

[1:05:21] Ilana Levine: So when this podcast is out in the world, people will know what ended up happening.

[1:05:26] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[1:05:27] Ilana Levine: And so that's the beauty of this story.

[1:05:29] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[1:05:29] Ilana Levine: Right?

[1:05:30] Joe Iconis: Yeah.

[1:05:31] Ilana Levine: What kept you going?

[1:05:33] Joe Iconis: So here's like time after time. You listen to that, you're weeping, you go to Party City, you buy some Halloween stuff, you do the show that night, you play it again.

[1:05:43] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[1:05:43] Joe Iconis: And now remarkably, like many people are in agreement with you. And they're really not crying. They're just like, oh my God, this is amazing.

[1:05:49] Ilana Levine: Yeah, yeah.

[1:05:49] Joe Iconis: How cool. Um, like, how do you from that not knowing two years later? I guess is the timeline.

[1:05:57] Ilana Levine: Yep, tears.

[1:05:58] Joe Iconis: That that's sort of like something strange is happening. Um, what is it?

[1:06:03] Ilana Levine: It's, it's alive, yeah, right?

[1:06:05] Joe Iconis: Yeah. Um, it's risen from the dead. How did you keep going?

[1:06:10] Joe Iconis: I just, you know, it's like what I've always done. I just keep working on new things. You know, I, I always, I, I for, for most of my career, I really believed that something would, would break for me and for the people who I work with, and that it would put me at the level that I have been, you know, trying to get at since 2008. Um, and, uh, but it really around like by after Be More Chill, things changed a little bit for me, and I kept, I kept working on a million things.

[1:06:43] Ilana Levine: So it changed in that you were not broken. You are momentarily broken. You let yourself have all your feelings deeply. But you're not, they haven't broken you.

[1:06:52] Joe Iconis: No.

[1:06:53] Ilana Levine: The, the whoever they are, the New York Times or whoever the powers that be are that are determining who gets to go to the next level.

[1:07:00] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:07:00] Ilana Levine: They do not break your spirit.

[1:07:02] Joe Iconis: No, no, no, no. I got close, but I never, I never stopped. I never, I never, you know, took a break. Um, which like maybe I should have, but I just, I just couldn't, you know. And I, um, and then I did a, you know, I, I after Be More Chill, I wrote this musical called Broadway Bounty Hunter that was the Barrington Stage Company the summer after Be More Chill in 2016. And, um, and that had sort of a similar trajectory, uh, to Be More Chill, uh, where, you know, we weren't able to get it, um, get it on a stage after its production. And, um, but I just, you know, I just kept, kept going. But it, it definitely got harder and harder and harder and harder. Uh just because it had happened to me so many times.

You know, I'm like working on these shows. And the problem is that I through all of this, I just kept feeling like I think that I feel like these shows are good. You know, I truly, I truly liked them and I truly believed that there was artistic worth in what I was doing. And my, I saw with my own eyes how my work and the work of the artists that I collaborate with was affecting people. Like I, I saw it time and time again. And you know, I do this.

[1:08:06] Ilana Levine: How it resonates for an audience.

[1:08:08] Joe Iconis: In huge ways. And like I, you know, do these, these concerts, you know, I've, I've been doing a concept and family shows for, you know, whatever, 10, 11 years. And so I, I'm lucky enough to see it. I can, I'm in a room with, you know, people reacting to my stuff. And, and it, it got to a point where like, you know, the, the better the reaction, you know, the after the show, it would just make me so sad.

[1:08:30] Ilana Levine: Please don't like it so much.

[1:08:31] Joe Iconis: It's, yeah, yeah, yeah. Cause I'd be like, what, what is going on where it feels like actual human beings? Or like, you know, the like Mark Shamans of the world or the Betty Buckleys of the world are just like losing their minds over this stuff.

[1:08:45] Ilana Levine: Right.

[1:08:45] Joe Iconis: But like sadly, they don't write for the New York Times.

[1:08:47] Ilana Levine: Right, exactly.

[1:08:48] Joe Iconis: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Or don't control like the keys to the kingdom in a certain way, you know. Um, and so yeah, it was, it was challenging. It was a weird few years pre-2017 with Be More Chill.

[1:08:59] Ilana Levine: Um, congratulations.

[1:09:01] Joe Iconis: Thanks.

[1:09:02] Ilana Levine: It's gonna be great.

[1:09:03] Joe Iconis: It's gonna be great.

[1:09:04] Ilana Levine: Can't believe it.

[1:09:05] Joe Iconis: That was really awesome.

[1:09:14] Ilana Levine: Thank you for listening.

[1:09:16] Sam Maher: Hey, you can find us on Instagram at how to be more chill.

[1:09:19] Ilana Levine: And one quick thing before we go, could you go to Apple Podcasts or whatever podcast platform you listen on and just take a moment to rate and review us?

[1:09:28] Sam Maher: We would really appreciate it.

[1:09:30] Ilana Levine: And do not forget, this is Ilana.

[1:09:33] Sam Maher: This is Sam.

[1:09:34] Ilana Levine: Tell us how to be more chill.

[1:09:36] Sam Maher: Never hung with a girl like you before.

[1:09:39] Ilana Levine: I don't know if you know it, but I am sure that for me, you are an operating.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred