Tim Prottey-Jones - writer, singer, producer, radio host AND Jesus from ITV's search for a West End leading man Superstar - joins me as we recap episode three of the ITV show Mamma Mia!: I Have a Dream. Follow host Rich on TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@thebaldestbitch... Read More
From the show: I Can Sing: A "Mamma Mia: I Have A Dream" Recap Podcast
Featured Shows
About
Tim Prottey-Jones - writer, singer, producer, radio host AND Jesus from ITV's search for a West End leading man Superstar - joins me as we recap episode three of the ITV show Mamma Mia!: I Have a Dream.
Follow host Rich on TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@thebaldestbitch
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:05] Rich Hawkins: Hello, welcome to I Can Sing Episode 3.
[0:10] Rich Hawkins: It's Sky Week. It's our first Sky Week. Very exciting. Quickly before we start, the gayest thing that's happened to me this week. I went to see a Lizzie Borden themed musical at a South Playhouse. Very good. Nothing says funny like camp rock pop musicals about axe wielding parent killers. Happy days. Before we talk about Mamma Mia, I have a dream. Obviously, I have to introduce my guest this week. And ladies and gents, and in betweens, we have our first Jesus.
[0:36] Rich Hawkins: Jesus Christ is in the building. An actual Jesus, turned country music artist, turned rock artist, turned radio host, turned uh legend among the reality TV musical theatre competition shows. Welcome, Tim Prottey-Jones. Hi Tim.
[0:53] Tim Prottey-Jones: Good afternoon to you. Or morning. I don't even know what it is. I've not fully woken. It was a big weekend away of wedding celebrations for a very good friend.
[1:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um and then I decided to leave those celebrations early so I could come back and watch Mamma Mia.
[1:10] Rich Hawkins: I believe you. Always here for the community, always.
[1:13] Tim Prottey-Jones: God, yeah. Um so lots of things to talk to you about. The first one obviously though is that you were a Jesus.
[1:22] Tim Prottey-Jones: Uh you were I was the nation's eighth favourite Jesus. The top eight Jesus on ITV's Superstar. We were just talking off camera actually about the fact that you did a recap podcast, but you never re-watched the show.
[1:35] Tim Prottey-Jones: You're right. So yeah, so I uh Da David Hunter, who was also on the same show, who is obviously still a musical theatre legend and legend in general, but he had this wonderful idea of doing like a sort of ten years since Superstar podcast, and um with that came a lot of research, mostly on his behalf, I must be honest. He did all the re-watching and made some, you know, copious notes about what he'd seen.
[2:01] Tim Prottey-Jones: And uh I relied on a ten year old memory of how it went. So I don't know how accurate it was still, but most of it tallied up with what Dave was uh thinking and w and Yeah, I listened to it. I didn't spot any plot holes.
[2:13] Rich Hawkins: You're fine. Great. Fantastic.
[2:15] Rich Hawkins: Why unlike some of these shows.
[2:17] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[2:17] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, very well, we'll get there, we'll get there, don't we worry.
[2:21] Rich Hawkins: Of course, of course. Um why didn't you want to rewatch it?
[2:24] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um I have very particular memories about that whole time and it was such a step away from what I was doing at the time. It was my first sort of venture into musical theatre properly, particularly as a performer.
[2:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: I'd done a bit of writing before, but nothing overly serious. And, you know, I get it now where people go, Oh, so I'm a musician and producer now, and so people go, Oh, so you started off in musical theatre, and I was like, That's definitely not true. I started off as a musician in bands, you know.
[2:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um I did the Superstar show when I was 32, and that was uh that was now eleven years ago. So I'm old. Um so I people just assume I take it as a compliment that people thought that was the beginning of my career, um, as anything. I was just like, no, there was ten years before that since university where I did other things, but um it was a very nice uh venture into musical theatre, and I think because of that, um I want to remember it in a very particular way, and I for the most part had a wonderful time doing Superstar.
[3:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um I struggled massively when it came to the live shows. That's when I really realised that um the public uh have the potential to be very horrible. Um and and actually, in fairness, I you know, I and we all got off very, very lightly, um probably due to the uh viewing figures.
[3:48] Tim Prottey-Jones: But uh I you know, it wasn't X Factor, that's something I definitely couldn't cope with, but um that's the bit I found hard, but the the months prior to that, the sort of build-up and stuff, I absolutely loved, you know, sort of um being with the other finalists and and the entire process I enjoyed now looking back on it, and I didn't want to watch it and go, Oh Lord, it was it was horrendous. I was horrendous. We were all horrendous.
[4:14] Tim Prottey-Jones: It was great. It was no and I and I love it, and I still, you know, there's obviously some bits I've seen since it all happened, but um I'm quite selective as to what those are.
[4:23] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, keep it keep it at fresh as you might. So you went into doing Superstar, but you weren't doing theatre or weren't trying too much theatre before that. What made you want to do so what happened was is I'd um I I didn't I've got a music degree and this, that and the other, so I I was I've always studied music, uh and then I I was straight out of university, I became a session musician for a lot of country artists, um, even though there wasn't much of a scene here in the UK.
[4:50] Tim Prottey-Jones: And um so I was doing that for many years and it's sort of when I really found songwriting. I wrote for years. I always had a sort of nine to five job as well. Um so it was a busy time, but I I knew I wanted to pursue music, it's the only thing I've ever wanted to do.
[5:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: And um sort of fast forward to 2010, uh and the sort of way I learnt to sing, uh, because singing was actually the last thing that came to me just through nerves and confidence more than anything.
[5:16] Tim Prottey-Jones: So had a number of instruments under my belt or whatever, and then singing came late and the reason I wanted to sing was I heard Steve Balsamo sing Gethsemane and I was like, that's that's what I want to do. I want to sing those stupid notes. They sound fun you know so with sort of zero training vocally I sort of you know locked myself in my university room and just kept singing until I could hit those notes and you know that sort of stuff came out of me so I bet the uh people who lived in your halls were absolutely thrilled.
[5:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh yeah they hated me I I received many complaints and uh but it it spurred me on and uh but you know fast forward many years later and there was a sort of semi-pro version of JCS coming round uh where I grew up in the Midlands and a number of friends knew about my sort of you know love of Steve Balsamo particularly and uh said oh you should go for it, you know I'm sure not everyone can sing Gethsemane or whatever and I was like oh I'm sure they can anyway cut a long story short I sort of I went and auditioned and got offered this role uh and then you know they they had no idea who I was you know I'd never been to them or auditioned for the for them in any other way prior.
[6:26] Tim Prottey-Jones: They was like who's this guy who's come out of nowhere you know and they said uh we'd love to offer you the role uh PS can you please lose about three stone by November and I was like great okay so um so I hit what I call now the Jesus diet um just loaves and fishes probably just that's it that's it with they just kept getting more and more though it was annoying and um so I I did it I was very dedicated I lost loads of weight um and and did this role and then two years later these adverts started appearing on TV for Superstar and all the people that I'd met during my time doing the semi pro version, just basically were emailing me and messaging me going, You need to go for that, you need to go for that.
[7:06] Tim Prottey-Jones: I was like, Oh god, no, not a not a not on national TV. Anyway, it came round to it and I was like, I'm gonna kick myself if I don't. So I just turned up to that first audition.
[7:16] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um it was an open audition in London, so it was packed, it was rammed, it was full of real characters. And um, somehow or other I just kept going through the rounds, and I was like, Yeah, I didn't think this was gonna happen. I thought I'd just do it for the experience and get out of there, and uh uh so yeah, that was it really.
[7:32] Tim Prottey-Jones: So it was really the show. Uh really the show and the role that got me there. Had you seen the like find me a Maria, find me a Joseph, find me a Dorothy, etc.
[7:41] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, I loved them. Um and actually my only dabblings then with musical theatre were as as a writer. So I'd um I'd actually put out two albums before Superstar where I'd written the music and you know, with with a couple of other writing collaborators, and um uh that but they were all sung by sort of West End and Broadway stars, so Rachel Tucker, Louise Dearman, um Miranda Sings randomly.
[8:06] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um honestly the the names I somehow managed to get on there was was unbelievable. So I was sort of known in that scene a little bit as a writer, um, but no one really knew that I performed or sang, so it was kind of a a bit of a shock then to see me on the TV singing.
[8:23] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um but so that was my experience as a as a as a creative, more so, yeah. And then since Superstar, you've you know, you're in a a really a great band, in my opinion.
[8:33] Rich Hawkins: Thank you very much.
[8:34] Tim Prottey-Jones: You're on the radio, you're doing a lot of country stuff. Did you did you want to continue pursuing theatre?
[8:40] Tim Prottey-Jones: Do you know what? I would say so. Musical theatre really was my I I owe so much to it because it it was the reason I don't do a nine to five now and haven't done one since Superstar, and we are talking eleven years now, you know.
[8:52] Tim Prottey-Jones: You know, it I left my job, uh they they were very kind to give me sabbatical leave to do the show. Um then off the back of it, I was just in no headspace to go back to work. I thought I've had this taste of something now.
[9:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um and then very fortunately I was I think it was just there was maybe two of us, obviously the winner Ben and and myself were offered a role in the arena tour of Jesus Christ Superstar, which is why we were all there anyway, you know.
[9:21] Tim Prottey-Jones: So to to actually get that offer and to understudy um first cover Judas to Tim Minchin was was a massive honour. You know, this is literally my first job.
[9:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um and I somehow managed to get my wife on the tour as well in wardrobe, so it was sort of like Oh lovely. It was a dream, it was an absolute dream.
[9:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: But for you know, from that moment, that was the that's the reason why I, you know, I didn't have to go back to an office or or anything. I owe so much to it.
[9:46] Tim Prottey-Jones: And I had a I had a number of terrific years doing West End shows and tours and this, that and the other, but I did miss the creativity of of writing and performing my own stuff, which is what I'd always done prior, um, in bands.
[10:01] Tim Prottey-Jones: And you know, there was a point during my time in Kinky Boots in the West End where I was just like, I'm done now. Like th this has been amazing, but I I just want to do my bands again.
[10:13] Tim Prottey-Jones: And it it just so happened to coincide. I started a band during uh it was not the band I'm in now. Again, we're talking so many years ago.
[10:21] Tim Prottey-Jones: But I started a band called The Wondering Hearts during my time in Kinky Boots, and just as my f year contract for Kinky Boots was coming to an end and they were asking us to re-sign or whatever, um, we were just about to sign a major record deal uh with Universal.
[10:35] Tim Prottey-Jones: So that for me was like right, well that's the sign for me to just go, thank you, I've had a wonderful time, I'm gonna go and do this.
[10:42] Tim Prottey-Jones: Uh so yeah, that all went ahead uh and I was back in bands doing stuff here and in the States we had a wonderful run of stuff um uh we parted ways uh a number of years after that and uh yes as you say I'm in a a new band now which is my uh my pride and joy first time flyers and it's uh yeah it's always been seemingly rooted in this sort of country music scene which um is definitely an emerging thing in the UK it feels like um but it's it's definitely got its supporters shall we talk about Mamma Mia I had a dream sure let's just let's do it let's do it it's the reason I left the wedding I'm so sorry I ruined your friend's wedding talking to me about Mamma Mia how are you finding it as a show overall three weeks in um again we spoke off camera about just generally how much we love these shows yeah it's just entertainment it really is I would say I would say it's suffering a similar fate to Superstar in as much as you don't know who these people are at all you know th there's no sort of connection to them I would say um I and I and I think that the the BBC shows did it better um you know it was Superstar again suffered because it was every night they had it in a very limited time frame.
[12:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: It was just before the Olympics um and it really suffered for that you know it was sort of every single day which made the sort of three months prior to it grueling because you had to know every show inside out prior to the the beginning of filming.
[12:19] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh yeah, you had to basically learn all of your songs, yeah, brutal.
[12:23] Rich Hawkins: I had so many songs I never got to perform.
[12:26] Tim Prottey-Jones: Still cross about it.
[12:27] Rich Hawkins: What did you not get to do that you wanted to do?
[12:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: So I never got to do "Iris," which is going to be my next song's lovely.
[12:33] Rich Hawkins: Which would have been amazing.
[12:35] Tim Prottey-Jones: Brittany's "Every Time" in her key.
[12:37] Rich Hawkins: Oh my god, then run.
[12:40] Tim Prottey-Jones: Okay. Run, uh, but Leona Lewis's version in her key, I had a death wish essentially. I just wanted to do ridiculous things.
[12:48] Rich Hawkins: So you're also into the divas.
[12:50] Tim Prottey-Jones: Great.
[12:51] Rich Hawkins: Oh gosh, yeah, it's most fun to sing. Why would you not?
[12:55] Tim Prottey-Jones: But anyway, so I think it suffered that fate, and although "Mamma Mia!" is on once a week, like, you know, like the BBC show sorry used to be, I just felt like everything's very condensed.
[13:06] Rich Hawkins: Um, and it just feels like because you didn't see the process of these people getting chosen or selected, I think you've just missed out on so much backstory of these people, which is fine.
[13:17] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's fine because then you just, you are essentially just judging them on what they do on the show, the scene and the song, which is all we're getting really each week.
[13:28] Rich Hawkins: Which is fine, but it's that, I guess it's the balance between you're making a TV show and you're trying to find the lead of a West End show.
[13:37] Tim Prottey-Jones: So, but from an audience right now, we're just watching a TV show, and I do sort of lack the reason those shows do give backstories and give you more insight to who the people are is because you do root for the individual people.
[13:37] Rich Hawkins: And like I think you're right, right now I don't know who they are or anything. You don't get to see them really like hanging out and just chatting. You don't get to see them. They don't really get interviewed by Zoe Ball or anything, so you just don't really get anything from them.
[14:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: Which is a shame.
[14:05] Rich Hawkins: And um, it is a shame.
[14:06] Tim Prottey-Jones: I just know that Marcellus has got a sore throat.
[14:09] Rich Hawkins: That's all I know.
[14:10] Tim Prottey-Jones: Right, and that one girl's really tall.
[14:11] Rich Hawkins: That's all I know.
[14:12] Tim Prottey-Jones: But the boys, yeah, I'll be honest and say I think on the whole, I was pleasantly surprised.
[14:19] Rich Hawkins: Um, I felt like generally the girls were stronger.
[14:23] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, which I think in my head before the show, I thought, oh, this could be a car crash, you know.
[14:29] Rich Hawkins: Um, but I think there's some really good stuff on there.
[14:32] Tim Prottey-Jones: But it's an interesting one, this show, because they're casting two leads, but they're not really the two leads.
[14:40] Rich Hawkins: Like Sophie is the lead and Sophie's mum is the lead.
[14:43] Tim Prottey-Jones: Sky's not really a lead role, so he's not in a lot of it.
[14:47] Rich Hawkins: So it's an interesting thing for these boys where they're next to the Sophie.
[14:50] Tim Prottey-Jones: So if the Sophies are in every scene, and they will be in a very small number, actually.
[14:55] Rich Hawkins: I just feel like they should just cast Sophie, and then the Sophie can just, she gets her own pick of who Sky should be.
[15:02] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh, lovely twist.
[15:03] Rich Hawkins: Absolutely love that.
[15:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, and go just let that one.
[15:06] Rich Hawkins: No.
[15:06] Tim Prottey-Jones: Just the thumb down.
[15:08] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[15:09] Tim Prottey-Jones: That could be how they do the camp elimination because they've got rid of that scene, so then I'm gonna go.
[15:12] Rich Hawkins: And then they get pushed off the side of the cliff that they're on.
[15:15] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[15:17] Rich Hawkins: That would be amazing.
[15:18] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[15:19] Rich Hawkins: Um, so this episode they open with a group performance, "Gimme Gimme Gimme."
[15:23] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, best song.
[15:24] Rich Hawkins: Best song.
[15:25] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh, do you reckon?
[15:26] Rich Hawkins: I love "Gimme Gimme Gimme."
[15:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's got a real gallop to it.
[15:30] Rich Hawkins: Um, and uh, there was, oh, there's another one.
[15:33] Tim Prottey-Jones: One of us is good too.
[15:35] Rich Hawkins: I love that song.
[15:36] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's great.
[15:37] Rich Hawkins: Okay, they're my favourites.
[15:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[15:39] Rich Hawkins: I strongly disagree, I have to say.
[15:42] Tim Prottey-Jones: That's which is fine.
[15:43] Rich Hawkins: I think it's fine too.
[15:45] Tim Prottey-Jones: One of my worst episodes.
[15:47] Rich Hawkins: But like, yeah, I think so.
[15:49] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[15:49] Rich Hawkins: I mean, I don't have any ABBA songs I don't like because that's not a thing.
[15:52] Tim Prottey-Jones: But um, no, that doesn't exist.
[15:55] Rich Hawkins: But it's one of my, it's one of those ones that maybe comes on at a wedding and I'm like, hmm, maybe just gonna little bit.
[16:01] Tim Prottey-Jones: I don't know.
[16:02] Rich Hawkins: It's not, I don't know.
[16:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's not for me.
[16:05] Rich Hawkins: But this performance on this show was for me because the level of like steps choreography, like the S Club 7 was coming through, like it was so, oh, it was so too loud.
[16:16] Tim Prottey-Jones: It was very, they also, um, they do that thing that lots of um, boys on tell do when they have to pretend to be best friends.
[16:24] Rich Hawkins: They just hold each other around the arms.
[16:27] Tim Prottey-Jones: I can't stand it. I have a real, I have a real aversion to the, yeah, the constant touching, yeah, and the sort of anytime it also happens in shows as well where it's the immediate embrace of anyone that walks on stage even though they've just been together.
[16:27] Rich Hawkins: Even though they were just, you know, in the post office or whatever in the previous scene.
[16:52] Tim Prottey-Jones: I don't know how many post offices there are in shows essentially, but it was it post my pat the musical or something.
[16:57] Rich Hawkins: That's it, it's a great show.
[16:57] Tim Prottey-Jones: Mrs. Goggins is a sort of epilogue which is just rivaled.
[17:02] Rich Hawkins: It really is, um, always delivers.
[17:02] Tim Prottey-Jones: Way and um, sorry that was awful, this is why I get kicked off TV shows.
[17:13] Rich Hawkins: I'll cut that, cut that, yeah, cut, get rid of it.
[17:13] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, yeah, it's the laddy stuff because it, you, I don't think you can be laddy in "Mamma Mia."
[17:23] Rich Hawkins: No, I don't think any place for it.
[17:25] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's um, yeah, it's that like it's male contact but it has to feel like laddie, but it's in "Mamma Mia," so it's not laddy.
[17:33] Rich Hawkins: It just looks like why are you walking down the street holding on to all of your friends like that? It looks really annoying and inconvenient for everyone involved, like get off each other.
[17:41] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[17:42] Rich Hawkins: So they introduced that it's Sky week and they give us something, and I don't think I know this about Sky.
[17:48] Tim Prottey-Jones: They tell us that he's a banker who has packed it all in and run off to this Greek island and met Sophie.
[17:55] Rich Hawkins: Do we know that?
[17:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: Is that canon in "Mamma Mia?"
[17:58] Rich Hawkins: I, I don't know that.
[18:00] Tim Prottey-Jones: I don't know that either, and I know a lot about "Mamma Mia." I'm sure you probably know a lot more than I do.
[18:06] Rich Hawkins: They also make a joke about Sky having abs, but they last week had this very long conversation about how the Sophies don't all look like the Sophie we might expect, and Leah talks about being plus-sized and wanting to work in the West End, and I thought that was an interesting thing to introduce that like it's essentially canon that he has to have abs.
[18:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: Because it essentially excludes basically everybody else.
[18:33] Rich Hawkins: So I don't know, I don't know if I love that.
[18:35] Tim Prottey-Jones: That's an interesting technique.
[18:37] Rich Hawkins: I think if you're gonna be, if you're gonna be diverse as you should be with, you know, with the Sophies and stuff, and you want to break sort of popular opinion as to how you imagine someone's gonna look, then it needs to be universal, right?
[18:51] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, Sky with a bit of a tummy, I want that representation for myself, you know what I mean?
[18:58] Rich Hawkins: Obviously Sky was a, you know, a banker with a dad bod.
[19:02] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, obviously it's canon, we know that.
[19:04] Rich Hawkins: And then we get an acting challenge for approximately 25 seconds.
[19:10] Tim Prottey-Jones: And it really was a challenge, it was for everyone involved a challenge.
[19:16] Rich Hawkins: Um, they didn't do it with the judge, which is what the Sophies had to do, and I think that's much kinder.
[19:23] Tim Prottey-Jones: Having to try and do it with Samantha Box and Amber Riley was an intense moment for the Sophies.
[19:28] Rich Hawkins: So I think it's nice for the Skies.
[19:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[19:30] Rich Hawkins: No, I think this was much better.
[19:32] Tim Prottey-Jones: Imagine if you'd had to do it with like Dawn French and Amanda Holden or someone.
[19:36] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, I mean, I'd have been up for it.
[19:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: I would too.
[19:39] Rich Hawkins: I would absolutely love that.
[19:41] Tim Prottey-Jones: They were both delightful.
[19:42] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, I think that'd be really fun, actually.
[19:45] Tim Prottey-Jones: They were great.
[19:45] Rich Hawkins: Actually, we might as well say, like, I really enjoy the panel on "Mamma Mia."
[19:50] Tim Prottey-Jones: I think they're terrific.
[19:51] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[19:51] Tim Prottey-Jones: Like great characters.
[19:52] Rich Hawkins: Jesse Ware is just someone I would not have thought would have been there.
[19:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: But you know, you have to respect her as a performer.
[20:00] Rich Hawkins: I think she's unbelievable.
[20:01] Tim Prottey-Jones: She's an incredible voice.
[20:03] Rich Hawkins: Um, I just wanted to throw that in there.
[20:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: I thought it was great.
[20:06] Rich Hawkins: I think Alan Carr's doing a great job too.
[20:07] Tim Prottey-Jones: I do too.
[20:08] Rich Hawkins: I think it's a good balance of, um, you know, two very like musical theatre, you know, leading ladies.
[20:14] Tim Prottey-Jones: Jesse Ware does the pop, which is what ABBA is, and Alan Carr's there, he's a performer, but also it's a TV show, and someone has to be funny, and he's very funny.
[20:22] Rich Hawkins: So I found it hard to make any notes about the acting challenge because they're really, you don't see much of it.
[20:28] Tim Prottey-Jones: No, it's really, really brief.
[20:30] Rich Hawkins: And they're only gonna show you the bits they want to show you, which is people messing up or people doing exceptionally well.
[20:36] Tim Prottey-Jones: You know, and there were some good performances.
[20:39] Rich Hawkins: Um, I feel like they were setting some people up to look bad.
[20:45] Tim Prottey-Jones: Even though I don't think they were terrible, and then, but I think they always knew that they were gonna bring it back with their, you know, singing performance.
[20:55] Rich Hawkins: Well, yeah, like you go into these reality shows, and there's either the storylines they like are redemption storylines, or they like to, any reality TV show will basically tell you who's gonna go home in the first instance, and you kind of, if you can read them, then you know.
[21:10] Tim Prottey-Jones: And it's kind of doing, it's doing one of those two things.
[21:12] Rich Hawkins: Of course it is, of course it is.
[21:13] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, but they're all pretty good.
[21:14] Rich Hawkins: No one massively messed it up, Tobias is, we're told, messed it up a bit, but like I didn't really see that as being a failure.
[21:21] Tim Prottey-Jones: I think even him, if that's him not good, then I think that's great for him because it wasn't terrible.
[21:28] Rich Hawkins: It wasn't at all.
[21:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: And then we do our first performances as Sky, what solo performances.
[21:33] Rich Hawkins: If you were gonna be Sky, what would your solo number be?
[21:38] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, that's such a good question.
[21:42] Rich Hawkins: It's, I mean, I'm really reaching here to ever see myself in that role.
[21:46] Tim Prottey-Jones: So if it was down to me, I'd want to do something clever, you know, and I always try to make sure, even when I did "Superstar," they're very adamant about what you should sing.
[21:56] Rich Hawkins: Um, I think I got off quite lightly with regards to what I ended up singing because they seem to trust my opinion as to what would work and what doesn't.
[22:06] Tim Prottey-Jones: So I'd try and implement that again if I could.
[22:10] Rich Hawkins: Um, just full.
[22:11] Tim Prottey-Jones: And the first song I did on "Superstar" was "Stone Cold Sober," Paloma Faith, which is a song I would never have chosen to do.
[22:18] Rich Hawkins: They gave it to me, and it was my first one.
[22:21] Tim Prottey-Jones: I didn't feel like I had any place to go, oh no, I don't think it's right for me or whatever.
[22:25] Rich Hawkins: So I just went right, knuckle down, learn it and do the best you can.
[22:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: Anyway, I ended up absolutely loving it.
[22:30] Rich Hawkins: So I'd say something like that, that is a pop song that has either a real sort of severe level of sass or something that is extremely emotional, and I never know quite what the people want.
[22:44] Tim Prottey-Jones: People seem to remember the emotional ballads where everyone cries, um, and then you get the songs that are just fine, and I think there was a lot of just fine this week on "Mamma Mia," which is a shame.
[22:56] Rich Hawkins: Um, people do like ballads on reality TV shows.
[22:59] Tim Prottey-Jones: Like that's why Leona Lewis is so like beloved by, like, exactly.
[22:59] Rich Hawkins: Um, a lot of the X Factor winners, their most popular performances are massive ballads that make you cry.
[23:09] Tim Prottey-Jones: Like one more ballad version of "Purple Rain" and we need to end all television, like it never stops.
[23:15] Rich Hawkins: Ruth Lorenzo.
[23:16] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, exactly that. It was, it was the key, it was the key one, that one she was a queen and it's a great cover, but like everyone else needs to stop.
[23:22] Rich Hawkins: But I said that last week when um, when Desmonda did "On My Own."
[23:31] Tim Prottey-Jones: No, no, she did the Gaga song from "A Star is Born."
[23:37] Rich Hawkins: And then um, somebody else did "On My Own," and I was like, those two are just being set up to win because those are two of those songs that the British public just eat up.
[23:45] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's like doing "The Greatest Showman."
[23:47] Rich Hawkins: People will just love it.
[23:48] Tim Prottey-Jones: So it's true, it's true.
[23:51] Rich Hawkins: I look, I think I would do something of a similar era to "Mamma Mia!" potentially, but um, in my opinion, this sounds like I'm knocking ABBA, I am obsessed with ABBA, but something a bit cooler.
[24:03] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[24:04] Rich Hawkins: So I'd probably do something Fleetwood Mac-y or something, you know what I mean?
[24:07] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, as you can see that you can act it as well, can't you?
[24:11] Rich Hawkins: You really can.
[24:12] Tim Prottey-Jones: I mean, uh, because of the amount of, again, because of the stories that Fleetwood Mac had, because so much of it was going on within the band, you know.
[24:19] Rich Hawkins: Um, I feel like there could be something really good there, especially for if they're incorporating dances or, you know, other performers as someone to play opposite, then yeah, I'd maybe do something like that, I think.
[24:31] Tim Prottey-Jones: I see that.
[24:32] Rich Hawkins: I'd probably do um, N-Dubz just because Talisa's the next natural choice.
[24:37] Rich Hawkins: I just think Talisa's a storyteller and we should all take notes, I just think we really should.
[24:43] Tim Prottey-Jones: No, sorry, I've always said this. I love you, sorry.
[24:46] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[24:48] Tim Prottey-Jones: I'm looking at my friend bought me. I've got a kind of weird obsession with Talisa, which is not that I'm not a fan, it's not mean, but I think there's something very funny about Talisa as a pop entity. And as I'm now mocking her, I'm looking at a picture of her autobiography that someone bought me as a joke. That's kind of, and I feel like she's watching me being like, "You're such a little bitch."
[25:10] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[25:11] Tim Prottey-Jones: I love you. Um, our first performer is Owen, who did "Be a Lady."
[25:17] Rich Hawkins: Yes.
[25:18] Tim Prottey-Jones: Owen works in a clothes shop. That's about all we got to know about him.
[25:22] Rich Hawkins: That's all we know.
[25:22] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, and it's his first ever audition, it's his first ever thing he's tried to do professionally, which is why I think fair play to the lad.
[25:28] Rich Hawkins: Right. Fair play.
[25:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: What did you think?
[25:32] Rich Hawkins: I thought it was all good. Do you know what I mean? I think it was better than I thought it was going to be for some reason. I'm not entirely sure why. Um, I'm still from a sort of producer, sort of musician's point of view, I'm still trying to work out how much of what they're doing is live. Like, I know there's a band there, I can see them in the background. It all seems set up to be live, but there's a lot of elements of it that do sound very pre-recorded. Um, there's also an element to the vocals where I'm thinking, have they tuned that like after the event? Which that's just the way I hear music now. I don't know. I don't know. I would just say that the atmosphere that they're singing in outdoors, with just, you know, those little microphones, and particularly the other week when the weather was atrocious. Did you see that?
[26:25] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, there was no blowing away.
[26:27] Tim Prottey-Jones: There was no element of that in the microphone. I don't know. I might be reaching there. I thought it was very good. I thought it was very strong. Um, I just, and I feel like yes, the song is probably like a really good choice for a Mamma Mia casting. It's just not what I'd want to hear personally, but that's just personal choice. I'm never gonna opt for that style of song for an audition, but I see why it's needed. I thought it was very good. I thought the acting was quite strong, like acting through the song made a lot. It's not, I don't think it's that memorable. I feel like it's one of those songs that you hear a lot in kind of, um, a lot of singers do, a lot of like loud singers and wedding singers and stuff, um, yeah, which is great, but yeah, as a result it doesn't really stand out in my mind.
[27:17] Tim Prottey-Jones: Next up we had Darcy singing "Kiss Me" by Sixpence None the Richer, I want to say.
[27:22] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[27:26] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, sure. I don't have the huge response. He seems like a nice lad.
[27:33] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, and uh, it's like when you invite your friends to watch you in a show and all they can talk about is how nice the scenery was or how swift a costume change was.
[27:43] Tim Prottey-Jones: You hated it, didn't you?
[27:44] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[27:44] Tim Prottey-Jones: Well, it looked like you were having fun.
[27:46] Rich Hawkins: You know, that's what you don't want to hear when you come off stage.
[27:49] Tim Prottey-Jones: He was, it was good. I mean, the vocal was good. He starts by chucking his hair and saying, "Yeah, it's fine," which I don't necessarily agree with, but um, so much fringe. I don't have any hair, so who am I? It's a great song. It just doesn't, it just doesn't show off any real vocal range, I would say, and ability, and I think, but that's typical of these shows where they know what the standout songs are gonna be from that episode. They know it's probably gonna be a ballad or one that has a massive, you know, dance routine in it. Um, which does mean that everyone else has to play ball and do something safe and yeah. I've seen it happen and it felt like that was what was happening here to a certain degree, particularly with this performance.
It just didn't, it didn't go off anywhere. Because the song doesn't go off, it's just, it's a really great, I love that song, but it doesn't have big notes, it doesn't have high moments. No, uh, at all and so I don't know what they would have wanted him to do with it. And it's a shame.
[28:50] Rich Hawkins: Same, same. I think for what he was given, he did a good job, but that's it, you know.
[28:55] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, and then the judges, they're really complimentary because they always are in the show, but they just said, they just said he's very likable, which I think is a bit like, did you have fun up there? Like it's not a compliment you think it is. Um, I remember, I remember Superstar, uh, obviously reading like Twitter and stuff as it was happening, and um, Jenny Eclair, the wonderful Jenny Eclair was watching, wherever she was, she was watching. Uh, and she tweeted that she thought I looked like a really nice supply teacher.
[29:22] Rich Hawkins: Um, Jenny.
[29:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: That obviously went straight on my bio, and um, that is kind of iconic though, I've made a career out of it ever since.
[29:36] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, I'd have that on a t-shirt immediately.
[29:38] Tim Prottey-Jones: Really nice supply teacher. Uh, honestly that killed me off. I was, uh, I was overjoyed to be honest that she was even bothered to watch it, but um, a really nice supply teacher.
[29:50] Rich Hawkins: So funny because you know exactly what she means as well.
[29:53] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, because I had a short beard, you know, I was, it was, I was quite neat back then. Now look, homeless chic.
[29:59] Rich Hawkins: Um, I think you look great.
[30:01] Tim Prottey-Jones: You don't look like a supply teacher anymore though.
[30:03] Rich Hawkins: No, god no, they wouldn't let me in a school now.
[30:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: Not like, not for any ri, I'm fine. I've got my CRB.
[30:09] Rich Hawkins: Pass the checks, whatever they are.
[30:12] Tim Prottey-Jones: Just, uh, I've got a child, it's fine. Um, I'm allowed to be there. Um, Jenny Eclair called you a supply teacher.
[30:20] Rich Hawkins: I love that.
[30:21] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's great, isn't it? Sorry, I digress. But yeah, it's the thing you don't really want to be classed as. It's like the, it was nice. You're cute, yeah. Whatever, you know. Good, good job. But whatever. Then we had Sakil doing "Footloose."
[30:35] Rich Hawkins: Um, but line dancing his way through "Footloose," which I thought was an interesting choice.
[30:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: I mean, given the chance, I think we'd all do it, but um, I can't. You know, I just, it's not for me. Um, I was very again gladly surprised by what he was able to do. I feel like it's probably a massive, I think they nailed it, you know, when they said that he clearly works extremely hard. And I think he would have had to have to, you know, they said it's clear that he puts in work.
[31:02] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[31:02] Tim Prottey-Jones: And I think he would have had to to learn to the, you know, the choreography. Um, let's be real, like, you know, there are people there who only had to worry about when to pick up the microphone, you know.
[31:20] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, and he had a lot to do.
[31:22] Tim Prottey-Jones: All of that and sing. Um, and he came off, you know, he came off stage still looking fresh as a da, uh, fresh as a daisy. It's all you can ask, isn't it? Really? Fair play to him.
[31:31] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, yeah. It was good. I mean, I don't like the song.
[31:35] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh, that's my truth. Um, no, I don't not like it, but I'm just like, oh, it's one of those songs that just, uh, something about it.
[31:41] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[31:42] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's like that and "Fame." Like I just, all those songs, a bit annoying.
[31:45] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, but um, it was good.
[31:47] Tim Prottey-Jones: It was, yeah. Amber Riley said that she thinks he isn't pushing his voice very far, which I think it's a bit unfair when you give somebody "Footloose."
[31:56] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, what you're supposed to do.
[31:58] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, it's, they would have chosen that song for the very reason of showing what he can do physically as well. Um, because, you know, and this is no disrespect. Maybe he doesn't look like he's someone that could do that prior to that. You know, he's, he's, I think he's quite tall, isn't he? He seems like quite a bit of a unit.
[32:19] Rich Hawkins: Seems massive, you know.
[32:20] Tim Prottey-Jones: He's a unit.
[32:21] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, and um, Sakil's also a rapper, which, you know, a rapper who loves musical theatre speaks to me. I like that.
[32:27] Tim Prottey-Jones: There you go. Umdubs again. Listen, I'm telling you, after this, I'm gonna send you an end dub song that exactly shows off why I think she's a storyteller. Um, then we had Craig doing "Your Song," but the Moulin Rouge version of "Your Song," which, camp.
[32:45] Rich Hawkins: One of my favourite films of all time.
[32:47] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, Kylie is that little fairy, beautiful work.
[32:50] Rich Hawkins: Oh, Tinkers, eh?
[32:52] Tim Prottey-Jones: Little Tinkerbell. No, I love Moulin Rouge. Um, and I really like Craig. Um, I do, I, yeah, I even though we haven't seen much of them prior to this week, he was probably my front runner, um, going into this week. Something about him I really liked.
[33:09] Rich Hawkins: Um, I would say there's very little coming from him personality-wise. I'm not saying he doesn't have one, but I'm just saying he's not giving much away. Do you know what I mean?
[33:19] Tim Prottey-Jones: Uh, yeah, they're not, he's not in a lot of the, his screen time isn't coming from like talking and the acting workshop stuff. He's not in any of that stuff.
[33:26] Rich Hawkins: No, he's not, is he?
[33:27] Tim Prottey-Jones: Which appeals to me a little bit for some reason. I kind of, I kinda like that. And it's so hard like watching these and not trying to compare him to previous contestants of other shows. You know what I mean? Like there's one that we'll talk about in a bit where sort of I can see exactly who he was in the Superstar lineup, if you know what I mean. It's sort of like, oh, you're the of, you know, of this season.
[33:50] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, yeah.
[33:50] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, and it feels obvious. Craig is the Ruth Lorenzo of Mamma Mia.
[33:54] Rich Hawkins: I mean, I think we all are deep, but yeah, he can have it.
[33:58] Tim Prottey-Jones: He's the, he's the Matt Cardle um of, uh...
[33:58] Rich Hawkins: Oh, he is the Matt Cardle, yeah, I see that.
[34:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, yeah. I um, who I also thought was terrific, by the way. Um, yeah, great, great singer. I um, I think Craig is beautiful as a man.
[34:14] Rich Hawkins: Okay.
[34:15] Tim Prottey-Jones: And that's not the point, but it doesn't hurt a bit, isn't it?
[34:19] Rich Hawkins: It is a little bit.
[34:20] Tim Prottey-Jones: It helps, especially when you're playing Sky, like he's very pretty.
[34:23] Rich Hawkins: Especially when you're a retired banker.
[34:25] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, well, with a dad bod.
[34:28] Rich Hawkins: Obviously.
[34:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah. I mean, I'm starting to think more and more that I should have been Sky.
[34:33] Rich Hawkins: I think we're all disappointed not to see you though.
[34:35] Tim Prottey-Jones: Like at this wedding, I did look like I worked at Halifax. You know.
[34:39] Rich Hawkins: I had a light blue shirt, and I just, I just felt like it was my calling.
[34:44] Tim Prottey-Jones: They're missing you.
[34:45] Rich Hawkins: I think we're all not there.
[34:46] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah. You know, I think the final of this should have been me against Howard from the Halifax.
[34:52] Rich Hawkins: Um, I was just trying to remember his name to make that joke. I was like, oh, I'll always remember Howard.
[34:57] Tim Prottey-Jones: Me versus Howard in a dance off.
[34:59] Rich Hawkins: My mum had such a crush on Howard when I read when those adverts were on.
[35:03] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, she loved it.
[35:04] Rich Hawkins: What a man.
[35:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: What a man.
[35:05] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, beautiful.
[35:06] Tim Prottey-Jones: Who was next? Callum, the dinner lady.
[35:09] Rich Hawkins: Oh god, love him.
[35:10] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yes. He's a dinner lady. He sang "Shivers" by...
[35:15] Rich Hawkins: Yes, Ed Sheeran, that's right.
[35:17] Tim Prottey-Jones: Tedwood. Um, he was surrounded by lots of women in red dresses, which made me think of that Special K advert. Remember when they used to go on diets just to eat Special K?
[35:28] Rich Hawkins: So true.
[35:28] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's a really specific reference, but that's all I could think when I watched it.
[35:31] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, but I hear you. I know exactly what you mean.
[35:34] Tim Prottey-Jones: My other notes were he's a little bit cursive in his scene.
[35:37] Rich Hawkins: Oh, he's very cursive.
[35:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: Which, okay, I was being nice, but he's really cursive in singing. Although, and I am one who does not enjoy said cursive, but I think he was just enough.
[35:53] Rich Hawkins: I don't think he was overboard.
[35:54] Tim Prottey-Jones: I like cursive singing because I find it very funny.
[35:58] Rich Hawkins: Yeah.
[35:59] Tim Prottey-Jones: But I don't like it to listen to.
[36:01] Rich Hawkins: Like it's funny to observe, but not true.
[36:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: That's true. I don't want it on a stage. My favourite, I like cursive singing from like, uh, 2000s punk rock bands. You know, like, where are you? Like those boys.
[36:11] Rich Hawkins: Who doesn't?
[36:13] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah. That's the cursive I'm looking for. Or Diana Vickers. Those are the two I want.
[36:18] Rich Hawkins: Diana.
[36:19] Tim Prottey-Jones: Sort of two ends of a spectrum, but um, he's somewhere in the middle, I guess.
[36:23] Rich Hawkins: He really is.
[36:24] Tim Prottey-Jones: I've always thought that about Callum.
[36:26] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, my note with him is that he feels like a pop star, not a musical theatre star, potentially.
[36:30] Rich Hawkins: I would probably agree.
[36:31] Tim Prottey-Jones: And he obviously doesn't have much—well, I don't think he has any background in musical theatre, does he?
[36:37] Rich Hawkins: He didn't seem to know any musical theatre songs.
[36:39] Tim Prottey-Jones: No, which is an interesting debate though, because plenty of pop stars do musical theatre, and they probably don't know the entire back catalogue of Sondheim or whatever. So, like, how much does it actually matter?
[36:51] Tim Prottey-Jones: I mean, I'll put my hands up and go, that was pretty much me in Superstar.
[36:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: I wasn't, you know, I've never been a super fan or owned really any soundtracks or anything. I was aware of the big shows because I liked what I heard, but it wasn't something that I pursued to listen to really. Um, and it's, I don't know, there's also, and again, this is me putting my hands up to this, there's a stubbornness about it of going, oh well I don't really know much musical theatre so I'm just gonna, you know, rely on learning a couple of them to use for my repertoire. And I, you know, I had a, I probably had two songs in my repertoire for every job I've ever had. I've probably used the same songs. Musical theatre songs. Yeah, Gethsemane because it was the one that I first learnt many years ago, um, and then Bring Him Home, but that was just because I kept getting seen for Valjean, so I was just kind of like, I'll do that one again.
Just do that. You know, just do that. Um, and you know, they're so obvious and they're so, you know, so I just tried to make sure that those two were great, you know, as great as I could do them. Um, so I kind of get it. Um, I'm not excusing it because I think if you know that you're in a competition like this, come armed with a couple of ideas or something, you know, and it's tricky, isn't it? Because there's so many, it's such a competitive industry. There's so many people who are desperate to work in the West End. And I personally don't think that means that you're entitled to, and I don't think he shouldn't just because he's not a massive musical theatre fan. But you can see from the point of view, if you are a massive, if you're a performer and you love, you live and breathe theatre, and then someone else is like, oh, I don't really like it. Yeah, but I'm gonna be Sky, you'd be a bit put out.
[38:41] Rich Hawkins: Oh, it's definitely irritating, uh, like it would be. Um, and I always felt that a little bit myself. I always thought I'm gonna get judged or they're gonna find me out, sort of thing, you know what I mean? And it's not that I don't like it, I just, I don't know. It just, it was never my go-to.
[38:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: It's just not your passion, it's not.
[38:58] Rich Hawkins: No, it's not, but the passion comes from actually performing stuff, um, and being on the stage doing it. I hated auditions, always have. Um, but actually in the moment and doing that stuff, you know, I felt eventually that I was in the right place, if that makes sense. Um, and I think he needs to feel that too, and I think he will with more performances, um, because I do like him.
[39:25] Tim Prottey-Jones: I do too. I think he's really good. I think he's, I do like him. He's seemingly a great actor. Um, although he definitely didn't put that across in his performance, you know, the scene was great, but the performance wasn't, you know.
[39:40] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, it's, it was just, it was okay. The judges weren't raving about it. Um, they were kind of like, didn't have a lot of connection, and Jessie Ware said she wants to have a duet with him, but as a pop star, which she definitely does not.
[39:53] Tim Prottey-Jones: She won't, but that will never happen.
[39:54] Rich Hawkins: No, things that will never happen. He's more likely to do a duet with Alan Carr, I think.
[39:59] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, just one night again.
[40:02] Rich Hawkins: I'd listen.
[40:03] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, um, who do we have next?
[40:07] Rich Hawkins: Oh, Marcellus, our 36-year-old baby. Did you know he had a sore throat, by the way?
[40:11] Tim Prottey-Jones: He had a sore throat, oh yeah, did you do it?
[40:13] Rich Hawkins: I don't know if you're featured it, yeah.
[40:15] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, no, I feel sorry for him. Like, I don't want to mock him because there's nothing you can do about it, unless it's a recurring thing that genuinely will keep happening, he needs to get it sorted. But at one point they made it sort of feel like they were about to kick him out for it, and I was like, I kind of get it if it's going on and on, then what are you gonna do? But yeah.
[40:33] Rich Hawkins: I thought that's where it was heading, if I'm honest. I thought he was the one to go. Um, not that I didn't, I thought he was a terrific performer, you know.
[40:42] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, yeah, he seems great. I'm sure if he was like at his full, you know, full vocal ability and whatever it might be. And I think if this illness or whatever is gonna keep going, then he just needs to go because it's not fair on people getting kicked off who are turning up each week and actually being able to do the job, essentially.
[41:00] Rich Hawkins: Um, so he sang "I Love You, Baby."
[41:05] Tim Prottey-Jones: Is that what it's called?
[41:06] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, that's what it's called.
[41:09] Tim Prottey-Jones: Let's say yes.
[41:10] Rich Hawkins: Let's get what you did.
[41:11] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah. That lovely wedding towards the end of a wedding, everyone's dancing. Very quite nice one. Very nice. I liked it. Um, I thought he was more actor than vocal, but maybe that's because his vocals were off.
[41:25] Rich Hawkins: It might be. It might just, yeah, it might be that. Um, very natural performer, can obviously move well as well.
[41:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[41:31] Rich Hawkins: Um, nice sequences. And then the judges were kind of lukewarm on it. And then Jessie Ware said something was weird. She was like, she was questioned, like, well, is this gonna happen all the time? I said, is he gonna get sick all the time?
[41:42] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[41:43] Rich Hawkins: Which that's a bit like, well, no, why would that happen? That's not a thing. What do you know? Why would that happen all the time? He's just ill now. But like he's not, this isn't like, oh, he's always ill. Like he's got a bad throat. Like, what are you talking about?
[41:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, I do feel bad for him. It must be so hard. Like, he's done all those auditions and whatever and then, yeah, no, that is rough. And again, you know, I saw it on the show where someone got ill, and it was nothing they could have done about it. And they tried everything to get better. Um, there's nothing you can do about it. It's a shame. It's tough. It is a shame. It's really tough.
[42:23] Rich Hawkins: Yeah. Um, and then we end with Tobias, who sings "Pointless" by Lewis Capaldi. And they recap his acting. So again, going back to like, is it redemption or is it home time? The fact that he got that means they're trying to tell a story, and then he got a redemption because he did, I mean, his voice was beautiful, yeah. Loved the way he sang it. Um, he's very musical theatre in the way he sings, but that's the point, so I like it. He just, I thought it was just great. He has been given the song that is supposed to make the audience feel something.
[42:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: Absolutely, and that's why he's on last. You can sort of tell.
[42:59] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, absolutely. Um, but it, you know, it still needed to be done very well, and he did, thank goodness. Um, and I mentioned it earlier how he sort of, it's hard not to compare to like Superstar and past shows of like, oh, he's the whatever of this year. He’s my David Hunter of this one, you know. Yeah, that very similar mannerisms and um, just like extremely good acting, extremely good singing, um, and I would say one of the few that can combine the two, you know, because I often feel like that's the problem. Uh, you can be a great singer and a great actor, it doesn't mean you can do them both at the same time, but I feel like he's probably the one that can.
[43:48] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, for sure.
[43:49] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, he does feel, yeah, I see that David Hunter. Maybe we'll see him in a Time Traveller's Life somewhere down the line.
[43:55] Tim Prottey-Jones: Let's hope so following in the state. Current guy's not great. Um, that was the end of our performances. They have a bit of a debate at the table. Judy wanders over to give her opinion slash tell them what to do, potentially.
[44:10] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, don't mess this up.
[44:11] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, you kind of get that vibe, don't you? She's like good.
[44:14] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, yeah, no, we'll let Alan Carr pick, but nothing.
[44:17] Tim Prottey-Jones: Definitely that one.
[44:18] Rich Hawkins: Yeah. Um, and they do that debate again about Callum not knowing theatre and whether that matters.
[44:23] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah.
[44:24] Rich Hawkins: Um, if I were to have guessed at this point, I would have said Callum was going home.
[44:29] Tim Prottey-Jones: I would have been worried. I was honestly between Callum and Marcellus. I really was. I just thought, do they just go, okay. Well he's had two weeks of not being vocally strong enough because he's poorly ill, whatever. At what point you'll just, you know, pull the plug and go, okay, well, let's make room for people that are in good health and can sing week in, week out at the moment.
[44:53] Rich Hawkins: So that I, so when the result came, you know, I was surprised in as much as it wasn't either of the two people that I thought it was gonna be.
[45:02] Tim Prottey-Jones: But I was too. And I felt like from a, because I watch a lot of reality TV and stuff, and I just felt like that's where they were leading us, those two. Like they both had storylines that were, one's got a bad voice, that's a very easy out for the judges. On a show that's very supposed to be very kind, it's a very easy out, yeah. Or the one who they critiqued for not knowing theatre, because again, it's quite an easy defendable thing to do. Well, that's why we did it.
[45:25] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, but they don't do that, they kick out Darcy with his big madness.
[45:30] Tim Prottey-Jones: The fringe is gone.
[45:32] Rich Hawkins: The fringe has spoken, and it is out. Like on reflection, it was a quite safe performance.
[45:41] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh, it's far too safe, I think.
[45:42] Rich Hawkins: Yeah, yeah. It was just kind of, maybe they're just uninspired by it.
[45:46] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, I just thought maybe he was one of the bigger characters, so I thought they might have kept him around if I'm honest. Um, or maybe they just thought he'd fall in love with every guest Sophie that they brought in.
[45:57] Rich Hawkins: Um, seems to be a lot of that.
[46:02] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah. I thought it was interesting because he feels like, yeah, he's very likable, and casting off of a TV show. Yeah. If you cast someone that the public really likes, you're gonna sell the tickets. Like that's the point, right? Like you get them to come to watch the performer they like. So it was an interesting moment for him to go. Um, I feel like they were showing him a lot, you know. I felt like he did more segments and, you know, bits to camera than most of the others, if not all of the others.
[46:30] Rich Hawkins: Um, I was surprised. So I'm hoping they'll show a bit more of the other guys now. Um, give them a bit of a bit of time. Who's the top two, if you had to guess now?
[46:40] Tim Prottey-Jones: For me, um, I would definitely say Tobias.
[46:48] Rich Hawkins: Definitely Tobias. Uh, I'm torn. I'm gonna say Craig at the moment.
[46:56] Tim Prottey-Jones: Okay, Scottish boy.
[46:57] Rich Hawkins: But only because I don't feel like I know anything about him, and I'm intrigued to find out more. Um, I feel like, uh, yeah, I feel like there's more there, I really do. Um, and I feel like he can act, which I always think is the thing that lacks in musical theatre is a solid, solid acting performance.
[47:18] Tim Prottey-Jones: Um, that's probably got a massive general generalization, but I just mean—
[47:18] Rich Hawkins: No, but I know, I think you're right. Like there are so many terrific singers around singing.
[47:26] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah, exactly.
[47:27] Rich Hawkins: And with, um, yeah. And I think vocally, I'm probably the most excited to hear him sing again. Um, Tobias.
[47:34] Tim Prottey-Jones: Well, there we go. That was Mamma Mia. I done had a dream. We've solved a problem like Sophie and Sky. Solved a problem. We've gone over the rainbow and found a Sophia Sky. All is well.
[47:50] Rich Hawkins: Thank you so much for joining me.
[47:51] Tim Prottey-Jones: Oh, it's a pleasure. It's brought back very nice memories of the previous podcast and all of the experiences of doing these shows. So, um, when and where can people hear you on the radio and find your music, etc.?
[48:04] Tim Prottey-Jones: So, um, I am the only Tim Prottey-Jones in the entire world, so do just pop that into the interweb. Um, my show is on Countryline Radio every Wednesday evening at eight o'clock. It's called Homegrown. My band are called First Time Flyers, and that's pretty much the be all and end all to my music at the moment. That's where all my efforts are. So please do give us a follow and check us out. Um, we're just like Dolly Parton. That's all you need to do.
[48:30] Rich Hawkins: Actually, it's all done buttons.
[48:34] Tim Prottey-Jones: Yeah. And that's just my outfits.
[48:36] Rich Hawkins: Yeah. The wigs really sell up.
[48:38] Tim Prottey-Jones: The wigs, I think. I need beautiful wig work.
[48:42] Rich Hawkins: Cool, thanks, Tim. And everybody else, thanks for listening. You can follow me, I'm the boldest bitch on TikTok, bald like a Mitchell brother, not bald like a bold eagle.
[48:51] Tim Prottey-Jones: No, actually, it's a bold eagle, isn't it?
[48:53] Rich Hawkins: I think it is. What's, uh, how, um, uh, the bold and the beautiful, which is our new double act.
[48:59] Tim Prottey-Jones: Which is us, yeah. You choose which one you want to be.
[49:02] Rich Hawkins: I'll be both, I'm bold and beautiful.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
