In the first episode of what we're calling How To Be More Chill "4.0", Sam and Ilana interview someone who could not be a more integral part of the Be More Chill story: Jason SweetTooth Williams. Jason played Mr. Heere, Mr... Read More
From the show: How To Be More Chill
Featured Shows
About
In the first episode of what we're calling How To Be More Chill "4.0", Sam and Ilana interview someone who could not be a more integral part of the Be More Chill story: Jason SweetTooth Williams. Jason played Mr. Heere, Mr. Reyes, and (of course) Scary Stockboy both Off-Broadway and on and is one of the kindest humans ever and an absolute joy to talk to. No wonder Joe Iconis was the best man at his wedding!
Get the inside scoop on his name (spoiler alert: the reason could not be more awesome!), what it was like performing The Goodbye Song after the last performance of #BeMoreChill on Broadway, and all sorts of other lovely things you might not know about him and the show. Jason SweetTooth Williams, let's do this!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:03] Sam Maher: I feel like every episode should start with come on.
[0:07] Ilana Levine: I'm waiting for my new know what to load, but I guess that's not quite appropriate.
[0:12] Sam Maher: Well, I'm Sam.
[0:14] Ilana Levine: And I'm Alana, and you are listening to the podcast, How to Be More Chill.
[0:18] Sam Maher: Alana, you're always better at me than us. So can you tell everyone what How to Be More Chill is?
[0:23] Ilana Levine: Yes, I can, Sam. Um, so for all of you listening, you are probably fans of the musical Be More Chill. For people who are just tuning in to this podcast for the first time, and for maybe the one person who might not know the miraculous journey of this show, this is a show that was never actually going to go to Broadway unless you, the fans, had made it happen. I mean, it's just a fact. When the original cast recording was dropped, suddenly millions and millions and millions of downloads and streams were happening all over the world. And the Broadway community paid attention. And for the first time, producers allowed a show to go to Broadway because the fans demanded it, and it was an incredible success.
And you know, you probably know the story. Ned Vizzini wrote the book. Joe Trace and Joe Iconis adapted it into this extraordinary musical. And you, the fans, and Sam and I, the super fans, could not get enough of it. And so the story of the journey of this show is what makes it all the more intriguing and so incredibly joyous.
[1:35] Sam Maher: Never hung with a girl like you before. I don't know if you know. Alana and I chose to work together on this project thanks to Will Roland himself, Broadway's Jeremy here, who did a bit of matchmaking. Um, Alana has an incredible podcast called Little Known Facts. She's one of the best podcast hosts I've ever encountered in my life. Um, and I am a super fan-turned producer of the show and even worked on the marketing team for Broadway. So Alana and I both agreed with Will that this would be a perfect fit, mostly because we are both at our core, Be More Chill super fans ourselves. I don't know about you, Alana, but I even still get butterflies and like so excited when assigned to interview someone.
[2:16] Ilana Levine: Yep, it's the best. This isn't work. This is pure joy.
[2:28] Sam Maher: So this is what we're gonna call How to Be More Chill 4.0. Our first few episodes, which maybe one could consider 1.0, were recorded between Off-Broadway and Broadway. Those are so incredible. We highly recommend going back and listening to those. Then 2.0 was a batch of episodes we did during the Broadway run. Those were incredible because a lot of times it was interviewing cast members like between shows, like between a matinee and an evening show. And then since the pandemic started, we were able to do some video interviews. They're live on YouTube with some of the London cast members. Now we're in what we're gonna call version 4.0, which is maybe we could call that looking back at the good old days when we could all be in a room together and see live theater.
[3:17] Ilana Levine: Jeremy is in big bad trouble right now. So to kick off 4.0, we finally got the incredible Jason Sweet Tooth Williams at the mic. Jason played Mr. Heere, Mr. Reyes, Scary Stock Boy, off Broadway, and then on Broadway. And he simply could not be a more integral part of the Be More Chill story. Joe Iconis was his best man at his wedding. So when we say integral, we mean integral. Plus, we finally find out why his name, in fact, is Jason Sweet Tooth Williams, which we've all wanted to know for a long time. And we have the scoop right here. Plus, he's literally one of the sweetest people we've ever met or have had the pleasure of talking to or working with. I love him so much. Jason Sweet Tooth Williams, let's do this.
[4:28] Sam Maher: We have Jason Sweet Tooth Williams on the How to Be More Chill podcast. How long have we been waiting?
[4:33] Ilana Levine: Years.
[4:34] Sam Maher: Years. Literal years to get the inside scoop from one of Be More Chill's most invaluable players, one of the most important characters in the Be More Chill story. Mr. Jason Sweet Tooth Williams.
[4:50] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Hello.
[4:51] Ilana Levine: Hello, you both.
[4:53] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, no, I've wanted to be a part of this for years, so I'm so thrilled to be here. And I like hearing you say all the nice things about me and my character. So I was gonna let you talk for the whole time just about how important I am, but we can just say some other things too if you want.
[5:10] Ilana Levine: No, there are only nice things, because that's the world of Be More Chill, obviously. But I have had a question for you since the very first time I met you. Can you talk to me about your name?
[5:23] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yes. Um, Jason, no, just kidding, I know what you mean. Yes, so Jason is no Williams. A classic English name. No, so Sweet Tooth is my nickname. It is my equity name. Um, and it was a nickname that I first got back like late in high school and early in college. And at the time I was very into spoken word and rap. And so I had designs on doing that in a more serious way as I got older in life. And um, so Sweet Tooth was essentially my rap name. And um, it sort of followed me to college, and then when my college friends found out about that, of course they called me nothing else because they thought it was hilarious. And um, but it was cool, and it gave me the excuse to like, you know, I would like rap at parties for people, and you know, it was like a cool thing, or I thought it was cool.
And uh so when I moved to New York and I joined Actors Equity, um, you have to have, you know, a unique name to be in the union. And there was already a Jason SweetTooth Williams in the union, and so I was asked to change my name or alter my name. And uh it was I'll never forget being like at the desk where you have to like you know pay your dues and all the things. And um I said, you know, can I can I just say Jason Sweet Tooth Williams is my name? And the woman at the desk said, you can if you want to. And uh I said, yes, I want to. And um it sort of stuck ever since. And I keep waiting for that time when it's like, you know, I'm gonna be 40 this year. So I keep waiting for someone to be like, hey, you're 40 now. Maybe you should like drop the old Sweet Tooth thing. But I just can't. I can't let it go. And um I'm gonna stick with it.
[7:21] Ilana Levine: If you would have given me a list of if someone would have given me a list of the possible reasons as to why you were called Sweet Tooth before I knew, which is right now, because it was your rap name would have been absolutely not my choice of like that's probably what it is.
[7:37] Jason SweetTooth Williams: That is amazing.
[7:38] Ilana Levine: Yeah, and I cannot wait to tell everyone to know for the rest of my life that your name is Jason Sweet Tooth Williams because Sweet Tooth was your rap name.
[7:46] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Well, and I'll tell you.
[7:48] Ilana Levine: Yeah.
[7:48] Jason SweetTooth Williams: I asked Lauren Marcus about your name. Uh and Lauren said, It is not mine to tell.
[7:56] Ilana Levine: Oh, well, that's very sweet.
[7:58] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yes. She was like, it's so good. And I just feel like Jason needs to tell you.
[8:04] Ilana Levine: So there you have it. A loyal friend.
[8:07] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, she's been guarding that secret for me, so I'm thrilled for that.
[8:10] Ilana Levine: I know, but this is a reveal. This is this is tea, people, and this is we're going viral. We can stop this right now.
[8:16] Sam Maher: We already have what we need, Sam.
[8:22] Ilana Levine: As a big Be More Chill and Jason Sweet Tooth Williams fan, you know, I've seen a lot of footage of you performing musical theater and Joe Iconis songs. Is there footage out there anywhere of the spoken word rap version of Jason Sweet Tooth Williams?
[8:38] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um, I don't know that there must be somewhere because I a few years, well, many years ago now, I did a sort of one-man show at the Laurie Beechman Theater, and it was called Hits from the Cookie Jar, and it was a lot there was a lot of rap in it. There was a lot of musical theater, but I did I did do some rapping in it, and I can imagine that there's like some kind of footage. Yeah, so I'll have to dig that up, I'll see if I can find it. Or if we're at a party again in you know in the next decade of our lives in person, I will I will rap for you.
[9:13] Sam Maher: Yeah, that's the goal.
[9:15] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yes, I love it. Um so we love to always begin our episodes and our interviews and you telling us how to be more chill by asking you one question, which is a difficult question for you, only because for a lot of people this question has a clear start point. And for you, I think the answer to the question is gonna be much earlier than that this question even indicates. But our question is when is the first time you heard the words Be More Chill?
[9:49] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um the first time I heard those words were in the context of the musical. Um I didn't know of the book prior to working on the musical. Um and actually I was in a very early workshop of Be More Chill prior to its production at Two River Theater, so I was sort of privy to it, you know, in that way. Um, but uh it was like literally when I got the email from Joe or whoever was casting that reading um saying here's this show called Be More Chill, and I hadn't I knew nothing about it, and I didn't know anything about it really until going into rehearsal, although you know, Joe and I are very close friends, and so he had mentioned that he was working on it, but the sort of material and the vibe of it was all was all new to me.
And I just remember, you know, hearing the songs on that first day of a rehearsal, and just my mind being blown, I was like, oh my god, this is gonna be insanely huge. And when it wasn't huge right at the time that it happened, I was shocked. And I was like, this has to, this is gonna blow up at some point. And of course, after the album came out and the whole story of it going viral, it did. But just just hearing the music, I remember even being on break during rehearsal, just already singing the songs like on my way to like get a glass of water or whatever, and I just said to Joe, like, that's gonna be the single, man. This is gonna be the single that everyone's gonna be singing. And I think I was actually talking about Halloween at the time, but um, but of course, there's so many earworms in the show. Um, so that was my first real intro to Be More Chill.
[11:27] Ilana Levine: Awesome. And can you back us up a little bit to sort of the introduction to Joe Iconis? I mean, it's no secret that you are not only Iconis in family, you are Iconis and immediate family. Um very close friends with Joe and have been for quite a long time, as I understand it. So can you sort of give us the history of your friendship and relationship with Joe?
[11:49] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, absolutely. Um I love telling this story because I think it's a real testament to the concept of being in the right place at the right time, but also being in a place that you that you put yourself in through your um through the work and that you put into your own, you know, furthering of your life. So I think it's like a little bit of luck and a little bit of um not. So here's the story. Um when I was 10, and I swear it goes jumps more quickly from the 10 years old to my adult life. But when I was 10, I was in a show at the Goodspeed Opera House. I was in um Here's Love, the musical version of a Miracle on 34th Street. And um, because I grew up nearby, and so I was like the local kid that was in the show.
Um and cut to when I graduated from college. I um I reached out to the people at Goodspeed and I said, Hey, I'm moving to New York. I don't know anybody, I don't know like what how to be an actor. Um, and wondering is there anything happening at Goodspeed? Does anyone remember me from you know 15, 20 years ago? Um, and they said, Yeah, we do remember you. Um, and we're doing we happen to be doing this pilot program for this like recent college graduate thing. Um, would you like to be a part of it? And I, as a recent college grad, I said yes. And so what it was, there were five actors that went to stay at Goodspeed for two weeks. And in the first week, there was um, I think it was um, I forget they were working on a workshop of a show, and we as the five actors would come help, you know, work on the songs and take classes for like dancing and auditioning and all these things.
And the second week of the program was coincided with the New York musical theater NYU graduate musical theater writing program. Uh they have a residency at Goodspeed Opera House as well. And that was the year that Joe was getting his master's, and um, so I was assigned randomly to sing uh backups for um rock and roll band, which is the opening number from the black suits. And um I just sang backup for you know, I met him one day at the rehearsal studio and we sang and it was fine. And afterwards he was like, Hey man, uh I like your voice. You uh we should like hang out and sing sometime. And um, that's really terrible, Joe Iconis impression, but the essence is there.
[14:14] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um I disagree. I thought it was essentially iconic.
[14:20] Ilana Levine: Yes.
[14:20] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um, it's exactly um, and so I did. We hung out one afternoon, and that was kind of it. Like he went his separate way, I went my separate way.
[14:31] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And um I didn't hear from him again until they were casting.
[14:36] Ilana Levine: Together that afternoon.
[14:38] Jason SweetTooth Williams: That afternoon, what did like what did you do? I don't remember. I think it was like we I think he asked me to sing like the lead part from rock and roll band, which I like had quickly learned because I loved the song. Um, and that was it. I mean, it was like five minutes, it wasn't like a long like hangout. Um, but I remember thinking that he was cool. And I was like, I want to I want to know this guy, you know, he seemed cool. And uh so like some months later, I got a call from NYU that they were casting the black suits as his thesis musical, and would I be in the reading? And I was like, you know, shocked and thrilled, and I also knew nothing about how what that program was, and or really, you know, I was so green to the whole to the whole world of it all, and I had no idea that my uh world would open up so much from that.
And it really changed my life, not only my relationship with Joe, but I met so many amazing writers through that program in subsequent years and worked on so many shows that came from there. Um, so it really became my life in a huge way at the time. Um, but very quickly, Joe and I just became so close. You know, we were I I I love looking back occasionally at like old emails when it's like, hey, you know, we should get a drink sometime. And and you know, and then suddenly it was like we were best friends. It happened so quickly, and I think we just both needed needed each other in at that point in our lives, and and luckily have still continued to need each other as we've become um grown men.
And you know, he was the best man at my wedding. It's it's like brothers, you know, in that sort of way. Um so yeah, it's been it's been like one of the most fulfilling personal and obviously professional relationships of my life. Uh amazing.
[16:23] Ilana Levine: So fast forward to the the workshop production. Are are you the first person who ever plays Mr. Here in that workshop production?
[16:27] Jason SweetTooth Williams: The first person who ever brings you a character to life on in uh in the musical context. Yeah, so it wasn't even a production, it was just it was just a two-week sort of workshop in a in a rehearsal room. Um and yeah, I was. It was um it was uh he was you know, Mr. Here was largely the same, but there was a lot had been has changed obviously over the years. Um but it was hilarious. And I remember thinking that I was like, I I was like, I can't believe I'm playing a dad. Like I'm I'm a dad in this musical. And um, you know, I it's sort of now what I do is play the is play the dad kind of character in a lot of things, but it was I remember it being the first time that I was doing that, and um and and sort of being like weirded out, but also like excited by that.
Um and and you know, getting to sing those songs. And there was actually a there was a song that Mr. Here used to also sing uh called No Pants Is Pants Enough for Me. And uh it was it was subsequently cut for a future. Yeah. Maybe one day we'll do like a uh you know, a cut songs version of the show and and throw it back in there or something.
[17:42] Ilana Levine: Why what was that? Tell us the the story of that song.
[17:46] Jason SweetTooth Williams: So the story of that song was it was it was pr it was kind of Mr. Here's introduction. Um, you know, he was there in that opening number in that opening sequence coming and going, interacting with Jeremy. But when he when he first sort of had a scene with Jeremy, it was he was kind of came out and you know, Jeremy was like, you know, dad, put your pants on. And it was this sort of like um jaunty uh like 3-4 kind of like rollicking number. And uh it was brief, but it was something like I hope Joe doesn't mind that I'm revealing this, but um it was like no pants is pants enough for me, Jeremy, can't you see? It's and then it goes on, but that's that was like the main hook of the song, and so um it didn't make the cut, but it was a lot of fun sing for sure.
[18:35] Ilana Levine: It it's so funny to me to think that there was probably parts in the process where Joe is thinking, all right, we need to set it up that he is gonna say I'm not wearing pants and have a whole song about it so that the band song later can be about actually putting them on and then maybe realizing that like we we see that he's not wearing pants, and so it makes sense that he's wearing pants.
[18:55] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, there's a lot of um later. Yeah, there's a lot of power in actually seeing uh a man with no pants on stage, and so it goes a long way, I think, in in uh setting up that plot point. And and I've realized as I've been asking you this, that you know, I basically refer to your character as as Mr. Here, but obviously the character is also um Mr. Reyes. And I was just thinking as you were answering that question, like it it's just as big of a role in the sense of like stage time, right? Like, do you know the answer to that? Like, is Mr. Reyes on stage just as much as Mr. Heroes, or more or less?
[19:30] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um, I mean, he might actually have more physical stage time because he, you know, he appears uh throughout the play in like the in the play rehearsal moments. Um, and then in that whole final sequence where there's like the battle and he comes out and you know, my script says I could go all the way to Broadway and all of that stuff is is quite a good chunk of time. Um so it's funny, yeah. I don't I I consider him an equal part of my of the the role that I played in Be More Chill. And and for that matter, I also kind of give Scary Stockboy a lot of weight because he um while he is a sort of more limited character uh in in terms of time, he's such a crucial uh you know, plot point character, and also I was I really had so much fun just being like insane with that part, and um, and so it kind of I wish you could have seen it in rehearsals because when I first started doing it, it was like the most insane, you know, and just for purposes of like not destroying my voice and and just not scaring the hell out of everybody in the theater, um, it did kind of you know become a coalesced character, but um yeah, he he's also a very important character to me.
And you know, obviously peppered throughout, there's so many other little little characters that I that I played. And um, you know, even in the final um version that ended up being on on the stage in in in uh previews, there were other things that were happening too. There was a lunch lady that I played um that made a very quick cross-through with like a tray of peas, and there was a a teacher uh who ended up beginning.
[21:20] Ilana Levine: In the opening number?
[21:21] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yes, in the opening number. So you would see dad, you would see Mr. Here, and then you would see me as the bus driver driving the kids to school, and then you would see me as Mr. Reyes, and then you would see me as um this lunch lady, and then there was another teacher, um, this like art teacher woman who I played who uh was so awesome, and I loved her her costume was so beautiful, and just like the most art teachery art teacher you've ever seen. Um, and just it ended up being practically it was just impossible to change make the changes, you know. We had limited um wardrobe people who were like unbelievable, and truly that show could not happen without the wardrobe crew that we had because everyone was it was a marathon the entire time.
There was no downtime for anybody in the show, and uh especially the wardrobe people, it was just unbelievable to see. And I think it just came down to like we we've reached our capacity uh for getting another piece of clothing onto this person at this time.
[22:24] Ilana Levine: Um well, it sounds like they wanted like these Mrs. Doubtfire level. Like that's a lot of women to play who are different women, and then you have to go back and be these two male characters.
[22:37] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, absolutely. And the um the art teacher woman, she had a full like Mrs. Dowfire bodysuit that like gave her a figure, and she she wore this great, like flowing sort of dress and a great wig. And there was a day actually, we shot um there's this other hidden character, actually, if you don't mind me saying, is is um after after Rich the after the Halloween episode and Rich um song and Rich sets the fire and all that, prior to the Pants song, Mr. Here comes out and he's watching uh television, and on the television is a news report about the fire, and it's by this reporter who is another woman played by me. And so she um we we shot that in this in a studio, and she looks uh pretty awesome, I think. She's like wearing like a uh smart like suit and um sort of beautiful wig and full beat and the whole thing, and and so she gives the news report that that you see on the on the screen there.
[23:38] Ilana Levine: You know, you said earlier that as soon as you heard it, even before the actual rehearsal workshop that turns into Two River, that turns into signature, that turns into Broadway, that you were like, this is gonna be huge. It there was just this sense immediately that there was something about what Joe wrote, and the word zeitgeist comes to mind in terms of him hitting on something so essential for so many people at the right time. All these things have to happen at the same time. And and then the obvious, you know, now it's like mythical, uh, the viralness of the the cast recording. When did you understand that your premonition had happened?
[24:25] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Like the explosion of fantasy and reality, and now it's happening with your best friend and all these people you love, like which even that, like even more. Right. Um, so you know, there was another actor who played Mr. Here in the True River production named Paul Whitdy, who was an amazing actor and and very sweet guy. And he at the time that um the off-Broadway version of Be More Chill was coming out, was working on another project, and it just the stars aligned. And I remember um before that even was a real thing. Again, sitting with Joe, uh, we were getting drinks at a bar, and um he was like, you know, there's this crazy thing that's happening with that show, Be More Chill, that like it's become really popular on the internet, and the album is like getting a lot of streams, and kids are starting to like do fan art, and it's like on Tumblr and all these things, and and um, you know, I was like, oh, cool.
I I didn't really get a sense of the scope of what he was talking about. I don't even know that he knew at the time um what he the scope of it all. And then sort of the next time we hung out, he was like, it's kind of kind of going crazy. This this be more chill thing is really really blowing up. And so there started to be this like tingle in the air, I felt like where like Be More Chill was starting to enter the ether and starting to be just this part of my world and his world, and it was something we started like talking about all the time again, and and I I remember him being a little frustrated because he had a hard time, I think, convincing a lot of people that the streams and the and the sort of music the internet love for the show could translate into a production of the show.
I think it like sort of had never happened this way before, and so a lot of producers who are like smart, great producers, were just like, I don't know what to do with this information. That you know, there's this this viral album, which we I guess we know what the word viral means, but we don't we have no way of knowing how to like turn this into something. Um, and so Jerry uh Gehring, who who ended up being the lead producer on the on the on the musical to his credit, I think, really was like, I don't know what this is gonna be either, but I want to like make this happen. Um, and and had had the faith to do it. But I remember um they there was a production of Be More Chill prior to it being off Broadway that happened in New Jersey, um, like a you know, a local production, and the original cast members from Be More Chill all were like invited to go see it.
So they were like, Oh, this is cool, they're doing that show Be More Chill that we did a couple years ago. And apparently, I I wasn't there for it, but the the scene there was like astronomical where they were just like mobbed by thousands of people, and they had to like close down the street with security, and they were just in this like town in New Jersey, and everyone loved the show and was like singing along with the as the production was happening, and they all said they were just sitting in their seats like, what is happening right now? This is insane. And so I think from that moment, for Joe, especially, it was like this is a thing, like I can tell that this is a thing, and cut to the first time that I ever walked out on stage for my entrance in Be More Chill, which is right at the top, you know.
The the crowd response was just deafening. I mean, it was it felt like you know, a lot of people say, Oh, it felt like I was it we were the Beatles or something. It felt like that. It felt like these these people were so excited to be witnessing this, to be hearing it live, and to be a part of this thing that they had dreamed of, you know. And there's a great um a great part of this story too, where I think George, you know, who obviously has been so instrumental to getting it through its journey and and all its next steps. I remember him tweeting prior to it to it even being announced that it was gonna be off Broadway, like, hey, I would love to see B-Mort show live on a stage, wouldn't you?
And the tweet like went insane, and everyone started retweeting it. I think it was like kind of a big step for other people to see the sort of mass power that was behind this this musical and the love for it. And really it never waned. I mean, you know, from that moment to to the final closing show where like we could barely get the words out because everyone was just screaming so much. Um, it was the most rewarding, insane love fest that I could have ever imagined for a piece of theater, you know.
[29:01] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And I like hearing stories of, you know, old theater pieces where they're like, it was such a hit, it caused a riot in the streets, like some old story about like, you know, some 1930s play. Um, and I feel like this was that, you know, for this time and for these people, and to be a part of it is, you know, I pray that some things will be as exciting, but I feel like this is definitely a high watermark for my career and for that feeling.
[29:30] Jason SweetTooth Williams: The thing that comes to my mind is this viral picture. I don't know who posted it, you or Jen or Joe. I think it's the three of you. And is it like the first preview on Broadway? And right after the curtain call, you're right under that stage, and the embrace and the pride, and that moment was finally there, and that's what I think of when I hear you talk about that. Is that that first—was it the first preview on Broadway?
[29:56] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, yeah, exactly. Exactly. I'm always jealous of hearing everyone talk about that first preview off Broadway. Because I don't know if you know this, but first of all, it's important to know that everyone we've interviewed brings up that first performance off Broadway, and I love hearing those stories. And I, along with several other producers, couldn't get in. And the doors at the Signature Theater are soundproof. And so we are sitting out there just so proud and excited and wanting so badly to go in the room. Even Jerry, the lead producer, who like could not get a ticket to the show that he had produced. And there's this picture I had someone take of the five of us trying to hear through the soundproof door the screams from the opening number; couldn't even hear it.
And so, you know, I am very lucky to have had so many incredible experiences being a part of the show as well. That was the one moment that I'm always like, oh, I was so sad I wasn't in that room with you all and hear those screams. But I was in the audience the next night and, in fact, leading the screams on the second night, so I guess it sucked for y'all.
[30:59] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Nice. Are there any significant mishaps that you recall from the Broadway run that might bring a smile to fans' faces as they listen to this?
[31:11] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um, sure, always. Um, there was one day particularly that I will never forget that was toward the end of the run, actually, where there was a massive rainstorm outside, and the Lyceum, as many Broadway theaters are, is like super old and, you know, full of holes. And it just could not protect itself from this rainstorm, and so it started to leak in on the stage, but particularly backstage. And when I say leak, I mean pour through the ceiling onto the deck; everyone was throwing towels down. Um, Bertie, our stage manager, Bertie Michaels, was up in the booth, which is, you know, just 10 feet above from where the actors are on deck, had an umbrella, like literally covering the board where she was, and we were all like we should probably stop the show because they were like standing on, you know, this 120-year-old building with like wires everywhere; it just feels like this is how people get electrocuted.
And there's a scene, there's a moment in the show where I and George come down for the smartphone hour, and these smartphone things come down from the ceiling on a grid. And I remember being like, I don't feel like this is safe, you guys. Like this is not the best time to like try to see if it works, as we're like dangling from this thing, and everyone reassured me. They said it's fine, it's like gonna be cool, just we're gonna do it. We all talked about it, we feel like we can do it. So we did it, we came down, everything was fine. The very next scene is when Jason Tam comes down from the ceiling as well, and he's like in a sort of more glorious squip outfit. And they were like, we can't do it, we can't, it's not safe to send Jason Tam down.
I said, it's safe to send me and George down, but you're gonna protect Jason Tam. What is this? But I think it was getting to the point where we were like, we have to stop the show, and no one—and we didn't stop; we just kept going. And it was totally bizarre. And so there was no backstage meeting. They didn't have a cast meeting where they were like, let's vote if this feels safe. It wasn't like that. They sent you out. It was like we were like in the smartphone hour. It's like there's those I meetings. People were throwing on their costumes. I'm like looking on Twitter backstage, being like, um, it is now raining on the stage of Frankie and Johnny and Leclerc Delune, like literally in the apartment of that show, and I'm like just trying to stay out of the way and be like, but I need to let you know that this is happening. It was wild.
[33:57] Jason SweetTooth Williams: You know, you mentioned that it was really a sort of extraordinary thing for you to wrap your head around suddenly playing a father on stage. Um, except you have also since then, well, you become a father twice since that first moment of being cast as a dad. What how do you feel like having your daughter, your first daughter at the time, um, what was that for you? Like to have your dream come true, to be a real dad in real life? Like, can you just talk about the emotion and the power of that?
[34:35] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, absolutely. And I think power is the exact word for it because there's something that, you know, you can always pretend to be playing something, but there's something to actually feel that sense of like wanting to protect somebody that you are responsible for and that you love beyond any love that you knew existed. Um, I think it's just, you know, I think it definitely deepens Mr. Heere as a character. Um, but it also deepened the whole experience for me. You know, as I dreamed of being on Broadway when I was younger, I didn't really—I sort of had a very singular vision about it in that like this is my dream is to be on Broadway. But it becomes a bigger thing when it's like my dream was also to be a dad.
And my dream was to like be a good father and be a husband. And it becomes this sort of big picture part of your life where the moment was so much more than I get to be on Broadway, which is like a huge thing for me and a huge accomplishment. But coupled with these other amazing things that were happening in my life, it just was a real sort of, you know, moment for me that I think inspires me even now to, you know, the responsibility that I feel for my family and for, you know, for delivering a show like Be More Chill, it just like the sense of responsibility, I think is the biggest feeling I have for it. And you know the idea of loving something, um, I always—I love my friends and I love Broadway and I love these things, but that sense, like I said, of having this deeper sense of love, um, I think it can only make everything that you do that much richer.
Um, and so the experience was just, you know, beyond in that way for me. So it wasn't a very eloquent way to say it, but it just, um, yeah, I mean it—the whole thing is just more than I ever thought I would have in my life. And, um, so to wake up every day and be like, I had this amazing experience while my daughter, you know, was coming to tech and like meeting all the people backstage and hanging out in my dressing room, you know, it was just perfect. You know, there are very few people who had a full backstage pass. And Mara was a full backstage pass, lifetime. When she was coming, I knew to clear the way, let her through. She was the VIP of the VIPs backstage.
[37:13] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Can I—I know Sam has a million questions, but I do want to just talk for a second about, you know, there's so much joy and pure hilariousness in Be More Chill. And obviously, there's also a lot of darkness, and there's sort of like these competing tones in some ways that Joe and the whole team kind of brilliantly found to like synthesize so that it always felt even and balanced and not out of step. But Mr. Heere has so much sadness to contend with for so much of this play. And I'm wondering, sort of, did you come up with a backstory for yourself about what had happened in your marriage and sort of what the steps were that led to the moment we met you in this piece?
[38:12] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, absolutely. Um, I'll keep most of it for myself, but yeah, I think that for sure the family history and the relationship with Mrs. Heere, um, I think was not a good one and did not end well, obviously, for them as a couple. Um, but I think there's also something very telling that Jeremy lives with Mr. Heere and not Mrs. Heere. So I think that there's something that happened there too. You know, I have an idea in my mind, but where, you know, that's not usually or not typically the case. I maybe it's changed now, but I always think of custody and how important it is for people to be with their mothers and all these stories that you hear, but that I've never had to go through myself personally.
Um, but yeah, so I think there's a lot going on there. And I think there's also on top of that, just that thing of that I think every parent goes through with a teenager of how the hell can I connect to my child, and the more that I try, it seems like the more we separate, and the more he thinks I'm trying too hard, and he thinks I'm this like loser. And even if he doesn't really think I'm a loser, you know, when to feel like your son thinks you're a loser, I think is probably one of the deepest cuts that a parent can feel. Um, because you've spent your life taking care of them and doing everything you could to make sure that they're happy and safe. Um, and so I think he is very sad, and that's why I think the pants song is such a great turn for him because it's actually less about being happy, I think, in that moment for him, and it's more about finding his strength and finding his spark again.
And I think that he needed that, and you know, I think you're talking about the tone. I think that that song and that character could have very easily gone some silly route, and even that song could have just been a sort of lark of a moment. Um, but because we know that like Jeremy needs his dad and his dad needs Jeremy and we see the actual sadness going on there, there is so much happening. And also, you know, I think to see Joe, uh, Michael—and I was gonna call him George, but to see Michael and Mr. Heere bonding in that way, and I'm familiar with that sort of relationship too of like, you know, if you're buddy with your friend's dad, or like some, you know, it's a little awkward, but like they're cool with you, and where suddenly the student becomes the teacher kind of, and I think Michael really, you know, shakes him awake in a big way in that moment.
So it's a big moment for Michael too, I think. Um, but I also think, you know, you're talking about the tone, the dark and the light of it. I think even the story when the school gets swiped, the play at the end, and how sort of bizarre that all is and, you know, theoretically hilarious, um, and it is, um, is also very, very disconcerting and scary. And, um, you know, when you—I think when you first see all the sort of squips doing the pitiful children song, um, that is so terrifying, and they're all marching in unison and doing all this like the face and everything, it just feels militant and it feels aggressive and scary, you know, and I think times being what they are, I think it rings even more true now.
[41:58] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Let's talk just for a second about the fans of Be More Chill, because you know, the fans were obviously such a crucial and anchor for this show. And you know, I always like to think about how like, you know, it always sounds so silly when people in like Oscar speeches are like, without my fans, I, you know, you're number one, you're who I'm doing this for, and I always think it sounds so silly. And for Be More Chill, that really is true. I mean, especially for this show. I know that you had some wonderful experiences with, you know, specific fans and stage door experiences. Are there any that stand out to you that you could share with us that really mean extra special to you?
[42:40] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um, yeah, I mean there were certain fans that I actually came to know because they would come to the show so often that we knew each other by first names. And so it started to be someone that you like looked forward to seeing, you know, and when you saw them you felt comforted; you're like, oh, they're here again. That's great. Um, and then even fans that didn't come see the show that night or whatever but would come to the stage door and be part of that experience. Um, so that whole thing was kind of crazy, but a few, you know, they all also sent a lot of artwork and letters and all these things, and that really is the stuff that I treasure the most because when you can read a person tell you how much Be More Chill has meant to them, um, and the fact that anyone spends time drawing a picture of you, it's an amazing thing.
[43:31] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Like you know I can't imagine that somebody was thinking about the way my person as they were creating their own art I think that's like the most humbling flattering thing in the entire world.
[43:42] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And I kept all of that stuff. I have boxes in my closet of Be More Chill fan art and posters and letters and buttons and dolls that people made and just all kinds of things and some that I'm still in contact with that you know I have a friendship with now that will message me and ask me for advice or a question and you know the cool thing about the fact that this thing was born on the internet in so many ways is that it sort of it still lives on the internet and the relationships that came from it are still alive and bubbling as they always were because there's no end to the internet you know and to that experience.
[44:24] Jason SweetTooth Williams: There were definitely some people that you know were able to come backstage and meet people and to see I think to see some fans experience that was really kind of amazing. The sort of behind the scenesness of it all I think if you think of something that you love more than anything in the world and if you get to get this inside look at it you know the inner geek of you just can't help but explode you know um so that was pretty amazing to see and you know to people see the Michael in the bathroom bathtub backstage and you know the gingivitis Halloween costume and all these cool things and actually there's a fan named Marie who made me a Be More a gingivitis head like a huge paper mache head and gingivitis is that you know is that crazy white character that I played in the Halloween sequence and um it sat in the green room like for most of the run of the show um and so it was you know part of everyone's daily life and I hope that she knows that it was so important to everybody as a young Broadway fan who got some of those experiences myself when I was 17 backstage at Rent, thanks to Anthony Rapp and backstage at Your Government Charlie Brown getting to meet Broadway stars like Ilana Levine and getting to take photos with them.
[45:46] Jason SweetTooth Williams: I can confirm that that stuff can quite literally change the course of people's lives. And I was so proud that we all got to kind of pass the torch on a little bit, that would be more chill. And like, you know, it should be no surprise at all that anyone who actually did get to come backstage and have those experiences. I mean, it would just brighten up my entire soul and being and everyone's soul and being and in there. And it's really great that you bring that up because I love nothing more than being a part of being able to help give some fans that experience.
[46:16] Jason SweetTooth Williams: But it was such a testament to you guys because you're a for a for it was a small ensemble of people making that show. Um you made a big sound and a big statement, and you all carried it on your backs eight shows a week, and vocally it was so challenging. And I go back and watch some of the YouTube rehearsal footage and seeing you guys learn the choreography. It's real choreography. This is Broadway choreography that you guys are doing. And the fact that not only did you do the show, not only did you do the stage door, not only did you make yourselves available on social media and really engage deeply. Not only did you receive gifts, but like say thank you for the gifts and continue to do so. I think your cast really set a new standard for performer generosity in a way that did not happen before.
[47:15] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And we'll see, we'll see if anyone can kind of have the energy that you guys had, and sort of the way you encouraged people not just to come see your thing, but to make their own thing is really part of what made this show so remarkable. And when Sam and I talked about wanting to do this podcast as a way to continue to like have a community with the fans of the show, the cast and creatives, of course, but like to keep this unbelievably special community going. Um, it's been one of like our highest honors to be in some small part able to keep these connections happening and these stories going, especially what's been going on right now, but this will live forever and all time, and the show will continue to happen all over the world forever. And you made that. Like it's mind blowing.
[48:13] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, it is it is um insane to think about the that the sort of lasting impact of it and and to forever be a part of this experience that that has meant so much to so many people around the world. And I think because we we all knew that this show was on Broadway because of the of the fans in in a unique way that had sort of never happened before. Um, it was completely fan, um, you know, fan motivated, and the energy behind from them and you know, behind us from them was so real that I think we just felt this sense of gratitude for every fan that we would not have existed were it not for them and for their time and energy.
[48:58] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And and also because the play deals with young people dealing with issues, there's a huge responsibility, I think, to to show up when when an actual young person says, Hey, I'm dealing with this, and can I talk to you about it? Because your character deals with your son's thing. Where, you know, there are so many so many tricky things that that teenagers especially go through that I think is um it's a big responsibility to to hear that and and want to live up to the expectation for them and give them some kind of guidance and um a sounding board as well.
[49:37] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And you know one of the things I'm most proud of too is that there's so many um trans members of the fan base. And I just love that they found in Be More Chill a place that they felt safe and a place that they felt um a community. And I think especially like I say for young people high school can be really tricky. And if you're if you're coupling that with a huge life change and a huge self-actualization, it can be you know scary and downright uh depressing and and hard to get through. So to be one sort of bright light for anyone going through an issue like that or a or a an exciting time in their life like that I think was a real special moment. Even when the show closed both the Two River and the Broadway cast album I mean these are this is just music that will live and live and live and it's it's really great that we have that to hold on to also.
[50:30] Ilana Levine: So Jason can you tell us a little bit about that closing performance um you know as as the guy who kind of is the goodbye song guy um and was tasked with this incredibly important uh on the closing performance. Can you talk just a little bit about uh what what that was like for you going through that closing performance and then having to lead the goodbye song with hundreds of your closest friends in this incredibly emotional moment.
[50:56] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, you know, it was um it was uh amazing and difficult, um, as you sort of suggest. And in when we did a sort of run through of the song earlier that afternoon where all of the people that were on stage, all the Iconis and family extended members and and and you know, like you say, a hundred people, um, they all came to sort of run through the show in the afternoon or run through the number. And I was so emotional I got through maybe like one verse of the of the song before I was a complete mess and just crying and and could not get through the song. And I thought, how the hell am I ever gonna uh sing this tonight after the you know, after the show with everything I'll be feeling and and all of that?
[51:43] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And I just um I remember standing up there and just feeling this sense of of love around me and uh from from behind me and also coming from all the fans that were standing and singing along. Um, that I just I was so calm about it suddenly, and I'll never forget the sense where I took a breath. There was one there was one moment where I was about to cry, and I was about to like, and I'm I'm the sort of person that when I start crying, it's like I can't get it back. And so I I was about it was about to happen, and I was like, no, I have to get through the song. Um, and I remember just like taking a breath in between words and and calming myself down in in a way that was just like look at where you are, like look at this moment that you're that you are sharing and experiencing, and I suddenly felt like I have to get through the song, right? I I personally need to get through this song because this feeling is too special to let go by and not and not make it to the end, you know.
[52:46] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Um and you know, there were definitely tears, and I'm glad once we got to the sort of raucous end of it all that uh we were surrounded by so many voices because that was a time where I could let it out. Um, but yeah, getting through it was really hard and really special.
[53:06] Ilana Levine: I can imagine. I I I remember my reaction later on at the party was explaining to Joe, and or I think it was actually to Joe's brother, mom and dad. I was like, what's so wild about that is that that moment, especially about Ian and the raucousness of it, it actually felt joyous and and optimistic, which is so strange because you know we're we're dealing with kind of the opposite emotions of oh my gosh, the show is now closed, and we're not performing on Broadway again. Um, and and I think that that's obviously a testament to Joe's writing about that song, but also your performance and leaking a lot with that group. So know that I Be More Chill fan. Love, love, love thinking about that. I'm glad it's recorded. I still haven't watched it yet.
[53:46] Jason SweetTooth Williams: My boyfriend Slade does always like being on my I I haven't been able to watch it either. And um, you know, it it's funny that you mentioned the joy at the end because I think actually the trick of that song or the the sort of genius of that song is it's not a sad song. There it's a it's a it's a range of things that the song goes through, but the end of the song does feel like a celebration, whoever it is that you're saying goodbye to, or whatever it is that you're feeling, at the end, it's a celebration of that person or that thing, and and so you can let the joy take over and let the sadness go.
[54:21] Jason SweetTooth Williams: And when in other times that we've done it, I remember um the director John Simpkins, who who I work with a lot and Joe works with all the time, um, talking about that song and and talking about how the end of that song actually feels like running through a field, and so it's not it's not like angry, it's not like we're we're sad and we're and we're upset. It's more like we're open and we are we're just gonna like take the world and and and run through this field together, you know. And so I think I think that's right on so I kind of feel like closing a door feels like opening it.
[54:58] Ilana Levine: Well, the song provides tremendous, I mean, every time you stand up there, I'm like, oh no, here I go.
[55:04] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Yeah, oh absolutely, really, Mr. Williams. Let me get my tissues, give me one second, and then there's a release, like this extraordinary release at the end. Um, and it makes you want to get up on your feet and dance, like it's an amazing journey that that song can take you on every time. Uh, not to be corny, but thank you for the amazing journey that you took us on today, and such a like trip down memory lane, and so looking forward to getting to be in a room and hearing you perform live again soon.
[55:39] Ilana Levine: Um, before we let you go, uh if you could just finish this sentence for us, which is Be More Chill is be more chill is momentous, word, word spoken word, word. Word up.
[56:06] Jason SweetTooth Williams: Hi, Jason Sweet. That's my first time crying on the pod.
[56:09] Ilana Levine: Everyone cries on the pod night, and I haven't yet, and that was the time I just uh thank you so much. This was so extraordinary. And and your fans and the show's fans and the world are getting to hear so many new things about something they thought they knew. And you're just incredible. And thank you, thank you, thank you.
[56:31] Jason SweetTooth Williams: No, thank you both. I um I don't get a chance to to talk about Be More Chill much um with or about anything with anybody because we're all so isolated. Um so thank you for the for the trip down memory lane and and reminding myself that uh what a what a special thing I got to be a part of. It's it's important to remind yourself of.
[56:49] Ilana Levine: You did that.
[57:02] Ilana Levine: Hey, thanks for listening to How to Be More Chill. And if you have a moment, please drop a review of this podcast for us wherever you listen to podcasts. It helps more than you know. And don't forget to smash that subscribe button.
[57:02] Ilana Levine: How to Be More Chill has an official Instagram. Be sure to follow us there at How to Be More Chill. Alana, where can we find you on social media?
[57:24] Ilana Levine: On Twitter, you can find me at Ilana Levine and on Instagram, it's just Little Known Facts Podcast.
[57:30] Sam Maher: And I'm at YesBroadway on all the platforms.
[57:34] Sam Maher: I'm Sam.
[57:35] Ilana Levine: And I'm Alana. And don't forget to reach out and tell us how to be more chill.
[57:44] Ilana Levine: Voices in my head, but now they're the normal kind.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
